Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    1/22

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    2/22

    (http://o!therecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-

    boston-project/)

    It was one of those early May mornings so typical of New York City. Bright sunshine and a cold,

    fresh breeze that blew occasional clouds and rain showers over the streets of Riverdale. Not

    quite springtime but a promise that it was on its way. And then the phone rang and the cloudssuddenly darkened.

    I have some bad news said the voice on the other end. But before I say anything you must

    promise me. Keep me out of this. It was a friend at Boston College where from 2001 to 2006 I

    had been director of an oral history project set up to collect interviews with participants from

    both sides of the conflict in Northern Ireland.

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    2 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    3/22

    The e!ort to include the

    police had been stillborn

    but we had created an

    historically valuable if

    small project

    The IRA ceasefire and the 1998 Good Friday Agreement had made the idea possible; Boston

    College had made an indirect approach, asking for ideas for projects it could fund to mark the

    historic moment. I suggested creating an oral history archive that would collect the accounts of

    activists from all sides of the conflict, from paramilitaries to police; it would be a view of

    Irelands most traumatic quarrel from a grassroots level and the college was enthusiastic. We

    both agreed, it should be done quickly before time and age made it impossible. And we agreed

    security for the participants was paramount.

    Discussions started with the college in the summer of 2000 and

    by early the following year the archive was under way. By 2006,

    when college funding ended, archives with IRA and Ulster

    Volunteer Force interviews (the UVF was the most violent

    Loyalist/Protestant group) had been created. The effort toinclude the police had been stillborn but we had created an

    historically valuable if small project, one that would provide

    many insights to historians.

    Gallons of ink have been spilled detailing the dispute between myself, the Irish researchers and

    Boston College over whether false guarantees were knowingly given to participants. My view

    was then and still is that the college had underwritten a guarantee that the interviewees had sole

    rights over access until their death, that it would be safe from hostile intrusion, particularlyfrom a foreign government. This was an American archive after all and was it conceivable that

    Washington would allow foreigners to invade and pillage it?

    What we did not know until only recently, thanks to an investigation carried out by the

    Washington-based Chronicle of Higher Education (http://chronicle.com/article/Secrets-

    from-Belfast/144059/), was that a promise given to us by BC back in 2001 that the crucial

    donor contract would be vetted by the colleges lawyers was a lie. The donor contract as we

    wrote it guaranteed confidentiality until death, in other words that no-one except theinterviewee could access the interviews. If the contract has been vetted, as we were told it would

    be and later that it had been, the contract should have included a health warning; we would

    certainly have withdrawn from the project had that happened and I would not be writing this

    account. But it hadnt been vetted, we had been given a false promise. We had been misled;

    there was no vetting.

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    3 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    4/22

    The colleges hostility to

    me deepened and as time

    passed and our criticism

    of the colleges cowardice

    intensi"ed

    But less attention has been paid to the character of the response of one of Americas

    more prestigious colleges to the threat to academic freedom, as well as to the wellbeing of

    those who had agreed to take part in its project, posed by subpoenas served by the DoJ

    on behalf of Northern Irish police in 2011. How did Boston College acquit itself in one of

    the most consequential struggles ever between government and academe in the US?

    So back to that May 2011 phone call. My friend had called to tell me that a subpoena had

    just been served on behalf of the British authorities seeking two interviews, both with

    former IRA figures, Brendan Hughes and Dolours Price. Hughes was dead and at his request

    a book Voices From The Grave had been published, based on his recollections; Price was

    still alive. But the friend was nervous. We, the Irish researchers, were not supposed to know

    about the subpoena, he said. It was being kept a tightly guarded secret inside the college even

    from those who had most to lose. That alarmed me even more than the news that a supposedlyinviolable archive had been invaded.

    I put in a series of calls to the colleges legal counsel, Nora Field. I had only one question to ask,

    at least initially: was Boston College going to resist the subpoena? Each call was met with a

    similar response: she was busy, she couldnt get to the phone and so on. So I called the college

    librarian, Bob ONeill, explained what I knew and asked him to get a message to Field, I needed

    to speak to her about the subpoena.

    He never called back, so I phoned him only to hear him admit what I already suspected. Boston

    Colleges legal counsel did not want to speak to me even though the subpoena could put the lives

    and freedom of our interviewees at risk. Since I only wanted to discover if the college would

    fight, her silence told me all I needed to know. I had also heard that sentiment in the counsels

    office was edging towards an immediate handover; people there, I was told, were saying things

    like .these people (the interviewees) were just a bunch of terrorists anyway.

    So, I picked up the phone and called Jim Dwyer at the New

    York Times, an experienced and skilled Irish-American reporter

    who would understand the gravity of the situation and its

    implications. The next morning the story was on the front page.

    By the beginning of the following week Boston College had

    hired an outside attorney; the tactic of shaming them into a

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    4 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    5/22

    fight had worked but at a cost. The colleges hostility to me deepened and as time passed and

    our criticism of the colleges cowardice intensified so did the antagonism to me and to Anthony

    McIntyre, the lead IRA researcher.

    In the months and years that followed I would often have cause to recall a story that HarveySilverglate, that venerable champion of civil liberties in Massachusetts, told me. Bob Drinan

    was a Jesuit priest who had been president of Boston Colleges law school back in the 1970s and

    had been elected to Congress on an anti-Vietnam war ticket. Had Drinan still been around when

    the subpoenas were served, Harvey said, he would have removed them from the archive, locked

    them in his office safe and defied the federal government to come and get them. And he would

    have mobilised the Jesuit Order and all of Boston Colleges not inconsiderable legal, financial,

    academic and political resources to resist the intrusion, all the things the modern Boston

    College lamentably failed to do. They were frightened of the fines the federal government couldimpose, he explained.

    So this story is as much the tale of an altered American academe in which the business model

    has replaced the place of learning and research.

    A week or so later the IRA researcher Anthony McIntyre and the UVF interviewer

    Wilson McArthur and myself had a conference call with the college librarian Bob ONeill, who

    kept the archive, and Tom Hachey who headed up the Center for Irish Programs. Hachey,a close friend of the college president, Fr William Leahy, also a Jesuit, was in charge of

    the project. The call was notable for two things: the two academics were keen to know what we

    remembered about the guarantees of confidentiality each had given us, as if they wanted to

    know what our defence would be, and it would be last contact any of us had with them. In

    subsequent weeks phone calls and emails to them went unanswered.

    With one exception. We were worried that there could be more subpoenas and to avoid that, we

    asked, surely the remaining interviews could be moved to a location outside the reach of the

    British? I wrote to Hachey and ONeill suggesting that the archive be relocated to the south of

    Ireland, to McIntyres home. He had vowed never to surrender the interviews and anyone who

    knew him would realise he meant it.

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    5 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    6/22

    Anthony McIntyre was a lead researcher on the Boston Project. (Click for image source)

    The British would have to launch a legal action in hostile territory and the odds were that the

    interviews could be safeguarded. But the two men refused, citing an interview I had given to the

    Boston Globe saying that if the other interviews were really in danger they should be destroyed.

    I still believe that in preference to a handover that was an acceptable option but if the archive

    had been moved it could have been safely preserved and kept out of British hands. We never

    heard another word from Hachey and ONeill.

    In August 2011, the Boston Globe published an editorial urging Boston College to handthe tapes over and I immediately emailed Hachey and ONeill asking if the college

    would respond. There was no reply. The refusal to relocate the archive was a bad sign, this

    was even worse. The college had agreed to fight, or rather had been forced to, but it

    was becoming clear there was no enthusiasm for the struggle. The signals from Boston

    College to the British were clear: they were pushing at an open door.

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    6 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    7/22

    So unsurprisingly, the same month a second subpoena was served, as we had feared, asking for

    any and all interviews that mentioned Jean McConville, the widowed mother-of- ten whose

    abduction and disappearing by the IRA in 1972 over allegations that she was an informer was

    supposedly the reason for the legal action. (It should be noted that prior to this the authorities

    cared so little for her that for the best part of twenty years her death had not even been

    classified as murder and there had never been an investigation into her killing worthy of the

    name. When I revealed the story back in 2002, (in my book A Secret History of the IRA)

    essentially the same story allegedly contained in the archive, the police showed no interest at

    all.)

    In the interim, McIntyre and myself had penned a reply to the Globe editorial and we

    soon discovered how this had enraged the administration at Boston College. On August

    17th, 2011 we received an email from the colleges attorney informing us about thesecond subpoena and telling us that the previous day the colleges response had been filed

    with the court. It was too late for our input and the message was clear: we were being excluded

    from the case.

    The next day another email from the attorney arrived. It read: Ed Boston College asked me to

    remind you that my keeping you informed about developments in the case is with your

    agreement that you will not go to the media about the information, but let us proceed with the

    court process. We were being punished because we had dared criticise the Boston Globe foradvocating surrender to the PSNI.

    So to summarise: the colleges lawyer had refused to speak to me when the subpoenas were

    served and if the college had got its way the first we would have known about the matter was

    when people were arrested in Belfast; I had been forced to go to the New York Times to compel

    and embarrass Boston College to fight; the two people at the college we had trusted most had

    cut us off and the college was refusing to publicly criticise the British action. Now we were being

    muzzled and sidelined, told to keep our mouths shut or suffer the consequences.

    The college was abdicating the fight outside the courtroom and signaling furiously that it didnt

    care much about the fight inside it. As that email indicated, Boston College was refusing to

    organise a campaign to protest the subpoenas. Anyone who has experienced this sort of ordeal

    can tell you that you win or lose outside the courtroom as much as inside. It was time for

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    7 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    8/22

    action.

    We asked Eamonn Dornan, a Queens, New York-based, Irish-American attorney who also

    practises as a barrister in Belfast and Dublin if he would represent us on a pro bono basis. He

    agreed and set about filing pleas to establish our standing in the case. Jim Cotter in Bostonagreed to represent our interests there, again on a pro bono basis, and thanks to Harvey

    Silverglate, the Massachusetts ACLU joined the team. Our gratitude to all these lawyers was in

    direct proportion to our dismay over Boston Colleges behavior.

    By this point Irish-American groups, the Ancient Order of Hibernians, the Brehon Law Society

    and the Irish-American Unity Conference, had joined the campaign. These groups were alarmed

    at the consequences for the peace accords and for the architect of the IRAs peace process

    strategy, Gerry Adams who we all agreed was the real target of the British action. Their firstachievement was to recruit John Kerry, then the Massachusetts-based chairman of the Senate

    Foreign Relations Committee, now Secretary of State. He issued a statement urging Hilary

    Clinton to intervene, to get the British to withdraw the subpoenas in order to protect the Good

    Friday Agreement, the deal that had been brokered in large part thanks to the efforts of

    Presidents Clinton and George W Bush.

    Gerry Adams who we all agreed was the real target of the British action

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    8 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    9/22

    The striking thing about Kerry is that he is a graduate of Boston College Law School but it was

    Irish-Americans who recruited him, not Boston College. I later lobbied Kerrys successor in

    Washington Robert Menendez and discovered Boston College had never been near him. Not

    only was Boston College boycotting this campaign but there was no effort that we could see to

    mobilise other colleges to the cause; some people suggested that it was actually discouraging

    them and while we never had evidence of that theres no doubt that had Boston College tried, a

    well organised effort could have galvanized American academe; after all the subpoenas

    potentially had enormously negative consequences for scholars.

    The first court challenge was in December 2011 at the Federal District court in Boston, in front

    of Judge William Young who had presided over the trial of the shoe-bomber, Richard Reid.

    No-one expected success here. The important phase would be the appeal, in front of the First

    Circuit based in Boston and then perhaps at the Supreme Court.

    As expected we lost but within days Boston College announced it would not appeal. We had

    fallen at the first hurdle and now the college was abandoning the fight.

    But worse was to come. After Judge Young ruled against the college he then had the task of

    deciding which interviews were responsive to the subpoena, in other words which interviews

    should be handed over. His first instinct was to ask the college to undertake that task; after all

    Bob ONeill would be familiar with the archives contents given that he was its custodian.

    When he called his court to order in late December 2012, Judge Young was presented with a

    sealed affidavit by the Boston College attorney. We only know its contents because the

    subsequent interaction between an astonished Judge Young and the college attorney was

    witnessed by Jim Cotter, our attorney. The affidavit, he learned, contained the extraordinary

    claim from ONeill that he could not help the court because he had not read the interviews!

    I knew this was a lie because ONeill and myself had often discussed the interviews and it was

    always evident to me that the librarian was so familiar with their contents because he had read

    them, as indeed he was duty bound to do.

    The true purpose of the colleges ploy soon became evident. The college attorney suggested that

    instead the court should approach Anthony McIntyre in Ireland to ask for his guidance. Given

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    9 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    10/22

    Extravagant lies about

    myself and Anthony

    McIntyre have

    characterised Boston

    Colleges campaign

    against ourselves

    that six years had elapsed since the project had ended McIntyre could hardly be expected to

    remember such fine detail but anyway he took a principled stand, in contrast to ONeill, saying

    he refused to co-operate in the betrayal of his sources.

    And of course that opened the way for Boston College to lay the blame on McIntyre for whatfollowed. Judge Young announced that since no-one from the college would help him, he would

    take the entire archive into his custody and read them over the Christmas vacation.

    All 186 interviews were removed from the colleges sealed archive, the sanctity and security of a

    confidential collection of interviews sacrificed entirely unnecessarily. In his final judgement the

    true cost of Boston Colleges temerity became evident. Judge Young ruled that if an interviewee

    had given say 15 interviews but only one mentioned Jean McConville, all fifteen would be

    handed over. The total was 85 interviews; in Belfast the police were undoubtedly licking theirlips. It was a disaster directly caused by Boston Colleges cowardice.

    ONeill and Hachey then wrote an Op-Ed piece for the Irish Times blaming McIntyre for this

    mass handover.

    Shifting blame away from the college onto ourselves for everything that had happened had by

    this stage become the hallmark of the colleges approach to the subpoenas.

    Leading that offensive was the colleges flack, an extraordinarily aggressive individual by the

    name of Jack Dunn, whose attitude towards the truth was that it was an inconvenient obstacle

    in his way, to be discarded, ignored or shaped to fit whatever narrative was necessary. Nor did

    he bother too much with due diligence.

    Not long after the District Court hearing, Dunn gave an

    interview to the Irish state television station RTE, alleging that

    a book I had written, Voices From The Grave, based on the

    interviews given by Brendan Hughes had been inspired by

    financial greed. (The truth was that the book was written to

    fulfill a promise given by McIntyre: when Hughes was

    interviewed he knew he was dying and he asked that his

    account be published after his death.)

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    0 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    11/22

    ONeill and Hachey were excited by the prospect. Faber agreed to publish it and the two

    academics asked to share the byline with myself; I was agreeable but Faber baulked, preferring

    a single byline by an author who was known in Ireland and the UK for his coverage of the IRA.

    Instead the two academics agreed to write the foreword.

    They also asked that Boston College share the royalties equally with myself; 50 per cent for me

    and 50 per cent to be given to ONeills library and Hacheys Irish Institute. I happily assented

    to the deal and the only extra payment I received was an advance of some $13-14,000 to write

    the book.

    The problem was that neither man had told Jack Dunn, or it seems anyone else in authority at

    Boston College. Dunn went on RTE to announce: I think quite frankly that Mr Moloney was so

    excited about this project and quite frankly so eager to write a book from which he would profitthat he chose to ignore the obvious statements that were made to him including a contract he

    had signed expressing the limitations of confidentiality.

    Unfortunately for Dunn there was an email record to substantiate my account; this showed that

    ONeill and Hachey had asked my agent and through him Faber, to share the byline and had

    then cut a deal to share royalties equally with myself. RTE broadcast a corrected version and on

    the programme Dunn was forced to admit that he had only learned the truth from ONeill the

    day before.

    The story didnt end there. The royalties were supposed to go into BC accounts but didnt; the

    money instead ended up in the private bank accounts of Hachey & ONeill and I have the bank

    records and emails to prove it. Even so, Dunn is still repeating this canard about the book and

    my role in it. Extravagant lies about myself and Anthony McIntyre have characterised Boston

    Colleges campaign against ourselves for compelling the college to fight the subpoenas even to

    the limited extent they did.

    Getting a bang for its buck was, with hindsight, always a priority for Boston College and this

    explains why the folks there were so happy at the prospect of having a book published and so

    eager to bask in the reflected glory after it was published. It also explains why and how the

    project ended.

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    1 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    12/22

    Towards the end of the academic year in 2006, I received a phone call from Tom Hachey. Do

    you think, he asked, that there might be a chance that the interviewees would agree to change

    their contracts, so their interviews could be made public while they were still alive? The

    significance of that question is that it demonstrates that Boston College had no evident legal

    worries about interviewee confidentiality. While that served to reinforce our confidence in the

    projects safety, I refused on the grounds that we had given our word and that breaking it would

    mean participants facing a vengeful IRA.

    Hachey then traveled to Belfast and met the two researchers who gave him the same response.

    A few weeks later we were told the college was ending its funding; the project would be closed

    down. Would the response have been different if we had agreed to Hacheys request? I dont

    know but I suspect the answer is yes.

    After the District Court setback, we and the Irish-American groups lambasted Boston College

    for their cowardice in refusing to take the case to appeal. A shamed college eventually

    announced it would challenge Judge Youngs decision to hand over so many interviews but not

    his ruling to accept the subpoena. It was rather like the condemned man arguing with the

    hangman over the length of the rope; he would still die but perhaps a little slower. Boston

    College won that appeal, thankfully; but it was all so unnecessary. We took our claim to enter

    the case to the doorstep of the Supreme Court but failed to get a hearing. Last Fall, the

    remaining interviews, reduced from 85 to eleven were handed over.

    I have always believed that if Boston College had thrown its full weight behind the campaign to

    resist the subpoenas we might well have won; at the very least the message would have gone out

    from American academe that US colleges were ready to fight to guard the confidentiality of their

    research subjects, especially from a foreign power. Instead the signal has been sent that they

    will in all probability be abandoned. Who now in their right mind would agree to participate in a

    controversial research project in America, especially any dealing with its recent conflicts and

    wars?

    Ed Moloney

    Go to top

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    2 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    13/22

    Ed Moloney (http://o!therecordni.com/author/moloneyed/)

    Ed Moloney is an Irish journalist who now lives and works in New York

    City. For most of his professional life he covered the Troubles in

    Northern Ireland, writing for the Irish Times and the Sunday Tribune.

    Moloney is the author of three books dealing with aspects of the Irish

    Troubles, A Secret History of the IRA (2007), Paisley: From Demagogue

    to Democrat? (2008) and Voices from the Grave: Two Mens War in

    Ireland (2010)

    More Posts (http://offtherecordni.com/author/moloneyed/) - Website

    (http://thebrokenelbow.com/about-ed-moloney/)

    Share this:

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=twitter&nb=1)!4

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project

    /?share=facebook&nb=1)"

    1

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=reddit&nb=1)

    #

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=pinterest&nb=1)$

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/#print)%

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project

    /?share=stumbleupon&nb=1)&

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=pocket&nb=1)'

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=google-

    plus-1&nb=1)(

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=tumblr&nb=1))

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=email&nb=1)*

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    3 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    14/22

    Featured (http://o!therecordni.com/category/featured/), Politics (http://o!therecordni.com/category

    /politics/)

    Toggle comments [ 0 ] "

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=digg&nb=1)+

    (http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-college-and-me-a-personal-account-of-the-boston-project/?share=linkedin&nb=1),

    Like this:

    Like

    Be the first to like this.

    !

    AUTHOR SPOTLIGHT

    Ed Moloney

    (http://o!therecordni.com/author/moloneyed/)

    Ed Moloney is an Irish journalist who now lives and works in New York City. For most of his professional lifehe covered the Troubles in Northern Ireland, writing for the Irish Times and the Sunday Tribune. Moloney is

    the author of three books dealing with aspects of the Irish Troubles, A Secret History of the IRA (2007),

    Paisley: From Demagogue to Democrat? (2008) and Voices from the Grave: Two Mens War in Ireland

    (2010)

    Also by Ed Moloney (60) (http://o!therecordni.com/author/moloneyed/)

    RECENT POSTS

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    4 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    15/22

    (http://o!therecordni.com/brian-john-spencer-by-failing-to-encourage-diversity-of-opinion-and-idea-unionism-disempowers-itself/)

    Brian John Spencer | By failing to encourage diversity of opinion andidea, unionism disempowers itself (http://o!therecordni.com/brian-john-spencer-by-failing-to-encourage-diversity-of-opinion-and-idea-unionism-disempowers-itself/)

    August, 2014

    One point repeatedly made in the Israel-Gaza debate has been, as Ed OLoughlin said, that it is eminently possible to

    Read More (http://o!therecordni.com/brian-john-spencer-by-failing-to-encourage-diversity-of-opinion-

    and-idea-unionism-disempowers-itself/)

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    5 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    16/22

    (http://o!therecordni.com/dr-orna-young-attacking-another-person-for-their-identity-speaks-more-to-a-lack-of-con"dence-in-your-own/)

    Dr Orna Young | Attacking another person for their identity speaksmore to a lack of con"dence in your own (http://o!therecordni.com/dr-orna-young-attacking-another-person-for-their-identity-speaks-more-to-a-lack-of-con"dence-in-your-own/)

    August, 2014

    You would be forgiven for thinking in the wake of the recent hate crimes in east Belfast that the

    Read More (http://o!therecordni.com/dr-orna-young-attacking-another-person-for-their-identity-speaks-

    more-to-a-lack-of-con"dence-in-your-own/)

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    6 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    17/22

    FOLLOW OTR ON TWITTER

    (http://o!therecordni.com/audio-we-discuss-the-resignation-of-jim-dowson-what-will-he-do-next/)

    Audio: We discuss the resignation of Jim Dowson What will he donext? (http://o!therecordni.com/audio-we-discuss-the-resignation-of-jim-dowson-what-will-he-do-next/)

    August, 2014

    A "ve-minute segment from our weekly podcast For Pod and Ulster, we discuss Jim Dowson ex BNP fundraiser,

    Read More (http://o!therecordni.com/audio-we-discuss-the-resignation-of-jim-dowson-what-will-he-do-

    next/)

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    7 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    18/22

    Podcasts!

    Fantastic article on @crackedon the alarming rate of suicide incomedy. 'Why Funny People Kill Themselves' |cracked.com/quick-fixes/ro

    Off The Record@offtherecordNI

    Expand

    Edward Snowden: The untold story of the most wanted man inthe world wrd.cm/1sY07tH

    Retweeted by Off The Record

    WIRED @WIRED

    Show Summary

    @offtherecordNIso many staff who raise concerns have told usthat telling their story to the media was the only option they had

    Retweeted by Off The Record

    PatientsFirstNI@PatientsFirstNI

    Expand

    @offtherecordNIfor example if a nurse contacts a trust or RQIAthere is a fear once their employer finds out they will be victimised

    Retweeted by Off The Record

    PatientsFirstNI@PatientsFirstNI

    Expand

    39m

    1h

    1h

    1h

    Tweets Follow

    Tweet to @offtherecordNI

    (

    unionism-disempowers-itself/

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    8 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    19/22

    (http://o!therecordni.com/the-otr-culture-

    podcast-episode-one-the-phantom-podcast/)

    The OTR Culture Podcast! Episode One(http://o!therecordni.com/the-otr-culture-podcast-episode-one-the-phantom-podcast/)

    August, 2014

    (http://o!therecordni.com/for-pod-and-ulster-

    podcast-11-obamas-iron-dome/)

    For Pod and Ulster Podcast 11 Obamas Iron Dome(http://o!therecordni.com/for-pod-and-ulster-podcast-11-obamas-iron-dome/)

    August, 2014

    (http://o!therecordni.com/for-pod-and-ulster-

    special-our-10th-anniversary/)

    For Pod and Ulster SPECIAL Our10th Anniversary

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    9 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    20/22

    (http://o!therecordni.com/for-pod-and-ulster-special-our-10th-anniversary/)

    July, 2014

    (http://o!therecordni.com/for-pod-and-ulster-

    things-can-only-get-better/)

    For Pod and Ulster Things CanOnly Get Better(http://o!therecordni.com/for-pod-and-ulster-things-can-only-get-better/)

    July, 2014

    NEXT POST

    Brian John Spencer | Byfailing to encouragediversity of opinion andidea, unionism

    disempowers itself(http://o!therecordni.com/brian-john-spencer-by-failing-to-encourage-

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    20 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    21/22

    diversity-of-opinion-and-idea-unionism-disempowers-itself/)

    by Brian John Spencer

    About O!The Record

    O!the Record is an online magazine based in Northern

    Ireland covering politics, arts, culture and comment.

    Founded by Jason Murdock and Jason Ashford in 2013,

    originally as a print publication, we aim to provide fresh,

    exciting and relevant content. You can reach us on Twitter

    (@o!therecordni) or contact us via email

    ([email protected]). Thank you for reading! Viva la

    OTR!

    Categories

    Select Category

    Contributor Sign In

    Register (http://o!therecordni.com

    /wp-login.php?action=register)

    Log in (http://o!therecordni.com/wp-login.php)

    Entries RSS (Really Simple Syndication)

    (http://o!therecordni.com/feed/)

    Comments RSS (Really Simple Syndication)

    (http://o!therecordni.com/comments/feed/)

    WordPress.org (https://wordpress.org/)

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle

    21 of 22 13/08/2014 0

  • 8/11/2019 Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal account of the Boston Project | Off The Record

    22/22

    (http://www.queens"lmtheatre.com/)

    Ed Moloney: Boston College and Me | A personal acc... http://offtherecordni.com/ed-moloney-boston-colle