Upload
kristen-dailey-ahlers
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
1/39
Action Research Project
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom?
Western New England University
Kristen DaileyED 601
Research for TeachersJune 8, 2013
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
1
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
2/39
Research Question:
This study sought to pursue the correlations that exist between teacher's wardrobe and
the relationships and perceptions that they maintain. The basis of this study was formed
around one key question, specifically, does a teacher's dress code have any influence upon
student and teacher relationships? The hypothesis was that clothing shapes first impressions,
but that other factors change the dynamics of student / teacher relationships. The core of this
project aimed to answer whether or not a dress code for teachers is merited, to examine how
the clothing we wear influences the ways in which our students perceive us as professionals,
and to explore and develop whether what we wear as educators has a direct influence on the
ways in which we interact with our students.
Background:
My current workplace has few limitations for faculty dress code, and there are great
differences in the ways that the teachers dress. While some of the teachers come to school in
dresses, skirts, and collared shirts, others come in flip flops and jeans. I am curious to
explore what impression this gives the students about the staff.
With no formal dress code for teachers in place at my school, teachers are permitted
to wear whatever they like, from Bermuda shorts to flip flops. I was interested to see if I
could highlight any direct correlation between faculty dress and student behavior, and to
assess whether or not students pay much attention to what their teachers are wearing. Often,
rules are difficult to enforce at my school, particularly in terms of the student uniform. Can I
reasonably question a student's sandaled feet when some of my colleagues are also wearing
flip-flops? Should I challenge a rogue bra strap peeking out of a student's shirt when another
teacher is dressed similarly? The students are required to wear uniforms Monday through
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
2
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
3/39
Thursday, and Friday is free dress day. I wonder if the school environment would change if
teachers had to adhere to similar rules.
This study uses surveys of students and teachers from the International School of
Monagas in Maturn, Venezuela. I also solicited responses from teachers I know who are
teaching in places other than Venezuela. Several of my past students also completed a
survey; they too are located in places other than Venezuela. In total, I received 62 student
responses from Venezuela, 11 from the United States, 1 from Canada and 3 from Taiwan.
The survey for teachers did not include a question of where they were located.
Review of Literature:
Clothing choices lead to personal style. The stores frequented and the purchases
made can help distinguish anyone as an individual. Whether a distinct pair of earrings, a
penchant for prints or pocket squares, or a bow-tiemost people enjoy a certain level of
personalization to a wardrobe. The clothing worn by educators is noticed by the students;
this is a point reinforced by numerous studies.
With stories of students like Jeff Bliss, the current viral sensation who questions the
role of his teacher in a world history classroom, it is important to reflect upon the fact that
our students are thinking, breathing people who look to us to guide them through their
academic experiences. Perhaps this student presents a valid criticism of his teacher; only
those in the classroom can really make a sound judgement. Perhaps he is just a disgruntled
adolescent who has fallen into the seemingly easy tendency to blame teachers for his own
student apathy. The message we can take from this is a simple one. Our students are
watching. They notice our behavior, the work we assign, the materials we present and the
clothing we wear.
The issue of profession attire in an educational setting is not a new one. Images of
high-collared, stocking clad school teachers reference another time; high heeled shoes have
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
3
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
4/39
given way to ballet flats, and many men have cast aside their jackets and ties for a tucked-in
polo shirt and khaki pants. Students seated in teacher-preparation classes are advised to
dress professionally, to present themselves in a fashion which will command a level of
respect from their own students. Some schools within the United States have adopted formal
dress code policies for teachers, while others call into question whether or not it is a
violation of one's rights as an individual. In some instances, unions have stepped forward to
challenge these policies.
Although there has been an ongoing conversation about professional attire and
clothing choices for educators, there is little formal research which addresses this specific
topic. Some of the research supports the premise that teachers who are dressed formally are
viewed in higher esteem than their less well-dressed colleagues, while others suggest that a
teacher's wardrobe has little direct correlation to command in the classroom.
This review is presented with limitations. Much of the material found speaks to a
population of students in university settings, while the subject of this action research project
seeks to focus on high school students. Another limitation that manifested during the
research for this review was that much of the existing data is dated and consequently
unavailable.
Much of the literature which exists on this topic supports the premise that teachers
who are dressed formally are perceived in the most positive way. According to Morris,
Gorham, Cohen & Huffman (1996), a study done by Rollman in 1980 determined that
"teachers dressed formally were seen as more organized, knowledgeable and better
prepared; those dressed informally were seen as more friendly, flexible, sympathetic, fair and
enthusiastic than the other modes of dress. Males were rated as most stimulating in
moderately formal attire, and both males and females score highest on perceived clarity in
the moderately formal condition(137). This stands as one example among several which
support the idea that dressing formally puts forth a greater perception. The disconnect
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
4
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
5/39
occurs, it seems, in terms of approachability; this study suggests that those dressed more
casually gain more friendship points. Perhaps this is what caused faculty attire to yield to
more casual selections.
Rollman's study, like many of the others referenced, was conducted more than thirty
years ago. Today's classroom hosts students quite different from those thirty years their
senior. Today's students are unfamiliar with a time before the internet, with card catalogs or
VHS tapes. For this reason, one might question how relevant studies conducted with the
students of thirty years ago is for today. Have opinions changed regarding whether or not
teacher attire is important? In a more recent study conducted by Morris et al (1996), guest
lecturers were invited into classrooms wearing various modes of dress from casual to formal.
The findings showed that the instructors dressed more formally had the most consistent
results for "cool" perceptions, such as competence, composure and knowledge. This study
also supports preexisting studies on this topic which suggest that clothing which raises
perceptions in "cool" categories creates a greater distance for students and teachers in the
"warm" categories, which include sociability, extroversion, kindness, empathy and being
interesting. Casually dressed teachers were rated highest in the warm categories. One key
distinction between this present study and others before it is that it evaluates perceptions in a
live context; studies done previously used photographs. The study found that the effects of
attire in a live setting was not as apparent as results found in studies using photographs. It
seems impossible to eliminate the notion that the human factor of a live study introduces
many more variables than clothing alone.
As a way to follow the initial study conducted, Gorham, Cohen, & Morris (1997)
sought to recreate and reevaluate their previous findings the following year. Many of the
variables remained the same; once again psychology classes were used, with a new year
bringing a new pool of students. The modification introduced into this second study was the
idea of teacher immediacy, or behavior. The study determined that their "results parallel
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
5
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
6/39
previous findings (Morris, Gorham, Cohen & Huffman, 1996) that have indicated less
pronounced effects of attire on personal perceptions studied in a live interaction setting
rather than as responses to photographs... behavior was clearly of more importance in
influencing rater judgements" (pgs. 18-19). This brings forth a series of questions. Do the
clothes truly make the man, so to speak? Could a professional wardrobe guarantee academic
engagement while earning respect from the students? Do Birkenstocks and a graphic tee-
shirt ensure that someone is approachable? In education, there are so many factors which
influence the success of a lesson, clothing is just one of them.
Gorham, et al., assembled for a third time to evaluate the role of teacher attire on
student perceptions, with the framework of the study again altered slightly. "The third
principle of attribution concerns homophily, the degree to which two people perceive
themselves as similar to one another. Homophily has been found to be related to voluntary
exposure to communication and the ability to influence (Morris, Gorham, Cohen & Huffman,
1996, 1999, p. 285). As Gorham et al. (1999) predicted, much of the study reinforced
previous findings. In terms of homophily, gender played a large role. "Much of the research
on clothing and person perceptions concludes that females are more responsive to clothing
cues than are males" (p. 292). Findings suggest that in addition to perceptions formed by
one's gender, age was influential in the results of this study. After three studies, the team has
determined that conventions of dressing for success do not have a direct correlation to
student perceptions of instructors in a university setting; "based on findings...we are
convinced that conventional wisdom does not in this case apply" (Morris, Gorham, Cohen &
Huffman, 1996, 1999, p. 296).
Experts within the field of education suggest that clothing does, in fact, matter. While
a great deal of the information is anecdotal, the volume of people speaking to this concept
suggests that it is worth reflecting upon. Ronald Lemos (2007), for example, claims that "[f]
ormality provides a useful structure for helping students accomplish their academic
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
6
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
7/39
objectives" (p. 46). Perhaps he stands as a figurehead for a time rapidly fading into antiquity.
Set against the backdrop of the studies conducted by Gorham et al., Lemos represents the
part of academia wishing to hang onto the formality of a classroom. He claims that "[h]ow
faculty members present themselves in class influences how students respond to them.
Using etiquette in the classroom shows respect for students and demonstrates their
importance" (p. 47). After listing an Emily Post-esque list of dos and don'ts for teachers, he
reaches his point, [if] "you would not do this when presenting a paper at a professional
conference; do not do it during your lectures" (p. 47). Within the field of education exists a
vast span of topics which can be debated and disputed; with the material that currently exists
regarding the issue of teacher attire, it is possible that this may just come down to personal
and professional opinion.
Ronald Lemos is not alone in his support of formality in the classroom. Karen
Thickstun (2007), a music teacher, reinforces the necessity of dressing as a professional in
order to gain the professional respect of others. Sebastian & Bristow (2008) reference studies
which reinforce their ideas. They cite others before them who have determined that formality
in the classroom has favorable results. They reference Molloy (1988), who "inferred that
formal dress strongly affects how people are treated and that formal codes on dress improve
performance, motivation, and attendance. 'We are more likely to believe, respect, and obey
the man who wears a suit than the man who does not...In any level of society, suits are
associated with authority, with position, with power' (Molloy, p. 41)" (Sebastian & Bristow,
2008, p. 196). Research aside, this sentiment is still held by many within the field of
education.
When Sebastian and Bristow conducted their own studies, they concluded, like
Gorham's study before them, that "formal dress led to greater attributions of expertise than
did casual dress, whereas formal dress led to lower feelings of likeability on both indexes
than did casual dress. It can thus be asserted that either style of dress can be effective,
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
7
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
8/39
depending on the professors impression management objectives, in university
classrooms" (p. 200). Research shows that there are many other factors which play into
student perceptions of an educator; perhaps it is nearly impossible to isolate the
presentations of clothing alone to gain a complete understanding of how educators are
perceived.
It is fair to suggest that certain clothing styles immediately lead to a judgement of the
type of person someone is. It may result in whether or not people are deemed intelligent or
trustworth. In the 1950s, John T. Molloy, America's first wardrobe engineer, claimed that
clothing possessed its own psychology. "During his early research, for example, he
discovered that the Boston Strangler invariably wore beige or gray repairman-like outfits; the
light colors tended to reassure housewives and helped him get into their homes" (Time,
1972). He researched the psychological implications that wardrobe had on others and made
an enterprise from it. His interest in this subject was piqued while working as a teacher.
Does this same idea still hold true forty years later?
While existing research may not support the benefits of a professional wardrobe, many
teachers still maintain that dressing up changes the feeling of a school for the better. In 1996,
Joe Catalano and his colleagues from Niagara Falls, New York collectively decided to dress
up on a daily basis to heighten the level of academic expectations from their students. They
chose to do this without a district mandate or suggestion from their administration (Bradley,
1996). It is possible that the key points Molloy was making thirty years earlier still rang true
for the students in Catalano's classroom; that his own presentation of himself as a
professional who took his work seriously had a direct influence on their behavior and
approach to their own educational experiences.
Everyone involved in a classroom setting has opinions about certain rules of conduct.
In public schools, there are often norms stated in handbooks and teacher manuals that
specifically dictate modes of behavior. Prenni and Lord (1992) focus on the differences
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
8
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
9/39
which exist between school administrators and teachers in the clothing discussion. Much of
their findings were anecdotal, articulating the personal preferences of several hundred staff
members, including both administration and faculty. Their findings reinforce the work of
Butler and Roesal (1989), who "found that while the teacher's attire did play a role in student
learning, no single, particular style was better than another" (Prenni and Lord, 1992 p. 581).
This supports the idea that clothing style is often a mode of professional and personal
preference. Even though the research suggests that attire is secondary to the success of a
teacher in a classroom, they point out that "strong differences of opinion between school
administrators and teachers on the appropriate dress for effective teaching tend to exist in the
nation's schools" (p. 579). Overall, this study found teachers and administrators split on the
role clothing plays in the classroom. Million (2004) also found that many administrators
support a professional dress code, "teachers should dress for the business of school" (p. 59).
In a series of studies conducted by Carr, Davies, & Lavin, the question of perception
and attire is again tested. While seeking to determine a correlation between student
perceptions of a professor in terms of professionalism and instructional quality, a study was
done with students in business classes. They found, similarly to the work of Gorham, et al,
that "[i]t has been documented that attire has communicative power and that nonverbal
messages may be much more powerful than the spoken word. As educators strive to prepare
students for their futures, it is important to be mindful of the fact that all which is conveyed
plays a part in the educational process, be it spoken or unspoken" (Carr, Davies, & Lavin,
2009, p. 59). It is clear that other factors reinforce student perceptions of their teachers.
To further their research, Lavin, Carr & Davies (2009) sought to examine perceptions
of professor attire according to gender. The studies demonstrated that opinions of both males
and females were ranked similarly in terms of professional dress. "An examination of the
results indicates that in almost all cases, students had a higher opinion of the model female
instructor when she was depicted in professional attire" (Lavin, Carr, Davies, 2009a, p. 9).
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
9
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
10/39
Similarly, "results presented in this paper suggest that both male and female students
generally had a higher opinion of the model male instructor when he was depicted in
professional attire versus casual or business casual attire" (Lavin, et al., 2009a, p. 11). The
gender difference was presented in professors dressed in casual attire, "[w]hen the sample
was split based on the gender of the respondents, there were significant differences in male
and female student perceptions of male instructors dressed in casual and business casual
attire" (Lavin, et al., 2009b, p. 10). Overall, the two studies determined that women were
more inclined to evaluate a professor favorably, stating that women "rate faculty more highly
than male students do, even when the instructor is not of their own gender" (Lavin, et al.,
2009b, p. 11). The findings of these two research studies conclude that gender plays a role in
student perceptions of professors in the university setting.
How much does our credibility impact our capacity to teach well? Does whether or
not a student views us as a credible source of information influence the way they behave in
class? In a 2010, another study led by Lavin, Carr, & Davies was conducted to examine
perception of the credibility of the professor from clothing. "On the surface, this finding
suggests that students tend to rate the professor, the quality of instruction and the overall
educational experience more positively when the professor's attire is perceived to be
professional when compared to a less professional, more casual instructor
appearance" (Lavin, et al., 2010, p. 51). It appears that the research throughout these studies
is the same, while the points of evaluation change. Additionally, this study focuses upon the
other traits and characteristics that may impact student perceptions of their professors, which
they determine have a significant impact upon the students. These traits include "the
instructors level of preparation, knowledge of the subject matter, and ability to prepare
students for a career" (Lavin, et al., 2010, p. 56). The findings of this study suggest that
professors who are respected and considered more credible than others have less disciplinary
issues from their students. Students who behave make any instructor's life easier.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
10
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
11/39
What other points of judgement are influenced by the clothing educators wear? Carr,
Davies, & Lavin, 2010, reference an earlier study, noting that "Lukavsky, Butler and Harden
(1995) studied the impact of attire on the personal characteristics of approachability,
inflexibility, and respect. They found significant differences in student perceptions of those
three characteristics based on whether the instructor was formally or informally dressed. The
instructor who dressed informally was rated most approachable and most flexible but at the
same time commanded the least amount of respect" (p. 3). While much of the existing
research questions the merits of a professional attire on student perceptions, is it possible that
professional clothing does in fact earn a deeper level of respect from students?
In the ways that our students make judgements about us based upon the clothing we
wear, often teachers make judgements about their students upon these same principles. A
different perspective on the influence of clothing and the perception of others is addressed by
Dorothy Behling, 1995. In contrast to most of the studies presented in this review, she
discusses the ways in which a student's clothing can guide a teacher to make an opinion
about his or her potential and capacity to learn. She references Behling & Williams, 1991,
who suggest "clothing alone can create [a] 'halo effect'." Research indicates individuals who
follow the cultural dress norms (e.g., suits are "good" and ragged jeans and worn t-shirts are
not) are viewed more positively, even being perceived as a student with academic
potential" (p. 11). Could this same philosophy apply to our students' perceptions of their
teachers? Would a well-dressed person not seem more knowledgable and prepared than
their flip-flop wearing, tousled colleagues? In an article by Stacey Patton, 2012, Ernest L.
Gibson III speaks to a different necessity to dress well. He states, "[a]s a person of color, I
feel that I must be 10 times more invested in how I present myself. As one unable to escape
the markers and significations of a black body, I am always aware of the role my race plays in
coloring people's perception of me, especially as an intellectual" (p. 3). If research is correct
and many other factors influence student perceptions of their educators, does Gibson present
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
11
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
12/39
a valid argument? In a profession that is largely represented by people from ethnic
backgrounds other than African-American, are his feelings justified in feeling as if he has a bit
more to prove?
James Lang (2005) directly addresses the motivations for teachers to select the clothing
they do in an opinion essay. "I will confess that I wonder about the motivations of the sharp
dressers. I wonder whether they use sharp dressing as a means to establish their authority
with students: 'Within these pointy shoes are contained the wisdom of the ages. The pointy
shoes make me the boss.' I'm tempted, too, to equate sharp dressing with teaching style.
According to reports from his students, the sharpest-dressed faculty member I ever knew
expensive suits hanging off a sculpted body presented his views forcefully in his
humanities classes, in lecture form, and expected students to repeat those views back to him
on papers and exams" (p. 2). Is it possible that the clothing we wear is in fact reflective of the
teachers we are? Is it fair to equate formality with a formalized, more traditional approach to
education as a whole? Is this a statement we can make about the selection of clothing across
the spectrum?
At this point, current research reinforces that the role of clothing on student
perceptions of their teachers is a limited scope of vision. Our clothing only plays a minimal
role; many other factors determine the relationships we are able to develop with our
students. The studies have demonstrated that there is existing support for both casual
presentation of clothing as well as a formal presentation; one gives the perception that the
subject matter is taken seriously, while the other presents a level of approachability. If the
studies demonstrate that other factors are more important to the ways in which we are
perceived by our students, it seems that teachers can dress the way they feel best works for
them and fill in the gaps later.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
12
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
13/39
Methodology:
The data for this study was collected through two online surveys. One was written
and drafted for teachers (Table 1) to determine feelings about the clothing they wear and
gather opinions on dress codes. The second was written for students. This first portion (Table
2) of the student survey solicited opinions about clothing choices in general; the second
portion (Table 3) presented ten models wearing a variety of outfits, and asked students to
assess the "teacher" based upon the clothing they were wearing.
Two online surveys were used for the purpose of this project. The International School
of Monagas has a relatively small number of students; the entire population of the school is
under two hundred. Creating a survey that was accessible online allowed for a broader range
of students and teachers to provide information, and offered a consistent method of data
collection for all participants.
Students from Venezuela were taken to the computer lab in groups to complete the
student survey. The average time of completion was between ten and twelve minutes.
Several of the students were unable to submit their results as the internet failed, which
presented difficulties. Teacher surveys were solicited through email and an online posting.
The results of both surveys were compiled to try to form an answer about the core
question of this project, assessing whether or not the clothing a teacher wears influences the
perceptions of that teacher held by the students. The surveys provided an opportunity to
conduct research with two populationsteachers and studentsaround a similar topic,
teacher wardrobe.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
13
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
14/39
Teacher Survey: ardrobe
1. What is your gender?
Male
Female
2. What is your age?
18 to 24
25 to 34
35 to 44
45 to 54
55 to 64
65 or older
3. What grade(s) do you teach?K-5, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth
Ninth, Tenth, Eleventh, Twelfth
4. Do you think that teachers' wardrobes influence theway they are perceived by colleagues?
Care to explain?
Yes
Sometimes
Rarely
No
5. Do you think that teachers' wardrobes influence the
way they are perceived by their students?
Care to explain?
Yes
Sometimes
Rarely
No
6. Do you think teachers' wardrobes influence the ways
they are perceived by the parents of their students?
Care to explain?
Yes
Sometimes
Rarely
No
7. Do you feel that student behavior can be influenced by
a teacher's wardrobe?
Care to explain?
Yes
Sometimes
Rarely
No
8. Do you feel that a teacher's wardrobe can influence
student success?
Care to explain?
Yes
Sometimes
Rarely
No
9. Do the clothes you wear influence how professional
you feel?
Care to explain?
Yes
Sometimes
Rarely
No
10. Do you support a dress code for teachers?Yes
No
Table One:SurveyLink to Survey
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
14
https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/M65SXRDhttps://www.surveymonkey.com/s/M65SXRD7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
15/39
Student Survey: Teacher Wa drobe, Part One
1. What is your gender? Male, Female
2. What is your age? 12 or younger
13 to 17
18 to 24
25 to 34
35 or older
3. What grade are you in? K-5
Sixth
Seventh
Eighth
Freshman, Sophomore, Junior, Senior,Undergraduate, Graduate
4. Where in the world are you? (Country, state, etc.) Open Answer
5. How often do you pay attention to what the people
around you are wearing?
Always
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
I don't know
6. How often do you pay attention to what your teachers
are wearing?
Always
SometimesRarely
Never
I don't know
7. When you meet someone new, how much does what
they are wearing influence your first opinion of him or
her?
Very much
A little
Not at all
I don't know
8. Do you think the clothes your teacher wears
influences the way you think about him or her as a
person?
Always
Sometimes
RarelyNever
I don't know
9. Does clothing tell you about someone's personality?
Please explain
Always
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
10. Do your clothes reveal anything about your
personality?
Please explain
Always
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
Table Two: SurveyLink to Survey
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
15
https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/X2WGKFRhttps://www.surveymonkey.com/s/X2WGKFR7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
16/39
For the second part of the survey, students were shown ten individual photographs of models
wearing a variety of clothing combinations. For each photograph they were asked to
respond to the following questions:
Student Survey: Teach r Wardrobe, Part Two
1. What adjectives would you use to describe the
teacher pictured above?
(check all that apply)
Organized, Strict, Kind, Knowledgeable, Distant,
Interesting, Unprofessional, Disorganized, Easygoing,
Mean, Unprepared, Approachable, Boring,
Professional
2. Are there any other adjectives you can think of? Open Answer
3. Would you like it if your teacher dressed this
way?
Care to explain?
Yes
No
No opinion
4. Does this seem like a teacher who would have a
good command of his students?
Yes
No
No opinion
The images below were presented in the survey. They were created using H&M's online
dressing room. They are presented larger in the results portion.
Table Three: Survey
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
16
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
17/39
Weeks Action
Monday, May 6thSunday,May 12th, 2013
1. Review literature.2. Create and prepare materials for data collection: sample photographs, survey
questions, response forms for teachers and students.
Monday, May 13thSunday, May 19th, 2013
1. Contact friends/previous students and solicit involvement from other schools.2. Prepare final copies of survey questions and materials.3. Begin administering surveys in school, and post to Facebook.
Monday, May 20thSunday, May 26th, 2013
1. Conduct research and have students complete surveys and response forms.2. Collect and organize data.
Monday, May 27thSunday, June 2nd 2013
1. Compile and analyze data.2. Create data representationscharts, graphs, etc.3. Determine if professional attire influences student perceptions of their
teachers.
Results/Analysis:
43 teachers completed the survey on teacher wardrobe; twenty-nine are female, and
fourteen male. A majority of the teachers are aged 35-44, and most are high school teachers.
The participants are located in Venezuela, Taiwan, Japan, the United Arab Emirates, Korea,
Oman, Vietnam and the United States.
60.47% of the teachers polled feel that teacher wardrobes influence the ways they are
perceived by their colleagues. 39.53% feel that this is true sometimes. Several comments
suggest that a professional appearance influences the perceptions made about a person's
intelligence and ability to teach and that someone with a professional wardrobe is taken
more seriously. Others suggest that clothing can make a teacher appear too uptight, or too
liberal. Three people commented that once you know someone, looks can be deceiving.
When asked if teacher wardrobes influence the ways that students see teachers,
67.44% chose yes, 27.91% chose sometimes, and 4.65% chose rarely. The comments
section revealed that quite a few teachers feel that this is increasingly more important for
young teachers, as they can use clothing to distance themselves from students who are close
in age. Affirmative numbers rose when addressing whether teachers' wardrobes influence
Table Five: Research Timeline
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
17
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
18/39
the way they are perceived by their students' parents. 74.42% chose yes, 23.26%
sometimes, and only 2.33%, one person, chose rarely. Several of the comments pointed to
the tendency of most teachers to dress up nicely for parent meetings and Back to School
night functions. Others pointed out that adults have a greater consciousness of
professionalism and the need to dress appropriately for school.
The participants of this study were split on whether or not a teacher's wardrobe can
influence student behavior. 32.56% chose yes, 39.53% sometimes, 9.30% rarely and
18.60% no. The comments reflect that personality and rapport with students has a greater
influence than clothing, but dressing too casually may convey a message that the teacher is
not taking the class seriously, so the students do not need to either. A similar split was
demonstrated regarding whether or not a teacher's wardrobe can influence student success.
23.81% chose yes, 30.9% sometimes, 19.05% rarely and 26.19% no. Many of the
comments suggested that a teacher is a role model, and that teachers lead by example; quite
a few of the participants suggest that there are much better ways to motivate students than the
clothing they wear.
68.29% of the teachers polled state that the clothes they wear can influence how
professional they feel. 19.51% said sometimes, 2.44% rarely, and 9.76% no. "When I am
dressed like a teacher, I feel more like a teacher," said one of the participants. Overall, a
greater percentage of participants favor a dress code, with the count coming in 34 to 9. One
flaw in these results occurs because there are so few participants. While responses were
solicited several times, only 43 people completed the survey. This answers indicative of what
was expected.
It would be interesting to develop this study and complete it on a larger, more
international scale. In Japan, all teachers are required to wear suits to school for a large
portion of the year; in the hot months, a "cool biz" dress code is acceptable. In Taiwan,
many of the women tend to wear clothing that is tight, and casual. In Venezuela, a nice pair
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
18
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
19/39
of jeans with high heels is considered dressed up. Examining cultural norms of expectation
for clothing may help to advance this study and give clarity to cultural differences in clothing
style.
The student survey had a total of 77 participants from the United States, Venezuela,
Taiwan and Canada. The participants consisted of, 16 grade 7 students, 9 grade 8 students,
11 students in grade 9, 10 students in grade 10, 12 juniors, 6 seniors, 5 undergraduates, and
7 graduate students. The survey sought to determine student perceptions of teachers based
upon the clothing that they wear. It built upon similar ideas as the teacher survey, while
allowing an opportunity to compile data with a practical application. The data was compiled
using ten different photographs with the same questions for each. Ten images were used to
present both male and female teachers in a range of clothing from very casual to dressy.
Since the participants are mostly in grades 7-12, ten images with the same questions may
have been too many. The rate of skipped questions increased the further into the survey they
got. This age bracket represented the highest rate of skipped questions.
Students were asked to complete a series of questions based upon their observations
of others based upon clothing. 63.64% of students say that they pay attention to what the
people around them are wearing sometimes, and 22.08% said they notice always, 10.39%
rarely, and 3.90% never. 49.35% said that they sometimes notice what their teachers are
wearing, 25.97% always notice, 15.58% rarely notice, and 7.79% never notice. More
females than males chose yes for these two questions, and the only never votes were from
males. The hypothesis for this study considered that clothing would have a greater impact for
first impressions. Only 18.8 % of the students demonstrate that clothing has a great impact
on a first meeting of someone, while a majority of students, 57.14% said that clothing
matters a little. 20.78% suggest that clothing matters not at all in a first impression, and
3.90% said that they don't know whether or not it matters. Many of the comments
suggested that you can often determine how much wealth a person has according to his or
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
19
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
20/39
her clothing. Others indicated that clothing is a good way to convey style, so clothing
provides insight into someone's personality.
When asked specifically about teacher wardrobes, 16% of students said that their
opinions of a teacher are shaped by the clothing he or she wears, 44% suggest that this
occurs sometimes, 24% rarely, and 16% never. The high ranking from sometimes suggests
that largely students use clothing as only one component of judging a teacher. In response to
a question about the correlations between clothing and personality, 16.88% said clothing
always tells about someone's personality, 67.53% sometimes, 10.39% rarely and 5.19%
never. Comments from the students highlight the links between clothing choices and style,
personality and interests. A few point out that looks can be deceiving. When asked about
their own clothing choices in relation to their personalities, 23.38% said their clothing
always reveals something about their personality, 58.44% said sometimes, 11.69% rarely,
and 6.49% said clothing never reveals anything about their personality. In the comments,
students suggest that clothing choices can be indicative of mood; darker colors or
comfortable clothing are more appealing when a person is feeling sad, brighter colors or
dressing up shows when someone is happy.
The charted data below demonstrates the responses yielded from the students
regarding each photograph and their stylistic preferences for each. Each student was asked
to apply a series of adjectives and an opportunity to add additional comments, as well as to
vote whether or not this is how they would like a teacher to dress, and whether or not this
teacher appears like someone who could manage a classroom well. There were few
common themes to draw from the comments sectionoften these yielded perceptions based
upon other factors and building upon stereotypes, for example Asians are smart. Perhaps
with the amount of options provided students had difficulty applying additional terms to each
photograph. Also, as the students worked further through the essay, the amount of comments
rapidly dwindled.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
20
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
21/39
Table Six: Male Teacher Results
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
21
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
22/39
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
22
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
23/39
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
23
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
24/39
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
24
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
25/39
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
25
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
26/39
The students determined William One, wearing one variation of casual dress was the
least interesting and mean of the teachers presented. They decided that David Two, the most
dressed up, was the most organized, strict, knowledgable, and professional, and the least
unprofessional, distant, easygoing, and unprepared. William Three, wearing an outfit
indicative of the more casual end of business casual dress, had the most preferred style for
students, and was voted the least distant and boring of all the teachers. David Four, wearing
a business casual outfit, had rankings in the middle of the spectrum, reaching neither
maximum highs nor lows for the students. William Five, was the most casual and the least
desired from students. He was viewed as the least organized, strict, kind, knowledgable, and
professional. Students also determined that he was the most easygoing, distant,
unprofessional and unprepared of his peers.
Table Seven: Adjectives for Males
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
26
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
27/39
Table Eight: Female Teacher Results
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
27
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
28/39
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
28
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
29/39
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
29
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
30/39
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
30
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
31/39
What adjectives would you use to describe the teacher pictured above?(check all that apply)
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
31
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
32/39
Claire One, the most dressed up of the teachers presented, was found as the most
organized, strict, knowledgable, and professional. She was also perceived as the least
unprofessional, distant, easygoing, and unprepared. The students determined that while she
may have the greatest command of a class, they would not like a teacher who dresses this
way. Leah Two, the most casually dressed of the styles presented, was seen as the least
organized, strict, knowledgable, and professional. She ranked highest for unprofessional,
unprepared, easygoing and distant. Students determined that she would have the least
command of a classroom out of the teachers presented, and also found her look to be the
least desirable. Claire Three, in a casual dress with a sweater, had the look most preferred by
students. She was perceived as the most kind, interesting and approachable, and the least
Table Nine: Adjectives for Females
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
32
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
33/39
distant. A great percentage of students also determined that she would have a strong
command of her classroom. Leah Four ranked in the middle of the spectrum. Students had
the least opinions about her of all the teachers presented. The final teacher was Claire Five.
In a pair of jeans and a blazer, students determined that she was the second most
professionally dressed. Statistics show that she was in the middle of the spectrum for all
categories. A majority determined that they would like a teacher who dresses this way, and
that she appears as someone who would have a good command of a classroom.
Conclusions / Interpretations:
The results yielded from the male models in this study were varied. According to the
students, most would like a teacher who dresses like the third one presented in the series,
William Three. Interestingly, this is the clothing style worn by most of the teachers at the
International School of Monagas, as a collared shirt and dark jeans are permissible according
to the dress code. The least preferred style was that of the last teacher, William Five, who
dons flip flops and a tank top. This dress code also yielded negative results about
professionalism and preparedness, and although he was ranked as the most easygoing,
students determined that he would have little control over a classroom.
David Two, who wears a bow tie, was the clear leader in professionalism, knowledge
and organization. Additionally, the students found that out of the five teachers presented,
David Two was perceived as someone who would have the greatest command of a
classroom. This demonstrates that students associate someone who is well dressed with
positive character traits. Interestingly, he was not ranked highly for any of the negative traits,
although he was voted the least easygoing of the teachers profiled. William Three was
ranked as the kindest and the most preferred dressing style, and David Four was ranked in the
middle for almost all categories, except he seems the most distant of all the teachers by a
small margin.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
33
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
34/39
This study yielded a great number of responses from the students who took this survey,
and a large percentage demonstrated that when it comes to teacher wardrobe and what
teachers choose to wear, they have no opinion. The comment portion of these survey
questions indicated that there are many other contributing factors for the way a teacher
manages a classroom, so clothing does not play a large role in that. Other comments spoke
to the aesthetics of the clothing in general, questioning pairings of shirts and pants, shoes,
etc.
The results yielded from the female models in this study were less varied than that of
the male teachers. According to the students, most would like a teacher who dresses like
the third one presented in the series, Claire Three. Just as the most preferred clothing style of
the males most resembled the teachers at the International School of Monagas, it was Claire
Three who inspired the most comments about how it seems like something several of the
teachers at school, myself included, would wear. It is curious to wonder if these added a
more personal element to the ranking given by students. The least preferred style was that of
the second teacher, Leah Two, pictured wearing tennis shoes, jean shorts and a sleeveless
shirt. Students determined that she looked like someone with limited knowledge,
preparedness and professionalism. A large percentage of students assessed that she would
not have great control over a classroom while determining that she was the most easygoing.
Claire One was rated as the teacher with the greatest control over a classroom either
male or female, and the least easygoing. There appears to be a correlation with someone
being easygoing and having an out of control classroom. The students also determined that
David Two had the best command of a classroom; he was also ranked the least easygoing. It
is easy to find similarities between Claire One and David Two, as they are paired together as
the most professionally dressed of the lot. Additionally, statistics students give strong
credence to the idea that a person who is dressed professionally will behave accordingly, and
the converse also appears true.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
34
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
35/39
From the data collected, it is clear to see that there are limitations to a full assessment
of teacher wardrobe and the dynamics of a classroom. There are many other factors which
influence student perceptions, and, for that matter, teacher success. The one point that seems
most clear from the data collected is that there is such thing as too casual, as the teachers
wearing shorts and tank tops were given very little credit in terms of professionalism,
preparedness, knowledge and management. Even though personality may greatly influence a
teacher's success in the class and his or her students' perceptions, it may be difficult to
transcend the opinions formed by students when the teacher dresses in an unprofessional
manner.
Reflections:
This project may have worked differently at a different time in the school year. It
would be interesting to see how the results may have been different if a new teacher at the
beginning of the year with students who did not know the teacher manipulated wardrobe to
see if it in any way changed the dynamics of the classroom. The results, however, would be
difficult to analyze as there are many factors which contribute to classroom management and
student behaviors. The goal of this project was to collect as much data as possible to gain
insight into the feelings held by both teachers and students about wardrobe.
In the future, it would be more beneficial to work with a larger population of students
and teachers from different areas, and to try and develop the cultural implications of teacher
dress code. With the teacher survey, it would be nice to include a geographical component
to determine a point of origin and a current place of residence. This would help to support
the cultural norms and boundaries presented in the opinions held by teachers regarding
teacher wardrobes.
The second survey was a bit long, as the students continued and the photographs of
the women teachers began, there were far fewer responses from students in the comment
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
35
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
36/39
portions. It is difficult to discern whether this is because the process was becoming tiresome
or whether the women teachers inspired students to say less. For future studies, it might be
advisable to randomize the presentation of the photographs and questions, to determine if it
is order, or the photograph itself that triggers certain responses. Administering this survey to
teachers may also help to compile information of the differences between student and
teacher perceptions about wardrobe. To do this, a modified version of the second survey
would need to be developed, perhaps changing the grade to age, and offering an opportunity
to declare whether the participant is a teacher or a student.
This project was successful in collecting information about student perceptions about
teacher clothing styles and the correlations to personality and skill sets. Although this study
was able to yield enough information for analysis, the scale through which it was conducted
is limited. It might be beneficial to further research of this nature to manipulate different
factors to determine whether results would vary.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
36
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
37/39
References
Bradley, A. (1996). Teachers make style statement by dressing up. Education Week, 16(2), 1.
Carr, D., Davies, T., & Lavin, A. (2009). The effect of business faculty attire on student
perceptions of the quality of instruction and program quality. College Student Journal,
43(1), 45-55.
Carr, D. L., Davies, T. L., & Lavin, A. M. (2010). The impact of instructor attire on college
student satisfaction. College Student Journal, 44(1), 101-111.
Curwin, R. L. (2010). Motivating Urban Youth. Reclaiming Children And Youth, 19(1), 35-39.
Dowling-Sendor, B. (2005). What not to wear.American School Board Journal, 192(8), 33-34.
Gorham, J., Cohen, S. H., & Morris, T. L. (1997). Fashion in the Classroom II: Instructor
immediacy and attire. Communication Research Reports, 14(1), 11-23.
Gorham, J., Cohen, S. H. & Morris, T. L.(1999). Fashion in the classroom III: effects of
instructor attire and
immediacy in natural classroom. Communication Quarterly, 47(3), 281-299.
The Groomer. (1972). Time, 100(10), 69.
Kizis, S. (2000). School uniforms and dress codes: the pros and cons. Writing, 23(1), 18.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
37
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
38/39
Lang, J. M. (2005). Looking like a professor. Chronicle Of Higher Education, 51(47), C2-C3.
Lavin, A., Carr, D., Davies, T., (2009a), Does image matter? Female and male student
perceptions of the impact of the female professor's attire,Journal of Business and
Accounting, 2(1).
Lavin, A., Carr, D., Davies, T., (2009b), The male professor's attire and student perceptions of
instructional quality, Research in Higher Education Journal, 4.
Lavin, A. M., Carr, D., & Davies, T. (2010). The impact of instructor attire on student
perceptions of faculty credibility and their own resultant behavior.American Journal of
Business Education. 3(6), 51-62.
Lemley, C. R. (1980). Teacher dress codes. Education, 101(2), 130.
Lemos, R. S. (2007). Etiquette for the professoriate.Academe. pp. 46-49.
Million, J. (2004). Dress codes for teachers? Eddigest, 59-61.
Morris, T. L, Gorham, M., Cohen, S. H, & Huffman, D. (1996). Fashion in the classroom:
effects of attire on student perceptions of instructors in college classes.
Patton, S. (2012). Black dandies fashion new academic identities. Chronicle Of Higher
Education, B10-B11.
Prenni, T., & Lord, T. (1992). Comparing secondary school teacher and administration
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
38
7/28/2019 ED 601: Action Research Kristen Dailey
39/39
reaction to a required dress code. Education, 112(4), 579.
Ruuska, L. (2013, May 10). In defense of the teachers of america: What we can learn from
jeff bliss. Huffington Post. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/luis-ruuska/
jeff-bliss-rant_b_3253307.html
Sebastian, R. J., & Bristow, D. (2008). Formal or informal? The impact of style of dress and
forms of address on business students' perceptions of professors.Journal Of Education
For Business, 83(4), 196-201.
Silos-Rooney, J. (2010). Student bodies. Chronicle Of Higher Education, 57(12), B24.
Thickstun, K. (2007). It's all your business.American Music Teacher, 57(1), 60-61.
Walker, J. (2011). Make it work: a professor's style makeover. Chronicle Of Higher Education,
57(18), D20-D21.
Walmsley, A. (2011). What the United Kingdom can teach the United States about school
uniforms. Phi Delta Kappan, 92(6), 63-66.
Wearing Me Out. (2012). Chronicle of Higher Education, 59(6), A34.
Yasmeen, A., & USA, T. (n.d). Teachers get lesson in dress codes. USA Today.
Looking Sharp: Do a teacher's clothes matter in the classroom? K. Dailey
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/luis-ruuska/jeff-bliss-rant_b_3253307.htmlhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/luis-ruuska/jeff-bliss-rant_b_3253307.htmlhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/luis-ruuska/jeff-bliss-rant_b_3253307.htmlhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/luis-ruuska/jeff-bliss-rant_b_3253307.htmlhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/luis-ruuska/jeff-bliss-rant_b_3253307.html