Environmental Report Information for R. E. Ginna Nuclear ... · 11/5/2002 · From: Sarah Boyce Senior Research Associate, CGR 585-327-7065 ... 3. Wayne and Monroe County Land Use

Mt4-A.z ,, /

New and Significant Information

Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation (RG&E) prepared the Ginna Station Environmental Report - Operating License Renewal Stage (ER) in accordance with the regulations at 10 CFR 51.53(c). The NRC regulation specifically states that applicants need not provide additional analysis for Category 1 issues [10CFR51.53(c)(3)(i)]; however, the NRC regulation requires that license renewal applicants submit in the ER "...any new and significant information regarding the environmental impacts of license renewal of which the applicant is aware..." [10CFR51.53(c)(3)(iv)].

RG&E conducted an assessment for new and significant information as part of its preparation of the ER for the license renewal of Ginna Station. The process was directed by the License Renewal Project Environmental Review Lead and included the following actions: (1) interviews with RG&E subject experts on information related to the conclusions in the Generic Environmental Impact Statement for the License Renewal of Nuclear Power Plants (NUREG1437, GEIS) as they relate to Ginna Station, (2) review of RG&E's environmental management system and the plant's environmental management matrix for how current programs manage potential impacts and/or provide mechanisms for RG&E staff to become aware of new and significant information, (3) correspondence with state and federal regulatory agencies to determine if the agencies had concerns not addressed in the GEIS, (4) review of documents related to environmental issues at Ginna Station and regional environs.

As a result of this assessment and as stated in Chapter 5 of the ER, RG&E is aware of no new and significant information regarding the environmental impacts of Ginna Station license renewal and continued operation.

MEMORANDUM

GINNA LICENSE RENEWAL ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW

Date: November 5,2002

To: Yvonne Abernethy, CNS Katherine Allen Cort, PNNL

From: Sarah Boyce Senior Research Associate, CGR 585-327-7065

Clarification of Information

1. Additional Information on Water Departments [new information indicated in bold]

MCWA (Monroe County Water Authority) water supply (See Reference 2.12-1) Capacity: 145 million gallons/day Peak: 122 million mgd Average: 55-60 mgd

Town of Ontario Water Utilities Department (see Ref 2.12-4) Capacity = 3.5 million mgd Peak = 3.5 million mgd (they do sometimes reach their full capacity) Average = 1.9 million mgd

Town of Wiliamson Water Department (see Ref 2.12-5) Capacity = 4 mgd

Peak = 3.7 mgd -:"note change in peak usage figure, based on clarification. Average = 1.8 mgd

Town of Newark Wastewater Department (see Ref 1.12-6) Capacity = 3.5 mgd Peak = 2.14 mgd Average = 1.4 mgd

City of Rochester (Ref 2.12-2, and supplemental information from Enrique Maisch, Engineer, Rochester CityWater Bureau, 428-7569, 11/5/02).

Peak = 46.5 mgd Capacity = 48 million mgd

Average = 37 million mgd

2. Information on Port of Rochester The Port of Rochester was decommissioned as a commercial port in 1980. It is now used by two cruise ships in the summer, each of which docks four times per summer to discharge and pickup passengers. In addition, a cement freighter passes by the Port of

Rochester, but docks further south on the Genesee River at a cement plant on Boxart

Street.

If the Fast Ferry project moves forward, the Port of Rochester will be designated a Class

A Federal Port of Entry, which would allow commercial use. The very earliest this might

occur is Fall 2003.

Sourc- Sarah Bokw pow" camorntion uz Robett W1itmig, Dpay Camrnisioner ofParks and Rwcation, City ofRodxster, 585-428-6749, 11/5/02.

3. Wayne and Monroe County Land Use

We do not have the information readily available. Rachel Bell from the Monroe County

Planning Department said that they do produce a land use report on a yearly basis but it

doesn't appear to have land use by acreage anywhere. The link is below.

http://www.growmonroe.com/orgl64.asp?storyID= 1783

4. Confirmation of calculation of density calculation > The density calculation of 449 people per square mile within a 20 mile radius

includes the water portion of the radius.

> The density calculation of 165 people per square mile within a 50 mile radius includes the water portion of the radius.

Ken Kemmet To: George WrobeVRG&E@ RG&E

11/15/02 01:14 PMI cc: Debra Wegman Subject. Real Estate - NRC Re-Licensing

George,

During the interview with NRC (Jennifer Davis) and Argonne National Laboratory (Bruce Verhaaren), I was

requested to provide information regarding the following:

"* Map of Ginna property as referenced in interview.

"* The year the homes (1181, 1319 and 1601 Lake Road) were built. Information I am including is from

the County Clerks Office.

"* Record of Title papers noting the acquisition of Ginna property.

Yvonne Abernethy is aware of the request. I will let you decide what should be included and sent.

I am sending you the packet of info today (11/15/02).

If you need additional information or have any questions regarding the info I am sending you, please call

me at 771-4515.

Thanks Ken

Display Selected Records

Selected Records (Range 1 to 25)

VIEW TAX MAP

IJNK TO STREET / AERIAL MAP Print Senarate Per PaneaxAcct: 030.119-0000

Owner: ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC Acct:40 00 Acct#: I _____________________ 4.44000 Ac1#

[Owner 2: COMPANY CODE 139000 [CKDG: DG Rentable SF: 0

Use: 151 AG. Prop Addr #: 1181 APPLES/PEARS Bldg Sq Foot: 3850

Prop Street: LAKE RD East: 0302540 9Nrt: 1st Floor Footage:

1 1 9 12086 2nd Floor Footage:

[Mail Addr 1: 89 EAST AVE Phone: 716 546-2700 1764

______________________________________ [v c LATEST PHN~r.E _ _ _ _ _ _ NUMBER Number

Mail Addr 2: ROCHESTER NY Misc 1: r ____________________ ____________________ ____________________ Frepaces: 1

Area: TOWN OF Subdiv: BAR DECISION Story Height: 0 ONTARIO 1'95-96

SMisc2: BAR DECISION Number Res Units: [zip Code"14649- '95-96 0

Lot Size (acres): 121.27 Lot Size: 100000 Number 1 Bdrm.:

[House Type: OLD i [sTYL Heat: HOT AIR Number 2 Bdrm:

[Basement: FULL IlFuel: GAS [Number Bedrm: 6.0 Number 3 Bdrm:

[Basement SF: 0 []Water: PUBLIC INumber Baths: 2.5 Used Asl:

[Exterior: WOODsewer: PRIVATE Number Stories: 2.0 JUsed As2:

[Garage: 0 ]Util: ilNumber Bldgs: 0

Year Built: 1890 Assess Total: $ 771400 County Tax: $ 1 110.00

Improvmtl: BARN,1.0 Size: 19 X 36 City Tax: $ 0.00 [GEN S571400 C x

Improvmt2: Size: 14 X 20 Old Assessment: $ 0 School Dist:

[BARN,POLE Size: WAYNE

tSize: 3X0 School Tax: Improvmt3: 0 _________ 1 es $0.0 $11,318 $11,331.87

SHDmprovmt4: Size:2 X 22 Sale Date: N/A E~xempt: Y

http:/Aand.netacc.net/Scripts/foxweb.exe/land-net/altview-all?startat=l &login=rge99&k... 11/14/2002

Page 1 of 3



VIEW TAX MAP

LINK TO STREET I AERIAL MAP Print Senarate Per PageTax Acct: 030.119-0000- Acct#: 0346-00

Owner: ROXDEL CORP 455.342000 A

Owner 2: ___CKDG: ZL __Rentable SF: 0

Prop Addr #: 1319 Use: 151 AG. Bldg Sq Foot: 1784 PropAddr_#:_1319 APPLES/PEARS Bd S Prop Street: LAKE RD East: 0304550 North: 1193420 1 st Floor Footage:

Pro 1 1460

Mail Addr 1: 89 EAST AVE Phone: 2nd Floor Footage:

CI-IECK KATESTPI ONE _ __ ___.! ECK _ _ES____p__I_ ___

NUMBER I I Number

Mail Addr 2: ROCHESTER NY Misc1: Fireplaces: 0

Area: TOWN OF SbdHeight: ONTARIO ]VStory H

Zip Code :14649-000 ]Misc2: ]Number Res Units:

Deed Book-Deed Page: Number 1 Bdrm.: Lot Size (acres): 14.96 Lot Size: 00827-00227

[House Type: OLD Heat: HOT AIR Number 2 Bdrm: [STYLE I

Basement: FULL Fuel: OIL Number Bedrm: 4.0 JINumber 3 Bdrm: I IBasement SF: 0 Water: PUBLIC Number Baths: 1.0 IFUsed AsI:

lExterior: WOOD Sewer: NONE Number Stories: 2.0 J[Used As2:

IGarage: 2 Util: Number Bldgs: 0

IYear Built: 1866 jAssess Total: $ 140700 County Tax: $ 0.001

Improvmtl: BARN,2.0 Size: 28 X 44 Land Assessment: $ 42500 ;City Tax: $ 0.00 IGEN 1

[Impovm2: GR,10 ISchool Dist: Improvmt2:GAR,1.0 Size: 29 X 79 Old Assessment: $ 140700 W isAYNE IDET 1FI

Impromt3:School Tax:

mt3 Size: 3 X 0 Sales Price: $0.00 $2,066.88

Improvmt4: GAR,1.5 1 IDETov,4GR . Size: 22 X 28 Sale Date: N/A Exempt:

http://land.netacc.net/Scriptslfoxweb.exelland-netlview-all?startat=1&login=rge99&key... 11/14/2002

Page 1 of 2



VIEW TAX MAP

IINK TO 5TRPPET / AERIAl, MAP Print Senarate Per Paae

Ownr:ROCESERGAS& LECRI Iax Acct: 03 0.119-0000- Acct#: 2017-00 Owner: ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC 838.432000

[Owner 2: COMPANY CODE 139000 CKDG: CV Rentable SF: 0

Use: 150 AG. Bldg Sq Foot: 1506 iPropAddr#: 1601 ORCHARD

1 1st Floor Footage: :Prop Street: LAKE RD East: 0308380 North: 1194320 861

Mail Addr 1: 89 EAST AVE Phone: 716 546-2700 2n Floor Footage: 0

[ C. •EQK_ LATESTPH!!ONE ENUMBE•R:

FMail Addr 2: ROCHESTER NY Miscl: NubrFrelcs

Area: TOWN OF Subdiv: #13 GINNA Story Height: 0 ONTARIO

[Misc2: ELWANGER Number Res Units: Zip Code:14649- [REMOD'96 100K 0

ILot Size (acres): 76.57 Lot Size: Deed Book-Deed Page: - Number 1 Bdrm.:

House Type: OLD Heat: HOT AIR Number 2 Bdrm: STYLEIII

IBasement: FULL Fuel: GAS Number Bedrm: 3.0 [Number 3 Bdrm:

IBasement SF: 0 Water: PUBLIC INumber Baths: 1.5 = Used Asl:

lExterior: WOOD Sewer: NONE Number Stories: 1.7 [Used As2:

IGarage: 2 IlUtil: I[Number Bldgs: 0

[Year Built: 1921 Assess Total: $ 743500 [County Tax: $ 0.00

ImprovmtlE BARN,1.5 S62 Land Assessment: $ 495100 City Tax: $ 0.00 GEN F

Improvmt2: MILK Size: 13 X 22 Old Assessment: $ 743500 School Dist: HOUSE I WAYNE

mprovmt3: Size: 3 X 0 Sales Price: $0.00 Sc2hool Tax:

1mrvm3 11ae F [_$10,922.02 Improvmt4: GAR,1.0 1Size: 20 X 80 -ale Date: N/A Exempt: Y DET ][Sa

-------------------- 1

http://land.netacc.net/Scriptslfoxweb.exelland-net/view-all?startat=l &login=rge99&key...

Page I of 2

11/14/2002

DATE

7/14/58 7/16/58 7/14/58

7/16/58

7/16/58

7/12/58 7/26/60

5/27/60 S6/29/6o 7/11/60 8/10/6o 8/12/6o 8/l1'•59 8/19/59 11/10/59 11/12/5 9 12/3/59 12/8/59 12/10/59 12/29/59 12/24/59 1/7 60 1/106o

1/19/6o 1/14/60 1/19/6o

12/1/59 2/6/60o 2/18/6o

4/5/61 1/26/61 1/31/61 2/6/6o

2/14/61 LOCATION

DATE

7/16/58

7/16/58

7/!6/58

5/27/60

7/11/6o

8/lo/6o

8/19/59

11/12/5!

12/8/59

12/29/51

1/7/6o

1/19/6o

1/19/60

1/19/6o

2/18/60

4/5/61 415761

1/31/61

2/14/61

0 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATIONRECORD

RECORDED

L

2

5 6 7 8 RD

COUNTY

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

Wayne Wayne

Wayne

Wayne

OF TITLE PAPERS

NATURE

Deed, 'Ev Abstract EvE Deed Ra]

Rol Abstract Ral

Rol Abstract Ra]

Rol Deed -El~ Abstract El•

Deed Ph Abstract Deed Rol Abstract "

Deed Lil Abstract " Deed Rut Abstract Ruc Deed avi

Abstract lwvi Deed )sca Abstract Deed Fel Abstract Fel Deed Wall Abstract Deed Flo Abstract Deed Cha Abstract Deed Cha Abstract Deed Leo Abstract

Deed Pel Deed He Abstract

Deed LeR' Abstract "

Deed ohn Abstract "

COUNTY OF CITY

Wayne

J. Trapp of It

Roch IH Roch

is

geer

ilson

bert Lewis Trapp & Barbara II t It

lean G. Closser

it h Z. Connolly h Z. Connolly n J.Harris & Bertha M.Har nJ.Harris & BerthaM.Harri: .r R.Hillegeer & Ruth Hillt

111 11 m N

ton Dixon ton Dixon ace E.Wilson & Pauline F.$

rence H.McGlashan

•rles H. Pratt

.rles/Ethel/Howard L. Hurle 1 i N N It

E.Curtis & Margaret E.Cur It n Nf 15 Nl f

ter Cornelius & Wife rbert A. Michielson

go it oI

oy A. Dickinson & Evard Wea It to oI It 11

W. Caskey & Eleanor M. Ca it fg Io if it

0REMARKSFROM

*lyn S.'Field elyn S. Field

bt F.` Bailey and EnniB ,ert F."Bdiley and An

Roch. Gas & Elec. •orp to go it 71

ester Gas & Elec. Corp.

iester Gas & Elec. Corp

N1 I St It Nl It II I 11 I

It " it It go

It It II t o

It f it it Nf

to 11 to It 1 t N II it tN

II i Nt I

II 91 II tN

to it Nf II tI

II to II HI It

is It iI it of

Herbert. Rochester it

oner

key

TOWN OP

ont

. Michielson as & Elec. Corp. II is i

Roch. Gas It II

of I

& E: II

IS

ario

Iece. CorD.

See 65302 - emffr~ni

7b R. Oa=-P N-ED

SI`

KNOWN AS PRO?. o1 13

TO

R66dhester Gas &"?Ele*tric Corp Rochester Gas & Electric Corp

iley RHch.. Gas, & Electric Cor

ey ey Rochester Gas & Electric C• ey ey Rochester Gas & Electric U Rochester Gas&,, Electric Corp Rochester GAs & Electric Corp,

Rochester Gas & Elec. Corp. is to ofo

or

Lph B. Bailey & Elsie Bail ert F. Bailey & Anna Bail

Lph B. Bailey & Elsie Bail bert F. Bailey & Anna Bail

izabeth Wickes grain ilip & Frances Profeta

to of it

tis

VILLAGE OF

',. 4n AC_ . 15R.5\ A

irp.

,rp .

I

I

DATE

RECORD OF TITLE PAPERS ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATIONRECORDED

T 1 r

NATURE

6l:DATE

-WyCOUN~TY

2, & 46 - D-' m lar7& ,TUH¶, Rochecstpir Gas & F.1e. Pt' nrpn.

Ab2.Il/. RIP/51/L Wayn.__ ~I nd Contract Glen E. Gates RcetrGs&Ec CZ._ Doe, No. 614122 L1' V2ý6& Abstract "

-198236 / 25/64 Wayne-- Land Contract Luther Gates-Elizabeth Gates Dloc. No. 61l21 -20 .~L iAbstract is______is _____it__

.2 0 Wayne Easement George T. Packard 'I :1 I Clio - r

.2 3-7-i4-F; 7-.5 -66 Wayne... nppd Prxane-- M- Thr'i ckn t nn Is of t

12.s. 5~~66 _____Re P1 ea s -mnto-A.- S;;noi and Charlesp P2 Dhickinson and _________

126 7-14-66 __________Aareement rancsMDnlinRrptrC q&Pe~rr ~ 21-Z 1 lil-6"A A W- I W Ay m i Theerloedk- gne Roches~ter ('.a &. Flpntric C lorp -ti ~)

8- 9-8-66- Rim Im____ la co Unriann Rnrhpc~tpr Trilst ( R-~ nhprt 9-T Panngiait7. and

LS.... 0 21-fi6 A~hctr~r-t ________T4-_____________And

______ Al_ ma A- Pannpit7 Rochester Ga & Plecrtri-c Corp j~ i~~ _____ flA~ .MP.N ~ n ~W ter intake tunnel

~3 i-3 1/Q-63 W-rý3 Eci~ement Charles W. Kemp 41_____________ -RWEt.....

34 1 0-3-63 14~---63 Way~ne Eas~ement Charles A Morrison _________7____ ~g 15 4.12q.H.. -4-96-6- need Meluirn M wj1_g~ and - _______________________

_________ Harriptt#p A Wilr~nx his~ wifp 36 42-26-68 Ab___ ltrarct-- Melvin, M Mir=nc and _____________

_______ _________ ___________Hrariette A Wilr~ox hig w~ife _______________

17.. A-.-Al=6. d-=9-2=6.8--XAan n eed Frank Mdletta Mary MAlptt ______________

____________________his wife 11 egm

38 4-12-6E____ _____ Abstract rdnk Malettd Mdry Maletta- -2_______L ____to __

39 1186 1-20-6 ________ Deenqp~ph Rn1buiqtn &TnrMpnj1n

AO 6-26-68 iAii. ran R_&_E________.___

AL 6A-2 6-6 6{28-fr8- tayne n-eg e state Ba- of Ontario so Im 11 of________________________________

144 1-2-69 __of to______s-of_ i I

kRD LOCATION :ýC OUNTY OF CITY OF VILLAGE OF ITOWN OF KNOWN AS- PROP. OF1.

I Ii

13. GA

0 RECORD OF TITLE PAPERS ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATTAN

00. DATE RECORDED NATUR E FRMTO REMARKS

DATE COUNTY _____ _____

4.5_ 6-6- a 6-1Q= n-(- A n Dteed ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ______________ohn

____________n Amni ~rt wifp Rnh-h Crac & Elec. Cor_________

UZ1-7J2-.. 1-59fW fitBn in Theeri .thýr (Zatpc & Elizabeth Gates ()Rca ,zp..a n c

- ~ ~ Wan -i.25.fi orl ~ Toep Ho1,jtch -An,' ___ __ __ __Qdtherlne (', TLal~pvtch of__ _ __ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ __ _ _ _

15 .i..5f Ahstrar~t io~hT.LaT-Tovitch and _______________________

("ththerine G _ LT-aTrivite-h of_________________ of___________

~53 1-25 6 g&f-~. Ikicah LT.Tniwitvh and _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

W -1-229 - 6 6 1-30-.=6. -Wa;.unen DeeAo John 0. OPPp&Nanmi A Popp F' R-rrrnyt55.L 6- 9-6 6-56 WA~p nher P,!3 trt PR'mepn d Cu~r tIc and' _____________________

__________El I zahpt h tir t i ; hi _, wi f~ A__________

56 6-25-68 Abstract__________ ___________Curt____an

________El izabet h Curt Is hi q wife P'" . "11

7~ WJtayne...... -Supre-me Couirt Prorh- C,'a & Fp.1e Crpn 0 jarel Paq~il!svi (also nam a-c-l'51ipe _____nirtit-r rJi:jfiACJjot' ~ nfse ai-u a aec

MA___________________rvwn as T-Ta~d] pac'1fiiic

WL. -3 0-.,7 j _____ Aaynpa.ffadavit P-rdereic-T 14enryz Jr o 627-6 Wan Lis-Pdndens Roch. Gas and Mlen- Corp- 'S Jose ap h Paalitiso at a] ________

_________ ___________ Abstract I t S

.9 3-29271 4-S9-71 Wa~ 3z Deed -Sanf ord. IJ C~r I no 1Roch -Gas Pl-c a-oQrp.

.... .1-2.1.271 RpI.4l M a- nf a gqcj _qtitc Ratik nf (rt~imrin R an f~rd I C~ar11nn ________

,Evly P.l~i Sc- - Deed Roch. Gas &ERlec. Corn. Orn - 31-cfP

19. J2.p2k71 1p2_q_7l. waýme flepri i.wrence JT. Panipninto ,Robert

'0 io______ Wayne Easement -Robert R. Place Roch. Gas and Ebect. Corp. #t68167 r~ig - ef io2P•27 4 Wayne Easement Robert R. Place W6 -In af "

9/11/74- 1__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

4L#,___ ~ EfEMEUT I AIEL ftŽ(A TrO 55 5ATIOV3 FrG________A RD ILOCATION COUNTY OF CITY OF IVILLAGE 0P TOWN OF KNOWN AS PROP. OF

DATE R ECORDED MATURE FROM TO REMARKS DATE COUNTY

2- 811/54 Ab--trArt wm n 14mmhu IOS=h Gates TnC Ra k Title za- 1212917 -Ahqt-ync!t Rc)rq (:ý3tý- Thr, T a:4 7A r% m no; 71206 wmm rAntl My -ch:aldm -- l - -ý rl_ f;,a6,a6 f Dbdd - 'A , 4--7 A 2k- 12129175 Abstract alther- Gqhýg IMF 77 6/7176 AfEidavit Ta id= (ýFibgs; 117ý2 78 6/7/76 6/23aG kk&m Tý Dither Gatp-q TT=. 79 10/28al Ahgh7r-t T.- n=nirdnin, -,- nHi7q, r. R- 'n EGEE Tnr-lirlcx:: TaX SeaCh B[L 11 11c; MR Abstmcf: BdbE3t Taara= a= Trrl

ai- lion-itzi Tlmleaw B33lem Tbist (b ME 19.m.ni Wayne r--l- cf Tien a whl o Horas Trn ME

a3- 19RAM l2agal wEnm Taka33Xe.T- illmirdnbn, M=EXSM, )tdiý FGE U- 11 6M 17 ýl -3 56 U6m rimpA Tiltbar Qý C=3:i.a TaArm-,85- '445144 A.11A.14A wwm Wm= T)=FA Acla BMMbMt rhr-r4a 3turAW pj; R ' n ' ni TFryi rrTifT,-r+ --- alfn G3tes- FME R7 --I a 1 ff37 TIM:f3- F= Wallam Z Pallira Wlam pffl9mi M- 4a2M BAPFA:ýA wrrinim Mirllayi Tnr-+ RZE 2001 x- 2001 pmml 39- 5114U Absbmct W- & p- Wilsm FME Iqn Q , /ic; , ni Abstmc:t -ScbmibEr R25E u- 105ffis 1 t,-n jffl wmm W-T)- Wn Bo=:d rl F, Wi f-p- TY-1cp 4 ell 7 v 1125168 lal-ým Abstrar-L & Wf- RME

)3- 14598 Wým is z wl-fn Utý Q c D.

)5- TIT TAl,-f M -JdTi-&-Eleai= Qm!Ey FGE T 70 P,ý) ýT )6 Vgiii -Jdn-& Mm= Q351= M-n- Abst. 4 662-91

7 1/30/67 klq= Jd-n & Mad BW Mm- Abst- # 50656 98 12IM171 DpEd & Eýeý FG&E Paiinintp, Teqý & Gbitz L.644 P. 437 ;g 31,ýjjjq q) vq waym EamTfft FGZ BmbEtra Bomm -,-rares &-oe-wa emssSm bAq amed

93-7 P115 nmugs

)0 5-5- cIQ LP-L4-qg via\/nL Warranty DQ.Qd KU i E lb -0104') N rMan i 140ra..ý .ý L'B'l I P 94 3 A 4-QJ-cIlZ 1. -q-cla WaqnR_ DLIVI M -ru5t (1911 PlM -tA0rtQ r4 ý9n L4 -,?ýi -Q a 6-L4 - CIT \mcLQnp- RýýM Q, - Jrid banKu-5- lrost mny-ld t Jrpj0n-&p-0) Ly- ALI -cua IWQne Abstmc--ý Loomis Lam- )Rd i QrIf0k r i 14 J-Jq-n TL3-0-7ff! \sm Qo r. pe-d

-;,q-gq mpmognmQUIA -:IDwftl OF QNTAR-%0 gaart A _ss, 6 SSmr jm:r PCOW

vi % 7 -mE mcD PE7ER 5A QQ BA DUEL

13 A W LM'ý, I TW'$- r I

tD LOCATION ICOUNTY OF I CITY OF VILLAGE OF TOWN OF KNOWN AS PROP. OF 13

I F I I I

017-4,

I I I

RECORD OF TITLE PAPERS ROCHESS GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION

E RECORD OF TITLE PAPERS ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION 912-26

RECORDED DATE COR FROM TO REMARKS

DATE COUNTY________ _____

A;% Wa,~ 2£~.Z AZ,L " " A ?- •• •

I L11 12 1 iYE ,••I ,,.D- TIT P. R

- - I Qflw

A* ACT El L,(•*0EI jc L CLCP.

S19 lW 71.WjI.E AGREEl " 7 -1 A. ("D I' ICa S- "i -.. ] A-7•L 54-•TF• BETA I LTT)P•A RCEL

LOCATION COUNTY OF CITY OF VILLAGE OF TOWN OF KN'OWN AS PROP. OF

I I I I 7 oP./Jo . I13

THIS PAGE IS AN OVERSIZED DRAWING

OR FIGURE,

THAT CAN BE VIEWED AT THE RECORD TITLED:

DWG. NO. 33013-1504, MAP SHOWING ROCHESTER GAS

AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION PROPERTY NO. 13- GINNA SITE

TOWN OF ONTARIO, WAYNE COUNTY, NEW YORK

WITHIN THIS PACKAGE...OR, BY SEARCHING USING THE

DWG. NUMBER: 33013-1504

D-1

NOTE: Because of this page's large file size, it may be more convenient to copy the file to a local drive and use the Imaging (Wang) viewer, which can be accessed from the Programs/Accessories menu.

R 7A Subsfdiary of RGS Energy Group, Inc

ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION * 89 EASTAVENUE, ROCHESTER, N.Y 14649-0001 * 716 546-2700 wwwrge.com

October 4, 2002

NIA FEDERAL EXPRESS

Ms. Kimberly Merchant, Environmental Analyst NYS Department of Environmental Conservation Division of Environmental Permits, Region 8 6274 East Avon-Lima Road Avon, New York 14414-9519

Ms. Merchant:

Re: Joint Application for Section 401 Water Quality Certification in support of RG&E's Ginna Nuclear Power Plant Operating License Renewal

Attached please find the Subject Application, which consists of the following items. 1. A completed copy of the Joint Application for Permit. 2. Three copies of "Attachment to Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation's Joint Application

for Permit, Regarding Section 401 Water Quality Certification for Ginna Station License Renewal".

3. Three sets of two aerial photographs of Ginna Station and the associated Lake Ontario shoreline.

4. One hardcopy of the Ginna Station License Renewal Environmental Report, dated July 2002, submitted to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission as part of the Ginna License Renewal Application.

The above materials were mutually agreed upon to be incorporated into this submittal in a telephone conversation between you and I on October 2, 2002, in consideration of the fact that I

had previously submitted an electronic copy of the Environmental Report (ER) (Item 4, above) to

you on August 15, 2002. Further information concerning Ginna Station, such as maps and operations, are detailed within the ER. As specified on the Joint Application, there are no physical or operational modifications to the Ginna facility associated with the Ginna Operating License Renewal.

Should you require additional information, please contact me at 585.771.2706 or e-mail: [email protected].

Sincerely,

Paul M. Sawyko Ginna License Renewal Environmental Report Lead

enc.

cc: G. Wrobel D.J. Money

PMS&43 doc

-------- ------ --

.JOINT APPLICATION FOR PERMIT

-� � .�-. I.4.A l.� b..�. 4 Di.... ... �4 .11 h�.ir�r�,nm on ba& Aiiadn addbonal ii*rnr.bon as needed Please prat le�ly or type0p - L - Pe- a--

1. Check permits applied for:

NYS Dept. of Environmental Conservation

0 Stream Disturbance (Bed and Banks)

0 Navigable Waters (Excavation and Fill)

0 Docks, Moorings or Platforms (Construct or Place)

0 Darns and Impoundment Stnuctures (Construc. Reconstruct or Repair)

EJ Freshwater Wetlands

[) Tidal Wetlands

0 Coastal Erosion Control 0 Wid, Scenic and Recreational Rivers [] 401 Water Qualty Certification 0 Potable Water Supply 0 Long island Wells 0 Aquatic Vegetation Control ] Aquatic Insect Control 0 Fish Control

NYS Office of General Services (State Owned Lands Under Water)

0 Lease. Ucense, Easement or other Real Property Interest

0 Utility Easement (pipelines, conduits, cables. eto)

0 Docks, Moonngs or Platorms (Construct or Place)

Adirondack Park Agency

0 Freshwater Wetlands Permit

0 Wild, Scenic and Recreational Rivers

Lake George Park Commission

0 Docks (Construct or Place)

0 Moorings (Establish)

US Army Corps of Engineers

0 Section 404 (Waters of the United States)

0 Section 10 (Rivers and Harbors Act) 0 Nationwide Permit (s)

Identify Number(s)

For .WIY Uey.1 Only" DEC APPLICATION NUMBER

US ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

____________________________I_

Y" o

2. Name of Applicant (Use full name)

Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation8elephone Nu5mr 7a1ay270 585-771-2706

Mailing Address 89 East Avenue

Post Office IState I Zip Code Rochester NY 14649

3. Taxpayer ID (if applicant is not an Individual)

16-0612110 4. Applicant Is &fan: (check as many as apply) [] Owner Operator Q Lessee Q Municipality I Governmental Agency

5. If applicant Is not the owner, Identfy owner here- otherwise, you may provide AgantContact Person Information Owner or AgentfContact Person Q Owner [] Agent /Contact Person Telephone Number (daytime)

PaiiI M. Sawvko I 585-771-2706Mailing Address Sane as above

Post Office Istate I ip Code

6. Project I Facility Location (Owl-ocatlon on map, see Instruction 1a) County: kE..ityMliage Tax Map Section/ Block /Lot Number

Wayne Ontario Location (mcluding Street or Road) Telephone Number (daytime)

1503 Lake Road 585-771-2706 Post Office State ZiP Code 1 7. Name of Stream or -- rbody (on or near project site)

Ontario NY 14519 Lake Ontario 8. Name of USGS Quad Map: Location Coordinates:

Furnaceville NYrM-E NYTM-N 4

9. Project Description and Purpose: (Category of Actvty e g. new constiuctlonilnstallation, maintenance or replacement Type of Structure orActivity • g bulkhead, dredging. fifing, dam, dock. taking of water, Type of Materials and Quantities, Structure and Work Area Dimensions; Need or Purpose Served)

-..To_ provie _401 Water Quality.Certificationin support ofthe

Ginna License Renewal Application for the period 2009-2029.. - -------------------------------------------------

There are no phkysical or operational modifications to the ---------------------------------------------------------Ginna facility associated with this license renewal.

..........................................................

Additional information is attached. . ..s .....................

S........................................................................................

10. Proposed Use:

C10 0911. Will Project Occupy 12.Proposed Start 13. Estimated Completion

State Land? (C Date Date: Yes No

14. Has Work Begun on Project? (If yes, attach ( 0 15. List Previous PermItlApplIcation NumbersandDates: (ifAny) explanation of why work was started withoutpermit) y, No Section 401 Water Quality Certification, 4/26/74

16. Will this Project Require Additional F 0 If Yes, Federal, State, or Local Permits? Ye" N See AttacPsLent.

17. If applicant Is not the owner, both must sign the application I hereby affirm that Information provided on this form and aNl attachments submitted herewith Is true to the best of my knowledge and belief. False statements made herein

are punishable as a Class A misdemeanor pursuant to Section 210 45 of the Penal Law. Further, the applicant accepts full responsibility for al damage, direct or Indirect

of whatever nature, and by whomever suffered, ansing out of the project described herein and agrees to Indemnify and save harmless the State from suits, actons,

damages and costs of every name and description resulting from said project. In addition. Federal Law, 18 U S.C., Section 1001 provides for a fine of not more than

$10,000 or imprisonment for not more than 5 years. or bothW e ar applicant ty and wllingly conceals, or covers up a material fact or knowirnly makes

or uses a false, fickclous or fraudulent statement f / 6L h.4 t•t 0.. SNf4M i

Date 10/4L/02 Signature of Applicantz ".'fe t-Cinnatr~linr irni /'fh in I

6'

q

95-19-• I (UM VIP

New York State United States Army Corps of Engineers

I

PrWaft Public

Q # f rl'WaLV ýd.. - ý

r4

Attachment to Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation's Joint Application for Permit, Regarding Section 401 Water Quality Certification for Ginna Station

License Renewal

Joint Application Item 14 Work on this project has been restricted to the preparation and submittal of the Ginna

License Renewal Application.

Joint Application Item 16 1) Operating License Renewal for Nuclear Power Plants, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory

Commission. 2) Per the Coastal Zone Management Act, a Federal Consistency Assessment Form has

been submitted to NYSDOS. A draft copy of this Consistency Review is included within the License Renewal Application Environmental Report included with this Joint Application.

Additional Information

In partial fulfillment of an application by RG&E for a new Section 401 Water Quality Certification (WQC) in conjunction with Ginna Station License Renewal, the NYSDEC requested a brief status report regarding the 1974 401 WQC as it relates to the current Ginna SPDES Permit and water quality standards, as well as new items of relevance brought into the Ginna SPDES Permits since its initial issuance1. Previously, the NYSDEC had submitted comments regarding environmental issues to be included within the Environmental Report submitted as part of the Ginna Station License Renewal Application2. Therefore, in support of this 401 WQC Application RG&E hereby provides information which encompasses the three areas identified below.

1) A status report of the Section 401 WQC for the Ginna Nuclear Facility, dated April 26, 1974, with respect to its incorporation into the Ginna Station N/SPDES Permit(s).

2) Identification of new items of relevance incorporated into Ginna SPDES Permits since the original 401 WQC.

3) Identification of the environmental issues put forth by NYSDEC to date concerning the Ginna Station License Renewal Application Environmental Report.

1) 401 WQC Status Report

The 401 WQC status report required a comprehensive review of historical Ginna Station 401 WQC and N/SPDES files. This review identified a lengthy period of negotiation among NYSDEC, USEPA and RG&E following the issuance of the 401 WQC in 1974, which culminated with the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit being agreed upon by all parties in June 1978. NYSDEC's acceptance of this Permit substantiates that all water quality concerns contained within the 401 WQC were satisfied. Specifically, the following list identifies the effluent limitations, other limitations and monitoring requirements which were contained within the 401 WQC for Ginna Station, and specifies how each condition was incorporated within subsequent Ginna Station N/SPDES Permit(s).

Page 1 of 7PMS842 doe 10/04/2002


License Renewal

0 401 WOC Condition 1: The Ginna intake system was to be modified in order that, or information submitted which demonstrated that, its operation would not result in unacceptable damage to aquatic biota.

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit as Condition 10(b).

* 401 WQC Condition 2: Submittal of a report defining all water treatment, corrosion inhibitor, anti-fouling, slimicide, bio-cide and boiler cleaning chemicals or compounds. Also, wastewaters containing chemicals and oils shall be collected and treated prior to dilution with non-contact cooling water.

N/SPDES Condition: Compliance with the first part of this WQC Condition, concerning identification of water treatment chemicals, was achieved by a submittal to NYSDEC on August 2, 1974. The second portion of this WQC Condition, concerning treatment of individual wastestreams, was incorporated within the SPDES Permit effective May 1985.

* 401 WOC Condition 3: Submittal of a report on chlorine use and chlorination practice, and a maximum discharge effluent concentration of 0.5 mg/l residual chlorine.

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit as Conditions 9.b.(1)(d) and 1 1(c).

* 401 WQC Condition 4: Submittal of a report on fish impingement to that date.

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit as Condition 11 (c).

* 401 WQC Condition 5: Submittal of a report on entraiment to that date.


* 401 WQC Condition 6: Submittal of a detailed biological program designed to determine the effects of facility operation on aquatic organisms.

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit as Condition 11 (b), and includes the requirement for a Section 316(a) Demonstration Supplement.

* 401 WQC Condition 7: Submittal of monthly operating reports which include station electrical output, station water use, and intake and discharge temperatures.

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit as Condition 1 l(h)(2).

PMS842 doc Page 2 of 7 10/04/2002


License Renewal

0 401 WQC Condition 8: Submittal of a monthly tri-axial program and subsequent reporting of measurements.


* 401 WOC Condition 9: Submittal of any applications, reports and supporting data pursuant to Sections 316(a) and (b).

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit as Condition 11 (b).

* 401 WQC Condition 10: Any 401 WQC condition that requires construction in or on waters of the state or banks or bed thereof, requires approval under stream protection regulations.

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit as Condition 7.

* 401 WQC Condition 11: No residue attributable to sewage, industrial wastes or other wastes nor visible film nor globules of grease.

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1975 Ginna NPDES Permit as Condition 10(a)(2).

* 401 WQC Condition 12: No taste and odor-producing substances, toxic wastes and deleterious substances in amounts that would be injurious to, or adversely affect the flavor, color or odor of fishlife.


* 401 WQC Condition 13: No thermal discharge which will be injurious to fishlife, or prevents the best usage determined for the water's class.


* 401 WQC Condition 14: No suspended, colloidal or settleable solids from sewage industrial wastes or other wastes which will cause deposition or be deleterious for any best usage determined for the water's class.


* 401 WOC Condition 15: Copies of any environmental related reports submitted to any Agency shall also be submitted to DEC.

Page 3 of 7PMS842 doe 10/04/2002


License Renewal

N/SPDES Condition: This WQC Condition was incorporated into the 1985 Ginna SPDES Permit as Additional Requirement 5.

* 401 WQC Condition 16: This condition refers to severability of the WQC from other legal issues between DEC and RG&E.

N/SPDES Condition: Not applicable to inclusion in an N/SPDES Permit.

The above review verifies that the 1974 401 WQC was fully incorporated into the Ginna Station N/SPDES Permits, and that RG&E is in compliance with all conditions of that 401 WQC. This includes the incorporation of water quality standards in existence at the time of issuance. As part of the NYS SPDES Permitting Program, water quality standards revised since the initial permit would have been incorporated into SPDES Permit renewals, as necessary.

2) New Items of Relevance Since the Original 401 WQC for Ginna Station

" The 1975 NPDES Permit was renewed as an SPDES Permit in 1985, expiring in 1990. > This Permit reflected results of priority pollutant sampling required in the Permit

Application. > Monitoring and limiting requirements were required for all significant discharges (i.e.,

internal waste streams), increasing the number of discharge points from 2 (CHECK NO.) to 11, along with a corresponding increase in required monitoring, including Action Levels for a number of parameters.

> NYSDEC granted RG&E's request for a 316(a) thermal variance, with no further tri-axial

studies required. > NYSDEC tentatively determined to approve RG&E's request pursuant to 316(b),

concerning the intake system. Further biological monitoring with respect to impingement was required.

> In 1988 pH excursions within the 002-A discharge were addressed by RG&E through extensive modifications to the retention tank system.

> In August 1990, a permit modification was adopted regarding a zebra mussel control treatment program utilizing chlorine.

" The next Ginna SPDES Permit was effective 1992 to 1997. > NYSDEC continued the 316(a) thermal variance. > A High Conductivity Waste Tank discharge limit was included for iron which

subsequently required RG&E to install an extensive filtration system. > NYSDEC tentatively approved RG&E's request pursuant to 316(b), requiring continued

impingement monitoring and the following two new requirements. 1. Investigate means to reduce water use during both normal operations and outages.

RG&E complied with this requirement in July 1998. 2. Modify and resurface screen washwater / fish and debris sluice to improve fish

survival. RG&E complied with this requirement in July 1998.

Page 4 of 7PMS842 doc 10/04/2002


License Renewal

" The Ginna SPDES Permit was renewed for the period July 1997 to July 2002 under the NYSDEC Environmental Benefit Permit Strategy. > The Permit was modified for addition of Discharge Notification Act Requirements.

Compliance October 1997.

" Based upon RG&E's request for permit modifications, the Permit was modified and reissued in February 1998, effective to February 2003. > No changes were made to the 316 (a) or (b) approvals, or biological monitoring program. > Much of the increased monitoring incorporated in the 1985 permit was reduced or

eliminated due to results documented over the previous 12 years. > A stormwater pollution prevention plan was required by this permit. RG&E complied

with this requirement in July 1998.

3) NYSDEC License Renewal Environmental Issues

NYSDEC has previously provided RG&E with comments regarding environmental issues to be included within the Environmental Report submitted as part of the Ginna Station License Renewal Application2, and RG&E has subsequently responded to these comments3. Following is a summary of the NYSDEC comments and RG&E's responses.

* Entrainment

NYSDEC suggests that an entrainment study be conducted at Ginna, and has recently included a condition for such monitoring within a draft modification of the Ginna SPDES Permit. Overall, RG&E acknowledges the value of conducting an in-plant entrainment study to update and expand the existing database, and looks forward to developing a mutually acceptable program with NYSDEC.

* Impingement

NYSDEC recommends that the Ginna Station impingement reports be used to summarize the facility's potential impacts upon the Lake Ontario fisheries within the Environmental Report, and that gobies and yellow perch be included as target species within the impingement program. RG&E agrees, and has already complied, with both of these recommendations.

The NYSDEC also reviewed RG&E's modifications to the travelling water screens, which are currently underway, and concluded that they will meet Best Available Technology standards.

* Heat Shock

NYSDEC has approved RGE's request for alternative effluent limitations pursuant to Section 316(a) of the Clean Water Act and 6 NYCRR Part 704 for the 5 year life of the permit.

Page 5 of 7PMS842 doc 10/0412002


License Renewal

NYSDEC has also requested that RG&E evaluate the issue of exposing impinged fish to elevated temperatures as they return to the lake via the discharge canal. This evaluation was performed and included within RGE's Ginna License Renewal Environmental Report, Section 4.3.

9 Threatened and Endangered Species

NYSDEC determined that no threatened, endangered, rare, or protected species are known to exist in the project area. Also, since no new construction is proposed, NYSDEC does not recommend any field confirmation of the federal and state databases.

"* Electromagnetic fields (Acute Effects) - No comments

"* Public Services - No comments

"* Off-site Land use - No comments

"* Historical and archeological resources

Since no new construction is proposed, NYSDEC does not recommend any literature or field studies concerning historical or archeological resources.

* Severe Accidents

The NYSDEC provided lengthy comments concerning this topic, however, RG&E believes that such comments relate to the technical portion of the License Renewal Application, and appear to be a repetition of responses RG&E provided to earlier NYSDEC questions put forth during previous presentation meetings between NYSDEC and RG&E. RG&E further believes that these items are not within the scope of the 401 WQC, and will therefore be addressed in another aspect of the application

* Environmental Justice

NYSDEC will provide comments, if necessary, on this issue after the Department has adopted a final Environmental Justice Policy.

* 6 NYCRR Part 373 Hazardous Waste Facility Permit

NYSDEC and RG&E concur with the continuation of Interim Status for the Ginna Station 373 Permit and associated annual inspections, pending final determination by NYS concerning adoption of a USEPA exemption for facilities in compliance with 40 CFR Part 266.

* State Pollution Discharge Elimination System (SPDES) Permit Compliance

A SPDES inspection conducted by NYSDEC Region 8 on March 22, 2002 found Ginna Station to be in compliance with the facility's SPDES Permit. Further, NYSDEC is currently processing

Page 6 of 7 10/04/2002PMS842.doc


License Renewal

a SPDES Permit Modification concerning the Reverse Osmosis Water Treatment System and the use of ethanolamine in the secondary system.

* Shoreline Protection

NYSDEC requested that RG&E provide an evaluation of coastal erosion on-site and on neighboring properties. This evaluation was performed and included in the Ginna License Renewal Environmental Report, Section 2.2.

SNYSDEC and RG&E meeting on September 12, 2002.

2 "NYSDEC Comments on the RG&E Nuclear Power Plant License Renewal Environmental

Review Process". transmitted via letter dated May 1, 2002 from NYSDEC (K. Merchant) to RG&E (P. Sawyko). 3 Letter dated June 21, 2002 from RG&E (P. Sawyko) to NYSDEC (K. Merchant).

Page 7 of 7 10/04/2002PMS842 doe

13

ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION

GINNA STATION

CONTROLLED COPY NUMBER__

Procedure No. CH-ENV-LAND-USE

GINNA-STATION UNIT #1

COMPLETED

DATE:

TIME:

Revision No. 4

TECHNICAL REVIEW

Respon le Manager

9 ///

Effective Date

CATEGORY 1.0

REVIEWED BY:________

This procedure contains 6 pages

,.Xa 41

1.0 PURPOSE

To describe a method of determining the use of surrounding lands for crops, home sites and industrial sites.

To identify the nearest gardens and locations of milk animals used for commercial production within 5 miles.

1.1 Frequency

Annually between June 1 and October 1.

1.2 Applicability

The use of the land surrounding the plant is checked annually to determine if any changes have occurred. Changes in land use may require modifications in monitoring programs for evaluating doses to individuals from principal pathways of exposure given in the ODCM or updating of information contained in the UFSAR.

2.0 REFERENCES

2.1 Technical Specifications

Volume III, Offsite Dose Calculation Manual (ODCM)

2.2 Codes, Regulations and Standards

1OCFR50 App I Section IV.B.3, Numerical Guides for Design Objectives and Limiting Conditions for Operations to Meet the Criterion "As Low As is Reasonably Achievable" for Radioactive Material in Light-Water-Cooled Nuclear Reactor Effluents.

2.3 Referenced Procedures

2.4 Technical Information

2.5 Supplemental References

None

None

None

None

None

2.6 Action Items

2.7 Commitments

CH-ENV-LAND-USE Rev. 4Page 1

ý4

3.0 DEFINITIONS

Distance - For the purposed of the Land Use Census, as described in the ODCM, distances are measured from reactor centerline.

4.0 EQUIPMENT DESCRIPTION

None

5.0 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA

None

6.0 PRECAUTIONS

None

7.0 LIMITATIONS AND ACTIONS

The land use census is to be taken between June 1 and October 1 each year.

8.0 PREREQUISITES

Previous years Land Use Census mapand data.

9.0 INSTRUCTIONS

Note: Use of Global Positioning System (GPS) may assist in determining position and distance from the plant site.

9.1 Travel along each of the roads surrounding the Ginna Plant and determine if ihe use of the land has changed from that previously established.

9.2 Record changes on the attached maps and list on Table I.

Note: In lieu of a garden census, an onsite garden located in the meteorological sector having the highest historical D/Q or in a location with a higher D/Q than the maximally exposed individual may be used for broad leaf vegetation sampling.

9.3 Check for home gardens within 5 miles and estimate if their area exceeds 500 sq. ft.

Page 2CH-ENV-LAND-USE

Rev. 4

F- .

- - - -. -, ... �-', -, -�

- �y;-7-

9.4 Record on Attachment I the location of the nearest garden exceeding 500 sq. ft. in each sector.

9.5 Identify the location of the nearest residence within 5 miles in each sector and list on Table I.

9.6 Identify all locations of milk producing animals within five (5) miles of the plant for each sector and list on Table I.

Note: Only those houses associated with barns are likely to have milk animals. It may be necessary to inquire at each house if it is not readily discernable whether milk animals are kept.

Talking to the County Agent may determine locations of cows and goats used for milkproduction. Goats are of concern when their milk is used for children.

9.7 Update Attachment I and the attached maps as necessary.

9.8 Report any new location identified which yields a calculated dose or dose commitment greater than that of the maximally exposed individual currently used in the Annual Radioactive Effluent Release Report.

9.9 Include Attachment I with updated maps in the Annual Radiological Environmental Operating Report.

9.10 Evaluate industrial or land use change for affect on information contained within the UFSAR.

10.0 ATTACHMENTS

10.1 Attachment I, Land Use Census

10.2 Attachment II, Map of Area Within 5 Miles of Plant

Page 3

CH-ENV-LAND-USE Rev. 4

-� .-- ' WV

Attachment I

Land Use Census

Chanoes from previous year:

Milk animal locations:

UFSAR change request: Y N

Land Use Census Completed by: Date:

Reviewed by: Date:

CH-ENV-LAND-USE Page 4 Rev. 4

Sector Distance to Nearest Distance to Nearest Distance to Milk

Residence Garden Producing Animals

E

ESE _ _ _

SSE _______

SSW ..

SW

WSW

W

-a

'4

÷

- V -� -'r,4.fl* .�kN1V�tEC '��? �

E - .•- .5 'A - -_E

--- : Attachment II Map - Area West of Ginna

Page 1 of 2

c; " -: C" S

CH-ENV-LAND-USE Rev. 4Page 5 - -.

"Attachment II Map - Area East of Ginna

Page 2 of 2

La

- -A-

SE

.,..

CH-ENV-LANIPage 6

)-USE - l y Rev.4 -

f A Subsidiary of RGS Energy Group, Inc.

ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION - 89 EAST AVENUE, ROCHESTER, N.Y. 14649-0001 * 716 546-2700 www.rge.com

January 23, 2002

CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED

Bernadette Castro, Commissioner NYS Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation 20th Floor Agency Building #1 Empire State Plaza Albany, NY 12238

SUBJECT: Ginna Nuclear Power Plant License Renewal Project Town of Ontario, Wayne County OPRIHP Project Review No. 01PR5031

Dear Commissioner Castro,

Rochester Gas and Electric (RG&E) is preparing an application to renew the operating license for the Ginna Nuclear Power Plant for a period of twenty years, thereby extending operation into

the year 2029. We intend that the application be consistent with your Agency's interests and the

priorities of our community. The attached information includes an overview of the facility, the

license renewal process, and license renewal Environmental Report (ER) activities. Please be

advised that this license extension would result in no new operational or refurbishment activities

for the period of the proposed extended operations, and there would be no increase in generation

nor any change in any physical process associated with the generating plant. In summary, operations throughout the license renewal period would essentially be a continuation of current

operational practices and procedures.

The National Historic Preservation Act requires the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) to consult

with the State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO) to determine whether there are properties present

that require protection. These findings will be used by NRC in their preparation of an environmental

impact statement to support the license renewal process. It is our intent to contact your Office early in

the process in order to identify and address any concerns, so that the NRC consultation proceeds

smoothly and efficiently. Please be advised that RG&E has previously contacted SHPO regarding this

project, and has received a response dated October 31, 2001 (copy attached). Although RG&E has

already been in communication with SHPO, we believe it is appropriate to send your Office the

enclosed supporting materials concerning the Ginna Plant License Renewal Project for your

information.

Commissioner Castro Page 2 of 2

NYS Office of Parks, R-ecreation and Historic Preservation

January 23, 2002

Should you have questions or need further information regarding this Project after reviewing this

letter and the enclosed materials, please contact Dennis Money, of RG&E's Environmental

Affairs Group, or myself. Dennis can be reached at 585.771.2113 or e-mail:

[email protected], and myself at 585.771.2706 or e-mail: [email protected].

Sincerely,

Paul M. Sawyko Ginna License Renewal Environmental Report Lead

Enc.

cc: D.J. Money Ray Goll (NYS OPRHP Genesee Region)

Jack Clancy (NYS OPRHP Finger Lakes Region)

Ruth L. Pierpont (NYS SHPO)

BC: P. WILKENS R.MECREDY G. WROBEL R. WATTS D. MANDELARO R. BERGIN M. POWER G. ELMER K. HYLTON M.E. DANGLER J. HOVEY (CNS) Y. ABERNETHY FILE: LRERCOR 020123B

PMSw08 doe

New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation Historic Preservation Field Services Bureau

SNEWYORSTATER Peebles Island, PO Box 189, Waterford, New York 12188-0189 Bernadette Castro

Commissioner

518-237-8643

October 31, 2001

Dennis J. Mooney Principal Environmental Analyst Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation 89 East Avenue Rochester, New York 14649-0001

Dear Mr. Mooney:

Re: NRC Ginna Nuclear Power Plant/2640 Lake Rd/Extend License Ontario/Wayne County 01PR5031

Thank you for requesting the comments of the State Historic Preservation Office

(SHPO). We have reviewed the project in accordance with Section 106 of the National Historic

Preservation Act of 1966.

Based upon our review, it is the SHPO's opinion that your project will have No Effect

upon cultural resources in or eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places.

If further correspondence is required regarding this project, please be sure to refer to the

OPRHP Project Review (PR) number noted above.

Sincerely,

Ruth L. Pierpont Director

RLP: cmp

An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Agency 0 pnnted on recycled paper

Documents

Environmental Report Information for R. E. Ginna Nuclear ... · 11/5/2002 · From: Sarah Boyce Senior Research Associate, CGR 585-327-7065 ... 3. Wayne and Monroe County Land Use