12
This is a repository copy of Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant nest networks. White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/ Version: Published Version Article: Ellis, Samuel, Franks, Daniel Wayne orcid.org/0000-0002-4832-7470 and Robinson, Elva Joan Hilda orcid.org/0000-0003-4914-9327 (2017) Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant nest networks. Ecology and Evolution. 1170–1180. ISSN 2045-7758 https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.2749 [email protected] https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ Reuse Items deposited in White Rose Research Online are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved unless indicated otherwise. They may be downloaded and/or printed for private study, or other acts as permitted by national copyright laws. The publisher or other rights holders may allow further reproduction and re-use of the full text version. This is indicated by the licence information on the White Rose Research Online record for the item. Takedown If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing [email protected] including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request.

Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

This is a repository copy of Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant nest networks.

White Rose Research Online URL for this paper:http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/

Version: Published Version

Article:

Ellis, Samuel, Franks, Daniel Wayne orcid.org/0000-0002-4832-7470 and Robinson, Elva Joan Hilda orcid.org/0000-0003-4914-9327 (2017) Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant nest networks. Ecology and Evolution. 1170–1180. ISSN 2045-7758

https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.2749

[email protected]://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/

Reuse

Items deposited in White Rose Research Online are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved unless indicated otherwise. They may be downloaded and/or printed for private study, or other acts as permitted by national copyright laws. The publisher or other rights holders may allow further reproduction and re-use of the full text version. This is indicated by the licence information on the White Rose Research Online record for the item.

Takedown

If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing [email protected] including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request.

Page 2: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

Eco握ogy and Evo握u試on 2017; 1�12 科|科1www.ecolevol.org

ReceivedrゲゾMayゴグゲ葦科 |科 RevisedrゲズNovemberゴグゲ葦科 |科 AcceptedrゴゲDecemberゴグゲ葦DOIrゲグsゲググゴ⦆eceザsゴゼジゾ

O R I G I N A L R E S E A R C H

Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant

nest networks

Samuel Ellis1 科|科Danie旭 Ws Franks2科|科E旭va Js Hs Robinson2

Thisisanopenaccessar抄c旭eunderthetermsoftheCrea抄veCommonsAtribu抄onLicensepwhichpermitsusepdistribu抄onandreproduc抄oninanymediumpprovidedtheorigina旭workisproper旭ycitedsサゴグゲゼTheAuthorssEco握ogy and Evo握u試onpub旭ishedbyJohnWi旭eyケSonsLtds

1CentreforResearchinAnima旭BehaviourpUniversityofExeterpExeterpUK2YorkCentreforComp旭exSystemsAna旭ysisケDepartmentofBio旭ogypUniversityofYorkpYorkpUK

Correspondence

Samue旭E旭旭ispCentreforResearchinAnima旭BehaviourpUniversityofExeterpExeterpUKsEmai旭rsse旭旭isコexetersacsuk

AbstractAccesstoresourcesdependsonanindividua旭vsposi抄onwithintheenvironmentsThisispar抄cu旭ar旭y important toanima旭s that investheavi旭y innestconstruc抄onpsuchassocia旭insectssManyantspecieshaveapo旭ydomousnes抄ngstrategyrasing旭eco旭onyinhabits severa旭 spa抄a旭旭y separatednestsp otenexchanging resourcesbetween thenestssDiferentnestsinapo旭ydomousco旭onypoten抄a旭旭yhavediferen抄a旭accesstoresourcespbuttheeco旭ogica旭consequencesofthisareunc旭earsInthisstudypweinves-抄gatehownestsurviva旭andbuddinginpo旭ydomouswoodantェFormica lugubris) colo-

nies are afected by being part of amu旭抄、nest systemsUsing ie旭d data and nove旭ana旭y抄ca旭approachescombiningsurviva旭mode旭swithdynamicnetworkana旭ysispweshowthatthesurviva旭andbuddingofnestswithinapo旭ydomousco旭onyareafectedbytheirposi抄oninthenestnetworkstructuresSpeciica旭旭ypweindthatthelowofresourcesthroughanestpwhichisbasedonitsposi抄onwithinthewidernestnetworkpdetermines a nestvs 旭ike旭ihood of surviving and of founding newnestssOur resu旭tshigh旭ighthowapparent旭ydisparateen抄抄es inabio旭ogica旭systemcanbe integratedintoafunc抄ona旭eco旭ogica旭unitsWea旭sodemonstratehowposi抄onwithinadynamicnetworkstructurecanhaveimportanteco旭ogica旭consequencess

K E Y W O R D S

dynamicnetworksppo旭ydomypredwoodantspsocia旭grouppsurviva旭ana旭ysis

ゲ科 |科INTRODUCTION

Anindividua旭vsaccesstoresourcesisstrong旭yinluencedbyitsposi抄onintheenvironmentre旭a抄vetothatresourcesThiscanhaveimportantbehaviora旭 consequencesq for examp旭ep op抄ma旭 foraging strategieshaveevo旭vedtomakebestadvantageofavai旭ab旭eresourcespgivenanindividua旭vsposi抄onintheenvironmentェYdenbergpゴググゼォsThisispar-抄cu旭ar旭ytrueinspeciessuchassocia旭insectspwhichformneststhatarespa抄a旭旭yixedェat旭eastintheshorttermォsTheposi抄onofanestintheenvironmentis旭ike旭ytoafectaccesstoresourcesandu旭抄mate旭ytheitnessoftheindividua旭swithinthenestェMcG旭ynnpゴグゲゴォs

Manyantspeciesinhabitmu旭抄p旭espa抄a旭旭yseparatedpbutsocia旭旭yconnectednestspastrategyca旭旭edpo旭ydomyェDeboutpSchatzpE旭iaspケMckeyp ゴググゼqRobinsonp ゴグゲジォsNestswithin a po旭ydomous sys-temotenexchangeresourcesェesgspBuczkowskipゴグゲゴqE旭旭ispProcterpBuckham、BonnetpケRobinsonp inpressqHofmannpゴグゲジォsAnestvsaccess toresourceswi旭旭dependnoton旭yon its 旭oca抄onwithin theforagingenvironmentbuta旭soonitsposi抄onre旭a抄vetoothernestssForexamp旭epinpo旭ydomouswoodantェFormica lugubrisォco旭oniesfoodandotherresourcesaretransportedthroughtheco旭onybyworkerstrave旭inga旭ongtrai旭sbetweennestsェE旭旭ispFrankspケRobinsonpゴグゲジqE旭旭isケRobinsonp ゴグゲズp ゴグゲ葦ォsThe combined nests and trai旭s of a

Page 3: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

ゴ科 |科 科架 ELLIS ET AL.

po旭ydomouswoodantco旭onythereforeactasaresourceredistribu-

抄onnetworkrfoodresourcesaretransferreda旭ongthetrai旭sbetweenpairs of nestsp resu旭抄ng in co旭ony、旭eve旭 redistribu抄on of resourcesorganizedata旭oca旭 旭eve旭ェE旭旭isケRobinsonpゴグゲ葦qE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォsWoodantsvmajorsourceoffoodishoneydewpaspa抄a旭旭yandtem-

pora旭旭y stab旭e resource ェDomischp Rischp ケ Robinsonp ゴグゲ葦ォs For aworkerpthereforepaccesstofoodwi旭旭dependnoton旭yontheirnestsv旭oca抄onwithin the stab旭e foraging environment but a旭so on theirnestsvposi抄oninthenestnetworkstructuresWorkersfromthesameco旭onypbutinhabi抄ngdiferentnestspthereforehavediferentaccesstoresourcessHoweverptheeco旭ogica旭consequencesofthisdiferen-

抄a旭accesstoresourcesofnestswithinthenetworkpandtheefectthat thisdiferen抄a旭accesshason thestructureof theco旭onypareunc旭ears

Inapo旭ydomousco旭onyptherearesevera旭possib旭eeco旭ogica旭con-

sequencesofanestvsaccesstoresourcessForexamp旭epanestvssur-viva旭pisespitscon抄nuedinhabita抄onpis旭ike旭ytodependonitsabi旭itytoaccessenoughresourcestosustaintheantswithinthenestsSimi旭ar旭ypworkerswithinanestmaybeinluencedbyaccesstoresourceswhenfoundingnewnestssInpo旭ydomouswoodantco旭oniespnewnestsareoten estab旭ished by buddingrDuring buddingpworkers and queens旭eave a nest on foot to found a newnest ェBourkeケ Franksp ゲゾゾズqE旭旭isケRobinsonpゴグゲズォsItwou旭dbeexpectedthatthedecisionofantswithinanesttobudanewnestisinluencedpposi抄ve旭yornega抄ve旭ypbytheirnestェthefoundernestvsォaccesstoresourcesェHo旭wayケCasepゴグググq LananpDornhauspケBronsteinp ゴグゲゲq SorvariケHakkarainenpゴググズォs It is important tonote thatbothof these traitsr surviva旭andbuddingpare inherent旭y抄medependentandneedtobestudiedinadynamicframeworks

Theeco旭ogica旭interdependenceofnestswi旭旭deinethenatureofthepo旭ydomoussystemsInamonodomousco旭onyェaco旭onyinhab-

i抄ngasing旭enestォp thesurviva旭andbuddingofanestareafectedon旭ybyproper抄esinherenttothatnestpsuchasitssizeand旭oca抄onin the environmentsNestswithin a po旭ydomous systemmay simi-旭ar旭ysurviveandbudbasedon旭yontheirinherentproper抄espwithnoeco旭ogica旭consequencesofthenestnetworkstructuresSurviva旭andbuddingbasedon旭yoninherentproper抄esofanestwou旭dsuggestthatthereisa旭ow旭eve旭ofintegra抄onbetweennestsinthesystemandthatapo旭ydomousco旭ony issimp旭yac旭usterofmutua旭旭ynon-

aggressivenestsandnotpartofasing旭ecoopera抄veandfunc抄ona旭units In contrastp if the nests of a po旭ydomous system are part ofthesamefunc抄ona旭unitpthesurviva旭andbuddingofeachnestwi旭旭beafectednoton旭ybyinherentnestproper抄espbuta旭sobyeitheritsposi抄onintheco旭onynestnetworkormoregenera旭co旭ony、旭eve旭efectss

Inthisstudypweinves抄gatehowthesurviva旭andbuddingofnestsinpo旭ydomousco旭oniesareafectedbythree 旭eve旭soforganiza抄onrェiォatributesoftheindividua旭nestp ェiiォposi抄onoftheindividua旭nestwithinthenetworkpandェiiiォproper抄escommontothewho旭enetworksTheeco旭ogica旭consequencesofdiferen抄a旭accesstoresourceswithinapo旭ydomousco旭onywi旭旭giveimportantinsightsintohowpo旭ydomousco旭oniesarestructuredandpmoregenera旭旭ypthepoten抄a旭importanceofanindividua旭vsposi抄onwithinadynamicnetworks

ゴ科 |科MATERIALS AND METHODS

ゴsゲ科|科Study species and study site

Weinves抄gatedthedynamicsofthenestnetworksofthepo旭ydomousredwoodantFormica lugubrisp amemberof theeco旭ogica旭旭y impor-tantF. rufaspeciesgroupェStockanケRobinsonpゴグゲ葦qStockaneta旭sp2016).Wood ants are the dominant invertebrate predator in theirenvironmentq they hunt and scavenge for a variety of invertebratepreypinc旭udingotherantspeciesェDomischeta旭spゴグゲ葦qMabe旭ispゲゾ芦ジqSavo旭ainenケVeps士旭士inenpゲゾ芦芦ォsHoweverpthemajorityoffoodforredwoodantco旭oniesisprovidedbyforagingforhoneydewco旭旭ectedfrom sap、feeding hemipterans in the canopy ェDomisch eta旭sp ゴグゲ葦qRosengrenケSundstr塾mpゲゾゾゲォsThesehemipteranco旭oniesprovideaspa抄a旭旭yandtempora旭旭ystab旭efoodsourcefortheantssAna旭ysisofthestructureofwoodantnestnetworkshashigh旭ightedtheimpor-tanceofhoneydewtransportinstructuringtheco旭onytrai旭structureェE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォsDetai旭edobserva抄onofthetrai旭sbetweenwoodantnestshasa旭sosuggestedthathoneydewisthemainresourcebeingtransporteda旭ongtheinternesttrai旭sェE旭旭isケRobinsonpゴグゲズpゴグゲ葦ォsThisstudywasconductedattheLongshawEstateincentra旭Eng旭andsFormica lugubrisistheon旭yF. rufagroupェtheredwoodantsォspeciesatthissitesTheF. rufagrouparethedominantantsinEuropeanwood-

旭ands ェJohansson ケ Gibbp ゴグゲ葦q Savo旭ainen ケ Veps士旭士inenp ゲゾ芦芦ォsTheiron旭ysigniicantcompe抄torsarethereforeotherwoodantspe-

ciesェJohanssonケGibbpゴグゲ葦ォsTheabsenceofotherwoodantspeciesatthissitemeanstheF. lugubrishavenosigniicantinterspeciiccom-

pe抄torssThesiteisamixtureofwood旭andpastureandhistoricp旭anta-抄onssWoodantsconstructnestmoundsfrompineneed旭esandothermateria旭 avai旭ab旭e in the 旭eaf 旭iters In Eng旭andp Formica lugubris are

po旭ygynousandeachnestoftheco旭onyis 旭ike旭ytocontainmu旭抄p旭equeensェE旭旭isケRobinsonpゴグゲジqProctereta旭spゴグゲ葦ォsScotspineェPinus

sylvestrisォpoakェQuercus sp.ォp旭archェLarix sp.ォsycamoreェAcer pseudopla-

tanusォpandsi旭verbirchェBetula pendulaォarethemostcommontreespe-

ciesatthesitesWoodantco旭oniesatthesiteshownopreferenceforpar抄cu旭artreespeciespneitherdotheyshowanytempora旭varia抄onintreespeciespreferenceェSamue旭E旭旭isunpublishedォsThe旭ackofprefer-enceforpar抄cu旭artreespeciessuggeststhattheresourcesavai旭ab旭efrom thediferent tree species at the site are approximate旭y equa旭sTheir旭argesizepstab旭efoodsourcespand旭ackofsigniicantpredatorsandcompe抄torsmeanthatwoodantnestsareotenpresent inthesame旭oca抄onfora旭ongperiodof抄meェRischpE旭旭ispケWiswe旭旭pゴグゲ葦qRobinsonケRobinsonpゴググ芦ォs

ゴsゴ科|科Network mapping

Werepresentedthepo旭ydomousco旭oniesasnetworkspwiththenestsandtreesasnodesandtheinternestandforagingtrai旭sasedgesェesgspLatyeta旭spゴグゲゲqCookpFrankspケRobinsonpゴグゲジqE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジqFigureゲォsWoodants formc旭earabove、ground trai旭sbetweennestsェinternest trai旭sォ and between nests and trees ェforaging trai旭sォs Thetrai旭sconsistofworkerstrave旭inga旭ongixedpathsotentranspor抄ngresourcesp predominant旭y honeydewp invertebrate preyp and brood

Page 4: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

科架 科 | 科ザELLIS ET AL.

F IGURE  ゲ科Timeseriesofco旭onyIIbusedinthisstudytoi旭旭ustratesomeoftheeco旭ogica旭consequencesofnestnetworkpositioninpo旭ydomousFormica lugubris

co旭oniessAsma旭旭networkwaschosenforthepurposeofsimp旭icitysェaォCo旭onyIIbatthefivetimepointsusedinthisstudysNestsarerepresentascirc旭esandcategorizedashavinga旭owresourcef旭owェnorma旭izedbetweenessof旭essthanグsゴズrpa旭eorangeォamedium旭eve旭ofresourcef旭owェnorma旭izedbetweenessofmorethanグsゴズand旭essthanグsゼズrorangeォpandahigh旭eve旭ofresourcef旭owェnorma旭izedbetweenessofgreaterthanグsゼズrdeeporange⦆brownォsNestswithab旭ackcrossarethosewhichwi旭旭notsurviveunti旭thenexttimepointェnodataforaftersummerゴグゲジpsononestsaremarkedasbeingabandonedォsGreentriang旭esrepresenttreessThe旭inesbetweenpointsrepresentforagingェgreenォandinternesttrai旭sェgrayォsNestswitha旭owormediumf旭owwereabandonedmoreoftenthanthosewithahighf旭owsェbォCo旭onyIIbatジtimepointsinthestudysAsabovepcirc旭esrepresentnestssCirc旭eco旭orrepresentthechangeinf旭owthroughthenestsincethe旭asttimepointqb旭ueindicatesadecreaseornochangeinf旭owofresourcessincethe旭asttimepointsPinkshowsnestswhichhaveincreasedinresourcef旭owsincethe旭asttimepointsB旭ackcirc旭esarethenew旭yfoundednestssB旭ackout旭inesrepresentnestsfromwhichanewnestェsォhasbeenfoundedェfoundersォqgrayout旭inesrepresentpossib旭efounderssNestswithanincreasedresourcef旭owweremore旭ike旭ytofoundnewneststhanthosewithastaticordecreasedresourcef旭ow

Page 5: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

ジ科 |科 科架 ELLIS ET AL.

ェE旭旭is ケ Robinsonp ゴグゲズp ゴグゲ葦ォsWorkers show very high ide旭ity totrai旭sprare旭yswitchingbetweentrai旭soncetheyhavebeenrecruitedェE旭旭is ケ Robinsonp ゴグゲ葦q Gordonp Rosengrenp ケ Sundstr塾mp ゲゾゾゴォsWedeineapo旭ydomousco旭onyastwoormorenestsconnectedbyinternesttrai旭sェE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォsOurdeini抄onofaco旭onyispthere-

forep basedon func抄ona旭 resource exchangebetweennestsp ratherthanonthebasisofaggressionorre旭atednesss

Weusethesamemappingmethodemp旭oyedbyE旭旭iseta旭sェゴグゲジォprevious旭y at this site tomap the same co旭onies over ジ addi抄ona旭抄me points over the next ゴyearss For each co旭onyp at eachmap-

ping抄me pointpwe recorded the spa抄a旭 and topo旭ogica旭 旭ayout ofthenestsptreespandtrai旭ssForthetrai旭spwemeasuredthe旭engthofthe trai旭p compassdirec抄onof the trai旭p and the traicon the trai旭sThe traicon the trai旭wasmeasuredas the 旭engthof trai旭neededto ind ゲグworkersp which can be converted into number of antspercmoftrai旭andthennumberofantsontheen抄re旭engthofthetrai旭sTheadvantageofbasingtrai旭traicondistanceneededtoindantspratherthanarate、basedmeasurepisthatitisnotre旭iantonthespeed atwhich the ants aremovingpwhich is strong旭y afectedbytheambienttemperatureェRosengrenpゲゾゼゼォsAnttraicisameasureoftrai旭strengthbasedon旭yonthenumberofantspassinga旭ongthetrai旭q howeverp this is 旭ike旭y tobeafectedby thenumberofwork-ers avai旭ab旭e to trave旭 a旭ong the trai旭ssTrai旭weight is ameasureoftrai旭importanttoapar抄cu旭arnestpre旭a抄vetothepopu旭a抄onsofthenestsbeingconnectedsWeca旭cu旭atedeachtrai旭vsweightbydividingthetota旭numberofantsonthetrai旭bythemeanpopu旭a抄onofthenestsconnectedbythetrai旭ェE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォsForforagingtrai旭sptheweightofthetrai旭sarere旭a抄vetothepopu旭a抄onoftheforagingnestェE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォs

Foreachmappingofeachco旭onypwea旭soes抄matedthepopu-

旭a抄onsofthenestsェChenケRobinsonpゴグゲザォpmeasuredthecanopy

cover over the nestsp and recorded the species of the trees usedfor foragingsTheworker popu旭a抄on in a nestwas es抄mated fromthevo旭umeofthenestmoundpca旭ibratedatthissitewithamark・re旭ease・recapture measure ェChen ケ Robinsonp ゴグゲザq E旭旭is eta旭spゴグゲジォsCanopy coverwas es抄matedon thebasis of digita旭 photo-

graphstakenfromver抄ca旭旭yaboveeachnestェE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォsEachmapwasusedtoconstructaspa抄a旭旭yembeddednetworkoftheco旭-onypwithedgesweightedbytrai旭strengthpandthenodeproper抄esofnestpopu旭a抄onェhereaterrnestsizeォpdistancetothenearesttreepandcanopycoversWeexaminedhowthenestnetworksofthirteenpo旭ydomouswoodantco旭onieschangedover抄mesThirteenofthe旭argestco旭oniesatthesitewerestudiedpchosenfromapre旭iminarysurveyinMayゴグゲゴェTab旭eゲqAppendixSゲォsTheco旭onieswereirstfu旭旭ymapped in 旭ateAugust ゴグゲゴ ェana旭yzed as sta抄c networks inE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォsFor thenextゴyears ェゴグゲザandゴグゲジォp theco旭o-

nieswere fu旭旭ymapped ェusing themethods out旭ined aboveォ twiceperyearroncein旭atespringandagainin旭atesummersEachremap-

pingwasperformedb旭indpwithoutreferencetothemapsofprevious抄me pointssWood ants show seasona旭 ac抄vity paternsrThey arequiescent over winterp beginning foraging ac抄vity ェand producingsexua旭ofspringォin旭atespringpandcon抄nuingforagingthroughoutthesummerandear旭yautumnェMaedereta旭spゴグゲ葦ォsRemappingco旭-onies in 旭ate springandagain in 旭ate summer therefore representsthebeginning and theheight of the foraging seasonp respec抄ve旭ysThe抄mingof the 旭ate springmappingwasdependenton the抄m-

ingofspringineachyearandwasnotperformedun抄旭temperatureswerehighenoughthatbothforagingandinternesttrai旭ac抄vitywerebeing performed ェRosengrenp ゲゾゼゼォs Late summer mapping wasa旭waysperformed in thesecondha旭fofAugustsWoodantac抄vitycanbedependentontemperatureandweathercondi抄onssoa旭旭co旭-oniesweremappedinwarmpdrycondi抄onss

TABLE  ゲ科Detai旭softheco旭oniesusedinthisstudysNumbersrefertothenestspresentintheco旭onyatthat抄mepointsSpringrefersto旭ateMayェthebeginningoftheforagingseasonォandsummerin旭ateAugustェthepeakoftheforagingseasonォsNetchangeinnestsdescribesthediferenceinnumberェandpercentageォofnestsintheco旭onybetweensummerゴグゲゴandsummerゴグゲジsAveragenestpopu旭a抄onェnestsizeinthetextォreferstothemeannumberofantspredictedtobeinthenestsofeachco旭ony

Tota旭 number of nestsNet change in number of nests

Average nest popu旭a抄on (range)2012- Summer 2013- Spring 2013- Summer 2014- Spring 2014- Summer

I 21 16 ゲズ 11 ゲジ ┋ゼェ┋ザザsザ鯵ォ ゼ芦pゼ芦グェ葦ゴズ・ゲpゼゾゲp葦ゲゼォ

IIa ジ ザ ジ ジ ジ グェグ鯵ォ ゴゴpゾジゲェゴゾグ・ゾザp芦芦ザォ

IIb 6 6 6 9 9 ┊ザェ┊ズグ鯵ォ ゲゼp葦グゲェゲズ葦グ・葦ゴp葦ジゲォ

III 12 12 芦 9 16 ┊ジェ┊ザザsザ鯵ォ ザズジザズェゲズ葦・ゲ葦葦p芦ゲズォ

IV 12 9 6 7 7 ┋ズェ┋ジゲs葦鯵ォ ザ葦pズ芦芦ェ芦ズゲ・ゲ芦ズpズググォ

V ゲジ 11 10 芦 2 ┋ゲゴェ┋芦芦鯵ォ ゴゾpゴゼゴェズゴゴ・ゴ葦ズpググズォ

VI ゲジ 12 12 ゲザ 11 ┋ザェ┋ゴゲ鯵ォ ゲ芦p芦ゴゼェゲゲゾ・ゲゲグpグザゾォ

VII 7 7 ジ ズ 芦 ┊ゲェ┊ゲジ鯵ォ ゴゲpゲグゾェゴ芦ズ・ゲゲジpゴザ芦ォ

VIII 6 ザ ジ 6 ジ ┋ゴェ┋ザザsザ鯵ォ ズジpゴズズェゴゲグ・ザ芦ジpゲ葦葦ォ

IX 9 11 17 11 ゲズ ┊葦ェ┊葦葦s葦鯵ォ ザゴp葦芦ゲェ葦芦・ゴ芦芦pザ芦グォ

X ゲザ 芦 10 9 芦 ┋ズェ┋ザ芦鯵ォ ゲ芦pジゴザェゲ葦グ・ゾグpグ葦ジォ

XI 20 ゲズ 10 10 17 ┋ザェ┋ゲズ鯵ォ ゲグpゲゼズェ芦ゾ・ゲザグp芦葦グォ

XII 6 6 ザ 芦 ザ ┋ザェ┋ズグ鯵ォ ゼジpズゴ芦ェゲ芦グズ・ゴジグpザゴゾォ

Page 6: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

科架 科 | 科ズELLIS ET AL.

ゴsザ科|科Ana旭ysis

Weare interested inhowdynamicproper抄esofnestswithinpo旭y-domous co旭onies are inluenced by their inherent atributes ェnestatributesォp their posi抄on within the nest network ェnetwork posi-抄onォpandatributessharedwiththewho旭eco旭onyェco旭onyatributesqsummarized inTab旭eゴォsA旭旭networkana旭ysiswasperformed inR ェRDeve旭opmentCoreTeamゴグゲゲォusingthewigraphxpackageェCsardiケNepuszpゴググ葦ォs

Nestatributesarethosebaseddirect旭yoninherentatributesofthenestsThepopu旭a抄onofanestェhereaternestsizeォpcanopycoveroverthenestpandthedistancefromthenesttothenearesttreea旭旭havebeenshown tobeeco旭ogica旭旭y important forwoodants ェChenケRobinsonpゴグゲジォandthereforehavethepoten抄a旭toinluencethesurviva旭andreproduc抄onofnestss

Network posi抄on proper抄es depend on a nestvs 旭oca抄on in theco旭ony nest networks Resource exchange between the nests of apo旭ydomouswoodantco旭onyisbasedonworkersfromagivennesttrave旭inga旭onginternesttrai旭stoneighboringnestspco旭旭ec抄nghoney-dewpandthenreturningtotheirorigina旭phomepnestェE旭旭isケRobinsonpゴグゲ葦ォsThismechanismisbasedon旭oca旭resourceexchangepbetweenneighboringnestspwithoutreferencetotheeiciencyofco旭ony、旭eve旭resourceredistribu抄onェE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォsAresourceexchangemecha-nismbasedonworkersfromagivennesttrea抄ngothernestsasfoodsourceshasthepoten抄a旭toresu旭tinresourceexchangethroughtheen抄reco旭ony ェCookpFrankspケRobinsonpゴグゲザqSchmo旭kepゴググゾォs Inasystembasedon旭oca旭resourceexchangepthequan抄tyofresourceavai旭ab旭etoagivennestcanberepresentedasthelowthroughthatnestr Inwoodantco旭oniesp resourceslowfromthe treespand theninsomecasesthroughtheinternesttrai旭networkptothenestssF旭owthroughanodeinanetworkcanbemeasuredasbetweenesscentra旭-itysBetweeness is ameasureof the tota旭 numberof shortestpathsbetweenpairsofnodesinthenetworkwhichpassthroughapar抄cu旭arnodeェesgspCrotpJamespケKrausepゴググ芦qWhiteheadpゴググ芦ォsWecor-rectforigraphvsreversetreatmentofweightedva旭uesbyinver抄ngthestrengthoftrai旭sforcentra旭ityana旭ysissOurmappednetworksinc旭udeboththenestsoftheco旭onyandthetreesonwhichtheyareforagingpisesp theana旭yzednetworkscontainboth theco旭onyand its foragingenvironmentsInourpo旭ydomousnetworkspa旭旭treesareattheendofanetworkontheirownbranchandthereforehaveabetweenessofzerosIncontrastpthebetweenessofanestisbasedonthenumberof

shortestpathspassingthroughitpinc旭udingthosefromtreestoothernestsinthenetworksBetweenesscanthereforeactasameasureofェpoten抄a旭ォresourcelowthroughapar抄cu旭arnestpdependentonthatnestvspaternoftrai旭sconnectedtoothernestsandtreesinthenet-worksWeusedaweightedmeasureofbetweenesstoaccountforthenumberofantsonatrai旭pgiventhesizeoftheconnectednestsェtrai旭weightォsToa旭旭owcomparisonbetweennetworksforeachco旭onypthebetweenesswasnorma旭izedtothe旭argestva旭uewithineachnetworkェesgspLusseauケNewmanpゴググジォs

Co旭ony atributes are those which are shared by a旭旭 the nestswithinanestnetworksAttheco旭ony旭eve旭pweareinterestedinhowtheamountofresourcesco旭旭ectedbytheen抄reco旭onyinluencesthesurviva旭andbuddingofthenestssWeusethenumberofantsonfor-agingtrai旭sasameasureofaco旭onyvsforagingefortsThenumberofantson foraging trai旭scanbeca旭cu旭atedbymu旭抄p旭ying theantspercmforeveryforagingtrai旭bythe旭engthofthatforagingtrai旭andthensummingtheseva旭uesforthewho旭eco旭onysThisforagingmetricisameasureoftheresourceacquisi抄onefortoftheen抄reco旭onypnotacountofthenumberofforagersintheco旭onysThera抄oofthetota旭popu旭a抄onoftheco旭onyェsummedsizeofa旭旭thenestsintheco旭onyォto the foragingefortof theco旭onyphereaterworkerrforaging ra抄opgivesanes抄mateof foragingefortperworker in theco旭onysA 旭owworkerrforaging ra抄o suggests a high foraging efort per workerpwhereasahighworkerrforaging ra抄o indicatesa 旭ow foragingefortperworkersWeusetheworkerrforagingra抄oasameasureofco旭ony、旭eve旭 resourceacquisi抄onsWe inves抄gatehowworkerrforagingra抄opredictsvarioussurviva旭ppopu旭a抄onchangepandbuddingofnestsェseebe旭owォtoseehowthisco旭ony、旭eve旭measureofresourceacquisi抄oncompares to the network posi抄on、based resource acquisi抄onmea-surernorma旭izedbetweenesss

Internesttrai旭scana旭sohaveinherentpwithin、networkpandco旭onyatributessAn important inherenttraitofan internesttrai旭 istheanttraiconthattrai旭sAnttraica旭ongatrai旭doesnottakeintoaccountthesizeof thenestsconnectedby the trai旭ssTrai旭weight takes intoaccountthesizeofthenestsbeingconnectedbythetrai旭ssTheper-sistence of an internest trai旭 is 旭ike旭y to be afected by the proper-抄esandnetworkposi抄onofthenestswhichtheyjoinsSimi旭ar旭ypthenumberofinternesttrai旭sandforagingtrai旭sassociatedwiththetwoneststhataninternesttrai旭connectscana旭sobeconsideredawithin、networkatributesThebetweenessofatrai旭pun旭ikethebetweenessofanestp isaco旭ony、旭eve旭efectsTrai旭betweenessisaco旭onyatribute

TABLE  ゴ科Thenestatributepnetworkposi抄onpandco旭onyatributevariab旭esusedtoinves抄gatetheeco旭ogica旭consequencesofanestposi抄oninapo旭ydomousco旭ony

Nest atributes Network posi抄on Co旭ony atributes

The popu握a試on of the nestsCa旭cu旭atedbasedonnestvo旭umes

Nest betweenness.Ca旭cu旭atedfromtheweightednetworkmapspinc旭udingbothtreesandnestss

Worker器forager ra試osThetota旭popu旭a抄onoftheco旭onyェthesumofa旭旭nestpopu旭a抄onsォdividedbytheinstantaneousnumberofworkersonforagingtrai旭sェfromthetrai旭strengthsォs

The canopy coverabovethenestssCo旭旭ectedusingdigita旭photographsofthecanopyabovethenests

The distance to the nearest treesCa旭cu旭atedasthe旭ineardistanceェisespnota旭ongforagingtrai旭sォfromanesttothenearesttrees

Page 7: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

葦科 |科 科架 ELLIS ET AL.

becauseitrepresentstheimportanceofatrai旭toco旭ony、旭eve旭resourcelowpratherthantheamountofresourcespassingthroughapar抄cu旭arnests

Anunder旭yingassump抄onofourmeasuresofbothnetworkposi-抄onproper抄esandco旭ony、旭eve旭proper抄esisthatthe旭eve旭oftraicon a foraging or internest trai旭 is representa抄ve of the quan抄ty ofresources ェspeciica旭旭y honeydewォ being transported a旭ong this trai旭sThisassump抄onisbasedondatashowingthatェiォthestrengthofaninternesttrai旭 isposi抄ve旭yre旭atedtothe旭eve旭offoragingbeingper-formedateachendofthetrai旭ェE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォpェiiォゼグ鯵ofinternestjourneysinvo旭vetransportofhoneydewェE旭旭isケRobinsonpゴグゲ葦ォpandェiiiォ the presence of internest trai旭s predicts transport of resourcesbetweennestsェProctereta旭spゴグゲ葦ォs

ゴsジ科|科Nest surviva旭

Weareinterestedinwhichfactorsェnestatributespnetworkposi抄onporco旭onyatributesォinluencethesurviva旭ofanestinapo旭ydomouswoodantco旭onysWeusesurviva旭ana旭ysispadaptedforusewithnet-workdataptoinves抄gatethefactorsinluencingnestsurviva旭sSurviva旭ana旭ysis is used to describe the抄meun抄旭 an event occursq for ourpurposesptheeventinques抄onisthatanestisabandonedェK旭einbaumケK旭einpゴグゲゴォsNestabandonmentcanbe inferred fromtheco旭onymapsby theabsenceof aprevious旭ypresentnest at thenext抄mepointsTheadvantageofusingsurviva旭ana旭ysisratherthanmorecon-

ven抄ona旭sta抄s抄ca旭techniquesisthatcensoreddatacanbeinc旭udedsCensoreddataoccurwhensomeinforma抄onisknownaboutanindi-vidua旭pforexamp旭ewhenanestisfoundedpbutnototherinforma抄onpforexamp旭ewhenitisabandonedsThisisusefu旭forourdataasmanynestssurvive旭ongerthanourstudyperiodsSurviva旭ana旭ysisa旭旭owsustoinves抄gatehowthesurviva旭ofanestchangeswith抄meinre旭a抄ontonetworkdynamicss

WeusedanextendedCoxpropor抄ona旭hazardェCoxPHォmode旭toinves抄gatetheefectofexp旭anatoryvariab旭esェXnォonthehazardpoten抄a旭ph(t) ェEqua抄onゲforthebasicCoxPHmode旭ォsThehazardpoten抄a旭 is the instantaneous poten抄a旭 per unit 抄me that a nestェor trai旭ォ is abandonedp given that the nest ェor trai旭ォ has survivedupto抄met ェK旭einbaumケK旭einpゴグゲゴォsThesurviva旭 func抄onpS(t)pdescribes the probabi旭ity that a nest survives 旭onger than a given抄metsTheextendedCoxPHmode旭a旭旭ows抄me、dependentexp旭an-

atory variab旭es to be inc旭uded in the ana旭ysis ェK旭einbaumケK旭einp2012).

IntheextendedCoxPHmode旭sreportedinthisstudyptheexp旭an-

atoryvariab旭esェXpォwerethenestatributepnetworkposi抄onporco旭-onyatributevariab旭eェsォbeing inves抄gatedsCo旭onywasa旭sousedasanexp旭anatoryvariab旭e ina旭旭mode旭ssWhen themode旭wasused todescribethesurviva旭ofatrai旭pthesurviva旭ofthenestsassociatedwiththetrai旭wasusedasanaddi抄ona旭exp旭anatoryvariab旭esThepresence

ofthenestswhichboundthetrai旭ispc旭ear旭ypvita旭tothesurviva旭pres-enceofthetrai旭itse旭fandwasa旭wayshigh旭ysigniicants

Surviva旭mode旭sassumeindependenceofdatapanassump抄onthatisvio旭atedbynetworkdatasThereforepweconstructedanu旭旭mode旭basedonthequadra抄cassignmentprocedureusingゲグpグググnodeatri-butepermuta抄onsェCrotpMaddenpFrankspケJamespゴグゲゲォsWethenmeasuredtheexperimenta旭teststa抄s抄cagainstthisnu旭旭distribu抄ontoderivesta抄s抄ca旭signiicancesPermuta抄onswereconstrainedwithineachmapェisespwithineachco旭onymapfromapar抄cu旭ar抄mepointォsA旭旭reportedsta抄s抄csassociatedwithsurviva旭werebasedonthequa-dra抄cassignmentproceduresForsomeana旭ysespthesma旭旭estco旭oniesェIIaandVIIIォwerenotinc旭udedbecausethe旭ackofvaria抄onpreventedthemode旭 deining the conidence interva旭sq this is indicated in thetextby旭oweredva旭uesofnsSurviva旭ana旭ysiswasperformedinRusingthewsurviva旭xpackageェTherneaupゴグゲゴォs

ゴsズ科|科Nest budding

Newnestswereotenfoundedwithinthepo旭ydomousco旭oniesusedinthisstudysAnestthatwasnotpresentattheprevious抄mepointwas considered to be new旭y foundedsWe used our co旭ony 旭ayoutmaps ェdescribedaboveォ to inferwhichnestactedasthefounderofthenew旭yfoundednestsWerefertoanestfromwhichanewnestisbuddedasitsnata旭nestsToinferwhichnestsarethenata旭nestspweassumedthatェiォnew旭ybuddednestsstayconnectedtotheirnata旭nestbyatrai旭andェiiォthenata旭nestisthenearestnesttowhichthenew旭ybuddednestisatachedsWeusetheseassump抄onstocategorizea旭旭thenestswithinaco旭onyaseitherrnew旭yfoundedpfounders ェthosefromwhichanewnesthasbeenbuddedォpornonfoundersェthosefromwhichanewnesthasnotbeenbuddedォsInsomecasespthenearestnest toanew旭y foundednestwasanothernew旭y foundednestsAstheorderof founda抄oncannotbe inferredp thenearestestab旭ishedェisespnotnew旭yfoundedォnestwascharacterizedasapossib旭efoundersNew旭yfoundednestscanbeeitherforagingornonforagingandarefounded both on and of exis抄ng trai旭s ェE旭旭isケRobinsonp ゴグゲズォs Inaddi抄onpthereisnoseasona旭efectofnestfounda抄onwithinthe抄meperiodsofourstudyrNestsareequa旭旭y旭ike旭ytobefoundedinspringandsummerェE旭旭isケRobinsonpゴグゲズォs

Weusedgenera旭旭inearmixedefectmode旭sェGLMMsォtoana旭yzehow budding re旭ates to various nestp nestwithin the networkp andco旭ony atributess In theGLMMsp founder status ェisesp founderp non-

founderporpossib旭efounderォwasusedastheresponsevariab旭ewiththevariab旭eェsォofinterestastheixedefectsCo旭onypnestIDpandsea-sonwereinc旭udedasrandomefectssFurtherdetai旭softhetestsaregiveninthesuppor抄nginforma抄onqthesuperscriptinthetextrefersto the rowof the tab旭e ェAppendix SゴォsA旭旭GLMMsused a binomia旭errorstructureanda旭ogit旭inkfunc抄onsWetestedsigniicanceusingachi、squaredana旭ysisofdevianceェAoDォwhichcomparesthefu旭旭mode旭to a nu旭旭 mode旭without the ixed efects If the nu旭旭 mode旭 and fu旭旭mode旭aresigniicant旭ydiferentpitindicatesthattheixedefecthasasigniicantimpactinexp旭ainingthedatasHerewereporttheresu旭tsoftheAoDsGLMMswereperformedinRusingthew旭meジxpackageェRDeve旭opmentCoreTeamRpゴグゲゲォs

ェゲォh�

t,X�

=h0(t)e

p∑

i=1

βiXi

X= (X1,X2,…Xp)

Page 8: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

科架 科 | 科ゼELLIS ET AL.

ザ科 |科RESULTS

ザsゲ科|科Nest surviva旭

The posi抄on of a nestwithin the network is a key predictor of itssurviva旭sNestswithahighernorma旭izedbetweenessaresigniicant旭ymore 旭ike旭y to survive than nestswith a 旭ower norma旭ized betwee-

nessェCoxPHrz┎┋ザs芦pn┎ズズ芦pp┎sグググゴqFigureゴォsThisre旭a抄onshipbetween norma旭ized betweeness and surviva旭 is robust evenwhennestsize is introduced intothesurviva旭mode旭sLargernestsaresig-niicant旭ymore旭ike旭ytosurvivethansma旭旭ernestsェCoxPHpz┎┋ゴsゼpn┎ズズ芦pp┎sググゴ葦ォpbutwheninc旭udedinthesamemode旭asanaddi-抄ona旭ixedefectpnestswithahighernorma旭izedbetweenessares抄旭旭signiicant旭ymore 旭ike旭y to survive thannestswith a 旭owernorma旭-izedbetweenessェCoxPHrnorma旭izedbetweenessrz┎┋ゴsグ葦pn┎ズズ芦pp┎sグゲジ葦qnestsizerz┎┋ゴsゴゲpn┎ズズ芦pp┎sグゲゾ芦ォs

Thesurviva旭ofinternesttrai旭sispsimi旭ar旭yppredictedbytheposi-

抄onwithinthenestnetworkoftheneststheyconnectsInternesttrai旭s

connecttwonestsqeachnesthasava旭ueofnorma旭izedbetweenesss

The旭owerofthesetwonorma旭izedbetweenessva旭uesissigniicant旭y

re旭atedtothesurviva旭oftheinternesttrai旭ェCoxPHrz┎┋ゲsザグpn┎ジゼ葦p

p┎sグザゼザォsThere旭a抄onshipisnega抄verAtrai旭associatedwithanest

witha旭ownorma旭izedbetweenessis旭ess旭ike旭ytosurvivethanatrai旭

associatedwithanestwithahighnorma旭izedbetweenesssNestswith

ahighnorma旭izedbetweenessaremore 旭ike旭ytosurvivethannests

witha旭ownorma旭izedbetweenessェaboveォwhichmayexp旭aintheneg-

a抄vere旭a抄onshipbetweentrai旭surviva旭andnestnorma旭izedbetwee-

nesssTrai旭s associatedwithanestwith 旭ownorma旭izedbetweeness

maybe旭ess旭ike旭ytosurvivebecausethenestis旭ess旭ike旭ytosurvivep

ratherthanduetotheposi抄onofthetrai旭withinthenetworksWe found no re旭a抄onships between surviva旭 and co旭ony、旭eve旭

efectss Nest surviva旭 is not signiicant旭y re旭ated to co旭onyworkerr-foragingra抄oェCoxPHrz┎グsゴジpn┎ズズ芦pp┎sザゼザゾォpevenwhennestsizeisa旭soinc旭udedinthesurviva旭mode旭ェCoxPHrz┎グsザ芦pn┎ズズ芦pp┎sザジ芦ズォsSimi旭ar旭yptrai旭surviva旭isnotsigniicant旭yre旭atedtoeithertrai旭 betweeness ェCox PHr z┎┋ゲs葦芦p n┎ジゼ葦p p┎sグ葦ジ葦ォ or co旭onyworkerrforagingra抄oェCoxPHrz┎┋ゲsザゼpn┎ジゼ葦pp┎sゲグゲ葦ォs

Atributesofthenestsandtrai旭scana旭soinluencetheirsurviva旭sLargernestsaresigniicant旭ymore旭ike旭ytosurvivethansma旭旭ernestsェCoxPHpz┎┋ゴsゼpn┎ズズ芦pp┎sググゴ葦ォsHoweverptheothernestatri-buteswemeasureddonotafectsurviva旭sThesurviva旭ofagivennestis not signiicant旭y afected by either the distance from the nest tothenearesttreeェCoxPHrz┎┋ゲsゴジpn┎ズ芦ゲpp┎sゲグゲゼォorthecanopycoveroverthenestェCoxPHrz┎┋グsゲゼpn┎ズ葦ザpp┎sザゼゾ芦ォsInternesttrai旭swithahighant traicweresigniicant旭ymore 旭ike旭y tosurvivethantrai旭swith旭owanttraicェCoxPHrz┎┋ゴsジpn┎ジゼ葦pp┎sググジゴォsHoweverp there is no signiicant re旭a抄onship between trai旭 weightェwhichisadjustedforthesizesoftheconnectednestsォandtrai旭sur-viva旭ェCoxPHrz┎┋グsズゾpn┎ジゼ葦pp┎sゴ葦ゾゾォs

ザsゴ科|科Nest budding

Nests fromwhichnewnests havebeen founded ェfoundersォ have asigniicant旭y higher norma旭ized betweeness than those from whichno new nests have been founded ェnonfoundersォ ェAoD1: χ

2┎ゲゴsジpdf┎ゲpp┑sググゲqFigureザォsNestsotenchangeinnorma旭izedbetwee-

ness between two 抄me pointss Founder nests have a signiicant旭ygreaterincreaseinnorma旭izedbetweenessovertheperiodwhichthenewnestwasfoundedthannonfoundernestsェAoD2: χ2┎ゲジsゼpdf┎ゲpp < .0001).

Nestsinco旭onieswitha旭owworkerrforagingra抄oェisespahighfor-agingefortperworkerォarenotsigniicant旭ymore旭ike旭ytobefound-

ers than nests in co旭onieswith a highworkerrforaging ra抄o ェAoDザ: χ

2┎グsゲズp df┎ゲp p┎sゼグォs Simi旭ar旭yp nests in co旭onies which have a旭oweredworkerrforagingra抄o ェisespan increase inforagingefortperworkerォarenotsigniicant旭ymore 旭ike旭y tobefounders thannest inco旭onieswitha raisedworkerrforaging ra抄o ェAoDジ: χ2┎グsグジpdf┎ゲpp┎s芦グォs

F IGURE  ゴ科Nestsurviva旭dependsonthef旭owェmeasuredasnorma旭izedbetweenessォofresourcessェaォThemeanェ┓standarderrorォnorma旭izedbetweennessェpotentia旭resourcef旭owォofnestswhichsurvivetothenexttimepointpandthenestswhichareabandonedbeforethenexttimepointsェbォSurviva旭ofnestspredictedbytheextended、coxPHsurviva旭mode旭sCurvesrepresenthowthesurviva旭ofnestswithadefinedェandunchangingォresourcef旭owispredictedtochangewithtimesAhighresourcef旭ownestisanestwithanorma旭izedbetweenessofグsゾpmediumresourcef旭ownestisanestwithanorma旭izedbetweenessofグsズpanda旭owresourcef旭ownestisanestwithanorma旭izedbetweenessofグsゲsCurvesareca旭cu旭atedusingtheKap旭an・MeiermethodsTheerrorェSEォisthedifferencebetweensurviva旭indifferentco旭oniessEachpointrepresentsthesurviva旭ofanestatt+xtimepointsafterthenestisfoundedqfouristhemaximumtimepointsafterfoundationasourstudyon旭ycoveredfivetimepoints

(a)

(b)

Page 9: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

芦科 |科 科架 ELLIS ET AL.

Nest atributes do not predictwhether the nest has acted as afounders Founder nests are not signiicant旭y 旭arger thannonfoundernests ェAoDズ: χ

2┎グsゴグp df┎ゲp p┎s葦ズォs Simi旭ar旭yp nestswhich had agreaterincreaseinsizearenotsigniicant旭ymore旭ike旭ytobefound-

ersthannestswhichhavehada旭owerincreaseoradecreaseinsizeェAoD.6: χ

2┎グsグザp df┎ゴp p┎s芦ゼォs Founder nests are neither signii-

cant旭y c旭oser to trees ェAoD7: χ2┎グsゲゾp df┎ゲp p┎s葦葦ォp nor have a

signiicant旭y旭owercanopycovernestェAoD芦: χ2┎グsゼ芦pdf┎ゲpp┎sザ芦ォthannonfoundernestssNestsarenotsigniicant旭ymore 旭ike旭ytoactasfoundersinspringthaninsummerェAoD9: χ2┎グsゲ葦pdf┎ゲpp┎s葦ゾォs

We a旭so inves抄gated how the popu旭a抄on change of nests isafectedbynestatributespnestposi抄onpandco旭onyatributessWefoundnosigniicantefectsェresu旭tsreportedinAppendixSザォs

ジ科 |科DISCUSSION

In this studypwe found that the posi抄on of a nestwithin the net-workofpo旭ydomousFormica lugubrisco旭onieshasimportanteco旭ogi-ca旭consequences for thatnestandthestructureand integra抄onoftheco旭onysNestswithahigherlowofresourcespevenifthiscomesindirect旭yviaothernestsphaveanincreasedchanceofsurvivingandfoundingnewneststhannestswitha 旭owerlowofresourcesqnestsizeisa旭soaccountedforanddoesnote旭iminatethisefectsDistanceto thenearest foraging treedoesnotafectnestsurviva旭sResourcelowthroughanestdependsonitsconnec抄onstotheothernestsandhowititsintothebroaderstructureofthenetworksThesurviva旭andbuddingofanestisdependentonitsre旭a抄onshipwithothernestsandthewiderpaternofinterac抄onbetweenthenestsinthepo旭ydomousco旭onysOurresu旭tsshowthatpdespitebeingspa抄a旭旭yseparatedptheinterconnected nests of a po旭ydomous co旭ony can be considered asing旭e eco旭ogica旭 unitp at 旭east in terms of resource acquisi抄onsWea旭sodemonstratethatdynamicnetworkposi抄oncanhaveimportanteco旭ogica旭consequencess

Theviewofthenestsofpo旭ydomouswoodantco旭oniesasforminga sing旭e eco旭ogica旭 unitp supported by our resu旭tsp suggests that thefactorsinluencingtheitnessofindividua旭sinagivennestare旭ike旭ytobestrong旭y 旭inkedtotheitnessof individua旭s inothernestssTheabi旭ityofanesttosurviveandbuddependspinpartponitsposi抄onintheco旭onynestnetworksThisdependenceshows that the resourcemovementthroughtheco旭onyhasanimportanteco旭ogica旭inluencesChanges in theenvironmentnearanygivennesthave thepoten抄a旭toafectthesurviva旭andbuddingofneststhroughoutthenetworksHoweverp it is important tonote that the surviva旭 and reproduc抄onofnestsaredrivenbyproximateprocesspname旭ytheaccessofnestsvia the workers within themp to resourcess This inding supportsotherworkthathasdetectednoevidencefortop、downpco旭ony、旭eve旭efectsonthestructureofpo旭ydomousco旭oniesェE旭旭iseta旭spゴグゲジォsTheextenttowhichnestscanbeconsideredaspartofthesameco旭onypsuper、co旭onyporsuper、organismisanimportantconsidera抄onwhenassessingp forexamp旭ep the 旭eve旭atwhichse旭ec抄onacts inaco旭onyェHe旭anter士p StrassmannpCarri旭旭opケQue旭旭erp ゴググゾqKennedypU旭旭erpケHe旭anter士pゴグゲジqMofetpゴグゲゴォs

Resourcesareotendistributedheterogeneous旭y in theenviron-

mentqpo旭ydomymaybeawaytomoreeicient旭yexp旭oit thesedis-persedresourcesェCooketa旭spゴグゲザqHo旭wayケCasepゴグググqLananeta旭spゴグゲゲqSchmo旭kepゴググゾォsThenestandforagingnetworkofpo旭ydomousco旭oniescanbeviewedasatransporta抄onnetworktomoveresourcesfromfoodsourcestothenestsandthenbetweennestsェCooketa旭spゴグゲジqLatyeta旭spゴグゲゲォsTransporteiciencyreferstotheeasewithwhichresourcescanlowthroughanetworksInthepo旭ydomousnestsystempnestswithahighresourcelowareatpointsinthenetworkimportant for co旭ony、旭eve旭 resource redistribu抄on and thereforeco旭ony、旭eve旭transporteiciencyェesgspCroteta旭spゴググ芦qPernaケLatypゴグゲジォs Ifnetworktransporteiciency isbeingretainedwithinaco旭-onypnestsandtrai旭swithahigherresourcelowpandthereforegreaterimportance for eiciencypmaybemore 旭ike旭y to survive than thosewitha 旭owerbetweenesssWefoundthatnestswithahighresourcelowaremore 旭ike旭ytosurvivethannestswitha 旭owerbetweenesssHoweverptrai旭swithahigherresourcelowarenotmore旭ike旭ytosur-vivethantrai旭switha旭owerbetweenesssEicienttransportstructuresare therefore not preferen抄a旭旭y being retained in the nest networksAddi抄ona旭旭yptheprocessofnestfounda抄onwi旭旭a旭sodegradeeicienttransportstructuressAsnewnestsarefoundedbynestswithahightransportva旭ueェahighlowofresourcesォpthiswi旭旭a旭terthestructureoftheco旭onyaroundthatnestsThisestab旭ishmentofnewnestsandtrai旭swi旭旭changetheprevious旭yexis抄ngpeicientp transportstructuress Inasystemwhichisunderstrongse旭ec抄vepressureforeiciencypit isexpectedthathigh旭yefec抄vetransportstructureswi旭旭beretainedsAsthisisnotthecaseintheredwoodantpo旭ydomousco旭oniespitmaybethattransporteiciencyisnotunderstrongse旭ec抄vepressures

Thelowofresourcesthroughapar抄cu旭arnestcanchangeover抄meduetoothernestsinthenetworkbeinggainedand旭ostsTheinte-

gratednatureofthesystemmeansthatagivennestcou旭dmaintainthesameconnec抄onstoneighboringnestsandtreesbuts抄旭旭undergoachangeintheamountofresourcesavai旭ab旭etoitェandthereforeitschancesofsurvivingandreproducingォpduetonestsbeingabandoned

F IGURE  ザ科Nestswithahighernorma旭izedbetweenessaremore旭ike旭ytoactasfoundersofnewneststhannestswitha旭owernorma旭izedbetweenessェAoDrχゴ┎ゾsゼpdf┎ゴpp ┎ sググ芦ォsForthefigurepbetweenessiscategorizedasグpゲp旭owェ┑グsゴズォpmediumェグsゴズ・グsゼズォporhighェ┒グsゼズォ

Page 10: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

科架 科 | 科ゾELLIS ET AL.

orfoundede旭sewhereintheco旭onysNestsinunproitab旭eareaspandthereforewitha旭owresourcelowparemore旭ike旭ytobeabandonedthannests inproitab旭eareassThesedynamicswi旭旭 resu旭t in theco旭-onymovingtowardresourcesandawayfromunproitab旭eareassFora spa抄a旭旭y embeddednetworkp suchas apo旭ydomousnetworkp thismovementisphysica旭movementofnodessInnetworkswhicharenotspa抄a旭旭yembeddedpsuchassocia旭networkspthisprocesscou旭dresu旭tin anetworkc旭usteringaroundcertainnodesp forexamp旭e individu-

a旭swith informa抄onsThe reversecou旭da旭sooccurqanetworkcou旭dc旭uster away from speciic nodesp for examp旭e diseased individua旭sinasocia旭networksThesechangesinthenetworkstructurearese旭f、organizedpresu旭抄ngfromse旭ec抄vepressurebasedonan individua旭vsposi抄oninthenetworks

Thenestnetworksofpo旭ydomousantco旭oniesarepinsomewayspana旭ogous to the socia旭 networks of individua旭 organismss Like indi-vidua旭spantnestscansurviveandreproduceェinthesenseoffoundingnewnestsォsTherearep howeverp crucia旭 diferencessForexamp旭ep thedeathofanindividua旭anima旭inasocia旭networkhasdirectitnesscon-

sequencess In contrastp a旭though abandoning anestwi旭旭 resu旭t in the旭ossoftheresourcesinvestedinconstruc抄ngthenestェwhichmaybeconsiderab旭eォpitisun旭ike旭ytoresu旭tinthedeathoftheantsinthenestqtheywi旭旭simp旭yjoinothernestsintheco旭onysDespitetheseimportantdiferencesppo旭ydomousant co旭oniesmaybeusefu旭mode旭sof socia旭networkssSimi旭artotheantnestnetworksptheposi抄onofanindividua旭inasocia旭networkcanhaveimportantconsequencesfortheiraccesstop forexamp旭ep informa抄on ェesgspB旭onderケDornhauspゴグゲゲqFarinepAp旭inpShe旭donpケHoppitpゴグゲズォanddisease ェesgspCrosseta旭spゴググジqOterstaterケThomsonpゴググゼォsHoweverp旭inkingthesenetworkposi-抄onefectstothe旭ifehistoryofindividua旭sischa旭旭engingpduetothedif-icu旭抄esinco旭旭ec抄ngsuicient旭yhigh、qua旭itytempora旭datatoa旭旭owthenetworkstobeexamineddynamica旭旭yェCroteta旭spゴググ芦pゴグゲゲqKurverseta旭spゴグゲジqWhiteheadpゴググ芦ォsUsingthepo旭ydomousnestnetworkspwehavedemonstrated thatnetworkposi抄oncanhavean importantinluenceonthesurviva旭ppopu旭a抄onchangepandbuddinginadynamicsystemsThisprovidesausefu旭basis forexamining the importanceofnetworkposi抄oninotherbio旭ogica旭systemssuchassocia旭systemss

The network dynamics observed in these po旭ydomous co旭oniesi旭旭ustratethepoten抄a旭feedbackbetweentheindividua旭旭eve旭andthesystem旭eve旭inbio旭ogica旭networkssTheposi抄onofanindividua旭withinabio旭ogica旭systemcanafectthatindividua旭vsexposuretopforexam-

p旭epfoodpmatespinforma抄onpanddiseaseェesgspAp旭inpFarinepMorand、FerronpケShe旭donpゴグゲゴqChrist旭eyeta旭spゴググズqOhケBadyaevpゴグゲグォsThestructureofthenetworkispinturnpafectedbythenodeswithinthenetworksForexamp旭eptheovera旭旭paternofinterac抄onsbetweenindividua旭s in a systemcanbe inluencedby avarietyof bio抄c andabio抄cfactorssuchasfoodavai旭abi旭itypsexdemographicspandseasonェBrentpMacLarnonpP旭atpケSemp旭epゴグゲザqDardenpJamespRamnarinepケCrotpゴググゾqFostereta旭spゴグゲゴォsThenestswithinpo旭ydomousco旭-onieshigh旭ighthowtheseefectscanbereciproca旭inadynamicsys-temsDiferen抄a旭surviva旭andreproduc抄onofnodes inasystemwi旭旭changethestructureofthenetworkasnewnodesappearandothersdisappears Thiswi旭旭p in turnp change an individua旭vs re旭a抄ve posi抄onwithinthenetworkpa旭teringitschancesofsurvivingandreproducings

Thenetworkpthereforepwi旭旭becon抄nua旭旭yrestructuringpresu旭抄nginadynamicsystemwhichisnotstab旭ethrough抄mesDynamicprocesseswi旭旭reactdiferent旭ytosta抄csystemswhenfacingeco旭ogica旭andenvi-ronmenta旭changesェKurverseta旭spゴグゲジォs

In conc旭usionpwe found that the surviva旭 and budding of nestswithinpo旭ydomousFormica lugubrisco旭oniesarere旭atedtotheirposi-抄oninthetrai旭networksTheseresu旭tshigh旭ighthowapparent旭ydispa-rateen抄抄esinabio旭ogica旭systemcanbeintegratedintoafunc抄ona旭eco旭ogica旭unitsIta旭soshowshowindirectaccesstoresourcespthroughothersinaresourceexchangesystempcanhaveimportanteco旭ogica旭consequencess

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We wou旭d 旭ike to thank Duncan Procterp Phi旭ip Buckham、BonnetpJonPitchfordpKanchonDasmahapatrapandLotaSundstr塾mforva旭u-

ab旭ediscussionandcommentsonthemanuscriptsWea旭sothanktheEvo旭u抄onandTheore抄ca旭Eco旭ogyresearchgroupsattheUniversityofYorkforhe旭pfu旭discussionssWewou旭daddi抄ona旭旭y旭iketothankChrisMi旭nerpCar旭Hawkepandthestafandvo旭unteersattheNa抄ona旭TrustvsLongshawestatefortheirhe旭pandsupportsSEacknow旭edgesfundingfromtheNa抄ona旭Environmenta旭ResearchCounci旭andtheNa抄ona旭TrustsEJHRacknow旭edgesfundingfromtheRoya旭Societys

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

Nonedec旭areds

DATA ACCESSIBILITY

Dataareprovidedinthesupp旭ementarymateria旭ss

REFERENCES

Ap旭inpLsMspFarinepDsRspMorand、FerronpJspケShe旭donpBsCsェゴグゲゴォsSocia旭networks predict patch discovery in awi旭d popu旭a抄on of songbirdssProceedings of the Royal Society Bp 279p ジゲゾゾ・ジゴグズs doirゲグsゲグゾ芦⦆rspbsゴグゲゴsゲズゾゲ

B旭onderp Bsp ケ Dornhausp As ェゴグゲゲォs Time、ordered networks revea旭 旭im-

ita抄ons to informa抄on low in ant co旭oniess PLoS ONEp 6p ゲ・芦sdoirゲグsゲザゼゲ⦆journa旭sponesググゴグゴゾ芦

BourkepAsFsGspケFrankspNsRsェゲゾゾズォsSocia握 evo握u試on in antssPrincetonpNJrPrincetonUniversityPresss

BrentpLsJsNspMacLarnonpAspP旭atpMsLspケSemp旭epSs ェゴグゲザォsSeasona旭changes in the structure of rhesus macaque socia旭 networkssBehavioral Ecology and Sociobiologyp 67p ザジゾ・ザズゾs doirゲグsゲググゼ⦆sググゴ葦ズ、グゲゴ、ゲジズズ、芦

Buczkowskip Gs ェゴグゲゴォs Co旭ony spa抄a旭 structure in po旭ydomous antsrComp旭imentaryapproachesrevea旭diferentpaternssInsectes Sociauxp59pゴジゲ・ゴズグsdoirゲグsゲググゼ⦆sグググジグ、グゲゲ、グゴゲゲ、ゾ

ChenpYspケRobinsonpEsJsHsェゴグゲザォsAcomparisonofmark・re旭ease・recap-

turemethodsfores抄ma抄ngco旭onysizeinthewoodantFormica旭ugu-

brissInsectes Sociauxp60pザズゲ・ザズゾsdoirゲグsゲググゼ⦆sグググジグ、グゲザ、グザググ、zChenpYsp ケ Robinsonp Es Js Hs ェゴグゲジォs The re旭a抄onship between canopy

coverandco旭onysizeof thewoodantFormica lugubris、 Imp旭ica抄onsforthetherma旭efectsonakeystoneantspeciessPLoS ONEp9pゲ・ゲ芦sdoirゲグsゲザゼゲ⦆journa旭sponesグゲゲ葦ゲゲザ

Page 11: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

ゲグ科 |科 科架 ELLIS ET AL.

Christ旭eypRsMspPinchbeckpGsLspBowerspRsGspC旭ancypDspFrenchpNsPspBennetp Rsp ケ Turnerp Js ェゴググズォs Infec抄on in socia旭 networksr Usingnetworkana旭ysis to iden抄fyhigh、risk individua旭ssAmerican Journal of

Epidemiologyp162pゲグゴジ・ゲグザゲsdoirゲグsゲグゾザ⦆aje⦆kwiザグ芦Cookp Zsp FrankspDsWsp ケ Robinsonp Es JsHs ェゴグゲザォs Exp旭ora抄onversus

exp旭oita抄oninpo旭ydomousantco旭oniessJourna握 of Theore試ca握 Bio握ogyp323Cpジゾ・ズ葦sdoirゲグsゲグゲ葦⦆jsjtbisゴグゲザsグゲsグゴゴ

CookpZspFrankspDsWspケRobinsonpEsJsHsェゴグゲジォsEiciencyandrobust-ness of ant co旭ony transporta抄on networkss Behavioral Ecology and

Sociobiologyp68pズグゾ・ズゲゼsdoirゲグsゲググゼ⦆sググゴ葦ズ、グゲザ、ゲ葦葦ズ、芦CrotpDsPspJamespRspケKrausepJsェゴググ芦ォsExploring animal social networksp

ゲstednsPrincetonpNJrPrincetonUniversityPresssCrotpDsPspMaddenpJsRspFrankspDsWspケJamespRs ェゴグゲゲォsHypothesis

tes抄ng in anima旭 socia旭 networkss Trends in Eco握ogy キ Evo握u試onp 26pズグゴ・ズグゼsdoirゲグsゲグゲ葦⦆jstreesゴグゲゲsグズsグゲゴ

CrosspPsCspL旭oyd、smithpJsOspBowerspJsAspeta旭sェゴググジォsIntegra抄ngasso-

cia抄ondataanddiseasedynamicsinasocia旭ungu旭ate過rBovinetuber-cu旭osisinAfricanbufa旭ointheKrugerNa抄ona旭ParksAnnales Zoologici

Fennicip41p芦ゼゾ・芦ゾゴsCsardipGspケNepuszpTsェゴググ葦ォsTheigraphsotwarepackageforcomp旭ex

networkresearchsInterJournal, Complex Systemsp1695.

DardenpSsKspJamespRspRamnarinepIsWspケCrotpDsPsェゴググゾォsSocia旭imp旭i-ca抄onsofthebat旭eofthesexesrSexua旭harassmentdisruptsfema旭esocia旭ityandsocia旭recogni抄onsProceedings of the Royal Society Bp276pゴ葦ズゲ・ゴ葦ズ葦sdoirゲグsゲグゾ芦⦆rspbsゴググゾsググ芦ゼ

DeboutpGsp Schatzp Bsp E旭iaspMspケMckeypDs ェゴググゼォs Po旭ydomy in antsrWhatweknowpwhatwethinkweknowpandwhatremainstobedonesBiological Journal of the Linnean Societyp90pザゲゾ・ザジ芦s

Domischp Tsp RischpAs Csp ケ Robinsonp Es Js Hs ェゴグゲ葦ォsWood ant forag-

ingandmututa旭ismwithaphidss InJsAsStockanpケEsJsHsRobinsonェEdssォpWood Ant Eco握ogy and Conserva試on ェppsゲジズ・ゲゼゼォsCambridgerCambridgeUniversityPresss

E旭旭ispSspFrankspDsWspケRobinsonpEsJsHsェゴグゲジォsResourceredistribu抄oninpo旭ydomousantnestnetworksrLoca旭org旭oba旭nBehavioral Ecologyp25pゲゲ芦ザ・ゲゲゾゲsdoirゲグsゲグゾザ⦆beheco⦆aruゲグ芦

E旭旭ispSspProcterpDsSspBuckham、BonnetpPspケRobinsonpEsJsHsェinpressォInferringpo旭ydomyrAreviewoffunc抄ona旭pspa抄a旭andgene抄cmeth-

ods for iden抄fyingco旭onyboundariess Insectes Sociauxp doirゲグsゲググゼ⦆sグググジグ、グゲ葦、グズザジ、ゼ

E旭旭ispSspケRobinsonpEsJsHs ェゴグゲジォsPo旭ydomyinredwoodantss Insectes

Sociauxp61pゲゲゲ・ゲゴゴsdoirゲグsゲググゼ⦆sグググジグ、グゲザ、グザザゼ、zE旭旭ispSspケRobinsonpEsJsHsェゴグゲズォsThero旭eofnon、foragingnestsinpo旭y-

domouswood ant co旭oniessPLoS ONEp10p eグゲザ芦ザゴゲs doirゲグsゲザゼゲ⦆journa旭sponesグゲザ芦ザゴゲ

E旭旭ispSspケRobinsonpEsJsHs ェゴグゲ葦ォs Inter、nestfoodsharingwithinwoodantco旭oniesrResourceredistribu抄oninacomp旭exsystemsBehavioral

Ecologyp27p葦葦グ・葦葦芦sFarinepDsRspAp旭inpLsMspShe旭donpBsCspケHoppitpWsェゴグゲズォsInterspeciic

socia旭 networkspromote informa抄on transmission inwi旭d songbirdssProceedings of the Royal Society Bp282pゴグゲジゴ芦グジs

Fosterp Es Asp Franksp DsWsp Morre旭旭p Ls Jsp et a旭s ェゴグゲゴォs Socia旭 networkcorre旭ates of food avai旭abi旭ity in an endangered popu旭a抄on of ki旭旭erwha旭espOrcinus orca. Animal Behaviourp83p ゼザゲ・ゼザ葦s doirゲグsゲグゲ葦⦆jsanbehavsゴグゲゲsゲゴsグゴゲ

Gordonp Ds Msp Rosengrenp Rsp ケ Sundstr塾mp Ls ェゲゾゾゴォs The a旭旭oca抄onof foragers in red wood antss Ecological Entomologyp 17p ゲゲジ・ゲゴグsdoirゲグsゲゲゲゲ⦆jsゲザ葦ズ、ゴザゲゲsゲゾゾゴstbグゲゲ葦ゼsx

He旭anter士p Hsp Strassmannp Js Esp Carri旭旭op Jsp ケ Que旭旭erp Ds Cs ェゴググゾォsUnico旭onia旭 antsr Where do they come fromp what are they andwhere are they goingn Trends in Eco握ogy キ Evo握u試onp 24p ザジゲ・ザジゾsdoirゲグsゲグゲ葦⦆jstreesゴググゾsグゲsグゲザ

HofmannpBsDsェゴグゲジォsQuan抄ica抄onofsuperco旭onia旭traitsintheye旭旭owcrazyantpAnoplolepis gracilipes. Journal of Insect Sciencep14pゲ・ゴゲs

Ho旭waypDsAspケCasepTs ェゴグググォsMechanismsofdispersedcentra旭、p旭aceforaginginpo旭ydomousco旭oniesoftheArgen抄neantsAnimal Behaviourp59pジザザ・ジジゲsdoirゲグsゲググ葦⦆anbesゲゾゾゾsゲザゴゾ

JohanssonpTspケGibbpHsェゴグゲ葦ォsInterspeciiccompe抄抄onandcoexistencebetweenwoodantssInJsAsStockanpケEsJsHsRobinsonェEdssォpWood

Ant Eco握ogy and Conserva試on ェpps ゲゴザ・ゲジズォs Cambridger CambridgeUniversityPresss

KennedypPspU旭旭erpTspケHe旭anter士pHs ェゴグゲジォsAreant superco旭oniescru-

cib旭es of a newmajor transi抄on in evo旭u抄onn Journa握 of Evo握u試onary Biologyp1�13pdoirゲグsゲゲゲゲ⦆jebsゲゴジザジ

K旭einbaumpDsGspケK旭einpMsェゴグゲゴォsSurvival analysis: A self-learning textpザrdedssNewYorkrSpringers

KurverspRsHsJsMspKrausepJspCrotpDsPspeta旭sェゴグゲジォsTheevo旭u抄onaryandeco旭ogica旭consequencesofanima旭socia旭networksrEmergingissuessTrends

in Eco握ogy キ Evo握u試onp29pザゴ葦・ザザズsdoirゲグsゲグゲ葦⦆jstreesゴグゲジsグジsググゴLananpMsCspDornhauspAspケBronsteinpJsLsェゴグゲゲォsThefunc抄onofpo旭y-

domyr The ant Crematogaster torosa preferen抄a旭旭y forms new nestsnear food sources and for抄ies outsta抄onss Behavioral Ecology and

Sociobiologyp65pゾズゾ・ゾ葦芦sdoirゲグsゲググゼ⦆sググゴ葦ズ、グゲグ、ゲグゾ葦、芦LatypTspRamschpKsp ItopKspeta旭s ェゴグゲゲォsStructureandforma抄onofant

transporta抄onnetworkssJournal of the Royal Society, Interfacep8pゲゴゾ芦・ゲザグ葦sdoirゲグsゲグゾ芦⦆rsifsゴグゲグsグ葦ゲゴ

Lusseaup Dsp ケ Newmanp Ms Es Js ェゴググジォs Iden抄fying the ro旭e that ani-ma旭sp旭ay in their socia旭 networkssProceedings of the Royal Society Bp271ェSupp旭ォpSジゼゼ・Sジ芦ゲsdoirゲグsゲグゾ芦⦆rsb旭sゴググジsグゴゴズ

Mabe旭ispAsAsェゲゾ芦ジォsInterferencebetweenwoodantsandotherantspe-

cies ェHymenopterap Formicidaeォs Netherlands Journal of Zoologyp 34p1�20.

MaederpAspCherixpDspBernasconipCspeta旭sェゴグゲ葦ォsWoodantreproduc抄vebio旭ogyandsocia旭systemssInJsAsStockanpケEsJsHsRobinsonェEdssォpWood Ant Eco握ogy and Conserva試onェppsズゲ・芦ゲォsCambridgerCambridgeUniversityPresss

McG旭ynnp Ts Ps ェゴグゲゴォs The eco旭ogy of nest movement in socia旭insectss Annual Review of Entomologyp 57p ゴゾゲ・ザグ芦s doirゲグsゲゲジ葦⦆annurev、ento、ゲゴグゼゲグ、ゲググゼグ芦

MofetpMsWsェゴグゲゴォsSuperco旭oniesofbi旭旭ionsinaninvasiveantrWhatisasocietynBehavioral Ecologyp23pゾゴズ・ゾザザsdoirゲグsゲグゾザ⦆beheco⦆arsグジザ

OhpKsPspケBadyaevpAsVsェゴグゲグォsStructureofsocia旭networksinapasser-inebirdrConsequencesforsexua旭se旭ec抄onandtheevo旭u抄onofma抄ngstrategiessThe American Naturalistp176p芦グ・芦ゾsdoirゲグsゲグ芦葦⦆葦ズズゴゲ葦

OterstaterpMsCspケThomsonpJsDsェゴググゼォsContactnetworksandtrans-mission of an intes抄na旭 pathogen in bumb旭e bee ェBombus impa試ens)

co旭oniessOecologiap154pジゲゲ・ジゴゲsdoirゲグsゲググゼ⦆sググジジゴ、ググゼ、グ芦ザジ、芦PernapAspケLatypTsェゴグゲジォsAnima旭transporta抄onnetworkssJournal of the

Royal Society, Interfacep11pゴグゲジグザザジsProcterpDsSspCotre旭旭pJspWatspKspeta旭sェゴグゲ葦ォsDoescoopera抄onmean

kinshipbetweenspa抄a旭旭ydiscreteantnestsnEco握ogy and Evo握u試onp6p芦芦ジ葦・芦芦ズ葦s

RDeve旭opmentCoreTeamRsェゴグゲゲォsRrALanguageandEnvironmentforSta抄s抄ca旭Compu抄ngsRFoundsStatsComputsゲrジグゾs

RischpAsCsp E旭旭isp SspケWiswe旭旭pHs ェゴグゲ葦ォsWhere andWhynWood antpopu旭a抄oneco旭ogysInJsAsStockanpケEsJsHsRobinsonェEdssォpWood

Ant Eco握ogy and Conserva試on ェpps 芦ゲ・ゲグ葦ォs Cambridger CambridgeUniversityPresss

RobinsonpEsJsHsェゴグゲジォsPo旭ydomyrTheorganisa抄onandadap抄vefunc-抄onofcomp旭exnestsystemsinantssCurrent Opinion in Insect Sciencep5pザゼ・ジザsdoirゲグsゲグゲ葦⦆jscoissゴグゲジsグゾsググゴ

RobinsonpNsAsp ケ Robinsonp Es JsHs ェゴググ芦ォsThe popu旭a抄on of the redwoodantFormica rufaLsェHymperopterarFormicidaeォatGaitBarrowsNa抄ona旭NatureReservepLancashirepEng旭andovertheゴグyearperiodゲゾ芦葦、ゴググ葦 nest 旭ongevityp reproduc抄on and the efect of manage-

mentsBri試sh Journa握 of Entomo握ogy and Natura握 Historyp21pゴゴズ・ゴジゲsRosengrenp Rs ェゲゾゼゼォs Foraging strategy of wood antss Acta Zoologica

Fennicap150pゴ・ザグsRosengrenpRspケSundstr塾mpLsェゲゾゾゲォsTheinterac抄onbetweenredwood

ants Cinara aphidsp and piness A ghost of mutua旭ism pastn In Cs RsHux旭eypケDsFsCut旭erェEdssォpAnt「P握ant Interac試onspゲstedsェpps芦グ・ゾゲォsOxfordrOxfordUniversityPresss

Page 12: Ecological consequences of colony structure in dynamic ant ...eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/109858/2/...Trail_Networks.pdf · the structure of wood ant nest networks has highqighted the

科架 科 | 科ゲゲELLIS ET AL.

Savo旭ainenpRspケVeps士旭士inenpKs ェゲゾ芦芦ォsAcompe抄抄onhierarchyamongborea旭antsrImpactonresourcepar抄抄oningandcommunitystructuresOikosp51pゲザズ・ゲズズs

Schmo旭kep As ェゴググゾォs Beneits of dispersed centra旭、p旭ace foragingr Anindividua旭、based mode旭 of a po旭ydomous ant co旭onys The American

Naturalistp173pゼゼゴ・ゼゼ芦sdoirゲグsゲグ芦葦⦆ズゾ芦ジゾザSorvaripJspケHakkarainenpHs ェゴググズォsDeforesta抄onreducesnestmound

sizeanddecreasestheproduc抄onofsexua旭ofspringinthewoodantFormica aquilonia. Annales Zoologici Fennicip42pゴズゾ・ゴ葦ゼs

Stockanp JsAsp ケ Robinsonp Es Js Hs ェEdssォ ェゴグゲ葦ォsWood Ant Ecology and

Conserva試onsCambridgerCambridgeUniversityPresssStockanp JsAsp Robinsonp Es Js HspTragerp Js Csp et a旭s ェゴグゲ葦ォs Introducing

woodantsrEvo旭u抄onpphy旭ogenypiden抄ica抄onanddistribu抄onsInJsAsStockanpケEsJsHsRobinsonェEdssォpWood Ant Eco握ogy and Conserva試on

ェppsゲ・ザゼォsCambridgerCambridgeUniversityPresssTherneaupTsェゴグゲゴォsApackageforsurviva旭inRsWhiteheadpHsェゴググ芦ォsAna握yzing Anima握 Socie試es器 Quan試ta試ve methods for

vertebrate social analysissChicagorUniversityofChicagoPresss

YdenbergpRsCsェゴググゼォsProvisioningsInDsWsStephenspJsSsBrownpケRsCsYdenbergェEdssォpForaging: Behaviour and Ecologypゲstedsェppsゴゼザ・ザグザォsLondonrTheUniversityofChicagoPressLtdss

SUPPORTING INFORMATION

Addi抄ona旭Suppor抄ngInforma抄onmaybefoundon旭ineinthesupport-inginforma抄ontabforthisar抄c旭es

How to cite this ar抄c旭erE旭旭isSpFranksDWpRobinsonEJHsEco旭ogica旭consequencesofco旭onystructureindynamicantnestnetworkssEcol Evolsゴグゲゼqググrゲ・ゲゴsdoirゲグsゲググゴ⦆eceザsゴゼジゾs