Upload
hubert-stevens
View
217
Download
3
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
INTERNATIONAL BACKDROP Euro Zone debt crisis dominating global agenda Euro Zone economy under significant pressure,
Germany the most positive, but has its problems US economy has surprised positively in 2012, but
growth still below trend UK suffering from austerity Emerging world still doing well Interest rates to remain at historically low levels for
foreseeable future – ECB will probably cut further Debt the big evil issue in developed world Fiscal consolidation will dominate developed world
agenda, with implications for global growth
10-YEAR BOND SPREADS (19/5/12)COUNTRY SPREAD OVER GERMANY
Germany 1.42%
France +142 bps
Belgium +189 bps
Italy +437 bps
Spain +482 bps
Portugal +1,054 bps
Ireland +584 bps
Greece +2,713 bps
DEBT & UNEMPLOYMENT IN DEVELOPED WORLD 2012 – WHAT A MESS!
Source: OECD, Dec 2011
Gross Govt Fin Liabilities % GDP
Net Govt Fin Liabilities % GDP
Net Borrowing % GDP
Unemployment Rate (Latest)
US 103.6% 80.3% -9.3% 8.1%
Euro Area 97.9 62.8% -2.9% 10.9%
Germany 87.3% 51.6% -1.1% 6.8%
France 102.4% 66.2% -4.5% 10.0%
Italy 128.1% 100.6% -1.6% 9.8%
Japan 219.1% 134.8% -8.9% 4.5%
UK 97.2% 68.9% -8.7% 8.3%
Canada 92.8% 36.6% -4.1% 7.2%
Ireland 118.8% 72.5% -8.7% 14.3%
THE EURO ZONE CRISIS Perception that crisis had eased at beginning of year,
now back with a bang Strong and unorthodox approach to – very non-
Germanic Realisation that cost of keeping EMU together < cost
of it falling apart Can Greece possibly survive? If not, implications for
the rest very tricky Spain, Portugal, Ireland and Italy face serious
challenges Another LTRO/more bond purchasing/further interest
rate cuts etc etc – a lot more work to be done Fiscal Compact small step towards solution – impose
new rules on fiscal management
THE FISCAL COMPACT
Crisis has exposed deep flaws in EMU structure
Lack of banking oversight; fiscal federalism & super finance ministry; Political union; Euro Debt Agency; Fiscal Discipline; lack of focus on growth
Structural Deficit not to exceed 0.5% GDP; Debt not to exceed 60% GDP; strict EU oversight/European Court of Justice
Rules based approach to fiscal management or political fig leaf?
What choice for Ireland?
IF IRELAND VOTES NO Ireland cannot prevent ratification of Treaty – 12 of 17 Euro
Zone countries required No obvious upside from voting NO Risk premium on Irish debt would increase In event of not being able to return to markets, could not
access ESM-would depend on more expensive funding Will undermine confidence in Ireland Impact on FDI? Would require greater austerity – delivery of public services
would come under massive pressure Croke Park deal shredded? Hard choices would become even harder Potential relief on promissory notes would be undermined Could we remain part of the euro?
THE IRISH ECONOMY TODAY?
Export sector doing well – broadly based Domestic Demand still very weak In 2011 GDP +0.7% but GNP -2.5% Two ‘Pillar Banks’ allegedly starting to lend at modest rates – long
way to go to normal credit conditions Public finances stabilising-deficit gradually narrowing-tax take ahead
of target Competitiveness gradually improving Households saved €12.9 bln in 2011: Gross Savings Ratio 14.1% IDA created extra 13,000 jobs in 2011 – inflow FDI continuing in
2012 House prices still falling -49.3% Sept 2007-March 2012 Bond yields have fallen-markets have greater confidence in policy-
but they remain high International coverage much more positive – Ireland perceived to be
taking the pain and doing the right things
SO FAR IN 2012
Q1 Retail Sales Volume -1.3%; Value -0.9% Q1 Retail Sales Ex-Cars Volume -2.6%; Value -1.8% Q1 Manufacturing Output -3.3% ‘Modern’ -2.0% ‘Traditional’ -
5.4% Jan-Feb Merchandise Exports +2.7% Live Register April -40,300 from July 2011 peak – role of
emigration? Jan-April 2012 Exchequer Deficit €7.1 bln (€9.9 bln in 2011) –
tax take ahead of target €370 million Credit remains very weak – SME sector a particular concern Housing activity continues to weaken Still a very challenging environment
PLANNED FISCAL CONSOLIDATION 2012-2015 (DEPT OF FINANCE)
2012 2013 2014 2015
Total Consolidation
€3.8 bln €3.5 bln €3.1 bln €2.0 bln
-Tax €1.6 bln €1.25 bln €1.1 bln €0.7 bln
-Current Expenditure
€1.45 bln €1.70 bln €1.9 bln €1.3 bln
-Capital Expenditure
€0.75 bln €0.55 bln €0.1 bln €0.0 bln
General Gov Deficit (% GDP)
8.6% 7.5% 5.0% 2.9%
General Gov Debt (% GDP)
114.3% 118.3% 117.0% 113.5%
GDP 1.3% 2.4% 3.0% 3.0%
Budget 2012 Breakfast Briefing
THE CHALLENGES AHEAD
Restoring sustainable public finances Improve competitiveness Market the country aggressively Sort personal debt overhang Rebuild sustainable economic model – identify
and nurture sectors that will represent the future
Continue to negotiate debt relief Create functioning banking system Create confidence Recovery in domestic demand the imperative and
the challenge