Upload
aida-ida
View
253
Download
4
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
1.0 INTRODUCTION
At its core,nursing deals with issues and situations that have elements of ethical
or moral uncertainty. A spiraling dependence on technology and the resulting
longer lifespan and higher health care costs, coupled with increasing professional
autonomy,creates an atmosphere in which we are faced with problems of ever-
increasing complexity. We need to be able to recongnize situations with ethical
and moral implications, and make coherent and logical ethical decisions based
upon recognized ethical principles and theory.
Nurse need to be able to recognize ethical components of practice and engage in
a structured ethical decision-making process. Ethical decision making models
offer a variety of methods for coming to rational conclusions.
( Margaret & Alvita 2002 )
1.1 Definition of ethic
Ethic is concerned with motives and attitudes and the relationship of these
attitudes to the good of the individual. Ethics may be distinguished from the
low as ethics concerns the good of individual within society while low
concerns society as a whole. Low can be reinforced through courts and
satues while ethic are enforced via ethics committee and professional code.
(Raijah,Khatijah & Rohani 2010).
1.2 Definition of ethical dilemma
Ethical dilemmas can be definined as having to choose between two equally
Desirable or undersirable alternatives ( Marquis & Huston 1994). Curtin
(1982) maintain that for a problem to be an ethical dilemma, it must have
there characteristics:
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 1
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
The problem cannot be solved using empirical data
The problem must be so perplexing that deciding what facts and data
need to used in making the decision difficult.
The result of the problem must affect more then the immediate
situation: there should be far-reaching effects.
By the very nature of and ethical dilemma, there is no good solution,and the
decision made often has to be defended against those who disagree with it.
The ethical decision making process provides a method for nurses to answer
key questions about ethical dilemmas and to organise their thinking in a more
logical and sequential manner.
1.3 Ethical decision making
Ethical decision making requires knowledge and attention to many factors.
Determining the existence of an ethical dilemma is the beginning step in the
process which includes defining the problem, identifying desired objectives,
listing and evaluating alternatives, choosing, the best course of action based
on one’s knowledge and the current circumstances, and evaluating the
outcomes of the action taken.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 2
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
2.0 SCENARIO
Mr Y malay, 64 years old was hospitalized due the severe left diabetic foot
with gangrene,fever and decrease oral intake for one week. Patient have
hypoglycemia attack before.
Seen by doctor X suggest for left below knee amputation,but patient and
relative were refused. Explaination was given by doctor regarding side effect
of gangrene of left foot such as can be septicaemia and worse patient’s
condition.
2.1 ETHICAL ISSUE: THE RIGHT TO REFUSED TREATMENT
FOR BELOW KNEE AMPUTATION.
2.2 Definition of right to refused treatment
The right of a patient to refuse treatment after the physician has informed the
patient of the diagnosis, prognosis, available alternative interventions, risks
and benefits of those options, and risk and probable outcome of no interva-
tion.
( Mosby’s Medical Dictionary 2009)
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 3
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
2.3 Difinition of Below Knee Amputation
Below knee amputation is transtibial amputation in which the devision is in
The proximal third of tibial or distal or the tibial.
( Mosby’s Medical Dictionary 2009)
2.4 Implications if patient refused for below knee amputation
2.4.1 Based on hospital implications
Higher cost hospital for example cost medication,material for dressing
or equipment for treatment. Another implication increase workload for
nurses such as to do activities daily living for patient, dressing , etc.
Implication to the doctors spent more time to do same work. Lastly can
be congested in ward.
2.4.2 Based on the patient’s and family’s refused for below knee amputation
The implication to patient would be high risk for septicaemia and can
cause of death. Implication for family members such as increase
cost due to prolong hospitalization.
.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 4
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
3.0 CONCIDER THE 4 STEPS
3.1 ASSESSMENT ( by using 5 steps ethical decision making process)
3.1.1 Collect , analyse, and interpret data.
Data collected shows the patient is considered severe weakness
Looking pale and bad smelling from gangrene side. Investigation
result become worse especialy haemoglobin was decreased.
Patient and family refused for below knee amputation because their
feel that wound can heel. Besides his family used more cost for
traditional treatment before.
Patient and family make hasty dicision under unstable emotion.
Patient’s family have to bear living cost when to looking for patient
in hospital or stay with patient in ward and can be stress.
3.1.2 State the dilemma
The dilemma in this case is a conflict between nurse’s decision and the
patient ’s family’s decision. The nurse’s decision is patient need do below
knee amputation due to high risk of septicaemia.
The patient’s family’s decision is refused to do below knee amputation
because their feel that wound can be heeling later.
In this case, the nurse prefer doing what is best for patient,applies the
principle of beneficence and non maleficence or do not harm, whether
Can cause pain or suffering but can bring out good for the patient.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 5
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
However before do any action must be take consent from patient or patient’s
family.
3.1.3 Consider choices of action
My opinion, patient should do below knee amputation because to prevent
septicaemia and for live on.
3.1.4 Analyse the advantages and disadvantages of the course of action
Advantages if below knee amputation done.
Patient not stay in ward too long time and can be save his leg.
If amputation is not perfomed in these circumstances gangrene can be
fatal. Besides this save patient’s and family’s cost regarding hospitalized.
Another advantage patient can use prosthesis when after stump healing.
Disadvantage after below knee amputation.
However disadvantage become for temporary example pain in the
amputation stump. It’s main cause is the presence of neuromas
adhered to the local scars also swelling can cause pain and limit
movement.
The loss of foot it means that cannot walk or run as before. Losing
of a limb has also a negative psychological impact. It least amputee
feeling depressed,angry or alone
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 6
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
Recovery is never a fast process. Each step is difficult example
Sitting up in bed, sitting in a wheelchair and standing when using
Crutches.
Lastly patient can feel phantom limb pain. In the amputation
"phantom" limb which has been removed, such as itching, tingling,
warmth, cold, pain, cramping, constriction, movement and any other
imaginable sensation; it is experienced by almost all amputees.
The brain is “remembering” the missing part of the limb, and is still
“reporting” its feelings.
In the missing or amputated part of the limb; it varies from person to
person - a little annoying, very unpleasant, severe, or disabling; it is
different from pain in the residual limb and experienced by about 60–80
percent of amputees.
3.1.5 Make the decision
Consider with patient’s condition, making decision to do below knee amputa-
tion more advantages to patient.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 7
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
3.2 PLAN OF ACTION
3.2.1 Convince patient and family regarding need for below knee amputation is a
very important to save his leg becomes worse.
In this case , amputation is performed because the arteries of the
leg has become blocked due to hardening of the arterie (atherosclerosis).
Blockages in the arteries result in insufficient blood supply to the limb.
Because diabetes can cause hardening of the arteries, about 30-40% of
amputations are performed in patients with diabetes. Patients with diabetes
can develop foot/toe ulceration and about 7% of patients will have an active
ulcer or a healed ulcer. Ulcers are recurrent in many patients and
approximately 5-15% of diabetic patients with ulcers will ultimately require an
amputation. Because hardening of the arteries occurs most commonly in
older men who smoke, the majority of amputations for vascular disease occur
in this group. Diabetes may be an important factor in nearly 40% of patients
undergoing major amputation (Moxey et al 2010).
When hardening of the arteries becomes so severe that gangrene
develops or pain becomes constant and severe, amputation may be the only
option. If amputation is not performed in these circumstances infection can
develop and threaten the life of the patient. Sometimes bypass surgery can be
performed to avoid amputation, but not all patients are suitable for bypass
surgery. Before amputation, the limb can cause serious problems with
infection and pain and may even be a threat to the life of some patients.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 8
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
3.3 IMPLEMENTATION
Amputations in the case of disease are performed as a lifesaving measure.
The diseases that cause the most amputations are peripheral vascular disease
(poor circulation of the blood) and cancer.
The arteries of the legs have become narrowed, hardened and, finally blocked
due to a disease called atherosclerosis or arteriosclerosis. Blockages in the
arteries result in insufficient blood supply to the limb. In this case, diabetes can
cause vascular insufficiency, about 30-40 percent of amputations are
performed in diabetics. When narrowing or hardening of the arteries becomes
gangrene develops and amputation may be the only option. If left untreated –
depanding on the severity of someone’s condition infection can develop and
threaten the life of the patient. If amputation is not performed, in these
circumstances gangrene can be fatal.
Preparation
Before an amputation is performed, extensive testing is done to determine the
proper level of amputation. The goal of the surgeon is to find the place where
healing is most likely to be complete, while allowing the maximum amount of limb
to remain for effective rehabilitation.
The greater the blood flow through an area, the more likely healing is to occur.
These tests are designed to measure blood flow through the limb. Several or all
of them can be done to help choose the proper level of amputation.
measurement of blood pressure in different parts of the limb
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 9
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
xenon 133 studies, which use a radiopharmaceutical to measure blood
flow
oxygen tension measurements in which an oxygen electrode is used to
measure oxygen pressure under the skin. If the pressure is 0, the healing
will not occur. If the pressure reads higher than 40mm Hg (40 milliliters of
mercury), healing of the area is likely to be satisfactory.
laser Doppler measurements of the microcirculation of the skin
skin fluorescent studies that also measure skin microcirculation
skin perfusion measurements using a blood pressure cuff and
photoelectric detector
infrared measurements of skin temperature
No single test is highly predictive of healing, but taken together, the results give
the surgeon an excellent idea of the best place to amputate.
Aftercare
After amputation, medication is prescribed for pain, and patients are treated with
antibiotics to discourage infection. The stump is moved often to encourage good
circulation. Physical therapy and rehabilitation are started as soon as possible,
usually within 48 hours. Studies have shown that there is a positive relationship
between early rehabilitation and effective functioning of the stump and
prosthesis. Length of stay in the hospital depends on the severity of the
amputation and the general health of the amputee, but ranges from several days
to two weeks.
Rehabilitation is a long, arduous process, especially for above the knee
amputees. Twice daily physical therapy is not uncommon. In addition,
psychological counseling is an important part of rehabilitation. Many people feel a
sense of loss and grief when they lose a body part. Others are bothered by
phantom limb syndrome, where they feel as if the amputated part is still in place.
They may even feel pain in the limb that does not exist. Many amputees benefit
from joining self-help groups and meeting others who are also living with
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 10
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
amputation. Addressing the emotional aspects of amputation often speeds the
physical rehabilitation process.
(Gale encydopedia of medicine 2001)
3.4 EVALUATION
Bases on findings the decision to do below knee amputation is protecting the
patient from septicaemia. Usually, before the operation (although not always)
the surgeon decides at what level the amputation will be performed.
In the below the knee operation, the bone in the lower leg (tibia) is divided
about 12-15 cm below the knee joint. This produces a good size stump to
which a prosthesis can be fitted.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 11
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
4.0 RECOMMENDATATIONS / SUGGESTIONS
Patient refused undergone below knee amputation. These are list of recommen-
dation:
Patient condition will become worse if the procedure is not done or delay.
Introduce other successful patient that already went for below knee
amputation.
Explain and introduce prosthesis equipment that is use post below knee
amputation.
In condition of low income or poor family patient will be refer to social
welfare.
Special rehab team is a allocated to follow up patient with post below knee
amputation.
Nurses and health worker team will follow up at home.
According to (Ozana Gajic 2002) Kinesitherapy plays a prominent role in medical
rehabilitation of the person with limb loss. Some kinesitherapeutic techniques used
in all the phases of rehabilitation are presented . The presented kinesitherapeutic
techniques are highly effective on the entire motoric activity as well as on a good
postural adjustment, at the same time giving a number of proprioceptive
information for a successful use of the prosthesis. Immediately after
the amputation exercises are extremely important to prevent contractures
(tightening of the muscles) which, when present, prevent efficient use of
aprosthesis.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 12
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
Pre-prosthetic Training
Education on shrinkage device use
Reinforcement of residual limb (stump) skin care
Range of Motion activities and positioning
Education on progressive strengthening exercises of all extremities. Goal is to
improve strength of all muscles to their maximum in preparation for prosthetic
training. Active exercises progressing to resistive exercises including a variety of
concentric, eccentric, and isometric therapeutic exercises
Reinforcement of bed mobility skills - patient must be independent moving in
bed in all directions
Mobility on floor training - patient must be able to move in all directions on the
floor
Wheelchair Mobility Indoors and Outdoors
Education and reinforcement on transfers at all levels
Balance and coordination exercises
Endurance training
Reinforce content of Home Exercise Program to patient, family or caregiver as
necessary.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 13
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
Post Prosthetic Training
Fitting of prosthesis
Education to patient on appropriate use of prosthetic socks
Education on skin care
Education for proper independence in application and removal of prosthesis
Activities of Daily Living Skills with the prosthesis
Transfers training to all surfaces wearing the prosthesis
Balance and gait training with prosthesis. Outdoors and Indoors. Stairs,
ramps, curbs, elevators
Family training as necessary
Reevaluate ambulation skills periodically and "upgrade" assistive device as
applicable.
The rehabilitation of the person with limb loss is a complex process and period of
training to learn how to function using the prosthesis, with the aim of being
independent in all the activities of daily living, vocational and avocational
activities. The final aim is to live, in the way of life which the person used to live
before the amputation.
The purpose of physical therapy is to empower the person with an amputation to
develop the best level of physical and emotional function that can be achieved.
The rehabilitation program should be design to restore a meaningful quality of life
through return to function in the family, community and workplace. We should
focus not only on the prosthesis but on the individual amputee.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 14
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
5.0 CONCLUSION
Staff nurses make ethical decisions daily. It is important that nurses know how to
manage those decisions appropriately so that clients' ethical rights are honored
without compromising the nurse's own moral conscience. Nurse decide matters
related to management of care.
The process of making thoughtful decisions follow a similar pattern in most
Circumstances. This pattern includes gathering data, comparing options, using
some criteria for weighing the merit of each option, and making choice.
Evaluation of outcomes or circumstances surrounding the choice provides more
data regarding the rightness of the choice.
In this scenario patient should be doing below knee amputation for prevent
worse patient’s conditions and for his live on.
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 15
NBBS 1104 MANAGEMENT AND MEDICAL LEGAL
REFERENCES
Raijah A Rahim, Khatijah Lim,& Rohani Arshad (2010). Management and Medical
Legal Studies B ( 6th ed.) Selangor Open University Malaysia ( OUM )
Margaret A.B & Alvita K. N (2002). Ethics & Issues in Contemporary Nursing ( 2nd ed).
Columbia .Delmar Thomsom Learning.
Murray R B (1993) Nursing Assessment And Health Promotion(5th ed.) North Carolina.
HickoryHill Funiture Corporation.
Leddy S F & Pepper M (1993) Conceptual Base Of Professional Nursing (3rd ed) New
York. J.B.Lippincott Company.
Smith K V (1996). Ethical decision making of nursing. [Online]
Available: http://www.ncbi.nlm.gov/pubmed/8576496 [2010, November 18]
Foot gangrene “cut and medicate” treatment: Below knee amputation. (2005). [ Online]
Available:http://www.reversegangrene.com/foot_gangrene_amputation_picture_htm
[2010 November 18]
OPEN UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA Page 16