European Policy and Practice towards Ethnic Minorities:

Implications for the Czech Public and Social Policy

• Week 2: Lecturer: Lucie Cviklová Theory base – main paradigms of ethnicity and race in social theory

Conceptualization of ethnicity and race

• Sociological Trinity- Founders of Social Theory had different conceptions of race and ethnicity

• Karl Marx, Emil Durkheim, Max Weber had elaborated the first conceptions of ethnicity and race and their importance for social and political life

• Later on Pierre Bourdieu, Talcott Parsons, Jürgen Habermas and other thinkers elaborated their own conceptions concerning importance of race and ethnicity for social action and also for

social institutions •

Emile Durkheim

• Durkheim analyzed ethnic differences in the framework of his study which is dedicated to the similarities between ancien religious forms on the one hand and current Christian religion on the other

hand• According to Durkheim religion and its

symbols are important for every social and political order – religious symbols acts foster

common social identity• Religious symbols are born through interaction among the individual members of community – he

calls interaction effervescence

Max Weber

• Max Weber in his famous piece Economy and Society (Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft) explained the role of various social institutions such as class and status groups and

various processes such as integration/exclusion for constitution and maintenance of the ethnic cleavages

• he conceptualized different objective roots of race membership (common customs, common religious symbols,

etc.) • He conceptualized the belief in common ethnicity: its multiple

social origins and also its theoretical ambiguities

•

Race and stratification according to

Weber • In Weber‘s presentation, the factors that account

for stratification along ethnic or racial lines are largely the outcome of historical contingency – the reasons why one society was divided along

religious lines, another along racial lines, could no doubt be made intelligible in each particular case

• Weber was clearly sceptical that any general theory of this kind coud possibly cope with such diversity

and complexity

Race and and status groups according to

Weber • Weber points out that status groups of ethnic

provenance derive their sense of social honour from sources that are largely independent of the

formal structure of esteem and deference• Every communal group tends to construct a sense of

its own unique ethnic honour that is immune from the denigration of outsiders

• Each group jealously preserves and cultivates a sense of its own moral worth and dignity and of the

inferiority of all other groups• Weber thus considers ethnic honour to be a

specific honour of the masses

Ethnicity and social closureaccording to Max Weber

• The manner in which status groups seek to mobilize power in a similar way to class organizations is revealed most clearly in Weber‘s discussions of social closure

• by social closure he means the process by which various groups attempt to improve their lot by restricting access to rewards and privileges to a limited circle

• In order to do this they single out certain social and physical attributes they themselves possess and define these as the criteria of eligibility

• Weber says that almost any characteristic may be used to this end provided it can serve as a means of identifying and excluding outsiders

Class conflict and ethnicity according to Max Weber

• According to Max Weber under modern capitalist conditions conflicts on the class and status fronts seem able co-exist quite happily, in the present

depths of industrial gloom and depression • The activites that Weber would have predicted have

been accompanied by a resurgence of ethnic group demands that he would not have predicted

class and status group concerns do not, it seems, simply alternate with changes in the economic

climate

Pierre Bourdieu and his antropological research

• Bourdieu arrived in Algeria in 1956 as a soldier and a philosopher

• he left in 1960 as a self-taught ethnographer and social antropologist, he had published his first book

and undertaken, in person and using research assistants, field research among the Kabyle peasantry

of the Mahgreb and among the urban poor in the Algeria and elsewhere

• The body of data and ethnography thus accumulated was to provide him with enough material for a

substantial body of published work

•

Bourdieu and Algerian working class

• Sociologie de L‘Algérie is primarily a compendium of information about the various ethnic groups which constituted Algerian society in the 1950s (although

towards the end he does not begin to say some more interesting things about the effects of war and

nature of the Algerian revolution • The two other collaborative early books on Algeria, about the Algerian working class, published in 1963, and about the crisis in traditional Algerian agriculture,

published a year later, are, by and large, similarly prosaic•

•

Bourdieu and the disenchantement of the world

• One of the central themes which unifies Bourdieu‘s work is the attempt to understand the relationship betwen subjectivity – individual social being as it is experienced and lived, from the personal inside out, so to speak – and the „objective“ social world within which it is framed and towards the production and

reproduction of which it contributes• Bourdieu made efforts to develop a sociology which

can transcend the subjectivist/objectivist dichotomy• He noticed that Algerian working class members

have conception of time which is similar to Europan peasants before industrialization

Kabyle house

• Bourdieu wrote „La maison Kabyle ou le monde renversé in 1963 but it was published only in 1970

• The Kabyle house is rectangular, typically divided into two disctict parts by an internal half-wall: one-third is

stable space, the rest is for humans and is higher than the animal‘s area

• The front door is for men – the back door for women • A weaving loom faces the front door, against the west

wall by the back door, grain is stored by the north wall, on either side of the cooking area, and water by

the front door

Partial list of equivalences of Kabyle house

• The tangible presence of artifacts, commodities and physical structures symbolises and refers to the abstract cultural order

of values and morality• Male –female

• Outisde –inside• High –low• Light-dark

• Cooked – raw• Grain for eating –grain for saving

• That which is fertilising – that which can be fertilised• Weaving-loom wall –door wall

• Nif-hurma

Seminar work

• 1. When using economic reasons (Marxian approach) try to explain circumstances or reasons of

the war in Iraq.

• 2 When using social notions of closure/social exclusion (Weberian approach) try to explain the

circumstances or reasons of the war in Iraq.