Upload
jonathan-smoko
View
62
Download
8
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Business Management and Entrepreneurship
Citation preview
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 1
ENTREPRENEURSHIP MODULE (ENT 205)
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 2
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 3
Lecture 1
SMES are considered the economic units and catalyst for industrialisation and rural
transformation. It is the major contributor to employment in developing countries and have
potential for job creation and poverty alleviation. Many programmes have been put in place
to support SMEs (direct and indirect) but have not yielded the desired result. Prof. Prince
Izedonmi (2004) Alexander Scott= "somewhere, deep in the jungle where a few dare venture,
there lives a wild animal called success. It is rare and much sought after, but only a few ever
risk tracking it down to capture it. The hunt is long, hard and risky. Success is a clever
animal, rarely exposing itself; always quick to flee should it sense danger of being caught,
success is so uncommon, so unique and so challenging. Success is for us. Success means
winning and is the goal of life. Who does not want to be successful? Who wants to be
inferior, poor or wants to be pushed around?
Once on its trail, you cannot turn back. Have faith in yourself. Faith can move mountains. Do
not engage in wishful thinking because it will remain just that. You have to believe you can
succeed and you can get whatever you want- a good job, a good wife/husband you want, the
house you cherish, and the God you love. Live it and it becomes real."
Milton " the mind is its own place and in itself can make a heaven of hell or a hell of heaven"
Emerson: " great men are those whose see that thoughts rule the world." Shakespeare "there
is nothing either good or bad except that thinking makes it so .
Prophet David "as one thinketh in the heart, so is he."
All big businesses of today started small at some stage. Look at you heroes of today- Phillip
Chiyangwa, Strive Masiiwa, etc, they all started small and grew their businesses to what they
are today. As students to goal in life is to get the best job in company x or b but there other
career openings in life. One area that has been seriously under subscribed is entrepreneurship
rather than being an employee. Those who are rich today did not get there by being
employees but through going into business. Not only are small businesses necessary there
actually playing a pivotal role in economic development.
Joseph Nebesky put it well when he stated, "small businesses are the backbone of the
American economy, and they create two of every three jobs, produce 40% of the Gross
National Product and invent more than half the nation's technological innovations. In the last
ten years small businesses created 63.6 of all new American jobs."
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 4
Give the state of our economy and the scarcity of jobs, starting new businesses is interesting
challenging and rewarding. The government has also realised the noble objectives of
supporting small businesses and ministries and support schemes have been put in place to
support small business activities. This module becomes one of the many voices in support of
small business development and the nurturing of entrepreneurs.
However learning about small businesses is no guarantee that the small businesses will
succeed. In fact the majority of success businesses have experienced business failure at one
stage or the other. Strive Masiyiwa did not do very well with Retrofit but Econet is doing
very well. So fail should not act as a barrier to trying your hand at entrepreneurship but
should act as an incentive.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 5
Bernard Wysocki (Wall Street Journal) " Small businesses fail in prodigious numbers, but the
small business owner is clearly a winner... a folk hero, a source of jobs and growth, a role
model, a cultural icon."
If you think otherwise take solace from the wise words of David Starr Jordan " there is real
excellence in all this world which can be separated from right living". You there have to
believe yourself and everything will be okay. You can be an entrepreneur and no one can stop
you if you believe in yourself. Remember than rich people are in the majority of cases those
who start businesses. I am therefore urging to serious consider this option. In John Lafalce's
words "Entrepreneurs are economic visionaries whose efforts are consistently helping fuel
our nation's economic growth. They are the pied pipers of tomorrow's corporations, the
leaders who will pioneer new products and jobs, create exports. These creative men and
women need to know that they are crucial to the economic vitality of this economy."
To some up this line of thinking it will most appropriate to not Proverbs 13 v 14 " the
teachings of the wise are a fountain of life, they will help you escape when your life is in
danger."
Various people have written about the dynamic role of small to medium sized businesses
(SMEs) in the economies of developing countries. These enterprises have been seen as the
key to rapid industrial development and other developmental goals of these countries can be
realised. Zimbabwe is the same boat with other developing countries and is experiencing
severe economic crises arising from both internal and external factors. (Ask students to
discuss these and how they affect the economy.)
Unemployment is at its highest with estimates ranging from 60% to 80%. The small business
sector can be a source of employment and income. The numbers of people running small
businesses are not known but some figures being bandied by the Ministry of SMEs is 2
million people being engaged in this sector. Government has realised the role of small
businesses and is taking steps to provide for some of the needs of small businesses including
setting up of ministries and providing funds and other facilities.
What is a small business?
Andy Bangs Jnr" A small business is where you can bring your dogs to work." There are
many problems associated with coming up with a definition of small businesses. Small
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 6
business is a term used to describe a certain group of enterprises and how they are run. These
businesses have certain characteristics and management style, which differ from those of
large organisations.
Small business characteristics differ from industry to industry and the people who run them.
The sector includes manufacturing businesses, professional managers, and husband and wife
teams. It is therefore an easy task to come up with a single definition for small businesses.
People who run small businesses have often been described as being innovative, creative
and risk hungry. Yes small businesses have elements of innovation but are not limited to
innovative businesses only but will include all types of business activities pursed by small
businesspeople. Most businesses provide the small services or products that are already in
existence or are being provided by other businesspeople. Examples will include your vendors,
garages, hairdressers, carpenters to mention but a few.
Why define small businesses?
It is necessary to determine when a business can be classified as small. However as
previously alluded to, the way a business is measured is subject for debate. It is not possible
to provide a universal or national or international definition for small businesses. The need
for a definition includes the following:
There is need for quantitative definition when it is necessary to exclude larger businesses
from preferential treatment, which is designed to help small businesses. This preferential
treatment can be in the form of assistance through subsidies. It becomes necessary to lay
down rules as to which enterprises are eligible for such assistance.
It might be necessary to offer training/consultancy or any other form of assistance and there
is need to define businesses for which such for assistance is designed for.
There is also need to use qualitative measures, which are subjective judgements usually,
related to the management style and methods of operation. For example centralised decision-
making, labour intensive etc.
There are many methods, which can be used to measure the size of the business, but our
study will focus on a few quantitative measures often used and these are:
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 7
Employee numbers- is the most used measure in most industrialised countries and has
found application in developing countries. It is simple to use, which is its major attraction.
However this measure has serious problems. The first one is that the actual number of
employees is not known for most small businesses. In the majority of cases we depend on
family labour, which in the majority of cases is not paid. Usually this labour is not stated in
the employee numbers and figures provided tend to be understated for the benefit of the
business. In addition it necessary to use seasonal labour and for labour returns these are not
included in computing the number of employees at the organisation. There is therefore a
tendency to understate the number of employees in the organisation. Most small businesses
are created to generate employment opportunities. If measure is used most units generating
employee will be excluded yet it is these growing organisations which need the most
assistance as their resources will be stretched.
The value of capital- measure exclude enterprises employing more than a certain amount
of the scarce factor i.e. capital. The more capital employed the greater chances are of
disqualification.
However there are problems associated with using capital as an evaluation base. In the first
instance it is difficult to put value to the way capital is employed in a business. Some figures
may be unknown to a business owner and sometimes businesspeople deliberately conceal
certain figures or reduce their value.
Small businesses are notorious for failure to distinguish between personal and business
property. This makes the measurement of capital extremely difficult.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 8
The businesses use different bases to measure stocks or WIP. Capital equipment also possess
problems e.g. machinery might be very old or may be home made. Buildings might be used
as dwelling places as well as workshops. In most cases valuation tends to be arbitrary.
Other measures
Sales turnover is also used to define a small business. This refers to the scale of trading of a
business. This can be misleading if different businesses are used. What might be small in one
business might actually be big in another business. This is made more difficult by seasonal
variations.
Quantitative measures- various measures are used and vary from country to country.
Definitions can include the management style and the methods of operation. Small businesses
are those whose management is in the hands of one or two people who are responsible for the
major decisions.
However in Tanzania a business is considered small when it is within the reach of the people.
Definitions
According to the Ministry of Industry and International Trade (2000) To qualify as a small
and medium sized business, the employment criteria must be met as well as one of the other
two criteria:
Small scale enterprise
Sector No. Of People Asset base
Capital Base
Employed
Manufacturing < 75 < $6 million < $5 million
Other < 50
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 9
It must have a relative share of their market place.
It is managed by owners in a personalised way, and not through the medium of a formalised
management structure.
It is independent, in the sense that it is not a part of a large enterprise. This definition seeks
to formulate ways of defining small businesses. The statistical definitions sought to separate
small businesses on the following criteria:
Quantifying the size of the small firm and its contribution to GDP, employment, exports etc.
Comparing the extent to which the small firms sector's economic contribution has changed
over time.
Applying the statistical definition in a cross-country comparison of the small firm's
economic contribution.
Eventually it was discovered than it was difficult to establish criteria, which could be
applicable in all situations, and the Bolton Committee settled on the following: Sector
Definition
Manufacturing 200 employees or less.
Construction 25 employees or less.
Mining and quarrying 25 employees or less.
Retailing Turnover # 50 000 or less.
Miscellaneous Turnover #50 000 or less.
Services Turnover #50 000 or less.
Motor trade Turnover #100 000 or less.
Wholesale Turnover #100 000 or less.
Road transport 5 vehicles or less.
World Bank (Grindle et al) " A small business is one with fixed assets excluding land of
US$ 250 000 and less than or equal to 25 permanent employees."
USAID (1990's) A small business has less than 50 employees and at least half the output is
sold.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 10
UNIDO (Developing countries) Large - firms with 100 + employees Medium - firms with
20-29 workers. Small - firms with 5-19 employees.
According to D. Stokes- Small business management is different in several respects to the
management of larger organisations because of social structures and relationships, and
because of the resources available. There are no specialist managers to turn to for advice and
in a way the small businessperson does everything that needs doing in the business. All small
businesses share these experiences.
From our discussion so far there seems to be varied interest in the establishment of small
businesses to shore up unemployment and economic development. Theories have therefore
been put forward to explain the sudden growth in small businesses. There are basically three
frames of reference to consider when examining small businesses viz:
The free market model.
The Marxian model.
The Green or Ecological Model.
Small Business and the Free Economy Theory
The free market ideology dominated Government thinking about government thinking
especially in Britain when the Thatcher Government drove it. It is noted
for having pushed the agenda for small businesses to prominence. Most government that were
opening up their economies have borrowed a lot from this theory. " The theory envisages a
society constituted through the act of exchanging goods, services and individual capacities,"
(D Goss). There is widespread competition between buyers and between sellers in line with
the supply and demand - which helps determine prices at which commodities will be
exchanged. Goods in demand sell better, sellers will be able to cover their costs and make
profit. Sellers whose products do not sell will be forced to reduce prices or go out of business
due to lack of sales.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 11
Small businesses play a crucial role in the economy as follows:
Small businesses represent the bulk of the stock of competing supplies jostling to fulfil
customer demand. They help ensure productive efficiency and maximum utility.
Small businesses are avenues through which individuals with the ability, energy and
ambition can apply their skills in the market place to the benefit of themselves and society.
Samuel Smile in Anthony (1977) states that the free market provides an opportunity for even
the humblest member of society, if they are prepared to help themselves, to prosper and, by
so doing to serve the greater good. The above discussion forms the origins of the view that
that the human spirit responds best to insecurity, uncertainty and pressure of circumstances.
Such conditions foster entrepreneurial action and stimulate market activity as individuals
attempt, or are driven to overcome them (Coyne and Binks 1983). Government should not be
seen to inhibit the growth of small businesses by encouraging those with the ability to pursue
business careers.
Small businesses and the Marxian analysis
Marxists considered small businesses as an extension of the capitalist society. Marxists
theorists never gave small businesses a chance of survival as they were of the opinion that
they will eventually be wiped out by centralisation and concentration of capital. This would
result in the swallowing up of small businesses by monopolies. The result will be the
polarisation of society into bourgeoisie (very rich people) and the proletariat (impoverished
and exploited workers). This meant that small businesses would die a natural death. The
continued exploitation of the proletariat will forment class revolution. The theory failed to
explain the continued presence of small businesses and their increasing presence in social and
political discourse. Therefore the socialists sought a more convincing explanation for the
continued existence of small businesses. They contended that small businesses were a subtler
form of economic domination by large firms and was thus another form of exploitation of
labour. They believe that small businesses depend on large organisations which allow them to
thrive when it more profitable to operate in that manner. Large firms subcontract their less
profitable activities to smaller businesses in difficult times. These small businesses can
operate on a lower cost base because of their lack of unionisation, and poorer terms and
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 12
conditions of employment. Big businesses use small businesses as a secondary sector to
cushion themselves against market fluctuations. These small businesses survive because they
can exploit its unorganised, non unionise labour with lower pay, poorer working conditions
and safety records.
The Green Movement
This theory is premised in environmental consciousness. The environment is being depleted
at an alarming rate and there is need for redress if the environment is to be saved. Small
businesses are seen as the solution to moral and environmental crises within the advanced
industrialised societies. Basic assumption is that industrialisation has created a state of mind
indifferent and even hostile, to any other goal than short-term material gain. Materialism has
resulted in the indiscriminate exploitation of the environment using large-scale techniques to
violate the finite resources and the freedom, creativity and spontaneity of individuals and
society (Goss). Small businesses are the anti-thesis of such developments. It possesses an
essential quality that in it is
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 13
humane, non violent and benign, captured in the slogan " Small is beautiful" representing the
feeling that quality of life must come before profits and the materialistic motives of big
businesses. They advocate for a return to more order. They have put small businesses to the
forefront of their ideology. Small businesses are seen as more democratic and responsive to
society than large remote businesses following strategies of high growth, which take little
account of their effects either on the world environment or local communities.
Why small businesses?
They are several reasons proffered for the choice of small businesses as the way forward over
and above the three theories discussed above.
a. Large scale industry failures are behind the move towards small businesses because of the
following reasons:
They have not been an engine of growth and provider of employment. In fact there have
been cases of focussing on core businesses and downsizing in order to cope with a hostile
environment.
Large businesses are already beneficiaries of enormous support through general trade,
finance, tax policies and other direct subsidies. These have not achieved the desired goals and
as a result nothing more can be done to make big businesses grow. Most are already
downsizing.
b. Small businesses also offer reasons for pursuing that route and the reasons are as follows:
They mobilise funds which otherwise would have been idle.
Have been recognised as he seedbed for indigenous entrepreneurship.
Are labour intensive, employing more labour per unit of capital invested than large
enterprises.
Promote indigenous technological know how.
8
Use mainly local resources, thus have less foreign currency requirements.
Cater for the needs of the poor.
Adapt easily to the requirements of customer.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 14
c. Public opinion regarding small businesses has shifted. Small businesses had previously
been written off as outdated forms of economic activities. In 1980s it was hailed as the new
saviour of ailing western economies and with this focus people perceptions to small
businesses have changed. This is more so in the volatile economic situation prevailing in any
economic set up. People now find it easier to negotiate for prices, models and payment terms.
Big businesses only offer you what is available at their terms.
Why governments supported big businesses
There are several factors, which work for big businesses at the detriment of small businesses,
and these include the following:
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 15
Economies of scale help lower costs for manufacturers big enough to use mass production
techniques.
New products were transforming buying habits of society but the research and development
costs for new products are very high and affordable only to large companies with huge
profits.
Protectionists trade barriers fell away as market places became increasingly global to the
advantage of big businesses with international marketing and distribution resources.
On the basis of the above reasons policy markers concentrated their attention on the welfare
of big businesses that were considered to be the solution to economic problems and the way
forward for national success (economic). This led to a spate of mergers as small businesses
were seen as not having a role to play in national development.
Literature, which was produced, also focussed on how to manage and grow big businesses
and so were the teaching institutions of high learning. Small businesses were considered
amateurish, with backward technologies and limited financial resource. 1970s and 1980s a
shift with literature being produced on how to run small businesses. Politicians in various
countries enacted legislation to promote the interest of small businesses.
The first major in road into formulating policy for small businesses was made in the 1970s.
1971 saw the publication of the Bolton Report, which can political perception of small
businesses. It sought to establish the importance of small businesses and established eight
important roles of small businesses, namely:
A productive outlet for small enterprising and independent individuals (some of whom may
be frustrated under achievers in a larger, more controlled environment).
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 16
The most efficient form of business organisation in some industries or markets where the
optimum size of the production unit or sales outlet is small.
Specialist suppliers or sub-contractors to larger companies.
Contributors to the variety of products and services made available to the customer in
specialised markets, too small for larger companies to consider worthwhile.
Competition to monopolistic tendencies of larger companies.
Innovators of new products, services and processes.
The seedbed from which tomorrow's larger companies will grow, providing entry point for
entrepreneurial talent development that will become the industrial captains of the future.
The small firms can be extremely efficient, having the advantage of the commitment of
their owner-managers, plus the ability in certain circumstances to better exploit business
opportunities than their larger brothers.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 17
Lecture 2
The fact that small business are born each day it is no guarantee that all will be successful
business. Some are still born- they never see the light of day. Others die after one year will
the majority die before their 5th anniversary.
Very small businesses are most prone to fail than large ones due a number of reasons. Also
very young businesses are likely to fail than older ones. Businesses with less than 10
employees are likely to die than those with over than 100 employees.
When to set up
Small businesses are vulnerable in their early years. Best chance to set up a business is when
the business environment is most conducive. The following were said to be favourable in the
setting up on new businesses:
Unemployment- when there is lack of alternative employment people are pulled into
starting small businesses or into self employment. When unemployment is high often linked
with higher rates of unemployment.
Govt policy- govts are introducing measure to encourage the establishment of small
businesses. They offer incentives or amend regulations to suit the small business person best
time to start a business.
Profitability more people attracted to small businesses, when the income from self-
employment is higher.
interest rates- when real interest rates are high new owner managers find it more difficult
to obtain finance and are less willing to borrow.
Personal savings and assets- personal savings or borrowings guaranteed by most common
form of personal guarantee, are high, favour business start ups.
Consumer expenditure- during times of growing consumer expenditure, more
opportunities for new ventures appear in their sector.
Structural change in the economy favour the small business such as ESAP, 75% local
content, land reform.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 18
Factors may induce more new business start ups but do not "represent all positive forces in
the business environment which are likely to help the new owner manager. Some are
potentially negative factors which can push people into new ventures the wrong reasons:
Potential negative factors - unemployment and govt initiatives to reduce unemployment,
may encourage many people into employment. But no guarantee of a friendly business
environment. High unemployment can result in reduced demand or potential customer
expenditure with a new business.
Potential positive factors- when real interest rates are low and demand is growing, period
likely to be good to start new business, moreso if demand is not too dependent on a healthy
economy. Times of structural adjustment are also positive for starting businesses.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 19
Where to set up
There are areas where a new business can be set with high chances of success in a geographic
area
Population growth- high population growth or high levels of immigration into an area
Unemployment- high levels of local unemployment
Wealth- high income areas with more disposable income to spend esp. on services
Business size- large numbers of small firms already existing in an area may indicate low
barriers to entry into the predominant business a local small business culture may also
encourage more of the workforce into their own ventures by example and familiarity.
Housing - high levels of owner occupancy and houses prices in a region, give access to
capital.
Local government expenditure- higher levels of spending by local authorities create more
demand in the region (MSU)
Government policy- small business incentives and development schemes are target at
regions eg growth points, EPZ (Beitbridge)
Most of these factors are positive save for unemployment. Business likely to benefit from a
local environment more than a macro environment. Select a geographical area which exhibits
as many as possible of the positive factors listed above. Mny business ignore such advice and
locate businesses where they live and not where environmental factors are most favourable.
Which sector to choose
Starting small businesses in some sectors are more difficult than others. Starting a new
business entails confronting a series ofissues, or potential problems and these depend on the
industry one intends to enter. In every sector there are barriersto entry for small businesses.
These help determine the attractiveness of a specific sector to a prospective businessperson.
These can be presented diagrammatically as follows:
Capital requirements
Economies of scale
Product
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 20
differentiation
Switching costs
Access to distribution
channels
Other cost
advantages
Govt policy
Profitability in some industries is dependent on high levels of output. Helps reduce cost from
high levels of output in an industry. Small businesses will find it difficult to compete.
Increasing existence of economies of scale in mass markets Economies of scale
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 21
would lead to the decline of smaller businesses becoz large firms enjoying economies of scale
can use this cost advantage in a number of ways. Large companies can force competitors to
operate on low margins which can make it an unattractive market to new entrants. If prices
are kept high, additional profit enjoyed by large suppliers can be invested in marketing or
R&D for new products and again reduce the competitiveness of new entrants. Economies of
scale put barriers to entry by small businesses.
Existence of economies of scale does not mean that there are no opportunities for smaller
businesses. Look at the building industries - there are many big companies supplying window
frames and door frames. But in tandem there are many small businesses supplying these
products at a profit. Alternatively small businesses can provide components to big industries
i.e. they can specialise in something/areas where they can become more efficient than the
bigger companies and thus will be subcontracted by the bigger businesses.
Economies of scale also results in customisation of products i.e. there is little differentiation
of products/services. Standardisation of products leave niche markets open to people who
dislike uniform treatment e.g. personalised clothing by small tailoring businesses. Etc
Economies of scale achieved throu existing technology making them less flexible to change
to new technology. Big changes normally initiated by small firms rather than existing
businesses. Zimglass still locked in bottle packaging when market has moved to plastic
containers which are cheaper.
Product differentiation
Companies build customer loyalty over time (to prove reliability of products or services)
throu advertising, packaging or branding. (Nandoos, Geisha,Cascade etc) differentiation takes
time to prove reliability of products and services) and money (for advertising, packaging,
signage,and branding) this represents a barrier to entry for any new entrant. Direct
competition with the big guys can be detrimental and sometimes not feasible with established
brands- Royal Crown v coke, Hunters vs National Breweries. However there Once a
customer identify with a product it becomes difficult for another to enter that market
segment. Small companies not able to compete with large companies with branded products
and resources.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 22
However this should not deter small exploiting opportunities in a particular sector. Actually
small businesses can build loyalties, which are difficult to break except via its acquisition.
There are always opportunities if small businesspeople look hard enough. Branded products
are usually expensively priced small businesses might provide a cheaper substitute.
Small firms can build own loyalties, which differentiate them sufficiently to deter new
competition. People in Gweru are convinced that for that special meal one has to go to the
Dutch Oven. There is so much allegiance to the Dutch Oven by families/lovers etc. also there
are many small newspapers that do well against established tittles because they
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 23
cover local news. Others have branched into farming and sport magazine with significant
success.
Capital requirement
Cost involved can be a barrier to entry into certain markets. High start up investments block
small businesses from involvement esp. those in manufacturing. Use second hand equipment
and plant can circumvent the barrier. When buyer switches from one supplier to another,
there might be switching costs
Switching costs
Buyers who switch from one company's products to another may incur switching costs e.g.
retraining of staff to use new technology. The potential suppliers has to offer more than just
marginal benefits to persuade a buyer to change, e.g. giving free machinery to retain
customers thereby creating barriers to any competitors.
Access to distribution channels
Small businesses need established channels of distribution. This is not an easy task as new
products will complete with existing products e.g. when a small seeks shelf space from major
retailers for its products.
Other cost advantages
Learning curve- product improvements come with experience. You reduce wastage, as you
get more experienced. Most new business will expect higher production costs per unit than
established ones.
Location- is a crucial marketing factor. Existing firms often have good locations which will
be expensive for new entrants to equal. Such sites can command high rentals.
Government policy
Govt control certain industries thereby creating total or partial barriers to entry, e.g. licensing
to start a bank, radio station, telephone networks and newspapers. Licensing increases the
cost of start or running businesses. Most small businesses complain that most regulations
favour larger firms. Services industries have low entry barriers than manufacturing industries.
Others are:
Construction
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 24
Retail
Distribution
Hotel and catering
Transport and communication
Economies of scale
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 25
Lecture 3
The realization has dawned on most people that small businesses have play in economic
development and ending unemployment. According to Neck (1977) " for the greater part of
the poverty group, the small business is the only activity in which they can usefully hope to
be engaged, particularly in the immediate future. Studies have also shown than that the small
business sector has played a pivotal role in the development of Japan, Taiwan and Hong
Kong, and they continue to play in the development of these economies. According to Young
1987 and Gills et al "It is hoped that small enterprises would generate more employment,
permit greater decentralization, promote income equalization and mobilization.
Most small businesses face many problems most, which are different from those of big
corporations. It is admitted that government has focused to big businesses especially through
the establishment of the industrial policy, export promotion, protection from foreign
competition, foreign currency allocation. Government actions are seen as a vehicle to help or
at least stop hindering the development of successful small businesses. Government has
sought ways a leading role in the promotion and assistance towards small businesses.
However assistance from government to small businesses has in the majority of cases been ad
hoc. Most of these policies have emerged as by products of other policies such as those,
which promote industrial efficiency, training, technology etc.
There is no specific legislation for small businesses in Zimbabwe. When the country tried to
redistribute land it was hamstrung by lack of suitable legislation. However most of the policy
has been statements made by government officials through particularly the Ministry of Youth
Development, Gender and Employment Creation, the Ministry of Small and Medium Sized
Enterprises and the Ministry of Finance.
The enactment of the law allowed government to move forward and redistribute land. The
support for small businesses and the operating framework should also be legislated if we are
serious about making small businesses play a leading role. This calls for us to draw lessons
from other nations that are leaders in the development of small businesses.
UK
The UK was the leader in realizing the potential of small businesses and sought to create an
environment in which small businesses could thrive. To this end they tried to eliminate all
forms of discrimination against small businesses. Wherever efforts were made to support big
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 26
businesses, the end result was discrimination against small businesses. These had to be
reversed. The thinking then was that businesses will flourish unaided hence the following
policies:
Providing an environment in which small businesses could strive, free from interference of
any kind
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 27
Removing discriminatory impact of existing legislation In the 190s the British Government
adopted a more supportive role and sought to encourage the birth of small businesses and to
do so directly. Incentives and packages were put in place as an element of the policy. Various
assistance packages were put in place to finance the activities of small businesses directly
through the setting up of financial aid packages.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 28
USSR
In 1995 the number of people following the break up of the Soviet Union in the small
businesses sector was estimated at 10 million people. Small businesses became the answer in
the face of failing large businesses. They had vested with a lot potential, high paying,
efficient and profitable sector of the economy. However they continued to play a very small
role in the overall economy, in a country that was dominated by state companies. Reforms
were progressing slowly in the mainstream economy, there was need to boost the operations
of small businesses to create efficiencies in the face of collapsing state companies.
Government approved a Federal programme of state support for SMEs and then drafted laws
on SMEs, which targeted at simplifying taxation and accounting for small firms to encourage
the development of SMEs. It also provided tax exemptions for newly established for SMEs.
For the 1st 2 years with gradual increases in taxation from 3-5 years. Such assistance was
given to SMEs in priority areas (agricultural products, consumer products, medical supplies
and construction). Furthermore funding was provided for the establishment of SMEs to
develop competition, as well as a fund for the promotion of science and technology. System
of recording new SMEs was put in place so that registered SMEs will benefit from the
scheme. A track record can be kept of the number of SMEs formed and continuing in
operation.
Zimbabwe's policy has not been so pronounced in fact no legislation has been put in place to
support small businesses. Everything has been so ad hoc and short term in nature. Most of the
policy statements have been made at public gatherings making them difficult to implement or
pursue. This has left many a small businessperson confused and government officials not
knowing what is expected of them. Consequently people are shuttled from one ministry to
another. Presently the Ministry of SMEs is trying to push a policy document through and
hopefully policy could be in place before the end of the year. This document has been in
circulation for a long time since 2000 and it is frustrating to say the least that we have not
developed SMEs as should be the case given the pivotal role them play in an economy. The
assistance being given is mainly financial assistance, most of which does not have a clear
disbursement procedure in place. In cases such monies have remained idle or have benefited
the least deserving cases. (Refer new farmers and seed inputs, which find their way to the
street markets.) Can we be wrong if we look at the thinking of some Government Minister
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 29
who proclaimed that no economy has flourished on the back of SMEs (Simba Makoni)? In
addition funding provided does not go towards boosting specific sectors, which should drive
the economy. We have seen that targeted funding in cotton production has resulted in small
producers providing close to 80% of total cotton production. If it has worked in cotton
production why don't we draw lessons to the benefit of other sectors particularly SMEs.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 30
Zimbabwe's Policy Document
Goal: the main goal of SMEs policy is to generate sustainable jobs, reduce poverty, stimulate
growth and generate foreign currency earnings thereby contributing to the well being of all
Zimbabweans. The main aim is to create an enabling environment so as to double the number
of small businesses by the year 2005.
Objective: The main objective of this policy is to clearly define how the government, private
sector and other stakeholders can encourage and create an enabling environment for SMEs to
grow, and to enhance the contribution of this sector to national development. The Policy
will:
Coordinate the different policies and programmes at national level.
Set priorities and the appropriate allocation of limited public resources.
Rationalise support programmes
Coordinate resource mobilisation strategies.
Delegate tasks, responsibilities and accountability. Strategies
1. Create an enabling legal an enabling legal and regulatory environment to include:
Simplify complex regs
Improve access to info
Centralising and streamlining procedures in particular business formation, tax requirements
Simplified licensing procedures and reporting requirements.
2. Investment promotion
Tax relief
Rebates and discounts
Export promotion
3. Access to finance
Credit finance
Establishment of secondary market
4. Market penetration
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 31
Market intelligence
International marketing
Marketing and distribution networks
Quality assurance
5. Technology &infrastructure support and skills development
Technology information
Business incubators
National productivity centre
Electronic communication
6. Entrepreneurial management and skills development
Training
Mentorship by private sector
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 32
Provide guidelines to help SMEs comply regulations in setting up businesses.
Policy Framework
In coming up with policy the thrust should aim at addressing the following crucial issues:
How can govt help SMEs by ceasing to hinder them as well as trying to help them?
How do urban planning regulations make life difficult for SMEs and are the benefits
outweighed by the costs?
Do employees of small businesses benefit from minimum wage regulations and attempts to
improve working conditions?
What effects do business licences have on licensees, those who cannot obtain them and the
general public?
What impact of regulations affecting small enterprises have on their relationship with the
police?
Are financial incentives, which necessarily involve complicated claims procedures, an
effective way of helping small businesses or do they actually injure them?
What effect do highly concentrated assistance programmes which reach only a small
minority of small businesses, have on the remainder who do not benefit from them?
The following have been known to hinder the proliferation of small businesses:
An incomplete legislative basis for SMEs activity
The ill considered, unthought nature of the present system of taxing business people
The difficulty and high costs of registering businesses for registering business services.
The abundance of supervisory bodies and the parallelism and reduplication of their
functions
The actions of local executive bodies, at times hindering the development of businesses.
According to Harper: the obvious fact that the skills and initiative of the individual
entrepreneur are by far the most important determinants of success or failure. Some
businesses will succeed however difficult the circumstances in which they have to operate,
while others will fail in spite of a whole array have heavily subsided and well integrated
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 33
programmes of assistance. He concludes that an effective entrepreneur observes his
environment and organises his resources to take advantage of it. No amount of specific small
business compensation can compensate for lack of effective economic management. The key
role of the government it has been argued is to create a level playing field for business to
thrive. If the economy is well, a lot of opportunities arise for the establishment of businesses
and their growth.
Regional incentives or other incentives, industrial estates and similar devices can make a
contribution but these are effective in directing the location and nature of large businesses.
Most small businesses will start and develop ventures outside the framework of government
incentives. Govt to create an appropriate economic environment, successful small businesses
will make their contributions. This is so because of government restrictions. Small businesses
are required to observe a number of regulations, which increase their costs. There is therefore
an
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 34
incentive to operate illegally and most businesses use that channel especially to avoid
taxation, which is believed to be very high. Taxation also provides for small businesses to
remain small as growing a business attracts attention and you will be penalised through
taxation for doing well. It is cheaper and more profitable to operate illegally. Any expenditure
increases the costs of going business and might render profitable business unprofitable and in
case the business being wound up.
With regard to incentives Harper observed the following:
Government sponsored assistance programmes are often ineffective and can even damage
the interests of the businesses they intend to serve. Young also confirms this position by
stating that economic policy biases often constrain small scale and informal sector enterprises
and may offset the positive effects of direct credit or technical support to them. Governments
often come up with a cocktail of policies including monetary, fiscal, labour, trade, price and
regulatory policies. These have both positive and negative effects. They often contradict each
other in the absence of coordination. Biases usually favour big businesses and undercut
efficient growth. Te benefits to small businesses are often limited since the businesses have to
meet set criteria to qualify for assistance. Attempts to channel resources to companies
meeting set criteria is often undermined by political influence and inefficient squandering of
resources. Homeboys often benefit leaving the more deserving cases. In fact government
intervention can be counterproductive than making a positive contribution to the development
of SMEs.
Based on the needs of small business policy positions can be formulated to address the
concerns of small businesses. Small entrepreneurs have identified credit as their primary
need. There is need for financial tactics for SMEs. Lending can be character based. There is
also need to streamline administrative Based on the needs of small business policy positions
can be formulated to address the concerns of small businesses. Small entrepreneurs have
identified credit as their primary need. There is need for financial tactics for SMEs. Lending
can be character based. There is also need to streamline administrative processing of loans
requests. Credit to be extended through banks.
There is need to review legislation that constraints small businesses. Once reviewed such
regulation should be implemented if it were to benefit the intended group.
Educational systems to help in the development of entrepreneurial skills.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 35
There need to look at tax laws to make them an incentive for going into business.
Government, business officials and other stakeholders to collaborate.
There is need for communication such as roads and telephones. Small business should
benefit from infrastructure development.
The effectiveness of the above will hinge on the appointment of an agency to carry out
services for small businesses. Use must be made of existing skills in government and non-
governmental organisations.
There are many players hence the nee for coordination.
Actual policies to be adopted will depend on local circumstances.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 36
Role of government
The government should stop hindering the development of successful small businesses.
Government to confirm that skills and initiative of the individual entrepreneur are the most
important determinants of success or failure of a business. It should be noted that businesses
would succeed despite difficult circumstances in which they operate while others will fail in
spite of an array of heavily subsidised and well-integrated programmes of assistance. An
effective entrepreneur will observe the environment and take advantage of it rather than
objecting to obstacles that cannot be removed. Harper says for example if there is rapid
increases in inflation, recurrent shortages and an apparent system of import restriction and
controls, all within an unstable political environment, no amount of training or advice can or
bring him or her to save money for investment in the manufacturing industry with a view to
long term profits. He/she will opt for short-term gains through speculation and hoarding of
essential commodities.
Government must have an economic management programme in place if small businesses
are to flourish.
Government usually put in place and national investment incentives and industrial estates.
These are more effective at attracting big businesses. Small businesses normally start and
develop outside the framework of government incentives. If the economy is okay successful
small businesses will make a contribution to economic development. Successful small
businesses will make a contribution to the economic development.
They should introduce well-planned and efficiently integrated systems of assistance rather
directing them to a particular type of business or particular areas. The view here is that most
government sponsored assistance programmes are often ineffective and can militate against
the interest of small businesses they are intended to serve. Government often seen as an
agency for creating incomprehensible or irrelevant regulations whose enforcement promotes
corruption e.g. price controls. Government to examine how its role impinge on the
development of SMEs and make the development of SMEs and make the necessary changes
in order to remove unintentional discrimination which arise when regulations are conceived
for big businesses or transferred from industrialised nations are adopted for SMEs.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 37
There should be coordination between the various service providers that are offered. Many
players involved in giving assistance to small businesses might actually result in confusion on
the part of the small businesses. There should be greater cooperation among the various
players involved.
TYPES OF ASISTANCE PROGRAMMES- MALCOM HARPER
Credit programmes for SMEs
Cash often cite as an important consideration for which small businesses need assistance
from government or financial institutions. Remember small businesses are set up from
owners' savings and loans from friends and relatives. However additional capital is required
for machinery or equipment purchases and also for working capital. Most are unable to
access these funds due to lack of collateral or lack of accounting records needed to assess
small businesses. Important to have special schemes to provide credit to small businesses.
The scheme could include any of the following formats:
1. Set up an institution that specialises in small business financing e.g. SEDCO. Most
effective way but the volume of lending may not be sufficient to sustain the numbers of
branches to reach every small business enterprise. Institution should also accept deposits
from the public to boost the capital base.
2. Establishment of a small business division within a development bank but the institution
should be free from institutional rules, regulations that restrict its ability to function
effectively. It must be free of maximum amounts of loans regulations, collateral requirement,
amortisation schedules, etc.
3. Central bank can set up such a fund and give it to commercial banks for on lending to
small businesses. However success will depend on the willingness of commercial banks to
give loans to small businesses. Most see it as a burden with little returns.
Extension services and training
Individual consultancy normally carried out at the place of business aimed at providing
advice of all kinds to owners or operators of small businesses. Lack of experience and
education in their fields of endeavour results in ill designed and unprofitable ventures.
Extension services goal is to improve managerial, technical and vocational skills to small
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 38
businesspeople, and to help them analyse their problems themselves and develop methods of
solving them.
Training
Extension services might disclose management weaknesses i.e. common areas of deficiency.
Classroom training can help improve the technical and vocational skills of some
entrepreneurs' e.g. accounting, financial management to complement skills. Training to be
combined with incentives if it is going to work otherwise people will retain old attitudes.
Appropriate technology
Industrialised countries technology advanced than developing countries. However traditional
technology appears to be less efficient because of lower productivity. Government should
promote the use of appropriate technology over the long term to bridge the gap between
developing and developed countries. Alternatively adopt technology transfer strategies from
industrialised. However technology should be carefully selected and where necessary
modified to benefit the population. Supporting services
Infrastructure development necessary input for the generation of industrial activity on a
reasonable scale in underdeveloped areas this can be basic or supplementary services. Basic s
would be transport, power and communications (telephones and mail) supplementary
(hospitals, industrial estates/ areas, housing, schools, banks, storage and warehousing
facilities.
Supply of raw materials - these should be supplied on a regular basis at reasonable prices. It
is necessary to purchase and stock adequate quantities of raw materials. Approach locks up
capital in stock. Maybe approach could be the establishment of an agency to undertake
procurement and distribution of raw materials so that small businesses can obtain
requirements regularly.
Establish of information centres -SB runinto difficulties or do not find solutions to
problems partly due to ignorance. May not be aware of assistance and services available to
them , e.g. financial management packages, tax regs etc. create a sort of info centre to collect
and disseminate info of interest to SB. Info should be presented in a way that is easily
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 39
understood by entrepreneurs. Info to include government policy, rules and regs, training
programmes alternative technology, and production process available, domestic and export
markets, supply of raw materials and government documentation requirements.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 40
Incentives and tariffs restrictions- incentives given to local industries to protect them from
competition from foreign firms. Govt to make sure that incentives benefit the small
businesses otherwise they might be a disservice. It might be necessary to give special
incentives so that they can compete with local large companies incentives. Should help small
firms to become self-reliant and independent and should avoid making over dependent on
assistance. Incentives should therefore be temporary rather than permanent. Incentives
include tax holdings, exemption on import duties, conversion of tax into long term interest
free loans and tariffs protection.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 41
Marketing assistance: most small businesses lack of skills in marketing their products. Govt
can assist by actually buying and selling their products or by creating a favourable
environment to enable small business to do the selling themselves. Strategy involves
providing training, guidance, advice and assistance in promotion and marketing.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 42
Industrial estates- govt set up special industrial estates for small businesses. Physical
facilities to include common workshops, training, technical advice and consultancy or
marketing assistance for a group of businesses. Industrial estates to be available to businesses
who can benefit from such facilities.
Economies of scale
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 43
Lecture 4
One can go into business through various forms namely:
Start up i.e. creating a new business from scratch but this is not to mean
that the idea need necessarily new. Some people prefer to start a new business from scratch
i.e. they do not intend to buy an existing/established business. Starting from scratch has some
advantages and disadvantages. Would be owners prefer to start a business from scratch
because it is their creation and they are proud of it or they can be inhibited from buying an
existing business due to cash flow problems. They will be required to purchase goodwill,
which is an intangible asset and increases value beyond the ability of the would-be new
businessperson.
Advantages -
o Lesser funds are required to start a new business than would be the case
with buying an existing business, o One can choose a brand new name and location, o Select
and train staff.
o Select equipment according to specific needs.
o Order and purchase stock based on market research. Not burdened by old
stock from a going concern,
o Design and create a unique business climate,
o Design the layout.
o The newly created business does not carry a negative image.
Disadvantages
o Many barriers to entry e.g. start up costs, legislation, premises, problems
with suppliers; creditworthiness can be serious barriers to entry,
o Difficult to finance the business - banks and other lenders only willing to
give finances to businesses with a proven track record,
o Failure rate of small businesses is higher than when one buys an existing
business. Idea can be good but success will only be apparent when
business is operational,
o Businessperson does not have reliable information about sales, expenses
and profits. N the majority of cases they just estimates, which can be wide
off the mark.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 44
o It can take very long to be established and become popular. No market share or goodwill
exists when a business is established from scratch. The business resources might be
exhausted long before significant turnover is achieved.
It is easy for a businessperson to start a small business on a part-time basis to overcome the
disadvantages discussed above. In the process valuable experience and information is
gathered. Like in every business the businessperson should
o Conduct a proper market research or analysis.
o Should determine what customers need.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 45
Franchise - this method of starting a new business within the framework of existing larger
business entity. A separate legal enterprise operating in some way under the umbrella of
another organisation. This is a marketing system whereby an individual owner conducts
business according to the terms and conditions set by the franchiser. A franchise is the
agreement granting the right to do business and specifying the terms and conditions under
which the business will be conducted. The franchiser is the company that owns the franchise's
name and distinctive elements and grants others the right to sell its products.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 46
Types of franchising systems
Product and trademark franchising- here the franchisee is granted permission to sell a widely
recognised product or brand e.g. service stations, soft drink bottlers. Here the franchiser has
little control over the business of the franchisee. Control is however necessary to maintain
integrity of products. Business format franchising- franchisee given the right to use marketing
system along with ongoing assistance from the franchiser, e.g. Lucky Seven, Spar, Food
Chain Group, Sammy, Sheraton Hotel and Mercurri and Holiday Inn.
Advantages
o Reputation - An established and well-known franchise ensures that
customers buy the product often,
o Management assistance - franchising companies provide training in all aspects of
marketing, personnel and financial management,
o Profits - entrepreneur can expect reasonable profits. He/she depends on business expertise,
o Experience of the franchise owner makes up for the inexperience of
the entrepreneur.
o Finance - usually the franchiser provides the franchisee with financial assistance. Less
money needed to start the business, operate business on a day to day basis because of control
systems.
o The way to operate the business has already been worked out and tested. Starting up should
be easier and faster.
o Fewer franchises fail than other business start-ups. Therefore it can be easier to obtain
finance for a franchise.
- usually there are nationally agreed terms with suppliers that take
account of total franchised businesses.
Disadvantages
o Not your own creation, someone else's idea, franchisee only implementing and not creating.
o Lack of independence- entrepreneur has to follow the principles and methods of the
franchise owner. Rules made by the owner and followed by the franchisee.
o Standardisation- all franchise branches are standardised to create a uniform image among
customers- not much scope for own ideas.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 47
o Fees- considerable fees required for the use of the franchising business. Fees might be very
high resulting in poor profits. Furthermore franchisers put in place a profit sharing scheme
based on a fixed % of sales rather profits made.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 48
o The goodwill that a business builds p is never its own, as it is dependent on a continuing
franchise agreement. This could cause a problem when you decide to sell the business.
o The franchiser needs to ensure regular disclosure of information by the franchisee to protect
their royalties and the franchise agreement - this can become intrusive into the financial
affairs of the franchisee.
o Brand image of the franchiser can become a distinct liability if things go wrong. The
franchisee is depended on the stability of the franchiser-national problems with a franchisee
who has no control over events.
Buy existing business- outright purchase i.e. buying an existing business from somebody
else. There is a new owner but buying an established business. Some people do not
necessarily have to start a new business. A person may choose to buy an existing business or
may buy into an existing business to become a partner. There are several reasons why people
sell business and the would-be buy should critically examine the reasons and these include
the following:
o Recognition of lack of success of the business and low profitability in the future.
o Problems not related to business, which, forces a sale e.g., health problems, marital break-
up, or other personal issues.
o To pursue other business opportunities which make a sale desirable. Most people sell to
raise funds for another failing or successful business.
o A desire to change out of small businesses,
an,
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 49
o A dispute leading to the breakdown of a business partnership. Alternatively small
businesses might be available for sale from big businesses and the reasons for sale include the
following:
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 50
o Failure to meet financial targets set by parent company e.g. ROI is inadequate hence the
decision to sell and invest proceeds into
ventures showing greater potential,
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 51
o Company adopts new strategy meaning that the unit no longer fits
hence decision to sell especially when core activities are very varied to
those pursue by the business unit,
o When parent company is taken over and unit does not fit into to the
overall scheme of things. Forced sale
Liquidation following bankruptcy- in most liquidations people buy assets rather than the
business. The creditors will be seeking to recoup some of their monies. Advantages
- it may have an established and proven market share, o Location-
established firms often have the best sites, because the first owner had a wider choice of
locations than those available now.
o Profits- an established business may generate profit from the start.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 52
o Personnel- competent staff may be inherited. The already have knowledge
of key customers, sources of raw materials and business operating
systems to mention but a few.
- it is possible to buy business at a bargain price,
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 53
o Image/goodwill- it takes several years to build a favourable image. Good
image increases chances of the new owner being successful.
Disadvantages
o III will- businesses may have a bad reputation and it may take long to
reverse negative perceptions among customers. Mupata wachidembo.
o Misrepresentation- sellers may have omitted crucial facts that might affect
the future of the business success,
o Changing conditions- seller might even be unaware of the changing circumstances e.g.
population shifts or a major competitor might be entering the market etc. such issues will
affect the future of the business. There are many purchase methods available to the new
businessperson and these include the following:
Buyout - the buying of existing business from within e.g. management buyout. Refers to
the purchase of a business by existing management. Happened with TA when it sold BEC.
Management buy out made possible by the availability of finance from merchant banks,
banks and venture capital funds.
We also have MBO in public companies that are being privatised- more in the provision of
services to promote competition e.g. cleaning services, catering and ground maintenance.
Buy in- happens when existing owners accept a new partner or shareholder who buys a
small firm which already exists. People might not want to buy the whole business but to be
part owners of the business. This is done through being a partner or buying shares in an
existing business.
This is normally the case when a person joins professional services e.g. layers, accountants,
doctors etc. usually in partnership where there is a high turnover when partners leave or
retire. Not necessary to dissolve partnership, but gap has to be filled by recruiting another
partner into the practice.
Expanding small businesses can face serious cash flow problem. It becomes important to ask
other people to contribute additional capital needed to keep the business operational. Failure
to bring in additional cash might result in the failure of the business.
People can also buy in when a large company sells a part of the business to management and
if management is handicapped by lack of capital, o Buy in and management buy out-
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 54
BIMBO- this is a combination of outside and inside management in buying a business.
Aimed t reducing risk of buying into a company from outside existing management has in
depth knowledge of company and its markets, while new owners bring in fresh approaches.
Can be done via a number of ways including the following:
Sale or purchase of assets
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 55
When buying an existing business it is important to know what is up for sale. What is for sale
will depend on the wishes of the parties involved and the legal status of the business (i.e. a
sole trader, partnership that has no legal distinction from its owners, and limited liability
companies where ownership can change through the purchase or sale of shares.
The buyer must pay special attention to the assets, which are available for sale. Many assets
available might not be on the balance sheet especially for small businesses. The assets for
sale will include:
o Freehold property- business may own freehold property from which it trades. Mostly the
case when property is the key factor in the success of the business e.g. hotels, restaurants,
bars and other leisure facilities that depend on geographic location to attract customers. When
location is important it is important to acquire property through purchase or long-term lease
agreement. Owing the property is preferable to paying rent due to appreciation in property
values over time. When buying property take care and exercise caution. Check on ownership,
planning permission, restrictive covenants, mortgages and other charges. Assure yourself of
the suitability of the premises to the business. Premises are permanent and take long to
remove from the business especially when property market is slow.
o Leasehold property- leased property can be a valuable asset to a business. Most retailers
operate from leased premises. Location of such premises commands a premium/ goodwill
which can be sold when the business changes hands and must be taken in account however
the premium paid can disappear in times of recession. Value of leased premises depends on
desirability of premises, state of the premises and the state of the property market at the time.
Value likely to fluctuate depending on the above factors. When entering a lease agreement
there is need to consider the following factors:
Transferability of lease- most leases are not easily transferable. Landlords want to control
suitability of incoming tenants but some will allow the transfer of leases to third parties but
there often restrictions imposed which can devalue a lease.
Terms of lease- Commercial properties are held for shorter periods than residential
property. Normally businesses changing hands will have shorter terms on the lease and the
incoming person should look out for this situation as they might be left without premises
soon after taking occupation. Most landlords find it difficult to evict a sitting tenant. Landlord
may evict tenants on grounds of property redevelopment or intention to use the property.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 56
Repairs and dilapidations- most commercial properties require tenants to pay for the
upkeep of interior and exterior aspects of the building and surrounding land. Dilapidation
clauses require tenants to return the property to the landlord in a specified condition at the
end of a lease. Such cost represent considerable burden to tenants especially when premises
are old and near the end of the lease. Lease can have negative value as its liabilities outweigh
its usefulness.
Rent and provisions for review- where rent due is considered to be below market value /
levels, then this will add to the value of a
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 57
lease. Most leases provide for rent reviews after a certain period. Most leases provide for
upward reviews only.
Furniture and fittings- most business purchases include the purchase of furniture and
fittings. When new there is nothing to \Norry about and the tenant will have freedom to
choose. However going into existing premises can result in considerable costs in renovations
and removal of unwanted fittings (Look at what NMB did when it occupied premises
belonging to Zimbank). They have at times had to carry out massive alteration to make the
premises suitable for their use. The same would apply for any other venture. It is important to
examine the condition of the fixtures and fittings and their appropriateness to the business.
The type of business usually determines the nature and type of furniture and fittings when
assets are key to the business.
Machinery, equipment and vehicles- it is necessary to perform functions of a business and
these assets have to be acquired for the operations of the business. Type of equipment etc will
depend of the nature of the business and could include- manufacturing plan, commercial
equipment (freezers etc), office equipment and vehicles. Such assets have to be evaluated to
determine the purchase price. We can use the following methods to determine the purchase
price of these assets:
Written down book value which tends to be arbitrarily determined depending on the
depreciation method used by the business. Depreciation policies often tend to be optimistic or
cautious.
Market value.
Replacement value.
Original cost of equipment.
Stock and WIP- small businesses usually sell stock of the business to the new owner. Stock
can be classified as:
Raw materials, which is converted into products. Valuation of raw materials is the original
cost paid for the stock- however if there are price increases it will be necessary to negotiate a
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 58
higher price based on a replacement value. Buyer might ask for a reduced price if some of the
materials are damaged, obsolete, overstocked and perishable.
WIP, which is unfinished products. It is more complicated to calculate the price of work in
progress, as there are already components of raw materials plus other direct and indirect cost
for labour and overheads to be taken into consideration in determining the value of WIP.
Calculations have to been made on the state of completeness of the WIP, which is essential in
value determination.
Most small business people do not keep such records.
Finished goods ready for sale products. These are valued at the
selling price at the time of the sale taking into consideration any
overstocked position which decreases the value of some lines. Stock should be valued on the
day/date of transfer of the business. Should not be a fixed sum during negations. Use can also
be made of an independent valuer to determine the selling price.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 59
Debtors- people and companies will owe the business money. Debtors are a real asset to a
business problem not to negotiate value of debtors since their value is amount owing. Danger
is whether they will pay or not and how long they will take. Usually make it a point that the
seller retains debtors book and collect their money themselves after the sale or to guarantee
the amount in case of failure to collect.
Goodwill- accuracy of goodwill depends on circumstances and not reality. It is easier to
identify tangible assets and value these but very difficult to determine goodwill which is a
balance sheet item. Usually the practice is to remove the value of tangible assets and the
balance remaining from total assets will be the goodwill. Goodwill attempts to value the
likelihood of future success and therefore future profitability of the business. Goodwill is the
evaluation of future profitability, which is added to any market value of tangible assets.
Employees- existing employees can be a key to success i.e. their experience, skills, way of
doing business will impact on customer satisfaction. Employees can truly an intangible asset
but will dependent on worker motivation and individual expertise. Most small businesses
often run by the seller who is key to its success- impact of their removal is an important issue
particularly in the sale of a small owner managed businesses. Conversely you can take on
more than you bargained for with you being lumped with employees recruited on a partisan
basis who are a liability to the business. These cannot easily be jettisoned due to labour laws.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 60
Lecture 5
Once a decision is made to go into business, proper planning becomes essential. The
following steps will be taken in starting a business:
> Search for and identify a need for a product or service,
Study the market fore the product, using as many sources of information as possible.
Decide whether to start a new business, buy an existing one or buy a franchise.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 61
> Make strategic plans, including setting your mission, strategic objectives and strategies.
> Make operational plans, including setting policies, budgets, standards and methods, and
planning the many aspects of producing and marketing the product/service.
* Make financial plans including estimates of income and expenditure.
Develop these plans into a business plan.
There are many ways in which a person can go into business including the following:
Begin a new business/ Start up - this is new business that is not part of another organisation
though the idea being implemented might not be new. This is often referred to as a green field
business - no clearing of brush has been undertaken yet. The ideas are given a chance to be
started, grow and develop. Start-up is the only way of exploiting new ideas. Depending on the
investment start ups can be in the form of:
1. Sole trader i.e. where the individual makes all the investment on his or her own.
2. It can be shared with others i.e. in the form of a partnership with equal partners or any
other such arrangement.
3. It can be a registered company.
Low risk level- typified by someone who begins the business on a part time basis. Risk is
minimal as income is generated elsewhere and investment requirements are very small.
Motivation may be to turn a hobby or skill into a financial gain- rather like testing the water
before making a jump. High-risk level - when a professional etc becomes self-employed.
However liabilities are kept low by purchasing minimal equipment or overheads. Investment
can be made on an individual basis or at times shared with partners. Adv.
Creation of the owners thereby being free to choose what the business does, how it
operates and what its value are.
> Controls of the owners- personal decision count and external influences are minimised.
> Satisfaction of the owners - success due to skills and effort of the owners, which gives
them sense of heightened satisfaction when and if one, is successful.
Clean sheet - the business starts with no backlog of problems. It will create plenty but not
at least inherited from the past.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 62
New businesses are candidates for help from various agencies. Government assistance and
help from other agencies is available to encourage start-ups.
> Match between the founder and the enterprise- the founder can ensure that their individual
strengths are well used and weaknesses minimised by choosing a business well matched to
their own qualities and experience.
Fewer funds needed - costs are less than buying a similar franchise or existing business.
Disadv.
Unproven idea- may be creative but will it work? New businesses can only prove itself in
practice.
Entrepreneurship module
Frank Wilbert 63
High rate of failure- many new businesses have a high failure rate however other methods
have higher track record.
Hard and lonely work- entrepreneurs do it themselves and have unsocial working hours.
> No market share or goodwill- start up has to start from scratch to establish company name
and build name and to build loyalty.
> There are many barriers to market entry- legislation has to be considered, premises found,
accounts opened with suppliers/ creditworthiness proved etc.
Difficulties to come up with forecasts with no track record, difficult to predict financial
outcomes, sales volumes, overhead costs etc.
Difficulties to get finances since banks are willing to provide funds to someone with a
proven concept than to new ideas.
Franchising
> Product and trademark franchising where the franchisee is granted the right to sell a
widely traded product or brand. Franchisees concentrate on handling one franchiser's product
line and identify their business with that firm e.g. petrol stations. The franchiser will exercise
very little control over the operations of the franchisee. Control will mostly focus on
maintaining the integrity of the product.
Business format franchising - relationship in which franchisee is granted right to use the
entire marketing system, along with ongoing assistance and guidance from the franchiser-
including restaurants, retailing' hotels etc.
Opportunities are plenty to go through franchising route however there need to make
intensive studies and evaluations before jumping into a franchising bed. You should look to
franchises which are