24
Dinero Diablos” Dinero Diablos” Portfolio Analysis: Portfolio Analysis: Dashboard Diagnostics Dashboard Diagnostics April 21, 2010 Presented by: Mark Robertson Founder and Managing Partner – www.manifestinvesting.com

“Dinero Diablos” Portfolio Analysis: Dashboard Diagnostics April 21, 2010 Presented by: Mark Robertson Founder and Managing Partner –

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

““Dinero Diablos”Dinero Diablos”

Portfolio Analysis: Dashboard Diagnostics Portfolio Analysis: Dashboard Diagnostics

April 21, 2010

Presented by:

Mark RobertsonFounder and Managing Partner –

www.manifestinvesting.com

2

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Club History & CharacteristicsClub History & Characteristics

Club Name: “Dinero Diablos”

Location: Northern California

# of Members: 16 (All-Male)

Founded: TBD

The club uses a set of rules for selling: (1) Sell Zone, (2) Sales/EPS stagnant 3-4 quarters, (3) U/D = 1,

(4) Relative Value > 150%, (5) <5-7% Total Return, (6) Down trends in margins, (7) Stock

price decline for no apparent reason.

Simplify. Treat decisions from a total portfolio perspective. Core holdings: Sell if PAR is less than money market rates. Non-Core holdings: Sell if PAR is less than market average.

3

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90

Quality

3% 5% 7% 9% 11% 13% 15%

Sales Growth

0% 5% 10% 15% 20%

PAR

Dashboard View: (1) Returns, (2) Quality, (3) GrowthDashboard View: (1) Returns, (2) Quality, (3) Growth

4

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Sector Diversification

Cash3%Energy

7%Staples

6%

Communications6%

Discretionary17%

Technology7%

Industrials11%

Financials

Healthcare40%

5

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

6

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

Number of Holdings (Stocks)

% o

f T

ota

l A

sset

s

Position Size Range Recommendations …Position Size Range Recommendations …

7

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

8

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Challenge: EZCORP (EZPW) ... Auto-Sell?Challenge: EZCORP (EZPW) ... Auto-Sell?

9

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Summary (Points of View): EZCORP (EZPW) Summary (Points of View): EZCORP (EZPW) MANIFEST Value Line S&P Morningstar

Return Forecast 1.6% ($22.70) -1% [1] ($17.75)

Quality 59.3 B

Financial Strength

57 (5% of Capital @

6.22%)

B++ A

Growth Forecast 14% 8.5% (per sh)

Profitability 11.9% (Net)

14.6% (ROE)

12.9% (Net)

Valuation 10.0x 10.0x 10.7x ($17.70)

Overall Rating Weak Hold (48)

StockCharts RSI = 65.9 PnF Sentiment: “Bullish” (Price Objective: $24) CASPI = 97.8% April 21, 2010

[1] – Low VL 3-5 Year Forecast

StockCharts RSI = 65.9 PnF Sentiment: “Bullish” (Price Objective: $24) CASPI = 97.8% April 21, 2010

[1] – Low VL 3-5 Year Forecast

10

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Sales Growth & 5-Year Forecast (EZPW)Sales Growth & 5-Year Forecast (EZPW)

1. We’ve added 2010E and 2011E (ACE). 2. Note the “bends”, lower expectations for 2011 ... Cycle characteristics? 3. Note the

shift in shares outstanding in 2009.

11

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Sales Growth & 5-Year Forecast (EZPW)Sales Growth & 5-Year Forecast (EZPW)

1. Switching to Sales/share. 2. 5-Year historical growth aligns with VL. 3. VL forecasts a decline to 8.5% (influence of 2011?)

12

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

0%

5%

10%

15%

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

% Net Margin

Profitability ‘Report Card’ and Forecast (EZPW)Profitability ‘Report Card’ and Forecast (EZPW)

13

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Profitability ‘Report Card’ and Forecast (EZPW)Profitability ‘Report Card’ and Forecast (EZPW)

14

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Valuation Characteristic and Trend (EZPW)Valuation Characteristic and Trend (EZPW)

A projected average P/E in the realm of 10x seems pretty reasonable.

10 Years

5 Years

15

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

[Modified] Preferred Procedure (EZPW)[Modified] Preferred Procedure (EZPW)

Sales (Trailing 12-Mo) 673

X Net Margin (%) 11.9%

/ Shares (M) 48.7

Earnings Per Share $1.65

X P/E Ratio 13.8x

Stock Price (4/20/2010) $22.70

Income Statement (4/21/2010)

Income Statement (4/21/2015)

Sales 1268

X Net Margin (%) 12%

/ Shares (M) 52.0

Earnings Per Share $2.93

X P/E Ratio (Proj Avg) 10.0x

Stock Price $29.30

@ 13.5%

5.2%

+ 0.0% (Ann. Yield)

5.2% = Projected Annual Return (PAR)

16

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Technical Analysis (EZPW)Technical Analysis (EZPW)

Institutions hold 78.9% of shares

A single individual holds 100% of voting shares.

17

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Ask the Audience: Would you sell EZPW?Ask the Audience: Would you sell EZPW?

Yes, Sell!Yes, Sell!

No. Hold, I feel lots of No. Hold, I feel lots of momentum with this one.momentum with this one.

18

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Any holdings qualified as accumulation targets?Any holdings qualified as accumulation targets?

19

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Accumulation Candidate: FTI Consulting (FCN)Accumulation Candidate: FTI Consulting (FCN)

Growth=11% Profitability=10% P/E=18x ... PAR ~20% QR=74.7

20

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Accumulation Candidate: ITT Educational (ESI)Accumulation Candidate: ITT Educational (ESI)

Growth=16% Profitability=21% P/E=17x ... PAR ~19% QR=78.5

21

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Add 100 shares of FCN and 40 shares of ESI ...Add 100 shares of FCN and 40 shares of ESI ...

22

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

23

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Sold EZPW, Added ESI & FCN ... And Bought ORCLSold EZPW, Added ESI & FCN ... And Bought ORCL

24

Dashboard Diagnostics: Dinero DiablosDashboard Diagnostics: Dinero Diablos

Think Results. Impact. Before and After. Bigger Picture.Think Results. Impact. Before and After. Bigger Picture.

Before. After.

Converting the challenge stock to cash and accumulating a couple of high-return (high-quality) holdings with some non-healthcare

shopping nudges the portfolio in the right direction.