49
Draft Guidance for Industry and FDA Staff Heart Valves - Investigational Device Exemption (IDE) and Premarket Approval (PMA) Applications DRAFT GUIDANCE This guidance document is being distributed for comment purposes only. Document issued on: January 20, 2010 "#$$%&’( )&* (+,,%(’-#&( .%,).*-&, ’/-( *.)0’ *#1+$%&’ (/#+2* 3% (+3$-’’%* 4-’/-& 56 *)7( #0 8+32-1)’-#& -& ’/% !"#"$%& (")*+,"$ #0 ’/% &#’-1% )&&#+&1-&, ’/% )9)-2)3-2-’7 #0 ’/% *.)0’ ,+-*)&1%: ;+3$-’ 4.-’’%& 1#$$%&’( ’# ’/% <-9-(-#& #0 <#1=%’( >)&),%$%&’ ?@ABCD6EFG A##* )&* <.+, B*$-&-(’.)’-#&G EHD6 A-(/%.( I)&%G J##$ K6HKG J#1=9-22%G >< L6MEL: B2’%.&)’-9%27G %2%1’.#&-1 1#$$%&’( $)7 3% (+3$-’’%* ’# /’’8NOO444:regulations:,#9. B22 1#$$%&’( (/#+2* 3% -*%&’-0-%* 4-’/ ’/% *#1=%’ &+$3%. 2-(’%* -& ’/% &#’-1% #0 )9)-2)3-2-’7 ’/)’ 8+32-(/%( -& ’/% !"#"$%& (")*+,"$: A#. P+%(’-#&( .%,).*-&, ’/-( *#1+$%&’ 1#&’)1’ ").#27& <: Q)+,/)&G R00-1% #0 <%9-1% S9)2+)’-#&G D6KCT5HCHDDMG #. ;)&*7 A:": ;’%4).’G R00-1% #0 ;1-%&1% )&* S&,-&%%.-&, I)3#.)’#.-%(G D6KCT5HC LEKM: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Food and Drug Administration Center for Devices and Radiological Health Circulatory Support and Prosthetic Devices Branch Division of Cardiovascular Devices Office of Device Evaluation

FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Draft Guidance for Industry and FDA

Staff !

Heart Valves - Investigational Device

Exemption (IDE) and Premarket

Approval (PMA) Applications

DRAFT GUIDANCE !

This guidance document is being distributed for comment purposes only.!!

Document issued on: January 20, 2010

!

"#$$%&'(!)&*!(+,,%('-#&(!.%,).*-&,!'/-(!*.)0'!*#1+$%&'!(/#+2*!3%!(+3$-''%*!4-'/-&!56!*)7(!#0!

8+32-1)'-#&!-&!'/%!!"#"$%&'(")*+,"$!#0!'/%!&#'-1%!)&&#+&1-&,!'/%!)9)-2)3-2-'7!#0!'/%!*.)0'!

,+-*)&1%:!!;+3$-'!4.-''%&!1#$$%&'(!'#!'/%!<-9-(-#&!#0!<#1=%'(!>)&),%$%&'!?@ABCD6EFG!A##*!

)&*!<.+,!B*$-&-('.)'-#&G!EHD6!A-(/%.(!I)&%G!J##$!K6HKG!J#1=9-22%G!><!L6MEL:!!B2'%.&)'-9%27G!

%2%1'.#&-1!1#$$%&'(!$)7!3%!(+3$-''%*!'#!/''8NOO444:regulations:,#9.!!B22!

1#$$%&'(!(/#+2*!3%!-*%&'-0-%*!4-'/!'/%!*#1=%'!&+$3%.!2-('%*!-&!'/%!&#'-1%!#0!)9)-2)3-2-'7!'/)'!

8+32-(/%(!-&!'/%'!"#"$%&'(")*+,"$:!

!

A#.!P+%('-#&(!.%,).*-&,!'/-(!*#1+$%&'!1#&')1'!").#27&!<:!Q)+,/)&G!R00-1%!#0!<%9-1%!S9)2+)'-#&G!

D6KCT5HCHDDMG!#.!;)&*7!A:":!;'%4).'G!R00-1%!#0!;1-%&1%!)&*!S&,-&%%.-&,!I)3#.)'#.-%(G!D6KCT5HC

LEKM:!

!

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Food and Drug Administration

Center for Devices and Radiological Health

Circulatory Support and Prosthetic Devices Branch

Division of Cardiovascular Devices

Office of Device Evaluation

Page 2: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

Preface

Additional Copies!

B**-'-#&)2!1#8-%(!).%!)9)-2)32%!0.#$!'/%!U&'%.&%'!)'N!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+$1K

5D65H:/'$:!!W#+!$)7!)2(#!(%&*!)&!%C$)-2!.%P+%('!'#!*($-1)X0*)://(:,#9!'#!.%1%-9%!)&!

%2%1'.#&-1!1#87!#0!'/%!,+-*)&1%!#.!(%&*!)!0)Y!.%P+%('!'#!D6KCMZTCMKZ5!'#!.%1%-9%!)!/).*!1#87:!!

[2%)(%!+(%!'/%!*#1+$%&'!&+$3%.!?1607F!'#!-*%&'-07!'/%!,+-*)&1%!7#+!).%!.%P+%('-&,:!

! !

Page 3: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

Table of Contents

I.! INTRODUCTION.........................................................................................................................................1!

II.! BACKGROUND............................................................................................................................................2!

III.! SCOPE ...........................................................................................................................................................2!

IV.! RISK ANALYSIS..........................................................................................................................................3!

V.! THE PRE-SUBMISSION PROCESS..........................................................................................................4!

VI.! IDE AND PMA APPLICATIONS: GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS...................................................4!

VII.! TERMS AND DEFINITIONS......................................................................................................................5!

VIII.! DEVICE DESCRIPTION.............................................................................................................................5!

<SQU"S![BJB>S\SJ;::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::E![B"]BVU^V!U^ARJ>B\UR^::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::T!

IX.! PYROGENICITY .........................................................................................................................................8!

X.! STERILIZATION.........................................................................................................................................8!

XI.! PRECLINICAL IN VITRO ASSESSMENT .............................................................................................10!

B:! QBIQS!;B>[IS;::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KK!_:! JSASJS^"S!QBIQS; ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KK!":! _UR"R>[B\U_UIU\W ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KK!<:! QBIQS!<`JB_UIU\W!\S;\U^V ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KL!S:! "R>[R^S^\!AB\UV`S!\S;\U^V :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KL!A:! <W^B>U"!ABUI`JS!>R<S!\S;\U^V:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KL!V:! "BQU\B\UR^:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KL!@:! "RJJR;UR^!JS;U;\B^"S :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KD!U:! AIB>>B_UIU\W!RA!QBIQS<!"R^<`U\; :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KD!a:! @S>R<W^B>U"![SJARJ>B^"S!C!QSJUAU"B\UR^!RA!\@S!_SJ^R`IIU!JSIB\UR^;@U[ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KD!]:! >BV^S\U"!JS;R^B^"S!?>JF!;BAS\W!\S;\U^V :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KD!I:! ;@SIA!IUAS:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KZ!

XII.! PRECLINICAL ANIMAL STUDIES .......................................................................................................14!

B:! >S\@R<;:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KZ!_:! ;\`<W!<S;UV^:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KZ!":! <B\B!"RIIS"\UR^ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KE!<:! <B\B!B^BIW;U; ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KH!S:! AU^BI!JS[RJ\!RA!B^U>BI!;\`<W:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KH!A:! ;`_>U\\U^V!B^U>BI!;\`<W!U^ARJ>B\UR^!\R!WR`J!U<S!B^<![>B ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KT!

XIII.! CLINICAL INVESTIGATIONS ...............................................................................................................18!

B:! <B\B!;BAS\W!>R^U\RJU^V!_RBJ<::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KM!_:! "IU^U"BI!SQS^\;!"R>>U\\SS::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KM!":! ^`>_SJ!RA!U^QS;\UVB\RJ;::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::KM!<:! U^QS;\UVB\UR^BI!;U\S; ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::K5!S:! <B\B!"RIIS"\UR^ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::K5!A:! "R^\JRI!<B\B:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::K5!V:! ;B>[IS!;UbS!B^<!ARIIRcC`[!SAAS"\!R^!"R>[IU"B\UR^!JB\S:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::L6!@:! [JSCR[SJB\UQS!<B\B:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LK!U:! ARIIRcC`[!<B\B:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LL!a:! "IU^U"BI!IB_RJB\RJW!JS;`I\;!U^!"@UI<JS^::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LD!

! !

Page 4: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! !

]:! U>BVU^V!<B\B ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LD!I:! B<<U\UR^BI!U^ARJ>B\UR^ :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LD!>:! <B\B_B;S!"IR;`JS :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LZ!^:! ;`_aS"\!"R>[IUB^"S:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LZ!R:! <B\B![RRIU^V ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LE![:! B<QSJ;S!SQS^\;!B^<!"R>[IU"B\UR^!JB\S;::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LE!d:! ARJSUV^!<B\B ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LE!

XIV.! PMA SUPPLEMENTS ...............................................................................................................................25!

B:! >R<UAU"B\UR^;!\R!\@S!;ScU^V!JU^V!"R^AUV`JB\UR^:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LH!_:! QBIQS<!"R^<`U\;::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LH!

XV.! PROFESSIONAL LABELING..................................................................................................................26!

B:! ^R^C;\SJUIS!<SQU"S; ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LH!_:! JS;\SJUIUbB\UR^ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LT!":! >BV^S\U"!JS;R^B^"S!U>BVU^V!?>JUF:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LT!

XVI.! PATIENT LABELING...............................................................................................................................27!

APPENDIX A. SHELF LIFE VALIDATION........................................................................................................28!

B:! \S;\!QBIQS!;SIS"\UR^::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LM!_:! JSBIC\U>S!B^<!B""SISJB\S<!BVU^V:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::LM!":! <SQU"S!;\B_UIU\W:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::L5!

APPENDIX B. CAVITATION TESTING FOR RIGID HEART VALVES.......................................................32!

B:! \S;\!QBIQS!;SIS"\UR^::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DL!_:! \S;\!QBIQS!>R`^\U^V::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DL!":! JSASJS^"S!QBIQS; ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DL!<:! cRJ]U^V!AI`U< ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DL!S:! B\JUBI!"@B>_SJ :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DL!A:! B\JUBI![JS;;`JS :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DL!V:! "BQU\B\UR^!<SAU^U\UR^ :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DL!@:! <S;"JU[\UR^!RA!<S\S"\RJ:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DD!U:! [JS;;`JS![JRAUIS ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DD!a:! QS^\JU"`IBJ![JS;;`JS:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DD!]:! >BeU>`>!QS^\JU"`IBJ![JS;;`JS:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DD!

APPENDIX C. BERNOULLI VERIFICATION...................................................................................................34!

APPENDIX D. ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY PROTOCOL.....................................................................................35!

B:!!<B\B!"RIIS"\S<!_W!\@S!;\`<W!"S^\SJ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DE!_:!!"BI"`IB\UR^;!B^<!B^BIW;U;!_W!\@S!"RJS!IB_RJB\RJW ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::DT!":!!QBIQ`IBJ!JSV`JVU\B\UR^::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::ZD!

Page 5: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

Draft Guidance for Industry and FDA Staff !

Heart Valves - Investigational Device Exemption

(IDE) and Premarket Approval (PMA)

Applications !

This draft guidance, when finalized, will represent the Food and Drug Administration's

(FDA's) current thinking on this topic. It does not create or confer any rights for or on any

person and does not operate to bind FDA or the public. You can use an alternative approach

if the approach satisfies the requirements of the applicable statutes and regulations. If you

want to discuss an alternative approach, contact the FDA staff responsible for implementing

this guidance. If you cannot identify the appropriate FDA staff, call the appropriate number

listed on the title page of this guidance.

I. Introduction !

\/%!,+-*)&1%!-(!-&'%&*%*!'#!8.#9-*%!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!0#.!'/%!8.%8).)'-#&!#0!-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!

*%9-1%!%Y%$8'-#&!?U<SF!)&*!8.%$).=%'!)88.#9)2!?[>BF!)882-1)'-#&(!0#.!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!

9)29%(!'/)'!).%!&#'!)22#,.)0'!/%).'!9)29%(!#.!$#.%!'/)&!$-&-$)227!$)&-8+2)'%*!)22#,.)0'!/%).'!

9)29%(:!!\/-(!,+-*)&1%K!*%(1.-3%(!A<Bf(!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!)3#+'!$)&+0)1'+.-&,G!8.%12-&-1)2!*5'

6*,$1!3%&1/!'%('-&,G!8.%12-&-1)2'*5'6*61!('+*-%(G!12-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'-#&(G!)&*!2)3%2-&,!'/)'!).%!

*-00%.%&'!0.#$!#.!-&!)**-'-#&!'#!'/%!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!#0!'/%!U&'%.&)'-#&)2!R.,)&-g)'-#&!A#.!

;')&*).*-g)'-#&!?U;RFG!U;R!EMZ6NL66EG!h").*-#9)(1+2).!U$82)&'(!C!").*-)1!Q)29%![.#('/%(%(i!

?U;R!EMZ6F:L!B2'/#+,/!'/%!,+-*)&1%!8.#9-*%(!-&0#.$)'-#&!1#$82%$%&').7!'#!U;R!EMZ6NL66EG

D!

'/%!,+-*)&1%!1)&!)2(#!3%!+(%*!4-'/!#'/%.!$%'/#*(!%P+-9)2%&'!'#!U;R!EMZ6NL66E:!

!

\/-(!,+-*)&1%!-(!-&'%&*%*!0#.!+(%!37!$%$3%.(!#0!-&*+('.7!)&*!A<B!(')00!4/#!8.%8).%!#.!.%9-%4!

.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!U<S!)&*![>B!)882-1)'-#&(:!!U&!'/-(!*#1+$%&'G!'/%!'%.$(!h7#+i!)&*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!K!A<B!-((+%*!,+-*)&1%!#&!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(!-&!K55Z!?h'/%!K55Z!*.)0'iFG!3%0#.%!'/%!A<B!

V##*!V+-*)&1%![.)1'-1%(!4%.%!-$82%$%&'%*!-&!L666!)&*!3%0#.%!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!4)(!8+32-(/%*:!!

A<B!4-'/*.%4!'/%!K55Z!*.)0'!-&!L66E!?T6!AJ!MLZG!a)&+).7!EG!L66EF!)&*!-(!&#4!-((+-&,!'/-(!*.)0'!

,+-*)&1%!0#.!8+32-1!1#$$%&':!!!L!B**-'-#&)2!-&0#.$)'-#&!#&!'/%!"<J@!(')&*).*(!8.#,.)$!1)&!3%!0#+&*!)'!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O1*./O('*(8.#,:/'$2!!D!A<B!/)(!.%1#,&-g%*!#&27!'/%!L66E!9%.(-#&!#0!U;R!EMZ6G!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!?TK!AJ!KHDKDG!>).1/!

DKG!L66HF:!

! K

cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
Page 6: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

h7#+.i!.%0%.!'#!$%$3%.(!#0!-&*+('.7G!)2(#!=&#4&!)(!h(8#&(#.(i!#.!h)882-1)&'(Gi!)&*!'/%!'%.$(!

h4%Gi!h+(Gi!h#+.Gi!)&*!hB,%&17i!.%0%.!'#!A<B:!

!

A<Bj(!,+-*)&1%!*#1+$%&'(G!-&12+*-&,!'/-(!,+-*)&1%G!*#!&#'!%(')32-(/!2%,)227!%&0#.1%)32%!

.%(8#&(-3-2-'-%(:!!U&('%)*G!,+-*)&1%(!*%(1.-3%!'/%!B,%&17j(!1+..%&'!'/-&=-&,!#&!)!'#8-1!)&*!(/#+2*!

3%!9-%4%*!#&27!)(!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(G!+&2%((!(8%1-0-1!.%,+2)'#.7!#.!(')'+'#.7!.%P+-.%$%&'(!).%!

1-'%*:!!\/%!+(%!#0!'/%!4#.*!+718&#!-&!B,%&17!,+-*)&1%(!$%)&(!'/)'!(#$%'/-&,!-(!(+,,%('%*!#.!

.%1#$$%&*%*G!3+'!&#'!.%P+-.%*:!\/%!+(%!#0!'/%!4#.*!38+,!$%)&(!'/)'!(#$%'/-&,!-(!.%P+-.%*:!

!

II. Background B!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!-(!)!*%9-1%!-&'%&*%*!'#!8%.0#.$!'/%!0+&1'-#&!#0!)&7!#0!'/%!/%).'f(!

&)'+.)2!9)29%(:!!B!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!-(!)!8.%)$%&*$%&'!'78%!*%9-1%G!'/)'!-(G!)!*%9-1%!

$).=%'%*!8.-#.!'#!8)((),%!#0!'/%!>%*-1)2!<%9-1%!B$%&*$%&'(!'#!'/%!A%*%.)2!A##*G!<.+,G!)&*!

"#($%'-1!B1'!?'/%!B1'F:!!B!8%.(#&!$)7!$).=%'!)!8.%)$%&*$%&'(!*%9-1%!'/)'!-(!12)((!UUU!37!

#8%.)'-#&!#0!2)4G!'/.#+,/!8.%$).=%'!&#'-0-1)'-#&!8.#1%*+.%(!4-'/#+'!(+3$-((-#&!#0!)!8.%$).=%'!

)88.#9)2!)882-1)'-#&!?[>BFG!+&'-2!A<B!8.#$+2,)'%(!)!0-&)2!.%,+2)'-#&!+&*%.!(%1'-#&!EKE?3F!#0!

'/%!)1'!?LK!`:;:":!DH6%?3FF!.%P+-.-&,!8.%$).=%'!)88.#9)2:!

!

R&!>)7!KDG!K5MT!A<B!-((+%*!)!0-&)2!.+2%!?EL!AJ!KMKHLF!.%P+-.-&,!)![>B!#.!)!&#'-1%!#0!

1#$82%'-#&!#0!)!8.#*+1'!*%9%2#8$%&'!8.#'#1#2!?[<[F!0#.!)&7!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!'/)'!4)(!-&!

1#$$%.1-)2!*-('.-3+'-#&!3%0#.%!>)7!LMG!K5THG!#.!'/)'!#&!#.!3%0#.%!<%1%$3%.!5G!K5MTG!A<B!/)*!!

0#+&*!'#!3%!(+3(')&'-)227!%P+-9)2%&'!'#!)!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!'/)'!4)(!-&!1#$$%.1-)2!

*-('.-3+'-#&!3%0#.%!>)7!LMG!K5TH!?(%%!LK!"AJ!MT6:D5LEF:!!

!

A<B!.%0%.(!'#!*%9-1%(!'/)'!4%.%!&#'!-&!1#$$%.1-)2!*-('.-3+'-#&!3%0#.%!>)7!LMG!K5THG!)(!

h8#(')$%&*$%&'(!*%9-1%(:i!!\/%(%!*%9-1%!'78%(!).%!12)((-0-%*!)+'#$)'-1)227!37!(')'+'%!?(%1'-#&!

EKD?0F!#0!'/%!)1'!?LK!`:;:":!DH61?0FF!-&'#!12)((!UUU!4-'/#+'!)&7!A<B!.+2%$)=-&,!8.#1%((:!

>%1/)&-1)2!?8.#*+1'!1#*%!IcJF!)&*!&#&C)22#,.)0'!'-((+%!/%).'!9)29%(!?8.#*+1'!1#*%!IcdF!!).%!

8#(')$%&*$%&'!*%9-1%!'78%(!'/)'!/)9%!3%%&!.%9-%4%*!)&*!)88.#9%*!)(![>B(:!!

!

III. Scope

\/%!/%).'!9)29%(!)**.%((%*!-&!'/-(!,+-*)&1%!).%!-&'%&*%*!'#!8%.0#.$!'/%!0+&1'-#&(!#0!)&7!#0!'/%!

/%).'f(!&)'+.)2!9)29%(:!!\/-(!,+-*)&1%!)**.%((%(!9)29%(!1#&('.+1'%*!#0!8.#('/%'-1!$)'%.-)2(G!

3-#2#,-1!9)29%(!?%:,:G!8#.1-&%!9)29%(FG!#.!9)29%(!1#&('.+1'%*!#0!)!1#$3-&)'-#&!#0!8.#('/%'-1!)&*!

3-#2#,-1!$)'%.-)2(:!!!

!

! L

cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
Page 7: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

Classification

(21 CFR)

Class Product

Code

Description

MT6:D5LE! UUU! <WS! J%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!

†! UUU! Icd! @%).'!9)29%G!$%1/)&-1)2!

† UUU! IcJ! @%).'!9)29%G!&#&C)22#,.)0'!'-((+%!

†J%P+-.%(!8.%$).=%'!)88.#9)2!)882-1)'-#&!3%0#.%!$).=%'-&,!?(%%!(%1'-#&!EKD?)F!#0!'/%!A%*%.)2!

A##*G!<.+,G!)&*!"#($%'-1!B1'!?LK!`:;:":!DH61?)FFF:!

!

\/%!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!-&!'/-(!*#1+$%&'!$)7!)2(#!)8827!'#!&%4!'78%(!#0!/%).'!9)29%(!?%:,:G!'-((+%C

%&,-&%%.%*!9)29%(G!8#27$%.!2%)02%'!9)29%(F:!!!

!

\/-(!,+-*)&1%!)2(#!)882-%(!'#!8%.1+')&%#+(27!*%2-9%.%*!9)29%(k!/#4%9%.G!*-00%.%&'!#.!)**-'-#&)2!*5'

6*,$19'*5'6*61'8.%12-&-1)2G!)&*!12-&-1)2!('+*-%(!$)7!3%!)88.#8.-)'%!0#.!(+1/!*%9-1%(G!*%8%&*-&,!#&!

'/%!(8%1-0-1!*%9-1%!*%(-,&G!'/%!8.#8#(%*!-&*-1)'-#&(!0#.!+(%G!)&*!'/%!.%(+2'(!#0!7#+.!.-(=!)&)27(-(:Z!!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!7#+!1#&')1'!'/%!"-.1+2)'#.7!)&*![.#('/%'-1(!<%9-1%(!_.)&1/!'#!*-(1+((!82)&&%*!

(+3$-((-#&(!0#.!8%.1+')&%#+(27!*%2-9%.%*!9)29%(:!

!

\/-(!,+-*)&1%!*#%(!&#'!)8827!'#!9)29%C.%8)-.!*%9-1%(!?%:,:G!)&&+2#82)('7!.-&,(!?8.#*+1'!1#*%!

]J@G!MT6:DM66FE!#.!$-'.)2!9)29%!.%8)-.!*%9-1%(!?8.#*+1'!1#*%!^]>FF:!!

!

\/-(!,+-*)&1%!*#%(!&#'!)8827!'#!)22#,.)0'!/%).'!9)29%(:!![2%)(%!1#&')1'!A<Bf(!"%&'%.!0#.!

_-#2#,-1(G!S9)2+)'-#&!)&*!J%(%).1/!?"_SJF!0#.!-&0#.$)'-#&!)3#+'!'/%!.%,+2)'#.7!.%P+-.%$%&'(!

0#.!)22#,.)0'!/%).'!9)29%(:H!!!

!

\/-(!,+-*)&1%!*#%(!&#'!)8827!'#!$#.%!'/)&!$-&-$)227!$)&-8+2)'%*!)22#,.)0'!/%).'!9)29%(!?8.#*+1'!

1#*%!R@BFG!4/-1/!.%P+-.%!12%).)&1%!#0!)!EK6?=F!8.-#.!'#!$).=%'-&,:!!!

!

IV. Risk Analysis

J-(=!)&)27(-(!-(!)!0#.$)2!8.#1%*+.%!37!4/-1/!7#+!%('-$)'%!'/%!8.#3)3-2-'7!)&*!*%,.%%!#0!/).$!)!

*%9-1%!.%8.%(%&'(G!)&*!82)&!)88.#8.-)'%!-&9%('-,)'-#&(!)11#.*-&,27!'#!$-'-,)'%!'/#(%!.-(=(!'#!'/%!

%Y'%&'!8#((-32%:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!)!.-(=!)&)27(-(!)(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!

#.!-'(!%P+-9)2%&'!?%:,:G!/)g).*!-*%&'-0-1)'-#&G!)((#1-)'%*!0)-2+.%!$#*%(G!.-(=!%('-$)'-#&G!.-(=!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Z!A#.!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!'/)'!$)7!3%!)882-1)32%!'#!('+*-%(!#0!*%2-9%.7!(7('%$(!0#.!8%.1+')&%#+(27!

*%2-9%.%*!9)29%(G!(%%!'/%!(%1'-#&(!.%2)'%*!'#!*%2-9%.7!(7('%$!'%('-&,!*%(1.-3%*!-&!'/%!A<B!

,+-*)&1%G!Non-Clinical Tests and Recommended Labeling for Intravascular Stents and

Associated Delivery Systems!)'!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+1$6

TKMHD:/'$:! !E!;%%!'/%!A<B!,+-*)&1%G!Guidance for Annuloplasty Rings 510(k) Submissions!)'!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+1$6

TDHZZ:/'$:! !H!;%%!/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O13%.O'-((:/'$:!

! D

cris
cris
Page 8: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

%9)2+)'-#&G!.-(=!1#&'.#2G!)&*!.-(=!.%9-%4F:!!W#+.!U<S!)882-1)'-#&(!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!7#+.!-&-'-)2!.-(=!

)&)27(-(!0#.!7#+.!*%9-1%!)&*!7#+.![>B!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!)&!+8*)'%*!.-(=!)&)27(-(:!!!

V. The Pre-Submission Process

\#!+(%!'/-(!,+-*)&1%!%00%1'-9%27G!4%!%&1#+.),%!7#+!'#!/)9%!0.%P+%&'!)&*!%).27!-&'%.)1'-#&!4-'/!

A<B!.%9-%4%.(:!!c%!)2(#!%&1#+.),%!7#+!'#!+(%!A<Bj(!8.%C(+3$-((-#&!8.#1%*+.%!0#.!'/-(!

-&'%.)1'-#&:!!\/%!8+.8#(%!#0!)!8.%C(+3$-((-#&!-&'%.)1'-#&!-(!'#!8.#9-*%!)!$%1/)&-($!0#.!7#+!)&*!

A<B!'#!1#$$+&-1)'%!-&0#.$)227!)3#+'!8.%12-&-1)2!('+*-%(!?-:%:G!3%&1/!)&*O#.!)&-$)2F!3%0#.%!7#+!

1#&*+1'!'/%(%!('+*-%(G!#.!)3#+'!)!12-&-1)2!8.#'#1#2!3%0#.%!7#+!(+3$-'!)&!U<S!)882-1)'-#&:!!W#+.!

8.%C(+3$-((-#&!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!)!*%(1.-8'-#&!#0!'/%!*%9-1%G!-'(!-&'%&*%*!+(%G!)&*!)!.-(=!)&)27(-(:!!

W#+.!8.%C(+3$-((-#&!(/#+2*!)2(#!-&12+*%!(+$$).-%(!#0!7#+.!8.#8#(%*!'%('!82)&G!8.#'#1#2(G!)&*!

-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!82)&(:!!U&!)**-'-#&G!7#+.!8.%C(+3$-((-#&!(/#+2*!1#&')-&!12%).27!*%0-&%*!P+%('-#&(!

0#.!*-(1+((-#&!4-'/!A<B:!!W#+!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!8-1'+.%(G!(2-*%(G!9-*%#(G!#.!()$82%(G!-0!7#+!3%2-%9%!

'/%7!).%!+(%0+2!'#!+&*%.(')&*!7#+.!*%9-1%:!

!

VI. IDE and PMA Applications: General Considerations

"2-&-1)2!('+*-%(!1#&*+1'%*!-&!'/%!`&-'%*!;')'%(!-&!(+88#.'!#0!)![>B!)88.#9)2!$+('!3%!1#&*+1'%*!

+&*%.!'/%!U&9%('-,)'-#&)2!<%9-1%!SY%$8'-#&(!?U<SF!.%,+2)'-#&G!LK!"AJ![).'!MKL:!!A<B!3%2-%9%(!

*%9-1%(!)**.%((%*!37!'/-(!,+-*)&1%!*#1+$%&'!).%!(-,&-0-1)&'!.-(=!*%9-1%(!)(!*%0-&%*!-&!LK!"AJ!

MKL:D?$F:T!!U&!)**-'-#&!'#!'/%!.%P+-.%$%&'!#0!/)9-&,!)!A<BC)88.#9%*!U<SG!(8#&(#.(!$+('!

1#$827!4-'/!'/%!.%,+2)'-#&(!,#9%.&-&,!-&('-'+'-#&)2!.%9-%4!3#).*(!?LK!"AJ![).'!EHF!)&*!

-&0#.$%*!1#&(%&'!?LK!"AJ![).'!E6F:!

!

W#+.!U<S!)882-1)'-#&!$+('!-&12+*%!)!1#$82%'%!.%8#.'!#0!8.-#.!-&9%('-,)'-#&(!#0!'/%!*%9-1%!

-&12+*-&,!)22!8.-#.!12-&-1)2G!)&-$)2!)&*!2)3#.)'#.7!'%('-&,!?LK!"AJ!MKL:L6!?3F?LF!)&*!MKL:LT?)FF:!!

B!1#$82%'%!.%8#.'!4#+2*!-&12+*%!*5'6*,$1!2)3#.)'#.7!'%('-&,!.%(+2'(G!*5'6*61!)&-$)2!('+*7!'%('-&,!

.%(+2'(G!)&*!'/%!8.#'#1#2(!0#.!'/%!12-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'-#&(!0#.!8.-#.!-&9%('-,)'-#&(:!!

!

U&!,%&%.)2G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#$82%'%!*5'6*,$1!'%('-&,!#0!7#+.!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!

3%0#.%!7#+!(+3$-'!7#+.!U<S:!!U'!$)7!3%!)88.#8.-)'%G!/#4%9%.G!'#!1#$82%'%!1%.')-&!2#&,C'%.$!*5'

6*,$1!'%('(!4/-2%!7#+!1#&*+1'!7#+.!12-&-1)2!('+*7:!!W#+!(/#+2*!*-(1+((!7#+.!.)'-#&)2%!0#.!

(+3$-((-#&!#0!)&7!'%('(!0#.!4/-1/!'%('-&,!-(!&#'!1#$82%'%!4-'/!'/%!.%9-%4!3.)&1/!3%0#.%!

(+3$-''-&,!7#+.!U<S:!!c%!3%2-%9%!'/)'!-&!)22!1)(%(!7#+!(/#+2*!1#$82%'%!7#+.!)11%2%.)'%*!4%).!

'%('-&,!3%0#.%!7#+!(+3$-'!7#+.!U<S:!!!

!

W#+.![>B!)882-1)'-#&!$+('!1#&')-&!*)')!)&*!-&0#.$)'-#&!-&!(+00-1-%&'!*%')-2!'#!8%.$-'!A<B!'#!

)88.#9%!#.!*%&7!)88.#9)2!#0!'/%!)882-1)'-#&G!-&12+*-&,!'/%!$%'/#*(!)&*!8.#'#1#2(!+(%*!-&!12-&-1)2!

-&9%('-,)'-#&(!-&9#29-&,!/+$)&!(+3l%1'(!?LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6?3F?HFF:!!W#+!$+('!8.#9-*%!'/%!.%(+2'(!

0.#$!)22!8.%12-&-1)2!*5'6*,$1G!8.%12-&-1)2!*5'6*61G!)&*!12-&-1)2!'%('-&,!7#+!/)9%!1#&*+1'%*:!!U*:!!

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!T!;%%!/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O#1O#/.'O-.3(O*%9-1%(:/'$2m.-(=:!

! Z

cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
Page 9: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

VII. Terms and Definitions

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!+(%!'/%!'%.$(!)&*!*%0-&-'-#&(!*%0-&%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!4/%&!8.%8).-&,!

U<S(!)&*![>B(!0#.!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(:!!U&!)**-'-#&G!A<B!+(%(!'/%!0#22#4-&,!'%.$(N!!!

!

Replacement Heart Valve:!!B2'/#+,/!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!+(%(!'/%!'%.$!h/%).'!9)29%!(+3('-'+'%i!

'#!$%)&!)!8.#('/%'-1!/%).'!9)29%G!4%!+(%!'/%!'%.$!h.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%i!-&!LK!"AJ!

MT6:D5LE!)&*!-&!'/-(!,+-*)&1%:!!c%!+&*%.(')&*!'/%!'%.$!h.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%i!'#!3%!

%P+-9)2%&'!'#!h/%).'!9)29%!(+3('-'+'%i!?+(%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66EF!)&*!%P+-9)2%&'!'#!(+1/!'%.$(!

)(!h8.#('/%'-1!/%).'!9)29%i!)&*!h/%).'!9)29%!-$82)&'i!0#.!8+.8#(%(!#0!'/-(!,+-*)&1%:!

!

Pressure Gradient:!!B2'/#+,/!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!+(%(!'/%!'%.$(!h$%)&!8.%((+.%!*-00%.%&1%i!

)&*!h8%)=!8.%((+.%!*-00%.%&1%Gi!4%!+(%!'/%!'%.$!h$%)&!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'i!-&!'/-(!,+-*)&1%!

-&('%)*!#0!h$%)&!8.%((+.%!*-00%.%&1%i!)&*!'/%!'%.$!h8%)=!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'i!-&!'/-(!,+-*)&1%!

-&('%)*!#0!h8%)=!8.%((+.%!*-00%.%&1%i!3%1)+(%!'/%!'%.$!h8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'i!-(!+(%*!)2$#('!

%Y12+(-9%27!-&!'/%!`:;:!12-&-1)2!).%&)!)&*!-&!'/%!4#.2*4-*%!12-&-1)2!/%).'!9)29%!2-'%.)'+.%:!!c%!

.%1#,&-g%!'/)'!'/%!'%.$!h8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'i!/)(!)!9%.7!(8%1-0-1!*%0-&-'-#&!-&!%&,-&%%.-&,!?-:%:G!

8.%((+.%O*-(')&1%F!'/)'!-(!&#'!1#&(-('%&'!4-'/!'/%!+(%!#0!'/-(!'%.$!-&!'/-(!,+-*)&1%:!

!

Tissue Annulus Diameter:!!\/%!'-((+%!)&&+2+(!*-)$%'%.!?\B<F!-(!*%0-&%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!

)(!'/%!*-)$%'%.!-&!$-22-$%'%.(!)'!'/%!($)22%('!02#4!).%)!4-'/-&!'/%!8)'-%&'f(!9)29%!)&&+2+(:!!

\/%!9)29%!(-g%!-(!&#4!*-('-&1'27!1#..%2)'%*!4-'/!'/%!\B<!)'!-'(!&)..#4%('!#8%&-&,:!!B(!(+1/G!

7#+.!*%(-,&)'-#&!#0!)!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!(/#+2*!-&*-1)'%!'/%!\B<!#0!'/%!.%1-8-%&'!-&!

$-22-$%'%.(!?-:%:G!\B<!-(!&#4!.%0%..%*!'#!)(!'/%!*%(-,&)'%*!9)29%!(-g%F:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!

7#+!0#22#4!'/-(!(')&*).*-g%*!*%0-&-'-#&!'#!)((+.%!'/%!1#..%1'!(-g%*!9)29%!-(!+(%*:!

!

U0!7#+!+(%!)!'%.$G!*%0-&-'-#&!#.!)33.%9-)'-#&!'/)'!*-00%.(!0.#$!)&7!)3#9%!#.!0.#$!'/#(%!#0!U;R!

EMZ6NL66EG!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&12+*%!'/-(!-&0#.$)'-#&!-&!7#+.!)882-1)'-#&:!!!

VIII. Device Description

U&!7#+.!U<S!)&*![>B!)882-1)'-#&!7#+!$+('!-&12+*%!)!*%(1.-8'-#&!#0!'/%!*%9-1%!?LK!"AJ!

MKL:LE?*F!)&*!LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6?3F?DF?--FF:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!'/%!0#22#4-&,!

*%(1.-8'-9%!-&0#.$)'-#&!-&!7#+.!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!U<S!#.![>B!)882-1)'-#&:!!!!

!

Device Parameters

W#+.!U<S!)&*![>B!)882-1)'-#&!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!)!*%(1.-8'-#&!#0!%)1/!#0!'/%!,%&%.)2!*%9-1%!

*%(-,&!8).)$%'%.(!2-('%*!3%2#4:!!B!')3+2).!0#.$)'!-(!*%(-.)32%G!(/#4&!-&!'/%!%Y)$82%!

0#22#4-&,!'/%!2-('!3%2#4:!

! U$82)&')'-#&G!-&12+*-&,!9)29%!2#1)'-#&(G!)&&+2+(!8#(-'-#&(G!)&*!(+'+.%!'%1/&-P+%!

! I%)02%'(OR112+*%.G!-&*-1)'-&,!'/%!&+$3%.G!$)'%.-)2G!)&*!0#.!.-,-*!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!

9)29%(G!'/%!0+227!#8%&%*!)&,2%G!0+227!12#(%*!)&,2%G!)&*!'.)9%2!).1!0.#$!#8%&%*!'#!

12#(%*!

! E

cris
cris
cris
Page 10: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! J)*-#8)1-'7G!-*%&'-07-&,!'/%!.)*-#8)P+%!$)'%.-)2!)&*!2#1)'-#&!#0!.)*-#8)P+%!$)'%.-)2!

! @#+(-&,O;'%&'G!*%(1.-3-&,!'/%!2%)02%'!).'-1+2)'-#&!$%1/)&-($!)&*!('%&'!$)'%.-)2!

! ;%4-&,!1+00G!-&*-1)'-&,!4/%'/%.!'/%!(%4-&,!1+00!-(!.#')')32%!)&*!*%(1.-3-&,!'/%!

)'')1/$%&'!$%1/)&-($!)&*!$)'%.-)2!

! "#)'-&,(!)&*!'.%)'$%&'(G!-0!)&7G!%Y82)-&-&,!'/%!8+.8#(%!?%:,:G!!)&'-3-#'-1G!

)&'-'/.#$3#'-1G!)&'-1)21-0-1F!)&*!2#1)'-#&!

! B11%((#.-%(G!(+1/!)(!-$82)&')'-#&!'##2(!?%:,:G!/#2*%.G!.#')'#.G!2%)02%'!8.#3%G!(-g%.F:!

!

Valve General Design Parameters Tabular Format Example!GENERAL DESIGN FEATURES

PARAMETER DESCRIPTION

Valve locations(s):

Annulus position(s):

Implantation:

Suture technique:

No. leaflets/occluders:

Fully opened angle*:

Fully closed angle*:

Travel arc from opened to closed*:

Leaflets/ Occluder:

Material:

Radiopaque material: Radiopacity:

Location of radiopaque material:

Leaflet articulation mechanism: Housing/ Stent:

Material:

Rotatable/not:

Attachment mechanism:

Sewing cuff:

Material:

Purpose:

(antibiotic, antithrombotic, anticalcific, etc.)

Coatings/ Treatments:

Location:

Accessories: Implantation tools (holder, rotator, leaflet probe, sizer).

Other:

*Applicable only to rigid replacement heart valves.

!

W#+.!U<S!)&*![>B!)882-1)'-#&!(/#+2*!)2(#!-&12+*%!)!*%(1.-8'-#&!#0!%)1/!#0!'/%!*-$%&(-#&)2!

*%(-,&!8).)$%'%.(!2-('%*!3%2#4!0#.!%)1/!(-g%!7#+!82)&!'#!$).=%':!!!

! \-((+%!B&&+2+(!<-)$%'%.!?\B<F!?$$F!

! Q)29%!R+'%.!<-)$%'%.!?R<F!?*-1')'%*!37!1+00!R<F!?$$F! !

! H

Page 11: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! Q)29%!U&&%.!<-)$%'%.!?U<F!?*-1')'%*!37!/#+(-&,!U<F!?$$F!

! V%#$%'.-1!R.-0-1%!B.%)!?$$LF!

! [.#0-2%!@%-,/'?(F!?$$F:! !

!

Packaging Information

W#+.!U<S!)&*![>B!)882-1)'-#&!$+('!-&12+*%!)!*%(1.-8'-#&!#0!'/%!8)1=-&,!$%'/#*(!+(%*!?LK!

"AJ!MKL:L6?3F?DF!)&*!LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6?3F?ZF?9FF:!!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!7#+!-&12+*%!8)1=),-&,!

*%(-,&!)&*!8%.0#.$)&1%!-&0#.$)'-#&!)(!*%(1.-3%*!3%2#4:!!B!')3+2).!0#.$)'!-(!*%(-.)32%G!)(!

(/#4&!-&!'/%!%Y)$82%!)'!'/%!%&*!#0!'/-(!(%1'-#&:!

!

1. Package Design!!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*%(1.-3%!'/%!8)1=),%!*%(-,&!)&*!-&12+*%!$)((!)&*!9#2+$%!?0#.!

8+.8#(%(!#0!1)21+2)'-&,!2#)*!*%&(-'7!0#.!('%.-2-g)'-#&!9)2-*)'-#&FG!)22!1#$8#&%&'(G!)&*!)&7!

0%)'+.%!'/)'!-&*-1)'%(!4/%'/%.!'/%!8)1=),%!/)(!3%%&!#8%&%*:!!W#+.!*%(1.-8'-#&!(/#+2*!

-&12+*%!(%)2-&,!8).)$%'%.(G!(+1/!)(!'-$%G!'%$8%.)'+.%G!)&*!2-*!12#(+.%!'#.P+%:!!W#+.!

*%(1.-8'-#&!(/#+2*!)2(#!-&12+*%!8%.0#.$)&1%!(8%1-0-1)'-#&(!0#.!'/%!('%.-2-g)'-#&!1712%(G!2-*G!

(%)2G!9)1++$!2%)=!.%(-(')&1%G!)&*!)&7!(%)2-&,!')8%!#.!'%$8%.)'+.%!-&*-1)'#.(:!!!

!

2. Temperature Sensor

A#.!9)29%(!'/)'!1#&')-&!3-#2#,-1)2!'-((+%G!(+1/!)(!8#.1-&%G!3#9-&%G!#.!%P+-&%!9)29%(G!4%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!+(%!)!'%$8%.)'+.%!(%&(#.:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&12+*%!

-&0#.$)'-#&!)3#+'!/#4!7#+!9)2-*)'%!'/%!(%&(-'-9-'7!#0!'/%!(%&(#.:!

!

3. Storage for Valves that Contain Biological Tissue

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!)!2-('!#0!'/%!1#$8#&%&'(!#0!'/%!('#.),%!(#2+'-#&:!!c%!

)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&*-1)'%!'/%!)$#+&'!#0!'/%!.%(-*+)2!('#.),%!(#2+'-#&!2%0'!#&!'/%!

9)29%!'-((+%!)&*!-&!'/%!+(%*!.-&(%!(#2+'-#&!)0'%.!'/%!9)29%!/)(!3%%&!.-&(%*!)11#.*-&,!'#!'/%!

8.#1%*+.%!(8%1-0-%*!-&!7#+.!2)3%2-&,:!!!

Package Information – Tabular Format Example

Package Information

Package mass and volume

for purposes of calculating load density for sterilization validation

Package components i.e., container (jar), holder, lid and seal components (sealing tape), components or feature that indicates if the package has been opened

Storage solution amount of the residual storage solution left on the valve tissue and in the used rinse solution after the valve has been rinsed according to the procedure specified in your labeling

PARAMETER SPECIFICATION (average, min)

Seal time, temperature, and pressure

Sealing parameters

Lid closure torque

! T

Page 12: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!Maximum no. of sterilization cycles

Tensile strength Sealing tape

Shrinkage

Minimum seal width

Peel force

Seal

Burst strength

Lid removal torque

Vacuum leak resistance

Composition Storage solution

pH

Performance specifications

Temperature indicators

IX. Pyrogenicity

W#+!$+('!%(')32-(/!)&*!$)-&')-&!8.#1%*+.%(!0#.!)11%8')&1%!)1'-9-'-%(!?LK!"AJ!ML6:M6F:!!W#+!

$+('!%(')32-(/!)&*!$)-&')-&!8.#1%*+.%(!0#.!0-&-(/%*!*%9-1%!)11%8')&1%!'#!%&(+.%!'/)'!%)1/!

8.#*+1'-#&!.+&G!2#'G!#.!3)'1/!#0!0-&-(/%*!*%9-1%(!$%%'(!)11%8')&1%!1.-'%.-)!?LK!"AJ!ML6:M6?*FF:!!

B!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!-(!)&!-$82)&'%*!*%9-1%k!'/%.%0#.%!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!'%('!7#+.!

*%9-1%!0#.!87.#,%&-1-'7!?(8%1-0-1)227!0#.!%&*#'#Y-&(F:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%N!

! *%(1.-8'-#&!#0!'/%!$%'/#*!+(%*!'#!$)=%!'/%!*%'%.$-&)'-#&G!%:,:G!I-$+2+(!)$%3#17'%!27()'%!?IBIF!

! -*%&'-0-1)'-#&!#0!'/%!'%('-&,!%&*8#-&'!.%)1/%*!)&*!.)'-#&)2%!0#.!(%2%1'-&,!'/)'!%&*8#-&'!

! *%(1.-8'-#&!#0!'/%!%Y'.)1'-#&!'%1/&-P+%!+(%*!'#!#3')-&!'/%!'%('!02+-*!0.#$!'/%!'%('!*%9-1%G!(/#4-&,!'/)'!)22!12-&-1)227!.%2%9)&'!1#&')1'!(+.0)1%(!#0!'/%!'%('!*%9-1%!4%.%!

)((%((%*!

! -*%&'-0-1)'-#&!#0!'/%!.%0%.%&1%!$%'/#*!+(%*G!%:,:G!`&-'%*!;')'%(![/).$)1#8%-)!?`;[FG!B^;UOBB>U!;\!TLNL66LG!_)1'%.-)2!%&*#'#Y-&(!C!\%('!$%'/#*#2#,-%(G!

.#+'-&%!$#&-'#.-&,G!)&*!)2'%.&)'-9%(!'#!3)'1/!'%('-&,!#.!A<B!,+-*)&1%:!

X. Sterilization

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!0#22#4!'/%!('%.-2-g)'-#&!$%'/#*(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66EG!#.!

%P+-9)2%&'!$%)(+.%(:!

!

1. Non-Sterile Devices

U0!7#+!-&'%&*!'#!(+8827!7#+.!*%9-1%!&#&C('%.-2%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%Y82)-&!7#+.!

.)'-#&)2%:!!W#+!(/#+2*!-&*-1)'%!8.#$-&%&'27!#&!7#+.!2)3%2-&,!'/)'!'/%!*%9-1%!-(!(+882-%*!

&#&C('%.-2%!)&*!8.#9-*%!-&('.+1'-#&(!0#.!)11%8')32%!+(%!8).)$%'%.(G!(+1/!)(!'%$8%.)'+.%G!

8.%((+.%G!*4%22!'-$%(!0#.!'/%!-&-'-)2!('%.-2-g)'-#&:!!B**-'-#&)227G!7#+!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!-&!7#+.!

! M

Page 13: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

2)3%2-&,!4/%'/%.!.%C('%.-2-g)'-#&G!+(-&,!'/%(%!8).)$%'%.(G!-(!)88.#8.-)'%:!!\/%!

*%'%.$-&)'-#&!4/%'/%.!.%C('%.-2-g)'-#&!-(!)88.#8.-)'%!(/#+2*!3%!3)(%*!#&!'/%!9)2-*)'-#&!

'%('-&,!0#.!'/%!(')'%*!8).)$%'%.(G!)&*!'/%!&+$3%.!#0!.%('%.-2-g)'-#&(:!!

2. Resterilization

W#+.!2)3%2-&,!(/#+2*!8.#9-*%!-&('.+1'-#&(!0#.!)11%8')32%!8).)$%'%.(!'#!3%!+(%*G!(+1/!)(!

'%$8%.)'+.%G!8.%((+.%G!*4%22!'-$%(G!3)(%*!#&!9)2-*)'-#&(!*#&%!'#!9)2-*)'%!'/%(%!8).)$%'%.(!

)&*!&+$3%.(!#0!.%('%.-2-g)'-#&(:!!U0!7#+.!2)3%2-&,!-&*-1)'%(!7#+.!*%9-1%!-(!.%('%.-2-g)32%!

?-:%:G!0#.!8)1=),%(!'/)'!).%!h#8%&!3+'!+&+(%*iFG!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+.!)882-1)'-#&!

-&12+*%N!

! )!.)'-#&)2%!(+88#.'-&,!'/%!()0%!)&*!%00%1'-9%!8%.0#.$)&1%!#0!7#+.!*%9-1%!)0'%.!.%('%.-2-g)'-#&!

! )!*%(1.-8'-#&!'/)'!*-00%.%&'-)'%(!3%'4%%&!('%.-2-g)'-#&!1#&*+1'%*!)'!'/%!$)&+0)1'+.-&,!0)1-2-'7!)&*!('%.-2-g)'-#&!8%.0#.$%*!37!/#(8-')2!(')00!

! 9)2-*)'-#&!#0!'/%!%00%1'!#0!.%('%.-2-g)'-#&!#&!'/%!9)29%:!!?Q)2-*)'-#&!(/#+2*!*%$#&('.)'%!'/)'!'/%!$)Y-$+$!&+$3%.!#0!.%('%.-2-g)'-#&(!.%1#$$%&*%*!-&!7#+.!

2)3%2-&,!*#%(!&#'!)00%1'!'/%!()0%!)&*!%00%1'-9%!8%.0#.$)&1%!#0!'/%!9)29%:F!!!

3. Validation Study

c/%.%!'/%!.%(+2'(!#0!)!8.#1%((!1)&&#'!3%!0+227!9%.-0-%*!37!(+3(%P+%&'!-&(8%1'-#&!)&*!'%('G!

)(!4-'/!0-&-(/%*!*%9-1%!('%.-2-g)'-#&G!'/%!8.#1%((!$+('!3%!9)2-*)'%*!4-'/!)!/-,/!*%,.%%!#0!

)((+.)&1%!?LK!"AJ!ML6:TEF:!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!(+3$-'!.%(+2'(!#0!)!9)2-*)'-#&!('+*7!

'#!(/#4!'/)'!'/%!('%.-2-g)'-#&!8.#1%((!8.#9-*%(!)!('%.-2-'7!)((+.)&1%!2%9%2!?;BIF!#0!)'!2%)('!

K6CHG!-:%:G!'/%!8.#3)3-2-'7!#0!0-&*-&,!)&!+&('%.-2-g%*!*%9-1%!-(!#&%!-&!#&%!$-22-#&:!!\/%!

9)2-*)'-#&!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!+(%!#0!-&#1+2)'%*!8.#*+1'!#.!-&*-1)'#.(!?3-#2#,-1)2!#.!#'/%.!

'78%(F!82)1%*!-&!'/%!2#1)'-#&!#0!'/%!*%9-1%!'/)'!-(!$#('!*-00-1+2'!'#!('%.-2-g%G!)&*!4-'/-&!'/%!

('%.-2-g)'-#&!1/)$3%.:!!Q-)32%!(8#.%!1#+&'!#&!3-#2#,-1)2!-&*-1)'#.(!(/#+2*!3%!9%.-0-%*!

3%0#.%!%)1/!+(%:!!\/%!#.,)&-($!1/#(%&!)(!'/%!-&*-1)'#.!(/#+2*!.%8.%(%&'!'/%!4#.('!1)(%!

#.,)&-($!0#.!'/%!8).'-1+2).!'78%!#0!('%.-2-g)'-#&!$%'/#*!1/#(%&:!!B22!%P+-8$%&'!+(%*!

*+.-&,!'/%!8.#1%((!'#!$#&-'#.!1#&*-'-#&(!?'/%.$#1#+82%(G!,)+,%(G!%'1:F!(/#+2*!/)9%!3%%&!

.%1%&'27!1)2-3.)'%*:!!<%$#&('.)'%!)&*!*#1+$%&'!'/)'!'/%!9)2-*)'-#&!$%'/#*(!1/#(%&!).%!

1#$8)'-32%!4-'/!'/%!*%9-1%!)&*!8)1=),-&,!$)'%.-)2(!'/+(!%(')32-(/-&,!'/%!/-,/!*%,.%%!#0!

)((+.)&1%:!

!

4. Controls

\/%!%&9-.#&$%&')2!1#&*-'-#&(!#0!7#+.!0)1-2-'7!1)&!.%)(#&)327!3%!%Y8%1'%*!'#!/)9%!)&!

)*9%.(%!%00%1'!#&!8.#*+1'!P+)2-'7:!!W#+!$+('!%(')32-(/!)&*!$)-&')-&!8.#1%*+.%(!'#!

)*%P+)'%27!1#&'.#2!'/%(%!%&9-.#&$%&')2!1#&*-'-#&(!?LK!"AJ!ML6:T6?1F!)&*!LK!"AJ!

ML6:T6?%FF:!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&12+*%!-&0#.$)'-#&!#&!'/%!1#&'.#2(!+(%*!'#!%&(+.%!

'/)'!'/%!3-#3+.*%&!#&!'/%!*%9-1%!-(!2#4!?%:,:G!'/%!12%)&-&,!(1/%*+2%!0#.!'/%!02##.(!)&*!

#'/%.!(+.0)1%(G!*-(-&0%1'-#&!8.#1%*+.%(G!$)&),%$%&'!#0!4)'%.!)&*!)-.!(7('%$(G!2)$-&).!

! 5

Page 14: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

02#4!/##*(G!('%.-2-g%.(F:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!(8%1-07!'/%!4).&-&,!)&*!)1'-#&!

2-$-'(!0#.!3-#3+.*%&:!!!

!

5. Package Integrity

W#+!$+('!%&(+.%!'/)'!*%9-1%!8)1=),%(!).%!*%(-,&%*!)&*!1#&('.+1'%*!'#!8.#'%1'!'/%!*%9-1%!

0.#$!)2'%.)'-#&!#.!*)$),%G!-&12+*-&,!'/%!1#&')$-&)'-#&!#0!('%.-2%!*%9-1%(!?LK!"AJ!

ML6:KD6F:!!\%('-&,!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!)&!)((%(($%&'!#0!8)1=),%!-&'%,.-'7!?9-)!+(%!#0!)!

8/7(-1)2!$%'/#*G!(+1/!)(!)!2%)=!'%('G!#.!)!$-1.#3-)2!1/)22%&,%!0#22#4%*!37!('%.-2-'7!

)((%(($%&'!#0!'/%!1#&'%&'(F:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!'%('!'/%!0-&)2!4/#2%!8)1=),%!)0'%.!

(-$+2)'%*!#.!.%)2C'-$%!),-&,G!(/-8$%&'G!/)&*2-&,!)&*!%&9-.#&$%&')2!('.%((-&,:!!\%('-&,!

'/%!0-&)2!4/#2%!8)1=),%!-(!8.%0%..%*!#9%.!)((%((-&,!8)1=),%!1#$8#&%&'(!(%8).)'%27G!#.!

#&27!)((%((-&,!(%)2%*!).%)(:!!

!

XI. Preclinical In Vitro Assessment

_)(%*!#&!7#+.!.-(=!)&)27(-(G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!8.%12-&-1)2!*5'6*,$1!'%('-&,!#&!7#+.!

.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!0#22#4-&,!'/%!$%'/#*(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!#.!%P+-9)2%&'!

$%'/#*(:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!%Y82)&)'-#&(!0#.!)&7!*5'6*,$1!'%('-&,!7#+!#$-':!!

W#+.!U<S!)&*![>B!)882-1)'-#&(!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!'/%!'%('!1#&*-'-#&(G!()$82%!(%2%1'-#&G!)&*!'%('!

.%8#.'(!0#.!'/%!0#22#4-&,N!

! $)'%.-)2!8.#8%.'7!'%('-&,!

! 3-#2#,-1)2!()0%'7!

! /7*.#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%!

! ('.+1'+.)2!8%.0#.$)&1%!

! *%9-1%!*+.)3-2-'7!

! 1#$8#&%&'!0)'-,+%!)((%(($%&'(!

! *%9-1%!(8%1-0-1!'%('-&,:!

!

A#.!%)1/!'%('G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+.!'%('!.%8#.'!-&12+*%!'/%!8.#'#1#2G!)11%8')&1%!1.-'%.-)!)&*!

.%(+2'(!?%-'/%.!)(!*)')!#.!8)((O0)-2F:!!W#+.!8.#'#1#2!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!()$82%!(-g%G!%&9-.#&$%&')2!

1#&*-'-#&(G!'%('!8).)$%'%.(G!)&*!'%('!*+.)'-#&:!!B!')3+2).!0#.$)'!-(!*%(-.)32%G!(%%!'/%!%Y)$82%!

')32%!)'!'/%!%&*!#0!'/-(!(%1'-#&:!

!

U&!)**-'-#&G!*%(-,&!1#&'.#2(!)8827!'#!)22!/%).'!9)29%(:!!W#+!$+('!%(')32-(/!)&*!$)-&')-&!

8.#1%*+.%(!-&!#.*%.!'#!%&(+.%!'/)'!(8%1-0-%*!*%(-,&!.%P+-.%$%&'(!).%!$%'!?LK!"AJ!ML6:D6?)FF:!!

\/%(%!8.#1%*+.%(!$+('!-&12+*%!*%(-,&!9)2-*)'-#&!8.#1%*+.%(:!!<%(-,&!9)2-*)'-#&!$+('!%&(+.%!'/)'!

*%9-1%(!1#&0#.$!'#!*%0-&%*!+(%.!&%%*(!)&*!-&'%&*%*!+(%(!)&*!$+('!-&12+*%!'%('-&,!#0!8.#*+1'-#&!

+&-'(!+&*%.!)1'+)2!#.!(-$+2)'%*!+(%!1#&*-'-#&(:!!?;%%!LK!"AJ!ML6:D6?,FF:!!B11#.*-&,27G!4%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&12+*%!'/%!-&0#.$)'-#&!*%(1.-3%*!3%2#4!-&!7#+.!U<S!#.![>B!)882-1)'-#&:!!!

!

!

! K6

cris
cris
Page 15: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

A. Valve Samples

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!)22!*5'6*,$1!'%('(!#&!0-&-(/%*!9)29%(G!#0!'/%!0-&)2!*%(-,&G!

%Y8#(%*!'#!'/%!$)Y-$+$!&+$3%.!#0!.%1#$$%&*%*!('%.-2-g)'-#&!1712%(:!

!

B. Reference Valves

A#.!)&7!'%('!'/)'!*#%(!&#'!/)9%!9)2-*)'%*!8)((O0)-2!1.-'%.-)G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&12+*%!

'/%!+(%!#0!)!2%,)227!$).=%'%*!.%0%.%&1%!/%).'!9)29%!#0!(-$-2).!1#$8#(-'-#&!)(!'/%!9)29%!7#+!

).%!'%('-&,:!

!

C. Biocompatibility

A<B!.%1#$$%&*(!'/)'!7#+!1#&*+1'!3-#1#$8)'-3-2-'7!'%('-&,!)(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!'/%!A<B!

,+-*)&1%G!Use of International Standard ISO-10993, Biological Evaluation of Medical

Devices Part-1: Evaluation and TestingGM!0#.!32##*C1#&')1'-&,G!2#&,C'%.$!-$82)&'%*!

*%9-1%(:!!U0!7#+!0#22#4!)!9#2+&').7!(')&*).*!'/)'!-(!.%2%9)&'!'#!)&7!)(8%1'!#0!'/%!()0%'7!#.!

%00%1'-9%&%((!#0!'/%!*%9-1%!'/)'!-(!=&#4&G!#.!'/)'!(/#+2*!.%)(#&)327!3%!=&#4&G!'#!7#+G!7#+!

$+('!%Y82)-&!)&7!*%9-)'-#&!0.#$!(+1/!(')&*).*!?LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6!?3F?EF?--FF:!!>)'%.-)2C

$%*-)'%*!87.#,%&-1-'7!'%('-&,!+(-&,!'/%!.)33-'!87.#,%&!'%('!(/#+2*!3%!8%.0#.$%*!)(!8).'!#0!'/%!

3-#1#$8)'-3-2-'7!3)''%.7!#0!'%('-&,:!!B!')3+2).!0#.$)'!-(!*%(-.)32%G!)(!(/#4&!3%2#4: !

!

Biocompatibility Information – Tabular Format Example!TEST PERFORMED/

LAB REPORT #

(literature citation, standard reference)

EXTRACT(S) IF USED

(polar, non-polar), or animal model/cell line

EXTRACT CONDITIONS

(time, temperature, area or mass to volume

ratio compared to in-use conditions)

TEST AND CONTROL(S)

USED

RESULTS/COMMENTS

(include units when appropriate, and include

descriptions for all deviations from the standard/protocol

Cytotoxicity

Sensitization

Irritation / Intracutaneous Toxicity

Systemic toxicity

Sub-chronic toxicity

Genotoxicity

gene mutation

chromosome aberration

DNA damage

In vivo assay

Implantation

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!M!\/-(!,+-*)&1%!*#1+$%&'!1)&!3%!#3')-&%*!)'N!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+1$6

M6TDE:/'$! !

! KK

cris
Page 16: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!Hemocompatibility

hemolysis

complement

activation

in vivo thrombogenicity*

Pyrogenicity

Chronic toxicity

Carcinogenicity

Biodegradation

Reproductive or Developmental toxicity

*You may assess thrombogenicity in animal studies in place of this test.

D. Valve Durability Testing

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!)((%((!'/%!*+.)3-2-'7!#0!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(!+(-&,!)11%2%.)'%*!

4%).!'%('-&,!?Bc\F!$%'/#*(!*-(1+((%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!#.!%P+-9)2%&'!$%'/#*(:!!Bc\!

(/#+2*!1#&'-&+%!0#.!H66!$-22-#&!1712%(!0#.!.-,-*!9)29%(!)&*!L66!$-22-#&!1712%(!0#.!02%Y-32%!

9)29%(G!+(-&,!)!3)1=!8.%((+.%!3%'4%%&!KLE!)&*!KE6!$$@,G!'#!'%('!'/%!*+.)3-2-'7!#0!'/%!

1#$8#&%&'(!+&*%.!8+2()'-2%!02#4!)&*!8/7(-#2#,-1!2#)*-&,:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!0+227!

*%(1.-3%!)22!1#&*-'-#&(!*+.-&,!Bc\G!-&12+*-&,!.)'-#&)2%!0#.!'/%!1#&*-'-#&(!1/#(%&G!0#.!'/%!

0#22#4-&,N!

! '/%!02+-*!+(%*!!! '/%!02#4!.)'%(!'/.#+,/!'/%!9)29%(!!! '/%!8.%((+.%!2#)*-&,!-&12+*-&,!3)1=!8.%((+.%:!

!

E. Component Fatigue Testing

"#$8#&%&'(!#0!.-,-*!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(!)&*!'/%!2#)*!3%).-&,G!&#&C3-#2#,-1)2!

1#$8#&%&'(!#0!02%Y-32%!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(!?%:,:G!('%&'!4-.%F!(/#+2*!3%!-&*-9-*+)227!

0)'-,+%!'%('%*!'#!H66!$-22-#&!1712%(:!!!

!

F. Dynamic Failure Mode Testing

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!(+3l%1'!)!(%2%1'-#&!#0!9)29%(!'/)'!/)9%!(+.9-9%*!'/%!Bc\!'#!

)**-'-#&)2!'%('(!'#!*%'%.$-&%!'/%!$#*%!-&!4/-1/!'/%!9)29%(!4-22!0)-2:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

8.#9-*%!P+)2-')'-9%!)&*!P+)&'-')'-9%!)((%(($%&'(!#0!'/%!0)-2+.%!$#*%(!)&*!/-,/!('.%((!).%)(!-&!

'/%!9)29%!?-:%:G!$#*%!)&*!2#1)'-#&!#0!'/%!0)-2+.%F:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!+(%!'/%(%!

.%(+2'(!'#!(+88#.'!)&7!)&)27'-1)2!9)2-*)'-#&!#.!1#$8+')'-#&)2!$#*%2-&,!#0!('.%((!)&)27(%(!#0!

'/%!1#$8#&%&'(:!

!

G. Cavitation

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!1)9-')'-#&!'%('-&,!#0!.-,-*!/%).'!9)29%(!)(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!

B88%&*-Y!_:!

! KL

cris
cris
cris
cris
cris
Page 17: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

H. Corrosion Resistance

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*%'%.$-&%!'/%!1#..#(-#&!.%(-(')&1%!#0!'/%!$%')22-1!$)'%.-)2(!37!

'%('-&,!'/%!0-&)2!0-&-(/%*!*%9-1%!-&!)!8/7(-#2#,-1)2!%&9-.#&$%&'!)&*G!-0!)88.#8.-)'%G!+&*%.!

('.%((:!!U0!7#+!8%.0#.$!'%('-&,!+&*%.!1712-1!2#)*-&,G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#&*+1'!'%('(!

+&*%.!'/%!()$%!'78%!#0!2#)*-&,!)'!)!0.%P+%&17!'/)'!4-22!&#'!$)(=!2#1)2-g%*!)'')1=:!!c%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!1#..#(-#&!'%('-&,!3#'/!3%0#.%!)&*!)0'%.!7#+.!0)'-,+%!'%('-&,:!!

c%-,/'!2#((!$%'/#*(!(/#+2*!&#'!3%!+(%*!'#!%9)2+)'%!2#1)2-g%*!)'')1=!?%:,:G!8-''-&,F!+&2%((!7#+!

).%!)32%!'#!%(')32-(/!'/)'!7#+.!%Y8%.-$%&')2!'%1/&-P+%!-(!(+00-1-%&'27!(%&(-'-9%:!!c%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#&*+1'!)22!1#..#(-#&!'%('-&,!#&!0-&)2!0-&-(/%*!8.#*+1':!!!

!

I. Flammability of Valved Conduits

U0!7#+.!2)3%2-&,!.%1#$$%&*(!+(-&,!)&!%2%1'.#1)+'%.7!*%9-1%!'#!1+'!'/%!1#&*+-'!$)'%.-)2G!7#+!

(/#+2*!)((%((!'/%!02)$$)3-2-'7!#0!'/%!1#&*+-':!!!

!

J. Hemodynamic Performance - Verification of the Bernoulli

Relationship

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!)((%((!'/%!12-&-1)2!/%$#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%!37!<#882%.!

+2'.)(#+&*G!+(-&,!'/%!_%.&#+22-!.%2)'-#&(/-8G!

!

![!n!]?Q*L!C!Q8

LF!

!

4/%.%N!!

]!-(!)!1#&(')&'!

![!-(!'/%!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!

Q*!-(!'/%!*-(')2!9%2#1-'7!$%)(+.%*!37!1#&'-&+#+(!4)9%!<#882%.!

Q8!-(!'/%!8.#Y-$)2!9%2#1-'7!$%)(+.%*!37!8+2(%*!<#882%.!!!

!

\/%!9)2+%!#0!'/%!1#&(')&'!]!1)&!9).7!*%8%&*-&,!#&!9)29%!'78%:!!;%%!Appendix C. Bernoulli

Verification!0#.!)**-'-#&)2!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(:!!

!

K. Magnetic Resonance (MR) Safety Testing

A#.!-&0#.$)'-#&!.%,).*-&,!>),&%'-1!J%(#&)&1%!?>JF!()0%'7!'%('-&,G!82%)(%!(%%!A<B!

,+-*)&1%!*#1+$%&'!%&'-'2%*G!hS(')32-(/-&,!;)0%'7!)&*!"#$8)'-3-2-'7!#0![)((-9%!U$82)&'(!-&!

'/%!>),&%'-1!J%(#&)&1%!?>JF!S&9-.#&$%&':i5!!

!

;%%!)2(#!XVI. Professional Labeling:!

!5!!\/-(!,+-*)&1%!*#1+$%&'!1)&!3%!#3')-&%*!)'N!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+1

$K6TT6E:/'$!0#.!,+-*)&1%!#&!>J!()0%'7!'%('-&,!#0!7#+.!*%9-1%:!!!!!!!

! KD

Page 18: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

L. Shelf Life

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!'/%!(/%20!2-0%!('+*-%(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!B88%&*-Y!B!#0!'/-(!

,+-*)&1%:!

!

XII. Preclinical Animal Studies

A<B!.%1#$$%&*(!'/)'!)&-$)2!('+*-%(!3%!1#&*+1'%*!'#!%9)2+)'%!$#('!&%4!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!

9)29%!*%(-,&(!)&*!'/)'!'/%(%!('+*-%(!$)..7!3%('!8.)1'-1%(!#0!3-#$%*-1)2!.%(%).1/G!-&12+*-&,!

#3(%.9)&1%!#0!DJ!8.-&1-82%(!?-:%:G!.%*+1%G!.%0-&%G!#.!.%82)1%FG!4/%&%9%.!-'!4-22!&#'!1#$8.#$-(%!'/%!

-&9%('-,)'-#&!#0!()0%'7:K6!!\/%.%0#.%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!*5'6*61!)&-$)2!'%('-&,!#&!

7#+.!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!0#22#4-&,!'/%!$%'/#*(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!)&*!U;R!

K655DNL66H!#.!%P+-9)2%&'!$%'/#*(:!!U0!7#+!+(%!*-00%.%&'!%&*8#-&'(!#.!*%9-)'%!0.#$!'/%!'%('-&,!

*%(1.-3%*!-&!'/-(!,+-*)&1%!#.!)!(')&*).*!7#+!0#22#4G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%Y82)-&!4/7!7#+.!

)88.#)1/!-(!(1-%&'-0-1)227!9)2-*:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!%Y82)&)'-#&(!0#.!)&7!*5'

6*61!)&-$)2!'%('-&,!7#+!#$-':!![.-#.!'#!8%.0#.$-&,!)&-$)2!('+*-%(G!7#+!$)7!4)&'!'#!#3')-&!A<B!

-&8+'!#&!7#+.!)&-$)2!('+*7!8.#'#1#2!9-)!'/%!8.%C(+3$-((-#&!8.#1%((:!!W#+.!&#&12-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!

('+*-%(!$+('!3%!1#&*+1'%*!-&!)11#.*)&1%!4-'/!LK!"AJ![).'!EMG!V##*!I)3#.)'#.7![.)1'-1%!0#.!

^#&12-&-1)2!I)3#.)'#.7!;'+*-%(:!!c%!.%0%.!7#+!'#!'/#(%!.%,+2)'-#&(!0#.!1#$8.%/%&(-9%!.%,+2)'-#&!

#0!V##*!I)3#.)'#.7![.)1'-1%G!3+'!*-(1+((!(%9%.)2!)(8%1'(!#0!)&-$)2!('+*-%(!/%.%:!

!

A. Methods

U0!'%1/&-1)227!0%)(-32%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!1/.#&-1!)((%(($%&'!#0!7#+.!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!-&!

)22!)&)'#$-1)2!8#(-'-#&(!.%02%1'%*!-&!'/%!-&*-1)'-#&(!0#.!+(%:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

%Y82)-&!7#+.!.)'-#&)2%!0#.!'/%!)&-$)2!$#*%2!7#+!/)9%!(%2%1'%*:!!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!,%&%.)227!

.%1#$$%&*(!+(-&,!#&27!'/%!()$%!(8%1-%(G!)&*!(+,,%('(!+(-&,!)&-$)2(!#0!'/%!()$%!,%&*%.!)&*!

),%!-&!)&-$)2!('+*-%(k!/#4%9%.G!4%!3%2-%9%!'/-(!$)7!&#'!3%!)*%P+)'%!'#!%9)2+)'%!)22!)1+'%!)&*!

1/.#&-1!('+*-%(!#0!)!&%4!9)29%!*%(-,&:!!\/%.%0#.%G!4%!$)7!.%1#$$%&*!)**-'-#&)2!)&-$)2!

'%('-&,!3%7#&*!'/)'!*%(1.-3%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66E:!!!

!

B. Study Design

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%9)2+)'%!'/%!0-&)2!0-&-(/%*!8.#*+1'!-&!7#+.!)&-$)2!('+*-%(:!!c%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!)((%((!'/%!)&-$)2!)&*!'/%!*%9-1%!-$$%*-)'%27!)0'%.!-$82)&')'-#&!?)1+'%!

/%$#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%k!-$82)&')'-#&!/)&*2-&,!1/).)1'%.-('-1(F!)&*!)'!L6!4%%=(!?1/.#&-1!

/%$#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%k!%Y82)&'!8)'/#2#,7F:!!c%!$)7G!/#4%9%.G!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+.!

1/.#&-1!('+*7!1#&'-&+%!$#.%!'/)&!L6!4%%=(G!-0!'/%!.-(=!)((%(($%&'!#0!7#+.!*%9-1%!-&*-1)'%(!

'/)'!)!,.%)'%.!*+.)'-#&!-(!)88.#8.-)'%:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+.!('+*-%(!1#&(-('!#0!)!

!K6!;%%![+32-1!@%)2'/!;%.9-1%![#2-17!#&!@+$)&%!").%!)&*!`(%!#0!I)3#.)'#.7!B&-$)2(:!!

/''8NOO,.)&'(:&-/:,#9O,.)&'(O#2)4O.%0%.%&1%(O8/(8#2:/'$m@%)2'/oL6J%(%).1/oL6SY'%&(-#&oL

6B1'oL6#0oL6K5ME! !!! !!

! KZ

cris
cris
cris
cris
Page 19: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

C.

8.#(8%1'-9%27C*%0-&%*!&+$3%.!#0!)&-$)2(!0#.!'/%!)1+'%G!1/.#&-1!)&*!1#&'.#2(!).$(!#0!7#+.!

('+*7:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!)!.)'-#&)2%!0#.!(%2%1'-#&!#0!'/%!&+$3%.!#0!)&-$)2(!3%!8.#9-*%*:!!!

!

R+.!V##*!I)3#.)'#.7![.)1'-1%!.%,+2)'-#&(!.%P+-.%!'/)'G!0#.!%)1/!('+*7G!7#+!$+('!/)9%!)&!

)88.#9%*!4.-''%&!8.#'#1#2!'/)'!12%).27!-&*-1)'%(!'/%!#3l%1'-9%(!)&*!)22!$%'/#*(!0#.!'/%!

1#&*+1'!#0!'/%!('+*7!?LK!"AJ!EM:KL6?)FF:!

!

c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!)((%(($%&'!#0!)1+'%!)&*!1/.#&-1!/%$#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%G!9)29%C

.%2)'%*!8)'/#2#,7!-&!%-'/%.!)&!#.'/#'#8-1!#.!&#&C#.'/#'#8-1!8#(-'-#&G!)&*!1/.#&-1!8%.0#.$)&1%!

#0!)&'-1)21-0-1)'-#&!'.%)'$%&'(!?-0!)882-1)32%F:!!U&!)**-'-#&G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!L6!#.!$#.%!4%%=(!

#0!0#22#4C+8!0#.!1/.#&-1!-$82)&')'-#&:!

!

Data Collection

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#22%1'!'/%!*)')!2-('%*!3%2#4:!

!

1. Study of Acute Hemodynamic Performance

U&!7#+.!)1+'%!('+*7G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#22%1'N!!

! %)(%!#0!/)&*2-&,!)&*!(+.,-1)2!-$82)&')'-#&!!

! /%$#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%!?1)'/%'%.!*)')!)(!4%22!)(!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7F!

! 2%)02%'!$#'-#&!?37!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!)&*!)&,-#,.)8/7F!

! 8.%(%&1%!#0!('%&#(-(!#.!.%,+.,-')'-#&:!!!

!

2. Study of Chronic Hemodynamic Performance

U&!7#+.!1/.#&-1!('+*7G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#22%1'N!!

! %)(%!#0!/)&*2-&,!)&*!(+.,-1)2!-$82)&')'-#&!!

! /%$#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%!?1)'/%'%.!*)')!)(!4%22!)(!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7F!

! 2%)02%'!$#'-#&!?37!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!)&*!)&,-#,.)8/7F!!

! 8.%(%&1%!#0!('%&#(-(!#.!.%,+.,-')'-#&!

! 32##*!('+*-%(G!-$),-&,!('+*-%(!#0!2%)02%'!$#'-#&!)&*!.%,+.,-')'-#&!!

! *5'+*,8'8/#'#(!#0!-&02#4!)&*!#+'02#4!.%,-#&(!)&*!9)29%!(+.0)1%(!!

! &%1.#8(7!)&*!,.#((!8)'/#2#,7!

! %Y82)&'%*!9)29%!)&)27(-(!?-&12+*-&,!/-('#2#,7!#0!'/%!9)29%!)&*!(+..#+&*-&,!'-((+%F:!

!

3. Hemodynamic Performance Assessment

A#.!'/%!/%$#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%!)((%(($%&'G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&12+*%N!!

! 8%)=!)&*!$%)&!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!

! %00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!?SRBF!.%,+.,-')'-#&!

! )!*%(1.-8'-#&!#0!-&('.+$%&')'-#&!)&*!'%('!$%'/#*(:!!!

!

! KE

Page 20: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

D.

4. Laboratory Results

"#$82%'%!32##*!1#+&'!?"_"F!)&*!1/%$-('.7!)&)27(-(!(/#+2*!-&12+*%N!!

! .%*!32##*!1%22!1#+&'!

! 4/-'%!32##*!1%22!1#+&'!?4-'/!*-00%.%&'-)2F!

! /%$)'#1.-'!

! 0.%%!/%$#,2#3-&!

! (%.+$!2)1')'%!*%/7*.#,%&)(%!

! /)8'#,2#3-&!

! .%'-1+2#17'%!1#+&'!

! 82)'%2%'!1#+&':!

!

A#.!02%Y-32%!2%)02%'!9)29%(G!-&!)**-'-#&!'#!'/%!'%('(!2-('%*!)3#9%G!7#+!(/#+2*!-&12+*%N!

! (%.+$!1)21-+$!

! (%.+$!8/#(8/#.#+(!

! 2%)02%'!1)21-+$!

! 8/#(8/)'%:!!!

!

Data Analysis

U&!)**-'-#&!'#!'/%!-&0#.$)'-#&!*%(1.-3%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66EG!7#+.!'%('!.%8#.'!(/#+2*!-&12+*%N!!!

! )88%&*-1%(!4-'/!12-&-1)2!)&*!/%$)'#2#,-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!.%(+2'(!

! /%$#*7&)$-1!0-&*-&,(!

! '/%!0-&)2!8)'/#2#,7!.%8#.'!?-&12+*-&,!,.#((!8)'/#2#,7!4-'/!$)1.#(1#8-1!8/#'#,.)8/(G!

.)*-#,.)8/(G!('.+1'+.)2!-&'%,.-'7!)((%(($%&'!0#.!.-,-*!)&*!8%.1+')&%#+(!*%2-9%.%*!

9)29%(G!)&*!/-('#8)'/#2#,7!4-'/!.%8.%(%&')'-9%!$-1.#,.)8/(F!

!

E. Final Report of Animal Study

W#+!$+('!8.%8).%!)!0-&)2!.%8#.'!0#.!%)1/!&#&12-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!('+*7!?LK!"AJ!EM:KMEF:!!

B$#&,!#'/%.!'/-&,(G!7#+.!0-&)2!.%8#.'!$+('!-*%&'-07!)&*!*%(1.-3%!'/%!'%('!)&*!1#&'.#2!*%9-1%!

7#+!+(%*!-&!'/%!)&-$)2!('+*-%(!?LK!"AJ!EM:KME?)F?ZFF:!!!

!

W#+!$+('!)2(#!-&12+*%!'/%!&+$3%.(!#0!)&-$)2(!+(%*!'#!#3')-&!'/%(%!*)')!?LK!"AJ!

EM:KME?)F?TFF:!

!

\#!$%%'!'/%!0-&)2!.%8#.'!.%P+-.%$%&'(G!'/%!.%8#.'!$+('!-&12+*%N

! 9)29%!$#*%2?(F!

! 9)29%!(-g%?(F!

! 4/%'/%.!'/%!*%9-1%!4)(!('%.-2%!#.!&#&C('%.-2%!

! 4/%'/%.!'/%!*%9-1%!4)(!),%*!3%0#.%!-$82)&')'-#&!

! KH

Page 21: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! 1#&'.#2!*%9-1%!!

! -$82)&'!2#1)'-#&:!

!

\/%!0-&)2!.%8#.'!(/#+2*!)2(#!*%(1.-3%!)&-$)2!0#22#4!+8:!!\/%!*%(1.-8'-#&!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!

0.%P+%&17G!*+.)'-#&G!)&*!%9)2+)'-#&!$%'/#*?(F:!

!

W#+.!.%8#.'!(/#+2*!*%0-&%!0)-2+.%(!?%:,:G!*%9-1%!0)-2+.%(!(+1/!)(!2%)02%'!'%).G!('%&'!0.)1'+.%G!

3)22##&!.+8'+.%F:!!W#+!(/#+2*!-&*-1)'%!'/%!'#')2!&+$3%.!#0!*%9-1%!0)-2+.%(!)&*!-&12+*%!)!

1#$82%'%!*%(1.-8'-#&!0#.!%)1/:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%Y82)-&!)&7!8.#1%*+.)2!0)-2+.%(!

(+1/!)(!9)29%!$-()2-,&$%&'G!-$8.#8%.!(+'+.-&,G!#.!(-g%!$-($)'1/G!)&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!)!

1#$82%'%!*%(1.-8'-#&!#0!%)1/:!!\/%!.%8#.'!(/#+2*!(/#4!'/%!'#')2!&+$3%.!#0!0)-2+.%(G!('.)'-0-%*!

37!7#+.!*%0-&-'-#&(:

!

W#+.!'%('!.%8#.'!$+('!-&12+*%!)!*%(1.-8'-#&!#0!)22!1-.1+$(')&1%(!'/)'!$)7!/)9%!)00%1'%*!'/%!

P+)2-'7!#.!-&'%,.-'7!#0!'/%!*)')G!-&12+*-&,!)!2-('-&,!#0!)22!8.#'#1#2!*%9-)'-#&(!)&*!'/%-.!-$8)1'!

#&!('+*7!0-&*-&,(!?LK!"AJ!EM:KME?)F?5FF:!!!

!

F. Submitting Animal Study Information to your IDE and

PMA

W#+!$+('!(+3$-'!7#+.!0-&)2!.%8#.'!#0!)22!)&-$)2!('+*-%(!'#!7#+.!U<S!)&*![>B!?MKL:LT?)FG!

MKZ:L6?3F?HF?-FF: W#+!(/#+2*!8.#9-*%!0#.!%)1/!('+*7N!

! ('+*7!*)'%(!

! %&*8#-&'(!!

! 0)-2+.%!)&*!(+11%((!1.-'%.-)!

! 8/7(-#2#,-1)2!.%(8#&(%(!'%('%*!?%:,:G!1).*-)1!#+'8+'!?"RFF!!!

! )&7!-&#'.#8-1!*.+,!)*$-&-('%.%*!?)&*!*#(%F!

! )&-$)2!$#*%2?(F!%$82#7%*!

! &+$3%.!#0!)&-$)2(!+(%*!

! )&-$)2!),%!)&*!9%.-0-1)'-#&!?-0!3-.'/!.%1#.*(!).%!&#'!)9)-2)32%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!+(-&,!

*%&')2!%.+8'-#&!'-$%!)&*!$#.8/#2#,-1)2!1/)&,%(!#0!'/%!*%&')2!')32%F!

! $%*-1)'-#&(!)&*!*#(%(!,-9%&!0#.!8.%C8.#1%*+.%G!*+.-&,!8.#1%*+.%G!)&*!8#('C

8.#1%*+.%:!

c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%Y82)-&!/#4!'/%!)&-$)2!$#*%2(!)&*!$%*-1)'-#&(!)*%P+)'%27!

.%8.%(%&'!'/%!-&'%&*%*!8)'-%&'!8#8+2)'-#&!)&*!)&'-1-8)'%*!12-&-1)2!%Y8%.-%&1%:!

!

U0!'/%!*%9-1%!7#+!-&'%&*!'#!$).=%'!*-00%.(!0.#$!'/%!9%.(-#&!+(%*!-&!'/%!)&-$)2!('+*-%(G!4%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*%(1.-3%!)22!1/)&,%(!-&!*%(-,&!)&*!$)&+0)1'+.-&,!0#22#4-&,!'/%!('+*-%(!

)&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!)!.)'-#&)2%!'#!(+88#.'!+(-&,!)!*%9-1%!'/)'!-(!*-00%.%&'!0.#$!'/%!#&%!'/)'!-(!

-&'%&*%*!'#!3%!$).=%'%*:!

!

! KT

Page 22: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

XIII. Clinical Investigations

"2-&-1)2!('+*-%(!).%!&%1%(().7!'#!%9)2+)'%!$#('!&%4!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!*%(-,&(:!!c%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!12-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'-#&(!#0!7#+.!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!0#22#4-&,!

'/%!$%'/#*(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!#.!%P+-9)2%&'!$%'/#*(:!![.-#.!'#!(+3$-''-&,!7#+.!U<S!

)882-1)'-#&G!7#+!$)7!4)&'!'#!#3')-&!A<B!-&8+'!#&!7#+.!12-&-1)2!('+*7!8.#'#1#2!9-)!'/%!8.%C

(+3$-((-#&!8.#1%((:!

!

[2%)(%!(%%!B88%&*-Y!<!#0!'/-(!,+-*)&1%!0#.!)**-'-#&)2!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!)3#+'!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!

4/%&!+(%*!-&!'/%!12-&-1)2!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(:!!\/%!8.#'#1#2!(+3$-''%*!-&!7#+.!

U<S!)&*!'/%!0-&)2!12-&-1)2!.%8#.'!(+3$-''%*!-&!7#+.![>B!)882-1)'-#&(!(/#+2*!)**.%((!'/%!-((+%(!

*%(1.-3%*!3%2#4:!

!

A. Data Safety Monitoring Board

;8#&(#.(!).%!.%(8#&(-32%!0#.!%&(+.-&,!8.#8%.!$#&-'#.-&,!#0!'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&!)&*!$+('!(%2%1'!

$#&-'#.(!P+)2-0-%*!37!'.)-&-&,!)&*!%Y8%.-%&1%!?LK!"AJ!MKL:Z6!)&*!LK!"AJ!MKL:ZD?*FF:!c%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%(')32-(/!)!<)')!;)0%'7!>#&-'#.-&,!_#).*!?<;>_FKK!'#!.%9-%4!)*9%.(%!

%9%&'(!)&*!.%1#$$%&*!('+*7!'%.$-&)'-#&!-0!()0%'7!1#&1%.&(!4)..)&':!!\/%!<;>_!(/#+2*!

%(')32-(/!1.-'%.-)!0#.!.%1#$$%&*-&,!('+*7!'%.$-&)'-#&!0#.!()0%'7!.%)(#&(!3%0#.%!'/%!('+*7!

3%,-&(!)&*!(/#+2*!$%%'!)'!2%)('!'4#!'-$%(!*+.-&,!'/%!('+*7!'#!$#&-'#.!)*9%.(%!%9%&'(:!!\/%!

<;>_!(/#+2*!/)9%!$%$3%.(!4/#!).%!-&*%8%&*%&'!0.#$!'/%!('+*7!(8#&(#.(!)&*!

-&9%('-,)'#.(:!!\4#!#.!$#.%!$%$3%.(!(/#+2*!3%!8/7(-1-)&(G!-&12+*-&,!)!1).*-#'/#.)1-1!

(+.,%#&!)&*!)!1).*-#2#,-(':!!U0!'/%!('+*7!-&12+*%(!(')'-('-1)2!)&)27(%(G!#&%!$%$3%.!(/#+2*!3%!)!

(')'-('-1-)&:!

!

B. Clinical Events Committee

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%(')32-(/!)!"2-&-1)2!S9%&'(!"#$$-''%%!?"S"F!0#.!'/%!12-&-1)2!

-&9%('-,)'-#&!-&!#.*%.!'#!)*l+*-1)'%!)*9%.(%!%9%&'(!)(!3%-&,!9)29%C.%2)'%*!#.!&#'G!)&*!'#!

12)((-07!'/%!(%9%.-'7!#0!)*9%.(%!%9%&'(:!!\/%!"S"!(/#+2*!/)9%!$%$3%.(!4/#!).%!-&*%8%&*%&'!

0.#$!'/%!('+*7!(8#&(#.(!)&*!-&9%('-,)'#.(:!

!

C. Number of Investigators

U0!7#+.!('+*7!+(%(!#&27!#&%!12-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'#.G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!7#+.!

.)'-#&)2%!'#!(/#4!4/7!%Y8%.-%&1%!0.#$!'/-(!#&%!12-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'#.!-(!(+00-1-%&'!'#!

*%$#&('.)'%!'/%!()0%'7!)&*!%00%1'-9%&%((!#0!7#+.!*%9-1%!)&*!'#!%&(+.%!.%8.#*+1-3-2-'7!#0!'%('!

.%(+2'(!)1.#((!$+2'-82%!*%9-1%!+(%.(:!

!

!

!

!KK!;%%!V+-*)&1%!0#.!12-&-1)2!'.-)2!(8#&(#.(!#&!:+,%;&*+73"5,'%5#'<4"$%,*15'1.'=&*5*>%&'?$*%&'-%,%'

@15*,1$*5)'=133*,,""+G!>).1/!L66H:!!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9OJ%,+2)'#.7U&0#.$)'-#&OV+-*)&1%(O+1$KLT6H5:/'$:! !

! KM

Page 23: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

D. Investigational Sites

U&9%('-,)'-#&)2!(-'%(!).%!)22!'/%!1%&'%.(!-$82)&'-&,!'/%!9)29%!-&!'/%!`&-'%*!;')'%(G!)&*!)22!'/%!

0#.%-,&!1%&'%.(!-$82)&'-&,!'/%!9)29%!'/)'!(+3$-'!*)')!)(!8).'!#0!'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&:!!B22!(+3l%1'(!

(/#+2*!3%!1#$82%'%27!)11#+&'%*!0#.!-&!'/%!0-&)2!12-&-1)2!.%8#.':!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

8.#9-*%!1#$82%'%!(+3l%1'!)11#+&'-&,!#&!)!8%.!(+3l%1'!3)(-(!0#.!%)1/!1#/#.':!!W#+!(/#+2*!

-&12+*%!'/%!&+$3%.!#0!(+3l%1'(!%Y8%1'%*!0#.!0#22#4C+8G!*-(1#&'-&+%*!3%1)+(%!#0!*%)'/!#.!

*%9-1%!.%$#9)2G!)&*!)1'+)227!%9)2+)'%*!)'!%)1/!%9)2+)'-#&!'-$%!8#-&':!!!

!

E. Data Collection

\/%!(8#&(#.!4/#!*-(1#9%.(!'/)'!)&!-&9%('-,)'#.!-(!&#'!1#$827-&,!4-'/!'/%!(-,&%*!),.%%$%&'G!

'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!82)&G!.%P+-.%$%&'(!-&!LK!"AJ![).'!MKL!#.!#'/%.!)882-1)32%!A<B!

.%,+2)'-#&(G!#.!)&7!1#&*-'-#&(!#0!)88.#9)2!-$8#(%*!37!'/%!.%9-%4-&,!-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!.%9-%4!

3#).*!#.!A<B!-(!.%(8#&(-32%!0#.!8.#$8'27!(%1+.-&,!'/%!-&9%('-,)'#.(!1#$82-)&1%!#.!

*-(1#&'-&+-&,!(/-8$%&'!#0!'/%!*%9-1%!'#!'/%!-&9%('-,)'#.!)&*!'%.$-&)'-&,!'/%!-&9%('-,)'#.f(!

8).'-1-8)'-#&!-&!'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&!?LK!"AJ!MKL:ZH?)FF:!!W#+.!8.#'#1#2!$+('!%&(+.%!'/)'!'/%!

-&9%('-,)'-#&!-(!(1-%&'-0-1)227!(#+&*!37!%&(+.-&,!1#&(-('%&17!3%'4%%&!'/%!-&*-1)'-#&!('+*-%*G!

)&*!'/%!(+3l%1'!-&12+(-#&!)&*!%Y12+(-#&!1.-'%.-)!?LK!"AJ!MKL:LE?3FF:!!U&!)22!('+*7!*%(-,&(G!7#+!

(/#+2*!%&(+.%!'/)'!-&9%('-,)'#.(!1#22%1'!'/%!)88.#8.-)'%!-&0#.$)'-#&:!!;8%1-0-1)227G!7#+!(/#+2*!

%&(+.%!'/)'!'/%!12-&-1)2!*)')!1#22%1'-#&!0#.$(!+(%*!37!'/%!-&9%('-,)'#.(!)&*!-&('-'+'-#&(!).%!

1#&(-('%&'!4-'/!'/%!12-&-1)2!8.#'#1#2:!!W#+!(/#+2*!)2(#!%&(+.%!'/)'!-&0#.$%*!1#&(%&'!

*#1+$%&'?(F!).%!1#&(-('%&'!4-'/!'/%!12-&-1)2!8.#'#1#2:!

!

F. Control Data

_)(%*!#&!#+.!2#&,!/-('#.7!-&!'/%!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!/%).'!9)29%(!)&*!'/%!%Y'%&(-9%!.%8#.'-&,!-&!'/%!

2-'%.)'+.%G!A<B!3%2-%9%(!'/)'!)!(-&,2%C).$!('+*7!4-'/!2-'%.)'+.%C3)(%*!1#&'.#2(!-(!'/%!2%)('!

3+.*%&(#$%!)88.#)1/!'#!12-&-1)2!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!)!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%:!!W#+.!12-&-1)2!('+*7!

(/#+2*!-&12+*%!)88.#8.-)'%!1#&'.#2(!-&12+*-&,!2-'%.)'+.%C3)(%*!#3l%1'-9%!8%.0#.$)&1%!1.-'%.-)!

?R["(F!0#.!()0%'7!*)')G!)&*!2-'%.)'+.%!).'-12%(!)&*!.%8#.'(!0#.!3#'/!()0%'7!)&*!%00%1'-9%&%((!

*)'):!!\/%!R["(!(/#+2*!3%!%(')32-(/%*!0.#$!*)')!,%&%.)'%*!0#.!)!(-$-2).!'78%!#0!.%82)1%$%&'!

/%).'!9)29%G!)&*!'/%!).'-12%(!)&*!.%8#.'(!(/#+2*!)**.%((!)!(-$-2).!'78%!#0!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!

9)29%!-&!'/%!()$%!9)29%!8#(-'-#&:!!\/%!1#&'.#2!*)')!0.#$!2-'%.)'+.%!).'-12%(!)&*!.%8#.'(!(/#+2*!

3%!1#22%1'%*!0.#$!('+*-%(!8+32-(/%*!-&!8%%.C.%9-%4%*!l#+.&)2(!*+.-&,!'/%!8)('!E!7%).(:!!\/%!

2-'%.)'+.%!1#&'.#2!()0%'7!*)')!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!%).27!)*9%.(%!%9%&'!.)'%!*)')G!2-&%).-g%*!2)'%!

)*9%.(%!%9%&'!.)'%!*)')G!)&*!)1'+).-)2!?+(+)227!])82)&C>%-%.F!)*9%.(%!%9%&'!.)'%!*)'):!!\/%!

2-'%.)'+.%!1#&'.#2!%00%1'-9%&%((!*)')!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!^%4!W#.=!@%).'!B((#1-)'-#&!?^W@BF!

0+&1'-#&)2!12)((-0-1)'-#&12!*)')!)&*!/%$#*7&)$-1!*)'):!!;%%!)2(#!(%1'-#&!I. Follow-Up Data

3%2#4 0#.!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!#&!/%$#*7&)$-1!('+*-%(!*)'):!

!

!KL!\/%!".-'%.-)!"#$$-''%%!#0!'/%!^%4!W#.=!@%).'!B((#1-)'-#&:!^#$%&12)'+.%!)&*!".-'%.-)!0#.!

<-),&#(-(!#0!<-(%)(%(!#0!'/%!@%).'!)&*!V.%)'!Q%((%2(:!5'/!%*:!_#('#&G!>)((N!I-''2%G!_.#4&!p!"#k!

K55ZNLEDCLEH:!

! K5

Page 24: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A#.!-&0)&'(!)&*!7#+&,!1/-2*.%&!.%1%-9-&,!.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%(!#.!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(!?(+1/!)(!

8+2$#&-1!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(F!-&!12-&-1)2!('+*-%(G!^W@B!0+&1'-#&)2!12)((-0-1)'-#&!*)')!).%!&#'!

)88.#8.-)'%:!!R3')-&-&,!^W@B!0+&1'-#&)2!12)((-0-1)'-#&!*)')!#&!-&0)&'(!)&*!7#+&,!1/-2*.%&!-(!

,%&%.)227!&#'!0%)(-32%!3%1)+(%!'/%(%!(+3l%1'(!).%!'##!7#+&,!'#!8.#9-*%!'/%!(7$8'#$!

-&0#.$)'-#&!&%1%(().7!0#.!(+1/!12)((-0-1)'-#&:!!A#.!'/%(%!(+3l%1'(!'/%!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!

%00%1'-9%&%((!-(!'78-1)227!3)(%*!(#2%27!#&!'/%!/%$#*7&)$-1!*)')G!4/-1/!$)7!3%!9).-#+(27!

(+882%$%&'%*!4-'/!#'/%.!%00%1'-9%&%((!*)')!(+1/!)(!1).*-)1!-$),-&,!*)')!)&*!%Y%.1-(%!'%('-&,!

*)'):!!!!

!

A<B!.%1#$$%&*(!'/%!+(%!#0!'/%!R["(!)(!2-('%*!-&!\)32%!J:K!#0!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!B&&%Y!J!

(-&1%!'/%(%!R["(!).%!3)(%*!#&!)&!%Y'%&(-9%!2-'%.)'+.%C3)(%*!.%9-%4!#0!$)&7!).'-12%(!0.#$!

*-00%.%&'!-&('-'+'-#&(:!!c%!*#!&#'!.%1#$$%&*!'/%!+(%!#0!'/%!R["(!-&!\)32%!J:L!#0!B&&%Y!J!

(-&1%!'/%(%!2)''%.!R["(!).%!3)(%*!#&!#&27!#&%!(%.-%(!#0!(+3l%1'(!?)23%-'!)!2).,%!(%.-%(F!)'!#&%!

-&('-'+'-#&:!!@#4%9%.G!-0!7#+!4-(/!'#!-&12+*%!)!1#&1+..%&'!1#&'.#2!,.#+8!-&!7#+.!('+*7G!4%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#&')1'!'/%!<-9-(-#&!#0!").*-#9)(1+2).!<%9-1%(:!!

!

G. Sample Size and Follow-Up Effect on Complication Rate !

1. Patient-Years

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!$%)(+.%!0#22#4C+8!-&!h8)'-%&'C7%).(i!-&('%)*!#0!'/%!h9)29%C

7%).(i!3%1)+(%!*#+32%!9)29%!.%82)1%$%&'!?<QJF!(+3l%1'(G!4/#(%!0#22#4C+8!-(!%Y8.%((%*!

-&!9)29%C7%).(G!).%!'78-1)227!%Y12+*%*!0.#$!'/%!$)-&!)&)27(%(!#0!()0%'7!*)')!)&*!^W@B!

0+&1'-#&)2!12)((-0-1)'-#&!*)'):!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%Y12+*%!<QJ!(+3l%1'(!0.#$!

'/%!$)-&!)&)27(-(!3%1)+(%!)*9%.(%!%9%&'(!)&*!^W@B!0+&1'-#&)2!12)((-0-1)'-#&!1)&&#'!3%!

12%).27!)*l+*-1)'%*!'#!)!8).'-1+2).!9)29%!8#(-'-#&!-&!<QJ!(+3l%1'(:!!!

!

2. Duration of Follow-Up

U&!#.*%.!'#!8.#9-*%!)!12-&-1)227!(+00-1-%&'!)$#+&'!#0!*)')!#&!'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!

.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!)22!(+3l%1'(!3%!0#22#4%*!0#.!K 7%).!#.!$#.%:!!!

!

U0!7#+.!12-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'-#&!-(!0#.!#&%!9)29%!8#(-'-#&G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!0#22#4!

D66!#.!$#.%!(+3l%1'(!0#.!K!7%).!#.!$#.% 0#.!)!'#')2!#0!M66!8)'-%&'C7%).(!#0!0#22#4C+8:KD!

!

U0!'/%!('+*7!-(!0#.!'4#!9)29%!8#(-'-#&(!?-:%:G!)#.'-1!)&*!$-'.)2FG!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

0#22#4!KE6!(+3l%1'(!0#.!#&%!7%).!#.!$#.% 0#.!%)1/!9)29%!8#(-'-#&!0#.!)!'#')2!#0!Z66!8)'-%&'C

7%).(!#0!0#22#4C+8!8%.!9)29%!8#(-'-#&:!

!KD!\/%!.%1#$$%&*%*!0#22#4C+8!#0!M66!8)'-%&'C7%).(!-(!(')'-('-1)227!*%.-9%*!)(!0#22#4(N!!;-&,2%!

()$82%!#&%C(-*%*!/78#'/%(-(!'%('-&,!1)&!3%!+(%*!'#!*%$#&('.)'%!'/)'!%)1/!#0!'/%!1#$82-1)'-#&!

.)'%(!)((#1-)'%*!4-'/!'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!*%9-1%!-(!2%((!'/)&!L!'-$%(!'/%!R["!0#.!'/)'!

1#$82-1)'-#&:!!\/%!)88.#8.-)'%!&+22!/78#'/%(-(!-(!'/)'!'/%!'.+%!.)'%!)((#1-)'%*!4-'/!'/%!

-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!*%9-1%!-(!L!#.!$#.%!'-$%(!-'(!R[":!!\#!.%l%1'!'/-(!&+22!/78#'/%(-(!-(!'#!)11%8'!'/%!

)2'%.&)'-9%!/78#'/%(-(!'/)'!'/%!'.+%!.)'%!)((#1-)'%*!4-'/!'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!*%9-1%!-(!2%((!'/)&!L!

'-$%(!-'(!R[":!!!

! L6

cris
Page 25: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#&*+1'!'/%!12-&-1)2!('+*7!)'!%-,/'!#.!$#.%!8.-$).7!1%&'%.(G!4-'/!

D6!#.!$#.%!(+3l%1'(!-$82)&'%*!)'!%)1/!1%&'%.!0#.!)!#&%C8#(-'-#&!('+*7!)&*!KE!#.!$#.%!

(+3l%1'(!-$82)&'%*!)'!%)1/!1%&'%.!0#.!)!'4#C8#(-'-#&!('+*7:!!c%!3%2-%9%!'/)'!+(-&,!0%4%.!

'/)&!%-,/'!8.-$).7!1%&'%.(!1)&!-&'.#*+1%!3-)(!-&'#!'/%!('+*7:!

!

A#.!3#'/!#&%!8#(-'-#&!)&*!'4#!8#(-'-#&!('+*-%(G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!-$82)&'-&,!KE!#.!$#.%!

(+3l%1'(!0#.!%)1/!(-g%!)&*!%)1/!8#(-'-#&!0#.!)22!9)29%!(-g%(:!!U&!#'/%.!4#.*(G!-0!7#+.!('+*7!

)((%((%(!3#'/!)#.'-1!)&*!$-'.)2!.%82)1%$%&'(G!7#+.!('+*7!(/#+2*!%&.#22!KE!#.!$#.%!

(+3l%1'(!)'!'/%!)#.'-1!8#(-'-#&!)&*!)&!)**-'-#&)2!KE!#.!$#.%!(+3l%1'(!)'!'/%!$-'.)2!8#(-'-#&G!

0#.!%)1/!9)29%!(-g%:!!\/%!KE!(+3l%1'(!-$82)&'%*!8%.!(-g%!8%.!8#(-'-#&!1.-'%.-#&!-(!3)(%*!#&!

(')'-('-1)2!1)21+2)'-#&(!0#.!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!?SRBF!*)'):!!\/%(%!

1)21+2)'-#&(!(/#4!'/)'!-&!#.*%.!'#!)((+.%!)!(+00-1-%&'27!&)..#4!5Eo!1#&0-*%&1%!-&'%.9)2G!

'/%!$-&-$+$!&+$3%.!#0!(+3l%1'(!-$82)&'%*!4-'/!%)1/!9)29%!(-g%!-(!KE:!!U0!7#+!#$-'!)&7!

(-g%(G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%Y82)-&!/#4!'/%!*)')!7#+!1#22%1'!).%!.%8.%(%&')'-9%!#0!)22!

'/%!(-g%(!'/)'!7#+!-&'%&*!'#!$).=%':!

!

3. Complication Rates

B((+$-&,!'/%![#-((#&!*-('.-3+'-#&!)&*!'/%!'.+%!.)'%!3%-&,!%P+)2!'#!-'(!R["G!)&*!4-'/!

8.#3)3-2-'-%(!#0!\78%!U!%..#.!#0!6:6E!)&*!\78%!UU!%..#.!#0!6:L6G!'/%!)$#+&'!#0!*)')!

&%1%(().7!'#!)1/-%9%!'/%!($)22%('!R["!#0!K:Lo!8%.!8)'-%&'C7%).!?%Y12+*-&,!'/%!R["(!0#.!

9)29%!'/.#$3#(-(G!$)l#.!/%$#../),%G!)&*!$)l#.!8%.-9)29+2).!2%)=G!4/-1/!).%!)22!2%((!'/)&!

K:Lo!8%.!8)'-%&'C7%).F!-(!M66!8)'-%&'C7%).(!?)#.'-1!)&*!$-'.)2!8#(-'-#&(!1#$3-&%*F:KD!!\/%!

&+22!/78#'/%(-(!0#.!)!1#$82-1)'-#&!.)'%!1)&!3%!.%l%1'%*!)'!'/%!#&%C(-*%*!(-,&-0-1)&1%!2%9%2!

#0!6:6E!-0!'/%!+88%.!5Eo!1#&0-*%&1%!2-$-'!0#.!'/%!1#$82-1)'-#&!.)'%!-(!2%((!'/)&!L!'-$%(!'/%!

R["!0#.!'/)'!1#$82-1)'-#&:KZGKE

!

4. Complications

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!'/%!1#$82-1)'-#&!*)')!-&12+*%!/%$#../),%(!.%(+2'-&,!0.#$!)22!1)+(%(!

?)22C1)+(%!/%$#../),%F!.)'/%.!'/)&!l+('!/%$#../),%!.%2)'%*!'#!)&'-1#),+2)&'!'/%.)87!

?)&'-1#),+2)&'C.%2)'%*!/%$#../),%F:!!B**-'-#&)227G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!'/%!1#$82-1)'-#&!

*)')!-&12+*%!)22C1)+(%!.%#8%.)'-#&G!9)29%C.%2)'%*!.%#8%.)'-#&G!%Y82)&'G!)22C1)+(%!*%)'/G!)&*!

9)29%C.%2)'%*!*%)'/:!!!

!

H. Pre-Operative Data

\/%!*-),&#('-1!8.%C#8%.)'-9%!*)')!1#22%1'%*!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!'/%!&#.$)2!.)&,%(!0#.!'/%!12-&-1)2!

2)3#.)'#.7!32##*!'%('(!'/)'!).%!%9)2+)'%*G!4-'/!'/%!&#.$)2!.)&,%(!3%-&,!*%'%.$-&%*!37!'/%!

2)3#.)'#.-%(!+(%*:!!

!

!KZ!V.+&=%$%-%.!VIG!a#/&(#&!<>G!)&*!^)0'%2!<"G!;)$82%!(-g%!.%P+-.%$%&'(!0#.!%9)2+)'-&,!/%).'!

9)29%(!4-'/!1#&(')&'!.-(=!%9%&'(:!A'B"%$,'C%&6"'-*+!DNEDCEMG!K55Z:!KE!S*$+&*(!I@G!a.G!",'%&D!V+-*%2-&%(!0#.!.%8#.'-&,!$#.3-*-'7!)&*!$#.')2-'7!)0'%.!1).*-)1!9)29+2).!

#8%.)'-#&(:!A'?71$%>'=%$#*16%+>'E8$)!KKLNT6MCTKKG!K55H:!

! LK

Page 26: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

I. Follow-Up Data

S)1/!(+3l%1'!%&'%.%*!-&'#!'/%!('+*7!(/#+2*!3%!0#22#4%*!)11#.*-&,!'#!'/%!('+*7!8.#'#1#2:!!

B**-'-#&)227G!0#22#4C+8!*)')!(/#+2*!3%!1#22%1'%*!0#.!%)1/!(+3l%1'!+&'-2!'/%!%&'-.%!('+*7!-(!

'%.$-&)'%*!0#.!)22!(+3l%1'(:!!\/-(!0#22#4C+8!*)')!(/#+2*!3%!1#22%1'%*!37!#00-1%G!12-&-1G!#.!

/#(8-')2!9-(-'k!'%2%8/#&%!0#22#4C+8!(/#+2*!3%!+(%*!#&27!'#!9%.-07!*%)'/!#.!2#((!'#!0#22#4C+8:!!

B(!'/-(!0#22#4C+8!*)')!(/#+2*!3%!1#22%1'%*!+&'-2!'/%!%&'-.%!('+*7!-(!'%.$-&)'%*!0#.!)22!8)'-%&'(G!

'/%!0#22#4C+8!8%.-#*!$)7!3%!(-,&-0-1)&'27!2#&,%.!'/)&!(')'%*!-&!'/%!('+*7!8.#'#1#2!0#.!$#('!

8)'-%&'(:!!B11#.*-&,27G!7#+!$+('!.%1%-9%!-&0#.$%*!1#&(%&'!'#!(+1/!0#22#4C+8!8%.-#*!0.#$!)22!

(+3l%1'(!?LK!"AJ!E6:LE?)F?KFF:!!B&7!(+3l%1'!&#'!4-22-&,!'#!0+227!8).'-1-8)'%!-&!'/%!('+*7G!

-&12+*-&,!'/%!0#22#4C+8!8%.-#*G!(/#+2*!&#'!3%!%&'%.%*:KH!!!!!!

A#22#4C+8!*)')!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!'/%!&#.$)2!.)&,%(!0#.!'/%!12-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!32##*!'%('(!

%9)2+)'%*!)11#.*-&,!'#!'/%!&#.$)2!.)&,%(!+(%*!37!'/%!2)3#.)'#.-%(!'/)'!1#&*+1'%*!'/%!'%('-&,:!!

[2)($)!0.%%!/%$#,2#3-&!-(!8.%0%.)32%!'#!(%.+$!2)1')'%!*%/7*.#,%&)(%G!/)8'#,2#3-&G!)&*!

.%'-1+2#17'%!1#+&'!0#.!'/%!%9)2+)'-#&!0#.!/%$#27(-(!3%1)+(%!4%!3%2-%9%!82)($)!0.%%!

/%$#,2#3-&!/)(!/-,/%.!12-&-1)2!(%&(-'-9-'7!0#.!'/%!*%'%1'-#&!#0!/%$#27(-(!'/)&!'/%!#'/%.!'/.%%!

2)3#.)'#.7!'%('(:!!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!'/%!0#22#4-&,!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!/%$#*7&)$-1!*)')G!

('.)'-0-%*!37!9)29%!(-g%N!!

! 8%)=!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!

! $%)&!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!

! %00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!

! 9)29+2).!.%,+.,-')'-#&!

! %00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!-&*%YKT!

! 8%.0#.$)&1%!-&*%Y!

! 1).*-)1!#+'8+'!

! 1).*-)1!-&*%Y:!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!KH!R0'%&!8)'-%&'(!).%!0#22#4%*!37!'/%-.!8%.(#&)2!1).*-#2#,-('G!&#'!'/%!(+.,%#&k!'/%.%0#.%G!'/%!

-&9%('-,)'#.!(/#+2*!4#.=!-&!1#&l+&1'-#&!4-'/!'/%!8/7(-1-)&!.%(8#&(-32%!0#.!0#22#4-&,!'/%!8)'-%&'!

'#!%&(+.%!'/)'!'/%!-&9%('-,)'#.!1#22%1'(!'/%!)88.#8.-)'%!*)')!)'!'/%!1#..%1'!'-$%!8%.-#*(:!!\/-(!$)7!

3%!3%''%.!)11#$82-(/%*!-0!%-'/%.!'/%!-&9%('-,)'#.!#.!'/%!(8#&(#.!#3')-&(!1#&')1'!-&0#.$)'-#&!0#.!

'/%!0#22#4-&,!8/7(-1-)&G!(#!/%O(/%!1)&!3%!)*9-(%*!#0!'/%!)1'+)2!('+*7!8.#'#1#2:!KT!A#.!.%82)1%$%&'!8+2$#&-1!9)29%(!)&*!8+2$#&-1!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(G!4%!*#!&#'!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!

7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)G!(-&1%!'/%!1#&%!(/)8%!#0!'/%!.-,/'!9%&'.-1+2).!#+'02#4!'.)1'!

$)=%(!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!$%)(+.%$%&'!#0!'/%!.-,/'!9%&'.-1+2).!#+'02#4!'.)1'!*-)$%'%.!*-00-1+2':!!

\/-(!*-00-1+2'!$%)(+.%$%&'!2%)*(!'#!8#'%&'-)2!-&)11+.)'%!1)21+2)'-#&!#0!'/%!8+2$#&-1!9)29%!

%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!9-)!'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&!$%'/#*:!!;-$-2).27G!0#.!.%82)1%$%&'!8+2$#&-1!

9)29%(!)&*!8+2$#&-1!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(G!4%!*#!&#'!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!

).%)!-&*%Y!)&*!8%.0#.$)&1%!-&*%Y!*)')G!4/-1/!).%!1)21+2)'%*!+(-&,!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!*)'):!!

! LL

Page 27: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

J. Clinical Laboratory Results in Children

"2-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!1#22%1'-#&(!).%!9%.7!('.%((0+2!0#.!-&0)&'(!)&*!7#+&,!1/-2*.%&!.%1%-9-&,!

.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%(!#.!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(!?%:,:G!8+2$#&-1!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(F:!!\/%.%0#.%G!-'!$)7!3%!

)88.#8.-)'%!'#!#$-'!12-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!1#22%1'-#&(!0#.!/%$#27(-(!%9)2+)'-#&!)'!/#(8-')2!

*-(1/).,%!)&*!D!$#&'/(!8#('C-$82)&'!-&!'/%(%!8#8+2)'-#&(:!!@#4%9%.G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!

7#+!('-22!8%.0#.$!12-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!1#22%1'-#&(!)'!H!$#&'/(!)&*!K!7%).!8#('C-$82)&'G!)&*!

)&&+)227!'/%.%)0'%.!)(!(8%1-0-%*!-&!7#+.!8.#'#1#2:!!A#.!-&0)&'(!)&*!7#+&,!1/-2*.%&!4/#!).%!

+&)32%!'#!/)9%!)22!#0!'/%!12-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!32##*!'%('!1#22%1'-#&(!)11#.*-&,!'#!'/%!&#.$)2!

.)&,%(!+(%*!37!'/%!2)3#.)'#.-%(!'/)'!1#&*+1'%*!'/%!'%('-&,G!(8#'!+.-&%!+.#3-2-&#,%&!-(!)&!

)11%8')32%!'%('!0#.!/%$#27(-(!%9)2+)'-#&:!

!

K. Imaging Data

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!'/%!-$),-&,!*)')!4-'/-&!'/%!0#22#4C+8!*)')!-&12+*%!.%8#.'(!#0N!!

! %1/#1).*-#,.)$(!

! 1).*-)1!1)'/%'%.-g)'-#&(!

! )&7!#'/%.!1).*-#9)(1+2).!-$),-&,!8.#1%*+.%(G!-&12+*-&,!"\!)&*!>J!(1)&(!

! 1/%('!YC.)7(:!

!

L. Additional Information

U&!)11#.*)&1%!4-'/!LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6?3F?DF?9F?_FG!7#+.![>B!$+('!-&12+*%!)!(+$$).7!#0!'/%!

12-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'-#&(G!-&12+*-&,!)*9%.(%!.%)1'-#&(!)&*!1#$82-1)'-#&(:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!7#+.!

(+$$).7!(8%1-0-1)227!-&12+*%N!!

! 1)(%!(+$$).-%(!#0!%)1/!*%)'/!4-'/!)!*%'%.$-&)'-#&!#0!4/%'/%.!'/%!*%)'/!.%8.%(%&'(!)&!

%).27!#.!)!2)'%!*%)'/KMk!)&*!

! '/%!(+$$).7!#0!(+3l%1'(!&#'!1#$82%'-&,!('+*7!('.)'-0-%*!37!2#('C'#C0#22#4!+8G!*%)'/G!#.!

%Y82)&'F:!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!)2(#!-&12+*%!'/%!0#22#4-&,!-&0#.$)'-#&G!-0!)9)-2)32%N!

! 2#1)'-#&(!#0!'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!(-'%(k!

! 1#$8).-(#&!#0!8.%#8%.)'-9%!)&*!8#('#8%.)'-9%!^W@B!0+&1'-#&)2!12)((!?8.%(%&'%*!)(!

'/%!8%.1%&'),%!#0!(+3l%1'(!-&!%)1/!12)((!)'!3)(%2-&%G!)'!%)1/!0#22#4C+8!'-$%C8#-&'G!)&*!

)(!'/%!8%.1%&'),%!#0!(+3l%1'(!)'!%)1/!0#22#4C+8!'-$%C8#-&'!4/#!-$8.#9%*G!4#.(%&%*G!

#.!*-*!&#'!1/)&,%!-&!12)((Fk!

! '/%!q8.%C-$82)&'q!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!#0!'/%!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%k!!

!KM!A<B!1#&(-*%.(!)!*%)'/!#11+..-&,!4-'/-&!D6!*)7(!#0!-$82)&')'-#&!#.!*+.-&,!'/%!-&-'-)2!

/#(8-')2-g)'-#&G!4/-1/%9%.!'-$%!8%.-#*!-(!2#&,%.G!'#!3%!)&!%).27!*%)'/:!!A<B!1#&(-*%.(!)22!#'/%.!

*%)'/(!'#!3%!2)'%!*%)'/(:!

! LD

cris
Page 28: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! &+$3%.(!#0!-$82)&'%*!(+3l%1'(!('.)'-0-%*!37!-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!(-'%G!.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%!

8#(-'-#&!?%:,:G!)#.'-1G!$-'.)2G!#.!*#+32%!9)29%!.%82)1%$%&'FG!)&*!9)29%!(-g%k!

! &+$3%.(!#0!-$82)&'%*!(+3l%1'(!0#22#4%*!'#!K!7%).!8#('C-$82)&'!('.)'-0-%*!37!

-&9%('-,)'-#&)2!(-'%G!.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%!8#(-'-#&!?%:,:G!)#.'-1G!$-'.)2G!#.!*#+32%!9)29%!

.%82)1%$%&'FG!)&*!9)29%!(-g%k!

! 0#22#4C+8!*+.)'-#&!-&0#.$)'-#&!?'#')2!)&*!37!9)29%!8#(-'-#&FG!-&12+*-&,!$%)&!0#22#4C

+8G!(')&*).*!*%9-)'-#&!)&*!.)&,%!#0!0#22#4C+8G!)&*!1+$+2)'-9%!0#22#4C+8!-&!8)'-%&'C

7%).(k!

! 1#&0#+&*-&,!0)1'#.(!37!/)g).*!.%,.%((-#&!)&)27(-(!)882-%*!'#!-*%&'-07!.-(=!0)1'#.(!

?%:,:G!,%&*%.G!),%!)'!-$82)&'G!8.%C#8%.)'-9%!^W@B!0+&1'-#&)2!12)((-0-1)'-#&G!8.%9-#+(!

9)29%!(+.,%.7G!1#&1#$-')&'!1#.#&).7!).'%.7!378)((!(+.,%.7G!-$82)&'!8#(-'-#&G!)&*!

-$82)&'!(-g%FG!4/-1/!$-,/'!)00%1'!'/%!-&1-*%&1%!#0!.%#8%.)'-#&G!%Y82)&'G!)&*!*%)'/k!!

! 8)'-%&'!1#$82-)&1%!*)')!0#.!0#22#4C+8!9-(-'(G!^W@B!0+&1'-#&)2!12)((-0-1)'-#&!*)')G!

%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!*)')G!)&*!12-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!.%(+2'(k !

! 2-('!#0!1#$82-1)'-#&(!37!8)'-%&'!-*%&'-0-1)'-#&!&+$3%.k!

! (+$$).7!#0!(+3l%1'!1#$82)-&'(!.%1%-9%*k!

! 1)(%!.%8#.'!0#.$(!0#.!)!K6o!.)&*#$!()$82-&,!#0!'/%!(+3l%1'!8#8+2)'-#&k !

! 1#8-%(!#0!1)(%!.%8#.'!0#.$(!0#.!)22!(+3l%1'(!&#'!1#$82%'-&,!'/%!('+*7k!

! %Y82)&'!)&)27(-(!-&!)22!1)(%(!4/%&!)!9)29%!-(!%Y82)&'%*!#.!)&!)+'#8(7!-(!8%.0#.$%*k!

)&*!

! *%)'/!.%8#.'(!-&12+*-&,!)+'#8(7!.%8#.'(G!4/%&!)9)-2)32%G!%(8%1-)227!4/%&!'/%!1)+(%!#0!

*%)'/!/)(!3%%&!12)((-0-%*!)(!&#&C9)29%!.%2)'%*:!

!

M. Database Closure

\/%!12-&-1)2!*)')!-&!7#+.![>B!)882-1)'-#&!(/#+2*!3%!1+..%&'!'#!4-'/-&!(-Y!$#&'/(!#0!'/%!*)'%!

#0!(+3$-((-#&:!!W#+!$+('!)2(#!8%.-#*-1)227!+8*)'%!7#+.!8%&*-&,!)882-1)'-#&!4-'/!&%4!()0%'7!

)&*!%00%1'-9%&%((!-&0#.$)'-#&!2%).&%*!0.#$!#&,#-&,!#.!1#$82%'%*!('+*-%(!?LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6?%FF!

!

N. Subject Compliance

;+3l%1'!1#$82-)&1%!(/#+2*!3%!1)21+2)'%*!)(!'/%!0#22#4-&,!0#+.!8%.1%&'),%(N!'/%!&+$3%.!#0!

(+3l%1'(!/)9-&,!1#$82%'%*!0#22#4C+8!9-(-'(G!4-'/!^W@B!0+&1'-#&)2!12)((-0-1)'-#&!*)')G!4-'/!

%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!*)')G!)&*!4-'/!12-&-1)2!2)3#.)'#.7!.%(+2'(!)'!%)1/!0#22#4C+8!'-$%C8#-&'G!

*-9-*%*!37!'/%!'#')2!&+$3%.!#0!-$82)&'%*!(+3l%1'(!)9)-2)32%!?-:%:G!4/#!/)9%!&#'!*-%*!#.!/)*!

'/%-.!9)29%!%Y82)&'%*F!)&*!%2-,-32%!?-:%:G!4/#!/)9%!.%)1/%*!'/%!,-9%&!'-$%C8#-&'F!0#.!0#22#4C+8!

)'!'/)'!8).'-1+2).!'-$%C8#-&':!!\/%!'#')2!&+$3%.!#0!(+3l%1'(!/)9-&,!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!%Y)$(!

(/#+2*!3%!'/%!()$%!)(!'/%!'#')2!&+$3%.!#0!(+3l%1'(!4-'/!*)')!0#.!%)1/!(8%1-0-1!

%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!/%$#*7&)$-1!8).)$%'%.!?-:%:G!8%)=!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'G!$%)&!8.%((+.%!

! LZ

Page 29: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

,.)*-%&'G!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)G!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!-&*%YGKT!8%.0#.$)&1%!-&*%YG!1).*-)1!

#+'8+'G!1).*-)1!-&*%YG!)&*!9)29+2).!.%,+.,-')'-#&F:!

!

O. Data Pooling

c%!3%2-%9%!'/)'!8##2-&,!*)')!0.#$!$#.%!'/)&!#&%!9)29%!8#(-'-#&G!(+1/!)(!8##2-&,!'/%!*)')!

0.#$!'/%!)#.'-1!)&*!$-'.)2!9)29%!8#(-'-#&(G!$)(=(!8#'%&'-)2!*-00%.%&1%(!-&!9)29%!0+&1'-#&!)&*!

9)29%C.%2)'%*!)*9%.(%!%9%&'(:!!\/%.%0#.%G!7#+!(/#+2*!('.)'-07!'/%!*)')!37!9)29%!8#(-'-#&!

-&('%)*!#0!8##2-&,!'/%(%!*)'):!

!

P. Adverse Events and Complication Rates

W#+.![>B!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!'/%!)1'+)2!&+$3%.!#0!)*9%.(%!%9%&'(:!!U&!)**-'-#&G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!

'/)'!7#+!%Y8.%((!%).27!1#$82-1)'-#&!.)'%(!)(!'/%!&+$3%.!#0!)*9%.(%!%9%&'(!*-9-*%*!37!'/%!'#')2!

&+$3%.!#0!(+3l%1'(G!)(!.%1#$$%&*%*!37!S*$+&*(!",'%&DKE!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&12+*%!

2-&%).-g%*!2)'%!1#$82-1)'-#&!.)'%(:!!I-&%).-g%*!2)'%!1#$82-1)'-#&!.)'%(!).%!1)21+2)'%*!)(!'/%!

&+$3%.!#0!2)'%!)*9%.(%!%9%&'(!*-9-*%*!37!'/%!'#')2!&+$3%.!#0!2)'%!8)'-%&'C7%).(:!!

!!

Q. Foreign Data

B&7!0#.%-,&!*)')!(+3$-''%*!-&!(+88#.'!#0!7#+.![>B!)882-1)'-#&!$+('!1#$827!4-'/!LK!"AJ!

MKZ:KE:!

!

U0!7#+!).%!.%27-&,!(#2%27!#&!0#.%-,&!*)')!'#!(+88#.'!7#+.![>B!)882-1)'-#&!0#.!)!.%82)1%$%&'!

/%).'!9)29%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!7#+!8.#9-*%!'/%!+(+)2!#&%C7%).!*)')!)(!4%22!)(!+8C'#C*)'%!

-&0#.$)'-#&!-&12+*-&,!)&&+)2!0#22#4C+8!?%:,:G!^%4!W#.=!@%).'!B((#1-)'-#&!?^W@BF!/%).'!

0)-2+.%!12)((-0-1)'-#&!(1/%$%GKL!%1/#1).*-#,.)$G!)&*!32##*!'%('(!)11#.*-&,!'#!'/%!&#.$)2!

.)&,%(!+(%*!37!'/%!2)3#.)'#.-%(!'/)'!1#&*+1'%*!'/%!'%('-&,:!!W#+.!*)')!(/#+2*!*%$#&('.)'%!

2#&,C'%.$!8%.0#.$)&1%!)&*!0)-2+.%!$#*%G!)&*!-&12+*%!)+'#8(7!#.!%Y82)&'!)&)27(%(G!4/%&!

)9)-2)32%:!

XIV. PMA Supplements

B&!)88.#9%*![>B!(+882%$%&'!-(!,%&%.)227!.%P+-.%*!8.-#.!'#!$)=-&,!)!1/)&,%!)00%1'-&,!'/%!

()0%'7!#.!%00%1'-9%&%((!#0!7#+.!*%9-1%:!?LK!"AJ!MKZ:D5F:K5!!J%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!3%2#4!)**.%((!

(8%1-)2!1#&(-*%.)'-#&(!.%2)'%*!'#!$#*-0-1)'-#&(!#0!'/%!(%4-&,!.-&,!1#&0-,+.)'-#&!)&*!9)29%*!

1#&*+-'(:!

!

!

!

!

!K5!;%%!Modifications to Devices Subject to Premarket Approval (PMA) - The PMA

Supplement Decision-Making ProcessG!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+1$6

M5LTZ:/'$:!

! LE

Page 30: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A. Modifications to the Sewing Ring Configuration

V%&%.)227G!12-&-1)2!*)')!$)7!&#'!3%!&%%*%*!'#!%(')32-(/!'/%!()0%'7!)&*!%00%1'-9%&%((!#0!

)2'%.&)'%!(%4-&,!.-&,!1#&0-,+.)'-#&(!8.#9-*%*!7#+!/)9%!&#'!)2'%.%*!'/%!(+3('.+1'+.%(!#0!'/%!

9)29%:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!9)2-*)'%!1/)&,%(!'#!7#+.!(%4-&,!.-&,!1#&0-,+.)'-#&!37!

1#&*+1'-&,!*5'6*,$1!('+*-%(!'#!12%).27!%(')32-(/!'/)'!'/%!&%4!(%4-&,!.-&,!1)&!(+88#.'!'/%!

8/7(-#2#,-1)2!2#)*-&,:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#$8).%!'/%!(8%1-0-1!$)'%.-)2!?$)&+0)1'+.%.G!

4%)9%G!%'1:F!4-'/!'/%!$)'%.-)2!+(%*!-&!7#+.!)88.#9%*![>B:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

9)2-*)'%!1#$$#&G!12-&-1)227C)11%8'%*!(%4-&,!.-&,!$)'%.-)2(!?8#27'%'.)02+#.#%'/72%&%!r[\ASsG!

8#27%'/72%&%!'%.%8/'/)2)'%!r[S\sF!4-'/!)&-$)2!/%)2-&,!*)')!(+882%$%&'%*!4-'/!%Y82)&'!*)'):!!

A#.!)&7!(%4-&,!.-&,!$)'%.-)2(!#'/%.!'/)&![\AS!)&*![S\G!/#4%9%.G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

9)2-*)'%!'/%!$#*-0-1)'-#&!4-'/!12-&-1)2!*)'):!

!

B. Valved Conduits

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1#&*+1'!12-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'-#&(!0#.!.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(:!!

"2-&-1)2!-&9%('-,)'-#&(!$)7!&#'!3%!&%%*%*!4/%&!3#'/!'/%!9)29%!)&*!'/%!1#&*+-'!#.!,.)0'!).%!

2%,)227!$).=%'%*:!!U0!3#'/!).%!2%,)227!$).=%'%*G!*5'6*,$1!-&9%('-,)'-#&(!$)7!3%!(+00-1-%&':!!

c/%'/%.!)&!*5'6*,$1!-&9%('-,)'-#&!-(!)88.#8.-)'%!*%8%&*(!#&!7#+.!.-(=!)((%(($%&'k!%:,:G!'/%!

.-(=!)((%(($%&'!0#.!)!$#*-0-%*!*%(-,&!$)7!-&*-1)'%!'/%!)3-2-'7!#0!'/%!9)29%O,.)0'!-&'%.0)1%!'#!

4-'/(')&*!8/7(-#2#,-1)2!2#)*-&,!-(!8#'%&'-)227!*-00%.%&':!!U&!'/-(!1)(%G!*5'6*,$1!('+*-%(!$)7!3%!

)88.#8.-)'%!'#!9)2-*)'%!)!1/)&,%!-&!'/%!*%(-,&!#0!'/%!9)29%O,.)0'!-&'%.0)1%:!!R.G!0#.!-&(')&1%G!-0!

7#+!$#*-07!7#+.!*%9-1%!37!+(-&,!)!1#)'%*!,.)0'G!'/%!.-(=!)((%(($%&'!(/#+2*!)**.%((!4/%'/%.!

'/%.%!).%!)&7!8#'%&'-)2!)*9%.(%!%00%1'(!'#!'/%!1#)'-&,!?%:,:G!2#((!#0!1#)'-&,!-&'%,.-'7!2%)*-&,!'#!

32%%*-&,!*+%!'#!'/%!$)&+0)1'+.-&,!('%8(!)((#1-)'%*!4-'/!(%4-&,!'/%!9)29%!-&'#!'/%!,.)0'F:!

!

XV. Professional Labeling

I)3%2-&,!.%P+-.%$%&'(!0#.!$%*-1)2!*%9-1%(!).%!*%(1.-3%*!-&!LK!"AJ![).'!M6K:L6!!U&!)11#.*)&1%!

4-'/!LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6?3F?K6FG!7#+!$+('!(+3$-'!)22!8.#8#(%*!2)3%2-&,!-&!7#+.![>B:!!c%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+.!2)3%2-&,!-&12+*%!'/%!-&0#.$)'-#&!0#+&*!-&!;%1'-#&!H:L:D!)&*!B&&%Y!d!#0!

U;R!EMZ6NL66E!#.!%P+-9)2%&'!(+,,%('%*!0#.!-&12+(-#&!-&!2)3%2-&,!)&*!-&('.+1'-#&(!0#.!+(%. U&!

)**-'-#&G!7#+.!2)3%2-&,!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!'/%!-&0#.$)'-#&!*%(1.-3%*!3%2#4:!

!

A. Non-Sterile Devices!

U0!7#+!-&'%&*!'#!$).=%'!7#+.!*%9-1%!-&!&#&C('%.-2%!0#.$G!7#+!(/#+2*!8.#9-*%!12%).!)&*!

)*%P+)'%!-&('.+1'-#&(!0#.!('%.-2-g)'-#&!-&!7#+.!-&('.+1'-#&(!0#.!+(%!4-'/!)11%8')32%!8).)$%'%.(!

'#!3%!+(%*G!(+1/!)(!'%$8%.)'+.%G!8.%((+.%G!*4%22!'-$%(G!)&*!4/%'/%.!#.!&#'!.%C('%.-2-g)'-#&!

+(-&,!'/%(%!8).)$%'%.(!-(!)88.#8.-)'%G!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#$-&%&'27!-&*-1)'%!-&!

7#+.!8)1=),%!2)3%2-&,!)&*!-&('.+1'-#&(!0#.!+(%!'/)'!7#+.!*%9-1%!-(!8.#9-*%*!&#&C('%.-2%:!

!L6!;%%!CDRH!Device Advice!)9)-2)32%!)'!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OR9%.9-%4O<%9-1%I)3%2-&,O

*%0)+2':/'$!0#.!)**-'-#&)2!-&0#.$)'-#&!)3#+'!*%9-1%!2)3%2-&,!.%P+-.%$%&'(:!

! LH

Page 31: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

B. Resterilization

U0!'/%!*%9-1%!1)&!3%!.%('%.-2-g%*G!'/%&!'/%!2)3%2-&,!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!'/%!.%1#$$%&*%*!

('%.-2-g)'-#&!$%'/#*!)&*!8).)$%'%.(!'#!+(%:!

!

C. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)

A#.!-&0#.$)'-#&!.%,).*-&,!>),&%'-1!J%(#&)&1%!?>JF!()0%'7!'%('-&,G!82%)(%!(%%!A<B!

,+-*)&1%!*#1+$%&'!%&'-'2%*G!hS(')32-(/-&,!;)0%'7!)&*!"#$8)'-3-2-'7!#0![)((-9%!U$82)&'(!-&!

'/%!>),&%'-1!J%(#&)&1%!?>JF!S&9-.#&$%&':iLK!

XVI. Patient Labeling

U0!7#+!8.#8#(%!'#!8.#9-*%!8)'-%&'!2)3%2-&,G!%:,:G!!)!8)'-%&'!$)&+)2!#.!8)'-%&'!-*%&'-0-1)'-#&!1).*(!

4-'/!7#+.!*%9-1%G!7#+!$+('!(+3$-'!'/%!8.#8#(%*!2)3%2-&,!-&!)11#.*)&1%!4-'/!LK!"AJ!

MKZ:L6?3F?K6F:!!\/%!8)'-%&'!$)&+)2!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!)!*-(1+((-#&!#0!)&'-1#),+2)'-#&!'/%.)87!)&*!

'/%!-$8#.')&1%!#0!0#22#4C+8!9-(-'(:!!;%%!Guidance on Medical Device Patient LabelingLL!0#.!

$#.%!-&0#.$)'-#&!)3#+'!'/%!1#&'%&'(!#0!8)'-%&'!2)3%2-&,:!

\/%!8)'-%&'!-*%&'-0-1)'-#&!1).*!(/#+2*!(/#4!'/%!0#22#4-&,N!

! 8)'-%&'!&)$%!

! *)'%!#0!-$82)&'!

! &)$%!)&*!1#&')1'!-&0#.$)'-#&!0#.!'/%!-$82)&'-&,!8/7(-1-)&G!'/%!0#22#4-&,!8/7(-1-)&G!)&*!'/%!*%9-1%!$)&+0)1'+.%.!

! %$%.,%&17!1#&')1'!8%.(#&!

! *%9-1%!&)$%G!(-g%G!8#(-'-#&!)&*!(%.-)2!&+$3%.!

! )&7!$%*-1)'-#&(!)&*!*#(),%(!

! >J!;)0%!#.!>J!"#&*-'-#&)2!-&0#.$)'-#&LD:!

!LK!!\/-(!,+-*)&1%!*#1+$%&'!1)&!3%!#3')-&%*!)'N!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+1$K

6TT6E:/'$!0#.!,+-*)&1%!#&!>J!()0%'7!'%('-&,!#0!7#+.!*%9-1%:!!!!!!LL!\/-(!,+-*)&1%!*#1+$%&'!1)&!3%!#3')-&%*!)'N!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+1$6

T6TML:/'$:! !LD!!A#.!)**-'-#&)2!-&0#.$)'-#&G!82%)(%!(%%G!hS(')32-(/-&,!;)0%'7!)&*!"#$8)'-3-2-'7!#0![)((-9%!

U$82)&'(!-&!'/%!>),&%'-1!J%(#&)&1%!?>JF!S&9-.#&$%&'i!)'!

/''8NOO444:0*):,#9O>%*-1)2<%9-1%(O<%9-1%J%,+2)'-#&)&*V+-*)&1%OV+-*)&1%<#1+$%&'(O+1$K

6TT6E:/'$:!

! LT

Page 32: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

Appendix A. Shelf Life Validation

W#+.![>B!)882-1)'-#&!$+('!-&12+*%!)!'%1/&-1)2!(%1'-#&!4/-1/!(/)22!1#&')-&!*)')!)&*!

-&0#.$)'-#&G!-&12+*-&,!'/%!.%(+2'(!#0!'/%!(/%20!2-0%!'%('-&,G!-&!(+00-1-%&'!*%')-2!'#!8%.$-'!A<B!'#!

*%'%.$-&%!4/%'/%.!'#!)88.#9%!#.!*%&7!7#+.!)882-1)'-#&!?LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6?3F?HF?-FF:!!W#+!(/#+2*!

9)2-*)'%!7#+.!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!)&*!8)1=),%!#9%.!'/%!(/%20!2-0%!#0!'/%!*%9-1%!3%1)+(%!#0!'/%!

8#'%&'-)2!0#.!9)29%!*%'%.-#.)'-#&!'/)'!-(!&#'!.%)*-27!9-(-32%!'#!'/%!(+.,%#&G!3+'!'/)'!1#+2*!

(+3(%P+%&'27!$)&-0%('!-&!'/%!8)'-%&'!)(!8.%$)'+.%!9)29%!0)-2+.%:!!A#.!)22!9)29%(G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!

'/)'!7#+!1#&*+1'!1#$8).)'-9%!8%.0#.$)&1%!'%('-&,!#0!),%*!)&*!+&),%*!4/#2%!9)29%(G!)(!

*%(1.-3%*!3%2#4:!

!

c%!.%1#,&-g%!'/)'!(#$%!(/%20!2-0%!9)2-*)'-#&!'%('(!-*%&'-0-%*!-&!'/-(!,+-*)&1%!).%!)882-1)32%!'#!

#&27!1%.')-&!9)29%(:!!U0!7#+!3%2-%9%!'/)'!)!8).'-1+2).!'%('!*#%(!&#'!)8827!'#!7#+.!*%9-1%G!4%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!7#+.!.)'-#&)2%!0#.!#$-''-&,!'/%!'%(':!!!

!

A#.!(/%20!2-0%!9)2-*)'-#&G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%Y82)-&!/#4!%)1/!#0!'/%!0#22#4-&,!-(!12-&-1)227!

.%8.%(%&')'-9%!)&*!-&!),.%%$%&'!4-'/!'/%!#8%.)'-#&)2!(8%1-0-1)'-#&(!#0!'/%!*%9-1%N!

! '%('!8).)$%'%.(!?(7('%$-1!8.%((+.%G!3%)'!.)'%G!('.#=%!9#2+$%G!1).*-)1!#+'8+'!?"RFG!'-((+%!

1#$82-)&1%G!%'1:F!

! '%('!*+.)'-#&!!

! )882-1)32%!8%.0#.$)&1%!(8%1-0-1)'-#&:!

!

A. Test Valve Selection!!!

\#!%(')32-(/!)!(/%20!2-0%!0#.!7#+.!*%9-1%G!7#+!(/#+2*!%9)2+)'%!4/#2%!9)29%(!),%*!'#!'/%!2)3%2%*!

(/%20!2-0%!)&*!+&),%*!4/#2%!9)29%(!-&!)!(-*%!37!(-*%!$)&&%.!-&!#.*%.!'#!$)=%!)!1#$8).-(#&:!!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%9)2+)'%N!

! 9)29%(!#0!'/%!($)22%('G!-&'%.$%*-)'%G!)&*!2).,%('!(-g%(!

! 9)29%(!('%.-2-g%*!'#!'/%!$)Y-$+$!&+$3%.!#0!1712%(!-&!)11#.*)&1%!4-'/!'/%!%(')32-(/%*!

)&*!9)2-*)'%*!('%.-2-g)'-#&!8.#1%((!

! 0-&)2!0-&-(/%*!8.#*+1'!?-:%:G!(+3l%1'%*!'#!)22!$)&+0)1'+.-&,!8.#1%((%(G!-&12+*-&,!)&!

)&'-C1)21-0-1)'-#&!'.%)'$%&'G!-0!)882-1)32%F!

! 9)29%(!(+3l%1'%*!'#!(-$+2)'%*!*-('.-3+'-#&!)&*!/)&*2-&,!1#&*-'-#&(:!

!

B. Real-Time and Accelerated Aging

c%!,%&%.)227!.%1#$$%&*!.%)2C'-$%!),-&,!#0!'%('!9)29%(:!!@#4%9%.G!-0!7#+!+(%!)11%2%.)'%*!

),-&,!'%1/&-P+%(G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*%(1.-3%!/#4!7#+!9)2-*)'%*!7#+.!)11%2%.)'%*!),-&,!

$%'/#*(!)&*!8.#9-*%!'/%!.%(+2'(!#0!)&7!9)2-*)'-#&!('+*-%(!1#&*+1'%*:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!),-&,!

#0!'/%!4/#2%!9)29%G!-&12+*-&,!'/%!('%&'!0#.!'/#(%!9)29%(!4-'/!('%&'(G!3%1)+(%!'/%!('#.),%!

(#2+'-#&!1)&!/)9%!)&!-$8)1'!#&!'/%!-&'%,.-'7!#0!'/%!('%&':!!@#4%9%.G!'/%!('%&'!$)7!3%!.%$#9%*!

0#.!'%('-&,:!!B,-&,!('+*-%(G!4/%'/%.!.%)2C'-$%!#.!)11%2%.)'%*G!(/#+2*!)**.%((!'/%!%00%1'(!#0N!

! '%$8%.)'+.%!

! LM

cris
Page 33: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! /+$-*-'7!

! 8.%((+.%!

! 2-,/'!%Y8#(+.%!

! (/-88-&,!)&*!/)&*2-&,:!!!

!

C. Device Stability

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%9)2+)'%!'/%!0+&1'-#&)2!8%.0#.$)&1%G!('.+1'+.)2!-&'%,.-'7G!'-((+%!

$#.8/#2#,7G!-0!)882-1)32%G!)&*!8.#8%.'-%(!#0!'/%!*%9-1%!)'!g%.#!'-$%!)&*!)'!'/%!2)3%2%*!(/%20!

2-0%:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%Y82)-&!7#+.!.)'-#&)2%!0#.!%)1/!'%('!$%'/#*!+(%*:!

!

1. Hydrodynamic Performance

\#!*%$#&('.)'%!/7*.#*7&)$-1!8%.0#.$)&1%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!1#$8).-&,!*)')!0.#$!'/%!

0#22#4-&,!'%('(!#&!),%*!)&*!+&),%*!*%9-1%(N

! ('%)*7!0#.4).*!02#4!?"[G!SRBF!!

! 8+2()'-2%!0#.4).*!02#4!?"[G!SRBF!!

! 8+2()'-2%!.%,+.,-')'-#&!!

! )&'-C1)21-0-1)'-#&!%00%1'(G!-0!)882-1)32%G!?)(!*%'%.$-&%*!37!(+31+')&%#+(!

-$82)&')'-#&!-&!.)'(!#.!.)33-'(F:!

!

2. Structural Integrity

\#!*%$#&('.)'%!('.+1'+.)2!-&'%,.-'7G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!1#$8).-&,!*)')!0.#$!'/%!0#22#4-&,!

'%('(G!-0!)882-1)32%G!#&!),%*!)&*!+&),%*!*%9-1%(N!!

! 2%)02%'!*+.)3-2-'7!

! 2%)02%'!8.#2)8(%!?)(!*%'%.$-&%*!37!('%)*7!3)1=02#4!'%('-&,F:!

! (%4-&,!1+00!-&'%,.-'7!?8+22!'%('-&,F!

! (%4-&,!.-&,!-&'%,.-'7!?8+22!'%('-&,F!

! ('%&'!0)'-,+%!

! ('%&'!1.%%8!

! (1)&&-&,!%2%1'.#&!$-1.#(1#87!?;S>F!)&)27(%(!

! 8#27$%.-1!('%&'!1/%$-1)2!1#&1%&'.)'-#&!)&)27(%(:!

!

3. Tissue Morphology and Properties

\#!*%$#&('.)'%!'/)'!'/%!(/%20!2-0%!('#.),%!*#%(!&#'!)*9%.(%27!)00%1'!'-((+%!$#.8/#2#,7!)&*!

8.#8%.'-%(G!-0!)882-1)32%, 4%!.%1#$$%&*!1#$8).-&,!*)')!0.#$!'/%!0#22#4-&,!'%('(!#&!),%*!

)&*!+&),%*!*%9-1%(N!!

! /-('#2#,7!4-'/!(')-&-&,!

! L5

cris
cris
Page 34: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! 0-Y)'-#&!(')3-2-'7!?9-)!(/.-&=),%!'%$8%.)'+.%!#.!*-00%.%&'-)2!(1)&&-&,!1)2#.-$%'.7F!

! .%(-*+)2(!-&!('#.),%!(#2+'-#&!?%:,:G!)2*%/7*%!88$F!

! 3-#$%1/)&-1)2!8.#8%.'-%(!?3-)Y-)2!'%('-&,G!1.%%8!'%('-&,F:!

!

4. Storage Solution

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!)((%((!'/%!('#.),%!(#2+'-#&!)(!8).'!#0!'/%!(/%20!2-0%!9)2-*)'-#&:!!

"/)&,%(!-&!8@G!1/%$-1)2!1#$8#(-'-#&G!8#27$%.-g)'-#&!#.!3.%)=*#4&G!)(!4%22!)(!2%)=),%!

$)7!#11+.!)&*!(/#+2*!3%!%9)2+)'%*:!![.#2#&,%*!*%,.)*)'-#&!#0!'/%!('#.),%!(#2+'-#&!$)7!

/)9%!)&!%00%1'!#&!'-((+%!P+)2-'7:!!W#+.!)((%(($%&'!#0!'/%!('#.),%!(#2+'-#&!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!

)&!)&)27(-(!#0!'/%!.%(-*+)2(!-&!'/%!('#.),%!(#2+'-#&!)&*!)&)27(-(!#0!8)1=),%!1#$8#&%&'(!

2%)1/%*!-&'#!'/%!('#.),%!(#2+'-#&!)'!'/%!2)3%2%*!(/%20!2-0%!#0!'/%!*%9-1%:!!!

!

5. Package Integrity

W#+!$+('!%&(+.%!'/)'!*%9-1%!8)1=),%(!).%!*%(-,&%*!)&*!1#&('.+1'%*!'#!8.#'%1'!'/%!*%9-1%!

0.#$!)2'%.)'-#&!#.!*)$),%!*+.-&,!'/%!1+('#$).7!1#&*-'-#&(!#0!8.#1%((-&,G!('#.),%G!

/)&*2-&,G!)&*!*-('.-3+'-#&!?LK!"AJ!ML6:KD6F:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!%9)2+)'%!'/%!

8)1=),%!-&'%,.-'7!#0!'/%!8.#*+1'!8)1=),-&,!)'!g%.#!'-$%!)&*!)'!'/%!2)3%2%*!(/%20!2-0%G!

8.%0%.)327!+(-&,!)!$%'/#*!'/)'!%9)2+)'%(!'/%!4/#2%!8)1=),%!.)'/%.!'/)&!#&27!'/%!(%)2!).%):!!

\/%!8)1=),%!(/#+2*!1#&')-&!%-'/%.!'/%!.%)2!8.#*+1'G!#.!)!(-$+2)'%*!8.#*+1'!'/)'!/)(!

(-$-2).!$)((!)&*!,%#$%'.7:!!W#+!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!7#+.!.)'-#&)2%!0#.!'/%!'%('!$%'/#*(!

%$82#7%*:!

!

!

!

Shelf Life Validation Information – Tabular Format Example

SAMPLE PREPARATION PLANNED QUALIFICATION

& VALIDATION STUDIES

SAMPLE SIZE

[subject (control)] Sterilization Aging Distribution & Handling

Other (e.g., treatments)

ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA

Valve in vitro hydrodynamic performance:

Steady forward flow ("P, EOA)

Pulsatile forward flow

("P, EOA)

Pulsatile regurgitation

Anti-calcification effect (if applicable) determined by subcutaneous implantation in rats or rabbits

Valve structural integrity:

Leaflet durability

Leaflet prolapse determined by steady backflow testing

! D6

Page 35: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!Sewing cuff integrity (pull testing)

Sewing ring integrity (pull testing)

Stent fatigue

Stent creep

Stent SEM analyses

Polymeric stent chemical concentration analyses

Valve tissue morphology & properties:

Histology (with staining)

Fixation stability (shrink temperature or differential scanning!calorimetry)

Residuals in storage solution (e.g., aldehyde ppm)

Biomechanical properties (biaxial testing, creep, and corrosion)

Storage solution:

Volume

Chemical composition

pH

Leaching analysis (of package components into storage solution, particularly if EtO sterilized)

Package integrity:

Test method used

Real or simulated product

!

! DK

Page 36: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!

Appendix B. Cavitation Testing for Rigid Heart Valves

")9-')'-#&!%.#(-#&!?)&*!-&!(#$%!1)(%(G!1)')('.#8/-1!('.+1'+.%!0)-2+.%F!/)(!#11+..%*!-&!(#$%!.-,-*!

.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%!*%(-,&(:!!B**-'-#&)227G!1)9-')'-#&!1)&!3%!-&*+1%*!-&!$#('!.-,-*!/%).'!

9)29%(!*5'6*,$1D!!\/+(G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!1)9-')'-#&!8#'%&'-)2!'%('-&,!0#.!.-,-*!9)29%(:!!;-&1%!&#!#&%!

'%('!-(!(+00-1-%&'!'#!)((%((!'/%!1)9-')'-#&!8#'%&'-)2!#0!)!&%4!.-,-*!.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%!*%(-,&G!4%!

.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!)!8.%12-&-1)2!*5'6*61!('+*7G!(-$+2)'%*!2#&,!'%.$!*5'6*,$1!('+*7!?-:%:G!

*+.)3-2-'7!'%('-&,F!'#!)((%((!8#((-32%!1)9-')'-#&!*)$),%G!)&*!%Y)$-&%!'/%!)&-$)2!('+*7!)&*!

12-&-1)2!?-0!)882-1)32%F!%Y82)&'%*!9)29%(!0#.!%9-*%&1%!#0!1)9-')'-#&:!!!

!

\/-(!)88%&*-Y!.%8.%(%&'(!#+.!+&*%.(')&*-&,!#0!*5'6*,$1'1)9-')'-#&!'%('!$%'/#*(!)'!'/%!'-$%!'/-(!

,+-*)&1%!4)(!-((+%*:!!W#+!(/#+2*!.%9-%4!(')'%!#0!'/%!).'!1)9-')'-#&!'%('-&,!3%0#.%!-$82%$%&'-&,!)!

8.#'#1#2:!!R+.!,%&%.)2!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!0#.!'%('!8).)$%'%.(!).%!,-9%&!3%2#4:!!!

!

A. Test Valve Selection!!!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!'%('!'4#!#0!'/%!($)22%('!)&*!'4#!#0!'/%!2).,%('!9)29%!(-g%(:!

!

B. Test Valve Mounting!!!

A#.!1)9-')'-#&!'%('-&,G!'/%!9)29%(!(/#+2*!3%!.-,-*27!$#+&'%*!-&!'/%!$-'.)2!8#(-'-#&!#0!)!/%).'!

(-$+2)'#.:!!U0!&#!$-'.)2!9)29%!$#*%2!-(!+&*%.!%9)2+)'-#&G!)!'%('!8.#'#1#2!0#.!'/%!)#.'-1!8#(-'-#&!

(/#+2*!3%!*%9%2#8%*:!

!

C. Reference Valves!!!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!+(%!'4#!()$82%(!#0!)&!A<BC)88.#9%*!9)29%!)(!.%0%.%&1%!9)29%(:!

!

D. Working Fluid!!!

\/%!4#.=-&,!02+-*!(/#+2*!3%!8/7(-#2#,-1)2!()2-&%!)22#4%*!'#!1#$%!'#!%P+-2-3.-+$!4-'/!.##$!

)'$#(8/%.%!0#.!LZ!/#+.(:!

!

E. Atrial Chamber!!!

\/%!)'.-)2!1/)$3%.!(/#+2*!3%!#8%&G!4-'/!)!1.#((!(%1'-#&)2!).%)!,.%)'%.!'/)&!TE!1$L:!

!

F. Atrial Pressure!!!

\/%!$%)&!)'.-)2!8.%((+.%!#&!'/%!'%('!9)29%!(/#+2*!3%!2%((!'/)&!T!$$@,:!

!

G. Cavitation Definition!!!

A<B!*%0-&%(!1)9-')'-#&!)(!)'!2%)('!#&%!-&(')&1%!#0!3+332%!0#.$)'-#&!&#'%*!#&!9)29%!12#(-&,!

#+'!#0!%9%.7!'%&!1712%(!('+*-%*:!

! DL

Page 37: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

H. Description of Detector!!!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*%(1.-3%!'/%!1)9-')'-#&!*%'%1'-#&!(7('%$!)&*!-&*-1)'%!-'(!(%&(-'-9-'7:!

!

I. Pressure Profile!!!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8.#9-*%!)!8.#0-2%!#0!'/%!8.%((+.%!9(:!'-$%!?)9%.),%*!#9%.!'%&!

1#&(%1+'-9%!(7('#2-1!1712%(F!)'!KL6!$$@,G!)&*!)'!)&7!8%)=!9%&'.-1+2).!8.%((+.%!)'!4/-1/!

1)9-')'-#&!-(!0#+&*!0#.!)&7!9)29%G!%-'/%.!(+3l%1'!#.!.%0%.%&1%:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

.%8#.'!'/%!)9%.),%!8.%((+.%!#9%.!(7('#2%:!!!

!

J. Ventricular Pressure!!!

Q)29%(!(/#+2*!3%!'%('%*!)'!KL6!$$@,!8%)=!9%&'.-1+2).!1/)$3%.!8.%((+.%!)&*!)'!)!$)Y-$+$!

02#4!.)'%!#0!T:6!IO$-&:!!\/%!(7('#2-1!.)'-#!(/#+2*!3%!(%'!)'!DE!t!L!o:!

!

K. Maximum Ventricular Pressure!!!

U0!1)9-')'-#&!-(!&#'!#3(%.9%*!-&!%-'/%.!'/%!(%'!#0!(+3l%1'!9)29%(!#.!'/%!(%'!#0!.%0%.%&1%!9)29%(G!

'/%!8%)=!9%&'.-1+2).!8.%((+.%!(/#+2*!3%!-&1.%)(%*!+&'-2!1)9-')'-#&!-(!(%%&!-&!)'!2%)('!#&%!(%'!#0!

'/%!9)29%(G!#.!+&'-2!8%)=!9%&'.-1+2).!8.%((+.%!-(!%P+)2!'#!L66!$$@,:!!U0!7#+!9).7!(7('%$!

8).)$%'%.(!'#!)1/-%9%!1)9-')'-#&G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*%(1.-3%!'/%!(7('%$!8).)$%'%.(!

7#+!1/)&,%*:!

! DD

Page 38: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Appendix C. Bernoulli Verification!

!

"2-&-1)2!/%$#*7&)$-1!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(!-&!12-&-1)2!'.-)2(!'78-1)227!-&12+*%(!

$%)(+.%$%&'!#0!'/%!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!37!<#882%.!+2'.)(#+&*:!!<#882%.!9%2#1-'7!$%)(+.%$%&'(!

).%!1#&9%.'%*!-&'#!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'(!+(-&,!'/%!_%.&#+22-!%P+)'-#&G!![!n!]?Q*L!C!Q8

LF:!!

\/%#.%'-1)227G!'/%!1#&(')&'!]!4-22!%P+)2!ZG!3+'!9)29%C*%8%&*%&'!*%9-)'-#&(!0.#$!'/-(!9)2+%!/)9%!

3%%&!.%8#.'%*:LZGLEGLHGLT

!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*%'%.$-&%G!*5'6*,$1G!4/%'/%.!'/%!1#%00-1-%&'!Z!-(!

)88.#8.-)'%G!37!1#$8).-&,!![!$%)(+.%*!37!<#882%.!4-'/!'/)'!$%)(+.%*!*-.%1'27!37!)!8)-.!#0!8.%((+.%!'.)&(*+1%.(:!

!

\%('-&,!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!#&%!#0!'/%!2).,%('G!-&'%.$%*-)'%G!)&*!($)22%('!()$82%(!0#.!%)1/!9)29%!'78%G!

)(!4%22!)(!)&!)88.#8.-)'%!?()$%!(-g%!)&*!'78%F!2%,)227!$).=%'%*!9)29%!)(!.%0%.%&1%:!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!82#'!'/%!9)2+%(!#0!![!)(!$%)(+.%*!37!8.%((+.%!'.)&(*+1%.(!),)-&('!?Q*L!C!

Q8LF!)(!$%)(+.%*!37!<#882%.G!0#.!02#4!.)'%(!'/)'!7#+!+(%*:!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*%(1.-3%!/#4!'/%!.%(+2'-&,!%Y8%.-$%&')227!$%)(+.%*!1#&(')&'!]!$)7!

)00%1'!12-&-1)2!$%)(+.%$%&'(!#0!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'(G!0#.!*-),&#(-(!)&*!8.#,&#(-(.!

!

!LZ!W)$)(/-')!\G!>#.-7)$)!WG!;)')!^G!%'!)2:!<-(1.%8)&17!3%'4%%&!<#882%.!)&*!1)'/%'%.!

$%)(+.%$%&'(!#0!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'(!)1.#((!($)22C(-g%!8.#('/%'-1!9)29%:!!a8&!a!\/#.)1!").*-#9)(1!

;+.,:!L66EkEDNHZCM:!LE>)(1/%.3)+%.!aG!;1/-$)!@G!>)+.%.!VG!_)+$,).'&%.!@:!!<#882%.!)((%(($%&'!#0!$%1/)&-1)2!

)#.'-1!9)29%!8.#('/%(%(N!%00%1'!#0!9)29%!*%(-,&!)&*!(-g%!#0!'/%!)#.'):!!a!@%).'!Q)29%!<-(:!

L66ZkKDNMLDCD6:!!!LH;'%4).'!;AG!@%.$)&!_BG!^%22!<>G!J%'')!;>:!S00%1'(!#0!9)29%!1/).)1'%.-('-1(!#&!'/%!)11+.)17!

#0!'/%!_%.&#+22-!%P+)'-#&N!)!(+.9%7!#0!*)')!(+3$-''%*!'#!'/%!`:;:!A<B:!!a!@%).'!Q)29%!<-(:!

L66ZkKDNZHKCH:!LT_%1/C@)&((%&!RG!")-*)/2!]G!c)22%&'-&!UG!_.)&*3%.,!aG!c.)&&%!_G!B(=![:!!B#.'-1!8.#('/%'-1!

9)29%!*%(-,&!)&*!(-g%N!.%2)'-#&!'#!<#882%.!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!0-&*-&,(!)&*!8.%((+.%!.%1#9%.7C!)&!

*5'6*,$1!('+*7:!!a!B$!;#1!S1/#1).*-#,.:!L666kKDND5CE6:!

! DZ

Page 39: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

Appendix D. Echocardiography Protocol

!

W#+!$+('!(+3$-'!7#+.!12-&-1)2!8.#'#1#2(!4-'/!7#+.![>B!)882-1)'-#&!?LK!"AJ!MKZ:L6?3F?HF?--FF:!!

A#.!7#+.!U<S!)882-1)'-#&G!7#+!$+('!(+3$-'!)&!)11+.)'%!(+$$).7!#0!7#+.!8.#'#1#2(G!)&*!4%!$)7!

.%P+%('!)**-'-#&)2!-&0#.$)'-#&!1#&1%.&-&,!'/%!-&9%('-,)'-#&:!!LK!"AJ!MKL:L6?3F?LFG!?1FF:!!\/-(!

)88%&*-Y!*%(1.-3%(!A<Bf(!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!0#.!'/%!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!

.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(!-&!12-&-1)2!('+*-%(:!!U&0#.$)'-#&!.%,).*-&,!'/%!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!

8.#'#1#2!?.%1#.*-&,!('+*-%(G!*)')!1#22%1'-#&G!)&*!1#.%!2)3#.)'#.7!1)21+2)'-#&(!)&*!)&)27(-(F!1)&!3%!

0#+&*!-&!B&&%Y!@!#0!U;R!EMZ6NL66E:!!!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/%!0#22#4-&,!-&!)**-'-#&!'#!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!B&&%Y!@G!(+3(%1'-#&!@:K:!!\/%!

.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!)&*!$%'/#*#2#,-%(!).%!)882-1)32%!'#!)22!.%82)1%$%&'!/%).'!9)29%(!.%,).*2%((!#0!

-$82)&')'-#&!$%'/#*:!

!

B&!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!1#.%!2)3#.)'#.7!(/#+2*!8%.0#.$!'/%!1%&'.)2!.%9-%4!#0!)22!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!

*)'):!!\/%!1#.%!2)3#.)'#.7!(/#+2*!/)9%!)!(+8%.9-(-&,!*-.%1'#.!4/#!-(!)&!%1/#1).*-#2#,-('!

%Y8%.-%&1%*!-&!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%!%9)2+)'-#&:!!\/%!1#.%!2)3#.)'#.7!(/#+2*!+(%!

)!4.-''%&!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!8.#'#1#2G!0#22#4%*!37!)22!(#&#,.)8/%.(!)&*!-&9%('-,)'#.(!-&9#29%*!-&!

'/%!12-&-1)2!('+*7:!!U&'%.8.%')'-#&!#0!'/%!%1/#1).*-#,.)$(!37!'/%!1#.%!2)3#.)'#.7!(/#+2*!3%!

$)(=%*:!!U0!'/%.%!).%!)&7!*-00%.%&1%(!3%'4%%&!'/%!('+*7!1%&'%.(!)&*!'/%!1#.%!2)3#.)'#.7!-&!'/%!

-&'%.8.%')'-#&!#0!%1/#1).*-#,.)$(G!'/%&!'/%!1#.%!2)3#.)'#.7!4-22!')=%!8.%1%*%&'!-&!A<Bf(!.%9-%4!

#0!'/%!%1/#1).*-#,.)$(:!!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!('.)'-07!)22!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!/%$#*7&)$-1!*)')G!-&12+*-&,!9)29+2).!

.%,+.,-')'-#&!*)')G!37!9)29%!8#(-'-#&!)&*!9)29%!(-g%:!

!

U0!7#+!1#22%1'!'.)&(%(#8/),%)2!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!?\SSF!*)')G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!+(-&,!)!$+2'-82)&%!

\SS!%Y)$(G!.)'/%.!'/)&!$#&#82)&%!#.!3-82)&%!\SS!%Y)$(:!!>)&7!(')&*).*!/%$#*7&)$-1!

$%)(+.%$%&'(G!(+1/!)(!)#.'-1!9)29%!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'(G!'/)'!).%!)9)-2)32%!4-'/!'/%!+(%!#0!

'.)&('/#.)1-1!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!?\\SF!$)7!&#'!3%!)9)-2)32%!-0!7#+!+(%!\SS:!!;-&1%!-'!-(!-$8#.')&'!

'#!+(%!'/%!()$%!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!-$),-&,!$#*)2-'7!)'!)22!0#22#4C+8!'-$%C8#-&'(G!)&*!(-&1%!\\S!

-(!'/%!12-&-1)2!(')&*).*!)&*!2%)('!-&9)(-9%!$%'/#*!#0!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

8%.0#.$!\\S!%Y)$(!)'!)22!0#22#4C+8!'-$%!8#-&'(:!!\/%(%!'-$%!8#-&'(!(/#+2*!-&12+*%!h)'!/#(8-')2!

*-(1/).,%i!#.!)!'-$%!8#-&'!)'!D6!*)7(!#.!2%((!8#('C-$82)&'!-0!'/%!(+3l%1'!/)(!&#'!3%%&!*-(1/).,%*:!

!

A. Data Collected by the Study Center

U0!7#+!0#22#4!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!B&&%Y!@G!(+3(%1'-#&!@:DG!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/%!)**-'-#&(!

*%(1.-3%*!3%2#4:!

!

<)')!1#22%1'%*!37!'/%!('+*7!1%&'%.!(/#+2*!-&12+*%N!!

! 8%)=!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!

! $%)&!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!

! DE

Page 40: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! %00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!?SRB!#.!BSRF!

! %00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!-&*%Y!?SRBU!#.!BSRUF!

! 8%.0#.$)&1%!-&*%Y!?[UF!

! 1).*-)1!#+'8+'!?"R!#.!R"F!

! 1).*-)1!-&*%Y!?"UF:!!!

!\/%!*)')!(/#+2*!1#&(-('!#0!(+3l%1'!&+$3%.(!)&*!$%)&!?)9%.),%FG!(')&*).*!*%9-)'-#&G!

$-&-$+$!9)2+%(G!)&*!$)Y-$+$!9)2+%(:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!('.)'-07!'/%!*)')!37!9)29%!

8#(-'-#&!)&*!9)29%!(-g%:!!!

!

B2'/#+,/!U;R!EMZ6NL66E!+(%(!'/%!'%.$(!h9%2#1-'7!-&'%,.)2i!)&*!hr*-)('#2-1s!9%2#1-'7!-&'%,.)2!

?<QUFGi!'/%!1#$$#&!`:;:!12-&-1)2!'%.$!-(!h9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!?Q\UFi!#.!h'-$%!9%2#1-'7!

-&'%,.)2!?\QUF:i

!

U;R!EMZ6NL66E!.%1#$$%&*(!)9%.),-&,!E!/%).'!3%)'(!4/%&!#3')-&-&,!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!

/%$#*7&)$-1!$%)(+.%$%&'(!-&!(+3l%1'(!4-'/!)'.-)2!0-3.-22)'-#&:!!\/%(%!(+3l%1'(!$)7!/)9%!)!

/-,/27!9).-)32%!/%).'!.)'%!4/-1/!$)7!1)+(%!$%)(+.%$%&'(!'/)'!).%!%-'/%.!(%9%.)2!$-&+'%(!

)8).'!?(+1/!)(!IQR\!)&*!$-'.)2!9)29%!$%)(+.%$%&'(F!#.!#3')-&%*!#9%.!E!#.!$#.%!3%)'(:!!;+1/!

$%)(+.%$%&'(!$)7!3%!%..#&%#+(!3%1)+(%!'/%7!).%!(+3l%1'!'#!3#'/!/%).'!.)'%!9).-)'-#&!)&*!

.%(8-.)'#.7!)2'%.)'-#&:!!U&!#.*%.!'#!$-'-,)'%!$%)(+.%$%&'!%..#.(G!'/%!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/%.!(/#+2*!

(%2%1'!3%)'(!'/)'!0#22#4!)!8/7(-#2#,-1!8.%1%*-&,!1712%!2%&,'/!?%:,:G!M66!t!M6!$(!#.!TE!t!K6!

38$F!#.!3%)'(!4-'/!K6o!9).-)3-2-'7!-&!/%).'!.)'%:!!`(-&,!%-'/%.!#0!'/%(%!'4#!)88.#)1/%(G!'/%!

(')&*).*!$+2'-82%!3%)'(!?+(+)227!DF!1)&!3%!$%)(+.%*!)&*!)9%.),%*!.%,).*2%((!#0!'/%!

+&*%.27-&,!./7'/$:!

!

Q)29+2).!.%,+.,-')'-#&!*)')!(/#+2*!1#&(-('!#0!'/%!&+$3%.(!)&*!8%.1%&'),%(!#0!(+3l%1'(!0#.!

%)1/!,.)*%!#0!(%9%.-'7:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!('.)'-07!9)29+2).!.%,+.,-')'-#&!*)')!37!,.)*%!

#0!.%,+.,-')'-#&!(%9%.-'7G!9)29%!8#(-'-#&G!)&*!9)29%!(-g%:!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!*#1+$%&'!#'/%.!*)')!'/)'!).%!.#+'-&%27!#3')-&%*!)(!8).'!#0!)!

1#$82%'%!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!%Y)$-&)'-#&G!-&12+*-&,N!!

! &#&C('+*7!9)29%!?&)'-9%!#.!#'/%.!.%82)1%$%&'F!('.+1'+.%!)&*!0+&1'-#&!

! 2%0'!)&*!.-,/'!)'.-)2!(-g%!

! 2%0'!)&*!.-,/'!9%&'.-1+2).!(-g%!

! 2%0'!)&*!.-,/'!9%&'.-1+2).!0+&1'-#&!

! 9%&'.-1+2).!(%8')2!)&*!2%0'!9%&'.-1+2).!8#('%.-#.!4)22!'/-1=&%((!

! 1)9-').7!'/.#$3-!#.!#'/%.!$)((%(!

! 8%.-1).*-)2!)3&#.$)2-'-%(!?(+1/!)(!%00+(-#&F!

! )#.'-1!.##'!*-)$%'%.:!!

!

!

! DH

Page 41: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

B. Calculations and Analysis by the Core Laboratory

!

1. Effective Orifice Area

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!8%.0#.$!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!('+*-%(!)(!*%(1.-3%*!-&!U;R!

EMZ6NL66E!B&&%Y!@G!(+3(%1'-#&!@:Z!#.!-'(!%P+-9)2%&':!!U&!)**-'-#&G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!

7#+!8%.0#.$!'/%!1#.%!2)3#.)'#.7!1)21+2)'-#&(!)&*!)&)27(%(!)(!*%(1.-3%*!3%2#4:!!!

!

A#.!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)G!BSRG!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&!3%2#4:!

!

A#.!)#.'-1!9)29%(N!FC

GC<?GC<?=E:<

C?2

C?2FF

#$ : ! !

!

A#.!$-'.)2!9)29%(N!@C

GC<?GC<?=E:<

C?2

C?2FF

#$ : ! !

4/%.%! F:<!! -(!'/%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!-&!1$L!

F=EDGC<?! -(!'/%!2%0'!9%&'.-1+2).!#+'02#4!'.)1'!?IQR\F!1.#((C(%1'-#&)2!

).%)!-&!1$LG!1)21+2)'%*!0.#$!'/%!*-)$%'%.!)((+$-&,!1-.1+2).!

1.#((C(%1'-#&!

C?2GC<?! -(!'/%!IQR\!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!?Q\UF!-&!1$G!)(!$%)(+.%*!

37!8+2(%*!4)9%!?[cF!<#882%.!

C?2FC! -(!'/%!)#.'-1!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!?Q\UF!-&!1$G!)(!$%)(+.%*!

37!1#&'-&+#+(!4)9%!?"cF!<#882%.!

C?2@C! -(!'/%!$-'.)2!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!?Q\UF!-&!1$G!)(!$%)(+.%*!

37!"c!<#882%.!

!

U0!(-,&-0-1)&'!)#.'-1!.%,+.,-')'-#&!-(!8.%(%&'G!'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&!0#.!$-'.)2!9)29%(!4-22!

2-=%27!#9%.%('-$)'%!'/%!$-'.)2!9)29%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)G!-0!7#+!+(%!'/%!IQR\!1.#((C

(%1'-#&)2!).%)!)&*!IQR\!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2:!!U&!'/-(!1)(%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

(+3('-'+'%!'/%!IQR\!1.#((C(%1'-#&)2!).%)!)&*!IQR\!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!-&!'/%!

1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&!)(!0#22#4(:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!+(%!'/%!(+3('-'+'-#&(!(/#4&!-&!

'/%!')32%!3%2#4:!!!

!

IN PLACE OF: USE:

IQR\!1.#((!(%1'-#&)2!).%)!?F=EDGC<?F! 8+2$#&-1!)&&+2+(!1.#((!(%1'-#&)2!).%)!?F=EDHCF!-&!

1$L!?1)21+2)'%*!0.#$!'/%!8+2$#&-1!)&&+2+(!

*-)$%'%.F!

IQR\!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!?C?2GC<?F 8+2$#&-1!9)29%!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!?C?2HCF!-&!

1$!?)(!$%)(+.%*!37!"c!<#882%.F!

!

! DT

Page 42: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

\/%!$-'.)2!9)29%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!$)7!3%!1)21+2)'%*!37!'/%!8.%((+.%!/)20C'-$%!

$%'/#*!-&('%)*!#0!'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&:!!U0!(-,&-0-1)&'!$-'.)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!-(!8.%(%&'G!

'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&!0#.!$-'.)2!9)29%(!4-22!2-=%27!+&*%.%('-$)'%!'/%!$-'.)2!9)29%!

%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!-0!'/%!IQR\!1.#((C(%1'-#&)2!).%)!)&*!IQR\!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!

).%!+(%*:!!U&!'/-(!1)(%G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!+(%!'/%!8.%((+.%!/)20C'-$%!$%'/#*!-&('%)*:!!!

\/%!8.%((+.%!/)20C'-$%!?[@\F!-(!*%0-&%*!)(!'/%!'-$%!?-&!$-22-(%1#&*(F!0#.!'/%!$)Y-$+$!

?8%)=F!%).27!*-)('#2-1!'.)&($-'.)2!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!'#!*%1.%)(%!37!#&%C/)20!#.!0#.!'/%!

$)Y-$+$!?8%)=F!9%2#1-'7!'#!*%1.%)(%!37!KO"L!?n!KOK:ZF:!!\/%![@\!-(!*%'%.$-&%*!37!"c!<#882%.:!

!

A#.!$-'.)2!9)29%(N!!

!HB?

F:<LL6

$ ! !

!

! -?HB? #$ L5:6 ! !

!

4/%.%! HB?!! -(!'/%!8.%((+.%!/)20C'-$%!-&!$(!

!

-?' -(!'/%!*%1%2%.)'-#&!'-$%!-&!$('

!

B2'%.&)'-9%27G![@\!1)&!)2(#!3%!,.)8/-1)227!*%'%.$-&%*!)'!'/%!8#-&'!4/%.%!'/%!/)20C'-$%!

9%2#1-'7!?8%)=!9%2#1-'7OK:ZF!-&'%.(%1'(!'/%!2-&%).!9%2#1-'7!(2#8%!#&!'/%!"c!<#882%.!

(8%1'.)2!9%2#1-'7!'.)1%:!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&*-1)'%!'/%!$%'/#*!#0!1)21+2)'-#&!#0!'/%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!

+(%*!0#.!%)1/!9)29%!8#(-'-#&:!!c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!+(%!'/%!()$%!$%'/#*!#0!

1)21+2)'-#&!0#.!%)1/!9)29%!8#(-'-#&!0#.!)22!0#22#4C+8!'-$%C8#-&'(:!

!

R&%!.%0%.%&1%!1)+'-#&(!'/)'!'/%![@\!#9%.%('-$)'%(!'/%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!#0!&#.$)2!

.%82)1%$%&'!$-'.)2!9)29%(G!(-&1%!'/%!1#&(')&'!LL6!4)(!*%.-9%*!3)(%*!#&!&)'-9%!$-'.)2!

9)29%!('%&#(%(!.)'/%.!'/)&!.%82)1%$%&'!$-'.)2!9)29%!('%&#(%(:LM!!\/%.%0#.%G!4/%&!'/%.%!-(!

&#!(-,&-0-1)&'!$-'.)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&G!'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&!$)7!3%!)!3%''%.!$%'/#*!0#.!

*%'%.$-&-&,!'/%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!#0!.%82)1%$%&'!$-'.)2!9)29%(:

!

>#('!&#.$)227C0+&1'-#&-&,!.%82)1%$%&'!)#.'-1!)&*!$-'.)2!9)29%(!/)9%!(#$%!.%('.-1'-#&!'#!

02#4!*+%!'#!9).7-&,!*%,.%%(!#0!-&/%.%&'!('%&#(-(:!!"#&(%P+%&'27G!&#.$)227C0+&1'-#&-&,!

.%82)1%$%&'!$-'.)2!9)29%(!$)7!/)9%!/-,/!-&-'-)2!9%2#1-'-%(G!3+'!4-22!/)9%!)!.)8-*![@\G!)(!

1#$8).%*!'#!)&!#3('.+1'%*!.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%!4/-1/!4-22!/)9%!)!8.#2#&,%*![@\:!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!LM!R/!a]G!;%4).*!a_G!)&*!\)l-=!Ba:!\/%!S1/#!>)&+)2G!L&*!%*:!I-88-&1#''CJ)9%&![+32-(/%.(G!

[/-2)*%28/-)G![BG!^%4!W#.=G!^WG!K555:!!!!

! DM

Page 43: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

\/%!8.%((+.%!/)20C'-$%!$%'/#*!-(!+&.%2-)32%!-&!(-'+)'-#&(!-&!4/-1/!'/%!2%0'!9%&'.-1+2).!

?IQF!*-)('#2-1!8.%((+.%!.-(%(!.)8-*27!?*+%!'#!.%('.-1'-#&!'#!0-22-&,F!)(!4-'/!(-,&-0-1)&'!)#.'-1!

.%,+.,-')'-#&G!IQ!*-)('#2-1!&#&1#$82-)&1%G!#.!-(1/%$-):!!U&!'/%(%!(-'+)'-#&(!'/%!.)8-*!.-(%!

-&!IQ!*-)('#2-1!8.%((+.%!.%(+2'(!-&!.)8-*!%P+-2-3.)'-#&!#0!'/%!8.%((+.%!*-00%.%&1%!3%'4%%&!

'/%!2%0'!)'.-+$!)&*!'/%!2%0'!9%&'.-12%G!)&*!'/%![@\!-(!(/#.'%&%*:!!\/%!8.%((+.%!/)20C'-$%!

$%'/#*!-(!)2(#!+&.%2-)32%!-&!(-'+)'-#&(!-&!4/-1/!P+)2-'7!(8%1'.)2!<#882%.!4)9%!0#.$(!).%!

&#'!#3')-&%*G!(+1/!)(!-&!)'.-)2!')1/71).*-)!)&*!0-.('!*%,.%%!BQ!32#1=!?2#&,![J!-&'%.9)2F!

4/%.%!'/%!S!4)9%!)&*!'/%!B!4)9%!$%.,%G!)&*!-&!)'.-)2!02+''%.!4/%.%!'/%!02+''%.!4)9%!

<#882%.!8)''%.&(!$)7!1/)&,%!'/%!S!4)9%!*%1)7!8)''%.&:L5

!;+3l%1'(!4-'/!)3&#.$)2!

$7#1).*-)2!.%2)Y)'-#&!/)9%!)!8.#2#&,%*![@\G!3+'!'/%!8%)=!S!9%2#1-'7!-(!&#'!-&1.%)(%*!)&*!

-(!+(+)227!2#4%.!'/)&!K!$O(:LM!

!

U'!-(!)88.#8.-)'%!'#!1)21+2)'%!'/%!)#.'-1!9)29%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!37!'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!

%P+)'-#&!#&27!-0!7#+!/)9%!)&!)11+.)'%!IQR\!$%)(+.%$%&':!!U0!7#+!1)&&#'!#3')-&!)&!

)11+.)'%!IQR\!$%)(+.%$%&'G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!.%8#.'!'/%!<#882%.!9%2#1-'7!-&*%Y!)(!

)!(+..#,)'%!0#.!'/%!)#.'-1!9)29%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%):!!\/%!<#882%.!9%2#1-'7!-&*%Y!?)2(#!

1)22%*!'/%!*-$%&(-#&2%((!-&*%YF!-(!'/%!.)'-#!QIQR\OQBQG!4/%.%!QIQR\!-(!'/%!IQR\!9%2#1-'7!

)&*!QBQ!-(!'/%!)#.'-1!9%2#1-'7:!!B!<#882%.!9%2#1-'7!-&*%Y!2%((!'/)&!6:L6!0#.!)!$%1/)&-1)2!

.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%!#.!2%((!'/)&!6:KE!0#.!)!/%'%.#,.)0'!3-#8.#('/%'-1!9)29%!-(!,%&%.)227!

1#&(-('%&'!4-'/!(%9%.%!.%82)1%$%&'!)#.'-1!9)29%!#3('.+1'-#&:L5!

!

A#.!.%82)1%$%&'!8+2$#&-1!9)29%(!)&*!8+2$#&-1!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(G!4%!*#!&#'!.%1#$$%&*!

'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)G!(-&1%!'/%!1#&%!(/)8%!#0!'/%!.-,/'!9%&'.-1+2).!

#+'02#4!'.)1'!$)=%(!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!$%)(+.%$%&'!#0!'/%!.-,/'!9%&'.-1+2).!#+'02#4!'.)1'!

*-)$%'%.!*-00-1+2':!!\/-(!*-00-1+2'!$%)(+.%$%&'!2%)*(!'#!8#'%&'-)2!-&)11+.)'%!1)21+2)'-#&!#0!

'/%!8+2$#&-1!9)29%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!9-)!'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&!$%'/#*:!!;-$-2).27G!

0#.!.%82)1%$%&'!8+2$#&-1!9)29%(!)&*!8+2$#&-1!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(G!4%!*#!&#'!.%1#$$%&*!

'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!-&*%Y!)&*!8%.0#.$)&1%!-&*%Y!*)')G!4/-1/!).%!

1)21+2)'%*!+(-&,!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!*)'):!

!

@#4%9%.G!4%!('-22!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!'/%!8+2$#&-1!8%)=!,.)*-%&'!)&*!$%)&!,.)*-%&'!3%!

1)21+2)'%*G!+(-&,!"c!<#882%.G!)(!*#&%!0#.!#'/%.!9)29%!8#(-'-#&(:!!

!

A#.!)#.'-1!)&*!$-'.)2!9)29%(G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-&*%Y!'/%!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!'#!

3#*7!(+.0)1%!).%)!)(!(/#4&!3%2#4:!

!

!L5!]%.+'!S]G!>1U24)-&!SAG!)&*![2#'&-1=!V<:!@)&*3##=!#0!S1/#C<#882%.!U&'%.8.%')'-#&:!A+'+.)!

[+32-(/-&,!"#$8)&7G!U&1:G!B.$#&=G!^WG!K55H:!

! D5

Page 44: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

A#.!)#.'-1!)&*!$-'.)2!9)29%(N!

!

!IE

:<:<

F

F2F $ ! !

!

4/%.%! F:<2! -(!'/%!-&*%Y%*!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!-&!1$LO$

L:!

!

FIE! -(!'/%!3#*7!(+.0)1%!).%)!-&!$L!

!

2. Velocity Time Integral

\/%!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!r#.!'-$%!9%2#1-'7!-&'%,.)2!?\QUFs!-(!*%0-&%*!)11#.*-&,!'#!'/%!

0#22#4-&,!%P+)'-#&N!!

!

! ! !!EK6%##$ :A3"%5 ,CC?2

!

!

4/%.%! C?2!! -(!'/%!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!-&!1$!

!

! C$%)&!! -(!'/%!$%)&!9%2#1-'7!#0!0#.4).*!02#4!-&!$O(!

!

! ,Sa!! -(!'/%!%l%1'-#&!'-$%!-&!$(!

!

B2'%.&)'-9%27G!7#+!$)7!1)21+2)'%!'/%!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!?Q\UF!37!'/%!3+-2'C-&!(#0'4).%!

#0!$#*%.&!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!+2'.)(#+&*!$)1/-&%(!+(-&,!'/%!'%1/&-1-)&f(!82)&-$%'.7!

?'.)1-&,F!#0!'/%!<#882%.!9%2#1-'7!(-,&)2:!

!

3. Peak Pressure Gradient

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!8%)=!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!)1.#((!'/%!.%82)1%$%&'!

9)29%!9-)!'/%!$#*-0-%*!_%.&#+22-!%P+)'-#&!3%2#4:!!B2'%.&)'-9%27G!7#+!$)7!1)21+2)'%!'/%!

8%)=!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!+(-&,!$#*%.&!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!+2'.)(#+&*!$)1/-&%(!4-'/!3+-2'C-&!

(#0'4).%!'/)'!+(%(!'/%!%P+)'-#&!3%2#4:!

!

! & 'LKL

LZ CCHH"%J %$" ! !

!

4/%.%! H"%J'!H!! -(!'/%!8%)=!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!-&!$$!@,!

! ! !

CL! -(!'/%!9%2#1-'7!*-(')2!'#!'/%!9)29%!-&!$O(!?)(!$%)(+.%*!37!

"c!<#882%.F!

! ! !

CK! -(!'/%!9%2#1-'7!8.#Y-$)2!'#!'/%!9)29%!-&!$O(!?)(!$%)(+.%*!37!

[c!<#882%.FG!$%)(+.%*!-&!'/%!IQR\!0#.!)&!)#.'-1!

8.#('/%(-(!!

!

! Z6

Page 45: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

4. Mean Pressure Gradient

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!$%)&!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!)1.#((!'/%!.%82)1%$%&'!

9)29%!9-)!'/%!%P+)'-#&!3%2#4:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!+(%!'/%!3+-2'C-&!(#0'4).%!#0!

$#*%.&!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!+2'.)(#+&*!$)1/-&%(!'/)'!+(%!82)&-$%'.7!?'.)1-&,F!#0!'/%!"c!

<#882%.!(8%1'.)2!9%2#1-'7!(-,&)2!)&*!'/%!(-$82-0-%*!_%.&#+22-!%P+)'-#&!?#[!n!ZQLLF!'#!

#3')-&!$+2'-82%!-&(')&')&%#+(!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'(G!4/-1/!7#+!(/#+2*!'/%&!)9%.),%!'#!*%.-9%!

'/%!$%)&!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'G!)(!(/#4&!-&!'/%!0#22#4-&,!%P+)'-#&:!!!

!

!5

HHHH@"%5 5*** $$$ "(("("$"

:::LK ! !

4/%.%! @"%5'!H! -(!'/%!$%)&!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!-&!$$@,!

! ! #H*nK! -(!'/%!K('!-&(')&')&%#+(!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!-&!$$@,!

! ! #H*nL! -(!'/%!L&*!-&(')&')&%#+(!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!-&!$$@,!

! ! #H*n5! -(!5'/!-&(')&')&%#+(!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'!-&!$$@,!

! ! 5! -(!'/%!&+$3%.!#0!-&(')&')&%#+(!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&'(!

!

\/%!(-$82-0-%*!_%.&#+22-!%P+)'-#&!)((+$%(!&%,2-,-32%!8.#Y-$)2!9%2#1-'7:!!U&!#'/%.!4#.*(G!

-'!)((+$%(!QK!-(!2%((!'/)&!K$O(:!!U0!'/-(!)((+$8'-#&!-(!+&'.+%G!/#4%9%.G!'/%!%P+)'-#&!)3#9%!

$)7!#9%.%('-$)'%!'/%!$%)&!8.%((+.%!,.)*-%&':!

5. Transvalvular Flow

A#.!)#.'-1!)&*!$-'.)2!9)29%(G!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'.)&(9)29+2).!02#4!)(!

0#22#4(N!!!

!

! DK6#$:A

+

,

C!&1K ! !

4/%.%! !&1K!! ! -(!'/%!'.)&(9)29+2).!02#4!-&!$2O(!

! ,Sa!! -(!'/%!%l%1'-#&!'-$%!-&!$(!

C;!!! -(!'/%!('.#=%!9#2+$%!-&!$2G!1)21+2)'%*!+(-&,!'/%!0#22#4-&,!

('.#=%!9#2+$%!%P+)'-#&N!

!

!

C?2-

C?2-

C?2FC =EE

##$

#))*

+

,,-

.#/

01

234$

#$

TME:6

L

L

L

5 ! !

! !

! ZK

Page 46: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

4/%.%! F";!! -(!'/%!1.#((C(%1'-#&)2!).%)!#0!'/%!IQR\!-&!1$L!0#.!'/%!)#.'-1!

('.#=%!9#2+$%!1)21+2)'-#&G!#.!'/%!1.#((C(%1'-#&)2!).%)!#0!'/%!

$-'.)2!9)29%!)&&+2+(!-&!1$L!0#.!'/%!$-'.)2!('.#=%!9#2+$%!

1)21+2)'-#&!

-! -(!'/%!*-)$%'%.!#0!'/%!IQR\!-&!1$!0#.!'/%!)#.'-1!('.#=%!

9#2+$%!1)21+2)'-#&G!#.!'/%!*-)$%'%.!#0!'/%!$-'.)2!9)29%!

)&&+2+(!-&!1$!0#.!'/%!$-'.)2!('.#=%!9#2+$%!1)21+2)'-#&!

C?2! -(!'/%!IQR\!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!-&'%,.)2!-&!1$!0#.!'/%!)#.'-1!

('.#=%!9#2+$%!1)21+2)'-#&G!#.!'/%!$-'.)2!9%2#1-'7!'-$%!

-&'%,.)2!-&!1$!0#.!'/%!$-'.)2!('.#=%!9#2+$%!1)21+2)'-#&!

!

6. Cardiac Index

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!1).*-)1!-&*%Y!)(!0#22#4(N!

!

!IE

>

F

<=2 $ ! !

!

4/%.%! =2!! ! -(!'/%!1).*-)1!-&*%Y!-&!2O$-&O$L!

!

! <"!! ! -(!'/%!1).*-)1!#+'8+'!-&!2O$-&!

!

F_;!! ! -(!'/%!3#*7!(+.0)1%!).%)!-&!$L!

!

7. Performance Index

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!8%.0#.$)&1%!-&*%Y!)(!0#22#4(N!

!

!HC

:<

2<F

F6*61*5H2 $ ! !

!

4/%.%! H2'! ! -(!'/%!8%.0#.$)&1%!-&*%YG!4/-1/!/)(!&#!*-$%&(-#&(!

!

*5'6*61!FSR! -(!'/%!*5'6*61!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!-&!1$L!

!

2<F[Q! -(!'/%!8.%C-$82)&'!-&'%.&)2!#.-0-1%!).%)!#0!'/%!.%82)1%$%&'!

9)29%!-&!1$LG!#3')-&%*!0.#$!'/%!.%82)1%$%&'!9)29%!

(8%1-0-1)'-#&(!

!

A#.!.%82)1%$%&'!8+2$#&-1!9)29%(!)&*!8+2$#&-1!9)29%*!1#&*+-'(G!4%!*#!&#'!.%1#$$%&*!

'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!8%.0#.$)&1%!-&*%YG!4/-1/!-(!1)21+2)'%*!+(-&,!%00%1'-9%!#.-0-1%!).%)!

*)')G!(-&1%!'/%!1#&%!(/)8%!#0!'/%!.-,/'!9%&'.-1+2).!#+'02#4!'.)1'!$)=%(!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!

$%)(+.%$%&'!#0!'/%!.-,/'!9%&'.-1+2).!#+'02#4!'.)1'!*-)$%'%.!*-00-1+2':!!\/-(!*-00-1+2'!

! ZL

Page 47: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$%)(+.%$%&'!2%)*(!'#!8#'%&'-)2!-&)11+.)'%!1)21+2)'-#&!#0!'/%!8+2$#&-1!9)29%!%00%1'-9%!

#.-0-1%!).%)!9-)!'/%!1#&'-&+-'7!%P+)'-#&!$%'/#*:!

!

C. Valvular Regurgitation

U&!)**-'-#&!'#!U;R!EMZ6NL66EG!;%1'-#&!@:ZG!(+3(%1'-#&!@:Z:TG!4%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!

-&12+*%!'/%!-&0#.$)'-#&!*%(1.-3%*!3%2#4!-&!7#+.!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!9)29+2).!.%,+.,-')'-#&:!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!-*%&'-07!%)1/!l%'!)(!8%.-9)29+2).G!'.)&(9)29+2).G!3#'/G!#.!+&1%.')-&:!!

c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!(/#4!'/%!(-'%!#0!%)1/!8%.-9)29+2).!l%'!#&!'/%!(%4-&,!.-&,G!0#.!

%Y)$82%G!)(!)!q12#1=C0)1%q!*-),.)$:!!!

\/%!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!9)29+2).!.%,+.,-')'-#&!(/#+2*!-&9#29%!)&!-&'%,.)'%*!)88.#)1/!-&!4/-1/!7#+!

+(%!$+2'-82%!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/-1!$%'/#*(!'#!)((%((!.%,+.,-')'-#&!)'!%)1/!0#22#4C+8!'-$%C8#-&':!!

;-&1%!1%.')-&!$%'/#*(!$)7!&#'!3%!)9)-2)32%!)'!%9%.7!0#22#4C+8!9-(-'G!'/-(!)88.#)1/!)22#4(!7#+!

'#!1#$8).%!(%P+%&'-)2!.%(+2'(!0#.!'/%!%&'-.%!*+.)'-#&!#0!0#22#4C+8G!4-'/!'/%!.%(+2'(!#3')-&%*!37!

'/%!()$%!$%'/#*!#.!$%'/#*(:!!c%!.%1#$$%&*G!/#4%9%.G!'/)'!7#+!(+3$-'!)22!0#22#4C+8!

.%(+2'(G!-&12+*-&,!'/#(%!#3')-&%*!37!$%'/#*(!4-'/!$-((-&,!'-$%C8#-&'(:!!B88.#8.-)'%!$%'/#*(!

0#.!%9)2+)'-&,!.%,+.,-')'-#&!).%!(+$$).-g%*!3%2#4!)&*!*-(1+((%*!-&!0+.'/%.!*%')-2!-&!'/%!

2-'%.)'+.%:D6GDK

!

1. Aortic Regurgitation

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!,.)*%!)#.'-1!.%,+.,-')'-#&!37!)&!-&'%,.)'%*!%9)2+)'-#&!3)(%*!#&!

0)1'#.(!-&12+*-&,N!!

! -&('.+$%&'!(%''-&,!

! l%'!4-*'/!

! l%'!).%)!

! l%'!*%8'/!

! '/%!(/)8%!?1#&'#+.F!)&*!'/%!*%&(-'7!#0!'/%!1#&'-&+#+(!4)9%!(-,&)2!?%:,:G!'/%!

*%1%2%.)'-#&!'-$%!)&*!8.%((+.%!/)20C'-$%!3#'/!*%1.%)(%!4-'/!-&1.%)(-&,!BJ!(%9%.-'7k!

-&1.%)(%*!(-,&)2!*%&(-'7!,%&%.)227!-&*-1)'%(!$#.%!(%9%.%!BJF!

! '/%!*+.)'-#&!#0!'/%!1#&'-&+#+(!4)9%!(-,&)2!?%:,:G!)!3.-%0!*-)('#2-1!*+.)'-#&!+(+)227!

-&*-1)'%(!8/7(-#2#,-1!#.!$-2*!BJF!

!D6!b#,/3-!cBG!S&.-P+%gC;).)&#!>G!A#('%.!SG!V.)73+.&![BG!].)0'!"<G!I%9-&%!JBG!

^-/#7)&&#8#+2#(![G!R''#!">G!d+-&#&%(!>BG!J)=#4(=-!@G!;'%4).'!caG!c),,#&%.!BG!)&*!

c%-(($)&!^a:!J%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!0#.!%9)2+)'-#&!#0!'/%!(%9%.-'7!#0!&)'-9%!9)29+2).!.%,+.,-')'-#&!

4-'/!'4#C*-$%&(-#&)2!)&*!<#882%.!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7:!a!B$!;#1!S1/#1).*-#,.!KHNTTTCM6LG!

L66D:!DK!V#''*-%&%.!a;G!_%*&).g!aG!<%9%.%+Y!JG!V).*-&!aG!]2%-&!BG!>)&&-&,!caG!>#.%/%)*!BG!]-'g$)&!

<G!R/!aG!d+-&#&%(!>G!;1/-22%.!^_G!;'%-&!a@G!)&*!c%-(($)&!^a:!B$%.-1)&!;#1-%'7!#0!

S1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!.%1#$$%&*)'-#&(!0#.!+(%!#0!%1/#1).*-#,.)8/7!-&!12-&-1)2!'.-)2(G!a!B$!;#1!

S1/#1).*-#,.!KTNK6MHCKKK5G!L66Z:!

! ZD

Page 48: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

! '/%!('.+1'+.%!#0!'/%!)#.'-1!9)29%!

! '/%!(-g%!)&*!0+&1'-#&!#0!'/%!2%0'!9%&'.-12%!

! /#4!0).!*-)('#2-1!02#4!.%9%.()2!1)&!3%!9-(+)2-g%*!4-'/-&!'/%!)#.'):DL!!!

!

R0!'/%(%!,.)*-&,!0)1'#.(G!'/%!4-*'/!#0!'/%!)#.'-1!l%'!)(!)!8.#8#.'-#&!#0!'/%!2%0'!9%&'.-1+2).!

#+'02#4!'.)1'!*-)$%'%.!-(!'/%!$#('!0.%P+%&'27!+(%*!(-&,2%!$%)(+.%:DD!!@#4%9%.G!l%'!4-*'/!

(/#+2*!3%!)882-%*!1).%0+227!0#.!%11%&'.-1!l%'(:!!!

!

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!)2(#!,.)*%!)#.'-1!.%,+.,-')'-#&!37!'/%!)88%).)&1%!#0!'/%!*-)('#2-1!

0-22-&,!8)''%.&!-&!$-'.)2!-&02#4!?%:,:G!(%9%.%!)#.'-1!.%,+.,-')'-#&!.%(+2'(!-&!)!.%('.-1'-9%!$-'.)2!

0-22-&,!8)''%.&!4-'/!/-,/!S!9%2#1-'7G!2#4!B!9%2#1-'7G!-&1.%)(%*!SOB!9%2#1-'7!.)'-#G!)&*!(/#.'!

*%1%2%.)'-#&!'-$%F:!!!

!

c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!.%,+.,-')&'!9#2+$%G!.%,+.,-')&'!0.)1'-#&G!)&*!

%00%1'-9%!.%,+.,-')&'!#.-0-1%G!'#!#3')-&!)!$#.%!#3l%1'-9%!P+)&'-g)'-#&!#0!'/%!(%9%.-'7!#0!)#.'-1!

.%,+.,-')'-#&:!!\/%!.%,+.,-')&'!9#2+$%G!.%,+.,-')&'!0.)1'-#&G!)&*!%00%1'-9%!.%,+.,-')&'!

#.-0-1%!).%)!1)&!3%!1)21+2)'%*!37!'/%!9#2+$%'.-1!#.!8.#Y-$)2!-(#9%2#1-'7!(+.0)1%!).%)!?[U;BF!

$%'/#*(:!!^#.$)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!*+%!'#!3)1=02#4!(/#+2*!3%!*-('-&,+-(/%*!0.#$!8)'/#2#,-1!

.%,+.,-')'-#&:!!\/%!+(+)2!*-('-&,+-(/-&,!0%)'+.%(!#0!&#.$)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!).%!)!+&-0#.$!1#2#.!

8)''%.&!)&*!($)22!l%'(!4-'/!&#.$)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&:!!\/%!+(+)2!*-('-&,+-(/-&,!0%)'+.%(!#0!

8)'/#2#,-1!.%,+.,-')'-#&!).%!)!$#()-1!1#2#.!8)''%.&!)&*!2).,%.!l%'(:!!!

!

2. Mitral Regurgitation

c%!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!,.)*%!$-'.)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!37!)&!-&'%,.)'%*!%9)2+)'-#&!3)(%*!#&!

0)1'#.(G!-&12+*-&,N!

! -&('.+$%&'!(%''-&,!

! l%'!4-*'/!

! l%'!).%)!

! l%'!*%8'/!

! l%'!%11%&'.-1-'7!

! '/%!(/)8%!?1#&'#+.F!)&*!'/%!*%&(-'7!#0!'/%!1#&'-&+#+(!4)9%!(-,&)2!?%:,:G!(%9%.%!$-'.)2!

.%,+.,-')'-#&!$)7!.%(+2'!-&!)!q1+'C#00!(-,&i!*+%!'#!)!2).,%!9!4)9%k!-&1.%)(%*!(-,&)2!

*%&(-'7!,%&%.)227!-&*-1)'%(!$#.%!(%9%.%!>JF!

! '/%!8%)=!9%2#1-'7!#0!'/%!1#&'-&+#+(!4)9%!(-,&)2!?%:,:G!8%)=!9%2#1-'7!*%1.%)(%(!4-'/!

-&1.%)(-&,!$-'.)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!(%9%.-'7!*+%!'#!-&1.%)(%*!2%0'!)'.-)2!8.%((+.%F!

! '/%!*+.)'-#&!#0!'/%!1#&'-&+#+(!4)9%!(-,&)2!

! '/%!('.+1'+.%!#0!'/%!$-'.)2!9)29%!

!DL!;-$8(#&!UBG!<%!_%2*%.!>BG!]%&&7!BG!>).'-&!>G!)&*!^-/#7)&&#8#+2#(![G!@#4!'#!P+)&'-')'%*!

9)29%!.%,+.,-')'-#&!37!%1/#!<#882%.!'%1/&-P+%(G!_.-'!@%).'!a!!TD?E!;+882!LFNKC5G!K55E:!DD![%..7!VaG!@%2$1=%!AG!^)&*)!^"G!_7).*!"G!)&*!;#'#!_:!!S9)2+)'-#&!#0!)#.'-1!-&(+00-1-%&17!37!

<#882%.!1#2#.!02#4!$)88-&,G!a!B$!"#22!").*-#2!5N5ELC5E5G!K5MT:!

! ZZ

Page 49: FDA Guidance for Heart Valve Replacement

Contains Nonbinding Recommendations !

-$%.,'/'01,'.1$'234&"3"5,%,*15'

!

! ZE

! '/%!(-g%!)&*!0+&1'-#&!#0!'/%!2%0'!9%&'.-12%!

! '/%!(-g%!#0!'/%!2%0'!)'.-+$!

! -$8-&,%$%&'!#0!'/%!l%'!#&!'/%!2%0'!)'.-)2!4)22!

! '/%!*-.%1'-#&!#0!(7('#2-1!02#4!-&!'/%!8+2$#&).7!9%-&(!?%:,:G!(%9%.%!$-'.)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!

$)7!.%(+2'!-&!(7('#2-1!02#4!.%9%.()2F!

! '/%!4-*'/!#0!'/%!9%&)!1#&'.)1')!?'/%!&)..#4%('!8#.'-#&!#0!'/%!$-'.)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!l%'!

*#4&('.%)$!0.#$!'/%!#.-0-1%F:!!!

!

>-'.)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!$)7!)2(#!3%!,.)*%*!37!'/%!)88%).)&1%!#0!'/%!*-)('#2-1!0-22-&,!8)''%.&!-&!

$-'.)2!-&02#4!?%:,:G!(%9%.%!$-'.)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!.%(+2'(!-&!)!.%('.-1'-9%!0-22-&,!8)''%.&!4-'/!

/-,/!S!9%2#1-'7G!2#4!B!9%2#1-'7G!-&1.%)(%*!SOB!.)'-#G!)&*!(/#.'!*%1%2%.)'-#&!'-$%F:!!!

!

c%!)2(#!.%1#$$%&*!'/)'!7#+!1)21+2)'%!'/%!.%,+.,-')&'!9#2+$%G!.%,+.,-')&'!0.)1'-#&G!)&*!

%00%1'-9%!.%,+.,-')&'!#.-0-1%!'#!#3')-&!)!$#.%!#3l%1'-9%!P+)&'-')'-#&!#0!'/%!(%9%.-'7!#0!$-'.)2!

.%,+.,-')'-#&:!!\/%!.%,+.,-')&'!9#2+$%G!.%,+.,-')&'!0.)1'-#&G!)&*!%00%1'-9%!.%,+.,-')&'!

#.-0-1%!1)&!3%!1)21+2)'%*!37!'/%!9#2+$%'.-1!#.![U;B!$%'/#*(:!!^#.$)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!*+%!'#!

3)1=02#4!(/#+2*!3%!*-('-&,+-(/%*!0.#$!8)'/#2#,-1!.%,+.,-')'-#&:!!\/%!+(+)2!*-('-&,+-(/-&,!

0%)'+.%(!#0!&#.$)2!.%,+.,-')'-#&!).%!)!+&-0#.$!1#2#.!8)''%.&!)&*!($)22!l%'(!4-'/!&#.$)2!

.%,+.,-')'-#&:!!\/%!+(+)2!*-('-&,+-(/-&,!0%)'+.%(!#0!8)'/#2#,-1!.%,+.,-')'-#&!).%!)!$#()-1!

1#2#.!8)''%.&!)&*!2).,%.!l%'(:!!!