21
臺灣地區高中職悲傷輔導相關碩博士論文之分析 臺灣地區高中職悲傷輔導相關碩博士論文 之分析 楊文堯 * 摘要 本研究的目的在檢視國內高中職悲傷輔導相關碩博士論文的研究情形、內 容、結果與發現,提出意見,做為教育當局、學校進行悲傷輔導之參考,以及 未來研究之建議。主採內容分析法,自 2002 年至 2012 年間有關高中職悲傷輔 導相關的碩博士論文,共收集 64 篇。 研究結論如下:一、就研究內容之發現而言:()研究者的背景以「教育 心理與輔導研究所」最多;()研究方法以質性研究法為多(37 篇,57.9)其次為量化研究(25 篇,39.06),質量並用 2 (3.13)()碩士論文有 62 (96.875)、博士論文 2 (3.125)。二、就研究結果之發現而言:() 「生 命教育」一詞之涵義包含「生死教育」及「死亡教育」的內容;()失親者需 要輔導的相關機構協助,進行悲傷情緒的心理調適。 研究之建議如下:一、推動政策之建議:()加強高中職階段悲傷輔導相 關議題的課程;()加強學校或社政單位輔導人員的培訓;()師資培育機構 和護理學校開設「悲傷輔導」課程;()實施學校推動生命教育成果訪視。二、 未來悲傷輔導研究之建議:()增加行動研究法的研究;()鼓勵研究「臨終 關懷」的議題;()增加階段性、歷程性改變的研究;()進行以意義為中心 的喪親輔導(MCC)研究; ()鼓勵更多不同研究背景的研究者參與; ()增加博 士層面的研究成果。 關鍵詞:悲傷輔導、生死教育、失落事件 *高雄市立小港高中校長 投稿日期: 102 4 8 日;修改日期: 102 8 3 日;接受日期: 102 8 26 - 55 -

臺灣地區高中職悲傷輔導相關碩博士論文 之分析ntcuir.ntcu.edu.tw/bitstream/987654321/8070/2/3.pdf · 碩博士論文為範圍,共計64 篇(含2 篇博士論文、62

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    14

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • *

    2002 2012

    64

    ()

    ()(37 57.9)

    (25 39.06) 2 (3.13)() 62

    (96.875) 2 (3.125)()

    ()

    ()

    ()()

    ()

    ()()

    ()()

    (MCC)()()

    *

    102 4 8 102 8 3 102 8 26

    - 55 -

  • 28

    An analysis on theses and dissertations related to senior high school grief counseling studies

    from 1992 to 2012 in Taiwan, R. O. C.

    Wen-Yao Yang

    Abstract

    The purpose of this study is to review the theses and dissertations exploring

    any topic on senior high school grief counseling. Based on the results of the study,

    constructive suggestions are presented as a reference for educational authorities,

    guidance counselors, and future researchers. Content analysis method is mainly

    used to examine the collected 64 papers, finished from 1992 to 2012.

    The main findings of the study are summarized as follows.

    In terms of the content of the collected papers:

    1. The academic backgrounds of the researchers are mostly from the institutes

    of educational psychology and counseling.

    2. Qualitative research methods are used most frequently. Quantitative

    methods are used less; however, some of the papers used both methods at

    the same time. The numbers (and proportions) are as follows: 37(57.9%),

    25(39.06%), and 2(2.13%).

    3. There are 62(96.88%) theses and 2 dissertations (3.13%).

    In terms of the results of the study:

    1. The term life education is used to indicate life and death education and

    death education.

    2. The bereaved need the assistance from counseling institutions to achieve the

    emotional adjustment.

    The suggestions are proposed as follows.

    As for the implementation of policies:

    1. The course on the related topics on grief counseling should be reinforced in

    - 56 -

  • high school curriculum.

    2. The training for the guidance counselors at schools or social institutions

    should be enhanced.

    3. The course on grief counseling should be offered at teacher training

    institutes and nursing schools.

    4. The implementation of life education at schools should be evaluated.

    As for future research on grief counseling:

    1. Action research method should be encouraged.

    2. The topics on the hospice care should be explored more.

    3. The different stages and the process of grief counseling should be focused.

    4. The study on the meaning-centered counseling (MCC) for bereavement

    should be conducted.

    5. More researchers from different academic backgrounds should be involved

    in the studies on grief counseling.

    6. More doctoral dissertations should be encouraged on the study of grief

    counseling.

    Keywords: grief counseling, life-and-death education, loss in ones life

    - 57 -

  • 28

    (2012)

    2012 1 11 142,408

    2009

    (

    )

    19501960

    1970

    1993

    (2005)

    - 58 -

  • 1970

    1990 (2005)

    2002 2012

    ()

    ()

    ()

    2002 2012

    64 2 62

    ()

    1970

    (2012 ) 495 ( 15 480

    )

    - 59 -

  • 28

    2002 2012

    64 ( 2 62 )

    64

    ()

    1.

    2.

    3.

    (2005)

    - 60 -

  • ()

    (loss)

    (2010)

    StroebeSchut(1999)

    WongTomer(2011)

    StroebeSchut(2001)

    (Wong, 2008)

    ()

    TagliaferreHarbaugh(1990)

    Hughes

    Bowlby

    (Worden, 1991/1995)

    (2006)

    ()

    - 61 -

  • 28

    1999 9 21

    Wong(2008)

    ()

    (2000)

    (2005)(2002)

    (2005)bereavement

    Wong(2008)

    - 62 -

  • Wong Sherrie Mok 1996

    ( wong,

    2008)

    Wong 20022003

    ( wong, 2008)

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    - 63 -

  • 28

    (

    2003)1.2.

    3.

    Worden

    1.

    2.3.

    4.

    (2012)

    (2011)

    1.2.3.

    4.5.

    Parkes(1971)1.2.3.

    4.

    Bowlby(1980)1.2.

    3. 4.

    Rando(1988)1.

    2.

    3.Rando(1993)

    1. 2.

    Wong

    (MEANING-CENTERED COUNSELING ( MCC ) FOR BEREAVEMENT)

    (2012 11 26 )MCC

    - 64 -

  • MCC

    MCC

    ---

    MCC

    MCC

    MCC

    (MCC)

    2002

    2012 439 ( 12 427

    )

    2

    62 64

    64 (2005)

    - 65 -

  • 28

    ()

    22 34.38

    19 29.67 12 18.75 4 6.25

    2 3.13

    1 1.56

    1

    12 22 19 4 2 2 2 1

    18.75 34.38 29.67 6.25 3.13 3.13 3.13 1.56

    64

    ()

    (2003)

    ()(

    )(

    )()

    - 66 -

  • 29 45.3 24 37.5 4

    6.25 2 3.13

    1 1.56

    2

    29 24 1 2 4 2 2

    45.3 37.5 1.56 3.13 6.25 3.13 3.13

    64

    37 57.9

    25 39.06 2 3.13

    - 67 -

  • 28

    3

    37 25 2 64

    57.9 39.06 3.13 100

    64

    ()

    64

    2001

    ()

    ()

    - 68 -

  • ()

    ()

    24

    (DAP-R)

    ()

    p.01 1.2-.69

    68

    ()

    ()

    64 (3.125)

    - 69 -

  • 28

    2002 2012

    64

    ()

    1.

    64

    31 8

    2.

    (37 57.9)(25 39.06)

    2 3.13

    29 45.3 24 37.5

    4 6.25 2

    3.13 1 1.56

    3.64

    62 96.875 3.125

    ()

    1.

    2.

    - 70 -

  • ()

    1.

    (2008) 98

    2.

    3.

    4.

    98

    - 71 -

  • 28

    ()

    1.

    (2003)

    4

    2.

    3.

    37

    Parkes(1971)Bowlby(1980)

    Rando(1988) Stroebe Schut(1999200l)

    4.(MCC)

    Wong(2008)(MCC)

    /

    (MCC)

    5.

    - 72 -

  • ()

    6.

    64 2

    64

    2002 2012

    - 73 -

  • 28

    (2012)

    http://sowf.moi.gov.tw/stat/month/m1-02.xls

    (2011)301

    10-13

    (2003)2122-8

    (2012)(N.L.P)318

    2-4

    (2003)

    (2000)(

    )

    (2010)

    ()

    (2005)

    (2006)

    (2008)98

    http://life.ltsh.ilc.edu.tw/discenter/discenter2.aspx

    (2002)71-5

    Worden J. W. (1995)(

    )( 1991)

    Bowlby, J. (1980). Attachment and loss. Vol. 3. Loss: Sadness and depression.

    London: Hogarth Press and Institute of Psychoanalysis.

    Hughes, M.(1995). Bereavement and support. Washington, DC: Taylor & Francis.

    Parkes, C. M. (1971). Psycho-social transitions: A field for study. Social Science

    and Medicine, 5, 101-115.

    Rando, T. A. (1988). How to go on living when someone you love dies. New York:

    Bantam Books.

    - 74 -

    http://www.airitilibrary.com/pubissue.aspx?PublicationID=16846478&view=pubresult%20http://www.airitilibrary.com/searchresult_1.aspx?Search=true&Condation=2%04%22%e6%9d%8e%e7%8e%89%e5%ac%8b%22%020http://www.airitilibrary.com/pubissue.aspx?PublicationID=16846478&view=pubresult%20http://www.airitilibrary.com/pubissue.aspx?PublicationID=16846478&view=pubresult%20
  • Rando, T. A. (1993). Treatment of complicated mourning. Champaign, IL: Research

    Press.

    Stroebe, M. S., Schut, H. (1999). The daul process model of coping with

    bereavementRationale and description. Death Studies, 23, 197-224.

    Stroebe, M. S., Schut, H. (2001). Meaning making in the Dual Process Model. In R.

    Neimeyer (Ed.), Meaning reconstruction and the experience of loss.

    Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

    Tagliaferre, L. & Harbaugh, G. L.(1990).Recovery from loss: A personalized guide

    to thegrieving process. Deerfield Beach, FL: Heath Communications, Inc.

    Wong, P. T. P. Tomer, A (2011).Beyond terror and denial: The positive

    psychology of death acceptance. Death Studies, 35, 99-106.

    Wong, P. T. P. (2008). Transformation of grief through meaning: Meaning-centered

    counseling for bereavement. In A. Tomer, G.. Eliason, & P. T. P. Wong (Eds.) ,

    Existential & spiritual issues in death attitudes (pp. 417-437). Mahwah, NJ:

    Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

    - 75 -