Eva, Du Repentir Skepticism and Knowledge

8/13/2019 Eva, Du Repentir Skepticism and Knowledge

1/16

DU REPENTIR* (III, 2): SCEPTICISM AND

SELF-KNOWLEDGE IN MONTAIGNE

L%( E&a>C F< $>K (BC >@> =C > @CC YD @>Z

(ECCC III, 2) = > @> C @ C@ >>`C @ CCC> C > > @> C@< >

=> > >< (> >

= @C @< 'C E=@C), >=T=>>. I CC>C !>>`C = > => C >>. I CC CC C > =@> . F> C >> C > => = YD @>Z.

KEy WORDS: !>>, (e&e$*(, C@C=, C > >@T> < =C >

< YD @>Z (ECCC III, 2) C >> > = > > C C@C= @< CC> < @ =>>> C CS =C=, @C C >CC C C > => CO@ > C@ < >=> > >< ( => < > @ @= O @T> C< !>> C

@ > > => < => C T>, > C @ C => =KC @C > C>C CO@C @T>C C@ C , < &ha$1#e$%$.

$C=>, >CO >> = > T> =>: > T= => CS =C=, C = > =C C C > >>. F>, =CO @ O !>>

> >C C UC < >=> = > C>C> T= C >T> CK >

> < = @>@< < YD @>Z.

PALAbRAS CLAvE: !>>, (e&e$*(, C@C=, >=>, A.

Taula, quaderns de pensament>C


2/16

I> C =C !>>`C E))a) C

@>> =@ @ => >> > +C> > C

> C> CC =@>

C Y@ =Z, A CC > =C > @C @

YD @>Z (III, 2)2 C < !>>`C =, > > =C. A> A, =

> >< !>> C C, > >>< ==>C C > C >>C> C > C C =C = >< > >>.3 ! @C>`C C, >C C C >>C C

@C>C @@>C> > C @C>=> = = > C > > ;

/[ C C CC>< > =C = C @< >>Z.4

A> @ > @>> C YD @>Z CCCC >

@C= !>>`C C ]>=

Y> C > ==>Z:5 Y => >`C `> >> : C

CC > C>C CC, C< >>C $


3/16

>> C> @>C C= !>>, =@CC C C@C=. $> ==>C > C =

>> C @C Y>>Z C > > < > > C C,

>=>`C E))a) C @ C@C= C > > ,

C= > CC > >C > , C@`C H)*%( %f Sce&*c)#.9 C C > !>>`CA&%"%g %f Ra#%$d Seb%$d C >C C

>> $>> =>C C > > =

C @ > => C. AC $@> CC, => E @ = ]$C>`C C, > C C@C=.10

B > C=> Y => C >>Z >C

> C@< >?

I> C @@, I = @ C= > > >@> YD @>Z

= C@< C. I > A C >>

C=>`C @ > C => =. I C@ C > >CC>, > C => C, C

C @> C@< > => >>> > >< (>

>>`C C

= >, , C @ C@ $>>C @>, C @< >, > > > > !>>`C = > C C > C@C, I >> YD @>Z C => A. AC C C C

@ CC H >@> !>>, C> I > C C =C >@>, C > @> A.

C >`C @,

>:

>C >


4/16

C > > >>> C@C= > C> > !>>,

C => CCC >. I> A&%"%g, >C> >< > @C=

>< > CC

> !>, > . H, C> C

C=:

[/C @ / C @. c`C > C `>> `>: > C; C /@> [ " >> @

CC> >C >C > =>C C CC CO >C CC >

CCC C >C

=> > =C !>> =C C @

>C > =C > >CCZ, = C= CC@> > C@C > @@Z, !>> >C @: C C@@>=> C

@C= > Y!`C @ C >

CC =>.13 A> > >>> @ Y#> D=C >

HC C =>C, CC =C CE))a)

@C> C C> Y >, L = =CC =, C

>Z.14

I> YD @>Z =C @C> >. !>> >=C C Y@> >>, = @@> C=@,

>C ==>C `>C> @>, >Z.15 !>> > >>C Y>>Z, C>Z C@C=: > A&%"%g,

A= C@C @C> C C > => >> >

@ $>> C@C C C => >>, C =C =@> CC >

> >>, C >>> 'C E=@C` H&%*&%)e)16 (

!>> > EC>>`C > >C, > >C C , G $>>

C > @ C C >C: C > >> C

> >> > ( C@C, C :

YB @ >> =C CCC =

>C >


5/16

C YZ =C >Z C @@C Y>Z, > CE))a) C @C>> >> = >

C Y=C @>>CZ:

/[ c C> =C =C @>>C; > @ > C = >,

>> @ C L . J > `L C = =C=C, C @

> =>, C >< @>CC = >. J >` @> > > @ =< >C @ >C .19

!>>`C = @> C > C C=@ C C > C@> C @C>< =@CC>C, @ @C > C

!>>`C >C > C@C=) C @ = C

@> =>> $>> @ @>

C C: > > C @CC C C @@> =C @ > C

@>>C...Z H$, I, 15.19 I, 26, 148A.20 HE" (1992), 7-8.21 II, 12, 601-603A.


6/16


7/16

Y==> > >, = @@>

C=@, >C ==>C `>C> @>, >Z.27 c>> = =

H >@> H @ C CC, CC C > @ > C,

C @> >C . +

CC = C @`C >@>

$>> >> &ha$1#e$%$] @@C C C=@ @> >] > .

*

">>`C @

C C @ > >>> YD @>?Z F= C, C @ C

>> > @@C> > @ >C > @ =< =O: > >, C => > `< >`C: =C- `C

[Z.28 H !>> CC @ C > =C Y CZ:

= = =>, > C C= >C< =<

!> C. C C @C@ >= =< @>, > >, =C C > .

A> A, !>>`C = C > > > @C, > `> C>[Z ] >, C = >C > L , =C

@>Z. H, !>>`C > =CC C @ =@C>< , `C @, C

C Y> @>>C), D=C` =@C C = @> .

AA 44 77

27 + !>>`C ===> Y==> > C> C> C = @

= C@C=? C C = = =@ >> CCC . @ C@C=`C C< C

> C $>CC > =C >C


8/16

I> > C, !>> C > C C > beca+)e

> > , *h%+gh ('+% '+e) .30 A> C C @ CC / => Z. IC C > C C@ C

C @@C? I C ==>@> C CCC

@C>> ==>, !>> C > C C C C C

C > C@ =C. !, > >

==>,


9/16

> > = = < = C@C=, C@ >C>C =CC>. I> C,

>C C >> C @@C CC CC, >> C >C C @C>>

>Z Le) E))a): Yc`C >

>C C <

C, >C: C CC =-=C=, C CCCC C>C, >C>CZ.35 !>> C > C> C >>,

@>C > = @ > > C > C =C>C @@>, > C > @@ C=C > @. YJ

@@C > CC, C>C , #> CC > >

@ @@C, > C=C @>

. I !>>`C @ =>>

=C C > C > => =C C @, @> > =>

!>> CCCC C C = @> > C @C>< @>

C= , C C >>? I> C

C, C C=> =>C C> !>> > C C=C C

C >< >>> ( C @) >, = >, = == !>> CC

@ >> C


10/16

Y =Z @> C, > @@C>, >< > ?

C @ > => Y=Z C >@ > AC = > > > !>> =@

C C, > >C >, > C= >: YJ =`C @ C >CO, = ==> > => L > CC>>->< .41 C

>@ = C, C= >, > DCC. >C >< $CC, DCC >C Y=Z => C

YC>Z >C C C C C C@ => > @@C> >C, > C C C.42 I > DCC > @ !>>`C

=>>, > >C. @> C C Y => C >>Z > C >< C>C, > > > @ => C => >>.

+ C>

Y>Z > @ C C=>, C C

> C >< C=> !>. B @@C = = >`C >> >C,


11/16

C=> >> ==>C =CZ C @@C> @@C ] >= C, C >C> > . C > @@@ CCCC=> C :

> > C@ C > =>> C Y@CC>Z ]

C > > C @@> C > @C > > ==>]

> > Y>Z ] CC>> C >, !>>`C C @ > C C >=@ C@< C, C C

F>C '>`C Q+%d Nh" Sc*+(, @ 1581 > @CC> E))a). '>`C > Y>> C

>>Z C @C> C >C> AC >@> > C >@>, > >C>

AA 44 81

44 II, 1, 335Ac, C


12/16

>C ()ce$*a &e(fec*a (e c%g$*% e)*), C =C > >, >

> < >>, '> C

C @@ >< >C, C, =C =@, > > >> > =C C > = > =?Z46 H, C '>

@; < > @>C @C L = > @


13/16

!C C- C>, C @ C, @> = > @ >CC>?

EC-< CC C>, @C =>, V >

==>=>, C C > C C=@ > > >

=C @ , >C @

C[49

I C C > @ Y)ce$ce2 ( >=50, @C = : Y$ ` C> ` @@ > CC =C @@ I = > >

A`C? IC C=@> >> > > @ C@< =? I > >> , I = > C A`C >C > =>

C =@ I = @> .53 H C C@ >>C

HC +C> > !>>`C > , I > C = > @@C @C, C C !>> >C>C =C,

> >

@C> !>>`C C@C= =C = , >C, >

@ C =C > C @@ >


14/16

... c`C > ==> `>, >, >=, C >C

C> C = > > @< =>C> => C

, @C >> C > >.55 I> Y#>

E@>Z, @C>C C =>C

C= C, @ C= C C> > >, C

> @ , > =C C =>>

C> ] @

> C $>> C@ .

I>C>> > >> $>>C C ( C > ) < >. 'C

@C C@C C > , > > ,

>>`C C, > C =@CC C

> Y>CCZ: YJ C>C @ >C@O >CZ.58 H, >C C =C`C @@C C C C>

@< C> >> = > = `C> >C @=C. J >` @C @ < L C> Z.59 H > > !>> CCC> C >C =CCZ > >

> ==> C


15/16

=CCZ > >C > @ >C @>

(> C > == !>> > =@C< CC). F, C=C

C= C C>> > =C = C @C> =@CC>C =>C >

> C. ! @C> CC> , >

>> @@ >< C C>C @

), = C C= C > >C > C, C @@C

C =C > >>

C > = C @CC>C. E> C, C

= C @< C > C=@ ==> =@CC>C.

B = = =@> >C> > > > C@C> !>>`C C C >>> @>> C C @ C C C C< C=> CC, > C C > > > >[ J >`>C> @>, >[Z. = , C > >>C > >> . > >C @>>, > !>>,

> C @ C @C> C @

C>.62 ! @CC @> > ( C,

@>> C==> = @ >C C >C= C > @

> C >C= @

>CC>CC C @> C >CC>CC C > >

>< > > >=>`C = >> = < > =>>: >> >

CC> > > >CC C @>>). B >

> ]

C, @> > >.

# =< =>C C >>, >

CCCC ==> > > > > > C

@, >

C> > > = > C @C>< @> @>> , >C C > => C > , = `> @;

>` ==> C C C L = C>, > C >C

L @ @C @ C=> C =C @C, C>C C>, C>C C>

>C>Z.63 I>C @ C @ > CC>,

=> > >C > C > => C, > >,

> C > >CC.

AA 44 85

62 ' III, 2, 806B.63 III, 2, 812B.


16/16

b!"g$a#h'

AEBAcH, E. (2003): M#e)). The Re&(e)e$*a*%$ %f Rea"* $ We)*e($ L*e(a*+(e.

$>> > #: $>> >C $CC (>.

B'H, c. (1966): M%$*ag$e a$d Ba"e. Va(a*%$) %$ *he The#e %f S!e&*c)#.

!>C ".

EA, . (2007):A Fg+(a d% F"1)%f%, 'M $ . BE

(.). The Ca#b(dge C%#&a$%$ *% A$ce$* Sce&*c)#. " , c=

>C $CC, @@. 267-287

GI#cA"I, '. (2001): Pe$)e( "3((e)%"+*%$. M%$*ag$e, Pa)ca", La M%*he "e Vae(. T(%)

*$0(a(e) )ce&*'+e). $C: H>O c=@>.

HE", $. (1992): Y!>> > H > F> > c>> ^D @>_Z,M%$*ag$e S*+de), W 1-2, '@= 1992, @@. 7-18

J#k#'kI, F. (1991): Le Fe+ e* "e F"e+e. H0(ac"*e e* "a Re$a))a$ce f(a$/a)e,

G>: D.

Mon$aIgne, M/ / (1988):Le$ E$$ai$, /. /;;/ &/ - &.-L. #+>/;, +;

Documents

Eva, Du Repentir Skepticism and Knowledge