7
THE ECONOMIC WEEKLY August 20, 1955 Economic Study of a Malabar Village Thomas Shea MORAZHA village and the aur- rounding area constitute one of the chief strongholds of the Commu- nist Party in Malabar. The Kisan Sangham (the peasant organisation sponsored by the Communist Party) has a large branch office there with 400 members. Morazha became famous in 1940 as the scene of what was referred to in the courts as the Morazha Conspiracy Case, in which a large number of persons were sent to prison, and a prominent Communist leader was sentenced to death. (He was subsequently re- leased when the Congress came to power.) In September 1940, a Sub- Inspector of Police who was known to be a virulent anti-Communist left the area of his jurisdiction, which lay outside of Moraza, with a party of armed constabulary to smash up a Communist meeting be- ing held there. On his arrival, he ordered the crowd of over 3000 which had gathered in the square to disperse instantly on threat of opening fire. The crowd became unruly, and in the ensuing period of confusion, the Sub-Inspector was murdered. Morazha has ever since been regarded popularly as a centre of turbulence and discontent. The following study of the economic causes of unrest in this village was carried out during the months of February and March, 1955. Morazha Desam Morazha desam is situated about 13 miles north-west of Cannanore in Chirakkal Taluk, Malabar Dis- trict. It lies about 1½ miles from the main road to Taliparamba which has recently been converted into a national highway. It can be reached by a subsidiary road constructed by the Madras Govern- ment for military purposes during the period of widespread agrarian unrest which upset this part of the district following independence. It is one of the four drsnms which make up Morazha amsam, which in Malabar is the revenue village over which the authority of village offi- cers extends. The outline map shows the con- figuration of the village, and the location of paddy flats, garden lands and dry lands. Wet holdings (paddy flats) occupy 338 acres, or 21.9 per cent of the assessed lands in the village and account for nearly half of the total land revenue assess- ment; garden lands comprise 443 acres or 28.7 per cent of the asses- sed area and pay 42.9 per cent of the revenue assessment. Population and Land Use The total area of the village is 1,591 acres and the population is, according to the 1951 census, 3,036 —this gives a density of roughly 2 per acre, or about 9 per acre of paddy land. On the very extra- vagant assumption that each acre of paddy land in the village pro- duces on an average 1000 lbs of paddy per year, this would provide just over 100 lbs of paddy, or 60 lbs of rice per person per year. On the equally extravagant assumption that each acre of garden land was planted with the optimum number of coconut trees per acre, 120, and each tree yielded the district average of about 25 nuts per tree per year, there would be 443 nuts per year per person, or 9 per week. There are, according to the census. 1316 persons classified as engaged pri- marily in agriculture, a density of almost four per acre of wet. land. If the same assumptions regarding village production are used for pur- poses of calculation, each agricultu- ralist produces 250 lbs of paddy per year, or 150 lbs of rice a daily allowance of less than 8 ounces per person—and 1000 coconuts per year, or less than 20 nuts per week. Not Producing Enough These figures show that the vil- lage is not producing enough paddy and coconuts—the staple crops of the village- to feed itself. At one time 150 families were wholly or partially maintained on the earnings oi' those villagers who worked in the nearby Aaron spinning and weaving mills. This factory, one of the largest in Malabar, closed down about two years ago owing to mis- management and the villagers who formerly worked there have been unable to find alternative employ- ment. Apart from paddy and coco- nuts, the village produces several hundred lbs of cashew nut, and there are a few vegetable gardens. but in the aggregate this contributes little to village income. Some paddy is imported from Coorg; this is bought with the proceeds which a few families receive from members who earn money outside. The bulk of the inhabitants of Morazha are slowly starving to death. Salt Water Damage Natural causes are partially to blame. On the north, the desam is bounded by the Kuttikol River, a branch of the Taliparamba River;

Economic Study of a Malabar Village€¦ · "Travancore-Cochin Land Tenure Reform" in the Economic Weekly of September 18, 1954. In Malabar District, unlike In Travancore-Cochin,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    8

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Economic Study of a Malabar Village€¦ · "Travancore-Cochin Land Tenure Reform" in the Economic Weekly of September 18, 1954. In Malabar District, unlike In Travancore-Cochin,

T H E E C O N O M I C W E E K L Y A u g u s t 20, 1955

Economic Study of a Malabar Village Thomas Shea

M O R A Z H A v i l l age and the aur-r o u n d i n g area const i tu te one of

the chief s t rongholds of the C o m m u ­nis t P a r t y i n M a l a b a r . The K i s a n Sangham ( the peasant o rgan i sa t ion sponsored by the C o m m u n i s t P a r t y ) has a large b r a n c h office there w i t h 400 members . M o r a z h a became famous in 1940 as the scene of w h a t was re fe r red to in the courts as the M o r a z h a Conspiracy Case, in w h i c h a large number of persons were sent to pr ison, a n d a p rominen t Communi s t leader was sentenced to death. (He was subsequently re­leased when the Congress came to power.) In September 1940, a Sub-Inspector of Police who was k n o w n to be a v i r u l e n t a n t i - C o m m u n i s t l e f t the area of his j u r i s d i c t i o n , w h i c h l ay outside of Moraza, w i t h a p a r t y of a rmed cons tabulary to smash up a Communi s t mee t ing be­ing held there. On his a r r i v a l , he ordered the c rowd of over 3000 w h i c h h a d ga thered in the square to disperse i n s t a n t l y on threa t of opening fire. The c r o w d became un ru ly , a n d in the ensuing period of confusion, the Sub-Inspector was murdered . M o r a z h a has ever since been regarded popu la r ly as a centre of turbulence and discontent . The f o l l o w i n g s tudy of the economic causes of unrest in th is v i l l age was car r ied out d u r i n g the months o f F e b r u a r y and M a r c h , 1955.

Morazha Desam M o r a z h a desam is s i tua ted about

13 miles nor th -wes t of Cannanore i n C h i r a k k a l T a l u k , M a l a b a r Dis ­t r i c t . I t lies about 1 ½ miles f r o m the m a i n r o a d to T a l i p a r a m b a w h i c h has recent ly been conver ted i n t o a n a t i o n a l h i g h w a y . I t can be reached by a subs id iary road const ructed by the Madras Govern­men t fo r m i l i t a r y purposes d u r i n g the per iod of widespread a g r a r i a n unrest w h i c h upset th is p a r t of the d i s t r i c t f o l l o w i n g independence. I t is one of the fou r d rsnms w h i c h make up M o r a z h a amsam, w h i c h in M a l a b a r is the revenue v i l l age over w h i c h the a u t h o r i t y o f v i l l age off i ­cers extends.

The out l ine map shows the con­f igu ra t ion of the v i l lage , a n d the loca t ion of paddy flats, garden lands a n d d r y lands. W e t holdings (paddy flats) occupy 338 acres, or 21.9 per cent of the assessed lands in the v i l l age a n d account f o r nea r ly h a l f of the t o t a l l a n d revenue assess­

ment ; garden lands comprise 443 acres or 28.7 per cent of the asses­sed area and pay 42.9 per cent of the revenue assessment.

Population and Land Use The t o t a l area of the v i l lage is

1,591 acres and the popula t ion is, accord ing to the 1951 census, 3,036 —this gives a densi ty of r ough ly 2 per acre, or about 9 per acre of paddy l and . On the very ex t ra ­vagan t assumpt ion t h a t each acre of paddy l and in the v i l l age pro­duces on an average 1000 lbs of paddy per year, th is w o u l d provide jus t over 100 lbs of paddy, or 60 lbs of rice per person per year. On the equal ly e x t r a v a g a n t assumpt ion t h a t each acre of ga rden l a n d was p lan ted w i t h the o p t i m u m number of coconut trees per acre, 120, and each tree yie lded the d i s t r i c t average of about 25 nuts per tree per year, there w o u l d be 443 nuts per year per person, or 9 per week. There are, accord ing to the census. 1316 persons classified as engaged p r i ­m a r i l y in agr icu l tu re , a densi ty of a lmost four per acre of wet. l and . I f the same assumptions r ega rd ing v i l l age product ion are used fo r pur­poses of ca lcu la t ion , each a g r i c u l t u ­r a l i s t produces 250 lbs of paddy per year, or 150 lbs of rice a da i ly a l lowance of less t h a n 8 ounces per

person—and 1000 coconuts per year, or less t h a n 20 nuts per week.

Not Producing Enough These figures show t h a t the v i l ­

lage is no t p roduc ing enough paddy a n d coconuts—the staple crops of the vi l lage- to feed itself . At one t ime 150 fami l ies were w h o l l y or p a r t i a l l y m a i n t a i n e d on the earnings oi' those v i l l age rs w h o w o r k e d in the nearby A a r o n sp inn ing and weav ing m i l l s . Th i s fac tory , one of the largest in M a l a b a r , closed down about two years ago o w i n g to mis ­management and the v i l l age rs w h o f o r m e r l y w o r k e d there have been unable to f ind a l t e rna t i ve employ­ment . A p a r t f r o m paddy a n d coco­nuts, the v i l lage produces several hundred lbs of cashew nut , a n d there are a few vegetable gardens. but in the aggregate th i s cont r ibutes l i t t l e to v i l l age income. Some paddy is impor t ed f r o m Coorg ; th i s is bought w i t h the proceeds w h i c h a few famil ies receive f r o m members w h o earn money outside. The b u l k of the inhab i t an t s of M o r a z h a are s lowly s t a r v i n g to death.

Salt Water Damage N a t u r a l causes are p a r t i a l l y to

blame. On the n o r t h , the desam is bounded by the K u t t i k o l River , a b ranch of the T a l i p a r a m b a River ;

Page 2: Economic Study of a Malabar Village€¦ · "Travancore-Cochin Land Tenure Reform" in the Economic Weekly of September 18, 1954. In Malabar District, unlike In Travancore-Cochin,

A u g u s t 20, 1955 T H E E C O N O M I C W E E K L Y

th is r ive r , w h i c h is r ea l ly a back­water , i s a t Morazha , o n l y four miles f r o m the ocean, and is m a i n l y com­posed of sea-water. E a c h year, dur­i n g the monsoon i t overf lows i t s banks a n d submerges 1|3 of the paddy lands of the v i l l age in a foot o r t w o o f b rack i sh wate r . T w o dams have been b u i l t by some of the la rger l and lords to res t r i c t the overf low of the b rack i sh water , bu t one of these has in recent years been a l l o w e d to f a l l i n t o disrepair , a n d each year, th is b r a c k i s h over­f low spreads to new lands. L a s t October (1954) the M a d r a s Gove rn ­m e n t opened an extension service b lock in this pa r t o f N o r t h M a l a b a r as pa r t of the C o m m u n i t y Pro jec t development scheme, a n d has in con­nect ion w i t h t h i s sanct ioned 25,000 rupees for the cons t ruc t ion of an improved bund. The bund chosen for i m p r o v e m e n t (B on the map) lies f a r south o f the o r i g i n a l bund ( A ) . W h i l e i t w i l l prevent f u r t h e r encroachment on lands l y i n g to the south, i t w i l l increase dra inage problems for those l y i n g between i t a n d the r i v e r w h i c h a m o u n t to near ly 100 acres of paddy l and . The v i l l agers fear t h a t the Government ' s plans, i f car­r i ed out, m a y render the whole of th is area uncu l t ivab le a n d force more t h a n 100 cu l t i va to r s to aban­don the i r hold ings .

Special Type of Cultivation

Thi s annua l overf low of sa l t wa te r is responsible f o r a peculiar type of paddy c u l t i v a t i o n found on ly i n N o r t h M a l a b a r i n areas s i m i l a r l y s i tua ted near the coast, cal led K a i ­pad. I n F e b r u a r y o r M a r c h , t o ­w a r d the end of the d r y season, when the backwa te r s have receded

a n d the fields have become dry , mounds are ra ised on the f ie lds a t i n t e rva l s of about one every t w o square feet. A f t e r they have been b u i l t up, d u r i n g the m o n t h o f A p r i l o r M a y , wa te r f r o m nearby chan­nels is a l lowed to enter the fields t h r o u g h sluices in order to decrease the s a l i n i t y of the soil , f o r f o l l o w ­i n g the evapora t ion of the f lood waters d u r i n g the d ry season, the soil is of ten coated w i t h a layer of sal t . In June, seeds w h i c h have been a l l owed to ge rmina te are sown on top of the mounds. A f t e r a m o n t h or six weeks, when the seed­l ings have sprouted and the onset of the monsoon has fu r the r decreas­ed the s a l i n i t y of the w a t e r in the fields, the mounds are level led over the f i e lds , w h i c h t hen t a k e on the appearance of o r d i n a r y paddy f la ts . The crop is harves ted in October, when the f loodwaters have tempo­r a r i l y receded. F r o m then u n t i l Februa ry , the f ie lds r ema in a lmos t c o n t i n u a l l y submerged by the chan­nels and backwa te r s w h i c h are re­plenished by the nor th-east monsoon.

Cost Lower But Crop Precarious

T h i s type of c u l t i v a t i o n i s s l i gh t ­ly less expensive t han o r d i n a r y c u l t i v a t i o n . A l t h o u g h labour costs are subs t an t i a l l y more , on ly 113 of the seed necessary in t r ans ­p lan ted crops i s requi red in K a i p a d c u l t i v a t i o n ; th is usua l ly more t h a n cancels out the increase in l abour costs. However , the crop is an ex­ceedingly precarious one; s l i gh t bu t unexpected v a r i a t i o n s in the level of w a t e r d u r i n g the seedling stage can, a n d f requent ly do, des t roy the ent i re crop. Moreover , m u c h of th i s K a i p a d l a n d could produce t w o

ins tead of one crop year ly , were i t possible to regula te the f low of w a t e r f r o m the r ive r .

However , the p l i g h t o f M o r a z h a is due chiefly no t to the vagar ies of na ture bu t to the inefficient o rgan­iza t ion o f a g r i c u l t u r a l p roduc t ion a n d th i s is, in t u r n , an o u t g r o w t h o f the p r e v a i l i n g l a n d tenure struc­ture . The f o l l o w i n g p ic tu re m a y be dupl ica ted in any one of M a l a b a r ' s 2,222 desams a n d is l a rge ly respon­sible f o r l ow s tandards of ag r i cu l ­t u r a l p roduc t ion t h r o u g h o u t the d i s t r i c t .

Concentration of Holdings

E i g h t devaswoms, o r temples, h o l d the j a n m a m , o r p ropr i e to ry r i g h t t o h a l f of the l a n d in the v i l l age . They pay more t h a n 25 per cent of the l a n d revenue, and ho ld 1|3 of the wet lands. F o u r of these devas-woms are managed by t w o of the five la rges t landholders of the v i l ­lage. O n l y one of the temples, however, is managed by a resident o f the desam. A l l ho ld lands scat­tered t h r o u g h other vi l lages as w e l l . The largest p rop r i e t a ry holder, or j a n m i , in the v i l lage , one of the e ight devaswoms, holds nea r ly ¼ of the wet lands, and pays 13 per cent o f the t o t a l l a n d revenue. The f ive larges t j a n m i s h o l d 47.5 per cent of the w e t lands, 49 per cent of a l l lands, and pay more t h a n 40 per cent of the t o t a l l and revenue. J a n m a m t i t l e t o the r emainder o f the lands is he ld on more t h a n 250 pa t tas by app rox ima te ly 200 i n d i ­v i d u a l s ' .

None of the large j a n m i s h o l d the i r l a n d i n compact b locks . L i k e the hold ings of the devaswoms, t h e i r

998

Page 3: Economic Study of a Malabar Village€¦ · "Travancore-Cochin Land Tenure Reform" in the Economic Weekly of September 18, 1954. In Malabar District, unlike In Travancore-Cochin,

T H E E C O N O M I C W E E K L Y Augus t 20, 1955

lands are scat tered t h r o u g h o u t th i s a n d o ther v i l lages In haphaza rd con-fus ion. O n l y one, the manager of one of the temples, w h o is also the v i l l age headman o r a d h i k a r i , has any precise knowledge of the ex-l e n t of his lands. E v e n he is u n ­able to give deta i led i n f o r m a t i o n concern ing the ac tua l cu l t i va to r s , fo r the temple account books show on ly the names of the immedia t e lessees; as there is no r e s t r a i n t on sub- le t t ing , i t i s impossible in mos t cases fo r j a n m i s to say whe the r or not t he i r immed ia t e lessees are c u l ­t i v a t o r s o r in te rmediar ies . No re­cords are kep t of yields, a n d no interest I s o r d i n a r i l y t a k e n in ra is­i n g s tandards o f c u l t i v a t i o n .

* F o r a discussion of the m e a n i n g of the t e r m " p a t t a " see my a r t i c le "Travancore -Coch in L a n d Tenure R e f o r m " i n the Economic W e e k l y of September 18, 1954. In M a l a b a r D i s t r i c t , un l i ke In Travancore -Coch in , the j a n m i is the pa t ta -holder ; ten­ants, i f they h o l d pat tas , h o l d t h e m j o i n t l y w i t h the j a n m i . See also the M a l a b a r L a n d R e g i s t r a t i o n A c t , 1895, as modif ied up to M a y 1, 1948, Madras , Gove rnmen t Press, 1948.

J a n m i ' s Powers Rest r ic ted

The j a n m i i s no longer the o m n i ­potent l a n d l o r d he was a genera t ion ago. Successive tenancy leg i s la t ion has cu r t a i l ed his power to evic t a n d to raise rents . He m a y ev ic t ten­ants fo r the purpose of t a k i n g to d i rec t c u l t i v a t i o n himself , and t h i s device has been resorted to frequent­ly in recent years by j a n m i s desir­i n g to augment the i r incomes by a p p r o p r i a t i n g the f u l l economic rent . As a l a rge number of leases are o r a l (o f the leases of a l l types w h i c h I examined in th is v i l l age , I f ound 85 to be o r a l a n d 94 regis­tered) ev ic t ion , especially f r o m we t lands, should n o r m a l l y be an easy t a sk . M o s t j a n m i s w o u l d be dis­couraged f r o m e v i c t i n g tenants f r o m garden lands because of the f ac t t h a t they w o u l d usua l ly be obl iged to pay heavy compensat ion f o r i m ­provements made by the t enan t dur­i n g his per iod of tenure, such as newly-p lan ted trees a n d bu i ld ings . In the case o f paddy lands, how­ever, no compensat ion need o r d i ­n a r i l y be paid , because the o n l y " i m p r o v e m e n t s " o r d i n a r i l y made on paddy lands are the a n n u a l rou t ine tasks o f b u n d i n g and l e v e l l i n g o f the f i e ld s . My enquiries concern­i n g evic t ions i n M o r a z h a v i l l age b r o u g h t t o l i g h t on ly fou r incidents , a l l o f w h i c h i n v o l v e d evic t ions o f sub-tenants by an i n t e r m e d i a r y .

A l t h o u g h the j a n m i i s no longer a social menace, i t is d i f f icu l t to Bee w h a t posi t ive c o n t r i b u t i o n he makes to ag r i cu l t u r e as i t i s car­r i ed o n today i n Morazha . Th i s , of course, i s no t t r ue of the smal le r j a n m i s , w h o are of ten themselves c u l t i v a t i n g tenan ts (see Table V ) ; bu t i t does apply to the f ive largest ones w h o o w n h a l f the l a n d in the v i l l age . O n l y one is a resident; none have ever t a k e n a n y interest wha teve r in a g r i c u l t u r a l operations. H a d they ever chosen to do so, they w o u l d have f o u n d the task o f m a n ­agement s tagger ing , since t he i r lands are scat tered in the mos t i n d i s c r i m i ­nate manne r over the countrys ide . I t i s t rue t h a t the rents w h i c h they charge f o r m a n y of t he i r ho ld ings are n o m i n a l . Yet m a n y of the c u l t i ­va to r s examined by me w h o held leases d i rec t f r o m t h e m were as bad­

ly r ack- ren ted as those h o l d i n g leases f r o m Intermediar ies . The j a n m i , a t i l l ca l led the "absolute p ropr ie to r o f the s o i l " i n the M a l a b a r Tenancy A c t as i t s tands today, has been shorn of m u c h of his power. H i s v e r y existence as a passive rent-receiver is, however, a l o n g w i t h t h a t o f the n o n - c u l t i v a t i n g i n t e rmed ia ry , s y m p t o m a t i c of a misuse of econo­mic resources.

D a t a o n Concen t r a t i on o f Ho ld ings N . B . — T h e da t a s h o w i n g concent­

r a t i o n o f ho ld ings on the j a n m a m level is the on ly p o r t i o n of th i s en­q u i r y not based on con tempora ry (1955) evidence. I t was compi led f r o m the v i l l age regis ter w h i c h was prepared i n connect ion w i t h re­set t lement operat ions in 1936. Since t h a t t ime , there has been a sub­s t an t i a l change in the p a t t e r n o f j a n m a m holdings . I f ound i t , how­ever, impossible to keep t r a c k of

999

Page 4: Economic Study of a Malabar Village€¦ · "Travancore-Cochin Land Tenure Reform" in the Economic Weekly of September 18, 1954. In Malabar District, unlike In Travancore-Cochin,
Page 5: Economic Study of a Malabar Village€¦ · "Travancore-Cochin Land Tenure Reform" in the Economic Weekly of September 18, 1954. In Malabar District, unlike In Travancore-Cochin,

T H E E C O N O M I C W E E K L Y A u g u s t 20, 1955

the enormous number of sales, par­t i t ions , a n d re-combinat ions of Jan-m a m proper ty w h i c h have t a k e n place over the i n t e r v e n i n g 19 years, fo r m a n y of the changes have never been entered in the v i l l age records. The f i rs t permissive l eg i s la t ion en­a b l i n g p a r t i t i o n o f p roper ty be long­i n g t o H i n d u j o i n t f ami l i e s i n M a l a b a r to t a k e place was f i r s t passed in 1933. I t was several years before people genera l ly began to t ake advantage of i ts provis ions . Since 1936, when the register was prepared, however, cour ts in M a l a b a r have been swamped w i t h p a r t i t i o n suits. W h e n fami l ies of ten number­i n g t w o dozen or more sub-divide a n d p a r t i t i o n ho ld ings w h i c h even before p a r t i t i o n were d i m i n u t i v e and f ragmented , i n d i v i d u a l ho ld ings often become too sma l l to be w o r k ­able and are sold. P a r t i t i o n has gone on no t on ly the j a n m a m level , but a m o n g a l l categories of tenants as w e l l , and it f u r the r complicates a set of l and tenure pat terns a l ready complex in the extreme. T w o of the f ive larges t j a n m i s shown in Table I I are devaswoms, whose pro­pe r ty is impa r t i b l e . One of the r e m a i n i n g three s t i l l holds an un-part i t . ioned estate; p a r t i t i o n proceed­ings are now in progress for the second and t h a t estate has been placed in the hands of a receiver. The last of the three has lost v i r t u ­a l l y every scrap of h is l and ei ther t h r o u g h l i t i g a t i o n or sale d u r i n g the past 19 years.

Subinfeudat ion Table V I i l lus t ra tes the prevalence

of subinfeudat ion in the ho ld ings studied. I t is based chiefly on en­quir ies i n t o paddy hold ings of c u l t i ­va to r s . At first glance, it. w o u l d appear tha t tenure pat terns in the v i l l age were on the whole quite simple, a t least f o r paddy lands . In 63 per cent of the lands s tudied the j a n m i ei ther he ld his l a n d direc­t l y , or leased i t to a c u l t i v a t i n g tenant . In on ly 5 per cent of the lands s tudied were there t w o or more in te rmedia r ies between the j a n m i a n d the c u l t i v a t o r . However , 42 of the 67 c u l t i v a t o r s whose ho ld ­ings were s tudied in de ta i l he ld some l a n d in M o r a z h a desam as sub­tenants . There are a few fields in the v i l l age by no means the mos t p roduc t ive o r desirable lands- w h i c h have been parceled out by in te r ­mediar ies i n t o t i n y f r agmen t s w h i c h are leased ou t on exceedingly h i g h rents to an enormous number o f pe t ty c u l t i v a t o r s . One such f ield, 16 acres in ex tent w i t h an a p p r o x i ­ma te y i e l d of 750 lb per acre, was

le t by the j a n m i to an i n t e r m e d i a r y , by the i n t e r m e d i a r y to t w o sub­tenants , and by these t w o sub­tenants to about 30 c u l t i v a t o r s . Rents pa id by these c u l t i v a t o r s averaged 80 per cent of the gross y i e ld . The t w o second in te rmedia ­ries pa id about 50 per cent of the gross y i e l d to the f i r s t i n t e rmed ia ry .

Extreme concentration

E x t r e m e concen t ra t ion o f ho ld ­ings p reva i l ed no t o n l y on the j a n ­m a m level , bu t in the case of lands he ld by in te rmediar ies as w e l l . The la rges t i n t e r m e d i a r y tenant resident in the desam he ld in a l l 22 per cent of the t o t a l wet lands in the v i l l age . N o t a l l o f th i s was held, however, a s an in t e rmed ia ry , a s Table I I I w i l l show. In Ma laba r , a s ign i ­f i can t f r ac t i on of a g r i c u l t u r a l i s t s h o l d l a n d in more t h a n one capaci ty . E v e n the poorest c u l t i v a t o r m a y h o l d l a n d under half-a-dozen l and­lords and be h imse l f the l a n d l o r d of one or t w o tenants . As is the ease w i t h the l a rger j anmis , his ho ld ings as a j a n m i , as an in ter­m e d i a r y and as a c u l t i v a t i n g tenant were not confined to the v i l l age . He held leases under t w o j a n m i s in

th i s v i l l age , a n d h a d ho ld ings i n another revenue v i l l age as w e l l un­der three o ther l and lo rds . F o r t y per cent of the in te rmedia r ies h o l d ­i n g lands i n the v i l l age w h i c h were subjected to enqui ry were non-resid­ents, a n d others p resumably had ho ld ings in o ther v i l l ages as w e l l . Seventy per cent of the 11 resident in te rmediar ies of these lands held l a n d In o ther v i l lages . A n d a l l o f the resident in te rmedia r ies e x a m i n ­ed held l a n d in some other capaci ty - i.e., as j a n m i or cu l t i va to r—as we l l .

Type Case of an Intermediary

In his capac i ty a s j a n m i , th i s i n ­t e rmed ia ry h a d three t enan ts under h im , a n d as an i n t e r m e d i a r y , 37 more. As his paddy ho ld ings alone were studied, and o n l y those he ld in M o r a z h a Desam, a f u l l s t a tement o f a l l l a n d held by h i m w o u l d re­veal an even more compl ica ted pa t t e rn . A l t h o u g h his t o t a l j a n m a m holdings in th i s desam aggrega ted on ly 11 acres, they were he ld under 5 p a t t a numbers . In the a n n u a l j a m a b a n d i , or s ta tement of revenue col lect ion, f requent ly c i ted by Gov­ernment officials as an i n d i c a t i o n of

1001

Page 6: Economic Study of a Malabar Village€¦ · "Travancore-Cochin Land Tenure Reform" in the Economic Weekly of September 18, 1954. In Malabar District, unlike In Travancore-Cochin,

Augus t 20, 1955 T H E E C O N O M I C W E E K L Y

l andho ld ing pat terns on a j a n m a m level, he w o u l d thus appear as five separate "pat tadars ." The reason w h y his j a n m a m holdings are not a l l l is ted under one pa t t a number is t ha t since the last revenue settle­ment in 1935, he has purchased land f r o m several j anmis who held i t under other pa t ta numbers, and continues to pay revenue in the i r names, or ra ther under the i r n u m ­bers. The difficulties of expressing the degree of concentra t ion of ho ld ­ings in M a l a b a r in any mean ingfu l f o r m is amply i l l u s t r a t e d by this case. In any statement showing concentra t ion of holdings on a j a n ­m a m level, he wou ld appear to be a smal l j a n m i ; only about 65 per cent of his l and is held as an in ter ­mediary; the rest he holds as a cul ­t i v a t i n g tenant . However, nei ther he nor his f a m i l y themselves w o r k in the fields. The ac tua l physical labour of c u l t i v a t i o n is ca r r ied out by hired labourers. U n l i k e most in termediar ies or cu l t iva to rs , most of his l and in th is v i l lage is held in a single compact block, and is located near his residence. I t i s thus possible fo r h i m to exert effec­t ive supervision over lands in his direct possession. He has, however, made no a t tempts to introduce i m ­proved methods of c u l t i v a t i o n . H i s best lands he has re ta ined in his own possession; for the most part , the lands leased out are infer ior . The bulk of his lands are located in t i le zone devoted to K a i p a d cu l ­t i v a t i o n . Most of t hem are held under one j a n m i , a devaswom, the largest j a n m i in the v i l lage .

Rent Paid to Temple Deity To th is j a n m i he pays a ren t of

6.450 lbs of paddy a year w h i c h w o r k s ou t at 104 lbs per acre (ve ry rough ly 17 of the t o t a l y ie ld) plus another 450 lbs of paddy and Rs 150 as perquisites. These perqui­sites, not ment ioned in the lease document, are annua l offerings to the temple dei ty w h i c h have been made for generations by his an­cestors, w h o have been tenants of the devaswom f r o m t ime imme­m o r i a l . He receives a ren t of about 8000 lbs of paddy f r o m his 40 ten­ants , and another 17,000 lbs f r o m hold ings under his direct cu l t i va ­t i o n . F r o m this 17,000 lbs gross y ie ld , he mus t pay the wages of a g r i c u l t u r a l labourers , a t most about 6,000 lbs in the aggregate. He ob­tains, therefore, a net income of app rox ima te ly 18,000 lbs of paddy per year, provided the yields are nor­m a l and rents are pa id i n l u l l , wh ich i s no t of ten the ca se . A t the pur-

1002

Page 7: Economic Study of a Malabar Village€¦ · "Travancore-Cochin Land Tenure Reform" in the Economic Weekly of September 18, 1954. In Malabar District, unlike In Travancore-Cochin,

T H E E C O N O M I C W E E K L Y A u g u s t 20, 1955

chase pr ice o f paddy in M o r a z h a In M a r c h 1955 of 3 annas 4 pies per l b , h is net income f r o m paddy lands w o u l d thus be Rs 3,750 per year, or s l i g h t l y over Rs 300 per m o n t h .

Income from Fishing Rights He derives, besides th i s , income

f r o m lands i n ano ther v i l l age , a n d f r o m ano the r source as w e l l . T h e K a i p a d lands, d u r i n g f lood periods, teem w i t h fish, w h i c h together w i t h toddy, were f o r m e r l y the staple d ie t o f mos t o f the v i l l age r s . T w o years ago (1953) the above-ment ioned in t e rmed ia ry , w h o holds on lease m o s t o f the K a i p a d lands in the v i l l age , leased fo r a 5-year per iod f ishing r i g h t s over these lands, w h i c h were h i t h e r t o free t o a l l v i l ­lagers d u r i n g flood seasons, to a S y r i a n C h r i s t i a n f r o m Cochin on

Export of Electric Power from Yugoslavia (Contributed)

E L E C T R I C power as an expor t p roduc t has been a special con­

cern of the Economic Commiss ion fo r Europe. The subject has been touched upon in m a n y of i t s pub l i ­cat ions but m o s t l y in passing. Some sale of electric power across the n a t i o n a l f ron t i e r s takes place in Europe even n o w ; thus in 1951, t o t a l expor ts of e l ec t r i c i ty fo rmed 1.6 per cent of t o t a l p roduc t ion as compared w i t h 1.4 per cent in 1950. B u t th i s i n t e r n a t i o n a l t rade has so f a r been in the na tu re of an exchange between h y d r o a n d t h e r m a l power. Schemes fo r expand ing i n t e r n a t i o n a l t rade i n electr ic power are no longer a nove l ty . The proposal fo r l a y i n g t r an smi s s ion cables across the E n g ­l i s h channe l fo r connec t ing the g r i d systems o f B r i t a i n a n d France has been in the a i r fo r somet ime. The scope of i n t e r n a t i o n a l t rade in power, as in o ther th ings , rests on m u t u a l advan tage a n d depends l a r g e l y on the seasonal v a r i a t i o n s in demand a n d supply. To the extent t h a t n a t u r a l condi t ions influence the l a t t e r in a f avourab le d i rec t ion , there is scope f o r prof i table t rade . I f t w o countr ies do n o t have peak demands a t the same t i m e a n d in add i t i on , supply condi t ions also differ , one c o u n t r y m a y be in a pos i t ion to spare power j u s t w h e n the o ther passes t h r o u g h i ts peak demand a n d also experiences, because of the f reezing o f i t s wa te r - supp ly fo r i t s hydro-e lec t r i c s tat ions, f o r example, a decline in i t s power supply.

E x p o r t Prospects Unique I n Europe In t h i s respect, the prospects o f

p a y m e n t of Rs 5000. T h i s S y r i a n C h r i s t i a n has made a subs t an t i a l c a p i t a l inves tment In sluices, cer­t a i n improvemen t s in one of the dams, nets and d r y i n g a r range­ments a n d i s n o w e x p o r t i n g m o s t o f the f i s h w h i c h was f o r m e r l y a n i m p o r t a n t component o f the loca l d i e t

Rents f rom Cult ivat ing Tenants Tab le IV i s based on d i rec t en­

quir ies i n t o rents pa id by c u l t i v a t ­i n g tenants fo r leases of paddy lands he ld under t h i s i n t e r m e d i a r y . The 12 s ta tements inc luded in the tab le were care fu l ly checked and were the most re l iable t h a t cou ld be obta ined. A l l of the leases in the table are of K a i p a d l a n d . Cost of c u l t i v a t i o n was computed at a u n i f o r m ra te based upon loca l en-

e x p o r t i n g electric power f r o m Y u g o ­s l av i a are perhaps unique in Europe a n d i t i s not su rp r i s ing t h a t they shou ld be s tudied by the E C E. The C o m m i t t e e of the E C E on E lec t r i c Power appointed a group of experts f o r m a k i n g th is s tudy on a request by the countr ies w h i c h are mos t l i k e l y to benefit f r o m the expor t o f power f r o m Yugos l av i a . T h i s i n ­t e r - g o v e r n m e n t a l body, k n o w n as Yuge lexpor t , ca r r i ed on i t s s tudy of the technica l , economic, f inanc ia l a n d legal aspects of the project dur­i n g 1954. The f ina l t ex t of the s tudy was approved by the l iason Group of the Commi t t ee on E l e c t r i c Power a t its mee t ing in Geneva on December 14. 1954. Th i s is n o w a p r i o r i t y project .

The decision on i t was t a k e n by the Commi t t ee on Economic Power a t i t s seventh session, conf i rmed a t i t s t e n t h session a n d ampl i f i ed a t i t s t w e l f t h session. The reso lu t ion adopted at the las t session of the Commiss ion reads as fo l l ows :

" N o w t h a t the technica l , economic, f inanc ia l a n d legal s tudy o f the pros­pects of e x p o r t i n g electric power f r o m Yugos l av i a has been approved, e s tab l i shment a t the i n t e r -gove rn ­m e n t a l level of a Co-o rd ina t i on C o m ­m i t t e e cons i s t ing o f t w o representa­t ives each of A u s t r i a , the Wes te rn zone o f Germany , I t a l y and Y u g o ­s l a v i a was agreed, w i t h the f o l l o w ­i n g t e rms of reference:

" T o study, i n the l i g h t o f deve­lopments in the s i t ua t ion , the va r ious a r r angemen t s w h i c h m i g h t b e con-

1003

quir ies ; l abour charges per acre for a l l operat ions were on an average 47 man-days at 3 lbs of paddy per day, a n d 40 man-days a t 1½ lb of paddy per day, or a t o t a l of about 200 lb of paddy; seed rates were 1/3 the usua l ra te p r e v a i l i n g in the v i l l age of 100 lb per acre. F o u r of the 12 c u l t i v a t o r s paid v i r t u a l l y t h e i r en t i re surplus as ren t . In no case d i d rents con fo rm to the ra te l a i d d o w n fo r K a i p a d lands in the M a l a b a r Tenancy A c t of 1954, S. 6 (25 per cent of the gross produce) ! Rents for th i s ca tegory of l a n d were on the whole lower t h a n rents pre­v a i l i n g genera l ly , as reference to Table V I I w i l l show. T h i s is, how­ever, explained by the g rea te r r i s k i nvo lved in th is type of c u l t i v a t i o n .

( To be continued)

t empla ted for the execution of the scheme;

"To fac i l i t a te the nego t i a t i on of i n t e r -gove rnmen ta l agreements to m a t c h the b i l a t e r a l con t rac t s con­cluded between the u n d e r t a k i n g s of the countr ies concerned; a n d

"General ly , to co-ordinate the s tudy and execution of the several stages",

Yugelexport Study The Yugelexpor t s tudy, i t m a y

be noted, was not o n l y t a k e n up by the U n i t e d N a t i o n s Economic Commiss ion fo r Europe on i t s o w n ; i t h a d been d r a w n up j o i n t l y by experts of the Governmen t s of Aus ­t r i a , Germany , I t a l y and Yugos lav ia ,

countr ies w h i c h have a v i t a l in te r ­est in the success of the project . Fo r t w o f u l l years, these experts h a d been successfully co-opera t ing on a r e l a t i v e l y compl ica ted task , elabo­r a t i n g not o n l y the technical side, bu t also the economic, f inanc ia l and o rgan i sa t i ona l — legal aspects of ex­p o r t i n g electric power f r o m Y u g o ­s lavia .

The s tudy has es tabl ished:

(a) T h a t export o f considerable quant i t ies o f electr ic power f r o m Yugos l av i a is t e chn i ca l l y possible;

(b) T h a t such expor t could go on for decades; a n d

( c ) T h a t the expor t o f power w i l l not o n l y benefit Yugos l av ia , but w i l l a lso help the economic development o f the n e i g h b o u r i n g states w h i c h purchase w i n t e r cu r r en t f r o m Y u g o ­s lav ia .

T h e s tudy goes i n to detai ls a n d