1
excluded because they were sent for a medical or ophthalmic con- dition requiring a dilated fundus examination (Diabetes, JRA, Neuro- fibromatosis, Glaucoma, Trauma). Results: Of 190 patients analyzed, cycloplegic examination provided additional information in only 4 patients, 2 preverbal children, 1 with non-visually significant congenital cataract \1mm, one with refrac- tive amblyopia from moderate astigmatism, 1 child with moderate hy- peropia who was put into glasses because parents noted esotropia and was later found to have AET and 1 child with increased cupping but normal IOP. Although now being examined yearly, this patient is felt unlikely to have glaucoma. Discussion: A normal plusoptiX, combined with normal alignment/ motility evaluation and visual acuity was found to have a 98% nega- tive predictive value for ophthalmic pathology including significant refractive error. Conclusions: Dilating drops are traumatic for many children. The plu- soptiX and an abbreviated eye examination may obviate the need for dilation in select children. 031 Comparison of inferior oblique myectomy to recession for the treatment of superior oblique palsy. Elias I. Traboulsi, Reecha Sachdeva, Paul Rychwalski, Andreas Marcotty Purpose: To compare inferior oblique (IO) myectomy to recession for the treatment of superior oblique (SO) palsy. Methods: A retrospective chart review identified all patients with SO palsy who underwent IO weakening procedures. Patients were ex- cluded if IO muscle surgery was combined with other vertical muscle surgery and if follow up was less than 4 weeks. Good outcome pa- rameters were: improvement of deviation in primary gaze, resolution of diplopia in primary and reading gazes, and correction of head tilt to the contralateral side. We analyzed subsets of subjects with large preoperative vertical deviations (.20 D ) and those with small to mod- erate deviations ( \20 D ). Comparisons were made using Wilcoxon rank sum and the Fisher exact tests. Results: Eighty-seven eyes of 86 patients met the study criteria. Forty-five eyes underwent myectomy, and 42 underwent recession of the IO. Those patients who underwent myectomy compared to re- cession had less postoperative hypertropia (HT) in primary gaze (P 5 0.002) and were more likely to meet criteria for success as measured by #4 D residual HT (P 5 0.056). This difference was pronounced (P 5 0.005) in patients with preoperative small to moderate deviations, but statistical significance was lost in patients with large preopera- tive deviations. There was no difference between the two groups with respect to resolution of diplopia or anomalous head tilt. Discussion: IO weakening is effective in the treatment of SO palsy. Our findings support myectomy as more effective than recession in improving HT in primary gaze independent of preoperative measure- ments; this difference is more pronounced in individuals with small to moderate preoperative hyperdeviations. Conclusions: Simple inferior oblique myectomy is an excellent surgi- cal modality for the management of patients with SO palsy and mild to moderate vertical deviations. 032 Development and validation of a standardised tool for the reporting of retinal findings in abusive head trauma. Patrick Watts, Wai S. Ng, Zoe Lawson, Alison Kemp, Sabine Maguire Purpose: To develop and validate a robust standardized reporting tool for describing retinal findings in children with suspected abusive head trauma (AHT). Methods: Seven pediatric ophthalmologists and seven residents as- sessed a series of 105 high quality Retcam images of 21 eyes from AHT cases with varying degrees of retinal hemorrhage and associ- ated findings. The pediatric ophthalmologists performed repeated assessments of the randomized images. The images were observed simultaneously with standardized display settings. Retinal findings were recorded on a predefined assessment proforma, derived from the results of a recent systematic review of retinal findings in AHT. Inter and intra-observer variability were assessed by Free-Marginal Multi-rater Kappa (FMK), Intra-class Correlation Coefficient (ICC) and Concordance Coefficient (CC). Results: Almost perfect inter-observer agreement was observed for residents and pediatric ophthalmologists in assessing the presence and number of fundus haemorrhages (ICC 0.912 and 0.866). Both groups achieved very high inter-observer agreement for location of hemorrhages (CC 0.860 [0.769-0.950], 0.849 [0.743-0.955]). Substantial agreement was observed by both in assessing size of hemorrhage (CC 0.732 [0.640-0.824], 0.762 [0.669-0.854]), moderate agreement for hemorrhage morphology (CC 0.532 [0.485-0.579], 0.521 [0.451-0.592]) and other findings (CC 0.480 [0.419-0.541], 0.594 [0.497-0.691]). Intra- observer agreement for pediatric ophthalmologists was almost perfect (Free-marginal kappa 0.90-1.00) for presence of fundus hae- morrhage. Discussion: We have developed and validated a standardized, clini- cal reporting tool for ophthalmic findings in suspected AHT, which has excellent inter and intra-observer agreement among consultant specialists and trainees Conclusions: We suggest that the use of this tool will improve clinical reporting in AHT. 033 Objective detection of amblyopia and strabismus . . . not just screening for risk factors. Susan E. Yanni, Reed M. Jost, Cynthia L. Beauchamp, David R. Stager, Sr., Eileen E. Birch Background: To date, preschool vision screening for strabismus and/ or amblyopia involves assessment of risk factors, including refractive error and stereoacuity. Most children who are positive for risk fac- tors never develop strabismus or amblyopia. The Pediatric Vision Scanner (PVS) is the first objective, automated screening device that directly assesses bifoveal fixation. This study was undertaken to assess the ability of the PVS to identify patients with strabismus and/or amblyopia in a pediatric ophthalmology office setting. Methods: A total of 114 children (2-6 years) were tested with the PVS, which produced a pass, refer right eye, refer left eye, or refer bilat- eral recommendation. Children were also tested with the SureSight Vision Screener and the Randot Preschool Stereoacuity Test (RPST). A comprehensive pediatric ophthalmic examination served as the gold-standard. Results: 59 of 114 children had strabismus and/or amblyopia. Sensi- tivity of the PVS was 98% (95% CI, 90-100%), significantly higher than the SureSight (sensitivity 5 58%) and the RPST (sensitivity 5 73%). In this office setting, with high prevalence of strabismus and amblyopia, overall specificity was good and comparable among the 3 tests (74%- 88%). However, the SureSight had a significantly larger number of false positives due to refractive error than the PVS (13% vs 6%, P \ 0.04). Discussion: The PVS identified children with amblyopia or strabis- mus with high sensitivity, outperforming the SureSight and the RPST. Conclusions: Preschool vision screening may be more efficient with a device that directly identifies strabismus and amblyopia. The PVS provides rapid, accurate identification of children with amblyopia and/or strabismus early in life, when they are most amenable to treatment. Journal of AAPOS Volume 16 Number 1 / February 2012 e9

Development and validation of a standardised tool for the reporting of retinal findings in abusive head trauma

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Development and validation of a standardised tool for the reporting of retinal findings in abusive head trauma

Volume 16 Number 1 / February 2012 e9

excluded because they were sent for a medical or ophthalmic con-dition requiring a dilated fundus examination (Diabetes, JRA, Neuro-fibromatosis, Glaucoma, Trauma).Results: Of 190 patients analyzed, cycloplegic examination providedadditional information in only 4 patients, 2 preverbal children, 1 withnon-visually significant congenital cataract\1mm, one with refrac-tive amblyopia from moderate astigmatism, 1 child with moderate hy-peropia who was put into glasses because parents noted esotropiaand was later found to have AET and 1 child with increased cuppingbut normal IOP. Although now being examined yearly, this patient isfelt unlikely to have glaucoma.Discussion: A normal plusoptiX, combined with normal alignment/motility evaluation and visual acuity was found to have a 98% nega-tive predictive value for ophthalmic pathology including significantrefractive error.Conclusions: Dilating drops are traumatic for many children. The plu-soptiX and an abbreviated eye examination may obviate the need fordilation in select children.

031 Comparison of inferior oblique myectomy to recession for thetreatment of superior oblique palsy. Elias I. Traboulsi, ReechaSachdeva, Paul Rychwalski, Andreas MarcottyPurpose: To compare inferior oblique (IO) myectomy to recession forthe treatment of superior oblique (SO) palsy.Methods: A retrospective chart review identified all patients with SOpalsy who underwent IO weakening procedures. Patients were ex-cluded if IO muscle surgery was combined with other vertical musclesurgery and if follow up was less than 4 weeks. Good outcome pa-rameters were: improvement of deviation in primary gaze, resolutionof diplopia in primary and reading gazes, and correction of head tilt tothe contralateral side. We analyzed subsets of subjects with largepreoperative vertical deviations (.20D) and those with small to mod-erate deviations (\20D). Comparisons were made using Wilcoxonrank sum and the Fisher exact tests.Results: Eighty-seven eyes of 86 patients met the study criteria.Forty-five eyes underwent myectomy, and 42 underwent recessionof the IO. Those patients who underwent myectomy compared to re-cession had less postoperative hypertropia (HT) in primary gaze (P50.002) and were more likely to meet criteria for success as measuredby #4D residual HT (P 5 0.056). This difference was pronounced (P5 0.005) in patients with preoperative small to moderate deviations,but statistical significance was lost in patients with large preopera-tive deviations. There was no difference between the two groupswith respect to resolution of diplopia or anomalous head tilt.Discussion: IO weakening is effective in the treatment of SO palsy.Our findings support myectomy as more effective than recession inimproving HT in primary gaze independent of preoperative measure-ments; this difference is more pronounced in individuals with small tomoderate preoperative hyperdeviations.Conclusions: Simple inferior oblique myectomy is an excellent surgi-cal modality for the management of patients with SO palsy andmild tomoderate vertical deviations.

032 Development and validation of a standardised tool for thereporting of retinal findings in abusive head trauma. PatrickWatts, Wai S. Ng, Zoe Lawson, Alison Kemp, Sabine MaguirePurpose: To develop and validate a robust standardized reporting toolfor describing retinal findings in children with suspected abusivehead trauma (AHT).Methods: Seven pediatric ophthalmologists and seven residents as-sessed a series of 105 high quality Retcam images of 21 eyes from

Journal of AAPOS

AHT cases with varying degrees of retinal hemorrhage and associ-ated findings. The pediatric ophthalmologists performed repeatedassessments of the randomized images. The images were observedsimultaneously with standardized display settings. Retinal findingswere recorded on a predefined assessment proforma, derived fromthe results of a recent systematic review of retinal findings in AHT.Inter and intra-observer variability were assessed by Free-MarginalMulti-rater Kappa (FMK), Intra-class Correlation Coefficient (ICC) andConcordance Coefficient (CC).Results: Almost perfect inter-observer agreement was observed forresidents and pediatric ophthalmologists in assessing the presenceand number of fundus haemorrhages (ICC 0.912 and 0.866). Bothgroups achieved very high inter-observer agreement for location ofhemorrhages (CC 0.860 [0.769-0.950], 0.849 [0.743-0.955]). Substantialagreement was observed by both in assessing size of hemorrhage(CC 0.732 [0.640-0.824], 0.762 [0.669-0.854]), moderate agreement forhemorrhage morphology (CC 0.532 [0.485-0.579], 0.521 [0.451-0.592])and other findings (CC 0.480 [0.419-0.541], 0.594 [0.497-0.691]). Intra-observer agreement for pediatric ophthalmologists was almostperfect (Free-marginal kappa 0.90-1.00) for presence of fundus hae-morrhage.Discussion: We have developed and validated a standardized, clini-cal reporting tool for ophthalmic findings in suspected AHT, whichhas excellent inter and intra-observer agreement among consultantspecialists and traineesConclusions:We suggest that the use of this tool will improve clinicalreporting in AHT.

033 Objective detection of amblyopia and strabismus . . . not justscreening for risk factors. Susan E. Yanni, Reed M. Jost, Cynthia L.Beauchamp, David R. Stager, Sr., Eileen E. BirchBackground: To date, preschool vision screening for strabismus and/or amblyopia involves assessment of risk factors, including refractiveerror and stereoacuity. Most children who are positive for risk fac-tors never develop strabismus or amblyopia. The Pediatric VisionScanner (PVS) is the first objective, automated screening devicethat directly assesses bifoveal fixation. This study was undertakento assess the ability of the PVS to identify patients with strabismusand/or amblyopia in a pediatric ophthalmology office setting.Methods: A total of 114 children (2-6 years) were tested with the PVS,which produced a pass, refer right eye, refer left eye, or refer bilat-eral recommendation. Children were also tested with the SureSightVision Screener and the Randot Preschool Stereoacuity Test(RPST). A comprehensive pediatric ophthalmic examination servedas the gold-standard.Results: 59 of 114 children had strabismus and/or amblyopia. Sensi-tivity of the PVS was 98% (95% CI, 90-100%), significantly higher thanthe SureSight (sensitivity5 58%) and the RPST (sensitivity5 73%). Inthis office setting, with high prevalence of strabismus and amblyopia,overall specificity was good and comparable among the 3 tests (74%-88%). However, the SureSight had a significantly larger number offalse positives due to refractive error than the PVS (13% vs 6%, P\ 0.04).Discussion: The PVS identified children with amblyopia or strabis-mus with high sensitivity, outperforming the SureSight and the RPST.Conclusions: Preschool vision screening may be more efficient witha device that directly identifies strabismus and amblyopia. The PVSprovides rapid, accurate identification of children with amblyopiaand/or strabismus early in life, when they are most amenable totreatment.