54
1 BERGEN – NORWAY June 12, 2012 Massimiliano Bandini GE Inspection Technologies Global Account Manager O&G Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D Probe,during the Inspection on Gas Turbine.

Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

1

BERGEN – NORWAY June 12, 2012

Massimiliano Bandini GE Inspection Technologies Global Account Manager O&G

Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D Probe,during the Inspection on Gas Turbine.

Page 2: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

2

Summary :

• Gas Turbine Cross Section • Gas Turbine Failure mode • Software for NDE (Rhythm) • Software MDI • 3D Probe (XLG3) • Corrosion pitting • Study MS5002C – R0 • Eddy Current on Rotor MS5002C • Gas Turbine Fleet in Norway

Page 3: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

3

Gas Turbine

Page 4: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

4

Isometric View Gas generator

RPM : 7455

Power Turbine RPM : 5714

Thick wall cast iron casing

(with horizontal split)

11 Stages Axial Compressor

6 DLN Can combustors

2 stages HP turbine

2 stages LP turbine

MS5002E Heavy Duty

Page 5: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

5

Where Gas Turbines used?

Pipeline Floating Production

Vessels

Platform

LNG Liquefaction LNG Re-gasification

Refinery

Co-generation

Power plant

Page 6: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

6

CROSS SECTIONAL

Page 7: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

7

ROTOR FAILURE MODE

Components :Blades & Buckets - FOREIGN OBJECT DAMAGE

- EROSION

- CORROSION

- RUBBING

- CRACKS

-DIRT BUILD-UP

-MISSING MATERIAL

-BENT LEAVES

How we can be prevent failure Inspection

Page 8: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

8

POTENTIAL FAILURE AREA

Page 9: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

9

TYPICAL FAILURE MODES

Examples of Foreign Object Damage (FOD):

Bent leaf: Missing material on the blade:

Page 10: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

10

TYPICAL FAILURE MODES Corrosion pitting on leading edge: Liquid erosion on the leading edge:

Cross section

Point clouds 3D Volume

Page 11: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

11

TYPICAL FAILURE MODES

Corrosion pitting on radius and fillet:

Page 12: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

12

TYPICAL FAILURE MODES

Dirt build up on trailing edge:

Page 13: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

13

PHOTOS GALLERY

Page 14: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

14

PHOTOS GALLERY

Page 15: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

15

PHOTOS GALLERY

Page 16: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

16

PHOTOS GALLERY

Page 17: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

17

PHOTOS GALLERY

Page 18: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

18

CATASTROFIC FAILURE

Page 19: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

19

CATASTROFIC FAILURE

Page 20: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

20

DETAIL OF CATASTROFIC FAILURE

Page 21: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

21

Boroscope Inspection

Typical Inspection methods

XLGO+

XLG3

Page 22: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

22

The Rhythm Platform “Turning information into intelligence”

Inspect

Review

Report

Archive Share

DR

CR

UT

Visual

DICONDE “One standard = One platform”

EC

Page 23: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

Menu Directed Inspections ( MDI )

Software Solutions

Page 24: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

24

The Inspection Process The Present and Future

Build inspection using MDI Builder

Build

Load inspection on VideoProbe

(XL Go+ or XLG3)

Load

Perform inspection using

MDI

Inspect

Generate report on VideoProbe, Review on PC

Report

Send inspection to Rhythm

Send • Characterize

• Report

• Review

• Archive

One - Time Repeat

Page 25: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

25

Automatically generated on XL Go+

PC Setup (one time)

RhythmReportInspectPlan

Page 26: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

26

Menu Directed Inspection (MDI) making a routine inspection CFM56-7B

Page 27: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

3D Phase Measurement

• 3D Surface Scanning and Measurement System • Video Borescope Technology • Enables Internal 3D Examination of Equipment

Page 28: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

28

Imager Shadow

Tip

Fiber

Bundle

Shadows

Slit

Aperture

Z 1 Z 2

Phase Shifting

What if we had many shadows?

And the shadows had structure?

Page 29: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

29

Phase Shifting Typical Setup

Camera Projector

Object

Image 0

Image 1

Image 2

Image 3

Page 30: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

30

Phase Shifting in the XLG3 LED Arrays

Shadow

Pattern Viewing

Optics

Page 31: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

31

Optics Configuration

• Line patterns are projected using 3 LEDs on each side of viewing optics.

• Object distance at each point is computed using pattern trajectories (triangulation) known from calibration.

Page 32: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

32

Phase Images

Page 33: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

33

Phase Images

Page 34: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

34

Phase Images

Page 35: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

35

Image Capture and Analysis

1

3

2

4

Page 36: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

36

Types of 3D Measurement

Length

Multi-Segment Length

Area

Point to Line

Depth

Depth Profile

Page 37: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

37

Depth Profile Illustrative example:

Page 38: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

38

Depth Profile 0.180” Slot

Scale No Data

Distance

Between Cursors

Cross-Sectional Area (only when no red included)

Point furthest from reference plane

Should be in same plane

Page 39: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

39

Depth Profile

Tear in Welded Blade Edge

Page 40: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

40

Point Cloud

Page 41: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

41

Point Cloud – x,y,z file

Compare worn condition to new geometry

Page 42: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

42

Application – Turbine Blade

Page 43: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

43

Application – Weld Inspection

Page 44: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

44

Application – Corrosion Pitting

Page 45: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

45

What is pitting corrosion? Pitting Corrosion is the localized corrosion of a metal surface confined to a point or small area, that takes the form of cavities. Pitting corrosion is one of the most damaging forms of corrosion. Pitting factor is the ratio of the depth of the deepest pit resulting from corrosion divided by the average penetration as calculated from weight loss.

CORROSION PITTING

What causes pitting corrosion? For a defect-free "perfect" material, pitting corrosion is caused by the ENVIRONMENT (chemistry) that may contain aggressive chemical species such as chloride. Chloride is particularly damaging to the passive film (oxide) so pitting can initiate at oxide breaks.

Typical Pits

Page 46: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

46

Study on : GT MS5002 C –Blade R0

Material: GTD450 – Plant :LNG

0130_2

0130_5

AREA 0130 PIT IDENTIFICATION

Page 47: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

47

Study on MS5002 C –Blade R0

0130_5

Page 48: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

48

Methods

Eddy Current (Coil : Absolute)

(Freq:1Mhz)

Microscope (Confocal Microscopes)

RVI 3D PROBE ( 6 mm OD)

PIT ID Depth (µm)

Depth (µm)

Depth (µm)

130_5 262 240 210

130_2 177 163 148

Eddy Current

Microscope

RVI 3D PROBE

Lead time Day Week Hrs

Investment Low time by time High one time Medium

Skilled resource Medium High Low

Result Certificate Report Automatic report + point clouds

Page 49: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

49

Example of Eddy Current application on Turbine Wheel

Benefits

• Early Detection – helps to avoid catastrophic failures

• Patented multi-channel (96) eddy current array probe fully

conforms to dovetail profile

• Complete coverage in single pass

• Detects cracks as small as .030”

Page 50: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

50

Typical Failure mode on Turbine Wheel

Axial view reveals crack

locations in discs with

axial-entry fir tree type

blade attachment grooves.

Page 51: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

51

Example of Eddy Current application on R0 Blade

Benefits

• Early Detection – helps to avoid catastrophic failures

• Fast and accurate detection

•Detects cracks as small as .030”

P-Cut Feature

Leading Edge

R0 Blade

Page 52: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

52

GT Installed fleet (Norway example)

191 Gas Turbine installed, the oldest have more then 30yrs

0-25 MW

25-50 MW

>50 MW

140

48

3

Page 53: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

53

Q & A

Page 54: Detect, Measure, Analyse ,Compare Data with XLGO and 3D ...ndt.sitegen.no/customers/ndt/files/VT inspect with...making a routine inspection CFM56-7B 3D Phase Measurement • 3D Surface

54

Thank you !