“The City of Fond du Lac provides equal opportunities and services to allindividuals, including those individuals with disabilities.”

DOWNTOWN ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD AGENDA

April 3, 201812:00 PM

Meeting Room A 160 South Macy StreetCity-County Government Center Fond du Lac, Wisconsin

I. CALL TO ORDER

A. AttendanceB. Declaration Quorum Present

II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES

March 6, 2018

III. PROJECT UPDATES

A. Building Inspector Report

IV. ACTIONS

A. 35 N Main Street (S&B Alterations)Applicant: Bao Xiong d/b/a S&B AlterationsRepresentative: John Papenheim, SigncraftersProject: Wall sign.

B. 23 S Main Street (Envision/FDLCVB)Applicant: Cecilia Harry o/b/o Envision Greater Fond du Lac

Craig Molitor o/b/o FDL Area Convention &Visitors Bureau

Representative: Lauren Herlache, SignaramaProject: Wall signage on marquee.

C. 39 S Main StreetApplicant: Charter Group LLCRepresentative: Steve Schoofs, Excel EngineeringProject: Façade repair (north, south and east walls).

V. ADJOURN

DOWNTOWN ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD MINUTES

March 6, 201812:00 P.M.

Meeting Room A 160 South Macy StreetCity-County Government Center Fond du Lac, Wisconsin

CALL TO ORDER

ROLL CALL:Present: Howard Floeter

Sam MeyerLisa Pauly (arrived at 12:26 pm)Steve SchoofsScott Stelmacher

Absent: Jamie MolitorStan Ramaker

Administrative Staff: Joellyn Dahlin, Principal PlannerDoug Hoerth, Chief Building Inspector

Vice-chairperson Schoofs declared a quorum present.

APPROVAL OF MINUTES

February 6, 2018

Motion made by Floeter to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of theFebruary 6, 2018 Downtown Architectural Review Board.

Seconded by Meyer.

ROLL CALL VOTE: Aye – Floeter, Meyer, Schoofs, StelmacherNay – None

Carried.

DOWNTOWN ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD MINUTESMarch 6, 2018Page 2

PROJECT UPDATES

Chief Building Inspector Doug Hoerth gave a verbal update of DARB-approvedprojects and progress to date.

ACTIONS

44 N Main Street (Schmuck Coffee House)

Project: Wall sign.

Appearance:Mike Taylor, Project Applicant, 44 North Main Street

Motion made by Stelmacher to approve the project based on findings that theproposed sign complies with the spirit and intent of the Downtown Design OverlayDistrict regulations and the Downtown Fond du Lac Partnership Guidelines.

Seconded by Floeter.

ROLL CALL VOTE: Aye – Floeter, Meyer, Schoofs, StelmacherNay – None

Carried.

46 N Main Street (Jerome Young Hair Studio)

Project: Wall sign.

Appearance:Mike Taylor, Project Applicant, 44 North Main Street

Motion made by Meyer to approve the project based on findings that theproposed sign complies with the spirit and intent of the Downtown DesignOverlay District regulations and the Downtown Fond du Lac PartnershipDesign Guidelines.

Seconded by Floeter.

ROLL CALL VOTE: Aye – Floeter, Meyer, Schoofs, StelmacherNay – None

Carried.

DOWNTOWN ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD MINUTESMarch 6, 2018Page 3

15 N Main Street (Steve Awve)

Project: Replace windows, new wall finish on north and east façades.

Appearance:Steve Awve, Project Applicant, 3895 Shuster Drive

Motion made by Meyer to:

Approve two alternatives for exterior materials for renovation of the northand east facades, using the same materials/colors for both facades:

(1) Utilize plaster for the entire façade or(2) Install new brick on the first story, with color to match orcomplement existing façade materials, and utilize plaster for thesecond and third stories; and

Approve exterior color choices for plaster and flashing for north and eastfacades, as presented by the applicant:

(1) Plaster – “Laredo” color chip(2) Flashing – “Extra Dark Bronze”, “Matte Black”, or “Mansard

Brown”, color chips – applicant to choose one selection.

The motion to approve was based on findings that the proposed projectcomplies with the spirit and intent of the Downtown Design Overlay Districtregulations and the Downtown Fond du Lac Partnership Design Guidelines.

Seconded by Floeter.

ROLL CALL VOTE: Aye – Floeter, Meyer, Pauly, Schoofs, StelmacherNay – None

Carried.

ADJOURN

Motion made by Floeter to adjourn.

Seconded by Stelmacher.

ROLL CALL VOTE: Aye – Floeter, Meyer, Pauly, Schoofs, StelmacherNay – None

Carried.

DOWNTOWN ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD MINUTESMarch 6, 2018Page 4

Meeting adjourned at 12:35 p.m.MARGARET HEFTER, CITY CLERK

MH/ke

CITY OF FOND DU LAC - MemorandumDepartment of Community Development

Date: March 28, 2018

To: Downtown Architectural Review Board

From: Joellyn Dahlin, Principal Planner

Re: Project Review – 35 N Main Street (S&B Alterations)

Project Analysis

Proposal: Wall sign.

Historic Status: State and National register of historic places. The property doesnot retain a local historic designation. The North Main StreetHistoric District is a national district; historic review of theproposal is not required.

Design Review: The Downtown Architectural Review Board must determine thatthe proposed sign complies with the spirit and intent of theDowntown Design Overlay District regulations and theDowntown Fond du Lac Partnership Design Guidelines.

The subject property is located on the east side of North Main Street midblock between

Division Street and Merrill Avenue. A wall sign for a new business - S&B Alterations -

is proposed.

The proposed sign consists of an elongated oval Dibond panel with vinyl graphics. The

sign would be affixed on the wall directly above the storefront awning. Illumination of

the sign is not proposed. The sign complies with zoning code requirements for allowable

size.

Findings

The Downtown Design Overlay District is intended to:

Preserve and restore unique and historic buildings;

Ensure the coordinated design of new buildings and changes to existing buildings;

Project Review – 35 N Main Street Downtown Architectural Review BoardPage 2

Minimize adverse impacts on adjacent properties from buildings that may detractfrom the character and appearance of the district;

Aid in improving the overall economic vitality of the district.

Recommendation

The Downtown Architectural Review Board must determine that the proposed signcomplies with the spirit and intent of the Downtown Design Overlay District regulationsand the Downtown Fond du Lac Partnership Design Guidelines.

EXISTING SIGNAGE – 23 S MAIN STREET

Main St. CanopyConcept One

54.5

"6

.7.7

5"

311.75"66"

40"

73.5"

40"

Specifications- Qty: 1- Flat Cut Metal Logos and Lettering- Single Sided

www.Signarama-FDL.comN5528 Miranda Way Fond du Lac, WI 54937

(920) 921-7181 800-201-7553

Fond du Lac

Client

Project

LEGAL PROPRIETARY DISCLAIMER: THIS DOCUMENT ANDTHE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN IT IS PROPRIETARYTO SIGNARAMA / FLYWAY, INC. THE HOLDER NEEDS PRIORWRITTEN CONSENT OF SIGNARAMA / FLYWAY INC. TOUSE THE INFORMATION, DISCLOSE IT TO ANY THIRDPARTY OR REPRODUCE THIS DOCUMENT.

COLOR DISCLAIMER: THE INK COLORS SHOWN IN THISRENDERING MAY NOT MATCH THE ACTUAL PAINT, FINALPRINT OR VINYL COLORS THAT WILL BE USED.

A DIVISION OF FLYWAY INC.

2016SIGNARAMA-FOND DU LACFLYWAY SIGNS & LIGHTING

Date: 03/21/2018File Name: 4730Q Building Signage ConceptsRevision: 9File Drawn By: Becca

4730Q BuildingSignage Concepts

Main St. CanopyConcept Two

54.5

"6

.7.7

5"

311.75"66"

40"

73.5"

40"

www.Signarama-FDL.comN5528 Miranda Way Fond du Lac, WI 54937

(920) 921-7181 800-201-7553

Fond du Lac

Client

Project

LEGAL PROPRIETARY DISCLAIMER: THIS DOCUMENT ANDTHE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN IT IS PROPRIETARYTO SIGNARAMA / FLYWAY, INC. THE HOLDER NEEDS PRIORWRITTEN CONSENT OF SIGNARAMA / FLYWAY INC. TOUSE THE INFORMATION, DISCLOSE IT TO ANY THIRDPARTY OR REPRODUCE THIS DOCUMENT.

COLOR DISCLAIMER: THE INK COLORS SHOWN IN THISRENDERING MAY NOT MATCH THE ACTUAL PAINT, FINALPRINT OR VINYL COLORS THAT WILL BE USED.

A DIVISION OF FLYWAY INC.

2016SIGNARAMA-FOND DU LACFLYWAY SIGNS & LIGHTING

Date: 03/21/2018File Name: 4730Q Building Signage ConceptsRevision: 9File Drawn By: Becca

4730Q BuildingSignage Concepts

Specifications- Qty: 1- Flat Cut Metal Logos and Lettering- Single Sided

CITY OF FOND DU LAC - MemorandumDepartment of Community Development

Date: March 28, 2018

To: Downtown Architectural Review Board

From: Joellyn Dahlin, Principal Planner

Re: Project Review – 23 S Main Street (Envision Greater Fond du Lac;FDL Convention & Visitors Bureau)

Project Analysis

Proposal: Wall sign.

Historic Status: Local historic site; State and National register of historic places.The North Main Street Historic District is a national district;historic review of the proposal is not required.

Design Review: The Downtown Architectural Review Board must determine thatthe proposed sign complies with the spirit and intent of theDowntown Design Overlay District regulations and theDowntown Fond du Lac Partnership Design Guidelines.

The subject property is the site of the former Retlaw Theatre on South Main Street,

remodeled to provide commercial office space last used by the Commonwealth

Companies. New signage is proposed for two new uses, Envision Greater Fond du Lac

and the Fond du Lac Area Convention and Visitors Bureau.

The proposed signage consists of a flat panel affixed to the front and sides of the entry

canopy. Flat cut metal lettering and logos would be affixed to the sign panel to identify

the two business uses. Illumination of the signage is not proposed. The sign area

complies with zoning code requirements for allowable size.

Findings

The Downtown Design Overlay District is intended to:

Preserve and restore unique and historic buildings;

Ensure the coordinated design of new buildings and changes to existing buildings;

Project Review – 23 S Main Street Downtown Architectural Review BoardPage 2

Minimize adverse impacts on adjacent properties from buildings that may detractfrom the character and appearance of the district;

Aid in improving the overall economic vitality of the district.

Recommendation

The Downtown Architectural Review Board must determine that the proposed signcomplies with the spirit and intent of the Downtown Design Overlay District regulationsand the Downtown Fond du Lac Partnership Design Guidelines.

39 S Main Street - Existing

39 S Main Street – Existing East Façade

FIRST FLOOR100'-0"

APPROX. T.O. HIGH WINDOW125'-9 5/16"

APPROX. T.O. WALL133'-2"

DEMO BRICK FROM WINDOW HEAD TO ROOF, ON NORTH WALL

ALL DEMOLITION BY GENERAL CONTRACTOR UNLESSNOTED OTHERWISE.

GENERAL CONTRACTOR TO FIELD VERIFY ALL DIMENSIONS.LOCATIONS OF WALLS, DOORS AND OTHER ITEMS HAVEBEEN SHOWN FOR GENERAL LAYOUT ONLY. REPORT ANYDISCREPANCIES TO EXCEL ENGINEERING FORCLARIFICATION PRIOR TO THE START OF WORK.

GENERAL CONTRACTOR SHALL PROVIDE TEMPORARYENCLOSURE FOR KEEPING THE FACILITY IN OPERATIONDURING CONSTRUCTION. ENCLOSURE SHALL BE AWALLED-IN, DUST BARRIER, WATERPROOF WHEREEXPOSED TO THE EXTERIOR. MECHANICAL CONTRACTORSSHALL PROVIDED ALL NEEDED MECHANICALS FOR THEWORK TO PROGRESS AND THE FACILITY TO REMAINOPERATIONAL. SEE PLAN FOR ENCLOSURE LOCATIONS.

GENERAL NOTES

©2018 EXCEL ENGINEERING, INC.

SHEET INFORMATION

SHEET NUMBER

PROJECT INFORMATION

PROJECT NUMBER

PROFESSIONAL SEAL

PRELIMINARY DATES

NOTFO

RCO

NSTRU

C TION

100 CAMELOT DRIVEFOND DU LAC, WI 54935PHONE: (920) 926 9800WWW.EXCELENGINEER.COM

ARCHITECTS ENGINEERS SURVEYORS

3/21

/201

8 1:

52:1

3 PM

C:\U

sers

\Nat

hanH

\Doc

umen

ts\1

8021

00_A

rch

Cen

tral_

Nat

hanH

.rvt

DEMOLITION PLAN

1802100

PROPO

SEDALTERA

TIONSFO

R:

39.S.M

AINST.

39.S.M

AINST.

FONDDU

LAC,WI.54

935

MAR. 21, 2018

D1.1

SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"DEMOLITION PLAN

FIRST FLOOR100'-0"

APPROX. T.O. HIGH WINDOW125'-9 5/16"

APPROX. T.O. WALL133'-2"

114'-0" APPROX.

NEW PREFINISHED COPING

NEW E.I.F.S. OVER1/2" DENS GLASS OVER

2x4 (FIRE TREATED LUMBER) ROUGH FRAMING

EXISTING BRICK TOBE REPAINTED

FIRST FLOOR100'-0"

APPROX. T.O. HIGH WINDOW125'-9 5/16"

APPROX. T.O. WALL133'-2"

APPROX. 35'-10"

NEW PREFINISHED COPING

CEMENT PLASTER ON EAST ANDSOUTH SIDES OF BUILDING

OVER EXISTING BRICK

EXISTING BRICK TO BEREPAINTED ON EAST AND

SOUTH WALLS

GENERAL CONTRACTOR TO FIELD VERIFY ALLDIMENSIONS. LOCATIONS OF WALLS, DOORS AND OTHERITEMS HAVE BEEN SHOWN FOR GENERAL LAYOUT ONLY.REPORT ANY DISCREPANCIES TO EXCEL ENGINEERING FORCLARIFICATION PRIOR TO THE START OF WORK.

GENERAL NOTES

©2018 EXCEL ENGINEERING, INC.

SHEET INFORMATION

SHEET NUMBER

PROJECT INFORMATION

PROJECT NUMBER

PROFESSIONAL SEAL

PRELIMINARY DATES

NOTFO

RCO

NSTRU

C TION

100 CAMELOT DRIVEFOND DU LAC, WI 54935PHONE: (920) 926 9800WWW.EXCELENGINEER.COM

ARCHITECTS ENGINEERS SURVEYORS

3/21

/201

8 2:

14:0

8 PM

C:\U

sers

\Nat

hanH

\Doc

umen

ts\1

8021

00_A

rch

Cen

tral_

Nat

hanH

.rvt

EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS

1802100

PROPO

SEDALTERA

TIONSFO

R:

39.S.M

AINST.

39.S.M

AINST.

FONDDU

LAC,WI.54

935

MAR. 21, 2018

A2.0

SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"NORTH ELEVATION

SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"EAST ELEVATION

4' 0' 4' 8'

4' 0' 4' 8'

CITY OF FOND DU LAC - MemorandumDepartment of Community Development

Date: March 28, 2018

To: Downtown Architectural Review Board

From: Joellyn Dahlin, Principal Planner

Re: Project Review – 39 S Main Street

Project Analysis

Proposal: Repair and repaint north, south and east building facades.

Historic Status: N/A

Design Review: The Downtown Architectural Review Board must determine thatthe proposed changes to the building comply with the spirit andintent of the Downtown Design Overlay District regulations andthe Downtown Fond du Lac Partnership Design Guidelines.

The subject two-story building is located at southeast corner of South Main and

Sheboygan Street. Existing brick on the north, south, and east walls is damaged and the

building has fallen into disrepair.

Proposed changes to the building include replacement of damaged brick on the north wall

with an EIFS system. The EFIS would cover the building area above the second floor

windows. Cement plaster over existing brick on the east and south walls of the building

in the area above the second floor windows is planned.

Existing brick on the south, east and north walls will be repainted

Findings

The Downtown Design Overlay District is intended to:

Preserve and restore unique and historic buildings;

Ensure the coordinated design of new buildings and changes to existing buildings;

Minimize adverse impacts on adjacent properties from buildings that may detractfrom the character and appearance of the district;

Project Review – 39 S Main Street Downtown Architectural Review BoardPage 2

Aid in improving the overall economic vitality of the district.

DARB Action

The Downtown Architectural Review Board must determine that the proposed projectcomplies with the spirit and intent of the Downtown Design Overlay District regulationsand the Downtown Fond du Lac Partnership Design Guidelines.