14
June 2017 Evaluation of Polycom Pano Hands-on testing of a feature-rich wireless presentation solution This evaluation sponsored by …

Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

June 2017

Evaluation of Polycom Pano Hands-on testing of a feature-rich wireless presentation solution

Thisevaluationsponsoredby…

Page 2: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page2

Background Foundedin1990andheadquarteredinSanJose,California,Polycomisaprivately-held1companythat

develops,manufactures,andmarketsvideo,voice,andcontentcollaborationandcommunication

productsandservices.Thecompanyemploysapproximately~3,000peopleandgeneratesmorethan

$1Binannualrevenue.

InJune2017,PolycomannouncedanewsolutioncalledPano–awirelessandwiredpresentation

solutionintendedtomakeitquickandeasyformeetingparticipantstopresentandsharevarioustypes

ofcontent.

InMay2017,PolycomcommissionedtheWainhouseResearch(WR)testteamtoperformathird-party

assessmentofPano.Tofacilitatethiseffort,Polycomprovidedapre-releaseversionofthePanodevice,

andaSharpPN-L703B1080ptouch-capable70”display.

Thisdocumentcontainstheresultsofourhands-ontesting.

Understanding Pano Panoisa4K-capablewirelesspresentationsolution(WPS)thatincludesanarrayofadvancedfeatures

andcapabilities.

ThePanopackageisavailablewithanMSRPofUS$1,990fromanetworkofPolycomchannelpartners/

resellers,andincludesthefollowing:

- Panobaseunit

- Accessories(VESAmount,cables,etc.)

ThePanobaseunitincludesthefollowing:

- SupportforPoE+oranexternalpowersupply

- One(1)4KHDMIoutput(capableof60fpswithRGB4:4:4color)

- One(1)4KHDMIinput(30fps)

- Two(2)Ethernetports–oneactive,andoneforfutureuse

- One(1)Analogaudiooutput(3.5mmjack)

- Built-in2.4GHzand5GHzWi-Firadios(forusewithMiracastsources)

- SupportforBluetooth4.0

- Two(2)USBports(fortouchcontrol,mousecontrol,etc.)

Panosupportsuptofive(5)concurrentliveconnectedsources(onewiredandfourwireless),four(4)of

whichcanbedisplayedsimultaneouslyontheconnecteddisplay.

1PolycomwasacquiredbyprivateequityfirmSirisCapitalinSeptember2016

Page 3: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page3

Hands-On Testing System Installation ThePanobaseunitcanbeplacedonatableorinsideacredenza,installedinanequipmentrack

(requiresarackshelf/mountingkit–notincluded),ormountedalmostanywhere(onawall,undera

table,onthebackofadisplay)usingtheincludedVESA-compatiblemountingadaptor.Giventhebase

unit’ssmallsize,weexpectsomecustomerswillsimplyaffixthedevicetothebackofthein-room

displayusingVelcro.

InstallingPanorequiresonlypower,

network,andasingleHDMIconnection

betweenthebaseunitandthedisplay.

ThankstoPoE+support,bothpowerand

networkcanbeprovidedviaasingleCATx

cable.

Whenpowerisfirstapplied,thesystem

bootsupanddisplaysthePanoinitialsetup

page(seeimageatright).

Toconfigurethesystem,theinstaller(user,administrator,etc.)simplyenterstheIPaddressdisplayed

on-screenintoanywebbrowserandstepsthroughthesetupwizardwhichincludes:

- ChangePassword–theinstallermustchangethedefaultpassword

- SystemLanguage

- CloudRegistration–allowstheinstallertoeithersign-intoanexistingPolycomCloudaccountor

createanewaccount

- DeviceName

TheinstallerthenclickstheFinishbutton,at

whichpointthePanosystemrebootsandis

readyforuse.

Afterthesystemreboots,theinstallernowsees

thePanowebuserinterfaceinhisbrowser.This

UIprovidesaccesstovariousadditionalsystem

settings(e.g.enablewirelesssharingprotocols,

definewhetherpin-codesarerequiredfor

sharing,etc.).

Forourhands-ontesting,weusedPano’sdefault

settings.Allinall,ittookuslessthan10minutes

toinstallPanowithinourlabenvironment.

Page 4: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page4

Wired and Wireless Presentation Testing Onceconfigured,Panodisplaysananimatedwelcomemessage(seebelow)ontheroomdisplay.

Forourfirstroundoftesting,wefocusedonPano’scorecompetency–wirelessandwiredcontent

presentation.Panosupportsthefollowingpresentationmethods/protocols:

- Wired(HDMI)presentation

- WirelesspresentationusingthePolycomPanoApp(WindowsandMacPCsonly)

- WirelesspresentationusingAppleAirPlay

- WirelesspresentationusingMiracast

Thetablebelowhighlightsthemethods/protocolsavailabletospecificusersanddevicesbasedonthe

followingassumptions:

- PanoisconnectedtothecorporateLAN

- InternalusersareconnectedtothecorporateLAN

- GuestuserscannotconnecttothecorporateLAN

Wired PanoApp AirPlay MiracastGuestuser X X

InternalUsersWindowsPCuser X X XMacPCuser X X X iOSuser(iPad,iPhone) X Androiduser X(ifsupported)

Thedecisionastowhichmethod/protocoltousedependsontheuser,thedevice(s)inuse,the

features/capabilitiesrequired,andeventhecorporateculture.

Page 5: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page5

Forthepresentationtesting,weusedthefollowingdevices–eachconnectedtothesamenetworkas

thePanodevice.

- MicrosoftSurfacePro4notebookrunningWindows10Pro

- DellInspiron15notebookrunningWindows10Pro

- MacBookAirnotebookrunningmacOS10.12.5

- iMac5kdesktopPCrunningmacOS10.12.5

Wired(HDMI)PresentationTotestwiredpresentationsupport,weconnectedanHDMIcablebetweenthePanodeviceandthefour

testPCslistedabove.Inallcases,theHDMIcontentwasdisplayedontheroomdisplayproperly.

WirelessPresentationusingthePanoAppThePanoappisafreesoftwareapp,availableforWindowsandMacPCs,whichcanbedownloaded

fromthePolycomwebsite.TosharecontentwiththePanoapp,wecompletedthefollowing:

- InstalledthePanoapponourfourtestPCs

- Clickedonthe“StartScreenSharing”button(seeimageatright),atwhichpointtheapp

presentedalistofnearbyPanodevices(dubbedroomswithintheapp)2

- SelectedthePanodevicetousefromthelist

- Enteredtheroom’spresentationpincode(ifthesystemisconfiguredtorequireacode)

- Selectedthecontenttosharefromtheon-screenlistpresentedwithinthePanoapp(seeimage

belowatright)

WeusedthePanoApptosharecontentfrombothWindowsandMacPCs,andinallcasesthesystem

workedasexpected,providingahighqualitycontentsharingexperience.

2ThePanoAppusesBluetooth4.0todetectnearbyPanodevices.ThismethodologyeliminatestheneedfortheIPnetworktosupportdevicediscoveryprotocols.PCslackingBluetoothsupportcanentertheIPaddressofthedesiredPanodevicedirectly.

Page 6: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page6

WirelessPresentationusingAirplayForourAirPlaypresentationtesting,weusedthefollowingAirPlay-capabledevices;aniPhone7,aniPad

Mini2,andaMacBookAirnotebook.TosharecontentwithAirPlay,wecompletedthefollowingsteps:

- Clicked(onthenotebooks)orpressed(onthe

mobiledevices)theAirPlayicon.

- SelectedPanoasthe“AirPlayTo:”device

(seeimageatright).

- Enteredtherequiredpincode,atwhichpoint

ourdevice’sdisplaywasmirroredonthe

Panodisplay.Ondeviceswithmultiple

displays,themaindisplaywasmirrored.

WhenwesharedfromaMacPC,wethenhadtheabilitytochoose:

- Whichdisplaytomirror(ourtestMacPChastwodisplays)

- Whethertomirrororextendthedevice’sdisplay.Extendingessentiallycreatesanextravirtual

displayonthatdevicethatispresentedonthePanodisplay.

Wetestedalloftheabovecapabilities,andPanometorexceededourexpectation.Weespecially

appreciatedthefactthatPano’simplementationofAirPlayincludedadvancedfeatureslikeorientation

awareness(whenweturnedthemobiledevice,theimageturned)andtheabilitytoshareaudio.

Author’sNoteonAirPlay:Asabitofbackground,AirPlayisaproprietaryprotocoldevelopedbyApplethatenablesthesharingof

contentfromAppleMacandiOSdevicesoverIP(usuallywireless)toanydevicerunninganAirPlay

server(e.g.AppleTV).AllApplePCandmobiledevicesincludenativeAirPlayfunctionality

AirPlay,aswellassomeotherwirelesspresentationprotocols(e.g.GoogleCast),followaworkflowin

whichtheclient(e.g.notebookPC,mobiledevice)broadcastsadiscoverymessageovertheIPnetwork

todiscovercompatibleserversthatwillacceptaconnection.Allcompatibleserversthatreceivethe

discoverymessagethenrespondwithaconfirmationmessageincludingconnectioninformation.

Unfortunately,notallIPnetworksareconfiguredtoallowthedevicediscovery/responsetraffic.

AirPlayalsosupportsdevicediscoveryoverBluetooth4.0insteadoftheIPnetwork.Unlikemany

competingvendors,PolycomimplementedBluetoothdiscoverywithinPano’sAirPlaysupport,soAirPlay

userscanseealistofnearbyPanodeviceswithoutdependingontheIPnetwork.

Inaddition,AirPlayincludesamodecalledDirectPlayinwhichInternetmedia(e.g.aYouTubevideo)

thatausertriestoopenonaMacoriOSdeviceisinsteadopenedandplayeddirectlyontheAirPlay

server.Thisprovidesabetterviewingexperiencethanopeningthemediaonthedeviceandusing

screenmirroringtoshareitwiththeAirPlayserver.Unfortunately,Panodoesnotcurrentlysupport

DirectPlaymode.

Page 7: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page7

WirelessPresentationusingMiracastWetestedPano’ssupportforwirelesspresentationusingMiracastwiththefollowingdevices:

- AMicrosoftSurfacePro4runningWindows10Pro

- ASamsunggalaxytab3LiterunningAndroid4.4.4

WhilewehaveanumberofconcernsrelatedtotheMiracastprotocolandworkflow,Pano’s

implementationofMiracastworkedasexpected,allowingustopresentcontentfromourWindowsand

AndroiddevicesonthePanodisplay.

Author’sNoteonMiracast:Asabitofbackground,MiracastisastandardforwirelesspresentationratifiedbytheWi-Fialliance.

Unlikeotherwirelesspresentationprotocols(e.g.AirPlay,MirrorOp,ChromeCast,etc.),Miracastuses

Wi-Fidirect(a.k.a.Wi-FiP2PorPeertoPeer)todiscoverandsendcontentfromthesourcedevicetothe

Miracastserver.

Theadvantageofthismethodologyisthatdevicescansendcontentwirelesslytodeviceswithoutthe

needtobeonthesameIPnetwork.

Unfortunately,therearemanydisadvantagesassociatedwithMiracastincludinglimiteddevicesupport,

possibleWi-Fiinterference,thefactthatsharedcontentisoftenscaled(reducesquality),acomplex

workflowthatisnotconsistentbetweendevices,andmore.AdetailedreviewofMiracastisbeyondthe

scopeofthisstudy,butsufficeittosayMiracastisnotideal.

AutomaticOn-ScreenLayoutPanoallowsuptofoursources,eachatuptofullHD(1080p)resolution,tobedisplayedonscreen

simultaneously.

- Thefirstsharedsourcewillbedisplayedinfullscreen.

- Sharingasecondsourceautomaticallychangestheviewtoaside-by-sidelayout.

- Sharingathirdsourceautomaticallychangestheviewtoaoneabove,twobelowlayout.

- Sharingafourthsourceautomaticallychangestheviewtoaquad-screenlayout.

Blackboard and Annotation Capabilities Panoincludesafewfeaturesnormallyfoundonadvancedcollaboration/ideationsolutions:local

(display-based)blackboardingandannotatingoversharedcontent.

Tousethesefeatures,Panomustbeconnectedtoacompatibletouch-capabledisplayorstandardUSB

mouse.Currently,Polycomhastestedandverifiedthatthefollowingtouchdisplaysprovidean“optimal

touchexperience”withPano:

- SharpPN-L703B-70”1080ptouchdisplay(usedforthisassessment)

- VolantiVB-6500-65”4Ktouchdisplay

HopefullyPolycomwillexpandthelistoftestedandsupportedtouchdisplaysinthenearfuture.

Page 8: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page8

Whenconnectedtoacompatibletouchdisplay,thePano

animatedwelcomemessageautomaticallyexpandstoa

loopingmessagethatinvitestheuserstoshare/present

contentorwalkuptothedisplayandstartwriting(see

imageatright).

BlackboardCapabilitiesTousetheelectronicblackboardfunction,userssimply

needtotapontheboardandstartwriting.

Pano’sblackboardsupportsthefollowingcapabilitiesaccessiblefromaverticaltoolbaralongtheleft

sideofthedisplay:

- Threepensizes/widths

- Sixpencolors(green,blue,red,yellow,whiteandblack)

- Amagichighlighterfunction(writingdisappearsafterafewseconds)

- Anadvancederaserfunction(seedetailbelow)

- Undothelastwritingstroke

- Takeasnapshot

- Createnewpage(withwhiteorblackbackground)

- Displayhelppage

- Endthesession(whichalsoclearstheentireworkspace)

FirstwetestedtheblackboardingfunctiononthePolycom‘testedandapproved”Sharptouch

display.Withthisdisplay,Panoprovidedanexceptionalblackboardingexperience.Wewere

especiallyimpressedbythelow(~80ms)delaywhileinking.

Panoalsosupportsarangeofgesturecontrols.Forexample,movingtwoormorefingersina

circularmotionactivateerasermode.Similarly,movingtwofingersfromoneareatoanother

activatesapanfunction(movecontentfromoneareatoanother).Two-fingerpinchandzoomare

alsosupported,andtogethertheyprovideanalmostunlimitedvirtualblackboardsize.These

controlsmakeitquickandeasytojumpbetweenwritingtoimagemanipulation.

WealsotestedPanousinganadditionaltouchdisplaywehadinourlabenvironment.Onthismon-

Polycom-approveddisplay,theblackboardingfeaturesworkedfine,buttheresponsivenesswasslower.

Page 9: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page9

AnnotationCapabilitiesPanoallowsuserstoannotateoveranyshared(wiredorwireless)content.Butunlikesomesolutions

thatsupportannotationoverstaticimagesonly(viascreenshots),Panosupportsannotationoverlive

andscreenshotimages.

Viewedanotherway,annotationisessentiallytheblackboardingfunctionwithadifferentbackground–

inthiscasethesharedcontentimage(s).

Annotationisalwaysavailableontheleftsideofthedisplaywheneveracontentsource(wired,wireless,

orevenblackboardimages)isonscreen.Bydefault,theannotationmarkingsactasanoverlayontopof

thelivecontentstream.

WetestedPano’sannotationcapabilitieswithexcellentresults.

The Pano Content Tray (with Advanced Layout Control) OneofPano’smostpowerfulandcompellingfeaturesistheabilitytonotonlysharemultiplecontent

items,butalsotocontrolandmanagethePanoon-screenexperience.

Panosupportslivesources(sharedwiredandwirelesscontent,andblackboardcontent),aswellasstatic

contentitems(snapshots).AndeachoftheseitemsliveswithinanareacalledthePanoTray.

Essentially,thePanoTrayisaqueueofavailablecontentitemsthatuserscanchoosetodisplay(make

active)ornotdisplay.TheimagebelowshowsthePanoTray(lowerarea)withseveralcontentitems.

ClickingonacontentitemwithintheContentTraycausesthatitemtobedisplayed(becomeactive).

Clickingonanothermakesthatsecondcontentitemactiveaswell(seescreenshotbelowshowingthree

activecontentitems–onelivesourceandtwoblackboards).

Page 10: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page10

Thiscontentitemselectionprocesscontinuesuntilallfour(4)on-screenpositions/quadrantsareused.

Makingafifthcontentitemactivecausesthefirstactiveitemtobede-activated(first-infirst-out).

Inaddition,amulti-fingerpressonanactivecontentitemallowstheusertomovethatitemtoa

differenton-screenlocation.

Theprocessofchoosingwhichcontentitemstodisplayandpositioningthemon-screensoundsmuch

harderthanitis.Thecontrolsarequiteintuitive,andahelppageisjustasingletouchaway.

TheContentTrayandon-screenlayoutcontrolsmakeitquickandeasyto

createandmanipulatecontentwithPano.However,thePanoon-screenUI

doesnotcurrentlyofferawaytosaveoremailthecontenttoothers.

Fortunately,thePanoAppoffersasavefunction(seethedisplayiconatthe

bottomrightofthescreenshotatright)which:

- Takesasnapshotthatincludesallofthecurrentlyactivecontent

itemsbeingshownonthePanodevice

- Takessnapshotsofeachcontentitem(livesources,blackboards,

etc.)currentlywithinthecontenttray

- Savesallofthesesnapshotsontheuser’sPC(ornetwork/clouddrive)

Wetestedthesavefunction,anditworkedfine.However,thisislessconvenientthananon-screen

saveoremailbutton,andthisworkflowrequirestheusertoopenthePanoAppandconnecttothe

Panodevice.

Additional Features / Functions

IntegrationwithPolycomRealPresenceGroupSeriesEndpointsItcomesasnosurprisethatPolycomhasincludedsomedegreeofintegrationwithPolycomGroup

SeriesvideoendpointswithinPano.

AsshowninthePolycom-provideddiagrambelow,Pano’sHDMIoutputcanbeconnectedtothe

contentinputofaGroupSeriesendpoint.Inaddition,thePanowebuserinterfaceallowsadminsto

“pair”thePanodevicewithaGroupSeriesendpoint.

Oncepaired,PanowillsendanAPIcommandtotheGroupSeriesendpointinstructingittoactivate

contentsharingwheneversomeoneworkswiththePanodevice(e.g.connectingthePanoapptothe

device,sharingwiredorwirelesscontent,etc.).

Wetestedthiscapability,anditworkedasexpected.However,asitstandstoday,theintegrationis

one-sidedonly,meaningthattheGroupSeriesendpointdoesnotchangeitsbehaviorbecauseitis

connectedtoaPanodevice.Asaresult,theresultingexperienceisnotasseamlessasitcouldbe.

Page 11: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page11

Forexample,whileinthisconfiguration,Pano’suserinterfaceisnotalwaysvisible.ToseethePanoUI

(andtheinstructionsuser’sneedtoconnecttoandusePano),oneoftwothingsneedstohappen:

- Auserneedstoactivatecontentsharingonthevideosystem.However,there’snothingthat

promptstheusertoactivatecontentsharing;thesecond(“allcontent”)displayiseitherblank

(whilenotinacall)ordisplayingnear-endvideo(whileinacall).

- AuserneedstoconnecttoPanosothatPanocommandsthevideosystemtoactivatecontent

sharing(viatheAPI).However,inmostcases,toconnecttoPano,theusermustenterapin

code.Unfortunately,thepincodeisdisplayedonthePanoscreenonly,whichisnotvisibleuntil

thePanoUIisvisibleonscreen.

TheabovesituationissomewhatofaCatch-22.

AdditionalNote–thePanoAdministratorGuidehighlightsadditionalwaystousePanowithGroup

Seriesvideoendpointsindualandtriple-monitorconfigurations,withorwithouttouch.Insomecases,

additionalAVhardware(e.g.ascaler/splitter)isrequired.However,eachoftheseapproachesinvolve

somedegreeofcompromise.

HopefullyPolycomwillenhancethisintegrationinthenearfuture.

Page 12: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page12

ThePolycomCloudWhileinstallingPano,wecreatedafreeaccountonthePolycomCloudservice.Wethenregisteredour

Panodevice,usingitsuniqueMacID,tothePolycomCloudservice.

RegisteringaPanodevicetothePolycomCloudoffersahandfulofbenefitsincluding:

- Theabilitytoseethedevice’sstatus(onlineoroffline,name,IPaddress,MacID,etc.viathe

PolycomClouduserportal

- InclusionofthePanodeviceinthedirectoryofPanosystems

- Automaticfirmwareupdates

Inaddition,Polycomhasintroducedafeaturecalled,“CloudServiceContentSharing”thatallowsusers

toshareMicrosoftOneDriveforBusinessdocumentsviathePolycomCloud.Essentially,thePolycom

Cloudhandlestheuser’sauthenticationtoOneDrive,andtheworkflowtoshareOneDrivecontentisas

follows:

- AlistofavailableOneDrivecontentisdisplayedwithinthePanoapp

- Theuserselectsthecontentitemtobeshared

- Thecontentitemis“opened”withinthePolycomCloud

- Thecontentitemisthen“rendered”onPanoandontheuser’sdesktop

AlthoughtheCloudServiceContentSharingfeatureiscurrentlylistedasaPolycomLabsfeature,we

tookthetimetotestthisfunctionality.Intheend,althoughwewereabletoshareourOneDrive

contentsuccessfullyviathePolycomCloud,wethinktheworkflowaroundthisfeatureisnotquiteready

forprimetime.

Page 13: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page13

Analysis and Opinions PanorepresentsPolycominitialforayintothewirelesspresentationmarket.Andwhilenotperfect,

Panobringsquiteabitofpowertothemeetingroom.

Asapartofthisassessment,wetestedvariousfeaturesandfunctionsofPanoincluding:

- Wiredandwirelesspresentation

- Blackboardingandcontentannotation

- Advancedfeatures(integration,cloud-basedmanagementandcontentsharing)

Simplystated–Panoisapowerfulwirelesspresentationsolution.Regardlessofthecontentsource

(WindowsPC,MacPC,mobiledevice,etc.),Panoprovidedahighqualitycontentsharingexperience.

Pano’sAirPlaysupportisanotherareaofstrengththankstoitssupportforBluetoothdevicediscovery.

Andthewiredcontentinputmakesitquickandeasyforgueststosharecontent.

Panoalsosupportsblackboardingandannotationoversharedcontentwhileusingacompatibletouch

display.Wefoundthedigitalinkingwithinthesystemtobeextremelyresponsive–amongthebest

we’veseen.Inaddition,wewereparticularlyimpressedbythebroadrangeofgesturecontrols

supported.Pano’sContentTrayandon-screenlayoutcontrolsalsoworkedextremelywell.Some

solutionsfocusonimagequality.Othersfocusoneaseofuse.Panocoversbothquitewell.

Ourtestingalsorevealedafewweakerareas.Forexample,sharingcontentfromAndroiddevices

dependsonMiracast–whichisalessthanidealprotocol.HopefullyPolycomwillreleaseaPanoappfor

Androidinthefuture.Inaddition,Panolacksanon-screensavebutton.AlsoPolycomhastestedand

verifiedonlyahandfuloftouchdisplaystodate.Andfinally,PanodoesnotcurrentlyofferanyAPIs,and

thecurrentlevelofintegrationbetweenPanoandPolycom’sGroupSeriesvideosystemsislimited.

Overall,PolycomPanoisawellperformingwirelesspresentationsolutionthatoffersarobustfeature-

setandstrongeaseofuse,atacompelling,sub-US$2kpricepoint.Basedonourtesting,Panoshould

berightathomeinalmostanymeetingroom.

Page 14: Evaluation of Polycom Pano · 2020-03-23 · Pano device, using its unique Mac ID, to the Polycom Cloud service. Registering a Pano device to the Polycom Cloud offers a handful of

©2017WainhouseResearch Page14

Contributing Authors / Research Team

IraM.WeinsteinisaSeniorAnalyst&PartneratWainhouseResearchanda25-yearveteranoftheconferencing,collaborationandaudio-visualindustries.Irahasauthoredandcontributedtodozensofarticles,whitepapers,studies,reports,andevaluationsonrichmediacommunications,videoconferencing,streamingandwebcasting,audio-visualdesignandintegration,businessstrategy,andgeneralbusinesspractices.Iraspecializesinprovidingstrategicadvisoryservicestovendors,resellers,andend-userswithinthecollaborationspace.Iracanbereachedatiweinstein@wainhouse.com.

SaarLitmanisaSeniorAnalyst&ConsultantatWainhouseResearchandhas17years’ofexperienceintheaudio-visualandvideoconferencingindustry.Saar’sprimaryfocusistheproducts,services,andcompanieswithintheaudio-visualspace.Inaddition,SaarprovidesAVdesignservices,helpsenterpriseorganizationsdefineandimplementglobalAVstandardsystemsanddesigns,andmanagestheWRtestlabinCoralSprings,[email protected].

PeterSchwarckisaResearcher&TechnicalWriteratWainhouseResearch.Peterhasauthoredanddevelopedcontentforprivatecorporations,non-profits,andgovernmentorganizations.Inaddition,Peterworkedasaneducationalconsultantwhilewritinganddevelopingtextbooksandcurriculumsforforeigncompaniesabroad.Petercanbereachedatpschwarck@wainhouse.com.

About Wainhouse Research WainhouseResearch,www.wainhouse.com, isan

independentanalystfirmthatfocusesoncriticalissuesinthe

UnifiedCommunicationsandCollaboration(UC&C).The

companyconductsmulti-clientandcustomresearchstudies,consultswithendusersonkey

implementationissues,publisheswhitepapersandmarketstatistics,anddeliverspublicandprivate

seminarsaswellasspeakerpresentationsatindustrygroupmeetings.

About Polycom (copyprovidedbyPolycom) Polycomhelpsorganizationsunleashthepowerofhuman

collaboration.Morethan400,000companiesandinstitutions

worldwidedefydistancewithsecurevideo,voiceandcontent

solutionsfromPolycomtoincreaseproductivity,speedtimetomarket,providebettercustomer

service,expandeducationandsavelives.Polycomanditsglobalpartnerecosystemprovideflexible

collaborationsolutionsforanyenvironmentthatdeliverthebestuserexperience,thebroadestmulti-

vendorinteroperabilityandunmatchedinvestmentprotection.Visitwww.polycom.comorconnect

withusonTwitter,Facebook,andLinkedIntolearnmore.

Polycom,RealPresence,RealPresenceTrio,RealPresenceDebut,RealPresenceDesktop,RealPresence

Mobile,VVX,AcousticFence,andNoiseBlockaretrademarksorregisteredtrademarksofPolycom,Inc.