Upload
isabel-pinto
View
7
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
This essay illustrates the advantages and disadvantages of using textbooks. It also shows some criteria to bear in mind for teachers who decide including textbooks to their classes.
Citation preview
7/18/2019 Essay Textbooks
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/essay-textbooks 1/9
UNIVERSITY OF CALDAS
SCHOOL OF ARTS AND HUMANITIES
FOREIGN LANGUAGES DEPARTMENT
MA IN ENGLISH LANGUAGE TEACHING
COURSE TITLE: Language Learning Resources
INSTRUCTOR: Yai!" #os$ Fan%i&o Parra
Au!"or: Isa'e( Cris!ina Pin!o Garc$s an% A(e)an%ra Pin!o Garc$s
Outline
Title: Ho* Signi+ican! Te)!'oo,s are in (earning a Secon% Language
1. Introduction:
O-ening:
Te)!'oo,s are -er"a-s one o+ !"e os! coon resources use% '. !eac"ers in %i++eren!
ins!i!u!ions /uni0ersi!.1 sc"oo(s1 ins!i!u!es or -ersona(i2e% e%uca!ion34
Con!e)!:
5T"e. -ro0i%e con!en! an% o--or!uni!ies +or (earning as *e(( as !"e. are a source +or !eac"ers !o
,ee- c(asses -(anne% an% organi2e%4
5Te)!'oo,s "a0e se0era( c"arac!eris!ics an% are concei0e% in %i++eren! *a.s4
5Te)!'oo,s "a0e -osi!i0e an% nega!i0e as-ec!s !o 'e consi%ere% +or -(anning c(asses using !"e4
7/18/2019 Essay Textbooks
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/essay-textbooks 3/9
5T"e secon% a%0an!age o+ !e)!'oo,s is !"a! !"e. are a -o*er+u( source o+ i%eas !o a--(. in !"e
c(assroo4
5T"e !"ir% a%0an!age o+ !e)!'oo,s is !"a! !"e. are enric"ing e(een!s +or !"e organi2a!ion o+ a
s.((a'us an% s!ruc!ure o+ a course4
'4 To-ic sen!ence:
Using !e)!'oo,s re-resen! a(so soe %isa%0an!ages in !ers o+ (anguage1 !eac"ing -er+orance
an% cos!4
Su--or!ing E0i%ence:
5Ric"ar%s1 #4 /9;934 T"e ro(e o+ !e)!'oo,s in a (anguage -rogra4 Re!rie0e% +ro
"!!-:BB***4-ro+essorac,ric"ar%s4coB*-5con!en!Bu-(oa%sBro(e5o+5!e)!'oo,s4-%+
5 Tsi-(a,i%es1 I4 /9;;34 Se(ec!ing an Eng(is" course'oo,: T"eor. an% -rac!ice4 Theory and
practice in language studies1 ;/31 --4 @54
Ana(.sis:
5T"e +irs! %isa%0an!age is !"e one re(a!e% !o !"e unrea(is!ic use o+ (anguage in !"e ac!i0i!ies +oun%
in an. !e)!'oo,s4
5T"e secon% %isa%0an!age is re(a!e% !o !"e a%0erse e++ec! !e)!'oo,s ig"! "a0e in !eac"ers<
-ro+essiona( %e0e(o-en!4
5T"e !"ir% %isa%0an!age is re(a!e% !o !"e aoun! o+ 'u%ge! a0ai(a'(e +or in0es!ing on !e)!'oo,s
!"a! +i! s!u%en!s< nee%s an% !eac"ers< re6uireen!s4
c4 To-ic sen!ence:
7/18/2019 Essay Textbooks
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/essay-textbooks 4/9
Using !e)!'oo,s re6uire +or !"e !eac"er !o es!a'(is" co"erence *i!" !"e s.((a'us1 (earners< nee%s
an% use o+ !"e (anguage4
Su--or!ing E0i%ence:
5Ric"ar%s1 #4 /9;934 T"e ro(e o+ !e)!'oo,s in a (anguage -rogra4 Re!rie0e% +ro
"!!-:BB***4-ro+essorac,ric"ar%s4coB*-5con!en!Bu-(oa%sBro(e5o+5!e)!'oo,s4-%+
5 Tsi-(a,i%es1 I4 /9;;34 Se(ec!ing an Eng(is" course'oo,: T"eor. an% -rac!ice4 T"eor. an%
-rac!ice in (anguage s!u%ies1 ;/31 --4 @54
Ana(.sis:
5T"e +irs! cri!erion !o 'ear in in% is !"e use o+ !e)!'oo,s !"a! s"o* (ogica( re(a!ions *i!" !"e
con!en! an% o'ec!i0es o+ !"e s.((a'us4
5T"e secon% cri!erion !o 'ear in in% is !"e +u(+i((en! o+ (earner<s nee%s *i!"in !"e con!en! an%
arrangeen! o+ !"e !e)!'oo,4
5T"e !"ir% cri!erion !o 'ear in in% is !"e in%ica!ion o+ (anguage use e++ec!i0e(. *i!"in !"e
ac!i0i!ies1 !e)!s an% o!"er con!en! o+ !"e !e)!'oo,4
3. Conclusion
As a conc(usion using !e)!'oo,s re6uire !eac"ers an% !"e ins!i!u!ions !o c(ear(. ana(.2e *"a! i!
rea((. i-(ies c"oosing !o *or, *i!" !"e4 esi%es1 +or %eci%ing on a !e)!'oo, i! is rea((. "e(-+u(
!o co-are !"e a%0an!ages an% %isa%0an!ages i! "as in re(a!ion !o s!u%en!s< nee%s an% !eac"ers<
e)-ec!a!ions4
7/18/2019 Essay Textbooks
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/essay-textbooks 5/9
UNIVERSITY OF CALDAS
SCHOOL OF ARTS AND HUMANITIES
FOREIGN LANGUAGES DEPARTMENT
MA IN ENGLISH LANGUAGE TEACHING
COURSE TITLE: Language Learning Resources
INSTRUCTOR: Yai!" #os$ Fan%i&o Parra
Au!"or: Isa'e( Cris!ina Pin!o Garc$s an% A(e)an%ra Pin!o Garc$s
Ho* Signi+ican! Te)!'oo,s are in (earning a Secon% Language
Te)!'oo,s are -er"a-s one o+ !"e os! coon resources use% '. !eac"ers in %i++eren!
ins!i!u!ions /uni0ersi!.1 sc"oo(s1 ins!i!u!es or -ersona(i2e% e%uca!ion34 T"e. -ro0i%e con!en! an%
o--or!uni!ies +or (earning as *e(( as !"e. are a source +or !eac"ers !o ,ee- c(asses -(anne% an%
organi2e%4 Accor%ing !o Ric"ar%s1 !e)!'oo,s “serve as the basis for much of the language input
learners receive and the language practice that occurs in the classroom” /9;91 -4;34Te)!'oo,s
"a0e se0era( c"arac!eris!ics an% are concei0e% in %i++eren! *a.s %e-en%ing on !"e !eac"er or !"e
(earner -ers-ec!i0e4 T"e. ig"! 'e 0ie*e% as 0er. i-or!an! e(een!s in !"e c(assroo or as !"e
ones *"o %o no! in+(uence (anguage e%uca!ion in a 0er. signi+ican! anner4 In !"is essa. *i(( 'e
e)-(aine% soe a%0an!ages1 %isa%0an!ages o+ using !e)!'oo,s in !eac"ing as *e(( as soe cri!eria
!o "a0e in in% +or an e++ec!i0e use o+ !"e4
7/18/2019 Essay Textbooks
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/essay-textbooks 6/9
Using !e)!'oo,s re-resen! a 0arie!. o+ a%0an!ages !"a! a((o* *or,ing on s!u%en!s< nee%s1
-ro0i%ing crea!i0e ac!i0i!ies in !"e c(assroo an% i-ro0ing course -re-ara!ion4 T"e +irs!
a%0an!age is !"a! !"e. are re(a!e% !o s!u%en!s< nee%s4 O<Nei(( es!a'(is"es !"a! “even if they are not
written specifically for them… they allow for improvisation to suit the requirements of a given
teaching situation” /O>Nei((1 ;?@934 Soe !e)!'oo,s can 'e rea((. "e(-+u( +or !eac"ing (earners
since os! o+ !"e are s-eci+ica((. %esigne% !"in,ing a'ou! *"a! !"e. nee% !o acco-(is" an%
*"a! !"e. nee% !o (earn *i!"in a course4 T"e secon% a%0an!age o+ !e)!'oo,s is !"a! !"e. are a
-o*er+u( source o+ i%eas !o a--(. in !"e c(assroo4 Te)!'oo,s -ro0i%e a 0arie!. o+ ac!i0i!ies !o
*or, in an% ou! o+ c(ass an% soe!ies !"e. are a(so -ro0i%e% *i!" a!eria(s +or i!s -ro-er use4
In !"is *a.1 !"e. coe *i!" *or,'oo,s1 CDs1 !eac"ers< gui%es or access !o *e' -ages !o *or, on
a s-eci+ic con!en!4 T"e. “usually have high standards of design and production and hence are
appealing to learners and teachers8 /Ric"ar%s1 9;91 -4934 T"e !"ir% a%0an!age o+ !e)!'oo,s is
!"a! !"e. are enric"ing e(een!s +or !"e organi2a!ion o+ a s.((a'us an% s!ruc!ure o+ a course4 As
Ric"ar%s s!a!es1 “without textbooks a program may have no central core and learners may not
receive a syllabus that has been systematically planned and developed” (2!2" p#!$# Te)!'oo,s
are %esigne% +o((o*ing a se! o+ as-ec!s enc(osing goa(s1 e0a(ua!ion1 a'i(i!ies1 !o-ics1 s,i((s1 socio5
cu(!ura( issues4 Su'se6uen!(.1 i! is -ossi'(e !o sa. !"a! !e)!'oo,s con!ri'u!e asser!i0e(. !o !"e
i%en!i+ica!ion o+ s!u%en!s< rea( goa(s an% !"e con!ri'u!ions a%e !o a !eac"ing -rogra in !ers o+
crea!i0i!.1 o!i0a!ion1 -ur-ose an% con!en!4
Using !e)!'oo,s re-resen! a(so soe %isa%0an!ages in !ers o+ (anguage1 !eac"ing
-er+orance an% cos!4 T"e +irs! %isa%0an!age is re(a!e% !o !"e unrea(is!ic use o+ (anguage in !"e
ac!i0i!ies +oun% in an. !e)!'oo,s4 T"e. -resen! a!eria(s an% ac!i0i!ies in *"ic" (anguage is
7/18/2019 Essay Textbooks
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/essay-textbooks 7/9
arrange% accor%ing !o s-eci+ic (anguage necessi!ies or s!u%en!s< (e0e(4 In an. cases !"e.
e)e-(i+. rea( si!ua!ions *i!" unrea( (anguage a,ing c(asses an% !e)!'oo,s (ac, au!"en!ici!.4 In
Tsi-(a,i%es !ers i! is o+!en +oun% !e)!'oo,s *i!" ar!i+icia( (anguage /9;;1 -4 ?34 T"e secon%
%isa%0an!age is re(a!e% !o !"e a%0erse e++ec!s !e)!'oo,s ig"! "a0e in !eac"ers< -ro+essiona(
%e0e(o-en!4 "en re(.ing os! o+ !"e !ie on !e)!'oo,s1 i! is -ro'a'(e !"a! !eac"ers *i((
'ecoe %e-en%en! on !"e an% *i(( re%uce crea!i0e -ro%uc!ion o+ ac!i0i!ies an% a!eria(s
/S,ierso1 ;??;1 -4 934 Teac"ers ig"! recei0e !"e ro(e o+ in!ere%iaries s"o*ing !"e s!u%en!s
*"a! !"e !e)!'oo, es!a'(is"es as goa(s !o acco-(is"4 T"e !"ir% %isa%0an!age is re(a!e% !o !"e
aoun! o+ 'u%ge! a0ai(a'(e +or in0es!ing on !e)!'oo,s !"a! +i! s!u%en!s< nee%s an% !eac"ers<
re6uireen!s4 Te)!'oo,s are an. !ies e)-ensi0e an% %i++icu(! !o a%us! !o s!u%en!s< or !eac"ers<
-ossi'i(i!ies a,ing !"e %e-en% os!(. on !"e resources a! "an%4 For !"ose reasons1 !e)!'oo,s
e)"i'i! i-e%ien!s on !"e %e0e(o-en! o+ e++ec!i0e an% genuine (anguage1 !eac"ers<
in%e-en%ence !o se(ec! a!eria(s +or !eac"ing an% (ac, o+ +inancia( su--or!4
Using !e)!'oo,s re6uire +or !"e !eac"er !o es!a'(is" co"erence *i!" !"e s.((a'us1 (earners<
nee%s an% use o+ !"e (anguage4 T"e +irs! cri!erion is !"e use o+ !e)!'oo,s !"a! s"o* (ogica(
re(a!ions *i!" !"e con!en! an% o'ec!i0es o+ !"e s.((a'us4 "en %eci%ing on using a !e)!'oo, i! is
no! on(. i-or!an! !o (oo, a! a%0an!ages or %isa%0an!ages 'u! !o %eci%e on one !"a! +i!s *"a! !"e
s.((a'us nee%s !o +u(+i((4 For e)a-(e1 i+ !"e !e)!'oo, is co-(e!e in !ers o+ goa(s1 (earners<
nee%s1 an% con!en! re6uire% +or !"e ins!i!u!ion or (anguage -rogra1 i! ig"! 'e sui!a'(e +or i!s
a--(ica!ion4 T"e secon% cri!erion !o 'ear in in% is !"e +u(+i((en! o+ (earner<s nee%s *i!"in !"e
con!en! an% arrangeen! o+ !"e !e)!'oo,4 As en!ione% 'e+ore1 (earners< nee%s are i-or!an! !o
%eci%e on a !e)!'oo, use4 T"e. nee% !o 'e +(e)i'(e in !ers o+ (earners< (earning s!.(es or
7/18/2019 Essay Textbooks
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/essay-textbooks 8/9
(ii!a!ions +or ge!!ing e++ec!i0e un%ers!an%ing /Ric"ar%s1 9;1 -434 T"e !"ir% cri!erion is !"e
in%ica!ion o+ (anguage use e++ec!i0e(. *i!"in !"e ac!i0i!ies1 !e)!s an% o!"er con!en! o+ !"e
!e)!'oo,4 In !"is case1 !e)!'oo,s ig"! s!reng!"en s!u%en!s< s,i((s +or using !"e secon% (anguage
e++ec!i0e(.4 esi%es1 !e)!'oo,s se(ec!ion nee% !o +o((o* s-eci+ic cri!eria !o consi%er in a (anguage
course since !"e. are os!(. use% !o +aci(i!a!e (earning1 (anguage use an% (earners< au!ono. +or
i-ro0ing !"e (anguage4
As a conc(usion using !e)!'oo,s re6uire !eac"ers an% !"e ins!i!u!ions !o c(ear(. ana(.2e
*"a! i! rea((. i-(ies c"oosing !o *or, *i!" !"e4 esi%es1 +or %eci%ing on a !e)!'oo, i! is rea((.
"e(-+u( !o co-are !"e a%0an!ages an% %isa%0an!ages i! "as in re(a!ion !o s!u%en!s< nee%s an%
!eac"ers< e)-ec!a!ions4 E0er. !e)!'oo, !"a! is c"osen +or !eac"ing "as %i++eren! c"arac!eris!ics
an% i! is !rue !"a! i! is i-or!an! !o 'ear in in% "o* recogni2e% !"e e%i!oria( is an% !"e %esigners
are4 Li,e*ise1 a! !"e en% *"a! *ou(% rea((. a!!er is i+ !"e !e)!'oo, +u(+i((s a(( goa(s an% nee%s
re6uire% +or !"e ins!i!u!ion an% i+ i! is 0arie%1 crea!i0e an% engaging enoug" !o "e(- s!u%en!s
(earn4
7/18/2019 Essay Textbooks
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/essay-textbooks 9/9
Re+erences
O>Nei((1 R4 /;?@934 %hy &se Textbooks'# )T *ournal 1 /931 ;5;;;4
Ric"ar%s1 #4 /9;934 The role of textbooks in a language program4 Re!rie0e% +ro
"!!-:BB***4-ro+essorac,ric"ar%s4coB*-5con!en!Bu-(oa%sBro(e5o+5!e)!'oo,s4-%+
S,ierso1 A4 /;??;34 Te)!'oo, se(ec!ion an% e0a(ua!ion1 in M4 Ce(ce5Murcia /E%43 Teaching
nglish as a second foreign language4 os!on: Hein(e an% Hein(e Pu'(is"ers4
Tsi-(a,i%es1 I4 /9;;34 Se(ec!ing an Eng(is" course'oo,: T"eor. an% -rac!ice4 Theory and
practice in language studies1 ;/31 --4 @54