8/14/2019 Evidence Summary Letter, Pine Bush Plaintiffs.pdf

1/4

07 17 2013 WED 11:41 FAX 2127635001 ECBA LLP IlJ002/005

EMERY CELLI BRINCKERHOFF &ABADYLLPR1(' IAftD n. F . ~ 1 ' 1 ' ( Tn ::I'J)I,)NEANDRP.W (1, Ct-.u,I, JR, 12\'l)7bMMOJ\ . ' l ' \ Ol 'U. !V.... A:rr-L MA,'nmw I), h l I N ' : ' I l I ~ U I ' !'t\CSIMILE,ION Hl l'I $. ,\RAlIY 1 1 I \ O r ; " ~ , I ' ~ . I . I , E I I , Pr,/\1. \,21P'" "I-tk>i\ (212) 7635UO IliARI.::>. WM c k e r s . " ( H 114),"cufeterio::tables,,; ":;chooi.wull s,17 'cia51il\'OOll1. o o ~ s t "textbooks," "notebooks;"'''backpacks;'"sturlentclothing/' "kids' shoes/, (H:165"67), the "nrt:table," I ~ I ~ b : f r i b l ~ , " (H J::i4":93). Twice.i.li!6iitl1 thl'6ughoi1t tenlh grade, a s t u d e l ~ t ~ p ~ n t "tlw.:wh9.Le'day in j n ~ ~ l . i s h pigl1 S:cliool with aswastika visible on his ~ h o u l d e r : ; ~ without conseqtlertoe(I 1 166): AsJ-_. tes t i f ied: swastikasare."sttch.a common thing tharlikel'ma:ctuO:lly; I'm stalting to p f l s s t 1 ~ e ~ p y n < > " W . ' 1 (1152); idHt 169 : s ~ e s "swu:stiktls almost every tlayin high SChl,llil"):.? Scil'o.1 secul'ity'tonk pitturet: ( ) f a n t i ~ .I Togi,,"\! t h ~ COllrl just 11 Ulimpso of lUI ovcrwhchnlng, multi-thousand page record, plailitiff.

8/14/2019 Evidence Summary Letter, Pine Bush Plaintiffs.pdf

2/4

07/17/2013 WED 11:41 FAX 2127635001 ECBA LLP ~ 0 0 3 / 0 0 5

E M ~ \ { Y CELLI BRINCKERHOFP ABA:DY LUPage 2OvJJJil l . . , gnll : . t lLl

8/14/2019 Evidence Summary Letter, Pine Bush Plaintiffs.pdf

3/4

07 17 2013 WE 11:41 FAX 2127635001 ECBA LLP ~ 0 0 4 0 0 5

EMERY CELl. BRINCKP.RHOf.r & AnADY 1.l.PPage 3)'Vimess .and its alleged Tltle Vl compllnnce officer, never "discussed anti-Semith; harassment orbullying in any of the Pii1e Bush schools with Boyle) Peters, Winter, llopmayel\ Fistlh andSteinberg. 7 (C 46). . T l literally htmdj'eds 6ftop-Ieve.l.meetirigs iil thedistrict; not oneadministrator'''cverraisc(d] the issue 'of anti-Semitio harassment conduct or bullying in PineHush schools'.' (C 122-23); Carb()nc'swrittcnj66 descriptIon doesn't even include ':'Titlc"Vlcompliance'," (C 148-49.). The district had no policy..ot training:tccllllnng securilyto.repoitr111tiScniitic or olher 1'Ilclsl graffiti to aunlinislmLion (C 56), no wiittenpolicy or. guideline' or .prucedure ti.hi):ut what to do iftacis t; iinti':'Semi.lic or l l l e r . g r a . m G i l f O l l l ~ ~ t i n ..schoorqc57),').mill() Ild.oc;UI.1Wntatk'm.wllen um;l vhere anti-Semitic graffiti i 'i found" (C 65:-(6) .Administrators were "not trained torepolt disciplil1e'" o r ~ o n t i ' : ' S e m i t i c c o n d u c t l ) 'to Carbone at oj1(C136, 151); Defore 2012, eachers were.noteven:required to.:do:cument " b h r s ~ l ' c l a t e d 'incidcnt[sl at the.school"( C 177), or report either " b u l 1 y i n g ~ or;'raeist or antiScmilie?' 'conducttp. n y ' o l 1 ~ . ( C 15.3:..:54). theY'did'reportan incide11t, they could (and sometimes did) omit theanti-Stnl1ilic mtLure uf the incident (d 162-69.); Th.eie..is.no. mon{tQI:lng.o{"mLi-Semitic

l i a r a ~ ; i n ~ ~ t o r ' b ~ L ' l I y i n g ; ' witnessed by staffandteacners (C 154). There is no Uistricl policy .g 1 j i ~ ~ l i . l ~ ~ ~ . } ) r ~ H ; ~ i l w e ' 91; tntjning l ) p w h ~ T l : to fill"the "bias-relnted" 'box on: disciplinary forms (C191':'?8) .. De.felldnnts f < l i I ~ d Lo -repDrt even L b i i ~ s - r e l i . t t l : l , f i n o i d ~ n t \ ) P l ~ i I ) ~ d ~ n t of " li"H\de' fUll oflhe speaker.1lIlolOC;llIst victim.

Case 7:12-cv-02303-KMK-PED Document 42 Filed 07/17/13 Page 3 of 4

http:///reader/full/ctnnpi.lehttp:///reader/full/biJ.1s::-telated.orhttp:///reader/full/awtlyln~chO.olhttp:///reader/full/speaker.1lhttp:///reader/full/ctnnpi.lehttp:///reader/full/biJ.1s::-telated.orhttp:///reader/full/awtlyln~chO.olhttp:///reader/full/speaker.1l

8/14/2019 Evidence Summary Letter, Pine Bush Plaintiffs.pdf

4/4

07 17 2013 WED 11:42 F X 2127635001 ECBA LLP ~ 5 1 5

EMERY CELLI BRINCKERI rOFF D DY LLPPage

. .All cuunsel ofreconl via email)

he Clerk of the CourtS respectfully requestedto docket this letterSo Ordered

Case 7:12-cv-02303-KMK-PED Document 42 Filed 07/17/13 Page 4 of 4