Upload
bharadwaj-santhosh
View
225
Download
5
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Electrochemical Importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell Chlor Alkali Industry
1/8
Electrochemical importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell
Chlor Alkali Industry.
Document by:Bharadwaj
Visit my website
www.engineeringpapers.blogspot.comMore papers and Presentations available on above site
Abstract
Membrane Cell operation for the production of Caustic and Chlorine is the latest environment and
energy friendly process for a Chlor-Alkali Plant. The membrane cell consists of Cathode (Nickel),
Anode (Titanium) and a florocarbonated membrane. By the continuous process and process
requirement in energy point of view in a normal running Chlor-Alkali Plant Anode and Cathode
coating is required in order to increase more lifetime and more productivity for a cell. This anode
and cathode coating not only increase the total productivity of a Chlor-Alkali Unit but also can
decrease the fixed cost for a unit by increasing process reliability. A study has been done to
understand the electrochemical importance of anode and cathode coating and the thrust zone for
more research in this area to increase the productivity as well as increasing the depreciation time
for the Cell.
Keywords: Anode Coating, Cathode Coating, Membrane, Cell, Caustic Soda, Chlorine.
http://www.engineeringpapers.blogspot.com/http://www.engineeringpapers.blogspot.com/8/3/2019 Electrochemical Importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell Chlor Alkali Industry
2/8
Introduction:
Chlor Alkali Industry is a special and separate zone of chemical Engineering process and design
which meets the need of tones of caustic for textile, pulp and paper, pharmaceutical industries
and chlorine for PVC, water purification, and bleaching industries. In industry, from the last
century caustic and chlorine is produced by Electrolysis of saturated Brine (320gpl of NaCl in
H2O) by diaphragm or mercury or Membrane cell operation.
But for operational and cost Excellence Membrane cell electrolysis process In Chlor-Alkali
Industry dominates over the other two processes from the last four to five decades. In Membrane
cell Electrolysis process, the membrane is set between a Cathode (Ni) and Anode (Ti) and the
electrolysis takes place in both Cathode and anode side by high current. Saturated Brine comes
in anode side and depleted into Na+ and Cl- ions. 26% caustic comes in Cathode side where
depletion of water into H+ and OH- ion takes place. Membrane is a very thin perfluroted substance
with carboxylic coating in Cathode side and sulphonic coating in anode side which only allows
Na+ ion in cathode side from anode side. NaOH forms in cathode side with H2 as a by product,
and Cl2 forms in the anode side with lean brine recycle after dechlorination process. Membrane
structure and selectivity is a separate zone of research and is not the scope of present study. The
Membrane cell dominates over other two electrochemical manufacturing process of Chlor-Alkali
Industry due to the following reasons.
The power requirement is very high in Chlor-Alkali industry. Applications of Membrane cell
technology decrease the power consumption over the other two processes. But reduction of
power is still a thrust zone of research because Chlor-Alkali Industry is still the largest consumer
of power. It is tried to reduce the voltage from the root i.e. one single cell voltage to reduce power
requirement in the Electrolysis process. The cathode and anode ageing is another problem and
replacement cost is also very high. Reminding both causes i.e. increasing cathode and anode life
and decreasing cell voltage; anode side and cathode side coating is generally done. In presents
8/3/2019 Electrochemical Importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell Chlor Alkali Industry
3/8
the need, factors affecting and methods for applying cathode and anode coating is highlight with
latest development in this zone. It is expected that the study will help to understand the anode
and cathode coating in details manner in Chlor-Alkali Industry and modification needed in this
zone. The objective of the study is given below:
1. To see the various causes of the failure of electrode coatings.
2. To discuss the effective coating process.
3. A one shop stop for the knowledge of anode coating.
Anode and Cathode Coating [1] [2]:
The key components of all electrochemical processes are the electrodes and, in some cases, the
separators. The last century has seen many developments in both for the electrode materials and
ion permeable membranes and allows successful implementation of many novel concepts. Where
optimum performance of electrode material is needed, electrodes made from noble metals or
noble metal oxides are the components of choice. The common features of the materials of
electrodes are
a) The use of the platinum group and there oxides as coatings on inert substances.
b) The minimization of platinum metal loading.
c) Minimization of interelectrode gaps and having high energy efficiency by fabrication of
membrane or the electrodes.
d) To increase electrode stability by the use of platinum group metal alloys that also helps to
minimize overpotentials.
8/3/2019 Electrochemical Importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell Chlor Alkali Industry
4/8
In late 50s particularly in the year of 1965 by Henri Beer, the Dimensionally Stable Anodes were
introduced that changes the pathway of electrochemical processing. A new approach to the
manufacture of coated electrodes and increased expectations of the performance of the
electrodes were introduced by the introduction of the DSA. The coated titatanium anodes are
found in rapid application as there has a unique combination of properties like a very low over
potential for chlorine evolution and a very long service life. These two applications have replaced
graphite which early used as anode in electrochemical applications. There are various series and
various groups of researches associated to increase the performance and life time of an
electrode by introduction of various coatings in Anode side or in Cathode side. The main focus
area has gone to the anode side as main problems appear in the anode side which is discussed
later. The improvement by the coatings of the electrodes was seen in extended lifetime, stable
low voltage operations and predictable inefficiency product splits. The Dimensionally stable
anode coatings are a unique combination of value metal, precious metal oxide catalysts,
chemically bound to a value metal substrate. For most commercial applications the value metal of
choice is titanium by which the anode side of the electrodes in membrane cell technology is
generally made. A valve metal is a metal that will form a protective oxide layer on exposed
metallic surfaces upon anodic operation in aqueous electrolytes. Use of the protective oxide layer
gives the valve metals a remarkable corrosion resistance in many operating environments but
also prevents the use of the valve metal independently as an anode without the addition of a
property formed catalytic layer.
Mainly all these dimensionally stable anodes are used for all the mercury diaphragm or
membrane cell technology in Chlor Alkali Applications. DSAs can be used in all types of
application whether high hypochlorite or chlorate content in anode side or oxygen evolving
applications. There are also protective layers or coatings for high current density applications in
Chlor alkali industries.
8/3/2019 Electrochemical Importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell Chlor Alkali Industry
5/8
In case of Cathode coatings, the over potential for the cathode reaction in an electrode for Chlor
alkali applications, is also critical to the process energy consumptions. Practically it is very difficult
to eliminate the significant over potential of the electrolysis of water which partially takes place in
cathode of an electrode. The elimination of the over potential of cathodic reaction in electrode in
Chlor alkali applications is partially achievable by using noble metal coatings over the nickel
cathode which is vastly used in Chlor alkali applications.
The Coating Materials and Types:
In cathodic coating, it is believed that platinum/ruthenium coatings are used. Nickel is used as
substrate, to ensure stability against corrosion and the coatings contain 3 to 3.5 gm/m2 of
platinum and 1-1.5 gm/m2 of ruthenium [5]. Immersion plating method is applied for cathode
coating. After appropriate surface preparation, the nickel substrate is simply dipped into the
solution of noble metal chlorides and left to stand the electrode at room temperature unless
required loading of noble metal is obtained. The Nickel metal is the reducing agent in this
reaction. Typically, the over potential of Hydrogen evolution is 100mV with a current density of
3kA/m2 in 35% NaOH at 363K [5] [6].
In anodic coating, there are 13 series of coatings available for both Chlorine and Oxygen evolving
anode applications. One series are ruthenium titanium oxide combinations. Each of the
formulations is suitable for use in all chlorine generating applications. Another series of anode
coating contain ruthenium, tin and titanium oxides and diaphragm anode applications. The latest
application is a series of anode coatings which contain ruthenium, iridium, and titanium oxides for
latest membrane cell applications in Chlor Alkali technology [6].
Factors affecting Anode and Cathode Coating [3] [4]:
There are three ways to interrupt the electrical circuit between the metal substrate and the
electrolyte in case of anode coating. The interface between the catalyst and the substrate can
8/3/2019 Electrochemical Importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell Chlor Alkali Industry
6/8
become non conductive preventing electron flow from the catalyst to the substrate. Secondly te
catalyst can be lost in service exposing the valve metal substrate, which oxides and cannot
accept electrons from solution without the presence of the catalyst. Finally a foreign material can
deposit on the surface of the catalyst effectively isolating the catalyst from the solution. Brine
impurities directly or indirectly impact on each of these failure mechanisms. The three ways
described is names as passivation, wear, and blinding deposits.
Substrate passivation is defined as the growth of a non conductive oxide barrier between the
catalyst and the valve metal. The passivation is observed as a case of brine impurities, low NaCl
concentration in brine, voltage increase, higher current density operations, Oxygen rate in anode
side, Sulphate presence in brine and the anode potential.
Passivation is the primary failure mode for use in oxygen evolving applications such as Electro
galvanizing [8]. Although this failure is not rare in Chlor Alkali applications especially in diaphragm
and membrane cell applications, the passivated anodes is observed in 15-20 years of operation.
In this life period, generally it is considered to an economic end of the service life of a coated
anode. A non destructive type Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) technique can be
utilized to examine the anode and determine whether or not a passivation layer is present [3].
In case of wear, brine impurities can directly or indirectly impact. Typically a 10-15% loss of
catalyst is observed over the first six months of operation, followed by a gradual wear with time
throughout the useful life of the coating. Increasing wear in anode coating causes increasing in
voltage. Current will shift to remaining active areas, locally increasing current density and
observed operating voltage.
Fluoride ion in brine causes heavily to this wear problem of anode coating. Other brine impurities
that directly affect catalyst stability is sugar, EDTA and CN- ion [9].
8/3/2019 Electrochemical Importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell Chlor Alkali Industry
7/8
Blinding deposits are most frequently encountered problems associated with the coating erosion
in anode side. Both organic and inorganic deposits have been encountered over the years. In
general all the deposits are a result of electrochemical and electrophoretic processes. After
formation, they alter the current distributions within the cell and can result in locally high current
densities in non blinded regions. The first indication of this problem is usually rising cell potentials.
Inorganic deposits are normally visible on inspection.
Conclusions:
Electrochemical technology is the cleanest technology considered today. The Membrane cell
technology is the most environment friendly technology and energy efficient technology [7]. All this
technology depends on stable electrode materials and frequently only platinum group metal
materials fulfill this requirement. The objective of the electrode and coating catalyst design is
often therefore to place the noble metal in a stable matrix and to achieve the required
performance with a minimum noble metal loading. In today research is going on further reduction
of over potential of both sides of electrodes to reduce energy consumption and also to increase
its operating life and this is the challenge for the Chlor alkali industries in the 21st century.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
The author wish to thankfully acknowledge the Mr. C S Babu, HOD, Chlor-Alkali Plant of RIL-
Dahej for providing sufficient infrastructure for the completion of this paper and also all the other
Plant personnel who have helped directly or indirectly to execute this work.
8/3/2019 Electrochemical Importance of Anode and Cathode Coating in a Membrane Cell Chlor Alkali Industry
8/8
References:
[1] Electrodes based on Noble Metals by G Kim Chandler, J David Genders and Derek Pletcher.
Platinum Metal Rev., 1997, 41, (2), 54-63.
[2] Comprehensive Treatise of electrochemistry Vol-2, eds, J. OM, Bockris, B E Conway E.
Yeager and R E white, by D L Caldwell, Plenum, Newyork, 1981, P 122.
[3] Modern Chlor Alkali Technology S Scaley by K L Hardee and R A Kus Vol 7 p 43-54 1998.
[4] Deactivation of thermally formed Ru/Ti Oxide electrodes by B V Tilak, V I Birss, J Wang, C P
Chen and S K Rangarajan, Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 148 (9) D112-D120 (2001)
[5] The Electrochemistry of Novel Materials, J Lipkowski and P N Ross editors, by S Trasatti, P
207, VCH Publications, New York (1994)
[6] The Effect of Brine Impurities on Dimentionally Stable Anodes by R C Carlson. 2005 Eltech
Chlorine seminar, Cleaveland, Ohio, Sept 13-15, 2005.
[7] Operating manual Of Chlor Alkali Plant of Dahej Manufacturing Division, RIL Vol 2.
[8] Modern Chlor Alkali Technology, Volume 4, N M Prout and J S Moorhouse eds. By D S
Cameron and P M Willis, Elsevier Applied Science, 1986.
[9] Encyclopedia Electrochemistry, Chlor-Alkali Processes: PP 1-3