EXHIBIT 3 - KCC Class Actionclassaction.kccllc.net › Documents › NWD0001 › 579-3 - Goldman Dec… · 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/08/2015 Reviewed Mixson deposition transcript

EXHIBIT 3

Case 1:13-cv-06802-WHP Document 579-3 Filed 07/13/16 Page 1 of 57

Exhibit 3: Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP Time Detail from February 1, 2015 through June 30, 2016

Timekeeper ID Timekeeper Name Title Work Date Narrative Billed Hours Billed Amount

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/03/2015 T/cs E. Coddon of PH and S. Musallam; attend management conference call 1.50 1,680.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/04/2015 T/cs E. Coddon of Paul Hastings 0.50 560.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/04/2015 Met w/D. Goldman re: case; coordinated pulling case materials from docket; reviewed complaint. 3.80 3,515.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/05/2015 T/cs S. Musallam re: Mixson; c/w E. Coddon; mtw S. Sparling re: Mixson deposition 2.00 2,240.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/06/2015 reviewed expert reports and previous deposition transcripts of Christopher Mixson (2.40). 2.40 840.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/06/2015 Review of Mixson deposition transcripts 5.00 5,600.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/06/2015 Met with Steven Sparling to discuss introductory broad overview of case. 0.10 55.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/06/2015 Reviewed background case materials; spoke w/S. Sivan re: case; emails w/D. Goldman re: same. 2.70 2,497.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/07/2015 Conference call w/ S. Sparling re new Heinz v. News Corp. (Dan Goldman) matter. Reviewed complaint from same for background education. 1.60 1,168.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/07/2015 Reviewed expert report; t/c w/K. Denk re: case; emails w/D. Goldman re: same. 4.00 3,700.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/08/2015 Read complaint and expert reports. 3.10 1,705.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/08/2015 Reviewed Mixson deposition transcript. 3.10 2,867.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/09/2015conferences with Kurt Denk, Steven Sparling and Shaked Sivan regarding various tasks (1.10); created binders of Mixson's previous testimony (3.20); conferred with TSG regarding preparation of L drive folders and organized same (2.70); created calendar for team (1.0). 8.00 2,800.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/09/2015Reviewed background materials for Heinz/News Corp (Dan Goldman) matter; meeting w/ S. Sparling, and calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan, re Mixson depo prep. 2.20 1,606.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/09/2015 Prepare for Mixson deposition 5.50 6,160.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/09/2015 Read Mixson's past depositions (7.0); met with Kurt Denk to discuss case (0.3); began going through hot documents (0.9). 8.20 4,510.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/09/2015Met w/D. Goldman and S. Sivan re: Mixson deposition; discussed same w/K. Denk; emailed w/team re: same; reviewed materials for same; prepared outline for same. 11.20 10,360.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/10/2015 Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re Heinz/News Corp (Dan Goldman) matter. 0.60 438.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/10/2015 Attend management conference call; prepare for Mixson deposition; review draft PH/KL addendum to joint representation agreement 6.30 7,056.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/10/2015 Going through hot documents in preparation for Mixson deposition. 12.20 6,710.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/10/2015 Drafted and revised Mixson deposition outline; reviewed background materials re: same; discussed issues re: same w/team. 11.30 10,452.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/11/2015 created calendar for team and reviewed documents on local drive for organizational purposes (1.40). 1.40 490.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/11/2015 Meeting w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re Heinz/News Corp (Dan Goldman) matter; reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ same re Mixson depo prep. 0.90 657.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/11/2015 Prepare for Mixson deposition 5.70 6,384.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/11/2015 Reading documents and preparing outline for Mixson deposition. 12.30 6,765.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/11/2015Discussed Mixson deposition outline and documents w/KD and SS; drafted and revised outline; reviewed underlying documents re: same; discussions w/SS re: same. 11.40 10,545.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/12/2015 load deposition exhibits and deposition transcripts off TSG share site 3.80 1,330.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/12/2015 Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re Mixson depo prep. 0.30 219.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/12/2015 Review of Bevalaqua deposition transcript; prepare for Mixson deposition; review of discovery related e‐mails; c/w E. Coddon 6.00 6,720.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/12/2015 Met with Steve Sparling to discuss outline (0.3); continued work on outline for Mixson deposition (10.7). 11.00 6,050.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/12/2015 Management call; discussed Mixson deposition w/team; reviewed materials for same; edited and revised outline for same. 6.30 5,827.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/13/2015 Assisted counsel with Mixson Deposition Preparation 17.00 5,950.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/13/2015Reviewed materials relevant to Mixson depo prep. Reviewed draft outline, exhibits, and supervised work of S. Sivan & S. Cipolla in preparation for Mixson depo. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling, S. Sivan, & S. Cipolla re same. 6.80 4,964.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/13/2015 Prepare for Mixson deposition 7.00 7,840.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/13/2015 Continued working on outline (12.9); met with Kurt Denk and Santo Cipolla to discuss production of deposition binder (0.4). 13.30 7,315.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/13/2015 Emailed w/team re: Mixson deposition; call w/S. Sivan re: same; reviewed and edited outline for same. 4.60 4,255.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/14/2015 Assisted counsel with finalizing documents for Christopher Mixson deposition 5.80 2,030.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/14/2015Reviewed materials relevant to Mixson depo prep, reviewed/revised draft outline and exhibits, and supervised work of S. Sivan & S. Cipolla relating to same. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling, S. Sivan, & S. Cipolla re same. 9.60 7,008.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/14/2015 Continued finalizing outline and binder in preparation for Mixson deposition. 13.70 7,535.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/14/2015 Emails w/team re: Mixson deposition; call w/K. Denk re: same; reviewed and edited outline re: same; emailed team re same. 2.80 2,590.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/15/2015 Finalized binder and highlighted passages for Mixson deposition. 4.80 2,640.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/15/2015 Emails w/team re: Mixson deposition 0.20 185.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/16/2015 Calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, S. Sivan, & S. Cipolla re Mixson depo prep. 0.30 219.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/16/2015 Mixson deposition prep 6.00 6,720.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/16/2015 Created riders for Mixson deposition in response to suggestions from Steve Sparling. 0.70 385.00




05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/16/2015 Emailed w/team re: Mixson deposition. 0.20 185.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/17/2015 Assisted with finalizing documents for Mixson deposition 15.00 5,250.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/17/2015 Meeting w/ D. Goldman & S. Sivan re Mixson depo. Calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same. 1.70 1,241.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/17/2015 Mixson deposition prep 12.00 13,440.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/17/2015 Met with Dan Goldman and Kurt Denk to discuss deposition (1.0); updated outline and binder in preparation for Mixson deposition (8.2). 9.20 5,060.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/17/2015 Emails w/team re: Mixson deposition. 0.20 185.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/18/2015Assisted counsel with preparation of documents for Mixson Deposition (.50); provided assistance during deposition of Christopher Mixson (2.0); reviewed and forwarded hard documents to records (2.70). 5.20 1,820.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/18/2015 Prepare for and take deposition of Mixson; draft e‐mail to defense team re: deposition 6.00 6,720.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/18/2015 Prepped for and second chaired Mixson Deposition. 6.00 3,300.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/18/2015Attended Mixson deposition; discussed same w/team; discussed next steps in case w/team; reviewed emails amongst co‐counsel; reviewed information re: Naze. 6.00 5,550.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/19/2015Call w/ management committee; e‐mail to J. Southwick re: Garafalo; revise joint representation agreement addendum and first amended joint representation agreement 2.00 2,240.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/19/2015 Began gathering and organizing documents for Naze deposition. 0.60 330.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/19/2015 Discussed Naze deposition w/SS; emailed w/team re: same. 0.40 370.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/20/2015 Mtw S. Sparling re: W. Naze deposition 1.00 1,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/20/2015 Began overview and organization of Naze documents in preparation for deposition. 0.40 220.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/20/2015 Emails w/SS re: Naze deposition. 0.20 185.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/21/2015 Organized more documents that were received from co‐counsel. 0.20 110.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/22/2015 Read prior testimony in preparation for Naze deposition. 3.80 2,090.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/23/2015 Conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding preparation of binder regarding deposition testimony of West Naze (.30); prepared binders for team (1.60). 1.90 665.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/23/2015 Review of Carlucci deposition transcripts 5.00 5,600.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/23/2015 Reading prior depositions (0.4); reading hot documents in preparation for Naze deposition (6.9). 6.90 3,795.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/23/2015 Emails w/DG re: case management and status; emails w/SS re: Naze deposition; reviewed Naze deposition testimony. 5.70 5,272.50 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/24/2015 Review of Carlucci deposition transcripts; attend management call 3.50 3,920.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/24/2015 Met with Steven Sparling to discuss preparation for Naze deposition (0.2); continued going through documents as part of preparation (0.8). 1.00 550.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/24/2015Management call; discussed Naze deposition w/SS; discussed matter status w/DG; emails w/defense counsel re: Naze deposition; reviewed emails from co‐counsel; reviewed Naze deposition transcripts; emails w/J. Blackman. 5.30 4,902.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/25/2015 Phone conference w/ S. Sparling re case status; correspondence re same. 0.30 219.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/25/2015 E‐mails to B. Taibleson re: hot doc second level review; c/w S. Sivan re: hot doc review 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/25/2015 Met with Steve Sparling (0.1) to discuss several documents and next steps; reviewed hot documents (0.2). 0.30 165.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/25/2015 Reviewed Naze prior testimony; discussed deposition prep issues w/KD; discussed Naze deposition w/SS. 5.50 5,087.50 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/26/2015 Reviewed background materials re: Naze deposition; discussed same w/team; emails w/News counsel re: deposition date for Naze. 4.50 4,162.50 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/27/2015 Finalized date for Naze deposition; emailed w/counsel re: same; reviewed deposition prep materials for Naze. 7.20 6,660.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/02/2015 created calendar of events for team (1.30); updated local drive with deposition transcripts and exhibits (.90). 2.20 770.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/02/2015 Reviewed documents and drafted outline for Naze deposition. 4.30 2,365.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/02/2015 Reviewed emails from co‐counsel; reviewed Naze deposition transcripts; reviewed Naze deposition materials. 6.30 5,827.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/03/2015conferred with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of binders regarding Christopher Mixson and Carlucci (.30); attended to same (2.90); reviewed copies of deposition transcripts from Dan Goldman (.40); forwarded same to files (.30); 3.90 1,365.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/03/2015 Case status team mtg w/ S. Sparling; correspondence and follow‐up items re same. 1.00 730.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/03/2015 Attend management committee conference call; prepare for Carlucci deposition 5.00 5,600.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/03/2015Met with Kurt Denk and Steve Sparling to organize plan for depositions and other case tasks (0.2); organized and reviewed documents for Naze outline (0.2). 0.40 220.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/03/2015Call w/DG re: deposition issues; emails w/team re: same; met w/KD and SS re: depositions and next steps in litigation; reviewed Naze deposition transcripts. 2.00 1,850.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/04/2015 Finalized deposition binders of Christopher Mixson and Paul Carlucci for Kurt Denk 0.10 35.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/04/2015update local drive (.30); and reviewed deposition transcripts and exhibits and forwarded same to records (.50); updated calendar with Notices of Depositions (.40). 1.20 420.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/04/2015 Review of Garafalo rough deposition transcript 2.00 2,240.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/04/2015Gathered documents in preparation for Carlucci deposition (0.1); arranged logistics for hosting Naze deposition (0.1); continued reviewing documents and drafting Naze deposition outline (2.8). 3.00 1,650.00




05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/04/2015 Reviewed Naze depositions; reviewed emails from counsel on discovery issues; discussed next steps w/associates. 4.80 4,440.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/05/2015 Review and respond to e‐mails re: deposition scheduling 0.50 560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/05/2015 Continued reviewing documents and drafting Naze deposition outline. 9.80 5,390.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/05/2015 Emails w/team re: PTO issues; prepared for Naze deposition and reviewed materials for same; reviewed emails from counsel re: discovery issues. 5.80 5,365.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/06/2015Case status team mtg w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan. Calls/emails w/ co‐counsel & S. Sivan re document review platform and workflows; follow‐up emails w/ KL team re same. Reviewed materials relevant to pending depositions. Drafted and circulated workflow schedule for KL team. 3.50 2,555.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/06/2015

Finished first draft of Naze outline (1.2); responded to emails about organizing PTO and deposition designation tasks (0.2); met with Steve Sparling and Kurt Denk to discuss same (0.7); discussed document review with Kurt Denk (0.3); discussed logistical problems related to document review with Kurt Denk and technical support (0.7). 3.10 1,705.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/06/2015 Reviewed deposition prep materials for Naze; met w/KD and SS re: PTO issues and deposition preparation; t/c w/DG re: same. 4.30 3,977.50 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/07/2015 Review of e‐mails re: scheduling 0.30 336.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/08/2015 Reviewed Naze deposition outline. 2.50 2,312.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/09/2015Reviewed TSG Shared site for copies of deposition transcripts and deposition exhibits (.70); attended to same (2.40); prepared exhibits and hot documents for Naze deposition (.60); conference with Shaked Sivan regarding ptx files and assistance with same (.40). 4.10 1,435.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/09/2015 Prepared for and attended KL team status meeting, and completed misc diligence follow‐up items re same. 1.20 876.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/09/2015Met with Steve Sparling to discuss and edit Naze deposition outline (1.0); met with Sparling, Dan Goldman, and Kurt Denk to discuss pre‐trial orders and case strategy (0.7); organized and reviewed documents in preparation for deposition (1.5); read Hansa deposition (0.5) 3.70 2,035.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/09/2015Met w/SS re: Naze deposition; team meeting re: PTO issues and next steps; reviewed deposition transcripts and materials for Naze deposition; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 8.20 7,585.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/10/2015 continued to work on deposition exhibits 2.60 910.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/10/2015 Reviewed/responded to team status update correspondence. 0.50 365.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/10/2015 Participate in management committee meeting; c/w team; review of discovery related e‐mails. 1.00 1,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/10/2015 Responded to emails and organized and reviewed documents in preparation for Naze deposition and pre‐trial orders and tasks. 1.50 825.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/10/2015Management call; discussed next steps w/DG; discussed deposition and PTO issues w/KD and SS; t/c to JB re: deposition issues; prepared for Naze deposition and reviewed deposition transcripts. 4.20 3,885.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/11/2015Calls/emails w/ co‐counsel & S. Sivan re document review platform and workflows; follow‐up emails w/ KL team re same. Reviewed circulated substantive materials relevant to depo prep. 1.80 1,314.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/11/2015 Review of draft letter re: use of third party depositions at trial; c/ws S. Sparling re: deposition designations 1.50 1,680.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/11/2015Responding to logistics‐related emails and organizing documents to review in response to pre‐trial orders and tasks (0.7); discussing same with Kurt Denk and James Smith (0.3). 1.00 550.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/11/2015Call w/co‐counsel re; deposition designation issues; discussed same w/associates; discussed Naze deposition issues w/SS; reviewed materials for Nazedeposition; reviewed deposition transcripts. 6.60 6,105.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/12/2015reviewed deposition transcripts and exhibits forwarded by Kellogg and incorporated same to shared file (3.20); conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding same (.20). 3.40 1,190.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/12/2015Calls/emails w/ co‐counsel & S. Sivan re document review platform and workflows; follow‐up emails w/ KL team re same. Reviewed materials relevant to pending depositions. 2.10 1,533.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/12/2015Review and revise letter to Judge Pauley re: NAM's request for extension of discovery cut‐off; e‐mails to J. Briody re: letter to Judge Pauley; c/ws S. Sparling 2.80 3,136.00


Reviewing CPG documents in preparation for Naze outline (2.1); editing Naze outline (1.3); meeting with Kurt Denk and Santo Cipolla to discuss logistics for deposition designations (0.2); call with associates at other counsel for Plaintiffs to discuss deposition designations (0.4); writing emails related to document review and deposition preparation (0.1). 4.10 2,255.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/12/2015 Reviewed deposition outline; discussed same w/SS; reviewed materials for Naze deposition and for PTO. 6.30 5,827.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/13/2015

Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of background binder (.30); attended to same (1.60); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding deposition designations to be handled by Kurt Denk and Shaved Sivan (.30); prepared folders for each (.80); reviewed and revised local drive of deposition designations (2.20). 5.20 1,820.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/13/2015Calls/emails w/ co‐counsel & S. Sivan re document review platform and workflows; follow‐up emails w/ KL team re same. Reviewed materials relevant to pending depositions. 2.50 1,825.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/13/2015 Review e‐mails re: letter to Judge Pauley re: request for extension of discovery cut‐off 0.50 560.00


Reviewed CPG documents for use in Naze outline (0.4); met with Kurt Denk to discuss document review, deposition designations, and other pre‐trial tasks (0.3); spoke with Kim Briggs, Ben Taibleson, and Kurt Denk about outstanding document review and document sharing issues (0.4); responded to specific research questions from Steve Sparling (0.5); began working on designations (0.4); edited Naze outline (5.2). 7.20 3,960.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/13/2015 Reviewed materials for Naze deposition and PTO issues. 5.80 5,365.00




17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/14/2015Calls/emails w/ co‐counsel & S. Sivan re document review platform and workflows; follow‐up emails w/ KL team re same. Reviewed materials relevant to pending depositions. 0.70 511.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/14/2015 Responded to research question relating to Naze deposition from Steve Sparling (0.2); worked on deposition designations (2.8). 3.00 1,650.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/14/2015 Reviewed Naze deposition outline; reviewed background materials re: Naze deposition and PTO issues. 4.20 3,885.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/15/2015 Calls/emails w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re case status and workflows. Reviewed materials relevant to pending depositions and depo designations. 5.70 4,161.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/15/2015 Review of NAM expert reports 5.00 5,600.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/15/2015 Discussed Naze outline with Steve Sparling (0.2); further edited outline and updated citations (1.3). 1.50 825.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/15/2015 T/c w/SS re: Naze deposition and PTO issues; t/c w/KD re: PTO issues. 0.60 555.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/16/2015 prepared binder of deposition preparation materials regarding West Naze for Steven Sparling. 7.30 2,555.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/16/2015Calls/emails w/ co‐counsel & S. Sivan re case workflows; follow‐up emails w/ KL team, and conference w/ S. Sivan, re same. Reviewed materials relevant to pending depositions. 2.20 1,606.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/16/2015 Review of NAM expert reports 3.00 3,360.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/16/2015Read and organized documents and responded to emails in preparation for Naze deposition (1.4); continued working on deposition designations (0.9); met with Kurt Denk and Harold Robinson to discuss deposition designations (0.5); participated in cross‐firm associate call (0.3). 3.10 1,705.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/16/2015 Reviewed Naze deposition outline and potential exhibits; discussed PTO issues w/associates. 8.00 7,400.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/17/2015 updated Kurt Denk's transcript binder (.40); reviewed Naze deposition exhibits (3.70). 4.10 1,435.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/17/2015Calls/emails w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re case workflows. Reviewed/responded to plaintiff litigation team emails. Completed misc diligence items pertaining to same. 0.90 657.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/17/2015 Call w/ R. Pfau and J. Mackie‐Mason experts; review of NAM expert reports; c/w S. Sinaiko re: Carlton deposition 2.50 2,800.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/17/2015 Review expert reports; conf. call with experts re: same; conf. DBG re: same 2.40 2,304.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/17/2015Met with Steve Sparling to discuss Naze outline (0.5); read Marty Garofalo deposition and responded to emails about the deposition (1.5); responded to emails about the expert reports (0.4); designated depositions (1.9); read and reviewed documents related to preparation for Naze deposition (1.3). 5.60 3,080.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/17/2015 Discussed depositions and PTO issues w/team; t/c re: expert reports; email to team re: same; prepared for Naze deposition. 10.20 9,435.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/18/2015 Prepared exhibits for Naze deposition 7.00 2,450.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/18/2015Calls/emails w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re case workflows. Reviewed/responded to plaintiff litigation team emails, and completed misc diligence items pertaining to same. Reviewed materials relevant to depo designations. 1.60 1,168.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/18/2015 Management committee call; mtw S. Sinaiko re: Carlton deposition; review e‐mails re: trade promotions 2.50 2,800.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/18/2015 Meet with S. Sparling and S. Sivan on review of case and important documents 1.00 550.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/18/2015 Review expert materials 1.30 1,248.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/18/2015Continued working on deposition designations (1.7); sat in on cross‐plaintiffs call with Steve Sparling and Dan Goldman (0.7); read and reviewed documents in connection with preparation for Naze deposition (4.5); edited outline for Naze deposition (3.7). 10.60 5,830.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/18/2015 Management call; discussed deposition and PTO issues w/associates; discussed deposition and trial themes w/DG; prepared for Naze deposition 8.30 7,677.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/19/2015Prepared binder of deposition transcripts per Shaked Sivan's instructions (.60); reviewed revised Naze outline and reviewed deposition exhibits to same (2.60). 3.00 1,050.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/19/2015Conference w/ S. Sivan & H. Robinson re depo designation workflows. Reviewed/responded to plaintiff litigation team emails, and completed misc diligence items pertaining to same. Calls/emails w/ S. Sparling re case workflows. Reviewed materials relevant to depo designations. 2.10 1,533.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/19/2015 Review e‐mails from team re: trade promotions; retailers and Valassis; review Pfau memos 1.00 1,120.00

18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/19/2015Meet with K. Denk on review of the case and other important issues (1); Review the complaint and other case documents in anticipation of deposition designations (1) 2.00 1,100.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/19/2015 Review expert reports 2.90 2,784.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/19/2015Continued working on deposition designations (5.1); met with Kurt Denk to discuss designations and other potential issues in preparation for trial (0.7); read and reviewed documents in preparation for Naze deposition (0.2); responded to questions and updated Naze deposition outline (1.5); 7.50 4,125.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/19/2015 Discussed deposition and PTO issues w/associates; prepared for Naze deposition; reviewed emails from co‐counsel re: discovery issues 6.80 6,290.00


Conference with Steven Sparling and Shaked Sivan regarding binder of West Naze documents (.30); reviewed TSG repository for Hansa exhibits (.20); updated files for same (.20); Conference with Kurt Denk and Shaked Sivan regarding preparation of folders on local drive for Harold Robinson, Shaked Sivan and Kurt Denk's designations (.40); attended to same (.90); attended to Affirmative designations per Shaked Sivan's instructions (.50); prepared for Naze deposition (2.60).` 5.10 1,785.00




17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/20/2015Reviewed prior deposition transcripts and marked designations; reviewed/responded to KL team emails re same; reviewed junior associate work product. Reviewed/responded to plaintiff litigation team emails. Completed misc diligence items pertaining to same. 5.20 3,796.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/20/2015 C/w S. Sparling re: Naze deposition 1.00 1,120.00

18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/20/2015Review completed deposition designations and other background material in anticipation of deposition designations (2.0); Review depositions for any relevant deposition designations and summarize initial findings for review (5) 7.00 3,850.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/20/2015 Review expert materials; e‐mail AG re: same 0.80 768.00


Met with Steve Sparling to discuss Naze outline (0.5); spoke with Sparling and Dan Goldman on phone about Naze deposition (0.3); received training in the Viewpoint document review platform (0.6); continued reviewing documents and editing outline in preparation for Naze deposition (1.6); continued working on deposition designations (1.8). 4.80 2,640.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/20/2015Discussed Naze deposition w/SS and SC; discussed same w/SS and DG; emailed w/co‐counsel re: defendants' privilege log; prepared for Naze deposition; discussed deposition designations w/KD. 6.50 6,012.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/21/2015 Reviewed prior deposition transcripts and marked designations; supervised junior associate work product (S. Sivan & H. Robinson) pertaining to same. 7.60 5,548.00

18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/21/2015Review and incorporate K. Denk edits on initial deposition designations (1.5); Review depositions for any relevant deposition designations and summarize initial findings for review (2.5) 4.00 2,200.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/21/2015 Responded to questions related to Naze deposition outline (0.4); continued working on deposition designations (3.7). 4.10 2,255.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/21/2015 Revised Naze deposition outline; prepared from same deposition; emailed w/associates re: deposition designations. 8.50 7,862.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/22/2015 Attended to preparing deposition designations 7.00 2,450.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/22/2015 Reviewed prior deposition transcripts and marked designations; reviewed/responded to KL team emails re same. 6.80 4,964.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/22/2015 Review depositions for any relevant deposition designations(3) 3.00 1,650.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/22/2015 Review expert reports 3.00 2,880.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/22/2015Researched and drafted emails in response to questions related to preparation for Naze deposition (3.0); continued working on deposition designations (4.2). 7.20 3,960.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/22/2015 Prepared for Naze deposition; emailed w/team re: PTO issues. 7.80 7,215.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/23/2015 Assisted counsel with preparation of Naze deposition exhibits 6.00 2,100.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/23/2015Reviewed case material background. Reviewed prior deposition transcripts and marked designations; reviewed/responded to KL team emails re same. Conferences/calls with S. Musallam, plaintiff firms' weekly associates call, S. Sparling / Pfau expert and follow‐up tasks pertaining to same 8.10 5,913.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 03/23/2015 Read MacKie‐Mason and Carlton expert reports and met with S. Sinaiko to discuss the matter. 9.00 7,290.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/23/2015 Review depositions for any relevant deposition designations 3.00 1,650.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/23/2015 Review expert reports; conf. AG re: deposition prep 4.80 4,608.00


Responded to research questions in emails from Steve Sparling in preparation for Naze deposition (0.4); met with Santo Cipolla to discuss logistics for deposition (0.3); spoke with Kurt Denk to discuss deposition designations (0.3); read and reviewed documents in preparation for Naze deposition (3.2); continued designating past depositions (5.7). 8.90 4,895.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/23/2015 Prepared for Naze deposition; email and discussions w/team re: PTO and deposition issues; call w/co‐counsel re: deposition and expert witness issues 10.30 9,527.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/24/2015 Assisted counsel with final preparation of Naze deposition exhibits (5.50). 5.50 1,925.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/24/2015Team call and follow‐up tasks re pretrial schedule and diligence items. Completed misc. admin tasks. Continued review and marking of deposition transcripts for designation at trial. 7.30 5,329.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 03/24/2015Read portion of Kevin Murphy's expert report, read Dhar expert report, and gathered and began reviewing articles written by Carlton in preparation for his deposition. 8.30 6,723.00

18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/24/2015 Review depositions for any relevant deposition designations 7.00 3,850.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/24/2015 Review expert materials & conf. SSS re: status, planning; e‐mail DBG re: same 2.50 2,400.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/24/2015Continued deposition designations (1.9); met with Santo Cipolla to discuss logistical issues for Naze deposition (0.2); finalized outline and preparation for Naze deposition (4.1); discussed Carlton report and deposition with Stephen Sinaiko (0.3). 6.50 3,575.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/24/2015Management call; discussed PTO issues w/associates; discussed deposition schedule and case w/S. Sinaiko; discussed Naze deposition w/team; prepared for Naze deposition; emailed w/co‐counsel re: exhibits for same. 12.30 11,377.50


Assisted counsel with final preparations for Naze deposition (.50); conference with Steven Sparling and Shaked Sivan regarding Naze deposition (.30); reviewed unused deposition exhibits in Naze deposition (.60); conference with Alissa Goodman regarding Dennis Carlton published works (.30); reviewed list of published works and compared same to list provided by Carlton (2.0); follow‐up conference with Alissa Goodman (.20) 3.90 1,365.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/25/2015 KL team calls/correspondence re pretrial schedule and diligence items; completed misc admin tasks pertaining thereto. 0.60 438.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 03/25/2015 Coordinated gathering of expert background materials, spoke to S. Sinaiko, reviewed articles written by Carlton. 6.50 5,265.00




18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/25/2015 Review depositions for any relevant deposition designations 5.00 2,750.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/25/2015 P/m & t/c Pfau re: expert issues & prep; t/cs AG re: prep & status; review materials 2.00 1,920.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/25/2015 Second chaired West Naze deposition (5.10); edited summary of deposition after reading through transcript (1.0). 6.10 3,355.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/25/2015Prepared for Naze deposition; deposed Naze; email to team re: same; discussed PTO issues w/team and upcoming depositions; reviewed Naze transcript. 7.20 6,660.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/26/2015 continued creating deposition designations` 7.00 2,450.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/26/2015 Conference call w/ experts and client rep. M. Findlan re fact issues relevant to expert reports. 0.40 292.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/26/2015 T/c J. Southwick 0.50 560.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 03/26/2015 Reviewed email re collection of materials for Carlton deposition. 0.20 162.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/26/2015 Review depositions for any relevant deposition designations 1.00 550.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/26/2015 Conf. SSS re: status, strategy; review materials re: expert issues; t/c SS re: Carlton prep 3.40 3,264.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/26/2015Responded to emails from Dan Goldman and Steve Sparling (0.4); met with Steve Sparling to discuss preparation for upcoming depositions (0.2); read and reviewed potentially relevant documents (0.3); read Carlton expert report and related memo (1.2). 2.10 1,155.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/26/2015Met w/Stephen Sinaiko re: depositions and next steps; discussed deposition prep issues w/S. Sivan; drafted summary of Naze deposition for co‐counsel; reviewed emails from co‐counsel re: case developments; conference call w/experts. 2.40 2,220.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/27/2015 attended to deposition designations 3.40 1,190.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 03/27/2015 Reviewed and sent email re collection of materials for Carlton deposition. 0.20 162.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/27/2015 Review materials re: expert issues; conf. SS re: prep; t/c Pfau, SS re: same 3.50 3,360.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/27/2015Met with Stephen Sinaiko to discuss Carlton deposition and speak to Pfau (1.6); found and emailed relevant documents and deposition summaries to Sinaiko (0.4). 2.00 1,100.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/27/2015 Call w/K. Denk re: next steps in case. 0.10 92.50 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 03/28/2015 Emailed with S. Sinaiko re collection of materials for Carlton deposition preparation. 0.10 81.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/29/2015 Reviewed Carlton expert report again to consider questions for Pfau. 0.60 330.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/30/2015 worked on Affirmative designations charts 4.70 1,645.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/30/2015

Reviewed relevant hot docs circulated by co‐counsel. Prepared for and participated in weekly associate team conference call re case status, and completed misc diligence items re same. Supervised work of junior associates S. Sivan & H. Robinson, and paralegal S. Cipolla, relating to pending tasks and workflows. 2.40 1,752.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/30/2015 T.c J. Southwick; L. Leclair and S. Benz; review of e‐mail from R. Caughey to R. Pfau 0.50 560.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 03/30/2015 Review depositions for any relevant deposition designations 2.00 1,100.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/30/2015 Conf. DBG re: strategy for Carlton deposition; review expert materials & deposition prep 3.80 3,648.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 03/30/2015Discussed organizing deposition designations with Santo Cipolla (0.1); responded to questions from Steve Sparling (0.1); spoke with Kurt Denk and co‐counsel about continuing tasks in preparation for trial (0.2). 0.40 220.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/30/2015 Reviewed correspondence; discussed projects w/associates; reviewed deposition materials and transcripts. 7.80 7,215.00

07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 03/31/2015Analyze, extract, format, quality control review and upload of electronically stored information into ViewPoint, the firm’s electronic discovery review platform. 1.00 300.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/31/2015conferred with Alissa Goodman regarding Dennis Carlton working papers (.40); reviewed and de‐duped same (1.60); continued to work on affirmative designations (5.0). 7.00 2,450.00


Reviewed correspondence circulated by co‐counsel re hot docs and agenda items. Prepared for and participated in weekly management team conference call and completed misc diligence items re same. Emails/call w/ K. Briggs re Casemap functionality for ongoing doc review and fact development. Reviewed key fact docs in preparation for pending deposition outline development. 3.10 2,263.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/31/2015 Participate in management committee call; c/w S. Sparling and K. Denk 1.00 1,120.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 03/31/2015 Reviewed documents in preparation for Carlton deposition, spoke to S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan, coordinated collection of materials with library. 8.40 6,804.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 03/31/2015 T/c AG & e‐mails SS re: status; review expert materials & Carlton prep 4.70 4,512.00


Installed and began working with CaseMap (0.4); spoke with Kurt Denk and received detail from Kim Briggs about using CaseMap (0.8); received new documents and dealt with logistics in preparation for Kelly deposition and other pre‐trial tasks (0.5); began reviewing documents and past depositions in preparation for Carlton deposition (1.4); spoke with Alissa Goodman and Stephen Sinaiko about plan and preparation for calrton deposition (0.4). 3.30 1,815.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/31/2015 Management call; discussed projects w/team; reviewed expert report; reviewed fact background materials; reviewed correspondence. 7.50 6,937.50

07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 04/01/2015Analyze, extract, format, quality control review and upload of electronically stored information into ViewPoint, the firm’s electronic discovery review platform. 0.50 150.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/01/2015 continued to review Affirmative designations 7.00 2,450.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/01/2015 Review discovery related e‐mails including e‐mails re: interrogatories 0.50 560.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/01/2015 Reviewed articles in preparation for Carlton deposition. 7.00 5,670.00




00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/01/2015 Conf. AG, SS re: Carlton prep 0.40 384.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/01/2015 Prepared for Kelly and Carlton depositions; gathered documents for interrogatories. 1.90 1,045.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/01/2015 Reviewed expert report; discussed projects w/team; reviewed correspondence. 2.60 2,405.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/02/2015 Reviewed affirmative designations 7.00 2,450.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/02/2015 Call with ApplEcon re: rebuttal expert report on damages and merits; c/w S. Sinaiko re: Carlton deposition 1.50 1,680.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/02/2015 Reviewed articles in preparation for Carlton deposition, listened to conference call re rebuttal reports, typed notes re conference call 7.50 6,075.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/02/2015 Review background materials; conference call with plaintiffs counsel, Mackie‐Mason and Pfau re: expert issues 1.40 1,344.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/02/2015 Reviewed correspondence; discussed developments w/team. 0.20 185.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/03/2015 Reviewed Affirmative designations (2.0); conferred with Dana Holton regarding databases (.40). 2.40 840.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/03/2015 Call w/expert and co‐counsel. 0.40 370.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/06/2015Prepared for and participated in weekly co‐counsel associates team conference call and completed misc diligence items re same. Emails w/ S. Sivan re case status and ongoing doc review. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re case status and pending tasks. 1.00 730.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/06/2015 Review expert rebuttal outline; review discovery related e‐mails 1.00 1,120.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/06/2015 Reviewed articles in preparation for Carlton deposition. 8.20 6,642.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/06/2015 Review background materials 1.50 1,440.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/06/2015 Reviewed documents in preparation for Kelly deposition; participated in team case management call. 4.70 2,585.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/07/2015Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re case status and pending tasks. Reviewed co‐counsel memos on fact development and strategy. Reviewed documents in preparation for J. Kelly deposition. Calls/emails w/ S. Sivan re same. 3.90 2,847.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/07/2015 Attend management committee call 2.00 2,240.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/07/2015 Reviewed Carlton background materials and articles in preparation for his deposition. 4.20 3,402.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/07/2015 Prep for Carlton deposition 4.70 4,512.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/07/2015 Preparation for Kelly deposition; privilege log review. 1.80 990.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/08/2015 prepared binder of documents to be used during John Kelly's deposition 3.50 1,225.00


Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re case status and pending tasks. Reviewed co‐counsel memos on fact development and strategy. Reviewed documents in preparation for J. Kelly deposition. Calls/emails w/ S. Sivan re same. Participated in plaintiffs counsel team call re NAM interrogatories / RFAs. 4.70 3,431.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/08/2015 Call re: interrogatories and requests for admission; c/w K. Denk and S. Sivan 1.00 1,120.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/08/2015 Reviewed background materials and Carlton's articles and spoke to S. Sinaiko about case background. 5.10 4,131.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 04/08/2015 Assist with preparation of deposition designations 1.50 825.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/08/2015 Prep for Carlton deposition 4.30 4,128.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/08/2015 Tasks related to preparing for Kelly deposition, Carlton deposition, and responding to requests for admission. 5.00 2,750.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/09/2015 revised binders of John Kelly potential exhibits for Kurt Denk 3.50 1,225.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/09/2015Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re case status and pending tasks. Reviewed S. Sivan work product re permissible scope of interrogatories / RFAs, conducted follow‐up legal research, and forwarded summary memo to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 2.50 1,825.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/09/2015 Review of research re: RFAs; review of e‐mails re: discovery 1.00 1,120.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/09/2015 Reviewed articles for Carlton deposition preparation and participated in call with S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan re same. ` 1.70 1,377.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/09/2015 Prep for Carlton deposition; e‐mail & t/c AG, SS re: same 5.80 5,568.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/09/2015 Tasks related to preparing for Carlton deposition and reviewing privilege log. 6.40 3,520.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/10/2015Prepared binders of Christopher Mixson and West Naze deposition exhibits; conferred with Steven Sparling regarding obtaining copies of documents forwarded by Kellogg; updated defense witness binder for Kurt Denk 7.00 2,450.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/10/2015Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re case status and pending tasks. Reviewed documents in preparation for J. Kelly deposition, and drafted/updated outline for same. Reviewed NAM privilege log and circulated summary memo re same. 4.50 3,285.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/10/2015 Email with S. Sivan re Carlton deposition preparation. 0.10 81.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/10/2015 Prep for Carlton deposition; conf. DG re: strategy; p/m & e‐mails Briody re: expert invoices; t/c SS re: prep issues 5.00 4,800.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/10/2015 Document review and preparation for Carlton deposition. 5.50 3,025.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/10/2015 Reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; emailed w/KD re: Kelly deposition and privilege log issues; reviewed factual materials from co‐counsel. 6.50 6,012.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/11/2015Reviewed documents in preparation for, and drafted/updated outline for, J. Kelly deposition; email correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Reviewed/responded to KL team emails re case status and diligence items. 8.10 5,913.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/11/2015 Review draft MacKie‐Mason rebuttal report; prep for Carlton deposition 3.70 3,552.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/11/2015 Preparation for Kelly and Carlton depositions, including summarizing depositions for Kurt Denk and reading a draft expert rebuttal report. 2.50 1,375.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/12/2015Reviewed documents in preparation for, and drafted/updated outline for, J. Kelly deposition; telephone conference and email correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. 6.10 4,453.00




00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/12/2015 Prep for Carlton deposition 9.00 8,640.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/12/2015 Prep for Kelly and Carlton depositions, including a call with Kurt Denk, reviewing documents related to Kelly, and reading past testimony of Carlton. 4.20 2,310.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/12/2015 Reviewed and commented on draft expert rebuttal report (1.3); emailed w/team re: privilege log issues (.2). 1.50 1,387.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/13/2015 Assisted counsel with preparation for John Kelly deposition (5.0); prepared binder of documents for Steve Sinaiko's review (.80); 5.80 2,030.00


Reviewed documents in preparation for, and drafted/updated outline for, J. Kelly deposition; conferences and email correspondence w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same; prepared for and participated in plaintiffs counsel associates team weekly call; supervised paralegal S. Cipolla in preparation of materials for Kelly depo. 14.30 10,439.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/13/2015 Review draft merits rebuttal report 1.00 1,120.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/13/2015Reviewed and summarized articles in preparation for Carlton deposition, reviewed S. Sinaiko's executive summary of Carlton's report, and met with S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan re Carlton deposition preparation. 8.10 6,561.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/13/2015Review draft MacKie‐Mason rebuttal report; t/c DBG re: same; e‐mail DSG, SSS, KMD, SS re: comments on draft rebuttal report; prep for Carlton deposition; conf. AG, SS re: prep, logistics; p/m Pfau re: Carlton prep 3.20 3,072.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/13/2015 Preparation for Kelly and Carlton depositions, including document review and discussions with Stephen Sinaiko and Kurt Denk. 6.90 3,795.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/13/2015 Reviewed correspondence; discussed privilege log review issues and Kelly deposition w/KD; reviewed expert reports and factual background materials. 3.70 3,422.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/14/2015 Prepared binder of Carlton documents for Alissa Goodman (.90); assisted counsel with preparation of John Kelly deposition documents ; (12.80). 13.70 4,795.00


Reviewed documents in preparation for, and drafted/updated outline for, J. Kelly deposition; conferences and email correspondence w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same; prepared for and participated in plaintiffs counsel management team weekly call; supervised paralegal S. Cipolla in preparation of materials for Kelly depo. 11.20 8,176.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/14/2015 Management committee call 1.00 1,120.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/14/2015Reviewed and summarized articles for Carlton deposition preparation and prepared binder of relevant articles, created list of topics for Carlton deposition, met with S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan re Carlton deposition preparation, and reviewed draft rebuttal report. 8.00 6,480.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/14/2015Review Carlton materials; call with plaintiffs' management group; conf. AG, SS re: Carlton prep & status; review draft MacKie‐Mason rebuttal report; e‐mails DBG, SSS, KD, SS re: same; e‐mail Pfau re: comments on rebuttal report 3.90 3,744.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/14/2015 Preparation for Kelly and Carlton depositions. 6.40 3,520.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/14/2015Reviewed correspondence; management call; discussed Kelly deposition w/KD; reviewed draft expert report; reviewed factual background documents re: discovery, deposition, and trial prep. 4.30 3,977.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/15/2015 set up conference room in preparation of John Kelly deposition (.40); reviewed documents and forwarded same to records after deposition (.10). 0.50 175.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/15/2015Prepared for and conducted J. Kelly deposition; completed misc. follow‐up tasks pertaining to same. Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. 7.10 5,183.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/15/2015Reviewed additional Carlton articles and updated bullet point list of relevant articles, spoke to S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan about deposition preparation, began outlining deposition outline for Carlton deposition. 8.80 7,128.00

18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 04/15/2015 Assist with preparation of deposition designations 2.00 1,100.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/15/2015Carlton prep; conf. AG re: same; t/cs AG, SS re: same; plaintiff group call re: rebuttal expert reports; t/c Pfau re: issues for Carlton; conf. SS re: Carltondeposition outline 6.70 6,432.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/15/2015 Kelly deposition; preparation for Carlton deposition. 11.10 6,105.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/15/2015 Attended Kelly deposition; discussed case tasks and projects w/associates. 7.00 6,475.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/16/2015 updated litigation binder (.20); prepared binders of deposition exhibits of Chris Mixson and West Naze (1.80); 2.00 700.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/16/2015Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Reviewed transcript from J. Kelly deposition and drafted summary memo re same, circulated to team. 3.60 2,628.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/16/2015 Reviewed Carlton articles and drafted Carlton deposition outline. 3.40 2,754.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/16/2015 T/c SS re: Carlton prep; e‐mail AG re: same; review revised draft MacKie‐Mason rebuttal report 2.00 1,920.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/16/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition; document review. 2.60 1,430.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/16/2015 Reviewed Kelly recap email; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; discussed next steps w/team; reviewed factual background materials. 2.20 2,035.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/17/2015Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Reviewed background materials in preparation for P. Carlucci deposition outline drafting. Conducted legal research on privilege log issues. 6.60 4,818.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/17/2015 Spoke to S. Sinaiko re Carlton deposition preparation. 0.10 81.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 04/17/2015 Assist with preparation of deposition designations 2.00 1,100.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/17/2015 Review revised MacKie‐Mason draft; e‐mail Pfau re: same; review prep materials for Carlton deposition 3.20 3,072.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/17/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition. 1.00 550.00




05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/17/2015 Correspondence w/co‐counsel; discussed case w/team; reviewed background factual material re: upcoming depositions. 3.20 2,960.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/18/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition. 0.90 495.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/19/2015 Email with S. Sivan re Carlton deposition preparation and reviewed articles for Carlton deposition. 0.60 486.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/19/2015 Review prep materials for Carlton deposition 1.10 1,056.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/19/2015 Discussed issues relating to privilege log review. 0.30 165.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/19/2015 Reviewed email correspondence from co‐counsel; emailed w/team re: same. 0.10 92.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/20/2015created binder of Rebuttal reports for Kurt Denk (.60); reviewed documents from privilege log per Shaked's instructions (1.10); created binder of Carlucci's prior testimony (1.80); updated computer drive with John Kelly deposition exhibits (.20). 3.70 1,295.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Conducted legal research on privilege log issues and sent summary memo re same to co‐counsel. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates team call. Reviewed background materials in preparation for P. Carlucci deposition outline drafting. Emails/calls with KL team re case status and diligence items. 5.30 3,869.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/20/2015 Worked on outline for Carlton deposition and met with S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan re same. 5.50 4,455.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/20/2015 Prep for Carlton deposition; t/cs SS, AG re: same 7.90 7,584.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/20/2015 Tasks related to document review and preparation for the Carlton deposition. 7.10 3,905.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/20/2015 Discussed discovery issues w/team; emailed w/co‐counsel re: same; reviewed background materials re: upcoming depositions. 6.80 6,290.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/21/2015 Reviewed privilege logs for entries of various members of Heinz personnel. 3.00 1,050.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Prepared for/participated in weekly team management call. Completed misc diligence items re privilege log issues and conducted further review of privilege log. Reviewed discovery files re interrogatories and requests for admission and drafted responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA. Emails/calls with KL team re case status and diligence items. 8.30 6,059.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/21/2015 Drafted outline for Carlton deposition and met with S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan re same. 6.50 5,265.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 04/21/2015 Assist with deposition designations 3.00 1,650.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/21/2015Participate in plaintiff group call; e‐mail Briody re: invoices; prep for Carlton deposition; conf. SS, AG re: Carlton prep; t/c Pfau, SS, AG re: same; e‐mails SSS, SS re: Carlton deposition notice; revisions to same 9.90 9,504.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/21/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition; document review related to interrogatories and privilege log issues. 12.10 6,655.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/21/2015 Management call; discussed discovery issues w/team; emailed w/co‐counsel re: discovery issues; reviewed final expert report. 5.30 4,902.50


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Completed misc diligence items re privilege log issues and conducted further review of privilege log. Drafed/sent notices re Valassis subpoena. Conference w/ S. Sparling re draft responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA. Emails/calls with KL team re case status and diligence items. 6.20 4,526.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/22/2015Reviewed R. Pfau's comments re Carlton preparation, reviewed S. Sinaiko's deposition outline, met with S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan re Carlton deposition, drafted Carlton deposition outline. 8.10 6,561.00

18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 04/22/2015 Assist with preparation of deposition designations 1.50 825.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/22/2015 Prep for Carlton deposition; e‐mails & t/c Pfau re: issues and strategy; t/cs Benz re: strategy; conf. AG, SS re: prep, strategy 8.30 7,968.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/22/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition; document review. 7.40 4,070.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/22/2015Reviewed and commented on draft RFAs; met w/KD re: same; emailed w/co‐counsel re: various discovery issues; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition. 4.30 3,977.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/23/2015 page checked proposed deposition exhibits for Dennis Carlton deposition 4.60 1,610.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Completed misc diligence items re privilege log issues. Revised/circulated draft responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA. Correspondence w/ client re same. Emails/calls with KL team re case status and diligence items. 5.10 3,723.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/23/2015 Edited Carlton deposition outline, met with S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan re Carlton deposition outline. 9.20 7,452.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/23/2015 Conf. AG, SS re: Carlton prep; revisions to Carlton outline 5.40 5,184.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/23/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition; document review in response to interrogatories; document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 14.00 7,700.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/23/2015Discussed discovery issues w/KD; emails w/SS and KD re: same; discussed expert depo w/SS; emailed w/co‐counsel re: discovery issues; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition; reviewed draft discovery responses and commented on same. 4.30 3,977.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/24/2015 Reviewed Dennis Carlton deposition exhibits and prepared to have same shipped to hotel for upcoming deposition (4.40)/ 4.40 1,540.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Completed misc diligence items re draft responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA; correspondence w/ client and KL team re same. Reviewed background materials in preparation for P. Carlucci deposition outline drafting. 5.40 3,942.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/24/2015 Reviewed Carlton's articles in preparation for his deposition. 1.20 972.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 04/24/2015 Assist with deposition designations 1.00 550.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/24/2015 Review materials for Carlton deposition; revisions to outline; confs. SS & t/cs AG re: prep & strategy 6.80 6,528.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/24/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition; review of documents and other depositions in Heinz case. 5.40 2,970.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/24/2015 Reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition. 6.50 6,012.50 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/25/2015 Drafted list of Carlton's prior testimony and spoke to S. Sinaiko re outline for Carlton deposition and edited Carlton deposition outline. 3.50 2,835.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/25/2015 Review prep materials; revisions to Carlton outline; confs. SS & t/cs AG re: strategy, prep 8.10 7,776.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/25/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition. 6.70 3,685.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/26/2015 Spoke to S. Sinaiko and S. Sivan about Carlton deposition outline and edited outline. 6.10 4,941.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/26/2015 Review materials & prep for Carlton deposition; confs. SS & t/cs AG re: strategy & issues 9.50 9,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/26/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition. 8.20 4,510.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/26/2015 Reviewed materials re: Carlucci deposition; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 4.20 3,885.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/27/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts and exhibits for references to Paul Carlucci per Kurt Denk's instructions 4.00 1,400.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Prepared for and participated in co‐counsel associate team call. Completed misc diligence items re draft responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA; phone conference w/ S. Sparling & client officer M. Findlay re same; correspondence w/ client and KL team re same. Prepared materials for P. Carlucci deposition. 5.60 4,088.00

06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/27/2015 Reviewed articles for Carlton deposition and edited deposition outline and reviewed edited outline. 1.80 1,458.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 04/27/2015 Assist with deposition designations 1.00 550.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/27/2015 Travel to Chicago (4.9); confs. Pfau, SS re: prep & strategy; revise & update deposition materials (9.9) 14.80 14,208.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/27/2015 Travel for Carlton deposition. 4.00 2,200.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/27/2015 Preparation for Carlton deposition. 13.00 7,150.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/27/2015Worked on discovery responses; discussed open issues w/associates; emails w/DG re: status of issues; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition; reviewed co‐counsel correspondence; reviewed letter re: discovery issues from KG; emailed w/group re: same. 8.10 7,492.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/28/2015Reviewed files for copies of documents (requests for admissions and Interrogatories & Responses) and forwarded same to Kurt Denk (.30); reviewed deposition transcripts and exhibits forwarded by TSG Reporting (.40). 0.70 245.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/28/2015Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Completed misc diligence items re draft responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA; correspondence w/ co‐counsel and KL team re same. 1.70 1,241.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/28/2015 Attend management meeting call; t/cs S. Musallam re: Dole; c/w S. Sparling re: status 2.00 2,240.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/28/2015 Prepared for and listened to Carlton deposition and reviewed and summarized invoices for Carlton deposition. 8.70 7,047.00 18128 Robinson, Harold Associate 04/28/2015 Assist with deposition designations 1.00 550.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/28/2015 Confs. SS, Pfau re: prep; conduct Carlton deposition; t/cs Benz, AG re: same; e‐mail DBG, SSS re: same (9.1); travel to New York (5.0) 14.10 13,536.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/28/2015 Carlton deposition, preparation and cleanup. 10.00 5,500.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/28/2015Discussed case status w/DG and next steps; management call; discussed projects w/KD; drafted letter to JO re: discovery issues; emailed w/KG re: discovery issues; emailed w/co‐counsel re: discovery issues; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition. 6.60 6,105.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/29/2015Updated Binder of deposition transcripts for Kurt Denk (.40); reviewed deposition exhibits from Carlton deposition (.30); organized documents on local drive for consistency purposes per Kurt Denk's instructions (.70). 1.40 490.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Completed misc diligence items re draft responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA; correspondence w/ client, co‐counsel, and KL team re same. Telephone conference w/ counsel from Catalina (C. Tramontano, Holland & Knight) re subpoena issues; corresponded with co‐counsel re same. 5.90 4,307.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/29/2015 Review letter to court on document issue; e‐mails re: same; read beginning of Berg deposition 1.50 1,680.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/29/2015 Review Carlton rough 2.60 2,496.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/29/2015 Responding to emails related to document review for interrogatory responses. 0.70 385.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/29/2015 Travel back from Carlton deposition. 4.00 2,200.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/29/2015Correspondence w/co‐counsel re: discovery issues; discussed projects w/team; discussed Carlton deposition w/SS; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition. 5.30 4,902.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/30/2015 updated files with deposition transcripts and deposition exhibits 1.10 385.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Completed misc diligence items re draft responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA; correspondence w/ client, co‐counsel, and KL team re same. Plaintiffs counsel team conference call re court letter addressing NAM document production errors; finalized and filed letter re same. 5.90 4,307.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/30/2015 Review revised draft letter to Judge Pauley; review e‐mails re: discovery issues; management call 1.00 1,120.00 06154 Goodman, Alissa R. Associate 04/30/2015 Read email from S. Sinaiko re Carlton deposition. 0.10 81.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 04/30/2015 T/c SS & e‐mail plaintiff group re: Carlton deposition; conf. DBG re: status 1.50 1,440.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 04/30/2015 Document review in response to interrogatory requests. 4.30 2,365.00




05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 04/30/2015Emails and calls w/co‐counsel re: discovery letter; coordinated finalization and filing of same; discussed discovery issues w/team; correspondence re: discovery issues w/co‐counsel; reviewed Carlucci testimony. 7.80 7,215.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/01/2015 updated database of deposition transcripts and exhibits. 0.40 140.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/01/2015Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Completed misc diligence items re draft responses/objections to defendants' 3rd Interrogatory and 1st RFA; correspondence w/ client, co‐counsel, and KL team re same. 2.10 1,533.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/01/2015 Review of discovery e‐mails 0.50 560.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/01/2015 Correspondence w/co‐counsel re: discovery issues; discussed discovery issues w/team; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition 5.60 5,180.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/03/2015 Reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 0.20 185.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/04/2015 Updated database of transcripts (.50); updated records (.50). 1.00 350.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/04/2015Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status and diligence items. Prepared for and participated in weekly co‐counsel associates call. Reviewed deposition transcripts. 4.60 3,358.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/04/2015 Review of privilege log and related issues. 2.00 1,100.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/04/2015 Emailed w/team re: discovery issues; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel; discussed case issue w/SS; reviewed Carlucci deposition materials 5.10 4,717.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/05/2015 Updated binder for Kurt Denk 0.90 315.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status, diligence items, and status of discovery dispute; conference w/ D. Goldman and S. Sparling re same. Prepared for and participated in weekly management call. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan & DTI re ediscovery hosting platform. 2.50 1,825.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/05/2015 Attend management committee call; c/ws S. Sparling re: 30b6 re: document production issues 1.50 1,680.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/05/2015 Reviewed documents; analyzed letter related to document production issues and discovery dispute. 1.90 1,045.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/05/2015Discussed projects and issues w/KD and DG; management call; reviewed court filing by News on discovery issue; emailed w/team re: same; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition. 4.10 3,792.50


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status, diligence items, and status of discovery dispute; conference w/ S. Sparling re same. Prepared for and participated in meet/confer call w/ S. Sparling & adversary re document production dispute. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan & DTI re ediscovery hosting platform. Finalized and served plaintiffs' responses/objections to defendants' 1st & 2nd requests for admission; misc admin tasks and calls/emails w/ co‐counsel re same. 4.60 3,358.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/06/2015 Review discovery related e‐mails; c/ws S. Sparling re: 30b6 1.00 1,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/06/2015 Review of privilege log and related issues. 8.00 4,400.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/06/2015Call w/defense counsel re: discovery production issues; discussed same w/KD; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition; discussed status of discovery issues w/DG; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 3.10 2,867.50


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status, diligence items, and status of discovery dispute and privilege log issues. Calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman and S. Sparling re same. Reviewed documents pertaining to privilege log revision, took notes re same. Correspondence w/ co‐counsel re same. 3.60 2,628.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/07/2015 Review e‐mails re: 30b6 witness; c/ws K. Denk and S. Sparling 1.00 1,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/07/2015 Review of privilege log and related issues. 7.20 3,960.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/07/2015 Discussed discovery issues w/KD; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; reviewed correspondence from defense counsel. 0.40 370.00


Prepared binder of deposition transcripts of various experts for Kurt Denk (.40); updated local drive of deposition transcripts (.40); conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding preparation of chart in Excel and Word showing request for production of documents and interrogatories and our responses thereto (.30); attended to same (3.10). 4.20 1,470.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel team correspondence pertaining to case status, diligence items, and status of discovery dispute and privilege log issues. Calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same. Reviewed documents pertaining to privilege log revision, took notes re same. Conducted legal research re 30(b)(6) witnesses and e‐discovery per S. Sparling's request, and circulated summary memo re same. 6.30 4,599.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/08/2015Review research on 30b6 on document production protocols; review of discovery related e‐mails; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk; review of draft of market definition section of letter to judge on summary judgment 6.00 6,720.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/08/2015 Review of privilege log and related issues. 5.70 3,135.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/08/2015Reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition; discussed open discovery projects w/team; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; reviewed deposition transcripts. 5.70 5,272.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/09/2015 Reviewed correspondence pertaining to defendants' letter request for MSJ conference. 0.50 365.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/10/2015 Reviewed documents pertaining to privilege log revision, took notes re same. 2.20 1,606.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/11/2015Finalized charts in Excel and Word reflecting Interrogatories and Production of Documents (2.80); reviewed docket sheet for copy of Third Amended Complaint and forwarded same to Kurt Denk (.20); 3.00 1,050.00





Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel correspondence re case status and draft letters pertaining to defendants' contemplated summary judgment motion and plaintiffs' request for 30(b)(6) document custodian deposition. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Conference w/ Dan Goldman re case status and updated interrogatory responses; revised responses and conducted legal research re mitigation; circulated research work product pertaining to same. Conducted legal research re 30(b)(6) witnesses and remedies for belated document production; calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same; circulated draft work product to D. Goldman & S. Sparling re same. Completed misc tasks re privilege log revision & supervised work of associate S. Sivan pertaining to same. 11.20 8,176.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/11/2015Mtw K. Denk re: interrogatory responses; review of research re: mitigation of damages; review draft letter to J. Pauley; review of document discovery deposition law 4.00 4,480.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/11/2015 Review and revisions to privilege log; research into mitigation issue. 4.70 2,585.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/11/2015Discussed 30(b)(6) request w/DG; met w/KD re: letter to court re: same; reviewed background materials for Carlucci deposition; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 5.80 5,365.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/12/2015 updated litigation binder (.50); updated deposition transcripts and deposition exhibit folders (.30). 0.50 175.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel correspondence re case status and draft letters pertaining to defendants' contemplated summary judgment motion and plaintiffs' request for 30(b)(6) document custodian deposition. Prepared for/participated in weekly management team call. Correspondence w/ Dan Goldman re updated interrogatory responses. KL team correspondence re draft court letter requesting 30(b)(6) witness/remedies pertaining to belated document production; supervised work product of associate S. Sivan re same. 2.50 1,825.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/12/2015Participate in management call; review and revise 30b6 letter to Court; review contract related documents produced by NAM re: retailers; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk; review discovery related e‐mails 7.00 7,840.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/12/2015 Review of privilege log and other documents; research for 30(b)(6) letter. 6.60 3,630.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/12/2015 Edited and revised discovery letter; discussed same w/team; discussed case status w/DG. 7.10 6,567.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/13/2015 reviewed docket for copies of pleadings and forwarded same to Kurt Denk and Steve Sparling 0.40 140.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel correspondence re case status and draft letters pertaining to defendants' contemplated summary judgment motion and plaintiffs' request for 30(b)(6) document custodian deposition. KL team correspondence re draft court letter requesting 30(b)(6) witness/remedies pertaining to belated document production; supervised work product of associate S. Sivan re same. Completed misc tasks re privilege log revision & supervised work of associate S. Sivan pertaining to same. 1.30 949.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/13/2015Review draft interrogatory responses; review revised letter to court re: NAM’s proposed motion for summary judgment; review revised letter to court re: request for 30b6 witness; review emails re: same; c/ws K. Denk and S. Sparling; t/c A. Johnstone of Sears; review of Berg deposition 8.00 8,960.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/13/2015 Review and research for 30(b)(6) letter. 3.00 1,650.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/13/2015Finalized draft discovery letter for transmittal to PW; emailed w/co‐counsel re: same; emailed w/team re: same; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition. 6.30 5,827.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/14/2015Reviewed Request for Admissions and forwarded same to Kurt Denk for review (.30); reviewed Plaintiffs' Supplemental Responses and Objections to Defendants' Interrogatories (.50). 0.80 280.00


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel correspondence re case status and draft letters pertaining to defendants' contemplated summary judgment motion and plaintiffs' request for 30(b)(6) document custodian deposition. KL team correspondence re draft court letter requesting 30(b)(6) witness/remedies pertaining to belated document production; supervised work product of associate S. Sivan re same. 3.90 2,847.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/14/2015Review and comment on letter opposing request for summary judgment and letter to court re: 30b6 witness on NAM document production; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk 6.50 7,280.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/14/2015 Review and research for 30(b)(6) letter. 4.20 2,310.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/14/2015 Discussed discovery letter issues w/team. 0.50 462.50


Reviewed/responded to plaintiffs counsel correspondence re case status and draft letters pertaining to defendants' ` contemplated summary judgment motion and plaintiffs' request for 30(b)(6) document custodian deposition. KL team ` correspondence re draft court letter requesting 30(b)(6) witness/remedies pertaining to belated document production; ` supervised work product of associate S. Sivan re same. Correspondence/calls with co‐counsel and counsel for Insignia ` (J. Ansel) re subpoena to Dial in Valassis/NAM litigation. 2.20 1,606.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/15/2015 Review Berg deposition and related materials 7.00 7,840.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/15/2015 Review of documents; research and revisions for 30(b)(6) letter. 1.60 880.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/15/2015 Reviewed court filings; reviewed draft letter insert from PW on discovery dispute; emailed w/team and co‐counsel re: same. 1.10 1,017.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/18/2015 created chart of undated documents (.50); renamed documents in date format in folder in preparation of Dan Goldman's binder (2.0). 2.50 875.00


Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence and work product pertaining to case status, 30(b)(6) discovery dispute, and NAM summary judgment motion. Prepared for/participated in associates team weekly conference call. Drafted 30(b)(6) notice addressing NAM document production error; conferences & correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & B. Schulman re same; circulated draft 30(b)(6) notice to co‐counsel. Reviewed materials relevant to deposition preparation (Carlucci). 6.60 4,818.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/18/2015 Review of Berg deposition; review of letters re: 30b6 deposition; review of 30b6 topics; c/ws S. Sparling, K. Denk and Brendan Schulman 7.00 7,840.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/18/2015 Review of privilege log; research and revisions of 30(b)(6) letter. 2.60 1,430.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/18/2015 Discussed discovery dispute w/DG; worked w/team to draft deposition notice on document production failures; emailed w/team re: same. 1.30 1,202.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/19/2015 Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding copy of binder provided to Dan Goldman (.20); 0.20 70.00


Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence and work product pertaining to case status and 30(b)(6) discovery dispute; conference w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly MC conference call. Revised and served 30(b)(6) notice addressing NAM document production error. Reviewed materials relevant to deposition preparation (Carlucci). 4.80 3,504.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/19/2015Participate in management call; review e‐mails re: NAM's recent document production; c/ws K. Denk and S. Sparling; review of Berg deposition; prepare for Carlucci deposition 7.00 7,840.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 05/19/2015 Review Carlton transcript & draft e‐mail to DBG re: same 1.00 960.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/19/2015 Review of privilege log. 3.00 1,650.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/19/2015 Management call; discussed open issues w/team; finalized 30(b)(6) notice; emailed w/co‐counsel re: same; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition 7.30 6,752.50


reviewed Marion Findlay video deposition transcript (.30); added same to local drive for team (.40); conference with Shaked Sivan and Kimberly Briggs regarding obtaining copy of same (.40); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding references to Paul Carlucci from other deposition transcripts (.20); attended to same (1.60). 2.90 1,015.00


Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence and work product pertaining to case status and updated Interrogatory responses. Reviewed documents for production of revised/supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction log, and edited log for same; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Reviewed materials relevant to deposition preparation (Carlucci). 7.10 5,183.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/20/2015 Review of Berg deposition; review of retailer contracts; review of discovery related e‐mails including e‐mails re: NAM's recent document production 6.00 6,720.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 05/20/2015 Review final Carlton transcript & draft e‐mail to DBG re: same 3.90 3,744.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/20/2015 Review and revisions to privilege log. 6.60 3,630.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/20/2015 Reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition; discussed discovery issues w/K. Denk. 1.30 1,202.50


Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence and work product pertaining to case status and updated Interrogatory responses. Reviewed documents for production of revised/supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction log, and edited log for same; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Completed misc tasks pertaining to 30(b)(6) issues. Deposition preparation (Carlucci). 7.80 5,694.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/21/2015Review of Mackie‐Mason expert reports; review of retailer contracts and Valassis' efforts to penetrate market; c/ws S. Sparling and S. Sivan; review of discovery related e‐mails 6.30 7,056.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 05/21/2015 Drafting e‐mail to DBG re: Carlton deposition 2.30 2,208.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/21/2015 Review and revisions to privilege log; review of retailer contracts. 3.00 1,650.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/21/2015 Reviewed privilege log revisions; discussed same w/KD; reviewed deposition transcripts; email to team re: Carlucci deposition. 7.80 7,215.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/22/2015 Reviewed transcripts of testimony for references to Paul Carlucci (1.40). 1.40 490.00


Finalized and served updated Interrogatory responses. Completed misc tasks pertaining to revised/supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction log, and edited log for same; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same; correspondence with D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & client re same. Reviewed/responded to KL correspondence re 30(b)(6) issues. Deposition preparation (Carlucci). 6.50 4,745.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/22/2015Review e‐mails re: privileged logs and 30b6 deposition; c/ws S. Sparling re: 30b6 deposition; review of documents and contracts; review Mackie‐Mason merits reports 6.00 6,720.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/22/2015 Review and revisions to privilege log. 0.90 495.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/22/2015Reviewed deposition transcripts; discussed discovery issues w/team; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel; t/c w/WM re: 30(b)(6) witness; emails w/team re: same. 7.50 6,937.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/23/2015 Reviewed/responded to KL team correspondence re 30(b)(6) witness issues. Deposition preparation (Carlucci). 2.00 1,460.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/23/2015 Emailed w/team re: 30(b)(6) witness notice and PW's counteroffer. 0.10 92.50 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/24/2015 Emailed w/team re: 30(b)(6) witness notice and PW's counteroffer; reviewed deposition transcript. 3.10 2,867.50 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/25/2015 Deposition preparation (Carlucci). 4.30 3,139.00


Prepared for/participated in weekly management call. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ S. Sparling & KL team re 30(b)(6) deposition negotiations. Supervised work/correspondence of S. Sivan and DTI pertaining to Heinz privilege and redaction log revisions, and reviewed revised work product and related documents. Deposition preparation (Carlucci). 7.90 5,767.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/26/2015Management committee call; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk; review e‐mails re: 30b6 doc deposition; review Mackie‐Mason reports; review Carlucci materials 7.00 7,840.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/26/2015 Review of retailer contracts; review and revision of privilege log. 9.10 5,005.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/26/2015Management call; discussed 30(b)(6) issues; w/team; contacted PW re: same; discussed discovery issues w/KD; reviewed deposition transcripts and documents for Carlucci deposition. 4.10 3,792.50





Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ S. Sparling & KL team re 30(b)(6) deposition negotiations and completed misc admin follow‐up re same. Supervised work/correspondence of S. Sivan and DTI pertaining to Heinz privilege and redaction log revisions, and reviewed revised work product and related documents. Deposition preparation (Carlucci). 8.90 6,497.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/27/2015 C/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk; review of emails re: 30b6 depositions; review of Mackie‐Mason reports; review of Carlucci materials to prep for deposition 7.30 8,176.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 05/27/2015 Meet with D. Goldman to discuss Heinz litigation and research project; review and analyze caselaw concerning predatory bidding 2.00 1,560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/27/2015 Privilege log review. 0.60 330.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/27/2015Discussed 30(b)(6) issues w/BS and KD; discussed discovery issues w/KD; call w/W. Michael re: 30(b)(6) notice; reviewed deposition transcripts and correspondence w/co‐counsel. 5.20 4,810.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/28/2015conference with Legal Technology Services regarding hard drive from Kimberly Briggs which contained selected videos (.40); conformed information on database to contain dates of each video (3.60). 4.00 1,400.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/28/2015Supervised work/correspondence of S. Sivan and DTI pertaining to Heinz privilege and redaction log revisions, and reviewed revised work product and related documents. 0.80 584.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/28/2015T/c J. Southwick; review email from S. Sparling; c/w C. Pak re research re: raising Valassis’ costs as predatory conduct; review of Mackie‐Mason reports and underlying materials; prepare for Carlucci deposition 8.00 8,960.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 05/28/2015 Review and analyze caselaw concerning predatory bidding 5.00 3,900.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/28/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; t/c w/W. Michael re: 30(b)(6) notice; email to co‐counsel re: same. 2.20 2,035.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/29/2015Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ S. Sparling & KL team re 30(b)(6) deposition negotiations, and completed misc admin follow‐up re same. Telephone conference w/ co‐counsel J. Smith re privilege and redaction log revisions; follow‐up correspondence w/ KL team re same. 2.40 1,752.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/29/2015Review of Mackie‐Mason merits reports; review of deposition transcripts and documents from fact witnesses taken in case; c/w C. Pak re: research re: predatory bidding 7.00 7,840.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 05/29/2015 Research and review caselaw concerning monopoly profit margins; research and review caselaw concerning predatory bidding practices 4.00 3,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 05/29/2015 Review of privilege log. 0.20 110.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/29/2015 Emailed w/W. Michael re: 30(b)(6) notice; emailed w/team re: same; reviewed deposition transcripts. 6.90 6,382.50 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 05/31/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts. 6.20 5,735.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/01/2015 reviewed hard drive of video depositions and conferred with LTS regarding loading same 0.50 175.00


Drafted work product for, and participated in conference w/ S. Sparling & B. Schulman re 30(b)(6) deposition negotiations; reviewed/responded to follow‐up correspondence re same. Prepared for and participated in weekly associates call re case status; reviewed/responded to follow‐up correspondence pertaining to privilege log revisions. Correspondence with document platform and review vendor DTI re pending workflows and revised Master Services Agreement. Deposition prep (Carlucci). 8.80 6,424.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/01/2015 Review documents relating to News’ contracting practices re: retailers; c/ws S. Sparling, K. Denk and C. Pak 8.00 8,960.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/01/2015 Research and review caselaw concerning market foreclosure; review and analyze expert reports of Drs. Jeffrey Mackie‐Mason and Kevin Murphy 7.20 5,616.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/01/2015 Review of specific retailer contracts and negotiations. 2.80 1,540.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/01/2015 Discussed 30(b)(6) notice issues w/KD and BS; discussed variety of discovery issues w/KD; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 1.10 1,017.50


Drafted work product for, and participated in conference w/ S. Sparling & B. Schulman re 30(b)(6) deposition negotiations; participated in conference call w/ adversary re same; reviewed/responded to follow‐up correspondence re same. Prepared for and participated in weekly MC call re case status; reviewed/responded to follow‐up correspondence pertaining to privilege log revisions and document review/fact development projects. Correspondence with document platform and review vendor DTI re pending workflows and revised Master Services Agreement. Deposition prep (Carlucci). 10.50 7,665.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/02/2015 C/ws S. Sparling, C. Pak and S. Sivan; review of documents relating to News’ Corp.’s retailer contracting practices; attend management committee cal 7.00 7,840.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/02/2015 Research and review caselaw concerning market foreclosure 6.30 4,914.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/02/2015 Privilege log review and revisions. 5.60 3,080.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/02/2015Management call; discussed discovery issues w/KD; discussed 30(b)(6) notice issues w/BS and KD; call w/W. Michael re: same; follow up discussion w/KD re: same. 2.30 2,127.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/03/2015 Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding Carlucci outline (.20); reviewed outline and began to prepare documents for binder (4.50). 4.70 1,645.00


Correspondence/conferences w/ S. Sparling & B. Schulman re 30(b)(6) deposition negotiations; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re same; drafted work product and conducted fact research pertaining to same. Prepared for and participated in associates call re fact development project assignments. Reviewed/responded to follow‐up correspondence pertaining to privilege log revisions; correspondence with document platform and review vendor DTI re pending workflows and revised Master Services Agreement. Deposition prep (Carlucci). 11.20 8,176.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/03/2015 C/ws S. Sparling, K. Denk and S. Sivan; review documents relating to News’ Corp.’s retailer contracts; prepare for Carlucci deposition 7.50 8,400.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/03/2015 Research and review caselaw concerning market foreclosure; draft memorandum of summaries of cases 9.00 7,020.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/03/2015 Review of documents in preparation for Carlucci deposition; review of specific retailer contracts. 4.00 2,200.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/03/2015Emails w/co‐counsel re: 30(b)(6) witness; discussed same w/team; call w/co‐counsel re: same; discussed discovery issues w/KD and DG; reviewed correspondence from defendants; emailed w/team re: same. 1.10 1,017.50

07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 06/04/2015

Call with legal team regarding subsets of document productions that co‐counsel received from the adversary and co‐counsel will forward to us as soon as they finish preparing the subsets (these documents should be loaded to Viewpoint, the firm’s electronic discovery review platform, as requested by legal team). 0.20 60.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/04/2015Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding Pail Carlucci deposition preparation binder (.50); prepared binder of documents in preparation of Paul Carlucci deposition (6.0). 6.50 2,275.00


Revised draft work product pertaining to 30(b)(6) dispute; calls/conferences/correspondence w/ S. Sparling & B. Schulman re same; reviewed/responded to follow‐up co‐counsel correspondence re same; finalized responsive letter to adversary and circulated to same. Correspondence with document platform and review vendor DTI & KL team re pending workflows and revised Master Services Agreement. Finalized draft depo outline (Carlucci) and circulated to D. Goldman & team. 7.30 5,329.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/04/2015 C/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk re: 30b6 deposition; review documents relating to News’ Corp.’s retailer contracts; prepare for Carlucci deposition 7.00 7,840.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/04/2015 Research and review caselaw concerning market foreclosure; draft memorandum of summaries of cases 7.00 5,460.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/04/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition; review of specific retailer contracts. 1.20 660.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/04/2015 Reviewed and revised letter to PW re: 30(b)(6) witness dispute; emails w/team and co‐counsel re: same; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition 2.20 2,035.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/05/2015 updated Dan Goldman's deposition preparation binder regarding Paul Carlucci 1.60 560.00


Conducted legal research and drafted court letter pertaining to 30(b)(6) dispute, circulating to KL team; calls/conferences/correspondence w/ S. Sparling & B. Schulman re same; reviewed/responded to follow‐up co‐counsel correspondence re same. Correspondence with document platform and review vendor DTI & KL team re pending workflows and revised Master Services Agreement. 4.40 3,212.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/05/2015C/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk re: 30b6 deposition; review letter to counsel for News Corp.; review documents relating to News’ contracting practices; prepare for Carlucci deposition 7.50 8,400.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/05/2015 Research and review caselaw concerning market foreclosure; draft memorandum of summaries of cases 8.50 6,630.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/05/2015 Review of documents in preparation for Carlucci deposition; review of specific retailer contracts. 2.70 1,485.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/05/2015 Revised letter to Court on 30(b)(6) witness; discussed same w/team; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 4.30 3,977.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/06/2015Revised draft court letter pertaining to 30(b)(6) dispute, and circulated to co‐counsel for review; reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ KL team re same. 1.60 1,168.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/06/2015 Revised letter to court on 30(b)(6) witness; reviewed letter from PW re: same; emailed w/team re: same. 1.20 1,110.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/08/2015Reviewed and revised binders of Paul Carlucci deposition preparation documents for Kurt Denk and Shaked Sivan (2.80); conference with Kurt Denk regarding electronic copies of exhibits (.20); attended to same (.20)/ 3.20 1,120.00


Finalized draft court letter pertaining to 30(b)(6) dispute, and circulated to adversary; reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re same. Prepared for and participated in weekly associates team call. Completed misc admin tasks pertaining to privilege log amendments and updates. 2.70 1,971.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/08/2015 Review Carlucci related documents to prepare for Carlucci deposition; c/ws K. Denk re: Carlucci deposition 7.00 7,840.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/08/2015 Reviewing and amending privilege log; document review. 1.40 770.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/08/2015Emailed w/co‐counsel re: letter to court on 30(b)(6) witness; reviewed final version of letter re: same; reviewed outline for Carlucci deposition; emailed w/KD re: discovery issues; reviewed factual background materials. 3.80 3,515.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/09/2015 conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding video depositions and having same added to local drive (.30); attended to same (.80). 1.10 385.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/09/2015Prepared for and participated in weekly MC call. Completed misc admin tasks pertaining to privilege log amendments and updates. Completed misc diligence items re fact development, document review, and Carlucci depo prep. 2.20 1,606.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/09/2015 Prepare for Carlucci deposition including review of videos from Sale Summits and documents 7.00 7,840.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/09/2015Conduct legal research regarding market foreclosure and barriers to entry; review and analyze caselaw regarding market foreclosure and barriers to entry 8.00 6,240.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/09/2015 Responding to emails throughout the day about privilege log and document management issues. 1.00 550.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/09/2015Reviewed Carlucci deposition outline; email to D. Goldman re: same; emails w/team re: discovery issues; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel; reviewed deposition transcripts. 4.20 3,885.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/10/2015 conferred with Claudia Pak regarding preparation of binder regarding Market Foreclosure (.20); attended to same (1.50); 1.70 595.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/10/2015Completed misc admin tasks pertaining to privilege log amendments and updates. Completed misc diligence items re fact development, document review, and Carlucci depo prep. 1.90 1,387.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/10/2015 Prepare for Carlucci deposition 8.00 8,960.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/10/2015 Review and analyze federal cases regarding market foreclosure; draft memorandum summarizing relevant cases 7.50 5,850.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/10/2015 Review of video and documents in preparation for Carlucci deposition; review of privilege log. 6.20 3,410.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/10/2015 Reviewed PW's portion of 30(b)(6) letter to the court; discussed same w/team; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition; discussed same w/DG. 7.10 6,567.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/11/2015Conferred with Claudia Pak regarding binders for Dan Goldman (.20); attended to same (.40); conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding Carlucci deposition preparation binder (.30); attended to preparation of additional binder (.80); assist Kurt Denk with exhibits to Judge Pauley (.40); 1.90 665.00


Finalized and filed parties' joint 30(b)(6) witness deposition dispute letter to Court, and completed misc diligence/admin follow‐up tasks re same; corresponded with KL team and co‐counsel re same. Calls/correspondence w. S. Sivan re privilege log amendments and updates. Completed misc diligence items re fact development pertaining to Carlucci depo prep. 2.60 1,898.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/11/2015 Prepare for Carlucci deposition 7.00 7,840.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/11/2015 Draft memorandum summarizing cases on market foreclosure in support of plaintiff's theory 3.20 2,496.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/11/2015 Review for Carlucci deposition prep; privilege log review. 6.70 3,685.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/11/2015Finalized letter to court on 30(b)(6) witness; reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition; discussed same w/team; discussed discovery issues w/team; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 5.10 4,717.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/12/2015Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re privilege log amendments and updates. Completed misc diligence items re document review and fact development projects; correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. 0.90 657.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/12/2015 Prepare for Carlucci deposition 4.50 5,040.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/12/2015 Review for Carlucci deposition prep; privilege log review. 6.60 3,630.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/14/2015 Review for Carlucci deposition prep. 0.20 110.00


Completed misc diligence items re document review and fact development for Carlucci depo and retailer projects, and re privilege log amendments and updates. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan & K. Briggs re same. Prepared for and participated in weekly associates team call. Calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman re Carlucci depo prep/fact development. 6.60 4,818.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/15/2015 Prepare for Carlucci deposition 5.00 5,600.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/15/2015 Conduct legal research of federal cases discussing staggered contract terms; review and analyze cases 3.40 2,652.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/15/2015 Review of videos and documents for Carlucci deposition prep. 9.30 5,115.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/15/2015 Reviewed materials for Carlucci deposition; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 2.30 2,127.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/16/2015 Conferred with Claudia Pak e regarding preparation of binders (.20); attended to same (.20). 0.40 140.00


Completed misc diligence items re document review and fact development for Carlucci depo, and drafted memo notes re same. Completed misc tasks re privilege log amendments and updates, and supervised work of S. Sivan re same. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan & K. Briggs re document request status. 7.60 5,548.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/16/2015 Review of documents re: Carlucci 5.00 5,600.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/16/2015 Conduct legal research of federal cases discussing staggered contract terms; review and analyze cases; draft memo summarizing relevant cases 6.30 4,914.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/16/2015 Privilege log review; document review for Carlucci deposition prep. 1.60 880.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/16/2015 Met w/DG and KD re: open issues; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 0.50 462.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/17/2015 prepared labels for binders created for Christina Pak 0.40 140.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/17/2015Continued review of additional Carlucci docs and drafted memo notes re same. Completed misc tasks re privilege log amendments and updates, and supervised work of S. Sivan re same. 2.30 1,679.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/17/2015 Review case law re: staggering of long term contracts and foreclosure; review Carlucci related documents 4.00 4,480.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/17/2015 Review memorandum on market foreclosure and cases discussed therein 0.50 390.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/17/2015 Privilege log review. 4.50 2,475.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/17/2015 Reviewed emails from co‐counsel and team re: various discovery issues. 0.20 185.00


Participated in weekly MC call; conference w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re case status. Drafted and circulated memo to D. Goldman & S. Sparling re fact development relevant to Carlucci depo. Reviewed documents and correspondence from S. Sivan re privilege log updates and completed misc diligence follow‐up re same; supervised priv log work product of S. Sivan. Reviewed Court decision granting class certification and reviewed/responded to team emails re same. 6.60 4,818.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/18/2015 Review class cert decision; c/ws co‐defense counsel re: class cert decision; review of Carlucci related documents 4.00 4,480.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/18/2015 Review and analyze Order granting class certification 0.50 390.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/18/2015 Privilege log review. 2.10 1,155.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/18/2015 Management call; discussed next steps w/D. Goldman and K. Denk. 0.40 370.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/19/2015Reviewed documents and correspondence from S. Sivan re privilege log updates. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ K. Briggs re document productions. 1.30 949.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/19/2015 E‐mails re: class cert decision; t/cs co‐counsel re: class cert decision; review case law re: appointment of lead counse 2.00 2,240.00




18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/19/2015Conduct legal research regarding appointment of four law firms as co‐lead counsel in class action per D. Goldman; review correspondences between counsel regarding appointment of law firms as co‐lead counsel 4.20 3,276.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/19/2015 Privilege log review. 1.50 825.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/19/2015 Reviewed decision on class cert; discussed same w/team. 0.70 647.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/22/2015Reviewed case law re antitrust damages theories. Prepared for and participated in weekly associates call re case status, and sent summary email re diligence items to KL team. 1.60 1,168.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/22/2015 C/w C. Pak re: research re: letter to Court re: lead counsel; t/c co‐counsel re: lead counsel issue; review draft letter to court 2.00 2,240.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/22/2015Draft response to Judge Pauley's directive ordering parties to propose co‐lead class counsel; research, review, and analyze cases concerning the appointment of co‐lead class counsel in antitrust class action lawsuits; review and analyze Manual for Complex Litigation per D. Goldman 11.30 8,814.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/22/2015 Discussed hearing issues w/D. Goldman; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 0.30 277.50


reviewed Carlucci outline for copies of documents used during previous depositions per Kurt Denk's request (2.40); assisted Kurt Denk with miscellaneous requests of documents (.30); conferred with Claudia Pak regarding redactions to copies of decisions showing multiple law firms hired as counsel (.30); attended to same (1.80). 4.80 1,680.00


Prepared for/participated in weekly MC call. Completed misc document review, diligence tasks, and supervision of S. Sivan/S. Cipolla work re revised and supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction logs and supplemental document production; reviewed/responded to correspondence with KL team and vendor re same. 3.80 2,774.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/23/2015 Draft and revise letter to court concerning appointment of lead counsel; e‐mails to co‐counsel re: letter; c/ws C. Pak re: same 4.00 4,480.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/23/2015Revise and edit draft of letter‐motion to Judge Pauley renewing request for the appointment of five law firms as co‐lead class counsel; coordinate with managing attorney's office and S. Cipolla concerning filing of exhibits on ECF 3.50 2,730.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/23/2015 Reviewed and amended privilege log. 1.90 1,045.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/23/2015Reviewed and commented on court letter; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; management committee call; discussed hearing issues w/D. Goldman. 1.00 925.00

03812 Suris, Liliya Other Tkpr 06/23/2015 Researched and attempted to find out Judge Pauley schedules. 2.50 425.00


Conferred with Claudia Pak regarding redactions to exhibits to letter to Judge Pauley regarding Class Counsel letter (.50); attended to redactions and putting documents in proper pdf format for filing (2.0); assisted counsel with courtesy copy for Judge (.40); conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding privilege log (.20); updated local drive with letter to Judge Pauley regarding Class Counsel and exhibits thereto (.20); Assisted Shaked Sivan with revisions to spreadsheet (1.50). 4.80 1,680.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 06/24/2015 Deliver courtesy copy of a letter to Judge Pauley at SDNY. 2.50 487.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/24/2015Completed misc document review, diligence tasks, and supervision of S. Sivan/S. Cipolla work re revised and supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction logs and supplemental document production; reviewed/responded to correspondence with KL team and vendor re same. 3.60 2,628.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/24/2015Finalize letter to court concerning appointment of lead counsel; management committee call; review of Carlucci related documents; prepare for hearing on 6/30 5.00 5,600.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 06/24/2015Review exhibits attached to letter‐motion renewing request for appointment of five law firms as class counsel; revise and file letter‐motion renewing request for appointment of five law firms as class counsel; file appearance of new counsel form 5.00 3,900.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/24/2015 Reviewed and amended privilege log. 12.30 6,765.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/24/2015 Call w/D. Goldman re: hearing; emails w/K. Denk and S. Sivan re: privilege log issues. 0.30 277.50

03812 Suris, Liliya Other Tkpr 06/24/2015Researched and find out Judge Pauley schedules. E‐filed Letter with exhibits and Notice of Appearance. Conf. with Claudia Pak re: parties to be selectedon the Notice of Appearance. 2.90 493.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/25/2015 Attended to privilege log 6.40 2,240.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/25/2015Completed misc document review, diligence tasks, and supervision of S. Sivan/S. Cipolla work re revised and supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction logs and supplemental document production; reviewed/responded to correspondence with KL team and vendor re same. 8.40 6,132.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/25/2015 Reviewed and amended privilege log. 7.50 4,125.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/25/2015 Reviewed emails from team and co‐counsel re: discovery and hearing issues. 0.20 185.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/26/2015 conferred with Kurt Denk and Shaked Sivan regarding revisions to privilege log (.40); attended to same (4.0). 4.40 1,540.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/26/2015Completed misc document review, diligence tasks, and supervision of S. Sivan/S. Cipolla work re revised and supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction logs and supplemental document production; reviewed/responded to correspondence with KL team, vendor, and co‐counsel re same. 5.60 4,088.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/26/2015 Reviewed and amended privilege log. 4.70 2,585.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/26/2015 Discussed discovery issues w/K. Denk; reviewed court order re: lead counsel. 0.30 277.50 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/27/2015 E‐mails and conferences among counsel re: lead counsel 0.50 560.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/28/2015 Reviewed and revised Privilege Log spreadsheets reflecting beginning and ending Bates ranges 6.80 2,380.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/28/2015Completed misc document review, diligence tasks, and supervision of S. Cipolla work re revised and supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction logs and supplemental document production. 3.40 2,482.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/28/2015 Reviewed and amended privilege log. 1.20 660.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 06/29/2015 Reviewed John Kelly's errata sheet and reviewed proposed changes for Kurt Denk (.70); 0.70 245.00


Finalized review of revised and supplemental Heinz privilege and redaction logs and supplemental document production, and produced same; completed misc diligence tasks re same. Participated in weekly associates call. Conference w/ S. Sparling re class counsel appointment research project, and conducted legal research and drafted memo notes re same to circulate to D. Goldman & S. Sparling; reviewed work product of S. Sivan re same. 7.40 5,402.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/29/2015 Prepare for conference with Judge Pauley 3.00 3,360.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/29/2015Reviewed and amended privilege log and conducted other document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition (1.80); researched class counsel appointment issues (6.5). 8.30 4,565.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/29/2015Addressed hearing related issues; discussed lead counsel issues w/team; reviewed law re: same; reviewed privilege log production; reviewed new discovery materials. 4.20 3,885.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/30/2015Conducted legal research and drafted memo notes and work product re class counsel appointment. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re fact development diligence items. Conference/calls w/ S. Sparling re case status and diligence items. 3.30 2,409.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/30/2015 Prepare for and argue at conference with Judge Pauley 2.50 2,800.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 06/30/2015 Review and editing of outline in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 4.70 2,585.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 06/30/2015Attended hearing; met w/co‐counsel re: same; discussed next steps w/team; responded to court reporter request for information from hearing; discussed same w/S. Sivan; reviewed discovery materials. 6.10 5,642.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/01/2015 Reviewed court transcript from 6/30 status conference; reviewed/responded to correspondence re same. 0.60 438.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/01/2015 Reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 0.20 185.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/02/2015 Review of News Corp.’s 23f petition to Second Circuit 1.00 1,120.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/06/2015 Reviewed Paul Carlucci outline for copies of deposition exhibits previously entered into record from previous depositions per Kurt Denk's instructions 2.60 910.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/06/2015Reviewed adversary 23(f) petition. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates team call. Reviewed/responded to misc team correspondence re class cert and 30(b)(6) issues. Drafted correspondence to adversary re 30(b)(6) deposition notice, and completed misc admin tasks pertaining to same 3.30 2,409.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/06/2015 Review draft class notice; review draft letter to counsel for News on 30b6 document deposition; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk 1.00 1,120.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/06/2015 Emails w/KD re: discovery issues; reviewed and edited letter re: 30(b)(6) witness. 0.30 277.50


Prepared for/participated in weekly MC call, and met w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re case status and diligence items. Calls/correspondence with KL team and vendors re document hosting and possible retention for 30(b)(6) depo consulting; completed misc diligence items re same. Reviewed additional documents and preparation materials pertaining to pending Carlucci and 30(b)(6) depositions. 4.90 3,577.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/07/2015Attend management call; draft management committee resolution; c/w J. Southwick, S. Berry and S. Benz re: management committee resolution; t/c L. LeClair re: management committee resolution 3.00 3,360.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/07/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 4.90 2,695.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/07/2015 Reviewed draft letter to court; management committee call; discussed deposition issues w/KD and DG; discussed case strategy issues w/KD and DG. 0.90 832.50


Calls/correspondence with KL team and vendors re possible retention for 30(b)(6) depo consulting; completed misc diligence items re same. Reviewed additional documents and preparation materials pertaining to pending Carlucci and 30(b)(6) depositions; reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ K. Briggs & S. Sivan re same. 2.70 1,971.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/08/2015 Review e‐mails re: dismissal of FSI claims 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/08/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 7.40 4,070.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/08/2015 Reviewed draft stipulation to dismiss FSI claims; discussed same w/DG; reviewed emails from co‐counsel; reviewed draft class notice. 0.60 555.00


Calls/correspondence with C. Fletcher (OmniVere) re possible retention for 30(b)(6) depo consulting; reviewed/responded to corresp w/ S. Sparling re same. Reviewed additional documents and preparation materials pertaining to pending Carlucci and 30(b)(6) depositions; correspondence w/ S. Sivan re pending fact development projects. 1.30 949.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/09/2015 Draft email to defense counsel group re: thoughts on News’ 23f petition; review of Sykes, Roach and other cases re: class cert in Second Circuit 2.00 2,240.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/09/2015 Reviewed 30(b)(6) vendor proposal; discussed same w/KD and BS; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; reviewed draft class notice. 0.90 832.50


Reviewed/responded to corresp w/ C. Fletcher (OmniVere) re possible retention for 30(b)(6) depo consulting; correspondence w/ KL team (N. Woods & M. Ng) re same. Call/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re document review/fact development diligence items. Reviewed plaintiffs' draft 23(f) response brief and co‐counsel responsive comments, and sent memo notes re changes to D. Goldman re same. Corresp w/ client (S. Hudson) re Heinz corporate disclosure statement. 1.80 1,314.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 07/10/2015 Review and analyze defendants' Rule 23(f) petition to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals 1.00 780.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/10/2015 Document management related to retailer review and preparation for Carlucci deposition. 0.10 55.00




17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/11/2015 Reviewed D. Goldman and co‐counsel responsive comments to draft 23(f) response brief. 0.50 365.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/11/2015 Review of draft 23f opposition and comment thereon 2.00 2,240.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/11/2015 Reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 0.50 462.50 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/12/2015 Reviewed co‐counsel responsive comments to draft 23(f) response brief. 0.30 219.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/12/2015 Review and respond to e‐mails re: 23f draft opposition 0.50 560.00 07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 07/13/2015 Upload electronic documents to review database, perform quality checks and make same available to legal team in review database. 1.30 390.00


Calls/correspondence w/ client, KL team, and co‐counsel re updating Heinz corporate disclosure statement and amending case caption; filed revised Rule 7.1 statement and completed misc diligence items pertaining to same. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates team call. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan and K. Briggs re document review/fact development diligence items. Completed misc tasks pertaining to pending Carlucci and 30(b)(6) depositions. 6.20 4,526.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/13/2015 Review of emails re: Heinz corporate disclosure issue 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/13/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 2.30 1,265.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/13/2015Reviewed legal research re: staggering contracts; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel and draft submissions; discussed open issues w/KD; reviewed documents found in discovery. 3.40 3,145.00


Prepared for/participated in weekly MC call.; calls/correspondence/conference w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re case status and diligence items. Calls/correspondence w/ co‐counsel and KL team re 30(b)(6) depo planning and consultant retainer. Corresp w/ S. Sivan re document review/fact development diligence items. 1.90 1,387.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/14/2015 Participate in management committee call; c/w S. Sparling and K. Denk re: consultant for 30b6 deposition on document issue 1.00 1,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/14/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition; privilege log review. 4.50 2,475.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/14/2015 Call w/DG re: next steps in litigation; discussed discovery issues w/K. Denk; reviewed emails correspondence w/co‐counsel. 0.90 832.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/15/2015 Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of 30(b)(6) deposition preparation binder 0.80 280.00


Calls/correspondence/conference w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re case status and diligence items. Calls/correspondence w/ co‐counsel, KL team, and adversary re 30(b)(6) depo planning; completed misc diligence items re same. Corresp w/ S. Sivan re document review/fact development diligence items. 1.60 1,168.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/15/2015 Review focus group proposals 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/15/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 2.90 1,595.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/15/2015 Emailed w/co‐counsel re: discovery issues; discussed same w/KD; reviewed legal research on summary judgment issues; reviewed discovery materials. 5.10 4,717.50 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/16/2015 Completed misc diligence items re 30(b)(6) depo planning, Carlucci depo, and document review/fact development diligence items. 3.70 2,701.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/16/2015 Review work order for discovery expert; review newly discovered Carlucci hot documents; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk 2.00 2,240.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/16/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 4.60 2,530.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/16/2015Reviewed and commented on vendor agreement; emailed w/KD re: discovery issues; emailed w/co‐counsel re: same; reviewed draft materials from co‐counsel; reviewed research materials. 3.70 3,422.50


Prepared for and participated in all‐counsel call re fact development and related diligence items; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Drafted 30(b)(6) deposition outline; correspondence w/ C. Fletcher (OmniVere) and S. Sparling re same. Correspondence w/ adversary and D. Goldman re scheduling of Carlucci depo. 6.50 4,745.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/17/2015 Review class notice; review changes to NAM's website 0.50 560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/17/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition; fact gathering call with co‐counsel. 6.20 3,410.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/17/2015 Call w/co‐counsel re: next steps in factual development for summary j. 0.20 185.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/20/2015 Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding forwarding copy of letter to Judge Pauley 0.30 105.00


Prepared for and participated in weekly associates call re task list, and completed misc admin tasks pertaining to same. Finalized and filed letter with court requesting change to case caption reflecting client name change. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails circulating drafts pertaining to class notice and NAM's 23(f) petition. 2.30 1,679.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/20/2015 E‐mails to co‐counsel about NAM’s request to file 23(f) reply; review of motion for 23(f) reply and 23(f) reply brief; review associate task list 2.00 2,240.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/20/2015Reviewed 30(b)(6) deposition outline; emailed w/KD re: letter to court; discussed trial prep issues w/DG; reviewed filing by News; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; reviewed comments on class notice. 1.20 1,110.00

07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 07/21/2015 Begin upload of electronic documents to review database. 0.70 210.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/21/2015Prepared litigation binder and copied pleadings to local drive (4.70); reviewed hard drive received from Kimberly Briggs (.20); conferred with Jill Ranson regarding same (.30). 5.20 1,820.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/21/2015Prepared for and participated in weekly management committee call, and completed misc admin tasks pertaining to same. Telephone conference w/ S. Sparling re 30(b)(6) deposition outline; follow‐up correspondence with vendor (OmniVere) re same. Edited outline.` 1.50 1,095.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/21/2015 Attend management committee call; review stipulation of dismissal of FSI 1.50 1,680.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/21/2015 Reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel; MMC call; discussed next steps w/DG; call w/KD re: 30(b)(6) witness outline. 1.50 1,387.50




07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 07/22/2015 Upload electronic documents to review database, perform quality control checks and make same available to legal team in review database. 2.10 630.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/22/2015Continued to create litigation binder and conduct research to obtain copies of pleadings filed (6.10); conference with Kurt Denk regarding upcoming 30(b)(6) deposition (.10); attended to organizing set‐up of conference rooms for same (.30). 6.50 2,275.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/22/2015Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails circulating drafts pertaining to class notice and NAM's 23(f) petition. Call/emails w/ S. Sparling re 30(b)(6) deposition outline; revised same. 3.80 2,774.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/22/2015Review and provide comments on draft opposition to motion to file reply on 23(f) petition; t/c J. Southwick and R. Caughey re: draft opposition to motion to file reply brief on 23(f); review of Laumann case 4.00 4,480.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/22/2015 Reviewed and commented on deposition outline for 30(b)(6) witness; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 2.10 1,942.50 07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 07/23/2015 Upload electronic documents to review database, perform quality control checks and make same available to legal team in review database. 1.30 390.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/23/2015Calls/emails w/ S. Sivan re next steps in fact development tasks. Conference w/ S. Sparling re 30(b)(6) deposition prep, and case status and diligence items. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re NAM 23(f) petition. Correspondence with client re recent filings in case. 1.70 1,241.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/23/2015 E‐mails to co‐counsel re: 23(f) reply opposition 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/23/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition; retailer review. 5.10 2,805.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/23/2015 Discussed 30(b)(6) deposition w/K. Denk; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; call w/J. Blackmon re: jury exercise; email to D. Goldman re: same. 1.20 1,110.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/24/2015 Correspondence with client re recent filings in case. Revised 30(b)(6) deposition outline. 1.80 1,314.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/24/2015 Retailer review. 1.60 880.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/24/2015 Reviewed emails from co‐counsel and team re: various litigation issues. 0.20 185.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/25/2015 Revised 30(b)(6) deposition outline. 1.80 1,314.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/27/2015 continued to pull documents off Pacer to update litigation binder and update computer drive 3.70 1,295.00


Conf calls/emails w/ S. Sparling and S. Sivan re case status and diligence items. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re adversary correspondence. Prepared for and participated in weekly associates call re fact development tasks and case status; follow up conference w/ S. Sivan re same. Reviewed S. Sivan work product re additional Carlucci depo prep document review/analysis, and revised depo outline accordingly. 5.60 4,088.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/27/2015 Retailer review. 3.00 1,650.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/27/2015 Reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel; t/c w/K. Denk re: open discovery issues and projects. 0.40 370.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/28/2015 Updated litigation binder and prepared updates to Paul Carlucci Deposition Preparation binder for Daniel Goldman 7.00 2,450.00


Prepared for and participated in weekly MC call; follow up conference w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re case status, and completed misc diligence items re same. Conf calls/emails w/ S. Sivan re case status and diligence items. Conference call w/ C. Fletcher & F. Huang (OmniVere) re Miran depo prep. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re misc case status items. Reviewed S. Sivan work product re additional Carlucci drop prep document review/analysis, finalized revised depo outline and circulated to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 8.80 6,424.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/28/2015 Review revised mock trial bids; participate in management committee call; c/w K. Denk and S. Sparling re: Carlucci and 30b6 deposition 2.50 2,800.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/28/2015 Retailer review. 1.80 990.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/28/2015 Management committee call; discussed next steps w/team; discussed deposition issues w/K. Denk. 1.00 925.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/29/2015 Updated Paul Carlucci deposition preparation binders for team 5.90 2,065.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/29/2015Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re misc case status items. Conf calls/emails w/ S. Sivan re fact development projects and related diligence items. Reviewed additional Carlucci drop prep documents and updated outline. 1.10 803.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/29/2015 Retailer review. 4.50 2,475.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/30/2015 Updated Paul Carlucci Deposition binders for Steve Sparling, Kurt Denk and Shaked Sivan 5.30 1,855.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/30/2015Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re misc case status items. Conf calls/emails w/ S. Sivan re fact development projects and related diligence items. 0.60 438.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/30/2015 Retailer review. 6.50 3,575.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/30/2015 Reviewed emails from co‐counsel; discussed discovery issues w/team; reviewed new documents produced by NAM; reviewed trial task list from KD. 1.30 1,202.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 07/31/2015 Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of binders for 301(b)(6) deposition (.20); attended to same (.70). 0.90 315.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 07/31/2015Conference w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re case status, timeline, fact development projects, and related diligence items. Reviewed OmniVere comments to Miran 30(b)(6) deposition outline; revised depo outline and prepared for depo. 5.20 3,796.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 07/31/2015 Review letter re: third party depositions; review revised Carlucci outline 5.00 5,600.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 07/31/2015 Discussion of case schedule and tasks with Steve Sparling and Kurt Denk; case management tasks. 1.60 880.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 07/31/2015 Met w/associates re: next steps and projects; call w/DG re: same; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 1.60 1,480.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/01/2015 Reviewed adversary correspondence re productions. Revised Miran 30(b)(6) depo outline and prepared for depo. 2.00 1,460.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/03/2015 Prepared for Miran deposition (.30). organized L drive by renaming documents in a systematic and uniform way per Kurt Denk's request (2.10). 2.40 840.00




17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/03/2015Revised Miran 30(b)(6) depo outline and prepared for depo; conference w/ S. Sparling re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re discovery matters and fact‐gathering projects. 4.50 3,285.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/03/2015 Retailer review; developing case task list. 7.50 4,125.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/03/2015 Discussed 30(b)(6) deposition w/KD; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 0.70 647.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/04/2015Attended to page checking documents for 30(b)(6) deposition; reviewed docket for copies of pleadings filed for purposes of updating litigation binder and computer drive 5.00 1,750.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/04/2015Prepared for/participated in weekly co‐counsel management call; correspondence w/ D. Goldman re same. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re discovery matters and fact‐gathering projects. Revised Miran 30(b)(6) depo outline and prepared for depo; conference w/ S. Sparling re same. 5.20 3,796.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/04/2015 Review e‐mails re: class mailing list; review of new firm task list; e‐mail to S. Sparling; review draft stipulation re: FSI e‐mails 2.00 2,240.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/04/2015 Retailer review. 10.40 5,720.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/04/2015 Management Committee call; reviewed and commented on 30(b)(6) witness outline; discussed same w/KD. 2.70 2,497.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/05/2015 Prepared for Emmanuel Miran deposition (.40); continued to update litigation binder and computer drive of pleadings filed (6.20). 6.60 2,310.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/05/2015 Finalized Miran 30(b)(6) depo outline and prepared for depo; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling and vendor (C. Fletcher) re same. 5.50 4,015.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/05/2015 Retailer review. 7.70 4,235.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/05/2015 Discussed 30(b)(6) deposition w/KD. 0.10 92.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/06/2015Prepared for deposition of Emmanuel Miran (1.70); reviewed deposition transcripts for Kurt Denk to ascertain if depositions took place around November 2014 (.20); 1.90 665.00


Prepared for and took Miran 30(b)(6) deposition; drafted and circulated depo summary and completed follow‐up admin tasks pertaining to same. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling and S. Sivan re ongoing fact development projects and case status; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails pertaining to same 7.20 5,256.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/06/2015 Review draft letter re: taking depositions of witnesses on witness lists; e‐mail to team re: same 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/06/2015 Privilege log review; providing assistance for 30(b)(6) deposition. 2.60 1,430.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/06/2015 Attended Miran deposition; discussed same w/KD; reviewed and revised summary of same. 4.50 4,162.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/07/2015Completed follow‐up admin tasks pertaining to 30(b)(6) deposition. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re ongoing fact development projects and case status; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails pertaining to same. 0.70 511.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/07/2015 Privilege log review. 0.30 165.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/08/2015 Reviewed NAM privilege log; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. 1.00 730.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/08/2015 Privilege log review. 0.20 110.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/10/2015Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Reviewed NAM privilege log; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same, and re fact development projects. Drafted trial prep calendar and task list and circulated to S. Sparling. 5.60 4,088.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/10/2015 Review e‐mails re: FSI stipulation of dismissal; review Mackie‐Mason and Pfau e‐mails re: potential work 0.50 560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/10/2015 Privilege log review; associates' call; case management tasks. 2.40 1,320.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/10/2015 Discussed open issues w/KD; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 0.10 92.50


Prepared for/participated in weekly management team call; drafted and circulated to D. Goldman, summary re same. Reviewed 30(b)(6) transcript and sent summary memo to S. Sparling pertaining to follow‐up points with adversary. Calls/correspondence w/ associates team and S. Sivan re NAM privilege log, and w/ S. Sivan re fact development projects. 2.90 2,117.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/11/2015 C/w K. Denk; review e‐mails re: class mailing list 0.50 560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/11/2015 Retailer review. 8.30 4,565.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/11/2015 Management call; follow up discussion w/KD; reviewed task list and calendar prepared by KD and SS. 1.30 1,202.50 07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 08/12/2015 Upload electronic documents to review database, perform quality control checks and make same available to legal team in review database. 0.80 240.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/12/2015Conference w/ S. Sparling re 30(b)(6) follow‐up and case status. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re NAM privilege log and fact development projects; reviewed background material pertaining to same. Calls/emails w/ S. Cipolla re case management calendar. 3.90 2,847.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/12/2015 C/w S. Sparling re: trial prep division of duties 0.50 560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/12/2015 News America privilege log review; retailer review. 10.40 5,720.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/12/2015 Reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel; discussed ongoing projects w/associates; reviewed background documents. 2.00 1,850.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/13/2015Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan and co‐counsel associates re NAM privilege log and fact development projects; reviewed NAM revised priv log and circulated summary memo and work product re same to team. Reviewed/responded to misc emails pertaining to case status and diligence items. 4.30 3,139.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/13/2015 E‐mails re: response to defense counsel concerning FSI stipulations; c/ws S. Sparling 2.00 2,240.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/13/2015 Retailer review. 5.90 3,245.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/13/2015 Reviewed privilege log issue email; responded to same; met w/KD re: trial prep issues. 1.20 1,110.00




17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/14/2015Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan and co‐counsel associates re NAM privilege log and fact development projects. Reviewed/responded to misc emails pertaining to case status and diligence items. 1.00 730.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/14/2015 C/ws K. Denk and S. Sparling; review revised Carlucci materials 4.00 4,480.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/14/2015 Retailer review. 5.20 2,860.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/14/2015 Met w/D. Goldman to discuss open projects and issues; met w/S. Sivan re: follow up discovery and trial prep issues. 1.10 1,017.50 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/15/2015 Retailer review. 4.00 2,200.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/16/2015 Review of News America privilege log. 0.20 110.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/17/2015Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan and co‐counsel associates re NAM privilege log and fact development projects; completed further priv log review and miscellaneous diligence items pertaining to same. Reviewed/responded to misc emails pertaining to case status and diligence items. 1.10 803.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/17/2015 C/w K. Denk and S. Sparling re: trial prep tasks; review revised Carlucci outline and prepare for Carlucci deposition 7.00 7,840.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/17/2015 Review of NAM privilege log; retailer review. 3.90 2,145.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/17/2015 Reviewed deposition transcript. 1.90 1,757.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/18/2015 prepared calendar of deadlines for Kurt Denk and Shaked Sivan (2.30); finalized witness list for Shaked Sivan (.40). 2.70 945.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/18/2015Prepared for/participated in weekly associates, and weekly MC calls. Reviewed/responded to follow‐up correspondence w/ S. Sivan and co‐counsel associates re NAM privilege log and fact development projects. Reviewed/responded to misc emails pertaining to case status and diligence items. 1.20 876.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/18/2015 Review drafts of letter re: privilege log; participate in management call; Carlucci deposition prep 6.00 6,720.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/18/2015 Retailer review. 9.10 5,005.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/18/2015 Reviewed Berg deposition; emailed w/team re: discovery issues. 3.60 3,330.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/19/2015 Continued to revise chart regarding deponents (1.50). 1.50 525.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/19/2015Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re NAM privilege log and fact development projects. Reviewed/responded to misc emails w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re case status, additional discovery tasks, and misc. diligence items. 1.10 803.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/19/2015 C/w S. Sparling re: Kmart subpoena; Carlucci deposition prep 6.00 6,720.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/19/2015 Retailer review. 12.00 6,600.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/19/2015 Reviewed Berg deposition transcript; emailed w/team re: subpoena. 2.70 2,497.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/20/2015 continued to update chart regarding various deponents and their affiliations 2.80 980.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/20/2015Reviewed S. Sivan retailer analysis work product, and circulated summary of same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re NAM privilege log and fact development projects. 3.30 2,409.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/20/2015 Prepare for Carlucci; c/ws S. Sparling; K. Denk and S. Sivan 7.00 7,840.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/20/2015 Retailer review. 7.80 4,290.00 07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 08/21/2015 Upload electronic documents to review database, perform quality control checks and make same available to legal team in review database. 2.80 840.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/21/2015 Finalized chart of deponents 2.50 875.00


Reviewed S. Sivan retailer analysis work product, and circulated summary of same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling; drafted summary memo and circulated same to co‐counsel associates team; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re case status, NAM privilege log, and misc diligence items. 2.10 1,533.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/21/2015 prepare for Carlucci; e‐mails re: FSI dismissal 4.00 4,480.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/21/2015 Retailer review. 8.50 4,675.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/21/2015 Emailed re: privilege issues. 0.20 185.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/23/2015Reviewed retailer analysis work product circulated by co‐counsel. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same and misc diligence items. Reviewed materials for preparation of third‐party subpoena. 1.40 1,022.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/23/2015 Call with Kurt Denk to discuss fact development tasks. 0.20 110.00


Reviewed materials for preparation of third‐party subpoena (Kmart), drafted subpoena, and circulated to S. Sparling for review. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re retailer memos, fact development projects, and misc diligence items. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Reviewed subsequent retailer analysis work product circulated by co‐counsel. 5.80 4,234.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/24/2015Review e‐mails re: FSI dismissal; review and comment upon draft subpoena to Kmart; c/ws K. Denk; review memo re: Food Lion and Delahaze contract negotiation; prepare for Carlucci; t/c J. Southwick re: assessment issues 7.00 7,840.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/24/2015 Document review of custodians' documents produced by Defendants after discovery cutoff; development of witness list. 2.70 1,485.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/24/2015 Emailed w/team re: subpoena for KMart and reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 0.20 185.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/25/2015Reviewed filed pleading and added same to database per Kurt Denk's instructions (.20); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding upcoming assignments (.40); reviewed retailer agreements (.20). 0.80 280.00





Completed follow‐up revisions and diligence items pertaining to third‐party subpoena (Kmart); calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly MC call; conference w/ D. Goldman re case status and diligence items. Prepared and circulated potential trial witness list. Reviewed retailer analysis work product circulated by co‐counsel. 7.50 5,475.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/25/2015 Attend management conference; review e‐mails re: assessments; prepare for Carlucci 6.70 7,504.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/25/2015 Development of witness list. 0.10 55.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/25/2015 Reviewed and commented on draft subpoena. Emailed w/K. Denk re: same; emailed w/team re: discovery issues. 2.70 2,497.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/26/2015 Finalized calendar of events for Kurt Denk and Shaked Sivan; reviewed DM 5 for copy of cover letter regarding transcript and errata form; 3.60 1,260.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/26/2015Reviewed supplemental request for admission served by adversary, and completed misc legal and fact research pertaining to same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman and client pertaining to same. 3.80 2,774.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/26/2015Review NAM’s third RFA; review related documents to NAM’s third RFA; review Kraft/Heinz corporate structure; review e‐mails re: assessments; prepare for Carlucci; review of memos re: NAM’s retailer contracts 7.00 7,840.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/26/2015 Emails re: discovery related issues. 0.30 277.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/27/2015 Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding retailer memos(.10); reviewed same and added same to L drive (.20). 0.30 105.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/27/2015Calls/correspondence (D. Goldman, S. Sparling, co‐counsel) and completed misc diligence items pertaining to request for admission served by adversary, and preparation of third‐party subpoena. 0.90 657.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/27/2015 Review of e‐mails re: assessments; review of e‐mails re: Kmart subpoena; prepare for Carlucci 4.00 4,480.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/27/2015 Reviewed fact background memoranda; emailed w/team re: discovery issues. 7.60 7,030.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/28/2015conferred with Kurt Denk regarding Jury Instructions (.20); reviewed DM5 for copies of examples (.80); reviewed cases regarding Jury Instructions per Kurt Denk's instructions (.90). 1.90 665.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 08/28/2015Completed misc diligence items pertaining to request for admission served by adversary, and third‐party subpoena. Completed pretrial prep diligence items: researched jury instructions. 1.10 803.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 08/31/2015Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding LTS invoices (.10); attended to same (.30); reviewed retailer memos regarding staggering (.30); prepared spreadsheet for Retailer references 6.60 2,310.00


Completed misc diligence items pertaining to request for admission served by adversary, and third‐party subpoena; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call re case status and diligence items. Reviewed co‐counsel fact development work product and revised Carlucci depo outline in light of same. 4.50 3,285.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 08/31/2015 T/c S. Hudson of Kraft/Heinz re: NAM’s 3rd RFA; e‐mail K. Gallo re: Carlucci deposition; review memos re: retailer contracts; prepare for Carlucci 8.00 8,960.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 08/31/2015 Weekly call with associates at co‐counsel; discussion of fact development tasks with Kurt Denk and Santo Cipolla. 0.50 275.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 08/31/2015 Email to B. Michael re: discovery issues; discussed projects w/K. Denk; reviewed memoranda prepared by co‐counsel and team. 8.10 7,492.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 09/01/2015Conferred with Conference Center Services and Security for upcoming deposition of Paul Carlucci (.40); conference with Kurt Denk regarding various assignments (.40); reviewed local drive for additional Carlucci documents (.70); attended to preparation of binders regarding retailer memos (5.40) 6.90 2,415.00


Prepared for/participated in weekly MC call re case status and diligence items; follow‐up conference w/ D. Goldman re same, and re Carlucci deposition prep. Prepared for/participated in conference call w/ S. Sparling and adversary re 30(b)(6) deposition follow‐up. Conference/correspondence w/ S. Cipolla re diligence on admin tasks. 1.70 1,241.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/01/2015 Review emails re: privilege log; prepare for Carlucci deposition 6.00 6,720.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/01/2015Management call; call w/D. Goldman re: next steps; call w/B. Michael and K. Denk re: discovery issues; discussed same w/K. Denk; reviewed background memos from co‐counsel. 3.00 2,775.00


Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding non Kramer Levin Retailer Memo documents (.20); prepared binders for team consisting of documents relating to various retailer memos not created by Kramer Levin (3.10); reviewed Paul Carlucci deposition outline for additional documents that might be used during the deposition (1.80). 5.10 1,785.00


Completed misc. diligence items pertaining to Carlucci deposition prep; reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman re same. Conducted legal research re privilege waivers and circulated summary analysis memo to D. Goldman & S. Sparling re same. Prepared for/held conference call w/ C. Fletcher (vendor, OmniVere) re 30(b)(6) deposition follow‐up; completed misc diligence items and drafted work product pertaining to same, and circulated to S. Sparling for review. Correspondence w/ S. Cipolla re diligence on admin tasks. 7.90 5,767.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/02/2015Emails to R. McLeod of Doar re: Carlucci deposition; t/c S. Hudson re: Kraft and Doug Cherry; prepare for Carlucci deposition; attend management committee call; review attorney work research re: NAM’s third RFA 7.00 7,840.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/02/2015 Document review; NAM privilege log review. 0.30 165.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/02/2015Reviewed email from KD re: legal research; emailed w/team re: same; reviewed memoranda on contract issues; discussed trial projects w/team; reviewed deposition and background documents. 7.60 7,030.00





Conference with Kurt Denk regarding Docugate documents (.30); conducted research to create list of Docugate documents per Kurt Denk's instructions (.70); conferred with Kevin Olsavsky regarding upcoming deposition of Paul Carlucci (.30); reviewed Giant Eagle memo and added documents to spreadsheet per Kurt Denk's instructions (.40); reviewed documents to be used during Carlucci deposition (2.50). 4.20 1,470.00


Completed misc. diligence items pertaining to Carlucci deposition prep. Conducted follow‐up fact development and legal research re 30(b)(6) deposition diligence and privilege waivers; conference w/ S. Sparling re same; revised and circulated summary analysis memos to D. Goldman & S. Sparling re same. Correspondence w/ S. Cipolla re diligence on admin tasks. 3.70 2,701.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/03/2015Review emails from J. Briody and K. Denk re: NAM’s RFA; review K. Denk email re: 30b6 deposition on NAM’s document production; prepare for Carlucci deposition 5.00 5,600.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/03/2015 Document review. 0.20 110.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/03/2015Reviewed privilege law research; met w/KD to discuss same; reviewed memoranda on contract issues; reviewed deposition transcripts; emails w/co‐counsel re: open issues. 7.30 6,752.50


Conference with Kurt Denk regarding additional documents to be added to Paul Carlucci folder (.30): attended to same (.40); updated binders of Paul Carlucci documents for Shaked Sivan, Steven Sparling, Kurt Denk and Dan Goldman (2.0); assisted counsel with preparation for Paul Carlucci deposition (3.50). 6.20 2,170.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 09/04/2015Completed additional diligence items and outline revision in preparation for Carlucci deposition; supervised work product of paralegal S. Cipolla re same. Reviewed fact materials and legal research re legal themes for development of deposition and pretrial work product (retailer issues and staggering). 5.40 3,942.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/04/2015 Review emails and email re: NAM’s request for an extended summary judgment brief page limit; prepare for Carlucci deposition 4.30 4,816.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/04/2015 Document review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 1.20 660.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/04/2015 Emailed w/co‐counsel re: summary judgment issues. 0.20 185.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/05/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts 7.20 6,660.00


reviewed binders containing Kmart Retailer Memo, conferred with Kurt Denk regarding documents that were produced via Docugate; revised chart to reflect additional documents; conference with Document Processing regarding NAM Organizational chart; distributed binders internally to the team; prepared final preparations for Paul Carlucci deposition 6.80 2,380.00


Prepared for and participated in weekly MC call; conference w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re case status, Carlucci depo prep, and related diligence items. Completed additional diligence items and outline revision in preparation for Carlucci deposition; supervised work product of paralegal S. Cipolla re same. Revised materials for D. Goldman in connection with third‐party subpoenas (Kmart). 10.40 7,592.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/08/2015 Prepare for Carlucci deposition 8.00 8,960.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/08/2015 Document review; review of potential third party subpoena. 1.10 605.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/08/2015Management call; discussed projects and next steps w/KD and DG; reviewed correspondence and draft letters from co‐counsel; t/c w/D. Goldman re: Carlucci deposition; reviewed deposition transcripts. 6.20 5,735.00


conference with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of Paul Carlucci deposition including obtaining copy of thumb drive for videos to be used during deposition; conferred with Conference Center Services regarding large room to be used during deposition; updated memo with documents regarding Kmart; updated binders for upcoming deposition; conferred and reviewed changes to NAM Organizational chart 5.20 1,820.00


Calls/conferences/emails w/ D. Goldman re Carlucci depo prep and related diligence items; conference w/ R. McLeod (DOAR) re depo exhibits; completed additional diligence items and outline revision in preparation for same; supervised work product of paralegal S. Cipolla re same. Reviewed adversary letter re privilege log issues, and reviewed internal work product and records pertaining to same. 6.70 4,891.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/09/2015 Mtw R. McLeod for Carlucci video cuts; prepare for depositions 9.00 10,080.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/09/2015 Review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 0.70 385.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/09/2015 Reviewed emails from co‐counsel; reviewed deposition transcripts and memoranda from co‐counsel re: factual issues. 6.50 6,012.50


Final preparation for Paul Carlucci deposition including but not limited to preparing documents to be used during deposition; conferred with Kurt Denk regarding revisions to his full set of binders to be used during the deposition; prepared binder of documents to be used during Carlucci deposition for Dan Goldman, Steve Sparling, Kurt Denk and Shaked Sivan; prepared binder for Dan Goldman's outline; 8.00 2,800.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 09/10/2015Finalized preparation of materials for Carlucci deposition; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman re same; supervised work product of paralegal S. Cipolla re same. 5.10 3,723.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/10/2015 Prepare for Carlucci deposition` 8.50 9,520.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/10/2015 Review in preparation for Carlucci deposition. 0.40 220.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/10/2015 Reviewed outline for Carlucci deposition; discussed same w/team; reviewed background documents; reviewed deposition transcripts. 7.60 7,030.00


prepared for Paul Carlucci deposition (.80); conference with Kurt Denk regarding additional documents to be used during the deposition (.20); reviewed database and made appropriate copies for deposition (.40); reviewed rough draft of Paul Carlucci Deposition Transcript (.20); Added same to local drive (.20). 1.80 630.00




17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 09/11/2015Prepared for and second‐seated Carlucci deposition; drafted summary memo of same and circulated to co‐counsel; completed misc diligence follow‐up following deposition. 6.70 4,891.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/11/2015 Prepare for and take the deposition of Carlucci; revise Carlucci depo summary for counsel team 5.00 5,600.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/11/2015 Attended Carlucci deposition; discussed same and next steps w/team; reviewed email re: same; reviewed deposition transcript. 6.40 5,920.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 09/14/2015Reviewed documents in connection with updating plaintiff privilege logs / challenging NAM logs; correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Completed misc case management diligence items. 3.20 2,336.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/14/2015 Review of Heinz privilege log; associates' call. 1.80 990.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/14/2015 Reviewed emails from co‐counsel; emailed w/team re: projects. 0.30 277.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 09/15/2015 Attended to shredding documents from Carlucci deposition 0.40 140.00


Prepared for/participated in weekly management call; follow‐up conference w/ D. Goldman re open diligence items. Reviewed documents in connection with updating plaintiff privilege logs / challenging NAM logs; correspondence w/ S. Sivan and co‐counsel re same. Conducted research on NAM corporate structures and sent summary memo re same to KL team. Completed misc case management and fact development diligence items. 7.30 5,329.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/15/2015 Attend management committee call; review draft letter to the court re: privileged documents 1.00 1,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/15/2015 Privilege log review. 0.30 165.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/15/2015Management call; reviewed and commented on draft letter to court; t/c w/DG re: same; call w/KD re: projects; emails w/co‐counsel; reviewed deposition transcripts. 6.30 5,827.50

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/16/2015 C/ws co‐counsel re: strategy; review draft letter to court; review memo re: law applicable to summary judgment 4.00 4,480.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/16/2015 Privilege log review; meeting with Steve Sparling. 0.50 275.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/16/2015 Attended court hearing [TIME TO BE WRITTEN OFF] 0.50 462.50 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/16/2015 Discussed developments with D. Goldman and R. Hess; discussed strategy re: same w/D. Goldman; discussed same w/K. Denk and S. Sivan. 1.50 1,387.50 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/17/2015 Review and revise letter to court; c/ws co‐counsel 4.00 4,480.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 09/17/2015Review, edit and revise letter to Judge Pauley concerning split role between lead and trial counsel; research cases in the second circuit permitting separate trial counsel role in class action lawsuits 2.00 1,560.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/17/2015 Reviewed and revised letter to the court; discussed same and next steps w/D. Goldman. 1.00 925.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/18/2015 Review and respond to e‐mails re: letter to Judge Pauley 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/18/2015 Pulling cases in opponent's letters to the court and discussed during court conference. 1.40 770.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/18/2015 T/c w/DG re: status of letter to court; reviewed materials and research for summary judgment briefing. 4.30 3,977.50 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/19/2015 Review and respond to e‐mail re: taking of depositions of third party witnesses 0.30 336.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 09/21/2015Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Reviewed documents in connection with updating plaintiff privilege logs; correspondence w/ S. Sivan and co‐counsel re same. 0.80 584.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/21/2015 Associates' call. 0.10 55.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/21/2015 Reviewed case law re: summary judgment issues in anticipation of opposition briefing; discussed case status w/DG. 6.40 5,920.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 09/22/2015 Created binder of Mackie Mason Expert Reports and Expert from the News for Steven Sparling 1.00 350.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 09/22/2015Prepared for/participated in weekly management call; follow‐up conference w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re open diligence items. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence re same. 1.20 876.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/22/2015 Management committee phone call 0.50 560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/22/2015 Privilege log review. 0.20 110.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/22/2015Management Committee call; discussed next steps w/DG and KD; reviewed expert reports and background materials in anticipation of summary judgment briefing. 6.20 5,735.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/23/2015 Reviewed expert reports and background materials re: summary judgment briefing issues. 8.30 7,677.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 09/24/2015Prepared binder of cases cited in Summary Judgment motion; reviewed depositions transcripts of Paul Carlucci and updated records; reviewed docket for copy of latest version of Case Management Order specifying close of discovery; conferred with Kurt Denk regarding same. 2.00 700.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 09/24/2015Reviewed documents in connection with updating plaintiff privilege logs; correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Drafted and revised responses/objections to adversary's third set of requests for admission, and circulated same to KL team and co‐counsel. 4.70 3,431.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/24/2015 Review draft response to NAM’s third set of RFA to Kraft/Heinz; t/c S. Sparling and K. Denk re: same; review class opt notice and e‐mails re: same 1.50 1,680.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/24/2015 Readying and reviewing small production of redacted and/or formerly withheld documents. 0.90 495.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/24/2015 Reviewed response to RFAs; discussed same w/team; reviewed case law, documents, and expert reports for summary judgment issues. 7.40 6,845.00


Reviewed documents in connection with updating plaintiff privilege logs / supplemental production; correspondence w/ S. Sivan re same. Reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel correspondence re responses/objections to adversary's third set of requests for admission. Reviewed materials in preparation for summary judgment briefing. 2.00 1,460.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/25/2015 S. Berry summary of issues re: NAM's s/j motion 0.50 560.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/25/2015 Reviewing small production of redacted and/or formerly withheld documents. 0.60 330.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/25/2015Reviewed materials for summary judgment briefing; outlined issues for briefing re: same; t/c w/S. Sivan re: next steps for summary judgment preparation; emailed w/co‐counsel re: RFA response. 8.70 8,047.50

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/27/2015 reviewed emails from co‐counsel re: summary judgment issues. 0.10 92.50


Reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel correspondence re responses/objections to adversary's third set of requests for admission; completed and circulated revisions thereto. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence re pending task items and scheduling. 1.20 876.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/28/2015 Review S. Berry e‐mails 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/28/2015 Gathering cases discussed in emails among co‐counsel. 0.30 165.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/28/2015Call w/DG re: open issues and next steps; reviewed emails from co‐counsel; reviewed legal analysis and case law from co‐counsel on SJ issues; reviewed background fact memoranda for SJ purposes. 7.20 6,660.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 09/29/2015 conferences with help desk and TSG Court reporting regarding failure to load video depositions 1.50 525.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 09/29/2015Completed misc diligence items pertaining to Carlucci deposition follow‐up; correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re same. Reviewed case law and work product circulated by co‐counsel in anticipation of summary judgment pleadings. 2.60 1,898.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/29/2015 Review e‐mails re: management committee; review video of Carlucci deposition 1.00 1,120.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/29/2015 Emails w/co‐counsel re: summary judgment issues. 0.10 92.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 09/30/2015compared Miran deposition transcript to errata sheet for possible changes in meaning of testimony (.70); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding same (.10); conference with TSG regarding ability to play video depositions (.80). 1.60 560.00


Completed misc diligence items pertaining to Miran deposition follow‐up; correspondence w/ S. Sparling re same. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence re third‐party depositions, reviewed deposition material from Valassis litigation and conducted follow‐up fact research, and circulated summary analysis re same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling; reviewed/responded to KL team correspondence re same. Reviewed case law and work product circulated by co‐counsel in anticipation of summary judgment pleadings. 3.90 2,847.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 09/30/2015 Review S. Berry memo re: depositions of third parties; review Mazetti deposition, former Heinz employee; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk 1.00 1,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 09/30/2015 Gathering and review of past deposition of client employee. 0.30 165.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 09/30/2015 Reviewed evidence re: summary judgment issues; emailed w/team re: deposition issues; reviewed deposition transcript. 3.20 2,960.00


Conferred with Shaked Sivan and Kurt Denk regarding preparation of binders regarding pleadings filed by Defendants' in Support of Their Motion for Summary Judgment; and case binders relating to cases cited in Summary Judgment Brief and motion in limine brief (.30); conducted research to obtain copies of same (1.40); prepared Index to binders (2.40); prepared copies for team (2.20). 6.30 2,205.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/01/2015Reviewed adversary's summary judgment and Daubert motion papers; calls/conferences with KL team and co‐counsel conference call re same. Completed misc admin tasks / supervised paralegal S. Cipolla in organization of materials for drafting opposition papers. 8.80 6,424.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/01/2015Review News Corp.’s moving papers in support of summary judgment and motions in limine; conference call with management team; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk; t/cs L. LeClair 6.00 6,720.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/01/2015 Reading summary judgment motion and related briefs. 1.70 935.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/01/2015 Reviewed summary judgment papers; discussed same w/team. 7.80 7,215.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/02/2015Prepared case binders relating to Defendants' Motion for Summary judgment and case binder relating to motion to exclude testimony of Paul Ferris and Dr. Mackie‐Mason (6.20); obtained copies of Dr. Mackie‐Mason transcript and forwarded same to Steve Sparling (.20); 6.60 2,310.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/02/2015 Reviewed adversary's summary judgment and Daubert motion papers; took memo notes re same in preparation for drafting opposition papers. 5.50 4,015.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/02/2015 Review News Corp. papers in support of summary judgment including motions in limine 8.00 8,960.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/02/2015 Pulling documents; beginning research for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 0.60 330.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/02/2015 Reviewed summary judgment and motion in limine papers; t/c w/D. Goldman re: same; outlined response issues. 9.70 8,972.50 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/04/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 4.20 2,310.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/05/2015Created binder of Michael exhibits for Shaked Sivan in preparation of upcoming meeting; updated binders regarding cases cited in motion in limine brief relating to Mackie‐Mason; reviewed computer drive for copies of Court depositions and moved same to new location per Kurt Denk's instructions 7.00 2,450.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/05/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; correspondence/calls w/ KL team re same, and re case status and diligence items. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call 10.90 7,957.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/05/2015 Review motion in limine re: Mackie Mason and his 2 reports; mtw team re: opposition to motion in limine 5.00 5,600.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/05/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 8.00 4,400.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/05/2015 Discussed motion and limine and summary judgment w/team; reviewed pleadings and evidence regarding same; prepared for response to same. 9.30 8,602.50




17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/06/2015Prepared for/participated in weekly management committee call. Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; correspondence/calls w/ KL team re same, and re case status and diligence items. 8.80 6,424.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/06/2015 Participate in management call; c/w S. Sparling and K. Denk 0.50 560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/06/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 5.40 2,970.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/06/2015 Management committee call; discussed MIL w/team; reviewed materials and evidence re: same. 8.20 7,585.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/07/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; correspondence/calls w/ KL team re same. 8.30 6,059.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/07/2015 Review memo from R. Pfau of ApplEcon concerning criticisms of Mackie‐Mason market definition opinions 1.00 1,120.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/07/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 2.20 1,210.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/07/2015 Discussed MIL response w/team; reviewed materials/evidence in anticipation for response to same. 10.20 9,435.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/08/2015created binder of MacKie‐Mason Merits Reports Exhibits for Kurt Denk (.40); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding page references to various Daubert motion references to MacKie‐Mason evidence (.40); created chart regarding same for future reference (.30). 1.10 385.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/08/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; correspondence/calls w/ KL team re same. Prepared for and participated in conference call with expert and KL team. 8.40 6,132.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/08/2015

Prepare for and participate in phone conference with R. Pfau of ApplEcon re: News Corp.’s criticisms of Mackie‐Mason’s opinions in News Corp.’s motion in limine; review memo from R. Pfau re: motion in limine re: Mackie‐Mason; c/ws S. Sparling, K. Denk and S. Sivan re: opposition to Mackie‐Mason motion in limine; review News Corps. response to draft letter to Judge Pauley on privileged documents and emails to counsel group re: same 3.50 3,920.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/08/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; call with Rick Pfau. 3.80 2,090.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/08/2015Reviewed materials in prep. for MIL response; discussed same w/team; call w/expert re: same; reviewed and discussed draft discovery dispute letter; discussed management committee issues w/DG. 8.30 7,677.50


Created binders of cases decided by Judge Pauley as it relates to Summary Judgment (1.30); updated expert's deposition transcript binder as it relates to MacKie_Mason Daubert Motion per Kurt Denk's instructions (.60); Reviewed Court's docket sheet and obtained copy of various pleadings (2.0); created binder of MacKie‐Mason Merits Reports‐Exhibits for Kurt Denk (.70). 4.60 1,610.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/09/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; correspondence/calls w/ KL team re same. 7.40 5,402.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/09/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 3.50 1,925.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/09/2015 Reviewed evidentiary materials in connection w/MIL response; discussed same w/KD; t/c to DG re: same. 8.90 8,232.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/10/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; correspondence/calls w/ KL team re same. 5.80 4,234.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/10/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 3.30 1,815.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/10/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts in connection with MIL response. 3.00 2,775.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/11/2015 Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 7.10 5,183.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/12/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Conference w/ S. Sparling re same; reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same. 10.90 7,957.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/12/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 3.90 2,145.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/12/2015 Reviewed cases and evidence re: MIL response; discussed same w/team; drafted outline of evidentiary proof re: same. 10.40 9,620.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/13/2015Conducted research to obtain copies of cases for Steve Sparling regarding MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion (1.10); prepared binder regarding same including preparation of Index (3.10); conducted research for copies of additional cases for Steve Sparling's review (.50). 4.70 1,645.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/13/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same. 14.40 10,512.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/13/2015 T/c Valerie Bomar, Senior Counsel, Kraft Heinz re: status of case against News Corp. 0.50 560.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/13/2015 Research for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 7.60 4,180.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/13/2015 Reviewed evidence re: MIL response; drafted outline re: same; reviewed cases re: same; discussed MIL response w/team 9.20 8,510.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/14/2015conferred with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of case binder for Steven Sparling (.30); attended to same (3.20).; attended to updating Table of Contents to binder of authorities cited in Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Motion in Limine to exclude testimony of Dr, MacKie‐Mason (2.30). 5.80 2,030.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/14/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Conference, and follow‐up calls/correspondence, w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same. 11.40 8,322.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/14/2015 Management committee call 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/14/2015 Research for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 8.70 4,785.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/14/2015 Edited and revised MIL response; reviewed research for same; discussed MIL w/team. 13.70 12,672.50





Conference with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of binder of cases and authorities for Dan Goldman (.30); attended to same (.80); conducted research to obtain copies of cases for Steven Sparling (.40); prepared binder of documents for Steven Sparling (.90); reviewed cases and authorities for case binder (2.90). 5.30 1,855.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/15/2015Reviewed materials and cases, conducted research, and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Calls/correspondence, w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re adversary filings and diligence items. 13.60 9,928.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/15/2015Review of memo from R. Pfau of ApplEcon re: News Corp.’s motion for summary judgment; review letter from K. Gallo to Court re: request to speak to in‐house counsel for class members; e‐mails re: response strategy; review memo from S. Sivan re: individual settlements after class opt‐out period 2.00 2,240.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/15/2015 Research for reply to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; research into plaintiff communication with class members. 4.90 2,695.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/15/2015Edited and revised MIL response; discussed legal research w/S. Sivan; discussed MIL w/K. Denk; emails w/team re: same; reviewed court order on class counsel issue; t/c w/D. Goldman re: same. 13.50 12,487.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/16/2015Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding documents to be forwarded to Steve Sparling (.30); attended to same (1.10); prepared and finalized binder of authorities for Dan Goldman regarding MacKie‐Mason (5.20). 6.60 2,310.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/16/2015Conducted legal research and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Calls/correspondence, w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re adversary filings and diligence items. 7.30 5,329.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/16/2015 Review draft letter to court re: response to K. Gallo's letter requesting permission to contact class members for settlement purposes 0.30 336.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/16/2015 Research for reply to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 2.60 1,430.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/16/2015 Edited and revised response brief to MIL; discussed same w/team; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 16.20 14,985.00


18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/17/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 4.70 2,585.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/17/2015 Edited and revised response brief to MIL; discussed same w/team; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 14.50 13,412.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/18/2015Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding additional authorities to be included in Dan's binder (.30); conducted research to obtain copies of same and update index (2.70). 3.00 1,050.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/18/2015Reviewed/revised work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Calls/correspondence, w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly co‐counsel associates call. Correspondence w/ R. Caughey re depo facts for MSJ opposition 7.10 5,183.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/18/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 3.50 1,925.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/18/2015 Edited and revised response brief to MIL; discussed same w/team; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 14.30 13,227.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/19/2015 finalized binder of authorities on MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion (6.0); attended to cite checking brief (1.0). 7.00 2,450.00


18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/19/2015 Review and revise draft opposition to News Corp.'s motion in limine to exclude the opinions of Mackie‐Mason from evidence 5.00 5,600.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 10/19/2015Review and analyze defendants' motion in limine to exclude the expert testimony of Dr. MacKie‐Mason; review and analyze plaintiffs' draft opposition brief 2.50 1,950.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/19/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 3.90 2,145.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/19/2015 Edited and revised MIL brief; t/c w/S. Sivan re: same; emails w/team re: same; reviewed evidence and law in support of brief. 9.00 8,325.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/20/2015 Attended to cite checking Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Motion to exclude the testimony of Dr. MacKie‐Mason (7.0). 7.00 2,450.00


Conducted legal research and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment motion (injury/damages), and MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Calls/correspondence, w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & S. Sivan re same. Prepared for and participated in conference call with expert consultant R. Pfau. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re adversary filings and diligence items. 7.90 5,767.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/20/2015Review and revise memo of law in opposition to motion in limine to exclude testimony of Mackie‐Mason; t/c R. Pfau re: Mackie‐Mason's yardstick damages model; c/ws C. Pak re: distinguishing cases; management committee call 9.00 10,080.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 10/20/2015Review and analyze defendants' motion in limine to exclude the expert testimony of Dr. MacKie‐Mason; review cases and draft sections of plaintiffs' draft opposition brief 6.00 4,680.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/20/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 6.30 3,465.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/20/2015 Management call; discussed brief w/team; worked on same. 7.30 6,752.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/21/2015 finalized cite checking brief 5.00 1,750.00


Conducted legal research and drafted/revised work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment motion (injury/damages), and MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Calls/correspondence, w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & S. Sivan re same. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re adversary filings and diligence items. 13.10 9,563.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/21/2015 Revise memorandum of law in opposition to motion in limine to exclude testimony of Jeff MacKie‐Mason 9.00 10,080.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 10/21/2015 Review cases and draft sections of plaintiffs' opposition brief to defendants' motion to exclude MacKie‐Mason 8.40 6,552.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/21/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 3.00 1,650.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/21/2015 Discussed MIL w/team; reviewed and revised brief for same; reviewed legal research re: same; call w/Appelcon re: same. 9.20 8,510.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/22/2015 conferred with Steven Sparling regarding copies of damages cases on local drive (.10); obtained copies of cases for Steve Sparling (.20) 0.30 105.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/22/2015Reviewed/revised work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment motion (injury/damages), and MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Calls/correspondence, w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & S. Sivan re same. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re adversary filings and diligence items 14.20 10,366.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/22/2015 Revise memorandum of law in opposition to motion in limine to exclude testimony of Jeff MacKie‐Mason 10.00 11,200.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 10/22/2015Draft sections of plaintiffs' opposition brief to defendants' motion to exclude expert testimony of MacKie‐Mason; review and edit plaintiffs' draft opposition brief 2.50 1,950.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/22/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 5.90 3,245.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/22/2015 Worked on SJ rider; reviewed research re: same; discussed same w/KD; reviewed revisions to MIL brief; emailed w/team re: same. 12.30 11,377.50


Finalized and circulated work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment motion (injury/damages), and MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. Reviewed co‐counsel draft opposition papers; prepared for/participated in co‐counsel call re same. KL team calls/correspondence re same. Revised draft work product and conducted additional fact review and legal research. 7.60 5,548.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/23/2015 Revise MacKie‐Mason motion in limine opp., t/c R. Pfau; review draft opposition to motion for summary judgment 8.00 8,960.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 10/23/2015 Review and revise plaintiffs' draft opposition brief; research and review cases concerning benchmark analysis and averaging 3.80 2,964.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/23/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; reviewing documents for sealed submissions. 2.10 1,155.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/23/2015 Edited and revised MIL response and SJ rider; management call; discussed motions w/team; reviewed draft briefing. 8.20 7,585.00


Conducted follow‐up legal research and revised work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment motion (injury/damages), and MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling & S. Sivan re same. Reviewed co‐counsel draft opposition papers and 56.1 statement took memo notes re same. Revised draft work product and conducted additional fact review and legal research. 6.10 4,453.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/24/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 5.60 3,080.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/24/2015 Edited and revised brief in response to MIL; reviewed draft briefs from co‐counsel; reviewed legal research for briefing; discussed motions w/team. 8.30 7,677.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/25/2015Reviewed/revised work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment and Daubert motions; correspondence w/ KL team re same. Conducted additional fact review for contribution to 56.1 counter‐statement / plaintiffs statement (deposition testimony and exhibits). 9.40 6,862.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/25/2015 Review and comment on draft summary judgment brief, rule 56.1 statement, Farris motion in limine opposition 7.00 7,840.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 10/25/2015 Research antitrust cases in connection with plaintiffs' draft opposition brief to defendants' summary judgment motion 6.10 4,758.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/25/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion. 0.50 275.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/25/2015 Reviewed draft briefs; edited and revised riders for same; discussed same w/team; reviewed legal research for same. 7.20 6,660.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/26/2015 Attended to cite checking new version of Plaintiffs' Opposition of Defendants' Motion to Exclude the Testimony of Dr. Jeffrey MacKie‐Mason 8.70 3,045.00


Reviewed/revised work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment and Daubert motions; correspondence w/ KL team re same. Conducted additional fact review for contribution to 56.1 counter‐statement / plaintiffs statement (deposition testimony and exhibits). Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call re case status and diligence items. Correspondence/calls w/ client (V. Bomar & S. Hudson) re sealing of documents attached to News's summary judgment papers, and completed misc admin tasks pertaining to same. 10.20 7,446.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/26/2015 Revise MacKie‐Mason motion in limine brief; comments on summary judgment opposition brief; review case law 8.00 8,960.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 10/26/2015Conduct legal research in connection with plaintiffs' draft opposition brief to defendants' summary judgment motion and plaintiffs' draft opposition brief to defendants' motion to exclude; review and edit plaintiffs' draft opposition brief to defendants' motion to exclude` 7.30 5,694.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 10/26/2015 Reviewing Fourth Amended Complaint, Defendant's Memo in Support of Summary Judgment and case docket. 4.50 2,475.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/26/2015 Research and drafting for response to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; supplementing factual citations for 56.1 statement. 5.80 3,190.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/26/2015Reviewed and revised brief in response to MIL; reviewed legal research for same; discussed legal and evidentiary issues for same w/team; call w/AppleCon re: same; reviewed draft briefs from co‐counsel. 8.70 8,047.50


Conference with Kurt Denk regarding finalizing other authorities to be delivered to trial counsel (.30); reviewed same and finalized folder (.60); reviewed and revised Table of Authorities and Table of Contents (1.60); attended to cite checking new cases, created new version of brief and updated Table of Authorities (2.50). 5.00 1,750.00


Reviewed/revised work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment and Daubert motions; correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re same. Conducted additional fact review for contribution to 56.1 counter‐statement / plaintiffs statement (deposition testimony and exhibits). Prepared for/participated in weekly management team call re case status and diligence items. Correspondence/calls w/ client (V. Bomar & S. Hudson) re sealing of documents attached to News's summary judgment papers, and completed misc admin tasks pertaining to same. 7.90 5,767.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/27/2015 Revise briefs in opposition to NAM’s motions for summary judgment and in limine 6.00 6,720.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 10/27/2015Review, analyze and edit plaintiffs' draft opposition brief to defendants' motion to exclude MacKie‐Mason; review cases cited in plaintiffs' draft opposition brief 4.00 3,120.00




18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 10/27/2015 Reviewing MacKie‐Mason expert report, Defendants' rebuttal expert report, and Defendants' Daubert motion to exclude testimony. 5.80 3,190.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/27/2015 Reviewing drafts of opposition to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion and related materials. 1.80 990.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/27/2015Management call; discussed motions w/team; reviewed legal research for briefing; edited and revised MIL response; discussed same w/D. Goldman; discussed sealing declaration w/K. Denk; reviewed same. 8.50 7,862.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/28/2015Reviewed and Revised Table of Authorities (1.60); conference with Kurt Denk regarding same (.40); reviewed documents sent to local counsel for completeness (.60); attended to miscellaneous projects (1.40) 4.00 1,400.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/28/2015Reviewed/revised work product for opposition to defendants' summary judgment and Daubert motions; correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re same. Reviewed/revised 56.1 counter‐statement / plaintiffs statement. 8.20 5,986.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/28/2015 Revise briefs in opposition to NAM's motions for summary judgment and in limine 7.00 7,840.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 10/28/2015Reviewing MacKie‐Mason expert report, Defendants' rebuttal expert report, and Defendants' Daubert motion to exclude testimony (2). Reviewing cases cited in Daubert opposition motion for negative treatment (3.7). 5.70 3,135.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/28/2015 Research and drafting for reply to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; review and editing of 56.1 statement and other briefs. 5.10 2,805.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/28/2015 Reviewed and commented on draft motion papers; discussed same w/team. 8.20 7,585.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/29/2015reviewed and revised table of authorities per Kurt Denk's request (1.30); conference with Kurt Denk regarding final revisions to Table of Authorities (.40). 1.70 595.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/29/2015Finalized work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion; correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re same. Reviewed co‐counsel drafts of additional opposition work product. Correspondence w/ client re sealing of Heinz material. 4.80 3,504.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/29/2015 Revise briefs in opposition to NAM's motions for summary judgment and in limine 6.00 6,720.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/29/2015 Review of MacKie‐Mason declaration and discussion of contract length analysis. 1.30 715.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/29/2015 Reviewed and finalized briefs; discussed issues re: same w/team. 6.90 6,382.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 10/30/2015conferred with Kurt Denk regarding computer drive (.40); reviewed court docket and added documents to local drive (2.0); renamed various documents for consistency purposes (1.40). 3.80 1,330.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/30/2015Reviewed/finalized work product for opposition to defendants' MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion and summary judgment motion; correspondence w/ KL team and co‐counsel re same. Completed misc admin tasks pertaining to same. 6.20 4,526.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 10/30/2015 Review and revise briefs in opposition to NAM motions 5.00 5,600.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 10/30/2015 Meeting with SS and SS regarding trial preparation projects (.8). Reviewing J. Pauley individual rules and scheduling orders (.3). 1.10 605.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 10/30/2015 Reviewing Christopher Mixson deposition and exhibits. 3.70 2,035.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 10/30/2015 Editing drafts of reply to MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion and accompanying filings and exhibits. 2.70 1,485.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 10/30/2015Reviewed final motion papers; coordinated w/co‐counsel to correct papers; discussed same w/K. Denk; discussed next steps for trial prep w/S. Sivan and E. Rosoff; t/c w/D. Goldman re: same. 6.50 6,012.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 10/31/2015Reviewed final MSJ/Daubert opposition filings and completed misc admin tasks pertaining to same. Reviewed correspondence and files pertaining to case status and pretrial tasks, took memo notes and outlined workflows pertaining to same. 1.10 803.00


Conferred with Eric Rosoff regarding binders of exhibits to Caughey declaration in opposition to Defendants' motion for summary judgment (.30); conducted research to obtain copies of exhibits (2.0); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding issue with Dropbox and video clips (.20); follow‐up conference with Kurt Denk regarding video conference scheduled for Thursday (.30); conducted research to obtain copies of exhibits off Dropbox (1.40) 4.20 1,470.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/02/2015Reviewed fact materials relevant to developing pretrial task strategy and work product (timeline, witness lists); calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same, and reviewed work product of E. Rosoff re same. Prepared for and participated in weekly associates call. 3.30 2,409.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/02/2015 Management committee call; review emails re: mock trial prep; review NAM’s proposed trial schedule; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk 4.00 4,480.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/02/2015 Editing list of potential witnesses. 0.70 385.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/02/2015 Outlined issues for mock trial; discussed trial prep issues w/K. Denk; discussed next steps and trial prep issues w/D. Goldman. 6.90 6,382.50


Finalized four volume set of exhibits to Caughey's Declaration in Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment (2.40); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding revisions to binders (.20); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding associates meeting (.20); made preparations for same (.20); prepared binders of summary judgment documents for Dan Goldman, Steven Sparling, Shaked Sivan and Kurt Denk (4.0). 7.00 2,450.00


Prepared for and participated in weekly management team call. Conference w/ S. Sparling re trial prep strategy and tasks. Reviewed fact materials relevant to developing pretrial task strategy and work product (timeline, witness lists); calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same, and reviewed work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re same. Supervised work of paralegal S. Cipolla. Calls/correspondence with trial vendor personnel (E. Brickman ‐ DOAR) re mock trial. 6.90 5,037.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/03/2015Management committee call; emails re meeting with Doar; review proposed pre‐trial schedule; c/ws K. Denk and S. Sparling re: pre‐trial schedule; t/cs L. LeClair re mock trial; t/c J. Blackman re: mock trial 3.50 3,920.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/03/2015 Editing potential witness list. 4.10 2,255.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/03/2015Management call; discussed trial prep issues w/D. Goldman and K. Denk; drafted trial outlines; reviewed and commented on witness lists; reviewed key exhibits; discussed pre‐trial schedule w/co‐counsel and D. Goldman. 8.90 8,232.50




03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/04/2015Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding DOAR conference (.20); prepared for meeting (.30); updated binders per Kurt Denk's request (.60); downloaded JP Morgan document production per Kurt Denk's request (.40). 1.50 525.00


Conference w/ S. Sparling re trial prep strategy and tasks. Reviewed fact materials relevant to developing pretrial task strategy and work product (timeline, witness lists); calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same, and reviewed work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re same. Supervised work of paralegal S. Cipolla. 4.90 3,577.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/04/2015Emails re: pre‐trial schedule; t/c H. Weinberger re: voire dire in trials before Judge Pauley; c/ws. S. Sparling and K. Denk re: mock trial; email to L. LeClair re mock trial; review of MacKie‐Mason to prepare for mock trial and trial 5.00 5,600.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/04/2015 Editing potential witness list; doc review; reviewing CaseMap summaries of hot documents. 1.80 990.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/04/2015Discussed trial prep issues w/D. Goldman; drafted and revised trial outlines; discussed pre‐trial deadlines and tasks w/K. Denk; emailed w/co‐counsel re: pre‐trial issues; reviewed draft pre‐trial lists and commented on same. 7.00 6,475.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/05/2015 finalized binder of cases cited in pleadings on MacKie‐Mason Daubert motion (1.80). 1.80 630.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/05/2015 updated Kurt Denk's binders 2.40 840.00


Prepared for and participated in strategy meeting with mock trial/trial prep vendors (DOAR); follow‐up correspondence re same with E. Brickman (DOAR). Reviewed fact materials relevant to developing pretrial task strategy and work product (timeline, witness lists); calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same. 5.60 4,088.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/05/2015T/c J. Southwick re: conference before J. Pauley; prepare for and attend meeting with Doar re: Mock trial; mtw J. Briody re: mock trial; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk re: mock trial; email to J. Southwick re: summary judgment argument; review and revise pre‐trial deposition assignment list for designations 4.50 5,040.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/05/2015 Legal research regarding FRCP 32 admissibility of prior deposition testimony of a now‐deceased witness (2.3). 2.30 1,265.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/05/2015 Meeting with John Briody and DOAR regarding mock trial and trial strategy. 3.80 2,090.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/05/2015Meeting w/J. Briody, D. Goldman, K. Denk, S. Sivan, and trial consultant re: trial prep tasks and mock trial; worked on trial outline; reviewed evidence for same; discussed trial prep. tasks w/associates; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel re: trial issues 5.00 4,625.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/06/2015conducted research to obtain copies of cases referenced in pleadings regarding motion to exclude testimony of Dr. MacKie‐Mason (1.40); created index to same crossed checked for duplicates (3.10). 4.50 1,575.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/06/2015Correspondence with E. Brickman (DOAR) re mock trial/trial prep; follow‐up calls/correspondence re same w/ KL team and co‐counsel. Reviewed fact materials relevant to developing pretrial task strategy and work product (timeline, witness lists); calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same. 5.70 4,161.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/06/2015Review deposition and trial testimony to prepare for mock and actual trial including the testimony of George Rebh from Floorgraphics trial and testimony of Robert Emmel 5.00 5,600.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/06/2015 Meeting with SS, KD and SS regarding mock trial and trial prep tasks (.9). 0.90 495.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/06/2015 Meeting regarding pre‐trial tasks; document and transcript gathering in preparation for deposition designations. 2.70 1,485.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/06/2015 Worked on trial outlines; discussed trial prep tasks and PTO deadlines w/associates; reviewed deposition transcript for trial designation and trial prep 4.00 3,700.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/07/2015 Drafting memorandum re. admissibility of Rebh deposition under Rule 32 (5). 1.00 550.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/07/2015 Reviewed deposition transcript for trial designation and trial prep; reviewed market definition evidence for same. 3.00 2,775.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/08/2015 Review of deposition and trial testimony to prepare for mock and actual trial including testimony o George Rebh and Robert Emmel 4.00 4,480.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/08/2015 Designating deposition testimony of News witnesses Devoe and Barrette for potential use at trial. 1.00 550.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/09/2015 conference with Eric Rosoff regarding chart of potential trial exhibits (.40); prepared same (3.30). 3.70 1,295.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/09/2015Correspondence/calls w/ E. Brickman (DOAR) and KL team re mock trial/trial prep. Reviewed fact materials relevant to developing pretrial task strategy and work product (timeline, witness lists); calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same. 2.80 2,044.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/09/2015Review of deposition and trial testimony to prepare for mock and actual trial including testimony of George Henderson, Robert Emmel, George Rebh and Nancy Perkins 5.00 5,600.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/09/2015Preparing deposition designations of News witnesses Bernard, Benson, Devoe, Fasano, Feldgajer from prior litigations for potential use at trial; meeting with SAC regarding preparation of a master document index; reviewing Rule 32 memorandum to DG and SS. 4.00 2,200.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/09/2015 Pre‐trial tasks, including deposition gathering and review. 2.10 1,155.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/09/2015Discussed trial projects w/paralegal; worked on deposition designation for trial; emails and calls w/associates re: trial prep. issues; discussed same w/D. Goldman; drafted and revised trial outline. 4.00 3,700.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/10/2015 reviewed and revised spreadsheet of exhibits to Caughey Declaration 4.80 1,680.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/10/2015Prepared for/participated in weekly co‐counsel management call. Correspondence/calls w/ E. Brickman (DOAR) and KL team re mock trial/trial prep. Reviewed fact materials relevant to developing pretrial task strategy and work product (timeline, witness lists). 1.30 949.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/10/2015 Participate in management committee meeting; review trial and deposition testimony including testimony of Nancy Perkins 3.00 3,360.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 11/10/2015 Conf. DBG re: status, motion to exclude Carlton 0.30 288.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/10/2015 Pre‐trial tasks, including gathering and reviewing trial transcripts. 0.60 330.00




05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/10/2015 Management committee call; drafted and revised trial outlines; reviewed and analyzed evidence for the same; discussed trial projects w/associates 4.00 3,700.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/10/2015 Worked on updating exhibit chart for attorney reference in advance of trial. 3.00 1,050.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/11/2015 finalized spreadsheet breaking out Caughey Declaration exhibits 3.70 1,295.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/11/2015 Review trial and deposition testimony to prepare for mock and actual trial including testimony of Robert Ball and W. Naze 6.00 6,720.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/11/2015 Discussed trial preparation issues w/associates; drafted and revised trial outlines; reviewed and analyzed evidence for same 3.00 2,775.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/12/2015 prepared chart for Eric Rosoff regarding documents referenced in MacKie‐Mason Merits reports (5.70). 5.70 1,995.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/12/2015Prepared for/participated in KL strategy and workflow planning meeting. Reviewed fact materials relevant to developing pretrial work product; calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same. 4.40 3,212.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/12/2015 Review trial and deposition testimony to prepare for mock and actual trial including testimony of R. Kroc and J. Aversano 8.00 8,960.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 11/12/2015 Review Gitkin deposition. 2.00 1,850.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/12/2015 Meeting regarding pre‐trial tasks; review of client documents. 2.40 1,320.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/12/2015 Edited and revised trial outlines; discussed trial projects w/team. 4.00 3,700.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/12/2015 Finished working on excel spreadsheet identifying exhibits for attorney reference. 1.50 525.00


Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding Defendants' filed pleadings (.40); reviewed docket sheet for copies of same (.40); reviewed un redacted copies of pleadings filed by Defendants and added same to computer drive (1.20); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding Carlucci documents for Steven Sparling (.10); obtained copies of documents for Steven Sparling (.40); added samples of jury instructions to the local drive per Kurt Denk's instructions (.30). 2.80 980.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/13/2015 Calls/correspondence w/ KL team re developing pretrial work product; reviewed adversary's summary judgment and Daubert reply papers. 0.70 511.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/13/2015 Review trial and deposition testimony to prepare for mock and actual trial including W. Campanelli and D. Lucidi and Floorgraphics opening statements 7.50 8,400.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 11/13/2015 Review and summarize Gitkin and Hendrix depositions. 2.00 1,850.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/13/2015 Reviewing produced Heinz documents for potential use at trial and drafting chart summarizing the same. 7.00 3,850.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/13/2015 Pre‐trial tasks; gathering documents. 0.20 110.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/13/2015 Edited and revised trial outlines. 2.00 1,850.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/13/2015Updated digital files. Met with Santo Cipolla to review digital records and acquaint myself with necessary documents and information. Received instructions for upcoming tasks in said meeting. 1.00 350.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/16/2015Conferred with Eric Rosoff regarding chart of documents referenced in Merits Report including Rebuttal Report (.40); conferred with Joshua Trachtenberg regarding same (.30); reviewed and revised chart (6.30). 7.00 2,450.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/16/2015Prepared for/participated in DOAR team call w/ S. Sparling, and weekly associates call. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence re pretrial workflows and court memorandum order. 1.60 1,168.00


Review of defendants’ reply papers in support of summary judgment; t/c J. Smith re mock trial; review of order of Judge Pauley re: communications between NAM and class members; review research re: mandamus; c/ws S. Sparling and K. Denk; review of deposition and trial testimony to prepare for mock and actual trial including testimony of Allan Verdun 7.00 7,840.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 11/16/2015 Review and summarize Dietz and Jeannet depositions. 5.70 5,272.50

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/16/2015 Legal research re. admissibility of MacKie‐Mason's declaration in support of Pls.' Opp. to MSJ and draft memorandum regarding the same (4.3). 4.30 2,365.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/16/2015 Associates' call, research into mandamus. 1.30 715.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/16/2015Discussed trial witnesses w/D. Goldman; t/c w/trial graphics vendor re: demonstrative exhibits; edited and revised trial outline; reviewed briefing on MIL and SJ; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 4.00 3,700.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/16/2015 Worked on excel chart that indexed the citations in the MacKie Mason rebuttal report. 1.50 525.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/17/2015 Reviewed Merits Report of Jeffrey MacKie‐Mason and revised chart of documents referenced in report 7.00 2,450.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/17/2015Prepared for/participated in weekly team management call; follow‐up conference w/ KL team re same. Conducted legal research and drafted memo notes re class communications issues, and circulated same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 3.60 2,628.00


Participate in management call; draft email to counsel re: potential appeal of J. Pauley order on settlement with class members; review case law on settlement with class members after expiration of opt‐out period; c/ws K. Denk and S. Sparling re: potential appeal issues; c/w L. LeClair re: potential appeal issues 6.00 6,720.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 11/17/2015 Review and summarize Jeannet and Merritt depositions. 1.00 925.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/17/2015 Legal research re. potential avenues for relief from Court's settlement discussions order and drafting memorandum chart regarding the same. 7.00 3,850.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/17/2015 Meeting regarding research into defendant's communications with class members. 0.90 495.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/17/2015 Edited and revised trial outline; management committee call; reviewed court's order on settlement communications; discussed same w/team. 3.00 2,775.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/18/2015Prepared documents for computer drive to be readable and text word searchable per Kurt Denk's instructions (.70); reviewed production from Kellogg (.40); downloaded production to computer drive (.40).; created binder for Steve Sparling (.70). 2.20 770.00





Conducted legal research and drafted memo notes re class communications issues, and circulated same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling; calls/conferences with same and with co‐counsel. Completed misc mock jury and pretrial preparation tasks. Supervised junior associate and paralegal team work product re same. 8.30 6,059.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/18/2015 Phone calls and e‐mails to absent class members; prepare for mock trial 8.00 8,960.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 11/18/2015 Conf. DBG re: status, strategy 0.50 480.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/18/2015Drafted and revised trial outline; drafted and revised letter to the court; reviewed research and pleadings underlying same; discussed projects w/team; emails w/co‐counsel. 5.00 4,625.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/19/2015 Updated spreadsheet regarding documents relied on by MacKie‐Mason 7.00 2,450.00


Conducted legal research and drafted work product and correspondence re class communications and settlement issues, and circulated same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling; calls/conferences with same and with co‐counsel. Completed misc mock jury and pretrial preparation tasks. Supervised junior associate and paralegal team work product re same. 8.60 6,278.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/19/2015 Phone calls and e‐mails to absent class members; prepare for mock trial; participate in mock summary judgment argument 7.00 7,840.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/19/2015 Call with co‐counsel in preparation for summary judgment argument; began preparation for MacKie‐Mason direct by gathering documents. 6.60 3,630.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/19/2015Call w/co‐counsel re: SJ and MIL arguments; reviewed and edited trial outlines; reviewed and commented on court letter; discussed open issues w/team. 7.00 6,475.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/19/2015Proofread draft of letter to Judge Pulley, assisted attorneys with preparation for internal meeting, organized and provided documents to be reviewed during those meetings. 1.70 595.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/20/2015 Updated spreadsheet on documents relied on by MacKie‐Mason 7.00 2,450.00


Conducted follow‐up legal research and drafted work product and correspondence re class communications and settlement issues, and circulated same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling; calls/conferences with same and with co‐counsel. Completed misc mock jury and pretrial preparation tasks. Supervised junior associate and paralegal team work product re same. 6.50 4,745.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/20/2015 Phone calls and e‐mails to absent class members; prepare for mock trial 8.00 8,960.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 11/20/2015 Review and summarize Brotherton and Warus depositions; review draft opening for mock trial. 2.00 1,850.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/20/2015 Preparation for MacKie‐Mason direct; research into quantum meruit and litigation over settlements with class members after opt‐out. 5.80 3,190.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/20/2015 Call w/co‐counsel; reviewed legal research re: letter to court; discussed open issues and trial projects w/team; edited and revised trial outline 5.00 4,625.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/20/2015 Created binder for Steve Sparling consisting of testimony from expert deposition. Printed and provided documents to attorneys for internal meeting. 1.80 630.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/21/2015 Drafted materials for mock jury exercise preparations and circulated same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 3.90 2,847.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/21/2015 Reviewed prior trial testimony for trial. 1.00 925.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/22/2015Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re class communications issues. Revised draft materials for mock jury exercise preparations and circulated same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 1.70 1,241.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/22/2015 Review draft summary judgment slides; e‐mails to J. Southwick re: slides; draft e‐mails to absent class members re: possible settlement 1.00 1,120.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/22/2015 Reviewed prior testimony in anticipation of trial. 2.00 1,850.00


updated local drive with docket entries (1.20); created binder for Shaked Sivan for upcoming meeting (.90); organized meeting for Kurt Denk (.40); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding John Kelly deposition designations (.30); updated local drive of copies of jury instructions (.40); conferred with Steven Sparling regarding providing documents to Samuel Shepson (.20); attended to same (.30); 3.70 1,295.00


Conducted legal research re prior testimony issues and circulated analysis to D. Goldman. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re class communications issues. Revised draft materials for mock jury exercise preparations and circulated same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call re case status and diligence items. 8.80 6,424.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/23/2015 E‐mails and phone calls to absent class members; prep for mock trial and actual trial 8.00 8,960.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 11/23/2015 Research caselaw discussing admissibility of prior trial testimony per D. Goldman 0.50 390.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/23/2015 Prep for MacKie‐Mason direct; document review. 3.20 1,760.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/23/2015Worked on trial outlines; reviewed depositions and trial transcripts for trial; reviewed and commented on jury instructions; discussed open issues and trial projects w/team. 4.00 3,700.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/23/2015 Assisted Kurt Denk with intake and filing of mock jury sample verdict sheet. 0.70 245.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/24/2015Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding MacKie‐Mason documents received from Kellogg (.30), downloaded deposition videos received from Kellogg to database (5.0); updated docket entries per Kurt Denk's instructions (1.70). 7.00 2,450.00


Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & co‐counsel re discovery dispute letter to court; drafted and circulated revisions of same; transmitted plaintiffs' draft to adversary. Revised draft materials for mock jury exercise preparations; calls/correspondence/conference w/ S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re same. 7.10 5,183.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/24/2015 Prepare letter to Court re: depositions of Emmel, Ball and Lucidi‐Chammis; c/ws co‐counsel re: same; e‐mails and calls to absent class members 7.50 8,400.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/24/2015 Preparation for MacKie‐Mason direct; call with Rick Pfau; review of documents from third parties. 3.00 1,650.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/24/2015Discussed expert testimony issues w/S. Sivan; call w/ApplEcon re: same; reviewed draft letter to court on discovery issues and discussed same w/team; discussed summary judgment argument with team; drafted and revised witness outline for trial; discussed open projects with K. Denk. 4.00 3,700.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/24/2015 Reviewed deposition designation transcript of J. Kelly, noted mistakes in designation and discussed with Kurt Denk, filed designation data in excel. 2.40 840.00


Conferred with Eric Rosoff regarding deposition transcripts done through Adobe Professional (.20); updated litigation binder index (.90); updated spreadsheet of documents used during depositions and references to MacKie‐Mason reports (2.40); conferred with Steven Sparling regarding copies of pleadings for review (.10); attended to same(.30). 3.90 1,365.00


Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & co‐counsel re discovery dispute letter to court; finalized revisions to same and transmitted to adversary for filing. Revised draft materials for mock jury exercise preparations; conference w/ S. Sparling re same; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re same; supervised work of paralegals S. Cipolla & J. Trachtenberg re same. 6.30 4,599.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/25/2015 Review documents and testimony to prep for trial and mock trial; e‐mails and phone calls to absent class members 6.00 6,720.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/25/2015 Reviewed emails from co‐counsel; discussed open projects w/team; edited and revised trial outline; t/cs w/D. Goldman re: trial issues. 7.80 7,215.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/25/2015 Updated deposition designation excel file and PDF for J. Kelly deposition. Inserted designations for W. Naze into excel. 0.50 175.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 11/26/2015 Preparing demonstratives and supporting materials for use at mock trial (1.8) 1.80 990.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/27/2015 Drafted and revised trial outlines; emailed w/team re: projects. 3.00 2,775.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 11/28/2015Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & expert (P. Farris) re pretrial planning matters. Drafted materials for mock jury exercise preparations. 6.50 4,745.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/29/2015 Prep for mock trial including review of graphics 2.00 2,240.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/29/2015 Worked on demonstratives for mock trial. 0.40 220.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 11/30/2015added deposition exhibits to master chart (3.0); conference with Eric Rosoff and Joshua Trachtenberg regarding excel chart (.30); attended to revisions to same (.80); updated docket entries (1.10). 5.20 1,820.00


Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & expert (P. Farris) re pretrial planning matters. Drafted materials for mock jury exercise preparations, reviewed work product of associates S. Sivan & E. Rosoff, and circulated drafts to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. Prepared for/ participated in weekly associates call. 10.80 7,884.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 11/30/2015 Draft mock opening and mock graphics; review draft NAM mock opening 8.00 8,960.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 11/30/2015 Review materials for motion in limine 1.30 1,248.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 11/30/2015 Work on demonstratives for mock trial; document review. 8.50 4,675.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 11/30/2015 Worked on trial outline; reviewed evidence re: same; discussed open projects w/team; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 4.00 3,700.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/30/2015 Reviewed and highlighted designations in PDF's of deposition transcripts for Eric Rosoff, alerted him of typos and corrections, revised accordingly. 2.30 805.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 11/30/2015 Met with Santo Cipolla to receive instructions, updated excel chart to include exhibits referenced in multiple deposition transcripts. 5.40 1,890.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/01/2015 assisted counsel with review of Mock Opening and review outline for copies of referenced documents (5.50). 5.50 1,925.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/01/2015Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, & expert (P. Farris) re pretrial planning matters. Drafted and revised materials for mock jury exercise preparations, reviewed work product of associates S. Sivan & E. Rosoff, and circulated drafts to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 7.70 5,621.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/01/2015Prepare for mock trial, including drafting of opening statement, choosing video clips for case and drafting graphics; t/cs McKool and Doar re mock trial; review deposition designations for trial 8.00 8,960.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 12/01/2015 Gilreath and Ross deposition summaries; review Maguire deposition. 5.70 5,272.50

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/01/2015Reviewing exhibits introduced at Mixon, Naze, Kelly, Carlucci and Findlay depositions and tagging for trial themes (6.7). Reviewing mock trial opening and compiling evidentiary support and demonstrative exhibits (5.5). 12.20 6,710.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/01/2015 Document review in connection with exhibit list. 1.70 935.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/01/2015T/c w/D. Goldman and K. Denk re: trial projects; reviewed evidence for trial; emailed w/co‐counsel re: trial deadlines; reviewed work product for trial prep. 9.30 8,602.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/01/2015

Reviewed work from exhibit chart that I completed yesterday to make sure that there were no duplicative mentions of exhibits. Reviewed trial exhibit designation list from Kellogg to ensure that all Heinz exhibits were included on that list and made a note of which of those exhibits were included and which were not for Kellogg's reference. Updated Kelly transcript designations per instructions from Kurt Denk. 2.30 805.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/01/2015 Stayed late to review Findlay deposition transcript designations and enter data into excel. 3.60 1,260.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/02/2015Conference with Kurt Denk regarding meeting with DOAR (.20); prepared copies of documents for meeting (.30); assisted counsel with paralegal support during meeting (2.60). 3.10 1,085.00





Prepared for/participated in weekly MC call; follow‐up conference w/ D. Goldman re pretrial planning. Drafted/circulated correspondence re absent class member settlement contacts. Prepared for/participated in meeting with D. Goldman, S. Sparling & DOAR team re mock jury exercise preparations, and completed misc diligence items re same. 9.70 7,081.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/02/2015Prepare for mock trial, including drafting of opening statement, choosing video clips for case, drafting of graphics, drafting statement of mock judge, drafting of mock jury instructions 7.00 7,840.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 12/02/2015 Review Welch deposition; deposition summaries for Welch and Maguire; telephone call and correspondence with DG and KD re witness list. ` 8.50 7,862.50 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/02/2015 Reviewing deposition exhibits and tagging for trial themes and finalizing trial themes chart. (4.3). 4.30 2,365.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/02/2015 Reviewing third party documents in connection with exhibit list. 0.70 385.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/02/2015Reviewed deposition transcripts for trial; reviewed evidence for trial outlines; met w/DG, KD, and trial graphics consultants re: demonstrative exhibits for trial. 7.90 7,307.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/02/2015 Retrieved documents cited in expert reports per instructions from Eric Rosoff and updated master excel chart. 1.10 385.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/03/2015Attended to deposition designations (4.40); conference with Kurt Denk regarding DOAR meeting (.20); attended to preparations for same (.40); assisted counsel during DOAR meeting (.60); attended to miscellaneous issues (4.20). 9.80 3,430.00


Calls/conferences w/ D. Goldman re pretrial planning. Reviewed/responded to correspondence with D. Goldman, S. Sparling & DOAR team re mock jury exercise preparations, and completed misc diligence items re same. Supervised pretrial preparation work product of associates S. Sivan & E. Rosoff & paralegals S. Cipolla & J. Trachtenberg. Drafted/circulated pretrial work product ‐ witness list, and exhibit list addenda. 11.20 8,176.00


Designate Carlucci transcript for trial; prepare for mock trial including drafting of opening statement, choosing video clips for case, drafting of graphics, drafting statement of mock judge, drafting mock jury instructions; numerous emails and calls to R. McCleod and Maria Obregon of Doar re mock presentation materials 8.00 8,960.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/03/2015 Reviewing draft mock opening statement (0.3). Meeting with KD re. exhibit list (1). Preparing trial exhibit list (11.6). 12.90 7,095.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/03/2015 Reviewing potential hot documents produced by third parties. 5.60 3,080.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/03/2015 Worked on deposition designations for trial; discussed trial projects w/team; reviewed evidence for trial; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 8.30 7,677.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/03/2015Reviewed PDFs of trial designations and input revisions into excel sheets. This included entering into excel references to exhibits made in various deposition transcripts. Also revised mock trial opening statement document per instructions from Kurt Denk. 4.40 1,540.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/04/2015prepared binder of documents for Steve Sparling (.50); attended to deposition designations (.90); reviewed deposition transcript from Dickson (.20); prepared for mock trial meeting (1.50). 3.10 1,085.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/04/2015Conferences w/ D. Goldman, KL team, and DOAR team re pretrial planning. Completed pretrial tasks: depo designations, exhibit list, witness list diligence items; supervised pretrial preparation work product of associates S. Sivan & E. Rosoff & paralegals S. Cipolla & J. Trachtenberg. 8.10 5,913.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/04/2015Designate Mixson transcript for trial; give practice run through of mock opening; mtw R. McCleod and M. Obregon re graphics and materials for mock trial; review of draft exhibit list for trial; review and revise draft witness list for trial 8.00 8,960.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 12/04/2015 Attend run‐through of mock opening and provide comments. 1.90 1,757.50 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 12/04/2015 Attend Mock Trial Opening Argument 2.00 1,560.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/04/2015Meet with DG, SS, KD and SS for trial run through mock opening statement (2.5). Edit exhibit list prior to sending to Kellogg (2.2). Review and update Carlucci, Naze and Kelly deposition designations, meet and t/c with KD, J. Trachtenberg and S. Cippola regarding the same (3.2) 7.90 4,345.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 12/04/2015 Mock opening statement strategy session with DBG 1.70 1,632.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/04/2015 Preparation for mock trial, including giving comments on opening and working on demonstratives. 4.80 2,640.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/04/2015 Discussed trial projects w/team; reviewed evidentiary materials for trial; reviewed and commented on materials for trial exercise. 9.30 8,602.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/04/2015Recorded deposition designations in excel and provided Eric Rosoff with information relating to when exhibits were mentioned in two witness' deposition transcript in lines that were not designated. 2.80 980.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/05/2015 Reviewed trial transcripts; reviewed demonstrative exhibits. 1.20 1,110.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/06/2015Reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel emails re depo designations, exhibit list, and witness list diligence items; reviewed/responded to KL team and vendor correspondence emails re mock trial prep. 0.90 657.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/06/2015 Revise mock opening statement; revise graphics for mock trial 6.00 6,720.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/07/2015Conference with Dan Goldman regarding request for binder (.10); attended to same (.30); Conferred with Steven Sparling regarding highlighting deposition transcript (.10); attended to same (.40) 0.90 315.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/07/2015Conferences w/ D. Goldman & KL team re pretrial and mock trial planning. Reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel emails re depo designations, exhibit list, and witness list diligence items; reviewed/finalized work product pertaining to same. Reviewed final materials for mock trial. 10.30 7,519.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/07/2015 Prepare for mock including finalizing opening statement, video clips, graphics, jury instructions; c/ws R. McCleod and J. Blackman of Doar 11.00 12,320.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 12/07/2015 Review materials in connection with jury instructions. 1.20 1,110.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/07/2015

Preparing Mixson and Naze deposition designations (1.5). Updating list of deposition designations with KD prior to exchange with Defendants (0.5). Reviewing Heinz documents and other additions to exhibit list and updating internal trial exhibits chart with trial theme tags (1.2). Reviewing final Plaintiffs' exhibit list (1.4). 4.60 2,530.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/07/2015 Deposition designations; reviewing exhibit list. 5.10 2,805.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/07/2015 Discussed trial projects w/team; reviewed exhibits and deposition designations; discussed same w/team; reviewed evidence for trial outlines. 9.80 9,065.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/08/2015 reviewed Plaintiffs and Defendants trial exhibits; created copy on local drive (.90); made preparations for meeting post mock trial (.40). 1.30 455.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/08/2015 Prepared for/attended mock trial. Reviewed/responded to correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. 9.10 6,643.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/08/2015 Participate in mock trial; prepare closing argument 12.00 13,440.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/08/2015Review final exhibit list and cross‐check with internal exhibit list (2.2). Review Defendants' Findlay deposition designations (0.9). Prepare final versions of Mixson, Carlucci, Kelly, Findlay and Naze deposition transcripts with Plaintiffs' designations (2.5). 4.80 2,640.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/08/2015 Reviewing witness list; document review. 2.70 1,485.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/08/2015 Attended and observed trial exercise; discussed same w/co‐counsel. 10.10 9,342.50 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/08/2015 Deposition designations of multiple transcripts. 5.70 1,995.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/09/2015 Attended to deposition designations and reviewed and organized all deposition designations and trial materials 7.00 2,450.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/09/2015 Prepared for/attended mock trial. Reviewed/responded to correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. 8.40 6,132.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/09/2015 Prepare closing argument; participate in mock trial 10.00 11,200.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/09/2015Review selected documents to ensure inclusion on Plaintiffs' exhibit list (.7). Review parties' deposition designations and prepare transcripts of the same(6.3). 7.00 3,850.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/09/2015 Reviewing juror responses to mock trial. 0.20 110.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/09/2015 Attended and discussed trial exercise. 8.00 7,400.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/09/2015Continued deposition designations project from yesterday. Compiled binder of various deposition transcripts per instructions from Kurt Denk for Steve Sparling. 6.70 2,345.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/10/2015 conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding additional documents to be loaded in View Point (.20); assisted Kurt Denk with documents for Mock Trial (2.30). 2.50 875.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/10/2015Completed follow‐up diligence items from mock trial. Conference w/ D. Goldman re pretrial tasks. Reviewed pretrial submission materials and reviewed/responded to correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. 5.10 3,723.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/10/2015 T/c J. Blackman of Doar; t/c J. Briody; review News’s proposed jury questionnaire; e‐mail to J. Southwick re: Lucidi deposition 2.00 2,240.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/10/2015 Review parties' deposition designations and prepare transcripts of the same (7.4). 7.40 4,070.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/10/2015 Reviewing documents for exhibit list. 1.00 550.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/10/2015Reviewed deposition materials for trial prep; reviewed emails from co‐counsel; discussed trial prep issues w/team; discussed demonstrative exhibits w/graphics vendor. 8.80 8,140.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/10/2015Finished compiling binder of mock trial witness transcripts for Steve Sparling, performed quality control of said binder. Also updated digital files with documents received from Kurt Denk and applied designations of defendant to PDF's of witness transcripts. 4.80 1,680.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/11/2015 updated files regarding Mock Trial (1.10); prepared binders regarding deposition designations (5.40). 6.50 2,275.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/11/2015Reviewed pretrial submission materials and reviewed/responded to correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. Drafted work product for pretrial prep. 4.50 3,285.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/11/2015Research re: modification of class period; email to co‐plaintiffs’ counsel; c/w C. Pak re: research; e‐mails to J. Briody re: News’s interrogatory responseon its affirmative defenses 4.00 4,480.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 12/11/2015Review and analyze memorandum discussing impact of provisions in agreements purporting to shorten Clayton Act's prescribed statute of limitations; research and review cases discussing statute of limitations issues in context of antitrust and class actions 3.00 2,340.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/11/2015 Review parties' deposition designations and prepare transcripts of the same (7.5). 7.40 4,070.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/11/2015 Emailed w/team re: trial projects; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 0.30 277.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/11/2015Made chart comparing MSG witness' to trial witness combined list per instructions from Kurt Den, finished highlighting designations. Updated digital files. 5.10 1,785.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/14/2015 Attended to deposition designations 7.00 2,450.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/14/2015Reviewed pretrial submission materials and reviewed/responded to correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. Drafted work product for pretrial prep. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. 4.90 3,577.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/14/2015Review research concerning modification of class periods after class certification; e‐mails to R. Caughey re: modification of class periods after classcertification; review of plaintiffs’ deposition designations to determine whether to cut witnesses from witness list 7.00 7,840.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 12/14/2015Research and review cases discussing standard for modifying class certification order; research and review cases moving to shorten class period; summarize research findings 7.00 5,460.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/14/2015 Review parties' deposition designations and prepare transcripts of the same (5.8). 5.80 3,190.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 12/14/2015 Review materials for in limine motion re: Carlton; conf. DBG re: strategy 1.30 1,248.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/14/2015 Associates' call; review of exhibit list. 0.70 385.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/14/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts; call w/K. Denk re: PTO issues. 7.80 7,215.00




18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/14/2015 Reviewed and highlighted designations in transcript from earlier trial. 2.10 735.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/15/2015Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding updating computer with deposition transcripts and other tasks (.40); attended to same (2.20); attended to highlighting Findlay counter deposition designations (.40); updated binder of deposition designations for team (3.0). 6.30 2,205.00


Reviewed pretrial submission materials and reviewed/responded to correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. Reviewed deposition transcripts and designations; drafted counter‐designations. Prepared business records declaration and circulated to D. Goldman. Conference w/ S. Sparling re deposition designations and case status. 6.20 4,526.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/15/2015Review of e‐mails concerning Emmel and Lucidi depositions; review of Emmel transcript; review of deposition designations to determine whether witnesses can be cut from witness list 7.00 7,840.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 12/15/2015 Research and review cases discussing class period and damages period concurrently; review class certification order; summarize research findings 2.50 1,950.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/15/2015 Read Lucidi and Emmel deposition transcripts (3.3). 3.30 1,815.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/15/2015 Reviewed depositions for trial prep; discussed trial projects w/team; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 8.80 8,140.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/15/2015 Proof read highlights of deposition designations to ensure accuracy. 0.50 175.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/16/2015 conferred with Kurt Denk regarding Pre‐Trial Calendar (.20); attended to same (1.70); conference with Eric Rosoff regarding designations (.30); 2.20 770.00


Prepared for/participated in weekly management team call; follow‐up conference w/ S. Sparling re diligence items. Reviewed pretrial submission materials and prepared responsive pretrial work product; reviewed/responded to team correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. Reviewed trial exhibit list materials and deposition transcripts and designations. 7.90 5,767.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/16/2015Participate in management committee call; review of deposition designations; review of News’s exhibit for objections; e‐mail to co‐counsel re: objections 6.00 6,720.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/16/2015 Review and draft email summary of Heinz documents included in News's trial exhibit list and t/c with SS regarding the same (4.5). 4.50 2,475.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 12/16/2015 Review materials re: Carlton Motion 1.00 960.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/16/2015 Review of documents on exhibit list. 3.00 1,650.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/16/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts for trial prep; emailed team re: same; discussed trial projects w/team; management committee call. 8.40 7,770.00 03812 Suris, Liliya Other Tkpr 12/16/2015 Obtained and paid for various transcripts. 2.30 391.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/16/2015Assisted Santo Cipolla with creation of pre‐trial calendar in excel. Received hard drive of defendant's exhibits from KH, coordinated with LTS to arrange download of exhibits, organized exhibits on L drive per instructions from Sivan Shaked. Also briefed Eric Rosoff on contents of materials received. 3.90 1,365.00


conferred with Kurt Denk regarding binders (.10); attended to same (.50); conference with Eric Rosoff regarding deposition designations (.30); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding pretrial calendar (.20); conferred with Dan Goldman regarding Plaintiffs and Defendants trial exhibits (.10); reviewed incoming deposition transcripts and exhibits and added same to the L drive (.70); conference with TSG Court reporting regarding issue with Ball exhibits (.30). 2.10 735.00


Reviewed pretrial submission materials and prepared responsive pretrial work product; reviewed junior associate and paralegal work product pertaining to same. Reviewed/responded to team correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. Reviewed trial exhibit list materials and deposition transcripts and designations. 7.20 5,256.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/17/2015T/c K Rohrback, in‐house counsel for Kraft Heinz; e‐mails to in‐house counsel for Novartis; e‐mails to Reckitt; review of deposition designations of plaintiffs 5.00 5,600.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/17/2015Review ISP photographs included on News's exhibit list for possible objections and t/c with KD and SS regarding the same (2.9). Review mock trial transcript designations for inclusion as supplemental designations at trial and meet with KD regarding the same (1.7). 4.60 2,530.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 12/17/2015 Review materials re: Carlton motion 1.70 1,632.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/17/2015 Reviewing and editing exhibit list; reviewing depositions and editing deposition designations. 3.80 2,090.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/17/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts for trial prep; emailed team re: same; discussed PTO issues w/associates; reviewed emails from co‐counsel 9.20 8,510.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/17/2015Worked with tech dep't to see if it was possible to improve resolution on a potential photo exhibit. Updated L drive folder with newly received deposition transcripts. 0.60 210.00


Prepared for/attended KL team conference w/ S. Sparling and associate team. Reviewed pretrial submission materials and prepared responsive pretrial work product; reviewed junior associate and paralegal work product pertaining to same. Reviewed/responded to team correspondence re pretrial filings and diligence items. Reviewed trial exhibit list materials and deposition transcripts and designations. 8.40 6,132.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/18/2015 T/cs J. Southwick and S. Benz; review of exhibit list for purpose of eliminating exhibits 7.00 7,840.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/18/2015Meet with SS, KD and SS regarding photographs included on News's exhibit list and review photos for objections (1.5). Review mock trial transcript designations for inclusion as supplemental trial designations (1.3). Prepare set of News's exhibits for use by DG (2.4). 5.20 2,860.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 12/18/2015 Review materials re: motion to exclude Carlton 0.90 864.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/18/2015 Meeting with Sparling and associates to discuss pre‐trial tasks; review and editing of exhibit list. 1.40 770.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/18/2015 Discussed trial exhibits w/associates; emailed w/D. Goldman re: same; reviewed evidence and deposition transcripts for trial. 8.20 7,585.00




18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/18/2015 Coordinated loading exhibits onto DVD discs for Dan Goldman. 4.50 1,575.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/19/2015Reviewed pretrial submission materials and prepared responsive pretrial work product; correspondence w/ D. Goldman and KL team re same. Circulated pretrial work product re exhibits and deposition designations to co‐counsel associates team. 5.20 3,796.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/19/2015 E‐mail to Kellogg re: list of exhibits that should be eliminated from exhibit list 1.00 1,120.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/19/2015 Emails and t/c with KD regarding parties' exhibit lists and exhibit files (0.8). 0.80 440.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/19/2015 Review and editing of exhibit list. 0.60 330.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/19/2015 Reviewed deposition transcripts for trial. 1.00 925.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/20/2015 Reviewed/responded to KL team emails re pretrial submission materials and responsive pretrial work product re exhibits and deposition designations. 0.70 511.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/20/2015Review parties exhibit lists and cross‐check with files provided by Kellogg to ensure completeness of exhibits; draft email to team regarding the same (4.9). 4.90 2,695.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/20/2015 Review and editing of deposition designations. 1.00 550.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/20/2015 Reviewed deposition transcript for trial prep; reviewed emails from co‐counsel. 1.50 1,387.50 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/20/2015 Worked with Eric Rosoff to ensure that hard drive received from KH was consistent with our records of PX and DX. 4.30 1,505.00


Updated computer of docket entries (.60); reviewed files for copy of Plaintiffs' Exhibit List and forwarded same to Steven Sparling (.30); updated Emmel deposition transcripts to computer (.20); conferred with Help Desk regarding hard drive received from Kellogg firm to be added to our computer (1.0); assisted Joshua Tractenberg with Defendants' and Plaintiffs' trial exhibits (2.60). 4.70 1,645.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/21/2015Reviewed/revised responsive pretrial submission materials re exhibit lists and deposition designations; reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel emails re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Reviewed work product of junior associates and paralegals. 8.70 6,351.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/21/2015 Review of exhibit to find additional exhibits to eliminate from exhibit list 5.00 5,600.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/21/2015 Weekly associates conference call (0.2). Review parties' exhibits on file, t/c with JT and SC, and emails to DG and Kellogg regarding the same (0.6). 0.80 440.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/21/2015 Review and editing of exhibit list; associates call. 3.00 1,650.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/21/2015 Reviewed trial exhibits; reviewed deposition testimony; discussed trial prep issues w/team; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 9.80 9,065.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/21/2015 Added hard drive to l drive. 2.70 945.00 07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 12/22/2015 Begin upload of thousands of exhibits in PDF format to the review database. 1.10 330.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/22/2015updated deposition designation binders for the team (.80); conferred with Joshua Tractenberg and Kurt Denk regarding missing Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibits (.80); reviewed database for same (.40). 2.00 700.00


Reviewed/revised responsive pretrial submission materials re exhibit lists and deposition designations; reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel emails re same; circulated draft materials to co‐counsel re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly management team call. Reviewed work product of junior associates and paralegals. 8.20 5,986.00


Review of exhibits from plaintiffs’ list and defendants’ list for the purposes of objections and revisions; c/ws K. Denk and S. Sparling re: exhibits; review of J. Southwick e‐mails re: communications with counsel for News concerning motions on class period and deposition designations; review and comment upon jury questionnaire 7.00 7,840.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/22/2015Review proposed objections to Defendants' exhibit list and prepare edits to Plaintiffs' exhibit list, and emails with DG, SS, KD and SS regarding the same (5.8). 5.80 3,190.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/22/2015 Review and editing of exhibit list. 7.70 4,235.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/22/2015 Reviewed and commented on defendant's trial exhibit list; reviewed our trial exhibits; discussed pre‐trial issues w/team; management committee call. 8.70 8,047.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/22/2015Reviewed PIX file received in hard drive from KHZ. This file included a sub‐file with documents produced in native format. Reviewed excel sheet to match bates numbers with corresponding exhibit numbers and copied into main PIX file. 3.20 1,120.00

07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 12/23/2015 Upload remaining exhibits to review database, perform quality control checks and make same available to legal team in review database. 0.80 240.00


Reviewed/revised responsive pretrial submission materials re exhibit lists and deposition designations; reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel emails re same; circulated draft materials to co‐counsel re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly management team call. Reviewed work product of junior associates and paralegals. 2.70 1,971.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 12/23/2015 Review of e‐mails concerning exhibit lists and jury questionnaire; e‐mails to CPGs re: settlement 1.00 1,120.00


Edit internal master trial‐prep document review list based on exhibit list removals (0.6). Review email from Ryan Caughey re. statute of limitations affirmative defense (0.4). Review final objections to News's exhibit list and emails with SS and SS regarding the same (2.3). Meet with J. Trachtenberg re. native files in Plaintiffs' exhibits and email to team regarding the same (0.3). Review Plaintiffs' First Amended Trial Exhibit List and consolidated defense exhibit objections (1.7). 4.90 2,695.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 12/23/2015 Reviewing supplemental exhibit list before service to Defendants. 3.90 2,145.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/23/2015 Reviewed e‐mail correspondence; worked on pre‐trial order materials and exhibits, reviewed evidence for trial. 7.00 6,475.00




18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/23/2015Finished revising digital folder of plaintiff's exhibits. Sat down with Eric Rosoff to explain issue with PX files received from KH. Worked on chart to group together exhibits with potentially extraneous attachments per his suggestion. 4.90 1,715.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/24/2015 Update internal database with parties' materials served on December 23, 2015 (0.7). 0.70 385.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/28/2015Reviewed parties' revised exhibit and deposition designation submissions; reviewed/responded to KL team emails re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Reviewed mock jury report. 2.70 1,971.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/28/2015 Updating internal transcripts with designations served on Dec. 23, 2015 (4.9). 4.90 2,695.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/28/2015Created binder of DOAR mock trial report for Dan Goldman, Steve Sparling & Kurt Denk per instructions from Kurt. Worked on deposition designation highlighting. 3.20 1,120.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/29/2015Reviewed mock jury report, and sent summary notes re same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. Reviewed parties' revised exhibit and deposition designation submissions, and reviewed/responded to KL team emails re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly management call. 4.60 3,358.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/29/2015 Updating internal transcripts with designations served on Dec. 23, 2015 (7.2). 7.20 3,960.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 12/29/2015 Reviewed e‐mail correspondence 0.20 185.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/30/2015 Reviewed/responded to team emails and adversary correspondence re motion filing; correspondence w/ D. Goldman re same. 0.50 365.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/30/2015 Update internal transcripts with designations served on Dec. 23, 2015 (4.1). 4.10 2,255.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/30/2015 Deposition designations. Received new transcripts from KH via Eric Rosoff and filed in L‐drive according to his instructions. 1.60 560.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 12/31/2015 Attended to Defendants' Counter Designations (3.50). 3.50 1,225.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 12/31/2015Reviewed/responded to D. Goldman and co‐counsel correspondence re motion filing, and drafted updated work product re same; correspondence w/ KL team re same. 1.90 1,387.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 12/31/2015Updating internal transcripts with designations exchanged on Dec. 23, 2015 (3.8). Read News's Mem. of Law in Support of Mot. to Preclude Prior Testimony and related email correspondence (0.7). 4.50 2,475.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 12/31/2015Saved files to L‐drive per instructions from Eric Rosoff. Met with Santo Cipolla to update him on what occurred during his week out of the office. Worked briefly on transcript designations. 0.70 245.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/02/2016 Updating internal transcripts with designations served on Dec. 23, 2015 (2.5). 2.50 1,375.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/04/2016 Attended to Defendants' Counter Deposition Designations 2.30 805.00


Reviewed and updated deposition designation, exhibit list, and witness list work product; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel and KL team correspondence re same; supervised/reviewed paralegal pretrial work product re same. Reviewed draft work product pertaining to adversary motion and letter motion filings, and draft plaintiffs' responses. Prepared for and participated in weekly associates call. 8.20 5,986.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/04/2016Revise and research letter to Judge Pauley in response to defendants’ letter to Court seeking pre‐motion conference to alter class period; review deposition designations to determine which designations can be cut 7.50 8,400.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/04/2016 Research and summarize class action cases discussing the shortening or modification of the class period 4.50 3,510.00


Update internal transcripts with Plaintiffs' counter‐designations served on Dec. 23, 2015 (3.3). Update Plaintiffs' exhibit list with issue tags for use in trial preparation (2.5). Review Plaintiffs' exhibit list documents and tag for trial themes and t/c with SS regarding the same (3.1). Review witness list with KD (0.8). 9.70 5,335.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/04/2016 Review cases for motion to exclude Carlton 2.60 2,496.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/04/2016 Reviewing exhibit list; associates' call. 4.20 2,310.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/04/2016 Discussed trial issues w/DG; reviewed deposition designations; prepared, edited, and revised trial outline; discussed trial projects w/team 10.40 9,620.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/04/2016Met with Eric Rosoff to discuss new project regarding merger of spreadsheet data and coordinated project execution with ` Santo Cipolla. Began work on project. Also saved release agreement documents between CPG's and & NAM to L‐drive per instructions from Kurt Denk. 0.80 280.00


Reviewed and updated deposition designation and witness list work product; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel and KL team correspondence re same; supervised/reviewed paralegal pretrial work product re same. Reviewed draft work product pertaining to plaintiffs' responses to adversary motion and letter motion filings. Prepared for and participated in weekly management team call. Conference w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re pretrial tasks and pretrial strategy. 9.50 6,935.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/05/2016Participate in management call; review designations of depositions of non‐parties and others who were not deposed in the case to respond to News’s motion in limine; t/c J. Southwick re: trial prep; c/w S. Sparling re: drafting task list for trial preparation 7.00 7,840.00


Review Plaintiffs' exhibit list documents and tag for trial themes (2.4). Prepare chronological versions of parties' exhibit lists, t/c and email with KD regarding the same (1.3). Review News's counter‐designations and Plaintiffs' rebuttal designations for KL witnesses (1.4). Review internal transcript designation highlighting prepared by paralegals (1.6). T/c with KD regarding Plaintiffs' amended exhibit list (0.2). 6.90 3,795.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/05/2016 Review cases & research materials re: Carlton motion 2.30 2,208.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/05/2016 Reviewing exhibits, preparing MacKie Mason outline. 4.80 2,640.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/05/2016 Management committee call; discussed trial prep w/team; reviewed PTO designations; edited, revised, and prepared trial outline. 11.30 10,452.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/06/2016 Updated docket entries 0.60 210.00





Reviewed and updated deposition designation and witness list work product; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel and KL team correspondence re same; supervised/reviewed paralegal pretrial work product re same. Conferences w/ S. Sparling re pretrial tasks and pretrial strategy; prepared work product for trial preparation workflows. Prepared motion for CPG access to confidential information and circulated same to D. Goldman. 8.40 6,132.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/06/2016Review and revise trial task list; review documents on exhibit list to prepare for witness exam outlines; review and revise rebuttal deposition designations 7.00 7,840.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/06/2016 Review Plaintiffs' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (3.1). Meet with KD re. master trial prep timeline (0.5). 3.60 1,980.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/06/2016 Review cases re: Carlton motion 3.50 3,360.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/06/2016 Preparing MacKie‐Mason outline, reviewing documents. 6.00 3,300.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/06/2016Revised and drafted trial outline; discussed trial tasks w/KD; discussed trial testimony prep w/SS; discussed open issues w/DG; edited and revised trial project task list; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 11.60 10,730.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/06/2016 Discussed issue with Plaintiffs' Exhibit List with Santo Cipolla, created binder tabs and delivered to Kurt denk per his instructions. 0.50 175.00


Conferred with Claudia Pak regarding creating binder of Summary Judgment Pleadings for herself and Dani James in addition to a binder of documents relating to Jury Instructions (.40); attended to same (2.40); follow‐up conversation with Claudia Pak and Joshua Trachtenberg regarding Table of Cases cited in Summary Judgment Pleadings for Claudia Pak and Dani James (.30); attended to same (1.40); updated litigation binder (.30); conference with Joshua Trachtenberg regarding additional tasks (.40); 5.20 1,820.00


Reviewed and updated deposition designation and witness list work product; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel and KL team correspondence re same; supervised/reviewed paralegal pretrial work product re same. Revised work product for trial preparation workflows; correspondence w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re same. Prepared motion for CPG access to confidential information and circulated same to D. Goldman. Calls/correspondence with KL and vendor (DOAR) personnel re trial logistics preparation. 7.40 5,402.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/07/2016T/c K. Slavitt of Reckitt re: possible settlement efforts; t/c N. Bearce of Unilever re: possible settlement efforts by NAM; t/c L. LeClair and J. Southwick re: trial prep; review of PXs to prepare for witness examinations 7.00 7,840.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 01/07/2016 Telephone call with DG; review mock trial materials and sample jury instructions; telephone call with CP re jury instructions. 3.90 3,607.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/07/2016Confer with D. James and D. Goldman concerning drafting of jury instructions; confer with S. Cipolla concerning model and sample jury instructions on the L drive; review contents of materials available on the L drive concerning jury instructions 0.80 624.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/07/2016Review Plaintiffs' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (5.6). Update internal deposition designations tracking chart and t/cs with KD regarding the same (1.4). Review master timeline and projects calendar (0.2). 7.20 3,960.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/07/2016 Preparing outline for MacKie‐Mason; reviewing documents. 6.30 3,465.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/07/2016 Discussed trial prep issues w/team; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel; edited, revised, and drafted witness outline for trial 9.20 8,510.00


Printed exhibit lists and witness lists per instructions from Kurt Denk. Created index of cases cited in both parties' briefs regarding motion to dismiss per instructions from Shaked Sivan for Dani James and Claudia Pak. Worked on creating those binders with Santo Cipolla. Also provided Dani James with a copy of the binder of the DOAR Mock Trial Report. 5.20 1,820.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/08/2016Conferred with Josh Trachtenberg regarding preparation of binder relating to Summary Judgment (.40); attended to preparation of same (3.20); conferred with Claudia Pak regarding Pre‐Trial Schedule (.20); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding same (.20); revised binders for Kurt Denk (2.20). 6.00 2,100.00


Reviewed and updated deposition designation and witness list work product; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel and KL team correspondence re same; supervised/reviewed paralegal pretrial work product re same. Conference w/ S. Sparling, S. Sivan, & E. Rosoff re trial preparation tasks and strategy. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails, and reviewed related work product, pertaining to proposed stipulation with adversary re prior testimony designations. Reviewed work product and correspondence pertaining to evidentiary issues and News motions. 8.10 5,913.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/08/2016Review exhibits to determine for the purposes of drafting examination outlines; review of Simcox and Biery deposition cuts for the purposes of stipulated agreement with News 8.00 8,960.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 01/08/2016 Review materials relevant to jury instructions. 2.80 2,590.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/08/2016 Confer with S. Cipolla concerning sample jury charge and cases binder; review sample jury charge binder 1.00 780.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/08/2016Meet with SS, KD and SS regarding pretrial tasks (0.5). T/c with K. Briggs at Kellogg re. exhibits (0.2). Update designations tracking chart and internal transcripts with rebuttal designations exchanged on 1/7/16 (4.5). Review Plaintiffs' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (2.9). 8.10 4,455.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/08/2016 Preparing MacKie‐Mason outline; document review. 4.30 2,365.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/08/2016Met w/associates re: trial projects; discussed deposition designation objections w/K. Denk; discussed MM testimony w/S. Sivan; edited, revised, and drafted witness outline for trial. 8.00 7,400.00


Reviewed and updated deposition designation and witness list work product; calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling and E. Rosoff re same. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails, and reviewed related work product, pertaining to proposed stipulation with adversary re prior testimony designations. 3.80 2,774.00





Review Plaintiffs' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (5.1). Review objections to News's designations of Findlay, Carlucci, Naze, Mixson, Kelly testimony (1.3). T/c with KD re. supplemental News exhibits provided by Kellogg (0.4). Update internal transcripts with Plaintiffs' rebuttal designations (1.5). 8.30 4,565.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/09/2016 Edited, drafted, and revised trial outline; emailed w/K. Denk re: trial prep issues. 6.00 5,550.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/10/2016Reviewed updated deposition objections and related work product. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails re case status, diligence items, and legal issues/research. Reviewed fact materials and drafted trial prep work product. 4.00 2,920.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/10/2016 Review Plaintiffs' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (2.2). 2.20 1,210.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/10/2016 Worked on trial outlines. 4.30 3,977.50 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/11/2016 prepared binder of sample Jury instructions for Dani James and Claudia Pak (1.40). 1.40 490.00


Reviewed finalized deposition objections and related work product; calls/correspondence with co‐counsel and KL team re same. Prepared for/ participated in weekly associates call. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel and KL team emails re case status, diligence items, and legal issues/research. Reviewed fact materials and drafted trial prep work product. 8.80 6,424.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/11/2016C/w C. Pak re: jury instructions; review of depositions and exhibits to prepare witness outlines; review of materials to prepare for meet and confer on JPTO; review of defendants’ exhibit lists and schedules; t/c J. Southwick 7.50 8,400.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/11/2016 Review sample and model jury charges; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft jury charges 7.00 5,460.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/11/2016Review Plaintiffs' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (5.3). Compare Plaintiffs' January 7 exhibit list with draft exhibit list to be served on January 11 (1.8). 7.10 3,905.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/11/2016 Conf. DBG re: strategy; conf, SS re: research on Daubert motion 0.90 864.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/11/2016 Preparing MacKie‐Mason outline; reviewing depositions. 5.30 2,915.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/11/2016 Worked on trial outlines; discussed trial projects w/team. 12.30 11,377.50 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/11/2016 Discussed upcoming project regarding organization of exhibits with Eric Rosoff and Santo Cipolla. 0.30 105.00


Conferred with Steven Sparling regarding working files, requests for various documents for review; conferred with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of Plaintiffs Initial Objections to Defendants' Deposition Designations; conferred with Dan Goldman regarding Plaintiffs' exhibits to be added to external hard drive 4.20 1,470.00


Reviewed adversary's updated deposition designation and objections materials, and case filings. Prepared for/ participated in weekly management team call. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel and KL team emails re case status, diligence items, and legal issues/research; conference w/ S. Sparling re same. Reviewed fact materials and drafted trial prep work product. 8.70 6,351.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/12/2016 Management call; mtw L. LeClair and J. Briody re: trial organization; participate in call w/ counsel for News re: JPTO; c/ws. S. Sparling and K. Denk 7.00 7,840.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/12/2016 Review sample and model jury charges; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft jury charges 9.00 7,020.00


Update internal database with materials served on 1/12 (0.3). Update internal transcripts with newly designated testimony (1.1). Review Plaintiffs' exhibits and prepare key documents chart for internal use (1.9). Prepare copy of Plaintiffs' second amended exhibit list featuring Defendants' objections (1.2). Review Defendants' exhibits and prepare spreadsheet with comments regarding the same (4.9). 9.40 5,170.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/12/2016 Exhibit list review; legal research for Carlton Daubert motion. 2.20 1,210.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/12/2016 Management call; meet and confer call w/defendants; discussed trial projects w/team; worked on trial outlines. 10.80 9,990.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/13/2016Reviewed and revised index of Summary Judgment Pleadings for Claudia Pak and Dani James (.30); reviewed and revised chart of deposition designations (3.90) 4.20 1,470.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/13/2016Reviewed parties' pretrial filings and correspondence re same pertinent to pretrial order (PTO) drafting. Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails, and reviewed related work product, pertaining to proposed stipulation and PTO. Reviewed fact materials and drafted trial prep work product. 6.70 4,891.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/13/2016 Review sample and model jury charges; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft jury charges 11.30 8,814.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/13/2016Review Defendants' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (4.4). Prepare chart of parties' objection codes (1.2). Update transcripts with revised rebuttal designations (3.3). 8.90 4,895.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/13/2016 Review research materials re: Daubert; conf. SS re: same 0.80 768.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/13/2016 Research for Carlton Daubert motion; exhibit list review. 4.70 2,585.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/13/2016 Worked on trial witness projects; reviewed draft court letter from co‐counsel; discussed trial issues w/associates. 7.90 7,307.50 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/13/2016 Met with Santo Cipolla to discuss project regarding organization of exhibits this weekend. Spoke over the phone with Kurt Denk about this. 0.40 140.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/14/2016 downloaded MacKie‐Mason documents received from Kimberly Briggs (.40); reviewed Plaintiffs' counter designations of Rebh (.60); 1.00 350.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/14/2016Reviewed fact materials and drafted trial prep work product. Reviewed parties' pretrial filings and correspondence re same pertinent to PTO; calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same. Correspondence w/ KL team and vendor re trial logistics and technology needs. 6.40 4,672.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/14/2016 Review draft JPTO; review e‐mails from R. Pfau re: damages; c/ws D. James re: CPG testimony; review documents for trial outlines 7.00 7,840.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 01/14/2016 Discussion with DG; review materials. 0.50 462.50 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/14/2016 Review sample and model jury charges; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft jury charges 7.50 5,850.00




18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/14/2016 Review Defendants' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (6.1). 6.10 3,355.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/14/2016 E‐mail SS re: Daubert issues 0.10 96.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/14/2016 Drafting Carlton Daubert motion; exhibit list review. 2.40 1,320.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/14/2016 Worked on trial outlines and witness prep; discussed projects w/team. 10.50 9,712.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/14/2016Highlighted deposition designations per instructions from Eric Rosoff. Spoke with Jill Ranson from LTS, as well as with Santo Cipolla, regarding digital storage of hard drive to be received from Kellog Huber tomorrow. 2.30 805.00


Team meeting w/ S. Sparling, S. Sivan, and E. Rosoff. Supervised admin tasks and work product of paralegals S. Cipolla & J. Trachtenberg. Filed notice of appearance for D. James. Reviewed fact materials and drafted trial prep work product. Reviewed parties' draft PTO, and correspondence re same; calls/correspondence w/ KL team re same. Correspondence w/ KL team and vendor re trial logistics and technology needs. Reviewed Court's memorandum and order re summary judgment and Daubert motions. 8.80 6,424.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/15/2016Review court’s summary judgment opinion; e‐mails to co‐counsel re: opinion; draft e‐mail to clients re: summary judgment opinion; review of documents to prepare examination outlines for trial 8.00 8,960.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 01/15/2016 Review materials. 2.00 1,850.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/15/2016Review sample and model jury charges; review and analyze antitrust section 1 and 2 caselaw; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft jury charges 10.00 7,800.00


Meet with SS, KD and SS regarding pretrial tasks (0.8). Review Defendants' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (8.4). Review Mackie‐Mason supplemental report submission and t/c with SS regarding the same (0.5). Review memorandum and order denying defendants' motion for summary judgment (0.8). 10.50 5,775.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/15/2016 Exhibit list review; reading denial of summary judgment. 4.40 2,420.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/15/2016 Discussed trial projects w/team; worked on trial outlines; reviewed court ruling on SJ and MIL; discussed same w/co‐counsel. 8.00 7,400.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/15/2016 Worked on highlighting deposition transcript designations per instructions from Eric Rosoff. 0.40 140.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/16/2016Reviewed fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; correspondence w/ S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re same. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, and co‐counsel re court's summary judgment decision, and issues pertaining to trial preparation. 6.30 4,599.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/16/2016 E‐mails to class members re: summary judgment opinion 1.00 1,120.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 01/16/2016 Review Farris rept. 0.70 647.50 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/16/2016 Review Defendants' exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (10.6). 10.60 5,830.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/16/2016 Reviewing defendants' exhibit list. 2.00 1,100.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/16/2016 Reviewed testimony; worked on trail witness prep issues. 5.50 5,087.50

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/17/2016 Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; correspondence w/ S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re same. 5.00 3,650.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/17/2016 Review Defendants' trial exhibits and prepare chart of key documents (7.4). 7.40 4,070.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/17/2016 Reviewing defendants' exhibit list. 4.00 2,200.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/17/2016 Worked on trial witness prep issues. 8.00 7,400.00


Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; correspondence w/ KL team re same; conference call w/ S. Sparling re same; reviewed work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re same. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, and co‐counsel re court's summary judgment decision, and issues pertaining to trial preparation. Prepared for / participated in weekly associates call. 8.60 6,278.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/18/2016 Review of various e‐mails from co‐counsel re: trial issues 0.50 560.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 01/18/2016 Review Farris rept. 0.50 462.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/18/2016Review sample and model jury charges; review and analyze antitrust section 1 and 2 caselaw; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft jury charges 12.00 9,360.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/18/2016 Review Defendants' trial exhibits and prepare chart of key documents for internal use (8.7) 8.70 4,785.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/18/2016 E‐mails DBG, SSS re: Carlton motion; review materials re: same 1.80 1,728.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/18/2016 Responding to emails regarding review of News's audits of compliance rates. 0.30 165.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/18/2016Reviewed depositions for trial witness prep/outlines; drafted memo to D. Goldman re: same; t/c w/K. Denk re: open projects; reviewed exhibits for use at trial. 11.30 10,452.50


Assisted Kurt Denk with Subpoenas (.70); Prepared Pre‐Trial Binder for Kurt Denk (2.80); assisted Kurt Denk with forwarding Subpoenas to counsel via Federal Express (.40); conferred with Eric Rosoff regarding Deposition Designation Review (.30); Attended to same (2.0); conference with Kurt Denk, Eric Rosoff and Joshua Trachtenberg regarding review of Public and Private companies (.40); Attended to same (6.0) 12.10 4,235.00





Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; correspondence w/ KL team re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly management call and court conference prep meeting w/ D. Goldman. Conducted legal and fact research to draft responsive letter at Court's request to class member public entity issue; supervised associate/paralegal team work product re same; drafted and filed letter to Court. 12.40 9,052.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/19/2016Attend management call; prepare for and attend telephonic conference before Court; draft letter to Court concerning public class members; review and organize public company class list 8.00 8,960.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 01/19/2016 Review materials re jury charges. 1.70 1,572.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/19/2016Research recusal standard; meet with D. James to discuss structure of jury charges; review sample and model jury charges; review and analyze antitrust section 1 and 2 caselaw; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft jury charges 11.50 8,970.00


Review JPTO and exhibits and update internal files (1.6). Review parties' final deposition designations and update internal transcripts (2.2). Fact research regarding News and competitors' compliance rates, t/c with KD regarding the same (.9). Review class list and research public/private status of class members for letter to the Court (9.4). 14.10 7,755.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/19/2016 Review cases & materials for Carlton motion 2.70 2,592.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/19/2016Call w/co‐counsel and damages consultant; call w/co‐counsel re: case management; worked on trial outlines and witness materials; discussed projects w/associates; discussed open issues w/D. Goldman. 9.10 8,417.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/19/2016 Worked on excel spread sheet detailing members of class action that are public companies per instructions from Kurt Denk. 5.40 1,890.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/20/2016 Reviewed Deposition Designations for Meet and Confer meeting 3.40 1,190.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/20/2016Conducted follow‐up diligence on class member/public entity issue; calls/correspondence w/ team and expert re same. Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; correspondence w/ KL team re same; conference call w/ S. Sparling re same. 6.10 4,453.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/20/2016Prepare for and participate in court conference; c/ws K. Denk re: jury questionnaire; t/c J. Anderson; t/c co‐counsel; t/c J. Swindell of J&J; c/w S. Sparling re: trial witnesses; prepare trial exam outlines 8.00 8,960.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 01/20/2016 Revise jury instructions; meeting with C. Pak re same. 8.50 7,862.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/20/2016Review and analyze cases cited in summary judgment papers; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft and revise plaintiff's proposed jury charges 11.80 9,204.00


Factual research regarding News's competitors' compliance rates (2.4). Prepare list of all public class members and public parent companies for presentation at pretrial hearing and t/c with KD regarding the same (2.7). Proofread and qc company lists for draft jury questionnaire and emails and t/c with KD regarding the same (2.3). Meet with S. Cippola regarding QC of parties' designations (.3). 7.70 4,235.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/20/2016Reviewed deposition transcripts for trial; discussed trial witnesses w/D. Goldman; discussed trial projects w/associates; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; drafted witness outline for trial. 10.30 9,527.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/21/2016Conferred Steve Sparling regarding copies of various videos (2002, 2004 and 2006 Sales Summit Videos) (.20); reviewed sales summit videos and categorized same (4.50); attended to deposition designations for Meet and Confer (4.10). 8.80 3,080.00


Conducted follow‐up diligence on class member/public entity issue; calls/correspondence w/ team and expert re same. Revised and circulated draft jury questionnaire to co‐counsel and adversary. Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; correspondence w/ KL team re same. 5.20 3,796.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/21/2016Review and revise jury questionnaire; mtw S. Sparling re: trial witnesses and order of proof; review of exhibits for the purposes of trial examination outlines and opening statement; t/c J. Anderson, counsel for defendants 5.00 5,600.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 01/21/2016 Review case materials; revise jury instructions. 6.00 5,550.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/21/2016Review and analyze cases cited in summary judgment papers; review and analyze summary judgment motion papers; draft and revise plaintiff's proposed jury charges 11.00 8,580.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/21/2016Factual research regarding News's competitors' compliance rates ‐ review Henderson transcript and exhibits, Carpenter transcripts, News's trial exhibits (8.8). 8.80 4,840.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/21/2016 Discussed trial projects w/team; drafted trial witness outline; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 7.00 6,475.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/21/2016 Worked on deposition designations and organizing video exhibits per instructions from Kurt Denk. 2.20 770.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/22/2016Conference with Kurt Denk, Eric Rosoff and Joshua Trachtenberg regarding upcoming projects (.70); reviewed plaintiffs' exhibits for copies of videos and analyzed contents of same (8.40) 8.40 2,940.00


Prepared for and attended team meeting w/ S. Sparling. Conducted follow‐up diligence on class member/public entity issue; calls/correspondence w/ team re same. Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ adversary and co‐counsel re deposition designation objections meet/confer, and reviewed materials in preparation for same. Correspondence w/ vendor (DOAR) and KL team re trial logistics and technology needs. 7.80 5,694.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/22/2016 Prepare for pretrial conference; e‐mails to co‐counsel; review exhibits to prepare trial outlines. 4.00 4,480.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 01/22/2016 Revise jury charge. 1.00 925.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/22/2016 Review and analyze cases cited in summary judgment papers; draft and revise plaintiff's proposed jury charges 2.30 1,794.00





Factual research regarding News's competitors' compliance rates ‐‐ review Carpenter transcript (1.0). Meet with SS and KD regarding pretrial tasks (1.4). Meet with JK, SS and DK regarding pretrial tasks (0.5). Review parties' exhibits for key Garofalo documents and prepare subset for SS (5.5). Review class list for non‐CPG and foreign entities and t/c with KD and SS regarding the same (5.6). 14.00 7,700.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/22/2016 Review and edits to CPG class list. 2.00 1,100.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/22/2016Reviewed evidence for M. Garofalo witness outline and trial testimony; emailed w/team re: same; discussed trial projects w/K. Denk and E. Rosoff; discussed trial issues w/D. Goldman; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; emailed co‐counsel re: trial evidence issues 8.00 7,400.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/22/2016Worked on deposition designation PDF's, created binder of Hendrix and Carlucci depositions for Dan Goldman, Steve Sparling, and Kurt Denk, worked on reviewing the video exhibits received from Kellogg Huber. Met with Kurt Denk, Eric Rosoff, and Santo Cipolla to discuss upcoming tasks and trial prep. 4.10 1,435.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/23/2016 Reviewed videos of NAM Sales summits and created chart outlining contents; Reviewed deposition designations (2.20). 2.20 770.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/23/2016Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; reviewed work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re same. Reviewed/responded to KL and co‐counsel emails re trial strategy and trial prep / diligence items. 7.60 5,548.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/23/2016 Review and revise draft jury charge. 0.30 336.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/23/2016 Review class list and public companies lists for jury questionnaire (5.5) 5.50 3,025.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/23/2016 Review and edits to CPG class list. 4.00 2,200.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/23/2016 Drafted and revised trial outline; emailed w/associates re: open trial prep issues. 10.20 9,435.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/24/2016 Reviewed deposition designations for Friday Meet and Confer 4.90 1,715.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/24/2016Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product. Reviewed work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re follow‐up diligence on class member/public entity issue; correspondence w/ team re same. Reviewed adversary motion filings. 5.70 4,161.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/24/2016Review companies listed on jury questionnaire and prepare internal chart of all companies and changes for expert review (4.2). Fact research regarding News's competitors' compliance rates ‐ review Candice Hamilton transcript (1.5). 5.70 3,135.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/24/2016 Review of Larry Mortimer documents for Garofalo preparation. 0.90 495.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/24/2016 Worked on trail witness outline; emailed w/team re: open projects; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 3.00 2,775.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/25/2016Continued to work on Deposition designations (3.40); reviewed video files regarding NAM Sales Summits for 2002, 2004 and 2006 (3.10); reviewed and revised chart regarding same (1.60). 8.10 2,835.00


Reviewed designated trial exhibits and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; circulated memo analysis to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. Reviewed work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff re follow‐up diligence on class member/public entity issue; circulated memo analysis to D. Goldman. Reviewed/responded to team emails re trial planning and meet/confer items with adversary. Correspondence w/ KL team and vendor (DOAR) re trial support logistics. 10.40 7,592.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/25/2016Prepare for pretrial conference; e‐mails and calls to co‐counsel re: pretrial conference and letter to court from Crowell Moring; t/c K. Gallo of Paul Weiss;review exhibits to prep trial outlines. 7.00 7,840.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/25/2016Review and edit plaintiffs' proposed jury charges; review model jury verdict forms in antitrust cases; draft plaintiffs' proposed jury verdict form; confer with S. Cipolla regarding project to cite‐check and bluebook draft jury charges 5.50 4,290.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/25/2016Draft memo regarding News's competitors' compliance rates and review Carpenter, Henderson, Hamilton and Porco transcripts regarding the same (11.7). T/c and emails with SS and KD regarding factual research of News's retailer contracts with negative contribution margins (0.2). 11.90 6,545.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/25/2016 Review cases re: Daubert issues; draft memorandum of law for motion to exclude Carlton 2.50 2,400.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/25/2016 Garofalo outline preparation; document review. 0.80 440.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/25/2016 Discussed trial projects w/team; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; edited and revised trial outlines; reviewed trial exhibits. 10.30 9,527.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/25/2016Surveyed videos in Plaintiff's exhibits and worked on labeling and indexing them per instructions from Kurt Denk. Also surveyed Defendant's exhibits to check if any of them were videos. 7.80 2,730.00


Assisted Josh Trachtenberg with cite checking jury instructions (.40); conferred with Claudia Pak regarding docket numbers of various cases involving jury instructions (.30); conducted research for docket numbers (.80); reviewed documents regarding meet and confer (2.0); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding same (.30); reviewed and indexed videos (4.20). 8.00 2,800.00


Reviewed designated trial exhibits, deposition testimony, and related fact materials and drafted trial prep work product; circulated memo analysis to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. Reviewed/responded to team and co‐counsel emails re trial planning and meet/confer items with adversary. Correspondence w/ KL team and vendor (DOAR) re trial support logistics. Conference w/ S. Sparling, S. Sivan, E. Rosoff re pretrial court conference follow‐up diligence. 8.40 6,132.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/26/2016 Prepare for and attend final pre‐trial conference; e‐mails to co‐counsel re: trial exam outlines. 8.00 8,960.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/26/2016 Citecheck plaintiffs' proposed jury charges; revise and edit plaintiffs' proposed jury charges and jury verdict form 7.00 5,460.00


Review emails and letter regarding settlement efforts by outside counsel (.2). Edit and revise compliance memorandum (2.1). Review MacKie Mason Report, MSJ filings and trial exhibits for retail contract offers with negative contribution margins and draft rider for Garofalo outline regarding the same (7.5). Meet with SS, KD and SS regarding pretrial tasks (0.7) 10.50 5,775.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/26/2016 Drafting brief for motion to exclude Carlton 5.10 4,896.00




18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/26/2016 Garofalo outline preparation; document review. 4.40 2,420.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/26/2016 Attended court conference; discussed same w/associates; emails w/co‐counsel re: same and trial projects; worked on trial outline. 13.20 12,210.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/26/2016 Worked on sorting video exhibits and creating index. Cite checked jury instructions brief per instructions from Claudia Pak. 7.80 2,730.00


Conferred with Kimesha Scarbrough, Rachel Goot and Joshua Trachtenberg regarding trial prep (.70); reviewed and revised deposition designations (4.0); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding documents from Drop Box received from Kim Briggs (.30); attended to same (1.0); revised exhibits on local drive to show old and new exhibit numbers (1.20); created chart for Kim Briggs regarding missing exhibits (.80). 8.00 2,800.00


Prepared for/participated in weekly management team call; follow‐up conference w/ S. Sparling re pretrial prep tasks and pending meet/confer. Reviewed/responded to team and co‐counsel emails re trial planning and meet/confer items with adversary. Reviewed designated trial exhibits, deposition testimony, and related fact materials and drafted work product for pending meet/confer. 10.10 7,373.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/27/2016 Review PXs for trial outlines; c/w K. Denk re: meet and confer; t/c Bill Michael. 10.00 11,200.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 01/27/2016Incorporate edits from co‐counsel into jury charges and jury verdict form and revise proposed jury charges and jury verdict form; conduct legal research on comments raised by co‐counsel regarding jury charges 3.50 2,730.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/27/2016Draft Garofaolo cross outline rider on issue of money‐losing contracts (4.3). Meet with KD regarding review of key Garofalo documents (0.7). Draft Garofalo cross outline rider on issue of News's competitors (5.1). Review transcript of pre‐trial conference held on January 22 (0.8). 10.90 5,995.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 01/27/2016 Drafting papers re: motion to exclude Carlton; e‐mails & t/c SS re: same; e‐mail DBG re: same 3.80 3,648.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/27/2016 Garofalo outline preparation; editing Carlton Daubert motion. 5.70 3,135.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/27/2016 Management call; discussed projects w/team; emails w/co‐counsel; worked on trial witness outline. 9.30 8,602.50


Completed video organization project per instructions from Kurt Denk and corresponded with Kellogg Huber about outstanding issues with video exhibits. Created a binder for Eric Rosoff per his instructions. Met with other paralegals who had gone on trial with Dan Goldman previously per instructions from Kurt Denk to gather information on how Dan likes to operate. 8.40 2,940.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 01/28/2016 Assisted Kurt Denk with preparation for Meet and Confer meeting (5.0). 5.00 1,750.00


Reviewed/responded to team and co‐counsel emails re trial planning and meet/confer items with adversary. Reviewed designated trial exhibits, deposition testimony, and related fact materials and drafted work product for pending meet/confer. Reviewed trial prep work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff; reviewed/responded to KL team follow‐up correspondence re same. Travel to Washington, DC for meet/confer with adversary. 11.20 8,176.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/28/2016 Prepare for meet and confer; review exhibits and trial outlines. 8.00 8,960.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/28/2016Review and edit Garofalo outline rider for News's competitors (0.6). Review Garofalo Retail Hustle presentation transcripts and video and t/c with SS regarding the same (1.1). Review documents for Garofalo witness prep (6.5). 8.20 4,510.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/28/2016 Garofalo outline prep; document review. 4.80 2,640.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/28/2016 Worked on trial outline; discussed trial projects w/team; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 9.20 8,510.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/28/2016Continued revision of video project, updated pre‐trial calendar excel file, reviewed deposition designation highlighted transcripts per instructions from Eric Rosoff. 7.50 2,625.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/29/2016Prepared for/attended meet/confer with adversary re pretrial diligence items and pending amended JPTO; drafted meeting notes and circulated to co‐counsel, and reviewed/responded to follow‐up correspondence re same; return travel to NYC. 10.60 7,738.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/29/2016 Prepare for and participate in meet and confer with defense counsel in DC; review PXs to cull down list and to prepare for examination outlines. 10.00 11,200.00


Review documents for Garofalo witness outline (3.2). Meet with SS and SS regarding pretrial tasks (.4). Review News's exhibit list for public filings and calculate profit margins for named plaintiffs (0.8). Legal research regarding defendants' FRE 106 objections to video clips and draft email memo regarding the same (8.7). 13.10 7,205.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/29/2016 Garofalo outline prep; document review. 4.80 2,640.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/29/2016 Worked on trial outline and reviewed evidence; discussed trial projects w/team. 8.20 7,585.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 01/29/2016 Deposition quality control. 1.10 385.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 01/30/2016Reviewed existing work product and conducted follow‐up research pertaining to review of class member list; circulated work product re same to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. Reviewed trial prep work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff; reviewed/responded to KL team follow‐up correspondence re same. 6.80 4,964.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/30/2016 Review PXs to cull down exhibit list and to prepare for examination outlines. 5.00 5,600.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/30/2016 Review documents provided by R. Caughey for inclusion in Garofalo witness outline, t/cs with SS and SS regarding the same (9.2). 9.20 5,060.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/30/2016 Garofalo outline prep; document review. 1.80 990.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/30/2016 Drafted and revised witness outline; reviewed evidence re: same; t/c w/ER re: gathering relevant trial exhibits. 12.00 11,100.00


Reviewed deposition designation materials and related exhibits and sent summary work product to D. Goldman re same; follow‐up correspondence w/ D. Goldman re same. Reviewed trial prep work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff; reviewed/responded to KL team follow‐up correspondence re same. Revised summary notes and plaintiffs' proposal to adversary re pending amended JPTO and meet/confer follow‐up conference; reviewed/responded to co‐counsel correspondence re same; circulated summary and proposal to adversary. 5.90 4,307.00




18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 01/31/2016 Review PXs to cull down exhibit list and to prepare for examination outlines. 5.50 6,160.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 01/31/2016Review Garofalo depositions from 5/16/07, 7/10/2008, 10/27/2008 and exhibits thereto and prepare chart outlining News' disparagement of competition (7.2). Review trial exhibit list for exhibits marked at prior Garofalo depositions (1.2). 8.40 4,620.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 01/31/2016 Garofalo outline prep; document review. 0.60 330.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 01/31/2016Emailed w/team re: trial prep issues and exhibits; revised and drafted witness outline; reviewed evidence for same; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel. 10.50 9,712.50

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/01/2016 Reviewed Deposition Designations with Joshua Trachtenberg 9.80 3,430.00


Reviewed deposition designation materials and related exhibits and drafted summary work product for D. Goldman re same. Reviewed trial prep work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff; reviewed/responded to KL team follow‐up correspondence re same. Reviewed/responded to correspondence re pending amended JPTO and participated in meet/confer follow‐up teleconference re same. Reviewed/commented on circulated drafts and correspondence re motions in limine. 9.60 7,008.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/01/2016 Prepare and attend meet and confer; review PXs and DXs. 8.00 8,960.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/01/2016 Revise and edit plaintiffs' proposed jury charges and jury verdict form; confer with D. Goldman regarding edits 2.30 1,794.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/01/2016Update Garofalo financial disparagement rider (4.5). Review Garofalo outline and Plaintiffs' trial exhibits for use as evidentiary backstops (3.1). Meet with SS and SS regarding Garofalo witness outline (1.5). 9.10 5,005.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/01/2016 Conference DBF re motion to exclude Carlton. 0.30 288.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/01/2016 Review in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 4.50 2,475.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/01/2016 Worked on witness trial outline; discussed same w/S. Sivan and E. Rosoff; reviewed evidence re: same; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 11.50 10,637.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/01/2016Worked on quality control of designated transcripts per instructions from Kurt Denk. Also received and sorted new video files from KH and updated index of videos. 10.10 3,535.00


Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding preparation of Charles Gitkin witness prep binder for Dani James (.30); reviewed exhibits list for documents referencing Charles Gitkin,, Morrell & Co and Smithfield Foods, created Table of Contents and began to prepare binder (6.0); reviewed final versions of deposition designations for accuracy (4.0); updated docket entries (.40); attended to miscellaneous tasks (2.50). 13.20 4,620.00


Prepared for / participated in weekly management team call; conference w/ D. Goldman re pending trial prep tasks. Reviewed deposition designation materials and related exhibits and drafted summary work product for D. Goldman re same; supervised paralegal team work product re same. Reviewed trial prep work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff; reviewed/responded to KL team follow‐up correspondence re same. Reviewed/responded to correspondence re pending amended JPTO. Reviewed/commented on circulated drafts and correspondence re motions in limine; drafted motion in limine work product and circulated to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 7.80 5,694.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/02/2016Review motions in limine; review, meet and confer e‐mails; management call; review briefs on class period and releases; revise jury instructions; draft trial outlines. 9.00 10,080.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 02/02/2016 Review documents and transcripts for trial outlines. 1.20 1,110.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/02/2016 Revise and edit plaintiffs' proposed jury charges and jury verdict form 4.20 3,276.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/02/2016Review emails re. motions in limine (.2). Review Garofalo transcripts re. annual budget preparation (0.7). Garofalo witness prep ‐‐ update cross outline with evidentiary backstops and review documents and exhibits regarding the same (9.7). 10.60 5,830.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/02/2016 Revisions to draft brief for motion to exclude Carlton; conference and emails DBG re same. 4.20 4,032.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/02/2016 Review in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 8.40 4,620.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/02/2016Edited and drafted witness travel outline; discussed same w/team; reviewed evidence for same; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel; management committee call. 11.40 10,545.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/02/2016 Deposition Designations, Video organization, Worked on witness prep binder for Dani James, assisted team with Garofalo prep outline. 12.90 4,515.00 07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 02/03/2016 Upload exhibits to review database, perform quality control checks and make same available to legal team in review database. 1.30 390.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/03/2016continued to work on witness preparation binders relating to Charles Gitkin, Morrell & Co and Smithfield Foods for Dani James (3.50); reviewed and finalized deposition designations (8.50). 12.00 4,200.00


Calls/conference w/ D. Goldman re pending trial prep tasks. Calls w/ co‐counsel re exhibits database management. Reviewed deposition designation materials and related exhibits and drafted summary work product for D. Goldman re same; supervised paralegal team work product re same. Reviewed trial prep work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff; reviewed/responded to KL team follow‐up correspondence re same. Reviewed/responded to correspondence re pending amended JPTO. Reviewed/commented on circulated drafts and correspondence re motions in limine. Conference call and correspondence w/ co‐counsel and vendor (Applecon) re class list. 9.90 7,227.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/03/2016Review and revise Carlton MIL; review other draft MILs; c/ws S. Sparling re: Garafolo; call among co‐counsel re: settlement; review of PXs and other docs to prepare exam outlines; draft trial assignment list 8.80 9,856.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 02/03/2016 Review deposition transcripts. 2.10 1,942.50 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/03/2016 Review, edit and finalize plaintiffs' proposed jury instructions and jury verdict form 2.30 1,794.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/03/2016 Review trial exhibits and update Garofalo outline with evidentiary backstops (10.7). Meet with SS and SS regarding the same (0.8). 11.50 6,325.00




00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/03/2016 Emails and telephone call SS re Carlton brief; conference DBG re strategy; revisions to Carlton brief; conference SS re finalizing papers 4.50 4,320.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/03/2016 Research and drafting for Carlton Daubert motion. 11.60 6,380.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/03/2016Reviewed evidence for trial witness outline; discussed outline w/S. Sivan and E. Rosoff; discussed trial witness issues w/D. Goldman and K. Denk; emailedw/D. Goldman re: settlement issues; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 11.50 10,637.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/03/2016Worked with LTS to have exhibits uploaded to viewpoint. Worked on highlighting deposition designations. Worked on compiling documents for witness prep meeting for Dani James. Assisted Eric Rosoff with revisions of Garofalo trial examination outline. 13.10 4,585.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/04/2016 Conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding preparation of courtesy copies of filed pleadings for Judge Pauley (.30); 12.00 4,200.00


Calls w/ co‐counsel re exhibits database management. Calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re pending trial prep tasks. Reviewed deposition designation materials and related exhibits and drafted summary work product for D. Goldman re same; supervised paralegal team work product re same. Reviewed trial prep work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff; reviewed/responded to KL team follow‐up correspondence re same. Reviewed/responded to correspondence re pending amended JPTO. Reviewed/commented on circulated drafts and correspondence re motions in limine. Reviewed motions filed by adversary. 10.70 7,811.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/04/2016 Review deposition designations and other trial issues 7.00 7,840.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/04/2016 Review depos for trial outlines. 4.30 3,977.50

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/04/2016Garofalo witness prep: update cross outline with evidentiary backstops, review exhibits regarding the same (9.9). Draft email to SS regarding News Corp interest in retail contract expiration dates and review exhibits and testimony regarding the same (2.5). 12.40 6,820.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/04/2016Review and revise draft papers for motion in limine to exclude Carlton; emails DBG re same; telephone call and email Pfau re same; review and revise papers re motion to seal; telephone calls and emails SS re papers. 6.40 6,144.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/04/2016 Research and drafting for Carlton Daubert motion. 12.50 6,875.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/04/2016 Worked on trial witness outline; reviewed evidence for same; discussed same w/E. Rosoff and S. Sivan. 8.50 7,862.50 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/04/2016 Deposition designations, worked on witness prep binder for Dani James, other trial prep. projects. 11.90 4,165.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/05/2016conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding courtesy copies of recently filed pleadings related to Motions in Limine (.50); attended to same (2.30); finalized Charles Gitkin binder for Dani James; prepared binders regarding Motions in Limine (7.0) 9.80 3,430.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/05/2016 Deliver redacted courtesy copies to Judge at SDNY. 3.00 585.00


Reviewed News motions in limine; conference call w/ D. Goldman & S. Sparling re same. Performed legal research and drafted responsive motions in limine. Supervised paralegal team workflows re deposition designations, exhibits, and witness materials. Reviewed trial prep work product of S. Sivan & E. Rosoff; reviewed/responded to KL team follow‐up correspondence re same. Prepared exhibits and demonstratives for class member review and circulated to D. Goldman. 8.20 5,986.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/05/2016 Review News's motions in limine; make opposition assignments; review of PXs to cut list down and prep for witness outlines 7.00 7,840.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/05/2016 Review exhibits to prepare witness outlines. 2.50 2,312.50

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/05/2016Compile key Garofalo docs for SS (1.9). Update Garofalo cross outline with exhibits and evidentiary backstops, review trial exhibits, and t/c with SS and SS regarding the same (8.8). Review and compile documents referencing News Corp for KD (1.2). 11.90 6,545.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/05/2016 Review and revise draft letter to Judge Pauley re motions in limine; telephone call and emails SS re same. 0.50 480.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/05/2016 Preparing courtesy copies of MiL papers for Chambers; Review in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 5.00 2,750.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/05/2016 Reviewed defendants' MIL; discussed same w/K. Denk and D. Goldman; edited and revised trial outline; discussed same w/E. Rosoff and S. Sivan. 12.00 11,100.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/05/2016Worked on highlighting deposition transcripts. Also spent some time collecting Defendants' Exhibits from HP Hood's production and assisted Eric Rosoff with his work on the Garofalo trial examination outline. 5.80 2,030.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/06/2016 Reviewed and quality control checked deposition transcripts 7.80 2,730.00


Drafted/revised responsive motions in limine, performed legal research pertaining to same, and circulated drafts to D. Goldman & S. Sparling; reviewed/responded to correspondence re same. Supervised paralegal trial prep work product. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ vendor (Applecon) re class list; reviewed revised class list work product and conducted follow‐up research pertaining to same; updated class list work product. 10.40 7,592.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/06/2016 Review PXs and prepare trial outlines 5.00 5,600.00 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/06/2016 Garofalo witness prep: revise Garofalo cross outline, review trial exhibits and testimony regarding the same (10.7). 10.70 5,885.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/06/2016 Review in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 4.30 2,365.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/06/2016 Edited and drafted witness trial outline; emailed w/S. Sivan and E. Rosoff re: same; emailed w/K. Denk re: MIL response. 6.50 6,012.50 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/06/2016 Continued work on cross outline for trial. 2.00 1,850.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/07/2016conferred with Kurt Denk regarding 2002 NAM Sales Summit videos relating to Martin Garofalo (.30); reviewed videos for length of videos (1.40); continued to work on deposition transcript designations (2.50). 4.20 1,470.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/07/2016Reviewed/revised MIL opposition drafts, performed legal research pertaining to same; reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel correspondence re same, and re trial outlines. Reviewed fact documents and work product; reviewed/responded to team correspondence re same. 6.30 4,599.00




18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/07/2016 Review and revise motion in limine oppositions; review of PXs 6.00 6,720.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/07/2016 Review exhibits to prepare witness outlines. 5.10 4,717.50 18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/07/2016 Garofalo witness prep: update cross outline with evidentiary backstops, review trial exhibits regarding the same (6.4). 6.40 3,520.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/07/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 1.70 935.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/07/2016Reviewed and revised draft response to MILs; discussed same w/K. Denk and D. Goldman; edited and revised cross outline for trial; discussed same w/S. Sivan and E. Rosoff. 10.50 9,712.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/07/2016 Worked on highlighting deposition designations and binder of documents from HP Hood's production in the Defendants' exhibits for Dani James. 4.40 1,540.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/08/2016finalized review of deposition designations (.70); highlighted charts for Dani James regarding Gitkin exhibits placed in binder (.40); distributed motion in limine binders to team (.30). 1.40 490.00


Revised/finalized MIL opposition drafts; reviewed/responded to KL team and co‐counsel correspondence re same. Prepared for/participated in weekly associates call. Supervised paralegal trial prep work product. Reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ vendor (Applecon) re class list; reviewed revised class list work product and conducted follow‐up research pertaining to same; updated class list work product. Assembled trial prep review materials for client review and forwarded to D. Goldman. 8.90 6,497.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/08/2016 E‐mails to P&G and Reckitt; draft memo for P&G re: highlights of case; review draft oppositions to motions in limine; review of PXs 8.00 8,960.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/08/2016Garofalo witness prep: update cross outline, review exhibits and testimony regarding the same (9.9). Meet with SS and SS regarding Garofalo outline (0.6) 10.50 5,775.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/08/2016 Review and fact check MIL. 1.00 350.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/08/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 4.00 2,200.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/08/2016 Edited and revised trial outline; discussed same w/team; reviewed MIL motions; discussed same w/team. 8.50 7,862.50


Trail Prep‐tagged various exhibits in ViewPoint as Garofalo Trial Exhibit (.50); updated litigation binder (.80); reviewed documents in Garofalo trial outline per Eric Rosoff's instructions (3.0); updated Motion In Limine binders (.90); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding same (.30); attended to miscellaneous tasks (1.80). 7.30 2,555.00


Reviewed adversary's MIL opposition filings. Prepared for/participated in weekly management team call; follow‐up conference/correspondence w/ S. Sparling & D. Goldman re same. Performed legal research re witness testimony rules, drafted and circulated summary of same. Supervised paralegal trial prep work product. Conference call w/ vendor (Applecon) re class list; reviewed revised class list work product and conducted follow‐up research pertaining to same; updated class list work product and circulated to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 10.30 7,519.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/09/2016 Management call; review motions in limine oppositions; review class list issues; review of PXs; trial exam outlines 11.00 12,320.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/09/2016 Review Ross testimony and documents. 6.20 5,735.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/09/2016Garofalo witness prep: update cross outline with evidentiary support, review trial exhibits and testimony regarding the same (9.0). Review and compile exhibits referencing News Corp. (1.8). 10.80 5,940.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/09/2016 Trial prep. 7.10 2,485.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/09/2016 E‐mails & t/cs SS re: papers on Carlton motion; review opp papers; email Pfau re: same 1.50 1,440.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/09/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony; reading opposition to Carlton Daubert motion. 5.30 2,915.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/09/2016Reviewed court decision on SOL; management committee call; discussed trial projects and legal research w/K. Denk and D. Goldman; discussed witness outline w/S. Sivan and E. Rosoff; edited and revised same. 11.00 10,175.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/09/2016 Worked on placing all exhibits used in Garofalo outline in l drive and view point per instructions from Eric Rosoff. 1.70 595.00


Updated Motion In Limine binders (.50); conferred with Eric Rosoff and Joshua Trachtenberg regarding Garofalo project in ViewPoint (.20); attended to same (.90); updated litigation binder (.40); Conferred with Claudia Pak regarding News' authorities on Jury Instructions (.20); prepared binder of documents relating to Gitkin, Morrell & Co. and Smithfield Foods for Dani James (3.90) 6.10 2,135.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/10/2016 Obtain room for upcoming trial at SDNY. 4.00 780.00


Reviewed documents pertaining to revised JPTO and witness prep. Supervised paralegal trial prep work product. Prepared Carlucci trial subpoena; completed misc admin tasks pertaining to filing of same. Conference call w/ vendor (Applecon) re class list; revised class list work product and circulated to D. Goldman & S. Sparling. 9.40 6,862.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/10/2016 Review PXs; prepare trial outline; review of In Limine motions. 12.00 13,440.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/10/2016 Review Hood material; prepare notes for client meeting. 6.60 6,105.00


Garofalo witness prep: update cross outline with evidentiary backstops, review trial exhibits and testimony regarding the same (5.0). Draft emails to SS regarding News Corp's receipt of staggering charts, titles and functions of Finance dep't personnel, t/c with SS regarding the same (2.4). Compile and review trial exhibits referring to Kroger, draft email to DG and SS regarding the same (2.6). 10.00 5,500.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/10/2016 Trial prep. 7.00 2,450.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/10/2016 Review opp to Carlton motion; t/cs Pfau, SS re: issues for motion; confs. & e‐mails SS re: strategy; t/c DBG re: strategy; drafting reply papers 6.10 5,856.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/10/2016 Research and drafting for Carlton Daubert briefing; drafting sealing papers; review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 8.50 4,675.00




05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/10/2016Edited and revised trial witness outline; drafted memo to team re: fact issue for trial outlines; emails w/D. Goldman re: trial subpoena issues; correspondence w/co‐counsel; discussed trial projects w/associates. 11.20 10,360.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/10/2016 Worked on making sure all Garofalo outline exhibits were in view point and L‐drive, worked on indexing HP Hood defendants' exhibits for Dani James. 6.40 2,240.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/11/2016Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding Top 100 Trial Exhibits (.20); reviewed same and inputted data in spreadsheet (.90); updated litigation binder (.30); updated Gitkin binder (5.60). 7.00 2,450.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/11/2016 Attempt service of subpoena on P. Carlucci at 422 E 72nd Street. 5.00 975.00


Reviewed draft MIL replies and circulated comments re same. Revised class list; conference w/ D. Goldman re same. Calls/correspondence w/ adversary re technology needs; drafted and filed proposed order re same. Reviewed documents pertaining to revised JPTO and witness prep. Supervised paralegal trial prep work product. Calls/correspondence w/ co‐counsel re JPTO filing and pretrial logistics, workflows, and diligence items. 10.60 7,738.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/11/2016 Review PXs; trial outlines; multiple communications to trial team. 13.00 14,560.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/11/2016 Call with counsel; review CPG materials; discussion with DG. 4.90 4,532.50

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/11/2016Meet with S. Sparling re. Garofalo outline (1.0). Garofalo trial prep: update outline with evidentiary backstops, review exhibits and testimony regarding the same and t/cs with SS regarding the same (12.2). 13.20 7,260.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/11/2016 Review and make revisions to Jury Questionnaire; and other trial prep task. 7.50 2,625.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/11/2016 Drafting papers for reply on Carlton motion; t/cs SS re: same; e‐mails SS, KD re: papers; p/m Pfau re: same 7.50 7,200.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/11/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony; research, drafting, and filing of Carlton brief 10.00 5,500.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/11/2016Edited trial outline; discussed same w/E. Rosoff; emailed w/associates re: trial projects; discussed court conference w/D. Goldman and K. Denk; call w/cocounsel re: same; discussed letter to court w/K. Denk. 10.70 9,897.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/11/2016Finalized binder of documents from HP Hood's production in the defendant's exhibits for Dani James. Created a digital folder of PX's & DX's that refer to Nancy Perkins per instructions from Shaked Sivan. 4.60 1,610.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/12/2016Prepared courtesy copies of pleadings for Judge Pauley (1.20); conferred with Shaked Sivan regarding same (.40); finalized Gitkin binder for Dani James (4.0); assisted Kurt Denk, Shaked Sivan and Eric Rosoff with deposition designations (4.0). 9.20 3,220.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/12/2016 Attempt service of subpoena on P. Carlucci at 422 E 72nd Street. 4.50 877.50


Finalized draft revised class list and jury questionnaire; supervised work of paralegal K. Scarbrough re same. Calls/correspondence w/ adversary and vendor re trial technology needs. Reviewed documents pertaining to revised JPTO and witness prep. Supervised paralegal trial prep work product. Calls/correspondence w/ co‐counsel re amended exhibit list, JPTO filing and pretrial logistics, workflows, and diligence items. Revised amended exhibit list, circulated to co‐counsel, and exchanged with adversary. 15.20 11,096.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/12/2016 Review of PXs and DXs; prepare trial outlines and outline of opening statement. 8.00 8,960.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/12/2016 Review motions and witness materials. 3.30 3,052.50 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/12/2016 Review and analyze News's draft jury charges and compare against plaintiffs' proposed jury charges 3.50 2,730.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/12/2016Compile revised exhibit list based on Garofalo outline exhibits, t/c and emails with SS, SS and KD regarding the same (9.2). Garofalo trial prep: update outline with evidentiary backstops, review exhibits and testimony regarding the same (2.6). Review mater protective order (1.6) 13.40 7,370.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/12/2016 Review and make revisions to Jury Questionnaire. 4.00 1,400.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/12/2016T/cs Pfau re: prep for oral argument on Carlton motion; review materials re: same; t/c SS re: binder prep; revisions to letter to Judge Pauley re: motion papers; e‐mail SS re: same 1.30 1,248.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/12/2016Reducing length of exhibit list; preparation for oral argument for Carlton Daubert briefing; review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 9.30 5,115.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/12/2016 Drafted and revised witness trial outline; discussed same w/associates; discussions w/team re: trial issues; correspondence w/co‐counsel re: same 12.30 11,377.50 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/12/2016 Trial prep 2.10 735.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/13/2016 Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding review of Plaintiffs' Amended Exhibit list (.60); revised exhibits in accordance with amended list (7.80). 8.40 2,940.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/13/2016 Attempt service of subpoena on P. Carlucci at 422 E 72nd Street. 4.00 780.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/13/2016Revised amended exhibit list, JPTO, and deposition designations; meet/confer w/ adversary re same; circulated amended document drafts to co‐counsel, reviewed/responded to correspondence w/ co‐counsel re same, and exchanged drafts with adversary. 9.20 6,716.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/13/2016 Communications w/ K. Gallo; review of PXs; review revised pre‐trial order. 8.00 8,960.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/13/2016 Review CPG documents and defendants RTCs. 3.50 3,237.50

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/13/2016Garofalo witness prep: update outline and supporting documents to reflect exhibit list changes (8.5). Garofalo witness prep: update cross outline with evidentiary backstops, review exhibits and testimony regarding the same (4.0) 12.50 6,875.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/13/2016 Review and work on trial exhibits and other trial prep tasks. 8.60 3,010.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/13/2016 Document review in preparation for Ross and Gitkin testimony; review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 5.00 2,750.00




05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/13/2016 Drafted and revised witness trial outline; discussed same w/associates; discussions w/team re: trial issues; correspondence w/co‐counsel re: same 12.80 11,840.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/14/2016attended to trial preparation including revising exhibits to Amended Joint Pre‐Trial Order for Filing; prepared index for Authorities cited by News' with respect to jury instructions; scanned authorities into the L drive for references; reviewed and revised amended exhibit list (11.50). 11.50 4,025.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/14/2016Revised and finalized JPTO and associated exhibits (amended exhibit lists, deposition designations); calls/correspondence with co‐counsel and adversary re same. 8.40 6,132.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/14/2016 Finalized and filed JPTO and associated exhibits (amended exhibit lists, deposition designations); supervised paralegal work produce pertaining to same. 1.00 730.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/14/2016 Review of motions in limine; review various pretrial issues subject to meet and confer. 5.00 5,600.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/14/2016Garofalo witness prep: revise trial outline, update with evidentiary backstops, review trial exhibits and testimony regarding the same (12.6). T/cs with SS and SS regarding Garofalo outline (0.7) 13.30 7,315.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/14/2016 Review and work on trial exhibits and other trial prep tasks. 8.30 2,905.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/14/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 8.20 4,510.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/14/2016 Drafted and revised witness trial outline; discussed same w/associates; discussed trial prep projects w/team; discussed MIL hearing w/co‐counsel 12.60 11,655.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/14/2016 Worked on witness prep binders for Dani James and other trial prep tasks. 12.50 4,375.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/15/2016Prepared for pretrial conference / motions in limine hearing; conference w/ S. Sinaiko re same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman re same. Prepared for/participated in co‐counsel call re prep for pretrial/MIL hearing. 10.90 7,957.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/15/2016 Prepare for MIL arguments; review of proposed stipulations; e‐mails to co‐counsel. 5.00 5,600.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/15/2016 Review CPG documents; call with J. Smith and C. Gitken re scheduling. 2.50 2,312.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/15/2016Review and analyze Defendants' proposed jury charges and jury verdict form; review and analyze defendants' sources cited in proposed jury charges; draft joint jury instructions 5.00 3,900.00


Garofalo witness prep: update trial outline with evidentiary backstops, review trial exhibits and testimony regarding the same (9.7). T/cs with SS regarding Garofalo outline (0.3). Edit and revise email to KD regarding News's confidential designation of Carlucci deposition (0.9). Review Valassis data on News's exhibit list (0.9). 11.80 6,490.00

00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/15/2016 Prep for oral argument on motion to exclude Carlton; confs. KD, SS re: same 4.60 4,416.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/15/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony; preparation for oral argument for Carlton Daubert motion 7.40 4,070.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/15/2016 Drafted and revised witness trial outline; discussed same w/associates; discussed trial prep projects w/team; discussed MIL hearing w/co‐counsel 12.00 11,100.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/15/2016 Assisted with preparing PDF's to be filed with court. 1.00 350.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/15/2016 Prepared materials for meeting in court tomorrow morning. 8.40 2,940.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/16/2016Attended to trial preparation including preparation of binders of cases cited by News Corp. on jury instructions, traveled to Court with Kurt Denk regarding documents needed for hearing 6.50 2,275.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/16/2016Prepared for/attended pretrial conference / motions in limine hearing. Completed trial prep work product; calls/correspondence w/ co‐counsel re same. Calls/correspondence w/ adversary re joint proposed order for trial technology. 10.60 7,738.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/16/2016 Prepare for and participate in pretrial conference. Conferences co‐counsel; review jury instruction issues. 8.00 8,960.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/16/2016 Review CPG documents. 2.70 2,497.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/16/2016Review and analyze Defendants' proposed jury charges and jury verdict form; review and analyze defendants' sources ` cited in proposed jury charges; draft joint jury instructions; draft revised joint jury charges 9.70 7,566.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/16/2016Garofalo witness prep: update trial outline with evidentiary backstops, review trial exhibits and testimony, t/cs with S. Sivan regarding the same (7.8). Garofalo witness prep: cite check testimony and revise outline, t/cs with S. Sivan regarding the same (8.0). 15.80 8,690.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/16/2016 Trial prep. ` 6.30 2,205.00 00929 Sinaiko, Stephen Partner 02/16/2016 Attend hearing on in limine motions & argue motion to exclude Carlton 6.70 6,432.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/16/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 10.70 5,885.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/16/2016Attended court conference; discussed same w/co‐counsel; drafted and revised trial witness outline; discussed same and trial issues w/associates;discussed trial issues w/D. Goldman. 12.60 11,655.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/16/2016 Deposition designations and other trial prep tasks. 2.90 1,015.00


conference with Claudia Pak regarding binder of Jury instructions cited by News (.40); attended to revisions of binder (2.20); attended to scanning of documents to be added to computer folder (.80); conferred with Kurt Denk regarding top 100 exhibits (.20): reviewed and revised excel charts (2.10); attended to miscellaneous tasks (.90). 6.60 2,310.00


Calls/conferences w/ D. Goldman re trial prep diligence items; drafted/revised trial prep work product, supervised work product of paralegal team re same. Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sparling and co‐counsel re trial themes development. Calls/correspondence w/ adversary re joint proposed order for trial technology. 8.80 6,424.00




18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/17/2016 Trial preparations including review of materials for opening statement and witness outlines; c/ws co‐counsel; t/c N. Bearce of Unilever 10.00 11,200.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/17/2016 Meeting with C. Ross, S. Benz and F. Hall; discussion with DG; telephone call with RC re Corsiglia Keim; review hearing transcript and order. 8.70 8,047.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/17/2016Review and analyze Defendants' proposed jury charges and jury verdict form; review and analyze defendants' cases and sources cited in their proposed jury charges; draft joint jury instructions; draft memo concerning key issues between the parties' proposed jury charges 8.50 6,630.00


Emails to SS regarding Garofalo outline exhibits (0.5). Draft email to SS regarding distinction between News's Management Council/Management Board, review Garofalo, Mixson, Carlucci testimony and exhibits regarding the same (2.5). Draft email to SS regarding Insignia's ability to compete, review expert reports, 10K, MSJ regarding the same (2.3). Review sales summit videos, scripts and slide presentations, prepare summary table of the same (2.1). Cite check and revise Garofalo outline, t/c with SS and SS regarding the same (2.5). 9.90 5,445.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/17/2016 Trial prep. 7.00 2,450.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/17/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo testimony. 9.90 5,445.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/17/2016Drafted and revised trial witness outline; discussed same and trial issues w/associates; reviewed correspondence from co‐counsel; reviewed order re: MILs. 13.50 12,487.50

03812 Suris, Liliya Other Tkpr 02/17/2016 Attempted to serve a Trial Subpoena on West Naze. 5.00 850.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/17/2016Provided Dani James with various documents during witness prep meeting this morning, updated JPTO binders and distributed them to the team per instructions from Kurt Denk. Assisted Santo Cipolla with compiling Jury Instructions references and providing to Claudia Pak. 6.80 2,380.00

07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 02/18/2016Download Plaintiffs’ trial exhibits with stickers (excluding videos) provided by Kellogg Huber to the legal team's folder on the firm's network; communications with legal team and Project Manager regarding the exhibits that have been downloaded. 0.30 90.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/18/2016trial preparation including additional round of deposition designations, updated litigation binder of filed pleadings; updated binders of MIls and comprehensive review of Plaintiffs Stickered set of Trial Exhibits 12.00 4,200.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/18/2016 Follow‐up on war room at SDNY. 3.00 585.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/18/2016 Obtain transcript at SDNY. 3.00 585.00


Drafted/revised trial prep work product, supervised work product of associate and paralegal team re same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, and co‐counsel re same. Conference w/ S. Sparling re trial themes development. Calls/correspondence w/ adversary re joint proposed order for trial technology; filed same. 13.90 10,147.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/18/2016Review Judge Pauley's order re: MILs; c/w co‐counsel re: settlement strategy; review Garofalo cross outline; review deposition designations; prepare opening statement; review jury instruction issues 11.00 12,320.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 02/18/2016 Telephone call with S. Sparling re trial prep and strategy; review CPG documents. 0.80 740.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/18/2016

Draft revised joint jury charges and revised joint jury verdict; review jury model charges involving class actions and antitrust claims; research caselaw on whether named plaintiffs must individually demonstrate injury and prove damages in antitrust lawsuit; confer with defendants' counsel regarding jury charges 7.50 5,850.00


Respond to emails from SS regarding Garofalo outline (0.3). Review sales summit videos, speeches and slide deck exhibits and prepare summary chart of the same (0.8). Meet with SS, KD and SS regarding Naze, Aversano witness outlines (.9). Review and compile Aversano trial exhibits for KD (2.5). Review Rebh deposition designations (1.3). Compile and review Naze trial exhibits (0.8). Revise Naze outline, review testimony and t/c with SS regarding the same (4) 10.60 5,830.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/18/2016 Review/revise deposition designations and other trial prep tasks. ` ` 13.10 4,585.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/18/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Garofalo and Naze testimony. 8.90 4,895.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/18/2016Discussed potential trial witness testimony w/D. Goldman; discussed same and related evidence w/K, Denk and R. Caughney; discussed trial issues w/D. James; discussed next trial projects w/associates; reviewed testimony for trial witness outline prep. 10.20 9,435.00

03812 Suris, Liliya Other Tkpr 02/18/2016 Attempted to serve West Naze with a trial subpoena. 5.50 935.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/18/2016 Various trial prep tasks including quality control of exhibits, deposition designations, and preparing materials for upcoming witness prep meetings. 14.00 4,900.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/19/2016Attended to trial prep including review of Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibits(page checked same and compared to list for accuracy); assisted Claudia Pak with copies of ABA Model Jury Instructions (7.0). 7.00 2,450.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/19/2016Drafted/revised trial prep work product, supervised work product of associate and paralegal team re same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, and co‐counsel re same. Updated/circulated deposition designations for exchange w/ adversary. 11.10 8,103.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/19/2016Trial preparations including review of materials for opening statement and witness outlines; c/ws co‐counsel; c/w D. James re: CPG testimony; c/w C. Pak and R. Hess re: jury instructions 9.00 10,080.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 02/19/2016 Review Corsiglia‐Keim depo and documents; draft witness outline. 7.00 6,475.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/19/2016Draft revised joint jury charges and revised joint jury verdict; review jury model charges involving class actions and antitrust claims; research caselaw on whether named plaintiffs must individually demonstrate injury and prove damages in antitrust lawsuit 8.50 6,630.00





Review Hendrix, Berg, Hansa, Bevilaqua and Lucidi deposition designations (1.8). Draft Naze background for outline, review exhibits and testimony regarding the same (4.3). Review exhibits for convergence zone/impulse shopper themes, emails with SS, KD and SS regarding the same (1.4). Revise, edit and check Plaintiffs affirmative deposition designations prior to filing (2.7). Review motion to enjoin settlement offers (1.0) 11.20 6,160.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/19/2016 Review/revise deposition designations and other trial prep tasks. 9.30 3,255.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/19/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Naze testimony. 6.90 3,795.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/19/2016 Discussed trial projects w/associates; worked on trial witness outlines; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 8.00 7,400.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/19/2016 Worked on quality control of stickered plaintiffs' exhibits with Santo Cipolla per instructions from Kurt Denk. 6.30 2,205.00 07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 02/20/2016 On‐call litigation technical support. 3.70 1,110.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/20/2016Drafted/revised trial prep work product, supervised work product of associate and paralegal team re same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, and co‐counsel re same. Updated/circulated deposition designations for exchange w/ adversary. 11.20 8,176.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/20/2016 Trial preparations including reviewing cross exam outlines and opening statement 8.00 8,960.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/20/2016Conference call with R. Hess to discuss and review revised joint draft of jury charges and jury verdict forms; confer with Justin Anderson of Paul Weiss concerning scheduling of meet and confer; provide R. Hess with draft of preliminary instructions with tracked changes 4.80 3,744.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/20/2016 Draft Aversano trial outline, review trial exhibits and testimony regarding the same (5.9). Compile and review Retail Meeting Agendas (1.0). 6.90 3,795.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/20/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Aversano testimony. 7.80 4,290.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/20/2016 Worked on trial witness outlines; emailed w/associates re: same; call w/K. Denk re: witness outline; emailed w/D. Goldman re: trial projects. 12.30 11,377.50 03812 Suris, Liliya Other Tkpr 02/20/2016 Served Subpoena to appear and testify at a hearing or trial in a civil action on West Naze. 2.50 425.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/21/2016Drafted/revised trial prep work product (witness outlines, depo designations/objections), supervised work product of associate and paralegal team re same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, and co‐counsel re same. 8.80 6,424.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/21/2016 Trial preparations including reviewing cross exam outlines and opening statement 8.00 8,960.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/21/2016 Draft witness outline; prepare for meeting with Gitkin. 6.70 6,197.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/21/2016Participate in meet and confer with defendants concerning joint draft of jury charges and jury verdict forms; confer with R. Hess concerning meet and confer; provide summary of meet and confer to team; provide defendants with updated version of preliminary jury instructions 4.00 3,120.00


Revise Garofalo outline rider re. contract extensions and preemptive renewals, review documents and t/c with SS regarding the same (2.8). Review Aversano documents provided by Kellogg, t/c and emails with TSG, KD and SS regarding the same (2.7). Review and compile CPG spending data from Def.s' exhibit list and MM reports for DJ (2.1) 7.60 4,180.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/21/2016 Review and outline drafting in preparation for Aversano testimony. 5.20 2,860.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/21/2016Reviewed evidence for witness outline drafting; reviewed and edited rider to witness outline; emailed w/associates re: same; reviewed emails from co‐counsel re: trial issues. 14.60 13,505.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/22/2016 Assisted Joshua Trachtenberg with deposition designations of Smithfield witnesses (4.40); assisted with trial support (4.10). 8.50 2,975.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/22/2016 Obtain abstract of judgment and attempt certificate of judgment at SDNY and Weschester County 6.00 1,170.00


Drafted/revised trial prep work product (witness outlines, depo designations/objections), supervised work product of associate and paralegal team re same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, and co‐counsel re same. Calls/correspondence w/ adversary re tech order, jury questionnaire, depo designations protocol. Calls/correspondence w/ economist team re damages issues and class list. 16.30 11,899.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/22/2016 Trial prep including opening statement and Garofalo cross outline 11.00 12,320.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 02/22/2016Review CPG documents; telephone calls with counsel; telephone call with J. Smith and C. Gitkin; review video clips and transcripts; telephone call with Caughey and Corsiglia‐Keim. 7.30 6,752.50

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/22/2016Research issues in jury charges; review and analyze defendants' edits and proposed jury instructions and jury verdict form; draft, revise, and edit parties' joint proposed jury charges 15.00 11,700.00


Review Aversano documents provided by Kellogg (4.2). Review News's objections and counter‐designations to Naze testimony (1.5). Meet with SS and SS regarding News's objections to Naze designations (0.5). Meet with KD regarding Naze designation objections (0.6). Review Rebh counter‐designations for objections with KD and SS (7.5) 14.30 7,865.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/22/2016 Review/revise deposition designations and other trial prep tasks. 7.70 2,695.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/22/2016 Reviewing and preparing outline for Aversano testimony; working on deposition designations; reviewing draft of jury instructions. 10.60 5,830.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/22/2016Discussed deposition designations w/associates; drafted and revised witness outline; reviewed evidence for witness outline; reviewed correspondence w/co‐counsel. 13.30 12,302.50

03812 Suris, Liliya Other Tkpr 02/22/2016 Composed proof of service on a trial subpoena. Conf. with Kurt Denk. 0.70 119.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/22/2016Compiled documents and excel sheets of exhibits pertinent to particular witnesses for Dani James. Also worked with tech department to upload database of exhibits and performed other trial prep tasks. 11.90 4,165.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/23/2016 Assisted with trial support 7.30 2,555.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/23/2016 Deliver box with jury questionnaires to Judge Pauley at SDNY. 3.00 585.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/23/2016 Working with Ray from Doer to open war room and prepare to get equipment in room at SDNY. 4.00 780.00





Drafted/revised trial prep work product (witness outlines), supervised work product of associate and paralegal team re same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, and co‐counsel re same. Calls/correspondence w/ adversary re tech order, jury questionnaire, depo designations protocol. Calls/correspondence w/ economist team re damages issues and class list. Completed misc admin tasks re trial technology and logistics. 11.10 8,103.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/23/2016 Trial prep including opening statement, Garofalo cross outline, depo designations, graphics, CPG witnesses 10.00 11,200.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/23/2016 Review exhibits; witness outlines. 8.80 8,140.00

18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/23/2016

Research issues in jury charges and jury verdict forms; review and analyze defendants' edits and proposed jury instructions and jury verdict form; draft, revise, and edit parties' joint proposed jury charges and jury verdict forms; file jury charges and jury verdict forms; confer with J. Anderson concerning jury charges 15.00 11,700.00


Review video clips produced by Defendants and summarize the same (0.2). Review objection to Defendants' counter‐designations (0.2). Review Local Rules and Judge Pauley's Individual Rules, email KD regarding the same (0.2). Review Aversano outline, compile documents cited therein, meet with KD and SS regarding the same (0.4). Review documents provided by Kellogg and draft email to SS regarding PX‐3965 (0.8). Review Defs.' Aversano exhibits (0.6). Review Perkins depo transcript (2.1). 4.50 2,475.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/23/2016 Review/revise deposition designations and other trial prep tasks. ` ` 5.00 1,750.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/23/2016 Reviewing and filing jury instructions; reviewing and preparing outline for Aversano testimony 8.70 4,785.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/23/2016

Reviewed evidence for trial witness outline; management call; correspondence w/co‐counsel; t/c w/D. Goldman re: trial issues; emailed w/D. James re: same; calls w/K Denk re: trial issues; reviewed deposition designation objections; emailed w/associates re: trial issues; drafted and revised trial witness outline. 15.70 14,522.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/23/2016 Prepared materials and sent fed ex in advance of Dani James' meeting with witness in Chicago and other trial prep tasks. 8.30 2,905.00


continued with trial preparation including additional rounds of deposition designations (4.0); updated litigation binder (.40); assisted Joshua Trachtenberg with preparation of binder for Dani James (2.0); attended to jury questionnaires including traveling to and from court to pick up questionnaires and preparing copies of same for Dan Goldman (3.80); continued to work on jury binder for Claudia Pak (2.60). 13.80 4,830.00


Conference w/ D. Goldman & trial vendor re trial preparation work product. Drafted/revised trial prep work product (deposition designation objections/responses and witness outlines), supervised work product of associate and paralegal team re same; calls/correspondence w/ D. Goldman, S. Sparling, D. James, and co‐counsel re same. Calls/correspondence w/ adversary re tech order, depo designations protocol. Completed misc admin tasks re trial technology and logistics. 12.30 8,979.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/24/2016 Trial prep including voire dire questions, jury charge, opening and Garofalo cross 11.00 12,320.00

06945 James, Dani Partner 02/24/2016 Review exhibits; revise outlines; discussion with DG re outlines; discussion with KD re exhibits and demonstratives; telephone call with Smith & Gitkin. 8.00 7,400.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/24/2016 Coordinate sending courtesy copies of jury charges and jury verdict form to chambers; review draft cover letter 0.50 390.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/24/2016Update Aversano outline, review testimony and exhibits regarding the same (9.8). Compile exhibits for DG and KD (0.7). Prepare Rebh transcript for J. Briody per DG (0.5). Review trial conference transcripts for designation protocol (0.9). 11.90 6,545.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/24/2016 Review/revise deposition designations and other trial prep tasks. 13.50 4,725.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/24/2016 Reviewing and preparing outline for Aversano testimony, drafting deposition designation objections. 6.90 3,795.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/24/2016 Discussed trial projects w/associates; correspondence w/co‐counsel re: trial issues; drafted and revised trial witness outline 17.00 15,725.00


Worked on deposition designations. Also worked on compiling sources cited in Jury instructions for Claudia Pak. Created binder of Smithfield related Defendants' Exhibits for Dani James and delivered to her apartment in advance of her trip to Chicago. Worked with tech services on data base version of trial exhibits. Various other trial prep tasks. 18.20 6,370.00


Conferred with Josh Trachtenberg regarding preparation of Jury instruction binder for Claudia Pak(.40); reviewed jury instructions and created pdfs and index of documents for binder (2.0); began to prepare binder (4.0); traveled to and from office to Court to deliver and pick up Jury Questionnaires (2.60); attended to review and revising deposition designation and other related tasks (4.70). 13.70 4,795.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/25/2016 Pay for trial transcripts at SDNY. 3.00 585.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/25/2016 Working on jury room and setup for trial at SDNY. 4.00 780.00


Prepared for, traveled to/from court for tech setup supervision; meet/confer w/ adversary re same. Prepared for, traveled to/from, attended court conference re jury selection and trial logistics. Prepared pretrial work product, and finalized plaintiffs' deposition designations; supervised paralegal and junior associate work product re same; conferences/correspondence w/ co‐counsel re same. Conference w/ D. Goldman & vendor re trial demonstratives and opening; completed follow‐up admin and research tasks re same. Calls/correspondence w/ co‐counsel re trial logistics. 13.80 10,074.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/25/2016 Prepare and attend hearing with Judge Pauley; review of jury questionnaires; opening statement work with graphics 12.00 13,440.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/25/2016 Travel to Chicago. 4.00 3,700.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/25/2016 Prepare for meeting with Gitkin; meeting with Gitkin, Smith and Schulte. 5.20 4,810.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/25/2016 Return travel to NYC. 4.50 4,162.50




18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/25/2016Update Aversano outline (4.6). Review and edit designation charts and transcripts and prepare set for the Court (5.5). Meet with SS and SS re. Dickson and Spitz outlines (0.6). Gather exhibits for DG to add back to exhibit list (0.6). Review Dickson transcript (1.3). 12.60 6,930.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/25/2016 Review/revise deposition designations and other trial prep tasks; coordinate with vendor re: exhibits to be printed. 14.00 4,900.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/25/2016 Reviewing and preparing outline for Aversano testimony; reviewing and serving deposition designations. 7.60 4,180.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/25/2016Discussed trial projects w/team; reviewed deposition transcripts for trial witness outline prep; attended court conference; discussed trial issues w/co‐counsel; reviewed and revised trial witness outline. 11.00 10,175.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/25/2016 Worked on deposition designations, binder of sources in Jury Instructions for Claudia Pak, and other trial prep tasks. 12.60 4,410.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/26/2016 Attended to trial preparation‐reviewed trial exhibits, delivered deposition exhibits to Dani James' residence; reviewed deposition designations 11.40 3,990.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/26/2016 Deliver letter to Judge Pauley at SDNY. 2.00 390.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/26/2016 Deliver boxes with supplies for trial set‐up at SDNY. 4.00 780.00


Prepared pretrial work product (witness and deposition designation materials); supervised paralegal and junior associate work product re same; conferences/correspondence w/ co‐counsel and adversary re trial objections and depo designations. Calls/correspondence w/ co‐counsel re trial logistics. 14.20 10,366.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/26/2016 Prepare for opening statement; revise graphics; opening statement run through; trial preparations including Garofalo cross outline 12.00 13,440.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/26/2016 Review evidence for witness prep; revise outlines; mock openings; discussion with DG re witnesses and themes. 9.20 8,510.00 18178 Pak, Claudia Associate 02/26/2016 Confer with paralegals concerning jury charge conference prep binder 0.70 546.00


Review and revise designation charts and transcripts for the Court (7.3). Review Garofalo transcripts for prior positions (0.2). Trial preparation: meetings with team members re. trial logistics issues and pending projects (2.5). Review DX exhibit list for ISP pricing data, and summarize the same, meet with KD and SS regarding the same (2.3) 12.30 6,765.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/26/2016 Review of exhibits and other trial prep tasks. ` 11.60 4,060.00 18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/26/2016 Reviewing and preparing outline for Aversano testimony; reviewing and editing highlighted transcripts of deposition designations. 12.10 6,655.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/26/2016Drafted and revised trial witness outline; discussed trial projects w/associates; met w/co‐counsel to discuss opening and trial issues; reviewed correspondence from defense counsel. 13.50 12,487.50

03812 Suris, Liliya Other Tkpr 02/26/2016 Waited and delivered documents for trial to Judge Pauley. 5.00 850.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/26/2016 Various trial prep tasks. 6.50 2,275.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/27/2016 Attended to trial prep‐reviewed Plaintiffs and Defendants Trial Exhibits 15.00 5,250.00


Prepared trial work product; supervised paralegal and junior associate work product re same; conferences/correspondence w/ co‐counsel and adversary re trial objections and depo designations. Conference w/ D. James re witness materials. Calls/correspondence w/ co‐counsel re trial work product and trial logistics. 16.10 11,753.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/27/2016 Prepare for opening statement and Garofalo cross; review and deal with numerous and ongoing trial logistical issues 11.00 12,320.00 17668 Goot, Rachel L. Paralegal 02/27/2016 Trial prep. 12.50 4,375.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/27/2016 Trial prep. 10.20 9,435.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/27/2016Trial prep: compile Garofalo outline trial exhibits (1.5). Compile trial exhibits for deposition witnesses Carlicci, Lucidi, Berg, Ball, Hansa and review transcript designations (4.0). Review Garofalo documents for material subject to redaction (8.3). Revise Aversano outline (1.6). 15.40 8,470.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/27/2016 Review of exhibits and other trial prep tasks. ` 12.80 4,480.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/27/2016 Reviewing and preparing outline for Aversano and Garofalo testimony; page checking witness exhibits and reviewing for redactions; other trial prep. 12.30 6,765.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/27/2016 Drafted and revised trial outlines; emailed w/team re: trial issues. 15.00 13,875.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/27/2016 Quality control of trial exhibits. 4.90 1,715.00

07244 Baldeon, Elliott A. Other Tkpr 02/28/2016

Upload data for PX and DX exhibits that was provided by Kimberly Briggs (Kellogg Huber) to review database, perform quality control checks and make same available to legal team in review database; communications with legal team and Kimberly Briggs regarding problems encountered during the upload of data for exhibits to the review database; create an error log for the data that Kimberly Briggs provided and forward it to legal team and Kimberly Briggs; copy specific contents of the legal team's folder on the firm's network (trial materials and others) to an encrypted external hard drive; on‐call litigation technical support. 9.00 2,700.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/28/2016 Trial preparation‐page checked PX and DX exhibits and other tasks in preparation for trial tomorrow (13.90). 13.90 4,865.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/28/2016 Assist with preparation of boxes for trial at SDNY. 15.00 2,925.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/28/2016Revised and finalized trial work product; supervised paralegal and junior associate work product re same; conferences/correspondence w/ co‐counsel re same. Completed misc admin tasks re trial logistics. 17.80 12,994.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/28/2016 Prepare for opening statement and Garofalo cross; review and deal with numerous and ongoing trial issues; c/ws re settlement 14.00 15,680.00 17668 Goot, Rachel L. Paralegal 02/28/2016 Trial prep. 14.50 5,075.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/28/2016 Trial prep. 12.00 11,100.00




18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/28/2016Trial prep: review Garofalo documents for material subject to parties' stipulation on redaction (5.1). Compile Garofalo documents for DG and meet with DG and SS regarding the same (7.3) 12.40 6,820.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/28/2016 Review of exhibits and other trial prep tasks. 15.60 5,460.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/28/2016 Reviewing and preparing outline for Aversano and Garofalo testimony; page checking witness exhibits and reviewing for redactions; other trial prep. 14.30 7,865.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/28/2016 Worked on trial witness outlines; discussed trail projects w/associates; discussed issues w/co‐counsel; attended trial team meeting 15.00 13,875.00 18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/28/2016 Created binders for trial, quality control of exhibits, various other trial prep tasks. 15.20 5,320.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 02/29/2016 Traveled to and from Court for first day of trial (1.70); set up war room in preparation for trial (.80); provided assistance in war room during trial (7.50). 10.00 3,500.00 05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 02/29/2016 Deliver boxes for trial set‐up and move breakout room at SDNY. 13.00 2,535.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 02/29/2016 Trial. 12.30 8,979.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 02/29/2016 Prepare for and participate in trial 10.50 11,760.00 06945 James, Dani Partner 02/29/2016 Witness prep; trial. 12.00 11,100.00

18331 Rosoff, Eric Associate 02/29/2016Revise and edit Aversano outline (4.0). Review Garofalo exhibits for redactions and redact exhibits (3.8). Compile email to KD of all exhibits designated in depo testimony, but not listed as trial exhibits (1.2), 9.00 4,950.00

06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 02/29/2016 Trial Prep/attended trial. 9.50 3,325.00

18129 Sivan, Shaked Associate 02/29/2016 Reviewing and preparing outline for Aversano and Garofalo testimony; page checking witness exhibits and reviewing for redactions; other trial prep. 7.60 4,180.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 02/29/2016 Attended trial; worked on trial outline; discussed issues w/co‐counsel and team; discussed issues w/clients. 9.50 8,787.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 02/29/2016Prepared materials to send to court house, printed some additional documents for Kurt Denk, worked on Jury sources project for Claudia Pak, quality control of exhibits for anticipated cross examination 11.00 3,850.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 03/01/2016 Pickup boxes at SDNY. 7.00 1,365.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/01/2016 Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails and completed misc admin tasks re post‐trial matters. 0.50 365.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/01/2016 T/c M. Frient and J. Finocharo of Procter and Gamble; e‐mails to co‐counsel re: settlement 0.50 560.00 06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 03/01/2016 Organizing files used at trial.` 3.00 1,050.00 05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/01/2016 Reviewed emails from co‐counsel re: settlement briefing. 0.10 92.50

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 03/01/2016Collected and stored all of Claudia Pak's materials from this case per her request. Also had a brief conversation with Kurt Denk about beginning the process of shredding or storing materials from trial. 0.50 175.00

05855 Colbourne, Paul E. Other Tkpr 03/02/2016 Pickup check from court reporter and other services at SDNY. 4.00 780.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/02/2016 Reviewed/responded to co‐counsel emails and completed misc admin tasks re post‐trial matters. 0.90 657.00 06190 Scarbrough, Kimesha Paralegal 03/02/2016 Organizing files used at trial. 1.00 350.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 03/02/2016 Sorted materials for shredding and storage in the war room per instructions from Kurt Denk. Returned various tech apparatuses to TSG and LTS. 1.40 490.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/04/2016reviewed Steven Sparling working documents for shredding and records (.60); conferred with Joanna Stanley regarding Box of documents belonging to Richard Hess and Think Pad belonging to James Southwick (.20); attended to returning items to Susman Godfrey (.50). 1.30 455.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/10/2016 Review draft settlement agreement; provide comments thereon to J. Southwick of Susman Godfrey 2.00 2,240.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/11/2016 Review preliminary settlement allocation 0.30 336.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/14/2016 Researched Kraft agreements for D. Goldman; conference call w/ D. Goldman re same. 0.40 292.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/15/2016 reorganized war room. 1.00 350.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/15/2016 Participate in Management Committee call 0.30 336.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/16/2016 Reviewed co‐counsel emails and completed misc admin tasks re post‐trial matters. 0.30 219.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/16/2016 Review draft proposed order re: settlement 0.30 336.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/17/2016 Follow‐up correspondence re Kraft agreements. 0.20 146.00

03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 03/18/2016Conferred with Kurt Denk regarding relocating of documents to conference room 2163 and reviewed binders and boxes for shredding (.60); conference with offices services regarding same (.30); prepared binder labels for various binders of Kurt Denk (.20). 1.10 385.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 03/18/2016 Completed misc post‐trial admin tasks (identifying materials for records/preservation, digital storage, etc.). 0.90 657.00

05628 Sparling, Steven Partner 03/24/2016Edited and reviewed memo re: background issues; t/c w/DR re: same; reviewed and commented on chronology from ER; reviewed email correspondence re: developments. 4.50 4,162.50

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 03/29/2016 Attend management committee call 0.30 336.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/04/2016 Review Paul Weiss’ comments on draft settlement agreement; review of draft preliminary approval memorandum of law 2.00 2,240.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/05/2016 Attend management committee call 0.50 560.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/12/2016 Attend management committee call 0.50 560.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/15/2016 T/c N. Bearce of Unilever; email to N. Bearce of Unilever 0.50 560.00




18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/19/2016Attend management committee call; review Paul Weiss’ second round of edits to settlement agreement; review and comment upon memo to Kimberly Clark re settlement 2.50 2,800.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/20/2016 Email to J. Southwick and S. Benz comments to settlement agreement; review of emails from L. LeClair and S. Berry 0.50 560.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 04/26/2016 conferred with Kurt Denk regarding invoices for transcripts (.10); attended to same (.30). 0.40 140.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 04/26/2016Prepared for/participated in conference call w/ Kellogg Huber & Susman Godfrey co‐counsel (S. Benz, J. Southwick, F. Hall) re class list diligence items; follow‐up correspondence w/ same & D. Goldman. 0.90 657.00

18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/26/2016 Attend management committee call 0.50 560.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 04/28/2016 Review revised settlement agreement; email to J. Southwick and S. Benz re settlement agreement 0.50 560.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/02/2016 E‐mails to Kat Rohrbaugh, Kraft Heinz re: settlement; e‐mails to J. Southwick re: settlement 0.50 560.00 03871 Cipolla, Santo A. Paralegal 05/03/2016 Updated litigation index relating to Motion and supporting papers to approve settlement agreement 0.20 70.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/03/2016 Attend management committee call; e‐mail to B. Henry of Coke; review of e‐mails from J. Southwick and S. Berry 0.80 896.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/04/2016 E‐mails to N. Bearce of Unilever and J. Finocharo of Proctor and Gamble 0.30 336.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/06/2016 E‐mail to K. Rohrbaugh of Kraft Heinz re: settlement 0.30 336.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/09/2016 T/c K. Rohrbaugh of Kraft Heinz re: settlement 0.30 336.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/10/2016Correspondence/calls w/ KL team re billing and administrative matters. Correspondence w/ F. Hall (Kellogg Huber) & D. Goldman re class administration diligence. 0.40 292.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/12/2016 Correspondence w/ KL team re follow‐up billing and administrative matters; correspondence w/ D. Goldman re class administration diligence. 0.90 657.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 05/12/2016 E‐mails to P&G, Coke, ConAgra, GSK and Unilever re: address and contact info for class notice 0.50 560.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/13/2016 Correspondence w/ D. Goldman & F. Hall re class administration diligence; admin follow‐up tasks re same. 0.40 292.00

17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 05/31/2016Completed misc diligence items pertaining to filing/delivery of courtesy copies of settlement papers; correspondence/calls w/ F. Hall (Kellogg‐Huber) re same; correspondence w/ D. Goldman re same; supervision of paralegal J. Trachtenberg re same. 1.20 876.00

18244 Trachtenberg, Joshua Paralegal 05/31/2016 Prepared and coordinated for courtesy copies of settlement papers to be delivered to Judge Pauley's Chambers per instructions from Kurt Denk. 2.80 980.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/01/2016 E‐mail and t/c to N. Bearce of Unilever; review revised order and notice 0.50 560.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/02/2016 Review order granting preliminary approval of settlement; e‐mails to M. Frient of Proctor and Gamble 0.30 336.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/07/2016 Attend management call 0.50 560.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/08/2016 Call w/ F. Hall (Kellogg‐Huber) re class list diligence. 0.60 438.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/08/2016 E‐mail to M. Frient of Proctor and Gamble 0.30 336.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/14/2016 Management conference call 0.50 560.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/15/2016 E‐mail to Kraft Heinz 0.30 336.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/21/2016 Calls/correspondence w/ S. Sivan re post‐settlement administration and diligence issues. 1.30 949.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/23/2016 Correspondence w/ D. Goldman & F. Hall re post‐settlement administration diligence (P&G claims). 0.40 292.00 17732 Denk, Kurt M. Associate 06/27/2016 Correspondence w/ S. Sivan re post‐settlement administration diligence / reviewed billing records and summary of work 0.60 438.00 18175 Goldman, Daniel B. Partner 06/29/2016 T/c Procter and Gamble 0.50 560.00

Total 9,556.60 6,908,426.00
