23
_.' (J \J 14 NORTH WELL FIELD ANALYSIS DECEMBER 6, 1994 PRESENTATION eder associates environmental scientists and engineers

EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

_.' (J \J 14

NORTH WELL FIELD ANALYSISDECEMBER 6, 1994

PRESENTATION

eder associatesenvironmental scientists and engineers

Page 2: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

EAU CLAIRE, WISCONSIN

NORTH WELL FIELD ANALYSISDECEMBER 6, 1994

PRESENTATION

PROJECT #497-08DECEMBER 1994

Office Location: Office Contact:EDER ASSOCIATES William M. Warren201 South Main Street (313) 663-2144

Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104

Offices in New York, Wisconsin, Michigan, Georgia, Florida, and New Jersey

Page 3: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page No.TCA and TCE Graphs for Wells 11, 15, 16, and 17 1-8

VOC Graph for Well 19 9

• Computer Model Output showing Capture Zone ofWell 19 (one, five, and 20 year simulations) 10-12

• Statistical Predictions of TCE and TCA Concentrationsin Wells 11, 15, 16, and 17 13

North Well Field Data 14

• Water Treatment Plant Process Diagram 15

• Cross Section of Packed Tower 16

• Air Stripper Operation 17-18

• Results of Air Stripper Capacity Analysis 19

• Conclusions 20

497-01.002 . 12/5/94

Page 4: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

-I-

Concentration, ppb

O

> E

se^eposse jape

Page 5: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

-I-

Concentration, ppbon

3

B-<n.fl

q.

a.

VIpJpn•nff

c•a

en

O

m 0!

Page 6: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

in-jm

o

co"5

cCO-3

COco"5—3CO

i ICMCO

OCVJ

J

CMCO|

CCO

CO

0E

2t/3

ONWM

*

"u

4>"

9cCO-3oCO113

~3OO)1cCO-3CO001

cts-o

COC/J

•ac&

o^•3!TUO^

C

a>CDcCO~30000 O

Z

qdd'

-3-

Page 7: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

Concentration, ppbzo

': f*H=r"

' §'ft^ .

5'

f: ft

• CP

5'C/>

< 5CLP

enP30.V)P3.C/5

P^1

ft•n

f

' —

*

\c<s>Pa.•o

i <do00c_CD

1

COc_ _c_

100COc_

1COoc_c_CDoc_03

1CO^^

1 C-""H -

I-"'CD 05•pCOroc_ .c_

1COroc_03Di —COCOc_c_

1COCOc_DiCO

D cnt - - - - - - - ^ — — - - - [ — - - - - - -t

%•. ^x

/' K' v.

/

- / " " : ?M mi "^! £

\ : n

* \; x

/' K>" ifwf\« \

\M \N *V

X \M \

M ^^^" X — ,

/

/•» 1

/ K

/ ^/ M

* \, «

X !') X

.''' KX:' '

XM

H 'M 1

'x

- ^ 8" ^

- / ' •?:a77 v/

/ X '/ ^7/* //'/ «

/M/ \?' Bi </r^>^

fol1

T3O_5'f^

2o<5'

00

M

•-w

M

ICO

_U

?8N)

0IIu>(o

vO *O)X

T3

toSO

•X-

roo

O

o

ssm Q!

en

sejepossB

Page 8: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

Concentration, ppbz£aHrt

rtn

c.

3B31n

3n

pc•o

o

> E

o>

sajeposse

Page 9: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

-9-

Concentration, ppbzoHn

-DC

v:in

CL

VI

ft

n= CD

C_c_CX)00c_0}IJcx>CO

00COc_ff>

COoc_c_I

COoc_0313CO

CO

Q>IJCOroc_c_COroc_<uDiCOCOc_c_I

COCOc_03DCO^c_c_CO*>

roo

o

r £.

so •—U) ^C

m 03

o>

seieposse

Page 10: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

-L-

Concentration, ppb

zo

Hn

re

.

XJ

SI

e-

dooo

00

c_I

00

0)DiCOo

cb

CO

n

rilCO

= CD

3•o

ro

•COroc_0}I

COCO

ICOCO

DI

c_CO

Oiroo

oH

m

sejepossB japs

Page 11: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

00ON m—i OS* 2

13 ri

o

oCM

LO

a.3cn

ON

u

u

-t—Si-

•o

OST3C

«

=ruu

c

u

OJoZ

O ^

qdd 'UOHBJJU90U03

-8-

Page 12: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

ECMWFPUMPING WELL #19

^14 *_CD ' *^^~~~^ «.9*19 m ^^^*^L • *• ^^^ - "

Z 10 -;.---•••••---•••--«•• ...-............-.-........—.-......-.-.-.... .....'..•,....../.......... . ..^r i v/ , ~ _ 72 ,4••HI* ' ''

i Q ' / '.v

1 D ~ ~ r-,' """" /T^S '

LLJ 4 •

T7 O •- ^~^ • — ' *O i •~^<"::::~ »— -~*X ,• •— Hi(") n . . v •-•'

LEGEND

1,1-DCE

1,1 -DCA

"*~1,1,1-TCA '

TCE

ppc

1993DATE

-9-

Page 13: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

sin^^—

^

5e-Q^

•rcnJi•

T)GO01

u.OU

1i

L/I »• inU ' -• ^ in

- c .. „cro

o "o a,£ ^^5 eaTJ :r oa r m

mC

I f

3 - 1

1 - l

I i i

*• ji ! " !- c - ,- o o i rl" . . . . , 5 (

• " •• ; t! IU

£> * « - !^i I * *i - TJ -Ci - 0 0- c c

> » - - ' - ' , . ci ll * I" 1» —6 -. C C > "O; c a o - >.a - v o w TJ6 o c 6 o oz z z z z z

r i ••

- !<£z : 2c i 'o- 10

QC<LJJ

LUZoI

LJJZoNLUQC

Oo>

LLJ

OOOZI :oooi 0008 0009 000V oooz

-10-

Page 14: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

nq10*»*M*

r _

5"r.

COcn

iCOen

2.

^5.

oo

0;**

3

U

cr0

0 d;CT i2 3

^ 0£. ui

Ul «-

5 ,.-ic^

'•*i

^

£ 3

<D

i

'ou

6

— o

C ~a -

i i

—•i\n«*Q>

co

ns

o'

o

coo

s

0z

0

ul&T0c£

r

o 3>

« . — i* —1 3

! <n

1 I

i

UU) i

••

I/)TJ 1„ , |

0

QC<LU>LU

LLI

LUZoNLUQC

OO)

LJJ

OOOZl 00001 0008 0009

-11-000 » oooz

Page 15: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

TCT)<n

COCT)

t/i •• m »• Z,- ^ < s - o - ~ o o

croT>T3

- O 9 &

— /» W•fl 5 1* *s = 1 1

CT _, CT m i C2 i " > - - ' - ' . . c~ ^ ° 3 I 3 2 l ' i ; c > 5~ f\ : I ~——— -^ -^ ~> /- rt ^ ___ | , - 0 3 2 C O O -' • ' ^ j a . - w u .

•— o 13•—• u 2

QC<LU

OCMI

LLIZONLUQC

Oo>

LU

OOOZ! 00001 0008 0009 000 ^ 0002

-12-

Page 16: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

O)

(0

o

uoOg•D«UJO

"8J[S£a."au

re**CO

0)il

O

C

a_iUJ

UJ

2Oz3SUJg5O

2

(2 "co

1 gU. H

C ^CO ^

U. UJ

° £U. ^

(/> OCO *""

1 g-£ I-

t/> C_5co .a> •"

£ "J>- O

^

0CO )—CO^~

2 ujO O

0co Ho>o>T uj> o1 •-

ciZ

1

9§d

§d

eo§d

id

COcood

o>

d

CN

d

^JId

^»cod

f>.CO

d

COco<N

op

^.

Ulsd

§d

id

OO

d

co

6

Sd

mSd

oo•*d

COCO^CN

(V.

CO

9

o>CO

LO

oo -od

o§d

§od

§d

§d

id

od

o>od

CNcoCNd

ocod

cvi

ooCO

CO

oood

o§d

ood

§d

CO

§d

oo§d

o>

d

^Sd

COoCOd

oo>CNd

ooop

00

^

-13-

Page 17: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

cu:

IQM«(X

8ft.

3

tad^

^

K

U

£*"*

V1MDaa,i9eu

6srV^

Q2

Q2

Q2

Q2

Q2

1

0

Os

i

2

Q2

(N

Q2

oo1Q2

p

oOs

Q2

oo

00(N

••*

"*

VO

~

(N(NiQ2

(N

iQ2

8P-H

*r>

a

s*«n

Q2

ots

1Q2

Q2

o

SO

Q2

iQ2

Q2

ii

Q2

o00

^

r-

«n•t

Q2

iOs

^

mw->

(N

1

oOSi

8*p"*

OS

Q2

•o<N

COm

Q2

^ts

Q2

iQ2

oooo

iol-boni_i••

^

1

1

^

u•

<Q

O """> &bo a.2 c

« .200 -3

v

81> U

8

5

-1A-

Page 18: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

WELLS NO.10, 11, 15,16, 17, 19,

STRIPPINGTOWER

SETTLJNGBASINS(OPEN)

RLTERS

aN>

(/> O~no> rs>

CLEARWELL

X XQ

WASHWATERTANK

HIGHSERVICEPUMPS

EAU CLARE WATER TREATMENT PLANTPROCESS ALTERNATIVE: EXJSTWGPOTASSIUM PERMANGANATE OXDATION

Dot*

6/20/94

Dgur*

Page 19: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

STACK SAMPLING PORT

ACID/HYPOCHLORITEWASH FEED INLET

RAW WATER INLET

DIFFERENTIAL PRESSUREGAUGE

ACID/HYPOCHLORITEADDITION INLET

MIST ELIMINATOR

INLET DISTRIBUTION HEADER

WEIR-TROUGH DISTRIBUTOR

BED LIMITER

PACKING SUPPORT

48" WIDE X 36" HIGH AIR INLET

HIGH LEVEL SWITCH

PRESSURE TRANSDUCER

TOWER EFFLUENT PIPEVESSEL I.D.

FIGURE 3-1CROSS SECTION OF PACKED TOWERSCITY OF EAU CLAIRE

-16-

Page 20: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

eder associates

I 1Q £

fiu -3O .&* -8

CO0.2

IaON

tv

•5<oS&G2I<L>S

1S

a>E•<— »Cd

' £•MUi2cd£«

J3+->O•*— >•*-»O

_3

1.c50CO

1•4—t

'iT34^JW

odpr

• •

O•<_>ac0CO

21sexc

*^4

T3228-

[ tow

ers

(

31

&1o£

•*.<j=<c^o(N

X

£2'-6d(N

_co

ed'•5a>

iiCO

flUiu11w

ex00oooor^5£cd.£2&'i&o•&1i^ob

r-00o\

ts&0=r<tgc

'-*— >

2&00<u

PQ

cdrir*A\o**>n^

^^

*O

co

"S^E£Ui

i.o1o.1

c ao ••-•3 <2«

^12

1V

2CO1100

m2ex

I+•>COUj

'3

1tsex

ex

100

CO

OO

•2ccdUi

1O•&

%Cd<u(4-1O

t12•o8,exCO'if^•4

0>s

cd

o>£

1•a1exC3

£2

CO*^N

Ui

*ed(4-1OC

«S«O

A

'•O<N

2&•j>• VN

"1

1CO

'5«a

ex

12T3VCO

PUicd

aexo4

«s

2CO

•aUigs(UD

* tiC cd0 U

2"w«a

1f§D•5

IUi

3iTD

1'S

COUi

'cd

1•V

C<u1£00c'§Q

ul

!213w

-17-

Page 21: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

Mt < IMCULCV AbCA*« (-,»o« tnrcr «) | •

"'I"_._.-•••••• . . . -—L

Page 22: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

IIIIIIIIIIII1J

eder associates

Bi

ower Dimensions

Packjn-.;

Tower C.

Area =

Volume

crating Conditions

Case (1

Water F

Air Faw

Air/Wa-

Case(2

Water ;

Tempera-

jred Air/Water arc

/OC RawW

-DCE

-DCA

EAU CLAIRE WELL FIELD

AIR STRIPPING ANALYSIS

26 ft

= 12 ft

Current Conditions

0 gpm (521 cfm) or ( 5.616 Mgd Each )

rfm

3.6

oposed Conditions

gpm (668 cfm) or (7.200Mgd Each)

,'6.r

-actor (R)

Date Effluent Detection Limit(ppb) (ppb)

3/1/94 ND

4/11/94 ND

8/5/94 ND

8/5/94 ND

0.3 AWR

0.2 A/WR

0.3 A/WR

0.2 A/WR

Case(1)

5.62 MgdND

21.7

172.3

103.7

112.5

Case (2)

7.20 MgdND

21.7

182.4

114.1

133

-19-

Page 23: EDER ASSOC PC - PRESENTATION 12/06/94 NORTH WELL FIELD ... · air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only. | • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells

. " eder associates

CONCLUSIONSEau Claire Municipal Well Field

• In 1994, VOCs in Wells 11, 15, 16, and 17 showedsignificant decreases caused by the plume blocking effect ofpumping Well 19. VOCs are not detected in Well 10.

• VOCs are consistently below MCLs in the air stripper| influent (Wells 10, 11, 15, 16, 17, and 19). Therefore, the

air stripper currently provides a fail-safe only.

| • After 5 years of pumping Well 19 continuously, VOCs in. Wells 11, 15, 16, and 17 will be non-detect and will not

require air stripping.I•^ • After 5 years, air stripping will only be needed for well 19,. which would only require one of the two stripping towers.

I • The air stripper can treat more than 10,000 gpm (14.4 mgd)• at the current VOC concentrations, which would permit the. addition of wells in any area of the plume to meet future

demands.I• 497-OS002 -20- IJ/S/94