Democratic Centralism Lassallean

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/26/2019 Democratic Centralism Lassallean

    1/2

    Democratic Centralism

    posted to www.marxmail.orgon October 30, 2003

    The best discussion of democratic centralism I!e e!er seen is in chapter se!en of "aul

    #e$lancs %#enin and the &e!olutionar' "art'%. (e explains that the term predates #enin b'man' 'ears and was first used in )*+ b' -.$. chweit/er, a #assallean.

    urthermore, in &ussia it was first used b' the 1enshe!is at a o!ember )40 conference.

    In a resolution %On the Organi/ation of the "art'% adopted there, the' agree that %The &D#"

    must be organi/ed according to the principle of democratic centralism.% 5 month later the

    $olshe!is embraced the term at their own conference. 5 resolution titled %On "art'

    Organi/ation% states6 %&ecogni/ing as indisputable the principle of democratic centralism, the

    Conference considers the broad implementation of the electi!e principle necessar'7 and,

    while granting elected centers full powers in matters of ideological and practical leadership,

    the' are at the same time sub8ect to recall, their actions are gi!en broad publicit', and the' are

    to be strictl' accountable for these acti!ities.%

    There is !irtuall' no difference between the 1enshe!is and the $olshe!is about the need

    for democratic centralism or its meaning. o claims that the two factions differed o!er this

    %#eninist% organi/ational breathrough are simpl' mistaen. 1oreo!er, the two groups had

    resol!ed man' outstanding differences following the )40 re!olution. 1enshe!i

    leader "a!el 5xelrod stated that %on the whole, the 1enshe!i tactics ha!e hardl' differed

    from the $olshe!i. I am not e!en sure that the' differed from them at all.% #enin concurred6

    %The tactics adopted in the period of the whirlwind did not further estrange the two wings of

    the ocial Democratic "art', but brought them closer together9The upsurge of the

    re!olutionar' tide pushed aside disagreements, compelling the ocial Democrats to adopt

    militant tactics.%

    In an' case, whate!er differences would resurface in the period leading up to )4):,

    %democratic centralism% was not one of them. 5t a unit' conference held in )40+, the

    $olshe!is and 1enshe!is !oted for a resolution that stated6 %5ll part' organi/ations are

    built on the principles of democratic centralism%.

    The report on the commission that adopted this resolution was gi!en b' a

    1enshe!i, ;agors'ue which is online at6

    http6@@www.marxists.org@archi!e@luxemburg@)40?@>uestions

  • 7/26/2019 Democratic Centralism Lassallean

    2/2

    recall -ames ". Cannon e!er fa!oring this practice, despite being committed to the sort of

    democratic centralism that e!ol!ed under ;ino!ie!s authorit'.

    ot that #uxemburg is opposed to centralism itself. he is not a oucauldian. Bhen it taes

    shape from the self