Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    1/251

    2009 Federal Low Income Housing

    Tax Credit Program

    Application For Reservation

    Virginia Housing Development Authority

    601 South Belvidere Street

    Richmond, Virginia 23220-6500

    Deadline for Submission

    9% Competitive Credits

    Applications Must Be Received At VHDA No Later Than 5:00 PM

    Richmond, VA Time On May 15, 2009

    Tax Exempt Bonds

    Applications should be received at VHDA at least one month

    before the bonds arepriced (if bonds issued by VHDA), or 75

    days before the bonds are issued (if bonds are not issued by

    VHDA)

    2009 v1.4.2009

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    2/251

    Low Income Housing Tax Credit Application for Reservation

    Electronic Copy of the Microsoft Excel Based Application (MANDATORY)

    Hard Copy of All Application Pages With Signature (MANDATORY)

    Scanned Copy of the Tax Credit Application with all Attachments (excluding market study and plans & specs) (MANDATORY)

    $750 Application Fee (MANDATORY)

    Tab A: Documentation of Development Location:

    A.1 Qualified Census Tract CertificationA.2 Revitalization Area Certification

    Location MapSurveyor's Certification of Proximity To Public Transportation

    Tab B: Partnership or Operating Agreement, including chart of ownership structure with percentage of interests (MANDATOR

    Tab C: Virginia State Corporation Commission Certification (MANDATORY)

    Tab D: Principal's Previous Participation Certification and Resum (MANDATORY)

    Tab E: onpro t uest onna re or po nts or pooThe following documents need not be submitted unless requested by VHDA:-Nonprofit Articles of Incorporation-IRS Documentation of Nonprofit Status-Joint Venture Agreement (if applicable)-For-profit Consulting Agreement (if applicable)

    Tab F: Architect's Certification (MANDATORY)

    Tab H: PHA / Section 8 Notification LetterTab I: Local CEO LetterTab J: Homeownership PlanTab K: Site Control Documentation (MANDATORY)

    Tab L: Plan of Development Certification LetterTab M: Zoning Certification LetterTab N: Copies of 8609s To Certify Developer Experience

    Tab O: (Reserved)Tab P: Plans and Specifications and Work Write-Up (MANDATORY)

    Tab Q: Documentation of Rental AssistanceTab R: Documentation of Operating BudgetTab S: Documentation of Project BudgetTab T: Documentation of Financing SourcesTab U: (Reserved)Tab V: Nonprofit or LHA Purchase Option or Right of First RefusalTab W: r g na ttorney s p n on

    Tab X: (Reserved)Tab Y: Marketing Plan for units meeting accessibility requirements of HUD section 504

    Tab Z Market Study (MANDATORY-Application will be disqualified if market study not submitted with the application

    Please indicate if the following items are included with your application by checking the appropriate boxes. Your assistance in

    organizing the submission in the following order, and actually using tabs to mark them as shown, will facilitate review of your

    application. Please note that all mandatory items must be included for the application to be processed. The inclusion of other items may

    increase the number of points for which you are eligible under VHDA's point system of ranking applications, and may assist VHDA in

    its determination of the appropriate amount of credits that it may reserve for the development. You are therefore encouraged to submit

    as much requested information as is available, but their inclusion is not mandatory for review of your application.

    2009 Submission Checklist

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    3/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    VHDA TRACKING NUMBER 2009-Z-054

    I. General Information

    All code "Section" references are to, and the term "IRC" shall be deemed to mean, 5/12/2009

    the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended. (Date of Application)

    A. Development Name and Location:

    1. Name of Development Ferncliff South Apartments

    2. Address of Development 3666 Ferncliff Ave. NW

    (Street)Roanoke VA 24017

    (City) (State) (Zip Code)

    3. If complete address is not available, provide longitude and latitude coordinates (x,y) from

    location on site your surveyor deems appropriate.

    Documentation from surveyor attached (TAB A) (Only necessary if street address or street intersections are not available.

    (Coordinates should be the same as those listed on pg 13, if applicable)

    4. The Circuit Court Clerk's office in which the deed to the property is or will be recorded:

    City/County of Roanoke City (ie; Richmond City, Chesterfield County; see application manual)

    5. Does the site overlap one or more jurisdictional boundaries? Yes No

    If yes, what other City/County is the site located in besides the one mentioned above?

    6. Is the development located in a Metropolitan Statistical Area? Yes No

    7. Census Tract the development is located in: 23

    Is this a Qualified Census Tract: Yes No (If yes, attach required form in TAB A)

    8. Is the development located in a Difficult Development Area? No

    9. Is the development located in a revitalization area? Yes No (If yes, attach required form in TAB A)

    10. Is the development an existing RD or HUD S8/236 development? Yes No (If yes, attach required form in TAB Q)

    Note: If there is an identity of interest between the applicant and the seller in this proposal, and the applicant is seeking points in

    this category, then the applicant must either waive their rights to the developer's fee or other fees associated with acquisition and/or

    rehabilitation, or obtain a waiver of this requirement from VHDA prior to application submission to receive these points.

    a. Applicant agrees to waive all rights to any developer's fee or

    other fees associated with acquisition and/or rehab. Yes n/a

    b. Applicant has obtained a waiver of this requirement from VHDA

    prior to the application submission deadline. Yes n/a

    11. Is the development located in a census tract with a poverty

    rate

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    4/251

    Low Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    C. Reservation Request

    1. Total annual credit amount request (Must be the same as Part IX-D8) $360,863ec cre t amount,

    2. Credits requested from:

    9% Credits

    Nonprofit Set-Aside (All nonprofit owned developments which meet tests

    described in Part II-D hereof may select this)Local Housing Authorities Tidewater MSA Pool

    Northern Virginia MSA Pool Small MSA/Micropolitan Pool

    Richmond MSA Pool Rural Pool

    Non-Competitive Pool (Preservation) Non-Competitive Pool (Disability)

    Tax Exempt Bonds

    new construction, or

    rehabilitation, or

    acquisition and rehabilitation.

    Federal SubsidiesThe development will not receive federal subsidies.

    This development will receive federal subsidies for:

    all buildings or

    some buildings.

    D. Type(s) of Allocation/Allocation Year

    1. Regular Allocation

    All of the buildings in the development are expected to be placed

    in service this year. For those buildings the owner will, this year, request an

    allocation of 2008 credits for new construction, or

    rehabilitation, or

    acquisition and rehabilitation.

    2. Carryforward Allocation

    All of the buildings in the development are expected to be placedin service within two years after the end of this calendar year, 2009, but the

    owner will have more than 10% basis in the development before the end of six

    months following allocation of credits. For those buildings, the owner requests

    a carryforward allocation of 2009 credits pursuant to Section 42(h)(1)(E) for:

    new construction, or

    rehabilitation, or

    acquisition and rehabilitation (even if you acquired a building this year and

    "placed it in service" for the purpose of the acquisition credit, you cannot receive

    the 8609 form for it until the rehab 8609 is issued for that building once the rehab

    work is "placed in service" in 2010 or 2011).

    3. Federal Subsidies

    The development will not receive federal subsidies.

    This development will receive federal subsidies for:

    all buildings or

    some buildings.

    2009 Page 2

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    5/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    E. Acquisition Credit Information

    NOTE: If no credits are being requested for existing buildings being acquired for the development,

    so indicate and go on to Part F: No Acquisition

    Ten-Year Rule For Acquisition Credits

    All buildings satisfy the 10-year look-back rule of IRC Section 42 (d)(2)(B), including the10% basis/ 15,000.00 rehab costs ( 10,000 for Tax Exempt Bonds) per unit requirement.

    All buildings qualify for an exception to the 10-year rule under IRC Section 42(d)(2)(D)(i),Subsection (I)

    Subsection (II)

    Subsection (III)

    Subsection (IV)Subsection (V)

    A waiver of the 10-year rule for all buildings has been or will be requested from the

    Department of the Treasury pursuant to IRC Section 42(d)(6)(B)

    Different circumstances for different buildings: Attach a separate sheet and explain for eachbuilding.

    F. Rehabilitation Credit Information

    NOTE: If no credits are being requested for rehabilitation expenditures, so indicate and go

    on to Section II. No Rehabilitation

    Minimum Expenditure Requirements

    All buildings in the development satisfy the rehab costs per unit requirement of IRCSection 42(e)(3)(A)(ii).

    All buildings in the development qualify for the IRC Section 42(e)(3)(B) exception to the10% basis requirement (4% credit only).

    All buildings in the development qualify for the IRC Section 42(f)(5)(B)(ii)(II) exception.

    Different circumstances for different buildings. Attach a separate sheet andexp a n or eac u ng.

    2009 Page 3

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    6/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    II. OWNERSHIP INFORMATION

    A. Owner Information:

    Name Ferncliff South Preservation, L.P.

    Contact Person First: Matthew Middle: K Last: Finkle

    Address 60 Columbus Circle(Street)

    New York NY 10023(City) (State) (Zip Code)

    Federal I. D. No. 27-0153822 (If not available, obtain prior to Allocation)Phone 212-801-1073 Fax 212-801-3731 Email address [email protected]

    Type of entity: Limited Partnership Other

    Individual(s) Corporation

    Owner's organizational documents (e.g. Partnership agreements) attached (Mandatory TAB B)Certification from Virginia State Corporation Commission attached (Mandatory TAB C)

    Principal(s) involved (e.g. general partners, LLC members, controlling shareholders, etc.)Names ** Phone Type Ownership % OwnershipStephen M. Ross 212-421-5333 Member 59.69%Jeff T. Blau 212-421-5333 Member 5.52%Bruce A. Beal/Michael Brenner 212-421-5333 Member 3.80%Mark E. Carbone/Matthew Finkle 212-421-5333 Member 21.00%Akiim Kiambu Barber 212-421-5333 Member 5.10%Mark Lepselter/Drew Sheinman 212-421-5333 Member 3.68%Joseph A. Baratta/Arthur L. Aidala 212-421-5333 Member 1.23%

    This should be 100% of the GP or managing member interest: 100.00%

    ** These should be the names of individuals who comprise the GP or managing members, not simply the names ofseparate partnerships or corporations which may comprise those components.

    Principals' Previous Participation Certification attached (Mandatory TAB D), resum, & ownership structure char

    B. Seller Information:

    Name Ferncliff South LP Contact Person Charles NimmoAddress 3130 Chaparral Drive, Suite 200Roanoke, VA 24018 Phone 540-774-1641

    Is there an identity of interest between the seller and owner/applicant? Yes No

    If yes, complete the following:

    Principal(s) involved (e.g. general partners, controlling shareholders, etc.)

    Names Phone Type Ownership % Ownership

    0.00%

    0.00%

    0.00%

    0.00%

    NOTE: VHDA may allocate credits only to the tax-paying entity which owns the development at the time of the allocation. The term "Owner" herein refers to that entity. Please fill in the legal

    name of the owner. The ownership entity must be formed prior to submitting this application. Any transfer, direct or indirect, of partnership interests (except those involving the admission of

    limited partners) prior to the placed-in-service date of the proposed development shall be prohibited, unless the transfer is consented to by VHDA in its sole discretion. IMPORTANT: The

    Owner name listed on this page must match exactly the owner name listed on the Virginia State Corporation Commission Certification.

    Must be an individual or legally formed entity

    2009 Page 4

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    7/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    C. Development Team Information:

    Complete the following as applicable to your development team.

    1. Tax Attorney: H. David Embree Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: Williams MullenAddress: 1700 Dominion Tower, P.O. Box 3460, Norfolk, VA 23514

    Phone: 757-629-0608 Fax: 757-629-0660

    2. Tax Accountant: Joseph Crivelli Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: Friedman, LLPAddress: 1700 Broadway, New York, NY 10019

    Phone: 212-842-7550 Fax: 212-265-4761

    3. Consultant: None Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: Role:Address:

    Phone: Fax:

    4. Management Entity (Contact): Charles Nimmo Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: F&W ManagementAddress: 3130 Chaparral Drive, Roanoke, VA24018

    Phone: 540-774-1641 Fax: 540-774-2488

    5. Contractor (Contact): William C. Barton Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: Linden Contracting, Inc.Address: 1212 Butterworth Ct., Stevensville, MD 21666

    Phone: 410-643-8822 Fax: 410-643-8604

    6. Architect: Donald R. Witt Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: Hughes Associates ArchitectsAddress: 656 Elm Ave, SW, P.O. Box 1034, Roanoke, VA 24005-1034

    Phone: 540-342-4002 Fax: 540-342-2060

    7. Real Estate Attorney: David Boccio Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: Michael, Levitt & Rubenstein, LLCAddress: 60 Columbus Circle, New York, NY 10023

    Phone: 212-801-3739 Fax: 212-801-3762

    8. Mortgage Banker: Charles Wilson Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: Virginia Capital Advisors, Inc.Address: 1915 Pocahontas Trail, Suite B-5, Williamsburg, VA 23185

    Phone: 757-220-3147 Fax: 757-220-5764

    9. Other (Contact): Michael Antonik Related Entity? Yes NoFirm Name: PresCon, LLC Role:Address: 60 Columbus Circle, New York, NY 10023

    Phone: 212-801-1067 Fax: 212-801-3731

    2009 Page 5

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    8/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    D. Nonprofit Involvement:

    Tax Credit Nonprofit Pool Applicants: To qualify for the nonprofit pool, an organization described in IRC Section 501

    (c)(3) or 501 (c)(4) and exempt from taxation under IRC Section 501 (a), whose purposes include the fostering of low-income housing:

    1. Must "materially participate" in the development and operation of the project throughout the compliance period,2. Must own all general partnership interests in the development .

    3. Must not be affiliated with or controlled by a for-profit organization.

    4. Must not have been formed for the principal purpose of competition in the nonprofit pool, and

    5. Must not have any staff member, or member of the nonprofit's board of directors materially participate in the proposed project

    as a for-profit entity.

    pp cants: To qualify for points under the ranking system, the nonprofit's involvement need not necessarily

    satisfy all of the requirements for participation in the nonprofit tax credit pool

    1. Nonprofit Involvement (All Applicants)

    If there is no nonprofit involvement in this development, please indicate by checking hereand go on to part III

    2. Mandatory QuestionnaireIf there is nonprofit involvement, you must complete the Non-Profit Questionnair

    Questionnaire attached (Mandatory TAB E)

    3. Type of involvement

    Nonprofit meets eligibility requirement for points only, not pool o

    Nonprofit meets eligibility requirements for nonprofit pool and points

    4. Identity of Nonprofit (All nonprofit applicants)The nonprofit organization involved in this development is

    the Owner

    the Applicant (if different from Owner)

    Other

    (Name of nonprofit)

    (Contact Person) (Street Address)

    (City) (State) (Zip code)

    (Phone) (Fax)

    5. Percentage of Nonprofit Ownership (All nonprofit applicants)

    Specify the nonprofit entity's percentage ownership of the general partnership interest: 0.0%

    Applications For 9% Credits - Must be completed in order to compete in the nonprofit tax credit pool.

    All Applicants - Must be completed for points for nonprofit involvement under the ranking system.

    2009 Page 6

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    9/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    III. DEVELOPMENT INFORMATION

    A. Structure and Units:1. Total number ofall units in development 84

    Total number ofrental units in development 84 bedrooms 180

    Number of low-income rental units 84 bedrooms 180Percentage of rental units designated low-income 100.00%

    2. The development's structural features are (check all that apply):

    Row House/Townhouse Detached Single-family

    Garden Apartments Detached Two-family

    Slab on Grade Basement

    Crawl space Age of Structure: 31

    Elevator Number of stories: 3

    3. Number of new units 0 bedrooms 0Number of adaptive reuse units 0 bedrooms 0Number of rehab units 84 bedrooms 180

    4. Total Floor Area For The Entire Development 90,552.23 (Sq. ft.)

    . n eate oor rea (Breezeways, Balconies, Storage) , . (Sq. ft.)

    6. Nonresidential Commercial Floor Area 0.00 (Sq. ft.)(Not eligible for funding)

    7. Total Usable Residential Heated Area 81,888.56 (Sq. ft.)

    8. Number of Buildings (containing rental units) 7

    9. Commercial Area Intended Use: NA

    10. Project consists primarily of a building(s) which is (are) (CHOOSE ONLY ONE)

    Low-Rise (1-5 stories with any structural elements made of wood)

    Mid-Rise (5-7 stories with no structural elements made of wood)

    High-Rise (8 or more stories with no structural elements made of wood)

    B. Building Systems:

    Please describe each of the following in the space provided.Community Facilities: Playground, Laundry Facilities, Leasing Office

    Exterior Finish: T1-11 siding with bottom brick

    Heating/AC System: Heat: Electric Heat Pump, A/C: Split System

    Architectural Style: Garden Style, Pitched Roof

    2009 Page 7

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    10/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    C. Amenities:

    1. Specify the average size per unit type: (Including pro rata share of heated common area)Assisted Lvg 0.00 SF 1Bdrm Eld 0.00 SF 3-Bdrm Gar 1,160.77 SF1-Sty-Eff-Eld 0.00 SF 2Bdrm Eld 0.00 SF 4-Bdrm Gar 0.00 SF1-Sty 1BR-Eld 0.00 SF Eff-Gar 0.00 SF 2-Bdrm TH 0.00 SF1-Sty 2BR-Eld 0.00 SF 1-Bdrm Gar 738.66 SF 3-Bdrm TH 0.00 SFEff-Eld 0.00 SF 2-Bdrm Gar 940.96 SF 4-Bdrm TH 0.00 SF

    2. Total gross usable, heated square feet for the entire project less nonresidential commercial area:

    81,888.56 Documentation attached (TAB F) Mandatory(Sq. ft.)

    NOTE: All developments must meet VHDA's Minimum Design and Construction Requirements.

    By signing and submitting the Application For Reservation of Low Income Housing Tax Credits theapplicant certifies that the proposed project budget, plans & specifications and work write-ups incorporateall necessary elements to fulfill these requirements.

    . hec the o ow ng tems wh ch app y to the proposed pro ect:Documentation attached (TAB F Architect Certification) Mandatory

    For any project, upon completion of construction/rehabilitation: (Optional Point items)

    0% a(1) Percentage of 2-bedroom units that have 1.5 bathrooms

    0% a(2) Percentage of 3 or more bedroom units that have 2 bathrooms

    b. A community/meeting room with a minimum of 749 square feet is provided

    27% c. Percentage of exterior walls covered by brick (excluding triangular gable ends, doors and windows)d. All kitchen and laundry appliances meet the EPA's Energy Star qualified program requirements

    e. All windows meet the EPA's Energy Star qualified program requirements

    f. Every unit in the development is heated and air conditioned with either (i) heat pump units with both arat ng o . or more and a rat ng o . or more and a var ab e speed a r hand ng un t

    (for through- the-wall heat pump equipment that has an EER rating of 11.0 or more), or (ii) airconditioning units with a SEER rating of 14.0 or more and a variable speed air handling unit, combinedwith gas furnaces with an AFUE rating of 90% or more

    g. Water expense is sub-metered (the tenant will pay monthly or bi-monthly bill)

    h. Each bathroom consists only of low-flow faucets (2.2 gpm max.) and showerheads (2.5gpm max.)

    i. Provide necessary infrastructure in all units for high speed cable, DSL or wireless internet sevice

    j. All water heaters meet the EPA's Energy Star qualified program requirements.

    2009 Page 8

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    11/251

    Low Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    For all projects exclusively serving elderly and/or handicapped tenants, upon completionof construction/rehabilitation: (Optional Point items)

    a. All cooking ranges will have front controls

    b. All units will have an emergency call system

    c. All bathrooms will have an independent or supplemental heat source

    d. All entrance doors have two eye viewers, one at 48" and the other at standard height

    For all rehabilitation and adaptive reuse projects, upon completion of construction or

    or rehabilitation: (Optional Point items)

    The structure is listed individually in the National Register of Historic Places or islocated in a registered historic district and certified by the Secretary of the Interior asbeing of historical significance to the district, and the rehabilitation will be completedin such a manner as to be eligible for historic rehabilitation tax credits

    Accessibility

    Checkone or none of the following point categories, as appropriate:

    For any non-elderly property in which the greater of 5 or 10% of the units (i) provide federal project-based rent subsidies o

    equivalent assistance in order to ensure occupancy by extremely low-income persons; (ii) conform to HUD regulationinterpreting accessibility requirements of section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act; and (iii) are actively marketed to people witspecial needs in accordance with a plan submitted as part of the Application. (If special needs include mobility impairmentthe units described above must include roll-in showers and roll under sinks and front controls for ranges).

    For any non-elderly property in which the greater of 5 or 10% of the units (i) have rents within HUDs Housing ChoicVoucher (HCV) payment standard; (ii) conform to HUD regulations interpreting accessibility requirements of section 504 othe Rehabilitation Act; and (iii) are actively marketed to people with mobility impairments, including HCV holders, iaccordance with a plan submitted as part the Application.

    For any non-elderly property in which at least four percent (4%) of the units conform to HUD regulations interpretingaccessibility requirements of section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and are actively marketed to people with mobilitimpairments in accordance with a plan submitted as part of the Application.

    Earthcraft or LEED Development CertificationApplicant agrees to obtain Earthcraft or LEED certification prior to issuance of IRS Form 8609. Architectcertifies in the Architect Certification that the development's design will meet the criteria for such certification

    Yes - Earthcraft Yes - LEED

    If Yes to either, attach appropriate documentation at TAB F

    LEED Accredited Design Team MemberOne or more members of the design team is a LEED accredited professional.

    Yes No If Yes, attach appropriate documentation at TAB F

    Universal Design - Units Meeting Universal Design Standards

    a. The architect of record certifies that units will be constructed to meet VHDA's Universal Design standards.Yes No If Yes, attach appropriate documentation at TAB F

    b. Number of Rental Units constructed to meet VHDA's Universal Design standards:0 Units 0%

    VHDA Certified Property Management AgentOwner agrees to use a VHDA Certified Property Management Agent to manage the property.

    Yes No

    Yes No N/A The market-rate units' amenities are substantially equivalent to those of thlow-income units. If no, explain differences:

    2009 Page 9

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    12/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    IV. TENANT INFORMATION

    A. Set-Aside Election: UNITS SELECTED BELOW IN BOTH COLUMNS DETERMINE

    POINTS FOR THE BONUS POINT CATEGORY

    Units Provided Per Household Type:

    # of Units % of Units # of Units % of Units

    0 0.00% 40% Area Median 10 11.90% 40% Area Median84 100.00% 50% Area Median 74 88.10% 50% Area Median0 0.00% 60% Area Median 0 0.00% 60% Area Median0 0.00% Non-LMI Units 0 0.00% Non-LMI Units

    84 100.00% Total 84 100.00% Total

    B. Special Housing Needs/Leasing Preference:

    1. If 100% of the low-income units will be occupied by either or both of the following special needsgroups as defined by the United States Fair Housing Act, so indicate:

    Yes Elderly (age 55 or above)

    Yes Physically or mentally disabled persons (must meet the requirements of the federalAmericans with Disabilities Act)

    2. Specify the number of low-income units that will serve individuals and families with children byproviding three or more bedrooms: Number of units 29% of total low-income units

    3. If the development has existing tenants, VHDA policy requires that the impact of economic and/or physical

    displacement on those tenants be minimized, in which Owners agree to abide by the Authority's RelocationGuidelines for LIHTC properties.

    4. If leasing preference will be given to applicants on public housing waiting list and/or Section 8waiting list, so indicate:

    Yes

    No

    Locality has no such waiting list; If yes, provide the following information:

    Organization which holds such waiting list: Roanoke Redevelopment and Housing AuthorityContact person (Name and Title) Helen Shampshire - Housing Choice Vouchers Administrator

    Phone Number 540-983-9218 Required documentation attached (TAB H)

    5. If leasing preference will be given to individuals and families with children.

    (Less than or equal to 20% of the units must have of 1 or less bedrooms).

    Yes

    No

    Income Levels Rent Levels

    24

    Note: In order to qualify for any tax credits, a development must meet one of two minimum threshold occupancy tests. Either (i) at least 20% of the units

    must be rent-restricted and occupied by persons whose incomes are 50% or less of the area median income adjusted for family size (this is called the 20/50

    test) or (ii) at least 40% of the units must be rent-restricted and occupied by persons whose incomes are 60% or less of the area median income adjusted for

    family size (this is called the 40/60 test), all as described in Section 42 of the IRC. Rent-and income-restricted units are known as low-income units. If youhave more low-income units than required, you qualify for more credits. If you serve lower incomes than required, you receive more points under the rankin

    system.

    2009 Page 10

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    13/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    V. LOCAL NEEDS AND SUPPORT

    A. Provide the name and the address of the chief executive officer (City Manager, Town Manager, or

    County Administrator) of the political jurisdiction in which the development will be located:

    Chief Executive Officer's Name Darlene L. Burcham

    Chief Executive Officer's Title City Manager

    Street Address 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Phone 540-853-2333

    City Roanoke State VA Zip 24011

    Name and title of local official you have discussed this project with who could answer questions for thelocal CEO: Angie Williamson, Neighborhood Service

    Letter from CEO attached (TAB I) CEO letter to be submitted separately by June 1, 2009

    VHDA notification letter to CEO submitted prior to 5:00 PM 3/5/09: (9% competitive credits only) Yes No

    If the property overlaps another jurisdiction please fill in the following:

    Chief Executive Officer's NameChief Executive Officer's TitleStreet Address PhoneCity State Zip

    Name and title of local official you have discussed this project with who could answer questions for th

    local CEO:Letter from CEO attached (TAB I) CEO letter to be submitted separately by June 1, 2009

    VHDA notification letter to CEO submitted prior to 5:00 PM 3/5/09: (9% competitive credits only) Yes No

    B. Project Schedule

    ACTUAL OR NAME OF

    ACTIVITY ANTICIPATED PERSON

    DATE RESPONSIBLE

    Site

    Option/Contract 9/11/2007 Mark Carbone

    Site Acquisition 11/1/2009 Mark Carbone

    Zoning Approval naSite Plan Approval na

    Financing

    A. Construction Loan

    Loan Application 7/15/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Conditional Commitment 9/1/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Firm Commitment 10/1/2009 Matthew Finkle

    B. Permanent Loan - First Lien

    Loan Application 7/15/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Conditional Commitment 9/1/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Firm Commitment 10/1/2009 Matthew Finkle

    C. Permanent Loan-Second Lien

    Loan Application 7/15/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Conditional Commitment 9/1/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Firm Commitment 10/1/2009 Matthew Finkle

    D. Other Loans & GrantsType & Source, List

    Application 5/15/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Award/Commitment 8/5/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Formation of Owner 5/1/2009 Matthew Finkle

    IRS Approval of Nonprofit Status na

    Closing and Transfer of Property to Owner 11/1/2009 Matthew Finkle

    Plans and Specifications, Working Drawings 5/1/2009 Michael Antonik

    Building Permit Issued by Local Government 10/1/2009 Michael Antonik

    Start Construction 12/1/2009 Michael Antonik

    Begin Lease-up in-place rehab

    Complete Construction 8/1/2010 Michael Antonik

    Complete Lease-Up in-place rehab

    Credit Placed in Service Date 11/1/2010 Matthew Finkle2009 Page 11

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    14/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    VI. SITE CONTROL

    A. Type of Site Control by Owner:

    Applicant controls site by (select one and attach document - Mandatory TAB K)Deed - attached

    Long-term Lease - attached (expiration date: )

    Option - attached (expiration date: )

    Purchase Contract - attached (expiration date: 01/01/11 )

    If more than one site for the development and more than one form of site control, please so indicateand attach a separate sheet specifying each site, number of existing buildings on the site, if any,

    type of control of each site, and applicable expiration date of form of site control. A site controldocument is required for each site.

    B. Timing of Acquisition by Owner:

    Select one:

    Owner already controls site by either deed or long-term lease or

    Owner is to acquire property by deed (or lease for period no shorter than period propertywill be subject to occupancy restrictions) no later than 11/01/09 (must be prior to November 6, 2009).

    If more than one site for the development and more than one expected date of acquisition byOwner, please so indicate and attach separate sheet specifying each site, number of existingbuildings on the site, if any, and expected date of acquisition of each site by the Owner.

    C. Market Study Data:

    Obtain the following information from the Market Study conducted in connection with this tax credit application and enter below:

    Project Wide Capture Rate - LIHTC Units

    Project Wide Capture Rate - Market Units

    Project Wide Capture Rate - All Units

    Project Wide Absorption Period (Months)

    4.20%

    na

    4.20%

    7 mos

    Note: Site control by the Owner identified herein is a mandatory precondition of review of this application. Documentaryevidence of it,

    in the form of either a deed, option, purchase contract, or lease for a term longer than the period of time the property will be subject to

    occupancy restrictions must be included herewith. (9% Competitive Credits - An option or contract must extend beyond the

    application deadline by a minimum of four months.)

    Warning: Site control by an entity other than the Owner, even if it is a closely related party, is not sufficient. Anticipated future transfers

    to the Owner are not sufficient. The Owner, as identified in Subpart II-A, must have site control at the time this Application is

    submitted.

    NOTE: If the Owner receives a reservation of credits, the property must be titled in the name of or leased by (pursuant to a long-term

    lease) the Owner before the allocation of credits is made this year.

    Contact us before you submit this application if you have any questions about this requirement.

    2009 Page 12

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    15/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    C. Site Description

    1. Exact area of site in acres 7.451

    2. Has locality approved a final site plan or plan of development?

    Yes No

    Required documentation form attached (TAB L)

    3. Is site properly zoned for the proposed development?

    Yes No

    Required documentation form attached (TAB M)

    4. Will the proposal seek to qualify for points associated with proximity to public transportation?

    Yes No

    Required documentation form attached (TAB A)

    D. Photographs

    Include photographs of the site and any existing structure(s) inTAB O. For rehabilitation projects,

    provide interior pictures which document the necessity of the proposed work

    E. Plans and Specifications

    Minimum submission requirements for all properties (new construction, rehabilitation and adaptive reuse)

    1. A location map with property clearly defined.

    2. Sketch plan of the site showing overall dimensions of main building(s), major site elements

    (e.g., parking lots and location of existing utilities, and water, sewer, electric,

    gas in the streets adjacent to the site). Contour lines and elevations are not required.

    3. Sketch plans of main building(s) reflecting overall dimensions of:

    a. Typical floor plan(s) showing apartment types and placement

    b. Ground floor plan(s) showing common areas;

    c. Sketch floor plan(s) of typical dwelling unit(s);

    d. Typical wall section(s) showing footing, foundation, wall and floor structure.

    Notes must indicate basic materials in structure, floor and exterior finish.

    In addition: required documentation for rehabilitation properties

    A unit-by-unit work write-up.

    Plans and specifications/unit-by-unit work writeup attached(TAB P) or

    Plans and specifications/unit-by-unit work writeup submitted separately

    2009 Page 13

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    16/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    VII. OPERATING BUDGET

    A. Rental Assistance

    1. Do or will any low-income units receive rental assistance?

    Yes No

    2. If yes, indicate type of rental assistance:

    Section 8 New Construction Substantial Rehabilitation

    Section 8 Moderate RehabilitationSection 8 Certificates

    Section 8 Project Based Assistance

    RD 515 Rental Assistance

    Section 8 Vouchers

    State Assistance

    Other:

    3. Number of units receiving assistance: 84

    Number of years in rental assistance contract: 40

    Expiration date of contract: 02/01/18

    Contract or other agreement attached (TAB Q)

    B. Utilities

    1. Monthly Utility Allowance Calculations

    Utilities Type of Utility Utilities Enter Allowances by Bedroom Size

    (Gas, Electric, Oil, etc.) Paid by: 0-bdr 1-bdr 2-bdr 3-bdr 4-br

    Heating Electric Owner X Tenant 0 72 75 93 0

    Air Conditioning Electric Owner X Tenant 0 0 0 0 0

    Cooking Electric Owner X Tenant 0 0 0 0 0

    Lighting Electric Owner X Tenant 0 0 0 0 0

    Hot Water Electric Owner X Tenant 0 0 0 0 0

    Water Water X Owner Tenant 0 0 0 0 0

    Sewer Sewer X Owner Tenant 0 0 0 0 0

    Trash Trash X Owner Tenant 0 0 0 0 0

    Total utility allowance for costs paid by tenant $0 $72 $75 $93 $0

    2. Source of Utility Allowance Calculation (Attach Documentation TAB Q)

    HUD

    Utility Company (Estimate) Local PHA

    Utility Company (Actual Survey) Other:

    2009 Page 14

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    17/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    C. Revenue1. Indicate the estimated monthly income for the Low-Income Units: **

    Total Number of Total Monthly

    Tax Credit Units Rental Income

    0 $0

    12 $5,424

    48 $26,832

    24 $15,168

    0 $0

    84

    Plus Other Income Source (list): Laundry, Tenant Charges $321

    Equals Total Monthly Income: $47,745

    Twelve Months x12

    Equals Annual Gross Potential Income $572,940

    Less Vacancy Allowance ( 7.0% ) $40,106

    Equals Annual Effective Gross Income (EGI) - Low Income Unit $532,834

    ** Beginning at Row 75 enter the appropriate data for both tax credit and market rate units in the yellow shaded cells.

    2. Indicate the estimated monthly income for the Market Rate Units: **

    Total Number of Total Monthly

    Market Units Rental Income

    0 $0

    0 $0

    0 $00 $0

    0 $0

    Total Number of Market Units 0

    Plus Other Income Source (list): $0

    Equals Total Monthly Income: $0

    Twelve Months x12

    Equals Annual Gross Potential Income $0

    Less Vacancy Allowance ( 0.0% ) $0

    Equals Annual Effective Gross Income (EGI) - Market Rate Units $0

    Documentation in Support of Operating Budget attached (TAB R)

    List number of units by type: TOTAL UNITS

    ASSISTED LVG EFF-ELD 1 BD RM-ELD 2 BD RM-ELD EFF-GAR 1 BD RM-GAR

    0 0 0 0 0 12

    2 BD RM-GAR 3 BD RM-GAR 4 BD RM-GAR 2 BD RM-TH 3 BD RM-TH 4 BD RM-TH

    48 24 0 0 0 0

    1 STY-EFF-ELD 1 STY-1 BR-ELD 1 STY-2 BR-ELD Note: Please be sure to enter the number of units in the

    0 0 0 appropriateunit category. If not, you will find an error on

    the scoresheet at 5a, 6a & 6b.

    List number of units by type: TAX CREDIT UNITS

    ASSISTED LVG EFF-ELD 1 BD RM-ELD 2 BD RM-ELD EFF-GAR 1 BD RM-GAR

    0 0 0 0 0 12

    2 BD RM-GAR 3 BD RM-GAR 4 BD RM-GAR 2 BD RM-TH 3 BD RM-TH 4 BD RM-TH

    48 24 0 0 0 0

    1 STY-EFF-ELD 1 STY-1 BR-ELD 1 STY-2 BR-ELD

    0 0 0

    Efficiency Units

    Unit Type / Net Rentable Monthly Rent Total

    Rent Targeting Number Units Square Feet Per Unit Monthly Rent

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 Bedroom Units

    1 Bedroom Units

    2 Bedroom Units3 Bedroom Units

    Efficiency Units

    4 Bedroom Units

    Unit Type

    Unit Type

    1 Bedroom Units

    2 Bedroom Units

    3 Bedroom Units

    Total Number of Tax Credit Units

    Efficiency Units

    2009 Page 15

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    18/251

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Total Efficiency Total Monthly Eff.

    Tax Credit Units: 0 0.00 Tax Credit Rent: -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Efficiency - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Total Efficiency

    Market Units: 0 0.00 Total Monthly

    Eff. Market Rent: -$

    Total Eff. Units: 0 Total Eff. Rent -$

    1-Bedroom Units

    Net Rentable Monthly Rent Total

    Rent Targeting Number Units Square Feet Per Unit Monthly Rent

    1 BR - 40% 1 658.32 452$ 452$2009 Page 15

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    19/251

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    20/251

    2-Bedroom Units

    Net Rentable Monthly Rent Total

    Rent Targeting Number Units Square Feet Per Unit Monthly Rent

    2 BR - 40% 5 863.11 559$ 2,795$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 43 863.11 559$ 24,037$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Total 2-BR Total Monthly 2-BR

    Tax Credit Units: 48 41,429.35 Tax Credit Rent: 26,832$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$2009 Page 15

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    21/251

    Total 2-BR

    Market Units: 0 0.00 Total Monthly

    2-BR Market Rent: -$

    Total 2-BR Units: 48 Total 2-BR Rent 26,832$

    3-Bedroom Units

    Net Rentable Monthly Rent Total

    Rent Targeting Number Units Square Feet Per Unit Monthly Rent

    3 BR - 40% 3 1,044.38 632$ 1,896$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 21 1,044.38 632$ 13,272$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Total 3-BR Total Monthly 3-BR

    Tax Credit Units: 24 25,065.18 Tax Credit Rent: 15,168$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    2009 Page 15

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    22/251

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    3 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Total 3-BR

    Market Units: 0 0.00 Total Monthly

    3-BR Market Rent: -$

    Total 3-BR Units: 24 Total 3-BR Rent 15,168$

    4-Bedroom Units

    Net Rentable Monthly Rent Total

    Rent Targeting Number Units Square Feet Per Unit Monthly Rent

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 40% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 50% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - 60% 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Total 4-BR Total Monthly 4-BR

    Tax Credit Units: 0 0.00 Tax Credit Rent: -$

    2009 Page 15

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    23/251

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    4 BR - Market 0 0.00 -$ -$

    Total 4-BR

    Market Units: 0 0.00 Total Monthly

    4-BR Market Rent: -$

    Total 4-BR Units: 0 Total 4-BR Rent -$

    Total Units 84 Net Rentable SF: TC Units 74,388.72

    MKT Units 0.00

    Total NR SF: 74,388.72

    100.0000%Floor Space Fraction

    2009 Page 15

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    24/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    D. Operating Expenses

    Administrative:

    1. Advertising/Marketing $6,550

    2. Office Salaries $0

    3. Office Supplies $6,275

    4. Office/Model Apartment (type______) $0

    5. Management Fee $22,764

    4.27% of EGI 271 Per Unit

    6. Manager Salaries $27,713

    7. Staff Unit (s) (type______) $08. Legal $1,300

    9. Auditing $12,000

    10. Bookkeeping/Accounting Fees $0

    11. Telephone & Answering Service $4,375

    12. Tax Credit Monitoring Fee $2,100

    13. Miscellaneous Administrative $5,950

    Total Administrative $89,027

    Utilities

    14. Fuel Oil $0

    15. Electricity $15,925

    16. Water $19,600

    17. Gas $0

    18. Sewer $18,650

    Total Utility $54,175

    Operating:

    19. Janitor/Cleaning Payroll $0

    20. Janitor/Cleaning Supplies $3,575

    21. Janitor/Cleaning Contract $2,00022. Exterminating $1,900

    23. Trash Removal $9,300

    24. Security Payroll/Contract $31,000

    25. Grounds Payroll $0

    26. Grounds Supplies $550

    27. Grounds Contract $5,625

    28. Maintenance/Repairs Payroll $47,991

    29. Repairs/Material $14,575

    30. Repairs Contract $2,500

    31. Elevator Maintenance/Contract $0

    32. Heating/Cooling Repairs & Maintenance $2,450

    33. Pool Maintenance/Contract/Staff $0

    34. Snow Removal $300

    35. Decorating/Payroll/Contract $0

    36. Decorating Supplie $1,000

    37. Miscellaneous $1,650

    Operating & Maintenance Totals $124,416

    Taxes & Insurance

    38. Real Estate Taxes $34,366

    39. Payroll Taxes $7,250

    40. Miscellaneous Taxes/Licenses/Permit $0

    41. Property & Liability Insuranc $24,000

    42. Fidelity Bond $0

    43. Workman's Compensation $500

    44. Health Insurance & Employee Benefit $9,000

    45. Other Insurance $200

    Total Taxes & Insurance $75,316

    6544

    Total Operating Expense $342,934

    D1. Total Oper. Ex. Per Unit $4,083 D2. Total Oper. Ex. As % EGI (from E3) 64.36%

    Replacement Reserves (Total # Units X $300 or $250 New Const. Elderly Minimum) $25,200

    Total Expenses $368,134

    2009 Page 16

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    25/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    E. Cash Flow (First Year)

    1. Annual EGI Low-Income Units from (C1) $532,834

    2. Annual EGI Market Units (from C2) + $0

    3. Total Effective Gross Income = $532,834

    4. Total Expenses (from D) $368,134

    5. Net Operating Income = $164,7006. Total Annual Debt Service (from Page 21 B2) - $140,016

    7. Cash Flow Available for Distribution = $24,684

    F. Projections for Financial Feasibility - 15 Year Projections of Cash Flow

    Stabilized

    Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5

    Eff. Gross Income 532,834 548,819 565,284 582,242 599,710

    Less Oper. Expenses 368,134 382,859 398,174 414,101 430,665

    Net Income 164,700 165,960 167,110 168,142 169,045

    Less Debt Service 140,016 140,016 140,016 140,016 140,016

    Cash Flow 24,684 25,944 27,094 28,126 29,029

    Debt Coverage Ratio 1.18 1.19 1.19 1.20 1.21

    Year 6 Year 7 Year 8 Year 9 Year 10

    Eff. Gross Income 617,701 636,232 655,319 674,978 695,228

    Less Oper. Expenses 447,891 465,807 484,439 503,817 523,969

    Net Income 169,810 170,425 170,880 171,162 171,258Less Debt Service 140,016 140,016 140,016 140,016 140,016

    Cash Flow 29,794 30,409 30,864 31,146 31,242

    Debt Coverage Ratio 1.21 1.22 1.22 1.22 1.22

    Year 11 Year 12 Year 13 Year 14 Year 15

    Eff. Gross Income 716,085 737,567 759,694 782,485 805,960

    Less Oper. Expenses 544,928 566,725 589,394 612,970 637,489

    Net Income 171,156 170,842 170,300 169,515 168,471

    Less Debt Service 140,016 140,016 140,016 140,016 140,016

    Cash Flow 31,140 30,826 30,284 29,499 28,455

    Debt Coverage Ratio 1.22 1.22 1.22 1.21 1.20

    Estimated Annual Percentage Increase in Revenue 3.00% (Must be < 3%)

    Estimated Annual Percentage Increase in Expenses 4.00% (Must be > 4%)

    2009 Page 17

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    26/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    VIII. PROJECT BUDGET

    A. Cost/Basis/Maximum Allowable Credit

    Complete cost column and basis column(s) as appropriate through A12. Check if the followingdocumentation is attached at TAB S:

    Executed Construction ContractExecuted Trade Payment Breakdown

    AppraisalOther Cost DocumentationEnvironmental Studies

    Amount of Cost up to 100% Includable in

    Eligible Basis--Use Applicable Column(s):

    "30% Present Value Credit" (D)

    Item (A) Cost (B) Acquisition (C) Rehab/ "70 % Present

    New Construction Value Credit"

    1. Contractor Cost

    A. Off-Site Improvements 0 0 0 0

    B. Site Work 0 0 0 0

    C. Other: 0 0 0 0

    D. Unit Structures (New) 0 0 0 0

    E. Unit Structures (Rehab) 1,952,610 0 0 1,952,610

    F. Accessory Building (s) 0 0 0 0

    G. Asbestos Removal 0 0 0 0

    H. Demolition 0 0 0 0

    I. Commercial Space Costs 0 0 0 0

    J. Structured Parking Garage 0 0 0 0

    K. Subtotal A: (Sum 1A..1J) 1,952,610 0 0 1,952,610

    L. General Requirements 117,157 0 0 117,157

    M. Builder's Overhead 39,052 0 0 39,052

    ( 2.0% Contract)N. Builder's Profit 117,157 0 0 117,157

    ( 6.0% Contract)

    O. Bonding Fee 0 0 0 0

    P. Other: Completion LOC 2,226 0 0 2,226

    Q. Contractor Cost

    Subtotal (Sum 1K..1P) $2,228,201 $0 $0 $2,228,201

    2. Owner Costs

    A. Building Permit 10,000 0 0 10,000

    B. Arch./Engin. Design Fee 35,000 0 0 35,000

    ( 417 /Unit)

    C. Arch. Supervision Fee 35,000 0 0 35,000

    ( 417 /Unit)

    D. Tap Fees 0 0 0 0E. Soil Borings 0 0 0 0

    NOTE: Attorney must opine, among other things, as to correctness of the inclusion of each cost item in eligible basis, type

    of credit and numerical calculations of this Part VIII.

    2009 Page 18

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    27/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    Amount of Cost up to 100% Includable in

    Eligible Basis--Use Applicable Column(s):

    "30% Present Value Credit" (D)

    Item (A) Cost (B) Acquisition (C) Rehab/ "70 % Present

    New Construction Value Credit"

    2. Owner Costs Continued

    F. Construction Loan 0 0 0 0Origination Fee

    G. Construction Interest 0 0 0 0

    ( 0.0% for 0 months)

    H. Taxes During Construction 25,775 0 0 6,444

    I. Insurance During Construction 18,000 0 0 4,500

    J. Cost Certification Fee 45,000 0 0 45,000

    K. Title and Recording 35,000 11,200 0 20,809

    L. Legal Fees for Closing 75,000 30,000 0 0

    M. Permanent Loan Fee 14,250 0 0 0

    ( 0.0% )

    N. Other Permanent Loan Fees 45,000 0 0 0

    O. Credit Enhancement 0 0 0 0

    P. Mortgage Banker 17,993 4,498 0 4,498

    Q. Environmental Study 13,000 0 0 13,000

    R. Structural/Mechanical Study 0 0 0 0

    S. Appraisal Fee 3,000 0 0 3,000

    T. Market Study 2,000 0 0 2,000

    U. Operating Reserve 239,800 0 0 0

    V. Tax Credit Fee 26,020 0 0 0

    W. OTHER $2,026,698 $0 $0 $267,614

    (SEE PAGE 19A)

    X. Owner Cost

    Subtotal (Sum 2A..2W) $2,666,536 $45,698 $0 $446,865

    Subtotal 1 + 2 $4,894,737 $45,698 $0 $2,675,066

    (Owner + Contractor Costs)

    3. Developer's Fees 793,132 124,365 0 668,767

    4. Owner's Acquisition Costs

    Land 320,000

    Existing Improvements 1,197,956 1,197,956

    Subtotal 4: $1,517,956 $1,197,956

    5. Total Development Costs

    Subtotal 1+2+3+4: $7,205,825 $1,368,020 $0 $3,343,833

    If this application seeks rehab credits only, in which there is no acquisition and no change in ownership, enter the greater of

    appraised value or tax assessment value here: $0 Land(Attach documentation at Tab K) $0 Building

    2009 Page 19

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    28/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    Amount of Cost up to 100% Includable in

    Eligible Basis--Use Applicable Column(s):

    "30% Present Value Credit" (D)

    Item (A) Cost (B) Acquisition (C) Rehab/ "70 % Present

    New Construction Value Credit"

    W. OTHER OWNER COSTS

    Contingency Reserve 237,614 0 0 237,614(Rehab or Adaptive Reuse only)

    LIST ADDITIONAL ITEMS

    Interior Designer 10,000 0 0 10,000

    Survey 9,500 0 0 9,500

    Travel Expenses 5,000 0 0 0

    Organizational/Filing Fees 2,500 0 0 0

    Office Expenses/Copies/Postage 2,000 0 0 500

    Tenant Relocation 5,000 0 0 5,000

    Extra Security/Temp Labor 10,000 0 0 5,000

    PSA LOC 2,500 0 0 0

    Replacement Reserves 42,000 0 0 0

    VHDA Application Fee 500 0 0 0

    0 0 0 0

    Purchase of Reserves 1,682,044 0 0 00 0 0 0

    VHDA TCAP/TCEP Admin Fee: 18,040 0 0 0

    0 0 0 0

    0 0 0 0

    Subtotal (Other Owner Costs) $2,026,698 $0 $0 $267,614

    2009 Page 19A

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    29/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    Amount of Cost up to 100% Includable in

    Eligible Basis--Use Applicable Column(s):

    "30 % Present Value Credit"

    (C) Rehab/ (D)

    New "70 % Present

    Item (A) Cost (B) Acquisition Construction Value Credit"

    5. Total Development Costs

    Subtotal 1+2+3+4 7,205,825 1,368,020 0 3,343,833

    6. Reductions in Eligible Basis

    Subtract the following:

    A. Amount of federal grant(s) used to finance 0 0 0

    qualifying development costs

    B. Amount of nonqualified, nonrecourse financing 0 0 0

    C. Costs of nonqualifying units of higher quality 0 0 0

    (or excess portion thereof)

    D. Historic Tax Credit (residential portion) 0 0 0

    7. Total Eligible Basis (5 minus 6 above) 1,368,020 0 3,343,833

    8. Adjustment(s) to Eligible Basis (For non-acquisition costs in eligible basis)

    (i) For Earthcraft or LEED Certification AND 60 Bonus Points 0 167,192

    (ii) For QCT or DDA (Eligible Basis x 30%) 0 0

    Total Adjusted Eligible basis 0 3,511,025

    9. Applicable Fraction 100.0000% 100.0000% 100.0000%

    10. Total Qualified Basis (Same as Part IX-C) 1,368,020 0 3,511,025

    (Eligible Basis x Applicable Fraction)

    11. Applicable Percentage 3.28% 3.28% 9.00%

    (For 2009 9% competitive credits, use the May 2009 applicable percentages for acq.)

    (For 9% non-competitive & tax exempt bonds, use the most recently published rates)

    12. Maximum Allowable Credit under IRC 42 $44,871 $0 $315,992

    (Qualified Basis x Applicable Percentage)

    (Same as Part IX-C and equal to or more than $360,863

    credit amount requested) Combined 30% & 70% P. V. Credit

    2009 Page 20

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    30/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    B. Sources of Funds

    1. Construction Financing: List individually the sources of construction financing, including any such

    loans financed through grant sources:

    Date of Date of Amount of

    Source of Funds Application Commitment Funds Name of Contact Person

    1. VHDA Assumed Loan 07/15/09 $849,277 VHDA-John Hastings

    2. Deferred SPARC Loan 07/15/09 $950,000 VHDA-John Hastings

    3. Project Reserves 07/15/09 $1,682,044 VHDA-John Hastings

    Commitments or letter(s) of intent attached (TAB T)

    2. Permanent Financing: List individually the sources of all permanent financing in order of lien position:

    Interest Amortization Term

    Date of Date of Amount of Annual Debt Rate of Period of

    Source of Funds Application Commitment Funds Service Cost Loan IN YEARS Loan (years)

    1. $0 0.00% 30 0

    2. VHDA Assumed Loan 07/15/09 $849,277 $140,016 7.42% 40 40

    3. Deferred SPARC Loan 07/15/09 $950,000 $0 9.50% 30 30

    4. Project Reserves n/a $1,682,044 $0 0.00% 1000 0

    5. $0 $0 0.00% 1000 0

    6. $0 $0 0.00% 1000 0

    Totals: $3,481,321 $140,016

    Commitments or letter(s) of intent attached (TAB T)

    3. Grants: List all grants provided for the development:

    Date of Date of Amount of

    Source of Funds Application Commitment Funds Name of Contact Person

    1. $0

    2. $0

    3. $0

    4. $0

    5. $0

    6. TCAP N/A N/A $993,637

    Total Permanent Grants: $993,637

    Commitments or letter(s) of intent attached (TAB T)

    2009 Page 21

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    31/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    4. Portion of Syndication Proceeds Attributable to Historic Tax Credit

    Amount of Federal historic credits $0 x Equity % $0.00 $0

    Amount of Virginia historic credits $0 x Equity % $0.00 $0

    6. Equity that Sponsor will Fund:

    Cash Investment $0

    Contributed Land/Building $0 Assessment Attached (TAB S)Deferred Developer Fee $205,329

    Other: $0

    Equity Total $205,329

    7. Total of All Sources (B2 + B3 + B4 + B5 + B6) $4,680,287

    (not including syndication proceeds except for historic tax credits)

    8. Total Development Cost $7,205,825

    (From VIII-A5)

    9. Less Total Sources of Funds (From B7 above) $4,680,287

    10. Equals equity gap to be funded with low-income tax credit

    proceeds (must equal IX-D3) $2,525,538

    C. Syndication Information (If Applicable)

    1. Actual or Anticipated Name of Syndicator TBD

    2. Contact Person Phone

    3. Street Address

    City State Zip

    4. a. Total to be paid by anticipated users of credit (e.g., limited partners) $2,525,538

    b. Equity Dollars Per Credit (e.g., $0.85 per dollar of credit) $0.70

    c. Percent of ownership entity (e.g., 99% or 99.9%) 99.98%

    d. Net credit amount anticipated by user of credits $360,791

    e. Syndication costs not included in VIII-A5 (e.g., advisory fees) $0

    5. Net amount which will be used to pay for Total Development Cost (4a-4e)as listed in Part VIII-A5 (same amount as Part IX-D3) $2,525,538

    6. Amount of annual credit required for above amounts

    (same amount as Part IX-D6) $360,863

    7. Net Equity Factor [C5 / (C6 X 10)]

    (same amount as Part IX-D4) Must be equal to or greater than 85% 69.99%

    8. Syndication: Public or Private

    9. Investors: Individual or Corporate

    Syndication commitment or letter of intent attached (TAB U)

    2009 Page 22

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    32/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    D. Recap of Federal, State, and Local Funds/Any Credit Enhancements

    1. Are any portions of the sources of funds described above for the development financed directly or indirectlywith Federal, State, or Local Government Funds? Yes NoIf yes, then check the type and list the amount of money involved.

    Below-Market Loans Market-Rate Loans

    Tax Exempt Bonds $0 Taxable Bonds $0

    RD 515 $0 Section 220 $0

    Section 221(d)(3) $0 Section 221(d)(3) $0

    Section 312 $0 Section 221(d)(4) $0

    Section 236 $0 Section 236 $0

    VHDA SPARC/REACH $950,000 Section 223(f) $0

    HOME Funds $0 Other: $0

    Other: $0

    Other: $0

    Grants Grants

    CDBG $0 State $0

    UDAG $0 Local $0Other: TCAP $993,637

    This means grants to the partnership. If you received a loan financed by a locality which received one of the

    listed grants, please list it in the appropriate loan column as "other" and describe the applicable grant program

    which funded it.

    2. Subsidized funding: list all sources of funding for points. Documentation Attached (TAB T)

    Source of Funds Commitment date Funds

    1. $0

    2. $0

    3. $0

    4. $0

    5. $0

    3. Does any of your financing have any credit enhancement? Yes No

    If yes, list which financing and describe the credit enhancement:

    4. Other Subsidies Documentation Attached (TAB Q)

    Section 8 Rent Supplement or Rental Assistance Payment

    Tax Abatement

    Other

    5. Is HUD approval for transfer of physical asset required?

    Yes No

    E. For Transactions Using Tax-Exempt Bonds Seeking 4% Credits:

    For purposes of the 50% Test, and based only on the data entered to this

    application, the portion of the aggregate basis of buildings and land financed with

    tax-exempt funds is: N/A

    2009 Page 23

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    33/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    IX. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

    A. Extended Use Restriction

    This development will be subject to the standard extended use agreement which permits earlytermination (after the mandatory 15-year compliance period) of the extended use period.

    This development will be subject to an extended use agreement in which the owner's right to anyearly termination of the extended use provision is waived for 25 additional years after the 15-year compliance period for a total of 40 years. Do not select if IX.B is checked below.

    This development will be subject to an extended use agreement in which the owner's right to any

    early termination of the extended use provision is waived for 35 additional years after the 15-year compliance period for a total of 50 years. Do not select if IX.B is checked below.

    B. Nonprofit/Local Housing Authority Purchase Option/Right of First Refusal

    1. After the mandatory 15-year compliance period, a qualified nonprofit as identified in theattached nonprofit questionnaire, or local housing authority will have the option to purchaseor the right of first refusal to acquire the development for a price not to exceed the outstandingdebt and exit taxes. Such debt must be limited to the original mortgage(s) unless any refinancingis approved by the nonprofit. Do not select if extended compliance is selected in IX.A above.

    Option or Right of First Refusal in Recordable Form Attached (TAB V)

    Enter name of qualified nonprofit:

    2. A qualified nonprofit or local housing authority submits a homeownership plan committing tosell the units in the development after the mandatory 15-year compliance period to tenants whoseincomes shall not exceed the applicable income limit at the time of their initial occupancy.Do not select if extended compliance is selected in IX.A above.

    Homeownership Plan Attached (TAB J)

    C. Building-by-Building Information (Complete page 25 as appropriate)

    NOTE: Each recipient of an allocation of credits will be required to record an extended use agreement as required by the

    IRC governing the use of the development for low-income housing for at least 30 years. However, the IRC providesthat, in certain circumstances, such extended use period may be terminated early.

    2009 Page 24

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    34/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    C. Building-by-Building Information Must Complete

    Qualified basis must be determined on a building-by building basis. Complete the section below. Building street addresses are required by the IRS (must h

    allocation request).

    30% Present Value 30% Present Value

    Credit for Acquisition Credit for Construction

    TAX MARKET

    CREDIT RATE Actual or Actual or

    UNITS UNITS Estimate Anticipated Estimate Anticipated

    Build Street Qualified In-Service Applicable Credit Qualified In-Service Applicable Credit

    ing # Address Basis Date Percentage Amount Basis Date Percentage Amount

    1. 12 3666 Ferncliff Avenue - Building A $145,176 3.28% 4,762 $0 0.00% 0

    2. 12 3666 Ferncliff Avenue - Building B $203,807 3.28% 6,685 $0 0.00% 0

    3. 12 3667 Ferncliff Avenue - Building C $203,807 3.28% 6,685 $0 0.00% 0

    4. 12 3667 Ferncliff Avenue - Building D $203,807 3.28% 6,685 $0 0.00% 0

    5. 12 3668 Ferncliff Avenue - Building E $203,807 3.28% 6,685 $0 0.00% 0

    6. 12 3668 Ferncliff Avenue - Building F $203,807 3.28% 6,685 $0 0.00% 0

    7. 12 3669 Ferncliff Avenue - Building G $203,807 3.28% 6,685 $0 0.00% 0

    8. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    9. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    10. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    11. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    12. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    13. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    14. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    15. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    16. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0$1,368,017 $0

    $44,871 $0Qualified Basis Totals (must agree with VIII-A10)

    Credit Amount Totals (must agree with VIII-A-12)

    NUMBER

    OF

    2009

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    35/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    C. Building-by-Building Information Must Complete

    Qualified basis must be determined on a building-by building basis. Complete the section below. Building street addresses are required by the IRS (must h

    allocation request).

    30% Present Value 30% Present Value

    Credit for Acquisition Credit for Construction

    TAX MARKET

    CREDIT RATE Actual or Actual or

    UNITS UNITS Estimate Anticipated Estimate Anticipated

    Build Street Qualified In-Service Applicable Credit Qualified In-Service Applicable Credit

    ing # Address Basis Date Percentage Amount Basis Date Percentage Amount

    17. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    18. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    19. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    20. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    21. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    22. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    23. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    24. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    25. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    26. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    27. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    28. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    29. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    30. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    31. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    32. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0$0 $0

    $0 $0Qualified Basis Totals (must agree with VIII-A10)

    Credit Amount Totals (must agree with VIII-A-12)

    NUMBER

    OF

    2009

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    36/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    C. Building-by-Building Information Must Complete

    Qualified basis must be determined on a building-by building basis. Complete the section below. Building street addresses are required by the IRS (must h

    allocation request).

    30% Present Value 30% Present Value

    Credit for Acquisition Credit for Construction

    TAX MARKET

    CREDIT RATE Actual or Actual or

    UNITS UNITS Estimate Anticipated Estimate Anticipated

    Build Street Qualified In-Service Applicable Credit Qualified In-Service Applicable Credit

    ing # Address Basis Date Percentage Amount Basis Date Percentage Amount

    33. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    34. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    35. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    36. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    37. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    38. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    39. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    40. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    41. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    42. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    43. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    44. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    45. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    46. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    47. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0

    48. $0 0.00% 0 $0 0.00% 0$0 $0

    $0 $0Qualified Basis Totals (must agree with VIII-A10)

    Credit Amount Totals (must agree with VIII-A-12)

    NUMBER

    OF

    2009

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    37/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    D. Determination of Reservation Amount Needed

    1. Total Development Costs (from VIII-A5, Column A page 20) $7,205,825

    2. Less Total Sources of Funds (from VIII-B7 page 22) $4,680,287

    3. Equals Equity Gap $2,525,538

    4. Divided by Net Equity Factor (VIII-C7 page 22) 69.99%(Percent of 10-year credit expected to be raised as equity investment)

    5. Equals Ten-Year Credit Amount Needed to Fund Gap $3,608,634

    Divided by ten years 10

    6. Equals Annual Tax Credit Required to Fund the Equity Gap $360,863

    7. The Maximum Allowable Credit Amount $360,863(from VIII-A12-combined figure)

    (This amount must be equal to or more than 6 above)

    8. Reservation Amount (Lesser of 6 or 7 above)

    Credit per Unit 4,296 Combined 30% & 70% PV Credit

    Credit per Bedroom 2,005 $360,863

    Comprised of

    $44,871 and $315,99230% PV Credit 70% PV Credit

    (Based on same relative percentages as VIII-A12)

    E. Attorneys OpinionAttached in Mandatory TAB W)

    The following calculation of the amount of credits needed is substantially the same as the calculation which will be made by VHDA to

    determine, as required by the IRC, the amount of credits which may be allocated for the development. However, VHDA at all times retains the

    right to substitute such information and assumptions as are determined by VHDA to be reasonable for the information and assumptions

    provided herein as to costs (including development fees, profits, etc.), sources for funding, expected equity, etc. Accordingly, if the

    development is selected by VHDA for a reservation of credits, the amount of such reservation may differ significantly from the amount you

    compute below.

    Goal Seek Function

    If you incur the error message that your reservation amount is not equal

    to the equity gap amount you may use the goal seek function within the Excel

    spreadsheet to eliminate the error message. To use the Goal Seek function first

    place the curser box on cell V28. Using the mouse arrow, point and click on

    Tools on the top line and then click on the Goal Seek option. A box will

    appear with the V28 cell shown in the top space, place the cursor in the middle

    box and type in the new amount that you want the equity gap to be which should

    be the reservation amount below, then place the cursor in the bottom space and at

    the bottom of the page click on page 22. Then place the cursor on cell N15

    (Deferred Developer Fee) and click on OK. A message should then appear that

    a solution has been found and if the amount is correct click OK. If the amountsare now equal the error message will disappear.

    2009 Page 26

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    38/251

    Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Application For Reservation

    F. Statement of Owner

    The undersigned hereby acknowledges the following:

    1. that, to the best of its knowledge and belief, all factual information provided herein or in connection

    herewith is true and correct, and all estimates are reasonable.

    2. that it will at all times indemnify and hold harmless VHDA and its assigns against all losses, costs,

    damages, VHDA's expenses, and liabilities of any nature directly or indirectly resulting from, arising out of,

    or relating to VHDA's acceptance, consideration, approval, or disapproval of this reservation request and

    the issuance or nonissuance of an allocation of credits, grants and/or loan funds in connection herewith.

    3. that points will be assigned only for representations made herein for which satisfactory documentation is

    submitted herewith and that no revised representations may be made in connection with this application

    once the deadline for applications has passed.

    4. that this application form, provided by VHDA to applicants for tax credits, including all sections herein

    relative to basis, credit calculations, and determination of the amount of the credit necessary to make the

    development financially feasible, is provided only for the convenience of VHDA in reviewing reservationrequests; that completion hereof in no way guarantees eligibility for the credits or ensures that the amount

    of credits applied for has been computed in accordance with IRC requirements; and that any notations

    herein describing IRC requirements are offered only as general guides and not as legal authority.

    5. that the undersigned is responsible for ensuring that the proposed development will be comprised of

    qualified low-income buildings and that it will in all respects satisfy all applicable requirements of federal

    tax law and any other requirements imposed upon it by VHDA prior to allocation, should one be issued.

    6. that, for the purposes of reviewing this application, VHDA is entitled to rely upon representations of the

    undersigned as to the inclusion of costs in eligible basis and as to all of the figures and calculations relative

    to the determination of qualified basis for the development as a whole and/or each building therein

    individually as well as the amounts and types of credit applicable thereof, but that the issuance of areservation based on such representation in no way warrants their correctness or compliance with IRC

    requirements.

    7. that VHDA may request or require changes in the information submitted herewith, may substitute its own

    figures which it deems reasonable for any or all figures provided herein by the undersigned and may reserve

    credits, if any, in an amount significantly different from the amount requested.

    8. that reservations of credits are not transferable without prior written approval by VHDA at its sole

    discretion.

    2009 Page 27

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    39/251

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    40/251

    MANDATORY ITEMS: Score

    a. Signed, completed application Y Y or N 0b. Duplicate copy of application Y Y or N 0c. Partnership agreement Y Y or N 0d. SCC Certification Y Y or N 0e. Previous participation form Y Y or N 0f. Site control document Y Y or N 0g. Architect's Certification Y Y or N 0h. Attorney's opinion Y Y or N 0i. Nonprofit questionnaire (if NP) N/A Y, N, N/A 0

    0.00

    1. READINESS:a. Plan of development N 0 or 40 0.00b. Zoning approval Y 0 or 40 40.00

    Total: 40.00

    2. HOUSING NEEDS CHARACTERISTICS:a. VHDA notification letter to CEO Y 0 or -50 0.00b. Local CEO letter (Y,NC,N) Y 0 or 25 or 50 50.00c. Location in a revitalization area N 0 or 30 0.00d. Location in a Qualified Census Tract N 0 or 5 0.00e. Sec 8 or PHA waiting list preference Y 0 or 10 10.00f. Subsidized funding commitments 0.00% Up to 40 0.00g. Existing RD, HUD Section 8 or 236 program Y 0 or 20 20.00h. Tax abatement or new project based rental subsidy (HUD or RD) N 0 or 10 0.00i. Census tract with

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    41/251

    Total exactly with the Jurisdiction names listed in the Application Manual. 140.41

    7. BONUS POINTS: Locality AMI State AMIa. Units with rents at or below 40% of AMI $60,200 $50,600 12% Up to 10 10.00b. Units with rent and income at or below 50% of AMI 100% Up to 50 50.00

    or c. Units with rents at or below 50% rented to tenants at or below 60% of AMI 100% Up to 25 0.00or d. Units in Low Income Jurisdict ions with rents

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    42/251

    $/SF = $81.16 Credits/SF = $5.83 Const $/unit = $26,526

    TYPE OF PROJECT FAMILY = 11000; ELDERLY = 12000 11000 If an ERROR message appears here check

    LOCATION BELT=100; NVM=110; NVNM=200; RIC=300; TID=400; SMA=500; SMA-C=510; RUR=600 500 spelling of Clerk's Office on pg 1. It mustTYPE OF CONSTRUCTION N C=1; ADPT=2;REHAB(25,000+)=3; REHAB(15,000-25,000)= 3 match exactly with the Jurisdiction names

    listed in the Application Manual.

    ELDERLY

    AS LVG EFF-E 1 BR-E 2 BR-E EFF-E-1 ST 1 BR-E-1 ST 2 BR-E-1 STAVG UNIT SIZE 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

    NUMBER OF UNITS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

    PARAMETER-(COSTS=>25,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

    PARAMETER-(COSTS25,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0PARAMETER-(CREDITS25,000) 0 119,784 155,400 181,608 0 0 0 0

    PARAMETER-(COSTS25,000) 0 10,069 13,063 15,266 0 0 0 0

    PARAMETER-(CREDITS

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    43/251

    $/SF = $81.16 Credits/SF = $5.83 Const $/unit = $26,526

    TYPE OF PROJECT FAMILY = 11000; ELDERLY = 12000 11000 If an ERROR message appears here check

    LOCATION BELT=100; NVM=110; NVNM=200; RIC=300; TID=400; SMA=500; SMA-C=510; RUR=600 500 spelling of Clerk's Office on pg 1. It mustTYPE OF CONSTRUCTION N C=1; ADPT=2;REHAB(25,000+)=3; REHAB(10,000-25,000)= 3 match exactly with the Jurisdiction names

    listed in the Application Manual.

    ELDERLY

    AS LVG EFF-E 1 BR-E 2 BR-E EFF-E-1 ST 1 BR-E-1 ST 2 BR-E-1 STAVG UNIT SIZE 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

    NUMBER OF UNITS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

    PARAMETER-(COSTS=>25,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

    PARAMETER-(COSTS25,000) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0PARAMETER-(CREDITS25,000) 0 119,784 155,400 181,608 0 0 0 0

    PARAMETER-(COSTS25,000) 0 10,069 13,063 15,266 0 0 0 0

    PARAMETER-(CREDITS

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    44/251

    TAB A(Documentation of Development Location)

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    45/251

    TAB A.1(Qualified Census Tract Certification)

  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    46/251

    Qualified Census Trac t Ce rtific a tionDevelop ment Name : Ferncliff South Apa rtments

    Trac king # : 2009-Z-054

    1. Gene ral Instruc tions This Ce rtifica tion must be include d with the Ap plic at ion (b y App lic at ion Dea dline,

    5/15/ 09).

    The Ow ner/Deve lope r co mp letes this Ce rtifica tion. Any c hange in this form ma y result in a reduc tion of points und er the sc oring system. If

    you have any questions, plea se ca ll Jim C hand ler at VHDA (804) 343-5786.

    2. Definition of Qua lified Census Trac tPursuant to 42(d)(5)(C)(ii) of the IRC, a qua lified c ensus trac t is, (I) Any c ensus trac t

    whic h is designa ted by the Sec reta ry of Housing and Urban Develop me nt and , forthe m ost rec ent yea r for whic h c ensus data are a vailab le o n household inc om e in

    such tract, either in which 50% or more of the households have an income which is

    less tha n 60% of the a rea med ian g ross income (AMGI) for suc h yea r or which has a

    pove rty rate of a t least 25%. If the Sec reta ry of Housing and Urban Deve lop ment

    determines that sufficient data for any period are not available to apply this clause

    on the basis of c ensus trac ts, suc h Sec reta ry sha ll app ly this c lause fo r suc h p eriod on

    the basis of e numera tion d istric ts. (II) The p ortion o f a me trop olitan sta tistica l a rea

    (MSA) which ma y be de signa ted shall not e xc eed an a rea having 20% of the

    pop ulation o f suc h MSA. (III) Eac h MSA sha ll be trea ted as a sep ara te a rea and a ll

    non-me trop olitan area s in a Sta te sha ll be trea ted as one a rea .

    3. Census Trac t #(s):23

    To d ete rmine the d evelop ment s c ensus trac t, go to http://map.sba.gov/hubzone/init.asp and

    put in the deve lopm ent a dd ress or co unty. The c ensus trac t numb er will be revealed

    a fter p ressing the sea rch b utton. On a ra re oc casion, whe n a d eve lopm ent spans

    mo re tha n one c ensus trac t, this we bsite m ay show incom plete information. IF the

    sub jec t deve lopme nt is ac ross c ensus trac ts, p lease list ea c h census trac t by numb er

    and provide supp orting d oc umentation.

    Attac h a ma p showing c ensus trac t b ounda ries and the d evelopme nts loc ation!

    4. Leg al Desc ription Atta c h a c op y of the deve lopm ent s lega l de sc ript ion; the lega l desc ription should

    co rrespo nd to the site c ontrol do cum ent in the Ap plica tion.

    http://map.sba.gov/hubzone/init.asphttp://map.sba.gov/hubzone/init.asp
  • 8/8/2019 Ferncliff South Apartments - 2009 VA

    47/251

    DETERMINATION OF WHETHER AN ADDRESS IS IN A HUBZONE

    3666 Ferncliff Ave NW, Roanoke VA, 24017 is located in Census Tract "51770002300" which IS NOT HUBZonequalified.

    The map below shows the relationship of this address (marked with a star) to qualified HUBZone areas. Below the map, youmay find information on why the address was found not to be in a HUBZone Area.

    BASIS OF HUBZONE DETERMINATION

    U.S. MapAddress-Town-County

    SearchHel