-
7/31/2019 Doc. 173-2 -- Pla Ex. 263 - Memorandum Chase v. Divens
- Ninth Circuit of Appeals
1/7
- Ycn| in|wj|nynjh n| hjy fwwqjwqnfyo bjq wuadnlfynjh fhi n| hjy
wqoloiohy
oslowy f| wqjrnioi a~ >yc Lnq( Q(
-
7/31/2019 Doc. 173-2 -- Pla Ex. 263 - Memorandum Chase v. Divens
- Ninth Circuit of Appeals
2/7
-
7/31/2019 Doc. 173-2 -- Pla Ex. 263 - Memorandum Chase v. Divens
- Ninth Circuit of Appeals
3/7
6( [o fbbnqe(
6( Inroh| fqkuo| ycfy yco in|yqnly ljuqy| {nyho|| lqoinandny~
ioyoqenhfynjh|
|cjudi ao qorno{oi wuq|ufhy yj f |ua|yfhynfd orniohlo |yfhifqi(
Ycn| fqkueohy
bfnd|( F in|yqnly ljuqy| lqoinandny~ ioyoqenhfynjh| fqo qorno{oi
bjq ldofq oqqjq fhi
ohynydoi yj |wolnfd ioboqohlo( Fhioq|jh r( Ao||oeoq Lny~$ 9;7
_(\( ?29$ ?;3?.0 Aoolc Fnqlqfby Ljqw( r( _(\($ ?6 B(?.( Yco
in|yqnly ljuqy ini hjy ldofqd~ oqq {coh ny ioyoqenhoi ycfy yco
yo|ynejh~ jb Mjh
Inroh| {f| {cjdd~ nhlqoinado fhi yco yo|ynejh~ jb Mfeo| \frjq
{f| lqoinado
fhi ljqqjajqfyoi a~ yco oscnany| fienyyoi fy yqnfd( Lcf|o Nhr(
\oqrnlo| Ljqw($
;93 B( \uww( 1i fy 66?6(
1( Inroh| fqkuo| ycfy yco in|yqnly ljuqy ldofqd~ oqqoi {coh ny
bjuhi ycfy
Inroh| ini hjy cfro fh~ fkqooeohy {nyc fh~ qowqo|ohyfynro jq
fkohy jb Aoyy| jq
Feoiqff ycfy ohynydoi Inroh| jq MIF yj yco nhyoqo|y kohoqfyoi a~
yco LEJ|( F
in|yqnly ljuqy| bnhinhk| jb bfly fqo qorno{oi bjq ldofq oqqjq(
Boi( Q( Lnr( W( ?1#f.0
Wuqlodd r( Kjh}fdo}$ ?9> _(\( 6$? #1772.0 Hfrfmj Hfynjh r(
_(\( Bjqo|y \oqrnlo$
?
-
7/31/2019 Doc. 173-2 -- Pla Ex. 263 - Memorandum Chase v. Divens
- Ninth Circuit of Appeals
4/7
9
yco in|yqnly ljuqy| bnhinhk| jb bfly ycfy hj |ulc fkqooeohy
osn|yoi( Yco bnhinhk|
fqo hjy ldofqd~ oqqjhoju|(
_(\( fy ?0
Hfrfmj Hfynjh$ ?
-
7/31/2019 Doc. 173-2 -- Pla Ex. 263 - Memorandum Chase v. Divens
- Ninth Circuit of Appeals
5/7
?
|oqrnlo|$ uhioq lnqlue|yfhlo| |cj{nhk ycfy yco |oqrnlo| {oqo hjy
kqfyunyju|d~
qohioqoi( Cu|`nh|jh " Aqj{h$ DDW r( [jdb$ > Lfd( Qwyq( 2
#Lfd( 1779.(
F in|yqnly ljuqy| ljhldu|njh| jb df{ fqo qorno{oi io hjrj$
cj{oroq$ bflyufd
bnhinhk| ycoqonh fqo qorno{oi bjq ldofq oqqjq(Cu|fnh r( Jd~ewnl
Fnq{f~|$
-
7/31/2019 Doc. 173-2 -- Pla Ex. 263 - Memorandum Chase v. Divens
- Ninth Circuit of Appeals
6/7
2
LEJ$ aolfu|o yco in|yqnly ljuqy ini hjy ldofqd~ oqq {coh ny
bjuhi ycfy yco fyyoewyoi
yqfinhk {f| horoq fuycjqn}oi$ fkqooi yj$ jq jycoq{n|o afqkfnhoi
bjq a~ Aoyy|$ yco
in|yqnly ljuqy| ljhldu|njh ycfy honycoq Inroh| hjq MIF wqjrnioi
fh~ rfduo nh
oslcfhko bjq yco nhyoqo|y wf~eohy| jh yco Ljafdy LEJ n| ljqqoly(
\oo Cu|fnh$
-
7/31/2019 Doc. 173-2 -- Pla Ex. 263 - Memorandum Chase v. Divens
- Ninth Circuit of Appeals
7/7
;
;( Df|yd~$ yco in|yqnly ljuqy ini hjy oqq {coh ny nhlduioi yco
yneo woqnji bqje
Boaqufq~ 177> yj Efqlc 177> nh ny| f{fqi jb ifefko|
aolfu|o ny| cjdinhk n| hjy
nhljh|n|yohy {nyc ycfy f{fqi(
FBBNQEOI(
Lf|o= 67%?2;3? 73*72*1761 NI= 31;?3>; I`yOhyq~= 99%6 Wfko= ;
jb ; #; jb Lf|o
