Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Tahquamenon River Assessment
FIGURES
83
Tahquamenon River Assessment
This page was intentionally left blank.
84
85
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 1.–The Tahquamenon River watershed.
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Con Culhane’s Bridge Trestle
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Seewhy Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLanding Deadman’s
Farm
McNeamey’sFarm
Newberry
DollarvilleFlooding
DollarvilleGhost Town
EmersonGhost Town
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
0 5 10
Miles
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
86
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 2.–Named tributaries to the Tahquamenon River. Names were taken from the United States Geological Survey (USGS) topographic maps and county maps produced by the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) Engineering, Cartographic Services.
1 – Tahquamenon River 2 – Kings Creek 3 – Syphon Creek 4 – Red Creek 5 – East Creek 6 – Silver Creek 7 – East Lake Creek 8 – Carlson Drain 9 – Teaspoon Creek 10 – Otto Brandt Creek 11 – 39 Creek 12 – Sixteen Creek 13 – Auger River 14 – First Creek
15 – West Branch Sage River 16 – Third Creek 17 – Big Ditch 18 – East Branch Sage River 19 – Sage River 20 – Gimlet Creek 21 – Hendrie River 22 – McLeod Ditch 23 – West Branch Hendrie River 24 – South Branch Hendrie River 25 – Quinn Creek 26 – Naugle Creek 27 – East Branch Tahquamenon River 28 – Rileys Creek
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLandingNewberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
1
2
34
56
7 89
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
2122
2324
25 26
27
2829
3031
3233
34 3536
37
3839
40
41
42
0 5 10
Miles
29 – Grant Creek30 – Creek #831 – Creek #1432 – Big Beaver Creek33 – Murphy Creek34 – West Branch Murphy Creek35 – North Branch Murphy Creek36 – Baird Creek37 – O’Keefe Creek38 – Schouts Creek39 – Linton Creek40 – South Branch Linton Creek41 – West Branch Linton Creek42 – Cheney Creek
87
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 3.–Mainstem and East Branch valley segments of the Tahquamenon River.
1 – Upper River Segment2 – Dollarville Segment3 – Marsh Drainage Segment4 – Middle River Segment5 – Lower River Segment6 – East Branch Tahquamenon River
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
Hulbert
McPhee’sLanding
Newberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
1
2 3
4
6
5
0 5 10
Miles
88
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 4.–Major roads within the Tahquamenon River watershed.
1 – M-28 2 – M-117 3 – M-123 4 – H-40 5 – County Road 371 6 – County Road 373 7 – County Road 402 8 – County Road 405
9 – County Road 407 10 – County Road 415 11 – County Road 421 12 – County Road 422 13 – County Road 442 14 – County Road 455 15 – County Road 462 16 – County Road 500
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLanding
Newberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
LakeEastLake
McMillan MudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
1
1
1
2
3
3
3
3
4
5
6
78
9
9
10
10
11
12
13
14
14
14
15
16
17
18
19
2021 22
23
0 5 10
Miles
17 – Belle Lake Road 18 – Camp 7 Road 19 – Charcoal Grade 20 – North Hulbert Road 21 – North Road 22 – Salt Point Road 23 – Skyline Road
89
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 5.–Surface geology of the Tahquamenon River watershed. Data from Farrand and Bell (1982).
End moraines of coarse-textured till
Glacial outwash sand and gravel and postglacial alluvium
Coarse-textured glacial till
Lacustrine sand and gravel
Lacustrine clay and silt
Peat and muck
Thin to discontinuous glacial till over bedrock
Water
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLanding
Newberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
LakeEastLake
McMillan MudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
0 5 10
Miles
90
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 6.–Surface elevation map of the Tahquamenon River watershed and the local surrounding area. An arc connecting A, B, and C follows a former outlet of glacial Lake Minong (a precursor to Lake Superior). Sand dunes were formed around 10,000 years before present at Site A by glacial Lake Minong as a lower outlet (St. Mary’s River) became available. Site B is hypothesized to be a 30-mile wide eddy as the drainageway turned westward toward C, eventually entering into present-day East Branch Fox and Manistique rivers. Site C shows the present divide between the Lake Michigan and Lake Superior watersheds. The horizontal striations along the right side of the picture are due to a data anomaly (Walt Loope, United States Geological Survey, Munising, unpublished data).
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLanding
Newberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
LakeEastLake
McMillan MudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
0 5 10
Miles
Lake SuperiorA
BC
91
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 7.–Wetland composition of the Tahquamenon River watershed, as determined by the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality. Data is from the MDNR Spatial Information Resource Center, unpublished data, 2004.
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLandingNewberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
0 5 10
Miles
92
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 8.–Average monthly yield (mean monthly flow divided by catchment area) for the period of record at three similarly sized Michigan rivers with USGS gauges. Data from Blumer et al. (2004).
Month
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Yie
ld (c
fs/m
i2 )
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
Tahquamenon R. near ParadiseKalamazoo R. near Battle Creek Manistee R. near Sherman
93
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 9.–Sediment sampling locations in the Tahquamenon River, August 22–23, 2005. Samples were taken with a Ponar dredge. Data summary (Table 5) from each site consists of multiple samples taken in cross-section.
Watershed
boundary
Murphy Creek
Gimlet Creek
Joy Island
East Branch
Tahquamenon River
Sage R
iver
Hendrie R
iver
Auger Creek
McPheesLanding
Newberry
Dollarville Dam(Probable upstream limit)
Upper Falls(Downstream limit)
Betty BLanding
0 2 41
Miles
12
34
56
78
910
1112
1314
15
94
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 10.–Land type and use in the Tahquamenon River watershed. Data from MDNR Spatial Information Resource Center, unpublished data, 2004.
Range land
Agricultural land
Forest land
Urban and built up
Wetlands
Water
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLandingNewberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
0 5 10
Miles
95
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 11.–Public land ownership in the Tahquamenon River watershed. State ownership is from the MDNR Spatial Information Resource Center, unpublished data, 2004. The UFS land ownership is from the U.S. Forest Service Office, Escanaba, Michigan, unpublished shapefile data, 2005.
State owned land
USFS land
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLandingNewberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
0 5 10
Miles
96
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 12.–Mainstem elevation changes from Lake Superior to headwaters. River segments are those described in the Tahquamenon River watershed assessment.
Distance from Lake Superior (miles)0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Hei
ght a
bove
Lak
e S
uper
ior (
ft)
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Lowerriver segment
Upperriver segment
Middleriver segment
Marshsegment
Dollarvillesegment
97
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 13.–Dams in the Tahquamenon River watershed (Department of Environmental Quality, Dam Safety Section), modified locally to eliminate earth-bermed, isolated ponds, July 2005.
Known human-built dams
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLandingNewberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
0 5 10
Miles
98
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 14.–Stream classification and temperature data logger locations during 2004 and 2005 for the Tahquamenon River watershed. Classes are defined in Anonymous (2000a).
First quality cold
Second quality cold
Second quality warm
First quality warm
50 - 60°F61 - 65°F66 - 70°F71 - 75°F76+°F
July averagewater temperature
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLandingNewberry
DollarvilleFlooding
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
0 5 10
Miles
99
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 15.–Temperature regime profiles for sites on the Tahquamenon River and selected tributaries. The calculations and format follow the classification system described in Wehrly et al. (1999).
Average July temperature (ºF)
50 55 60 65 70 75 80
Ave
rage
wee
kly
tem
pera
ture
rang
e (º
F)
5
10
15
20
25
Extreme
Moderate
Stable
Cold Cool Warm
11
10 14
13
15
112
8
29
7
4
35
6
1 – Tahquamenon River at County Road 442 Bridge 2 – Tahquamenon River at County Road 415 Bridge 3 – Tahquamenon River at Dollarville Dam, upstream side 4 – Tahquamenon River at Dollarville Dam, downstream side 5 – Tahquamenon River at McPhee’s Landing 6 – Tahquamenon River about 2 miles downstream from Sage River confluence 7 – Tahquamenon River at mouth 8 – East Branch Sage River at M-28 Bridge 9 – East Branch Tahquamenon River at North Hulbert Road Bridge 10 – East Branch Tahquamenon River at old state hatchery site 11 – East Branch Tahquamenon River at Salt Point Road 12 – Sixteen Creek at Charcoal Grade Bridge 13 – Auger Creek at Charcoal Grade Bridge 14 – West Branch Murphy Creek at M-123 Bridge 15 – Gimlet Creek at Charcoal Grade culverts
100
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 16.–Limnological vertical profile sites in the Tahquamenon River, September 1, 2006. Data from these sites are shown in Table 15.
0 2 41
Miles
Watershed
boundary
Murphy Creek
Gimlet CreekJoy Island
East Branch
Tahquamenon River
Sage R
iver
Hendrie R
iver
Auger Creek
McPheesLanding
Newberry
Dollarville Dam
Upper Fallsriver mile 20.5
Betty BLanding
Site Friver mile 26.0
48’ depth
Site Eriver mile 31.5
28’ depth
Site Driver mile 32.5
23’ depthSite C
river mile 33.543’ depth
Site Briver mile 34.5
33’ depthSite Ariver mile 39.0
25’ depth
101
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 17.–Deep holes above the Upper Falls documented from survey data. Mainstem elevation changes from Lake Superior to headwaters. Elevation numbers are height above Lake Superior in feet. Most of the known holes are somewhat smaller than the 0.5 mi figure resolution. Also, some holes may be deeper, as there are several very small diameter deep spots that are easily missed during the sonar graphing effort.
Distance from Lake Superior (miles)0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Hei
ght a
bove
Lak
e S
uper
ior (
ft)
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Lower Falls
Upper Falls
Hendrie RiverSage River
Dollarville Flooding Dam(3’ head)
Deep holes in riverbottom above the falls
102
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 18.–Walleye locations observed by radio tracking in the Tahquamenon River, Middle River segment during April 2005. Data from 13 fish implanted with radio transmitters during October 2004.
0 2 41
Miles
Watershed
boundary
Murphy Creek
Gimlet CreekJoy Island
East Branch
Tahquamenon River
Sage R
iver
Hendrie R
iver
Auger Creek
McPheesLanding
Newberry
Dollarville Dam(Probable upstream limit)
Upper Falls(Downstream limit)
Betty BLanding
103
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 19.–Muskellunge locations observed by radio tracking in the Tahquamenon River, Middle River segment during May 2005. Data from seven fish implanted with radio transmitters during October 2004.
0 2 41
Miles
Watershed
boundary
Murphy Creek
Gimlet CreekJoy Island
East Branch
Tahquamenon River
Sage R
iver
Hendrie R
iver
Auger Creek
McPheesLanding
Newberry
Dollarville Dam(Probable upstream limit)
Upper Falls(Downstream limit)
Betty BLanding
104
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 20.–Location of electrofishing inventory stations in the East Branch Tahquamenon River in 1995 and 2004 (Bassett 2005). There was no Site 1 sampled in 2004. Data from the 2004 survey occur in Table 25.
Slater’s Landing
Betty ‘B’ Landing
McLoed Ditch Hendrie River
Eckerman
M-28M
-123
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
Hulbert
East BranchTahquamenon River
Old RailroadGrade
Lake Superior
2
34
56
78
0 5
Miles
USFS Hiawatha National Forest
105
Tahquamenon River Assessment
Figure 21.–Tahquamenon River watershed access sites and campgrounds.
Lower FallsUpper Falls
Joy Island
USGS Gauging Station
Slater’s Landingprivately owned
Tahquamenon State Parkrivermouth accessand campground
Betty ‘B’Landing
Eckerman
Old Hatcherysite
Natalie
Silver Creek PondBrockies Pond
WolverineLake
Strongs
Hulbert Lake
HulbertMcPhee’sLanding Deadman’s
Farm
Newberry
Dollarville Dam,upstream anddownstream
TwinLakeKaks
Lake
EastLake
McMillanMudLake
BassLake
BelleLakes
TahquamenonLakes
0 5 10
Miles
Lake Superior
Lake Superior
Carry-in or Walk-inBoat launch, shoreline orhard surface (See Table 13)
State Forest campgroundState Park campground
Access
Camping
Tahquamenon River Assessment
This page was intentionally left blank.
106