September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

P802.11u Report to EC on Conditional Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot

Authors:

Name Affiliation Address Phone email

Stephen McCannResearch in

Motion200 Bath Road, Slough,

Berks, SL1 3XE, UK+44 1753 667099

smccann@rim.com

Bruce Kraemer Marvell5488 Marvell Lane,

Santa Clara, CA 95054+1 (321) 427-4098

bkraemer@marvell.com

Slide 1

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

Introduction

• This document contains an updated report to the IEEE 802 Executive Committee completing conditional approval to send the IEEE P802.11u Draft to Sponsor Ballot.

• Revision 5 of this document (11-09-0715r5) was approved during the closing plenary session of the 802.11 working group on 17 July 2009.– Passed in the Task Group yes 14, no 1, abstain 0

– Passed in the Working Group yes , no , abstain

Slide 2

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

September 2009 status after LB156

• Recirculation ballot LB156 was completed on 18 August 2009 according to the schedule presented on slide #12

• The approval percentage from LB156 is 93%.

September 2009

Slide 3

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

LB156 required comments resolution

• There was 1 new valid DISAPPROVE vote with 1 required comment (CID 8001), but the voter then changed his required comment to not required on 22nd September 2009 (slide #5).

• There were 4 new required comments (CIDs 8015, 8016, 8013, 8014) from 1 existing DISAPPROVE voter, but the voter then changed these to not required on 22nd September 2009 (slide #6).

September 2009

Slide 4

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

• -----Original Message-----From: Liwen CHU [mailto:liwen.chu@st.com] Sent: 22 September 2009 09:14To: Stephen McCannSubject: RE: LB156 - IEEE 802.11u Draft 8.0 Comments

• Hi Stephen,

• Yes, I can change my comment to "T".

• Best Regards

• Liwen

• -----Original Message-----

• From: Stephen McCann [mailto:smccann@rim.com]

• Sent: Monday, September 21, 2009 6:47 PM

• To: liwen.chu@st.com

• Subject: LB156 - IEEE 802.11u Draft 8.0 Comments

• Liwen,

• TGu is currently addressing comments from LB156 and notes that you have 1 technical required "TR" comment. TGu currently has 4 "TR" comments and 1 "ER" comment.

• To allow TGu to progress to sponsor ballot, would you be willing to change your comment to "T", so that it is no longer a "TR".

• Thanks

September 2009

Slide 5

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

• -----Original Message-----From: AMalarky@ivhs.com [mailto:AMalarky@ivhs.com]

• Sent: 22 September 2009 03:28

• To: Stephen McCann

• Subject: Re: LB156 - IEEE 802.11u Draft 8.0 comments

• Yes I am okay with this.

• Alastair Malarky

• -----Original Message-----

• "Stephen McCann" <smccann@rim.com>

• 09/21/2009 09:51 PM To <amalarky@ivhs.com>

• Subject LB156 - IEEE 802.11u Draft 8.0 comments

•

• Alastair,

• TGu is currently addressing comments from LB156 and notes that

• you have 3 technical required "TR" comment and 1 editorial required "ER"

• comment. In total TGu currently has 4 "TR" comments and 1 "ER" comment.

• To allow TGu to progress to sponsor ballot, would you be willing to

• change your comments to "T" and "E", so they are no longer "required?"

• Thanks

September 2009

Slide 6

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

802.11 WG Letter Ballot Results – P802.11u

BallotID

Ballot Close Date

Title BallotType Pool Return %RtnAbstai

n%Abs Approve

Disapprove

%Approve

132 12 July 2008

Technical Letter Ballot for IEEE 802.11u_D3.0

Technical 213 182 85.5 35 19.2 113 34 76.9

137 08 October

2008

Recirculation Letter Ballot for IEEE 802.11u_D4.0

Recirculation 213 189 88.7 37 19.6 118 34 77.6

142 20 February

2009

Recirculation Letter Ballot for IEEE 802.11u_D5.0

Recirculation 213 191 89.7 39 20.4 125 27 82.2

148 24 April 2009

Recirculation Letter Ballot for IEEE 802.11u_D6.0

Recirculation 213 192 90.1 35 18.2 142 15 90.4

152 19 June 2009

Recirculation Letter Ballot for IEEE 802.11u_D7.0

Recirculation 213 194 91.0 33 17.0 142 19 88.2

156 18 Aug 2009

Recirculation Letter Ballot for IEEE 802.11u_D8.0

Recirculation 213 194 91.0 35 18.0 148 11 93

Slide 7

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

802.11 WG Letter Ballot Comments – P802.11u

Ballot IDBallot

Close DateTitle Ballot Type

Number of Comments received

132 12 July 2008Technical Letter Ballot for TGu Draft 3.0

Technical 944 (525 T, 419 E)

137 8 Oct 2008Recirculation Letter Ballot for TGu Draft 4.0

Recirculation 871 (487 T, 384 E)

142 20 Feb 2009Second Recirculation Ballot for TGu Draft 5.0

Recirculation 241 (35 T, 206 E)

14824 April

2009Third Recirculation Ballot for TGu Draft 6.0

Recirculation 229 (125 T, 104 E)

152 19 Jun 2009Fourth Recirculation Ballot for TGu Draft 7.0

Recirculation 225 (118 T, 107 E)

156 18 Aug 2009Fifth Recirculation Ballot for TGu Draft 8.0

Recirculation 68 (24 T, 44 E)

Slide 8

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

Unsatisfied comments by commenterVoter1 LB132 LB137 LB142 LB148 LB152 Total

Gabor Bajko 15 15

Clint Chaplin 1 20 21

Peter Ecclesine 4 4

Darwin Engwer 2 2

Tom Kolze 2 3 1 2 1 9

Alastair Malarky 8 8

Henry Ptasinski 17 10 4 31

Richard Roy 6 6

Dorothy Stanley 4 1 10 15

Alexander Tolpin 1 1

George Vlantis 2 2 3

Qi Wang 6 6

Total 25 13 5 5 73 121

Slide 9

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

Unsatisfied Comments – Topics

Topic #Comments

Interworking 15

Generic Advertisement Service 44

Subscription Provider Interface 15

Emergency Services 11

Editorial 28

Other 10

Total 121

Slide 10

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

Unsatisfied comments

• The composite of all unsatisfied comments and the resolutions approved by the comment resolution committee received during working group ballot may be found in the embedded document on the right:

– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.

• A copy of this same data presented using MyBallot access database report format is attached.

– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.

Adobe Acrobat Document

Microsoft Excel Worksheet

Slide 11

September 2009

Stephen McCann (RIM), Bruce Kraemer (Marvell)

doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0715r7

Submission

TGu Timeline Open Close

Third recirculation (TGu draft 8.0) 26-Jul-09 10-Aug-09

Clean recirculation (TGu draft 8.0) 28-Sep-09 13-Oct-09

Pool formation 15-Aug-09 29-Sep-09

First sponsor ballot 21-Oct-09 20-Nov-09

Second sponsor ballot 31-Jan-10 15-Feb-10

Third sponsor ballot 17-Mar-10 2-Apr-10

Fourth sponsor ballot 1-May-10 16-May-10

EC to RevCom Mar-10 (cond.) or Jul-10

RevCom to SB Sep-10 Slide 12