32
EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH Assistant Professor of Medicine Harvard Medical School Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center Boston, Massachusetts

EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

EARLY DETECTION SCREENINGThe Benefits, Risks, and Debate

J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPHAssistant Professor of Medicine

Harvard Medical School

Beth Israel Deaconess Medical CenterBoston, Massachusetts

Page 2: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Premise:Providing the HIGHEST

possible STANDARD OF CARE to the communities and

patients we serve

Page 3: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH
Page 4: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH
Page 5: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH
Page 6: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH
Page 7: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH
Page 8: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH
Page 9: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH
Page 10: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Key ---

Being able to offer a BROAD RANGE of Clinical Services to meet the needs of your patients

Page 11: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

QUALITY

Page 12: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

VALUE

Page 13: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Keep in mind:

Quality and Value

Are NOT mutually

EXCLUSIVE

Page 14: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Avoid

“CHEAP”

Page 15: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

“NO FRILLS”

is quite acceptable to most

Page 16: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Honestly assess your

capabilities

Page 17: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH
Page 18: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

….And the scope of services you COULD offer with the right

ALLIANCE

Page 19: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

For some, this GAP is a mere crack…..

Page 20: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

...For Others, it may be a…..CHASM!!!

Page 21: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Important factors to consider when looking to develop an

alliance

ALLIANCEversus

AFFILIATION

Page 22: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Factors to consider in developing an alliance

• Location

• Cost of Services/Procedures

• Reciprocity

Page 23: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Look for partners with INNOVATIVE programs

• Innovations -- Often HARD to implement

• Even when implemented are often more DIFFICULT to diffuse throughout an organization.

Page 24: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Carter’s Story:• Interest in Public Health and Medicine

• Role as a Primary Care Internist in an Academic Practice

• Care of Patients from Bermuda and the Caribbean (Jamaica, Barbados, Trinidad, Virgin Islands

Page 25: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

The HMFP - Family Hospital Corporation Relationship

Affiliation vs. Alliance

Page 26: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Reasons FHC wanted Relationships with Major

Medical Center

• Clinical Expertise

• Cutting edge Technology

• Training opportunities

Page 27: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Examples of Technologies

• Patientsite• Video Conferencing• On-line Continuing Medical Education

(CME)• Minimally Invasive Surgical Center• Joslin Vision Network (JVN)

Page 28: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Successes

• Emergency Medicine Training for Panama

• Liver Transplantation in Boston• Neonatal Cardiac Surgery• Emergency Medicine and ACLS

Training in Honduras• Visiting Professorships

Page 29: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Why Do Academic Medical Center develop Alliances?

• Access to New Markets• Expanding the scope of Clinical

Pathology for it Staff, Trainees• Name Branding• Mission-Driven

Page 30: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

These Relationships are :

• NOT a piece of cake!• NOT short-term• Take lots of work and perseverance

if either party hopes to reap any sustained benefits

Page 31: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Lessons Learned

• Program must be Doctor-supported and Doctor-Driven at the local level

• Must Have reliable, efficient Doctor to Doctor Communication

• Educational Opportunities are an important component for the local Physicians

Page 32: EARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and ...prostatehealthed.org/Summit2006/CARTER.pdfEARLY DETECTION SCREENING The Benefits, Risks, and Debate J. Jacques Carter, MD, MPH

Wrap Up

• Seek a BROAD range of Clinical Services

• Look for QUALITY with VALUE• Aim for INNOVATIVE programs• Recognize the importance of

DOCTOR to DOCTOR Collaborations• REMEMBER: This is a Two-Way

Street