Upload
akamola52
View
227
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
1/29
SCOPE OF WORK
Phase I Environmental Site Assessments
Date: July 12, 2004
NOMURACREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
2 WORLD FINANCIALCENTER, BUILDINGB
NEWYORK, NEWYORK 10281-1198
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
2/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Introduction.............................. ........................................................ ...................................... 1
1.1 Objective ................................................. ....................................................... ........... 11.2 The Consultant.................................................. ........................................................ . 21.3 Updated Report.............................. ........................................................ .................... 2
2.0 Scope of Work......................... ........................................................ ...................................... 3
2.1 Document Review and Interviews... ........................................................ .................... 32.1.2 General................................................. ........................................................ . 32.1.3 Government Agency Provided Information................................... .................... 42.1.4 Use and Ownership History ........................................................ .................... 62.1.5 Physical Setting Sources .................................................... ............................. 82.1.6 Zoning Designation................................................... ...................................... 9
2.2 Walk-Through Survey............................................................................. .................... 9
2.2.1 General................................................. ........................................................ . 92.2.2 General Site Setting .................................................. .................................... 102.2.3 Interior and Exterior Observations ............................................... .................. 122.2.4 Interior Observations ................................................ .................................... 142.2.5 Exterior Observations ........................................................ ........................... 15
3.0 Special Criteria ..................................................... ....................................................... ......... 16
3.1 Asbestos .................................................. ....................................................... ......... 163.2 Lead.............................................. ........................................................ .................. 173.3 Radon...................................................... ....................................................... ......... 173.4 Vehicle Lifts ..................................................... ....................................................... 183.5
Dry Cleaners..................................................... ....................................................... 18
3.6 Mold......... ........................................................ ....................................................... 19
4.0 Interviews............. ........................................................ ....................................................... 21
4.1 Site Personnel................................................... ....................................................... 214.2 Federal, State Provincial and Local Officials............................................. .................. 224.3 Third Party Personnel............................................................................. .................. 224.4 Prior Assessment Usage ....................................................... .................................... 22
5.0 Preparation of a Report..................................................................... .................................... 22
5.1 Executive Summary................................................................................ .................. 235.1.1 General Description...................... ....................................................... ......... 23
5.1.2 Conclusions .................................................... .............................................. 235.1.3 Project Summary Schedule.. ........................................................ .................. 235.1.4 Recommendations .................................................... .................................... 235.1.5 Operations and Maintenance Plans ....................................................... ......... 245.1.6 Cost Estimates ............................................... .............................................. 24
5.2 Salient Building Facts................................ ....................................................... ......... 245.3 Purpose and Scope ..................................................... .............................................. 245.6 Exhibits...................................................................... .............................................. 25
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
3/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
ii
5.6.1 Photographs ................................................... .............................................. 255.6.2 Additional Supporting Documentation............................................................. 255.6.3 Questionnaire................................................. .............................................. 26
Appendix
Sample Pre-Survey Questionnaire
Sample Dry Cleaner Checklist
Recommended Scope of Work for Phase II ESA involving Dry Cleaners
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
4/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
1
1.0 Introduction
The purpose of this guide is to define expected and customary practice for conducting Phase I
Environmental Site Assessments (ESA) on behalf of Nomura Credit & Capital, Inc. Nomura
Credit & Capital, Inc. and its affiliates (collectively, NCCI), its successors and assigns, ratingagencies and certain investors involved in the Securitization (as defined below) or other disposition,
will use and rely upon this Report in connection with a planned securitization involving the Subject,
or a whole loan sale or other disposition of the related loan (collectively the Securitization),
NCCI, may at its option elect to include selected information in the Report in the offering
memorandum or other disclosure materials relating to the Securitization.
The minimum criteria shall be American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) E 1527-00
Standard Practice for Environmental Site Assessments: Phase I Environmental Site Assessments:
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Process, which have been enhanced to meet NCCI
requirements. The specific enhancements are described below. For specific clarification, refer to
the published ASTM guidelines. The report shall be prepared in connection with the proposedrefinancing or financing of all property types (herein referred to as Subject). All ESAs
submitted by Consultant shall comply with the Scope of Work.
1.1 Objective
The purpose of the ESA is to observe and report, to the extent feasible pursuant
to the processes prescribed herein, recognized environmental conditions in con-
nection with the Subject and identify those areas of environmental uncertainty that
warrant further investigation or clarification. The Report will identify those areas
that will require remedial repair work and will assign them an associated esti-
mated remedial cost.
The ESA will be based upon six components:
Documentation Review
Walk-Through Survey
Special Criteria (Asbestos, Lead, Radon, Dry Cleaners, Vehicle Lifts, Mold,
etc.)
Interviews
Preparation of a Report
Without limiting the foregoing, the purpose of a Phase I Environmental Site As-sessment (ESA) is to determine the likelihood that environmental contamination
exists at the Subject due to current or previous activities on or in the vicinity of the
Subject. Based on the results of the ESA, the Consultant will state their conclu-
sions concerning potential environmental liability, the likelihood of any environ-
mental contamination at or surrounding the Subject and compliance with environ-
mental and health and safety laws and regulations. The Consultant will make a
recommendation regarding the need for any additional due diligence (e.g., soil
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
5/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
2
and/or groundwater sampling). The ESA shall be completed subject to the most
current ASTM standards and this Scope of Work.
1.2 The Consultant
Approved Consultants will be selected by NCCI based upon the firms experience
with conducting ESAs for securitizations, national recognition, and a consistent
track record of providing a high quality product that is generally well-received by
NCCI, the rating agencies, and investors that rely on these reports. It is our intent
to obtain a consistent level of reporting and standard formatting from a limited list
of approved Consultants. It is recognized, however, that the qualifications of the
Consultant are highly dependent on many factors that may include professional
education, training, experience, certification or professional licensing/registration
of both the Consultants field observers and the ESA reviewer. It is further rec-
ognized that the Consultant has the responsibility to select, engage, or employ the
field observer and the ESA reviewer with appropriate credentials. Notwithstand-
ing, the Consultant shall carry the following minimum insurance coverage:
Type of Coverage Coverage Amount
Workers Compensation Statutory Limits
General Liability $1,000,000 per claim / $2,000,000 aggregate
Umbrella $2,000,000
Automobile $1,000,000
Professional Liability (E&O) $2,000,000 per claim and aggregate
Approved Consultants will be asked to execute a Standard Master Agreement
with NCCI and to provide evidence of the foregoing coverage. All Consultants
will be retained directly by NCCI.
Although, it is NCCIs intent to obtain a consistent level of reporting and standard
formatting from a limited list of approved Consultants, from time-to-time, NCCI
may accept an existing report prepared by a Consultant not on NCCIs approved
list at the time such report is prepared, provided: (i) the report conforms with the
Scope of Work identified in this guide, (ii) the Consultants qualifications and insur-
ance coverage meet NCCI criteria, (iii) the report is certified to NCCI, including
NCCIs standard reliance language, (iv) the report is reviewed by a Consultant
from NCCIs approved list for conformance with NCCIs Scope of Work and
customary industry standards, (v) the existing report was prepared by prior to
NCCI considering financing, and preparation a new report would cause unduecost or hardship to the property owner, and (vi) the existing report was prepared
within the past six(6) months.
1.3 Updated Report
Updated reports are not acceptable. The ESA must be completed in
accordance with this scope of work. Worthy of note; however, the use of prior
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
6/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
3
reports in connection with preparation of this ESA is acceptable, and there is no
need to re-do work presented in a previous report, provided that the information
contained in the reports are reliable and proper supporting documentation is
provided so that the Consultant would come to the same independent conclusion.
For example, if the Consultant is relying on historical photographs from a previous
report, the photos must be included and in sufficient detail so the Consultant wouldreasonably come to the same independent conclusion. Previous reports
referenced in the ESA must be included in the report.
2.0 SCOPE OF WORK
2.1 Document Review and Interviews
2.1.2 General
The objective of the document review and interviews is to augment the
walk-through survey and to assist the Consultants understanding of the
Subject and identifying recognized environmental conditions in connection
with the Subject. Prior to conducting the walk-through survey, the Con-
sultant is to provide the borrower with a Questionnaire, which are to be
completed by the borrower or its representative and forwarded to the
Consultant. The Questionnaire will be included as an Exhibit to the Con-
sultants report.
The Consultant should make appropriate inquiries and review only such
record information that is reasonably ascertainable from standard
sources. If information is not practically reviewable or not provided to
the Consultant in a reasonable time for the Consultant to formulate an
opinion and complete the ESA, such fact should be stated in the ESA and
the Consultant is to have no further obligation of retrieving such docu-
mentation or reviewing it if it is subsequently provided. Nevertheless, if
pursuant to the Consultant's appropriate inquiry, material information is
received by the Consultant contemporaneous to the preparation of the
ESA, but too late to be included in the report, the Consultant should for-
ward it to the NCCI with a cover letter clearly defining the assessed
property and a description of the attached information..
Information typically requested from the borrower, or the borrowers rep-resentative include:
Previously Prepared ESAs
Safety Inspection Reports
Asbestos Surveys
Lead Paint Surveys of Inspection Reports
Operation & Maintenance Plans for Lead or Asbestos
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
7/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
4
Underground/Aboveground Storage Tank Registrations
Waste Disposal Records
Environmental Permits
Deed Restrictions or Environmental Liens
Historical and Current Tenants Listing
Outstanding citations for environmental violations Chain-of-Title
Leasing literature, listing for sale, marketing/promotion literature, floor
plans, etc.
Building and Site Plan
2.1.3 Government Agency Provided Information
Consultant shall solicit and obtain information or other record information
from government agencies or from commercial services. Records per-
taining to the Subject site as well as adjacent and surrounding propertiesshall be reviewed and an evaluation of potential impacts to the Subject
site shall be performed.
2.1.3.1 Database Review
A database search including a review of all applicable federal,
state and local agency files shall be conducted in order to identify
potential environmental concerns or public health concerns asso-
ciated with the Subject site as well as adjacent and surrounding
properties within the approximate minimum search distances as
outlined in the ASTM Standard E 1527-00 or the most recent re-
vision.
The database search shall include a compilation, summary and
reduction of data and an evaluation of the potential impacts to the
Subject. Orphaned (also known as unplottable) sites must be ad-
dressed within the contents of the report.
The Consultant must determine the potential impact on the
Subject from hazardous waste activities at neighboring properties.
The Consultant must review the most recent information
available on waste sites within one mile of the Subject. This
information may be obtained from state and federal
environmental protection agencies. The Consultant mustcomment on the impact of these sites on the Subject and explain
the rationale for Consultant's opinion.
The Consultant must review at least the following data sources.
Search radii must comply with ASTM 1527-2001:
Federal National Priorities List (NPL or Superfund).
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
8/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
5
Federal Comprehensive Environmental Response,
Compensation and Liability Information System (CERCLIS).
Federal RCRA CORRACTS TSD facilities list.
Federal RCRA non-CORRACTS TSD facilities list. Federal
ERNS list.
State lists of hazardous waste sites identified for investigationor remediation; State-equivalent NPL.
State-equivalent CERCLIS.
State landfill and/or solid waste disposal site lists State
registered UST lists for the Subject and adjoining properties.
State leaking UST lists. For identified LUSTs, the Consultant
should note (i) if it is up-gradient, down-gradient, or
cross-gradient to the Subject; (ii) the current status of
remediation; and, (iii) the probability of contamination to the
Subject.
2.1.3.2 Agency F il e Review
Reasonably ascertainable files pertaining to the Subject site shall
be reviewed. Reasonably ascertainable files pertaining to adja-
cent and surrounding sites identified as showing evidence of po-
tential environmental concern shall be reviewed to evaluate po-
tential impacts to the Subject site. This information may include
the following: distance from Subject site, hydraulic gradient from
the Subject site, type and extent of known contamination,
groundwater flow direction, regulatory status of issue, type of
remediation activities being performed or proposed, the status of
any remedial activities, and the likelihood of impact to the Subjectsite, etc.
2.1.3.3 Envir onmental Records Main tained On-Site
Environmental records maintained at the Subject site or available
from the site contact shall be reviewed. These records shall in-
clude, but may not necessarily be limited to: asbestos surveys,
Phase I or Phase II Assessments; contamination assessment re-
ports, remedial action workplans; underground storage tank regis-
tration; leak detection monitoring; construction materials; system
design details; installation details; installation dates; closuredocumentation; vehicle lift and other equipment maintenance re-
cords, frequency of maintenance, removal/decommissioning
documentation including any analytical results; previous environ-
mental site assessments; oil-water separator and/or similar drain-
age unit service records including draining, cleaning, and inspec-
tion records; waste disposal documentation; environmental com-
pliance, etc.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
9/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
6
2.1.3.4 Envir onmental Records Obtained From Other Sources
Pertinent environmental records from sources other than those
discussed above may be available and shall be reviewed. These
other sources may include, but may not necessarily be limited to:
previous site owner/operator(s); site with business associations tothe Subject site (i.e., headquarters site, another dealership with
the same owner as the Subject site, etc.); adjacent and surround-
ing property owner/operator(s), etc.
2.1.3.5 Additi onal Environmental Record Sources
One or more additional state or local source of environmental re-
cords should be checked, if readily available, in accordance with
ASTM Guidelines, to enhance and supplement federal and state
sources identified above. Some types of records and sources
that may be reviewed include: Department of
Health/Environmental Division; Fire Department; Engineering
Department; Planning Department; Building Department; Tax
Assessor; Local Pollution Control Agency; Local Water Quality
Agency; and Local Electric Utility Company.
2.1.4 Use and Ownership History
2.1.4.1 General
All obvious uses of the Subject and surrounding properties shall
be established from the present back to the Subjects obvious
first developed use or back to 1940, whichever is earlier. The
purpose of this review will be to identify potential sources of
contamination from historic site or neighboring site usage.
Particular attention should be focused on identifying past owners
or operations at the site that may have generated, treated, stored
or disposed of solid, hazardous or radioactive wastes, substances
or materials.
All relevant information sources should be investigated to come
to a definitive determination. The following is a list of
recommended information sources to be used in making thisdetermination.
Chain of Title
A chain of title search dating back to at least 1940 or a review of
readily accessible ownership records shall be performed at the
Subject site, if this information is reasonably ascertainable. Re-
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
10/29
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
11/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
8
Readily available historic maps such as Bromley Maps, Real
Property Maps and 7.5 Minute Series USGS Topographic Maps
should be reviewed as part of the assessment.
Prior Assessments
Standard Historical sources reviewed as part of a prior environ-
mental site assessments do not need to be searched or reviewed
again, provided the information is determined to be reliable and
the adequate supporting documentation is provided to reproduce
the same result, if the research was independently conducted by
the Consultant. However, uses of the Subject since the prior
assessment should be identified either through standard historical
sources.
Other H istorical Sources
Other credible sources can be used to identify the prior uses of
the Subject . The category includes, but is not limited to miscel-
laneous maps, newspaper archives, and the records in the files
and/or personal knowledge of the property owner and/or occu-
pants.
2.1.5 Physical Setting Sources
2.1.5.1 Topographi cal Map
A current USGS 7.5 Minute Topographical Map (or equivalent)
showing the area on which the Subject is located shall be re-
viewed. One or more additional physical setting sources may be
reviewed.
2.1.5.2 F lood Zones
The Consultant is to note whether the Subject encroaches upon
the 100-year flood area designated as Special Flood Hazard Ar-
eas Inundated by 100-Year Flood on FEMA maps, as amended.
2.1.5.3 Soil Maps
If maps are readily available, a discussion should be included of
the soil information, including, soil types, slope, drainage, texture,
depth, permeability, soil reaction, and depth to the seasonal water
table.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
12/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
9
2.1.5.4 Bedrock/surf icial Geology maps
If maps are readily available, a discussion should be included of
the geology including physiographic province, formation, material
type, and thickness.
2.1.5.5 Groundwater Maps
If maps are readily available, a discussion should be included of
the hydrology including source, aquifer formation, and estimated
ground water level. The local and site specific expected
groundwater flow direction and depth shall be determined or in-
ferred based on existing data specific to the Subject site or local
area data. If site specific or local data is not available, the
groundwater flow direction and depth shall be estimated.
2.1.6 Zoning Designation
The Consultant is to identify the zoning designation of the Sub-
ject.
2.2 Walk-Through Survey
2.2.1 General
The Consultant shall perform a complete walkthrough of the entire prop-
erty and a representative number of tenant spaces or apartments. The
Consultant shall make appropriate attempts to obtain access to all portionsof the Subject site and shall note any limitations of access to the Subject
site.
For complexes with multiple buildings, the exterior envelopes of all resi-
dential buildings should be surveyed. For complexes built in phases, each
construction phase should be surveyed. Representative observation of
the interiors should include a mix of units, which are occupied, vacant,
damaged, and under renovation or repair. Representative observation of
the interiors of each construction phase should include a sufficient num-
ber of top and bottom floors. Generally, a representative number of units
shall consist of 10% of all occupied, 100% vacant, and 100% damaged ordown units. The consultant may use their professional judgement for lar-
ger properties, greater than 200 units, if it is determined that the units are
typical, based upon their inspection of at least 5% of the occupied units.
All vacant and down units should be observed.
For non-residential properties or buildings built in phases, each construc-
tion phase should be surveyed. For a property that contains multiple
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
13/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
10
buildings, the concept of representative observations extend to each build-
ing individually and not to all buildings as a whole. Representative obser-
vations should include a mix of tenants (occupied and unoccupied) and
common areas. The Consultant shall include a tabular list of the tenants
names and use of the Project. Operational activities of environmental
concern should be discussed, such as industrial processes, dry cleaning,etc. Industrial processes should be discussed from raw material stage to
the finished product. Any required permits should also be discussed.
To the extent that the following items are visually and/or physically ob-
served on the site visit, or identified in the interviews or records review,
they shall be identified in the report.
2.2.2 General Site Setting
2.2.2.1 Curr ent Use of the Subject PropertyThe current use(s) of the Subject shall be identified in the report.
Any current uses of the Subject likely to involve the use, storage,
treatment, disposal, or generation of hazardous substances or
petroleum products shall be identified. Unoccupied spaces should
be noted. In identifying the current uses of theSubject, more
specific information is more helpful than less specific information.
2.2.2.2 Past Use of the Subject Property
To the extent that past uses of properties are visually and/or
physically observed on the site visit or are identified in theinterviews or records review, they shall be identified in the report.
Current uses identified shall be described in the report if they are
likely to indicate a recognized environmental condition.
2.2.2.3 Cur rent use of Adjoini ng Properti es
To the extent that current uses of adjoining properties are visually
and/or physically observed on the site visit, or are identified in the
interviews or records review, they shall be identified in the report.
Current uses so identified shall be described in the report if they
are likely to indicate a recognized environmental condition.
2.2.2.4 Past use of Adjoin ing Properties
To the extent that past uses of adjoining properties are visually
and/or physically observed on the site visit, or are identified in the
interviews or records review, they shall be identified in the report.
Past uses identified shall be described in the report if they are
likely to indicate a recognized environmental condition.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
14/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
11
2.2.2.5 Cur rent or Past Uses of the Sur rounding Ar ea
To the extent that current and past uses of the surrounding area
is visually and/or physically observed on the site visit, or are
identified in the interviews or records review, they shall be
identified in the report. Past uses identified shall be described in
the report if they are likely to indicate a recognized environmentalcondition.
2.2.2.6 Geologic, Hydrogeologic, Hydrauli c, and Topographi cal
Conditions
The topographic conditions of the Subject shall be noted to the
extent visually and/or physically observed or determined through
interviews, as well the general topography of the surrounding
area. If any information obtained shows there are likely to be
hazardous substances of petroleum on the property or on nearby
properties and those hazardous substance may migrate,topographic observations should be analyzed in connection with
geologic, hydrogeologic, and topographic information obtained
pursuant to the Record Review and Interviews to evaluate
whether hazardous substances or petroleum products are likely to
migrate to the Subject, or within or from the Subject, into
groundwater or soil.
2.2.2.7 General Description of the Structures
The report shall generally describe the structures or other
improvements on the property, for example: number of buildings,
stories, age, ancillary structures, heating and cooling systems, etc.
2.2.2.8 Roads
Public streets adjoining the Subject shall be identified in the report
and any roads, streets, and parking facilities on the property shall
be described in the report.
2.2.2.9 Potable Water Supply
The Consultant must identify the drinking water supplier and
verify with the supplier that the water quality is acceptable ac-
cording to federal and/or local guidelines as described below. If
the Subject is on a municipal system, the drinking water does not
need to be tested for lead or other impurities unless lead piping is
utilized (including water fountain supply lines).
If the Subject is not provided with municipal water or if lead
piping is utilized, drinking water samples for the Subject must be
obtained, tested and compared to State drinking water quality
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
15/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
12
standards to determine whether compliance is currently being
achieved. If a State program does not exist, Federal Safe
Drinking Water Act standards apply.
2.2.10 Sewage Disposal Systems
The sewage disposal system shall be identified in the report.
Inquiry shall be made as to the age of the system, specific
mention to on-site treatment facilities or septic systems should be
made.
2.2.3 Interior and Exterior Observations
2.2.3.1 Cur rent Use of the Subject
The current use(s) of the Subject shall be identified in the report.
Any current uses of the Subject likely to involve the use storage,
treatment, disposal, or generation of hazardous substances orpetroleum products shall be identified. Unoccupied spaces should
be noted. In identifying the current uses of the Subject, more
specific information is more helpful than less specific information.
2.2.3.2 Past Use of the Subject
To the extent that past uses of properties are visually and/or
physically observed on the site visit, or are identified in the
interviews or records review, they shall be identified in the report,
and current uses so identified shall be described in the report if
they are likely to indicate a recognized environmental condition.
2.2.3.3 Hazardous Substances
To the extent that present uses are identified that store, treat or
dispose of or generate hazardous substances and petroleum
products on the property, hazardous substances and petroleum
products shall be identified in the report and the approximate
quantities involved, container, and storage condition described in
the report. Conditions that do not appear to conform with good
commercial, customary practice, or regulation should be noted.
2.2.3.4 Storage Tanks
Aboveground
The Consultant shall observe and note the presence and location
of all aboveground storage tanks and storage areas.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
16/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
13
The Consultant shall observe and note the presence of secondary
containment around each aboveground storage tank and storage
area.
The Consultant shall visually inspect and note the integrity of
each aboveground storage tank, container and secondary con-tainment structure (if present) in each storage area.
The Consultant shall visually inspect each tank and container and
the surface beneath each tank and container for evidence of
staining or a release that may indicate a potential environmental
impact. If staining or a release is observed, the Consultant shall
visually inspect and note the integrity and type of the pavement
material including the presence of cracks, expansion joints, de-
grading material and floor drains that may indicate a potential re-
lease to the subsurface.
Underground
The Consultant shall observe and note the locations of all under-
ground storage tanks at the Subject . This shall include the loca-
tions of all currently operating, inactive, temporarily out of ser-
vice, abandoned and removed underground storage tanks.
The Consultant shall evaluate the operational status or closure
status of each tank. If the tank is active, the Consultant shall
opine as to the tanks expected useful life. If the tank is inactive,
the Consultant shall, if possible, evaluate if the tank has remaining
product or has been filled with concrete, grout, sand, etc.
The Consultant shall evaluate the regulatory compliance of each
underground storage tank. This shall include, but may not neces-
sarily be limited to, the following: review of tank registration
documents; visually inspecting and noting the presence or ab-
sence of overfill protection; leak detection; corrosion protection,
etc.
The Consultant shall visually inspect and note the condition of the
soil and pavement surrounding each tank for evidence of staining
and overfilling which may indicate a potential environmental im-pact. If staining or evidence of overfilling is present, the Consult-
ant shall note the integrity and type of the pavement material in-
cluding the presence of cracks, degrading material and expansion
joints that may indicate a release to the subsurface environment.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
17/29
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
18/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
15
2.2.4.2 Stains or Corrosion
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews, stains or corrosion on floors, wall, and ceilings shall be
described in the report, except staining from water.
2.2.4.3 Drains or Sumps
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews, floor drains and sumps shall be described in the
report.
2.2.5 Exterior Observations
2.2.5.1 Pits, Ponds or lagoons
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews or records review, pits, pond, and lagoons on the
property shall be described in the report, particularly if they are in
connection with waste disposal or waste streams.
2.2.5.2 Stained Soil or Pavement
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews, stained soil or pavement shall be described in the
report.
2.2.5.3 Stressed Vegetation
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews, material stressed vegetation shall be described in the
report.
2.2.5.4 Solid Waste
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews or records, areas that are apparently filled or graded
by non-natural causes suggesting trash or other solid waste
disposal, or mounds or depressions suggesting trash or other solid
waste disposal, shall be described in the report. In addition thelocation of trash dumpsters, compactors, or disposal areas should
be identified, including any indication of improper storage.
2.2.5.5 Waste Water
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews or records review, waste water or other liquid
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
19/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
16
(including storm water) or any discharge into a drain, ditch, or
stream on or adjacent to the property shall be described in the
report.
2.2.5.6 Wells
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews or records review all wells (including dry wells,
irrigation wells, injection wells, abandoned wells, other wells, or
irrigation wells shall be described in the report.
2.2.5.7 Septic Systems
To the extent visually and/or physically observed or identified in
interviews or records review all indications of on-site septic
systems or cesspools should be described in the report.
3.0 SPECIAL CRITERIA
3.1 Asbestos
If warranted by the age of the related building(s), the Consultant must inspect the
Subject for asbestos-containing materials (ACM). The purpose of the
inspection is to discover whether significant quantities of ACM were used in the
construction of the building or added subsequently and to determine the
approximate quantity and condition of such materials. As discussed in "Guidance
for Controlling Asbestos-Containing Materials in Buildings," EPA 56015-85-024(June 1985) ("Purple Book"), particular attention during the inspection must be
focused on identifying asbestos-containing pipe and boiler insulation,
texture-finished ceiling and wall materials (popcorn type) and sprayed or
troweled-on structural coverings. Friable ACM (that is, material that releases
fibers when subjected to finger pressure) is of greatest concern.
Samples of materials suspected of containing asbestos must be collected, if
possible, by methods that do not show visible destruction, and should be analyzed
by a qualified professional utilizing polarized light microscopy and dispersion
staining. The number and quantity of samples must be sufficient to provide
meaningful results. For all Subjects, the number of samples taken must be basedon the number of suspected materials observed. If the Consultant determines the
Subject to be free of ACM, the Consultant will so certify such within the report.
The Consultant shall develop and provide, upon request, an operations and
maintenance (O&M) program to maintain in place any ACMs that are
determined to be in good condition. All recommendations are to be made in light
of existing local asbestos handling regulations and must include the cost for
additional testing or remediation, if any.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
20/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
17
The report must include tabulations of the type of material, exact location of the
sample, condition and approximate quantity of the material, and asbestos
concentration. If samples are positive, photographs of typical conditions of the
areas tested must be included. A copy of the laboratory analytical report must be
appended to the ESA.
3.2 Lead
For multifamily projects, residential properties, schools, churches, and day care
centers only, the Consultant must test assets built before 1978 for the presence of
LBP.
An adequate number of samples must be collected commensurate with the
Subjects size to establish the content and condition of lead based paint. If the
Subject was a multi-phased project, all phases should be covered in the sampling.
However, if certain phases were constructed post 1978 it is not necessary to test
them. Between a minimum of 10 and a maximum of 30 samples must becollected, at a minimum of 10 samples per 100 units. In addition, the Subject shall
be tested in one of the following forms depending upon which form shall be more
suitable: 1) chemical reaction swabs (which indicate a presence of lead in excess
of .5% lead by dry weight), 2) XRF (X-ray Fluorescence Technology) and/or 3)
laboratory analysis of chip samples using Atomic Absorption Spectrometer in
accordance with ASTM D3335-85a. Set forth below are suggested surfaces to
be analyzed:
Doors and door frames
Painted woodwork
Stair railings
Chair rails
Window frames, wells and sills
Walls
Any areas of flaking and chipping paint
Exterior hand railings and playground equipment
Other painted surfaces that could be identified as chewable to a child
(typically within 4 feet of the finished floor)
The results of the testing are to be included in the written report along with
recommendations for either no further action, additional testing, remediation or
implementation of a lead based paint O&M program. All recommendations are tobe made in light of existing local lead based paint regulations and must include the
cost for additional testing, remediation of the implementation of an O&M
program.
3.3 Radon
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
21/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
18
Record searches must be completed for multifamily projects, residential proper-
ties, schools, churches, and day care centers only, to determine extent of radon
gas in the Subjects geographical area. If the Subject is in an area of known pro-
pensity of accumulation and exposure, based upon review of records, testing must
be completed to determine if the Subject is experiencing radon levels above the
maximum allowable level, as established by the EPA, of 4 Pci/L per million. If itis determined that the Subject is experiencing higher than maximum allowable
levels of radon gas than the Consultant shall recommend additional investigation
or a probable solution to the problem along with the costs to cure.
3.4 Vehicle Lifts
The Consultant shall observe and note the presence, location and type of all
currently operating and former vehicle lifts. The Consultant shall determine if
these vehicle lifts are underground hydraulic lifts or aboveground lift units and if
any subsurface components are associated with each type of these vehicle lifts.
The Consultant shall visually observe and note areas of patched concrete or pav-
ing in the buildings that may potentially indicate locations of former vehicle lifts.
3.5 Dry Cleaners
NCCI shall be advised by the Consultant, through its due diligence, as to the exis-
tence or former existence of on-site dry cleaning operations. If operations are or
were found to exist on site then the following scope of work shall apply and be
initiated after first consulting with NCCI. The review of all current and past ten-
ants must be performed to determine the existence of current or previous dry
cleaning activities.
In an effort to establish a uniform approach to dry cleaning issues, NCCI recom-
mends the following approach with regard to the performance of on-site dry
cleaning. The purpose is to make sure our liability is limited, to a reasonable extent
without going overboard with Phase II recommendations. In each case, a dry
cleaning Checklist should be completed for each operational dry cleaner.
Operational dry cleaning facilities which have either been present on a prop-
erty for more than 5 years and/or have had more than one owner/operator
will be considered a recognized environmental condition and warrant further
evaluation. Additionally, if a dry cleaner operated on the property and is nolonger present, this would be considered a recognized environmental condition
and further evaluation would be warranted.
It should be noted that this policy is NOT intended to exempt dry cleaning fa-
cilities which have not been present for more than five years from scrutiny
and independent conclusions and recommendations. A recent (< 5 yrs.) dry
cleaning operation will be expected to have appropriate secondary contain-
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
22/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
19
ment, identification and appropriate disposal of all hazardous waste streams,
and appropriate training/maintenance records for all dry cleaning equipment
that use PCE. The Consultant should affirmatively state these conditions ex-
ist in the report.
The Consultant will verify that the dry cleaner is operating in compliance with allapplicable Federal, State and Local laws. This includes, but is not limited to, any
dry cleaning program that each State may have.
Based upon a thorough field investigation of the surrounding area and examination
of waste manifests, etc. the Consultant shall make a determination as to whether
or not it is evident the dry cleaning establishment has conducted business without
incident or detriment to the environment.
If it is determined, through thorough investigation, that the dry cleaning establish-
ment has not apparently contaminated the environment then no further action is
required by NCCI. Notwithstanding, NCCI may require dry-cleaning establish-
ments to maintain an acceptable secondary containment system for storage drumsand any dry-cleaning equipment if deemed necessary by federal, state or local or-
dinances.
If identifiable risks are found to be evident with the handling practices, age, or
day to day operations of the dry cleaning establishment and, in the Consultants
opinion, those practices or operations may have detrimentally affected the envi-
ronment then a Phase II Environmental Site Assessment may be warranted.
3.6 Mold
A limited Mold Screening evaluation must be performed. The purpose of this task is
to provide limited property investigation to allow the NCCI to evaluate the potential
impacts of mold-related issues concerning the Property. The screening involves a
visual assessment for water-damaged areas, and a visual inspection for mold coloni-
zation and areas of amplification (Scope Abelow). Additionally, consultant will rec-
ommend response actions based on the results of visible observations and sampling,
if performed. It should be noted that a recommendation for additional investigation
and sampling may be warranted in certain situations.
As an option, NCCI may request non-culturable sampling to be performed that will
allow identification of genus, and relative density of mold spores on the area affected
(Scopes Aand B, below). As there are currently no regulatory guidelines concerning
exposure to mold, these sampling results can provide useful information regarding
the aggressiveness of mold growth.
A) V isual I nspection: Consultant will inspect interior building components for con-
spicuous visual indications of mold growth and/or water damage.
For multi-family properties, consultant will inspect the following building
components/areas in the representative number of units inspected (typically 10%):
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
23/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
20
- Interior walls and ceilings (bathrooms, kitchens and bedrooms);
- In-unit and common mechanical closets;
- Areas under kitchen and bathroom sinks;
- Flat roofs (for evidence of water ponding);
- Operative status of ventilation equipment (kitchen and bathroom fans).
For retail, office and industrial properties, consultant will inspect the following
building components/areas:
- Interior walls and ceilings;
- Mechanical rooms;
- Flat roofs (for evidence of water ponding).
Additionally, for both property types, consultant will perform the following tasks:
1) Interview the site contact for information related to water damage/intrusion,
mold growth, and tenant complaints;
2) Interview the site contact for information related to maintenance responsibility
(outsourced or in-house staff) history of HVAC equipment, and whether any
operational problems related to moisture accumulation have been identified;
3) Note the presence of olfactory indications of mold (musty odors);
4) Photograph all affected areas observed.
The following activities are excluded from the scope of this limited mold screening.
These activities should not be construed as all-inclusive, nor is it implied that any
exclusion not specifically noted below is a requirement of this screening:
Providing an opinion on the health effects of mold;
Identifying the source of moisture or water leaks conducive to mold growth and
amplification;
Entering of crawl or confined space areas, or determination of previous sub-
structure flooding or water penetration unless easily visible or if such informa-
tion is provided;
Walking on pitched roofs, or any roof areas that appear to be unsafe, or roofs
with no built-in access;
Observation of flue connections, interiors of chimneys, flues or boiler stacks, or
tenant owned or maintained equipment;
Removing or relocating materials, furniture, storage containers, personal effects,
debris material or finishes that obstruct access or visibility;
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
24/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
21
Conducting exploratory probing or testing of materials or equipment, or disman-
tling or operating of equipment or appliances;
Reporting on the condition of subterranean or concealed conditions, as well as
items or systems that are not permanently installed or are tenant owned and
maintained;
Entering or accessing any area of the Property deemed by consultants inspec-
tor to pose a threat to the safety of any individual or to the integrity of any build-
ing system or material.
B) Sampling Option: When the conspicuous presence of mold growth is observed
through visual analysis (as described in Scope A, above), consultant may con-
duct limited non-culturable bulk sampling, via tape lift method of each affected
area, or recommend further investigation by a mold remediation specialist
4.0 INTERVIEWS
Interviews shall be conducted in person, by phone or in writing. Proper supporting
documentation should be provided for all interviews, which should be included in the ESA
report. Questions shall pertain to current and historical activities and events that indicate
potential environmental concerns at the Subject site and adjacent and surrounding proper-
ties. This information shall be used to supplement information obtained through the
Records Review and Site Visit.
In the case of referrals made to other people or agencies, the Consultant shall make
follow-up inquiries, when appropriate. To the extent practical, persons interviewed as a
result of previous environmental site assessments shall be questioned again about newinformation learned since the prior assessment.
The following list of sources and types of information to be investigated is not intended to
be a complete list and only serves as a guide for the completion of this task.
4.1 Site Personnel
Site personnel interviewed shall include, but may not necessarily be limited to, the
site manager, maintenance personnel, employees, occupants, tenants, etc. At a
minimum, the Consultant shall request information concerning the following:
Location, age, and construction materials of all former and current above and be-
low ground storage tanks, in addition to staining and leaks associated with any and
all tanks on the subject property.
Location, age and installation design of all former and current vehicle lifts, opera-
tion and maintenance records of vehicle lifts including frequency, amounts of flu-
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
25/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
22
ids added, reported leaks, and decommissioning and removal activities including
analytical results.
Information concerning historical or current releases to the environment for the
subject site and adjacent and surrounding properties.
Pertinent information regarding the construction, modification and renovation of
the facility, the presence of former and current utilities and other processes or ac-
tivities which may indicate evidence of potential releases to the environment.
Location, age, construction materials, maintenance and operation information of
all former and current product/waste storage areas and drainage systems.
4.2 Federal, State Provincial and Local Officials
Officials interviewed shall include, but may not necessarily be limited to, representativesof the local fire department, representatives from the local health agency, representatives
from the building, planning, utilities departments, etc., and representatives from the agency
is responsible for environmental matters (i.e., concerning spills, releases, violations,
permits, etc.).
4.3 Third Party Personnel
Interviews with third party personnel shall include, but may not necessarily be lim-
ited to, former site owners, nearby property owners, former employees, tenants,
etc.
4.4 Prior Assessment Usage
Persons interviewed as part of a prior Phase I Environmental Site assessments
consistent with this Scope of Work and ASTM Standard 1527 do not need to be
questioned again about the contents of their answers they provided at the time.
However, they should be questioned about new information learned since that
time, or other questions about conditions since the prior Phase I Environmental
Site Assessment.
5.0 PREPARATION OF A REPORT
Consultant shall prepare a report describing the procedures, observations, and recommen-
dation. It is the desire of NCCI to obtain similar report formats for ease of use and
consistent reporting. Accordingly, NCCI recommends using ASTM Standard 1527 as a
guide. Notwithstanding, the format, each report must contain the following essential
elements.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
26/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
23
5.1 Executive Summary
5.1.1 General Description
The opening paragraph should identify the Subject, and provide pertinentinformation such as use, size, age, location, construction type, design style,
and apparent occupancy status.
5.1.2 Conclusions
The Executive Summary shall include a conclusion that summarizes all
recognized environmental conditions connected with the Subject and the
impact of these recognized environmental conditions on the property.
The report shall include one of the following statements:
We have performed a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment in con-
formance with the scope and limitations of ASTM Practice E 1527 and
NCCI Securities International, Inc. for the (Subject). Any exception to,
or deletions from, this practice are described in this report. This assess-
ment has revealed no evidence of recognized environmental conditions in
connection with the Subject, or This assessment has revealed no evi-
dence of recognized environmental conditions in connection with the Sub-
ject except for the following (to be listed).
5.1.3 Project Summary Schedule
A table of the salient aspects of the investigation should be included in theExecutive Summary.
5.1.4 Recommendations
Recommendations for further investigation must be provided in the ESA
if it is determined that further investigation may provide additional clarifi-
cation of a Recognized Environmental Condition, or quantification. In ad-
dition, recommendation for further investigation should be provided for
any areas of environmental uncertainty that warranted further investiga-
tion.
Recommendations may include a file review, Phase II Environmental Site
Assessments, obtain additional supporting documentation from the bor-
rower or third parties, etc.
In making recommendations for additional investigation, the consultant
must recognize that their recommendation must be practical, and give a
clear direction for NCCI.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
27/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
24
When no recognized environmental conditions and no further action is
warranted, a statement must be included in the report.
5.1.5 Operations and Maintenance Plans
Is some instances, typically encountered areas of environmental concern
can be addressed with a routine solution, such as Asbestos and Lead. In
those cases, it is appropriate to recommend the implementation of an op-
erations and maintenance plan.
5.1.6 Cost Estimates
General cost ranges should be provided, which correspond to recommen-
dations.
5.2 Salient Building Facts
Following the Executive Summary, the consult should provide a one page
summary of the salient building facts, such as Name, Location, Size of
Buildings, Rentable Square Footage, Units, Acreage, Parking, Construc-
tion Type, Mechanical Systems, Borrower name, Site Contact, Date of
Walk Through Survey, Person Conducting Site Visit, On-site Contact,
etc.
5.3 Purpose and Scope
Provide a short paragraph specifically stating the purpose of the report.
Subsequently, a general description of the methodologies utilized. This
section should also identify the date of authorization, any supporting
documentation provided by the borrower of their representative, i.e. plans,
rent roll survey, etc., and person interviewed for the ESA.
This section should also describe any material deviations from this scope
of work.
NCCI standard reliance language identified below must be included in this
section of the report.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
28/29
PHASE I ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENTS NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL, INC.
SCOPE OF WORKVersion 3 (May 14, 2002)
25
Nomura Credit & Capital, Inc. and its affiliates (collec-
tively, NCCI), its successors and assigns, rating agencies and certain
investors involved in the Securitization (as defined below) or other dispo-
sition, may use and rely upon this Report in connection with a planned se-
curitization involving the loan secured by the Subject or a whole loan sale
or other disposition of the related loan (collectively, the Securitization).NCCI, at its option, may elect to include selected information contained in
the Report in the Offering Memorandum or other disclosure materials re-
lating to the Securitization and the Consultant agrees to cooperate in an-
swering questions by any of the above parties in connection with the Se-
curitization.
5.6 Exhibits
5.6.1 Photographs
Photographic documentation of the site shall include, but shall not be lim-
ited to, the following:
Typical views of the exterior and interior
Typical views of the surrounding properties
Typical views or representative environmental issues investigated by the
consultant (USTs, ASTs, Transformers, Pits, Ponds, Lagoons, Dry
Cleaner Equipment, Mechanical Rooms, etc.)
All material concerns and/or areas of environmental uncertainty dis-
cussed in the text of the report.
5.6.2 Additional Supporting Documentation
The following additional supporting documentation should be included in
the report, if available:
Database Reports
Topographical Map
Aerial Photographs
Site Plans
Laboratory Results
References
Rent role
Leasing literature, listing for sale, marketing/promotion literature, floor
plans, etc.
8/14/2019 Final Phase I Scope - Nomura Standard.pdf
29/29
Environmental Permits or Registrations
Previous Reports
Any addition information deemed relevant to the report
5.6.3 Questionnaire
Copies of the completed (or incomplete) checklist should be included in
this section.