Evalulation of Azelaic Acid for Non-Prescription Use

Michelle BrownAndy ReynoldsTed Williams

Pharm. D candidates, OSU College of Pharmacy

Search Strategy

• Relied primarily on MedLine search

• Used tertiary resources at the discretions of the author

• One dermatologist interview

Diseases

• Mild to Moderate Acne Vulgaris

• Rosacea

• Melasma

Disease State Definition

• Acne– chronic inflammatory disease

of the pilosebaceous units in

the dermis

– Pilosebaceous unit location– Mainly face, back and chest

– Also neck and upper arms

Disease State Causes

• Causes of Acne– Exact causes unknown

– 4 factors involved• Excessive Sebum produced

• Hyperkeratinization of the hair follicle– Prevents shedding of the follicular keratinocytes

– Leads to the formation of microscopic lesions microcomedo

• Accumulation of lipids and cellular debris

• Colonization by Propionibacterium acnes

Disease State Progression

• Normal Follicle

Disease State Progression

• Microcomedo

Disease State Progression

• Open Comedo– “Blackhead”

Disease State Progression

• Closed Comedo– “Whitehead”

Disease State Progression

• Papule– Enflamed lesion

Disease State Progression

• Pustule– Enlarged papule

• Pus filled

• Raised

• Reddened

Disease State Progression

• Nodule (or Cyst)– Inflammation penetrates

deeper into skin– May lead to scarring

or pitting

Disease State Classification

• Defined by American Academy of Dermatology – Mild Acne

• A few to several papules or pustules

– Moderate Acne• Several to many papules and pustules along with several

nodules

– Severe Acne• Numerous or extensive papules and pustules as well as many

nodules

Drug Information

• Drug Requested

• Pharmacology

• Dose

• Indications

• Pharmacokinetics

• Side Effects

Efficacy

• Demonstrated effective vs. no treatment• Demonstrated effective vs. other topicals

(benzoyl peroxide)• Demonstrated effective vs. oral treatments

(tetracycline)• Effective in combinations with other

topicals (Glycolic Acid) and oral treatments (minocycline)

Safety

• Low systemic absorption– FDA Pregnancy category B– Not passed in lactation in above baseline levels– Good option for pregnant patients vs. oral

treatments

• No known drug interactions

CostName Manufacturer Quantity/Price Quantity/Price AW Price Retail Price

Azelaic Acid Gallipot 500 gm ($156.00)

  $0.31  

Azelex cream 20% Allergan 30 gm ($48.53)

50 gm ($84.88)

$1.62-$1.70

$2.26/gm

benzoyl peroxide (aqueous) gel 2.5%

Glades 60 gm ($17.82)

  $0.30  

benzoyl peroxide (aqueous) gel 5%

Glades 60 gm ($18.22)

90 gm ($23.91)

$0.27-0.3 $0.17-0.32/gm

benzoyl peroxide (aqueous) gel 10%

Glades 60 gm ($18.68)

90 gm ($25.06)

$0.28-0.31

$0.26-0.32/gm

erythromycin 2% gel

        $0.70/gm

clindamycin Pi 1% gel

        $0.95/gm

sulfacetamide sodium and sulfur

10% ointment

Allscripts 2.5 gm ($19.31)

  $7.72 $0.38/gm

tretinoin 0.025% Alpharma/USPD

20 gm ($35.50)

45 gm ($67.20)

$1.49-$1.78

$1.01-1.06/gm

Conclusions

• Effective

• Safe

• No known Interactions

• Low Pregnancy Risk

• Elevated Cost vs. Benzoyl Peroxide

• Recommended for OTC Use

References• Facts and Comparisons 4.0 Available from URL:Online http://online.factsandcomparisons.com/• Goulden, V. Guidelines for the Management of Acne Vulgaris in Adolescents. Pediatric Drugs

2003;5(5):301-313• Feldman, S, Careccia R, Barham K, Hancox J. Diagnosis and Treatment of Acne.. American Family

Physician 2004;69:2123-30• Thiboutot D. New Treatments and Therapeutic Strategies for Acne Treatment. Archives of Family

Medicine 2000;9:179-187. Berardi R, McDermott J, Newton G, Oszko M, Popovich N, Rollims C, et al. Handbook of Nonprescription Drugs 2004;913-927.

• The Red Book, (2003).• Arash Akhaven and Susan Bershad, “Topical Acne Drugs; Review of Clinical Properties, Systemic

Exposure, and Safety,” Am J Clin Dermatol 2003, 4(7): 473-492.• Mackrides, P S, Shaughnessy A F, “Azelaic Acid Therapy for Acne,” American Family Physician 1996,

54(8): 2457-2459.• Spellman M.C. and Pincus, S.H., “Efficacy and Safety of Azelaic Acid and Glycolic Acid Combination

Therapy Compared with Tretinoin Therapy for Acne,” Clinical Therapeutics 1998, 20(4): 711-720.• Physician’s Desk Reference 2005, 59th ed.: 907-908.• Drug Information Handbook 2005, 13th ed: 165-166.• RxList The Internet Drug Index on the web at http://www.rxlist.com/cgi/pharmclips.cgi?

keyword=AZELEX (last accessed Nov. 28, 2005).• Nazzaro-Porro, M., Passai, S., Picardo, M., Breathnach, A., Clayton, R. Zina, G., Beneficial effect of 15%

azelaic acid cream on acne vulgaris. British Journal of Dermatology (1983) 109:45-48• Cavicchini, S., Caputo, R. Long-term Treatment of Acne with 20% Azelaic Acid Cream. Acta Dermato-

Venereologica (1989) Suppliment 143:40-44• Hjorth, N., Graupe, K. Azelaic Acid for the Treatment of Acne: A Clinical comparison with Oral

Tetracycline. Acta Derm Venereologica (1989) Suppliment 143:45-48• Spellmajn, M.C., Pincus, S. H. Efficacy and Safety of Azelaic Acid and Glycolic Acid Combination

Therapy Compared with Tretinoin Therapy for Acne. Clinical Therapeutics (1998) 20:4 711-720• Gollinick, H. P. M., Graupe, K., Zaumseil. Comparison of combined azelaic acid cream plus oral

minocycline with oral isotretinoin in severe acne. European Journal Dermatology (2001) 11:538-44.• Gass, S. Expert opinion of a practicing dermatologist.