2
Fire Safety Journal 41 (2006) 628–629 Book review Design of Steel Structures Subjected to Fire: Background and Design Guide to Eurocode 3. Jean-Marc Franssen, Raul Zaharia. Editions de l’universite` de Lie` ge (2005) (h37, Hardbound, ISBN: 2-930322-99-3). The discipline of structural fire engineering is becoming more popular as clients and engineers realise the economic- al savings, and increased robustness, which can be gained from carrying out structural fire calculations, compared to following the traditional simple ‘deemed-to-satisfy’ pre- scriptive rules. The development of the Eurocodes, first in their ENV status and now in their recently published EN status, has encouraged the growth of structural fire engineering, with the loading code and suite of material response codes having dedicated fire parts (denoted as Part 1.2). As with all Eurocodes, the fire design parts provide concise information generally giving basic principles of design without any detailed guidance or explanation of how some rules were developed. To use the codes efficiently and safely it is important that the designer has some knowledge of the background leading to the development of the codes. This book by Franssen and Zaharia, who have an outstanding international reputation for research in structural fire engineering, provides significant background knowledge required in the general use of the fire part to the steel response code (EN1993-1-2) and, where appropriate, the fire-loading code (EN1991-1-2). In the first part of the book, the authors present the codified approach dealing with the different components of structural fire engineering, consisting of defining the design static load estimated at the time of the fire, the likely severity of the fire, the thermal response of the structure and the structural behaviour. Throughout each of these design stages, guidance of how the code can be applied is discussed together with relevant worked examples pre- sented to emphasise key points. Connections (or joints) are key components in both the ambient and fire design, which is highlighted by the authors who devote a separate chapter to the design of these components. Following the general theme of the book, the rules given in the code are first presented followed by a discussion on the background philosophy leading to these rules. By presenting the background information the authors can highlight areas where the designer needs to take particular care. In this example, the possible design error is highlighted of ‘over-sizing’ members for ambient temperature design to achieve the required fire resistance without checking whether the adjacent connections also require ‘over-sizing’. The codes provide a range of design methods to define the severity of the fire, the thermal response and the structural behaviour. In terms of the fire severity, the authors explain the background to the standard tempera- ture–time relationships, parametric curves, one and two zone models, and localised fires. Worked examples are presented defining the temperature–time relationship using the localised fire approach and the parametric curve. For the thermal response the authors explain the methods for defining the temperature of unprotected steel, fire-pro- tected steel and external steel, coupled with relevant and concise design examples. For the structural behaviour, the use of tabulated data, simple calculation models and advanced analysis are explained, although as correctly pointed out by the authors there is no tabulated data in EN 1993-1-2 due to the relatively ease in which the simple calculation models can be used. The explanation of the simple structural calculation methods covers all single members under tension, compression, bending and shear. Advanced calculation methods are beginning to be used by a number of well-known design organisations, with the authors dedicating a whole chapter to this area. The limitations of the advanced models are carefully explained by the authors, with illustrative figures of deformed structures showing the capabilities of advanced analysis. A range of design examples are presented in the final chapter of the book consisting of a continuous beam, a two-dimensional multi-storey moment resisting frame, a single-storey industrial building and a raking system. Although these show clearly the capabilities of the advanced models it is a shame that a design example involving a three-dimensional multi-storey building (in- cluding the floor slab) was not included, since this approach seems to be growing in popularity with practi- tioners. There are a few topographical errors (mainly gramma- tical) throughout the book, which hinders the reader in some places. However, the layout of the book does allow readers to use it as a quick reference to address specific issues with design. In summary, I recommend reading this book since it does provide useful information to the background ARTICLE IN PRESS www.elsevier.com/locate/firesaf doi:10.1016/j.firesaf.2006.06.005

Design of Steel Structures Subjected to Fire: Background and Design Guide to Eurocode 3. Jean-Marc Franssen, Raul Zaharia. Editions de l’universitè de Liège (2005) (€37, Hardbound,

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Design of Steel Structures Subjected to Fire: Background and Design Guide to Eurocode 3. Jean-Marc Franssen, Raul Zaharia. Editions de l’universitè de Liège (2005) (€37, Hardbound,

ARTICLE IN PRESS

doi:10.1016/j.fir

Fire Safety Journal 41 (2006) 628–629

www.elsevier.com/locate/firesaf

Book review

Design of Steel Structures Subjected to Fire: Background

and Design Guide to Eurocode 3. Jean-Marc Franssen, Raul

Zaharia. Editions de l’universite de Liege (2005) (h37,

Hardbound, ISBN: 2-930322-99-3).

The discipline of structural fire engineering is becomingmore popular as clients and engineers realise the economic-al savings, and increased robustness, which can be gainedfrom carrying out structural fire calculations, compared tofollowing the traditional simple ‘deemed-to-satisfy’ pre-scriptive rules. The development of the Eurocodes, first intheir ENV status and now in their recently published ENstatus, has encouraged the growth of structural fireengineering, with the loading code and suite of materialresponse codes having dedicated fire parts (denoted as Part1.2).

As with all Eurocodes, the fire design parts provideconcise information generally giving basic principles ofdesign without any detailed guidance or explanation ofhow some rules were developed. To use the codes efficientlyand safely it is important that the designer has someknowledge of the background leading to the developmentof the codes.

This book by Franssen and Zaharia, who have anoutstanding international reputation for research instructural fire engineering, provides significant backgroundknowledge required in the general use of the fire part to thesteel response code (EN1993-1-2) and, where appropriate,the fire-loading code (EN1991-1-2).

In the first part of the book, the authors present thecodified approach dealing with the different components ofstructural fire engineering, consisting of defining the designstatic load estimated at the time of the fire, the likelyseverity of the fire, the thermal response of the structureand the structural behaviour. Throughout each of thesedesign stages, guidance of how the code can be applied isdiscussed together with relevant worked examples pre-sented to emphasise key points.

Connections (or joints) are key components in both theambient and fire design, which is highlighted by the authorswho devote a separate chapter to the design of thesecomponents. Following the general theme of the book, therules given in the code are first presented followed by adiscussion on the background philosophy leading to theserules. By presenting the background information theauthors can highlight areas where the designer needs totake particular care. In this example, the possible design

esaf.2006.06.005

error is highlighted of ‘over-sizing’ members for ambienttemperature design to achieve the required fire resistancewithout checking whether the adjacent connections alsorequire ‘over-sizing’.The codes provide a range of design methods to define

the severity of the fire, the thermal response and thestructural behaviour. In terms of the fire severity, theauthors explain the background to the standard tempera-ture–time relationships, parametric curves, one and twozone models, and localised fires. Worked examples arepresented defining the temperature–time relationship usingthe localised fire approach and the parametric curve. Forthe thermal response the authors explain the methods fordefining the temperature of unprotected steel, fire-pro-tected steel and external steel, coupled with relevant andconcise design examples. For the structural behaviour, theuse of tabulated data, simple calculation models andadvanced analysis are explained, although as correctlypointed out by the authors there is no tabulated data inEN 1993-1-2 due to the relatively ease in which thesimple calculation models can be used. The explanationof the simple structural calculation methods covers allsingle members under tension, compression, bending andshear.Advanced calculation methods are beginning to be used

by a number of well-known design organisations, with theauthors dedicating a whole chapter to this area. Thelimitations of the advanced models are carefully explainedby the authors, with illustrative figures of deformedstructures showing the capabilities of advanced analysis.A range of design examples are presented in the final

chapter of the book consisting of a continuous beam, atwo-dimensional multi-storey moment resisting frame, asingle-storey industrial building and a raking system.Although these show clearly the capabilities of theadvanced models it is a shame that a design exampleinvolving a three-dimensional multi-storey building (in-cluding the floor slab) was not included, since thisapproach seems to be growing in popularity with practi-tioners.There are a few topographical errors (mainly gramma-

tical) throughout the book, which hinders the reader insome places. However, the layout of the book does allowreaders to use it as a quick reference to address specificissues with design.In summary, I recommend reading this book since

it does provide useful information to the background

Page 2: Design of Steel Structures Subjected to Fire: Background and Design Guide to Eurocode 3. Jean-Marc Franssen, Raul Zaharia. Editions de l’universitè de Liège (2005) (€37, Hardbound,

ARTICLE IN PRESSBook review / Fire Safety Journal 41 (2006) 628–629 629

to EN1993-1-2, together with the appropriate partsof EN1991-1-2, which will provide designers with con-fidence in its use. It is also appropriate for students andresearchers who need to learn the basic principles of thecode.

Colin BaileySchool of Mechanical, Aerospace, and Civil Engineering,

The University of Manchester, PO Box 88, Manchester M60

1QD, UK

E-mail address: [email protected].