Upload
frank-flynn
View
212
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 appliesR&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 1
DTM 11-003R&M Engineering
Implementation StrategyAndrew Monje
Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense, Systems Engineering Office of the Under Secretary of Defense (Acquisition, Technology and Logistics)
16 Aug 2011
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 2
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 applies
PURPOSE• Provide overview of the R&M Implementation
Strategy upon approval of DTM 11-003
AGENDA• DTM Overview• Policy Implementation - DTM 11-003• Process - Guidance & Standards/DIDs• People - Human Capital• Summary• Open Discussion
Purpose / Agenda
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 3
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 applies
• Engineering activities (AS to describe tasks and processes to be stated in the RFP)– R&M Allocations, block diagrams and predictions– Failure definitions and scoring criteria– Failure Mode, Effects and Criticality Analysis (FMECA)– Built-in test and maintainability demonstrations– Reliability Growth testing at system/subsystem level– Failure Reporting, Analysis and Corrective Action System (FRACAS)
• Preliminary RAM-C Report in support of MS A and updated for MS B & C– Provides early (Pre-MS A) reliability, availability, maintainability and ownership cost
feasibility assessments of alternative concepts− Includes early formulation of maintenance & support concepts
– Provides an audit trail that documents and supports JCIDS thresholds– Ensures correct balance between the sustainment metrics (Availability-KPP, Materiel
Reliability-KSA, and Ownership Cost-KSA)– Provides early risk reduction by ensuring requirements are realistic and correct
• AS and SEP to specify how the JCIDS sustainment thresholds have been translated into R&M design requirements for use in contract specifications
DTM 11-003 Overview
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 4
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 applies
DTM 11-003 Overview
• Reliability Growth Strategy– Documents system-level reliability growth curves in the SEP beginning at
MS A and updated in the TEMP beginning at MS B– Establishes intermediate goals for reliability growth curves that will be
tracked through fully integrated system-level test and evaluation events until the threshold is achieved
– Requires MS C PMs and Operational Test Agencies to assess reliability growth required to achieve the reliability threshold during Initial Operational Test and Evaluation
• Tracking and Monitoring– Requires PMs to report status of reliability objectives and/or thresholds as
part of the formal system engineering review process– Incorporates Reliability Growth Curves into the Defense Acquisition
Executive System (DAES) review process
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 5
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 applies
DoDI 5000.02Encl(6) Test
DAES
Quad Chart
Policy Implementation DTM 11-003
• Incorporating DTM in DoD 5000 and affected Governance Documents– DoDI 5000.02 & enclosure 12 (SE)
revision – Complete & sent to DPAP– Enclosure 13 (Logistics) – Comments
provided to L&MR– Systems Engineering Plan Outline –
Approved– Acquisition Strategy Outline – Approved– Preliminary Design Review Report
Guideline – Completed– TEMP outline – Currently in review– LCSP outline – In work– DAES RVW Growth Quad chart – In
work
SystemsEngineeringPlan (SEP)
Test & Evaluation
Master Plan
(TEMP)
TechnologyDevelopment
Strategy/Acquisition
Strategy
PreliminaryDesign ReviewReport
DTM11-0033/21/11
Life-Cycle Sustainment
Plan
Encl(12)System
Engineering
In review/In-work
Approved
Status:
DTM to Policy and Acquisition Document Relationships
DoDI 5000.02Encl(13)
Lifecycle Logistics
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 6
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 appliesv.01
Annotated Outlines for TDS/AS, SEP Released as “Expected Business Practice”
TDS/AS and SEP outlines signed
April 20, 2011
Technology Development Strategy [or] Acquisition Strategy
Annotated Outline
Systems Engineering PlanAnnotated Outline
April 20, 2011
http://www.acq.osd.mil/se/docs/PDUSD-ATLMemo-Expected-Bus-Practice-TDS_AS_SEP-20Apr11.pdf
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 7
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 appliesv.01
• Identify the engineering activities to be stated in the RFP and required of the contractor to demonstrate the achievement of the reliability and maintainability design requirements.
• Provide a table (see example below) to specify how the sustainment key performance parameter thresholds have been translated into reliability and maintainability design and contract specifications … The reliability threshold is often expressed as Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF). Use the appropriate life units (e.g., hours, cycles, etc.). “MTTR” is “mean time to repair;” “N/A” may be entered if an item is not applicable.
R&M in the TDS/AS
Reliability and Maintainability Requirements
Parameter ThresholdContract Specification
Requirement
Reliability (e.g., MTBF)
Maintainability (e.g., MTTR)
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 8
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 applies
New Reliability Reporting
Document the Reliability Growth Curve beginning at MS A, updated at each successive milestone, …
and report planning to generate R&M artifacts.
Implementation of New Reliability Policy
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 9
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 appliesv.01
• Update to DAG Chapter 4 R&M Sec 4.4.15– Include overview of R&M Eng Activities by phase– Apply R&M Eng activities based on program position in
Life Cycle– Also based on acquisition strategy and equipment type
− Provides guidance on Reliability Growth Program– Includes R&M contract guidance with associated DIDs
• Collaborate with DAG Editors (i.e., to ensure R&M guidance is properly integrated
• Develop R&M Engineering Guidance with task descriptions per phase
– Describes R&M engineering activities across typical program areas
• Forming R&M Standards working group– Priority given to standards that directly relate to the R&M
engineering activities required by the DTM– R&M Eng Mgt STDs 1st (i.e. 785, 470, & 2165)– Design & Reliability Growth STDs (i.e. 1629, 1635)
Process - Guidance & Standards/DIDs
DAG LM&R
Chapter 5Updates
DAG SE Chapter 4 Updates
Key R&MEngineeringStandards &
DIDs DAG DDT&EChapter 9Updates
Defense AcquisitionGuidebook
R&M Engineering Guidebook
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 10
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 appliesv.01
Materiel Solution Analysis Phase
MS A
MDD
DOD 5000.02
LIFECYCLE ENTRY
ICD TES
TDS
SEP
GOV TASK ASSIGNMENT
PR & RFP FOR MSA
INPUT TO TDS
PR/RFP TECH DEV
PHASE
PROPOSAL EVAL
CRITERIA
PROCUREMENT (SECT. VIII)
INPUT TO TES
TEST AND EVALUATION (SECT.
VII)
MAINT. ANALYSIS
LIFE CYCLE SUSTAINMENT
PLAN
R&M RQMTS.
ANALYSES
TRADEOFF STUDIES
R&M ANALYSIS REPORTS
SYSTEM ENGINEERING (SECT. V)
CONFIG MGMT.
TECH DEV SYSTEM
SPEC
CONFIGURATION MANAGEMENT (SECT.
IV)
R&M DATA RQMTS UPDATE
DATA CONTROL (SECT. III)
RAM-C REPORT
SUMMARY
INPUT TO SEP
PM PLAN
PROGRAM REVIEW
PROJECT CONTROL (SECT. II)
MS-A PHASE FUNCTIONS
R&M PLANS TECHNOLOGY
DEV PHASE
REJECT
ACCEPTA
R&M PLANS
MSAICD
1
4 5 6
12 15 19
8
7
2 1 23
10
9 11
17
16
18
13
20 14 22
2
R&M DATA
RQMTS
3
REVIEW CONTRACT
ITR ASR
FUNCTIONAL BASELINE
AOA
Draft CDD
LOGISTICS PLANNING (SECT. VI)
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 11
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 applies
PeopleHuman Capital
• Objective: Increase PM demand for R&M Engineering and enhance R&M Engineering professional capabilities to successfully implement a R&M program.
• Approach– Define R&M Engineering tasks– Develop R&M Engineering
competencies for PM and R&M Engineers
– Submit R&M competencies to DAU for curriculum development via SE FIPT chair
– DAU develops training architecture, curriculums, training content and delivers training.
R&M Engineering E&T Strategy
Capture/Define R&M Engineering Tasks and Associated Roles
Define R&M Engineering Competencies For Associated Roles (incl. KSAs)
Define R&M Engineering Learning Architecture (e.g. CLMs, SPRDE/SE Courses & R&M Competencies
Integration, Dedicated R&M Courses)
Develop and Deliver Training
R&M Engineering08/16/11 Page 12
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A: Cleared for Public Release by OSR on 8/04/11; SR Case # 11-S-3228 applies
Summary
• Actively engaged on all Focus Areas to improve “Technical Health” of R&M Engineering
• Institutionalizing the process across the Services• Collaborating with other functionals (e.g., test, logistics …)• DTM implementation will:
– Not burden the programs with unreasonable expectations– Not drive a “One Size Fit All Solution” on programs
– Smartly apply engineering activities based on acquisition strategy & life cycle position