36
DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS

Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCEAN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS

Page 2: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

The Investigation Process for OVUII

•Traffic Violation

•Reasonable Suspicion

Vehicle in Motion

•Observations made by officer

•Statements by suspect

Personal Contact •Sobriety Tests

•PBT/PAS

Pre-Arrest Screening

Page 3: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

How many have been in this position?

“Oh…shhhhoot! It’s da cops!”

Page 4: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Contacting DUI drivers■ Officers use their senses when contacting drivers on traffic stop.

■ Divide attention by asking multi-part questions and follow up questions.

– License, registration and insurance, then…

– “Where are you coming from tonight?”

■ DUI drivers are usually unable to divide their attention.

■ Watch vehicle exit.

Page 5: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Field Sobriety Testing

Page 6: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Top Fifteen List

■ HGN

■ Walk & Turn

■ One Leg Stand

■ Modified Romberg Balance

■ Finger Count

■ Finger to Nose

■ Counting backwards (by 3’s)

■ Tracing

■ Tongue Twisters

■ Tapping Rate

■ Letter Cancellation

■ Grip Strength

■ Coin Pickup

■ Two-Point Tactile

Discrimination

■ Color Naming

Page 7: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

COLOR NAMING?

RED YELLOW BLUE GREEN BLACK

PINK ORANGE BROWN GRAY PURPLE

GREEN GRAY BLACK BLUE YELLOW

Page 8: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

COLOR NAMING?

RED YELLOW BLUE GREEN BLACK

PINK ORANGE BROWN GRAY PURPLE

GREEN GRAY BLACK BLUE YELLOW

Page 9: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Study Comparison

1983 Stats

■ HGN – 77%

■ Walk & Turn – 68%

■ One Leg Stand –

65%

■ HGN & WAT – 80%

1998 Stats

■ HGN – 88%

■ Walk & Turn – 79%

■ One Leg Stand – 83%

■ HGN & WAT – 91%

Page 10: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

What is Nystagmus?

Nystagmus is the involuntary jerking of the eye

Page 11: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Alcohol will slow (depress) the optical muscles

Page 12: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

3 - Pre-Test Observations(medical assessment)

■ Stimulus is held 12”-15”

Slightly above eye level

HGN

Page 13: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Resting Nystagmus

Page 14: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

ARE THE PUPILS

EQUAL IN SIZE?

Eliminate any possible

medical conditions

Page 15: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

IS THERE EQUAL

TRACKING?ELIMINATING

MORE MEDICAL

PROBLEMS

Page 16: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Lack ofSmooth Pursuit

16

When the eyes jerk or bounce as they follow a smoothly moving stimulus

Stimulus should be moved in a smooth manner to best observe the eyes in motion

Two-second timing is provided based on how the eyes should follow the stimulus if the individual is not impaired by alcohol and/or other drugs

Clue #1

Page 17: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Lack of Smooth Pursuit

Page 18: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

■ At extreme lateral gaze,

the nystagmus is

obvious and sustained

when the stimulus is

held for a minimum of

four seconds

Distinct and Sustained Nystagmus at Maximum Deviation

18

Clue #2

Page 19: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Distinct and Sustained Nystagmus at Maximum Deviation

Page 20: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Angle of Onset Prior

to 45 Degrees

Does the jerking start prior to a 45 degree angle?

The higher degree of impairment, the sooner the jerking will start to be observed.

Clue #3

Page 21: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Angle of Onset Prior to 45 Degrees

Page 22: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

6 Clues Maximum

■ Clues are generally progressive starting with a lack

of smooth pursuit.

■ HGN can begin as early as a .02 -.03 BAC

4 or more clues = 88% chance

of .08 BAC

Page 23: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Vertical Nystagmus

Page 24: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Clues for Walk and Turn Test■ Cannot maintain balance while listening to the instructions

■ Starts too soon

■ Stops while walking

■ Does not touch heel-to-toe

■ Steps off the line

■ Uses arms to balance

■ Improper turn

■ Incorrect number of steps

24

2 or more clues = 79%

chance of .08 BAC

Page 25: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Clues for One Leg Stand Test

■ Sways while balancing

■ Uses arms to balance

■ Hopping

■ Puts foot down

25

2 or more clues = 83%

chance of .08 BAC

Page 26: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Preliminary Alcohol Screening

■ PAS is a roadside screening for alcohol

– Helps establish probable cause

– Not admissible in trial

– Voluntary in Hawaii

Page 27: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Where it all leads…

Page 28: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

It takes less than you think to get arrested.

- A few drinks

- Minor traffic

violation(s)

- Odor of intoxicants

(maybe)

- A few clues on the

SFSTs

Page 29: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Statewide OVUII Arrests

*Jan. 1 through Aug. 31

2016

Alcohol = 5,630

Drugs =

235

2017

Alcohol = 5,837

Drugs =

259

2018

Alcohol = 5,325

Drugs =

251

2019

Alcohol = 3,375*

Drugs =

194*

Page 30: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

2018 BAC Averages by County

■ BIG ISLAND = .139

■ HONOLULU = .143

■ MAUI = .159

■ KAUAI = .196

Statewide average = .159

Page 31: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Enough already…let’s take a break!

Page 32: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

WHAT “ROLL” DO YOU TAKE? IF ANY?

Page 33: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE“I would never do something like that…or would I?”

Page 34: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Treatment

Police

Liquor

Commission

Legislature Ignition

Interlock

Judiciary

Toxicologist

Prosecutors

Societal

Approach

Page 35: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

Liquor

Commission

Law

Enforcement

Education/Treatment

Dept. of Licensing

Judiciary

Legislature

Technology – IIL’s,

oral fluid testing

The Offender

Page 36: Driving Under the Influence - Honolulu County, Hawaii · DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AN OVERVIEW OF THE OVUII PROCESS. The Investigation Process for OVUII •Traffic Violation •Reasonable

THANK YOU

ANY QUESTIONS?