Upload
others
View
9
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ISSN: 0973-4945; CODEN ECJHAO
E-Journal of Chemistry
http://www.e-journals.net 2010, 7(1), 93-100
Developing Optimal Combination of Bulking Agents
in an In-Vessel Composting of Vegetable Waste
C. C. MONSON* and A. MURUGAPPAN
Department of Civil Engineering,
Annamalai University,
Annamalainagar, Tamilnadu, India.
Received 16 May 2009; Revised 19 July 2009; Accepted 26 August 2009
Abstract: The objective of the study is to determine the optimum combination
of feed stock components for composting the organic solid waste, a
prerequisite for effective microbial degradation and for obtaining quality
compost. Combination of dry leaves with locally available bulking agents like
sawdust, wood shavings, paddy straw, sugarcane bagasse and rice husk are
composted along with vegetable waste in a laboratory scale reactor for the
study. The central core of composting process is replicated in controlled
conditions in the in-vessel by keeping initial feed stock C/N ratio fixed
between 30 and 35. The study is monitored for 14 days for the variations in
temperature, pH, moisture and macronutrients C and N of the compost. It is
found that composting vegetable waste with the combination of paddy straw
and dry leaves provided best results of C/N ratio of 17.58 confirming that, if
right feedstock components are provided, an effective environment for the
growth of microorganisms is achieved to accelerate the process to produce a
resultant C/N ratio acceptable to be used as compost.
Keywords: Municipal Solid Waste, Aerobic composting, Bulking agents, In-vessel composting.
Introduction
Population upsurge, due to rapid industrialization in Indian cities, has led to the generation
of thousands of tonnes of municipal solid waste (MSW) daily that are disposed in low-lying
areas, without taking any precautions or operational controls. Therefore, Municipal Solid
Waste Management (MSWM) has become one of the major environmental problems for all
Indian cities that manage the activities associated with generation, storage, collection,
transport, processing and disposal of solid wastes1.
94 C. C. MONSON et al.
The collection and land disposal of solid wastes has become more and more difficult for
many municipalities, not only because of the increasing rate of daily per capita waste
generation2 from 0.2 to 0.6 kg day
-1, but also due to the steadily increasing cost of land and
its shortage in city outskirts3. Though, the recycling of MSW has been started to a large
extent in developing countries like India, it remains still in its infant stage compared to the
developed countries such as U.S.A, European countries and Japan4. Solid waste which is
usually disposed as landfills pollute the soil, groundwater by its leachates and also by the
gases evolved during decomposition, whereas the atmosphere gets directly polluted by the
release of green house gases due to incineration of the solid wastes5, 6
.
It has been found approximately that 134 kg/ha nutrients are exhausted every year in
India from the soil due to the raising of different crops but the amount of input (N, P and K)
to the soil is only 74 kg/ha by chemical fertilizers. The net result is that the soil is regularly
being depleted of these essential nutrient elements on a continuous basis. Composting of
degradable solid wastes not only addresses the problem of MSWM but also results in quality
end products that have high fertility value7.
Centralized Composting in windrows using forced aeration or turning or by passive
aeration could be a good alternative where land is available in plenty, even though it
involves large investments8
but for managing large quantities of organic solid wastes,
decentralized composting is the only eco-friendly option as it provides an efficient and
economical way of disposal. The development of In-vessel technique is found to be a better
alternative for decentralized units as this rotary vessel provides oxygen and nutrients in
controlled atmosphere and also hastens the process within 2 to 3 weeks to degrade the
organic waste fraction of MSW9.
Composting process
Composting is the biological decomposition of wastes consisting of organic substances of
plant or animal origin under controlled conditions to a state sufficiently stable for
nuisance-free storage and utilization10,11
.To produce high quality compost, it becomes
essential to optimize, from the start to the end of the whole process by managing the feed
components and also the process parameters like temperature, moisture content, bulk
density, aeration rates and C/N ratio12
. For proper microbial degradation, the initial C/N
ratio has to be kept in between13
40 to 20. Carbon serves primarily as a food source and
Nitrogen the primary constituent of protein. To bring to an optimum C/N ratio nearer to
30-35, bulking agents like saw dust, wood shavings, sugar cane bagasse, dry leaves, paddy
straw, paddy husk may be added as an amendment, as they give enough carbon source and
also reduce the excess moisture content, increasing the porosity and integrity of the
organic solid matrix.
To assure proper rate of biodegradation, moisture should be in the range of 50% to 70%
throughout the degradation process. If excess moisture is found, it reduces the available
oxygen supply, resulting in anaerobic pockets within the compost, releasing odorous
compounds. Air is to be supplied in order to provide oxygen facilitating the growth of
microorganisms and also to drive away the hot gases14
.
The temperature of the substrate within the reactor varies according to the type and size
of the microorganism community resident therein. The mesophilic microorganisms that are
present become less competitive as the temperature rises above 40 °C, and thermophilic
microorganisms take over. Current Environmental Protection Agency regulations require
temperatures in excess of 55 °C (131° F) for at least four hours to destroy pathogens within
Developing Optimal Combination of Bulking Agents 95
the composting reactor15
. Sanitization of the composting process is achieved by the
thermophilic temperatures which kill many of the pathogens that may be initially present in
the mixture. Optimum air and moisture contents are also necessary in sustaining adequate
microbial populations active15
. Carbohydrates are structurally simplest and degrade faster
than others and they do in the following order: Carbohydrates > hemi-cellulose > cellulose
> chitin > lignin. Thus, materials such as fruit and vegetables with higher concentrations of
simple carbohydrates are more rapidly compostable than leaves, bark and wood which
contain cellulose, hemi-cellulose and lignin16
. Composting systems which generally used
worldwide are: Naturally aerated windrow system, Forced aerated static piles, Tunnel
system and Rotating drums or cylinders (in-vessel systems).
Of all the above mentioned methods, the most adaptable to Indian conditions is the
closed in-vessel composting, which generally derives the techniques both from the windrow
and aerated pile methods and is a combined effort in a controlled atmosphere to overcome
the deficiencies and problems encountered by them to convert the entire organic solid waste
with suitable amendments of organic manure within a short duration17
Donahue et al18
demonstrated that food waste was successfully composted with saw dust and mulch chips in
an In-vessel system within 14 days, after which the product was placed in windrows for
curing. If the reactor performance does not meet the desired stability required for compost
then the partially stabilized material may be required to be further cured in windrows to
achieve maturity14
. Bulking agents are provided in order to have stability, integrity and
porosity to the solid matrix during the process of composting. Composting of vegetable solid
waste, with cow dung and different combinations of bulking agents were carried out in an
in-vessel so that an optimal combination of bulking agents with vegetable market waste is
found out during composting to produce a quality end product.
Experimental
The waste sample was collected from the waste generated from the main vegetable market
of Chidambaram, located at the centre of the town, which contributes a major share of
nearly 10-15 tonnes of organic waste out of the total daily generation of 32-39 tones of
MSW from the entire town. The characteristics of the waste were found to vary from
season to season. Physical and chemical characteristics of vegetable wastes and bulking
agents used in the study were determined. The bulk density and the moisture content of
vegetable wastes range about 300 – 400 kg/m3
and 70% - 80% respectively. The monthly
variations of the vegetable waste were significant with respect to their moisture content and
their C/N ratios. The C on a dry weight basis (dwb) was found to vary during April to
November. The mean monthly C of 36.3% (±0.77%) in May was higher than that of June,
July and August at 32.4% (±4.05%). The TKN (dwb) of 0.9% (±0.11%) in May also
increased to 1.4% (±0.30%) than in June, July and August. Thus, the C/N ratio was found
to decrease from 36.4 in May to 32.4 in June. The C/N ratio of vegetable waste in the
summer (April–August) is balanced enough to be composted without any correction from
the bulking agent, while that of May is slightly high compared to the recommended C/N
ratio of 30–35 for the effective composting of vegetable waste2. The experiment was
carried out in the month of June to get the optimum result.
The moisture content of the waste collected was relatively high due to vegetables and it
was sorted manually to ensure that it contained no oversized and undesirable materials. The
waste then was shredded manually to a size of 20-30 mm to give a better exposure for
microbial treatment and to expedite the ensuing metabolic process. The main function of the
96 C. C. MONSON et al.
bulking agents is to increase the proportion of free airspace and to assist in providing
optimum moisture content, besides satisfying the feedstock requirements before
composting. Carbon which plays an important role in Nitrogen immobilization is provided
in plenty through these bulking agents as microbes waste nearly19
from 60% to 70% of the
C as CO2. Bulk density should be low enough (less than 40 lb/ft3) to allow for good
aeration. Dense manures and sludge can be lightened by adding bulking agents, such as
wood chips, corn cobs, and straw20
. Using sawdust and bagasse as bulking agents, pH
profile rose from 5.5 to 6.8 within two weeks, whereas in that using cassava pulp dropped
down towards the end of the experiment21
. Bulking agents which are locally available in
plenty almost in all seasons and having low bulk density and high moisture absorbing
capacity namely, leaves, saw dust, bagasse, wood shavings, rice husk and paddy straw
were used in this study.
Six trials of composting vegetable solid waste and cow dung were carried out with the
following combinations of bulking agents provided in order to have stability, integrity and porosity
to the solid matrix during composting. These trial combinations were Mix-1 (Control without any
bulking agents), paddy straw and dry leaves in Mix-2, wood shavings and dry leaves in Mix-3,
bagasse and dry leaves in Mix-4, rice husk and dry leaves in Mix-5 and saw dust and dry leaves in
Mix-6. The mix combinations with different bulking agents are given in the Table 1.
Table 1. Bulking agents in different mix combinations.
Mix ratio
Materials* Mix-1
(Control) Mix-2 Mix-3 Mix-4 Mix-5 Mix-6
Vegetable waste:
Cow dung :
Bulking agents
5.32:1.05:0 5.20:1.14:1 5.91:1.17:1 5.04:1.04:1 5.54:0.85:1 4.93:1.06:1
Mix-1: Without any bulking agent; Mix-2: Paddy straw and dry leaves; Mix-3: Wood shavings and dry leaves
Mix-4: Bagasse and dry leaves; Mix-5: Rice husk and dry leaves; Mix-6: Saw dust and dry leaves. *The above ratios are by wet weight basis
The combination of dry leaves mainly of nettilingam tree, known in its botanical
name as Polyalthia longifolia from the family of Annaonaceae, was added with other
bulking agents as they were found in plenty, good in moisture absorbance and provides
good free air space at the initial stages. Cow dung was added to serve as inoculum for the
start up of the process in each trial as well as to bring the feedstock C/N ratio within the
acceptable range. The bulking agents selected are high in moisture absorbance (75%-
85%)14
; have a pH value ranging between 4.5 and 7.5. The resultant pH value of al the
mixes tried were in the range of 5.5-7.5. It was found that the saw dust had a higher C/N
ratio than that of the other bulking agents, which had to be supplemented with selected
higher nitrogen content materials. The moisture content was found to be balanced at a
range of 60-70% at the start of the trials and could be added in the course of composting
if it goes below 50%.
The laboratory scale bio-reactor fabricated was a cylindrical vessel used for the bio
conversion of the wastes. It had a Fibre Reinforced Plastic (FRP) drum of capacity of 50
litres with vinyl ester resin material coat given on the inside surface to take care of the load
intensity, as well as the temperature and chemical changes taking place at the time of the
waste conversion process. The airflow was regulated to achieve the required flow so that
optimal quantity of air was supplied to degrade the substrate. The process was totally self
heating, and air was supplied by an aerator at the rate of 10 L/min initially to cater to the
Developing Optimal Combination of Bulking Agents 97
volume of substrate inside the drum and decreased progressively up to the curing stage so that
a minimum of 5% of oxygen is maintained in the substrate for the growth of
microorganisms10,11
. The vessel was belt driven at a slow speed of about 3 rpm, with a 0.5 HP
motor facilitated by a reduction wheel pulley arrangement. The rotation was given for every
three hours with an hour break for rest and even distribution of microbial aerobic organisms.
However the air flow was maintained continuous throughout the period. Even when a highly
putrescible waste is processed using a fairly effective aeration system, a minimum of 12–14
days of active composting time is necessary for a relatively short residence time in the bio-
reactor10, 11
. Composting was carried out for 14 days and brought to an end when temperature
declined close to ambient. Simultaneously physical investigation was carried out, taking a
sample of 100 gm of waste every two days to find its degree of maturity.
Currently, indirect measures for determining the concentration of biodegradable organic
matter are used and most of them are based on respiration indices (oxygen consumption or
carbon dioxide production) but the direct measurement of chemical parameters Total
Organic Carbon (TOC) and Total Kjeldhal Nitrogen (TKN) will be useful in better
prediction of the rate of degradation19
. The initial feedstock components of the trial mixes
were optimized to have a C/N ratio around 35 for effective growth of microorganisms.
The pH had to be adjusted in Mix-3 (wood shavings and dry leaves as bulking agents)
by adding little bit of lime to neutralize, when it had gone very low during the process to
prevent the slowdown of the process. The drying up of moisture content during the 4th
and
5th
day in most of the trials due to the constant air flow had to be reduced progressively to
maintain the temperature and the moisture content had been supplemented for ensuring the
growth of microorganisms.
The moisture content of the trial mix samples were measured after drying at 105 °C for
overnight. The dried sample were ground and then used in the analysis. The Volatile Solids
(VS) was measured after igniting the sample in a muffle furnace at 550 °C for 2 hours. Total
Organic Carbon (TOC) was calculated by the formula19,14
TOC=(100% Ash)/1.8. Total
Kjeldahl Nitrogen (TKN) was measured by semi-micro and macro Kjeldahl method22
.
Moisture content, temperature, pH and Electrical Conductivity were measured using the
multipronged probe of Hitachi make.
Results and Discussion
Substrate temperature is one of the main parameters to ensure effective composting. Figure 1
shows the variation of substrate temperature with time duration since the commencement of
composting process for different trial mixes considered in the study. The temperature of the
substrate at the beginning of the composting process in all mixes was in the range 34.5 to 37.5 ºC.
From Figure 1, it is found that the temperature of the substrate has a rapidly increasing trend
during the first 3 days for all mixes except mix-1. In case of mix-1, the rise in temperature is
relatively very gradual. This could be attributed to the lack of free air space because of less
porosity. The peak temperature was attained at the end of the third day for all mixes except mix-6
and mix-1. In case of mix-6, the maximum temperature was attained at the end of the fourth day,
while in mix-1 the maximum temperature was attained at the end of the sixth day from the
commencement of composting. Of all the mixes, mix-2 attained the maximum temperature of
63.5 ºC at the end of the third day. The maximum temperatures attained by mix-3 were also
comparable to that of mix-2 at 61 ºC. Maximum temperatures of 58.5, 56.5, and 58.5 ºC were
attained respectively in case of mix-4, mix-5 and mix-6. The maximum temperature attained by
mix-1 was much lower at 42 ºC when compared to those obtained by other mixes.
98 C. C. MONSON et al.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Mix-1
Mix-2
Mix-3
Mix-4
Mix-5
Mix-6
Figure 1. Variation of substrate temperature.
The mix-1 had not crossed the mesophilic range of temperature because of its initial
higher bulk density and lower porosity13
. After reaching the peak temperature, the substrate
temperature started to fall for all mixes with the rate of fall found to be less than the rate of
increase in temperature in all mixes except mix-3. In mix-2 and mix-3, the falling
temperature was found to be above 55º C till the end of the sixth day after the
commencement of composting. These two mixes satisfy the conditions laid out by USEPA15
guidelines for quality compost. While in mixes 4, 5 and 6, the substrate temperature fell
below 55 ºC after the end of the fourth day/third day.
Chopped paddy straw and dry leaves used as bulking agents in mix-2 have a high water
absorption capacity of more than 80 per cent, neutral pH and moderate C/N ratio5,6
of about 50.
At the end of 14 days of composting process, the C/N ratio of mix 2 reduced to 17.58 while
C/N ratios of 19.35, 22.08, 22.21, 26.98 and 29.49 were attained for mixes 3, 5, 4, 6 and 1
respectively. The bulking agents wood shavings and dry leaves used in mix-3, even though
were found to be acidic5,6
and showed a lack of stability after absorbing moisture at the initial
stage had produced a C/N ratio of 19.35 because of addition of lime. Bagasse and dry leaves
used as bulking agents in mix-4, even though were found to provide structural stability in the
initial stage of composting after absorbing moisture did not produce the required reduction in
C/N ratio. This could be attributed to the higher lignin content in bagasse which takes a longer
duration for bio-degradation and less nitrogen content23
. Rice husk used as bulking agent in
mix-5 did not provide adequate porosity and hence resulted in C/N ratio of 22.08. In case of
saw dust used in mix-6, the free air space required for effective degradation of waste was not
adequate due to absorption of moisture. This resulted in slow down of biological activity and
resulted in a high C/N ratio of 26.98 at the end of fourteen days of composting. Linear
equations were fitted to the reduction in C/N ratio with respect to time duration for the
different trial mixes of composting. The results are shown in Table 2.
Time, days
Tem
per
atu
re,
oC
Developing Optimal Combination of Bulking Agents 99
Table 2. Linear equation fitted to reduction in C/N ratio with time duration for different
mixes of composting
Mixes of composting Linear Equation fitted R-squared
value
Mix-1 (Without any Bulking agents-Control) C/N = -0.463(td) + 34.83 0.903
Mix-2 (Paddy straw and Dry leaves) C/N = -1.134 (td) + 34.52 0.989
Mix-3 (Wood shavings and Dry leaves) C/N = -1.152 (td) + 36.60 0.964
Mix-4 (Bagasse and Dry leaves) C/N = -0.890(td) + 33.83 0.935
Mix-5 (Rice husk and Dry leaves) C/N = -0.962(td) + 35.58 0.988
Mix-6 (Saw dust and Dry leaves) C/N= - 0.671 (td) + 36.86 0.983
The rate of reduction in C/N ratio which is indicative of the rate of decomposition of the
waste is found to be maximum for Mix-3. But, the variation in the rate of reduction in C/N
ratio between the two mixes, Mix-2 and Mix-3, was not much and that they can be
considered insufficient. Hence, the ranking of mixes in terms of rate of reduction of C/N
ratio indicated by the slope of the fitted linear equation is in the order: Mix-3 < Mix-2 <
Mix-5 < Mix-4 < Mix-6 < Mix-1. However, the maximum reduction of C/N ratio occurred
in case of Mix-2 (Figure 2). Low C/N ratio ensures effective organic matter decomposition
and stabilization during composting. The ranking of mixes according to the total reduction in
C/N ratio is found to be in the order: Mix-2 < Mix-3 < Mix-5 < Mix-4 < Mix-6 < Mix-1.
Hence, it is concluded that paddy straw and dry leaves are used as bulking agents (Mix-2) is
found to be the best combination in composting of vegetable waste.
Conclusion
The falling temperature after attaining peak temperature at the end of third day was found to
be above 55º C till the end of the sixth day after the commencement of composting for mixes
2 and 3. These two mixes satisfy the conditions laid out by USEPA15
guidelines for quality
compost. Composting of vegetable waste with the combination of paddy straw and dry
leaves has provided the maximum reduction in C/N ratio equal to 17.58 at the end of 14 days
of composting. This confirms that if right feedstock components are provided, an effective
environment for the growth of microorganisms is achieved to accelerate the process to
produce a resultant C/N ratio acceptable to be used as compost.
References
1 Mufeed Sharholy, Kafeel Ahmad, Gauhar Mahmood and Trivedi R C, Waste
Management, 2008, 28, 459-467.
2 CPHEEO, Manual on Municipal Solid Waste Management, GOI, New Delhi, 2000,
262-409
3 Michael Gundry, Chris Visser, Water Environment Association of Ontario 36th
Annual Technical Symposium, 2007. 4 Agarwal Ankit, Ashish Singhmar, Mukul Kulshrestha and Atul K Mittal, Resources,
Conservation and Recycling, 2005, 44, 73-90.
5 Adhikari Bijaya K, Barrington Suzelle, Jose Martinez and Susan King, Waste
Management, 2009, 29(1), 197-203, doi:10.1016/ j.wasman.2008.04.001.
6 Adhikari Bijaya K, Suzelle Barrington, Jose Martinez and Susan King, Waste
Management, 2008, 28, 795-804 7 Ghosh C, Biores Technol., 2004, 93, 71–75. 8 Salona M L, Iriarte F, Ciria P and Negro M J, J Agric Eng Res., 2001, 79(3), 317-329.
100 C. C. MONSON et al.
9 Kalamdhad Ajay, Absar S and Kasmi A, Waste Management and Research, 2009,
27, 129-137
10 Diaz L F, Savage G M, Eggerth L L and Golueke C G, Composting and Recycling
Municipal Solid Waste, Lewis Publishers, Inc., 1993. 11 Diaz L F, Savage G M, Eggerth L L and Golueke C G, Compost Science and
Technology, Lewis Publishers, Inc., 1993. 12 Mohee Romeela and Ackmez Mudhoo, Powder Technology, 2005, 155, 92-99.
13 Rynk R et al., On-Farm Composting Handbook, NRAES, Ithaca, NY, 1992.
14 Haug R T, The practical handbook of compost engineering, Lewis Publishers,
Florida, USA, 1993.
15 USEPA, Part503 Rule-Land Application of Biosolids, 1994, http://www.epa.gov/owm/
biosolids/503pe. 16 Cooperband L R, The Art and Science of Composting [online], 2002,
http://www.cias.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2008/07/artofcompost.pdf.
17 Mbuligwe S E, Kassenga G R, Kaseva M E and Chaggu E J, Resources, Conservation
and Recycling, 2002, 36, 45-59. 18 Donahue D W, Chalmers J A and Storey J A, Compost Science and Utilization, 1998,
6(2), 75-81. 19 Barrington S, Choiniere D, Trigui M and Knight W, Biosys Eng., 2002, 81(4), 433-441. 20 Dana O Porter, Utilization of Organic Wastes: On-farm Composting;
http://www.wvu.edu/~Agexten/ageng/resource/utiliow.htm.
21 Sudarut Tripetchkul, Chuenjit Kinganara and Pawinee Chaiprasert, The 5th
Asia-
Pacific Biochemical Engineering Conference and The 11th
Annual Meeting of the
Thai Society for Biotechnology, 1999.
22 APHA, Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater, 1995, Washington DC.
23 Eklind Y and Kirchmann H, Biores Technol., 2000, 74, 115-124.
Submit your manuscripts athttp://www.hindawi.com
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Inorganic ChemistryInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
International Journal ofPhotoenergy
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Carbohydrate Chemistry
International Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Journal of
Chemistry
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Advances in
Physical Chemistry
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com
Analytical Methods in Chemistry
Journal of
Volume 2014
Bioinorganic Chemistry and ApplicationsHindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
SpectroscopyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Medicinal ChemistryInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Chromatography Research International
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Applied ChemistryJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Theoretical ChemistryJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Journal of
Spectroscopy
Analytical ChemistryInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Quantum Chemistry
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Organic Chemistry International
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
CatalystsJournal of
ElectrochemistryInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014