Estudio sobre cloud computing en el sector público en España

7/31/2019 Estudio sobre cloud computing en el sector pblico en Espaa

1/175

F}~vnad }d`pf fh mhdvn mdbsv~aekfe fh

}fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj

AE]^A^V^D EJMADEJH NF ^FMEDHDKJ] NF HJ MDBVEAMJMAE


2/175

F}~vnad}d`pf fh mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej 0 nf :;6

Fnamae? Ovhad 03:0

Fh F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjjlj }and fhj`dpjnd sdp fh Ae}~a~v~d

Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!?

Sj`hd Spf ]jeOd} ,napfmmae!

]v}jej nf hj Ivfe~f Pdnpkvf ,mddpnaejmae!

Hjvpj Kjpmj Spf

Mpa}~aej Kv~appf @dpkf

Fnvjpnd hyjpf Jhde}d

Hj pfjhajmae nf f}~f f}~vnad }f lj iaejemajnd nfe~pd nfh spdqfm~d ]FPSHJKD ,]fpyamad}

}d`pf shj~jidpbj mhdvn sjpj spdmf}d} dehaef nf kd`afped q jnbaea}~pjmae fhfm~peamd}!

sdp hj mdeydmj~dpaj 03:: nfh }v`spdkpjbj AEESJM^D nfh Shje Ejmadejh 033


3/175

ENAMF

ENAMF %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% =SVE^D] MHJYF %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 0%=%6 Fhj`dpjmae nfh mvf}~adejpad nf hj femvf}~j q pfjhajmae nf spf~f}~ %%%%%%%%% 0>0%=%9 Bdnfhd nf pfmdsahjmae q f|shd~jmae nf hj aeidpbjmae pf}vh~je~f %%%%%%%%%%%%%% 06

= AE^PDNVMMAE JH MHDVN MDBSV^AEK%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 09

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej = nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


4/175

=%: Nf}mpasmae q mjpjm~fp}~amj} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 09=%0 Mhj}aiamjmae nf hj} }dhvmadef} mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 0%: Mde~f|~d ae~fpejmadejh nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% =;>%0 Mde~f|~d ejmadejh nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% >:

6 BJPMD PFKVHJ^DPAD %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% >>6%: Bjpmd edpbj~ayd nf Spd~fmmae nf Nj~d} nf Mjpm~fp Sfp}dejh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% >6

6%:%: ]fpyamad} nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek j vej fe~anjn s`hamj f}sjdhj sdp vespf}~jndp nf }fpyamad vàmjnd fe F}sjj %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% >96%:%0 ]fpyamad} nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek j vej fe~anjn s`hamj f}sjdhj sdp vespf}~jndp nf }fpyamad vàmjnd ivfpj nf F}sjj %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% >1

6%0 Bjpmd edpbj~ayd nf hj Hfq nf ]fpyamad} nf hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae %%%%%%%%% 6:6%= Bjpmd edpbj~ayd fe bj~fpaj nf mde~pj~d} nfh ]fm~dp S`hamd %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 6:6%> Bjpmd edpbj~ayd nfh F}zvfbj Ejmadejh nf ]fkvpanjn q nfh F}zvfbj Ejmadejhnf Ae~fpdsfpjàhanjn %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 606%6 Bjpmd edpbj~ayd fe bj~fpaj nf spdsafnjn ae~fhfm~vjh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 606%9 Bjpmd edpbj~ayd fe bj~fpaj sfejh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 6=

9 PAF]KD] J]DMAJND] JH MHDVN MDBSVÂEK%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 6>9%: Paf}kd} hfkjhf} q mde~pjm~vjhf} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 6>9%0 Paf}kd} ~meamd} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 66

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej > nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


5/175

; MDEDMABAFE^D Q V]D NFH MHDVN MDBSV^AEKFE FH ]FM^DP S@HAMD FEF]SJJ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 6;

;%: Mdedmabafe~d nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 6;;%:%: Mjejhf} nf aeidpbjmae }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 6;%0%0 Spdyffndpf} nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ;0;%0%= Md}~f fmdebamd j}dmajnd j hj jndsmae nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ;=


6/175

:3 AE^FEMAE NF V]D IV^VPD %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :36:3%: Spfya}adef} nf hj} fe~anjnf} mde }fpyamad} fe mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :36

:3%:%: Spfya}ae nf bje~feabafe~d nf hj} }dhvmadef} mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :36:3%:%0 Spfya}ae nf v}d iv~vpd nf }dhvmadef} ed abshje~jnj} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :39:3%:%= Sjsfh spf}mpas~dp nf hj} fe~anjnf} s`hamj} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :3;:3%:%> F|sfm~j~ayj nf d`~femae nf `fefiamad} iv~vpd} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :31

:3%0 Spfya}adef} nf hj} fe~anjnf} }ae }fpyamad} fe mhdvn mdbsv~aek%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ::3:: JEHA]A] NJID %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ::=

::%: Idp~jhfj} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ::>::%0 Nfàhanjnf}%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ::9::%= Dsdp~veanjnf} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :: Jbfejj} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% ::1

:0

@VFEJ] SPMÂMJ] Q PFMDBFENJMADEF] %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :03

:0%: Pfmdbfenjmadef} f}~pj~kamj} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :03:0%0 Pfmdbfenjmadef} ~fmedhkamj} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :0::0%= Pfmdbfenjmadef} nf kf}~ae %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :00:0%> Pfmdbfenjmadef} nf pfkvhjmae %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :0=

:= MJ]D] NF \A^D %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :0>:=%: F|sfpafemaj} ae~fpejmadejhf} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :0>

:=%:%: F}~jnd} Veand} Sdp~jh V]J%kdy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :0>:=%:%0 F}~jnd} Veand} Shj~jidpbj Jss}%kdy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :06:=%:%= Pfaed Veand KMhdvn %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :0;:=%:%> Ipjemaj Spdqfm~d Jenpdbfnj %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :01:=%:%6 Mdhdbàj Spdqfm~d Spdf|sdp~MPB fe hj ev`f sjpj sqbf} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :=3:=%:%9 Ojse Pfn mhdvn Gj}vbakj}fga ,Shje ÂM Lj~dqjbj! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :=:

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej 9 nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


7/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej ; nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

:=%:%; Hv|fb`vpkd Ae~fkpj~fn @ad`jeg di Hv|fb`vpk ,A@@H! %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :=0:=%:%:=%0%: Jqve~jbafe~d nf Mjhsf F}mpa~dpad yap~vjh %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :=6:=%0%0 Nasv~jmae nf ]jhjbjemj Spf}femaj fe [f` nf hd} Jqve~jbafe~d} nf]jhjbjemj%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :=9:=%0%= ]dmafnjn nf Kf}~ae S`hamj nf F|~pfbjnvpj ,KSF\! Shj~jidpbj nfhama~jmae fhfm~peamj %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :=;:=%0%> Mdppfd} Shj~jidpbj nf ed~aiamjmadef} fhfm~peamj} ]A]ED^ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :=:JEF\D AA? PFHJMAE NF F\SFP^D] %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :>=JEF\D AAA? ]DHVMADEF] MDE BJQDP SPF]FEMAJ EJMADEJH F AE^FPEJMADEJH

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :>6A ]dhvmadef} Ajj] %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :>9AA ]dhvmadef} Sjj]%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :>;AAA ]dhvmadef} ]jj] %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :63

JEF\D AY? PFHJMAE NF FE^ANJNF] SJP^AMASJE^F] FE HJ FEMVF]^J %%%%%%%%%%% :6;ENAMF NF KPIAMD] %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% :9


8/175

SVE^D] MHJYF

Hj fydhvmae ~fmedhkamj f|sfpabfe~jnj fe hj} h~abj} nmjnj} lj ijmaha~jnd fh nf}jppdhhdnf ve evfyd bdnfhd nf mdbsv~jmae( fh mhdvn mdbsv~aekd mdbsv~jmae fe hj ev`f% @jod

f}~f sjpjnakbj( hd} pfmvp}d} nf aeidpbjmae svfnfe }fp jhbjmfejnd} fe }fpyandpf} nf

~fpmfpd} q jmmf}a`hf} j ~pjy} nf Ae~fpef~%

J}( fe ve bdnfhd mhdvn( hj} dpkjeajmadef} svfnfe sj}jp nf hj kf}~ae ~fmedhkamj

~pjnamadejh ,mde mvje~ad}j} aeyfp}adef} fe pfmvp}d}( aemhvqfend ljpn{jpf( }di~{jpf(

mfe~pd} nf spdmf}jbafe~d nf nj~d}( pfnf}( sfp}dejh( }fkvpanjn( f~m%!( jh evfyd bdnfhd nf

kf}~ae fe hj ev`f( ndenf }f fhabaej hj efmf}anjn nf kpjenf} aeyfp}adef} q md}~f} iaod} q

}f ~pje}idpbj j hd} spdyffndpf} fe ae}~pvbfe~d} zvf sdefe jh jhmjemf nf hd} v}vjpad}(

nf idpbj ihf|a`hf f ae}~je~efj( hj mjsjmanjn nf mdbsv~jmae jod nfbjenj%

Fh }fm~dp s`hamd ~jbàe }f lj ya}~d abshamjnd fe fh sjpjnakbj mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

AE^FMD sv`hamj fh F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj% Fh

f}~vnad sdef fe yjhdp hj jnjs~jmae nfh }fm~dp s`hamd f}sjdh j ve evfyd sjpjnakbj

~fmedhkamd( pfspf}fe~jnd sdp fh mdemfs~d nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

Sjpj hhfyjp j mj`d fh f}~vnad( }f lj pfjhajnd vej femvf}~j j vej bvf}~pj pfspf}fe~j~ayj

nf fe~anjnf} nfh }fm~dp s`hamd f}sjdh nf bà~d ejmadejh( jv~debamd q hdmjh%

J}aba}bd( }f lj mde~jnd mde hj sjp~amasjmae nf ve kpvsd nf f|sfp~d} nfh }fm~dp( zvf ljejsdp~jnd vej ya}ae mvjha~j~ayj jh dòf~d nf f}~vnad%

]f f|sdefe j mde~aevjmae hd} sve~d} mhjyf nfh jeha}a}%

A MDEDMABAFE^D Q V]D NFH MHDVN MDBSVÂEKFE FH ]FM^DP S@HAMD

FE F]SJJ

Hj f|~fe}ae nfhmhdvn mdbsv~aek fe~pf hj} fe~anjnf} nfh }fm~dp s`hamd f}sjdh f}

~dnjyj haba~jnj( q f} b} ipfmvfe~f fe~pf jnbaea}~pjmadef} hdmjhf} zvf fe~pf

dpkjea}bd} nf bà~d jv~debamd d f}~j~jh% Fe mvjhzvafp mj}d( fh bdnfhd nf

nf}shafkvf b} ljà~vjh f} fh spayjnd%

Ve 69(0& nf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} f}sjdhj} jiapbj mdedmfp fh mdemfs~d

nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek( mde bjqdp d bfedp spdivenanjn ,ve :6(9& namf mdedmfphd fe

spdivenanjn( q ve >3(9& lj dnd lj`hjp nf fhhd( }ae mde}anfpjp zvf hd ndbaej!%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej < nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

Fh v}d nf }dhvmadef} mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd f}sjdh f} ~dnjyj

pfnvmand% ^je }hd fh ==(>& nf hj} fe~anjnf} }de jm~vjhbfe~f v}vjpaj} nf jhke

}fpyamad fe bdnd mhdvn mdbsv~aek% Fh 99(9& je ed lj jsd}~jnd sdp aemdpsdpjp

jhke }fpyamad fe hj ev`f%


9/175

Hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} nf b`a~d hdmjh }de b} jm~ayj} fe hj jndsmae nf mhdvn

zvf }v} ldbhdkj} jv~debamj} q f}~j~jhf}% J}( ve =>(0& nf hj} fe~anjnf}

hdmjhf} }f nfmhjpj v}vjpaj nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek( bafe~pj} zvf fe fh mj}d nf hj}

jv~debamj} fh sdpmfe~jof f} nf 0& fe~pf hj} nf b`a~d f}~j~jh%

Hj ~fmedhdkj mhdvn mdbsv~aeklj hhfkjnd jh }fm~dp s`hamd nf bjefpj pfmafe~f%

Ve :>(0& hj lj aemdpsdpjnd ljmf bfed} nf ve jd( q ve 6:(0& hd lj lfmld ljmf

bfed} nf ~pf} jd}%

F|a}~f vej spadpanjn sdp fh nf}shafkvf nf }fpyamad} mhdvn mdbsv~aeknf mjpm~fp

spayjnd ,fh 6(>&!%


]dhjbfe~f fh >=(3& nf hj} fe~anjnf} nfh }fm~dp s`hamd }dhama~j j hd} spdyffndpf}

jhke ~asd nf f}~enjp nf }fkvpanjn% Hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} zvf } ds~je sdp}dhama~jp f}~enjpf} }f nfmje~je( fe hj bjqdpj nf hd} mj}d}( sdp hj idpbjhajmae


10/175

nf mde~pj~d} nf mde~aevanjn q jmvfpnd} nf }fpyamad ,66(0&!( sdp hj A]D 0;33:

,=3(;&! q sdp hj A]D 1333 ,:=(:&!%

AAA PF]VH^JND] NF HJ ABSHJE^JMAE NF MHDVN MDBSVÂEK

Hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} zvf lje jnds~jnd mhdvn mdbsv~aek sfpma`fe fh jldppd fe

~afbsd q md}~f} mdbd spaemasjhf} `fefiamad} nfh bdnfhd( q hj} mvf}~adef} nf

ae~fkpanjn nf }fpyamad} q nj~d} mdbd spaemasjhf} naiamvh~jnf}% Fh }fm~dp s`hamd

f}sjdh mde}anfpj hj ev`f mdbd vej yfe~joj ~fmedhkamj q( }d`pf ~dnd( dsfpj~ayj( q

lje ya}~d }j~a}ifmlj} }v} f|sfm~j~ayj} aeamajhf} mde pf}sfm~d j mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

Fh jldppd fe ~afbsd ,99(6&! q md}~f} ,6=(;&! }de hd} spaemasjhf} fifm~d}

sd}a~ayd} nfpayjnd} nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek( }fkvand} nf hj jbshajmae nf hd}

}fpyamad} dipfmand} sdp fh dpkjea}bd ,6:(0&! q vej bfodpj nf hj spdnvm~ayanjnkfefpjh ,>;(0&!%

Fe fh jeha}a} nf hj} naiamvh~jnf} j hj} zvf }f lje feipfe~jnd hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef}

f}sjdhj} fe hj jndsmae nf mhdvn( pf}vh~j zvf fh 01(6& nf hd} dpkjea}bd}

s`hamd} femvfe~pje zvf hj} mvf}~adef} nf ae~fkpanjn nf hd} }fpyamad} q nj~d} lje

naiamvh~jnd bvmld d `j}~je~f hj jndsmae nf mhdvn% Sdp nf~p} nf f}~j bfemae( hj

ijh~j nf mjsjmanjn ~fmedhkamj nfh dpkjea}bd ,03(&! }de spd`hfbj} mde hd} zvf }f lj femde~pjnd fh }fm~dp

s`hamd fe }v ~pje}amae j hj ev`f%

Hj} fe~anjnf} nfh }fm~dp s`hamd f}~e }j~a}ifmlj} mde }v} spdyffndpf} nf mhdvn

mdbsv~aek% Mvjend }f ~pj~j nf bfnap hj }j~a}ijmmae mde hj mjhanjn nfh }fpyamad(

hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} b} }j~a}ifmlj} }de hj} zvf lje mde~pj~jnd }v} }fpyamad}

mde spdyffndpf} ae~fpejmadejhf}% J}( fh ;1& nf hj} fe~anjnf} zvf lje

mde~pj~jnd }fpyamad} mhdvnmde vej fbspf}j ae~fpejmadejh f}~e bvq d `j}~je~f

}j~a}ifmlj} mde hj mjhanjn nf hj ae}~jhjmae7 fe fh mj}d nf dpkjea}bd} zvf ~afefe

mdbd spdyffndp j d~pj Jnbaea}~pjmae( fh eayfh nf }j~a}ijmmae f} nfh ;3(9&%

Fe mjbàd( fe fh jeha}a} nf hj }j~a}ijmmae fe ~pbaed} nf ijmahanjn nf mde~jm~d

mde fh spdyffndp q na}sdeaàhanjn nfh ba}bd( hd} pf}vh~jnd} }de bfodpf} mvjend

fh spdyffndp nfh }fpyamad f} vej Jnbaea}~pjmae s`hamj% Fh ;6(=& nf hd}

dpkjea}bd} zvf ~pj`joje mde spdyffndpf} nf mhdvnnfh }fm~dp s`hamd }f bvf}~pj

bvq d `j}~je~f }j~a}ifmlj mde }v na}sdeaàhanjn q ijmahanjn nf mde~jm~d% Mvjend

}f ~pj~j nf spdyffndpf} spayjnd} ae~fpejmadejhf}( fh sdpmfe~jof nf}mafenf lj}~j

93(>&%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej :3 nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

Fh 61(6& nf hj} fe~anjnf} s`hamj} v}vjpaj} nf hj ev`f mde}anfpj zvf mhdvn

mdbsv~aekf} vej yfe~joj ~fmedhkamj( ipfe~f j ve :;(


11/175

hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} femvfe~pj zvf hj ev`f jsdp~j ve absjm~d dsfpj~ayd sd}a~ayd

j hj spdsaj naebamj nf hj fe~anjn%

= nf mjnj > dpkjea}bd} s`hamd} yjhdpje zvf }f lje mvbshand }v} f|sfm~j~ayj}}d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek( q ve 1(>& jnamadejh mde}anfpj zvf }f lje }vsfpjnd% ]dhd

sjpj ve 9(>& nf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} hd} pf}vh~jnd} f}~e sdp nf`jod nf }v}

f|sfm~j~ayj} aeamajhf}%

AY AE^FEMAE NF V]D IV^VPD

Fe~pf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} zvf qj f}~e femhdvn mdbsv~aek( hj} sfp}sfm~ayj} nf

iv~vpd }de bvq sd}a~ayj}? ~afefe ae~femae nf }fkvap ~pj`jojend fe hj ev`f(

pfmdbfenjpe f}~j ~fmedhdkj j d~pj} ae}~a~vmadef} q f}sfpje }fkvap d`~feafend

yfe~joj} iv~vpj} nfh v}d nf mhdvn% Hd} dpkjea}bd} zvf je ed f}~e fe hj ev`f( fe

mjb`ad( }f bvf}~pje b} pfmfhd}d}? sdmd} ~afefe ae~femae nf aemdpsdpjp

}dhvmadef} ~fmedhkamj} q( nf fhhd}( }de baedpj zvafef} hd ljpe fe bdndmhdvn%

Hj ae~femae bjqdpa~jpaj ,1>(6&! fe~pf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} v}vjpaj} nf hj ev`f

f} bje~fefp fh v}d nf mhdvn mdbsv~aekfe jzvfhhj} }dhvmadef} zvf qj lje }and

bakpjnj} j f}~j ~fmedhdkj% ]dhd ve 3(0& nf fe~anjnf} pfmdedmfe zvf ed

bje~fenp fe fh iv~vpd hj ~fmedhdkj mhdvnjm~vjh( q ve 6(=& }f bvf}~pj aenfma}j%

Fh sdnfp spf}mpas~dp nf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} v}vjpaj} nf mhdvn f} absdp~je~f%^pf} nf mjnj mvj~pd fe~anjnf} bjeaiaf}~j zvf pfmdbfenjp fh v}d nf mhdvn

mdbsv~aek j d~pj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} }ae eaekvej nvnj( q ve :;(0& jnamadejh

pfmdedmf zvf spd`j`hfbfe~f hd pfmdbfenjp%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej :: nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

Ve & zvf ed f}~ nf jmvfpnd mde fhhd q ve :6& jnamadejh zvf ed }f sd}amadej%


12/175


Y JEHA]A] NJID

IDP^JHF_J] Jldppd fmdebamd%

Mdemfe~pjmae q idp~jhfmabafe~d nf hjkf}~ae nf hj }fkvpanjn%

Ihf|aàhanjn fe hj kf}~ae nf hj yjpajàhanjnnf hj nfbjenj%

Fhabaejmae nf nvshamanjnf} qpfnvenjemaj}%

Na}sdeaàhanjn nf hd} }fpyamad}% Spaemasjh fefiamad dpafe~jnd ljmaj hj

mavnjnjej% Jmmf}aàhanjn q bdyahanjn% Jh~j difp~j nf spdyffndpf}%

NF@AHANJNF] Aef|a}~femaj nf spdmfnabafe~d}

f}sfmiamd} sjpj hj mde~pj~jmae nf}fpyamad} fe mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

Spd`hfbj nf kd`fpejej fe fh spdmf}dnf ~pje}idpbjmae ljmaj }fpyamad}mdbsjp~and}%

Nf}hdmjhajmae nf hj aeidpbjmae qspnanj nf mde~pdh%

Nfsfenfemaj nfh spdyffndp% Ijh~j nf ihf|aàhanjn sjpj hj

pfdpkjeajmae nf PPLL% Ijh~j nf jbdp~ajmae nf pfmvp}d} A% Ijh~j nf jemld nf `jenj fe

nf~fpbaejnj} hdmjhajmadef}% Ijh~j nf mde}anfpjmadef} spfyaj} j hjmde~pj~jmae q nvpje~f fh }fpyamad%

DSDP^VEANJNF] Mdbsjp~amae nf pfmvp}d} q

f}~jenjpajmae mdbe% Spf}~jmae nf }fpyamad} q pfmvp}d} j d~pj}

dpkjeajmadef}% Hfmmadef} jspfenanj} nfh }fm~dp spayjnd% Spfnahfmmae sdp spdyffndpf} ejmadejhf}%

JBFEJ_J] Jv}femaj nf vej edpbj~ayj bjpmd zvf

pfkvhf fh bdnfhd mhdvn mdbsv~aekae~fpejmadejhbfe~f%

]d`pfnabfe}adejbafe~d nf hj}mjsjmanjnf} nfh spdyffndpnfkfefpjend hj} spf}~jmadef} nfh}fpyamad%


13/175

: AE^PDNVMMAE Q D@OFÂYD]

:%: SPF]FE^JMAEFh Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae( ]%J% ,AE^FMD!( f} vej

}dmafnjn f}~j~jh jn}mpa~j jh Baea}~fpad nf Aenv}~paj( Fefpkj q ^vpa}bd j ~pjy} nf hj

]fmpf~jpj nf F}~jnd nf ^fhfmdbveamjmadef} q sjpj hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae%

AE^FMD f} ve mfe~pd nf nf}jppdhhd nf mjpm~fp aeedyjndp q nf ae~fp} s`hamd nf bà~d

ejmadejh zvf }f dpafe~j j hj jsdp~jmae nf yjhdp( j hj aenv}~paj q j hd} v}vjpad}( q j hj

naiv}ae nf hj} evfyj} ~fmedhdkj} nf hj aeidpbjmae q hj mdbveamjmae ,ÂM! fe F}sjj(

fe mhjpj }ae~dej mde Fvpdsj%

]v dòf~ayd ivenjbfe~jh f} }fpyap mdbd ae}~pvbfe~d sjpj nf}jppdhhjp hj ]dmafnjn nf hj

Aeidpbjmae( mde jm~ayanjnf} spdsaj} fe fh bà~d nf hj aeedyjmae q fh nf}jppdhhd nf

spdqfm~d} j}dmajnd} j hj} ÂM( `j}end}f fe ~pf} sahjpf} ivenjbfe~jhf}? hj aeyf}~akjmae

jshamjnj( hj spf}~jmae nf }fpyamad} q hj idpbjmae%

Hj ba}ae nf AE^FMD f} jsdp~jp yjhdp f aeedyjmae j hd} mavnjnjed}( j hj} SQBF]( j hj}

Jnbaea}~pjmadef} S`hamj} q jh }fm~dp nf hj} ~fmedhdkj} nf hj aeidpbjmae( j ~pjy} nfh

nf}jppdhhd nf spdqfm~d} zvf mde~pa`vqje j pfidpjp hj mdeiajej fe hd} }fpyamad} nf hj

]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae fe evf}~pd sj}( spdbdyafend jnfb} vej hefj nf

sjp~amasjmae ae~fpejmadejh%

Sjpj fhhd( AE^FMD nf}jppdhhj jm~vjmadef} fe hj} }akvafe~f} hefj}?

]fkvpanjn ~fmedhkamj? AE^FMD f}~ mdbspdbf~and mde hj spdbdmae nf

}fpyamad} nf hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae mjnj yf b} }fkvpd}( zvf spd~foje

hd} nj~d} sfp}dejhf} nf hd} ae~fpf}jnd}( }v ae~abanjn( hj ae~fkpanjn nf }v

aeidpbjmae q fya~fe j~jzvf} zvf sdekje fe paf}kd hd} }fpyamad} spf}~jnd}% Q( sdp

}vsvf}~d( zvf kjpje~amfe ve mvbshabafe~d f}~pam~d nf hj edpbj~ayj hfkjh fe

bj~fpaj nf ÂM% Sjpj fhhd mddpnaej na}~ae~j} aeamaj~ayj} s`hamj} fe ~dped j hj

}fkvpanjn nf hj} ÂM( zvf }f bj~fpajhaje fe hj spf}~jmae nf }fpyamad} sdp sjp~f

nfh D`}fpyj~dpad nf hj ]fkvpanjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae( fh Mfe~pd nf Pf}svf}~j j

Aemanfe~f} nf ]fkvpanjn fe ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Aeidpbjmae ,AE^FMDMFP^!( mde

}v Mj~hdkd nf Fbspf}j} q ]dhvmadef} nf ]fkvpanjn ÂM( q hj Diamaej nf

]fkvpanjn nfh Ae~fpejv~j ,D]A!( nf hd} zvf }f `fefiamaje mavnjnjed}( sqbf}(

Jnbaea}~pjmadef} S`hamj} q fh }fm~dp ~fmedhkamd%

Jmmf}aàhanjn? AE^FMD spdbvfyf }fpyamad} nf hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae

b} jmmf}a`hf}( zvf }vspabje hj} `jppfpj} nf f|mhv}ae( mvjhzvafpj zvf }fj hj

naiamvh~jn d mjpfemaj ~meamj( idpbj~ayj( f~m%( aemhv}d na}mjsjmanjn( zvf ~fekje }v}

v}vjpad}% Q zvf ijmaha~fe hj ae~fkpjmae spdkpf}ayj nf ~dnd} hd} mdhfm~ayd} nf

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej := nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!
http://cert.inteco.es/cert/INTECOCERT/?postAction=getCertHomehttp://cert.inteco.es/cert/INTECOCERT/?postAction=getCertHome


14/175

v}vjpad}( nf bdnd zvf ~dnd} fhhd} svfnje `fefiamajp}f nf hj} dsdp~veanjnf} zvf

dipfmf hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae% Fe sjp~amvhjp( AE^FMD na}sdef nf jbshaj

f|sfpafemaj fe fh nf}jppdhhd nf spdqfm~d} fe fh bà~d nf hj jmmf}aàhanjn sjpj hj

~fhfya}ae naka~jh( j} mdbd nf jzvfhhd} dpafe~jnd} j kjpje~ajp hd} nfpfmld} nf hd}

mavnjnjed} j pfhjmadejp}f mde hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} sdp bfnad}

fhfm~peamd}( pfmdedmand} fe hj Hfq ::$033;( nf 00 nf ovead( nf jmmf}d fhfm~peamd

nf hd} mavnjnjed} j hd} ]fpyamad} S`hamd}

Mjhanjn ÂM? AE^FMD spdbvfyf ved} }fpyamad} nf hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae

zvf mjnj yf }fje nf bjqdp mjhanjn( zvf kjpje~amfe ved} jnfmvjnd} eayfhf} nf

}fpyamad( hd mvjh }f ~pjnvmf fe vej bjqdp pd`v}~f nf jshamjmadef} q }a}~fbj}( ve

mdbspdba}d fe hj na}sdeaàhanjn q hd} ~afbsd} nf pf}svf}~j( ve jnfmvjnd }dsdp~f

sjpj hd} v}vjpad}( vej aeidpbjmae spfma}j q mhjpj }d`pf hj fydhvmae nf hj}ivemadejhanjnf} nf hd} }fpyamad}( q fe pf}vbfe( }fpyamad} mjnj yf bfodpf}% Fe

f}~j hefj absvh}j hj mdbsf~a~ayanjn nf hj aenv}~paj nfh ]di~{jpf j ~pjy} nf hj

spdbdmae nf hj bfodpj nf hj mjhanjn q hj mfp~aiamjmae nf hj} fbspf}j} q

spdif}adejhf} nf hj aekfeafpj nfh }di~{jpf( j ~pjy} nfh Hj`dpj~dpad Ejmadejh nf

Mjhanjn nfh ]di~{jpf%

Idpbjmae? hj idpbjmae f} ve ijm~dp nf~fpbaeje~f sjpj hj j~pjmmae nf ~jhfe~d q

sjpj hj bfodpj nf hj mdbsf~a~ayanjn nf hj} fbspf}j}% Sdp fhhd( AE^FMD absvh}j hj

idpbjmae nf veayfp}a~jpad} q spdif}adejhf} fe hj} ~fmedhdkj} b} nfbjenjnj}sdp hj aenv}~paj%

F} ved nf hd} dòf~ayd} nfh Ae}~a~v~d nf}mpaàp nf bjefpj nf~jhhjnj q }a}~fb~amj fh eayfh

nf }fkvpanjn( spayjmanjn q mdeiajej fe hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae q nf kfefpjp

mdedmabafe~d f}sfmajhajnd fe hj bj~fpaj% Nf f}~f bdnd( }f femvfe~pj jh }fpyamad nf hd}

mavnjnjed}( hj} fbspf}j} q hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} f}sjdhj} sjpj nf}mpaàp(

jejhajp( j}f}dpjp q naivenap hj mvh~vpj nf hj }fkvpanjn nf hj aeidpbjmae( hj spayjmanjn q hj

fmdeiajej%

AE^FMD lj na}fjnd ve Shje nf Jm~ayanjnf} q F}~vnad} mde fh dòf~d nf spdnvmapmdedmabafe~d f}sfmajhajnd q ~ah fe bj~fpaj nf }fkvpanjn q spayjmanjn( j} mdbd nf

fhj`dpjp pfmdbfenjmadef} q spdsvf}~j} zvf nfiaeje ~fenfemaj} yhanj} sjpj hj ~dbj nf

nfma}adef} iv~vpj} sdp sjp~f nf hd} sdnfpf} s`hamd}%

Nfe~pd nf f}~f shje nf jmmae }f pfjhaje hj`dpf} nf aeyf}~akjmae( jeha}a}( f}~vnad(

j}f}dpjbafe~d q nayvhkjmae zvf j~fenfpe( fe~pf d~pj}( j hj} }akvafe~f} f}~pj~fkaj}?

Fhj`dpjmae nf f}~vnad} f aeidpbf} spdsad} fe bj~fpaj nf }fkvpanjn nf hj}

^fmedhdkj} nf hj Aeidpbjmae q hj Mdbveamjmae( mde f}sfmajh eij}a} fe hj]fkvpanjn q spayjmanjn fe Ae~fpef~%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej :> nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


15/175

]fkvabafe~d nf hd} spaemasjhf} aenamjndpf} q sdh~amj} s`hamj} pfhjmadejnj} mde

hj }fkvpanjn nf hj aeidpbjmae q hj mdeiajej fe fh bà~d ejmadejh f

ae~fpejmadejh%

Kfefpjmae nf vej `j}f nf nj~d} zvf sfpba~j fh jeha}a} q fyjhvjmae nf hj

}fkvpanjn q hj mdeiajej mde vej sfp}sfm~ayj ~fbsdpjh%

Absvh}d nf spdqfm~d} nf aeyf}~akjmae fe bj~fpaj nf }fkvpanjn ÂM%

Naiv}ae nf f}~vnad} f aeidpbf} sv`hamjnd} sdp d~pj} fe~anjnf} q dpkjea}bd}

ejmadejhf} f ae~fpejmadejhf}( j} mdbd nf aeidpbjmae }d`pf hj jm~vjhanjn

ejmadejh q fvpdsfj fe bj~fpaj nf hj }fkvpanjn q mdeiajej fe hj ]dmafnjn nf hj

Aeidpbjmae%

J}f}dpjbafe~d j hj} Jnbaea}~pjmadef} S`hamj} fe bj~fpaj nf }fkvpanjn nf hj

aeidpbjmae q mdeiajej( j} mdbd fh jsdqd j hj fhj`dpjmae( }fkvabafe~d q

fyjhvjmae nf sdh~amj} s`hamj} fe f}~f bà~d%

:%0 F]^VNAD ]D@PF MHDVN MDBSVÂEKFE FH ]FM^DP S@HAMD FE F]SJJ

Jm~vjhbfe~f( fh bdnfhd mhdvn mdbsv~aek}f fpakf mdbd vej nf hj} spaemasjhf} ~fenfemaj}

j ~fefp fe mvfe~j sjpj hj f|~fpejhajmae nf }fpyamad}% Hj} yfe~joj} zvf spf}fe~j f}~f

bdnfhd nf }fpyamad} aeidpb~amd} aeihvqfe fe hj ~dbj nf nfma}adef} sdp sjp~f nf hj}

fbspf}j}( jvezvf }v mde~pj~jmae abshazvf pfevemajp jh mde~pdh napfm~d }d`pf

aeipjf}~pvm~vpj}( jshamjmadef} d spdmf}d} ~fmedhkamd}%

Hd} bdnfhd} nf }fpyamad} `j}jnd} fe mhdvn mdbsv~aekspf}fe~je yfe~joj}( sfpd ~jbàe

paf}kd} sjpj hd} v}vjpad} nf hd} ba}bd}% Fe f}~f }fe~and( f} absdp~je~f zvf mvjhzvafp

fe~anjn zvf }f f}~ shje~fjend fbsfjp j ~pj`jojp fe hj ev`f ~fekj ve mdedmabafe~d

mdbshf~d }d`pf mbd j`dpnjp j}sfm~d} mhjyf( mdbd }de( sdp fofbshd( hj kf}~ae nf hj

pfhjmae mde fh spdyffndp nf }fpyamad}( hj nfiaeamae nf hd} eayfhf} nf }fpyamad d hj

edpbj~ayj j jshamjp% Nf ed ~fefp}f fe mvfe~j fh absjm~d nf f}~j} q d~pj} mapmve}~jemaj}(

fh pf}vh~jnd svfnf }fp ve nf}jspdyfmljbafe~d nf hj} yfe~joj} zvf dipfmf mhdvn

mdbsv~aek%

Hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} q dpkjea}bd} s`hamd} f}sjdhf} ljmfe ve v}d ae~fe}ayd nf hj}

~fmedhdkj} nf hj aeidpbjmae q( sdp hd ~je~d( ed }de jofed} j hj} evfyj} ~fenfemaj} nfh

bfpmjnd% Fe f}~f mde~f|~d( AE^FMD lj nf~fm~jnd hj efmf}anjn nf pfjhajp ve f}~vnad

nf~jhhjnd }d`pf fh v}d nf hd} bdnfhd} nf }fpyamad} `j}jnd} fe mhdvn mdbsv~aeksdp sjp~f

nfh }fm~dp s`hamd f}sjdh%

Mdbd sjp~f nf f}~f f}~vnad }f yjhdpj fh kpjnd nf abshamjmae pfjh q nf mdedmabafe~d zvfhj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} q dpkjea}bd} s`hamd} f}sjdhf} ~afefe fe pfhjmae jh mhdvn

mdbsv~aek% Hj f|sd}amae }f dpkjeaj fe hd} }akvafe~f} `hdzvf} mdemfs~vjhf}?



16/175

Abshje~jmae%Jeha}a} nfh kpjnd nf abshje~jmae nf hj ev`f fe }v} }a}~fbj} nf

aeidpbjmae( bdnfhd sjpj hj jndsmae nf f}~d} }fpyamad} q j}sfm~d} ~feand} fe

mvfe~j fe hj ~dbj nf nfma}adef}%

Paf}kd}% Pfjhajmae nf jeha}a} nf paf}kd} mde mjpm~fp spfyad j hj jndsmae nf

ve bdnfhd nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

Bd~ayjmadef} fe mde~pj? Pfhjmae nf pjdef} q bd~ayjmadef} sjpj hj ed

jndsmae nfh bdnfhd mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

]vsfpya}ae nfh }fpyamad% Nf~jhhf nf hd} pfzvfpabafe~d} f|akand} j hd}

spdyffndpf} fe mvje~d j hd} eayfhf} nf }fpyamad }dhama~jnd} q fh }fkvabafe~d nf }v

mvbshabafe~d%

Sd}aàhanjnf} iv~vpj} q `fefiamad}% F|jbfe nf hj} iv~vpj} bfodpj} fe mvje~d jh

nf}fbsfd nf hj ~fmedhdkj q yfe~joj} fmdebamj} zvf jsdp~j hj jndsmae nfh

bdnfhd nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

Naiamvh~jnf}? Jeha}a} nf hd} spaemasjhf} aemdeyfeafe~f} j}dmajnd} j hj

abshje~jmae nfh bdnfhd mhdvn mdbsv~aeknf}nf fh sve~d nf ya}~j nf }fkvpanjn(

fmdebamd( ~meamd q ovpnamd%

Iaejhbfe~f( mdbd sjp~f nfh f}~vnad( }f dipfmf vej ya}ae kfefpjh }d`pf fhsd}amadejbafe~d nf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} q dpkjea}bd} s`hamd} pf}sfm~d j hd} bdnfhd}

nf spf}~jmae nf }fpyamad} ~fmedhkamd} `j}jnd} fe mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

:%0%: Dòf~ayd kfefpjh

Fh spaemasjh dòf~ayd nfh f}~vnad f} mdedmfp fh sd}amadejbafe~d q sfpmfsmae nf hj}

fe~anjnf} s`hamj} f}sjdhj} pf}sfm~d nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek( j sjp~ap nf hj aeidpbjmae

spdsdpmadejnj sdp hj} spdsaj} jnbaea}~pjmadef}( dpkjea}bd} q fbspf}j} s`hamj}

f}sjdhj}( q mdbshfbfe~jnj mde hj} jsdp~jmadef} nf ve kpvsd nf f|sfp~d}%

:%0%0 Dòf~ayd} f}sfmiamd}

Nf bjefpj b} f}sfmiamj( j mde~aevjmae }f nf}mpa`fe hd} dòf~ayd} nf mjnj ved nf hd}

jsjp~jnd} fe hd} zvf }f f}~pvm~vpj fh f}~vnad%



17/175

Mde~f|~d nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek

Nf}mpaàp fh mdemfs~d mhdvn mdbsv~aek( }v fydhvmae q hd} spaemasjhf} mdemfs~d}

mhjyf nf f}~j bdnjhanjn nf }fpyamad}%

Na`vojp fh f}~jnd nfh jp~f nf hd} }fpyamad} nf mhdvn mdbsv~aekj eayfh ejmadejh f

ae~fpejmadejh%

Spdivenajp fe hd} na}~ae~d} pfzva}a~d} nf }fkvpanjn q edpbj~ayd} jshamj`hf}%

Anfe~aiamjp hj} spaemasjhf} yfe~joj} sjpj hj} dpkjeajmadef} zvf lje jnds~jnd

mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

Mdedmabafe~d q v}d nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aekfe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj

Nf}mpaàp fh eayfh nf mdedmabafe~d nf mhdvn mdbsv~aeknf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} fe

ivemae nfh bà~d ~fppa~dpajh ,f}~j~jh( jv~debamj( hdmjh!%

Mvje~aiamjp fh kpjnd nf abshfbfe~jmae q jmfs~jmae nfh bdnfhd mhdvnfe fh }fm~dp

s`hamd( q spdivenajp fe hj mjpjm~fpajmae nf }fpyamad} q shj~jidpbjj}%

Aenjkjp jmfpmj nf hd} kj}~d} fmdebamd} j}dmajnd} j hj abshje~jmae nfh bdnfhd%

Mdedmfp zv ~asd nf spdyffndpf} f}~e spdsdpmadejend hd} }fpyamad} nf mhdvnmdbsv~aekj hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} f}sjdhj}%

Bdnfhd nf nfma}ae }d`pf hj jndsmae nf }fpyamad} nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek

Jejhajp fh jm~vjh bdnfhd nf nfma}ae }fkvand fe hj} na}~ae~j} jnbaea}~pjmadef} q

dpkjea}bd} s`hamd} sjpj hhfyjp j mj`d hj jndsmae nfh }fpyamad%

Nf~jhhjp hd} pfzva}a~d} }dhama~jnd} jh spdyffndp%

Yjhdpjp fh jeha}a} nf paf}kd} fifm~vjnd spfyad j hj abshje~jmae%

Njp j mdedmfp hd} spaemasjhf} bfnad} nfiaeand} fe~pf fe~anjn s`hamj q spdyffndp

sjpj zvf f|a}~j vej }vsfpya}ae nf hj mjhanjn nfh }fpyamad? bfmjea}bd} nf mde~pdh

ae}~jvpjnd}( f}~enjpf} nf }fkvpanjn f|akand} q jmvfpnd} nf eayfh nf }fpyamad

iapbjnd}%

Fe fh mj}d nf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} zvf ed lje jnds~jnd }fpyamad} mhdvn

mdbsv~aek( fevbfpjp hd} bd~ayd} zvf lje aeihvand sjpj hj ed jndsmae nfh

bdnfhd%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej :; nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


18/175

Pf}vh~jnd} nf hj abshje~jmae nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek

Nf~jhhjp fefiamad} q naiamvh~jnf} f|sfpabfe~jnd} ~pj} hj abshje~jmae nfh }fpyamad%

Nf}mpaàp fh sd}amadejbafe~d khd`jh nf}nf fh sve~d nf ya}~j ~fmedhkamd q

dsfpj~ayd%

Njp j mdedmfp fh kpjnd nf }j~a}ijmmae nf hj} fe~anjnf} mde hd} }fpyamad}

spf}~jnd} sdp hd} spdyffndpf}%

Ae~femae nf v}d iv~vpd

Spdsdpmadejp vej ya}ae nf ljmaj nenf }f dpafe~jp fh mhdvn mdbsv~aekfe hd}

sp|abd} jd} q mbd }f yfpe jifm~jnj} hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} q dpkjea}bd}s`hamd} f}sjdhf}%

Nf~jhhjp hd} sp|abd} sj}d} nf hj} fe~anjnf} zvf lje jnds~jnd fh bdnfhd mhdvn%

Nf}mpaàp hd} sd}a`hf} bdnfhd} iv~vpd} nf abshfbfe~jmae nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

Jeha}a} NJID

Pfjhajp ve jeha}a} nf hj} spaemasjhf} idp~jhfj}( dsdp~veanjnf}( nfàhanjnf} q

jbfejj} j hj} zvf }f feipfe~j fh }fm~dp s`hamd f}sjdh fe }v jndsmae nfmhdvn mdbsv~aek%

@vfej} spm~amj} q pfmdbfenjmadef}

Fevbfpjp `vfej} spm~amj} j }fkvap sjpj hj jndsmae nfh bdnfhd mhdvn

mdbsv~aek% Nf~jhhjp pfmdbfenjmadef} f}~pj~kamj}( ~fmedhkamj}( nf kf}~ae q

pfkvhj~dpaj}%

Mj}d} nf |a~d

Nf}mpaàp f|sfpafemaj} ejmadejhf} f ae~fpejmadejhf} nf abshje~jmae f|a~d}j nf

}dhvmadef} j}jnj} fe mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej :< nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


19/175

0 BF^DNDHDKJ

Fh mvbshabafe~d nf hd} dòf~ayd} nfh spdqfm~d lj pfzvfpand fh shje~fjbafe~d nf vejbf~dndhdkj nf jeha}a} zvf sfpba~j hj f|~pjmmae nf mdemhv}adef} q pfmdbfenjmadef} j

sjp~ap nfh f}~vnad nf ivfe~f} q ha~fpj~vpj f|a}~fe~f fe hj bj~fpaj( nfh jeha}a} nf dsaeadef}

f|sfp~j} q nf hd} pf}vh~jnd} nf vej femvf}~j pfjhajnj j hj} fe~anjnf} nfh }fm~dp s`hamd

f}sjdh%

Fh feidzvf bf~dndhkamd zvf }f spf}fe~j j mde~aevjmae aemhvqf( j bdnd nf }e~f}a}( hd}

spaemasjhf} sjpbf~pd} ~meamd} zvf }f lje jnds~jnd sjpj hj pfjhajmae nfh f}~vnad% ]f

lje hhfyjnd j mj`d ~pf} spdmf}d} nf jeha}a} zvf jsdp~je naifpfe~f} ivfe~f} nf

aeidpbjmae mdbshfbfe~jpaj}?

Aeyf}~akjmae ndmvbfe~jh nf ivfe~f} }fmvenjpaj}% Fh jeha}a} nf ivfe~f}

ndmvbfe~jhf} ejmadejhf} f ae~fpejmadejhf} f|a}~fe~f} }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aeklj

sfpba~and feidmjp hd} mdemfs~d} mhjyf nfh f}~vnad q d`~fefp aeidpbjmae nf

mde~pj}~f sjpj hd} pf}vh~jnd} d`~feand} fe fh spf}fe~f ~pj`jod%

Aeyf}~akjmae mvjha~j~ayj% ]f lje pfjhajnd fe~pfya}~j} fe spdivenanjn j

f|sfp~d} nfh }fm~dp( spdif}adejhf} sfp~fefmafe~f} j naifpfe~f} jnbaea}~pjmadef}

s`hamj} mde mjpkd} nf pf}sde}jàhanjn fe fh bà~d nf kf}~ae ~fmedhkamj%

Aeyf}~akjmae mvje~a~j~ayj% Hj pfjhajmae nf vej femvf}~j ~fhfieamj j vej

bvf}~pj pfspf}fe~j~ayj nf fe~anjnf} nfh }fm~dp s`hamd f}sjdh lj sfpba~and

d`~fefp nj~d} evbpamd}%

Hd} pf}vh~jnd} d`~feand} j sjp~ap nf hj} ~pf} ivfe~f} nf aeidpbjmae v~ahajnj} lje

sfpba~and f|~pjfp pfihf|adef}( las~f}a} q mdemhv}adef} zvf f}~pvm~vpje hd} spaemasjhf}

jsjp~jnd} nfh aeidpbf% J}( fh f}~vnad mde}~a~vqf vej ya}ae spfma}j nf hj sfpmfsmae q

f}~jnd nfh jp~f nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aekfe fh mde~f|~d nf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} f}sjdhj}%

0%: IJ]F :? JEHA]A] NDMVBFE^JH

Mde mjpm~fp spfyad jh nf}shafkvf nf hd} ae}~pvbfe~d} bf~dndhkamd} v~ahajnd} sjpj hj

pfjhajmae nfh ~pj`jod nf mjbsd( }f lje jejhajnd hj} spaemasjhf} ivfe~f} à`hadkpiamj}(

pfya}~j} f}sfmajhajnj}( ed~amaj}( `hdk} nf dsaeae f aeidpbjmae fe hj Pfn pfhj~ayj jh

mde~f|~d q ivenjbfe~d} nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aekj eayfh ejmadejh f ae~fpejmadejh%

Fh jeha}a} ndmvbfe~jh spfyad lj and femjbaejnd j?

Spfma}jp hd} mdemfs~d} ivenjbfe~jhf} q ~pbaed} `}amd} nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aekq

mde}dhanjp ve khd}jpad nf ~pbaed} q mdemfs~d} zvf }f lje f}sfmaiamjnd sjpj~dnd fh bà~d nfh f}~vnad%



20/175

Jejhajp f}~vnad} ae~fpejmadejhf} nf ~fb~amj fzvayjhfe~f( mde dòf~d nf

anfe~aiamjp hd} spaemasjhf} fof} nf `fefiamad} q paf}kd} yjhdpjnd} sdp d~pd} jv~dpf}

q f|sfp~d}%

Mdedmfp fh f}~jnd nfh jp~f fe fh mde~f|~d ejmadejh f ae~fpejmadejh nfh mhdvn

mdbsv~aekfe hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj}%

Anfe~aiamjp spm~amj} mdbvef} fe fh jeha}a} nfh ifebfed nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek(

j} mdbd mj}d} nf |a~d fe fh mde~f|~d s`hamd%

Mdedmfp hj sfp}sfm~ayj q dsaeadef} nf hd} hnfpf} nf dsaeae }d`pf fh mhdvn

mdbsv~aek? aeidpbf} spd}sfm~ayd} nf fbspf}j} nf mde}vh~dpj f}~pj~kamj(

sdefemaj} nf pf}sde}j`hf} nf hj Jkfemaj F}sjdhj nf Spd~fmmae nf Nj~d}(dsaeadef} ndmvbfe~jnj} nf mjpkd} s`hamd} ejmadejhf} f ae~fpejmadejhf}( f~m%

Mdedmfp hj dsaeae q sd}amadejbafe~d nfh }fm~dp ÂM ejmadejh fe fh bfpmjnd nfh

mhdvn( }v mvpyj nf bjnvpf( hj difp~j nf }fpyamad} q spdnvm~d}( }v} ~jpaij} q d~pd}

j}sfm~d} pfhfyje~f}%

F}~j`hfmfp fh bjpmd edpbj~ayd nfh bà~d nf mhdvn mdbsv~aekj eayfh ejmadejh(

fvpdsfd f ae~fpejmadejh ,edpbj~ayj }d`pf spd~fmmae nf nj~d}( f}zvfbj ejmadejh

nf }fkvpanjn( f~m%!%

Hj} ivfe~f} q pfifpfemaj} v~ahajnj} svfnfe mde}vh~jp}f fe hj} pfifpfemaj} à`hadkpiamj}

nfh Jef|d A% J hd} hjpkd nfh aeidpbf }f f}sfmaiamjpe ~dnd} jzvfhhd} mdemfs~d}(

f|spf}adef} d mdemhv}adef} zvf }f `j}fe fe hj dsaeae nf vej ivfe~f d jv~dp jofed j

AE^FMD%

0%0 IJ]F 0? FE^PFYA]^J] J SPDIF]ADEJHF] Q F\SFP^D]

Fe f}~j ij}f }f lj mde~jnd mde hj sjp~amasjmae nf jkfe~f} f|sfp~d} fe hj bj~fpaj( mde

hd} zvf }f lj }fkvand vej bf~dndhdkj nf aeyf}~akjmae mvjha~j~ayj `j}jnj fe hj

pfjhajmae nf fe~pfya}~j} sfp}dejhf} fe spdivenanjn% ]f lj }fhfmmadejnd j :3 f|sfp~d}ejmadejhf} sfp~fefmafe~f} j naifpfe~f} eayfhf} nf hj Jnbaea}~pjmae s`hamj% ^dnd} fhhd}

d}~fe~je( fe fh bdbfe~d nf pfjhajmae nf hj} fe~pfya}~j} ,d lje d}~fe~jnd fe fh sj}jnd!(

mjpkd} s`hamd} pfhjmadejnd} mde hj kf}~ae s`hamj nf hj} ÂM( bdnfpeajmae

jnbaea}~pj~ayj( }fkvpanjn d absvh}d nf hj }dmafnjn nf hj aeidpbjmae% Hd} jkfe~f}

mde}anfpjnd} mdedmfe q ~afefe f|sfpafemaj} pfjhf} q fifm~ayj} }d`pf fh jeha}a}( na}fd d

abshje~jmae nf jh~fpej~ayj} mhdvnfe fh bjpmd nfh nf}jppdhhd nf }dhvmadef} ~fmedhkamj}

sjpj hj bfodpj nf }fpyamad} q sdh~amj} s`hamj}%

Fe hj }fhfmmae nf f|sfp~d} }f lj sfp}fkvand fh dòf~ayd nf j}fkvpjp hj spf}femaj nfspdif}adejhf} nf hj Jnbaea}~pjmae Kfefpjh nfh F}~jnd( Jnbaea}~pjmae Jv~debamj(

Jnbaea}~pjmae Spdyaemajh d Hdmjh q ]dmafnjnf} d Fe~f} S`hamd}%



21/175

Hj} fe~pfya}~j} lje }and f}~pvm~vpjnj} }fke ve bdnfhd jàfp~d j hj dsaeae nfh

ae~fpf}jnd( sfpd jmd~jnd j ve kvae spff}~j`hfmand fe fh zvf }f spfkve~j jh f|sfp~d

}d`pf }v f|sfpafemaj sfp}dejh fe fh nf}jppdhhd nf spdqfm~d} fe mhdvn( }v sfpmfsmae

}d`pf hj} jbfejj} q dsdp~veanjnf} zvf }f nfpayje nfh mhdvnsjpj hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef}

s`hamj} f}sjdhj}( }v ya}ae spd}sfm~ayj sjpj hd} sp|abd} jd} q hj} pfmdbfenjmadef}

zvf( }fke }v f|sfpafemaj sfp}dejh( svfnfe njp}f jh }fm~dp% Fh ha}~jnd nf f|sfp~d} svfnf

mde}vh~jp}f fe fh Jef|d AA%

0%= IJ]F =? FEMVF]^J J FEÂNJNF] NFH ]FM^DP S@HAMD

Hj iaejhanjn nf hj aeyf}~akjmae mvje~a~j~ayj f} jsdp~jp aeidpbjmae spabjpaj zvf sfpba~j

mdedmfp fh eayfh nf abshje~jmae nf hd} }a}~fbj} `j}jnd} fe fh mhdvn mdbsv~aekfe hj}

jnbaea}~pjmadef}( dpkjea}bd} q fbspf}j} s`hamj} f}sjdhj}( j} mdbd }v sfpmfsmae

f}sfmiamj }d`pf hd} ba}bd}% J sjp~ap nf f}~f dòf~ayd kfefpjh( fh f}~vnad lj sfpba~and

mjpjm~fpajp d~pd} bh~ashf} ijm~dpf} nf ae~fp} mdbd hj ~asdhdkj nf }fpyamad} abshje~jnj(

hj sfpmfsmae nf hd} paf}kd} q dsdp~veanjnf} nf f}~j ~fmedhdkj d hj} sfp}sfm~ayj} nf v}d

sjpj fh iv~vpd nf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} mde}vh~jnj}%

Hd} spdmf}d} nf aeyf}~akjmae }f pakfe sdp fh spaemasad nf }jhyjkvjpnj nf hj aeidpbjmae%

Fe f}~f }fe~and( hd} nj~d} nf mde~jm~d nf hj} veanjnf} nf aeyf}~akjmae lje }and ~pj~jnd}

mde j`}dhv~j mdeianfemajhanjn( mdbspdbf~aend}f fh fzvasd mde}vh~dp j hj f}~pam~j

d`}fpyjemaj nf hj spayjmanjn q mdeianfemajhanjn nf ~dnd ~asd nf aeidpbjmae bjefojnj d

kfefpjnj j hd hjpkd nfh nf}jppdhhd nf hd} ~pj`jod}% ]f kjpje~aj fh jedeabj~d q spd~fmmaenf hj aeidpbjmae yfp~anj fe hd} mvf}~adejpad} nf jmvfpnd j hd na}svf}~d fe hj Hfq

Dpkeamj :6$:111 nf := nf namafb`pf( nf Spd~fmmae nf Nj~d} nf Mjpm~fp Sfp}dejh q fe

fh Pfjh Nfmpf~d :;03$033;( nf 0: nf namafb`pf( sdp fh zvf }f jspvf`j }v Pfkhjbfe~d nf

nf}jppdhhd%

Hd} j}sfm~d} zvf lje mjpjm~fpajnd fh na}fd bf~dndhkamd nfh f}~vnad nf mjbsd

mvje~a~j~ayd }f pf}vbfe fe hd} }akvafe~f} sve~d}%

0%=%: Veayfp}d nfh f}~vnad q }vof~d nf dsaeae

Fh veayfp}d nfh f}~vnad f}~ mde}~a~vand sdp fh mdeove~d nfh }fm~dp s`hamd f}sjdh?

jnbaea}~pjmadef}( dpkjea}bd}( ivenjmadef}( fbspf}j} s`hamj}( f~m% nf ~dnd fh ~fppa~dpad

ejmadejh( aenfsfenafe~fbfe~f nf mvh }fj }v bà~d ,hdmjh( jv~debamd d f}~j~jh! d }v

ej~vpjhfj ovpnamj%

Fh sfpiah }fhfmmadejnd sjpj hj mde}vh~j lj }and( mde mjpm~fp kfefpjh( ve pf}sde}j`hf nfh

pfj nf aeidpb~amj q ~fmedhdkj% Fe hd} mj}d} fe hd} zvf hd} dpkjea}bd} ed na}sdefe nf

f}~f ~asd nf sfpiah hj femvf}~j }f lj pfba~and j sfp}dejh mhjyf fe hj ~dbj nf nfma}adef}

sjpj hj mde~pj~jmae nf spdyffndpf} d mddpnaejmae nf hj} efmf}anjnf} aeidpb~amj} nfh

dpkjea}bd%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej 0: nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


22/175

^j`hj :? Veayfp}d nfh f}~vnad

Fe~anjnf} nfh }fm~dp s`hamd Ebfpd &

Eayfh f}~j~jh >;3 0(:1&

Eayfh jv~debamd 0%=&

^d~jh 633 :33(3&

Ivfe~f? AE^FMD

F}~d mpfj( aefya~j`hfbfe~f( naifpfemaj} f}~pvm~vpjhf} pf}sfm~d j hj sd`hjmae pfjh( zvf

nf`fe }fp mdppfkanj} bfnaje~f ve ijm~dp nf sdenfpjmae%

F}~f ijm~dp sfpba~f kvjpnjp hj spdsdpmadejhanjn nf mjnj ved nf hd} f}~pj~d} nf hj bvf}~pj

pf}sfm~d nf hj sd`hjmae pfjh d`of~d nf f}~vnad% F} nfmap( fh ijm~dp nf sdenfpjmae mjb`aj

hd} sf}d} nf hd} na}~ae~d} f}~pj~d} bvf}~pjhf} sjpj zvf }~d} }f jov}~fe j hd}



23/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej 0= nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

~

a

~

a

e

e

E

E

sd`hjmadejhf}% Nf f}~j idpbj( svfnfe d`}fpyjp}f naifpfemaj} fe~pf hd} pf}vh~jnd}

mjhmvhjnd} }ae fh ijm~dp( ~jh q mdbd lje }and pfmdkand} fe fh ~pj`jod nf mjbsd( q hd}

pf}vh~jnd} vej yf jshamjnj hj spdsdpmadejhanjn pfjh nf mjnj f}~pj~d nfe~pd nf hj

sd`hjmae%

Fe f}~f mj}d( hj jshamjmae nfh ijm~dp nf sdenfpjmae }vsdef j}akejp b} sf}d j hj}

pf}svf}~j} jsdp~jnj} sdp hj} fe~anjnf} hdmjhf} q bfed} j hj} jv~debamj} q f}~j~jhf} qj

zvf nfe~pd nfh mdeove~d sd`hjmadejh f|a}~f f}~j naifpfemaj fe~pf fh ebfpd nf fe~f} nf

mjnj ~asd%

Ahv}~pjmae :? Ijm~dp nf sdenfpjmae

E

E

e

a2 ebfpd nf fe~f} zvf ljq fe mjnj f}~pj~d

~2 ebfpd nf fe~f} zvf ljq fe hj sd`hjmae nf pfifpfemaj

ea2 ebfpd nf fe~f} zvf ljq fe mjnj f}~pj~d nf hj bvf}~pj

~2 ebfpd ~d~jh nf fe~f} zvf mdbsdefe hj bvf}~pj

Ivfe~f? DE^]A:

Hd} nj~d} sd`hjmadejhf} sjpj hj fhj`dpjmae nf f}~f sdenfpjndp lje }and d`~feand} j

sjp~ap nf hj aeidpbjmae sv`hamjnj sdp fh Baea}~fpad nf Ljmafenj q Jnbaea}~pjmadef}

S`hamj}( fe mdempf~d j sjp~ap nfh Aeyfe~jpad nf Fe~f} F}~j~jhf}( Aeyfe~jpad nf Fe~f}

nfsfenafe~f} nf hj} Mdbveanjnf} Jv~edbj} q Pfka}~pd nf Fe~anjnf} Hdmjhf}%

0%=%= Fppdp bvf}~pjh

^feafend fe mvfe~j hd} mpa~fpad} je~fpadpf} q j}vbafend ve eayfh nf mdeiajej nfh 16(3&(

q fe hj} mdenamadef} b} nf}ijydpj`hf} nfh bvf}~pfd ,20( s2z23(6!( }f kjpje~aj fe

~dnd mj}d ve fppdp nf bvf}~pfd sjpj hd} nj~d} khd`jhf} nfh >(= &% F}~f eayfh nf fppdp

j}fkvpj hj pfspf}fe~j~ayanjn nf hd} nj~d}( hd zvf abshamj zvf ~dnd} hd} pf}vh~jnd} zvf }f

dipfmje nf hj f|shd~jmae f}~jn}~amj nf hj aeidpbjmae ~fenpe j}fkvpjnj hj mjhanjn( qj

zvf fh fppdp nf bvf}~pfd mdppf}sdenafe~f j mjnj ved nf hd} ~pf} f}~pj~d} }fp }afbspf

aeifpadp jh :3&%

: Fh D`}fpyj~dpad Ejmadejh nf hj} ^fhfmdbveamjmadef} q nf hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae ,DE^]A! f} ve pkjed jn}mpa~d jPfn%f} mvqd spaemasjh d`of~ayd f} fh f}~vnad q jeha}a} nf hj ]dmafnjn nf hj Aeidpbjmae fe F}sjj%


24/175

^j`hj =? Fppdp bvf}~pjh

Fe~anjnf} nfh }fm~dp s`hamd Bvf}~pj Fppdp bvf}~pjh

bà~d f}~j~jh :3; ^meamj nf femvf}~jmae

Hj femvf}~j }f pfjha fe hd} bf}f} nf edyafb`pf q namafb`pf nf 03::%

]f lj fbshfjnd hj ~meamj MJÂ ,Mdbsv~fp J}}a}~fn ^fhfsldef Ae~fpyaf{aek!% Hj

jnbaea}~pjmae nf hj} fe~pfya}~j} }f lj hhfyjnd j mj`d nf idpbj napfm~j nf}nf ve mjhh

mfe~fp f}sfmajhajnd( mde~jend sjpj f}~j ~jpfj mde ve fzvasd nf ~fhfdsfpjndpf} mde

f|sfpafemaj spfyaj fe femvf}~jmae ~fhfieamj q jnfmvjnjbfe~f idpbjnd fe pfhjmae j

f}~f f}~vnad%

Nf idpbj mdbshfbfe~jpaj }f lje v~ahajnd mjejhf} nf mdppfd fhfm~peamd d ij| sjpj hj

pfba}ae spfyaj nfh mvf}~adejpad j hj sfp}dej femvf}~jnj( j} mdbd fh }dsdp~f ~fhfieamd

sfpbjefe~f fe hj mvbshabfe~jmae nfh mvf}~adejpad q fe hj naejbajmae sjpj hj

d`~femae nf pf}svf}~j} fifm~ayj}%

0%=%6 Fhj`dpjmae nfh mvf}~adejpad nf hj femvf}~j q pfjhajmae nf spf"~f}~

Hd} ~fb} q spfkve~j} nfh mvf}~adejpad }f lje na}fjnd mde mjpm~fp mvje~aiamj`hf q

bvh~adsmae% Fe jhke mj}d( }f lje aemhvand dsmadef} nf pf}svf}~j jàfp~j zvf lje }and

jejhajnj} nf idpbj f}sfmiamj mdbd aeidpbjmae mvjha~j~ayj nf jeha}a}%

Mde mjpm~fp spfyad jh aeamad nfh spdmf}d nf femvf}~jmae( fh mvf}~adejpad lj }and

}dbf~and j ve spdmf}d nf mde~pj}~f ,spf~f}~! q nfsvpjmae iaejh mde vej }v`bvf}~pj

jhfj~dpaj nf fe~f} s`hamd} f}sjdhf} zvf mvbshje hj} f}sfmaiamjmadef} pfzvfpanj} sjpjidpbjp sjp~f nfh mdhfm~ayd j femvf}~jp% Fe f}~f mj}d }f ~pj~j`j nf pf}sde}j`hf} nfh

nfsjp~jbfe~d nf aeidpb~amj d ofif} nf }fpyamad nf }v mdppf}sdenafe~f Jnbaea}~pjmae $

Fe~f s`hamd%

J}( }f lj mde~jnd mde hj mdhj`dpjmae nf pf}sde}j`hf} nf fe~f} nf hd} naifpfe~f}

f}~pj~d} fe hd} zvf }f nayanf hj bvf}~pj( jh dòf~d nf pfmdkfp dsaeadef} nf ~dnd} hd}

sfpiahf} q sdnfp jejhajp hj bjqdp yjpafnjn nf }a~vjmadef} sd}a`hf} sjpj f}~j femvf}~j%

Bfnaje~f hj pfjhajmae nfh spf~f}~ }f `v}mj`j hj d`~femae nf ve mdeove~d nf aeidpbjmae

q$d mdemhv}adef} bf~dndhkamj} spfyaj} jmfpmj nf?

Hj jnfmvjmae nf hj} spfkve~j} nfh mvf}~adejpad j hj iaejhanjn nf hj aeyf}~akjmae%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej 0> nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


25/175

Hj f}~pvm~vpj q na}sd}amae fzvaha`pjnj q jpbeamj nf }v} `hdzvf} ~fb~amd}%

Fh dpnfe nf hj} spfkve~j} nfe~pd nf mjnj ved nf hd} `hdzvf}%

Hj fyjhvjmae nf hj nvpjmae q fh pa~bd nf hj} femvf}~j}%

Hj jv}femaj nf spfkve~j} pfhfyje~f} d f|a}~femaj nf spfkve~j} }vsfpihvj} d

pfa~fpj~ayj}%

0%=%9 Bdnfhd nf pfmdsahjmae q f|shd~jmae nf hj aeidpbjmae pf}vh~je~f

Hj d`~femae nf hj `j}f nf nj~d} nfiaea~ayj ~pj} hj} ij}f} nf ~pj`jod nf mjbsd q

~pj~jbafe~d spfyad nf hj aeidpbjmae ,nfsvpjmae( mdnaiamjmae q yjhanjmae! lj }and fh

sve~d nf sjp~anj sjpj }v jeha}a} f}~jn}~amd nf mjpj j hj d`~femae nf pf}vh~jnd} zvfmde~pa`vqje j f}mhjpfmfp ~dnj} hj} mvf}~adef} shje~fjnj} jh aeamad nfh spdmf}d nf

aeyf}~akjmae%

Fh ~pj~jbafe~d q f|shd~jmae nf hj aeidpbjmae pfmdsahjnj }f lj hhfyjnd j mj`d bfnaje~f

ldoj} nf mhmvhd q fh sjzvf~f f}~jn}~amd ]S]] :1%

Iaejhbfe~f( hd} nj~d} pf}vh~je~f} nfh spdmf}d nf jeha}a} }f lje }ae~f~ajnd q

pfspf}fe~jnd j ~pjy} nf bdnfhd} kpiamd}( aenamjndpf} }abshf} q f}~jn}~amd} zvf

ijmaha~je hj ae~fpspf~jmae nf hd} pf}vh~jnd} q hj idpbvhjmae nf las~f}a} q mdemhv}adef}%

Fe~pf hd} spaemasjhf} fhfbfe~d} nf pfspf}fe~jmae f}~jn}~amj v~ahajnd} }f femvfe~pje hj}

~j`hj} nf na}~pa`vmae nf ipfmvfemaj q pfspf}fe~jmadef} kpiamj}%



26/175


= AE^PDNVMMAE JH MHDVN MDBSVÂEK

=%: Nf}mpasmae q mjpjm~fp}~amj}J~fenafend j hj nfiaeamae spdsdpmadejnj sdp fh EA]^ ,Ej~adejh Ae}~a~v~f di ]~jenjpn} jen

^fmledhdkq!0( fh mhdvn mdbsv~aek f} ve bdnfhd nf mdbsv~jmae zvf sfpba~f( nf}nf

mvjhzvafp hvkjp q nf ve bdnd spm~amd( fh jmmf}d `jod nfbjenj q j ~pjy} nf hj pfn j ve

mdeove~d nf pfmvp}d} aeidpb~amd} mdbsjp~and} q mdeiakvpj`hf} ,sdp fofbshd? pfnf}(

}fpyandpf}( fzvasd} nf jhbjmfejbafe~d( jshamjmadef} q }fpyamad}!( hd} mvjhf} svfnfe }fp

psanjbfe~f jspdya}adejnd} q ha`fpjnd} ~pj} f}ivfpd} nf kf}~ae beabd} q sdmj

ae~fpjmmae mde fh spdyffndp%

D~pj nfiaeamae mdbshfbfe~jpaj f} hj jsdp~jnj sdp fh PJN Hj` nf hj Veayfp}anjn nf@fpgfhfq=( nf}nf ndenf }f f|shamj zvf fh mhdvn mdbsv~aek }f pfiafpf ~je~d j hj}

jshamjmadef} fe~pfkjnj} mdbd }fpyamad j ~pjy} nf Ae~fpef~( mdbd jh ljpn{jpf q }di~{jpf

nf hd} mfe~pd} nf nj~d} zvf spdsdpmadeje f}~d} }fpyamad}% Hd} }fpyamad} je~fpadpf} lje

}and mdedmand} nvpje~f bvmld ~afbsd mdbd ]di~{jpf j} j ]fpyamf d ]jj] ,}di~{jpf

mdbd }fpyamad!( bafe~pj} zvf fh ljpn{jpf q }di~{jpf nfh mfe~pd nf nj~d} mde}~a~vqfe hd

zvf }f lj yfeand fe hhjbjp ev`f%

Nf f}~j} nfiaeamadef} }f nf}spfenf zvf fh mhdvn mdbsv~aek pfspf}fe~j ve mjbàd

absdp~je~f sjpj hj} fbspf}j} q dpkjea}bd} s`hamd} fe hj idpbj nf spdmf}jp hj

aeidpbjmae q kf}~adejp hj} pfj} nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Aeidpbjmae ,Â!%

Bfnaje~f fh v}d nf f}~f sjpjnakbj( hj} dpkjeajmadef} svfnfe sj}jp nf hj kf}~ae Â

~pjnamadejh ,mde mvje~ad}j} aeyfp}adef} fe pfmvp}d}( aemhvqfend ljpn{jpf( }di~{jpf(

mfe~pd} nf spdmf}jbafe~d nf nj~d}( pfnf}( sfp}dejh( }fkvpanjn( f~m%!( jh evfyd bdnfhd nf

kf}~ae Â fe hj ev`f ,}f fhabaej hj efmf}anjn nf kpjenf} aeyfp}adef} q md}~f} iaod}!(

~pje}idpbjend j hd} spdyffndpf} fe ae}~pvbfe~d}( zvafef} sdefe jh jhmjemf nf hd}

v}vjpad}( nf idpbj ihf|a`hf f ae}~je~efj( hj mjsjmanjn nf mdbsv~jmae `jod nfbjenj%

F|a}~fe vej }fpaf nf mjpjm~fp}~amj} j hj} zvf }f ljmf pfifpfemaj pfmvppfe~fbfe~f sjpjpfbjpmjp hj} naifpfemaj} fe~pf fh mhdvn mdbsv~aekq hd} bdnfhd} nf Â ~pjnamadejhf}% Sjpj

vej bfodp mdbspfe}ae nf namlj} mjpjm~fp}~amj} q nfh v}d zvf }f ljmf nf hj} ba}bj} fe

fh pf}~d nfh ndmvbfe~d( j mde~aevjmae }f dipfmf vej `pfyf nf}mpasmae nf ved}

mdemfs~d} mhjyf%

0 EA]^ ,03::!% ^lf EA]^ Nfiaea~ade di Mhdvn Mdbsv~aek% Na}sdea`hf fe? l~~s?$$m}pm%ea}~%kdy$sv`hamj~ade}$ea}~sv`}$6$]S6%sni

= Veayfp}a~q di Mjhaidpeaj j~ @fpgfhfq ,0331!% J`dyf ~lf Mhdvn}? J @fpgfhfq Yaf{ di Mhdvn Mdbsv~aek% Na}sdea`hf fe?l~~s?$${{{%ffm}%`fpgfhfq%fnv$Sv`}$^fmlPs~}$0331$FFM]03310


27/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej 0; nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

J`}~pjmmae

Mjsjmanjn nf ja}hjp hd} pfmvp}d} aeidpb~amd} mde~pj~jnd} jh spdyffndp nf hd} }a}~fbj}

aeidpb~amd} nf hj fe~anjn mde~pj~je~f( ydhyafend }v kf}~ae ~d~jhbfe~f ~pje}sjpfe~f,nf}nf fh sve~d nf ya}~j nfh v}vjpad!( kpjmaj} jh v}d nf hj yap~vjhajmae% F}~d sfpba~f jh

mhafe~f ed pfzvfpap nf sfp}dejh nfnamjnd jh bje~feabafe~d nf hj aeipjf}~pvm~vpj(

jm~vjhajmae nf hd} }a}~fbj}( pfjhajmae nf spvf`j} q nfb} ~jpfj} j}dmajnj} jh

}fpyamad mde~pj~jnd%

F}mjhjàhanjn

Mjsjmanjn zvf mde}a}~f fe jvbfe~jp d na}baevap hj} ivemadejhanjnf} dipfmanj} jh mhafe~f(

fe ivemae nf hj} efmf}anjnf} sve~vjhf} nfh ba}bd( }ae efmf}anjn nf ~pjba~jp evfyd}

mde~pj~d} d sfejhajmadef}% F}~j mjpjm~fp}~amj fya~j hd} paf}kd} aelfpfe~f} nf ve sd}a`hf

bjh nabfe}adejbafe~d aeamajh fe fh mde}vbd d fe hj efmf}anjn nf pfmvp}d}%

Sjkd sdp v}d

Nfpayjnd nfh mdemfs~d nf f}mjhjàhanjn( fh md}~f nfh }fpyamad j}dmajnd }f bdnaiamj

~jbàe fe ivemae nf hj} efmf}anjnf} sve~vjhf} nf v}d nf hj }dhvmae% Nf f}~j idpbj( fh

sjkd zvf nf`f j`dejp fh mhafe~f yjpj fe ivemae nfh v}d zvf }f hf n jh }fpyamad mhdvn

mde~pj~jnd%

Jv~d}fpyamad jod nfbjenj

F}~j mjpjm~fp}~amj sfpba~f jh v}vjpad jmmfnfp j hj} mjsjmanjnf} nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aeknf

idpbj jv~db~amj j bfnanj zvf hj} yjqj pfzvapafend( }ae efmf}anjn nf vej ae~fpjmmae

lvbjej mde }v spdyffndp nf }fpyamad} mhdvn mdbsv~aek>%

Jmmf}d ahaba~jnd q bvh~ashj~jidpbj

Mde}a}~f fe hj sd}aàhanjn dipfmanj j hd} v}vjpad} nf jmmfnfp j hd} }fpyamad} mde~pj~jnd}

nf mhdvn mdbsv~aekfe mvjhzvafp hvkjp( fe mvjhzvafp bdbfe~d q mde mvjhzvafp na}sd}a~aydmde mdef|ae j Ae~fpef~% Fh jmmf}d j hd} }fpyamad} nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek}f pfjhaj j ~pjy}

nf Ae~fpef~( hd zvf ijmaha~j zvf na}~ae~d} na}sd}a~ayd}( ~jhf} mdbd ~fhided} byahf}

ae~fhakfe~f}( ~j`hf~j} v dpnfejndpf} sdp~~ahf}( svfnje jmmfnfp j ve ba}bd }fpyamad

dipfmand fe hj pfn bfnaje~f bfmjea}bd} nf jmmf}d f}~enjp%

> Ivenjmae anfj} ,03::!% Mhdvn Mdbsv~aek? Pf~d} q Dsdp~veanjnf}% Na}sdea`hf fe?l~~s?$${{{%ivenjmadeanfj}%f}$}a~f}$nfijvh~$iahf}$sni$N^MhdvnTMdbsv~aekFm%sni
http://www.fundacionideas.es/sites/default/files/pdf/DT-Cloud_Computing-Ec.pdfhttp://www.fundacionideas.es/sites/default/files/pdf/DT-Cloud_Computing-Ec.pdfhttp://www.fundacionideas.es/sites/default/files/pdf/DT-Cloud_Computing-Ec.pdf


28/175

=%0 MHJ]AIAMJMAE NF HJ] ]DHVMADEF] MHDVN MDBSVÂEK

Fe hj jm~vjhanjn( hj} naifpfe~f} }dhvmadef} mhdvn mdbsv~aekzvf }f dipfmfe fe fh bfpmjnd

svfnfe }fp mhj}aiamjnj}( ivenjbfe~jhbfe~f( fe `j}f j ~pf} mjpjm~fp}~amj}? eayfhf} nf}fpyamad( bdnfhd} nf nf}shafkvf q bdnfhd} nf efkdmad%

F}~j} ~pf} mjpjm~fp}~amj}( ove~d mde }v} naifpfe~f} ~asd} nf }dhvmadef} j}dmajnj}( }f

svfnfe pfspf}fe~jp fe ve mv`d nf ~pf} nabfe}adef}( ~jh q mdbd }f bvf}~pj fe hj abjkfe

aeifpadp( zvf ed} sfpba~f ae~vap fh ebfpd nf mdbàejmadef} sd}a`hf}%

Ahv}~pjmae 0? Mhj}aiamjmae nf }dhvmadef} mhdvn mdbsv~aek

Bdnfhd}nfnf}shafkvf

Eayfhf}

nf}fpyamad

Ivfe~f?fhj`dpjmae spdsaj

J ~pjy} nf hj mdbàejmae nf f}~j} ~pf} nabfe}adef}( j mde~aevjmae }f nf~jhhje hd}

na}~ae~d} ~asd} nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek f|a}~fe~f} fe fh bfpmjnd( j} mdbd }v} spaemasjhf}

mjpjm~fp}~amj}%

=%0%: Sdp eayfhf} nf }fpyamadF}~j mhj}aiamjmae ljmf pfifpfemaj jh ~asd q eayfh nf j`}~pjmmae nf hj} }dhvmadef}

dipfmanj} sdp fh spdyffndpmhdvn% Hj} spaemasjhf} ~asdhdkj} }fke f}~j mhj}aiamjmae }de?

Aeipjf}~pvm~vpj mdbd }fpyamad ,Aeipj}~pvm~vpf j} j ]fpyamf Ajj]!%

Shj~jidpbj mdbd }fpyamad ,Shj~idpb j} j ]fpyamf Sjj]!%

]di~{jpf mdbd }fpyamad ,]di~{jpf j} j ]fpyamf ]jj]!%

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej 0< nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!


29/175

Aeipjf}~pvm~vpj mdbd }fpyamad

Ijbahaj nf mhdvn mdbsv~aekzvf mde}a}~f fe hj fe~pfkj nf hj aeipjf}~pvm~vpj aeidpb~amj

,mjsjmanjn nf mdbsv~jmae( f}sjmad nf na}md q `j}f} nf nj~d}( fe~pf d~pd}! mdbd ve}fpyamad% ]d`pf f}~j aeipjf}~pvm~vpj( fh v}vjpad sdnp abshfbfe~jp }v} spdsad} }fpyamad} fe

bdnd ~pjnamadejh( }a j} hd nfmanf%

Hd} mhafe~f} zvf ds~je sdp f}~f ~asd nf ijbahaj mhdvn( fe yf nf mdbspjp napfm~jbfe~f

pfmvp}d} mdbd svfnfe }fp hd} }fpyandpf}( fh f}sjmad nfh mfe~pd nf nj~d} d hd} fzvasd} nf

pfn( }f nfmje~je sdp hj f|~fpejhajmae fe `v}mj nf ve jldppd fe hj aeyfp}ae fe }a}~fbj}

^A%

Mde f}~j f|~fpejhajmae( hj} ijm~vpj} j}dmajnj} j f}~f ~asd nf }fpyamad} }f mjhmvhje fe

`j}f j hj mje~anjn nf pfmvp}d} mde}vband} sdp fh mhafe~f( `j}end}f j} fe fh bdnfhd nf

sjkd sdp v}d%

Shj~jidpbj mdbd }fpyamad

Ijbahaj nf mhdvn mdbsv~aekzvf mde}a}~f fe hj fe~pfkj( mdbd ve }fpyamad( nf ve mdeove~d

nf shj~jidpbj} aeidpb~amj} dpafe~jnj} jh nf}jppdhhd( ~f}~fd( nf}shafkvf( ld}~aek q

bje~feabafe~d nf hd} }a}~fbj} dsfpj~ayd} q jshamjmadef} spdsaj} nfh mhafe~f% Fe f}~f

mj}d( hj kf}~ae nf hj aeipjf}~pvm~vpj zvfnj j`}~pjnj sjpj fh mhafe~f( sfpd bje~afef hj

pf}sde}j`ahanjn nf kf}~ae nf hj shj~jidpbj q hj} jshamjmadef}%

Hj} spaemasjhf} mjpjm~fp}~amj} j}dmajnj} jh Sjj] mdbd }dhvmae mhdvn}de hj} }akvafe~f}?

Ijmaha~j fh nf}shafkvf nf hj} jshamjmadef} nf hj fe~anjn( }ae fh md}~f q hj

mdbshfoanjn nfpayjnd} nf hj mdbspj q kf}~ae nfh ljpn{jpf q nf hj} mjsj} nf

}di~{jpf j}dmajnj}%

Dipfmf j ~pjy} nf Ae~fpef~ ~dnd} hd} pfzva}a~d} efmf}jpad} sjpj mpfjp q fe~pfkjp

}fpyamad} q jshamjmadef} j ~pjy} nf hj {f`%

]di~{jpf mdbd }fpyamad

Ijbahaj nf mhdvn mdbsv~aekzvf mde}a}~f fe sfpba~ap fh v}d nf hj} jshamjmadef} mdbd ve

}fpyamad( }akvafend ve bdnfhd nf nf}shafkvf nf }di~{jpf bfnaje~f fh mvjh fh spdyffndp

dipfmf hamfemaj} nf }v jshamjmae j hd} mhafe~f}( sjpj }v v}d mdbd ve }fpyamad `jod

nfbjenj( ha`fpjend sdp mdbshf~d jh mhafe~f nf hj kf}~ae nf hj aeipjf}~pvm~vpj q hj

shj~jidpbj%

Hd} spdyffndpf} nf hd} }fpyamad} ]jj] svfnfe jhdojp hj jshamjmae fe }v} spdsad}

}fpyandpf} {f` ,sfpba~afend j hd} mhafe~f} jmmfnfp( sdp fofbshd( bfnaje~f ve ejyfkjndp

{f`!( d fofmv~jp fh }di~{jpf fe hd} }a}~fbj} nfh mde~pj~je~f nfh }fpyamad% Fe f}~f h~abd



30/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej =3 nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

mj}d( }f spdnvmapj hj nf}jm~ayjmae nf hj jshamjmae vej yf iaejhamf fh }fpyamad d f|sapf fh

mde~pj~d nf hamfemaj nf v}d%

Hj }dhvmae nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek nf ]di~{jpf j} j ]fpyamf svfnf f}~jp dpafe~jnj jna}~ae~d} ~asd} nf mhafe~f} }fke }v mdenamae?

V}vjpad} sjp~amvhjpf} ,fo? }fpyamad} diab~amd}( pfnf} }dmajhf}( {f` 0%3( f~m%!

V}vjpad} spdif}adejhf} ,fo? MPB6( FPS9( f~m%!

=%0%0 Sdp bdnfhd} nf nf}shafkvf

F}~j mhj}aiamjmae ljmf pfifpfemaj jh eayfh q ~asd nf mdbsjp~amae nf hd} pfmvp}d}

mde~pj~jnd} fe hj ev`f mde d~pj} fe~anjnf} }fbfoje~f} d nf na}~ae~j} ej~vpjhfj}% Hj}

spaemasjhf} ~asdhdkj} zvf }f nf}spfenfe nf f}~j mhj}aiamjmae }de?

Mhdvns`hamd%

Mhdvnspayjnd%

Mhdvnl`pand%

Mhdvnmdbvea~jpad%

Ahv}~pjmae =? ^asdhdkj nf mhdvn mdbsv~aeksdp bdnfhd nf nf}shafkvf

Ivfe~f? fhj`dpjmae spdsaj

Mhdvns`hamd

^asd nf abshfbfe~jmae mjpjm~fpajnd sdp hj difp~j nf }fpyamad} nf mdbsv~jmae

yap~vjhajnd} ,`j}f} nf nj~d}( }a}~fbj} dsfpj~ayd}( shj~jidpbj} nf nf}jppdhhd(

6Mv}~dbfp Pfhj~ade}las Bjejkfbfe~%Jshamjmadef} sjpj hj Kf}~ae nf hj} Pfhjmadef} mde Mhafe~f}%9Fe~fpspa}f Pf}dvpmf Shjeeaek% Jshamjmadef} sjpj hj Shjeaiamjmae nf Pfmvp}d} Fbspf}jpajhf}%


31/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej =: nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

jshamjmadef}( f~m%! sdp sjp~f nf hd} spdyffndpf} sjpj bh~ashf} mhafe~f} lf~fpdkefd}(

jmmfnafend }~d} j namld} }fpyamad} j ~pjy} nf Ae~fpef~ d YSE};%

Mdbd mjpjm~fp}~amj} aelfpfe~f} j f}~f ~asd nf abshfbfe~jmae sdnfbd} ma~jp hj}}akvafe~f}?

Shjd} b} `pfyf} sjpj hj svf}~j fe bjpmlj nfh }fpyamad%

Ed }f pfzvafpf hhfyjp j mj`d aeyfp}ae nf mjsa~jh sjpj }v abshfbfe~jmae%

Sfpba~f hj f|~fpejhajmae( j ve spdyffndp nf }fpyamad} mhdvn( nf ~dnj} hj}

ivemadef} }amj} nf hj fbspf}j%

Sd}aàha~j fh jspdyfmljbafe~d nf hj aeipjf}~pvm~vpj nf hd} spdyffndpf} nf}fpyamad}( sfpba~afend jnamadejhbfe~f vej jh~j f}mjhjàhanjn q ihf|aàhanjn fe hj

bdnaiamjmae nfh nabfe}adejbafe~d nfh }fpyamad%

Ijydpfmf hj v~ahajmae nf mdeove~d} nf }di~{jpf f}~enjp%

Hhfyj j}dmajnj} vej} mvd~j} aeamajhf} nf sjkd b} `joj} zvf fh pf}~d nf

abshfbfe~jmadef}% Jnamadejhbfe~f hd} md}~f} nfh mhdvn s`hamd }de yjpaj`hf}(

mvbshafend fh spaemasad nf sjkd sdp v}d%

Hj aeidpbjmae mdpsdpj~ayj }f femvfe~pj jhdojnj fe hj ev`f s`hamj ove~d j hj nfh

pf}~d nf mhafe~f} nfh spdyffndp( hd zvf abshamj( jnfb} nf ed sdnfp ~fefp

hdmjhajnj i}amj f aeae~fppvbsanjbfe~f namlj aeidpbjmae( absdefp jh spdyffndp

vej }fpaf nf pfzva}a~d} nf jh~j f|akfemaj fe ~fbj} nf }fkvpanjn q spd~fmmae nf

nj~d}%

Mhdvnspayjnd

âsd nf abshfbfe~jmae mjpjm~fpajnd sdp fh }vbaea}~pd nf fe~dped} yap~vjhajnd}( zvf

svfnfe }fp abshfbfe~jnd} sdp hj spdsaj fbspf}j mde}vbandpj d sdp ve spdyffndp( q zvf}de v}jnd} q mde~pdhjnd} eamjbfe~f sdp hj fbspf}j mde~pj~je~f nfh }fpyamad% F}~f ~asd

nf nf}shafkvf} sfpba~fe }fp jnbaea}~pjnd} ~je~d sdp hj dpkjeajmae v}vjpaj mdbd sdp fh

spdyffndp( q svfnfe f}~jp nf}shfkjnd} fe hj} ae}~jhjmadef} nf }~f d nfh mhafe~f%

Mdbd mjpjm~fp}~amj} spdsaj} nf f}~f ~asd nf abshfbfe~jmae }f fevbfpje hj} }akvafe~f}?

Dipfmf ve ~afbsd nf svf}~j fe }fpyamad `jod q vej jh~j ihf|aàhanjn fe hj

j}akejmae nf pfmvp}d}%

;Yap~vjh Spayj~f Ef~{dpg% Pfn Spayjnj Yap~vjh%


32/175

Jh mde~pjpad zvf fh mhdvn s`hamd( pfzvafpf nf aeyfp}ae nf mjsa~jh sjpj hj

abshfbfe~jmae nf hj }dhvmae mde~pj~jnj%

Hhfyj j}dmajnd} }a}~fbj} q `j}f} nf nj~d} hdmjhf}%

Sfpba~f hj sd}aàhanjn nf jspdyfmljp fh sfp}dejh f|a}~fe~f q hj} aeyfp}adef} fe

}a}~fbj} nf aeidpbjmae pfjhajnj} mde je~fpadpanjn%

Abshamj b} f}sfmaiamanjn fe hj }dhvmae jnzvapanj( qj zvf f}~ na}fjnj sjpj

jov}~jp}f j hj} efmf}anjnf} spdsaj} nf hj fbspf}j mde~pj~je~f%

Sfpba~f na}sdefp nf ve mde~pdh ~d~jh nf hj aeipjf}~pvm~vpj( nf hd} }a}~fbj} q nf hj

aeidpbjmae mdpsdpj~ayj ~pj~jnj sdp }~d}%

Mhdvnl`pand

âsd nf abshfbfe~jmae mvqj aeipjf}~pvm~vpj mhdvn}f mjpjm~fpaj sdp jvejp nd} d b}

~asd} nf mhdvn},spayjnd( s`hamd!( zvf mde~aeje }afend fe~anjnf} eamj} ae~fpmdefm~jnj}

bfnaje~f ~fmedhdkj f}~jenjpajnj d spdsaf~jpaj( q zvf sfpba~f hj sdp~jàhanjn nf nj~d} q

jshamjmadef} ,fo% fh pf`jhjemfd nf mjpkj} fe~pf ev`f}!%

Vej fe~anjn zvf abshfbfe~f f}~f ~asd nf }dhvmae sdnpj `fefiamajp}f nf hj} yfe~joj}

j}dmajnj} jh ~asd nf mhdvn v~ahajnd sjpj mjnj ved nf hd} }fpyamad} mde~pj~jnd}(na}sdeafend nf vej }fpaf nf mjpjm~fp}~amj} jnamadejhf}?

Dipfmf vej bjqdp ihf|aàhanjn fe hj spf}~jmae nf }fpyamad} nf Â( jh ba}bd ~afbsd

zvf }f bje~afef ve bjqdp mde~pdh }d`pf hd} }fpyamad} nf efkdmad q nf nj~d}%

Mde vej }dhvmae nf mhdvn l`pand( jh akvjh zvf fe hd} mj}d} nf~jhhjnd}

je~fpadpbfe~f( }f mde}akvf vej psanj svf}~j fe }fpyamad%

Abshamj bjqdp mdbshfoanjn fe hj ae~fkpjmae nf hj }dhvmae mhdvn( mdbd

mde}fmvfemaj nf }fp vej }dhvmae zvf }f mdbsdef nf naifpfe~f} ~asd} nfabshfbfe~jmae nf }fpyamad} fe hj ev`f%

Sfpba~f ae~fkpjp hj} bfodpf} mjpjm~fp}~amj} nf hd} na}~ae~d} ~asd} nf }dhvmadef}

mhdvn( fe mvje~d jh mde~pdh nf hd} nj~d} q j hj kf}~ae nf hj} ivemadef} `}amj} nf

hj fe~anjn%

Sfpba~f hj }fhfmmae( sdp sjp~f nfh spdyffndp( nf aeipjf}~pvm~vpj f}mjhj`hf q

ihf|a`hf( dipfmafend vej jh~j jkahanjn fe fh pfnabfe}adejbafe~d nf hj }dhvmae%

Sfpba~f fh mde~pdh ae~fped nf hd} }fpyamad} mhdvnnf}nf hj spdsaj fe~anjn%



33/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej == nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

Mhdvnmdbvea~jpad

]f ~pj~j nf mhdvn} v~ahajnd} sdp na}~ae~j} dpkjeajmadef} mvqj} ivemadef} q }fpyamad}

}fje mdbvef}( sfpba~afend mde fhhd hj mdhj`dpjmae fe~pf kpvsd} nf ae~fp}%

Jh jejhajp vej ev`f mdbvea~jpaj d nf mdbveanjn( }f nf`f mde}anfpjp zvf( fe spaemasad(

}v} idp~jhfj} q nfàhanjnf} }f }a~je fe~pf hj} nf vej ev`f spayjnj q hj} nf vej s`hamj%

Fe kfefpjh( fh mdeove~d nf pfmvp}d} na}sdea`hf} mde ve mhdvnnf mdbveanjn f} bjqdp zvf

fe vej ev`f spayjnj( mde hj} yfe~joj} fyanfe~f} zvf fhhd mdehhfyj fe ~pbaed} nf

fhj}~amanjn% ]ae fb`jpkd( hj mje~anjn nf pfmvp}d} f} bfedp zvf hd} f|a}~fe~f} fe vej

}dhvmae nf ev`f s`hamj( haba~jend hj fhj}~amanjn pf}sfm~d j namld mhdvns`hamd% Sdp d~pj

sjp~f( fh ebfpd nf v}vjpad} nf f}~f ~asd nf ev`f f} bfedp zvf hd} nf hj ev`f s`hamj( hd

zvf sfpba~f bjqdpf} spf}~jmadef} fe mvf}~adef} nf }fkvpanjn q spayjmanjn nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

sdp hj} evbfpd}j} yfe~joj} zvf dipfmf fh bdnfhd nf }fpyamad mhdvn mdbsv~aek( ~jh q mdbd

nf}~jmj Nfhda~~f fe }v aeidpbf1? mfhfpanjn sjpj hj na}sd}amae nfh }fpyamad( md}~f nf

aeyfp}ae efmf}jpad q f}mjhjàhanjn nf pfmvp}d} ~meamd} fe `j}f j hj nfbjenj%

J mde~aevjmae }f nf}khd}je hd} na}~ae~d} `fefiamad} zvf }f svfnfe d`~fefp jnds~jend fh

bdnfhd nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

@fefiamad} pfhj~ayd} j hj svf}~j fe bjpmlj nfh }fpyamad

Hd} spdqfm~d} Â `j}jnd} fe vej aeipjf}~pvm~vpj i}amj efmf}a~je ve jeha}a} spfyad zvf

jqvnf j femde~pjp hj ae~fpdsfpjàhanjn nf ~dnd} hd} mdbsdefe~f} ~fmedhkamd} ,ljpn{jpf(

}di~{jpf( mdbveamjmadef}( f~m%!% F}~f jeha}a} }f svfnf yfp pfnvmand }a hj dsmae fhfkanj

}f `j}j fe hj ev`f% Hj ijmahanjn sjpj sdefp fe bjpmlj ve }fpyamad }f mde}akvf

}abshfbfe~f j ~pjy} nf vej mdeiakvpjmae }femahhj q nf hd} bfnad} jnfmvjnd} sjpj zvf

hd} v}vjpad} svfnje jmmfnfp% Hd} `fefiamad} j}dmajnd} j hj svf}~j fe bjpmlj nfh

}fpyamad ~afefe zvf yfp mde hd} }akvafe~f} j}sfm~d}?

Aebfnaj~f? ]f svfnf na}sdefp nf ve }fpyamad mvjhaiamjnd q spdnvm~ayd fe bvq

mdp~d shjd( }ae efmf}anjn nf aeyfp~ap ~afbsd} f|mf}ayd} fe f~jsj} je~fpadpf}% Nf

f}~j bjefpj }f svfnfe fya~jp ~jpfj} aeefmf}jpaj} mdbd hj pfjhajmae nf ve

f}~vnad nf mdbsj~aàhanjn ~fmedhkamj d hj fofmvmae nf spvf`j} nf mjsjmanjn%

Aeyfp}ae aeamajh? Ed f} efmf}jpad nf}~aejp eaekvej mje~anjn j hj mdbspj nf}fpyandpf} ea jmdenamadejp ve sd}a`hf mfe~pd nf spdmf}jbafe~d nf nj~d}%

Mdbdnanjn? Hd} v}vjpad} svfnfe v~ahajp fh evfyd }fpyamad }ae zvf }v} fzvasd}

~fekje zvf }fp jm~vjhajnd} d hd} }a}~fbj} }f ~fekje zvf sjpjhajp%

Difp~j? Fh |a~d nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek }f ~pjnvmf fe vej jbshaj yjpafnjn nf

}fpyamad} dipfmand} sdp hd} spdyffndpf}( svnaend}f femde~pjp ~dnj mhj}f nf

}dhvmadef}? kf}~ae iaejemafpj( }a}~fbj} nf mdbveamjmae( f~m%

@fefiamad} fmdebamd}

Hj jndsmae nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek spf}fe~j evbfpd}j} yfe~joj} nfe~pd nfh shjed

fmdebamd% Hj pfya}~j Idp`f} fe ved }v} jp~mvhd}:3( nf}~jmj hd} `fefiamad} fmdebamd}

mdbd spaemasjh pje sjpj ~pj}hjnjp}f j hj ev`f?

1 Nfhda~~f ,0331!? Mhdvn Mdbsv~aek% Idpfmj}~aek Mljekf% Na}sdea`hf ,fe aekh}! fe? l~~s}?$${{{%nfhda~~f%mdb$j}}f~}$NmdbKhd`jh$Hdmjh&03J}}f~}$Ndmvbfe~}$^B^$mhdvnTTbjpgf~Tdyfpyaf{TjenTsfp}sfm~ayf%sni

:3 Idp`f} ,03::!? ^lf Fmdedbam @fefia~} di Mdvn Mdbsv~aek% Na}sdea`hf ,fe aekh}! fe?l~~s?$${{{%idp`f}%mdb$}a~f}$gfyaeojmg}de$03::$31$:;$~lffmdedbam`fefia~dimhdvnmdbsv~aek$
https://www.deloitte.com/assets/Dcom-Global/Local%20Assets/Documents/TMT/cloud_-_market_overview_and_perspective.pdfhttps://www.deloitte.com/assets/Dcom-Global/Local%20Assets/Documents/TMT/cloud_-_market_overview_and_perspective.pdfhttp://www.forbes.com/sites/kevinjackson/2011/09/17/the-economic-benefit-of-cloud-computing/http://www.forbes.com/sites/kevinjackson/2011/09/17/the-economic-benefit-of-cloud-computing/https://www.deloitte.com/assets/Dcom-Global/Local%20Assets/Documents/TMT/cloud_-_market_overview_and_perspective.pdfhttps://www.deloitte.com/assets/Dcom-Global/Local%20Assets/Documents/TMT/cloud_-_market_overview_and_perspective.pdf


35/175


Mde~pj~jmae de"nfbjen? Hj fe~anjn mde~pj~je~f sjkj f|mhv}ayjbfe~f sdp fh v}d

zvf f}~ ljmafend nfh }fpyamad% Je~f ve aempfbfe~d nfh ebfpd nf dsfpjmadef}

}f sdnpje jbshajp hj} mjsjmanjnf} ~meamj} napfm~jbfe~f fe hj ev`f% Sdp d~pj

sjp~f( je~f mamhd} mde vej spdnvm~ayanjn bfedp }f sdnpj pfnabfe}adejp hj

mde~pj~jmae j hj `joj( baeabajend fh sjkd j pfjhajp jh spdyffndp%

Jspdya}adejbafe~d naebamd::? F} sd}a`hf jmmfnfp j mvjhzvafp }a}~fbj nf

aeidpbjmae }abshfbfe~f mde ve na}sd}a~ayd aeidpb~amd q mdef|ae j Ae~fpef~% Ed

f} efmf}jpad fh kj}~d fe aeipjf}~pvm~vpj} ~fmedhkamj} sjpj sdnfp ivemadejp%

Pfmvp}d} lvbjed}? Hj mde~pj~jmae nf sfp}dejh f}sfmajhajnd sjpj hj kf}~ae nf

hj} ~fmedhdkj} f} pf}sde}jàhanjn nfh spdyffndp% Mde hj fydhvmae ljmaj

fe~dped} b} jyjejnd}( fh spdyffndp }fp fh femjpkjnd nf idpbjp q mde~pj~jp jfbshfjnd} mvjhaiamjnd} fe mjnj bdbfe~d sjpj sdnfp bje~fefp hj mjhanjn

mde~pjm~vjh mde hd} mhafe~f}%

F}sjmad i}amd? ]f fya~j hj spdya}ae nf f}sjmad i}amd sjpj hj vàmjmae nfh mfe~pd

nf spdmf}jnd nf nj~d}% ^jbsdmd f} efmf}jpad aeyfp~ap fe jmdenamadejp }jhj} nf

dpnfejndpf} nf bjefpj jnfmvjnj ,}a}~fbj} f}sfmajhf} nf f|~aemae nf

aemfenad}( pfivfpd} nf }fkvpanjn i}amj( }a}~fbj} nf mhabj~ajmae aenv}~pajh(

f~m%!%

]vbaea}~pd fefpk~amd? ]f jldppj mde}vbd fhm~pamd fe ae}~jhjmae nf }a}~fbj} nf

jhabfe~jmae aeae~fppvbsanj( mhabj~ajmae( f~m% Hj jndsmae nf vej bfe~jhanjn

kpffe A^:0sfpba~ap aempfbfe~jp hj pfsv~jmae j hj sjp zvf kfefpjp jldppd nf

md}~f} napfm~d}%

Mdbsf~a~ayanjn fe~pf spdyffndpf}? Hj kpje difp~j f|a}~fe~f fe fh bfpmjnd }f yf

pfihfojnj fe hj mdbsf~a~ayanjn nf hd} spfmad}%

]abshamanjn fe fh v}d q fe hj dsfpjmae

Fh bdnfhd mhdvn mdbsv~aeksfpba~f dsfpjp mdbshf~jbfe~f fe ve mdp~d sfpadnd nf ~afbsd(

mde vej efmf}anjn beabj nf pfmvp}d} q kf}~adejend nf bjefpj }femahhj hj}

efmf}anjnf} ~meamj}% Hj fe~anjn mde~pj~je~f dmvsj f|mhv}ayjbfe~f hj iakvpj nf v}vjpad

nfh }fpyamad% Fh pf}~d nf ~jpfj} j}dmajnj} j hj kf}~ae q bje~feabafe~d }de

pf}sde}jàhanjn nfh spdyffndp%

:: Idppf}~fp Pf}fjpml ,03::!? ^lf PDA di Mhdvn Jss}% Na}sdea`hf spfyad pfka}~pd ,fe aekh}! fe?l~~s?$${{{%idppf}~fp%mdb$p`$Pf}fjpml$pdaTdiTmhdvnTjss}$z$an$610;;$~$0

:0 Idp`f} ,03::!? Mhdvn mdbsv~aek lannfe Kpffe fefia~}% Na}sdea`hf ,fe aekh}! fe?l~~s?$${{{%idp`f}%mdb$}a~f}$odfbmgfenpamg$03::$:3$3=$mhdvnmdbsv~aek}lannfekpffe`fefia~}$
http://www.forrester.com/rb/Research/roi_of_cloud_apps/q/id/59277/t/2http://www.forrester.com/rb/Research/roi_of_cloud_apps/q/id/59277/t/2http://www.forbes.com/sites/joemckendrick/2011/10/03/cloud-computings-hidden-green-benefits/http://www.forbes.com/sites/joemckendrick/2011/10/03/cloud-computings-hidden-green-benefits/http://www.forrester.com/rb/Research/roi_of_cloud_apps/q/id/59277/t/2


36/175

Jmmf}aàhanjn? Sjpj jmmfnfp jh }fpyamad fe hj ev`f( }abshfbfe~f }f efmf}a~j ve

na}sd}a~ayd aeidpb~amd q mdef|ae j Ae~fpef~( sfpba~afend jh v}vjpad hj mdef|ae

nf}nf ve dpnfejndp fe }v mj}j d nf}nf }v ~fhided ae~fhakfe~f%

^jpfj} nf bje~feabafe~d q jnbaea}~pjmae? Hj kf}~ae nf v}vjpad}( j} mdbd hj

pfjhajmae nf mdsaj} nf }fkvpanjn( svfnfe }fp ~jpfj} ~d~jhbfe~f ~pje}sjpfe~f}

sjpj hj fe~anjn mhafe~f%

Jh~j na}sdeaàhanjn? ]f svfnfe mde~pj~jp hj} bfnanj} jnfmvjnj} nf na}sdeaàhanjn

fe pfhjmae j hj mpa~amanjn nfh }fpyamad jhdojnd fe hj ev`f( fya~end}f spnanj} nf

aeidpbjmae q$d nfh }fpyamad% Pfnvenjemaj} nf hj aeidpbjmae j jh~d eayfh }de

kjpje~ajnj} sdp fh spdyffndp%

Jmmf}d mdbe j pfmvp}d}? Fh jmmf}d j pfmvp}d} aeidpb~amd} j ~pjy} nf Ae~fpef~

sfpba~f hj mdemvppfemaj nf yjpad} v}vjpad} q hj sd}aàhanjn nf mdbsjp~ap

ndmvbfe~d}( hd zvf abshamj vej bfodpj nf spdnvm~ayanjn q nf}fbsfd%

Jm~vjhajmadef}? Hj kf}~ae nf hj yfp}ae nf jshamjmadef}( }a}~fbj} dsfpj~ayd} q

`j}f} nf nj~d}( svfnf pfjhajp}f mde ve absjm~d bvq pfnvmand fe hj dsfpj~ayj nf

hd} v}vjpad} q }ae zvf }fj efmf}jpad nf}~aejp pfmvp}d} jnamadejhf} sjpj f}~f ~asd

nf jm~ayanjnf}%

Ijmahanjn sjpj spf}maenap nfh }fpyamad? Fe mj}d nf zvf fh }fpyamad mde~pj~jnd qj ed}fj efmf}jpad( hj aeyfp}ae pfjhajnj lj`pj }and }dhd pf}sfm~d j hj mde~pj~jmae

nf ve }fpyamad nvpje~f ve sfpadnd nf ~afbsd iaea~d%



37/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej =; nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

> MDE^F\^D EJMADEJH F AE^FPEJMADEJH NFH

MHDVN MDBSVÂEK

Fh mhdvn mdbsv~aekejmf mdbd vej evfyj jh~fpej~ayj d bdnfhd nf }fpyamad ~fmedhkamd

`j}jnd fe hj ds~abajmae nf md}~f}( fiamafemaj q ihf|aàhanjn sjpj fh jmmf}d j hd} pfmvp}d}

~fmedhkamd} sdp sjp~f nf hj} dpkjeajmadef}( mavnjnjed} q fe~anjnf} s`hamj}%

Hj abshje~jmae nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek}vpkf fe ve mde~f|~d nf ivfp~f pfmf}ae fmdebamj

ae~fpejmadejh( bjpmjnd sdp hj efmf}anjn nf jldppjp md}~f} f absvh}jp hj mdbsf~a~ayanjn nf

hj} fbspf}j} q jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} j ~pjy} nf hj} ÂM%

Fh f}~vnad ^lf mhdvn nayanfen? Sjp~ Def% ^lf fmdedbam `fefia~} di mhdvn mdbsv~aek ~d

`v}aef}} jen ~lf {anfp FBFJ fmdedbq% Ipjemf( Kfpbjeq( A~jhq( ]sjae jen ~lf VG(

pfjhajnd fe 03:3 sdp fh Mfe~pf idp Fmdedbam} jen @v}aef}} Pf}fjpml ,MF@P!( aenamj

zvf fh mhdvn mdbsv~aek svfnf hhfkjp j kfefpjp ve absjm~d fmdebamd( j ~pjy} nf hj

}vbj nf hj} 6 spaemasjhf} fmdedbj} fvpdsfj}( nf ;9=%333 bahhdef} nf fvpd} fe fh

sfpadnd 03:303:6% F}~f absjm~d fmdebamd }fpj fh pf}vh~jnd mdeove~d nf vej }fpaf nf

ijm~dpf}? nf}jppdhhd q mpfjmae nf evfyd} efkdmad}( jldppd nf md}~f} dsfpjmadejhf}(

mpfjmae nf b} nf 0(= bahhdef} nf fbshfd} napfm~d} f aenapfm~d} fe namld sfpdnd q

fifm~d} bvh~ashamjndpf} }d`pf d~pd} }fm~dpf} nf hj fmdedbj%

Mde}mafe~f} nf f}~f sd~femajh `fefiamad fmdebamd( q nf d~pj} bvmlj} yfe~joj} zvfsvfnf jsdp~jp fh mhdvn( hj} ae}~a~vmadef} nf hj Veae Fvpdsfj lje pfmdedmand fe hj evfyj

Jkfenj Naka~jh Fvpdsfj:= hj efmf}anjn nf absvh}jp fh nf}jppdhhd nfh bfpmjnd nfh mhdvn

mdbsv~aek% Sjpj fhhd }f sd}~vhj hj napfm~pa nf nf}jppdhhjp vej F}~pj~fkaj Fvpdsfj nfh

Mhdvn zvf nf`f absvh}jp ve bfpmjnd mdbe nf }fpyamad} ~fmedhkamd} zvf sfpba~j j

Fvpdsj mdbsf~ap mde fh bfpmjnd ae~fpejmadejh nf hj} ÂM( fe fh zvf jm~vjhbfe~f

spfndbaej ve ivfp~f sd}amadejbafe~d nf hj} fbspf}j} edp~fjbfpamjej}%

Fe f}~f mjs~vhd nfh aeidpbf }f spf}fe~j( j sjp~ap nf ivfe~f} f|~fpej}( vej ya}ae kfefpjh

}d`pf fh kpjnd nf abshje~jmae j eayfh ejmadejh f ae~fpejmadejh nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aekq hd}spaemasjhf} ijm~dpf} nf mde~f|~d zvf mdenamadeje fh nf}shafkvf q fydhvmae nf f}~f

bfpmjnd fe F}sjj%

>%: MDE^F\^D AE^FPEJMADEJH NFH MHDVN MDBSVÂEK

Hd} aekpf}d} bvenajhf} nf hd} }fpyamad} mhdvnjhmjejpe hd} 66%633 bahhdef} nf nhjpf}

fe fh jd 03:> ,ANM:>!% Fh mhdvn mdbsv~aek}fp fh spaemasjh bd~dp nf nf}jppdhhd nfh }fm~dp

:= Fvpdsfje Naka~jh Jkfenj ,03::!? Mdba}}ade }ffg} yaf{} de ld{ `f}~ ~d f|shda~ mhdvn mdbsv~aek ae Fvpdsf% Na}sdea`hf,fe aekhf}! fe? l~~s?$$fvpdsj%fv$pjsan$spf}}Pfhfj}f}Jm~ade%nd4pfifpfemf2AS$::$6;6:> ANM ,03:3!? [dphn{anf jen Pfkadejh Sv`ham A^ Mhdvn ]fpyamf} 03:3"03:> Idpfmj}~%
http://europa.eu/rapid/pressReleasesAction.do?reference=IP/11/575http://europa.eu/rapid/pressReleasesAction.do?reference=IP/11/575http://europa.eu/rapid/pressReleasesAction.do?reference=IP/11/575


38/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej =< nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

ÂM q mdenamadejp fh f}mfejpad nf nf}jppdhhd nf d~pd} bvmld} }fm~dpf} fmdebamd}

nvpje~f hd} sp|abd} jd}%

Fe vej femvf}~j pfjhajnj sdp hj mde}vh~dpj Jyjejnf j eayfh ae~fpejmadejh:6( fh ;>& nfhj} dpkjeajmadef} f}~e v~ahajend jhkvej ~asdhdkj nf }fpyamad nf mhdvn% Hd} sj}f} mde

bjqdp ~j}j nf mpfmabafe~d fe hj abshje~jmae nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh sfpadnd 0331

03:: }de? A~jhaj ,=&!( Jv}~pjhaj ,=:&! q

FF%VV% ,:1&!( mde}anfpjend zvf fe f}~f h~abd sj} fh kpjnd nf bjnvpf q sfpdnd nf

abshje~jmae nf hj ~fmedhdkj mhdvnlj ~feand ve bjqdp pfmdppand% @j}end}f fe hj ba}bj

ivfe~f( F}sjj pfsdp~j vej ~j}j nf mpfmabafe~d nfh :6&%

Fe fh bfemadejnd f}~vnad nf Jyjejnf( }f bfemadeje ~pf} mvf}~adef} nf kpje ae~fp} zvf

lje }and mde~pj}~jnj} mde hj pfjhanjn f}sjdhj?

Hj jndsmae nf ev`f} spayjnj} }f sd}amadej mdbd hj bfodp jh~fpej~ayj sjpj hd}

dpkjea}bd} jejhajnd}% Ljq zvf mde}anfpjp zvf hj bvf}~pj }fhfmmadejnj sdp

Jyjejnf aemhvj spaemasjhbfe~f j kpjenf} mdbsjj} nf hd} }fm~dpf}

fmdebamd} b} pfhfyje~f} zvf qj hhfyje bvmld} jd} jsd}~jend sdp hd}

spdmf}d} nf ds~abajmae ~fmedhkamj j ~pjy} nf hj yap~vjhajmae( q zvf mvfe~je

mde mjsjmanjn iaejemafpj sjpj j}vbap }fpyamad} nf mhdvn spayjnd% ]a àfe hj}

jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} }f femvfe~pje fe ve f}~jnad nf nf}jppdhhd bfed}

jyjejnd( jh bfed} fe hd} eayfhf} f}~j~jh q jv~debamd }f mde}anfpj zvf sdnpje

}fkvap f}~j ba}bj ~fenfemaj q bj|abajp hd} `fefiamad} nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek

bfnaje~f abshje~jmadef} spayjnj}%

Hj sfpmfsmae nf ijh~j nf mdeiajej q }fkvpanjn }de hd} spaemasjhf} paf}kd} q

`jppfpj} sfpmaànj} sdp hd} dpkjea}bd} mde}vh~jnd} fe ~dnd} hd} f}~vnad} sjpj fh

nf}jppdhhd nf spdqfm~d} nf bakpjmae j mhdvn mdbsv~aek%

Hj} spaemasjhf} yfe~joj} sfpmaànj} fe fh mhdvn }de fh jldppd nf md}~f} q hj

ihf|aàhanjn fe hj jndsmae nf pfmvp}d} ~fmedhkamd}%

Fh nf}jppdhhd nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek mdbd mdemfs~d ~fmedhkamd aemhvqf d~pj} ~fenfemaj}

spfyaj} zvf }f lje mde}dhanjnd j eayfh ae~fpejmadejh( mdbd }de hd} }fpyamad} nf ld}~aek q

hj yap~vjhajmae nf aeipjf}~pvm~vpj} ~fmedhkamj}% Nqejbam Bjpgf~} lj sv`hamjnd fe fh jd

03:: ve f}~vnad napakand j :%9:9 MAD} nf sqbf} fe dmld sj}f} fvpdsfd} ,Jhfbjeaj(

F}sjj( Ipjemaj( A~jhaj( Sj}f} @jod}( Sdhdeaj( Pfaed Veand q Pv}aj!% J mde~aevjmae }f

ha}~je jhkvej} mdemhv}adef} nfh f}~vnad?

Fh ;=& lje yap~vjhajnd sjp~f nf }v aeipjf}~pvm~vpj ~meamj q }fpyamad} Â%

:6 Jyjejnf ,03::!? Pf}fjpml ) Ae}akl~}? Khd`jh ]vpyfq? Lj} Mhdvn Mdbsv~aek Bj~vpfn4 ^lapn Jeevjh Pfsdp~ x Ovef 03::%


39/175


Fh ;1& zvf lje jnds~jnd mhdvn mdbd bdnfhd nf }fpyamad lje jnds~jnd

}dhvmadef} nf yap~vjhajmae mdbd sj}d spfyad%

Fh 69& zvf lje bakpjnd }dhvmadef} j mhdvn lje }fhfmmadejnd }fpyamad} nfjhbjmfejbafe~d( fh ==& hd} pfmvp}d} nf mdbsv~jmae( q fh 0;& nf f}mpa~dpad%

Hj} jshamjmadef} b} bakpjnj} j mhdvn }de fh mdppfd fhfm~peamd ,9:&! q hd}

spdkpjbj} nf kf}~ae nf diamaej ,>6&!%

Sdp }v sjp~f( hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} nf ~dnd fh bvend }f femvfe~pje fe ve

mde~f|~d nf ivfp~f spf}ae iaejemafpj q nf pfmdeyfp}ae sjpj hj bfodpj nf hj fiamafemaj( hj

spdnvm~ayanjn q fh mde~pdh nfh md}~f% Fe f}~f f}mfejpad( hj abshje~jmae nfh mhdvn

mdbsv~aek}f f}~ jejhajend mdbd vej sd}a`hf hefj nf ds~abajmae zvf svfnf pfsdp~jpve absdp~je~f jldppd nf md}~f} ~fmedhkamd}%

Hj mde}vh~dpj Kjp~efp:9 aenamj hj na}~pa`vmae sdp }fm~dpf} nf hj} }dhvmadef} nf mhdvn

s`hamd( }fke nj~d} nf 03:3% Sjpj Kjp~efp( hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} }de hj} zvf(

ove~d jh }fm~dp iaejemafpd( b} f}~e jsd}~jend sdp hj jndsmae nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek

mdbd jh~fpej~ayj ~fmedhkamj% Fh bfpmjnd nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek }f femvfe~pj fe ve

sfpdnd nf mpfmabafe~d% Sfpd je efmf}a~j ve sfpadnd nf bjnvpjmae( }d`pf ~dnd fe

jhkved} }fm~dpf} q fmdedbj}%

Kjp~efp pfjhaj ve jeha}a} }d`pf hj fydhvmae q bjnvpf nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek( fe fh zvfae~fe~j sdefp ifmlj} q nayanap fe ij}f} f}~f spdmf}d nf bjnvpjmae?

Fe~pf 033; q 03:: }f lj j~pjyf}jnd vej ij}f nf nf}jppdhhd nfh bfpmjnd

pf}fpyjnj j sadefpd}% Hj sdmj bjnvpf nf hj} }dhvmadef} hhfyj`j j aeyfp}adef}

fe hj} zvf fh ~abf ~d bjpgf~ q hj spdnvm~ayanjn fpje b} absdp~je~f} zvf hj

yaj`ahanjn ~meamj j hjpkd shjd% Hj} yap~vnf} ~meamj} spabje }d`pf fh

j}fkvpjbafe~d nf hj aeyfp}ae%

Fe~pf 03:: q 03:= }f f}~ spdnvmafend hj ij}f nf mde}dhanjmae nfh bfpmjnd% Fh

bfpmjnd nf hj} aeipjf}~pvm~vpj} q shj~jidpbj} nf mhdvn mdbsv~aek }fp bvq

ydhvbaed}d( mde vej jbshaj kjbj nf }dhvmadef} nf spdyffndpf} kpjenf} q

sfzvfd}% Hj} aeipjf}~pvm~vpj} }fpe mjnj yf b} j~pjm~ayj}( jvbfe~jend hj

`j}f nf v}vjpad} b} pfjm~ayd} lj}~j hj ifmlj%

Nf}nf 03:= j 03:6 fh mhdvnkfefpjp ve spdmf}d nf mdemfe~pjmae nf hj difp~j q

nfh }fm~dp% Hj `j}f mde}dhanjnj nf mhafe~f} f|sjenap fh bfpmjnd q ljp yapjp }v}

f}ivfpd} ljmaj hj f}~j`ahanjn( pfnvmmae nf md}~f} q spd~fmmae nf hj aeyfp}ae%

:9 Kjp~efp ,03::!? Idpfmj}~? Sv`ham Mhdvn ]fpyamf}( [dphn{anf jen Pfkade}( Aenv}~pq ]fm~dp}( 03:3"03:6%


40/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej >3 nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

Hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} f}~e hanfpjend f}~j ~pje}idpbjmae fe fh mde~f|~d

ae~fpejmadejh( jsdqjend hj f|sje}ae nfh }fm~dp q( }d`pf ~dnd( pfjhajend aeyfp}adef} q

spdqfm~d} spdsad} zvf kfefpfe ve fifm~d ~pjm~dp fe hj} ~fenfemaj} ~fmedhkamj} j ~pjy}

nfh absvh}d nf spdqfm~d} spdsad} nf jh~d absjm~d f}~pj~kamd `j}jnd} fe bdnfhd} mhdvn?

~fhf~pj`jod( ae~fpdsfpjàhanjn fe~pf jnbaea}~pjmadef}( fh kdàfped jàfp~d( hj jnbaea}~pjmae

fhfm~peamj( la}~dpaj mheamj( f~m%

Fh ed~j`hf nf}jppdhhd nfh bfpmjnd f}~jndveanfe}f f}~ sd}amadejend j }v} fbspf}j}

~fmedhkamj} j hj mj`fj nfh bfpmjnd nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aek( jbfejjend hj} sd}aàhanjnf}

nf mdbsf~a~ayanjn nfh }fm~dp fe Fvpdsj% Hj Veae Fvpdsfj( mde}mafe~f nf f}~j }a~vjmae q

nf~fpbaejnj j absvh}jp f}~f bfpmjnd( lj aemhvand napfm~pamf} q pfmdbfenjmadef}

f}sfmiamj} fe hj Jkfenj Naka~jh Fvpdsfj q fe fh Shje nf Jmmae nf Kdàfped Fhfm~peamd

03::03:6?

Hj f}~abvhjmae nfh }fm~dp sdp sjp~f nf hj} ae}~a~vmadef} s`hamj} q hj mpfjmae nf

ve bjpmd pfkvhjndp zvf nf}sfof hj} nvnj} }d`pf hj }fkvpanjn nfh bfpmjnd%

Fh nf}jppdhhd nf spdkpjbj} nf mdhj`dpjmae s`hamdspayjnj q nf f}~enjpf}

~fmedhkamd} fvpdsfd}%

Absvh}d nf hj F}~pj~fkaj Fvpdsfj nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aeknvpje~f fh jd 03:0( fe hj

zvf }f iaoje hj} sjv~j} mdbvef} nf nf}jppdhhd nf ve bfpmjnd fvpdsfd mdbe%

Mdbd jyjemf nf hj} aeamaj~ayj} sjefvpdsfj} nf mhdvn( fe fh aeidpbf sv`hamjnd sdp hj

Mdba}ae Fvpdsfj:;( ve sjefh nf f|sfp~d} pfjha ve spdivend najke}~amd nf sjp~anj

sjpj hj mde}~pvmmae nfh evfyd f}sjmad mhdvnfvpdsfd% Nd} sve~d} mhjyf pfihfojnd} fe fh

aeidpbf }de?

Fvpdsj nf`f jsd}~jp fe }v mdeove~d sdp fh nf}jppdhhd nfh bfpmjnd nfh mhdvn

mdbsv~aek( jsdqend}f sjpj fhhd }d`pf }v} spaemasjhf} idp~jhfj} mdbsf~a~ayj} fe

fh }fm~dp ~fmedhkamd? hj bjnvpf nf hj} fbspf}j} nfh }fm~dp nf hj} ~fmedhdkj} q

~fhfmdbveamjmadef} q hj mdlf}ae ae}~a~vmadejh sjpj hj mde}dhanjmae nff}~enjpf} ~fmedhkamd} mdbvef} q jàfp~d}%

Fh mhdvn mdbsv~aek nf`f }fp ved nf hd} spaemasjhf} fof} sjpj fh absvh}d nfh

nf}jppdhhd fmdebamd q }dmajh nf hj Veae Fvpdsfj% Fh mhdvnnf`f kfefpjp ve

fifm~d ~pjm~dp sjpj hj bfodpj nf hj} pfnf} nf ~fhfmdbveamjmadef}( fh jvbfe~d nf

mdbsf~a~ayanjn nf hj} fbspf}j} fvpdsfj}( hj mde}~pvmmae nf kdàfped} b}

jàfp~d} q fiamafe~f}( hj mde}dhanjmae nf hj} pfnf} nf aeedyjmae( aeyf}~akjmae q

nf}jppdhhd fe Fvpdsj( q hj bfodpj nfh àfef}~jp }dmajh q hj mjhanjn nf yanj j ~pjy}

nf hj fnvmjmae( hj }jeanjn q hj }dmafnjn nf hj aeidpbjmae%

:; F|sfp~ Kpdvs Pfsdp~ ,03:3!? ^lf iv~vpf di mhdvn mdbsv~aek% Dssdp~vea~af} idp Fvpdsfje mhdvn mdbsv~aek fqden 03:3%


41/175

F}~vnad }d`pf mhdvn mdbsv~aek fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd fe F}sjj Skaej >: nf :;6Ae}~a~v~d Ejmadejh nf ^fmedhdkj} nf hj Mdbveamjmae ,AE^FMD!

Sjpj hj Mdba}ae Fvpdsfj( hd} F}~jnd} bafb`pd nf hj Veae nf`fe yfemfp `jppfpj}

f}~pvm~vpjhf}? hj d`}dhf}mfemaj nf hj} aeipjf}~pvm~vpj} ~fmedhkamj} q nf mdbveamjmae( hj

ijh~j nf ae~fkpjmae nfh }fm~dp ^AM( hj sd}amae mdbsf~a~ayj jm~vjh nfh bfpmjnd

edp~fjbfpamjed q( }d`pf ~dnd( hj `jppfpj fe hj mdeiajej q }fkvpanjn fe fh bdnfhd%

>%0 MDE^F\^D EJMADEJH NFH MHDVN MDBSV^AEK

]fke ve f}~vnad pfjhajnd sdp ANM:


42/175

Hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef} s`hamj} f}sjdhj} f}~e }afend sadefpj} fe hj yjhdpjmae f

absvh}d nfh bdnfhd mhdvn% Hj mdqve~vpj nf jldppd q ds~abajmae nf md}~f} fe hj

zvf }f femvfe~pje jm~vjhbfe~f lj spdsamajnd zvf fh mhdvn}f sd}amadef mdbd ve

mdenvm~dp nf fiamafemaj} q jldppd}% Fh fifm~d spf}mpas~dp nf hj} jnbaea}~pjmadef}

~fenp ve fifm~d ~pjm~dp }d`pf fh }fm~dp( zvf jspdyfmljp }v absvh}d sjpj fh

nf}jppdhhd nf }dhvmadef} q }fpyamad} mhdvnfe bdnfhd} nf mdhj`dpjmae s`hamd

spayjnj%

Fh }fm~dp ^AM ejmadejh jsvf}~j nf idpbj nfmananj sdp fh nf}jppdhhd nfh mhdvn

mdbsv~aek% Hd} spaemasjhf} spdyffndpf} nfh }fm~dp }f femvfe~pje fe ve spdivend

spdmf}d nf ~pje}idpbjmae nf efkdmad( dpafe~jend }v mj~hdkd ,ld}~aek( hamfemaj}(

spdnvm~d}( }fpyamad}( f~m%! j bdnfhd} mhdvnzvf }f difp~je nf idpbj b} pfe~j`hf

jh bfpmjnd%

Jnfb} nfh }fm~dp ^AM( hj} dsfpjndpj} nf ~fhfmdbveamjmadef} v~ahaje }v

sd}amadejbafe~d mdbfpmajh( }v f|sfpafemaj nf }fpyamad q( }d`pf ~dnd( }v pfn nf

aeipjf}~pvm~vpj} nf ~fhfmdbveamjmadef} sjpj sd}amadejp}f fe f}~f }fm~dp%

Absdp~je~f} fbspf}j} f}~e j}vbafend aeyfp}adef} }akeaiamj~ayj} sjpj dsfpjp fe

fh bfpmjnd nfh mhdvn mdbsv~aekq( }fke f|sfp~d} mde}vh~jnd}( f} }fkvpd zvf fe

hd} sp|abd} jd} hj difp~j ~pjnamadejh nf }fpyamad} nf ~fhfidej( pfn d JN]H }f

jmdbsjf nf }fpyamad} nf aeipjf}~pvm~vpj d jshamjmadef} fe bdnd} Ajj] d ]jj](

~je~d sjpj fbspf}j} mdbd sjpj v}vjpad} sjp~amvhjpf}%

Fh mhdvn mdbsv~aekfe F}sjj ,q fe d~pj} fmdedbj}! ed }vsdef vej ~pje}amae

bvq jkpf}ayj ljmaj ve evfyd sjpjnakbj ~fmedhkamd% Nvpje~f hj h~abj nmjnj }f

lj mde}dhanjnd fe F}sjj fh mdemfs~d nf yap~vjhajmae nf }fpyamad} f

aeipjf}~pvm~vpj} q hd} bdnfhd} nf f|~fpejhajmae ~fmedhkamj j ~pjy} nfh ld}~aek

q fh dv~}dvpmaek( ~je~d fe fh }fm~dp s`hamd mdbd fe fh spayjnd( q ~je~d fe

fe~anjnf} kpjenf} mdbd s