29
DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF THE WATER RESOURCES OF ANDEAN CATCHMENTS (ECUADOR) Raúl F. Vázquez Z. & Henrietta Hampel University of Cuenca, Av. 12 de Abril S/N, Cuenca, Ecuador. R. Lelieveld, B. Fischer, N. Lam, S. Lyon University of Stockholm, Stockholm, Sweden.

DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF THE WATER

RESOURCES OF ANDEAN CATCHMENTS (ECUADOR)

Raúl F. Vázquez Z. & Henrietta HampelUniversity of Cuenca, Av. 12 de Abril S/N, Cuenca, Ecuador.

R. Lelieveld, B. Fischer, N. Lam, S. LyonUniversity of Stockholm, Stockholm, Sweden.

Page 2: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

LIST OF CONTENTS

1.- INTRODUCTION

2.- HYDROLOGICAL MODELLING OFANDEAN SYSTEMS: AN EXAMPLE

3.- QUESTIONS?

Page 3: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

WHY STUDYING WAT. RES.?

¿Water a granted good/service?

¿Is it in the right place and time ?

Page 4: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

WATER IN ECUADOR

Obvious increment of physical and human damages owing toextreme draughts and rain

Page 5: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

84

92

100

108

116

124

132

140

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010

Ener

gy c

onsu

mpt

ion

[TW

h]

GD

P pe

r cap

ita [U

S$ in

hab.

-1]

Year

GDP (OER)

Energy consumption

WATER IN ECUADOR

Page 6: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

SOCIETY AWARENESS& REQUEST

WATER IN ECUADOR

Page 7: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

LAB. ECOLOGÍA ACUÁTICA

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

75 100 125 150 175 200 225 250 275 300Número de pasos de tiempo

Cau

dal [

m3 s

-1]

Caudal (Zhurucay alto)Escorrentía (flujo rápido)Flujo subsuperficialFlujo lento

Page 8: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

LIST OF CONTENTS

1.- INTRODUCTION

2.- HYDROLOGICAL MODELLING OFANDEAN SYSTEMS: AN EXAMPLE

3.- QUESTIONS?

Page 9: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

MODELLING PROTOCOL

Page 10: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

• Is finding a (best fit) "only optimal parameter set"really valid in practice?

http://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/FS-121-97/

?MODEL CALIBRATION

Page 11: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

MODEL UNCERTAINTY

•DATA

•STRUCTURE•PARAMETER

uncertainty

uncertainty

•DATAuncertainty

Page 12: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

ST. CASE 2: RESULTS

Page 13: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

• Upgrading distribution function

MODEL UNCERTAINTY

Page 14: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

ST. CASE 2: RESULTS

IAG004 - distribución posterior (EF2>0.50)0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140Jul-08 Ago-08 Sep-08 Oct-08 Nov-08

Fecha

Lluv

ia [m

m]

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

Cau

dal [

m3 s

-1]

Banda predicción (90%) Lluvia Observaciones

Page 15: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

“MODELLING THE HYDROLOGY OF THE YANUNCAY SUBCATCHMENT, SOUTHERN

ECUADOR”

STUDY CASE

Page 16: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

YANUNCAY SUBCATCHMENT

Page 17: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

YAN: MAIN CARACTERISTICS

Average monthly precipitation over 21 years(1997-2018) and average monthlytemperature over 4 years (2014-2018).

Page 18: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

YAN: CLIMATE

Page 19: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

YAN: HBV - MODELLING

Page 20: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

YAN: HBV - MODELLING

Page 21: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

YAN: HBV CALIBRATION

Automatic calibration (single optimal model)

Page 22: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

YAN: HBV – PREDICTIONS

0.69 0.66

0.86

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

Yanuncay Pucán Soldados

EF2

[--]

Subsystem

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100Percentage of time that the discharge was equalled or exceed

10.0

1.0

0.1

Dis

char

ge [m

m d

-1]

YanuncaySoldadosPucán

Page 23: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

NAM CONCEPTUAL CODE

Page 24: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

CALIBRATION RESULTS

Page 25: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

CALIBRATION RESULTS

Page 26: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

CONCLUSSIONS

(i) Both conceptual structures seem to producesimilar predictions.

(ii) The scarcity of continuous information seems toplay the key role on the quality of the predictions.

(iii) Apparently, the model structures have moretrouble simulating the main reach than modellingthe tributaries (lower data uncertainty?).

(iv) There is a significant number of ongoing researchactivities that are aiming at better characterisingthese very important and sensible Andeansystems by using models. We hope to set upsome model tools that could be more or lessoperational in the future.

Page 27: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

LIST OF CONTENTS

1.- INTRODUCTION

2.- HYDROLOGICAL MODELLING OFANDEAN SYSTEMS: AN EXAMPLE

3.- QUESTIONS?

Page 28: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019

QUESTIONS?

THANKS very much !!

Page 29: DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE …...Flujo subsuperficial Flujo lento. IWA-IDB Conference @ Guayaquil Ecuador 01.10.2019. LIST OF CONTENTS. 1.- INTRODUCTION. 2.- HYDROLOGICAL

DEVELOPING HYDROLOGICAL MODELS FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF THE WATER

RESOURCES OF ANDEAN CATCHMENTS (ECUADOR)

Raúl F. Vázquez Z. & Henrietta HampelUniversity of Cuenca, Av. 12 de Abril S/N, Cuenca, Ecuador.

R. Lelieveld, B. Fischer, N. Lam, S. LyonUniversity of Stockholm, Stockholm, Sweden.