1
www.ScientificAmerican.com/Mind SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN MIND 11 SEBASTIEN ROCHE-LOCHEN iStockphoto ( coffee and cigarette); DREAMPICTURES/GETTY IMAGES ( soldier ) >> BASIC SCIENCE Prescription: Coffee and Cigarettes Discovering why even bad habits can protect the brain Inspired by human studies showing that avid coffee drinkers and smokers have a lower risk of Parkinson’s disease, scientists at the University of Washington decided to see what java and cigarettes do to fruit flies. The tremors and other movement impairments of Parkinson’s are triggered by the death of dopamine-producing cells in the brain, so the investigators used flies that had been genetically engineered to have their dopamine cells die off as they age. When Leo Pallanck and his colleagues fed coffee and tobacco extracts to these flies, they found that the animals’ dopamine cells survived and their life span increased. The scientists ruled out caffeine and nicotine as the protective substances, but there are other promising compounds in coffee and tobacco, which the researchers intend to test in these short-lived creatures. “Flies are a great system for quickly trying to zero in on the chemicals that are responsible,” Pallanck says. Michele Solis In dance clubs the drug called “ecstasy” is known as a po- tent (and illegal) way of enhancing your senses and boosting your mood. Now a study published online in July in the Jour- nal of Psychopharmacology suggests that when coupled with psychotherapy, the drug might also be an effective treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). South Carolina psychiatrist Michael Mithoefer, along with his co-therapist and wife, Annie Mithoefer, ran the trial with 21 participants who had developed chronic, treatment-resistant PTSD as a result of experiences with crime or war. They gave each participant two sessions with either MDMA (3,4-methylenedioxymethampheta- mine, which is ecstasy’s chemical name) or a placebo. Those who received MDMA took 125 milligrams, comparable to an amount a recreational user might take in a club, as their psychotherapy session began. Two and a half hours later, as the session progressed, subjects took a booster dose of half that amount to ensure the effects continued. The placebo group got sugar pills at corresponding times, and both groups received about eight hours of psychotherapy in total. Two months after the treatment fewer than 17 percent of the MDMA-treated subjects continued to qualify for a diagnosis of PTSD, as opposed to 75 percent of the subjects who received a placebo. “Our results are encouraging, and we had no significant safety problems. The next step is to find out if these results can be replicated elsewhere,” says Mithoefer, who is in private practice near Charleston. The study, sponsored by the Santa Cruz–based nonprofit Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies, was the first FDA-approved trial evaluating MDMA’s therapeutic applications. More trials of ecstasy for PTSD are under way in Switzerland and Israel, with other studies starting soon in Canada, Jordan and Spain. Mithoefer considers the findings especially notable given that 20 of the 21 participants had previously failed to obtain relief with currently approved medications and with at least one course of psychotherapy. PTSD is notoriously difficult to treat, affecting an estimated 7.8 percent of Americans. So why does MDMA work when current medications do not? The leading theory, proposed by Mithoefer, builds on a therapeutic technique in which patients are exposed to their disturbing memories in a safe environment. To be effective, the theory goes, exposure therapy must be accompanied by a degree of emotional engagement, while avoiding dissociation or overwhelming emotion. PTSD patients often have a narrow window between thresholds of underarousal and overarousal. If MDMA widens this window, allowing patients to stay emotionally engaged while revisiting traumatic experiences, then it may catalyze effective exposure therapy. In addition, MDMA elevates the hormone oxytocin, which is involved in feelings of affiliation and trust. Higher levels of oxytocin might help patients to form a more trusting bond with their therapist, so that they may revisit traumatic experiences in an emotionally engaged state. David Jay Brown >> EXPERIMENTAL MEDICINE Ecstasy Triumphs over Agony An illicit drug shows promise as a treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder

Ecstasy Triumphs over Agony

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Ecstasy Triumphs over Agony

www.Sc ient i f icAmerican.com/Mind Scientific AMericAn Mind 11

Se

BA

St

ien

rO

cH

e-L

Oc

He

n i

Sto

ck

ph

oto

(c

off

ee

an

d c

iga

rett

e);

dr

eA

Mp

ict

ur

eS

/ge

tt

y i

MA

ge

S (

so

ldie

r)

>> BASic Science

Prescription: Coffee and CigarettesDiscovering why even bad habits can protect the brain

Inspired by human studies showing that avid coffee drinkers and smokers have a lower risk of Parkinson’s disease, scientists at the University of Washington decided to see what java and cigarettes do to fruit flies. The tremors and other movement impairments

of Parkinson’s are triggered by the death of dopamine-producing cells in the brain, so the investigators used flies that had been genetically engineered to have their dopamine

cells die off as they age. When Leo Pallanck and his colleagues fed coffee and tobacco extracts to these flies, they found that the animals’ dopamine cells survived and their life

span increased. The scientists ruled out caffeine and nicotine as the protective substances, but there are other promising compounds in coffee and tobacco, which the researchers intend to test in these short-lived creatures. “Flies are a great system for quickly trying to zero in on the chemicals that are responsible,” Pallanck says. —Michele Solis

In dance clubs the drug called “ecstasy” is known as a po-tent (and illegal) way of enhancing your senses and boosting your mood. Now a study published online in July in the Jour-nal of Psychopharmacology suggests that when coupled with psychotherapy, the drug might also be an effective treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

South Carolina psychiatrist Michael Mithoefer, along with his co-therapist and wife, Annie Mithoefer, ran the trial with 21 participants who had developed chronic, treatment-resistant PTSD as a result of experiences with crime or war. They gave each participant two sessions with either MDMA (3,4-methylenedioxymeth amph eta -mine, which is ecstasy’s chemical name) or a placebo. Those who received MDMA took 125 milligrams, comparable to an amount a recreational user might take in a club, as their psychotherapy session began. Two and a half hours later, as the session progressed, subjects took a booster dose of half that amount to ensure the effects continued. The placebo group got sugar pills at corresponding times, and both groups received about eight hours of psychotherapy in total.

Two months after the treatment fewer than 17 percent of the MDMA-treated subjects continued to qualify for a diagnosis of PTSD, as opposed to 75 per cent of the subjects who received a placebo. “Our results are encouraging, and we had no significant safety problems. The next step is to find out if these results can be replicated elsewhere,” says Mithoefer, who is in private practice near Charleston. The study, sponsored by the Santa Cruz–based nonprofit Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies, was the first FDA-approved trial evaluating MDMA’s therapeutic applications. More trials of ecstasy for PTSD are under way in Switzerland and Israel, with other studies starting soon in Canada, Jordan and Spain.

Mithoefer considers the findings especially notable given that 20 of the 21 participants had previously failed to obtain relief with currently approved medications and with at least

one course of psychotherapy. PTSD is notoriously difficult to treat, affecting an estimated 7.8 percent of Americans.

So why does MDMA work when current medications do not? The leading theory, proposed by Mithoefer, builds on a

therapeutic technique in which patients are exposed to their disturbing memories in a safe environment. To be effective, the theory goes, exposure therapy must be accompanied by a degree of emotional engagement, while avoiding dissociation or overwhelming emotion. PTSD patients often have a narrow window between thresholds of underarousal and overarousal. If MDMA widens this window, allowing patients to stay emotionally engaged while revisiting trau matic experiences, then it may catalyze effective exposure therapy.

In addition, MDMA elevates the hormone oxytocin, which is involved in feelings of affiliation and trust. Higher levels of oxytocin might help patients to form a more trusting bond with their therapist, so that they may revisit traumatic experiences in an emotionally engaged state. —David Jay Brown

>> eXperiMentAL Medic ine

Ecstasy Triumphs over AgonyAn illicit drug shows promise as a treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder

MiQ510News4p.indd 11 7/26/10 5:50:49 PM