Upload
darie-nicolae
View
223
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
1/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
2/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
3/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
4/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
5/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
6/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
7/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
8/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
9/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
10/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
11/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
12/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
13/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
14/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
15/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
16/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
17/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
18/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
19/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
20/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
21/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
22/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
23/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
24/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
25/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
26/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
27/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
28/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
29/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
30/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
31/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
32/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
33/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
34/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
35/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
36/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
37/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
38/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
39/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
40/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
41/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
42/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
43/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
44/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
45/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
46/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
47/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
48/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
49/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
50/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
51/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
52/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
53/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
54/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
55/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
56/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
57/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
58/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
59/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
60/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
61/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
62/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
63/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
64/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
65/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
66/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
67/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
68/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
69/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
70/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
71/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
72/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
73/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
74/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
75/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
76/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
77/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
78/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
79/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
80/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
81/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
82/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
83/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
84/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
85/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
86/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
87/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
88/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
89/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
90/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
91/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
92/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
93/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
94/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
95/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
96/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
97/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
98/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
99/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
100/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
101/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
102/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
103/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
104/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
105/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
106/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
107/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
108/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
109/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
110/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
111/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
112/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
113/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
114/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
115/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
116/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
117/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
118/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
119/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
120/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
121/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
122/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
123/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
124/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
125/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
126/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
127/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
128/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
129/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
130/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
131/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
132/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
133/135
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
134/135
1
Further Addenda et Corrigenda (dec. 2014)
There is quite a number of entries in my personal copy of this booklet, including
additional references to primary sources as well as to secondary literature published inthe meantime, and I hope that in the future I shall have a chance to integrate them into thepresent file. Still, for the time being I have to confine myself to a few minor correctionsand additions. For a more detailed discussion of some issues, I may refer to Pt. I of mystudy "Plants in Early Buddhism and the Far Eastern Idea of the Buddha-Nature ofGrasses and Trees", Lumbini: Lumbini International Research Institute 2009.
n. 148: For Sanskrit fragments of the passage corresponding to Vin.Dh. (T vol. 22)584a24b7 see Jin-il CHUNG and Klaus WILLE, "Einige Bhikuvinayavibhaga-
Fragmente der Dharmaguptakas in der Sammlung Pelliot", in: Heinz BECHERT et al.(eds.), Untersuchungen zur buddhistischen Literatur II, Gttingen: Vandenhoeck &Ruprecht 1997: 7476.
n. 198: Vin IV 267 Vin IV 264,1f.
n. 231: aparaa = vegetables (CPD); cf. also Udo Heiner GRFE, SystematischeZusammenstellung kulturgeschichtlicher Informationen aus dem Vinayapitakam derTheravdin, Ph.d. diss. Gttingen 1974: 114.
n. 269: Cf. W.E. SOOTHILL and L. HODOUS, A Dictionary of Chinese Buddhist Terms(London 1937), p. 128a, s.v. , remarking with regard to the five pungent roots(which include garlic): "...if eaten raw they are said to cause irritability of temper, and ifeaten cooked, to act as an aphrodisiac." Cf. T vol. 39 No. 1791: 497a14f: ......,.
n. 390: Vi.M. Vin.M.
n. 414: On the meaning of mitradruh("belying a contract" > "harming a friend") see H.P.SCHMIDT, "Indo-Iranian Mitra Studies: The State of the Central Problem", in: tudesmithriaques (Acta Iranica 1978): 358.
29.1.1with ns. 444446: cf. also H.P. SCHMIDTin StII 5/6 (1980): 236 with n. 66.
31.2: Bhvaviveka Bhviveka.
n. 490: The ms. reading ritujant in MHd IX.144cd is (apart from the orthographic riinstead of ) metrically faulty (the syllables 2 and 3 in a pathymust not be both short)and has therefore been emended to tujatvt(cf. TJv P 360a2dus su skye ba yin pa'i phyir).My suggestion to read svpc cps tu (instead of ms. svpnnptu) is based onthe fact that there is no negation in the Tib. translation of the krik and on the fact thatthe TJv takes the whole verse IX.144 as an opponent's argument (introduced by ... gzhansmras pa: D 313b2) refuted only in the subsequent verse (introduced by 'di'i lan ni |: D313b6). To be sure, the reading of the ms., presenting verse 144 as negating theopponent's argument and verse 145 as supplying the appropriate argumentation, is by nomeans unacceptable. But in my opinion the structure as reflected in the Tib. translationand the TJv sounds more natural, the more so since we find the same structure in MH dIX.141 (opponent) and 142 (proponent's counterarguments).
7/25/2019 Early Buddhism Sentience Lambert
135/135
n. 494: Chr. Lindtner (in his edition of the Madhyamakahdaya, Chennai: The AdyarLibrary Research Centre 2001: 169) criticizes me for having emended the text of MHdIX. 146d (gadai ca vyabhicria) to gaai ca vyabhicrit, but actually I have merelystated that this is what the Tibetan translation of the verse seems to presuppose, withoutexpressing any preference for this reading, and my comment on the passage clearlysuggests the opposite. As for my emendation of dohaddyaprasiddhata in IX.146b(kept by Lindtner) to aprasiddhat(with Tib. ma grub nyid), it may be doubtful, a causalphrase being preferable for the argument. But aprasiddhata (suffix tas after aparticiple instead of a noun or an abstract) sounds problematic, and I was unable to findanother instance in the MHd. Perhaps we should emend to aprasiddhita.(cf. MHdV.30d).
n. 508: As regards MHd IX.145cd, Lindtner (op. cit. p. 108) follows Kawasaki'semendation of the ms. (vyabhicrt tu rpntena sidhyati sacittak, see KAWASAKI1986: 204 n.18) to vyabhicrt tu taravo na sidhyati sacittak. From the point of view of
meaning, this is impeccable, but I still think that my own emendation (vyabhicrttarte [or tair?] na sidhyati sacittat), amounting largely to the same as regards thepurport, is somewhat closer to the ms.
n. 542(forefathers wandering about in the form of birds): see also M. WITZELin StII 10(1984): 235.
Abbreviations:
Add. Additions to "Buddhism and Nature" (=BN 35-65).
AitU Aitareya-Upaniad
BN Lambert SCHMITHAUSEN, Buddhism and Nature. The Lecture
delivered on the Occasion of the EXPO 1990. An Enlarged Versionwith Notes. Tokyo (The International Institute for Buddhist Studies)1991. [Studia Philologica Buddhica, Occasional Paper Series, VII.]
Prt Bh Sa Bhiku-prtimokastra of the Sarvstivdins (see fn 21)