30
Literary Interdisciplinary Research, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies (IHCS) Semiannual Journal, Volume 2, Issue 4, Winter and Spring 2021, Pages. 191-220 DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis of the Characters of Two Male and Female Heroes in Souvashun's Novel Based on Karen Horne's Theory of "Nervousness" Mohammad Ali Rezaei * * * eh Zirak Dr. Sar Dr. Amir Ismail Azar *** Abstract In this article, two main characters of Souvashun's novel (Yousef and Zari) are psychoanalyzed by Karen Horney's theory of nervousness. Karen Horneydescribes different types of neurotic behavior as a result of overusing coping strategies to deal with basic anxiety caused by interpersonal relationships. She identified three broad categories of three neurotic needs in her theory: needs for power, prestige and affection. Horney considers the presence of anxiety as the main sign of nervous conflict in personality. Psychoanalytic analysis showed that the male character of the novel (Joseph) reflects all kinds of natural desires, feelings, and behaviors without anxiety, and that his behavioral contradictions are the kind of natural contradictions seen in ordinary human beings. But the character of the female one (Zari) is very anxious. The fundamental contradiction in his behavior reflects the symptoms of a benevolent nervous personality. Severe anxiety in Zari's character breaks down his character's defense structure. Eventually the fear of madness comes. Here, the neurotic character prepares to heal and undergo treatment. In Souvashun's novel, Dr. Abdullah Khan, by referring Zarito her real self, helps her overcome the gap between her imaginary self and his real self and regain her lost courage. Keywords: Souvashun, Psychoanalysis, Character, Nervousness, Anxiety. * PhD Student in Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, Tehran, Iran, E-mail: [email protected] * * (Corresponding Author) Assistant Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, Tehran, Iran, [email protected] *** Associate Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, Tehran, Iran, [email protected] Date of receipt: 2020-10-16, Date of acceptance: 2020-12-05 Copyright © 2010, IHCS (Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies). This is an Open Access article. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, PO Box 1866, Mountain View, CA 94042, USA.

DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

Literary Interdisciplinary Research, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies (IHCS)

Semiannual Journal, Volume 2, Issue 4, Winter and Spring 2021, Pages. 191-220

DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215

Psychoanalytic Analysis of the Characters of Two Male and Female

Heroes in Souvashun's Novel Based on Karen Horne's Theory of

"Nervousness" Mohammad Ali Rezaei ∗

∗∗ eh ZirakDr. Sar

Dr. Amir Ismail Azar ***

Abstract

In this article, two main characters of Souvashun's novel (Yousef and Zari) are

psychoanalyzed by Karen Horney's theory of nervousness. Karen Horneydescribes different

types of neurotic behavior as a result of overusing coping strategies to deal with basic anxiety

caused by interpersonal relationships. She identified three broad categories of three neurotic

needs in her theory: needs for power, prestige and affection. Horney considers the presence

of anxiety as the main sign of nervous conflict in personality. Psychoanalytic analysis

showed that the male character of the novel (Joseph) reflects all kinds of natural desires,

feelings, and behaviors without anxiety, and that his behavioral contradictions are the kind of

natural contradictions seen in ordinary human beings. But the character of the female one

(Zari) is very anxious. The fundamental contradiction in his behavior reflects the symptoms

of a benevolent nervous personality. Severe anxiety in Zari's character breaks down his

character's defense structure. Eventually the fear of madness comes. Here, the neurotic

character prepares to heal and undergo treatment. In Souvashun's novel, Dr. Abdullah Khan,

by referring Zarito her real self, helps her overcome the gap between her imaginary self and

his real self and regain her lost courage.

Keywords: Souvashun, Psychoanalysis, Character, Nervousness, Anxiety.

∗ PhD Student in Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch,

Tehran, Iran, E-mail: [email protected] ∗∗ (Corresponding Author) Assistant Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University,

Science and Research Branch, Tehran, Iran, [email protected]

*** Associate Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research

Branch, Tehran, Iran, [email protected]

Date of receipt: 2020-10-16, Date of acceptance: 2020-12-05

Copyright © 2010, IHCS (Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies). This is an Open Access article. This

work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this

license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, PO Box 1866,

Mountain View, CA 94042, USA.

Page 2: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

�������� ��� �������� ������� � ������ ��� !��"���� #��$� �

%&��$ '��(� #��$ )�* #�(� +������,- .� ��/ � 0�1�� #1399# 191-220

10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 DOI:

���� ������� � ����� � �� �� ��� � �� � ���� �� �

������ ���� � � � �!� »�� �#� «� ���% �� � ) �����(�� �

�1�8� �� 9:(;�1 �������� ����2����� ��� ���� �!���!3

&'�()

�� #�!������ ��$%�&'( )��� *+!),(�,� %��-. �/ (0�� � 1�,�)2 %�3&� 0�.�,� )��� $ ��*45)!���.!��� �6(�7( 0�.�,� )��� .6.!%�&'( 9�5 �� 0��:0�5�/ ��;<=/�. �> �?*

!�@.!A�� !� ?*>�=� � ?*>%B�. C�4� �! �/��;<= �/ �! D<�!� E,. � F'( ��,� )!����./��;<=0��� $�/�5 C�4� 0 0�.�,� .6.!����� *+! !� G!�HI!2.�. #��5 3&� ��J5 �,K�

%�&'( ��� ��L $ ��*45 .6.!�)!���.!��� �!� )�.%�&'($ (1�,�) ��� 2 � �.,:�� 5 0�� �M�*5��/ G!�HI! )�6/ !� N�3> 0�����L� � M���OP!� G��J5 � 6�� ��J5 E,. �! �! 0���L� 0���

$�! N�3> �� �� )�O.!� �6��� �, N� 0���,(� %�&'( ��(0��) )� $�/ �%6( $45 M%�&'( QR�*� ��! ���L� �� ���! ��J5 .��!� �!�S 6�6( T�5 � G!�HI! !� ?*>�=� 3&� $

١. ����L M�%�/�! � )�/� 0���� 0,;.!� �.�O.! U,*� � M��/�! V67.!� � U,*� 6P!� ���*�! �!�� ��W.!�

.)!��! �)!�=5 �M����[email protected]

٢ 6P!� ���*�! �!�� ��W.!� �.�O.! U,*� � M��/�! V67.!� ����L M�%�/�! � )�/� �������! :(Y,ZO� V6<O�,.).)!��! �)!�=5 �M����45 � U,*�[email protected]

٣ �)!�=5 �M����45 � U,*� 6P!� ���*�! �!�� ��W.!� �.�O.! U,*�� M��/�! V67.!� ����L M�%�/�! � )�/� ���.!� .)!��[email protected]

:=��1�$ >1��?25/7/1399 :C�1D� >1��? #15/9/1399

Copyright © 2018, IHCS (Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies). This is an Open Access article distributed

under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits others to download this

work, share it with others and Adapt the material for any purpose.

Page 3: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 193

� G�5��/%�&'( �� 6�6( G!�HI! .6����[�� �0�� $�L� �%�&'( � ��L Q� �! !� �! $�� 6(�� W.!,�� �! T�5/ !� 0���/ !�!6� ��\����=. � 6.!@�W.! �/2;��N� � 1�,� ]�� �!63� ����*� )�[

E�K�! �!� �! ^�,[ �/ 0�� NS!� �_!� ?K,� �,( �!2*+�L �/ ^�,[ )��� %,&5^�,[ � 0� NS!�_! ��L� $�� �! $��;( � 6<� �3*`.6/����/ !� _!

9��E!F����: .!�� �),(�,��0��7 $%�&'( �%�3&�.G!�HI! �$

1- ��:9G�

V�,P %�/�!V��� �� .���!� M� ����� ),:�.,: M��%,45 ��B�5 $45 ���,�� �+�N���5 ��� �K!V6� #�! �� � ��,/ W<��L � '� )!�� ��:6�� �! ��[! ��,� Q� ��<(

��L�: �!�S )!�W�� � � )�:6<O�,. �%K,5 2R!�! .$�! �/ ��� ),:�.,: M!�-.� ��2<�!� a��� !� E,I,� #�!)!�� �/ �� �;.� �5 ���� �5$%�&'( ��<(��� �/ ��/�� [�/

��[!��� @�. 0��L � �� �K! ��;<=/�. � ��;<=/ 0�����L�.6.! �0�.�,� )��� ��7��� �/ ��B�5 D5�%��-. �� $�! $%�&'( ��*45 M�,+

����O:)!�� �/ 0!��(!b: �+�N� 0��7.!�� � ��<( *+! $%*� �! �-. �/ .$�!.���O/�.)�O.! (�%�&'()0���L� � P�� 0�� �! .$�! ��;<=/�. � #[ C/!�� ���

�7.� �! ���/ �)�O.! _@�W.! �<� $�! 6��N� �. �6(�/ O<K 0���. 6���L Y,S �/ 6<���.$�! NS!� $%34� � $%� � + )!6�L �� � �*+! $3�&� � $�! $%34� � $%�<�! �/

�.!��7.!�� /�! 6�.)Psychoanalytic literary criticism(�.,: $�! /�! 6�. �! 0!_�� )� �� �� %��-. �Q���c� ����U�L � ��%BA�� ��L� ��� �/ 0�� $�! 0��7.!�� $<� �! �

�� 6., W��6���L)(Sigmund Freud �</ !� )�.��=. /�! 6�. �/)!���.!��� 6�. �)!��� @�. �[�<(6<�,: ��!@7�.)1391 :367.(

)!��6<�O� !@;� Q*� �� M��/�! � ��<(� %�!�� � �,[ h�[ ����� �/ U!6�)!�� .6(�/ ��(!� 0�W�� �/ =K,5 $�! #7 �� ��<(%,&5 �� 6<� �N��H� 6.!,5� ��

)!�� a3<� i� �! 6P �j �5 !� �,[ ���� <N� �/�! �B! i� 0���� . ��[�<( �k� ��3<K [�/ �! <N�R!� 0��� ?O� �)�O.! #�� �@l��) 6<�1379 :211.(

Page 4: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

194 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

2- ����� +��"��

����� �� 0��»)!�� 6�. ��.� �[�<( 0�<3� �/ ��O���0�.�,� )��� 2%��-. «� Q�=L U�*)1395 � �(»0�.�,� )��� ��W. �! �<� =5 $%�&'( 2.!��7.!�� ���/ � 6�. « W<(,�)1392� �(»)!�� ��:6�� T��! �/ �/�5 @ �K �! .���!� ���/ � 6�. )��� �[�<(

0�.�,� «) �.q�! $(� ��I�1388 � �(»)!�� ��*45$%�&'( �[�<( )���!� �� 0��:#�.��O��[ �!60�.�,� )��� 2%��-. 0�<3� �/ 06��� #�O4��*` .�6��s(� � ��«

) '/ � 0���(1394 � �(»)!�� 6�. )��� 2%��-. 0�<3� �/ �6.� . (���� �W�� �[�<(0�.�,� «U�<=/) ��*> � �L1392 � �(» 0�<3� �/ E,S� �N( .!�� �+�<� [�/ ��*45

0�.�,� ?�7� «<�� � �*O5�6 )1392%��-. �! ���c��! �/ (2 %�3&� [�/ 0�.�,� )��� $#�� 0������ ��*45 !� /�!�%�! t6.! ��*45 #�! 0��)!���.!��� 3> 0����J5 i�7c5 �/ N��. �/%��-. �� ��;<=2 � � ���7. �K,5 0�.�,� 2 %�&'( 0����J5 � 0���L� �,K�� !�

9�5 G,j��j ��%�&'( 0������ ��*45 ���,� �! .6.! ����� �� 0��» � �,=u �U�.$%�&'( D�.�,.!� #� �� �B! ),(�,� �� ��« S7(@� � �, )1386�( �

»$%�&'(),(�,� �/ 6���5 �/ �,.!� #� �� .���!� M��/�! �� )� 0�!���« � <����/#�l*: )1394�( �»$%�&'( D�� .��)$%�&'(�� . 0�!��� (),(�,� ��« 06% 4�

�,��*> �)1391(� �»Y� Y�*K � �,.!� #� �� ��B� �� )�.� )�/� 2O����6 P!« < =/0�S�/ � k*H�)1391( %�&'( ��$ ��*45 !� �,.!� #� �� ),(�,� )���!� 0��

����6.!� 23<K %�&'( .!��$ )��� �� 0�!���V,�( � ),(�,� �@�W.! _�!���0�� )!��D<� �[�<()��� �� �� �6���. !� #�� ��L�:#����/ �� $�! <�� ),(�,� .6.!

�3<K �M��,I,� �/ )� D'/�<��� � ��.��!� h�&�[! �� �K! � .!�� 0�� 2���� �I�P %�&'( �� �� (0�� � 1�,�) )� � ��� )���=S $ ),(�,� )���!� 0�<3� �/ !�

%��-.2 %�3&�� ��*45 0�.�,� )��� $.6<� 2<��� �� �l.�2N��H� �� $%�&'( #�!)��� )� #��O'. )!,<� �/ �,.!� #� ��

)���!�$%�&'( ��*45 ���L�: M�,+ .!��! v�,._�� �� � /�! �-<� �! �� 0��

Page 5: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 195

$%�&'(�/ 0�!��� ��,/ .���!� �&<� i� )!,<���:6�� �! �7<�! �� � t$�! � ��W��K� (�O�<� L)$%�O<K � ��!,.�[ ���O/ � 6(�/�3<K �/ @�j�.)!�� 0���[�<(

$%�&'()��� 0����[!��� ��.6.! *+! $%�&'( �� �I�P D�� � �� )��� #� ��)!�� 6Nw/ ��*45 T��! �/ �,.!�2%��-. i� 0�<3� �/ )�.� �[�<( )!�� F'� �[�<(

� #��35D�� � ��! ��,(0�� $%�&'( #���)��� #�! 0�� T��! �/ ?*`! !��-.�%����� ���/ ���` � !�W�[�� � /�! 6�. 0��.6.!

3- :1�H�+ »:�J& =«

)��� 0�.�,�)Karen Horney 1952-1885 (U���� ��c�� ��<� �� !�)Alfred Adler( � �� ( �/ QO�6���L,Z. �!bW.��</6.���. 0�.�,�G��� �� 0��$%�3&� �� 6(� ��

)1399�( .��� 0����J5 )1398 �(1�!$%�&'( .��� 3&�2 �� )1398 G�(0����,[ )1398 y � ()!��)� ��<()1396 ( ��7.! �/ O<K ��!,� �5�/ D�. ��2%��-. 6���L �

����.!%��-. �!2 w! �! z��.���O/�. *+! $%*�)�O.! �%�&'( � 0���L� � P�� 0�� ���. C/!�� !�/� ��;<= .6.!�

0�.�,�%�&'( �.,: �� �/ :$�! 6��N� $/�. � ��;<=/%�&'( � t��;<=$ �./� i�7c5 9�5 �� �/ !� ��;<=0�5�/ :6<�$�@� �?*>�=� �?*>3� �/ .?*> ���-. 0�<

%�3&��. �0�.�,� $V��� �� F'( �� 0��;<=/ �/ ��,� D<�!� �B! �/ � ��,��./� {� 0��;<= �0�.�,�) 6��1398 :1�!1-7(. �! $�! 6��N�� �l.�<j $�/�5 C�4

�/ U!,5 ��,�»%34�k�,5 � �� <�!� �i � �3O. 0�!�� �$�� P ���: � $ «/ 6(� � ��� 6�!,[ D�!�� � < �! T�OP! ��,�» 5 �k��*� �M���OP! 0������ � M�*��

!� _�,[ h�[ «�/�!� 6�!,[ 6(� �>�[ ?�> �/ � N�3> �,>t %�!�. C�!�( �� �/ ��;<=» %6N5 � |�4K! ����450 %h�[ M�K���P! )��7. $���� ���L � ��� � ���,�

// � WS�*�=K,5�l/ #�/ }�N35 ��! �/ ��� $'� �# �!�. C�4�/ 0��: �6P �! D��.�=/ � ����.! � �!��!/ �,K!,� ���,�u %34� )!6�L � �l/ �! 0���� $�� P � $3$

�.�S��+ « ��,� ��»,5 �G!�HI! �< �!�. T�OP!�� � D�V�= R!� « 6�!,[ ��;�!

Page 6: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

196 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

) ��� �0�.�,�1399 :13(. %���64� #�! �/ ��,[�/ �� ��,�$�!,:�. C�!�( � �� � 6.!,5�,�( �� �/� 6<� �~� �/ �*/��� � 6<� ��� [��O: � $.,[ :6�� )�. D<�!�

)0�5�/3*>( ��� !�!6� �� � (<�@:!�@.!) 6<� ��� )!�W�� �/ T� 5 �! @���� � !�@.! �!�i� �� D<�@: .(3*>�=�) 6<� ���L� )��L!�>! �!,'�� � ��� k/�H� � 6<� �!� �!0��

�0�W(�[�� � !�@.!!�W�O/� ���� �� �/ C/� :��!�»w[%��*%�+,&[ � M�[ P�� M� �,��,� « �» Y!,P! � E�I�!�,K� �/ D�!�/ )!�W�� �� H�!�( � C�4� �6.��� «)� �) :

14 .( �7� �! �;.���`� ���� G�'�.! �� �,(V,�( �� #�! �! U!6� �7� ��L�

�/ !�%*��P .6<�� _�� #�! �! U!6� �� G�'�.! !��� 0�����. G,��� 2<�@� �/ ��V,�( �� U� 5 �W�� �t�,( G,���)6( ��OK�/ �,�( �! 7�� )��� �/ ��L� 0�� �

�(�W�� V, %�&'( ��� ?K,� ��,� $.�,( �W�� )��/ �/ P�� 0��@��5 G,���%�&'( �� ��L $t��� 6�!,[ ��;�! �,�( �� M�,+ #�! �/�3. �/ �6( G,��� 0��� ��6

V,�( � 6( G�'�.!� ��635 6��/ �/ ��6�! �/ .6.,(�Y � ��6��/ #�! 0����6��3. i� ��^�,[ %,&5�6�! � 0��� �7( Y���:� %�!� $�! E,<�� )�O.! NS!� 0�����. i� ��� �

�,�( #�! �! 0��%�NS!� �/ ��,[�/ �� !� �! 0�����. U� 5 ��L�$ 0��D(,� C�4� ..6�� �#�!�/�</%�NS,� ��$ 0��),:�.,: �B! �/�,�( �[!65( �/ �6( G,��� 0��V,�

G�'�.! ��6(»���! ��J5 «� �7(���: . ��J5� �/ F'( Y��<� 1�NJ5 �/� ���[��L �� 6�6( /!�HI! ���L� � ��;�!�G!�HI! .6<� 2/,. �/ �/ ��<� ��,[ �� �,[

�! �� !� 0�W��6��,5 �#�! � 6<� � 6�65 !� �W�6 � ��<� � G!�HI! )� �! .6<<� � ����J5 NS!� � .��� $*� �/ �K,5 0�K �/ D������ ��K,5 0!�/ F'( v�

G!�HI!$*� �/ ���� 0�� ���[ (!�5 .�����/^�,[ )��� �*+�L ���65 [ � NS!�^�, �6�!�� %,&5)(0� �/ �! �� �,�( �� #�! �! 7� G�'�.! � �� ����OK $�! �6( ���/

���/ � ��,( :)� �)15-18.( �7( 6<�!�L%�&'( 0��:%��-. �� $2 2H�!� �/ 0�.�,� �.,W<�! C�4� :�,/ 6�!,[

Page 7: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 197

1�!- ���!6N��! 23.�K � � _���� ���;<=/ %&'( �$%34� � D�!�� #��S � 6<���;<�. G- / � |�4K! �0%6N5 #��S � ��;<=/�.=K,5� 0�5�/) ��;<=/�. $%�&'(?*> �

$�@� �?*>�=�(?*>� D'/ G,��������. �! ���� ���6��3. � ��6��/) P�� 0��@��5�7(�6�! �� 0�%,&5 ^�,[ 0��:(Y� ����! ��J5� �0�W�� �� �,[ �/ ��<� �G!�HI! ����kH<� �(!�5(!�5� ...� W.!,�� �! T�5 .

%��-. 0�<3� �/2 %�3&� �$*+!�. �,K� �/ ���� #��5/%�&'( �� 0��;<=L $ ��� ��J5 . !� 0���L� ��J5 �.,: �� .$�! ���!�. ���� )!,5/$O.!� 0��;<=) �0�.�,�1398

:y62()�O.! ���L� �� ����J5 �! 0���O/ . N�3> ��� ��(�W.!�,(.� Y�P ��7 .2.� �./ ���J5 )�,/ ��;<= G!�HI! 6�6( .$�!%�&'( ��$ 2 � �!�L! �55 �! 0��6PJ ��

� �6��� G!�HI! � ���L� �� .�,( ��J5 �G!�HI! ��. $��*� .���/ $�! 0��;<= %�&'( .6(�/ �!� � ��:��. � ��3K! �/ � �,[ �/ ��<� �/ ���. $/ �/ ��;<= �,K�I!G!�H

�� �,[� %�! $�! ��:�)� $*� �/ � ��!6. ��:��! . ! � G!�HI! )��� Q� 0!�/ Y��N5 ��;����� �/ ��L� ���[�� ��� 0�� (!�5����) �0�.�,�1398 :1�!113( .!b� ��*45 0!�/

%�&'($ ��$O'. �.�. 6��/ 0�� ��7(��./ ��J5 �,K� <N� �0��;<=I! ����! G!�H .��� ,;�OK !� �,[ �/ ��<� �^����<( �! v� �. Q��*�/%�&'( 9�5 �0��;<=� F'�

� ),j � �,(�<�� G!�HI!� ��,� )!��� �/ ��L 3&� 0�� �0�.�,�) 6��1398 :G76-78( .� 6��/�= %�/�;5 ,5�� �� !� .��� ��Oc5 � ��3N5 F'( ��,� M�

*+! #�!�/�</%�&'( �+�<� #��5%��-. 0�<3� �/ ��*45 0!�/ �2 %�3&� �� $ ������ #�!V��� C�4� ����! ��J5 ���,�9�5 � �0�W�� �� �,[ �/ ��<� �G!�HI!0��

%�&'(�.!6 .

4- %��;?+����N���� :�&O� =$�� .���,P (R*�1)

4-1- �E$�E .���$ T�;�

%34� � �=� �! ��,� )!��� �� 1�,��,[�/ �6� $��!�/ � �! �/ _�6� .$�! ��,/ �!� Q����!,/! D:�@/� kP (���� )�[) )�[ �� 6.��/ y��[ �/ ��&45 0!�/ �� 6��

Page 8: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

198 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

Q=�� !� D =� ���� )�[ .6<�� ��!�! :6.� �/ � 6.��W/ !� )�( ��!, � �j�:) ���:� M��OP 1�,� �/<�� ���! � 6/ �! kP �� �6� 6<� 1�,� �� ($�! ���� ��!6�

� y��[ �/� ��&45 � ���� �1�,� ��,� $�/�5 �! c�+,5 0!�/ .6<�L� >Q.�[ �,[!@/ �� ]�1�,� !� �! �6� *:,� �O� �,[�! 6. ��[ �/ ):6�,:� ���� »�[ )���� �6S#� � ��!�6� �. �� Q. � M�%6K�. M6���� U! $%<�!6P !� 0 $%<��. .6.6�7.

��W.�L ... �,[ $%<��.0��� 0�5�� �/� )!���6�� ...!� �P��, U�Py��SU % ���� !� _! �5� � � �[ �!6. �/ ��! $( �,/ #�.�.�[ � � i�.�.. !*:,� �O� 1�,� �: _!,/ �

#� � �/ ,/ $%*� �w[ �� k* �,[ 0,[!� !� _�$( «) ��,.!�1398 :24-25 .( V��� �! 1�+,5 #�! �/ �</ %��-. 0�<3� �/ �1�,� ��,�2 ( 6��/ 0�.�,� %�&' $

�/ 1�,��.,: 0!/�3<K G,��� 0�K �/ �M�,+ #�! �� �6(�/ ���� 6(� ��;<=�� �! � %�&'( 6��/ �$��N/! E,<��%�&'( � G,*H� ,4. �/ �! Y��N�� ���� � ���� 6(� U!6�

�<��� �1*�'� M�=K �� ���!6N��! N�3> 6(� �/ .6(�3. ��OK�/ �! ��J5 0!�/ 0! ��G!�HI! � N�3>��`�!,'. 3&� 0�� .�,/ 6�-. k3>2%� �0�.�,�%�&'( |�*[�/$

/%�&'( �� ���;<= 3&� $»k� � � �56�6( ��� �/ ��� ��J5� �5 ��6+ � ���:2I��� � ��;�! F'( �� )� a35 �/ 3&��,( « �0�.�,�)1398 :1�!31(.

4-2- U���8� � $�V?

�� .$�! G!�HI! �,K� �F'( ���L� �� 3&� ��J5 �,K� *+! $��*� %�&'($ ��� 1�,� . �6��� G!�HI! ),(�,� )���!� �� ��: .�,(

O�*W.! )�<'� �� �=<5 ���L� �� ��J5 �/ 1�,� )��� Q=��!�/ )�<'� �� @�. � �� ��� �6��� 1�,�� |!���! 1�,� ]�� �! v� ��) �,( ��,/ M��OP �� �! 6<�

:($�!»Qj ���� )�[��: #�W [ � �� Q� �/ !� D� �!� v� :$c*:,� ��!�/M! 1�,� �� $�! � _� S � �7( � 6<S #�,� $��� �! $�� i� �! $�� �! � ���:

5��� ��,45 �W��� ��6���) «��,.!�1398 :22(.

Page 9: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 199

2.�. �l.�<j 1�,� �� ���L� #�! �./%�&'( 9�5 0�����L� �/ �6(�/ 0��;<=� 0�5�/k�3H5 6��/ ?*> 0�5�/ .!�� ���[�� G,j��j �� �� 3*>� �/ ��!, � � $Nc<

� _�,[6�6.! .�,( �<N� � ��3N5 9�50�5�/ 0!�/ 0��� ��� ?*>@K )!�W�� �/$Nc<� |6�U�;.! 3*> .�0�.�,�) 6�� 1398 :1�! 58%�P �� ( )�< (� )�<'� ��

$�! �6( 6���5 �! ��!�/ )�<'� �� @�. � 1�,�� 1�,� �� ������ ��+ 6<��L� 0!�! �,[ 0!�/ :��!6. ...»2L�+ �)!��. U�� G,[ �� $S� �� �$O�j �*��N� #�! �� ,5

�5��� 0!�/ ���� !�� �� �6.@��/ M��� #�! ,5 !� ��.� 0��!�� U� 5 �:! !6[ �/ .��/5��� #�! ���!�� �� .�,( «��,.!�) 1398 :22(.

,� |!6�!9�5 |�*[�/ 1� 0�5�/ U�;.! )!�W�� �� ~��! |6� �/ �� ?*>� !� $��� ��!, � �! .$�! )!�W�� �! $�� P 0���!� �� �,(� |�J� _�,[ �/ 6<�

� �Q���� :6�,:0�= � �/ $3O. .� � ��!� OP #�<j @�. D.�<>, � � ���,: :60�= � :Q���»�/ 1�,�%�! :$c: '*5 �:� � =��� ��,(0�= � ...!�� 0�� � �,(

$(!� �W. �<��:) «...)� �: 16.( »� ���: #� $�� �! :6���� ?;N5 �/ [0�� �!] 1�,� . #� �<�.!,52 � �~� Q

. .Q(�/ U��� Q.!,5 W :� �6(�/ ��� �! ��[ ��[ <����� 6��3. .Q<�3/ �<��: !�« :)� �)18.(

1�,�»,*�«� i� 6.��L �� � ��,/ 1�,� )��,j _�6� �� !� 5��/ ����� �� _�,[ �.�[ :6.!,[6.��L �/ � ������ ���b� 2-4� �P ��,� )� Q` ]��

%��� :��!� !� $»� ��/ )��� .$(!� .�K � �. �,<� �S�6.@/ |�P �� ��� ..!,5 .$OU�� ...$�� ��zO/ �3/ ...,*� ...,*� :$c: .U��/ i��@. !�_��� � v� $��.. «. :)� �)251.(

%4+ �! $���6� � )�,/ �� ��! �/�S � $��;( � |�&.! ���.!� �/ @�. )!�W��� �:6.�!b: »% � :$c: � U�,[ 0���� )�[� !�� Q� !� 1�,� .Q��<( Q����!,/! .Q��<(

Page 10: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

200 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

|�+�. ����L! $���� Y��[ �/ �� Q� �S� �! .$O�. |�+ [1�,� ]�@/ ��!�/] )�[ �5�6( « :)� �)20.(

�/�!� �'O 5 � ����.! �! �/ ��!, � �� 1�,� ]�@/ �� � ���$c:: »� � $�! T,� 0�� �! _��� «... :)� �)23 �/ !� 1�,� _�,[ aL�<� 0!�/ � ( )��

»|�P/ 0��%���� «� Q=�����» :� �&� ����!|�P � ��/ 0�� Q� �%��� ...�)« :)� �24( �! v� �<~��! �/ 1�,� ]��� � )���! 1�,� )�,/|!���! � 6<� �� U�;.! M��OP �� �! !� �����L� #�! �� 6<� :$�! ��!� ...»V��� ���� ���!�/ .�,3. �!

� Q�� .#� Y�*P !�� �$�! �I�P �;<�! $P�� �:! w5 �!,� � �,N( � Q=L $�!,[� !��'O� Q�(!6. ),j � Q(�/ ��(!�� M! .U����/��! �!�� ��� i� �~� �,5 «... :)� �)

244^��!�/ |!���! �/ .( �V��/�� D.�<'� )�,3. NS!� �/ 1�, |�P ��3��! �1�,� D���%�&'( ��J5 �,K� �/�! 1�,� �� � )��� � .���

%�&'(3&� $ .%�NS!� �/ !� �,[ 0�����L� 6.!,5$ �� 6�� k�3H5 ��6(�/ U��� �� ��K �� 1�,� ����P!� Q� !� U��� 0�� )!�W��s(! �/!�/ �� 1�,� .6<�

y�[ �/ ��5,� #��� � . 0�J�! �! �P,�L �� 6��� �$O�., � G@P6�,: : ...»1�,�2 � �! )�[ %��L,� 6+�� �=j )�7�! �5 6<�c: )�(�,[ .6.�5��!� ��<j 6(�3. $ #�

��,[ Q7P �� )��� !� 0�H[ $�! «... :)� �)215 .( �! ���u �� 1�,� ���L� #�! $��7P ��J5��!� %�! �/ !�����!� ��J5 )�,/ T��. � )�,/ $�!��� �/ �! 0��t �� �/

0�<3� 2%��-. \� �P 6��/ 6(�/ �!� � 3&� ��J5 �/ 0���L� �l.�<j �0�.�,� HI! �� G!� $�! �6. �6��� /!�HI! 1�,� ���L� �� .6(�/ ��(!� �[ �����! �/ ��!, � �! � �,

.$�! ���� 6���5 :���O�! �/ �/ <��6/ ��: @�. 1�,� �� .$�! <��6/ �3&� F'( M�*�� 5 �!

� �6��� )!�W�� !� )�.� ��K �� .�,(»����,: «� :6��.»�. �/ D j �5 1�,� )!��L �������,: :$c:#�,Hj ��3J`��� $� !� )!6<�,/�«... ):)� � 5( ��W�� 0�K �� .

1�,� � �� G!�=� i*� �/�S��� 6�!,[ _!O�*W.! �/ � ��'/ !� $L���� �,� �� ��

Page 11: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 201

)!��! $�,7P �/ �<K 0!�/ �4*�!(��c/� #�W [ �6 :6�,:»5 �)�K G!�=� #�3/ ,� �l/ 1�! i�)@. ���. #� �/ �W�... « :)� �)50 1�,� ���L� �� ),j @�. ��!,� #�! �� (

G!�HI! � . �6���,(� . !� )� )!,5%�&'( 9�5 ���L� �/�. � 3&� �/ ��;<= .$O.!� k3H<� � #[ ���L� i� Q� �j �� $�! 6��N� 0�.�,� .��� �5 6(�/ ?�;�

: �� �W�� ��0�� � � .!�� ���[���/ ��L 6(�/ ��(!6. !� ��<� � G!�HI! � �����L�0 / .$�! N�3> � ��;<=

%�P 1�,� ��!,� ��2.�[ ^M,*[ �� �� 0 �,[ '�� # �� 0��J5 6�,:%�. � |!6�!$�6��� D��� .��+,5 .�,(� )�. _6.��L �/ �! ��/�5 0��6���

� 5 �/ 1�,�%�. � |!6�! � M�*�$��:� �,[ 0�� � ����� ����-5 ��� � ��!� � �� QO�������� 3&� 9�5 M�&'0�5�/$�! ?*> �! �� . 1�,� .$L�� )!,5

� ��O[ _6.��L �/ G�H[ :6�,:» $��� .)�K�/�/ $O�. ?�� �� #�(!� $���� #(�� !� U�� Y� #�(!�� ���� !� U�� Y� M�c. � �<�� ��! .6<� $�� ���P �! �:! .6<�

%34� �/$ V���� 06( �� Q� ]�@/ �$L�: v.! 0�3�� � G,[ 0��@�j #�(!� $���O� ��.� #�!w� �l`�/ i� #�� U�� Y� .� %34� �/ �:! .$�! �l<` �! ��l<` $ G� !� ��� ��/ 0�!��l<` 06���� M�c. �:! �6.,(� �6���*� �� M�c. �� 6.!6/ 6��/ U�� .6.,(

!�/ �$O�. ��3�� � /,[ 0!�/ �<�� �/ � �(� 0/ � L�(�! L�&.! �,K #�! .$ kP � |�( �/ k� $��*� M�c.$�! « :)� �)29.(

� 6���5 !� 1�,� |!6�! �� $S!6+ @�. )!�W��<�6�;� .6< ]�� �! v�V��/�� 1�,� � �! :6�,:»� _�,[V��� �,<� �� $O.!� %�! .�6���. �! Y�~�! �! �

� �� $c: U�,[ �/ ����/ $c:2c�u� .Q��!6<�/ ,*K !� ���� #�! )6��� �� $�! #�! ��« :)� �)244-245.(

%�&'( �/ 1�,� ��7<�! �;��.^�,[ �! �� � $�! ��:� _�,[ NS!� $ &5%, 0�%NL ���[ �/ .$�! �6. Y��0�.�,� )��� 2.!��7.!�� ��*45 �� 1�,� #�!�/�< O.!.� $�

: �� �/�� Y��N�� 0�� %�&'( i� $/ �/ ��;<=�� ( � .6��

Page 12: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

202 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

4-3- :�&O� X�?�

%��-. ��2 %�3&� F'( �0�.�,� $%�&'( 9�5 �� .���� �!�S ����L� �� ���: �!�. � 3&�/�. ���L� M�&'� �/ 1�,� ���L� �!� )�. ���/ ��*45 .6(�/ ��;<=/ ��;<=

t��!6. .!,' � |�+�! �,K� �7*/9�5���� 01�,� �� !� 0�.�,� 2.�: 0�<N� �/ 6��/ !� �! 1*�'� 0���!6N��! N�3> _�����( 0�J�S! �/ �� $O.� ��7(� C�!( .�,

�[�� ���O/ ��: �,[ ���L� �� 1�,��/) $�! ��:����. � #�W [ � �W( �� �� �%34� �/ � )�/�=� ���O/ ��: .()�W.�W�/ �/!�/ $ 6<'3� _�O � 0�� �/ �� � �!)

�$�@� @�. ��: � (6.�� ��<� �� �/) #�.�/� G��� � ���.!,[ .(6 2 � 1�+,5 '( �! 1�,� %�&w[ �! �� $�! #�! ��,� )!��� $ 0,[ � k*

%�&'( �� ��(!� !� _�6�%<� � ��,/ E�;( � �,OK ����O� �!� O� $ .� �6� .$�!%�&'( !6�/! �� �1�,� �6� �� .!�� M�*�� 5 � |�+�! #�! $0�5�/?*> �� !�

#�� ������ %�!! � �,[ � � U� 5 �� 1�,� �6� �� #��.�[#�. N� ��!, � � ��,/ �%<� ����67. !� O� $ Y�*���!)(3*>%�&'( 9�5 |�+�! � �$�@�*>? !�Q�

)�. �.6�� %�&'( $$�@�?*> N� ��!, � �W�� 9�5 �� |�*[�/ �[ #�/ 6<� �,6<7. !6�� 0��:�� � _@��� O� �/ ���> ��� �/ � ���� �!�S�/ �*+�L )!�W�� �: » ��W.!

V��� i� �,[ ��� �/ � R���.6<�) «�0�.�,� 1398 :1�!64(. ��!� ����.! 1�,� ���L� �/ �� � �� (1�,� �!��/) ���� )�[ @�.+,5 �! c�

���L�1�,� � 9�5 �/ �� 6<�$�@�?*> :$�! i��@.» !G!,[ � :$c: ���� )�[ ,5 �� $�! G!,[ �� Q� �� �� !G!,[ ���. 6</ ��OG��� �^v� #� .6.!,[ �� Q�

���� G��L� �! Q5�,+ .�6���5 %�! ��6( ���j��� 0�� !� _�,[ �S� ��.��(!6=W. �..« ) ��,.!�1398 :23(.

1+� #�! �2.�. 0��6P �5 6.!,5 $�@�3*> 0���L� �� .��� �5 ��! 6(�/ �. �/ ��635/�6. 0��;<=��3K! 0�� �! � 6(�3. G!�HI! �/ �!� � � ���! �@K 6.!,5 Y�

6�� �� ( �/ F'( N�3> .

Page 13: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 203

%�&'( 9�5 @�. 1�,� �W�� |�+�! [�/ �$�@�?*> #�� �/ !� � t���� ��c��,[ �/ ��� .��c��,[ � Y�*���! �/ �! 6���5 ��3S �!M�,+ �/ ���� �! @» %<�$� «

%�&'( �� 1�,� �6� $ @�.�6��� ��,( %�&'( . $$�@�?*> <�! 0!�// �7 �! 6.!,��� 6.� / )��! �� )!�W�� �!_�*5 � 0��� U��� �! 6<�6<�@: 2���� � �0��� #�!»��c��,[ « ��»:6<O/�,[ «) $�! �0�.�,�1398 1�! :64 .($�@�?*> M�K���P!

D�,[ ��64� !� �����» . y���P! �! (�. �� �� M,*[ �/ y���P! � :6<O/�,[Y�*���! �/ 6�6( 9�5 .6.!$�@�?*> �6<� ��� �,[ M,*[ �! !� )!�W�� �� #�! 0!�/

0�5�/ ?O� �/ ��: @�.M�6S �! 6.!,�/ �5 ��!� ���. �,[ W�� #�(!� �W. ��� 0!�/ )!���3/ ��=/ 9�5 �/ !���u !� �! �D� #�! .0�5�/?*> �/�� � ��! 6<� � �,�(� )� |6

) $�! M��c�� ��)� � :67(. $�@�?*> #��,[ �� #�! 0!�/ I!� )�,/ �5�/ �/ !��,[ �/ 6<� �/�%�&'( �! �� 6.!��/ � ��<~��! �;<: ),l � 6��/ � $�! ��-.

/ � ��-.6.� / ��� )!�W�� T���� �! 6< (��! ))� � :68.( � 1�,� G�H[ ��K ��,[ _�O � �/ M��c�� !� �!1�+,5 U��� � � � :6<� ...» . #�2 � �~� Q.!,5

...Q(�/ U��� « ��,.!�)1398 :18.( 06<���! ��W.�3[ ),��� i� @�. �/ 1�,� 1�+,5 �/»w: ̂� G���. «(! ��� �/ �

V��/�� 1�,� �-. �/ �� #�! »Y�*���! «'( 9�5 �$�! kL!,�$�@� �%�&?*> 0!�/ !�� ���! 1�,� :6<�»U�� JN/w: i� #�� [1�,� Q���O���` 1�+,5] ��^� . �6<�O� G���

�,*K �/ )!�W��� M��OP )�(Y��[ .6.�/ �w: #�! 6<<�^� !� #��� 0���. U� 5 G���. ��5 � G��L� D[�� U� 5 .���:!� !,� 0� ���� �<5 �=.� 0!�/ !� �K � 6N*/�/ �� 0!

6OP �! �/ .��(!bW. S�/ ) �O�! � G��L� �=.� �)��� � 6.�/ �(!6. �,K� 6�!,[ ���c: $��� ,5 1�,� �*/ ...6(�/� G,[ Q� ,5 0!�/ $�! G,[ #� 0!�/ Y�*���! �:!

%&S )� � $�!� 0!���,[ U��� �/ �6�j �c: ,5 �«... ) :)� �14(. �<l � . ) )!,5 #�(!� $c:2.�. ��L �� T�OP! #�! �./ �:! !��� $�! 0��;<= %�&'(�/ 1�,� $ 9�5$�@�?*> ��3H.! �0��L )!�W�� 6�� �! 1�,� 6��3. $L��

Page 14: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

204 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

� QP!@�»{�(�� «1�+,5 ���b5 �! �/ ),��� i� �� 6( � :6��» ���[ �/ ��/����06( {�(U�� ...\�N3> �� .6���� ��3( 6��/��H<� 0�� 0!�,K� �/ )� �� �� 6<(�/ �6��������L !�� .Y6�N� � 1�H� .6.! 6.!��O�. Y6�N� !�j Q�,W/ ,5 �/ ��[ ... �� ���

#� � Q� !�� .6<�3/ !� ,5 ��!6. Qj .���� �� ,5 �/ ��� Q�c: Y,O<S �/ ����� .�,>�� ���[ �6�7/ C[ !� 1�,� .�=.� ... ��!b: � � ,<. � #�3. 6<�,: ���( � .,W.

Q�!� 06<���!!� W<K ��W.�3[ �� '�! �`!�� 6<���L6<7/ D��. �5 D...«))� �: 14-12(» �� � �( � � #�!0,/ U�. ,5 �� Q�L�/ Q� �/...) « :)� �15(�3<K #�! . 0��

%�&'( 9�5 |�*[�/ 1�,� �� �$�@�?*> 9�5 �/0�5�/?*> ��!� ��3H.! 2���� !��� $�@� ��L �� $�! #�! �)�,3. U�. � )!�W�� �/ )6( {�(�� 9�5 �/ ��! .6(�3. !�:

0�5�/?*> %��-. k/�H� !��� $O�. )!,' � @�.2 F'( �0�.�,�0�5�/?*>� � ��!� N^�,� )!�W�� �! �M�6S � 0�5�/ ?O� �/ .6<� ���c��!

0��!,� �! )�. �� ),(�,� #�� �� � M�*�� 5 0!�!� 1�,� 6��$�@�3*>� �.�./$O�. ��;<=� ��+,5 0�� :$�! Q��� i*� �/ �!» ̂U�� �:! 6�!,'/ �=<5 �[ 6.!,5 _�,

<5 �! !� ��=*�[ .�����/��)�(�� kP |�P �� 6<�O� �� �!� kP vc. � �,( �<5 �! �=.� �/ !� M�,[ .6<�O� �6<�!�� �=�<� .6<��<( ��=...����) « :)� �48(.

1�,�0�5�/?*> $O�. Q�. 0�5�/?*> �V���3� 2<4+ ��.� $�! 6��N ��O��( C�L � $�! �6.� M!�,K,� #��5�6.� �=.� �t6.�� #�/ �! !� 1�NI 0,S ���/ .

U�3� M�K���P! �!0�5�/?*> %� ��P )!�W�� �/ �� $�! #�!�(!� �H*� � Y��<� �$ �6(�/. P!�+ �/ ��:� � $ %�. #OP )!,<� $45 ��: �Q��O )!�W�� �,�! �/ �S�*� � $

)�(��� ��$��[� �. �� ���� $� ��: �6<�$�� �� !� � � �/ ��: � ���:� 1*�'� #���<���u�� 45 )!�W�� �/ !� 5!6=N5 � 1 ��/ )!�W�� �/ $3O. .6<� %6( M

#�/6/ ��73��L �$�!. 2cO*L �/ %O 5 �������i ��� � )�,/ ���+ �! .6�,K�,: _!�K,5 �!,[��[ �/ !�� ����!� Y!6K � ����3� 0!�/ 3�;� :���� �6<� �!T�5 �� #�!

�/ 6<� �3*` �! �/%6(�*��� �� �/ �$�! �K@<� M 0!�3�� �5 �,(� �,[ |�P � �/ !

Page 15: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 205

/ �6.�</ ��� �)!�W�� k��*� �/ =K,5 ̂vP )��� �c[ �$/�S� � P��/ � M���( <��6/ �06��!�. � T�5 )��� )�=<� ���. � $c>�*� ��� � ���� �/ ��,5 � _�[�� �

�6<�O� �! |�+�! �W�� �! ... ) �0�.�,�1398 1�! :55-62( �! 1�,� |�+�! [�/ .� .��!� �/�5 9�5 #�! M�*�� 5 [�/ �/ �_�,[ )�/� �! @�. � )!�W�� )�/��,i� 1

!� _�,[ �K»�3/ 6<.��« � 6.!�i� � �K»�<��: ]�:« G�H[ �:6<� » 1�,� �.�[ �! )���/ �� �� #� ��O��/ #� ,*K �#� :�� ����L #�W [�J� %Y� O�� �� � Q

V%�/ i� ,5 �/!�/ �� ��.�[ /�����!� «...�,.!�) �1398 :129(. �/ 1�,� :$c: ��. ...» )�=<� #� �! !�j0��� $.�K �/ �<��: ]�: �~� �5

...Q�c�/«) :)� �131(. $O�. ���� ��! �� #�! � _�,[ )�,/ �� � ���+ �! �W�� 0���K �� 1�,� #'�

�6�,: :»�&� Q�cW. #� :$c: � 6�� �� 1�,� .P! .Q��QOS �/ Q� K��� %�! .$O�.V��/�� � Q�O� ��!��� U�� #� ��=.� )�� Y,: U�� �:! � ���� ��! ���/ Q�

Q�O�. �.�� «) :)� �24.( »!�� �� ,5 .Q.@/ |�P Q�O�. 6*/ 0�W�� �,K �,> #�! �! ��` #� :$c: 1�,�

�Q.����� #��5@�@� �/ �P .U�!6. �O��/���� 06P! �/ .��<( « :)� �)47(. »Q�O�. 6*/ #�« � �<N� #�! 5�,+ �� �� 6(�/ ���L� i� )�,/ 0��3K! <N� �/ 6.!,5

�� .6(�/ �!� � G!�HI! �/ �� $(!� 6�!,[ !� ),(�,� )����6��� . �� �,( 1�,� �6��� )���!� Y,> �� .6(�/ ��!� )�. _�,[ �! /!�HI! �����L� #�! U�W<� �/

,[ 0�����L� � ��:6�� �� 1�,� �� $�! �6.���5 ��,[ vc. �/ �� ��! � ���� 6 � !#�!�/�</ .6(�/ ��!� $�� �!� �����L� #�!6<j�� Q��. 0�<N� �/ 6(�/ 6�6(// ��;<= )�,

.$O�. )� _�*5 .��/ M!���-5 � ���, .D� � �� #7 � 3&���` � 3&� 0��6(�/ �/�� $�!t �<� ���/ �=.� 0�<N� #�<l � � �<3� ��%*��0�.�,�) $�! M��c��

1398:y61(��� . �! �! i�_�*5 �M���P #D� � M�*�� 5 ���L ���/ � �Oc. 0�,[2.�. �,[ 3&�%�N�3>��` � $ _��! 6S�L �� )�,/ :)� �) $O�. )�,/ .�O.! 0��60(.

Page 16: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

206 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

�,[ ��K �� 1�,� !�»���« �� 0��� 6.!��<~��! 6��/ �� ,*K �<5 i� � 6(�/ / )�W.�W� :6�O��/ ...» �56/ � � �!�P T�OP!� � ��W<�!� �� $�! 5���6( )�5� � ...�� !� )�5

�S!�� 6��!bW/ .)�(�,[ y� *�� � ���� � Y��� 6.��� )�� Q� �/ Qj i� ,*K �c. i��� 0,5 �5 6�O��/ �=.�[ :6<�,W/ )�,Q�6�� Q� ��� i� _�[� G) « ��,.!�1398 :

16.( »[] 1�,� :[0�� �/ G�H ...»6(�/ ��� �! ��[ ��[ <����� 6��3.) «:)� � 18.(

1�,� �����! �/»:���O�! «:�!� �'� �/ #5 6��/ )� 0!�/ � $�! ���O� _��! i� »... $�! :���O�! Q=� 2��O� �.) « :)� �30 �/!�/ �� $����� � :���O�! .( i� �Q*u

2 � �� � $�! .�O.! _��! )�O.! 0���6��� ����!� � .�,( ���+ )�,/ �� � 1�,� 6<5 ��,[�/ � �)!�W�� �/ )!�W�� M�c�+,5 �� �! �!.�6��� @�

�:�,( » :$c: 0�� �Q�,W/ ��/ 6+ �Q�c: �� #��/ ,5�5 ��>O� ���+ ��<� � ��...,5 $P!�+ #�!) « :)� �129(.

» D:�@/ ��!�/ �/ ���+ � |�+ #�3/ :[$c:] ���� )�[#��,5 �6<�« :)� �)16(. »:$c: ��O�� ���� )�[ �� �,'�/ _!�!� �...<� « :)� �)16.( »� )�[ :$c: � ���� �� 1�,� �,[ �/ ���� .!,K ,5 �U@�@� �Q.�K . #�! �/ . =L

%*��0��/ M�,[ )�K �/ �( �� � 0!�/ � <������ )�� �6��/ Q� �=.� �[� .(!�5 �/ ),S�� M�,[ .6<�6/ )�. !� :�@/ #�! �.!� . �/ ),S �,( !� :�@/ #�!

...$(!� �W. �<��:) «)� � :16.( ���*/� � 0�!��( 0��L ��) �W<�� Y�.! 0�����. |�> �! �� (��,/ ��!b� 0!�/ O�*W ���

V��/�� 1�,� �/ :$c: ��,/ �6�� M�*` _��L»��� �S� �/ 6.�,��L )�H�( �[ �! #� ...#���� 6<���/) « :)� �250.(

�� 1�,� W.! �/ $3O. �W<�� Y��� �/ ,W�c:O�* ��� _�[�� $P!�+ �/ ���O/ M��OK �:6<� »... ,W/ �W<�� �/ ��/� ,5 �7<�! 0�K �/ �!bW/,5 Y�~�! ��/ ��� ���j ��� �

�*j �5�,/6� �,/ �!6�,� $����! � #� �,��L �S� ... <���Q��!,[ 6�6P�*+ �W. �S� ..

Page 17: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 207

�,��L .�� �5 � 6( 5�� � �6� �,: :U�!6.!q ����� )�( �� D7. #� {� �/ Q� !� �� �� �:! .U�!6. ��5 Q� �=.� �!U�!6.!q �/ 6���/ 6���Y��� ...6�<7/ !� ����3.! �cS ��. ..

Q.�K�S� :$c:� 6/ ��!6<�.�� �=<�! �/ �#7. 6I �U��/ $.�/�S �#�! �! ...<�/ � �� 6<��5���� \�S�c5! �,��L �S� .�6/ )��O� ��� )��� U��� )!6 � �� :$�! #� � Q� #� 6&S��

� 6<�O/ !� ��,/ y��[ �=( V�!��� �! U6<: �.!� i� 6<�(!bW. !� )��S V�!��� �;<�!���� G!�[...6.!) «)� �:251-250(.

0�.�,� ��/ �� ��,� 6�,: �,> 0!�/ ��!� $����� � M��OK �/ ��� N�3>N� �,[ �! �!�� )��� ��� � .�����/ 0�� $.,[ � )�,/ �,OK � _�[�� �/ 6<�

.! �� #�! �/ 1�,� ��� #�!�/�</WO�* ��Q�6�� ��� i� �S!�� 6<�,W/ �,5 ��� #�! 6.! .���� ��7(� !��� @�. �;<�! 1�,� ���L� �� � 6���5 /!�HI! .6�� )!,55 . �� �=<

i� �L� �� G!�HI! �/�� ���P �<4+ �! ���6��� ��,( ����3�! �3> � R@K N :$�!» _,: �/ �� Y��� ���/�� ...����S� �� �� � $(!b: �S 0! .�� |�P _!,� _!,�

%�! �,/ �6( ?*�<� $L���L �7L �/ �S� �6( U� 5 �� DL�P$c: C�L .��7. ���s5 �: ��/�S��� G!�=� �/ #� ,W/ �W<�� �/ ��4*�! �. Q��/ �� U�,/ �6�� !� Q�!� ...� U�� �,<

2.���� �� !� Q��� W. �� �S� � ���L! )��*S U6�� Q�:�/ .6( 6<*/ ��5 0!6+ �� U�,/ ��(!b���L! �!� ),[ � 6( �*� Q�) «)� �: 251.(

2., . �� �=<5 ��.�H[ ��! �/ �� )� �! v� � �,L 6<.��t �_�,[ �/ ?���� D.�7��@. ��6( 6�6=5 )!�W�� ��6.! ?*�<� ����s5 ��! �,( . U�74��! .6<�

%�&'( � 1�,�)�. � M�*�� 5 � M���P �/ �! 6��%�. �$ 0���,[ #Z H� ���O/ � ��:� � $�!�K ��� ��)���!� 0 �� �G!�HI! �! �� �6��� T�5 � )�<� >! U6� ��� . .�,(

5- %��;? +����N���� .���,P =:�&O� ./ (�/)

5-1- �E$�E .���$ T�;�

�,� )���!��/ !� 0�� ��,� )!��� 2.���6W<5 :6.� � $'� ��:��� ),(�� � � v

Page 18: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

208 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

� $�!�� _�6� ]�� �!:6<�»��� )�%�! 0���<5 �6�j _���� Y,S �/ �6� ]�� Y 0���0@�j ��� �O� �,<� .6.�,/ 2��6� ��6� ��6N/ .�,3. ��� �� %���N(L #�! �/ ��7

6<O�,</ �I��5 �� )��[!6.!$c: � ��� �6;� !� #��� � 6( Q[ ���� ...: �O.!�.Q� �$�! ������ _�,[ !6[ Q�O.!� « :)� �)153.(

D.!� �! ���6� �� ��W<�� ��[� )!�,�� 0!�/ �� 6�!,[ Q�!��%6� i� �/ �,:6��(,[6.�,/ �6( ��!� )6<� �! ���5 �� O�*W.! �� ��� 6�c� �,*/

�6<(,z/ �6��,5!%�=5 0!�/ 0��2 � �+��O� )� :�,(» �� �� ��� �� 0�� ���P$(!� $S� �� ����� �Y,� U!6� �/ � 6<� �� � $�� 6�c� �,*/ ���� �,: U!6� �!«

)� �): 153.( )�>�� Q��*����/ G!,'�[� �� � �6( ��7(� Q� _� .�,/ �6�/!,[ Y�P%�! 6.��L �� ��W<� �0�� ���� �! v� _����O[) D� �� �=<5 �,/ ���� �� (��

2.�'J��� #�*���� ��.� �!���. V�!,.�[ 0��&�S! C�!�( %�<�! U6� � ��L � 0�� �/ �6� ]�� �! v� �� $

� ���� 0�� $(,.��%�NI� ���!6.! ��.� �� $�! ��;<=/�/ 6.!,5� N�3> �,> �� �P�� � OK ���[�� ?��<5 �/ ��,��. _!/0��;<= �� #�!�/�</ .6<� ��;�! ���

�. M�,+/ %�&'( )6( ��;<= U6� vP �,K� �/ �� $�! #�! )�7�! #����/ �0�� $%�&'( 9�5 �/ 0� ��! �� $�<�! .6(�/ ��L�� D�!�: ?*>�=� �

�!,.�[ ��LV M@� 0!�/ 0�� %6�!�.�=/ �/ ��� 0!� ��635 0�� ���45 0!�/ �,(#��,5 #�! �� #�! �/ 0�� �� !� ��I!���! �,<( . :)� �) 6<�86M@� .(%6�! �� ����

� 1�,� ��!,[ �/ ���,/ 0�� ��W��!,[ #���! )�[6� P _�O� :6�,:»Q��!,[... !6: U�� Q�,W/ .��!� )�>�� _���� Q�,W/ Q���/� $�!6: _�[� <7/ D.�K �/ )�K«

:)� �)88» .(%'�� Q.�[& � �� #� �~�� �,(2.�[!6: ��� �=.�� ��>! .0��W��!,[�!��b�1� i� )�( V�!6.! �/ $�! ��>! $�� 2.�[�� . !� Qj Qj )��*S ��� �! .��

.�N� �6( _���� .6<�/ .$*7�! �<�� U��� #� �� $�! �'���<. 6��/ !� T���L � �<=� � ���j #�!��� i� �����L! ,*K )!6.� ���� M�,+ �6�c� 0��,� .Q<�3/ $'�� )�

Page 19: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 209

D<5�� ,5 �/ Y�3S! ... ��[� � � )� )��� �! !� M��[� #� U,&N� �c> �� ������6�6<O�... « :)� �)87 .(

5-2- U���8� � $�V?

0���L� ��J5�,[ )���!� 1*�'� 0���K �� 0�� ���L� �� � )�. !� �/!�/ �� �! .6����!,(,: �� (y�5 )�*�:) Q��P ��[� � 1�,�� �! �! !� D��� 6.��: :)� �)8( �� �

� ��� �/ Q��P ��[� 0!�/ !� _�O� ?�! �� �W�� 0�K)�. ������ �6<.��� . 6�� :)� �)84�� �� �( �K ���@�. �/%6( _�,[ �! !� ���L� #�! |�*[ M���/ � �6��

� �,��� �.!���� $.,[ � 6�� �Y�~� )!,<� �/ .����� #��,5 �P,�L �/ :6<�» 0���/ .6<�(!� kP �=.� v� :$c: :���/ !� � (�,[ 0!�/ )���� � ( .6.�,/ ���� M,��

0�,[�� .)� � ���,� �� �,>Q� )�5��!,[ 0!�/ )���� .��,� $.,[ �! .��� M��P _�,[« :)� �)215(. _�O� ?�! )��/ 0!�/ Q��P |�> �! �� ��W<�

�� (1�,� �.�[ ��7��6[) U�*` � �6<�� �/!�/ �� �j�: 0�� 6<� $����� 6�!,[� ��5,� Q��P ���!,[� �,��� �.!��� U�*` �/ 6�� :6��»c: �.!��� 0�� #� �;<�! :$

� �,������� �*�,> �! !� �4� ��/ .Q�O� #� �.�[ Q.�[ .Q�� « :)� �)84 #�! �� .(�,� |�*[�/ �! U!6S!� G!�HI! ��;�! ���/ �1�.,: �/ ��,(�� 0! ��<� �,[ �/�� :��

» 0�� �$L� �� ��O[���6� � D��5 � _�!6K! � _�,[ �// � _!WI��! � _M@�%6�!�����L $<N� ��� « :)� �)94 .(

����!�� ��,�� �! ),(�,� )���!�G!�HI! ��� ��T�5 � 0�� #'� 0��$�! ��L� G!�HI! � *+!$�!�� ��J5 �,K� $��*� #��5 $�! tG!�HI! �<�� 0�

� ��,� )!��� �/ ��L 3&�� �7( ;��65 �7*/ $O�. NL� ��! 6���: �� � �� )�O7� �!�L! � � �0�.�,�) $�! )���� �/�S � $O�.1398 :G76-78 .(

:$�! M��c�� T�5 �/ G!�HI! » ��L� $�c�� i� )�O.! �,K� T�5 U�W<� ��� !6�� Y�NL � $3~� ���45��� G!�HI! $��P �� �� 6<�T,��� P�� $�c�� i �

// �E�L�� ��;�! �! �� )!,5�. � ��45�,( « :)� �)44» .( F'( G!�HI! $��P ��

Page 20: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

210 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

� .!,5�. � :6.���� T�OP! )�<j M�6S �� 6<�� ?*� �! �! 0��� �� U�;.!�,(« :)� �)44(.

F'( �� ��Nc.! $��P ��;�! ?3�� �,[ �� $��P #�! �/ $3O. �! �� �,( #�! �! @��: 0!�/ � 6<� M�c. T�OP! �M�c.� D(,����� �,�( �/ 1*�'� 0��

) 6.� / ��:��. D�,[ .��� G!�HI! �/ $3O.)� � :45kH<� :6<.�� ( )���!6��) (!�5 �/ �� ���� �� I �/ )� )�!6. �!�) ��7.! �(�,[ G!�HI! 0!�/ K��[ ����� I�!,�

� )��� ��� �Dz5 ),j (�6'� �!,� �! ���c��!) ��6'5 �($�! �!� � ... @����) G�<�K! �$�NS,� �! �.���:��. �� �.���:� 0��� �(��� G!�HI! M���OP! � ��7L! ��� ))� � :46(.

»?( � 6.�� 0�� � 6<�L� �=.�G!,[ � T,/�� �! �� 0��?( .��c(� 0�� ���! ��W. ���,/ ��'����. D��3.� �/ �3+ ���)��� �j �$P!��. D���[ �$(b:G!,[ � �5 D���

��c(��5 �6() « ��,.!�1398 :238.( »_�b. :�,=�/ �/ .���L! �!� �/ � ��� F[�� !� U�*` 0�� �|�P � 6��6.! 0��

V6��L :�� �,/ D(,: �� 1�,� %�3� � M!��[$�! G!�[ T��! �! ��� �$O�j ,5 M!. %�!��L _@s� �/ �j �� � ����� . .�,/ $��� ��� T��! �� ��� 6��/ �j $O.!�

�!��P��� ��=<�� 1�,� �� Q� ���.�H[ �! �-. �/ )�<j ��� �%�P �� 6�� �! D(6<j _�7L �6() « :)� �109.(

) $'����L 0�� Y� :)� �112.( »$L�: !�L !� 0�� Y� 06�6( G!�HI!« ) :)� �113.( »T!,P �/ 0���!� G!,K 5��...« ) :)� �114.( »���� � ��� �~� 0�� Y� � �,/ �;� �! .6�(,K � �! v� ��� ���� 0�;� 7� #�!

��!6. �3[ v� ��� Y�« ))� �: 114.( »�!�j �/ �,/ ��[�� Qj 0��0�� .$(!� ��/ 0��!6+ �/ _,: � )!,�! . �! $O.!�

�.!,�� #�� .6<� E��( �;�0�� w� Y� 0�=u�!6N/ $(!� >�*5�%�! �,[ �/ �!�� ���u ��,/ ��L�:« ) :)� �116.( � �� 3&� ��L ��� �� Y�P )� � �� 3&� F'( �,(

Page 21: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 211

� ��W. Y��N�� !� �,[ ���u.��!� »/,(� D�� �$[�� .,W. �� 6( _�� .�,/ ���/ )�/!,[ )� �� #�W<� |�4� ��� ��

0��/ ��! �� 6�� �U�� � 6.@/ ?�=. ��/ �~� $O.!,5$[�� � ��@�W.!�/ $��P �/ !� �� .�|�+ )� �� _�� �`�/ � 6( �),�*�� �! �� 6(?� _�� .Qj ��%�� 0�� y!

$[����/ !� |�P �� �� �/ .6.���,(�� :$c: ����[!6� Q���/ �;<�! �!) «)� �: 116.( �7� M��!6S! 0�K �/ 3&� F'( ��:� ��,�� ���� �/ :�,(»..._��.«

»:$c: i(! )��� �! 0�� ...� Q.!��*/� !� ,*� .�6�� U�O� �� �� #�! .U6� =L U6��������L U�O� 0�K !� ,*� !6[ .$�! �!6[ U���.!. ���: ����: ����: � ./ 1�,� 6( 6<*

�.�( 0�� $(!b: $�� � 0�� �� $�! #� ��&�5 .�6( $P!��. $/�&�! :$c: � )�S�c5! �� �,5 0!�/ 6�L! �.Q�,: #� )���/ M@s� �! !� M�L!�[ #�!) «...)� � :117-

116.( G!�HI! . S�/ i( 0�K 0�� 0�� �,K� ���! ��J5 �! .!�� ���[�� �� �� ��!b: � ��!� #�! ��J52/,. �/ ��,[ G!�HI! ���/ � .�,(

5-3- ?Z�[�� ��0�� ��&? $�\

��: 3&� ��L�,[ �! ! �� ��!� 5!��-�.V6=� �! �:! �P N�3> $�NI� �� )�O.! U�;.! �/�S �! P�� C�!�( $*� �/ 6(�/ .6���/ �! i� �� �P 0!�/ D(,� .$O�.

R�O��3&� )� �[�� � »�.�s/ !� �*ZO� )� �,[ �=<5 �.$��[� � �5� �5��/� . �7*/ 6�� ��/ �/ 06�6K �R�O��6<���!�� ?5!�� �/ *3S �R�O� �! �� ����5$��[� � ���/ �5

$�!) «�0�.�,� 1398 G :67�� .( *+! �! �aS!�QR�*� #��5 %�3&�$ �� $�! )� ��L . .��� a.!,� � ��@��5 $*� �/ ���c��! �,[ .��� 0���!6N��! � M�.�7�! �! 6.!,5

6<� :)� �) .63 (»$L!�( � $/�;. « ��!, � �! � 6<�O� 0�� .��� � .!�� 0��@��5 �� $�! ?u!,��(6[ )!�W�� �-. �� �! |�+�! #�! �� P�� 0��@��5 .�,. �!�

��/ �,[ 0!�/ F'(#�! .6<�O�. )�=<� )!�W�� 6�� �! 6<�@: ,[ �� P�� 0��@��5 ̂� �! � 0�,&5�6�� !� F'( 0�� � $�� 6<�O� Y ̂�,[ |�+�! .6.6</ �6�!� �� 0�� Y

Page 22: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

212 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

M@� )�<'�%6�! �6�� ����$�! ?�;. :�6.!,[ T�� � 1��( �» Y�3.� #� :$c: U�O�0@�j �:���[� #�! �W� Q�c: .U�!6. U�,[ �� U��� @�j ��/! � Qj $cK i� �! ��`

���� �U@�@� Q�c: .$O� Q� �6.!,[ T�� � 1��( � ?�;. :$c: ���!� Q� 0�W��ST�� � $L!�( � $/�;. ����/ $.�/�G� � )�. �� :6.!,[ .�,( . )�(�,[ ��s�!

6.�� )���3S! �/ �� $�) « ��,.!�1398 :88.( 5-4- :�&O� X�?�

_�*5 ��!, � 0�� �L�+�! 6<� )�,/ G,[ �/ <�3� �,[ �! �!bW/ D�� . �/� � �!,( ���/ �� 0��� �� U�;.! )!�W�� �)� : 6.�/ $O�. /,[ U�� �!��@���� + �.!�,3 �

_�� �/ !� ��/ #�! � .6� 0��»�( �5 �3+ ��U� �j� { :6. !��� #�OP �~���� .�: �� �/!�6�.� ,/ � � �/���$� _�!�� 0�/ 0!,[�_ �� ��� 0��7.�� ,/� ...!%� 6<'3� �

��W. � ���c: � � v � �,/0 �� �� ���� $�!�$( ��� �! _!�,/� «):)� � 193(. +,5 #�!��3> �� !� �! !��7(� �0�� �! 1� 06</%�&'( �!�S ?*>�=� 9�5 �� 0�.�,� �

���*+! �! )!�W�� 6�; 5 � #�O45 �/ ���. .6�c�,� #��5=� 9�5 �%�&'( 0�� ?*>� ?*>�=� $%�&'( .$�!»� )!�W�� �-. �/ �,<� !� �,[ _��!6.!�. �� ��! � _��!

Q� ��=<�! U6� �� )!�W�� $%34� �!�/! � ?�,&5 �6�; 5 �1��N5 �/ DOc. �/� ������,(. / ��� G!,K E,. �� #�!�/�<// � =K,5�/�I �!��P! �� $�! 74� 0

�%�� �/ !� �!� �,�� 0@�j�. T�OP! � M���P 06�� « �0�.�,�)1398 G :46 .(Q=� � � �! � )!�W�� $��I� ?*K � �� ��!, � 0�� 1�,� $��I� ?*K � �� �5

:$�!»i(! 0����� ��� ��� !� DM�,[ ,5 :$c: � ��OL! �0�,/ �6�� �c� �! � ����OL! Q��!,'. �0�,/ $P!��.Q<7/ M�5. ��� �I!� � ( �5 Q<� ��7j :6���� �6.�

�U,/ E�;( �5 Q<� ��7j �6�,/«) ��,.!�1398 :131.( %�&'( 9�5 . ?*>�=� �� �,3;� �� ����K �� � 6<� �!���! 6.!,5 �,(

!6S! �� #�/ �!7� U �/ !� � � �6<� G�'�.! !��/ !� Y��N5 �5��� �! �-. �/ �� 6<�@: ��/ �! .!�� ���[��� .6.!��:

Page 23: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 213

��� �/ �� 0�� ���� �� 3(� M,L )��� 0�� �! �6<� D�� ?( )� 6�!,[)� =� � _�O� �>�[ �/ 0�� 6.� /� 1�,� 0���� 6�,: . ��[ � 6.� / 6.!,5

1�,� ��!,[ �,/ ���!,[ _���� �� Q� $/�5– $(!6. 0��� �:!- ���3/ D�!�/������L .� ?( )� � ���� � �,(����» : :6���� ����»!��L« � � .��7. 0�!�+! �W� :$c:(!6. 0��� M��,( ��!,[ �:! .$��c/ Q�!�/ $/�5 � �O.!,5 �:!$ 6���/ ,W/!�/ �� � � 6���/ �.�[ �/ �! �5 .�����/ $/�5 Q�. Q.�[ !� D����5 � 6.!,'/ !� _�� 67/... �� 0��� #�! �/ �$��;/ 6P #�! �5 D(,: � _,� �� ��� ���*N/ .����«

:)� �)98.( 0�� .��,( ��!,.�[ � ���� #�/ 6.!,5 [�. �7*/ 6<� G�'�.!�=K �/ ���!,

� ����/ �� �,(�� T�OP! 0��3K! �,> !� �=.� � 6(�/ ��(!� 0���/ #�7 5 6��/ 6<��! .6.�;.�. . ��!�!� !� _��!,[��,( 6.!,5 ��� 0�K �/ �� � M�c��5 �/ #�[!

2��!,[ ...� ����5 )6�� ���� ���� #�! 0�K �/ .���� �K �/ !� DJ��� �����5 6(!��,[ � � I!� !�0��� #�! �/ � $��;/ D(,: � _,� _���� �� 6<� . .����

�� $�! )� $*� !� �( ��O/ Qj 6���5 � ��L ��!,� �� 3&� F'(��/�@: 6<�N5 U6� �5��� _�-. �/ ��� Y��N�� !� ��L� ���[�� �� Y�<� �0�.�,�) 61398 G :

117*&� � ac. ��!, � ?*>�=� 9�5 � (> $4��/ !� L��,[ �! �� 6<�@: �5�/�.6.!� 5-5- =���� �� �J& /���

��!, � �! �cP �/ �,K,� aI�� U� ��!���� .�/ ���. �cP � �,K,� aI� 0���wK #�O � ���s5 �.,:�� �!.,:�:� ̂6<���/ vP �! (�. G!�HI! �! �� $�! ��j

%�<�! U6�� �,K� �/ $6��. � U6� #�! )!,5!,(� C�!�( �! (�. !� $�<�! :6.� �/ � _�6� ]�� �! v� 0�� �� $�<�! U6� T�OP! .$O.!� _���� )�>�� � �,�

6(� 0�� � %�O5 �! :6.� 0��!�� � � �/ � 6<�0 �:6/�� »���: 0�� �� :$c: )�<�� 0���2.�� �/ !� �<K �%�! 6<<7/ 6<�!,[ �j #� �/ .6.����. #��=( �� �,/�� �6(

Page 24: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

214 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

2*4� #�� �[ #� � #� $7* � �#� �=( ...)������2.�[ �/ !� �<K �=.� �%�! �$�! �. � Q� #�...6<.��) «��,.!�1398 :19-18(%�NS!� �� .$ 0�����K! � 6.�!6����. :6.�

.��� 6<:6.� / Y��N�� ��!, � ��L� ���[� »�'� � $K� � � � �/ ��L� ���[�� 0! .$�! T�OP � �6<<7( ���N�! �,L ���!� �,[ �cP 0!�/ ��</ T�5 0���� �!6�� #�!�/�

��;�!�.T�5 )� �! 7� .6�� $�! )!�W. \� R!� F'( �� $�! #�! �� Y��N5 !��3� ��P�� 4H� )�!,5 ���,[ Q��/ D « �0�.�,�)1398 G :126(.

5-6- $�� $�\ ��

�,[ 0�� #�! �/ vP�� �5V��/�� �%�! $�! ��:� 6�� %*�D��5 $ �!� @�. ���;�! 0�� M����[ � Q�,5 ��j� Y��N5 � �� �,(:��.�H[ ���O/ ��!Q� &5 .6. ��� ���: D

2*/�S ����, ����� ��/ ?H� ���5 � ��,/ �6.!,[ T�� )!�=5 �� _! �l/ � ���/ �,/ _! 6<� C�� !���,.!�) 1398 :100.( »2 � �� 6( �j 6� =c. Q� _�,[ � !�!6� � �3+

� �� D 7( �/ Q74� $�� �/ .6(�� �6<+ 0�� �! )�=:�. .�!� $�� �! !� D�S�>5 �� 7� #�! _�� :$c:�,/ C�� ?�! #� � �$�! Q 7( 0,0!�/ ... 5 � ( U� �

��L� ]����:�/ � U! ��c� !� Q 7( Q�7P Q.�[ .U!�����. Q 7( 0�� ...2 �sK...L! T�OP! .�� ���: �/ � $L�!� �6<+ 0���W�O[ �/ ��� �� ���� �! W<��� � �

$O�. ��.� U� 5) « :)� �130.( 2 � &'� 0!�!� h�'(!�0�� �. � 3&�/��;<=� G!�HI! � .��� ��J5 �!�.� W� � �6<*/ �� � 6.�/��<� )�(�,[ �/ M6� � �/ @�. 0�����<� �� .6.���

� � M��c�� M�,+ ��,[ �/ !� 0�����<� $=K ?*>�=� .6<<� |,HN� ����� ��0�5�/?*> ��<� )!�W�� �/ � �,[ # (� !� � � � �����*5 �) 6<� �0�.�,�

1398 G: 113 .(0�� � D.��� !� �,[ ��!,� ?*`! ���/ �� � 6<� D.��� �P!� !� )!�W���:���b� » ��!� ��� \� �!� �� $�! #�! ?*>�=� 9�5 ���/ M�%�+,&[ �! 7�

$5� ( � ����.! 0���/ ,4. �/ �� 0��!,� �� %�P .���:�!�S $��*� � D.��� ��,� �,H<� � ��. �� 6.!6/ �&�� !� �,[ \�<>�/ � \�NS!� �!,[ �$��;�/ 0� �/ $3O. )!�W��

Page 25: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 215

!� �=.� $��*� � ����.! ��O/ Qj ����b�) «:)� � 44 Q��P ��[� ���� ?( .(��!,(,: D����! �! �*�P �/ !� � �6.��:*� ��,� ?�!�S� Q��P ��[� 0!�/ !� _�O� 0

� 6.�/)�=<� 1�,� �! !� �=<�! �! �� �6<� �,[ �! !� �! �5#�W [ ���O. .� �!� $,[� �.!� $P!$� �,/ ,��5 )� D�,[ !����<�� D.:6 »[ WI��/ ��&�5�, U�

!$� «!�),. ��1398 :60( .��S �� .��! �! $�! ?� !�6.�3/ �,5 .!,*K 6.� 0�=. 6�O��/. ,[ �/ � ��H[ G �/!:� ?�:6�, »�j ! $ j� !�� ��!6. �0�!�j ! �,: .

)� 0!� !�I��/!��L Q. !���!� !,[! �� ��!��/ )��O/ «!))� � :64(. 5-7- �� ���^_��:� U���8� =��

�� 5D� 0���./G!�HI! � T�5 �! ��(�� � �.,:�� �/ ��.,:��J5 �� ��;<= 0���6��� 0�� �� 6<�O� �.���:��. � 0��3K! �T�5 $*� �/ 0�� ��:��. .�,( D���

!���!�� �� )���!� �Q�<�/» :%�! ��� �! Q� 6��(��,/ ,��5 YQ� U�,[ � U! .Q.!� ... �#�� ,*K ��/ #�6<j #�/ �U��� :���O�! ��6� Q.�[ )� �� 0��� Q�! Q.!6/ �7<�!

�2 � ��!� _��,[ !� 0�=� V��� �� ��� )� ...$�! $��;( �� :���O�! Q<� �l/ ��%�! 6<�L��� )���5 �! U6.�� #� �#� � Q� 6��( ...��6�� D�� 0�,> . )� 6��( �Q.!�

��� Q�(!6. 0@�j ���� Q�6/ $�� �!%�! ...���P �) «... :)� �130.( 5-8- %��$a��� � ����?����?

/ ?*>�=� F'(�$.,[ ��:�. �y�[ �/ $��;( � ���� � � $�!�b: ��! 6���/%6(!� ?;N5 �/ !� �! M�.!,5�. �� 5 �7.� 0!�/ F'( .��!� �� �,[ �/ !�,O<� G

���O. �S��/ #��[� � 0�� �/ 6��! �/!,� Y�3.� �/ �,[ #�� �� 6�6. $�� �! !� ���s5�.���;( ���L� �! ����:» :�,/ �� ��[ �U��/ Q� #� 0!,[ U� $��;(!�Q�( «))� � :

129(���(! 0��� �/ . � �� 6<�» � ��� ,5! � $O( !� ���� �,*/ )� � � �� ���� �/ Y�$L� ���6� �/ �� 6��6.! � .�� U6�...) « :)� �153 � (» 0�� .!,[�N( $/,.

6��� ��� �N( 0�K �/ »�:!« �,[ �),�*�� �B! ),O��� 0�,� /� :6�� D.�/� �/ �,[ !��� �. D[�� U�:���: �� !i���5 !i���5 !i���5« ) :)� �155.(

Page 26: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

216 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

0������ �/ (!�5�., . �/ ����/ ����.���;( 0�����L� �!���(! _! �<�6 ����� !� �=.� )���/ �� 6.!� ���/ C�!�( �7*/ $O�. )!,5�. � ,��5 5!� �,> D.6(,��5$�! �6(�Y�~� )!,<� �/ . �&�� !� 1�,� � � $P!�+ �>�[ �/ �� 6.!�

� �! D��.�H[ 0����� .$�! ���� ��635 ,��5 &'( �/ !0�.�,� $�! 6��N� ( F' ��L� ���[�� �/ Y��N5 �6.! )6.!��:��/ 0!�/ !� �,[ 0���. #��[� k��> #�! �! 3&�

U�;.! � �:! !��� 6��G!�HI! 0!�/ *���� � .���/ a.!,� D���k��> #�! �! � 6(!��. �/�,/�. *� �/ �6<3. 6��! a.!,� )� aL� �/ 6��! ��,( �0�.�,�)1398 G :101-102(. 5-9- b�? �����1$ /�

ij,� �/ 3&� F'( ��L� ���[�� )�!,5Q� �� �/�I #��5 �)� 0�K �/ � �@�� D�,5 � ��=�� �/ �!� � 6�6( W�O[ � :��OL! 6�6( T�5 ��:6<�. »P 0�*�! 6

�! T�5 ��!� _�,[ P�� aI� )�,/ #Z H��. � �!6����. �! 3&� F'( �� ��5$�! W.!,�� «)� �) :145 .(2*P�� �� W.!,�� �! T�5 ]�� U�W<� �)��� .����

{� 0�� 0!�/ �1�,� � 6���*�!63� ���� )��!� �/ $�� 0�� �)�[ � \� ���O� � �,( ! �!V��/�� � W.!,�� )�7�!!_ � :6���»�!,[ 0�� ���� �!,�� �/ � ��6/ $

�*�!63�!� !� �! � ���/ )�[�!�!��� Q.�[ :6�,W/ � � �/ �� � �6. �.!,���� �6( ��c(� � .� .$�! M�� D�!,P �6�j �/ Q � $���.!,�� �56/ � ( .6���6. �! )���_!

�6�<�!) « ��,.!�1398 :280.( » :6���� �.��,&N� 0��� ( ��6. �.!,�� #� 6��,:.U! ���*�!63� �� :$c: )�[/ ��� �

�K�� .0� :6���� ��/Q� �.!,�� . �U,( �����*�!63� :$c: )�[� Y,S0,. Q��. $[�� 0�� Qj �� Qj :�!� ��!�! 0�W(�!,. 0!6+ �/ � %�! 0�!� Q�[6/ ��� i� �

�[�� #� �! DK�*� ��� / �0�O� $�! I�� .$O�. �,/ #�@� �7<�! �! D�� 6����� :$c: ���� �)�>�� :6���� 0�� .$�! B�! Q� ��: .<� D<��j �Q.�K �. !

$c�*�*�[ .T�5 ��� ��O�.$�! 0�O� �� Q�c: .6.�!� ��« ))� � :285( .

Page 27: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 217

3&� ���L� 0��b� )���� �/ 0�.�,� 6��N� $�!�P!��. aL� �� 0�� .!��»/ W�O%�3&� )� �[�� M6( �/$����� M6( �$ ��%NL � �6.� #�<l � � 0�����. )�,/ Y�

��!� F'( �,K� �6.��� � $3~�« ) �0�.�,�1398 G: 63!63� ���� .(�*� �/ )�[���(! 0�� 0�� �/ )�,/ #�@���` �6<� :$�! )���� �/�S v�»!� 0�� $�� ��/ ��

:��@L! �.!�3���� � $L�: $����.� #�! �� .Q.�K ,</ ������ #�! �! ...� �� @�j � � $! U�� �,[.T�5 �P �),<K �P �k� �P �$� .. ��(!� |,S� � ��!�! �� >�( �/

6(�/ «�,.!�) �1398 :285(. �*�!63� ���� ��c�! �#�L� U�W<� )�[»NS!� « �»%�NS!�$ « !�/ 0�� �/ G�H[� )�

�^�,[ �/ !� �! � 6<� NS!���b5 _! � :6��»�.NS!� Q.�[ .�O� Q.�[ Q.!� � Q.!�.�%�NS!� �! �� �O� 0,S � E�;( �6� $.0@��W... « :)� �)286 .( �� Q=� M�7. �!

%��-.2 %�3&� aL� �� $�! #�! 0�.�,�*7� � $��!� _,� �/ � ��35�! .!�� M� ) �0�.�,�1398 G :63(. ���� !63��*��� 0�� |�+�! �� @�. )�[ � �! �,3=/ �/ 6.!,5

6<� i �T�� �/ �! _,� � )�,/ �6.!,[���(! . .6<� ��:� �! v� 0�� .��� �/3&� 0�����L� $*� )�,/��/ !� DOc. �/ �� ��! �_! ��<� vz� �! .6/��^� ��;�!

_��,( a��5 Q�!�� 0�!@:�/ �/ 0�!63��! 6I $��P i� �.�,( � �K,�� �P!� �/ 3&� F'( )��L!�>! $�! 6��N� 0�.�,�.� �� 6.,( �l

'(^�,&5 k/�H� _�,[ �! 3&� F 6�!��1�+,5 � � ̂�,[ �/ ��!� ��-�.! � 6<� �K,�� ���� �;<�! �� .��!6. ��:� )� �/ 3&� F'( ��! ��!� �*+�L �! NS!� � �,(

��L�: �*+�L �! 0�,&5 �,[ �! 0�� NS!� �,[ �� .$�! 6- �c� �

G!�HI! �M���OP! �H�4� C�!�( ��*45� ������. ��� ���L� � Y� �! )�.���=S*+! ��� ),(�,� ) �/0�<3� %��-.2 %�&'( 9�5 �� 0�.�,� )��� D�� . �/ !� !@;� ����!b:%�&'( .)���!� ��� $ �/��J5 �,K� ��� �_���L� ���� V��64� %�&'($

/%�&'( .��!� �!�S ��;<=G!�HI! $*� �/ )���!� )� $ 0�� ��J5 �! �3&� 6�6(

Page 28: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

218 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

%�&'( 9�5 �� � $�! �.� �� ���!1��N5 ?*>�=� 3&� � � .�,(*[�/ |���*45 0��)!���.!��� D�� � �/�! ��B� �! %�&'( ��*45 �� �!� )�. �I�P$0��

0�����L� [�/ T��! �/ !� �! �F'( �� ���L� 0�<N� ��*45 �! D�� 6��3. )���!�%�&'( 9�5 i� �� Y�7�z�5 %�&'( .�!� �!�S 3&� �,� )���!� �� 1�,� $ �� ),(�

0���L� QR�*� ��0�5�/?*> � ?*>�=� �$�@�?*> %�NS,� �� !�$ 0���,[ �! 1*�'� )�. � %��-. 0�<3� �/ ��! 6��2 %�3&�.��� �=<5 0�.�,� $ � �T�OP! ���� i� )!,5

�. � 3&� !� ���L� �/( �� � 6(�/ ���! ��J5 �/ <�3� �� $O.!� ��;<=' ��;�! F %�&'( �� .6<� ��L� ���[�� (����L �! T�5 � G!�HI!��� 1�,� $� �! i� QR�*

)!�W�� �� �,[ �/ ��<� ���L� ���[�� Y��N5 U6� �! T�5 ����L� )�,/ 0��3K! �G!�HI!� 6���5� �6��� vc. �/ �� ��! U6� . �� .�,( %�&'((0��) )���!� )� $ � T�5

#��5���/ G!�HI![�( .$��! 0���L� F *+! G!�HI! �,K� #��5 ���! ��J5 �,K� �/ ����F'( .!�� ���[�� ��

.$�! 0�� ��,� )!��� ��*45 .6(�/ ��(!� ��,� )!��� �� ��� 6��/ ��J5 #�! ��*��. (�. M�W<5 � �6� )�!� $�� �!� 0��&�S! 0�<)�. ! �2/�;5 .6�� )!���

� G!�HI! �! �� ��,%�<�! U6�$ � ���L� ���[�� (����L T�5 ��;�! �/ G!�HI!\�*/���� 0�.�,� ��:6�� �! ��<� � G!�HI! .$�! ���� ��;�! �! �� !� �,[ �/ ��<� W�6 � �

6�65 !� � 0�� .6<<�%��-. 0�<3� �/ ��2 %�&'( 9�5 �� 0�.�,�!�S ?*>�=� �� � ����: %*� �! ��:��. ���� �/ 0�����L� $T�5 � �,[G!�HI! � ��(!�5 ���� �/ ��

0�� ����� 6<.�� ��.�H[ M��!6S! �/ Y��N5 ��;�! 0!�/ �! .��,�� #�<K C�� �(�, \����=. � ��[�� ���� (����L �! v�V���� �W.!,�� �! T�5 � ���L� � ��� � �;��N�)�

� �� ��! .�,(�,LV��N�! !63� ���� �/ 0���*�[ �! �/ �)�i � � )��� 2*+�L �5 6<�^�,[ ^�,[ � NS!� 0�,&5/ )��� �! !� _!D�,[ vc. �/ �� ��! ���/�� � ��!�� !�

.6/����/

U� E����

Page 29: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

���� �������� ���� �� ��� � �� ������ �� ������ ������ ����� ��� � �!...#�$% � &��� #'��(� 219

G��� :1�!�� ) ��c�� �����1379�( )!�� ��:6�� �! )�O.! $N�3> $[�<(��<( � ������!,K ����> 2 K�56(� :)!�=5.

#� �� ��,.!�)1398�( ),(�,����!,[ :)!�=5 �Q;<� � $O�/ ��j �. ) 6�,�� �@l��1379 �(�,�(/�! 6�. 0�� �c�,� #�O4��*` � .��S6+ �56% 4� 2 K�5 �

.W<��L � *� M!���.! :)!�=5 ) 6% 4� ��N<+1380 �(��*45)!�� 0��M�%�/�! � �<� �� �[�<( .@��� :)!�=5 �

��!@7�.�, 4� )1391 �()!�� a��K �<��L��<(.)�=�� 2O�,� :)!�=5 �06*K �� � ) )��� �0�.�,�1398 �(G 2.��� 3&� $%�&'(�� ��%c&� �cNK6% 4� 2 K�5� $;=/ :)!�=5. ) )��� �0�.�,�1398 �(y0����,[.$;=/ :)!�=5 ��%c&� �cNK6% 4� 2 K�5 � ) )��� �0�.�,�1399 �(��� 6(� � $%�3&� 2 K�5 �)!�=5 ��%c&� �cNK6% 4�: .$;=/ ) )��� �0�.�,�1398 �(1�!.��� 0����J5 � K�52 % 4�%c&� �cNK6�:)!�=5 � $;=/. ) !�,P �0����1374 �()�=K �� �)�O.! �� �#�� �� �M��/�! � 0��7.!��.)!��! ����5 :)!�=5 �

����G� :U

!��� �#�l*: � �*�� �<����/)1394(� »$%�&'()� 0�!��� �,.!� #� �� .���!� M��/�! ��),(�,� �/ 6���5 �/« M�>�35�! � )�/� �/�! 0�����OK ** �! #�/ D�� � �� �6( �R!�! �

W<��L. =/< v:�. �0�S�/ � �*�!6� �k*H�)1391(� »2O���� Y�*K � �,.!� #� �� ��B� �� )�.� )�/�

6 P! Y�«� �<��L � )�V��� ���=/ �3V�� ( �11F+ �43-59. U�<=/) ?<�� ���*> � 6% 4� ��L1392 �(»)!�� 6�. 2%��-. 0�<3� �/ �6.� . (���� �W�� �[�<(

0�.�,� )���«D�� � � V��� �)�=K �+�N� M�%�/�! 0��18 V�� ( �2 F+ �23-42 . ) �<�� ��6<�� � *� � �*O51392 �(» ?�7� 0�<3� �/ E,S� �N( .!�� �+�<� [�/ ��*45

0�.�,�«_��� � V�� ( ����L M�%�/�! � )�/� 2��.26 F+ �227-256. $(� ��I�) �, 4� ��.q�!1388 �(» ��:6�� T��! �/ �/�5 @ �K �! .���!� ���/ � 6�.

)!��0�.�,� )��� �[�<(«G�! �F+ �)��O�� �Q�� V�� ( ��� �206- 187 .

Page 30: DOI: 10.30465/LIR.2020.33381.1215 Psychoanalytic Analysis

220 D�� � 0��#�/��(�/�! 0! )��O�� � @���� �U��=j V�� ( �U�� Y�� �1399

) ��<=/ �'/ � ��*K �0���(1394 �(»!�� ��*45)$%�&'( �[�<( �!6: )���!� �� 0��#�.��O��[0�.�,� )��� 2%��-. 0�<3� �/ 06��� #�O4��*` .�6��s(� � ��«#�� �� � �/�! �

Y��19 V�� ( �63F+ ���=/ �88- 55. Q�=L) �/,34� �U�*�1395 �(»)!�� 6�.0�.�,� )��� 2%��-. 0�<3� �/ ��O��� ��.� �[�<(«. � 6�

%�/�! � )�/� V�� ( �Q��@�� V��� �K��[ M�17F+ �)��O�� � @���� �209-226. ���=( �7(@� � _,=� � �,S)1386(� »$%�&'( D�. � �,=u �U�. �B! ),(�,� �� ��

�,.!� #� ��«� �Q*S )��O/�5 � ��=/ 1386� V��� 3� V�� (5F+ �52- 33 . % 4� �O��� ��,��*> � Q��!�/! �06)1391(� » D�� .$%�&'(�� )$%�&'(�� . 0�!��� ( ��

),(�,�«#�� �/�! �� �V�� ( ���=/ � 51 F+ �33-52. ) 6�;� �W<(,�1392 �(»0�.�,� )��� ��W. �! �<� =5 $%�&'( 2.!��7.!�� ���/ � 6�.« �

F+����L M�%�/�! � )�/� D�� � #� �c�2001-2013