Derrick's Opposition to Demurrer

8/11/2019 Derrick's Opposition to Demurrer

1/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

DERRICK HOGANS9107 s. La Salle AveLos A!eles" CA. 90047#214$ 374%1476&la'(')) ' &*o &e*

SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA

FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

DERRICK HOGANS"

&LAIN+I,,"

-s.

CHILDRENS INS+I+/+E ESSICAOHNSON /D G/AN RA/L,ONSECA a DOES 1%20"

DE,ENDAN+S.

$ Case No C534169$$ Hoo*ale$$$ PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO$ DEFENDANTS DEMURRER TO

COMPLAINT$$ Time: 8:30 a.m.$ Date:$ Dept.:$

23

24

25

26

27

28

&la'(')) e*e: s;la:s Ca='(al Real Es(a(e" I>

??a Ho


2/34

N+I,,SOSI+ION +O /.S.

ANK ARCLASDE/RRER +O 3RD AENDED CO&LAIN+% 1 %


3/34

1

2

3

I. INTRODUCTION . . .

TALE OF CONTENTS

.!

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

II. STATEMENT OF FACTS. . . . "

III. ARGUMENT. . . . . . 8

A. PLAINTIFF HAS ADE#UATELY PLEAD EACH AND E$ERY CAUSE

OF ACTION . . . . . .8

%. P&ai'ti( Ha) State* Ca+)e) ,- Ati,' -,/ Ne&ie'e1 F/a+*a'*

/ea2 ,- t2e Imp&ie* C,e'a't ,- G,,* Fait2 a'* Fai/ Dea&i'aai')t

De-e'*a't). . . . 8

4. P&ai'ti( P/,pe/&5 A&&ee* Ca+)e) ,- Ati,' a)e* ,'De-e'*a't)

$i,&ati,') ,- Ca&i-,/'ia Cii& C,*e 64743.! . . . . .%0

3. P&ai'ti( Ha) P/,pe/&5 A&&ee* Ca+)e) ,- Ati,' a)e* ,'

De-e'*a't) $i,&ati,') ,- Ca&i-,/'ia Cii& C,*e 6 4743.". . . . .%%

. P&ai'ti( Ha) P/,pe/&5 A&&ee* Ca+)e) ,- Ati,' P+/)+a't t,

Ca&i-,/'ia +)i'e)) a'* P/,-e))i,') C,*e Seti,' %9!00 a'* %9400.. . . %3

!. P&ai'ti( Ha) P/,pe/&5 A&&ee* a Ca+)e ,- Ati,' -,/ #+iet Tit&e

a)e* ,' t2e I'a&i*it5 ,- t2e F,/e&,)+/e Sa&e. . . . . .%9

". T2e Te'*e/ R+&e D,e) N,t App&5 He/e. . . . ..%8

I$. CONCLUSION . . . . . %7

&LAIN+I,,

S O&&OSI+ION +O /.S. ANK ARCLAS

DE/RRER +O 3RD AENDED CO&LAIN+% 2 %


4/34


5/34

,/)1 I'. .e)BMi//,/#1980$ 102 Cal. 3 735" 740..........................................................

5

,/p,/ate* .

,*)#1927$ 202675" 677%678"&. 302 ......................................................

p&e .

a

'a

a&e)e

't H,me)1 I'. #1984$ 159 Cal. A==. 3 509" 530 ...... 15

Ri&e)) . Temp&e #1970$ 4 Cal. A==. 3 869" 84 Cal. R=(*. 828 ...

............................................................

.. 9

Sa+'*e/) . S+pe/i,/ C,+/t#1994$ 27 Cal. A==. 4( 832" 838%39............... 14

State Fa/m Fi/e ? Ca)+a&t5 C,. . S+pe/i,/ C,+/t #1996$ 45 Cal. A==. 4(1093"1104.... 15

&LAIN+I,,S O&&OSI+ION +O /.S. ANK ARCLASDE/RRER +O 3RD AENDED CO&LAIN+% 3 %


6/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Stat+te)

Cal')o*'a ;s'ess a &*o)ess'os Coe Se>('o

17200... Cal')o*'a C'v'l Coe Se>('o 2923.5...

Cal')o*'a C'v'l Coe Se>('o 2923.6...

S 1137...

.. 13, 14, 15, 16, 17

. 10, 11, 13, 17

. 11, 12, 13, 17

... 11, 12, 13

% 4 %


7/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES

I. INTRODUCTION

I a >lass'> (ae%(e%e'al (*asa>('os (a( o( ol: =*eve(e

&la'(')) )*o< e'! ale (o *e)'a>e (e loa" ;( )*o< eve e'! ale (o *easoal:

as>e*(a' B'( Bo< e Bas s;==ose (o e eal'! B'(. Iev'(al: a =*e'>(al:"

&la'(')) los( 's olos;*e.

As a >ose@;e>e o) (e B*o!);l >o;>( a =*ea(o*: le'! =*a>('>es o) (e

De)ea(s" ''v';all: a a>('! ' >o>e*(" &la'(')) Bas e=*'ve o) 's a'l'(: (o

=;*>ase a oess

*;''! 's >*e'( s(a'! : Ba: o) a o%;'>'al )o*e>los;*e B'> B'll (ae '< :ea*s (o

*e=a'*" (e*e:

e))e>('vel: =*eve('! &la'(')) )*o< e'! ale (o =;*>ase a o>oeee : Ba: o) a >o:" a *ea>es o) (e !ee*al e!l'!e>e ;('es o) ;e >a*e a ;e 'l'!e>e"

(e )';>'a*: ;(: o) (*;s( a >o)'e>e e's('! e(Bee )'a>'al 's('(;('os a (e'*

>;s(o


8/34



9/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

'le (e s>eovol;(e a >oo;l o( *e=a:. e (e 'ev'(ale a

=*e'>(ale

*es;l( o) (a( ove**ea>'!" ;s>*;=;lo;s >o;>( (e >a'al Se*v'>es" L(. #LIEF$" a s;s''a*:

o) De)ea( C*e'( S;'sse #CSF$" e!a!e ' a ;s'ess =*a>('>e o) l: ;le (e loas ' =ools a ;loa (e< (o 'ves(o*s o

'(e*a('oal

se>;*'('es ;l('va(e a >a*e o) e*s Bo Bo;l ;le (e loas '(o e se>;*'('es so (a( (e loas Bo;l

e

'a Bas

'ev'(ale.


10/34

I

:

a*:

7"

('))

*es=oe (o sol'>'(a('os : LEGEND (o e!a!e '(s

se*v'>es (o =*o>;*e a oa(e a( 5148

7(

Ave;e" Los A!eles" Cal')o*'a 90043 #(e S;e>( &*o=e*(:F$. LEGEND '*e>(e '< (o

&LAIN+I,,

S O&&OSI+ION +O /.S. ANK ARCLAS

DE/RRER +O 3RD AENDED CO&LAIN+% 6 %


11/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

s'! a os's('! o) a 80 )'*s( +*;s(

Dee?o*(!a!e

a a ='!!:a>e 20 se>o +*;s( Dee?o*(!a!e. 'le (e sale a loa a==l'>a('o

Be*e

=e'!" LEGEND e (e =*o=e*(: a( a loBe* )'e *a(e B'(' s' ;la*l: ' l'!(

o) (e

=*e=a:( )o* (e )'*s( (*ee :ea*s o) (e loas. He (;s Bas (*a==e '(o

(Bo '!%'(e*es( *a(e loas (a( >o;l o( e *e)'a>e as =*o>o*a>e B'( (e ove*all s>e


12/34

/.S.

NK" N.A

S.

NKF$

e>('vel:

**e (o

' as

De)ea(sF$" e>a'! A!*eee Se>;*'('es +*;s( 2007%HE1

o*(!a!e &ass +*o;! Ce*(')'>a(es Se*'es 2007%HE%1. I( 's =*ese(l: ;oB (o &la'('))

Be(e* (e o%;'>'al )o*e>los;*e ;=o 's o;(e : HOEJ o*

/.S.ANK.



13/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

I De)ea(sDe a >o=: o) (e a>(;al

No(e.

Is(ea" De)ea(s *e@;es( ;'>'al o('>e o) (e Dee o) +*;s( a a I(e*es( Ol: &e*'o

,'e?A;s(ale Ra(e R'e*" o( o) B'> *e)e*e>e a se=a*a(e No(e" (e o*'!'al o) B'>

a==a*e(l: as o( ee ass'!e (o a 's o( ' (e =ossess'o o) De)ea(s. A>>o*'!l:"

(e )o*e>los;*e o) (e S;e>( &*o=e*(: Bas 'ale laB.

De)ea( /.S. ANK ;l('ase (e &*o=e*(: )o* 268"000. eaB'le"

De)ea(s ase ao(e* o('o" &la'('))"

o

eal) o) ' as B*eae avo> o (e /'(e S(a(es e>oo


14/34


15/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

laB *e!a*'! >'v'l >os='*a>: a o'( ve(;*es. S=e>')'>all:" ' =a*a!*a= 12" &la'(')) alle!es

(a(

Ea> o) (e De)ea(s aos='*a(o* o* :" (e Cal')o*'a S;=*e: a*e

(e )o*os='*a>: a ae o) (e >o('o (e : l'es ' (e )a>( (a( '(*ee*s ea> =a*('>'=a( ' (e B*o!);l a>( *es=os'le as a o'( (o*()easo* )o* all

a('ve o) Be(e* o* o( e Bas a '*e>(a>(o* a *e!a*less o) (e e!*ee o) 's a>('v'(:.F

D,t,/) C,. . S+pe/i,/ C,+/t#1989$ 49 Cal.3 39" 44" 260 Cal. R=(*. 183" 775 &.2

508 #>'('! M, I',/p,/ate* . ;,,*)#1927$ 202 Cal. 675" 677%678" 262 &. 302$.

A'('oall:" a o'( ve(;*e 's a ;e*(a'! : (Bo o* (;al @;es('o (o e e(e*(. I*.

A>>o*'!l:" (e 'ss;e >ao( e

a;'>a(e (*o;! ('s ee o) oe o'( ve(;*e* 's '


16/34

s"

*e oe

o'( ve(;*e*" a>('! B'(' (e s>o=e o) (e o'( ve(;*e" a ' );*(e*a>e o) '(s



17/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

a!*ee =;*=ose" 's !;'l(: o) )*a; ' =*o>;*'! ee)'(s (a( a*e *e(a'e : (e o'( ve(;*e*s" all

a*e l'ale )o* (e )*a; ' >o:.

Ri&e)) . Temp&e#1970$ 4 Cal. A==. 3 869" 84 Cal. R=(*. 828.

He*e" De)ea(s a*e a( (e (a'l e o) (e o'( ve(;*e?>os='*a>:. HoBeve*"

&la'(')) as alle!e (a( (e: ave o(a'e (e ee)'(s o) (e o'( ve(;*e?>os='*a>: a

'*e>(l: =a*('>'=a(e. +e*e)o*e" (e: a*e o( 'la'< a!a's( lee* *ea> o) )';>'a*: ;(: a )*a;$. Cose@;e(l:" &la'('))s >o('o 2923.5#a$. HoBeve*" &la'(')) a*!;es (a( sa' =*ov's'o oes o( a==l: a (a(

Se>('o 2923.5#>$ a==l'es 's(ea. HoBeve*" ass;la'$

as Bell.

Se>('o 2923.5#>$ =*ov'es" ' =e*('e( =a*(" (a(

#>$ I) a ('o 2924)" '>l;e a

e>la*a('o (a( e'(e*

#1$ S(a(es (a( (e o**oBe* Bas >o(a>(e (o assess (e o**oBe*s )'a>'als'(;a('o a (o e=lo*e o=('os )o* (e o**oBe* (o avo' )o*e>los;*e.

#2$ L's(s (e e))o*(s o(a>( (e o**oBe* ' (e eve( o >o(a>(Bas


18/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

(e (*;( o) (e s(a(eo(a'e (e*e' 's '**eleva(. S;> '(e*=*e(a('o 's as;*.

He*e" &la'(')) as >lea*l: alle!e (a( De)ea(s ' o( >o('o 2923.5. +a( 's" De)ea(s ' o( e!o('a(e a loa a('o '

!oo )a'( a ' o( assess &la'('))s )'a>'al s'(;a('o a e=lo*e o=('os (o avo'

's>los;*e. See

&la'('))s +'* Aoe>('o B'( Se>('os

2923.5 a 2923.6 eve (o;! (e*e 's o a==ella(e >ase o =o'(. Neeless (o sa:" oe o)

(e >ases >'(e : De)ea(s 's ''! a;(o*'(: o ('s >o;*(.

Se>('o 2923.6 Bas s=e>')'>all: >*ea(e (o a*ess (e )o*e>los;*e >*'s's a

el= o**oBe*s. As o(e ' Se>('os 1 a 10 o) (e Le!'sla('ve I(e( e' (e

S(a(;(e"

SEC+ION 1. +e Le!'sla(;*e )'s a e>la*es all o) (e )olloB'!

#a$ Cal')o*'a 's )a>'! a ;=*e>ee(e (*ea( (o '(s s(a(e e>ooale>oolos;*e *a(es 'Cal')o*'aP

#!$ +'s a>( 's e>essa*: (o avo' ;e>essa*: )o*e>los;*es o) *es'e('al=*o=e*('es a (e*e: =*ov'e s(a'l'(: (o Cal')o*'as s(a(eB'e a *e!'oale>oo( a >oo;l avo' )o*e>los;*e a : )a>'l'(a('! (ea('o o* *es(*;>(;*'! o) loas ' a==*o=*'a(e >'*>;es.F


19/34

SEC+ION

10. #a$ +'s a>( 's a ;*!e>: s(a(;(e e>essa*: )o* (e '


20/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

=*ese*va('o o) (e =;l'> =ea>e" eal(" o* sa)e(: B'(' (e leI- o) (e Cos('(;('o a sall !o '(o imme*iatee))e>(. +e )a>(s >os('(;('!(e e>ess'(: a*e

I o*e* (o s(a'l'e a =*o(e>( (e s(a(e a lo>al e>oo( (o (ae e))e>('lea*l: 'll;s(*a(es (a( (e Cal')o*'a Le!'sla(;*e Bas s=e>')'>all: loo'! (o

>;* )o*e>los;*es a =*ov'e a('os (o o('o 2923.6" B'> Bas ' e))e>( a( (e ('los;*e a( 'ss;e"

=*ov'es (a( se*v'>'! a!e(s )o* loa =ools oBe a ;(: (o all =a*('es ' (e =ool so (a( a

Bo*o;( o* a('o 's ' (e es( '(e*es(s o) (e =a*('es ') (e loa 's ' e)a;l( o* e)a;l(

's *easoal: )o*eseeale" a (e *e>ove*: o (e Bo*o;( e>ees (e a('>'=a(e *e>ove*:

(*o;! a )o*e>los;*e ase o (e >;**e( val;e o) (e =*o=e*(:.

+;s" Cal')o*'a C'v'l Coe 2923.6#a$ s=e>')'>all: >*ea(es a eB ;(: o( =*ev'o;sl:

a*esse ' =ool'! a se*v'>'! a!*ee a ;(: o( ol: a==l'es (o

(e =a*('>;la* =a*('es o) (e loa =ool" ;( (o all =a*('es. +e*e)o*e" ;e* (e (e( o) (e

s(a(;(e" ') a ;(: e's(s ' (e =ool'! a se*v'>'! a!*ee('o )o* o**oBe*s.F De)ea(sDe


21/34



22/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

C,+'t/5( Co;*( >ases" B'> a*e o( ''! ;=o

('s >o;*(.

o*eove*" (e *easo'! o) (e >ases" C,'',/)' =a*('>;la*" s;))e*s )*o< a se*'o;s

)laB. o( Fa/'e/ a C,'',/)>o>l;e (a( se>('o 2923.6 oes o( >*ea(e a =*'va(e

*'!( o) a>('o )o* o**oBe*s. +e C,'',/)>o;*( !oes o (o >o>l;e (a( (e Le!'sla(;*e

' o( '(e (o

>*ea(e s;> a =*'va(e *'!( e>a;se aM s(a(;(e >*ea(es a =*'va(e *'!( o) a>('o ol: ') (e

ea>('! o: so '(ee.F C,'',/)1 )+p/a1 2009 L 1615989 a( 8. HoBeve*" ' ('s

>o(e(" s;> a asse*('o : (e C,'',/)>o;*( e))e>('vel: *es;l(s ' ;'>'al ;ll')'>a('o.

As a =*'va(e *'!( o) a>('o 's (e ol: *easoale e)o*>e'(e aove ''>a(es. +e Le!'sla(;*e '(ee (a( *e@;'*'! ea*l: >o(a>(

a >oo;l avo' )o*e>los;*e a : )a>'l'(a('! (e a('o

o* *es(*;>(;*'! o) loas ' a==*o=*'a(e >'*>;es.F S 1137" Se>('o 1" s;. #!$. +;s"

a =*'va(e *'!( o) a>('o e's(s ;e* Se>('o 2923.6. Al(e*a('vel:" as &la'('))s >la'>o*'!l:" &la'('))s alle!a('os a >la'a('o o) Cal')o*'a ;s'ess a


23/34



24/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

&*o)ess'os #&F$ Coe Se>('o 17200" et )e." (o (e ;s'ess =*a>('>es o) s;=*';se((s

S;=*ee(l: ;e*(oo a (o*o;! a =e*s;as've aal:s's o) '(s >os;('o s(a(;(es >losel: =a*allel'! Cal')o*'as Se>('o 17200 ' (e >o(e( o) a

al (o (a( 'volve e*e. & 17200 =*ov'es '

);ll as )olloBs

As ;se ' ('s >a=(e*" ;)a'* >oe a ;)a'*" e>e=('ve ;(*;e o*essa*: (o es(al's

a v'ola('o o) & 17200 et )e." 's (o soB (a( (e e)ea( 's a ;s'ess e!a!e '

a>(s o* =*a>('>es (a( a*e ;laB);l" )*a;;le( o* ;)a'*. +;s" (e*e a*e (*ee va*'e('es o)

;)a'*

>o('>es B'> a*e ;laB);l" ;)a'* o* )*a;;le(.F Da+2e/t5 .

Ame/ia' H,'*a M,t,/ C,.1 I'. #2006$ 144 Cal. A==. 4( 824" 837 #2006$. +e

;laB);l =*a>('>es =*o''(e : (e s(a(;(e a*e a: =*a>('>es )o*'e : laB" e '( >'v'l o*

>*''=al" s(a(;(o*:" *e!;la(o*:" o* >o;*( essa*: (a( (e =*e'>a(e laB =*ov'e )o* =*'va(e >'v'l

e)o*>e a*e l'el: (o

e e>e've. a' ,- t2e ;e)t . S+pe/i,/ C,+/t#1992$ 2 Cal.4(1254" 1267.

He*e" De)ea(s e!a!e ' a >o'al ee)'(. As =a*( o) ('s s>eeee : Ba: o) )*a;" e>e'("


25/34

>es o)



26/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

!ee*al e!l'!e>e ;('es o) ;e >a*e a ;e 'l'!e>e" (e )';>'a*: ;(: o) (*;s( a

>o)'e>e e's('! e(Bee )'a>'al 's('(;('os a (e'* >;s(o('>es a*e '!l: l'el: (o e>e've.F

+e ;)a'*F =*o! o) se>('o 17200 '(e('oall: =*ov'es >o;*(s B'( *oa

's>*e('o (o =*o''( eB s>e('>e o* a>( 's ;)a'*F Be '(

o))es a es(al'se

=;l'> =ol'>: o* Be (e =*a>('>e 's 'os;es" '>l;'! #1$ ';>'! &la'(')) (o o(a' a *'s: o e 's loa B'(' s' ;*e a

loBe* '(e*es( *a(e a a))o*ale ('os o))es es(al'se =;l'> =ol'>: a 's 'os;o


27/34


28/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

17200 (o (e ea*l: 'e('>al s>eo>l;s'o e*e. e:o (a(" oBeve*" &la'(')) alle!es a val' >la'< ;e* (e

;laB);lF =*o! o) 17200 as Bell as (e ;)a'*essF =*o!.

e>a;se (e ,*e(s a*e 'e('>al (o (e )a>(s a( a" '( 's Bo*( eval;a('! (e;='e ooa*: o(*a>(o*s Bo;l el= ao**oBe* sele>( a (" a >oo;(ee>;('ve (o *e@;es( a sele>(e =*o;>( a =*ov'e (e o**oBe*s loa a==l'>a('oa >*e'( *e=o*(. I) a==*ove : ,*eee oe%al) (e'* '>oe(. os( s;> )'a>'! Basa>>o'! a a a'('oal T='!!:%a> loaT =*ov''! (Be(: =e* >e(.F



29/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

F/em,'t1 )+p/a" a( ==. 735%739.

/e* assa>;se((s G.L. >. 93A 2" (e (*'al >o;*( )o;" a (e S;=*eo)'*es a( a Be*e 'ee ;)a'*.F +e >o;*( s(a(e

(e *e>o* e*e s;!!es(s (a( ,*ee e)o*e (e e o) (e '(*o;>(o*: =e*'o. +;s" ,*e('os Be*e

;*easoale" a ;)a'* (o (e o**oBe*PF

+e saa;se (e: ' o( (;al os='*a>:. See

I' /e C,+'t/5la'< so;l o( e

's


30/34

&la'(')

s alle!e

(e

al

=*o;**e(l: oB Bo

el



31/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

(e *es=e>('ve o>;lose" ;less (e ole* o) (eee o) (*;s( 's (e a!e( o) (e ole* o) (e o(e. C'(a('o o: *ela('os'=" (e =e*so ol'! ol: (e o(e la>s (e =oBe* (o )o*e>lose' (e eve( o) e)a;l(. +e =e*so ol'! ol: (e ee o) (*;s( B'll eve*e=e*'e>e e)a;l( e>a;se ol: (e ole* o) (e o(e 's e('(le (o =a:Be Loa Se*v'>'!" LLC" 284 S..3 619" 623 #o. A==. 2009$.F

La'*ma/1 )+p/a1 40 Ka. A==. 2 325 #2008$ #'(e*al @;o(a('o ases )o* (e =*o=os'('o (a( &la'(')) 's *e@;'*e (o (ee* (e

aases a*e

's('!;'sale as &la'(')) 's o( a ;'o* l'eole* ;( *a(e* (e (*;s(o*. o*eove*" '

M+'e/ . M,,/e#1970$ 11 Cal. A==. 3 1" 7" (e >o;*( el (a( (a( a (*;s(ee o*


32/34

a'e '

o*(!a!e

o* ee o) (*;s(.F S'


33/34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

)*a;;le(. +e >o;*( ' M+'e/(;all: 's('!;'sale" M+'e/!ove*s ('s >ase. +e*e)o*e" (e (ee* *;le oes o(

a==l:.

I-. CONCL/SION

,o* all o) (e )o*e!o'! *easos" &la'(')) *es=e>();ll: *e@;es(s (a( ('s Co;*(

ove**;le De)ea(sDe();ll: *e@;es(s leave o) >o;*( (o a


34/34

N+I,,SOSI+ION +O /.S.K

ARCLASDE/RRER +O 3RD AENDED CO&LAIN+% 19 %

Documents

Derrick's Opposition to Demurrer