Upload
city-limits-new-york
View
218
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
1/50
i y g e e h e
k g e } g y
b a y l w { } n k g
M g { n f e M g b n k n g e k n g {
h e M D a { } R a } g {
D E [ N
I K L h} Egv ^ay` Wenrgy{n}~ [koaad a Dhv
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
2/50
hiaw} }og iygeehe kge}gy bay lw{}nkg
] I K L E ` W [ D # l% A ` $ l
% H ` `$ $ I K $ $ $ %
Hiaw} }og Iygeehe Kge}gy{ Mgcakyhk~ Zyafyhc
] I K M Z ` ` H %
V | % V ` B H l | % V $ |$ %
hk`eavdgmfgcge}{
C | E ` % ] EHHKZE ^` [ K$ E K I` K Z$ B W Y G G$ $ ` H#H$ O$ %
] I K Z M @
` % V ` VX VX M K W V` $ %C $ ` G R E` ` %
] H F L @ I K$ H B`$ # E^W [ D%
] I K ` X B H% V ` I B B$ KK E ^`$ M H Z$ B B$ ] L B$ ]
N I% O B$ C @ B$ C @`$ E C CV$ A [ B$ Y` B B$ H B V FB `% ] $ $ I K L D Y% ] L I`$ DDZ$ [ H$ Y H$ C Y %
] %
88% ] K K H#E M#EK /
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
3/50
hiaw} }og hw}oay{
Dhvygekg Eaymge M M I K M Z% O | $ %
N H >$ C% E K A [ [ G [ K$ A 0 [ $ A H G A% N L >$
W Z H W N K D H ` % C% E ` ] C M< ZG G V /H K Z. G H K D /Y 6.%
C% E Hl Z E^W [ D$ I K
Z Z H K%
[wemggz N~gy B I K M Z% O ` % B $ O W ] O Z| F Y K Z|%C% N O W$ F
[%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
4/50
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
5/50
]HIDG AB KAE]GE][
N% Ggkw}ng [wcchy~ 8
H% KaygBnemnef{byacGxhcneh}naeab9:8:Mh}h 9I% Ygkaccgemh}nae{}aBwy}ogyYgmwkgArgyra}g{ 7
NN% Agya}nef ne Egv ay`< He Agyngv ab }og Mh}h 6
NNN% Mg}hndgm Hehd~{n{ ab Egv ay` Kn}~ Agya}g{ ?
H% OnfoArgyra}gHygh{I~Egv ay`Kn}~Iayawfo ?
8%OnfoArgyra}gMn{}ynk}{
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
6/50
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
7/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 8
N 8$ E ^` $ # % K| G M$ #
%
Iw} }ge{ a }oaw{hem{ a }ogny ra}g{ mnm ea} kawe}% [$ $ E ` [ % G ;$ $ % N $ $ $ cayg }ohe 8::$:::da{} ra}g{%
N $ E ^` % W` $ E ^` % I $
8 % A % H # $
$ |%
H % $ ` B % ] O H R H /OHRH.$ K $ W [
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
8/50
t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
] E ^` [ I G $ E 8< G / .$ / .%
] H H %
] 8$ %] $ $ % N $ $ ` # $ # % K$
%
B$ E ^`%
H% Kayg Bnemnef{ yac Ghcneh}nae a 9:8: Mh}h
E ^` $ $ % ]
$ E ^` K E ^` I K E `%2 ] K6 $ I K $
N E ^` K $ 2$7 $ $ %
] #
% %
Zaddnef zdhkg{ vn}o onfo kaekge}yh}nae{ a zaay yg{nmge}{ hem dhefwhfg cneayn}ng{ ohm }og onfog{}argyra}g yh}g{%
H E ` K$ ` O ` #
O % V 8 8 ` O E ` K %O K%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
9/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t ;
G $ K$L` O I I$ %] %
A I0 8 I % ] # O C O Z C% [ I %
Egv ay` Kn}~ hem a}ogy kawe}ng{ ne Egv ay` [}h}g hyg ea} wdd~ dgrgyhfnef neaych}nae zyarnmgm
i~ ra}nef chkoneg{ }a ge{wyg }oh} hdd ne}gemgm ra}g{ hyg kawe}gm%
H $ Y` K %
G $ E ^` K wehidg}a zyamwkg zygknek}#dgrgd mh}h ay cayg }ohe ohd a hdd gdgk}nae mn{}ynk}{ ne Xwgge{ hem
Iyaa`d~e% ] K # % A 76 E ` K$ 9? kawe}ng{ hndgm }a zyamwkg ygxwg{}gm argyra}g mh}hh} hdd%
A $ ` $ % B $ 8$ E ` K Z C [ I% ] K
$ cayg }ohe 8 ne 7 ra}g{ da{} % ] %
Zaay Ihdda} Mg{nfe Vndd Dghm }a Cayg Argyra}g{
M E ` K % K W%[% [ 8 %
N [% @ F $ % I $ [% [ l % ] [% F [% [ %
] [% F E ` K% ] %
] % Egv ^ay`{ ihdda}{ hyg h zhzgy ygzyg{ge}h}nae a }og dgrgy chkoneg{$ iw} }og
egv az}nkhd {khe chkoneg{ ma ea} ohrg eghyd~ }og dgrgd a argyra}g zya}gk}nae a dgrgy
chkoneg{ /vonko mnm ea} hddav argyra}g{.%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
10/50
t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
] $ $ % 8
]g Zyaidgc{ ne Egv ^ay` Ohrg Eh}naehd Nczdnkh}nae{
Y ` B A $ $ $ OHRH%
H E ^`$ %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
11/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 7
I% Ygkaccgemh}nae{ }a Bwy}ogy Ygmwkg Argyra}g{
H $ E ` $ 8 % I $
$ $ % E ^` `
E ^` % H $ ` %
V E `$ l % ]
;#2%
8% Ygxwnyg Zwidnkh}nae a Ygfwdhy Ygzay}{ a Gdgk}nae Mh~ Mh}h i~ Gdgk}nae Mn{}ynk}
E ` $ $ l #
% F 8$ E ^` B$ < /8. $ $ $ /. $ $ % V `
` Z C C O [ I 8%
9% Chemh}g [}h}g hem Dakhd Hk}nae }a Hmmyg{{ Zyaidgc{ Mn{kargygm Byac
Gdgk}nae Mn{}ynk} Ygzay}{
V $ % B $ G $ %V $ $ $ ` %
;% Zyarnmg Zwidnk Hkkg{{ }a Ihdda}{
I 8 ` `
% I $ %
] 88
% C$ 88 $ $ $ %E ^` %8 ]
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
12/50
2 t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
$ $ %
=% Nczyarg Egv ay`{ Ihdda} Mg{nfe Ygxwnygcge}{
] I K E ^` %8; ] ` ` ` ` ` % $ E ` # # % B $ E ^`
$ % ] $ % [
%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
13/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 6
I E ` K ? $vg g{}nch}g }oh} hzzyanch}gd~9:$::: ra}g{ ne }og fargyeay{ kae}g{} vgyg da{} mwg }a argyra}nef {}h}gvnmg$ vn}o ig}vgge 7:$:::
hem 2:$::: argyra}gm kae}g{}{ ne }a}hd%8
Vg wy}ogy g{}nch}g }oh} ne Egv ay` Kn}~ hdaeg$ }ogyg vgyg argy 2$7:: argyra}g{ kh{} ae Gdgk}nae
Mh~ ne }og 9:8: fwigyeh}aynhd kae}g{}%87N $ $ vg g{}nch}g }oh}}ogyg vgyg h} dgh{} 8?$>7? argyra}g{ mwynef Gdgk}nae Mh~ ra}nef ne }og Kn}~% H H K% V 8$ K %
B 8 8 E ^` [ % [ E ` [ E ` K $ K$ K$ F$ C$ A$ A$
% H %' l %A $ G$ C$ E
V $ $ %82 ] E ` [ # %
B 8< A 8 $ E ^` [%
W$ $ | % H$ E ^` K$ l / K$ F$ ^ .%
NN% Argyra}nef ne Egv ay`< He Argyrngv a }og Mh}h
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
14/50
? t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
8 8 E ^` K %
Ra}g a}hd{ ByacE^K Mh}h
Argyra}g Yh}gyac E^K Mh}h
a}hd + aGM Ra}g{
G{}nch}gm + a GMArgyra}g{
Iyae 86$>?7 %> 86$28; 8$76
Iyaa`d~e 8?;$ %78 ;>$76 $?
Cheoh}}he ;;>$8;? %;7 ;8$66? 8$8??
Xwgge{ 87;$?> % ;;6$;22 8$;
[}h}ge N{dhem >$?> %; >$>>; ;
a}hd{ >==$:2= :%=> zgykge} 8$;=9$6=6 2$78;
hidg 8< G 8 $ % Ra}g a}hd{ yac E^KMh}h Argyra}g Yh}g yac E^K Mh}h ` E ^` K I G I K Z% a}hd Ewcigy a Gdgk}nae Mh~ Ra}g{ ` E ^` [ I G % G{}nch}gm Ewcigy a Gdgk}nae Mh~ Argyra}g{ Argyra}g Yh}g yac
E^K Mh}h G M%
l $ zynay }a 9:8:$ }ogyg vgygrny}whdd~ ea argyra}g{ ae Gdgk}nae Mh~ ne Egv ay`$ %G l $
|% ] G H K % 86 I Z M @ C @ ? % A 2
?$ %8'% ] E ` K 8$
I%8?
H% Onfo Argyra}g Hygh{ I~ Egv ay` Kn}~ Iayawfo
B % ] 8 % ] %
NNN% Mg}hndgm Hehd~{n{ a Egv ay` Kn}~ Argyra}g{
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
15/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t >
Bnfwyg 9< A E ^ K$ 8 % ] ` E ` K0 #$ K
%
F `$ 8 % H $ E ^` K % N B$ 8%?% A ?%; E ^` K 8%?% ] %
' a Zygknek}{ vn}oArgyra}g Yh}g 5 8'
Iyae ;8%>'
Iyaa`d~e 8>%8'
Cheoh}}he 8%'
Xwgge{ 8%8'
[}h}ge N{dhem 8%8'
a}hd 8?%;'
hidg 9< Z 8 $ E ^` K %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
16/50
8 t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
8% Onfo Argyra}g Mn{}ynk}{< ]og Iyaex
H 8 B $
I% E 8 8 I %
Bnfwyg ;< A 8 I%
B ; I% K
$ % ] I% H$ ; 8 % [ I / .% ] C Z`
I%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
17/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 88
Nerg{}nfh}nef }og G}yhaymnehynd~ OnfoArgyra}g Yh}g{ h} Z%[% 27 ae 266 G 8=8 [}%
M K E ^` K
Z%[% 27 266 G 88 [ [ I% N $ %H $ %% ] 86 % E E ` K %] # 6;%6 O %? `%
] O G %
Bnfwyg =< A Z%[% 27 [ I% ] Z C C O %
V ` 0 $ % ] % ]
<
$ % A $ K 0 $ $ % E $ % ] $ `
$ %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
18/50
8 t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
HM!GM
F K HF [2 [ [KL K [[ H KKL
?!; ;>%' ;;%;' ;7%?' ;?%2' ;7%;' ;8%;' ;2%' %6' 6%6' ;;%>'
?!?? ;7%8' ;8%2' ?%' ?%2' 2%>' 6%' 6%6' 2%7' 6%;' ;%;'
?!7? 8>%' 7%' 88%7' 86%>' 2%>' 8?%7' 8%6' 8%?' %' ?%'
?!22 8>%;' 86%>' 87%>' 87%' 86%>' 82%2' 87%7' 82%' 82%7' 8%7'
?!76 82%7' 8;%7' 8%6' 8;%' 82%?' 8;%6' 8%?' 8;%' 87%?' 8;%8'
?!27 87%' 8;%;' >%?' 88%?' 8%' 8%7' 8%7' 88%7' 8;%8' 88%7'
HM!GM< HM!G M
F< FK< K
HF< H F[2< [ [
[< F [ [KL< [ K L
K< K[[< [ [
H< HKKL< K K L
hidg ;< Z E ^` K%H Z%[% 27 [ I%
] I K K I A 2$ 88$ [ I A 6$ Z%[% 27 8 % 8> M ` $ % E K
[ 88 %
9% Onfo Argyra}g Mn{}ynk}{< Iyaa`d~e
B 7 I` % ] K 72% I`%] #0
` % ] 8$27$ # I` 0 22%7 # #%I $ l 7>%8 # #% ] %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
19/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 8;
Bnfwyg 7< A 8 I` %F I` %
H K $ 88 ; 7
% %
HM!GM Argyra}g Yh}gay Fargyeay
Egnfoiayoaam Von}gRHZ '
Idhk`RHZ '
On{zhenkRHZ '
H{nheRHZ '
77!?7 88%?' I %7' 26%2' >%2' %>'
77!> ?%6' I %;' 2?%2' ?%' %6'
77!>; ?%7' I %;' 2?%2' ?%' %6'
77!>6 6%>' I %?' 68%?' 7%;' 8%'
72!8 2%?' I#[ 6%>' ?%7' 6%' %'
72!; 2%7' I#[ >%' 6;%' ?%7' ;%>'
77!>7 2%8' I 8%' 2%' ;;%7' '2!78 7%>' I I >%;' %7' 2%;' %;'
72!; 7%2' I#[ %' ?2%2' 6%?' 8%>'
77!>2 7%' I %?' 6%7' 7%' 2%;'
72!6; 7%' I#[ %7' >8%;' 2%;' 8%8'
hidg =< G M I` 7 %A % RHZ zgykge}
# $ 8 K%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
20/50
8 t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
I#[ I %] I H M 77 $I R M` l l Y` H I% ] I` 88%?
l% ] I < # I 77%8 ` ?%2 #$ ` ` % ] I I#[ 7 2!78 # I I%
Bnfwyg 2< A 8 $ I#[ I I`%
V B 2 I$ % L B 7$ #
% ] K %
H B 2$ I` l 0 $ ` I ` I#
[% V $ %
W` I$ I`
% N $ % N $ $
[ K 8?%8 0 $ 77!?$ 77!>7 72!; # 8 [ K % H I#[ I B 2%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
21/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 87
;% Onfo Argyra}g Yh}g Mn{}ynk}{< Cheoh}}he
B 6 C % E
C 8 % C
V O$ O$ G O C%
Bnfwyg 6< A C %
7 C % C
l G O$ ` 88 88; [ ] Z` H% ]
B 88$ I% H $ % ] # 77%7 O$ 7% ` l >%2 % H$ `
` % ] O $ [ I$ G %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
22/50
82 t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
HM!GM Argyra}g Yh}gay Fargyeay
Egnfoiayoaam Von}g RHZ'
Idhk`RHZ '
On{zhenkRHZ '
H{nheRHZ '
2?!78 2%=' G O %' 87%>' 78%;' 8%8'
68!>2 =%?' VO %8' 8?%' 62%?' %;'
2?!6; =%;' G O 8%' ;%2' 7>%' 2%8'
2?!88 ;%?' G O %' ;;%?' 7?%;' ;%>'
6!;; ;%?' G R 8%;' 87%' 78%' 8>%>'
hidg 7< ] C% A % RHZ '
# $ 8 %
A O G O $ C < K% ] K
$ K 8 l H # % ] H $ O [ I G O$ G % ] E ` K [$ K @$ l
%
=% Onfo Argyra}g Mn{}ynk}{< Xwgge{
B ? X%
] ` 0 B 7$ # X K % H I`$ K 72 X% ] % B $ K [ L
L F X< $ ` ` > # % N$ X K ?7$8;8 $ 6%6 #% I $
$ l 22 # #% N $ %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
23/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 86
Bnfwyg ?< O X % I` X0 ## X %
G K$ % 2 X %
HM!GM
Argyra}g Yh}g
ay Fargyeay Egnfoiayoaam{
Von}g
RHZ '
Idhk` RHZ
'
On{zhenk
RHZ '
H{nhe RHZ
'
;7!? =%2' Y Z` 6%7' 6%2' %8' %>'
!? ;%2' B 8%>' 8%6' 8?%' 2%>'
!; ;%;' B ;%>' 87%8' 8?%>' 2%>'
;!2 9%6' L` O %7' %' ?%6' 8%8'
;7! 9%6' DB` K 7%' %?' ;%;' 26%2'
2< B X% A % RHZ zgykge} #
$ 8 K%
] X # ` G
B$ L` O Y Z`% A 6 # 2 #% ] # $ 2 2 H% A $ # ` % ] %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
24/50
8? t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
7% Onfo Argyra}g Mn{}ynk}{< [}h}ge N{dhem
H K $ [ N % E$ #
%; $ 8 8
8 $ [ N% B > [ N % G 8 % O$ $ # V E I
I O A %
Bnfwyg >< A [ N %
6 [ N % ] 0 [ N% ] $ B >$ A 0 #
6>%6 % ] $ 6 # V E I 0 $ # 6 #$ ` O%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
25/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 8>
HM!GM Argyra}g Yh}g neFargyeay{ Kae}g{}
Egnfoiayoaam{ Von}gRHZ '
Idhk`RHZ '
On{zhenkRHZ '
H{nheRHZ '
2:!:9= >%' A 6>%6' %2' 88%' 6%'
28!:78 %8' V E I 2%>' 7%' ;7%' %8'
2;!::? %?' F 2?%7' %6' 8%' 8;%;'
28!:?2 %8' V E I ?%8' 86%' %8' 8;%8'
28!:== %' V E I 86%' 8%' ;;%>' %>'
2< B [ N% A % RHZ ' #
$ 8 K%
I% G{}nch}nef Egv ay` Kn}~ Argyra}g Yh}g{ i~ Yhkg
V ` E ^` K
% V # $ $ % B $ `$ O #O E ^` 8%
] E ` K `
% W ` $ ` O %8 H K 0 >7 % 6 0 %
Von}g Idhk` On{zhenk
Iyae %77' 8%?' 8%?'
Iyaa`d~e %;7' %2;' 8%;6'
Cheoh}}he %' %?' %>8'
Xwgge{ %' %2' 8%;6'
[}h}ge N{dhem %8' ,,, ,,,
hidg 6< G $ 8%
N ` ` O$
vg g{}nch}g }oh} idhk` hem On{zhenk ra}gy{ argyra}gm h} {nfenkhe}d~ onfogy yh}g{ }ohe von}gra}gy{% ] X$ ` | ` ` % E$ O X
` %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
26/50
t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
N I I`$ ` $ C$ % ] O I$ I` C$ X%
H %
; O ` `% ] O ` I$ I`$ X % ] O `
C$ ` % E$ O ` ` O %Z [#` $
[ % A O ` %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
27/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 8
[ % N $ % ]
F 8% W` [ $ $ F %
W$ F < ;$;7 E ^` K$
l 8$726 [ % V
$ $ argy 8:$::: da{} ra}g{ {}h}gvnmg ne }og Fnddniyhem kae}g{} % W$ [% F %
NR% ]og Nczhk} a Ihdda} Mg{nfe ae Argyra}nef ne }og Fnddniyhem [geh}g Kae}g{}
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
28/50
t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
] E ^` K $ K%
] $ /8. $
/. %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
29/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t ;
E ` 8 l % H $
% B$ $ %
I 0 $ $ %; ] O H R H /OHRH.$ $ $ $ < %
OHRH % I l %
] EHHKZ Egv ay [}h}g Kaegygekg r% Egv ay` [}h}g Iahym a Gdgk}nae{ E ` OHRH % 7 H $
% H E ^` % N B ?$ 8; E ` 8% ] B E `< $ 8$ %2 C G M %6 ]
[$ %?
C$ E ^`$ ` % B $ C#M K$ O 7' ` #O V$
H#H ` %>
[$ A 8 %7' 0 $ %; ] 0 $ l $
%;8 I G M$ %
R% ]og Eh}naehd [nfenbkhekg a Nehmgxwh}g Argyra}g Zya}gk}nae{
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
30/50
t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
N H% ]
H$ %
C A % I 8 $ % NH$ K$ K$ D $ $ / .
% N $ G M%
A K
G MA Y
8 F% Y
H A 8 F%
YD 8%8>' 8%>'
H %6?' 8%8'
K %7;' %76'
I $ O V A $ %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
31/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 7
] G M % ] G M D$H$ K K %
A K
G MA Y
8 F% Y
HA 8 F% Y
O %;' %6'
V %8' %6'
N A $ OK 7' $ V K$
' % ] ` $ / `0 ` $ . %
H B E `$ ` % H Z @
H B H#H ` #HH K K 8 % C # H H 8%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
32/50
2 t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
N ` W [%] G H K ` l % E %
[$ B$ A E ^` $ l% H % Z @ @ ? ?% N /N$ H`$ B N. %' $ G [% D K$N 8%;6'%;
] E `
Hzzgemn I< Argyra}g{ ne Egv ^ay` Kn}~ Gdgk}nae Kae}g{}{
] E ^` K
% N
8 0 8 % H $ 8?$>7? 8 % ] 0 W%[% [ # $ %
W [ [ /[#^ .
Ai{gyrgm +a Ra}g{
Ai{gyrgmArgyra}g Yh}g
a}hd + aGM Ra}g{
G{}nch}gm + aGM Argyra}g{
Iyae 86$>?7 %2' 86$28; 77
Iyaa`d~e 8?;$ %8' ;>$76 6;
Cheoh}}he ;;>$8;? %2' ;8$66? ?
Xwgge{ 87;$?> %8' ;;6$;22 ;
[}h}ge N{dhem >$?> %>' >$>>; ?6
a}hd{ >==$:2= :%8:' 8$;=9$6=6 8$726
Wen}gm[}h}g{[geh}g/]va# ghy]gyc.
Ai{gyrgm +a Ra}g{
Ai{gyrgmArgyra}g Yh}g
a}hd + aGM Ra}g{
G{}nch}gm + aGM Argyra}g{
Iyae 86$>?7 %78' 86$28; ?>>
Iyaa`d~e 8?;$ %' ;>$76 ?7
Cheoh}}he ;;>$8;? %8?' ;8$66? 2
Xwgge{ 87;$?> %' ;;6$;22 ?
[}h}ge N{dhem >$?> %8>' >$>>; 86>
a}hd{ >==$:2= :%92' 8$;=9$6=6 ;$;7:
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
36/50
; t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
K
Ai{gyrgm +a Ra}g{
Ai{gyrgmArgyra}g Yh}g
a}hd + aGM Ra}g{
G{}nch}gm + aGM Argyra}g{
Iyae 86$>?7 %;2' 86$28; 22
Iyaa`d~e 8?;$ %8' ;>$76 ?2
Cheoh}}he ;;>$8;? %8' ;8$66? ;78
Xwgge{ 87;$?> %8' ;;6$;22 2
[}h}ge N{dhem >$?> %8' >$>>; >6
a}hd{ >==$:2= :%82' 8$;=9$6=6 8$>22
H F
Ai{gyrgm +a Ra}g{
Ai{gyrgmArgyra}g Yh}g
a}hd + aGM Ra}g{
G{}nch}gm + aGM Argyra}g{
Iyae 86$>?7 %>' 86$28; 788
Iyaa`d~e 8?;$ %8' ;>$76 778
Cheoh}}he ;;>$8;? %?' ;8$66? ?
Xwgge{ 87;$?> %8' ;;6$;22 ;
[}h}ge N{dhem >$?> %88' >$>>; 8>
a}hd{ >==$:2= :%8=' 8$;=9$6=6 8$6>>
Wen}gm[}h}g{Ygzyg{ge}h}nrg
Ai{gyrgm +a Ra}g{
Ai{gyrgmArgyra}g Yh}g
a}hd + aGM Ra}g{
G{}nch}gm + aGM Argyra}g{
Iyae 86$>?7 %6' 86$28; 2
Iyaa`d~e 8?;$ %6' ;>$76 >6
Cheoh}}he ;;>$8;? %>' ;8$66? ;8
Xwgge{ 87;$?> %88' ;;6$;22 ;6>
[}h}ge N{dhem >$?> %8' >$>>; >>
a}hd{ >==$:2= :%8;' 8$;=9$6=6 8$72:
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
37/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t ;8
[ [
Ai{gyrgm +a Ra}g{
Ai{gyrgmArgyra}g Yh}g
a}hd + aGM Ra}g{
G{}nch}gm + aGM Argyra}g{
Iyae 86$>?7 %8>' 86$28; ;;2
Iyaa`d~e 8?;$ %2' ;>$76 86
Cheoh}}he ;;>$8;? %7' ;8$66? 828
Xwgge{ 87;$?> %>' ;;6$;22 >2
[}h}ge N{dhem >$?> %' >$>>;
a}hd{ >==$:2= :%:?' 8$;=9$6=6 8$:;9
[ H
Ai{gyrgm +a Ra}g{
Ai{gyrgmArgyra}g Yh}g
a}hd + aGM Ra}g{
G{}nch}gm + aGM Argyra}g{
Iyae 86$>?7 %;' 86$28; 72
Iyaa`d~e 8?;$ %2' ;>$76 72
Cheoh}}he ;;>$8;? %7' ;8$66? 828
Xwgge{ 87;$?> %' ;;6$;22 8>
[}h}ge N{dhem >$?> %2' >$>>; 28
a}hd{ >==$:2= :%8:' 8$;=9$6=6 8$868
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
38/50
; t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
Hzzgemn K< Argyra}g{ Yh}g{ I~ Kawe}~ ne Egv ^ay` [}h}g
] $ $ 8 E
`% ] [ I G / . ; 0
? % ] $ 8$ $ 0 E ` K 8% N $ % ; %
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
39/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t ;;
a}hd Ra}g{ Argyra}g{ ne Fargyeay{ Yhkg Argyra}g Yh}g
H >?$>8? 6; %?'
I 86$28; 8$76 %>'
I 2$787 8 %;'
K 8$7 ? %;?'
K ;2$;> 8; %;2'
K ;$28 88? %7'
K 8;$;> 78 %;?'
K 8$? 2 %?'
M 8;$828 78 %;>'
G 8$2 ;> %;'
F 82$>?> ; %'
F 87$8;? > %7>'O $226 6 %2'
@ ;>$76 $? %78'
C $;;6 ?? %;'
E ` ;8$66? 8$8?? %;7'
A >$?82 ;?> %8'
A 88$27 ; %;'
A >$66? 88? %'
Z ?$8 6 %2'
X ;;6$;22 8$; %'
Y >$>>; ; %;'
Y` ?7$67 87 %7'
[ 8$2> %8>'
[ 7$77 8 %;?'
[ 8$ %;'
[% D ?$? > %;'
[` 8$6 ? %8'
[ 8$?78 %8'
82??7 %8;'
W 7;$? > %86'
V 8$682 ; %'
V 86$; ;2 %8'
6$8>2 7; %6'
a}hd{< 9$=98$8;; >$22> :%=:'
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
40/50
; t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
Hzzgemn M< Cg}oamadaf~
]
E ^` K E ^` [% N
# %
Mh}h [awykg{
V E ` K I G
% B $ % ] $ ` %
$
% V R M /RM. 8 K%
] K I G$ $ # #% ] I G % H$
% O$ | $ < l X I` ` %H $ ` E ^` K $ $ # %
G{}nch}nef }og a}hd Ewcigy a Argyra}g{
] $ $ ` %
K$ $ E ` [ I G%
A ` % N $
K% I # O ` $ ` $ 2$7 8>$ K 8%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
41/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t ;7
H E ` % [ $ G$ C$ E V K% N E ` K$ ;$
2$ % H ` E ^` K % W %;> < 8?$7 7$ %;
G{}nch}nef I~#Yhkg Argyra}g Yh}g{
G # % ] R Y H
0 $ $ ` M Y% ]
< %
B R Y H $ # ` @ GN$ Z F @ O W% ;8 ]
| % V @ GN # %
N $ % E$
` @ GN % ] | %
N $ ` @ GN$ | $
% ] $ $ / . 0 H % ] H X$ %>
H% ] X %
V O ` [ N @GN % V $ @ GN R Y H
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
42/50
;2 t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
` % ` O # [ N$ ` O [ N ` O [ N @ GN %
] # E ` K0 6% ] >7 %
Von}g Idhk` On{zhenk
Iyae %77'/%88$ %>7. 8%?' /8%8$ 8%8. 8%?' /8%8;$ 8%.
Iyaa`d~e %;7'/%?$ %8. %2;' /%77$ %6. 8%;6' /%?$ 8%?.
Cheoh}}he %' /%82$ %6. %?' /%7$ 8%?. %>8' /%6>$ 8%.
Xwgge{ %' /%8?$ %;. %2' /%8$ 8%7. 8%;6' /8%;$ 8%?.
[}h}ge N{dhem %8' /%82$%?. ,,, ,,,
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
43/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t ;6
Hzzgemn G< Kw~hoafh Kawe}~ Ihdda}$ Eargcigy 9
Zaayd~ vaymgm
ne{}ywk}nae{ ne }og
fargyeay{ kae}g{}
ch~ ohrg khw{gm
{acg ra}gy{ }a igdngrg
}og~ kawdm ra}g
bay cayg }ohe aeg
khemnmh}g%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
44/50
;? t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
Hzzgemn B< Argyra}nef ne Kn}ng{ a Kw~hoafh Kawe}~ ne Fwigyeh}aynhd Gdgk}nae a9:8:$ Hehd~{n{ i~ Zyag{{ay Mhrnm K% @ncihdd$ Wenrgy{n}~ a Cn{{awyn#[}% Dawn{
] ` 7? K K% ] | % ] H#H %
] 2 % B 8' H#H $ $ $ %8 %
B 8' O $ $
$ %7 % I %
Oacafgegaw{ Kn}~ Hehd~{n{
N ?' H#H$ 8%;' / .%
N ' H#H$ %' /; .%
N >' H#H$ 8%;' / .%
N 8' H#H$ %' /;> .%Gkadafnkhd Ygfyg{{nae G{}nch}g{
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
45/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t ;>
G G M H#H < 8%8'
G G M #H#H < %'
Gkadafnkhd Negygekg G{}nch}g{
G G M H#H < 8%;'
G G M #H#H < %'
C$ 8
/ .%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
46/50
t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
GEMEA]G[
8% EHHKZ E%^% [ K % E ` [ I G$ E% 8#>7 /G%M%E%^% L ?$ 8.%
% H K 88#8$ EHHKZ E%^% [ K % E% % [ I% G$ E% 8#>7 /G%M%E% %
L ?$ 8.$ hrhndhidg h};>;Q22l%%
;% OHRH l $ $ /. 0 /. / .% O H R
H /OHRH. ;8/./8./I.$ W%[%K%H% 87?8/./8./I. /V 88.%
%EHHKZ E%^% [}h}g Kaegygekg$ E% 8#>7 /G%M%E%^% L% ?$ 8.%
7%Nm%
2%Nm%
6% N $ K # # $ $ P S % % % % % % %
H H I $ I K ` % W $ % V %
?% H neyh 8 82 K $ I K ` %
>% ] #% C % N $ # $ ` % K $ ` %
8%[gg fgegyhdd~Dhvygekg Eaymge g} hd%$ Iygeehe Kge}gy bay Lw{}nkg h} E^W [koaad ab Dhv$ Ig}}gy Ihdda}{/?.$ hrhndhidg h}$ Zwidnk Aznenae Xwhy}gyd~$ 7?$ 7 /7.$ hrhndhidg h}
88%[gg[ B K K K#H$H Ra}g a Kaebmgekg1 Bdaynmh{ Zwidnk Ygkaym{ Dhv hem }og 9:::Zyg{nmge}nhd Gdgk}nae Ygkawe}{< Kawdm n} Ohzzge ne he~ A}ogy [}h}g1$ 8; W% Bdh% L%D% " Zwi% Zad~ 8;7$ 86#? /8./ | # .% [ $ |
% Nm% 87%8% E% % Gdgk% Dhv ;# % O$
` % [gg$ g%f%$ Ne yg Ihy#yg}}$ E%^%[% 67$ 66 /E%^% H% M% 8>. /] $ ay }og zwyza{g a wyen{onef }a h khemnmh}g %. / .%
8;% Eaymge g} hd%$ {wzyh 8$ 2%8% H E ^` % N
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
47/50
MG[NFE MGBNKNGEKNG[ HEM DA[ RAG[ t 8
E ` K$ ;$ 2$ % H E ^`K % W % < 8?$7 7$ %
87% H $ 6$2 E ^`K 8 %
82% E K I K 0 % A $ % G$ C V %
86% W%[% Gdgk}nae H{{n{}hekg Kacce$ 9::= Gdgk}nae Mh~ [wyrg~ Ygzay} Argyra}g{ hem Wemgyra}g{ ?#8$ hrhndhidgh}
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
48/50
t IYGEEHE KGEGY BAY LW[NKG
;;% N 7$ $ E ^` K$ % V E ^` K % ] $ ; E ^`
8 8 K %
;%[ggF @$H [adw}nae }a }og Gkadafnkhd Negygekg Zyaidgc< Ygkae{}ywk}nef Nemnrnmwhd Igohrnay yac Hffygfh}g Mh}h$Zynekg}ae WZ /8>>6.%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
49/50
EGV " BAY]OKACNEF IYGEEHE KGE]GY ZWIDNKH]NAE[
]g Ka{} a Ra}gy N%M% Dhv{< Voh} }og Kawy}{ [h~R H`$ V V$ H [`
Ygmwknef Argykdh{{nbkh}nae ]yawfo Hkkawe}hindn}~G| F M C% [
H Cgmnh Fwnmg }a Ygmn{}ynk}nefG` V C Z|
Yg}one`nef Yhmnkhdn|h}naeB| Z
Zyaca}nef Bhny " Nczhy}nhd Kawy}{ ]yawfo Ygkw{hd Ygayc
H [` H [
Cghenefwd G}onk{ Ygayc ay }og Egv Hdihe~D E$ @ V$ L
Caeg~$ Zadn}nk{$ hem }og Kae{}n}w}nae< Ig~aem Kn}n|ge{ Wen}gmG C ^
Macg{}nk Ne}gddnfgekg< Egv Zavgy{$ Egv Yn{`{G I
H Ygzay} Khym ae Egv ay { Knrnk Dn}gyhk~G D C I
yhe{zhyge} Gdgk}nae{ h}gy Kn}n|ge{ Wen}gmK #[
Kyncnehd Lw{}nkg Mgi}< H Ihyyngy }a Ygge}y~H I$ C E$ Y` M
B $ %%
7/31/2019 Design Deficiencies and Lost Votes
50/50
h} Egv ^ay` Wenrgy{n}~ [koaad a Dhv