45
Enovate TM (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent Solstice TM Liquid Blowing Agent S l ti TM G Bl i A t z Solstice TM Gaseous Blowing Agent Technical Update

Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

EnovateTM (HFC-245fa) Blowing AgentSolsticeTM Liquid Blowing Agent

S l ti TM G Bl i A tz

SolsticeTM Gaseous Blowing AgentTechnical Update

Page 2: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Honeywell – a History of InnovationHoneywell a History of Innovation

KYOTO PROTOCOL

HCFC Phase out

CFC Phase out

F-Gas Regulation

MONTREAL PROTOCOL EU LEGISLATION

CFCs

Phase-out

Olefins

Phase-out

HCFCs HFCs

Ozone Depleting Non-Ozone Depleting Low-Global-WarmingOzone Depletingand Very High Global

Warming Potential

Non-Ozone Depleting but High Global Warming

Potential

Low-Global-Warming Potential and No Ozone

Depletion Effect

Innovating to enable industries’ compliance 22

Page 3: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Solstice Liquid Blowing Agent: 1233zd(E)Solstice Liquid Blowing Agent: 1233zd(E)• (E) 1-chloro-3,3,3-trifluoropropene

• (E) CHCl=CH-CF3

Physical PropertiesSolstice LBA 141b Enovate

M l W 130 117 134

HCl

• Trans or E (entgegen) isomer Mol. Wt. 130 117 134

Boiling Point, oC 19 32 15

Flame Limits, % by volume in air None 7.6-17.7 None

CC

CF3H

y

Flash Point None None NoneEnvironmental Properties

Solstice LBA 141b EnovateLBA

Atmospheric Life 26 days 9.3 yr 7.6 years

ODP ~0* 0.11 ~ 0*

GWP100 < 7 725 1030Short Life = Ultra Low Environmental

Impact

GWP100 7 725 1030

VOC, USA reg No (est.) No No

Toxicity / OEL 300ppm** 500ppm 300ppm*No impact on depletion of ozone layer and is commonly referred to as zero (0)

3

(Wuebbles , Private Communication)** Internal HON OEL

Solstice LBA: Short Lifetime in Atmosphere Ultra Low Environmental Impact

Page 4: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Solstice Gas Blowing Agent: 1234ze(E)Solstice Gas Blowing Agent: 1234ze(E)• (E) 1,3,3,3-tetrafluoropropene

• (E) CHF=CHCF3

Physical PropertiesSolstice GBA 134a

HCl

• Trans or E (entgegen) isomer Mol. Wt. 114.0 102.0

Boiling Point -19oC (-3oF) -26oC (-15oF)

Flame Limits None NoneF

CC

CF3H

Flash Point None None

Environmental PropertiesSolstice GBA 134a

Atmospheric Life 14 days 7.6 years

ODP ~0* ~ 0*

GWP100 < 6 1430

Short Life = Ultra Low Environmental Impact

VOC No (est.) No

Toxicity / OEL 1000ppm** 300ppm

*No impact on depletion of ozone layer and is commonly referred to as zero (0) (Wuebbles , Private Communication)(Wuebbles , Private Communication)

** Internal HON OEL

Solstice GBA: Short Lifetime in Atmosphere Ultra Low Environmental Impact5

Page 5: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Appliance Foam Evaluations

Page 6: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Commercial Appliance Trial ResultsCommercial Appliance Trial Results

Trial run with major global OEM and major global systems house– Commercially manufactured household refrigeratory g– 32 complete units – Conventional foam equipment, existing in the factory

• No modifications to the process or equipment

Solstice LBA processed very similarly to Enovate (245fa)– Comparable in all aspects to world scale processing parameters– Foam density: nearly identical– Minimum fill weights: nearly identical– Demold time: equal / improved – HIPS Liner compatibility excellent even after 2 years

6

Solstice LBA processes similar to Enovate in refrigerator/freezer applications

Page 7: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Solstice LBA PUR Cabinet Lambda DataSolstice LBA PUR Cabinet Lambda Data

EnovateEnovate EnovateEnovate

7

Solstice LBA optimized: 8% improvement over Enovate baseline

Page 8: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

DOE Energy Performance AssessmentDOE Energy Performance Assessment• DOE Energy Test Method • Sets of 5 refrigerators: Solstice LBA and Enovate Blowing Agent baseline

Enovate Enovate

2%

29.5%

8

Solstice LBA Refrigerators: DOE Standard minus 29.5% Energy RatingSolstice LBA Refrigerators: 4% system energy improvement over baseline Enovate

Page 9: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Solstice LBA versus 141bSolstice LBA versus 141bFoam performance of Solstice LBA• Polyol miscibility equal to 141b, improved compared to Enovate Blowing Agent• Similar strength properties to Enovate, improved compared to 141b at equal density• Improved k-factor than Enovate foams• Improved k-factor compared to c-pentane foams

21

22

23

/mK 6

810

Ener

gy

vs14

1b

Lambda Performance Energy Performance

Solstice LBA foam- 3% improved vs 141b- 4% improved vs 245fa

16

17

18

19

20

Enovatec-PentaneHCFC-141bLa

mbd

a, m

W/

4-2024

% C

hang

e in

C

onsu

mpt

ion 4% improved vs 245fa

- 12% improved vs cyclopentane

15

16

-20 0 20 40 60

Solstice LBA

Mean Temperature, oCSource: AHAM 3rd Gen BA study plus Hon data on Solstice LBA

-4Solstice LBA Enovate c-Pentane

Lambda and Energy Performance Superior to 141b, CP, and Enovate13

Page 10: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Blowing Agents ComparisonBlowing Agents ComparisonEnovate

Blowing AgentSolstice LBA

orm

ance Hydro

CarbonsHCFC141b

Energy Efficiency

Adoption Capital/ Easectiv

ePe

rfo In-Place

(mW/mK @ 24°C)• 141b 17• c-pentane 20-21• Enovate 18-

Lower Cost/Unit

Cos

t effe

c

Gl b l W i I t

19• Solstice 17-18

nviro

nmen

t

Ozone Depletion Impact

Global Warming Impact(Direct)

Volatile Organics

Flammability

Toxicity

ESa

fety

Volatile Organics

Toxicity

* Specifics will vary by energy efficiency standards and type of refrigerator

Solstice LBA: application economics, most efficient & environmentally-superior 15

Page 11: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Spray Foam Evaluations

Page 12: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Spray Trial FormulationSp ay a o u a o

Components Enovatephp

Solstice LBA phpphp php

Mannich polyether polyol 40.0 40.0Aromatic polyester polyol 60.0 60.0

Sili S f t t 2 0 2 0Silicone Surfactant 2.0 2.0Amine catalysts 2.0 2.0Metal catalysts 4.1 4.1Flame retardant 20.0 20.0

Water 2.0 2.0Enovate Blowing Agent 20 0 -Enovate Blowing Agent 20.0

Solstice LBA - Equal molarIndex 130 130

Solstice LBA used in existing generic industry formulation12

Page 13: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Formulation Properties - Vapor PressureFormulation Properties Vapor Pressure

180- 26%Enovate Blowing Agent

120

140

160 Lower Vapor Pressure Means:

• Less potential for bulging drums- 31%

6%Enovate Blowing Agent

Solstice LBA

60

80

100

sure

, kpa • Potential to use lower

gauge drums

59%

- 41%

0

20

40

Pres • Less potential for blowing

agent loss from system

- 59%

22 33 43 54Temperature, °C

Solstice LBA formulation has significantly lower vapour pressure at all temperatures

13

Page 14: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Formulation Properties - StabilityFormulation Properties Stability

30Solstice LBA Formulation Stability @ 54 °C

Enovate Blowing Agent

20

25g g

Solstice LBA

c

Solstice LBA Formulation Stability @ 23C• Solstice LBA

formulation shows acceptable gel

10

15

Gel

Tim

e, S

ec

• Solstice LBA formulation shows

p gtime variation at 54 °C

0

5

0 1 2 4

G formulation shows no gel time variation at RT

0 1 2 4Time @ 54 °C, Weeks

4 Weeks 8 WeeksTime @ 23C

0 Weeks

Solstice LBA formulation has acceptable stability14

Page 15: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Lambda of Foam Sprayed @ 25°C Room Temperaturep y @ p

• Initial lambda• Solstice LBA 5 to 8%30

32

Solstice LBA 5 to 8% lower than Enovate

• Aged lambda• Solstice LBA 4 to 8%

lower than Enovate26

28

22

24

Lam

bda,

mW

/mK

18

20

L

Initial Aged Initial Aged Initial Aged

164 24 33

Mean Temperature , oC245fa Initial Solstice LBA Initial

245fa 28 Day Solstice LBA 28 Day

Initial Aged

Enovate InitialEnovate 28 days

Solstice LBA produces spray with improved lambda vs Enovate15

Page 16: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Solstice LBS Versus 141b in Spray FoamSolstice LBS Versus 141b in Spray FoamInitial Thermal Conductivity

20.0

19.4

19.6

19.8

K

18.8

19.0

19.2

Lam

bda,

mW

/mK

18.2

18.4

18.6

L

18.0141b 245fa Solstice LBAEnovate

Solstice LBA shows superior performance to 141b and Enovate Blowing Agent

16

Page 17: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Panel Foam Evaluations

Page 18: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Chinese Generic Discontinuous Panel Formulations

Polyol Blend (B-side)

Chinese Generic Discontinuous Panel Formulations

Components (php) Solstice LBA Enovate cyclopentane 141b

Polyether Polyol 65.0

Polyester Polyol 35.0y y

Catalyst 2.0

Surfactant 1.5

Flame Retardant 22 0Flame Retardant 22.0

Water 2.0

Blowing Agent 23.3 24.0 12.5 21.0

Isocyanate (A-side)

PMDI 143.6

A Blowing Agent “Drop-in” Replacement Study was Conducted

18

Page 19: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Comparison of Physical Properties

Cold (-29oC) 28 days

Dimensional Stability

Comparison of Physical Properties

Cold (-29 C), 28 days

Hot/Humid (70oC/95%RH), Hot (90oC), 28 days

ot/ u d ( 0 C/95% ),28 days

Cyclopentane

141b

Parallel PerpendicularCompressive Strength Solstice LBA

Enovate

Comparable Properties to Enovate, Better Properties than Cyclopentane

19

Page 20: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Initial Thermal ConductivityInitial Thermal Conductivity

0.16

0.17

0.18

ctiv

ityo F

)

Therm23.1

24.5

26.0

Cold Chain Applications 4%

8%

0.14

0.15

rmal

Con

duc

Btu

.in/ft

2 .h.o

mal C

onduc(m

W/m

K)

18 7

20.2

21.6

Enovate

Cyclopentane

0.11

0.12

0.13

Ther (B tivity

15.9

17.3

18.7Enovate

Solstice LBA141b

0.1120 40 60 80 100 120

Temperature (°F)

oF oF-6.7 oC 4.4 oC 15.6 oC 26.7 oC 37.8 oC 48.9 oC

Temperature

oF oF oF oF

Best Thermal Insulation Performance for Cold Chain Applications

20

Page 21: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

28 Day Aged Thermal Conductivity28 Day Aged Thermal Conductivity

0.16

0.17

0.18

ctiv

ityo F

)

Therm23.1

24.5

26.0

6%

10%

21%

Cyclopentane

0.14

0.15

rmal

Con

duc

Btu

.in/ft

2 .h.o

mal C

onduc(m

W/m

K)

18 7

20.2

21.6Enovate

Solstice LBA

141b6%

0.11

0.12

0.13

Ther (B tivity

15.9

17.3

18.7Cold Chain Applications

0.1120 40 60 80 100 120

Temperature (°F)

oF oF-6.7 oC 4.4 oC 15.6 oC 26.7 oC 37.8 oC 48.9 oC

Temperature

oF oF oF oF

Best Thermal Insulation Retention at All Evaluated Temperatures

21

Page 22: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Solstice LBA in Panel FoamSolstice LBA in Panel FoamInitial Thermal Conductivity Vs Temperature

20

22

W/m

K

16

18

mbd

a, m

W

12

14

13 24

Lam

13 24Mean Temperature, oC

141b Enovate Solstice LBA

Solstice LBA shows superior performance to 141b and Enovate22

Page 23: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Solstice LBA / Cyclopentane Blends

Page 24: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Comparison of Physical PropertiesComparison of Physical Properties

Cold (-29oC) 28 days

Dimensional StabilityCold (-29 C), 28 days

Hot/Humid (70oC/95%RH), Hot (90oC), 28 days

ot/ u d ( 0 C/95% ),28 days

0/1000/ 0

Solstice LBA/Cyclopentane Mol. Ratio

Parallel PerpendicularCompressive Strength

100/075/2550/50

Solstice GBA/C-C5 Blend: Balanced Solution for Cost and Physical Properties

24

Page 25: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Initial Thermal Conductivity

Solstice LBA/Cyclopentane Blends

Initial Thermal Conductivity

0.16

0.17

0.18

ctiv

ityo F

)

Therm23.1

24.5

26.0

Cold Chain Applications

0.14

0.15

rmal

Con

duc

Btu

.in/ft

2 .h.o

mal C

onduct(m

W/m

K)

18 7

20.2

21.6

0/100

50/5025/75

Mol. Ratio

0.11

0.12

0.13

Ther ( tivity

15.9

17.3

18.7

100/075/2550/50

20 40 60 80 100 120Temperature (°F)

oF oF-6.7 oC 4.4 oC 15.6 oC 26.7 oC 37.8 oC 48.9 oC

Temperature

oF oF oF oF

Solstice LBA/Cyclopentane Blend: Balanced Solution of Cost and k-factors

25

Page 26: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

28 Day Aged Thermal Conductivity28 Day Aged Thermal Conductivity

Solstice LBA/Cyclopentane Blends

0.16

0.17

0.18

ctiv

ityo F

)

Therm23.1

24.5

26.0

0/100

25/75

0.14

0.15

rmal

Con

duc

Btu

.in/ft

2 .h.o

mal C

onduct(m

W/m

K)

18 7

20.2

21.6

100/0

50/5075/25

Mol Ratio

0.11

0.12

0.13

Ther ( tivity

15.9

17.3

18.7

Cold Chain Applications

Mol. Ratio

20 40 60 80 100 120Temperature (°F)

oF oF-6.7 oC 4.4 oC 15.6 oC 26.7 oC 37.8 oC 48.9 oC

Temperature

oF oF oF oF

Addition of Solstice LBA Enhanced Thermal Insulation Retention

26

Page 27: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Foam Flammability EvaluationsFoam Flammability Evaluations

DIN 4102-1:Class B2

15

20

m

Fail

10

15

Hei

ght,

cm

Pass

5

Flam

e H Pass

0100/0 75/25 50/50 25/75 0/100

Solstice LBA/Cyclopentane Blend, Mol. Ratio

Solstice LBA: Enhanced Foam Fire Retardancy

37

Page 28: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Gas Blowing Agent EvaluationsSolstice GBA in Panel ApplicationsSolstice GBA in Panel Applications

Page 29: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Comparison of Physical PropertiesComparison of Physical Properties

Dimensional StabilityCold (-29oC), 28 days

Hot/Humid (70oC/95%RH), Hot (90oC), 28 days

ot/ u d ( 0 C/95% ),28 days

Solstice GBA

134a

Compressive Strength

FlexuralStrength

Solstice GBA: Similar Physical Properties to 134a in Commercial Formulation

29

Page 30: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Initial Thermal ConductivityInitial Thermal Conductivity

0.16

0.17

0.18

ctiv

ityo F

)

Therm23.1

24.5

26.05%

134a

0.14

0.15

rmal

Con

duc

Btu

.in/ft

2 .h.o

mal C

onduct(m

W/m

K)

18 7

20.2

21.6

4%

Solstice GBA

0.11

0.12

0.13

Ther ( tivity

15.9

17.3

18.7

20 30 40 50 60 70 80Temperature (°F)

oF oF-6.7 oC -1.1 oC 10.0 oC

oF oF oF oF oF4.4 oC 15.6 oC 21.1 oC 26.6 oC

Temperature

Solstice GBA: 4% - 5% Better Thermal Insulation Value

41

Page 31: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Toxicity / Registration / Commercialization StatusToxicity / Registration / Commercialization Status

Solstice LBA• Toxicity – nearly complete

Solstice GBA• Toxicity – CompleteToxicity nearly complete

• Global Registrations– U.S.: SNAP / PMN applications filed

with U.S. EPA under review

Toxicity Complete• Global Registrations• U.S.: SNAP / PMN approvals complete –

commercial sales can commence– EU: REACH registration in-process

• Current REACH registration to 10 tonnes– Japan: Registration complete

commercial sales can commenceJ Ch i l S b C l

• EU: REACH registration process underway

– Current REACH registration to 10 tonnes• Japan: Registration complete

i l l• Japan Chemical Substances Control Law

– ROW Registrations to meet regional commercialization needs

• Solstice LBA registration complete:

commercial sales can commence– Japan Chemical Substances Control Law

• ROW Registrations to meet regional commercialization needs

– Solstice LBA registration complete: MexicoSolstice LBA registration complete: Mexico and India

• Commercialization– Semi-commercial – late 2012

C i l 2013

Solstice LBA registration complete: Mexico and India

• Commercialization– Semi-commercial - NOW

– Commercial - 2013 – Commercial - 2013Low environmental impact solutions will meet regulatory needs timing

31

Page 32: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

ConclusionsConclusions

• A environmentally sustainable and safe productL GWP S l ti GBA i 6 S l ti LBA i 7

• In foams, both molecules perform better than third generation benchmarksS l ti GBA

• Low GWP: Solstice GBA is < 6; Solstice LBA is < 7• Both are not flammable

• Solstice GBA• 5% better thermal conductivity than 134a• Comparable physical properties

• Solstice LBA• Lowest thermal conductivity and best thermal insulation retention• Comparable dimensional stability to Enovate and better than cyclopentane

• Solstice LBA/Cyclopentane Blend• A solution for formulation flexibility, but the blowing agent blend is most likely flammable

• Commercialization Status• Solstice GBA is commercialized, Solstice LBA will be commercialized in late 2012,

Solstice LBA or GBA: The Best Choices for Panel Foams

43

Page 33: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Enovate™ blowing agent HFC-245fa blending solutionsz

g g g

Shanghai Lab

Page 34: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Technical development backgroundTechnical development background

• China updated energy efficiency standards, – China appliance OEMs to face technical limits with CP system

• 245fa/CP technology is becoming a major solution for China appliance industry

• 245fa/CP technology provides an optimal combination of performance and cost

• Honeywell is the leader in 245fa/CP blend development and has IP for 245fa/CP application

• Honeywell has comprehensive technology solution for 245fa/CP application- Strong development capability- Good relationship with system house and equipment supplier- Offers refrigerator OEMs with tailor made solution for 245fa/CP blend technology- Offers excellent serviceOffers excellent service

Honeywell is the leadership for 245fa application

Page 35: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Boiling point of 245fa/CP blendBoiling point of 245fa/CP blend

• 245fa/CP is an Azeotrope-like Blend

Blowing agent (wt%)Boiling point at 745mmHg (°C)

245fa CP245fa CP

100 0 14.6

95~40 5~60 11.7±1

0 100 49

• The Boiling Point of Blend is Lower than 245fa and CP

Lower boiling point, better flowability* Honeywell Patent US 5,677,358

Page 36: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Thermal conductivity of 245fa/CP blown foam yRelative K-factor

7 days. Foam Density ~ 32kg/m3245fa/CP

1.15

1.20

r

Solo245fa blown

blend blown

1.05

1.10

ive

K-fa

ctor

0.95

1.00Rel

at

0.95100 90 75 50 40 30 25 20 10

0 25 50 60 75 90

% 245fa in blowing agent blend

% CP i bl i t bl d10 70 80

% CP in blowing agent blend

Better K-factor as 245fa Levels Increase* Honeywell Patent US 5,677,358

Page 37: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Dimensional stability of 245fa/CP co-blown foamDimensional stability of 245fa/CP co blown foam

Dimensional stability, -20°C after 22 days. Foam Density ~ 2.0lb/ft3 (32kg/m3)

0 6

0.8

1

e, %

0.2

0.4

0.6

ume

Cha

nge

‐0.2

0

100 50 30 25 20 10

Volu

100 50 30 25 20 10

0 50 70 75 80 90

% 245fa in blowing agent blend

% CP in blowing agent blend

Better Dimension Stability as 245fa Portion Increases* Honeywell Patent US 5,677,358

Page 38: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

245fa in Spray Applications245fa in Spray Applications

• Major challenges in 141b phase-out• Cost sensitive segment (Construction)

• HC and HFC 365mfc will not be an option due to safety concerns

• Water: poor thermal insulation and adhesion

• Blowing agent comparison:

--++++Foam cell

+

365mfc

-++++insulation

245fa HCFC-141b Water

++-++-price

-++++adhesion

++-+++handling

-++ ++ ++Flammable

++ ++-++ODP

Page 39: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Spray system developmentSpray system development

Wall system Roof system

Test Item Unit Standard Requirement 245fa foam Requirement 245fa foam

Density kg/m3 GB/T 6343 ≥35.0 37.0 ≥55.0 55.5

Thermal conductivity W/m·k GB 3399 ≤0.024 0.0208 ≤0.024 0.022

Compressive strength kPa GB/T 8813 ≥150 240 ≥300 340

Dimensional stability(-30 ,48h) % GB/T 8811 ≤1 0.8 ≤1 ≤1

Flammability cm GB/T 8624 ≤15 12 ≤15 13y

Dimensional stability(70 ,48h)

% GB/T 8811 ≤5 3.7 ≤5 3.7

Closed cell content % GB/T 10799 ≥90 93 ≥90 95Closed cell content % GB/T 10799 ≥90 93 ≥90 95

Page 40: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

HFC 245fa advantages in spray applicationHFC 245fa advantages in spray application

- Quicker rise

- Larger application window

- Lower operating temperature

- Less shrinkage - reversion

- Easily applies on cold surfaces

- Equivalent or better yield

- Drums used for 141b systems can be used forsystems with ~10% of 245fa

- Minimal 245fa loss during blendingC fi d b l l ti d i t ti- Confirmed by calculation and experimentation

Page 41: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

245fa in Panel Applications245fa in Panel Applications

• Some continuous panel manufacturers switching to HC and water from 141b

• Almost all discontinuous panel manufacturers are using 141b

• Major challenges in 141b phase-out• Water: poor thermal insulation and adhesion

• HC: high capital investment; safety

•Blowing agent comparison: 245fa HCFC-141b 365mfc Cyclopentane

insulation ++ ++ + +flowability ++ ++ + +

Demouldability ++ + + +Demouldability ++ + + +Polyol compatibility ++ ++ + -

Foam cell ++ ++ - -Flammability ++ ++ - -

Handling + ++ - -Adhesion ++ + + -

Price - ++ - ++

++ best + average - worst

Page 42: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Panel applicationPanel application

HCFC-141b 245fa/HCFC-141b 245fa

A 100 100 100B 92 92 92

CT 22 17 27GT 67 66 73TFT 105 105 115TFT 105 105 115FRD 26.7 25.3 27.5

filling W 500 452 437 420 454CD 42.2 42.6 40.8 42.8 44.8

K factor 21.69 21.52 21.45K factor 21.69 21.52 21.45

Compressive strength 122 143 124 202 194161 186 164 244 290

30 min 10.5 9.9 3.1333min 12.1 11.76 4.51

Demoudability NANA

36min 12.43 11.57 4.4639min 12.16 11.25 4.3242min 11.95 10.96 4.18

Dimensional stability

-30 ℃ -0.90% -1.11% -1.47% -1.17%70 ℃ 1 39% 1 30% 1 63% 0 17%stability 70 ℃ 1.39% 1.30% 1.63% 0.17%

Page 43: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Transitioning from Blowing Agent 141bg g g

PerformanceCost-effective

• May not meet emerging t d d d

Current: Transition to: Assessment Future Impact

Cyclo-pentane

Cost-effectiveEnvironment

Safety

energy standards and may require a 2nd transition to 245fa or Solstice LBAToday

141b

PerformanceCost-effectiveEnvironment245fa &

Blends

• Solution available today• Will meet energy efficiency

standardsToday

Safety

P f

Blends• Can transition to Solstice

LBA in future to meet GWP standards

• Most energy efficient

2013+

PerformanceCost-effectiveEnvironment

Safety

Solstice LBA& Blends

• Most energy efficient blowing agent with very low GWP (7) puts you in the best position now and in the future

245fa and LBA & Blends: Low Capital and Cost Transitions

the future

Page 44: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

Transitioning from Cyclopentaneg y p

Performance

Current: Transition to:

• While better positioned to

AssessmentFuture Impact

245fa &

Blends

Cost-effectiveEnvironment

Safety

• While better positioned to meet new energy standards, GWP may be an issue down the roadToday

Cyclo-pentanep

Performance • Most energy efficient 2013+

Solstice LBA & Blends

Cost-effectiveEnvironment

Safety

blowing agent with very low GWP (7) puts you in the best position now and in the future

245fa and LBA & Blends Offer Better Solutions Than Cyclopentane

Page 45: Enovate (HFC-245fa) Blowing Agent GBliAt Technical · PDF fileHoneywell.com Honeywell – a History of Innovationa History of Innovation KYOTO PROTOCOL HCFC Phase out CFC Phase out

Honeywell.com

www.honeywell.com

"Although all statements and information contained herein are believed to be accurate and reliable, they are presented without guarantee or warranty of any kind, expressed or implied. Information provided herein does not relieve the user from the responsibility of carrying out its own tests and experiments, and the user assumes all risks and liability for use of the information and results obtained. Statements or suggestions concerning the use of materials and processes are made without representationor warranty that any such use is free of patent infringement and are not recommendations to infringe on any patents. The usershould not assume that all toxicity data and safety measures are indicated herein or that other measures may not be required.”