Upload
aileen
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
El Cid
Citation preview
El CidRodrigo Díaz de Vivar (1040? – July 1099), was a Castilian military and political leader in medieval Spain.
Born of the Spanish nobility and nicknamed El Cid Campeador, Rodrigo Díaz was educated in the royal
court of the Kingdom of Castile and became an important general and administrator, fighting against the
Moors in the early Reconquista. Later exiled by Afonso VI, El Cid left service in Castile and worked as a
mercenary-general for other rulers, both Moor and Christian. Late in life, El Cid captured the
Mediterranean coastal city of Valencia, ruling it until his death in 1099. Fletcher (2003) describes him as
the “most famous Spaniard of all time” (72).
The nickname "El Cid Campeador" is a compound of two separate sobriquets. "El Cid" is derived from
the word al-sidi in the Andalusian dialect (from the Arabic sayyid, "sir" or "lord," a title of respect), while
the title el campeador (the champion) was granted by his Christian admirers. It is also a not so common
fact that he has been referred to by some Andalucians as "El Raffi." These titles reflected the great
esteem El Cid had among both Moors and Christians, as well as his fighting ability; Henry Edwards Watts
wrote that el campeador "[m]eans in Spanish something more special than ‘champion’ ... A campeador
was a man who had fought and beaten the select fighting-man of the opposite side in the presence of
the two armies" (1894, 71)
He remains as iconic figure that lived an adventurous life in turbulent times and gained the respect of his
enemies as well as his friends. His life shows that it is possible to cross barriers and even to work with
people who one's own culture usually demonize and stereotype as different from ourselves. His
honorific title, El Cid, by which he remains known, was given him by the Moors—who were hated and
despised by Christian Europe. At a time of hostility between Christians and Muslims, El Cid dealt with
both as equally human. The rights and wrongs of conquest and reconquest aside, this can be regarded
as a positive quality in an age when too many people thought it a duty to slaughter the religious and
cultural Other without any attempt to understand their faith, or even to persuade them to convert.
Early life
"El Cid" was pronounced /el tsið/ in medieval Castilian, but /el θið/ in modern standard Spanish (the c
like the th in "thin" and the d like the th in "then"). The exact date of El Cid's birth is unknown. Based on
his participation in 1063 at the Battle of Graus, however, most historians believe that El Cid was born
eighteen to twenty years earlier between 1043 and 1045, in Vivar (Bivar), a small town about six miles
north of Burgos, the capital of Castile. Historical records show that El Cid's father was Diego Laínez, who
was part minor nobility (infanzones) of Castile. Diego Laínez was a courtier, bureaucrat, and cavalryman
who had fought in several battles. Despite the fact in later years the peasants would consider him one of
their own, El Cid's mother's family was aristocratic. However, his relatives were not major court officials:
documents show that El Cid's paternal grandfather, Lain Nuñez, only confirmed five documents of
Ferdinand I of Leon's; his maternal grandfather, Rodrigo Alvarez, certified only two of Sancho II of
Castile's; the Cid's own father confirmed only one. This seems to indicate that El Cid's family was not
comprised of major court officials.
One well-known legend about the Cid describes how he acquired his famous war-horse, the white
stallion Babieca. According to this story, Rodrigo's godfather, Pedro El Grande, was a monk at a
Carthusian monastery. Pedro's coming-of-age gift to El Cid was his pick of a horse from an Andalusian
herd. El Cid picked a horse that his godfather thought was a weak, poor choice causing the monk to
exclaim "Babieca!" (stupid). Hence, it became the name of El Cid's horse. Today, Babieca appears in
multiple works about El Cid.
El Cid was educated in the Castilian royal court, serving the prince and future king Sancho II, the son of
Ferdinand I of León (the Great). When Ferdinand died in 1065, he had continued his father's goal of
enlarging his territory, conquering the Christian and the Moorish cities of Zamora and Badajoz.
By this time, the Cid was an adult. He had fought alongside Sancho against the Moorish stronghold of
Zaragoza (Saragossa) in 1067, making its emir, al-Muqtadir, a vassal of Sancho. In the spring of 1063 he
fought in the Battle of Graus, where Ferdinand's half-brother, Ramiro I of Aragon, had laid siege to the
Moorish town of Graus which was in Zaragozan lands. Al-Muqtadir, accompanied by Castilian troops
including the Cid, fought against the Aragonese. The party would emerge victorious; Ramiro I was killed,
and the Aragonese fled the field. One legend has said that during the conflict El Cid killed an Aragonese
knight in single combat, giving him the honorific title of "El Cid Campeador."
Service under Sancho
Early military victories
As a resident of Castile, the Cid was now a vassal of Sancho. Sancho believed that he, as Ferdinand's
eldest son, was entitled to inherit all of his father's lands. Once he conquered Leon and Galicia, he began
making war on his brothers and sisters. At this time some say that the Cid, having proved himself a loyal
and brave knight against the Aragonese, was appointed as the armiger regis, or alferez (standard-
bearer). This position entailed commanding the armies of Castile.
Victories over Afonso and Sancho's death
After defeating Sancho's brother Afonso at Llantada on the Leonese-Castillian border in 1068 and
Golpejera over the Carrión River in 1072, Sancho and the Cid forced Afonso to flee to his Moorish city of
Toledo under Al-Ma'mun. Toro, the city of Sancho's elder sister Elvira, fell easily, and for a while it
seemed as though Sancho and the Cid were unbeatable. But during the siege of Zamora, the city ruled
by Sancho's younger sister Urraca of Zamora, Bellido Dolfos assassinated Sancho with a spear on
October 7, 1072.
Service under Afonso
Much speculation abounds about Sancho's death. Most say that the assassination was a result of a pact
between Afonso and Urraca; some even say they had an incestuous relationship. In any case, since
Sancho died unmarried and childless, all of his power passed to his brother, Afonso—the very person he
had fought against. Almost immediately, Afonso was recalled from exile in Toledo and took his seat as
king of Leon and Castile. While he was deeply suspected in Castile (probably correctly) for being involved
in Sancho's murder, According to the epic of El Cid the Castilian nobility, led by the Cid and a dozen
"oath-helpers", forced Afonso to swear publicly in front of St. Gadea's Church in Burgos on holy relics
multiple times that he did not participate in the plot to kill his brother. This is widely reported as truth,
but contemporary documents on the lives of both Afonso VI of Castile and Leon and Rodrigo Diaz do not
mention any such event. This legend is believed because it adds to accounts of El Cid's bravery but there
is no proof that it took place. El Cid's position as armiger regis was taken away, however, and it was
given to El Cid's enemy, Count García Ordóñez. Later in the year, Afonso's younger brother, García,
returned to Galicia under the false pretenses of a conference.
Battle tactics
During his campaigns, El Cid often ordered that books by classic Roman and Greek authors on military
themes be read in loud voices to him and his troops, both for entertainment and inspiration during
battle. El Cid's army had a novel approach to planning strategy as well, holding what might be called
brainstorming sessions before each battle to discuss tactics. They frequently used unexpected strategies,
engaging in what modern generals would call psychological warfare; waiting for the enemy to be
paralyzed with terror and then attacking them suddenly, distracting the enemy with a small group of
soldiers. El Cid had a humble personality and frequently accepted or included suggestions from his
troops. He remained open to input from his soldiers and to the possibility that he himself was capable of
error. The man who served him as his closest adviser was his nephew, Alvar Fáñez de Minaya.
Marriage and family life
The Cid was married in July 1074 to Afonso's kinswoman Jimena de Gormaz (spelled Ximena in Old
Castilian), the daughter of the Count of Oviedo. This was probably on Afonso's suggestion; a move that
he probably hoped would improve relations between him and El Cid. Together El Cid and Ximena had
three children. Their daughters, Cristina and María, both married high nobility; Cristina, to Ramiro, lord
of Monzón and bastard descendant of kings of Navarre; María, first to Infante of Aragon and second to
Ramón Berenguer III, count of Barcelona. El Cid's son, Diego Rodríguez, was killed while fighting against
the invading Muslim Almoravids from North Africa at the Battle of Consuegra (1097). His own marriage
and that of his daughters increased his status by connecting El Cid to royalty; even today, living
monarchs descend from El Cid, through the lines of Navarre and Foix.
Service as administrator
El Cid was a cultivated man, having served Afonso as a judge. He kept in life a personal archive with
copies of the letters he mailed and important diplomas he signed as part of his cooperation in the king's
administration.
Exile
In the Battle of Cabra (1079), El Cid rallied his troops and turned the battle into a rout of Emir Abd Allah
of Granada and his ally García Ordóñez. However, El Cid's unauthorized expedition into Granada greatly
angered Afonso, and May 8, 1080 was the last time El Cid confirmed a document in King Afonso's court.
This is the generally given reason for El Cid's exile, although several others are plausible and may have
been contributing factors: jealous nobles turning Afonso against El Cid, Afonso's own animosity towards
El Cid, an accusation of pocketing some of the tribute from Seville, and what one source describes as El
Cid's "penchant" towards insulting powerful men.
However, the exile was not the end of El Cid, either physically or as an important figure. In 1081, now a
mercenary, he offered his services to the Moorish king of the northeast Spanish city of Zaragosa, Yusuf
al-Mutamin, and served both him and his successor, Al-Mustain II. El Cid offered his services to the rulers
of Barcelona, Ramón Berenguer II (1076-1082) and Berenguer Ramón II, Count of Barcelona (1076-
1097), but they turned him down. He then journeyed to Zaragoza, where found himself more welcome.
This was Muslim territory jointly ruled by Yusuf al-Mutamin (1081-1085) who ruled Zaragoza proper, and
his brother al-Mundhir, who ruled Lérida and Tortosa. El Cid entered the service of al-Mutamin's and
successfully defended Zaragoza against the assaults of al-Mutamdhir, Sancho I of Aragón, and Ramón
Berenguer II. In 1082, he briefly held the latter captive.
In 1086 the great Almoravid invasion of Spain through and around Gibraltar began. The Almoravids,
Berber residents of present-day Morocco and Algeria, led by Yusef I, also called Yusef ibn Tushafin or
Yusef ibn Tashfin, were asked to help defend the Moors from Afonso. A great battle took place on
October 23, 1086 at Sagrajas (in Arabic, Zallaqa). The Moorish Andalusians, including the armies of
Badajoz, Málaga, Granada, and Seville, defeated a combined army of León, Aragón, and Castile. At first,
the Christians seemed to be gaining the upper hand until Ibn Tashufin outflanked them. The Christians
then started to retreat. Soon, the retreat became a rout. Afonso, along with five hundred knights, was
able to escape.
This defeat actually served El Cid well. Terrified after this crushing defeat, Afonso recalled El Cid from
exile, considering his services essential once again. It has been shown that El Cid was at court on July
1087. However, what happened after that is unclear.
Conquest of Valencia
Around this time, with a combined Christian and Moorish army, El Cid began maneuvering in order to
create his own fiefdom in the Moorish Mediterranean coastal city of Valencia. Several obstacles lay in
his way. First was Ramón Berenguer II, who ruled nearby Barcelona. In May 1090, he defeated and
captured Berenguer in the Battle of Tébar. Berenguer was later ransomed, and his son, Ramón
Berenguer III, married El Cid's youngest daughter Maria to ward against future conflicts.
El Cid gradually came to have more influence on Valencia, then ruled by al-Qadir. In October 1092 an
uprising occurred in Valencia inspired by the city's chief judge, Ibn Jahhaf, and the Almoravids. El Cid
began a siege of Valencia. The siege lasted several years; in December 1093 an attempt to break had
failed. In May 1094, the siege ended, and El Cid had carved out his own kingdom on the coast of the
Mediterranean Sea.
Officially El Cid ruled in the name of Afonso; in reality, he was fully independent. The city was both
Christian and Muslim, and both Moors and Christians served in the army and as administrators. In 1096
Valencia's nine mosques were "Christianized"; Jérôme, a French bishop, was appointed archbishop of
the city.
On July 10, 1099, El Cid died in his home. Though his wife Jimena would continue to rule for two more
years, an Almoravid siege forced Jimena to seek help from Afonso. They could not hold the city but both
managed to escape. Afonso ordered the city burned to prevent it from falling into the hands of the
Moors. Valencia was captured by Masdali on May 5, 1109, and would not become a Christian city again
for over 125 years. Jimena fled to Burgos with El Cid's body. Originally buried in Castile in the monastery
of San Pedro de Cardeña, his body now lies at the center of the impressive cathedral of Burgos.
Legend
Legend has it that after El Cid died he was strapped onto his horse and ridden into battle. The enemy
was so afraid of the invincible rider that they all went back to their boats and El Cid won the battle dead
on a horse. The legend also tells that only his wife knew because she realized that if the men realized
their beloved leader was dead, they would surely lose.
Tizona
El Cid's sword, "Tizona," can still be seen in the Army Museum (Museo del Ejército) in Madrid. Soon after
his death it became one of the most precious possessions of the Castilian royal family. In 1999 a small
sample of the blade underwent metallurgical analysis that partially confirmed that it was made in
Moorish Córdoba in the eleventh century, although the report does not specify whether the larger-scale
composition of the blade identifies it as Damascus steel.
Revisionism
The famous Spanish epic, Poema de Mio Cid “presented its hero,” comments Fletcher (2003), in an
“entirely different light.” All reference to his having served Muslims is now edited out from his
biography. Now, he is “exclusively a Christian, crusading, Castilian patriot” (86). The crusading zeal
launched by Urban II also had Spain firmly in mind; “It is not surprising that Urban's eyes should also
have been on Spain…since the start of his pontificate he had enthusiastically supported…a drive to
reoccupy Tarragona, a ghost town in no man's land fift miles down the Spanish coast from Barcelona”
(Riley-Smith, 7). The crusaders took vows. Applying the term to El Cid is anachronistic, because the
Crusades started after his death—but it also inaccurate because he never took a vow.
El Cid was living prove that the Christian-Muslim frontier could be crossed, but as hostility towards Islam
intensified, that frontier-crossing became “unacceptable,” so El Cid's image was adjusted accordingly
(Fletcher 2003, 89). Fletcher suggests that the ethos of El Cid's own time had been closer to one of “live
and let live” (92). Later, the dominant attitude was one of hostility and outright “fanaticism,” yet the
earlier period shows that “human moral relationships usually have fuzzy outlines” (92). Europe gained
much from the often-tolerant rule of the Muslims in Spain, under whose patronage learning flourished.
Christian, Jewish and Muslim scholars interacted and many valuable texts were translated from Arabic
into Latin, including Aristotle, whose thought had been lost to Europe. The great Catholic theologian,
Thomas Aquinas, was in many respects a product of this period of religious pluralism, since he drew
both on Aristotle and on Muslim philosophy as well.
Legacy
El Cid enjoyed the unusual honor of being respected by Christians and Muslims alike, an honor that few
others can claim with the exception of such men as Saladin and Richard the Lionheart. At the time,
Christians thought Muslims to be servants of Satan, and when the recovery of the whole of Spain was
regarded as Christian duty. Success in winning back parts of Spain was a contributing factor in launching
the Crusades, as success emboldened the pope to believe that the Holy Land could also be recovered.
However, once the Crusaders had established a foothold in Palestine, and had recovered Jerusalem, the
Christians who then settled there adopted a much more pragmatic attitude towards the Muslims. They
quite often entered truces with them, and some, like El Cid, found themselves supporting some Muslims
against others or against a common enemy.
El Cid may not have been a model character, yet he could see his enemy as equally human. Perhaps
iconic figures that attract respect from both sides of traditionally opposed peoples can unite a world
that is often divided. It was a fluid time, which, says Pierson (1999), allowed “a personality like El Cid to
flourish” (34). The poem, El Cid, would serve as one of the founding discourses of modern Spain,
although it lay for many years “in a remote monastery near Burgos.” It was a time when some people at
least thought the motto “live and let live” was good advice. Border zones, such as Moorish Spain, could
be imagined and constructed either as a barrier or as a bridge. For El Cid, the frontier between Islam and
Christianity was a bridge; he could deal honorably with either side. His frontier-crossing example,
though, has largely been obscured by the myth and legend that his life of high adventure generated.