Deferred items of 235th meeting - SRC - National Council …srcncte.in/Decisions and Minutes 2010-13/Minutes/Minutes... · Web viewNo Code Course Name of the Institution State Remarks

236 th Meeting of SRC 16th –18th December, 2012

SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEENATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION

BANGALORE

Minutes of the 236th Meeting of SRC held at the

Conference Hall of NCTE, Bangalore on 16-18th December, 2012

The following members attended the Meeting :-

1. Sathyam I.A.S (Retired) - Chairman

2 Prof. K. Dorasami - Member 3. Dr. M.P. Vijayakumar I.A.S(retired) - Member

4. Prof. Sandeep Ponnala - Member

5. Prof. M.S. Lalithamma - Member

6. Famida Rahim (Karnataka) - Representative

(Deputy Director)

7. K.A. Hashim (Kerala) - Representative Director SCERT

8. Sri. P. Sriraman - Convenor Regional Director (I/c)

The following members/Representative could not attend the Meeting

Prof. M.A. Khader. Member and the Representatives of the Andhra

Pradesh, Tamilnadu, U.T’s of Lakshadweep, Pondicherry & Andaman

& Nicobar Islands.

(S.Sathyam) Chairman

1


SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEENATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION

BANGALOREMINUTES OF 236 th MEETING OF SRC-NCTE

Sl.No.

Brief Description Remarks of SRC

1. Confirmation of Minutes of 235th Meeting held on 21st – 22nd November, 2012

Confirmed2. Action Taken Report (ATR) on the

Minutes of 234th Meeting held on 17th-18th

October, 2012 Noted

Report of the Bangalore University Task Force – B.Ed colleges in Karnataka

3. --B.Ed

KarnatakaReport of

the Bangalore University, Task Force on Teacher Education relating to

B.Ed Colleges

KA

Presentation made by Chairman of the Bangalore Universities Task Force. SRC appreciated the initiative; and, observed that it could be developed and projected as a ‘Model’ for other Universities in the Region to follow.

University should consider action to disaffiliate. After receipt of formal communication from the University., through the State Govt., process for Show Cause Notice to the institutions. The procedure to be adopted in this regard by the Southern Regional Committee should be carefully decided. The implications of the recent Supreme Court order about the scope of inspections by Regional Committees for derecognition will have to be crefully analysed.

Fix interaction with the Vice-Chancellor during the next meeting.

Innovative courses – B.Sc.Ed, M.P.Ed and M.T.E

4. ----

Norms and Standards for

Four-Year Integrated Bachelor of

Science Education (BScEd)

Programme

The committee considered the matter and Norms and Standards developed by the Sub-Committee for three innovative courses were approved. Upload on website for general information. Send copies for information to NCTE (HQ). Send copies to the applicant institutions; and, cause inspection under these Norms/Standards.

5. ----



2


Five-Year Integrated Masters of

Physical Education

Programme leading to Master of Physical

Education (M.P.Ed-

Integrated)Degree

6. ----


Master in Education

Programme leading to Master of Teacher

Education (M.T.E) degree

Consideration of Show Cause Notice reply (Volume- 01)

Sl.No

CodeCourse

Name of the Institution

State

Remarks of SRC

7. SRCAPP575D.El.Ed

Gnanodaya College of

Elementary Education,

Karimnagar District

AP

Gnanodaya College of Elementary Education Metpally, Khasra No. 1338/a, 1st Street Metpally Village, Metpally Post Office, Metpally Taluka, Metpally Town, Karimnagar District, Andhra Pradesh 505325.

Gnanodaya Educational Society Metpally, 1-10- 301/1 , Vidyanagar , Near Court , Metpally Village , Metpally Post Office , Metpally Taluka , Metpally Town , Karimnagar District , Andhra Pradesh 505325 had applied for grant of recognition to Gnanodaya College of Elementary Education Metpally , Khasra No. 1338/a , 1st Street Metpally Village , Metpally Post Office , Metpally Taluka , Metpally Town , Karimnagar District , Andhra Pradesh 505325 for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 21/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 23/09/2011

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 14/10/2011 followed by reminder on 06/01/2012. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 20/12/2011.

The institution has submitted reply for deficiency letter on 20/03/2012.

The institution has submitted reply for deficiency letter after the stipulated time of 60 days period as per clause 7 (1) of NCTE Regulations.


3


The Southern Regional Committee in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April, 2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 20/3/2012, i.e., after 90 (Ninty Six) days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide F.No.SRCAPP575 /D.EI.Ed/ AP/2012-2013/41896 dated 30/05/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-358/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting-2012 dated 05.09.2012 states that ‘the council concluded that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the case for consideration of reply submitted by the institution and for taking further decision thereafter’.

The institution has submitted a written representation on 14.09.2012.

In obedience to the Appellate Authority order dated 05.09.2012, the application is being processed

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 has considered the Appellate authority order dt. 05/09/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 30/10/2012. the institution has submitted written representation on 08/11/2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.08-11-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Cause inspection8. APS06188

B.EdA.C.T. College of Education,

Tiruvallur District

TN

A.C.T. College of Education, No.1, Ganapathy Street, Ayyanambakkam, Mogappair West Extension, Maduravoil Post, Tiruvallur District, Pin-600095, Tamilnadu.A.C.T. College of Education, No.1, Ganapathy Street, Ayyanambakkam, Mogappair West Extension, Maduravoil Post, Tiruvallur District, Pin-600095, Tamilnadu has submitted application for B.Ed course on 03.01.2005. The institution has been granted recognition for B.Ed on 03.02.2007 with an intake of 100 students with the condition to shift to its own premises within 3 years from the date of recognition.

The institution has submitted D.D. no.996527 dated 14.07.2011 for Rs.40,000/- towards processing fees for shifting the premises.

The SRC in its 211th meeting held on 21st-23rd September, 2011 considered the written reply and other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting inspection at the new premises and to ascertain


4


infrastructural and instructional facilities. Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 19.02.2012.

The SRC in its 224th meeting held on 14th-17th June 2012, considered the VTR, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 06.07.2012. The institution submitted its reply on 31.07.2012.

The SRC in its 230th meeting held on 16th-17th August, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 31.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 10.09.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 04.10.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 04.10.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

In the approved building plan submitted, total land area is not mentioned, the approval of the competent authority is pasted on the back side of the building plan, which is not permissible. The institution has not submitted blue print of the building plan duly approved by the competent authority.

The institution has submitted true copy of sale deed executed on 28.09.2005, where encumbrance certificate reflects from 01.01.2011 to 11.06.2012 executed by “Dena Bank” Chennai, which needs clarification.

Notarised Non-encumbrance certificate is submitted, but original Non-encumbrance certificate since 2005 is not submitted. Encumbrance certificate dt. 12.06.2012 reflects “Deeds of loan is repayable on demand”.

Revised original affidavit showing the built up area is not submitted.

As per Affidavit submitted dt. 23.07.2012, total built up area shown as 3023 sq.mtrs, whereas, as per building plan it is 4860 sq.mtrs, and also Sy.Nos are not tallying, which needs to be clarified.

Staff profile as per Annexure I,II & III along with Qualification certificates not submitted.

The institution has not submitted individual A/c Nos. of each staff for payment of salary.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available,


5


with no further notice.

9. SRCAPP1633D.El.Ed

Siddhartha Institute of

Teacher Education,

Kadapa District

AP

Siddhartha Institute of Teacher Education, Plot/Khasara No. 562, 512/2A, Talla Proddatur Village & Post, Kondapuram City and Taluk, Kadapa District -516474, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri P.C. Nagireddy Educational Society, Plot No. 5/148, Regadi Palle Road, Talla Proddatur Village & Post, Kondapuram Taluk, YSR district, Kadapa District- 516474, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri P.C. Nagireddy Educational Society, Plot No. 5/148, Street/Road. Regadi Palle Road, Talla Proddatur Village & Post, Kondapuram Taluk, Kadapa District-516474, Andhra Pradesh for D.EL.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 01.10.2011 and physical copy received on 07.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 03.11.2011/ 22.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 28.02.12

The SRC in its 220th Meeting of SRC held on 30th – 31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 28.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 22.05.2012.

The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days period.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 223rd meeting held on 29th -31st May 2012, considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 22/05/2012, i.e., after 25 (Twenty Five) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt. 27/04/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution on 27/06/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-375/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting-2012 dated 05.09.2012 states that ‘the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to SRC for consideration of Show Cause Notice Reply and taking further action.’


The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 has committee considered the Appellate authority’s order dt. 05-09-2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.


6


Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 30/10/2012. the institution has submitted written representation on 09/11/2012.



Vivekananda College of Education,

Narasampet, Warangal

DistrictAP

Vivekananda College of Education, Sri.Venkateshwara Educational Society, Plot No: 715/1,724/1, Narsampet, Warangal, Narasampet – 506132, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Venkateswara Educational Society, Warangal Road, 622, Narsampet - 506132Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Vivekananda College of Education, Plot No: 715/1,724/1, Narsampet, Warangal, Narasampet – 506132, Andhra Pradesh, for D.El.Ed Course for two years duration under Section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 01.10.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 07.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 07.11.2011. A reminder letter to the State Government was sent on 28.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 05.03.2012.

The SRC in its 221st held on 19th -20th April 2012, considered the reply of the institution dt. 05.03.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show cause Notice.

Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 15.05.2012. The institution submitted its reply on 22.05.2012.

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

Sale deed of land document dated 17.02.2012 is registered after the date of on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009

The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory and unconvincing.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 224 th Meeting held on 14th-17th June, 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.Accordingly, rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No.SRCAPP1695/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/43704 dated 11/07/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority order in its order No. F.No. 89-359/2012 Appeal / 8th Meeting – 2012 dated 18/09/2012 stated that “…the council


7


concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC with a direction to process the applications and to take the further decision thereafter”.

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 has considered the Appellate authority order dated.18/09/2012. and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 06/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 09/11/2012.


11. APS01346T.T.C

Dr. Ambedkar Memorial Teacher Training Institute, Thrissur

KL

Dr. Ambedkar Memorial Teacher Training Institute, T.J.A M Corporation Building 4th Floor, Kuruppam Road Junction Round South, Thrissur

Dr. Ambedkar Memorial Teacher Training Institute, T.J.A M Corporation Building 4th Floor, Kuruppam Road Junction Round South, Thrissur was granted recognition on 18.10.2004 for Elementary course of two years duration from the academic session 2004-05 with an annual intake of 50 students.

On 31.8.2009, the Government of Kerala made a complaint against Dr. Ambedkar Memorial Teacher Training Institute, T.J.A M Corporation Building 4th Floor, Kuruppam Road Junction Round South, Thrissur as below:-“Dr. Ambedkar Memorial Teachers Training Institute, T.J.A.M. Corporation Building, 4th floor, Kuruppam Road, Junction Round South, Thrissur has been granted recognition to start TTI vide order no. F.KL/ELE/N/125/SRO/NCTE/2004-05/8042 dated 18.10.2004.

The TTI is functioning at the above address. However, on receipt of widespread Complaints about the functioning and the qualification/eligibility of the principal and staff of the TTI, the District Collector, Thrissur and Additional District Magistrate visited the institution and verified the facts. The report amongst other things states that the Principal, Dr. B. Soman was unable to submit any testimonials to prove his Educational Qualification or teaching experience and the Educational qualification of the teacher who was conducting the class was mere TTC. It was also found that the institute was functioning in a narrow room without any facilities to accommodate more than 40 boys and girls. There were also other complaints regarding the functioning of the TTI.

An enquiry has also been conducted by the Deputy Director of Education (QIP)(copy enclosed) which also confirms gross violation of the NCTE norms. Accordingly, Government have issued instructions to allow the TTI to function from 2009-10 after inspecting that all the Government/NCTE norms have been fulfilled.

Hence, the Secretary, Government of Kerala had requested SRC-NCTE to inspect the institution and to take appropriate action as deemed fit, since NCTE is the competent authority to accord/withdraw recognition to the TTIs.”

A letter was already issued to the institution on 21.8.2007, requesting to submit


8


Rs. 40,000/- towards shifting fee, since the institution had completed three years in temporary premises from the date of grant of recognition. The institution submitted Rs. 40,000/- as inspection fee, which was taken into account on 8.10.2007. Again, one more letter was issued to the institution on 29.5.2009 regarding proposal for shifting the institution to the permanent building and asking them to submit essential documents for shifting of the institution. The institution submitted a written representation on 25.6.2009 stating that joint account of Rs. 5 lakhs and Rs. 3 lakhs is not submitted and also stating that some more works have to be completed for shifting and requested for four months time, till the end of October, 2009.

The institution was required to shift to new premises by end of session 2006-07. It has submitted inspection fee on 8.10.2007. The institution should have been caused inspection by the end of session 2006-07 which did not occur. After expiry of another two sessions even now, the institution, as per its letter is not prepared for shifting as some construction work is still going on.

The above matter was placed before 187th meeting of SRC held on 29-30 December, 2009 and the Committee considered the matter and decided to issue Show Cause Notice and Notice was issued to the institution on 5.2.2010 under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following reasons:-

1. The institution was required to shift to new premises by end of session 2006-07.

2. After end of the session, even now(after over two more years) not prepared to shift as some construction still going on.

The institution submitted reply to the Notice on 1.3.2010. The institution has stated that

“The complaint of Government of Kerala is based on the false report of the then Dy. Director of Education, Ayyanthole, Thrissur who has malice motive against this institution for not complying her vested interest. Another reference is that the District Collector, Thrissur had verified the facts of this institute. Actually the District collector had verified the C.H.M.K.M. PPTTI, Thrissur under the same charitable Society and sent a report about this institute mistakenly. The District Collector called us “Scheduled castes, the down trodden community”. This caused the enemity against him and hence not submitted any records called for by him for verification.

The statement showing the details of staff approved by the Director, SCERT, Thiruvananthapuram was forwarded to the NCTE regional office at Bangalore as soon as it was approved. A copy of the list is forwarded along with this. The staff mentioned in the statement were handling the classes at that time. But the space was insufficient as is reported by the then District Collector. We will shift this institute in a permanent building by 31-3-2010 and compliance report to the NCTE. As per para 6, a joint account each for Rs.5 lakhs and 3 lakhs were not operated. As per instruction a joint action of 5 lakhs was operated and the certificate to the effect was forwarded to the NCTE then and there. A copy of the certificate is enclosed herewith. But, there was no instruction of operation a joint account for Rs.3 lakhs. That 3 lakhs was used for the disbursement of salary staff and as such it was not possible to operate as joint account. A property of 1 acre 89 cents was purchased for the construction of institute building. But unfortunately the construction was held up as there was rock under the top soil. Now, that we have advanced for a land of 55 cents with a school building for 12 lakhs of rupees for the purchase of a total of 55 lakhs rupees. The rest of 43 lakhs of Rupees have to


9


be paid during march 2010. On 31 March 2010, 23 we will shift the institution to the permanent building.”

Again on 30.3.2011, the Manager of the institution had requested for renewal of recognition. The Manager of the institution had stated that “50 cents of land with spacious buildings were purchased for Rs.60 lakhs during July 2010 for housing Dr. Ambedkar Memorial Teacher Training Institute. The adjacent plot of 44 cents of land also advanced for the purchase of additional land for the Teacher Training Institute and has requested for visit to the institution.”

On 24.08.2011, the Manager had requested for renewal of recognition and had stated that “If the visit of new premises is very late, it is not possible to invite applications and admit the students this year. I therefore request the SRC may be pleased to arrange a visit to arrange a visit to the new premises as early as possible”.

On 28.11.2011, the Manager forwarded copy of receipt forwarding of proof of having Joint account of Endowment fund and Reserve fund and has requested to pay visit to the institute for approval of shifting the institute in permanent building.

As seen from the file, the representations of the institution were not placed before the Committee and inspection was not conducted.

The Manager of the institution vide letter dated 31.1.2012 stated that they are in a pathetic condition as the continuous sanction is not received and they wanted to withdraw the money deposited in two joint accounts.

The SRC in its 217th meeting held on 8th- 9th February 2012 considered the written reply dated. 9.3.2010 and other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting inspection at the new premises and to ascertain infrastructural and instructional facilities Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The committee also taken the decision of advising the VT to look into the complaint received from the Kerala Govt.

The SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May 2012 has considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 25.06.2012 .

The institution submitted its written representations on 06.07.2012,16.07.2012 ,01.08.2012 and 16.08.2012.was placed before 235th

meeting of SRC held onb 21-22nd November 2012. The committee deferred the matter. In addition to the above, the institution has submitted reply to the notice on 17/10/2012.

Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 17.10.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in joint name and in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given.

No documentary proof is submitted towards strengthening of Physical


10


Education lab, Computer lab.

The institution has not submitted any documentary proof to prove the rectification of infrastructural facilities.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

12. APS07263

B.EdKET College of Teacher Education, Kozhikode

KL

KET College of Teacher education, Kokkalur P.O., Balussery via, Kozhikode-673612, Kerala was granted recognition on 26.11.2007 with a condition to shift to its own premises within three years of grant of recognition(in case the course is started in rented premises) as per regulations, 2002 (notified on 18.11.2002).

The matter was placed before 176th meeting of SRC held on 27-28 May, 2009. The Committee decided to issue Notice to the institution and Notice was issued to the institution on 2.7.2009 under Section 17 of NCTE Act for not shifting to its own premises after the expiry of the period mentioned in the recognition order.

The institution has submitted an application along with DD of Rs.40,000/- for shifting of premises which has been taken into accounts vide Receipt No.15150 dated 9.3.2010. Thereafter, there was no action in the file. The file was not placed before the Committee.

The institution vide letter dated 1.1.2012 had requested for permanent recognition order and has requested for the inspection of the new building of KET College of Teacher Education.

The SRC in its 217th meeting held on 8th – 9th February 2012 considered the written reply dt. 9.3.2010 and other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting inspection at the new premises and to ascertain Infrastructural and instructional facilities Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

The SRC in its 217th meting held on 8th –9th February 2012 considered the VT report and VCD, and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act,

Accordingly, a Notice was issued to the institution on 25.06.2012.

The institution submitted reply vide letter dated 23.07.2012.


The land is in the name of Kerala Education Trust & not in the name of KET College of Teacher Education.


11


Building plan approved by the Government Engineer /Competent Civil Authority is not submitted.

Building Completion Certificate is not approved by the Government Engineer. Address mentioned in the Building Completion Certificate is not matching with that of land document.

A notarized land use certificate stating that land is converted for usage of non-agricultural/ Educational purposes is not submitted.

The institution has submitted an Encumbrance Certificate in Malayalam, English version of Encumbrance Certificate is not submitted by the institution.

Principal is not appointed on regular basis.

The institution has not submitted staff list approved by Calicut University.


13. APS02091B.Ed

Vivekananda College of Education, Bangalore

KA

Vivekananda College of Education, Dr. Raj Kumar Road, 2nd Stage, Rajajinagar, Bangalore-560055, KarnatakaJanatha Education Society’s Vivekananda College of Education, Dr. Raj Kumar Road, 2nd Stage, Rajajinagar, Bangalore-560055, Karnataka was granted recognition for B.Ed. course vide this office Order No.F.SRO/NCTE/B.Ed./2004-2005/8671 dated 25.11.2004 with a condition to shift to its own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide letter dated 8.12.2011 had requested for renewal of Fixed Deposit Receipts which expired on 17.6.2011.

On going through the file, it was seen that the institution was granted recognition in leased premises. From the Visiting team report dated 9.10.2004, it was observed that the management was offering MBA, P.G. Courses, Pharmacy College, Law College, Degree Colleges, Schools etc. The institution is also sharing the Labs. with some other College. As per MIS, the institution is not running any other course recognized with NCTE.

In order to ascertain the maintenance of extant, NCTE regulations, norms and standards of 2009 by the institution, a proposal was placed before SRC to get the institution inspected under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

The SRC in its 216th meeting of SRC held on 11th -12th January, 2012 considered the VT and VCD of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Notice was issued to the institution on14.3.2012. The institution


12


vide its letter dated. 30.3.2012 has submitted written representation

The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th –20th April 2012 considered the reply of the institution dated 30.03.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act and accordingly, a final show cause notice was issued to the institution on 21.05.2012.The institution submitted its reply vide letter dated 12.06.2012.


Certified / Notarized copy of land document is not submitted.

As per the copy of the building plan submitted, there are only two class rooms. Multipurpose hall, Science lab, Psychology lab,ET labs are not reflected in the building plan. Approval terms mentioned in the building plan says sanction is for G.F,F.F,S.F,T.F,F.F and Fifth Floor for commercial purpose only. Original approved blue print of the building plan is not submitted.

Building Completion Certificate is not approved by Government Engineer/Competent authority. As per copy of building plan and BCC the land area and built up area is not as per NCTE norms. As per NCTE norms, the institution should have land area of 2500 sq.mts and built up area of 1500 sq.mts for offering B.Ed course.

Latest approved staff list is not submitted.


14. APS01901B.Ed

K.K. College of Education, Bangalore

KA

K.K. College of Education, Vasanthpur Road, Konanakunte Cross, Bangalore-560062, KarnatakaK.K. Educational and Charitable Trust, No.19/1A, 11th K.M. Kanakapura Road, Konankunte Post, (Near Delhi Public School), Bangalore-560062, Karnataka had applied for grant of recognition to K.K. College of Education, Vasanthpur Road, Konanakunte Cross, Bangalore-560062, Karnataka for B.Ed Course of one year duration on 31.12.2003 and was granted recognition for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students vide order dated 29.11.2004. with the condition to shift to its own premises.

The institution vide letter dated 25.10.2007 had submitted a proposal for shifting of premises along with Rs.40, 000/- towards shifting fee. The inspectio n was carried out on 27th October 2010. The inspection report was received by this office on 29.10.2010 along with VCD.


13


The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November 2010 considered the VT report and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to issue show cause notice and a Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011 for the following reasons:-

The institution is functioning in a multistoried building which is being shared for running management and Commerce Colleges. This is a gross violation of norms on the part of the management to share with other colleges.

The affidavit is being signed by a different person and land area and Survey Nos are different.

The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer has not been submitted.

Rs. 5 Lakhs FDR expired on 13.10.2010. Fresh FDR for Rs. 5 lakhs to be submitted.

The institution submitted its written representation on 28.01.2011. The Committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February, 2011 considered the reply submitted by the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed. course (APS01901) with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed course, if any, to complete their course. Accordingly, order withdrawing recognition was issued to the institution vide its order no F.SRO/NCTE/2010-2011/27861 dated 25.03.2011.

Aggrieved by the withdrawal order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-248/2011 Appeal/5th Meeting-2011 A40540 dated 03.08.2011 the Council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and set aside SRC’s order dated 25.03.2011 with a direction to the SRC for re-consideration of the entire matter and taking decision thereafter. Accordingly, the appeal is accepted and the order of the SRC dated 25.03.2011 is reversed.

The SRC in its 210th meeting held on 22nd –23rd August, 2011 considered the Council directions Dt. 03.08.2011 and decided to process the application and the institution be directed to submit all the relevant original documents.

Accordingly, a letter was addressed to the institution on October 11, 2011 to submit the required essential documents as per regulations, 2009 in order to process the application. But, so far the institution has not submitted any representation.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th –10th May 2012 considered the matter and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution was directed to submit all the relevant original documents to SRC, vide our letter dt. October 11, 2011 for further processing of the application. But so far the institution has not replied for the same. So, once again the institution is directed to submit the same for further processing of the application as per the direction of Council direction vide letter dt. 03.08.2011.

The institution submitted reply vide letter dated 27.06.2012.The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 23.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

A copy of the lease deed is submitted. As per NCTE norms “ No building shall be taken on lease for running any teacher training course. The


14


society sponsoring the institution shall have to ensure that proposed teacher education institution has a well demarcated land area as specified by the norms. The teacher education institution shall not be allowed to have any other institution within its demarcated area or building and shall not have any other course(s) in its building.”

According to the lease deed submitted, the area of the property is 10,890 sq. ft. As per NCTE norms, for offering B.Ed course 1500 sq. mts of built up area and 2500 sq. mts of land area is required.”

BCC is not submitted.

Original FDR of Rs. 5 Lakh is not submitted. FDR of Rs. 3 lakhs (as per the photocopy submitted ) is not issued by a Nationalized Bank.

The land where the institution is functioning in the building is in the name of an individual, it should be in the name of trust or institution as per the norms



Haragopal College of

Diploma in Education, Srikakulam

DistrictAP

Haragopal College of Diploma in Education, Plot No.124/2 , Polaki Village and Post Office, Polaki Taluka and City, Srikakulam District, Andhra Pradesh.

Haragopal Educational Society, Plot No. 124/2, Polaki Road and Village, Polaki Post and Taluk, Srikakulam District –532429, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Haragopal College of Diploma in Education, Plot No.124/2, Polaki Village and Post Office, Polaki Taluka and City, Srikakulam District, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 1491) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 26.09.2011. The institution had submitted hard copy of the application on 29.09.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 17.10.2011. A reminder letter to the State Government was sent on 01.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 26.12.2011. The institution had replied to the deficiency letter on 01.03.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 221st Meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.01.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 16.05.2012.


15


The institution has submitted written representation on 30.05.2012.The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist under :

Sale deed of land document on Sy.No.124/2 registered on 03.10.2012, which is registered after on-line application submission, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

The institution in their reply to the show cause notice also admitted that, the land to an extent of 3.4 acres was owned by the Secretary Cum Correspondent as on the date of application, which is meant for the purpose of running Educational institution. The same documents (viz: Sale Deed No.1224/2008 dt. 30.06.2008 were submitted at the time of application), which clearly indicates that the land was in individual name at the time of on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009. As per Regulations 2009, rule 8 (7) (i) the land should be in the name of the Society/Institution at the time of on-line application.


The Southern Regional Committee in its 224th meeting held on 14th -17th June 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution on 11.07.2012 vide no. F.No.SRCAPP730(2021-130 D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/43685 dated 11.07.2012.Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No. 89-411/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting-2012 dated 05.09.2012 states that ‘the council concluded that there was no ground to accept the appeal. Accordingly, the appeal is rejected and SRC order dated 11.07.2012 is confirmed’.The institution moved to Hon’ble High Court in Writ Petition No. 28301 of 2012, W.P.M.P No.36084 of 2012 the judgment dated. 14.09.2012 reads as under:-

“……..the impugned orders of both the respondents are set aside. Respondent No. 2, (National Council for Teacher Education, Southern Regional Committee, Nagarbhavi, Bangalore.) is directed to reconsider the petitioners’ application for grant of recognition for commencement of D.El.Ed Course for the academic year 2012-13, treating petitioner No.1 – Society as the owner and possessor of the land in question as on the date of its application and pass a fresh order within two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order “.The Committee in its 234th Meeting held on 17th – 18th October, 2012 considered the Hon’ble High Court Order dt. 14-09-2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Sale deed of land document on Sy.No.124/2 registered on 03.10.2012, which is registered after on-line application submission, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal & rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.


16


Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 09.11.2012.On 12.11.2012, this office has received a letter from NCTE H’qrs stating the following:-“the case has not been handled properly by the office of SRC, NCTE as well as legal counsel at Hyderabad as the following facts have not been placed before the Hon’ble High Court:-

Appeate Authority at NCTE, New Delhi is empowered to decide the correctness of the orders issued by the Regional Committees of the NCTE. As per Section 18 of the NCTE Act the Council may confirm or reverse the order appeal4ed against. Further, as per judgement dated 11.01.2011 (already sent ot the SRC, NCTE) in W.P No. 128/2011, the Hon’ble High Court at Delhi clearly held that the subsequent events cannot be a ground for finding error with the orders of the Regional Committee but the same can be a ground for a fresh application.

No recognition can be granted for the session 2012-2013 after the cut of date i.e. 31.08.2012.

You are, therefore, requested to provide the facts in the matter and immediately file an Appeal before the Division Bench without any in order to avoid any further complications like contempt. Accordingly, a letter dated. 13.11.2012 has been sent to the Legal Counsel to file an appeal n the matter. In the mean while the institution has replied to Show Cause Notice on 16.11.2012.

The committee considered the matter and decided to instruct the Lawyer to obtain stay and file an appeal.


Dhanalakshmi D.Ed College,

Guntur District

AP

Dhanalaksmi D.Ed College, Plot No. 137, Main Road, Muppala Village and Post, Ipur Taluk, Guntur District – 522661, Andhra Pradesh.

Mam Memorial Service Society, Plot No. 137, Muppala Village and Post, Ipur Taluk, Guntur District – 522661, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Dhanalaksmi D.Ed College, Plot No. 137, Main Road, Muppala Village and Post, Ipur Taluk, Guntur District – 522661, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 27.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 18.10.2011/14.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 27.02.2012.

The SRC in its 220th Meeting of SRC held on 30th – 31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 27.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012.The institution has submitted its written representation on 30.04.2012.

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:1. Certified copy of the land document issued by Sub-registrar are not in favour of


17


Society/institution as per on-line application is not given.2. In the building plan submitted, location of the institution/proposed course is not

given.

Reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory & unconvincing.Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.The institution has approached to Hon’ble High Court in Writ Petition No. 23914 of 2012 in the matter of Mam Memorial Services Society, Guntur. The Hon’ble High Court has directed in the said matter that Respondent No. 2 is directed to depute a fresh inspection team to inspect the petitioners premises within two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and submit the inspection report to respondent No. 1 before which the petitioner appeal is pending. Respondent No.1 is directed to dispose of the appeal within two weeks from the date of receipt of the report from respondent No.2.As per direction of Hon’ble High Court the inspection has been caused on 03.09.2012. The SRC office sent the VTR to NCTE Hq on 07.09.2012.

The SRC in its 230th meeting held on 16th – 17th August 2012 considered the court direction and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

The SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show Cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 13.11.2012.

The committee considered the matter and decided to await Appellate authority order.


GSR D.El.Ed College, Kurnool District

AP

GSR D.El.Ed. College, Plot No. 312/1,167/a, 170, Street No.10/442, Chinthakuntla, Koilkuntla, Kurnool Dt.-518134, Andhra Pradesh.Gurusanjeevareddy and peeraankireddy Memorial Educational Society, 3412/1, 167A, Koilkunta Owk Road, Chintakuntla village, Koilkuntla Town-518134, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to GSR D.El.Ed. College, Plot No. 312/1,167/a, 170, Street No.10/442, Chinthakuntla, Koilkuntla, Kurnool Dt.-518134, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course online on 29.09.2011 for two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act , 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 30.09.2011.NCTE – H'qrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009 and amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-2(B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely.” 1(1-A) (I) The application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

a. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of


18


submission of online application.b. Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7

days of the submission of the online application.c. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent

authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the Course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in 213th Meeting of SRC held on 06th – 07th

November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents. NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

Not submitted within time frame as per Regulation 2009.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on 13.01.2012. Aggrieved by the Rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs. The appellate authority in its order dated 17.07.2012 remands back the case of GSR D.El.Ed. College, Plot No. 312/1,167/a, 170, Street No.10/442, Chinthakuntla, Koilkuntla, Kurnool Dt.-518134, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated.

The Committee in its 230th Meeting held on 16th – 17th August 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17-07-2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) Original certified copy of the land documents from Sub-registrar is not submitted. Original Notarised English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted.

2) In the building plan submitted, total earmarked built up area for the existing course and proposed course is not mentioned. Survey No. is not mentioned.

3) Latest Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer in the prescribed format is not submitted.

4) Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes. Copy of LUC submitted is not notarized.

5) Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.The institution referring to NCTE website has submitted its reply on 29.08.2012

The Committee in its 232nd meeting held on 29th to 31st Aug 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 29.08.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) NCTE Act, for the following:

In the building plan submitted, college and course name is not mentioned.Sy.No. is also not mentioned.

Original Notarised English version of certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted.


19


The institution has submitted its written representation on 15.10.2012.


18. SRCAPP1732D.E.C.Ed

TSR Teacher Training Institute,

Srikakulam District

AP

TSR Teacher Training Institute, Khasara No. 20/2, 20/2A, Plot No. 4-1-146/3, 18 Ward, Amadalavalasa Village and Post, Srikakulam District-532185, Andhra Pradesh.Amadalavalasa Lakshmi Ganapathi Educational Society, Plot No. 4-1-146/3, Palakonda Road, Amadalavaqlasa Village and Post, Srikakulam District-532185, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to TSR Teacher Training Institute, Khasara No. 20/2, 20/2A, Plot No. 4-1-146/3, 18 Ward, Amadalavalasa Village and Post, Srikakulam District-532185, Andhra Pradesh for D.E.C.Ed course on 1.10.2011 for two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NOTE on 10.10.2011.NCTE-Hqrs., had directed to process the applications in accordance with NOTE Regulations 2009, and amendment notified on 26th November, 2010 which reads as follows:2(B) for Sub-Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely "1(1 -A)(I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:a) The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for

Teacher Educational Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of on-line application.

b) Hardcopy in triplicate of the application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the on-line application.

c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the Society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of on-line application.

The SRC in its 213th meeting held on 6-7th November, 2011 considered the matter and careful perusal of the file of the institution and other related documents, NOTE Act 1993, Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds: Not submitted within time frame as per Regulations, 2009.

Accordingly, rejection letter was issued to the institution vide F.No.SRCAPP1732 (2012-13) / D.E.C.Ed/AP/2011-12/36228 dated 23.1.2012.The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17/08/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

1) The institution has not submitted Rs. 41000/- towards inspection fee.2) Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil

authority in favour of college and course is not submitted. Total earmarked built up area for the proposed course is not mentioned.

3) Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs. 100/- stamp paper duly attested by


20


oath Commissioner or notary public, is not submitted. In the affidavit submitted, Sy. No. is not mentioned.

4) Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted.

5) Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

6) Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

7) Proof of completion of 3 academic sessions towards other teacher education courses which are already run by the institution from the affiliating body/State Govt/examining body is not submitted.

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012.Now the institution has submitted its written representation dt. 14.11.2012 received in the office of SRC on 16.11.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution dt. 14-11-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


Suprabhath College of

Diploma in Education,

Rangareddy District

AP

Suprabhath College of Diploma in Education, No.147/A, Cheeryal Village, Keesara Post & Taluk, Rangareddy District - 501 101, Andhra Pradesh.

KTTC Kaushik Educational Society, No.147/A, Cheeryal Village, Keesara Post & Taluka, Rangareddi District - 501301, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Suprabhath College of Diploma in Education, No.147/A, Cheeryal Village, Keesara Post & Taluk, Rangareddy District - 501 101, Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 17.10.2011.

NCTE-Hqrs , had directed to process the application in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009 and amendment notified on 26th November , 2010 which read as follows : 2 (b) for Sub-Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely 1(1-A) (1) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances :

a) The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

b) Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/ Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in its 213th meeting held on 6th – 7th November,


21


2012 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents NCTE Act 1993 Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds : Not submitted within time frame as per Regulation 2009..

Accordingly, a rejection letter to the institution vide F.No.SRCAPP1346/D.Ed/AP/2012-13/36243 dated 24.01.2012.Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-83/2012 Appeal/3rd

Meeting-2012 dated 18.04.2012 states that “ the council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the matter to the SRC for further processing of application on merit as per regulations.”The institution has submitted its written representation on 10.05.2012.

The SRC in its 228th meeting held on 24th –25th July 2012 considered the Appellate authority order, reply of the institution vide letter dt. 10.05.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted.

2) Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted. In the BCC submitted.


4) Notarized land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted.

5) In the affidavit submitted, column No. 5 is not duly filled up.6) Details of running other teacher education/technical course in the same

building/premises is not given.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 13.08.2012. The institution has submitted the written representation on 14/08/2012.The SRC in its 231st Meeting held on 22rd – 23rd August 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.14-08-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 07.09.2011.

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012, considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted.

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012.Now the institution has submitted its written representation dt. 14.11.2012 received


22


in the office of SRC on 16.11.2012.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

20. APS02622D.Ed

Ghulam Ahmed

College of Elementary Education, Hyderabad

DistrictAP

Ghulam Ahmed College of Elementary Education, 8-2-249, Mount Pleasant Road No-3, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad-500034, Andhra Pradesh. Course-D.Ed. ( Code No. APS02622), (B.Ed-0191), (M. Ed- 0028).

Ghulam Ahmed College of Education, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh has submitted application for additional intake in B.Ed course on 28.10.2009.

A deficiency letter was issued to the university on 22.12.2009. The institution submitted its written representation on 02.03.2010. The reply for deficiency letter was placed before SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29-30 March 2010 and SRC decided to cause inspection. Accordingly, inspection was carried out to the institution on 08.05.2010.On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, Visiting Team Report, Video CD, other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, written representation from the institution, the Regional Committee in its 192nd Meeting held on 10-11 May, 2010 decided to refuse recognition to the B.Ed-AI course for the following reasons: -

1) The institution is already having B.Ed. course, D.Ed. course and M.Ed. course. Total built-up area is 3804 sq. mtrs. As per norms of NCTE, 3500 sq.mtrs. is required for the existing courses and 500 sq.mtrs. additional built up area is required for the proposed course.

2) MBA, Law College, Junior College, Pharmacy College, a public school and Engineering College are all run in the same educational complex with no separate demarcation of land/ building for the Teacher Education courses.

The Committee also decided to serve Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act, for the existing D.Ed., B.Ed. and M.Ed. course for non-fulfilment of the infrastructural and instructional facilities as per NCTE norms. Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 09.07.2010 for D.Ed course. The institution has submitted its written representation on 23.07.2010.

The written representation was considered by the Committee in its 195th meeting held on 17-18 August, 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for M.Ed., B.Ed. and D.Ed. Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within 21 days.As per the decision of SRC the letter was sent on 22.09.2010. Till date institution


23


not submitted its written representation/documents and Inspection fee. The committee decided to cause composite inspection of the institution for M.Ed., B.Ed. and D.Ed. Courses, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, in anticipation of payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within 21 days.Meanwhile a complaint was received from the original owner of the land requesting to take stringent action against Ghulam Ahmed College of Education.In the above context a complaint letter dated 09.05.2011, has been received through CP NCTE. The complaint submitted that he is the absolute owner of ancestral property “Mount Pleasant” bearing MCH. No. 8-2-249 to 269, admeasuring Ac.24.10 gts, Road No.3, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, Which is governed by a family trust in the name of his father Prince Muazzam Jah.

By adopting fraudulent methods, a society by name Ul-Uloom education society took possession of above said ancestral property and started college of B.Ed, M.Ed and D.Ed., by name Ghulam Ahmed College of Education. The owner neither signed a lease agreement nor have sold the land to the said society. The owner came to know the society has given a wrong declaration to NCTE that society have perfect title over the property which is absolutely false. The society has also lost all cases filled against the owner family in the civil and High courts. Therefore the owner request to enquire into the matter and ascertain the truth.Complaint of Himayath Ali Mirza is placed before SRC.Inspection of the above Institution has been caused and VTR’s are placed before SRC also.The management is running D.Ed, B.Ed & M.Ed prgrammes in the same building.The inspection was carried out on 24.03.2011.The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

The Committee in its 217th meeting held on 08th – 09th February 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 28.11.2011, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) The multipurpose hall size is only 900 sq.ft, which is less than NCTE norms. The institution has not submitted any proof of multi purpose hall being increased nor its measurements.

2) Building completion certificate from competent authorized Govt. engineer is not submitted. The column Nos. 5 & 6 are left blank. In the copy of the building completion certificate submitted, type of roofing is not mentioned, whether it is RCC or Asbestos sheet roofing.

3) Original Affidavit on Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary attestation to be submitted.

4) Encumbrance certificate submitted by the institution is not readable, fresh Non-encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authorized person is to be submitted.

5) In the land documents submitted, survey numbers are not clear and visible properly. Certified copy of registered land document in favour Society/institution is required with Sy.No. Location and extent clearly mentioned.


24


6) The institution has to submit the latest purchase bills for strengthening of Science lab, E.T. lab and Psychology lab.

7) Certificate from Govt. department/University for details of the other programme/courses run by the management in the same building/premises is not submitted.

8) Status of property dispute is to be submitted with relevant documents.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 14/03/2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 04/04/2012.The Committee in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 04.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

1) Land documents submitted are not in the name of the Society/Institution and Sy.Nos are different and not matching with other documents submitted.

2) Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted.

3) Encumbrance certificate submitted is not clear/readable, Sy.Nos. are different.

4) The institution has submitted purchase bills for strengthening of Science lab, E.T. lab and Psychology lab, out of which some bills are old bills only.

5) Certificate from Govt. department/University for details of the other programmes/courses run by the management in the same building/premises is not submitted.

Accordingly, Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012,

Before the reply i.e. on 13.11.2012 a complaint from Kazeni Hussain, Secretary, NIGAH, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh was received against Sultan-ul-Uloom Educational Society

The institution was submitted its Final Show Cause Notice reply on 15.11.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 15.11.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

Land documents submitted are not in the name of the Society/Institution and Sy.Nos. are different and not matching with other documents submitted.

Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted.

Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted; copy of encumbrance submitted is not clear format and is not up-to-date.

Details of other Teacher Educational courses being run by the institution in the same building/campus is not submitted.


25


In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

21. SRCAPP474B.Ed (Open & Distance Edn)

Karnataka State

Women’s University,

BijapurKA

Karnataka State Women's University, Bijapur, Karnataka

Karnataka State Women’s University, Bijapur had applied to SRC –NCTE

through on-line made for the following two courses simultaneously for the

academic year 2012-13:-

a) B. Ed. ( ODL) – SRC APP 474b) M.Ed. (ODL) – SRC APP 476

The application submitted by the institution was summarily rejected and returned vide SRC’s letter dated 29.08.2011 as there was a ban in the state of Karnataka for B.Ed. course as per NCTE public notification dated 31.07.2011.

On the request dated 05.09.2011 made by the University, the matter was referred to the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi vide letter dated 05.10.2011 for directions whether the application submitted by the University may be processed or not in view of the ban imposed on B.Ed course in the State of Karnataka.

The NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi vide letter dated 21.10.2011 had advised that the SRC may examine the proposal in the light of the requirements of this course for in-service teachers and also look into the following aspects during examination of the proposal:-

a) Whether such course is being demanded by the in-service teachersb) Whether similar course is being offered by any other institution in the

State of Karnatakac) Views of the State Government on this issue shall be taken in to

consideration.

Accordingly, the office of SRC vide letter dated 15.11.2011 had sought the views of the State Government and the University (applicant institution) on the above points. The University had forwarded their view vide letters dated 24.11.2011and 02.12.2011.

The Sate Government had also forwarded their views in the matter vide letter dated 16.12.2011 stating the following:-

The number of teachers who are in-service without requisite qualifications is 7840 nos.

The required demand by in-service teachers in the State of Karnataka will


26


be about 9490. The State Government recommends to consider the application of the

university. No other institution/organization is offering the Teacher Education

programmes through Distance mode exclusively for women.

In the Meantime, the University had forwarded some additional documents vide letter dated 21.10.2011.

It was noted from the file that both the files have been processed by the office of the SRC. The file of B.Ed. was initially summarily rejected and returned vide letter dated 29.8.2011. However, the same was re-processed on the directions of NCTE, HQrs. vide letter dated 21.10.2011 at a later stage, while the file of M.Ed. course was already under process.

Further, as per clause 7(1-A) (c) of NCTE Regulations, 2009, as amended from

time to time, the application shall be summarily rejected if copy of the registered

land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the

society/institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of

application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the on-line

application. In both of the cases, the institution had not submitted the copy of

registered documents to the office of SRC.

Moreover, as per clause 8(3) of the NCTE Regulation, 2009 as amended from time to time “An institution can apply for one basic unit only of an additional course or for an additional unit of the existing recognized course after completion of three academic session of the respective course, for wich the institution shall submit application before the cut off date prescribed for submission of applications in the year succeeding the completion of three academic sessions.”

The University was requested vide this office letter dated 09.01.2012 to select

any one of the courses between M.Ed. & B.Ed., as per clause 8(3) of the NCTE

Regulation, 2009, as amended from time to time.

The Registrar, Karnataka State Women’s University, Bijapur submitted representation on 17.1.2012 which states as follows:-“1. Due to unavoidable administrative delays, the submission of land documents got delayed beyond 7 days of the submission of online application. It is requested that the delay may please be condoned. A copy of the land documents are enclosed.2. We request our application for B.Ed. with 500 seats for the University may please be proceeded.3. It is requested that the M.Ed. application may please be retained with you for


27


processing at a later date as and when applicable as per NCTE regulations.”

The University has requested to process the application of B.Ed. course with 500 seats and also has requested to retain the application of M.Ed. for processing at a later date as and when applicable as per NCTE regulations.

But, the request of the University to retain the application of M.Ed. course may not be acceded to. As per para 5 of NCTE Regulations, 2009, “All applications received on-line on or before the 1st day of October of the year shall be processed for the next academic session and final decision, either recognition granted or refused, shall be communicated to the applicant on or before the 31st day of July of the succeeding year”.

The SRC in its 217th meeting held on 8th and 9th February, 2012 considered the matter and decided to reject the application on the ground that:

There was a ban in the state of Karnataka for B.Ed course for the session 2011-12 & 2012-13.

The application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the on-line application, to the office of SRC, as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

The institution had not submitted the copy of registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application.

The built up area mentioned in the building plan is only 5792 sq.ft.which is less than the NCTE norms and it is housed in Yatri Nivas as submitted by the University.

The building plan is not approved by the competent authority and in the building plan roof is shown as ACC sheets, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

The proposed course is going to be housed/run in a rented premises from department of PWD, Govt. of Karnataka, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

The institution had applied for two courses (B.Ed & M.Ed) simultaneously for the academic year 2012-13. As per regulations 2009 of NCTE Act, an institution can apply for one basic unit only of an additional course or for an additional unit of the existing recognized course after completion of three academic session of the respective course, for which the institution shall submit application before the cut off date prescribed for submission of applications in the year succeeding the completion of three academic sessions.

Accordingly, the letter of rejection was issued to the University vide No.SRCAPP474(2012-13)B.Ed.(ODL)/TN/2011-12/39205 dated 14.03.2012.

Aggrieved by the withdrawal order, the institution approached the appellate authority. The appeal of Karnataka State Women's University, Bijapur, Karnataka dated 05/04/2012 is against the Order No. SRCAPP474 (2012-13)B.ED (ODL)/TN/2011-12/39205 dated 14/03/2012 of the Southern Regional Committee, refusing recognition for conducting B.Ed (ODL) course.

The Correspondent, Karnataka State Women's University (hereinafter referred to as the appellant), preferred an appeal dated 16/04/2012 to the National Council for Teacher Education, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the Council) under


28


Section 18 of the NCTE Act, 1993 against the said Order.

Dr. Meena Chandawarkar, Vice-Chancellor and Prof. Geeta Bali, Former VC, Karnataka State Women's University, Bijapur, Karnataka presented the case of the appellant institution on 24-05-2012. In the appeal and during personal presentation it was submitted that (a) the Principal Secretary Higher Education Department, Govt. of Karnataka exempted K.S.W.U. Bijapur from the ban prevalent in Karnataka vide letter no. ED55MVV2011 dated 26/03/2012. Further the State Govt. vide their letter dated 16-12-2011informed SRC about the demand of ÒDL’ mode course; (b) that the two days delay in submission of hard copy of the application was due to administrative reasons; (c) that a copy of the registered land document issued by the competent authority mentioned that 280 acre of land was in possession of K.S.W.U. on the date of application; (d) that a built up area of 18464.16 sq.ft. was earmarked exclusively for B.Ed. Distance Learning course in a huge campus of 280 acres of Karnataka State Women's University; (e) that the building plan was approved by the competent authority (District Registrar Bijapur) and the building was with R.C.C. roof; (f) that the proposed B.Ed. course was going to be housed in their own premises at Torvi Campus; (g) that their application for B.Ed. course for 500 seats may be considered and the fee of Rs. 41,000/- paid for M.Ed. course be refunded since their M.Ed. application had been withdrawn by the appellant.

The Council noted that (a) SRC vide their letter dated 15-11-2011 sought the views of the State Govt. and the applicant university about the need of ODL mode B.Ed. course in the State of Karnataka. The State Govt. vide letter dated 16-12-2011 informed SRC that (i) there are 7840 inservice teachers without requisite qualification; (ii) the required demand by inservice teachers in the State of Karnataka will be about 9490; (iii) No other institution is offering the teacher education programme thorugh distance mode exclusively for women. (b) that further State Govt. of Karnataka vide their letter dated 26-03-2012 exempted the appellant institution from the ban prevalent in Karnataka. (c) that the appellant institution is a State established University and as per submission made by the appellant, the institution was in possession of requisite physical infrastructure like land and building. (d) that the appellant had already requested SRC vide their letter dated 16-01-2012 to process their B.Ed. application.

In view of the above, the Council concluded that there was adequate justification to accept the appeal and remand the matter to SRC for further processing of B.Ed. course (ODL mode) application of the institution in accordance with the provisions contained in appendix -10 of Regulations 2009 pertaining to Norms and Standards for B.Ed. programme through ÒDL’ system. And also in accordance with the terms and conditions of ‘MOU’ between NCTE and ‘DEC’.

After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the matter to the SRC for further processing of B.Ed. course (ODL mode) application of the institution in accordance with the provisions contained in appendix -10 of Regulations 2009 pertaining to Norms and Standards for B.Ed. programme through ÒDL’ system. And also in accordance with the terms and conditions of ‘MOU’ between ‘NCTE’ and ‘DEC’.

The Appellate authority vide Order No.89-182/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting-2012 dated 18.6.2012 remands back the case of Karnataka State Women's University, Bijapur, Karnataka to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above.


29


The SRC considered the Appellate authority order dt. 18/06/2012 and decided to process further for B.Ed oucrse (ODL mode) application of the institution in accordance with the provision contained in appendix-10 of Regulations 2009 pertaining to norms and standards for B.Ed programme through ‘ODL’ system, and also in accordance with the terms and condition of ‘MOU” between ‘NCTE’ & ‘DEC’.

The matter was placed before SRC in 226th meeting held on 9-10th July, 2012 and the committee decided to process further on merit as per the Regulations. Accordingly, a leter dt. 27/07/2012 was written to NCTE Hqrs. New Delhi, to provide a copy of MOU between NCTE and DEC in order to take necessary action for processing the application further.

On 21/08/2012, a copy of the MOU signed on 9th July 2007 was received by this office from NCTE Hqrs New Delhi, which reads as under:-

“Arrangements under this MOU will be operative for an initial period of three years commencing from the date of signing of this MOU. However, either party shall have the right to terminate the agreement any time”.

The SRC in its 232nd meeting held on 29th and 31st August, 2012 considered the matter and all the relevant documentary evidences and Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 25.09.2012. The University has submitted its written representation on 25.9.2012 and 16.10.2012.

The committee considered the written representation of the institution vide letter dt. 25-9-2012 and 16.10.2012, and decided to close the case. KSWU may apply again after completion of all formalities with NCTE and DEC

Consideration of Visiting Team Report (Volume- 01)

22. APS09612B.Ed

Viswadarshini College of Education,

Thiruvanathapuram, Kerala

KL

Viswadarshini College of Education, Thiruvananthapuram - 695543, Kerala

Viswadarshini Charitable Society, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala submitted an application for seeking recognition for B.Ed course in the name and style of Viswadarshini College of Education on 24.09.2008.

The application was processed and a deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 08.10.08. The institution submitted reply on 07.01.2009. The file was under process and in the meanwhile, in view of the recommendations of the State Govt. of Kerala “not to further recognize/permit the institutions for conducting B.Ed course (s), a public notice was issued on 02.10.2008 to this effect that application for B.Ed courses from the State of Kerala will not be considered for the academic session 2009-2010 and all such application shall be returned along with processing fees and documents.”

Accordingly, the application along with processing fee was returned to the applicant institution on 27.01.2009.

The institution approached the Hon’ble High court of Kerala, through Writ Petition No.12971/2009. Shri V.M. Kurian, Advocate, in its letter dated 31.07.2009 forwarded a Certified copy of the judgement in respect of Writ Petition no. 12971/2009 filed by Vishwadarsini College of Education, Thiruvananthapuram,


30


Kerala for B.Ed Course. The Hon’ble High court has directed that “if the petitioner re-submit its application, pursuant to ext. P7, along with a copy of this Judgement, then it shall be processed and orders passed thereon by the 2nd Respondent within three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgement. Writ petition is disposed of as above.”

In obedience to the court direction the institution submitted application for B.Ed course along with processing fee of Rs 41,000/- on 06.08.2009.

As per public Notice issued by NCTE-Hqrts in Times of India dated 29.07.2009, a policy decision was taken by NCTE Head Quarters in consultation with the state Govt/UTs not to further recognize/permit institution for conduct of following teacher training courses for the academic session 2010-1011:-B.Ed, D.Ed, C.P.Ed, D.P.Ed, B.P.Ed, M.P.Ed.

The matter was placed in 181st meeting of SRC held on 21st August, 2009 and the Committee decided to file an appeal against the order dated 16.07.2009 of Hon’ble High court of Kerala. In this regard, a letter was issued to our advocate on 25.08.2009 and same was brought to the notice of NCTE -HQ also.

In response to the office letter dt.25.8.2009, Shri. V.M. Kurian, legal counsel for SRC has sent a letter received by this office on 31.08.2009 and has stated as under:-

“In the Judgment, the Hon’ble Court has only ordered the SRC to process the application and to take a decision within a time frame. In case the time fixed by the Hon’ble court is inadequate or there are other justifying reason, the time may be extended later. In view of the Public notice, applications can be entertained for 2010-2011 session and processed. The court has not directed to grant recognition.

Considered the above facts, there is no scope for filing appeal against the judgment as the directions do not violate the NCTE Act, Rules or Regulations under Article 226 of the constitution of India High court are entitles to issue directions as above.”

Shri. Kurian has sent the order of Hon’ble High court (Division Bench) order dated 18.12.2009 which was received by this office on 04.01.2010, wherein Hon’ble High court has directed as under :

“The learned Single Judge has only directed the applicants to process the application that may be resubmitted by respondent No.1 and pass orders thereon irrespective of any cutoff date. In that view of the matter, we do not find any reason to interfere with the direction issued by the learned single judge.Appellant No. 2 i.e. SRC shall process the application if it was resubmitted by respondent No. 1 as directed by learned Single Judge, and pass orders thereon in accordance with law. This shall be done as expeditiously as possible, at any date, within one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgement. “

The facts along with original file of the institution were placed before 188th meeting of SRC held on 28-29 January, 2010 wherein the Regional Committee decided to cause inspection. The SRC considered the matter and decided to cause inspection. The inspection report was considered by the Committee and the Committee decided to refuse recognition to the B.Ed. course.

The institution preferred appeal and the Appellate Authority vide order dated 21.01.2011 has confirmed the order of SRC. The Committee noted the Appellate


31


authority order dt.21.01.2011 confirming the SRC’s order dt. 02.09.2010. In the meanwhile, a Court Judgement is received from Advocate, Sri. V.M.Kurian on 12.3.2012 regarding W.P.(C)No.7618/2011 from the Hon’ble High Court of Kerala. The Hon’ble High Court has directed to reconsider the issue by NCTE,HQ and pass fresh orders within a period of two months.

Hence, a copy of the order was forwarded to NCTE,HQ on 13.4.2012. An Office Memorandum is received from the Under Secretary, NCTE, New Delhi to send files pertaining to the appeal on 14.5.2012 and 17.5.2012.

But, the file of Viswadarshini College of Education, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala(APS09612) was not at all traceable in the office of SRC. Even after a long search, the file is not traceable.

The appeal of Vishwadarshini College of Education, Trivandrum, Kerala dated 14/07/2010 is against the Order No. SRO/NCTE/2010/19542 dated 25/06/2010 of the Southern Regional Committee, refusing recognition for conducting B.Ed course on the grounds: “1) The total built-up area of 17600 sq.ft. is not as per NCTE norms since the institution is already having TTC course in the same building. As per NCTE norms, 3000 sq.mtrs. of built up area is required for running B.Ed. and D.Ed.(TTC) course. 2) Science lab, Psychology lab and E.T. lab are not equipped sufficiently as per NCTE norms. 3) Language learning lab is not available.”

The Correspondent, Vishwadarshini College of Education (hereinafter referred to as the appellant), preferred an appeal dated 15/07/2010 to the National Council for Teacher Education, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the Council) under Section 18 of the NCTE Act, 1993 against the said Order.

The Council rejected the appeal of the institution vide order dated 28-09-2010 on the grounds “an inspection team that visited the institution on 17.04.2010 recorded that the whole building is earmarked for the proposed course and Teacher Training Institute is run separately. However the Council noted that the appellant has produced copies of two building completion certificates, which contradict each other.

Whereas one certificate dt. 20.07.2009 enclosed to the application indicates the total built up area as 1272.3 sq. mts. another also dt. 20.07.2009 enclosed to the appeal indicates the

total built up area as 1534.76 sq. mts, even though the actual figures total up to only to 1470.41 sq. mts. which means that the ‘total’ figure seems to be tampered, the total built up area in these certificates is less than the area required as per NCTE Norms, i.e. 1500 sq. mts”.

Aggrieved by the decision of the Council the appellant filed a writ petition before the Hon’ble High Court of the Kerala at Ernakulum and the Court vide order dated 27-10-2010 disposed of the petition with the direction to the Appellate Authority to reconsider the appeal with the notice to the petitioner and decide the case within eight weeks of production of the certified copy of the judgement. Further the petitioner may produce the building completion certificate (Ext. p.14) before the appellate authority when the matter is reconsidered. In compliance with the court directions the case was listed for hearing on 20-12-2010.

Pursuant to the Court directions the Council reconsidered the case and vide order dated 01-02-2011 rejected the appeal on the grounds “a) the appellant on earlier


32


occasion produced two building completion certificates issued on the same date i.e.20-07-2009 by the Assistant Engineer, PWD, Aryanad, in favour of the society for a building, constructed in the year 2007 at Perumkulam village. Block No. 42, Sy. No. 75/5/1, 76/11, 76/1, 70/1, 71/9/1. One of the certificates indicated the availability of 1272.3 sq.mt. of built up area on three floors of a building( ground floor - 496.24 sq.mt, first floor- 505.58 sq.mt. and second floor - 270.48 sq.mt.) and another certificate issued for the same building indicated the availability of 1534.76 sq.mt. of built up area on three floors. (ground floor -550.65 sq.mt., first floor -459.88 sq.mt., second floor-459.88 sq.mt). The two building completion certificates contradict with each other in as much as the total of built up area mentioned in the second certificate on all the three floors is actually 1470.41 sq.mt., not 1534.76 sq.mt. And also the floor wise built up area dimensions mentioned in the two certificates are also totally different. Hence the Council rejected the appeal vide order dated 28-09-2010. The appellant during the

course of presentation on 20-12-2010 also admitted there were contradictions in the building completion certificate issued on 20-07-2009, so he obtained another building completion certificate on 29-09-2010. b) the Council further noted that the appellant produced before the Hon’ble High Court a new building completion certificate issued on 29-09-2010 by the PWD Engineer mentioning the total built up area as 1503.30 sq.mt. on three floors of a building ( ground floor - 450.18 sq.mt., first floor - 502.26 sq.mt., second floor- 502.26 sq.mt. tower - 21.76 sq.mt. and toilet -26.84 sq. mt.) situated at Perumkulam village, Block No. 42, Sy.No. 75/5/1, 76/11, 76/1, 70/1, 71/9/1. This certificate cannot be accepted as it is issued much later than refusal order and also the appellate order. Further the floor-wise area dimensions mentioned in the completion certificate do no match with the building plan and also earlier building completion certificate. The building plan attested by the Block Development Office mentioned that there are two buildings, building No. 1 with 702.06 sq.mt. and building no. 2 with 381.80 sq.mt. and temporary shed with 240 sq.mts. c) The appellant also contested that he has two separate buildings for conducting the existing TTC and proposed B.Ed. course and showed two building completion certificates dated 29-09-2010 for 1503.30 sq.mt. of built up area and another dated 06-07-2009 for 858.56 sq.mt. excluding the AC roof area. Each building was with three floors and they were constructed on the land at Sy.No. 75-5-1. Firstly the building completion certificate issued on 29-09-2010 cannot be acceptable as it was issued much after the date of refusal of recognition and rejection of the appeal. Secondly the total built up area available in both the buildings of 2361.86 sq.mt. (1503.30+858.56 sq.mt.) is not adequate for the existing TTC course and the proposed B.Ed. programme. As per the regulations 2007, which are applicable in this case, 2500 sq.mt. of built up area is required for both the TTC and B.Ed. course”.

Aggrieved by the decision of Appellate Authority the appellant again approached Hon’ble Court of Kerala in W.P. no.7618/2011 and the Court vide their order dated 02-03-2012 quashed Concil’s order dated 01-02-2011 and directed the First respondent (NCTE, HQ) to reconsider the issue inter-alia observing that “the petitioner can be permitted to rely on building completion certificate dated. 29-09-2010 The Petitioner shall be given an opportunity to explain the separate area available for TTC course. Fresh orders will be passed on the appeal in the light of the observations contained above within a period of two months”..Incompliance with the Court directions the case was listed for hearing on 24-05-2012 .

Shri. C. Rajagopalan Achari, Secretary and Shri. B. Jayaprakash, Member


33


appeared before the Council on 24-05-2011 and submitted that (a) only two buildings were included in the building completion certificate submitted by them for T.T.C. - building No.1 was a 3 storey building with 223.80 Sq.mt. on each floor and a tower having 13.53 sq.mt. The total built-up area of this building was 684.93 Sq.mt; building No2 was a 2 storey building with 187.16 Sq.mt. on each floor. The total area of their building was 374.32 Sq.mts. In addition to these two buildings the appellant has provided for TTC, an auditorium (59.84 Sq.mt.), toilets (62.15 Sq.mt.), canteen (35 Sq.mt.) and a temporary shed (240 Sq.mt.).

Including all these, the total built-up area for TTC course was 1456.24 Sq.mt. (b) The total built-up area as per building completion certificate dated 29-09-2010 for B.Ed. course was 1503 Sq.mt. (c) The total built-up area for TTC and B.Ed. course was 2959.54Sq.mt. (d) In support of his claim the appellant in the appeal produced building completion certificates dated 29-09-2010 (for 1503.30 Sq.mt.) which is known as exhibit 14 as mentioned in the Court order and building completion certificate dated 06-07-2009 and a certificate dated 16-05-2012 issued by Asst. Engineer PWD and a building plan for TTI.

The Council noted that the appellant had been producing before the Appeal Committee Building Completion certificate issued at various points of time for different built-up areas. Further the appellant had not been able to produce approved building plans to corroborate the built-up area mentioned in the building completion certificate produced before the Council, in support of having adequate built-up area for the proposed B.Ed programme and the existing T.T.C. The Council therefore concluded to remand the case to the SRC for causing composite inspection of the institution to verify the refusal grounds and take decision thereafter. The SRC in the meantime shall also verify the building completion certificates mentioned in the preceding paragraph from the issuing authority for their authenticity.

After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VT report rand after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded to remand the case to the SRC for causing composite inspection of the institution to verify the refusal grounds and take decision thereafter. The SRC in the meantime shall also verify the building completion certificates mentioned in the preceding paragraph from the issuing authority for their authenticity.

The Council vide order No. F.No.89-897/2010-Appeal dated 18/06/2012 remands back the case of Vishwadarshini College of Education, Uriyakode, Kanniyoor, Perumkulam Village, Nedumangal Town, Trivandrum - 695014, Kerala to the SRC, NCTE for necessary action as indicated above.

The SRC in its 226th meeting held on 09th-10th July, 2012 has considered the Appellate authority order dt. 18/06/2012 and decided to process further for causing composite inspection of the institution and also to verify the authenticity of the building completion certificate of the institution issued by the competent authority.

The inspection of the institution was conducted on 21/10/2012.

The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

Copy of the land documents submitted is in the name of the Society and not in the name of the institution.


34


Certified/Notarised land documents are not submitted.

Building plan is in the name of Vishwa Darshini Charitable Society and not in the name of the institution. Blue print of the building plan is not submitted.

Utilization Certificate is in the name of Society. Original FDR of Rs. 5.00 lakhs ( Endowment fund ) and Rs. 3

lakhs(Reserve Fund) are not submitted. Non-Encumbrance Certificate approved by the Sub-Registrar is not

submitted. All documents submitted is in the name of Society and not in the name of

the institution. The institution is also having TTC Course with an existing intake of 50

and additional intake of 50 thus making an annual intake of 100 at the Survey No. 75-5/1. Hence it is not known whether the built up area is exclusively provided for B.Ed Course or not.


Consideration of LOI Cases (Volume- 1)


Jhansi College of Education,

Prakasam District

AP

Jhansi College of Education, Plot No. 461/1, Darsi Village and Post, Darsi Taluka and Town, Prakasam District – 523247, Andhra Pradesh.

BMR Educational and Service Society, Plot No. 461/1, Addanki Road, Karsi Villlage and Post, Darsi Taluka and Town, Prakasam District – 532 247, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Jhansi College of Education, Plot No. 461/1, Darsi Village and Post, Darsi Taluka and Town, Prakasam District – 523247, Andhra Pradesh. for D.El.Ed course of two years duration under section 15(1)) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on on-line on 28.09.2011 and physical application has been received on 07.10.2011.

The said application was refused and rejected on 23.01.2012 on the ground that “Hard Copy not submitted within time bound as per Regulation 2009, against which the institution has preferred appeal before the Appellate Authority.

The Appellate authority vide its order dt. 18.04.2012 remands back the case to SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per regulations. Hence, the application was scrutinized as per the provisions contained in the Regulations 2009.

Accordingly, a deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 21.06.2012. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 25.06.2012.


35


The Committee in its 228th meeting of SRC held on 24th – 25th July 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 10.05.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Total earmarked built up area for B.Ed and for proposed D.El.Ed course is not given.

As per the directions of SRC a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 13.08.2012. The reply for show cause notice was received on 13.08.2012.

The SRC in its 230th meeting held on 16th - 17th August 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.13-08-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, a Letter of Intent was issued to the institution on 04.10.2012. Now the institution has submitted its reply to LOI on 15.11.2012.

The list of staff, signed by The Director, SCERT.

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.El.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (Fifty only) students from the year 2013-14, subject to production of joining report of Principal.


CSR D.Ed College,

Prakasam District

AP

CSR D.Ed College, Khasara/Plot No. 175, Street No. 01, Podili Village, Post & Taluk, Prakasam District, Pin-523240, Andhra Pradesh.

Sasi and Swathika Reddy Educational Society, Plot No. 175, Markapur Road, Podili Village, Post and Taluk, Prakasam District, Pin-523240, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to CSR D.Ed College, Khasara/Plot No. 175, Street No. 01, Podili Village, Post & Taluk, Prakasam District, Pin-523240, Andhra Pradesh. for D.El.Ed course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.10.2011.


36


The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 03.11.2011/22.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011. Now the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 24.02.2012.

The SRC in its 219th Meeting of SRC held on 15th – 16th March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 24.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

As per the direction of SRC, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 04.04.2012.

Now, the institution has submitted its written representation dt. 23.04.2012 received in the office of SRC on 24.04.2012.The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th – 10th May 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 23.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) Total earmarked plinth area of 1395.83 sq.mtrs for the proposed course given in building plan is inadequate against the requirement of 1500 sq,mtrs as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

2) Column No. 2 of building completion certificate is filled up with individual name, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

3) Building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not given.

Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 11.06.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 09/07/2012.

The institution has submitted reply to the Final Show Cause Notice after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days as per clause 7 (1) of NCTE Regulations.

The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days from the date of issue of the notice.Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal NO. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165-68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:

“An institution is not entitled to recognition unless it fulfils the conditions specified in various clauses of the Regulations. The Council is directed to ensure that in future no institution is granted recognition unless it fulfils the conditions laid down in the Act and the Regulations and the time schedule fixed for processing the application by the Regional Committee and communication of the decision on the issue of recognition it strictly adhered to”.

The committee considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 09/07/2012, i.e., after 28 (Twenty eight) days from the date of issue of of show cause notice dt. 11.06.2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.Accordingly rejection order was issued to the institution on 13.08.2012. Aggrieved by


37


the order of the SRC, the institution preferred to go for appeal to High Court and the High Court order was received on 14.08.2012 and placed in 230th Meeting.

The Committee in its 230th Meeting held on 16th – 17th August 2012, considered the order and decided to process the application.

The SRC in its 231st Meeting held on 22rd – 23rd August 2012 considered the order of Hon’ble High court of Andhra Pradesh and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 11.09.2012.

The SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2102 considered the VT report and other relevant documents and decided to issue LOI. Accordingly, LOI was issued to the institution on 04.10.2012. The institution has submitted its reply on 14.11.2012.

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.El.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (Fifty only) students from the year 2013-14, subject to production of joining report of Principal.


UK College of Elementary

Teacher Education,

Ranga Reddy District

AP

UK College of Elementary Teacher Education, Sy No. 32, Godumakunta Village, Keesara Post Office and Taluka, Hyderabad City, Ranga Reddy District – 501 301. Andhra Pradesh.

Society for Helping and Awakening Rural Poor Through Education, Sy No. 32, Godumakunta Street, Godumakunta Village, Keesara Post Office and Taluka, Hyderabad City, Ranga Reddy District-501301, Andhra Pradesh, had applied for grant of recognition to UK College of Elementary Teacher Education, Sy No. 32, Godumakunta Village, Keesara Post Office and Taluka, Hyderabad City, Ranga Reddy District – 501 301. Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 14.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 16.09.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State

Government for recommendation on 20.09.2011 followed by reminder on

15.11.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 23.11.2011. The

institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 16.12.2012. Recommendation

from State Government is not received.


38


The SRC in its 216th meeting of SRC held on 11th -12th January 2012 considered the written reply dated 16.12.2011 and other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the premises to examine whether the institution fulfills all the requirements as per the norms and to ascertain infrastructural and instructional facilities available at the premises for the proposed course. Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 01.02.2012 to 04.02.2012. The same was intimated to the institution on 24.01.2012. Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 26.02.2012.

The SRC in its 219th meeting held on 15th -16th March 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 04/04/2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 25/04/2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 25.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 09.06.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 29.06.2012.

The reply of the institution vide letter dt,. 29.06.2012 to the show cause notice was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:-

Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted.

The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory and unconvincing.Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Meanwhile this office has received a fax letter from Shri. MAdhav Rao, Advocate on 28.07.2012 stating that the institution has filed court case in W.P no 22935 of 2012 in Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh as follows:-

“As the application is rejected on the ground that the building certificate is not issued by competent authority the court observed that GHMC is the competent authority and its certificate can be considered. Thus the court has directed SRC to consider the certificate. The court has set aside the order passed by SRC”.

The matter was placed before 229th meeting held on 30th -31st July, 2012, the SRC committee considered the matter and decided to process & put up in the next meeting.

The institution has submitted court order dated 07th July, 2012 wherein the Hon’ble High court has passed an order as under:-

“At the hearing. The learned counsel for the petitioner placed before the court the national counsil for Teacher Education (Recognition Norms and Procedure)


39


Regulations, 2009 which was published in the Gazette of India (Extraordinary) Part – III, section 4 dated 31.08.2009. it is apt to refer to Regulations which Reads as under:

“at the time of inspection, the building of the institution shall be complete in the form of a permanent Structure on the land possessed by the institution in terms of sub-regulation (7) of Regulation 8, equipped with all necessary amenities and fulfilling all such requirements as prescribed in the norms and standards. The applicant institution shall produce the original completion certificate issued by the competent Government authority or local body authority, approved building plan in proof of the completion of building and built up area and other documents to the visiting team for verification. No temporary structure or asbestos roofing shall be allowed in the institution, even if it is in addition to the prescribed built up area."

On the strength of the above-mentioned regulation, the learned counsel submitted that the respondent has grossly erred in rejecting the building completion certificate issued by the Engineer licensed by the Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation which falls under the expression "local body authority":

It is not in dispute that the Greater Hyderabad -- Municipal Corporation is a local 'body authority. The respondent appeared to have lost sight of this aspect.) Therefore, the impugned order is set aside and the respondent is directed to re-consider the petitioner's application, in the light of Regulation 10 as re-produced above and communicate its decision to the petitioner, within two weeks from the date of receipt of this order.

Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed to the extent indicated above. As a sequel to allowing the writ petition, W.P.M.P.No 2930 of 2012 is disposed of as infructuous.

The institution submitted BCC from a GHMC Licensed Structural Engineer instead of directly from GHMC as quoted in Court order.

The Committee in its 230th Meeting held on 16th – 17th August 2012, considered the Court order and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) The institution has submitted building completion certificate from GHMC Licensed Structural Engineer instead of directly from GHMC.

2) The institution is directed to submit building completion certificate from GMHC as per Court direction.

The institution referring to the NCTE website has submitted its written representation on 21.08.2012.

The SRC in its 232rd meeting held on 29th – 31st August 2102 considered the show cause notice reply and other relevant documents and decided to issue LOI. Accordingly, LOI was issued to the institution on 05.09.2012. The institution has submitted its reply on 14.11.2012.

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.El.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (Fifty only) students from


40


the year 2012-13.

Consideration of Complaint Cases (Volume- 01)

26. AOS00301B.EdSree

Kaginele Mahasamst

hana Kanakaguru

Peetha College of Education,

MysoreKA

Sree Kaginele Mahasamsthana Kanakaguru Peetha College of Education, MysoreSri.Kaginele Mahasamsthana Kanaka Gurupeetha College of Education, Mysore, Karnataka was granted recognition by SRC for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 27.11.1996.

A complaint dated 20.08.2009 was received from Dr. P.R.Nair, Retd. Professor of Education, Mysore – 12, Karnataka stating that the Principal of the College is not eligible for the post and the University has rejected her appointment. It was also stated that a writ petition No.487831/04 is pending before the Karnataka High Court. The complainant has submitted the details of each person. The complainant has requested to investigate since the Salary to the employees are not being paid as per norms and also violating the reservation rules.

SRC considered the matter in its 184th meeting held on 26-27 October 2009 and decided to direct the complainant to submit affidavit and also call for remarks from the institution. Accordingly, a letter dt.22.12.2009 has been sent to the complainant and the letter has been received back undelivered. Further, a letter was also sent to the institution on 19.01.2010. The reply submitted on 08.02.2010 was considered by SRC in its 189th meeting held on 25-26 February 2010 and decided that no further action is required/necessary.

Another, complaint dated 18.02.2010 has been received from Ms. Sobana.S. Lecturer, KMKG College of Education against the institution and has alleged that she has not been paid salary as per NCTE norms and neither implementing relevant law/rules though her appointment has been approved by the University. The complaintee has stated that due to injury she was unable to move and had applied for leave on medical grounds and till date the institution had not paid salary for the vacation period also. The institution is harassing fully qualified staff by adopting unfair means. The Principal’s appointment is violation of NCTE norms and is an ineligible person for continuing as Principal of the college. The Principal had moved the court and the case pending and misleading the affiliation committee.

Further, the complainant has requested SRC to look into the irregularities and grant justice with regard to salary. Hence, the matter was placed before SRC in its 190th meeting held on 29-30 March 2010 and decided to call for remarks from the institution and an affidavit from the complainant. Accordingly, letters were issued on 07.05.2010. The SRC noted that the complainant has not submitted any affidavit till date.

The institution has submitted written representation on 30.06.2010 had stated that the complaintee is in the habit of writing letters to higher authorities like your establishment, University of Mysore, to the Vice-chancellor and mislead them, without providing any documental evidences. All this act is based purely on jealous and prejudice in mind for the deprivation of the aspired post.

The above matter was placed before SRC in its 194th meeting held on 21-22 July,2010. The SRC has noted the above matter.


41


On 25.4.2012, a letter is received from Dr. Sobana.S., Lecturer in Education, Sree Kaginele Mahasamsthana Kanakaguru Peetha College of Education, Mysore stating that “I had on 25.4.2012, in person, registered a complaint in the form of an affidavit , with your respectful self, with a request to take speedy action on the injustice meted out to me at my college. I am herewith enclosing a copy of the same so as to remind your respectful self to do the needy and oblige by doing this without any further delay, for which I will be ever grateful”.

In the meanwhile, a letter was also received from NCTE, HQ on 28.5.2012 forwarding a copy of the complaint of Dr. Sobana.S. dated 25.4.2012 and requested SRC to take action against the aforesaid institution and furnish action taken report to NCTE, HQ within 30 days.

Hence, the above complaint matter was placed before 222nd meeting of SRC held on 9-10 May, 2012. The SRC considered the matter and decided to seek comments from the management regarding the complaint against the appointment of Principal in Sree Kaginele Mahasamsthana Kanakaguru Peetha College of Education Mysore, and also to send a copy of this to the University.Accordingly, as per the decision of SRC, a letter was addressed to the Hon. Secretary, Sree Kaginele Mahasamsthana Kanakagurupeetha College of Education, Adichunchanagiri Road, Kuvempunagar, Mysore-23, Karnataka on 5.6.2012.

On 28.8.2012, again a letter is received from Dr. Sobana.S. to take action against the institution.

But, so far there was no reply from the institution so far. The letter of Dr. Sobana was again placed before SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26-28 Sept, 2012 wherein the Committee considered the matter and advised SRO to further examine the case of complaint received from the complainant for further needful action. Further decided to examine whether, any violation of rules/regulations/norms of NCTE is involved and should decide whether at all SRC has any jurisdiction in the matter.

The Committee considered the complaint of Dr. Sobana Lectuer of said institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under NCTE Act for the following:

The complaint dated 18.02.2010 has been received from Ms. Sobana.S. Lecturer, KMKG College of Education against the institution and has alleged that she has not been paid salary as per NCTE norms and neither implementing relevant law/rules though her appointment has been approved by the University. The complaintee has stated that due to injury she was unable to move and had applied for leave on medical grounds and till date the institution had not paid salary for the vacation period also. The institution is harassing fully qualified staff by adopting unfair means. The Principal’s appointment is violation of NCTE norms and is an ineligible person for continuing as Principal of the college. The Principal had moved the court and the case pending and misleading the affiliation committee.

From the documents submitted by the complainant, it is observed that


42


Smt. Uma. S.B. is not qualified for the post of Principal as per NCTE norms.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Notice to the institution, as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

Note: copy to be marked to the University of Mysore.

27. APS06174D.Ed

Seema D.Ed

College, Kolar

DistrictKA

Seema D.Ed College, S.N.M school Road, Anderson Pet, K.G.F – 563113, Kolar District, Karnataka

Seema Educational Charitable Trust, Kolar District, Karnataka had submitted an application to the SRC, NCTE for grant on recognition to Seema D.Ed College, S.N.M school Road, Anderson Pet, K.G.F – 563113, Kolar District, Karnataka and was granted recognition on 12.04.2007 for Elementary courses of two years duration with an annual intake of fifty students subject to the condition to shift its own premises/building with in 3 years from the date of recognition ( in case the course is started in rented premises). Hence, the institution should have shifted to its own premises with in 12.04.2010.

In the mean while SRC has received a telephonic and oral complaint about admitting the students by taking heavy donations in Andaman and Nicobar islands.

Accordingly, a letter dated F.SRO/APS06174-D.Ed/43589 dt. 06.07.2012 was issued to the institution seeking explanation regarding shifting of the premises to its own premises and also regarding collection of heavy donation.

The institution submitted a letter dated 24.07.2012 states as follows:-

“ Our Seema Education Charitable Trust clarifies that, the land had already been registered for the premises in favour of Seema Education Charitable Trust and hence seema D.Ed college will shift its premises within 6 months to the Registered land, as the college humbly request to grant 6 months of time for shifting of the premises.

Whereas collection of heavy donation for admission in our college is been fixed not more than Rs. 25000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand Only) for 2 years, hence the rumors are complete false and baseless.”The Committee considered the matter, reply of the institution dt. 24.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

The Institution was granted recognition in temporary premises to run D.Ed course on 14.04.2007 with a condition that it should shift to its own permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before 14.04.2010. The


43


Institution is still running in temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even after a lapse of stipulated 3 years and after lapse of time period of more than 5 years and 08 months.

The request of the institution to permit 6 months time to shift to new premises in registered land cannot be permissible, already 5 years and 08 months time period is elapsed for shifting. The institution has violated the condition of shifting to new building/premises as per NCTE norms of 2009.


Consideration of MISC., Cases (Volume- 01)

28. APS02145B.Ed

Sriman Dharamsingh B.Ed College,

Gulbarga District

KA

Sriman Dharamsingh B.Ed. College, Ambika Nagar, Old Jeevargi Road, Behind P&T Quarters, Gulbarga-585103, Karnataka

Praveen Education Society, Gulbarga, Karnataka had submitted an application to the SRC of NCTE for grant of recognition to Sriman Dharamsingh B.Ed. College, Ambika Nagar, Old Jeevargi Road, Behind P&T Quarters, Gulbarga-585103, Karnataka for B.Ed. course of one year duration and was granted recognition on 10.12.2004 from the academic session 2004-05 with an annual intake of 100 students.

On perusal of the file, it is observed that as requested by the institution dated 10.11.2009 the matter of shifting of premises was placed before SRC in its 187th

meeting held on 29-30 October, 2009 wherein the SRC had decided to cause inspection shifting of premises after payment of Rs.40,000/- by the institution within a period of four weeks from the date of confirmation of minutes.

As per the decision of SRC, a letter was addressed to the institution on 9.2.2010 to submit inspection fee of Rs.40,000/-. In reply, the institution had submitted a Demand Draft for Rs.40,000/- dated 9.10.2007 on 23.2.2010. Since, the Demand Draft had already expired, a letter was addressed to the institution on 30.6.2010 with a request to submit a revalidated Demand Draft.

The Committee considered the matter, reply of the institution dt. 23.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has submitted a Demand Draft for Rs. 40000/- dt. 9.10.2007 on 23.2.2010, since the Demand Draft already expired, a letter dt. 30.6.2010 is written to the institution for revalidation of the Demand draft,


44


but till date the institution has not revalidated the demand draft.


29. APS00937B.Ed

Rabindranath Tagore

College of Education for

women, Salem District

TN

Rabindranath Tagore College of Education for Women, Veerachipalayam Village, Sankagiri Taluk, Salem District, Tamilnadu

Rabindranath Tagore College of Education for Women, Veerachipalayam Village, Sankagiri Taluk, Salem District, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 31.12.2002. The institution was granted recognition on 24.02.2005 with an annual intake of 100 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dtd. 10.09.2012 has stated that the institution had obtained No Objection Certificate from the Higher Education (E1) Department on 30.08.2012 for changing the name of the college from Rabindaranath Tagore College of Education for Women to VIVEKANANDHA EDUCATIONAL COLLEGE FOR WOMEN, Veerachipalayam, Sankari West Post, Sankari Taluk, Salem District, Tamilnadu.

The Committee considered the matter and noted that

The Institution was granted recognition in temporary premises to run D.Ed course on 24.02.2005 with a condition that it should shift to its own permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before 24.02.2008. The Institution is still running in temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even after a lapse of stipulated 3 years and after lapse of time period of more than 6 years and 11 months.

The request of the institution for change of name of the college from “Rabindaranath Tagore College of Education for Women” to “Vivekanandha Education College for Women” can be considered only after comply to the condition of shifting and then only the request for change name thereafter. The case is closed.


Sri Venkateshwara Elementary

Teacher Education, Prakasam

DistrictAP

Sri Venkateshwara Elementary Teacher Education, Khasara No. 24/2, Darsi Road, Rajam Palli Village and Post, Darsi City and Taluk, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh.With reference to the application on-line dated 29.09.2011 which has been received in the office of Southern Regional Committee on 07.10.2011 for D.El.Ed Course. In first instant as per perusal of the file it is noted that the institution have not submitted application with time frame as per Regulation, 2009As per clause 7(1-A) of the new Regulation, 2009 wherein it is stipulated that “the application submitted online but not followed by dispatch through registered


45


post or by hand with the document mentioned at (I) to (VII) above within 7 days shall be considered as incomplete and shall be summarily rejected with reasons recorded in writing and returned to the applicant along with the processing fees within 30 days of the receipt of the application.Since the institution has not submitted application within time frame as per Regulation 2009, which is against NCTE Regulation 2009. In this regard a letter was issued to applicant institution on 22.11.2011 with request to submit proof of dispatch and simultaneously the matter was placed before SRC in 213th meeting inadvertently wherein the SRC rejected the file due to not submitting within time frame as per Regulation, 2009. However, Rejection order has not been issued to institution, as yet. The Application was processed and deficiency letter was made. Issue of deficiency letter is held up for the confirmation of SRC.In mean time the institution has submitted reply in response to this office letter on 13.12.2011. Submitting proof of having submitted the application within 7 days period on 05/10/2011 by hand. However inward entry has been made on 07/10/2011 only due to 06/10/2011 being a holiday and due to receipt of large number of applications received on 05/10/2011.Hence the file is put for further direction in the matter of issue of deficiency letter to the institution.The committee in its 216th meeting held on 11-12th January, 2012 considered the matter and decided to further process the application and issuance of DL.The Southern Regional Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 24.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution. The institution has submitted its written representation on 11.06.2012.The Southern Regional Committee in its 224th Meeting held on 14th to 16th June , 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 11.06.2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 4th – 8th July, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 29/06/2012 the Inspection of the institution was conducted on 04/07/2012.On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in it 227th meeting held on 17-19th July 2012 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2012-13 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, a letter of intent was issued to the institution on 27.07.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 27.08.2012.On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee 232nd SRC Meeting held on 29th – 31st August 2012 decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.El.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (Fifty only) students, from the session 2012-2013.


46


The Southern Regional Committee in its 232nd SRC Meeting held on 29th – 31st

August 2012 has decided to issue Formal Recognition to the institution and advised the institution to upload approved staff list, Photographs and affidavit in the website of their institution.Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution on 16.10.2012 and the institution has replied to the letter dt. 16.10.2012 on 15.11.2012.

The committee noted the matter.

Consideration of Show Cause Notice reply (Volume- 01)

31. APS07199B.Ed

Akshaya College of Teacher

Education, Tumkur District

KA

Akshaya College of Teacher Education, Plot No. 161, Baddihalli Village, Oordigere Hobli, Tumkur District-572102, KarnatakaAkshaya College of Teacher Education, Plot No. 161, Baddihalli Village, Oordigere Hobli, Tumkur District-572102, Karnataka had submitted an application for starting B.Ed course on 29.05.2006. The institution was granted recognition on 04.12.2008 with an annual intake of 100 students. This office was in receipt of letter No.TY:VCPS:2011-12:98 dated 21.05.2011 from the Vice-Chancellor, Tumkur University, Tumkur by enclosing a list of 19 institutions with the committee observations by conducting inspections. The SRC in its 206th meeting held on 9-10th June, 2011 noted the inspection report of the Vice-Chancellor, Tumkur University, dt. 21.05.2011 and the deficiencies in the 19 institutions in Tumkur District and decided to issue show cause notice under section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 22.07.2011. The institution had replied vide letter dt. 16.08.2011. The SRC in its 211th meeting held on 21-23 September, 2011 considered the letter dt.21.05.2011 from Vice-Chancellor, Tumkur University pointing out deficiencies in the 19 Tumkur University colleges and also reply of the above institution dt. 16.08.2011 and other documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause composite inspection for all the courses at premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act, to verify whether the institution is maintaining instructional and infrastructural facilities as per NCTE norms. The institution is directed to submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, with Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee towards the all the courses being run, in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore.Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was carried out on 29.10.2011.In the meantime, Tumkur University vide their letter received on 17.10.2011 has conducted re-visits to the institution on 18.8.2011 and made certain observations.In the meantime, R.O.,NCTE, HQ vide letter dated 3rd November, 2011 had forwarded a complaint dated 30.7.2011 made by Sri. V.N. Ramesh, No.45, 3rd Cross, Ashok Nagar, B.H.Road, Tumkur against 5 institutions(including this) with direction to seek the comments from the institution on the complaint. The complainant brought to the notice of NCTE about the gross irregularities in the functioning of Divya B.Ed. College and also other B.Ed. Colleges(including this) in Tumkur. He alleged that inspite of good reputation of Tumkur University affiliated teacher education colleges, a few black-sheep like Divya College of


47


Education, Nayala College of Education, Akshaya College of Education, Bharathi College of Education and Indira College of Education are bringing a bad name to other colleges in Tumkur. He had requested to initiate immediate action in the better interest of the students career and lives.The institution was also offering D.Ed. course from 6.11.2007 and requested for closure of D.Ed. course vide their letter dated 15.9.2011 for closing down of the D.Ed. College. The Committee in its 211 th meeting held on 21-23 September, 2011 considered the Institutions’ request for closure of D.Ed course and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the recognition for (APS07009) D.Ed course with effect from 2013-2014, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed, course, if any, to complete their final year course. Accordingly, withdrawal order for D.Ed. course was issued on 2.12.2011.The SRC considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act, for B.Ed. course and Notice was issued to the institution on 14.3.2012. The institution submitted reply vide letter dated 06.07.2012 received by this office on 11.7.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 230th Meeting held on 16th – 17th

July 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dated 11-07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under NCTE Act and Final Show Cause Notice was issued on 31/08/2012The institution has submitted written representations on 24/09/2012 and 05/10/2012.

As per records available in the file, the institution vide its initial application dated 29.5.2006 had applied for B.Ed. course at Baddihalli village(p-68-69/c). As per VT report (p-105/c), the inspection was also conducted at Baddihalli village. Thereafter, after consideration of VT, the application was refused and order was issued at Trust address(p-107/c). Further, on reversal of SRC order by appellate authority vide order dated 10.11.2008(p-109/c), Recognition was granted to the institution vide order dated 04.12.2008(p-365/c) at Baddihalli village where the inspection was conducted.

The contention of the institution stating that the address was wrongly mentioned is incorrect as the institution was inspected at the Baddihalli address and the report of the same is attested by the Managing Trustee of Akshaya Education Trust.

Now, on 05/10/2012, the institution has submitted a proposal to shift the institution to Lingapura Village from II Cross , Ashoknagar. A certificate issued by the Obalapura Gram Panchayath President and Secretary dated 15/10/2012 stating that Akshaya Education Trust has taken prior permission for construction of 1st Floor, II Floor and III Floor having 7182.9 sq.ft each at Tumkur Taluk, Kora Hobli, Obalalpura Grama Panchayath is completed. The Sy. No., location of the building and the course offered by the Trust is not mentioned in the certificate.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letters dt. 05/10/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was


48


decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

A photocopy of the building plan is submitted for Lingapura Village. Approved blue print of the building from competent authority is not submitted.

Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer in prescribed format is not submitted.

Approved staff list from Tumkur University is not submitted.


32. APS03278 / APS07649B.Ed / M.Ed

Ponnaiah College of Education, Thanjavur

DistrictTN

Ponnaiah College of Education, P.R. Group of Institutions, Central Office, M.C. Road, Natarajapuram South, Thanjavur-613 007, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 12.07.2004. The institution was granted recognition on 14.11.2005 ((APS03278) with an intake of 100 students. The institution had also submitted application for M.Ed on 09.11.2006. The institution was grated recognition on 06.11.2007 with an intake of 25 students (APS07649) with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dated 18.09.2007 submitted vide DD bearing no. 754538 dtd. 10.09.2007 for Rs. 40,000/- (APS00936) towards shifting of premises, stating that since the inception the institution has been functioning in Trust owned permanent Building. Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 03.06.2011 for both B.Ed (APS03278), M.Ed (APS07646) and M.Ed (APS07649) Courses and 04.06.2011 for B.Ed (APS04432) course.

The SRC in its 213th meeting held on 06th-07th November, 2011 considered the VT Report, and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 19.12.2011. The institution had submitted its written representation on 09.01.2012.

The SRC in its 217th meeting held on 08th-09th February, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 09.01.2102, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 14.03.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 26.03.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012 considered the


49


written reply vide letter dt 26.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 06.06.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 02.07.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 02.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, to B.Ed and M.Ed course for the following:

As per land documents, only three sy. nos. viz 338/2, 337 and 340/2 consist of land area of 5.60 acres whereas as per affidavit(s) submitted by the institution, Four sy. nos viz 338/2, 337, 340/2 and 553/1B2 consist land area of 5.60 acres. It may be clarified by the institution. No land documents have been submitted for the sy. no. 553/1B2.

Sl. No. 5 of the affidavit is not as per prescribed format.Original certified land documents are not submitted by the

institution so for.Building Plan is not in the name of running institution, it is the

name of Trust. Total site area is not mentioned therein. Moreover, built-up area is not matching with BCC.

Building Completion Certificate is not submitted in the prescribed format and not approved by the Competent Civil Authority.

The land and other documents are same for file no. APS03278, APS07649, APS07646 and APS00936.


33. APS07646M.Ed

Ponnaiah Ramajayam College of Education, Thanjavur

DistrictTN

Ponnaiah Ramajayam College of Education, P.R. Group of Institutions, Central Office, M.C. Road, Natarajapuram South, Thanjavur-613007, Tamilnadu

Ponnaiah Ramajayam College of Education, P.R. Group of Institutions, Central Office, M.C. Road, Natarajapuram South, Thanjavur-613007, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for M.Ed Course on 09.11.2006. The institution was granted recognition on 07.11.2007 with an annual intake of 25 students and as per the NCTE notification the intake of M.Ed course was increased from 25 to 35 students vide order dtd. 11.11.2010, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dated 18.09.2007 submitted vide DD bearing no. 754538 dtd. 10.09.2007 for Rs. 40,000/- (APS00936) towards


50


shifting of premises, stating that since the inception the institution has been functioning in Trust owned permanent Building. Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 03.06.2011 for both B.Ed (APS03278), M.Ed (APS07646) and M.Ed (APS07649) Courses and 04.06.2011 for B.Ed (APS04432) course.

The SRC in its 211th meeting held on 21st-23rd September, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 22.11.2011. The institution had submitted its written representation on 26.12.2011.

The SRC in its 216th meeting held on 11th-12th January, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 26.12.2011, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.02.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 14.03.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012 considered the written reply vide letter dt 14.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of N CTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 09.06.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 02.07.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 02.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, course for the following:






The same land and other documents have been submitted for file no. APS03278, APS07649, APS07646 and APS00936.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity


51


to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

34. APS00936B.Ed


DistrictTN

Ponnaiah Ramajayam College of Education, PR Engineering College Campus, Vallam, Thanjavur- 613403, Tamilnadu

Ponnaiah Ramajayam College of Education, PR Engineering College Campus, Vallam, Thanjavur- 613403, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 27.11.2002. The institution was granted recognition on 12.04.2005 with an annual intake of 100 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dated 18.09.2007 submitted vide DD bearing no. 754538 dtd. 10.09.2007 for Rs. 40,000/- towards shifting of premises, stating that since the inception the institution has been functioning in Trust owned permanent Building. Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 03.06.2011.

The SRC in its 211th meeting held on 21st-23rd September, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 22.11.2011. The institution had submitted its written representation on 26.12.2011.

The SRC in its 216th meeting held on 11th-12th January, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 26.12.2011, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 02.03.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 14.03.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012 considered the written reply vide letter dt 14.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 09.06.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 03.07.2012.




52






The same land and other documents have been submitted for file no. APS03278, APS07649, APS07646 and APS00936.

The institution has not made any comments in this regard for submission of deed of settlement attested and crossed.


35. APS04432B.Ed


DistrictTN

Ponnaiah Ramajayam College of Education, SR no. 99/2, 100/1B, 1E, 1D, Thiripu Village, Kumbakonam, Thanjavur-614 904, Tamilnadu

Ponnaiah Ramajayam College of Education, SR no. 99/2, 100/1B, 1E, 1D, Thiripu Village, Kumbakonam, Thanjavur-614 904, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 07.11.2005. The institution was granted recognition on 22.09.2008 with an annual intake of 100 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dated 18.09.2007 submitted vide DD bearing no. 754538 dtd. 10.09.2007 for Rs. 40,000/- (APS00936) towards shifting of premises, stating that since the inception the institution has been functioning in Trust owned permanent Building. Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 03.06.2011 for both B.Ed (APS03278), M.Ed (APS07646) and M.Ed (APS07649) Courses and 04.06.2011 for B.Ed (APS04432) course.The SRC in its 211th meeting held on 21st-23rd September, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 29.11.2011. The institution had submitted its written representation on 26.12.2011.

The SRC in its 216th meeting held on 11th-12th January, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 26.12.2011, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under Section of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 25.02.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 14.03.2012.


53


The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012 considered the written reply vide letter dt 14.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice Under Section of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 06.06.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 02.07.2012.


The institution has neither submitted building completion certificate in proper format nor approved by the competent Govt. authority.

Proceeding for land conversion issued by Revenue Department is not submitted.

Original notarized Non-Encumbrance Certificate is not submitted. English notarized version of NEC is also required to be submitted. There is no transaction in the name of Trust.

Certified copy of registered land documents is not submitted. English version of land documents is not originally notarized.

Building Plan is in the name of Trust not in the name of running institution. Site area is not mentioned in the same.

Multipurpose hall is also not shown in the building plan. Original Blue Print of the Building Plan is not submitted. Every

room has been shown in the building plan as “ Class room” of equal dimension instead of specify it as laboratory, office etc. Moreover, built up area is not matching in Building Plan and in the affidavit.



Sl.No

CodeCourseName of

the Institution

State

Remarks of SRC

36. SRCAPP1466

D.El.EdDRS

DRS College of Education, No.298/C1, Fatehpur Village, Thorrur Post & Taluk, Warangal District-506163, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Vignyan Educational Society, No. 10-4-170/A, Mamillagudem Road, Khammam


54


College of Education, Warangal

DistrictAP

Village, Post & Taluk, Khammam District-507001, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to DRS College of Education, No. 298/C1, Fatehpur Village, Thorrur Post & Taluk, Warangal District-506163, Andhra Pradesh for D.EI.Ed course online on 30.09.2011 for two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 10.10.2011 (by private courier without date).

Meanwhile, the matter was placed before SRC in its 213 th meeting held on 6th and 7the November, 2011. The committee decided to reject the application, since the hard copy of application is submitted after the stipulated period of 7 days.

NCTE-Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009, it amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-

2 (B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely. 1 (1-A) (I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

a. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

b. Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

c. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in its 213th meeting held on 06th-07th November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. the Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

Hard copy not submitted within time frame.

The institution has submitted proof of dispatch on 1.12.2011 & 5.12.2011 in response to this office letter dated 09/11/2011 i.e. after the decision of SRC 213 th

meeting held on 6th and 7th November, 2011. As per the decision of SRC, the rejection order was issued on 24/01/2012 for non-submission of hard copy within the time frame.

The reply to proof of dispatch was received late it could not be entertained, since the SRC has already taken a decision.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP1466 (2012-13)/D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/36231 dated 24/01/2012. Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-106/2012 Appeal/4th Meeting-2012 A 51640 dated 11/05/2012 state that “the council concluded that there was adequate Justification in remanding the case to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per


55


regulations”.

The SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th-31st May 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 11.05.2012 and decided to process the application on submission of original application and related supporting documents as per the regulations.

As per direction of SRC, the application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 02.07.2012. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 11.07.2012 and the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 23.07.2012.

The SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30th – 31st July 2012 considered the reply

of the institution dt.25-06-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 10th - 13th August 2012, the same was intimated to the institution 07.08.2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 12.08.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 231st meeting held on 22nd – 23rd August 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

The institution has submitted a written representation on 12.09.2012 based on information on the website


As per direction of Southern Regional Committee in its SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 letter of intent prior to recognition was issued to applicant institution on 12/10/2012. In response to this office letter the institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 19/11/2012.

The list of staff is signed as possessing qualification by Director SCERT, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh.

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional


56


Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.El.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (Fifty only) students from the year 2013-14.

37. SRCAPP1745

D.El.EdSri Harisha

D.Ed College, Nellore District

AP

Sri Harsha D.Ed Collage, Plot No 11/11, 15/18, 15/1, 16/2, NH-17 Street, Pothireddipalem Village & Post Office, Kovur Mandal, Nellore District – 524 137, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Harsha Educational Society, Plot No. 17/47A, Dronamrajuvari Street, Backside Shivapriya Lodge Village, Nellore Post & Taluk, Nellore District- 524001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Harsha D.Ed Collage, Plot No 11/11, 15/18, 15/1, 16/2, NH-17 Street, Pothireddipalem Village & Post Office, Kovur Mandal, Nellore District – 524 137, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 01.10.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 05.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 31.10.2011/21.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 24.02.2012.

The SRC in its 219th meeting held on 15th-16th March, 2012 considered the written reply of the institution and other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 09th-13th April, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 30/03/2012 the Inspection of the institution was conducted on 11/04/2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 222nd Meeting held on 9th – 10th May 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued on 09/06/2012.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 25/06/2012 based on information on the website.

The reply of the institution vide letter dt,. 25.06.2012 to the show cause notice was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

The institution has submitted one building completion certificate dt.22.06.2012 from Executive engineer, I & CAD Irrigation Division, Tirupati. The institution has submitted and second building completion certificate dt.15.02.2012 from Assistant Executive engineer, P.R. Projects, Atmakur, AP, The institution has submitted two different building completion certificates from two different engineers of two different locations, whereas the institution is located at Kovur Mandal, Nellure District AP as per Building plan, which is not acceptable.

The certificate issued by two different officials other than the certificate from the engineer of the area or location is not as per norms.


57



Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 226 th meeting held on 09th-10th July, 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on 21/08/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution has approached to Hon’ble High Court in W.P.No. 23586/2012

Now, the Hon’ble High Court has passed an order vide W.P.No. 23586 of 2012 reads as here under:

“ By order of High Court dated 21/08/2012 in WP.No 23586 of 2012 filed by the Petitioner Vizianagaram, 1. Sri Harsha Educational Society (Regn. No. 516/06) 17/47A, Dronam Raju Street, Nellore-524001, Rep. By its President M. Haribabu, 2. Sri Harsh D.Ed College, Pothireddipalem, Kovvur (M) Nellore-524137, Rep., by its Correspondent M. Hari Babu, The Writ Petition is allowed and order dated 9 th – 10th – 07- 2012 of Respondent No. 2 is set aside respondent no. 2 is directed to re-consider the petitioners application in the light of the building completion certificate dated 22/06/2012 and take a fresh decision within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of this order-order follows.”

The matter was placed before the committee and SRC in its 231st meeting held on 22nd – 23rd August 2012 decided to process the application.

The SRC in its 232nd meeting held on 29th to 31st August 2012 has considered the Hon’ble High court order dt. 21/08/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) NCTE Act for the following.

Meantime the institution submit its reply on 25.09.2012 with reference of 232nd

meeting minutes available on NCTE website.


As per direction of Southern Regional Committee in its SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17th-18th October, 2012 letter of intent prior to recognition was issued to applicant institution on 25/10/2012. In response to this office letter the institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 19/11/2012.

The list of staff are signed as possessing qualification by Director SCERT, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh.


58


On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.El.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (Fifty only) students from the year 2013-14, subject to creating their website.

38. SRCAPP738

D.El.EdGandhi

Centenary Institute of Elementary Education,

East Godavari District

AP

Gandhi Centenary Institute of Elementary Education, Khasara No. 13, Plot No. 46-13-01, Jagannaickpur Village & Post Office, Kakinada Urban Taluka, Kakinada City, East Godavari District-533002, Andhra Pradesh.

The Kakinada Education Society, Plot No. 46-13-1, Sivalayam Street, Kakinada Village, Jagannaickpur Post, Kakinada Taluka 7 City, East Godavari District-533002, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Gandhi Centenary Institute of Elementary Education, Khasara No. 13, Plot No. 46-13-01, Jagannaickpur Village & Post Office, Kakinada Urban Taluka, Kakinada City, East Godavari District-533002, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 26/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 3/10/2011.

The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 08/11/2011 followed by reminder on 9/12/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29/12/2012.

The institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on 5/03/2012.The Committee in its 222nd Meeting of SRC held on 09th – 10th May, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 05/03/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) Notarized English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted is not clear and not readable, hence required to submit a copy of the land documents.

2) The institution has submitted the approved photocopy of building plan in favour of Gandhi Centenary School, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009. Approved blue print of the building plan for proposed D.El.Ed course is not submitted.

3) Building completion certificate submitted is for School purpose not for proposed D.El.Ed course. Building completion certificate submitted is not approved by competent Govt. authorized engineer.

4) Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the purpose of educational institution only is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

5) In the encumbrance certificate submitted, the information is written by pen and transaction in whose favour took place is not clear/readable.

6) In the affidavit submitted, Sy.No. is not given.7) Land document, building plan and building completion certificate from

competent authority submitted is not for the proposed D.El.Ed course, but all the above documents are submitted for Gandhi Centenary School, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulations 2009.

8) Proof of completion of 3 academic sessions towards B.Ed course which is


59


already run by the institution from the affiliating body/State Govt/examining body is not submitted.

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 15.06.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation dt. 25.06.2012 received in the office of SRC on 28.06.2012




On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.El.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (Fifty only) students from the year 2013-14.

39. SRCAPP850

D.El.Ed-AlRousseau College of

Elementary Teacher

Education, Karimnagar

DistrictAP

Rousseau College of Elementary Teacher Education Institution, Plot No. 384, Venkatraopally, Narsingapur Post, Boinpally Taluka, Karimnagar District-505524, Andhra Pradesh.

St Anna Educational Society, Plot No.384, Vemulawada Road, Venkatraopally Village, Narsingapur Post, Boinpally Taluka, Karimnagar Town, Karimnagar District- 505524 had applied for grant of recognition to Rousseau College of Elementary Teacher Education Institution, Plot No. 384, Venkatraopally, Narsingapur Post, Boinpally Taluka, Karimnagar District-505524, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed-AI course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 11.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 11.07.2012 . A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 11.07.2012 and the institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on10.08.2012.

The SRC in its SRC in its 230th Meeting held on 16th-17th August 2012 considered the deficiency reply of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to Cause Inspection under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms,


60


for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 05.09.2012.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed-Al course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.


The list of staff is signed as possessing qualification by Director SCERT, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act for the following:

The Institution has not appointed Lecturer in Telugu, Science and foundation course.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Notice to the institution, as to why the recognition be not refused and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal and rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

40. SRCAPP939

D.El.EdJMJ D.Ed College, Kadapa District

AP

JMJ D.Ed College, No. 66/A4, A8, Kanumlopalli Village, R.J. Puram Post, Sidhout Taluk, Kadapa District-516002, Andhra Pradesh.

Society of Jesus Mary And Joseph Nirmala Convent, No. 66/A4, A8, Madras Road, Kanumloplli Village, R.J. Puram Post, Sidhout Taluk, Kadapa District-516002, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to JMJ D.Ed College, No. 66/A4, A8, Kanumlopalli Village, R.J. Puram Post, Sidhout Taluk, Kadapa District-516002, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011 .



61


Government for recommendation on 02.11.2011 followed by reminder on 14.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011.

The institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on 30.01.2012.

The SRC in its 217th meeting held on 08-09 February, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 30.01.2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

The inspection of the institution was fixed between 25-29 February, 2012. The same was intimated to the institution on 21.02.2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 27.02.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 221st Meeting held on 19th to 20th April 2012 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show Cause Notice under section 14(1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued on 16/05/2012.

The institution has submitted its written representations on 29.05.2012


1. Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted.

2. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

3. The institution has submitted land usage certificate for a Junior College for Girls at the premises/building. The management has given the same building/premises for proposed D.El.Ed course, which is not as per norms. The management has also admitted the same in its reply and further stated shifting of Junior College from the building to another building, without any documentary proof of shifting from the competent authority. As per Regulations 2009, the building should be ready at the time of making application/or at the time of visit and it should be solely meant for teacher education only.

4. In the building completion certificate submitted, column No. 9 is not duly filled up for course/college name.


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Further decided to return endowment funds and Reserve fund deposited with SRC


62


NCTE, Bangalore.

Accordingly, Rejection order was issued to the institution on 05.07.2012. Mean time the institution prefer to an appeal at NCTE, Hqtr. The file was sent to the NCTE, Hqtr on 26.07.2012.

The Council hereby remands back the case of JMJ D.Ed college, Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above.

The institution submits relevant document as per requirement of above the grounds





Consideration of Show Cause Notice Reply (Volume- 02)

41. SRCAPP1516D.El.EdSanjeev D.El.Ed

College, East Godavari District

AP

Sanjeev D.El.Ed College, No.1-4, Main Road, Gollapalem Village & Post, Kajuluru Mandal, East Godavari District-533468, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Ram Educational and Welfare Society, No.23, Sri Vidya Colony Road, Kakinada Village Post and Taluk, East Godavari District-533003, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Sanjeev D.El.Ed College, No.1-4, Main Road, Gollapalem Village & Post, Kajuluru Mandal, East Godavari District-533468, Andhra Pradesh for D.E.C.Ed course of two year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act.1993 online application on 30.09.2011 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 18.10.2011.

NCTE-Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009, it amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as


63


follows:-





The SRC considered the matter in its 213th meeting held on 6th-7th November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

1. Not submitted valid print out of online application and application code is not available. Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP1516 (2012-13)/D.E.C.Ed/AP/2012-13/40772 dated 03.05.2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-180/2012 Appeal/6th Meeting-2012 dated 17.07.2012 state that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the matter to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per Regulations”.

In obedience to the appeal order. The application has been processed for D.El.Ed

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 has considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) NCTE Act.Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 12/10/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 13/11/2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 13.11.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted. Notarised English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted.

The building plan submitted is not clear and total built up area of 131.65 sq.mtrs + 107.85 sq.mtrs = 239.50 sq.mtrs is inadequate as per NCTE norms of 2009.


64


Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

Notarised Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal & rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.


Jeremiah College of Education,

East Godavari District

AP

Jeremiah College of Education, Plot No. 673, Burugupadi Village & Post, Korukonda Taluk, East Godavari District-530016, Andhra Pradesh.

Banaiah Christian Educational Society, 2nd Floor, Satya Surya Complex, Opp Complex RTC Dwarakanagar, vishakapatnam District-530016, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Jeremiah College of Education, Plot No. 673, Burugupadi Village & Post, Korukonda Taluk, East Godavari District-530016, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course on 26.09.2011 for two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 28/09/2011. NCTE-Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009, it amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-2 (B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely. 1 (1-A) (I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

1. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

2. Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

3. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in its 216th meeting held on 11th-12th January, 2012 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional committee decided to reject the application on the


65


following grounds.

1. Proof of dispatch of hard copy of application not submitted within 7 days.

Accordingly, a rejection order to Jeremiah College of Education, East Godavari District, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course was issued vide F.No. SRCAPP734/(D.El.Ed) AP/2012-13/39677 dated 29/03/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No. 89-185/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting – 2012 dated 18/09/2012 stated that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the matter to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per regulations. The council hereby remands back the case of Jeremiah College of Education, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh to SRC, NCTE for necessary action as indicated above”.

The SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30th-31st July, 2012 considered Appellate authority order dt. 18/09/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

As per the information of the website the institution has submitted written representation on 21/08/2012

The SRC in its 231st Meeting held on 22nd – 23rd August 2012, considered the reply of the institution dt. 21/08/2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 08.09.2012 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 14.09.2012.

The SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has to submit a fresh VCD showing the infrastructural and instructional facilities provided in the building meant for the proposed course.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 02.11.2012. The institution has submitted the reply on 19.11.2012.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating


66


University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.


Sri Mallikarjuna D.Ed College,

Krishna District

AP

Sri Mallikarjuna D.Ed College, Khasra No. 446/4, 447/1, Plot No. 3-102/4, Subbarao Street, Dhavajigudem Village, Gannavaram Post Office, Gannavaram Taluk, Gannavaram Town, Krishna District, Andhra Pradesh - 521101

Sri Mallikarjuna Educational Society, Plot No. 3-102/4,Subbarao Nagar Street Dhavajigudem Village ,Gannavaram Post Office,Gannavaram Taluk , Gannavaram Town , Krishna District , Andhra Pradesh – 521101 had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Mallikarjuna D.Ed Village, Gannavaram Post Office, Gannavaram Taluk , Gannavaram Town, Krishna District , Andhra Pradesh – 521101 for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04/10/2011

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 17/10/2011 followed by reminder on 19/12/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29/12/2011.

The institution has submitted reply for deficiency letter on 15/03/2012.

The institution has submitted reply for deficiency letter after the stipulated time of 60 days period as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations

The Southern Regional Committee in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012, considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 15/3/2012, i.e., after 76 (Seventy Six) days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution on 30.05.2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-393/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting-2012 dated 05.09.2012 states that ‘the council concluded that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the case to the SRC for consideration of reply of the institution and for taking further decision there after. ’

In puissance to the Appellate Authority order dated 05.09.2012, the application is being processed.

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 considered the Appellate authority order of 5th meeting 2012, dt. 05.09.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 06/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on. 19/11/2012.


67



Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted.

As per building plan, the size of the multipurpose hall is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft. as per NCTE norms 2009.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal & rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

Consideration of Inspection u/s 14 (Volume- 02)

44. SRCAPP1532

D.El.EdK Narayana Memorial College of Education, Medak District

AP

K Narayana Memorial College of Education, Plot/Khasara No. 10-1/1, Khasara No. 480, Narsingi Village and Post, Narsingi City and Taluk, Medak District – 502248, Andhra Pradesh

Kamala Smaraka Vidhya Samiti, Plot No. 10-1/1, Narsingi Road and Village, Narsingi City and Post, Chegunta Taluk, Medak District – 502248, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to K Narayana Memorial College of Education, Plot/Khasara No. 10-1/1, Khasara No. 480, Narsingi Village and Post, Narsingi City and Taluk, Medak District – 502248, Andhra Pradesh for D.EL.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.09.2011 and physical copy received on 05.10.2011.


The SRC in its 220th Meeting held on 30th – 31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 28.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve show cause notice under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 07.05.2012.

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May 2012 and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:-


68


1. As per sale deed, land is registered on 10-11-2011, after the date of on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulation 2009.

2. The institution has admitted in its reply that land is registered on 10.11.2011, which is after on-line application submission, as well after submission of Hard copies of the application.

3. Original up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th-31st May 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide F.No.SRCAPP1532/D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/43148 dated 27.06.2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-356/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting-2012 dated 18.09.2012 states that ‘taking into account the facts, circumstances and recommendation of the state government it was decided that the application of the institution be processed by the SRC in accordance with the extant Regulations, relaxed by the NCTE Committee with regard to the date of the registration of land prior to the date of application owing to the Telangana Strike .

The council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC with a direction to process the applications and to take further decisions thereafter ’.In pursuance to the Appellate authority order dated 18.09.2012, the application is

being processed.

The institution has enclosed a copy of the explanation dated 05.07.2012 submitted by them to the appellate authority with regard to the points mentioned in the Rejection order dated 27.06.2012

The SRC in its 234th meeting held on 17th-18th October 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 18.09.2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 16.11.2012 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 19.11.2012

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14


69


subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Consideration of MISC., Case (Volume- 02)

45. APS09781B.Ed

Mahathma Gandhi Trust,

Mysore District

KA

Mahathma Gandhi Trust, C a 3&4, Adi Shakti Road, Shakti Nagara, Alanahallli Mysore District – 570019, Karnataka

Mahathma Gandhi Trust, # 106, 1st Floor, Raghavendra Building, N.S Road, Near Shanthala Theater, Mysore, Karnataka has made application for grant of recognition to Mahathma Gandhi Trust, C a 3&4, Adi Shakti Road, Shakti Nagara, Alanahallli Mysore District – 570019, Karnataka for B.Ed course to Southern Regional Committee on 31.10.2008

An inspection team was constituted by SRC-NCTE, which visited the institution on 08.05.2009 to verify the essential documents as per NCTE Regulations, Human Resources, Infrastructural and instructional facility provided by the institution for said course.

The report of the inspection team was placed before the SRC in its 175 th meeting held o9n 13th – 14th July 2009.

Upon consideration of the inspection team report submitted by the visiting team and other document furnished by the institution along with the application, the committee is of the opinion that the institution prima facie, does not fulfill the requirements, the Norms and Standards laid down by the NCTE in accordance with the provision of NCTE act, 1983, as detailed below:-

1. A portion of the ground floor of the main Building is constructed for commercial purpose. The rooms facing the road are fitted with rolling iron shatters. Therefore the Building is not suitable to run B.Ed course.

2. The furniture in class rooms are not suitable to run B.Ed course.3. The items in physical Educational are not provided.4. The Science, Psychology, E.T labs are not established properly.5. The management has to submit the approved Building Plan and Building

Completion Certificate with Built-up space and it is constructed for B.Ed course.

As per the Section 14(3) (b) of NCTE Act, 1993, an opportunity is hereby given to make written representation. Before the Regional Committee passes the final order on your application, You are hereby given an opportunity for making such written representation within 15 days as you may wish to make supported by documentary evidences. The institution may submit documentary proof duly certified by the Competent Authority with respect of the deficiency notified as above along with an affidavit and fresh VCD supporting removal of the above deficiencies.

Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the institution on 29.05.20o9. the institution submits its written representation on 19.06.2009.

The SRC in its 177th meeting held on 22nd – 23rd June 2009considering the relevant document and it was decided to issue Letter of Intent to the institution. Accordingly LOI was issued to the institution on 25.09.2009. The institution has submitted its reply on 09.07.2009.


70


The institution in its 178th meeting held on 13th – 14th July 2009concidering the reply of LOI and it was decided to issue Formal Recognition to the institution. Accordingly Formal Recognition was issued to the institution 15.07.2009.

Mean time a letter from University of Mysore issued by the director was received on 24.08.2012 in the which stated as follows:-

Local Inquiry Committee, University of Mysore, Mysore which conducted affiliation inspection recommended not to continue affiliation for the Mahatma Gandhi B.Ed College, Mysore for the year 2012.13. the recommendation of the committee was approved by the university Authorities, the Government Karnataka has approved the decision not to continue affiliation for Mahatma Gandhi B.Ed college Mysore for the year 2012-13. Hence, the said college has been informed not to make admission for the year 2012-13.

A letter dated 15.11.2012 requesting not to allot Government seats to the College has been received by this office 19.11.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

Local Inquiry Committee, University of Mysore, Mysore which conducted affiliation inspection recommended not to continue affiliation for the Mahatma Gandhi B.Ed College, Mysore for the year 2012.13. the recommendation of the committee was approved by the university Authorities, the Government Karnataka has approved the decision not to continue affiliation for Mahatma Gandhi B.Ed college Mysore for the year 2012-13. Hence, the said college has been informed not to make admission for the year 2012-13.

A letter dated 15.11.2012 requesting not to allot Government seats to the College has been received by this office 19.11.2012.



46. SRCAPP1077D.El.EdSri Vani Training

Institution, Prakasam

DistrictAP

Sri Vani Teacher Training Institution, Plot/Khasara No. Old Badwel Road, Giddalur Village, Post & Taluk, Prakasam District-523357, Andhra Pradesh.Sri Vani Educational Society, Maruthi Nagar, Kurnool Village, Post & Taluk, Kurnool District-518002, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Sri. Vani Teacher Training Institution, Plot/Khasara No. Old Badwel Road, Giddalur Village, Post & Taluk, Prakasam District-523357, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course on 29.09.2011 for two years duration


71


under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act.1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 07.10.2011. NCTE-Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009, it amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-2 (B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely. 1 (1-A) (I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:




The SRC considered the matter in 213th meeting held on 6th-7th November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

Hardcopy not submitted within time frame from the date of on-line submission as per Regulation 2009.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP1077(2012-13)/D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/36221 dated 23/01/2012.Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-169/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting-2012 dated 18.06.2012 state that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the case to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per Regulations”.The SRC in its 227th meeting held on 17th-19th July 2012, considered for processing of application.The SRC in its 228th meeting held on 24th – 25th July 2012 considered the Appellate authority order and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted. Notarized English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted. Land documents submitted is in individual name, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

2) Sy.No. 384 shown in building plan is not matching with land documents submitted.

3) Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted.

4) Notarized land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.


72



6) Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalized Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name if not given.

Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 10.08.2012. the institution has submitted the written reply on 07.09.2012.The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 31.08.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) In the building plan submitted, total earmarked land area is not given.

2) Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

3) Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given.

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 01.11.2012.Now the institution has submitted its written representation dt. 15.11.2012 received in the office of SRC on 16.11.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 16.11.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:


As per Building Plan submitted (P-92/C, the institution has proposed to run the institution in (GF+FF) of block A and (FF) of block B consisting of built up area 1907 Sq Mts. As per Regulations exclusive builtup area should be earmarked to run any Teacher institution utilization of GF of Block is not clear and also not shown in the Building Plan.

Online application is not reflecting any Sy No. but institution has submitted land with Sy No. 176/B.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter;


73


failing which action will be taken including the refusal & rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

47. SRCAPP1037D.El.EdKrishna

Institute of Teacher

Education, Mahabubnaga

r DistrictAP

Krishna Institute of Teacher Education, Plot/Khasara No.461/AA/ABapu Nagar Street, Narayanpet Village and Post, Narayanpet City and Taluka, Mahabubnagar District-509210, Andhra Pradesh.

Surya Laxmi Educational Society, Plot No.1-6-41/1, Bapu Nagar Street, Narayanpet Village and Post, Narayanpet City and Taluk, Mahbubnagar District-509210, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Krishna Institute of Teacher Education, Plot/Khasara No.461/AA/ABapu Nagar Street, Narayanpet Village and Post, Narayanpet City and Taluka, Mahabubnagar District-509210, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 20.10.2011 (speed post on 01.10.2011).

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 02.11.2011 / 26.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 01.03.2012.

The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th- 20th April, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 01.03.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 16.05.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 05.06.2012.

The SRC in its 224th meeting held on 14th-16th June, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.05-06-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 04 th to 08th

July, 2012. The same was intimated to the institution on 29.06.2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 26.07.2012.

The SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30th–31st July 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. The land documents submitted was executed/registered on 12.10.1970, after this, in the encumbrance certificate; land was against sold to Perur Sujatha i.e. in individual name, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

2. Land documents submitted is in favour of ”Vidya Vardhanik Samith


74


Junior College”, which is not the Society mentioned in on-line application. As per on-line application the Society name is “Surya Laxmi Educational Society”. Registration of land documents in different Society’s name is not permissible as per NCTE norms. Proceedings from Revenue Department submitted is for “Surya Laxmi Degree College”, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

3. In the affidavit submitted, column No.5 is corrected, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

4. The rectification deed is not submitted as per encumbrance certificate.

5. The institution is running a Arts College in the same building/premises, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

Meantime, by seeing the decision in the website, the institution has submitted its written representation on 28/08/2012.

The SRC in its 232nd meeting held on 29th-31st August 2012, decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, LETTER OF INTENT was issued to the institution on 05.09.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 08.10.2012


The institution has not submitted Marks sheets of Principal and Lecturers.

Principal’s Experience certificate is not showing the exact duration of his service in the previous institution. As per the experience certificate, the Principal is having only one year experience i.e. for 2007- 2008.

Appointment of Lecturer in Telugu is not as per NCTE norms.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 19.11.2012. By seeing the SRC website the institution has submitted the reply on 19.11.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice


75


Under section NCTE Act for the following:

The institution has not appointed lecturer in Telugu.



Adarsha Institute of

Teacher Education, Warangal

DistrictAP

Adarsha Institute of Teacher Education, No. 7-1-100/1, 1st Street, Ambedkar Nagar, Hanamkonda Village, Post & Taluk, Warangal District-506011, Andhra Pradesh.

Sagar Education Society, No. 5-6-16, Lashkar Bazar Road, Hanamkonda Village, Post & Taluk, Warangal District-506001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Adarsha Institute of Teacher Education, No. 7-1-100/1, 1st Street, Ambedkar Nagar, Hanamkonda Village, Post & Taluk, Warangal District-506011, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.9.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 01.11.2011 followed by reminder on 09.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011.

The institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days and till date.

As per sub-clause (1) of clause 7 of NCTE Regulation 2009, the applicant institutions is required to submit deficiencies to the Southern Regional Committee Office within 60 days from the date of receipt of communication of deficiencies , failing which the application will be treated as rejected and closed, no extension to time will be granted and any submission received after 60 days will be treated as invalid and not entertained.

The committee in its 221st Meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012, considered the matter, as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

As per the decision of SRC, rejection order was issued to the institution on


76


30.05.2012.

The institution had filed appeal under Section 18 of NCTE Act, before the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi against the rejection order of SRC.

The institution has submitted a letter along with a copy of appellate authority order dated 17.08.2012 and the order remands back the case.

The reply to the deficiency letter dated 29.12.2011.

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17/08/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14(1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted.

Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs. 100/- stamp paper duly attested by oath Commissioner or notary public, is not submitted.


Building plan submitted is showing the building as a residential staff quarters building and the plan is not a Blue print.

As per encumbrance certificate submitted, it is showing mortgage to Indian Bank. Which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

Details of other teacher educational programmes and other courses run by the institution in the same building/premises is not given.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 02/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 19/11/2012, which is as follows:

A letter dated 17/11/2012 stated that “with reference to above cited subject, I would like to submit that this institution has already submitted all the required documents vide ref (2) within the time frame of 60 days. Original certified copies of land documents along with the affidavit as per your norms. Blue print of plan of building are submitted along with the letter. A banker’s certificate was also submitted for Rs. 16 Lakhs towards the endowment fund and reserve fund.

Moreover, I humbly submit that this society has no other teacher educational program to run in the building which is shown in the application. Kindly consider this letter and take necessary action in favour of the institution”.

Note: - As stated in the letter dated 17/11/2012 has not submitted reply dt. 27/02/2012. However, from the center diary report for the period from


77


01/01/2012 to 20/11/2012 it is observed that the institution has never submitted reply dt. 27/02/2012.

The institution has not submitted reply for Show Cause Notice even after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days from the date of issue of the notice.

Keeping in view, Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal No. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165-68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:

“An institution is not entitled to recognition unless it fulfills the conditions specified in various clauses of the Regulations. The Council is directed to ensure that in future no institution is granted recognition unless it fulfils the conditions laid down in the Act and the Regulations and the time schedule fixed for processing the application by the Regional Committee and communication of the decision on the issue of recognition it strictly adhered to”.

The committee considered the non-reply of the institution to the issue of show cause notice and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course (SRCAPP838).

49. SRCAPP1044D.El.Ed-AISree Rama Institute of Elementary Education,

Chittoor District

AP

Sree Rama Institute of Elementary Education,Khasra No. 242,Plot No. 8,9,10,Street Ni.1,Sreenivasapuram Village, Tituchanoor Post, Tirupathi rural, Chittoor District- 517503, Andhra Pradesh

Sree Rama Educational Society, Plot No. 2-1, Srinivasa puram Street, Thituchanoor Road, Tirup Rural,Chittoor District – 517503, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Sree Rama Institute of Elementary Education,Khasra No. 242,Plot No. 8,9,10,Street Ni.1,Sreenivasapuram Village, Tituchanoor Post, Tirupathi rural, Chittoor District- 517503, Andhra Pradesh for D.EI.Ed-A.I course on 29.09.2011 two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 and received in the southern Regional committee , NCTE on 07.10.2011.

NCTE – H'qrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009 and amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-

2(B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely.” 1(1-A) (I) The application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:



c. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the


78


Course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in 213th Meeting of SRC held on 06th – 07th

November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents. NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

Hard Copy submitted after the stipulated period of 7 days from the date on on-line submission.

The application of Sree Rama Institute of Elementary Education,Khasra No. 242,Plot No. 8,9,10,Street Ni.1,Sreenivasapuram Village, Tituchanoor Post, Tirupathi rural, Chittoor District- 517503, Andhra Pradesh for permission to D.EI.Ed course is hereby rejected.Accordingly, a rejection order was issue to the institution on 23.01.2012.

The institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh ,W. P. No. 26366 of 2012 and the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in its order has stated that ‘.. “Directed respondent 1 to reconsider the petitioner’s application on merits with reference to the documents filed by it and communicate the decision thereon to the petitioner within two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order”

In obedience to the Andhra Pradesh High Court order (W.P.No 26366), the application is being processed

The SRC in its 232nd meeting held on 29th-31st August 2012, considered the Hon’ble High Court Order and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of ld NCTE Act, for the following:

Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted. Notarised English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted.

Original approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted. In the building plan copy submitted, proposed College name, course name and earmarked built up area for the proposed course is not mentioned.

Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted. In the BCC submitted, column No. 2 shows owner of the land is in individual name and also land is leased to Sree Rama College of Education, Sreenivasapuram, Tirupati, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.



79



Original Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

The institution has not submitted valid minority certificate issued by the competent authority from the State Govt. as B.Ed is banned in the State of Andhra Pradesh.

Proof of completion of 3 academic sessions towards B.Ed, M.Ed & D.Ed courses which are already run by the institution from the affiliating body/State Govt/examining body is not submitted.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 26.09.2012 (with reference to online).

The SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17th-18th October, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 26.09.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 19/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 20/11/2012,


certified copy of the land documents for Sy.No. 242 from Sub-registrar is submitted but it is not notarized in original.

Building plan is not submitted. Building completion certificate is submitted. But it is not in

prescribed format. Proceeding of revenue department not submitted for conversion

of land from agricultural to non-agricultural / Educational purpose.

Encumbrance Certificate is not approved by the Sub-Registrar.





80


50. SRCAPP1385D.El.EdRakesh

College of Diploma in Elementary Education, Nalgonda

DistrictAP

Rakesh College of Diploma in Elementary Education, Plot No. 183/A, Surya Pet Village, Post & Taluk, Nalgonda District-508213, Andhra Pradesh

Keetha Rakesh Verma Educational Society, Plot No. 183/A, Chinthacheruvu Road, Surya Pet Village, Post & Taluk, Nalgonda District-508213, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Rakesh College of Diploma in Elementary Education, Plot No. 183/A, Surya Pet Village, Post & Taluk, Nalgonda District-508213, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course on 30.09.2011 for two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 07.10.2011.






The SRC considered the matter in 213th meeting held on 6th-7th November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:-

1. Not submitted valid print out of online application and application code is not available.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP1385 (2012-13) /D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/36908 dated 13/01/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-465/2011 Appeal/3rd Meeting-2012 dated 18.04.2012 state that “the council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the matter to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per Regulations”.

The appellate authority order was placed before SRC in its 226 th meeting held on 09th-10th July 2012 and SRC decided to process the application for further processing of application on merit as per regulations.

The SRC in its 228th meeting held on 24th-25th July 2012, considered the Appellate authority order and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.


81


The institution has submitted its written representation on 22.08.2012 (with reference to online minutes).

The SRC in its 232nd meeting held on 29th-31st August 2012, considered the reply of the institution dt.22-08-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection for the 2013-14 under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.



Accordingly letter of intent was issued to the institution on 04.10.2012.

Another letter relating to submit revalidated DD’s of DD No. 539200 dt. 29.09.2011 of Rs. 40,000/- and DD No. 633928 dt. 28.09.2011.

The institution was its reply for Letter of intent on 19.11.2012 and another reply with revalidated DD’s.


Consideration of Inspection u/s-14 (Volume- 02)


G P Ladda D.Ed College,

Adilabad District

AP

G P Ladda D.Ed College , Plot No. 4-3-58/ 4C/ 1& SY No 219 ,Bhainsa Village , Bhainsa Post Office , Mudhol Taluka , Bhainsa City , Adilabad District 504103 ,Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Saraswathi Educational Society , Plot No. 2-2-119, Marwadi Gally , Bhainsa Village , Bhainsa Post Office , Mudhole Taluka ,Bhainsa Town , Adilabad District 504103 ,Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to G P Ladda D.Ed College ,Plot No. 4-3-58/4C/1&SY No 219 ,Bhainsa Village , Bhainsa Post Office , Mudhol Taluka ,Bhainsa City , Adilabad District 504103 ,Andhra Pradesh for D.EI.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act,1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 26/09/2011 and Physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 29/09/2011.

The Application was scrutinized and a copy of the application was sent to the


82


State Government for Recommendation on 14/10/2011 followed by reminder on 06/01/2012.A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30/12/2011.

Now the Institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 13/02/2012.

The committee in its 218th meeting held on 28th February 2012,considered the reply of the institution dated 13/02/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act . Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 22/03/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 16/04/2012 .

The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the stipulated time of 21 days period.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 222nd meeting held on 9th – 10th May,2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 16/04/2012, i.e., after 25 (Twenty five) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt. 22/03/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course

Accordingly, a rejection letter to G.P.Ladda D.Ed College, Bhainsa City, Adilabad ,Andhra Pradesh for D.EI.Ed course was issued vide F.No.SRCAPP723/D.EI.Ed/AP/2012-13/42778 dated 20.06.2012

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-189/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting-2012 dated 18.06.2012 states that “ the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for further processing of application on merit as per regulations.”

In obedience to the Appellate Authority order dated 05.09.2012, the reply of the Institution was processed and placed before SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17-18th of Oct, 2012.

The SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17th-18th October, 2012 considered the Appellate authority order d. 05-09-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 15 th-20th November, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 01/11/2012 the inspection of the institution was conducted on 17/11/2012.

The committee considered the VT report, VCD and all other relevant documents of the institution and decided to refuse and reject for the following reasons:

Building plan is approved by Commissioner Municipal Council Bhainsa, and total site area is not mentioned

Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for


83


conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes. Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a

Nationalised Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given. FDRS submitted is already expired.

As per VT report, the size of the multipurpose hall is only 1251.5 sq.fts as against the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms of 2009.

The institution has submitted lease deed executed on 06/08/2011 with Sy.No. 209 and online application is also reflecting Sy.No. 209.

Instution has submitted another saledeed copy with Sy.No. 569 executed on 15/12/2003 but all the land document such as encumbrance certificate, building completion certificate are reflecting Sy.No. 219.

Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted. The institution has submitted encumbrance certificate upto dt. 04/04/2012, land is on lease basis.

Notarised copy of the land document with Sy.No. as per online application is not submitted.



Sri Venkatasai D.Ed College,

Prakasam District

AP

Sri. Venkatasai D.Ed College, Plot No.418/A, Street No.1, Pernamitta Village and P.O., Ongole Taluk, Prakasam District, Pin – 523225, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri.Venkata Sai Educational Development Society, Plot No.6-31(D), Sri.Saibaba Mandir Bazar street, Ongole Village and P.O., Prakasam District, Pin – 523002, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri.Venkatasai D.Ed College, Plot No.418/A, Street No.1, Pernamitta Village and P.O., Ongole Taluk, Prakasam District, Pin – 523225, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 15.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 23.09.2011.

NCTE – H'qrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulation 2009, it amendment Notified on 26th November, 2010 which reads as follows:-

2(B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely’. 1(1-A)(I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

a) The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the ate of submission of online application.

b) Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application ID s not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.


84


SRC considered the matter in 213th Meeting of SRC held on 6th – 7th November 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993, Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

Not submitted within time frame as per Regulations 2009.

Accordingly, the application of Sri. Venkatasai D.Ed College, Plot No.418/A, Street No.1, Pernamitta Village and P.O., Ongole Taluk, Prakasam District, Pin – 523225, Andhra Pradesh for permission to D.El.Ed course was rejected.

Accordingly rejection letter was issued to the institution on 13.01.2012.Aggrieved by the order of SRC, the institution preferred to go for an appeal with High Court.

The SRC in its 230th Meeting held on 16th – 17th decided to process the application.

The SRC in its 231st Meeting held on 22rd – 23rd August 2012 considered the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh order and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Mean while the institution was has submitted its written representation on 11.09.2012 with online website minutes reference as follows:-

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012,considered the reply of the institution dt. 11.09.2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 16.11.2012 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 19.06.02012.

The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:


Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted.

Original Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

As per VT report, available books in the library is only 800, which is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms 2009.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with


85


necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal & rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

53. SRCAPP1166

D.El.EdSri Sivasai College of

Elementary Teacher Training Center,

Srikakulam District

AP

Sri Sivasai College of Elementary Teacher Training Center, Plot/Khasara No. 24/4, Rajayyapet Street and Village, Rajam Post, Taluk and City, Srikakulam District – 532127, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Sivasai New Educational Society, Plot No. S/4, 3rd line, Maruthi Nagar Road, Dolapeta /Rajam/Rajam Village, Rajam Post, City and Taluk, Srikakulam District – 532127, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Sivasai College of Elementary Teacher Training Center, Plot/Khasara No. 24/4, Rajayyapet Street and Village, Rajam Post, Taluk and City, Srikakulam District – 532127, Andhra Pradesh for D.EL.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical copy received on 30.09.2011.


Institution states deficiency letter received on 12/01/2012.


The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th –20th April, 2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 12/3/2012, i.e., after 74 (Seventy four) days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order no. F.No. 89-313/2012 Appeal/7th Meeting- 2012 has stated as follows:

“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for further processing as per the Regulations.

Now therefore, the Council hereby remands back the case of Sri Sivasai College of Elementary Teacher Training Center, Srikakulam, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.

In obedience to the Appellate Authority order dated 17.08.2012, the reply of the institution is considered and placed before SRC in 234 th meeting held on 17-18th of Oct, 2012.

The SRC in its 234th meeting held on 17th –18th October 2012 has considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17-08-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 15th to 20th November 2012, the same was intimated to the institution 05.11.2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 17.11.2012.


86


The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:


As per VT report, books in the library is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.



Al Zeeshan College of

Elementary Teacher

Education, Nalgonda

DistrictAP

Al Zeeshan College of Elementary Teacher Education, No. 112, Venkatadripalem Village, Miryalguda Post & Taluk, Nalgonda District – 508207, Andhra Pradesh.

Al-Zeeshan Educational Society, No.12-153, Seetharampuram Road, Miryalguda Village, Post & Taluk, Nalgonda District – 508207, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Al Zeeshan College of Elementary Teacher Education, No.112, Venkatadripalem Village, Miryalguda Post & Taluk, Nalgonda District – 508207, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 28.10.2011 followed by reminder on 21.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011 and the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 24.02.2012.

The SRC in its 219th meeting held on 15th – 16th March 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 24.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has submitted sale deed land documents dt. 25.11.2011, which is after date of on-line application and not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 04.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 24.04.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 24.04.2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


87


Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution vide F.No.SRCAPP990/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/42374 dated 12.06.2012.

The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order no.F.No.89-303/2012 Appeal/7th meeting-2012 dated 18.09.2012 has stated as follows:-

“the council concluded that there was adequate around to remand the case to the SRC with a direction to process the applications and to take the further decision thereafter.

The council hereby remands back the case of Al Zeeshan College of Elementary Teacher Education, No.112, Venkatadripalem Village, Miryalguda Post & Taluk, Nalgonda District-508207, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.

The matter is placed before SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th-28th September 2012, considered the matter decided to process.

The institution submitted that land was registered on 25.11.2011, due to unavoidable circumstances, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms and the land must be registered on or before the date of on-line application submission.

NCTE Hqtrs order dt. 18.09.2012 stated as “the appellant submitted representation with regard to rejection of their application for the academic year 2012-13 in light of the Sakala Janula Samme. The State Government of Andhra Pradesh has forwarded a letter dated 14.08.2012 recommending relaxation in NCTE Regulations relating to registration of land prior to the date of applications owing to the Telangana Strike.

This recommendation was placed before the NCTE Committee in its 19 th meeting held on 10th September 2012. Taking into account the facts, circumstances and recommendation of the State Government it was decided that the application of the institution by processed by the SRC in accordance with the extant Regulations, relaxed by the NCTE Committee with regard to the date of the registration of the land documents.”

The Committee in its 234th meeting on 16-17th October, 2012 considered the Appellate authority order and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 18.11.2012 and the VT report received in the office of SRC on 19.11.2012.



88


Note: Subject to strengthening of Library.


Chandana D.Ed College,

Nalgonda District

AP

Chandana D.Ed College, Sy. No. 743, 744, Pillalamarri Village and Post, Suryapet Taluk and City, Nalgonda District – 508213, Andhra Pradesh.

Srinivasa Educational Society, Plot No. 2- 89, Bopparam Village and Post, Atmakur Taluk, Nalgonda District – 508221, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Chandana D.Ed College, Sy. No. 743, 744, Pillalamarri Village and Post, Suryapet Taluk and City, Nalgonda District – 508213, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14 (1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 01.10.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.10.2011.


The Southern Regional Committee in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 05.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued on 14.04.2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 23.05.2012.

The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days period as per clause 14 (1) of NCTE Regulations.


1. Gift deed of land document registered dt. 24.02.2012 on Sy. No. 743 & 744 submitted is after submission of on-line application which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.


Under the above grounds and with the reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May 2012, decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP1737/2012-13/D.El.Ed/AP/43297 dated 29.06.2012.

The institution preferred appeal to NCTE Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order no. F.No. 89-387/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting- 2012 dated 18.09.2012 has stated as follows:

“ the Council conclude that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC with a direction to process the application and to take the further decision thereafter.

The council hereby remands back the case of Chandana D.Ed College, Sy. No.


89


743, 744, Pillalamarri Village and Post, Suryapet Taluk and City, Nalgonda District – 508213, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.

In obedience to the Appellate authority order dated 24.09.2012, the SRC in its 233rd

meeting held on 26th –28th September 2012 decided to process the application.

Accordingly, the application is being processed as followsThe SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17th – 18th October 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 24/09/2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 17.11.2012 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 19.11.2012..


Note: Subject to strengthening of Library as per NCTE norms.


Vikas D.Ed College, Guntur District

AP

Vikas D.Ed College, Plot No. 401, 403, 404, 405, 406, Rayavaram, Macherla, Guntur District - 522426, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Vikas Educational Society, Plot No. 13-4-406, 13th Ward, Macherla Guntur , Andhra Pradesh had applied for recognition to Vikas D.Ed college , Plot No. 401, 403, 404, 405, 406, Rayavaram ,Macherla , Guntur– 522 426, Andhra Pradesh to D.EI.Ed course online on 23.09.2011 for two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 and received in the southern Regional Committee NCTE on 26.09.2011.NCTE-Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009, it amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-






90


The SRC considered the matter in its 213th meeting held on 06th-07th November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

Not submitted valid print out of on-line application and application College of Diploma in Education is not available.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP642 (2012-13)/D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/36306 dated 24/01/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-102/2012 Appeal/3rd Meeting-2012 A509 dated 18/04/2012 states that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the case to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per regulations”.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 30th-31st March, 2012 noted and considered the Council order dt. 18.04.2012 and other relevant documents and decided to further process the file for necessary action.

The SRC in its 228th meeting held on 24th-25th July 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 18.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to institution on 13.08.2012. The institution has submitted in its written representation on 14.08.2012.

The SRC in its 231st meeting held on 22nd-23rd August 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 14.08.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted. Notarized English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted.

Sy.No. 403/C reflected in building in plan is not given in building completion certificate.

Encumbrance certificate submitted dated 21.04.2012, where as rectification deed in the name of Sri Vikas Educational Society is not submitted.

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalized Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 17.07.2012 and 25.09.2012(with reference to online).

The SRC considered the reply of the institution dt.25-09-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


91


Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 15th November to 20th

November 2012, the same was intimated to the institution 02.11.2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 17.11.2012.


Note: Subject to strengthening of Library as per NCTE norms.

57. APS00248B.Ed

Rabindranath Tagore

College of Education,

Rangareddy District

AP

Rabindranath Tagore College of Education,Chevella Revenue Division, Kummera Village Rangareddy - 501 503 Andhra Pradesh.

Rabindranath Tagore Educational Society submitted an application for grant of recognition B.Ed Course and recognition was granted to the institution vide SRC order dated 03.07.2003 at Rabindranath Tagore College of Education,Chevella Revenue Division, Kummera Village Rangareddy - 501 503 Andhra Pradesh.

Shifting of premises as per regulation 2002 to permanent structure within three year from the date of issue of recognition in Andhra Pradesh.

The above matter was placed in 178th meeting of SRC held on 13th – 147th July, 2010 where in the committee observed from the records of the institutions were accorded recognition in the rented premises and they had not yet shifted to permanent premises/building. In view of non shifting of colleges to permanent building the committee decided to issue show cause notice under section 17 of NCTE Act and obtain shifting fees and other document for causing inspection for shifting.

As per the direction of Regional Committee Shoe Cause Notice was issued with request to submit following document with in 21 days of receipt of letter.

1. Demand Draft of Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be submitted.

2. Land document of new building/location for having own land in the name of the Institution/Society/Trust.

3. Building plan of the new building duly approved by the Government authority.

4. Building Completion Certificate from the Government authority in the Prescribed format ( Format enclosed )

5. Land usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted / sanctioned for educational Purposes only should be submitted.

6. Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government should be submitted.

7. Fixed Deposits Receipts of Rs. 5 Lakhs Kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with SRC in Nationalized Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.


92


8. Fixed Deposits Receipts of Rs. 3 Lakhs Kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with SRC in Nationalized Bank for a period of 5 years towards Reserve funds in ORIGINAL should be submitted.

9. Certificate of registration / Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be submitted.

10. The affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper In the prescribed format with Notary attestation should be submitted regarding land and building.

As per the perusal of the file the institution and as per the statement enclosed the institution has not submitted reply even after lapse of more than one year.

The Southern Regional committee in its 201st meeting held on 22nd – 23rd February 2011 considered the matter and decided to Withdraw the recognition for the above 17 institutions in Andhra Pradesh as all the above 17 institutions in Andhra Pradesh as all the above 17 institutions which were given conditional recognition in temporary premises failed to shift to permanent premises within the prescribed time limit of three years as per the norms, and also they had failed to respond to Show cause Notices issued by SRC, NCTE long back during 2008-2009.

Accordingly the application of Sri Rabindranath Tagore College of Education,Chevella Revenue Division, Kummera Village Rangareddy - 501 503 Andhra Pradesh was rejected vide order 07.04.2011. The Institution preferred for go to appeal at NCTE Hqrs. Where in NCTE Hqr. Has directed in order dated 03.08.2011 as under :“After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, VT report and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and reverse the SRC’s order dated 07.04.2011 with a direction to the conduct an inspection of the institution and take appropriate action thereafter. Accordingly, the appeal is accepted and the order of the SRC dated 07.04.2011 is reversed”.

The SRC in its 210th Meeting held 22nd – 23rd August 2012, on considered the Appellate authority order Dt.03.08.2011 and all the relevant documents of the institution and decided to cause inspection at the premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit the following within 30 days of the receipt of the notice, all the necessary documents for land, building approval and completion certificate from a competent Govt. Engineer and other relevant documents along with Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee towards the B.Ed course in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore.Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution with informing to submit Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fees. And the institution has submitted its reply with the DD of Rs. 40000/-. (NCTE Receipt no. 16502 dated 06.01.2012). The SRC 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012, considered the written reply and other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting inspection at the new premises and to ascertain availability of infrastructural and instructional facilities Under NCTE Act.As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 16.11.2011 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 19.11.02012.

The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following: Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not

submitted.


93


In the building plan submitted, plinth area is not mentioned.

Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted.

Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted. Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that

the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted.

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in joint account and in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given.

As per VT report, Science lab, Psychology lab , Educational Technology lab & other labs needs to be strengthened.

As per VT report, multipurpose hall size is only 1432 sq.ft, which is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft. as per NCTE norms of 2009.

As per VT report, only 842 related to education are available in the library, which is inadequate as per NCTE norms.

As per VT report, science lab is being shared with attached School/college, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

As per VT report, in the questioner, the institution is having two unit of B.Ed and one unit of D.Ed.

As per VT report, two courses are running in the proposed building and the builot up area in VT report is 16332 sq,ft is less than regulation for both B.Ed and D.Ed courses.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice. Note: VT members have not duly filled up the essential data sheet, The institution is having two unit of B.Ed and one unit of D.Ed courses, Total built up area of all the 3 courses are not given.


58. SRCAPP1153

D.El.EdShayaan

Shayaan College of Elementary Education, Khasara/Plot No. 339, Deverkonda Village, Post and Taluk, Nalgonda District, Pin-508248, Andhra Pradesh.Mohmmedens Educational and Welfare Society, Plot No. 339, Deverkonda Village, Post and Taluk, Nalgonda District, Pin-508248, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant


94


College of Elementary Education, Nalgonda

DistrictAP

of recognition to Shayaan College of Elementary Education, Khasara/Plot No. 339, Deverkonda Village, Post and Taluk, Nalgonda District, Pin-508248, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course on 29.09.2011 for two years duration under section 14 (1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 07.10.2011. The NCTE- Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009 and amendment Notified on 26th November 2011 which reads as follows:-2(B) for sub-regulation (1-A), the following shall be substituted, namely:-The application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances;

1) The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application;

2) Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

3) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of applications is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

The SRC considered the matter in 213th Meeting held on 06-07 November, 2011 and after careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993, Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table, the Regional committee has decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

Not submitted within time frame as per Regulation 2009.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on 20.02.2012.The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order no. F.No. 89-120/2012 Appeal/4th Meeting-2012 dt. 11.05.2012 has stated as follows:-

“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per Regulations.

NOW THEREFORE, the Council hereby remands back the case of Shayaan College of Elementary Education, Nalgonda, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE , for necessary action as indicated above”. In obedience to the appellate authority order dated 11/05/2012 and as decided in the 227thmeeting of SRC held on 18th and 19th July, 2012 the application is being scrutinized.The inspection of the institution was fixed between 11 th-14th August, 2012. The same was intimated to the institution on 07.08.2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 14.08.2012.

The Committee in its 231st meeting held on 22-23rd Aug 2012 considered VT report, VCD & all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) In the building plan copy submitted, total land area for the proposed course is not mentioned.

2) As per VT report, total number of journals available in the library is only 1 against the requirement of 5 journals as per NCTE norms.

3) The size of each class rooms, multipurpose hall, and other details are to be


95


submitted.4) The management has to given an affidavit with regard to multipurpose hall

size as per NCTE norms availability.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 31.08.2012 (with reference to NCTE web).On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, Letter of intent was issued to the institution on 14/10/2012

And the committee noted to blacklist the VT members and to write separately to their HOD’s for not carrying out the inspection of the institution and filling all the columns and data as required by the SRC to the satisfaction of the committee.

Accordingly, letter’s were issued to both the VT members ( Dr. P. Sheela, Assistant Professor, Dept of Studies in Education, University of Mysore, Manasagangotri, Mysore-570 006 and Prof, N. Natesan, (Retired Prof. of MKU Madurai), No. 53, Sriniketan Apartment, 26. Pillyar Kili Street, SS colony, Madurai Tamilnadu.

Now replies from both VT members were received in the office of SRc on 31.10.2012.

The committee noted the matter and decided to see marginal comments for administrative action.

The institution has submitted reply to letter of intent on 21.11.2012.


59. SRCAPP873

D.El.EdScient

College of Education, Rangareddi

DistrictAP

Scient College of Education, Plot No. 26, Street No. 9-42, Medipally Village & Post, Ghatkesar Taluk, Uppal Depot Town, Rangareddi District-500098, Andhra Pradesh.

Scient Educational Society, Plot No. 26, Opp. CPRI, Medipally Village and Post, Ghatkesar Taluk, Hyderabad Town, Rangareddi District-500098, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Scient College of Education, Plot No. 26, Street No. 9-42, Medipally Village & Post, Ghatkesar Taluk, Uppal Depot Town, Rangareddi District-500098, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course on 28.09.2011 for two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 07/10/2011.


2 (B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely. 1 (1-A) (I) the


96


application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

1. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

2. Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

3. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in 213th meeting held on 6th-7th November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

1. Not submitted within time frame as per Regulation 2009.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP873 (2012-13) /D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/36222 dated 23/01/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-465/2011 Appeal/3rd Meeting-2012 dated 18.04.2012 state that “the council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the matter to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per Regulations”.

The appellate authority order was placed before SRC in its 226 th meeting held on 09th-10th July 2012 and SRC decided for further processing of application on merit as per regulations.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.23-04-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause composite inspection for both existing course B.Ed under NCTE Act. and Proposed course D.El.Ed under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms. VT members to be informed to get fresh building completion certificate from the institution, with total earmarked built up area separately for each course.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 10 th - 14th August 2012, the same was intimated to the institution 07.08.2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 10.08.2012.

The committee considered the VT report and all relevant documents were placd in 230th SRC meeting hled on 16-17th of August 2012 and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following: Notarised English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted.

Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that


97


the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted.

Total earmarked built up area towards existing B.Ed and proposed D.El.Ed course is not given.

Accordingly, by seeing the minutes in SRC website the institution has submitted the written representation on 12/09/2012. The matter was placed in 233rd meeting of SRC held on 26-28th Sept.2012.



60. SRCAPP1041

D.El.Ed-AIBest D.Ed College,

West Godavari District

AP

Best D.Ed College, Khasara No. 737/1, 742/1A, Plot No. 2/152B, K.N. Road, Tadepalli Village, Tadepalliguden Post & Taluk, East Godavari District, Pin – 534101, Andhra Pradesh.

Bhushan Educational Society of Tadepalliguden, Plot No. 2-153/B, K.N.Road, Tadepalli Vilalge, Tadepalligudem Post & Taluk, West Godavari District, Pin- 534101, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Best D.Ed College, Khasara No. 737/1, 742/1A, Plot No. 2/152B, K.N. Road, Tadepalli Village, Tadepalliguden Post & Taluk, East Godavari District, Pin – 534101, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed - AI Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011.


The SRC in its 220th meeting held on 30th-31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 28.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice. Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 24.05.2012. The institution submits its written representation on 17.05.2012.

The SRC in its 223rd Meeting held on 29th-31st May 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.17-05-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the


98


norms. Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 25 th to 29th June, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 22/06/2012 the inspection of the institution was conducted on 02/07/2012

The SRC in its 228th Meeting held on 24th-25th Meeting held on July, 2012 considered the matter, VT report of D.El.Ed-Al course (SRCAPP1041) and decided to Await composite inspection report of APS0363 B.Ed course also for further taking decision.

Accordingly, the composite inspection for APS00363 & SRCAPP1041 of the institution has been carried out on 11/08/2012. The decision for SRCAPP1041 was also kept pending till the receipt of composite inspection report.

The institution in its letter dated 31/08/2012 stated that “ the request your esteemed presence to clear our pending file for D.El.Ed additional intake which was kept in abeyance for the sake of our B.Ed (Code:0363) composite inspection.

As the composite inspection is over we request you to kindly grant the recognition for D.El.Ed additional intake for this academic year”.

The composite inspection report is placed in APS0 0363, the SRC in its 231st Meeting held on 22nd-23rd August, 2012 decided to issue show cause notice for B.Ed but incase of SRCAPP 1041 the decision was not taken.

The reply to show cause notice for B.Ed was placed before SRC in its 233 rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 and it has decided to put up all 3 cases SRCAPP1041, APS00363 & APS02532. (Best College of Education) Note for B.Ed Course.

Recognition was withdrawn for B.Ed course on 15/12/2011. The institution preferred an appeal to the NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order dated 18/04/2012. “remanding the case to the SRC for causing inspection of the institution and taking further decision thereafter. The institution directed to send to the SRC a D.D. of Rs. 50.000/- and affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper the format of SRC immediately”.

The matter was placed before SRC in its 222nd Meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012, the SRC decided to cause inspection of the institution on submission of Rs. 50.000/- inspection fee and an affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs.100/- stamp paper duly attested by oath commissioner or notary public and related supporting documents as per the regulations.

The institution has submitted Rs. 50.000/- inspection fee along with original affidavit.

The matter was placed before SRC in its 228 th Meeting held on 24th -25th July, 2012, the SRC decided to cause composite inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, and to process along with SRCAPP 1041 D.Ed-Al course and to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, composite inspection was conducted on 11.08.2012.


99


The visiting team report was placed before SRC 231st meeting held on 22nd-23rd

August, 2012, the SRC decided to serve Show cause Notice.

As per the NCTE website information the institution has submitted written representation on 31/08/2012.

The matter was placed before SRC in its 233 rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012. The SRC directed to putup all 3 cases SRCAPP1041, APSO0363 & APS02532, in the next SRC meeting.

The decision may be taken for APSO-0363-B.Ed & SRCAPP1041-D.Ed.AI.

Accordingly, all 3 cases are hereby being put up as Annexure-I

The Committee considered the composite inspection report, reply of the institution and other relevant documents, along with the original file of the institution and decided to restore recognition to APS00363-B.Ed and continue recognition accorded to the institution.

Further,

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed-Al course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2012-13 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session. Accordingly, a Letter of Intent was issued to the institution on 25.10.2012. Now the institution has submitted its reply to LOI on 21.11.2012 and 12.12.2012. The list of staff, signed by The Director, SCERT is as under:-Reference from pre page.

The institution has submitted another reply for LOI on 12.12.2012.


The institution has not appointed lecturer in Maths and Lectuer in foundation courses with proper qualification.



100




School of Distance

Education, Visakhapatna

m DistrictAP

School of Distance Education, No. 7-15-4, AU Outgate Street, Chinna Waltair Village, Andhra University Post, Visakhapatnam Taluka, Visakhapatnam District-530003, Andhra Pradesh.

Andhra University, No. 7-15-4, AU Outgate Road, Chinna Waltair Village, Andhra University Post, Visakhapatnam Taluk, & District - 530003, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to School of Distance Education, No. 7-15-4, AU Outgate Street, Chinna Waltair Village, Andhra University Post, Visakhapatnam Taluk, Visakhapatnam District-530003, Andhra Pradesh for M.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03/10/2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 09/11/2011 followed by reminder on 22/12/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29/12/2011. The institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on 23/02/2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 220th Meeting of SRC held on 30th – 31st

March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 23.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012.

Now the institution has submitted its written representation dt. 10.05.2012 received in the office of SRC on 16.05.2012.

The SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29-31 May, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.16-05-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause composite inspection for existing courses and proposed course M.Ed-DE, under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 25th-29th June 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 20/06/2012 the inspection of the institution was conducted on 28/06/2012.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in its 227th meeting heldon17-19th July 2012 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to M.Ed-DE course of One duration with an annual intake of 250(Two hundred and Fifty only)(Two academic session / year)( four semesters) for the academic year 2012-13 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.


101


Accordingly, LOI is issued to the institution on 28/07/2012.

The institution has replied to the LOI on 27-09-2012.

The SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17th – 18th October 2012, considered the LOI reply of the institution dt. 27-09-2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act for the following:

1) The institution has to appoint regular staff for Distance Education Department separately as per NCTE norms.

2) The institution has not submitted Marks cards and service certificates of the staff appointed for Distance Programme.

3) Further, the Committee decided to issue notice to the University for Transferring/Deputing Regular Staff from face-to-face programme to the Distance mode, thereby causing vacancy or not filling up the regular posts.

Accordingly LOI Notice was issued to the institution on 19.11.2011.

Now the institution has submitted its written representation dt. 19.11.2012 received in the office of SRC on 21.11.2012.


The Institution has not submitted separate staff lists as per NCTE norms.



Sai Baba District

Institute of Education

and Training, Kadapa District

AP

Sai Baba District Institute of Education and Training, Plot/Khasara No.43/1, Akkayapalli Street, Kadapa Village and Taluk, R.V.Nagar Post, Kadapa City and District - 516003, Andhra Pradesh.

Sai Baba Educational Society, Plot No.56/223 Akkayapalli Road Kadapa Village and Post, Kadapa City and Taluk, Kadapa District - 516003, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sai Baba District Institute of Education and Training, Plot/Khasara No.43/1, Akkayapalli Street, Kadapa Village and Taluk, R.V.Nagar Post, Kadapa City and District - 516003, Andhra Pradesh for D.El. Ed course of two years duration under Section 14(l) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09 2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011.NCTE - Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE


102


Regulations 2009 and amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-2(B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely." 1(1-A) (I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

a The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

b Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

c Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the Course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in 224th Meeting held on 161h - 17Ih June, 2012 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table the Regional committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:-

The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory as per Regulations 2009.

Accordingly the application of Sai Baba District Institute of Education and Training, Plot/Khasara No.43/1, Akkayapalli Street, Kadapa Village and Taluk, R.V.Nagar Post, Kadapa City and District - 516003, Andhra Pradesh for permission to D.E.C.Ed course was rejected on 13.01.2012.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on 09.07.2012.


“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for processing the application for D.E.C.Ed Course as per Regulations.

Now therefore, the Council hereby remands back the case of Sai Baba District Institute of Education and Training, Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement


103


of the academic session.



Note: the institution has filed W.P. No. 32814 of 2012 received on 18.10.2012 in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad. The Hon’ble Court has ordered that “… Respondent No. 1 is directed to permit the petitioner to commence the course from 2012-13 by appropriatelymodifying its order de. 04.10.2012 and include the peititoner college in the list of colleges for counseling for the year 2012-13.

The SRC considered the matter along with other similar matters and directed to obtain the stay and file an appeal against the aforesaid court order.

Thereafter, the NCTE has filed W.A NO. 1457 of 2012 dt. 30.11.2012 in the Hon’ble High court of Andhra Pradesh. The Hon’ble court oder has :”…direct that the 1st respondent /writ peititioner shall file the appeal before the appellate authority, in accordance with the provisions ofla, within a period of ne week from date, and consequently it is desirable tha the same should be disposed of by the appellate authority within a period of two weeks thereafter, and duly communicate the order to the 1st respondent/writ peititioner”.

The above court oder have been forwarded to NCTE hqrs on 5.12.2012 for appropriate action as per court directions.

The committee considered the matter and decided to Await Appellate authority order.

63. APS08129B.Ed

Indira College of Education,

Kadapa District

AP

Sri Vinayaka Educational & Rural Development Society, 50-120-24, Kothapeta, Rayachoty , Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh has submitted an application for grant of recognition to Indira College of Education, Kadapa District for B.Ed course on 27.12.2006.

The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and Regulation, Norms and standards in vogue at that point of time and the deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.03.2007.

The authorized signatory of the society/Trust vide their written communication dated 13.09.2007 requested not to process the application of the institution, rather the application may be closed as the society does not want to run the course.Consequent upon the request for closure of application the matter was considered and it was decided to close the application on 23.01.2008.

The institute has approached to Hon’ble High Court in W.PO No. 31926 of 2010 without approaching the appellate authority.The Hon’ble High Court has passed an order on 27.12.2010 vide W.P.No. 31926 of 2010 read as hereunder:

“ Pending further orders, first respondent is directed to consider the application of the petitioner dated 28.12.2006 for grant of permission, in the


104


upcoming meeting”

SRC considered the matter in its 200th meeting held on 20th and 21st January, 2011 and directed the Management/Institution to resubmit the old application returned by SRC along with necessary documents as originally submitted relating to land, building, FDR, Application fee, inspection of Rs. 40,000/-.Building completion Certificate from competent Government Engineer/Authority and other relevant documents for processing and for necessary action.

As per direction of SRC a letter was issued to the applicant institution on 01.03.2011 to submit the original application form along with other relevant documents. However, the same was return to the office of SRC as undelivered. The applicant institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 24.03.2011.

As per direction of SRC show cause notice was issued to the institution on 24.05.2011.In response to this office notice dated 24.05.2011, the institution has submitted its reply vide letter dt.22.06.2011 and 18.08.2011.The SRC in its 211th

meeting held on 21st – 23rd November, 2011, considered the replies of the institution dated 16.08.2011 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue Final Show Cause Notice to the institution. after careful consideration of the reply of the institution 22.06.2011 & 18.08.2011 for the show cause notice issued to the institution on 24.05.2011.Accordingly, a final show cause notice was issued to the institution on 14.11.2011.The institution has submitted written representation on 13.12.2011.

The SRC in its 216th meeting held on 11th and 12th January, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dated 13.12.2011 for the deficiency letter issued to the institution on 14.11.2011 and come to the conclusion that, since the land documents registered after making the application of the institution is rejected.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution vide F.No. APSO8129/B.Ed/AP/2012-13/37845 dated 21.02.2012

Aggrieved by the Rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-

183/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting-2012 dated 18/06/2012 states that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the matter to the SRC for re-examination of the land documents submitted by the appellant in reply to final show cause notice and for taking further decision thereafter.”

SRC in its 227th Meeting held on 17th – 19th June 2012 decided to process the application. According the file was processed.

The SRC in its 229th Meeting held on 30th – 31st July 2012 and decided to Cause Inspection.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 10.08.2012 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 14.08.02012.

The SRC in its 231st meeting held on 22nd – 23rd August 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice.

Meanwhile the institution has submitted the reply for notice on 21.09.2012 referred


105


by 231st minutes on website as follows:-

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(one hudred only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.



On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to B.Ed., course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 (Fifty only) students from the year 2013-14.

Consideration of Court Cases (Volume- 03)

64. APS01316B.Ed

St. Marys College of Education, Warangal

DistrictAP

St. Marys College of Education, 6-2-7/1, Hyderabad Road, Jangaon, Warangal – 506167, Andhra Pradesh.

An application was submitted by St. Mary’s College of Education, Warangal District, Andhra Pradesh recognition to B.Ed course was granted on in the office of SRC-NCTE Bangalore on 02.01.2002 which was refused vide order dt. 09.01.2004. Thereafter, recognition was granted to the institution vide order appeal dated 10.06.2004

Thereafter, the Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal vide letter dt.14.03.2008 drew the attention of Regional Director, SRC and informed that in the process of granting temporary affiliation to the institutions the university conducted inspection and observed that the building shown was meant for MCA. The fact was noticed by visiting team, which visited for affiliation.

The letter was placed before the SRC in its 157th meeting held on 23rd-24th April 2008. The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued on 28.05.2008 to the institution. In response to the notice the applicant institution replied on 19.06.2008 as under:

“The college started construction on second floor on existing building satisfying the NCTE and AICTE norms to run B.Ed and MCA in the existing B.Ed which has two separate entrances with no connectivity between the two colleges. The college promises to submit the approved building plan and photographs with in a month on completion of construction of second


106


floor which is in progress “.

The reply was placed before SRC in its 161st meeting held on 6th-7th August 2008. The SRC has decided and resolved to cause inspection under Section 17 to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

The SRC-NCTE conducted an inspection of the institution under section 17 of NCTE Act 1993 on 18.09.2008. The report received from the visiting team informs that the management was not ready for the inspection now on 18.09.2008 because of various factors and asked for postponement of the inspection by three more months.”

The institution has not cooperated in carrying out inspection of institution as per the Provisions of NCTE Act. Therefore, the SRC-NCTE in its 165 th meeting held on 27th-28th September, 2008 on careful perusal of the original file of the institution, two visiting team report under section 14 & 17, the letter dated 14.03.2008 from the Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal to the Regional Director, SRC and the reply dated.19.06.2008 to the show cause notice issued to the institution and other related documents, Act of NCTE 1993, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee noted the following:

1. The recognition of the institution has been refused vide order dated.09.01.2004. The institution preferred appeal whereby the order of the SRC was revised vide Appellate Authority Order 10.06.2004. As per the records available in the file the institution has not been issued any formal order of recognition for B.Ed course. It is not known as to how it got affiliation and is conducting B.Ed course.

2. The institution has started functioning in the building submitting an undertaking stating that the infrastructure and instructional facilities will be provided as per NCTE Norms and Standards issued from time to time.

3. As per the visiting team report of Kakatiya University, Warangal the institution has shown the same land for MCA. The same land documents have been submitted to other Regulatory Bodies. The institution misleads NCTE and other regulatory bodies like AICTE.

4. The institution breached oath taken by it in the affidavit dated.25.01.2003 swearing that the land is exclusively meant for running the educational institution and the same shall not be used for any purpose other than teacher education programme.

5. As per NCTE Norms and Standards and Rules and Regulations issued from time to time the institutions are required to have exclusive provision for land and building for teacher education courses, whereas the institution has sought recognition of B.Ed course and in the same premises it started BCA/ MCA. Courses. The land and building were shown to NCTE and suppressing this fact, the same were also shown to AICTE for BCA/ MCA in contravention of the NCTE Norms and Standards.

6. The institution itself accepted in writing to have accommodated B.Ed on first floor and BCA/ MCA on the ground floor in the same building.

7. The institution did not cooperate with the visiting team in carrying out inspection under section 17 on 18.09.2008.

8. The institution violated the provisions contained under various sections of NCTE Act and regulations there under.

The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects decided to withdraw the recognition of the institution from the academic session 2008-09. Further, the


107


SRC also decided to inform the decision to the State Government of Andhra Pradesh and Concerned University for follow-up action immediately, including redistribution of students admitted, if any.

As per the decision of SRC withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 06.10.2008.

Thereafter, the institution has gone in appeal and vide order dated 12.02.2010 the Appellate Authority has confirmed SRC’s withdrawal order but with effect from 2010-11 academic year.

The Institute has approached to Hon’ble High Court in W.P.No.14792 of 2010. Now, the Hon’ble High Court has passed an interim order dt. 12.07.2010 in W.P. No. 14792 of 2010 reads as hereunder:

“There shall be interim suspension of the impugned proceedings. However, it is made clear that the petitioner shall not be entitled to run the college in the next academic year in the same premises.

Post after two weeks”.

As such the college is not permitted by the Hon’ble Court order to run in the same premises for the next academic year i.e.2011-12. The institution has vide letter dated 29.04.2011 submitted a DD of Rs.40,000/- as inspection fee with request to cause inspection as the institution has constructed separate building for B.Ed and that it has been granted provisional affiliation by the university with an intake of 120 seats.

The latest status of the case is to be obtained from the advocate. The matter regarding correctness of the SRC order and appeal order is sub judice in W.P.No.14792/10

The SRC considered the written request of the institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution in the permanent premises.

The SRC in its 205th Meeting 18th – 19th May 2011 considered the written request of the institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution in the permanent premises.

Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 28.07.2011 & VT Report was received to the SRC-NCTE on 29.07.2011.

The SRC in its 221st Meeting held on 21st-23rd September, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

The institution has been informed accordingly vide letter dt. 09.11.2011.

Meanwhile a letter has been received in the office of SRC through E-mail from our legal counsel Shri P.Vinayaka, regarding W.P. No. 31165/2011 filed by St. Mary’s college of Education, Jangaon. Warnagal District, Andhra Pradesh.

He stated that the above writ petition came up for admission before Justice Noushal Ali on 25.11.2011. The Hon’ble Judge also orally directed to place the


108


matter before 215-4th SRC meeting scheduled on 28.11.2011 and SRC is at liberty to take an appropriate decision in the matter of the petitioner’s college and to report compliance to petitioner and as well as to the Hon’ble Court by 01.12.2011.

The SRC in its 214th Meeting held on 28th November 2011, decided to wait for High court order (Andhra Pradesh as the matter is pending in W.P. No. 31165 of 2011.

Now, the institution has submitted its written representation on 20.06.2012 stated that “as the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad has granted permission the withdrawal of the W.P.No. 31165 of 2011 filed by this institution against the NCTE and the 3 others respondents, and the W.P.No. 31165 is dismissed by the Hon’ble High Court as withdrawn, The Management of this institution has requested to consider the issue and extend the permanent recognition from the year 2012-13. The inspections by the affiliating University of the B.Ed colleges for grant of affiliation for the year 2012-13 has been completed in their region for admissions for the Ed.CET 2012 students. Requesting to consider recognition temporarily for the year 2012-13 also to enable us to submit to the affiliating university for affiliation for the year 2012-13 to join education. CET 2012 web-counseling admissions which will be commenced from the middle of July, 2012”.

The SRC in its 225th Meeting held on 25th-27th June, 2012 considered the matter and request of the institution and decided to await for final decision from the Hon’ble HIgh Court of Andhra Pradesh.

A Hon’ble High Court order dt. 20/07/2012 in W.P. No. 21826 of 2012 stated that “….the impugned order of respondent no. 2 is set aside and respondent No. 2 is directed to re-considered the petitioner’s application for temporary recognition for running B.Ed course in the new building, not with standing the pendency of W.P. No. 14792 of 2010. Respondent No. 2 shall take a final decision and communicate the same to the petitioner within a period of three weeks from the date of receipt of this order”

The Court order was placed before SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30-31st July, 2012 and the committee considered the matter and decided to process and put up in the next meeting.

Accordingly, as per the decision of SRC, the application is processed.

The SRC in its 230th meeting held on 16th and 17th July, 2012 considered the matter and decided as per the direction of the Hon’ble High order to grant temporary recognition for the academic year 2012-2013 only.

Accordingly, as per the decision of SRC and as per the court direction a temporary recognition order for the year 2012-13 for B.Ed course was issued vide order no.F.SRO/NCTE/APS01316/B.Ed/AP/2012-13/45590 dated 27.8.2012.

Meantime, the institution has submitted written representation on 20.11.2012 along with Court direction in W.P. No. 21826 of 2012. The Hon’ble court order stating as follows; “…..the impugned order of respondent no. 2 is set aside and respondent no. 2 is directed to re-consider the petitioner’s application for temporary recognition for running B.Ed course in the new building, notwithstanding the pendency of W.P. No. 14792 of 2010: Respondent no. 2 shall take a final decision and communicate the same to the petitioner within


109


a period of three weeks from the date of receipt of this order ” .

The institution in its letter dated 19.11.2012 requesting SRC-NCTE, Bangalore to consider the orders of the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh and grant formal recognition to this institution.

The committee considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to put up the file with a proper note on rectification of deficiencies.


Vikas D.Ed College,

Prakasam District

AP

Vikas D.Ed College, Plot/Khasara No.770/2A, Darsi Village and Post, Darsi City and Taluk, Prakasam District-523247, Andhra Pradesh

Sree Vikas Educational Society, Plot No.770/2A, Darsi Road and Village, Darsi Post and Taluk, Darsi City, Prakasam District- 523247, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Vikas D.Ed College, Plot/Khasara No.770/2A, Darsi Village and Post, Darsi City and Taluk, Prakasam District-523247, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 27.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 29.09.2011.


The SRC in its 220th Meeting of SRC held on 30th – 31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 29.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 18.05.2012.

The SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29-31st May 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.18-05-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted between 25-26 th June 2012. Mean time the visiting team members have submitted letter dt. 06.07.2012 as under:Due to ill health of Mr.M. Venkat Rao, Secretary and Correspondent Sree Vikas Educational Society Darsi, who is admitted to the Hospital at Hyderabad, stating that it is not possible for us to make any arrangement for the inspection of Sr Vikas D.El.Ed college by the visiting team fixed on 06.07.2012. So, Please postpone the inspection for two months at least and oblige.The SRC has taken note of the management vide letter dt. 06/07/2012 request for extension time to 2 months for causing inspection of the college for the proposed D.El.Ed course, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations of 2009:Further,Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal NO. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165-68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:

“An institution is not entitled to recognition unless it fulfils the conditions specified in various clauses of the Regulations. The Council is directed to ensure that in future no institution is granted recognition unless it fulfils the conditions laid down in the Act and the Regulations and the time schedule fixed for processing the application by the Regional Committee and communication of the decision on the issue of recognition it strictly adhered to”.


110


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 228 th meeting held 24th-25th July, 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly Rejection Order was issued to the institution on 10.08.2012.

The institution approached Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh vide W.P. No 26356 of 2012, judgment order received by SRC on 03.12.2012. The Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh vide order dated 03.10.201 as given the following orders:-

“The impugned order, the petitioners’ application was rejected. It is not in dispute that inspection of the premises of the proposed college is a condition precedent for consideration of the application for recognition of D.El.Ed., Course. The petitioners, having themselves asked for postponement of the inspection by two months, lost the valuable opportunity of getting such permission for the current academic year. The period of two months requested by the petitioners expired a few days before expiry of the cut-off date for consideration of their application for grant of permission. The petitioners, thus, having forgone a valuable opportunity cannot complain of the action of respondent No.2 in rejection their application in the absence of inspection and the report of the inspection team. I do not, therefore, find any illegality in the order of respondent No.2, impugned in this Writ Petition. This Order, however, does not preclude the petitioners from making a fresh application fro grant of permission to start D.El.Ed Course in the academic year 2013-14. Subject to the liberty given as above, the Writ Petition is dismissed.As a sequel, WPMP.No.33580 of 2012, filed by the petitioners for interim relief, is disposed of as infructuous”.

The Committee considered the Hon’ble High Court order dt. 03.10.2012 and decided to close this case. Further, it is concluded that if the institution apply again for the session 2013-14, their case can be considered according to Law.


Sri Sai Balaji College of

Elementary Education, Srikakulam

DistrictAP

Sri Sai Balaji College of Elementary Education, Satyasai Nagar, Siddipeta Street , Balaga (Rural), Chapuram Village, Srikakulam Post and Taluk, Srikakulam City and District-532001, Andhra PradeshSurapu Annamma Educational Society, Seddipeta Road, Chapurum Village, Srikakulam Post and District-532001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Sai Balaji College of Elementary Education, Satyasai Nagar, Siddipeta Street, Balaga (Rural), Chapuram Village, Srikakulam Post and Taluk, Srikakulam City and District-532001, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 24.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 26.09.2011

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 29.09.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 23.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 30.01.2012. Recommendation from State Government is not received.

The SRC in its 217th meeting of SRC held on 08th -09th February 2012 considered the reply for deficiency letter and other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the premises to examine whether the institution fulfills all the requirements as per the norms and to ascertain


111


infrastructural and instructional facilities available at the premises for the proposed course.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 1st to 4th March 2012 and the same was intimated to the institution on 21.02.2012. Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 03.03.2012.

The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th-20th April 2012, considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 16.05.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on


1. Notarised copy of the land document (gift deed) in English version is not submitted.

2. The proposed building is still under construction as per building completion certificate submitted. Total built up area available is 12084 sq.ft. which is inadequate as per NCTE norms and building is incomplete at the time of visit. The third floor of the building is still under construction.

3. No proof is submitted by the institution regarding providing of Language learning lab.

4. No. documentary proof is submitted by the institution regarding strengthening of Psychology lab, Physical Science lab, Science lab and computer laboratory equipments.

5. The institution has not given full address of the institution with Sy.Nos where the college is situated.

The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory and unconvincing.Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 224 th meeting held on 26th-28th September 2012, decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order no. F.No.89-410/2012Appeal/8th meeting -2012 has stated as follows:-

“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VT report and after considering the oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the council concluded that there was no ground to accept the appeal. Accordingly, the appeal is rejected and SRC order dated 09.07.2012 is confirmed.

The council hereby confirms the order appealed against”.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 18.10.2012, along with judgement copy of High Court of Andhra Pradesh Writ Petition No.31513 of 2012 dated 09.10.2012. The judgement order stated as follows:-


112


“the impugned orders of the respondents are set aside. Respondent No.2 is directed to reconsider the petitioners application and grant recognition to them for commencement of the D.El.Ed course from the academic year 2012-13 subject to their fulfillment of all other requirements as per the Regulations”.

The matter is placed before SRC in its 235 th meeting held on 20th-21st November 2012, decided to process the application.

In the meanwhile, the institution has submitted its written representation on 15.11.2012

The Committee considered the Hon’ble High Court order dt. 09-10-2012, reply of the institution vide letter dt. 15.11.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

In theon-line application, Sy.No. is not mentined.

Approved blue print of the building plan with all details like institutions name, Sy.No. and course proposed, issued by competent civil authority is not submitted.

Fresh Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted. At the time of earlier inspection the building was incomplete.

No. documentary proof is submitted by the institution regarding strengthening of Psychology lab, Physicalo Science lab, Science lab and computer laboratory equipments.


Note: SRO to verify position relating to progress of construction and list of equipments in the laboratories.

67. APS07938B.Ed

LNR College of Education,

Mahabubnagar District

AP

LNR College of Education, H.No. 5-45,Paipad Village and Post, Waddepally Mandal, Alampur, Mahabubnagar- 509 126, Andhra Pradesh.

Motati Nagi Reddy Memorial Educational Society, 45, Paipad Village and Post, Waddepally Mandal, Alampur, Mahabubnagar- 509 126, Andhra Pradesh has submitted in the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to LNR College of Education, H.No. 5-45,Paipad village and Post, Waddepally Mandal, Alampur, Mahabubnagar- 509 126, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course on 13.01.2006.


113


Application of the Institution was processed and deficiency letter dt.17.02.07 was sent to the Institution communicating therewith the deficiencies and directing therewith for removal of the same within 90 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter. The institution had not replied to the deficiency letter even expiry of stipulated period of 90 days. The matter of all such institutions was considered by the SRC in its 135th meeting held on 7th and 9th June 2007 after careful consideration of all the aspects vis-avis regulatory provisions, the SRC decided to close the file and communicate the applicant institution to this effect. Accordingly, the letter dt.12.07.07 was sent to the Institution intimating about the directions of SRC that the application submitted for grant of teacher education course has been treated incomplete, therefore the same is closed and that no further correspondence whatsoever will be entertained in this regard. However, to seek recognition for any teacher education course including the one which this application was submitted, they were advised to make fresh application in the prescribed format.

LNR College of Education, Mahabubnagar- 509 126, Andhra Pradesh has filed a court case vide Writ petition No. 3765 of 2011 in the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature, Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad verses – The Government of Andhra PradeshSRC and NCTE-SRC as first and second respondents respectively against the above SRC order dt.12.07.2007. The Hon’ ble High Court has passed an order dt.26.04.2011 in WP No. 3765 of 2011 as under:

The petitioner is aggrieved by the action of the respondents in not conducting the inspection and not granting recognition for establishment of the College of Education at Paipad village, Wadepally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District. It is the case of the petitioners that they filed an application for setting up B.Ed College at Palpad village on 29.12.2006.Howeve the same was returned on the ground that numerous deficiencies were found in the said college. The petitioner, after removing the said deficiencies, filed a fresh application on 28.12.2007. The grievance of the petitioner is that the said application is not being considered by the respondents till date. The petitioner has also submitted a representation on 18.11.2010 before the 2nd Respondent, but the same has not been considered as yet. After hearing the learned Counsel for the parties, this writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the 2nd respondent to consider the representation dt. 18.11.201 because the petitioner has filed its earlier application on 29.12.2006 i.e prior to coming into force of the policy decision 07.01.2009. The respondents are directed to consider the application of the petitioner, expeditiously, preferably, within eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. No. order as to costs.

The Court order along with file placed before SRC for direction/ decision.

The Institution has stated to have filed a representation dt. 18.11.10 wherein it is mentioned that fresh application is resubmitted on 28.12.2007 clearing deficiencies communicated on 17.02.2007. This resubmission of fresh application is well after closure of the case vide letter dt.12.07.07 for non compliance of deficiencies with stipulated time as per NCTE regulations

The Committee considered the matter and decided to process the application on submission of copy of original application dt. 28.12.2007 and related supporting original documents as per the regulations.


114


As per decision of Regional Committee a letter was issued to resubmit the application on 06.07.2011.

The Committee considered the written representation submitted on 21/07/2011 & 18/09/2011 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice for the following:

The sale deed of the land was registered on 10/05/2007, whereas the application submitted by the institution for consideration of recognition to B.Ed course was on 13/01/2006. As per the NCTE norms and Regulations, land should be available in the name of the institution/trust before the date of application.

1. Building completion certificate from competent Govt Engineer is not submitted. 2. Up to date Encumbrance certificate not submitted.

Accordingly, a show cause notice issued to the institution on 02.11.2011, in response to this office letter dt. 27.10.2011, the institution has submitted its reply vide letter dt. 17.11.2011.

The SRC in its 215th meeting held on 12-13th December, 2011 considered the reply of the institution dt, 17.11.2011 and all the relevant documents by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the premises, on payment of Rs. 4000/- towards inspection fee, to examine whether the institution fulfills all the requirement as per the norms, to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms. As per the direction SRC inspection of the institution was carried on 03.02.2012.

The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. As per VT report, total built up area is only 5870 sq.ft. Which is grossly inadequate as per NCTE norms. 16000 sq.ft. of built up area is required for the proposed course.

2. As per VT report, the size of multipurpose hall is 1280.92 sq.ft. which is less than NCTE norms. As per NCTE norms, 2000 sq.ft. is required.

3. In the approved building plan the survey number and site area is not mentioned.

4. From VCD, it appears that a school is being run in the same building/premises.

5. As per VCD, full view of the building is not shown, the construction of the building is still in progress, and the total built up area appears to be less than 16000 sq.ft.

6. Furniture provided in the class room/Hall / labs/ Principal room and staff room are inadequate. Needs to be strengthened.

7. Science lab, Psychology lab & ET lab needs to be strengthened.

As per decision of SRC show cause notice issued on 11.04.2012, the institution has replied vide letter dated 30.04.2012.

The SRC considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 30.04.2012 and all


115


the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

As per VTR, the size of the multipurpose hall is only 1280.92 sq,fts. Which less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.

Accordingly, Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution. The institution submitted its written representation .

As per direction of Southern Regional Committee in its meeting 225th letter of intent prior to recognition was issued to applicant institution on 02.07.2012. In response to this office letter dated 02.07.2012 the institution has submitted reply vide letter dated 06.07.2012

The list of staff are signed as possessing qualification by Registrar, Palamuru University, Mahaboobnagar, Andhra Pradesh. As per possessing observed by the Registrar, Palamuru University, Mahaboobnagar

The SRC in its 228th meeting held on 24th – 25th July 2012 considered the reply of the institution Dt. 06.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, notice was issued to the institution on 13.08.2012. the institution submitted its written representation on 06.09.2012 after the stipulated time of 21 days i.e., 3 days late.

The institution has submitted a letter dated 17.07.2012 stating “that the situation prevailing in Andhra region is for D.El.Ed course and admission of students for B.Ed course is not favorable and students are opting for the D.El.Ed courses, considering the prevailing situation I would like to withdraw the LOI issued to the B.Ed course for which already LOI issued. Since formal recognition is not yet issued for B.Ed course, the application for D.El.Ed course (SRCAPP1598) is applied in the session of 2012-13 and is in process. In this present situation, I request your good office to kindly issue LOI for D.El.Ed course in place of B.Ed (SRCAPP1598) course, which will help me to run D.El.Ed course in conductive atmosphere”.

The Formal Recognition order issued to the institution letter dated F.No. 45880/2012/05.09.2012 in respect of SRCAPP1598.

The SRC considered the written representation of the institution vide letter dt. 17-07-2012 for withdrawal of LOI issued to the institution’s B.Ed course (APS07938) s permitted to withdraw.

Further, with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided as per clause of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.Ed course (APS07938).


The institution moved to Hon’ble High Court of Judicature at Andhra Pradesh dtd. 27.11.2012 in W.P. No. 34518 of 2012 which reads as under:-

“…….. On the application of the Motati Nagi Reddy Memorial Educational Society


116


for grant of recognition under NCTE Act, 1993, the NCTE has already issued Letter of intent on 02.07.2012. Therefore, the impugned resolution was passed rejecting the application of Motati Nagi Reddy Memorial Educational Society, on the ground that the earlier application of the society was allowed to be withdrawn.

On instruction, it is submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the National Council for Teacher Education that the respondent i.e., NCTE would reconsider the matter and the Southern Regional Committee is likely to meet on 16.12.2012 and 17.12.2012.

Inasmuch as the Letter of Intent is already issued to the institution, a perusal of which indicate that the institution have already satisfied the criteria which is required for establishing a B.Ed College, prima facie, it appears that the impugned proceedings is not sustainable.

Accordingly, there shall be a direction to the respondent to reconsider the application of the institution in the next committee meeting, which is stated to be held on 16.12.2012 and 17.12.2012. In case, if any meeting is convened earlier to those dates, the same shall be placed in such meeting and appropriate decision shall be taken”.

The committee considered the matter and decided that the LOI for B.Ed was closed with reference to the applicant’s affidavit of July 2012 withdrawing his application for B.Ed. The SRC decision earlier taken was correct. The Closure has been communicated to the party. Noting more needs to be done at this state. The B.Ed case cannot be reopened now.

The applicant wants only his D.Ed application to be pursued. This also has alreadyt been done. Formal Recognition for D.Ed has also issued. Nothing more needs to be done at this stage.

It is unfortunate that, not withstanding his own affidavit for withdrawal of his application of B.Ed, the applicant should have agitated this issue in the court in this inappropriate manner. If he approaches the court again in this matter, the court should be appraised of these facts and requested to consider action against him for misleading the court.

Further, the committee advised SRO to read both the cases carefully and put up a clearer note for consideration in the meeting on 18.12.2012.

68. APS00318B.Ed

Azizia College of Education,

Kurnool District

AP

Azizia College of Education, Adoni Revenue Division, No. 02/189/C/2, Opp Floor Mill, Ashok Nagar Colony, Adoni Taluka, Kurnool District – 518 302, Andhra Pradesh

Azizia College of Education, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh has made an application for B.Ed course to Southern Regional Committee, NCTE, Bangalore on 31.12.2001. The application was processed and after considering the report of the Visiting Team as well as other relevant materials granted recognition to the institution for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 120 students vide order No.6652 dated 08.04.2003. The institution in its letter dated 25.06.2009 has submitted proposal for shifting the B.Ed course to the new location. Inspection for shifting was


117


conducted on 09.02.2011.

The Committee considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Show cause Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

1. The building plan submitted is not approved by competent Govt. authority. Plot no. and Khasara no. are not mentioned in the Building Plan. Approved building plan from Govt. authority is to be submitted.

2. FDRs for Rs. 5 lakhs & 3 lakhs towards endowment and reserve fund respectively from Nationalised Bank in the Joint account is to be submitted.

3. Non-encumbrance certificate from competent Govt. authority in English Version is to be submitted.

4. Furniture in the library needs to be strengthened.5. Science lab & other labs/Physical Education lab need to be

strengthened.

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued on 26.05.2011 for the above reason. The Institution submitted its reply on 29.06.2011.

The SRC in its 208th Meeting of SRC held on 13th – 14th July, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve the Final Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

Accordingly a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 26.08.2011 and institution has submitted its written representation on 26.09.2011 for the show cause notice.

The SRC in its 212th Meeting of SRC held on 24th October 2011 considered the reply and decided to seek clarification.

In meanwhile a letter dt. 03.03.2012 (continuation reply of Show Cause Notice) was received in the office of SRC on 07.03.2012.

As per the direction of SRC in 212th Meeting of SRC held on 24th October 2011, a clarification letter was issued to the institution on 05.12.2011.

The institution has submitted its reply to Clarification letter on 27.12.2011 requesting to extent for a period of one month for submitting approve building plan from Govt. authority.

The SRC in its 217th Meeting of SRC held on 08th – 09th February, 2012 considered the request of the institution vide letter dt. 23.12.2011 and decided to allow one month time for submitting approved building plan from Government authorities.

In meanwhile another letter (continuation reply to Clarification letter) dt. 03.03.2012 was received in the office of SRC on 07.03.2012 stating that the approval of Building Plan is under process and submitting the same shortly.

As per the direction of SRC (in 217th Meeting of SRC held on 08th – 09th February, 2012) a letter was issued to the institution on 14.03.2012 informing the institution to submit the approved Building Plan with in 30 days from the date of issue of this letter.


118


Now, the institution has not submitted its reply after stipulated time.




The committee considered the non-reply of the institution to the issue of show cause notice dt. 14/03/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 233 rd meeting held on 26th-28th September 2012, decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012 vide F.No.APS00318/B.Ed/AP/2012-13/46925 dated 30.10.2012.

W.P.No.46418/2012 in W.P.No.36559/2012 in the matter of Azizia College of Education, Adoni, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh.

The court order has been received in the office of SRC on 04.12.2012. the Hon’ble High court has passed an order as under:-

“petition under section 151 of C.P.C. praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in the W.P. the High Court may be pleased to direct the 1st respondent to grant the recognition to the petitioner institution for B.Ed Course from the academic year 2012-2013, by Suspending the proceedings issued by the 1st respondent vide F.No.APS0318/B.Ed/AP/2012-13/46925, dt.30-10-2012, pending disposal of WP No.36559 of 2012 on the file of the High Court.

The court, while directing issue of notice to the Respondents herein to show cause as to why this petition should not be complied with, made the following order. (The receipt of this order will be deemed to be the receipt of notice in the case).

Order

There shall be interim direction as prayed for.




119



Judgement passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in SLP © No. 14020/2009 filed by Adarsh Shiksha Mahavidalaya & others Vs Subhash Rahaangdale & others is:

“ In future, the High Courts shall not entertin prayer for interim relief by unrecognized institutions and the institutions which have not been granted affiliation by the examination body and or the students admitted by such institutions for permission to appear in the examination or for declaration of the result of examination. This would also apply to the recognized institutions if they admit students otherwise than in accordance with the procedure contained in Appendix-1 of the Regulations”.

Decision of NCTE Committee in r/o processing of applications for the session 2013-14, DT. 21st Sept, 2012.

The NCTE Committee in it; meeting held on 10.09.2012 took note of the fact that a number of applications nceived by the Regional Committees for the academic session 2012-13 did not reach finality on 31' August, 2012 due to various reasons. The Committee took note of the fact that a similar situation had arisen in August 2011 relating to grant of recognition for academic session 2011-12 wherein the Committee, after taking into account the time limit for processing of applications stipulated under the Regulations, the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the Civil Appeal No. 1125-1128 of 2011, and the legal advice received on the subject had decided that the Regional Committees may complete the • processing of the applications expeditiously; however, recognition may be granted only for the subsequent acade nic session, viz 2012-13.

The committee considered the Court order dt. 27.11.2012 and decided to inform lawyer to file a review petition.

69. SRCAPP840D.El.EdGood

Shephered Institute of Education, Rangareddi

DistrictAP

Good Shepherd Institute of Teacher Education, Plot No.2-2-96, Jeedimetla Village, Suchitra Centre Post, Quthbullapur Taluk, Secunderabad City, Rangareddi District-500067, Andhra Pradesh.

Operation Mercy India Foundation, Plot No.2-2-96, Medchal Road, Jeedimetla Village, Suchitra Centre Post, Quthbullapur Taluk, Secunderabad City, Rangareddi District-500067, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Good Shepherd Institute of Teacher Education, Plot No.2-2-96, Jeedimetla Village, Suchitra Centre Post, Quthbullapur Taluk, Secunderabad City, Rangareddi District-500067, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act,


120


1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of Southern Regional Committee on 29.09.2011.


The institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after the stipulated time of 60 days and till date.

As per sub-clause (1) of Clause 7 of NCTE Regulation 2009, the applicant institutions is required to submit deficiencies to the Southern Regional Committee Office Within 60 days from the date of receipt of communication of deficiencies, failing which the application will be treated as rejected and closed, no extension to time will be granted and any submission received after 60 days will be treated as invalid and not entertained. The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012 considered the matter, as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP840/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/41817 dated 30.05.2012.


“after perusal of the documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was no ground to accept the appeal. Accordingly, the appeal is rejected and SRC order dated 30.05.2012 is confirmed”.

The institution moved to Hon’ble High Court of Judicature at Andhra Pradesh dtd. 18.09.2012 in W.P. No. 29329 of 2012 and WPMP.No. 37435 of 2012 reads as under:-

“…….. the writ petition is allowed with a direction to the respondent (SRC, NCTE) to consider the petitioner’s application already made by them for grant of recognition for the academic year 2013-14 reasonable. Accordingly, the petitioners are exempted from making a fresh application for recognition for the year 2013-14 subject to their paying fresh inspection and other charges payable for a fresh application. SRC NCTE is directed to consider the first petitioner’s application by issuing a fresh deficiency letter and process the said application for the academic year 2013-14”.


121


The committee considered the Hon’ble High Court order dt. 18-09-2012 and decided to inform lawyer to file a petition for appeal and’Stay’.


Amaravathi D.Ed College,

Guntur District

AP

Amaravathi D.Ed College, Plot No.111/1A, Guntur Road, Amaravathi Village and Post, Amaravathi City and Taluk, Guntur District-522020, Andhra Pradesh.

Amar Educational Society, Plot No.111/1A, Guntur Road, Amaravathi Village and Post, Amaravathi City and Taluk, Guntur District-522020, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition Amaravathi D.Ed College, Plot No.111/1A, Guntur Road, Amaravathi Village and Post, Amaravathi City and Taluk, Guntur District-522020, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of Two year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 23.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of Southern Regional Committee on 26.09.2011.


The institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter within the stipulated time of 60 days and till date.

As per sub-clause (1) of Clause 7 of NCTE Regulation 2009, the applicant institutions is required to submit deficiencies to the Southern Regional Committee Office Within 60 days from the date of receipt of communication of deficiencies, failing which the application will be treated as rejected and closed, no extension to time will be granted and any submission received after 60 days will be treated as invalid and not entertained.

The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th-20th April 2012, considered the matter, as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide No.F.No.SRCAPP637/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/ dated 30.05.2012.The institution has submitted a Court order along with the documents / reply for deviciency letter dt. 20.12.2011. Submitted Hon’ble court W.P.No.26800 of 2012 dated 10.10.2012 order as follows:-“Respondent is directed to consider petitioner’s application already made at least for the academic year 2013-14. If respondent No.2 finds any deficiencies, it shall immediately issue notice to the petitioners and consider the reply, if any sent by the latter and take a decision on permitting the petitioners to commence course from the academic year 2013-14”.The SRC in its 235th Meeting held on 20th – 21st November 2012, considered the Court

order and decided to process.

The Committee considered the Hon’ble High Court rder dt. 10.10.2012. and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms, subject to submission of latest encumbrance certificate.


Bhanodaya D.Ed College, No. 66/13, 14, 15, 17, 18, 19, 20, Kanakampalam Village, Parameswara Mangalam Post Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517584,


122


Bhanodaya D.Ed College,

Chittoor District

AP

Andhra Pradesh

Bhanodaya Educational Society, No. 1 Chennai-Tirupathi NH, Kanakampalam Village, Parameswara Mangalam Post, Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517584, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Bhanodaya D.Ed College, No. 66/13, 14, 15, 17, 18, 19, 20, Kanakampalam Village, Parameswara Mangalam Post Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517584, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.9.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.10.2011.

The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 09.11.2011 followed by reminder on 19.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011.

The institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days and till date.

As per sub-clause (1) of clause 7 of NCTE Regulation 2009, the applicant institutions is required to submit deficiencies to the Southern Regional Committee Office within 60 days from the date of receipt of communication of deficiencies, failing which the application will be treated as rejected and closed, no extension to time will be granted and any submission received after 60 days will be treated as invalid and not entertained.

The SRC in its 221st Meeting held on 19th-20th April, 2012 considered the matter, as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


The institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh, W. P. No. 29618 of 2012 and the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in its order dated 21/09/2012 has stated that ‘respondent No. 1 is directed to reconsider the petitioner’s application forthwith treating the petitioner’s reply to the show casue notice as being sent within the stipulated time of twenty one days. If respondent No. 1 finds the application of the petitioner in accordance with the regulations and the prescribed norms, it shall permit the petitioner to commence D.El.Ed course from the academic year 2012-13.’

The committee considered the Hon’ble High Court order dt. 21/09/2012 and decided to inform Lawyer to file an appeal and obtain stay.


JP College of Elementary Education, Nalgonda

DistrictAP

JP College of Elementary Education, K.No. 670, Cherlapally Village and Post, Nalgonda Taluk and District – 508001, Andhra Pradesh

JP Educational Society, Plot No. 6-1-108, Ramagiri Street, Nalgonda Village and Post, Nalgonda Taluk and District – 508001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to JP College of Elementary Education, K.No. 670, Cherlapally Village and Post, Nalgonda Taluk and District – 508001, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional


123


Committee, NCTE online on 30.09.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 03.10.2011.


The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.02.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.


The reply of the institution to the Show Cause Notice was duly considered and the

reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

1. Land documents of Gift Settlement Deed dt. 25.01.2012, which is registered after the date of on-line application is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009. The management has advised the same in its reply to the Show Cause Notice.

2. Certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted.

3. The details of other teacher education programmes run by the institution in the same building/premises is not given.

4. In the building completion certificate submitted, Column No. 9 is not duly filled up for proposed course/college name and hence it is incomplete.


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected and based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 224 th meeting held on 14th

–17th June 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order no. F.No. 89-428/2012 Appeal/9th Meeting- 2012 has stated as follows:“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC with a direction to process the application and to take the further decision thereafter.

Now therefore, the Council hereby remands back the case of JP College of Elementary Education, Nalgonda, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.


124


The SRC in its 235th meeting held on 21st-22nd November 2012 decided to process the application.

The Committee considered the Appellate authority order and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


Sri Balaji Venkateshwa

ra Swamy College of


Rangareddy District

AP

Sri Balaji Venkateshwara Swamy College of Elementary Education, Khasara No. 81/2, Land Title 2461, Plot No. 81, Street No. 01, Keshvaram Village, Shamirpet Post and City, Medchal Taluk, Ranga Reddy District – 500078, Andhra Pradesh

P. Janardhan Reddy Memorial Educational Society, Plot No. 1-7, Toopran Road and Village, Toopran Post and City, Gajwel Taluk, Medak District – 502334, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Balaji Venkateshwara Swamy College of Elementary Education, Khasara No. 81/2, Land Title 2461, Plot No. 81, Street No. 01, Keshvaram Village, Shamirpet Post and City, Medchal Taluk, Ranga Reddy District – 500078, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course of two years duration under Section 14 (1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 01.10.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 08.11.2011 / 29.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011. Now the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 29.02.2012.

The SRC in its 220th meeting held on 30th – 31st March 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.29.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 30.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 21.05.2012.

The reply of the institution to the Show Cause Notice was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:


2. Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted.


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected and based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009 to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.



125


The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order no. F.No. 89-440/2012 Appeal/9 th Meeting- 2012 has stated as follows:

“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate justification to remand the case to the SRC for further processing as per the NCTE Regulations.

Now therefore, the Council hereby remands back the case of Sri Balaji Venkateshwara Swamy College of Elementary Education, Rangareddy, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.

The matter is placed before SRC in its 235th meeting held on 20th-21st November 2012 decided to process the application.

The Committee considered the Appellate authority order and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


St. Thomas D.Ed College, Vizianagaram

DistrictAP

St. Thomas Charitable Trust, No. 13-16, Dwarapudi Road, K.L.Puram, Maruthi Nagar Village & Post, Vizianagaram Taluk & District – 535003, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to St. Thomas D.Ed College, K.No. 119/7 P.No. 13-16, Dwarapudi Street, K.L.Puram Village & Post, Vizianagaram Taluk & District – 535003, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 05.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 28.10.2011/22.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011.

The institution has not submitted reply to the deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days and till date.

The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012 has considered the matter as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7 (1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.



126



“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for consideration of the reply to the deficiency letter and to take further decision thereafter. The institution is directed to send their reply dated 26.02.2012 again to SRC for consideration”.

Accordingly the SRC in its 235th meeting held on 20th – 21st November 2012 considered the matter and decide to process the application.

The Committee considered the Appellate authority order and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms, subject to submission of original FDRs.

75. SRCAPP580D.El.EdVishwa

Bharathi D.Ed College,

Ranga Reddy District

AP

Vishwa Bharathi D.Ed College, Sy No. 197/AA, Urellaroad, Devuni Erravally Village and Post Office, Chevella Taluka, Chevella City, Ranga Reddy – 501503, Andhra Pradesh.SVR Educational Development Society, H No. 9-4-84/9, Above Corporation Bank, Kakatiya Nagar & Post Office, Mehdipatnam, Hyderabad Taluka, Hyderabad District – 500028, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Vishwa Bharathi D.Ed College, Sy No. 197/AA, Urellaroad, Devuni Erravally Village and Post Office, Chevella Taluka, Chevella City, Ranga Reddy District – 501503, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course of two year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 21.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 22.09.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 27.09.2011 followed by a remainder on 08.12.2012. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 08.12.2011. The institution had replied to the deficiency letter on 08.02.2012. Recommendation from State Government is not received.The SRC in its 218th meeting of SRC held on February 2012 considered the reply for deficiency letter and other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause inspection at the premises to examine whether the institution fulfills all the requirements as per the norms and to ascertain infrastructural and instructional facilities available at the premises for the proposed course.Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 19 th-23rd March 2012 and the same was intimated to the institution on 13.03.2012. Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 19.03.2012. The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19-20 April 2012, considered the VT report, VCD and all other relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice.

Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 17.05.2012. The


127


institution submitted its reply on 05.06.2012.


1. As per VCD, the front full view of the building is not shown, entrance to the building looks like Godown only. Window shutters not fixed in first floor and the building construction is incomplete. No windows in frontage, lack of ventilation and building is not suitable for education purpose.

2. As per VT report total built up area is 16881 sq.ft, whereas the total outcome as per essential data sheet of page No. 5 is 7468 sq.ft only.

Contd...2-2-

3. As seen from VCD, all class rooms are having temporary partition walls, which is not permissible.

4. As per BCC, there are two buildings, one building consists of Ground + 1 st

floor and 2nd building consists of 1 +2 floors, where as in VCD only one building with Ground + 1st floor is shown; which is incomplete. The management/institution is trying to mislead NCTE & trying to suppress the correct information.

The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory and unconvincing.Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 224 th meeting held on 14th-17th June 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


Mean time, this office received a fax letter from Shri. Madhava Rao, Advocate on 28.07.2012 stating that the institution has filed Court case in W.P.No. 29412 of 2012 in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Prdaesh as follows:

“ the institution has filed writ without filing Appeal before the appellate authority (New Delhi) thus the Petitioner institution is directed to file appeal and the appellate authority in New Delhi is directed to dispose of the appeal within 3 weeks from the date of receipt of the ordr”.

Accordingly, the institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs on 22.08.2012 and the Appellate Authority vide order no. F.No. 89-473/2012 Appeal/9 th Meeting- 2012 has stated as follows:

“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VT report and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for re-inspection of the institution after obtaining payment of Rs. 40,000/- from the institution and for taking further decision thereafter.

Now therefore, the Council hereby remands back the case of Vishwa Bharathi D.Ed College, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.

The Committee considered the Appellate authority order dt. 09/10/2012 and


128


all other relevant documents and decided to cause Re-inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms, after collection of balance inspection fee.

Consideration of Complaint Cases (Volume- 03)

76. SRCAPP72B.Ed

Dr. Zakir College of Education, Sivagangai

DistrictTN

Dr. Zakir College of Education, Paramakudi Road, Ilayangudi Village and Post, Ilayangudi Taluk, Sivagangai District, Pin-630702, Tamilnadu

Dr. Zakir College of Education, Paramakudi Road, Ilayangudi Village and Post,

Ilayangudi Taluk, Sivagangai District, Pin-630702, Tamilnadu submitted its

application for B.Ed course through on-line on 29.10.2009. The institution had

submitted hard copy of the application on 29.10.2009. The institution was granted

recognition on 20.07.2011 with an annual intake of 100 students.

A complainant dtd. 01.11.2012 has been received against illegal functioning of Dr.

Zakir Husian College of Teachers Education, Ilayangudi-630702, Sivagangai

District from A.E.AL AMEEEN, No. 14, Sakkarai Ambalam Street, Ilayangudi –

630702, Sivagangai District, Tamilnadu on 07.11.2012. Accordingly, a letter was

issued to the complainant on 09.11.2012 requesting to submit an affidavit on Rs.

100/- stamp paper indicating they had written the complaint under his signature or

not.

The complainant had submitted reply alongwith remarks and documents on

26.11.2012. The complainant has also submitted original notarized affidavit of Rs.

100/- dtd. 19.11.2012 regarding illegal functioning of Dr. Zakir Husain College of

Education at Ilayangudi.

The committee considered the complaint vide letter dt. 01.11.2012 from the complainants and decided to seek comments from the Institution and to send a copy of the complaint to the affiliating aurhority for their comments.

77. SRCAPP394B.Ed

Kalaimagal College of Education,

Dharmapuri District

TN

Kalaimagal College of Education, 3/228, Unisinahalli Village, Kadathur Post, Pappireddipatti Taluk, Dharmapuri District, Pin-635303, Tamilnadu

Kalaimagal College of Education, 3/228, Unisinahalli Village, Kadathur Post,

Pappireddipatti Taluk, Dharmapuri District, Pin-635303, Tamilnadu had submitted

an application for B.Ed Course on 07.10.2010. The institution was granted

recognition on 19.07.2011 with an annual intake of 100 students, with the condition

to shift to own premises within 3 years.


129


The NCTE Hqrs vide letter dtd. 03.07.2012 has forwarded a complaint was received against the institution from Shri Ganesh through Email dated 21.06.2012 which has stated that the aforesaid institution is also running a school in the same building run by the same management/society.

NCTE, Hqrs had requested to examine the matter and to take necessary action against the institution as per the NCTE Act, 1993, by placing the complaint before the Regional Committee.

The committee considered the letter from NCTE Hqrs New Delhi regarding a complaint from Mr. Ganesh through e-mail dt. June 21st, 2012 and decided to seek comments from the Institution and to send a copy of the complaint to the affiliating authority for their comments.

78. APS06270B.Ed

Sri Sainath College of Education,

Kurnool District

AP

Sri Sainath College of Education, Yemmiganur, Kurnool District, AP.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 09.03.2012 stated that applied for recognition to run B.Ed course in Sri Sainath College of Education, Yemmiganur, Kurnool District, AP in the year 2005.

In exercise of the powers bested under Section 14(3)(a) of the NCTE Act, 1993, the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE granted recognition to Sri Sainath College of Education, Sri Shiridi Sainath Education, Ac./okmd Azimathulla, H.no. 1, channambatti Street, Yemmiganur, Kurnool District – 518360, Andhra Pradesh for conducting B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 students from the academic session 2012-1013 under clause 7(110 of NCTE (Recognition Norms & Procedure) Regulations, 2009 subject, to fulfillment of the certain conditions vide order dt. 03.09.2012.

Now, a complaint dt. 16.11.2012 has been received from T. Krishna Mohan, Vice President, Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra Pradesh requesting to with hold the admissions granted to.

1. M/s. Venkatarathna College of Education, Kurnool.2. M/s. Sri Sainath College of Education, Yemmiganoor, Kurnool District,

Andhra Pradesh.For the year 2012-13.

Copy of complaint is enclosed.

The file of another institution is being put up separately.

The committee considered the complaint from MR. T. Krishna Mohan, of Sri Shiridi Sainath Education society, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra Pradesh vide letter dt. 16.11.2012 and decided to seek comments from the Institution and to send a copy of the complaint to the affiliating aurhority for their comments.

.

79. APS09054 Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur,


130


B.EdVenkata Rathna


Kurnool District

AP

Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society, Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh has submitted an application to the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh for Secondary (B.Ed) course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 (Hundred) Students.

In exercise of the powers vested under Section 14(3)(a) of the NCTE Act, 1993, the Southern Regional Committee granted recognition to Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District – 518 002, Andhra Pradesh for conducting Secondary (B.Ed) course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 (Hundred) students under clause 7912) of Regulations dated 13.01.2006. This order of recognition shall be prospective and take effect from the date of issue of this order i.e. 18.01.2008, subject to fulfillment of the certain conditions.

Now, a complaint dt. 16.11.2012 has been received from T. Krishna Mohan, Vice President, Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra Pradesh requesting to with hold the admissions granted to.

3. M/s. Venkatarathna College of Education, Kurnool.4. M/s. Sri Sainath College of Education, Yemmiganoor, Kurnool District,

Andhra Pradesh.For the year 2012-13.

Copy of complaint is enclosed.

The file of another institution is being put up separately.

The committee considered the complaint from MR. T. Krishna Mohan, of Sri Shiridi Sainath Education society, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra Pradesh vide letter dt. 16.11.2012 and decided to seek comments from the Institution and to send a copy of the complaint to the affiliating aurhority for their comments.

Consideration of Inspection u/s-14 (Volume- 03)


Bethany D.Ed College, East

Godavari Distirct

AP

Bethany D.Ed College, No. 26/1, Ethakota Village, Ravulapalem Post, Kothapeta Taluk, East Godavari District-533238, Andhra Pradesh.

Bethany Educational Society, D.No. 7-28/2, Market Street, Ravulapalem Village & Post, Kothapeta Tlauk, East Godavari District-533238, Andhra Pradesh, had applied for recognition to Bethany D.Ed College, No. 26/1, Ethakota Village, Ravulapalem Post, Kothapeta Taluk, East Godavari District-533238, Andhra Pradesh, for D.El.Ed course of two year duration under section 14 (1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 and hardcopy received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 26.09.2011.

As per NCTE –Hqrs, have published a Public Notice in Deccan Herald on 30 th July, 2011 states as under;

National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) invites applications for recognition of teacher training courses for the academic session 2012-13. applications in the prescribed from should be submitted “on-line” to the


131


concerned Regional Committee along with fee ad essential documents as prescribed in NCTE regulations, 2009 from 1st August, 2011 to 30th

September, 2011 only.

There is discrepancy in the Demand Draft no. given in online form and photocopy with application. The application submitted by the institution does not possess prescribed processing fees either in form of Demand Draft or Challan Xerox copy of demand draft is submitted which is not acceptable. Hence, the request of the institution is found ineligible as per NCTE Regulations, 2009. Therefore, the application for starting D.El.Ed course cannot be entertained and the application submitted by the institution to be returned.

Accordingly, the application along with other documents submitted by the institution for D.Ed course is returned vide letter no. F.No.SRCAPP604/D.El.Ed/2012-2013/AP/31255 dated 18/10/2011.

The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-201/2012 Appeal/6th Meeting-2012 dated 17/07/2012 state that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per Regulations”.

In obedience to the appeal order dated 17/07/2012 F.No. 89-201/2012/Appeal / 6th

meeting-2012, the SRC in its 231st meeting held on 22nd-23rd August 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17/07/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. Notarized English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted.


3. Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted. In the BCC submitted.

4. As per encumbrance certificate submitted, land is in the name of an individual, nature of the document is release deed, date of registration of land document is different from the land document.

5. Proof of completion of 3 academic sessions towards B.Ed course which is already run by the institution from the affiliating body/State Govt/examining body is not submitted.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 06.09.2012 (with reference to online minutes).

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 considered the reply of the institution and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 15th-20th November, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 05/11/2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 16/11/2012.


132


The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following: Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil

authority is not submitted. In the approved building plan copy submitted, total earmarked built up area for both B.Ed and D.Ed is not mentioned.

Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted. In the BCC submitted, total earmarked built up area for both B.Ed and D.Ed is not mentioned.

As per V.T report, available seating capacity in the library is only 40 for both B.Ed and D.El.Ed courses, which is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.

As per VT report, No. of books available in the library is only 1000, which is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.

As per building plan submitted, the size of the multipurpose hall is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.

Original notarized Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.


81. SRCAPP1272

D.El.EdSri Vidya Teacher Training College, Chittoor District

AP

Sri Vidhya Teacher Training College, P. No. 239/5, Govindapalem Village, Puttur Post & Taluk, Chittoor district-517583, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Vidhya Educational Society, S. No. 28-17, Govindapalem village, Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Vidhya Teacher Training College, P. No. 239/5, Govindapalem Village, Puttur Post & Taluk, Chittoor District-517583, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course of two years duration under Section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 04.10.2011.



133


The SRC in its 220th Meeting of SRC held on 30th – 31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 27.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.


The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days period.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May 2012, considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 21/05/2012, i.e., after 25 (Twenty Five) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt. 26/04/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course. Accordingly a rejection order was issued to the institution on 27/06/2012.

Against SRC’s rejection order, the institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh ,W. P. No. 22244 of 2012 and the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in its order dated 23/07/2012 has stated that ‘the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE, Bangalore is directed to re – consider the petitioner’s application , pass a detailed order and communicate the same to the petitioner within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.’

In obedience to the court order dated 23.07.2012 In W.P.No. 22244 of 2012 the application has been processed and placed in the SRC in its 231st Meeting held on 22rd – 23rd August 2012 and the committee considered the matter and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Mean time the institution submitted its written representation on 25.09.2012 with reference of 231st meeting minutes. The same is placed in SRC meeting held on 17-18th Oct 2012.

The SRC in its 234th meeting held on 17th-18th October 2012, considered the reply of the institution dt.25-09-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following: Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from

a Nationalised Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name is not


134


submitted again, which were returned along with rejection order dt. 27.06.2012.

Up-to-date Notarised encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

As per VT report, No. of books available in the library is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.


82. SRCAPP95

3D.El.Ed

Srinivasa College of


Chittoor District

AP

Srinivasa College of Elementary Education, Khasara No. 60-3, Maratigate Street, Puttur Village & Post, Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517583, Andhra Pradesh.

Maharishi Educational Society, Khasara No. 60-3, Maratigate Street, Puttur Village & Post, Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517583, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Srinivasa College of Elementary Education, Khasara No. 60-3, Maratigate Street, Puttur Village & Post, Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517583, Andhra Pradesh, for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 01.10.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 04.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 03.11.2011. A reminder letter to the State Government was sent on 19.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011.

The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 27.02.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 220th Meeting held on 30th and 31st March 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 27.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012.The institution has submitted written representation on 21.05.2012

The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days period as per clause 14(1) of NCTE Regulations

The Southern Regional Committee in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May


135


2012, considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 21/05/2012, i.e., after 24 (Twenty Four) days from the date of issue of of show cause notice dt. 27/04/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course


Against SRC’s rejection order, the institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh ,W. P. No. 22257 and the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in its order dated 23/07/2012 has stated that ‘the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE, Bangalore is directed to re – consider the petitioner’s application , pass a detailed order and communicate the same to the petitioner within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.’

The SRC in its 231st meeting held on 22nd-23rd August 2012, considered the Court order dt. 23.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

As per encumbrance certificate dt. 23/02/2012 submitted, the land is on lease basis, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

8 (7) (i) of NCTE Regulations States:No institution shall be granted recognition under these Regulations unless the institution or society sponsoring the institution is in possession of required land on the date of application. The land free from all encumbrances could be either on ownership basis or on lease from Government or Government institutions for a period of not less than 30 years. In cases where under relevant State or Union Territory laws the maximum permissible lease period is less than 30 years, the State Government or Union Territory Administration law shall prevail. However, no building shall be taken on lease for running any teacher training course.

1. In the building plan submitted, total earmarked land area , Sy.No. is not mentioned.

2. As per building completion certificate, the college building is roofed with Asbestos sheets. Which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

8 (10) of NCTE Regulations 2009 states:

At the time of inspection, the building of the institution shall be complete in the form of a permanent structure on the land possessed by the institution in terms of sub-regulation (7) of Regulation 8, equipped with all necessary amenities and fulfilling all such requirements as prescribed in the norms and standards. The applicant institution shall produce the original completion certificate issued by the competent Government Authority or local body authority, approved building plan in proof of the completion of building and built up area and other documents to the visiting team for verification. No temporary structure or asbestos roofing shall be allowed in the institution, even if it is in addition to the prescribed built up area.


136


Built up area is not matching with building plan and building completion certificate.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 25.09.2012. (with reference to online).

The SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17th-18th October, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.25-09-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 15th-20th November, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 02/11/2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 19/11/2012.The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following: As per building plan, there are two blocks, one for B.Ed and another for

D.Ed having built up area of 1727 & 1440 sq.mtrs respectively. However, as per VT report, 25017 sq.ft built up area is available. Regarding B.Ed, VT members have not mentioned anything in VTR, however, in questionnaire they told regarding B.Ed, it is not clear how much area is earmarked for B.Ed and D.El.Ed separately.

As per V.T report, available seating capacity in the library is only 65 for both B.Ed and D.El.Ed courses, which is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.

As per VT report, No. of books available in the library is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.



83. APS05218B.Ed

Sri Raja Rajeshwari College of Education,

Vellore District

Sri Raja Rajeshwari College of Education, V.G.M. Nagar, Ammoor Road, Walajapet-632513, Vellore District, Tamilnadu.

Sri Raja Rajeshwari College of Education, V.G.M. Nagar, Ammoor Road, Walajapet-632513, Vellore District, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 02.01.2006. The institution was granted recognition on 26.10.2006 with an annual intake of 100 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.


137


TNThe institution in its letter dated 02.09.2010 stated as follows

“ I wish to submit that we launched our institution with the sole intention of including B.Ed Programme to the poor and village students at a very nominal fees and we have succeeded in achieving the same for the past 3 years, since our institution is located in a very remote village, the construction of the pucca building could not be completed within the prescribed time limitation. The construction is going on and we will inform you as soon as the construction work is completed”.

The institution has been inspected at Walajapet, Vellore District and granted recognition at Walajapet address where the institution entered a lease agreement of only three years as per lease deed dated 22.11.2005. The institution has also submitted another lease deed dated 17.10.2005 which is for 40 years but the address in this lease deed as per schedule of lease deed is Vellore District, Arakkonam Registration District, Arcot Taluk, Chakkarmallur Village.

Hence the institution, as per recognition order dated 26.10.2006 was supposed to shift to its own premises/building within 3 years from the date of recognition.

The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September, 2010 decided to issue show cause notice to the institution. Accordingly notice was issued to the institution on 26.10.2010.

The institution vide letter 26.11.2010 stated as follows:

“We started the B.Ed programme in the leased out building at the time of launching the same Subsequently the entire building along with another building was transferred in favor of our Trust on 16.09.2008 itself by way of a settlement deed. Thus the entire building under lease became the own property of the Trust. A Xerox copy of the same is enclosed herewith for your perusal. The total extent of the building available is 125sq.ft. Thus we are running the institution in the premises only.

Further I submit that to facilitate more amenities and infrastructures to the students we are now constructing a modern building in a vast area in the land situated at Chakramallur Village, Arcot Taluk. This land has been taken on lease for 40 years and we have already submitted the relevant document to you. Through we started to work 1 year age, due to the labors problem we could not complete the building in time. Now the work is going on very speedily and the same is about to be completed in 2 months time.

I undertake to shift the entire institution within a period of 2 months.

Hence I request you to grant me 2 months time only for shifting to the new building”.

The SRC in its 199th meeting held on 22nd-23rd December, 2011 considered the request and decided to cause inspection of the institution in Feb 2011; if the institution is not ready for inspection with completion of building, further action will be taken with no further notice.

The inspection of the institution was fixed between 14 th-18th March, 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 03.03.2011. The inspection of the institution is not yet conducted.


138


The institution vide its letter dated 09.04.2012 has submitted DD bearing no. 588976 dated. 31.03.2012 for Rs. 40,000/- towards processing fees for shifting of premises.

The SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th-31st May 2012 considered the written reply and other relevant documents submitted by the institution and decided to cause Shifting inspection at the new premises and to ascertain infrastructural and instructional facilities Under NCTE Act. Accordingly, inspection of the institution was conducted on 16.06.2012.

The SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30th-31st July,2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 24.08.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 05.10.2012.


The institution has not submitted approved staff list from affiliating body/University.


84. AOS00011 / APS08525/ APS08715

B.Ed/ B.Ed.DE / M.Ed-AIAnnamalai University,

Department of Education,

Cuddalore District

TN

Annamalai University, Department of Education, Annamalai Nagar, Chidambaram, Cuddalore District-608002, Tamilnadu

Annamalai University, Department of Education, Annamalai Nagar, Chidambaram, Cuddalore District-608002, Tamilnadu had submitted the applications for B.Ed course on 16.02.1996, B.Ed.ED course on 13.04.2007 and M.Ed-Al course on 26.05.2007. The institution was granted recognition for B.Ed course on 18.07.2001 with an annual intake of 300 students, B.Ed-ED course on 09.04.2008 with an annual intake of 500 students and M.Ed-Al course on 30.10.2007 thus making an annual intake of 50 students, which includes the existing intake of 10 and an additional intake of 40 students within 3 years from the date of recognition.

NCTE Hqrs vide its letter dt.09.09.2011 has forwarded a copy of the inspection report dt.13.06.2011 conducted Under Section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs has requested SRC to look into the matter in order to ascertain the compliance/adherence of the NCTE Norms and Standards by the institution and also to take appropriate action.

The SRC in its 213th meeting held on 06th-07th November, 2011 considered the VT Report, and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve


139


Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 02.01.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 16.01.2012.


Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not

submitted.


The institution has not submitted total intake course wise i.e, for B.Ed and M.Ed courses.

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in joint account in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given course wise.


85. APS04925D.T.Ed

Thozhilathibar Teacher Training Institute,

Trichy District

TN

Thozhilathibar Teacher Training Institute, No. 43, Rajiv Gandhi Nagar, Edamalaipatti Pudur, Trichy-620012, Tamilnadu

Thozhilathibar Teacher Training Institute, No. 43, Rajiv Gandhi Nagar, Edamalaipatti Pudur, Trichy-620012, Tamilnadu had submitted an applications for D.T.Ed Course on 28.12.2005 and D.T.Ed-AI course on 20.11.2006. The institution was granted recognition for D.T.Ed course on 07.09.2006 with an annual intake of 50 students and D.T.Ed-AI course on 16.01.2008 thus making an annual intake of 100 students which includes the existing intake of 50 and an additional intake of 50 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

On the basis of Direction of MHRD to re-inspect all the institutions granted recognition by SRC in its 116th meeting as per the recommendation of Sri. Sathyam Committee reports, the inspection of the institution under Section 17 was carried out on 18.12.2008. The institution has approached the Hon’ble Court in WP.29977/2008. The matter was considered by SRC in its 170 th meeting held on 16th-17th February 2009 and decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 04.04.2009. The institution had submitted its reply on 15.04.2009, the same was considered by SRC in its 180th

meeting held on 29th July 2009 and SRC decided to issue notice under Section 17.


140


Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 01.09.2009. The institution had submitted its reply on 26.10.2009.

The SRC considered the written representation submitted by the institution and decided to continue the approval given to Thozhilathibar Teacher Training Institute (D.T.Ed, APS04925) and withdraw the recognition for D.T.Ed-AI(APS08186) course for which the land/buildings/infrastructure are not available as per the norms, as inferred from the reply statements furnished by the institution.

As per the decision of SRC, a letter of continued recognition in respect of Thozhilathibar TTI, Trichy District, Tamilnadu was issued to the institution for D.T.Ed course on 09.02.2010(APS04925) and withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 09.02.2010 for D.T.Ed-AI course.

A complaint dated 09.09.2010 was received from Hope Foundation, which was considered by SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September, 2010. The committee considered the matter and decided to inform the complainant that he is free to seek legal remedy as it is a civil dispute.

The legal notices dated 25.10.2010 and 18.01.2011 was considered by SRC in its 200th meeting held on 20-21 January, 2011. The Committee considered the legal notices and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section of NCTE Act for the following :

The management has to submit all the original documents and land lease Deed agreement documents of the institution, along with the remarks on the contents of legal notice issued on behalf of the one M.T.Karunanidhi who claims to be the lessor, that the present land where the building is situated at Door No. 43, Rajiv Gandhinagar, Ekamalaipudur, Trichy-12, Tamilnadu, was partly leased to the above institution. The lease agreement was allegedly cancelled on 30.1.2007. Now the management has to file an affidavit on the authenticity of the above facts and submit the original records for verification.

Specific remarks on the allegation that the management/trust had concealed and suppressed the fact of cancellation of lease deed and thereby misled and violated NCTE norms and Regulations, to be submitted in the affidavit.

The SRC denies and takes strong exception to the mischievous, unfounded and false allegations against NCTE SRC, made out in the legal notice issued on behalf of one M.T. Karunanidhi said to be the lessor of the said land; that the information on the said cancellation of the lease deed said to have taken place as early as 30-01.2007, took more than four years to reach the SRC NCTE is un-understandable.

Any Civil/Criminal dispute arising out of lessor and lessee deal may have to be resolved by a Court of Law and the litigant is free to proceed legally in the matter; and any attempt to involve the regulatory authority in the issue and discredit the same is unwarranted.

In the meantime, one more legal notice dated 12.02.2011 was received on 15.02.2011 from Shri. A. Kumar, Advocate which was placed before SRC in its 201st

meeting held on 22-23 February, 2011 and the Committee decided as follows:-

“To take appropriate legal action against the complainant for indulgence in sinister campaign and casting aspersions on the NCTE, by making false and malicious allegations.


141


To call for remarks of the institution on the specific allegation that the institution had submitted some forged documents to the SRC.

To cause a composite inspection of the teacher education institutions of the above management, on receipt of the remarks and all the related documents and filled in questionnaire and the requisite inspection fee from the institution”.

As per the decision of SRC, letter was issued to the institution on 07.03.2011 and a letter was issued to Advocate Counsel on 07.03.2011 to take legal action.

In response to this office letter dated 07.03.2011 and a letter to the institution as per the SRC’s decision of 201st meeting, the institution has submitted reply on 18.04.2011 stated that a case is pending in the court of the District Municif Trichirapalli in O.S. No. 1359 of 2010 and I.A. No. 567 of 2010 regarding the right of possession of the building and land by the Management and other party.

The institution has not submitted D.D. of Rs. 40,000/- as an inspection along with essential documents as per the letter dated 07.03.2011. Instead the institution has submitted a copy of court order of the District Munisif of Trichirapally is as follows;

The prayed that “this Hon’ble court may be pleased to grant temporary injunction retraining the defendant, his men, agents, servants, and any persons claiming under him from in any way interfering with the petitioner’s peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property either by dispossess upon or otherwise in any manner whatsoever except under due process of law till the disposal of the suit and also pass an interim exparte injunction till the disposal of application and thus render justice”.

It appears that the place where institution is being run is the property right/dispute to which is under dispute. It also appears that interim injunction is given to the institution to run the institution. If the institution is running there inspection as directed by SRC can be carried out.

The SRC in its 204th meeting held on 26th-27th April 2011 considered the written reply and other relevant documents and decided to cause composite inspection at the premises in anticipation of inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/- per course, as originally decided and as the Court Order is not against the NCTE inspection under section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 30 th May to 4th June 2011, the same was intimated to the institution on 24.05.2011. VT report is awaited.

Meanwhile, the institution submitted letter alongwith rs.40000/- requesting 3 months time for the shifting and inspection of the institution. The institution has stated as follows:

“We received your letter on 26.05.2011, in which it has been mentioned that the visiting team of NCTE-SRO, will come for inspection of one institution between 30 th

May to 4th June and to submit the relevant documents to them.

Pertaining to this subject I wish to state that already we have sent the reply letter to you mentioning that we have dispute over the possession of building and land where the institution is running at present, for which a civil suit is pending in Munsif Court of Trichirapalli and we have obtained interim injection order also till 22.07.2011.


142


In such circumstances, again it has been insisted by the NCTE, SRC to be ready for the inspection in between the dates from 30.05.2011 to 04.06.2011. on seeing your letter, we have obtained the D.D also for Rs.40000/- which can be considered to have been paid well in advance for the inspection at that time of shifting of institution to the new building after 4 months. Apart from this we wish to state that the necessary documents/connected records are under the custody of court which can’t be obtained in view of the summer vacation to the courts in Tamilnadu.

Moreover, we want to insist that already the construction of building for the shifting of the institution is under progress and process after getting the application for construction and the construction will be completed by 15th September 2011 approximately. Hence the shifting and inspection will be possible only after that in view of shifting and court interim injection order.

In such circumstances, it is humbly requested that the inspection for shifting of institution may please be post-poned after 15th September 2011 and request that 4 months time may please be given for the shifting of building, besides allowing the institution to run in the present place and location without any disturbance to the students till September and without prejudice, since we have for the interim injection order of court also till 22.07.2011 which will be (can be) extended till 22.10.2011.

By and large it is shortly informed that it is subjudice, since the interim injection order is under existence till 22.07.2011 and apart from this we request he shifting time till 15.09.2011, for which kind of action use will be very much thankful to you.”

The SRC in its 206th meeting held on 09-10 June 2011 considered the Hon’ble High Court order and request of the institution and decided to cause composite inspection of the institution in the last week of September 2011. Accordingly visit was organized on 10.08.2011 and the VT Members has stated that the inspection could not be done due to the request for extension time period upto 15th September 2011.

Further, a letter dt.26.09.2011 was issued to the institution to remitted re-inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/-. However VT is fixed pending receipt of inspection fee. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 23.11.2011.

The SRC in its 215th meeting held on 12th-13th December, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.01.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 21.03.2012 alongwith DD bearing no. 071234 dtd. 02.02.2012 for Rs. 40,000/-.

APS04925-D.T.EdAPS07601-D.T.Ed-AI

The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th-20th April, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 21.03.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 17.05.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 19.06.2012.

The src in its 230th meeting held on 16-17 July 2012 considered the reply of the


143


institution vide letter dt. 19.06.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and its was decided to serve final show cause notice.

Accordingly, final show cause notice was issued to the institution on 10.09.2012. The institution has submitted its reply on 11.10.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 11.10.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has not submitted approved staff list from affiliating body.

Requisite affidavit(s) and joining reports (s) in respsect of Lectuer(s) in Fine arts & Physical Education are not submitted.

For two units of D.T.Ed course run by the institution, two lectuers in fine arts and Physical education are to be appointed.

The institution has not appointed lectuer in foundation course in any unit of D.T.Ed course.

No documentary proof is submitted by the institution regarding payment of salary to staff is being paid as per State/UGC/Central pay scales.


86. APS05167 / APS05785

B.Ed / D.T.EdR.K. Samy College of Education

and R.K. Samy Teacher Training Institute,

Ramanathapuram District

TN

R.K. Samy College of Education and R.K. Samy Teacher Training Institute, 1/780, Bharathinagar, Ramanathapuram, Pin-623503, Tamilnadu

R.K. Samy College of Education and R.K. Samy Teacher Training Institute, 1/780, Bharathinagar, Ramanathapuram, Pin-623503, Tamilnadu had submitted the applications for B.Ed and D.T.Ed Course on 02.01.2006. The institution was granted recognition for B.Ed on 05.10.2006 with an annual intake of 100 students and D.T.Ed course on 26.10.2006 with an annual intake of 50 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years

The SRC in its 181st meeting held on 20th-21st August 2009 where in it was decided that the institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under NCTE Act for further action.

Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 14.09.2009 giving 10 days to


144


submit reply. The institution had submitted its written representation on 01.10.2009 alongwith DD bearing no. 353668 dtd. 29.09.2011 for Rs.40000/- and another, DD bearing no. 353669 dtd. 29.09.2009 for Rs. 40,000/- towards inspection fee for shifting of premises at Seyyalur, Ettivayal Post, Via Chathirakudi, Ramanathapuram-623527, Tamilnadu for B.Ed and D.T.Ed course.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 11th-15th April 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 06.04.2011. Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 06.05.2011 for B.Ed and 07.05.2011 for D.T.Ed course.

The SRC in its 206th meeting held on 09th-10th June, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice to all the courses, under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution for D.T.Ed course on 05.07.2011. The Show Cause Notice was not issued for B.Ed course. However, the Show Cause Notice points is same in D.T.Ed course. The institution had submitted its written representation on 08.08.2011.

The SRC in its 215th meeting held on 12th-13th December, 2011 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 08.08.2011 and all other relevant documentary evidences and decided to allow for shifting of the institution to the new premises as under:

“Seyyalur, Ettivayal Post, Via Chathirakudi, Ramanathapuram-623527, Tamilnadu”, subject to the condition that production of valid Non-encumbrance certificate, information relating to equipping the psychology and language learning lab. Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 17.02.2012. The institution had submitted in its reply on 13.03.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 13.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 11.06.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 28.06.2012.

The SRC in its 232nd meeting held on 29th-31st August, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 28.06.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 08.10.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 30.10.2012.


The institution has not given exclusive built up area for both B.Ed and D.T.Ed

course separately.

The size of the multipurpose hall for both B.Ed and D.T.Ed courses is only


145


1313.64 sq.ft and 1313.64 sq.ft respectively. which is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.

Original Non-Encumbrance certificate dt. 07.07.2009, reflects that the land is in favour of individual name, so the institution is required to submit updated Encumbrance certificate.


87. APS01173D.T.Ed

K.N. Subbaraj Memorial Teacher Training Institute,

Thoothukudi District

TN

K.N. Subbaraj Memorial Teacher Training Institute, Manthithoppu Road, Kamarajav Nagar, Lakshmipuram Post, Kovilpatti, Thoothukudi District, Pin-628 502, Tamilnadu

K.N. Subbaraj Memorial Teacher Training Institute, Manthithoppu Road, Kamarajav Nagar, Lakshmipuram Post, Kovilpatti, Thoothukudi District, Pin-628 502, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for D.T.Ed Course on 31.12.2002. The institution was granted recognition on 13.09.2004 with an annual intake of 50 students. Further, the institution has submitted application for D.T.Ed-AI on 20.10.2004. The institution was grated recognition on 03.09.2005 with an annual intake of 50 students, thus making an annual intake of 100 students, which includes the existing intake of 50 and additional intake of 50 students with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dated 09.04.2010 submitted Rs.40000/- for shifting of premises at No.1, Kadalaiyur Road, Ettayauram-628902, Thoothukudi, Tamilnadu. Accordingly the inspection of the institution was fixed between 23rd March-2nd April 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 04.03.2011. Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 01.04.2011.

The management is also running B.Ed programme in the same building.

The SRC in its 204th meeting held on 27th-28th April 2011, considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve the Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act . Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 02.06.2011. The institution had submitted reply on 01.07.2011.

The committee considered the written reply and all other relevant documents, and decided to cause re-inspection at the premises under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on payment of inspection fee of Rs. 40000/- K,N,. Subbaraj Memorial Teacher Training Institute, Thoothukudi District Tamilnadu. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 18.02.2012.

The SRC in its 224th Meeting held on 14th-16th June, 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the


146


institution on 06.07.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 03.09.2012.

The Committee in its 233rd meeting held on 26-28th Sept, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide its letter dt. 03.09.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act.

Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on 29.10.2012. The institution has submitted its reply on 01.10.2012.

The reply of the institution vide letter dt. 01.10.2012 to the show cause notice was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

The built up area for both the courses as submitted by the institution is 16501 sq.ft. Which is less than the NCTE norms of 22000 sq.ft. The land area is 242834 sq.ft against the NCTE norms of 3000 sq.mtrs (32000 sq.ft).

Up-to-date original NEC along with its notarized English version is not submitted.

The institution is running two units of D.T.Ed however, details have been provided in respect of one set of FDRs only.

As per NCTE norms, the required staff for both the units is 1+6+5 = 12. The institution has to submit approved staff list as per norms.

Lecturer(s) in foundation course have not been appointed for both the unit of D.T.Ed.

Lecturer(s) in Fine Arts/Physical Director are also not available for both units.


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of APS0-1173 - D.T.Ed course.

88. APS03634 / APS03635

B.Ed / D.T.EdSri Vidya Lakshmi Teacher Training Institute, Vellore District

TN

Sri Vidhya Lakshmi Teacher Training Institute, Gudiyattam, Vellore District, Tamilnadu.

Sri Vidhya Lakshmi Teacher Training Institute, Gudiyattam, Vellore District, Tamilnadu submitted an application for granted of recognition to D.T.Ed course on 30.12.2004.

The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering D.T.Ed course with an intake of 50 students on 19.06.2007 & offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 08.05.2008 at Keelpudur Village, Chennangkuppam Post, Gudiyattam, Vellore District-632602, Tamilnadu with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution has submitted its written representation alongwith DD of Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee & relevant documents on 21.03.2011 for shifting of premises.

The SRC in its 203rd meeting held on 31st March & 1st April 2011 considered the


147


matter and decided to cause inspection of the institution. Accordingly the inspection of the institution was fixed between 16th-20th April 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 12.04.2011. Accordingly shifting inspection of the institution was conducted on 16.04.2011.

The SRC in its 205th meeting held on 18th-19th May 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice for both B.Ed & D.Ed course, under NCTE Act. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 07.07.2011. The institution has submitted its written representation on 25.07.2011.

The SRC in its 203rd meeting held on 31st March & 1st April 2011, considered the written reply and other relevant documents and decided to cause composite inspection at the premises for both D.T.Ed (APS03635) and B.Ed (APS03634) under NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit Demand Draft of Rs. 40,000/- inspection fee per course in favour of “The member Secretary, NCTE” Payable at Bangalore. Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was carried out on16.02.2012.

The SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30th-31st July,2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 24.08.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 27.09.2012.


Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted. Notarised English version of the certified copy land documents not submitted. As per notarized English version of land document, the land is in favour of an individual, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.


In the building plan submitted, total earamarked built up area for both B.Ed and D.T.Ed course is not mentioned.

In the building plan submitted, no demarcation for multipurpose hall is shown.

Sy.Nos. shown in building completion certificate is not tallying with other documents submitted.

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in joint account and in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given.


148


The institution has not submitted duly approved staff list as per NCTE norms for both B.Ed (APS03634) & D.T.Ed (APS03635) from affiliating body/University.

The institution has submitted staff list of D.T.Ed course (APS03635) and lectuers Mr. Ms. T. Arokia Marry Rani and Mr. A. Ragupathy are not approved by the DTERT, Chennai.

Lectuer in fine arts is not qualified as per NCTE norms.

Lectuer (s) in Fine Arts/Physical Education are not included in staff profile and it is not clear whether they have been appointed for each course separately.

The institution has not submitted staff profile as per Annexure I, II & III.


89. APS01094B.Ed

Bell College of Education, Tuticorin District

TN

Bell College of Education, 1/9, K.V.K. Nagar, Tuticorin-628008, Tamilnadu.

Bell College of Education, 1/9, K.V.K. Nagar, Tuticorin-628008, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 31.12.2002. The institution was granted recognition on 24.04.2009 with an annual intake of 100 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dated 03.02.2012 has submitted documents and DD bearing no. 889487 dtd. 27.01.2012 for Rs. 40,100/- towards shifting of premises and had stated the following:-

“As per the norms of NCTE all the infrastructure and instructional facilities are fulfilled. Hence, we request you to give us the permission for shifting the premises as early as possible and oblige”.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th-10th May 2012 considered request of the institution vide letter dt. 03.02.2012 and all relevant documents and decided to cause shifting inspection at the new premises, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms under NCTE Act.

Further, committee decided to inform institution to pay Rs. 10000/- towards inspection fee, as it has been raised to 50000/- with effect from 01.04.2012.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 15.06.2012.


149


The SRC in its 230th meeting held on 16th-17th August, 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

1. Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted.

2. Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted. In the BCC submitted.

3. Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in favour of Society/college/institution in Joint account is not given.

4. As per VT report, the size of the multipurpose hall is only 1820 sq.ft. which is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.

5. As per building plan the size of the multipurpose hall is not shown. The The size of each class rooms, multipurpose hall, and other details are not mentioned in the VTR.

6. Of the Auditorium is also 135.61 sq.mtrs which is equal to 1459.7 sq.ft, and less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.

7. The affidavit dt.30.01.2012 is incomplete, it appears that the thir page of

the same has not been attached. Moreover, Sy.No. 134/5A is appearing twice in the affidavit, while the Sy.No. 134/5D has not been mentioned. Further, the total land area in questionnaire and affidavit is also little bit variance in reference to land documents.

8. Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

9. Original Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted. As per Photocopy of the encumbrance certificate, the land is in joint name of Trust and Mrs Einstein (Finance Trustee), which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

10. The staff profile of the institution is not counter signed by the Principal of Head of the Institution.

11. As per staff profile(s) the staff is getting consolidated salary in cash which is contrary to NCTE norms.

12. Testimonials of the staff have not been submitted to ascertain their percentage of marks in Post Graduation etc., and their eligibility.

13. As per VT report, CPF/PPF facility is not provided to Staff members.14. The institution has not appointed Lecturer in Fine Art(s) and percentage

of marks of Lecturer in Physical Education is not given so as to ascertain his eligibility.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 10.09.2012.

The vide its letter dated 15.10.2012 has stated that “ the Show Cause Notice received on 22.09.2012 at our office. As given in the notice the rectification are made and it is ready for submission. The land usage certificate was received from the Thasildar for the Educational Purpose and submitted to the council, But now you have asked for the same certificate from the Revenue Divisional Officer. So we have applied for the certificate to the RDO, Kovilpatti and he has also visited our college campus on 03.10.2012 and it is in process. The official delay for the certificate may take a month.


150


Hence within a month we will submit all the documents for your perusal along with the RDO certificate. The delay may be condoned”.

Till date the institution has not submitted any written representation to Show Cause Notice.




The committee considered the non-reply of the institution to the issue of show cause notice dt. 10.09.2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.Ed course.

90. SRCAPP827B.P.Ed

DNR College of Physical Education,

West Godavari District

AP

DNR College of Physical Education, Khasara No. 444, Plot No. 25-5-33, bhimavaram Village, Sivaraopeta Post Office, Bhimavaram Taluka & City, West Godavari District-534202, Andhra Pradesh

DNR College Association, Plot No. 25-5-33, Bhimavaram Village, Post Office & Taluka & City, West Godavari District-534202, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to DNR College of Physical Education, Khasara No. 444, Plot No. 25-5-33, bhimavaram Village, Sivaraopeta Post Office, Bhimavaram Taluka & City, West Godavari District-534202, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 5/10/2011 .

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 8/11/2011 followed by reminder on 14/12/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29/12/2012. The institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on 27/02/2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 220th Meeting held on 30th and 31st March 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 27.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly show Cause Notice was issued on 26.04.2012.

The institution has submitted its written representations on 05.05.2012.The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory and unconvincing.


151


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Southern Regional Committee in its 223 rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May,2012, decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.P.Ed course.


Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-386/2012 Appeal/8 th

Meeting-2012 dated 05.09.2012 states that ‘there was adequate ground to remand the case to SRC for further processing as per regulations. The appellant is directed to submit all the documents to SRC for necessary action.”

The institution has submitted a written representation on 10.09.2012, as per appeal order.

In pursuance to the Appellate Authority order dated 05.09.2012, the application is being processed

The SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th-28th September 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 05.09.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 02/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 21/11/2012.


The institution has submitted two building plans in different Sy.Nos. different site areas and built up area for proposed course or existing course is not mentioned clearly. The institution has to submit fresh building plan with all details in one blue print of the building plan.

The institution has submitted two building completion certificates in different Sy.Nos, from which it is not clear in which Sy.No. the institution is exactly running.

As per building completion certificate for Sy.No 446/5 and other, utilization of first floor is not clear.

In the building plan submitted, the size of the multipurpose hall is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.

As per on-line application, the Sy.No. given is 444, however, the institution is mentioning other Sy.Nos also now.

In the building plan submitted, the institution has not shown multipurpose play field, athletic track, gymnasium and hall for indoor games.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected


152


& based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Final Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not refused and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the refusal & rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

91. SRCAPP1768D.El.EdVignan


Karimnagar District

AP

Vignan College of Education, No.54, By Pass Road, Yellareddypet, Karimnagar, Andhra Pradesh-505303.

Vignan Educational Society, No. 54, By Pass Road, Yellareddypet, Karimnagar District-505303, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Vignan College of Education, Plot No.54, By pass Road, Yellareddypet, Karimnagar District, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course on 04/10/2011 (Hard copy) of two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 02/10/2011.



d. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

e. Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

f. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The institution had submitted on line applications on 02/10/2011. whereas as per direction of NCTE (HQ) the Registration for online submission for application for academic session 2012-13 shall be open from 01st August 2011 to 1st October, 2011 only.

The institution submitted on-line on 02/10/2011.

The above matter was placed before SRC in its 216th Meeting held on 11th and 12th

January 2012 to suggest suitable derection whether the application which was made online after the stipulated dated 01/10/2011 can be entertained or not. The SRC in its 216th Meeting held on 11th-12th January, 2012 considered the matter and decided to reject the application – SRC APP-1768 since the applications was filed on-line the cut-off date, 01/10/2011.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on F.No.SRCAPP1768(2012-13)/D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/37967 dated. 23/02/2012.


153


Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order No. F.No. 89-328/2012Appeal/7th

Meeting-2012 dated 17/08/2012 stating that “…the Council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for considering the reply of the institution and taking an appropriate decision”.

The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17/08/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 07/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 26/11/2012, which is as follows:



Velangani Institute of Elementary

Training, Ranagreddi

DistrictAP

Velangani Institute of Elementary Training, Sy.No.237, Bogaram, Kesara, Hyderabad, Rangireddi District, Andhra Pradesh- 501 101.

Holy Trinity Educational Society, Sy.No.237, Bogaram, Kesara, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Velangani Institute of Elementary Training , Sy.no. 237, Bogaram, Kesara, Hyderabad, Rangireddi, Andhra Pradesh- 501 101 for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 05.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 09.11.2011/22.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 3012.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 28.02.2012The SRC in its 220th meeting held on 30th-31st March 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 28.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.


The SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May 2012 considered the matter and advised the SRO to prepare detailed agenda and put up the file in the next SRC’s meeting.In the meantime the institution has submitted the written representation dated 16.07.2012 stating:

“Based on Decisions of 226th meeting dt. 09th – 10th July 2012 from website, the three colleges namely SRCAPP1334, SRCAPP1338 & SRCAPP1339 were applied for new/additional intake in existing college for D.El.Ed course were rejected by referring Regulations 8 under the sub (2) and (3). Based on your letters


154


cited above we would like to withdraw following two applications:

1. HITS Institute of Educational Training (Elementary) – Application No. SRCAPP1334, Sy. No. 95A, Yenkepally (V), Pudur (M), R.R.Dist., A.P.

2. Holy Trinity Institute of Educational Training (elementary) – Application No..- SRCAPP1338 (AI), Sy. No. 238, Bogaram(V), Keesara (M), R.R.Dist., A.P.

We request you to conduct inspection for Velangini Institute of Elementary Training, Application No. SRCAPP1339. Hence we request you to conduct inspection for above mentioned college for the issue of LOI”.

The matter regarding these three institutions (SRCAPP1339, SRCAPP1334 & SRCAPP1338) was placed in 226th SRC meeting which was held on 09th – 10th July 2012. The committee has already decided to Reject and Refuse all the three applications.

The SRC in its 228th Meeting held on 24th – 25th July 2012, considered the matter and noted that the D.El.Ed (SRCAPP1339) course was already refused and rejected in 226th SRC meeting held on 09-10th of July, 2012, hence, the earlier decision of refusing and rejecting of the said course is reconfirmed.

Accordingly Rejection order was issued to the institution on 10.08.212.

Aggrieved by the order of SRC, the institution has approached to Hon’ble High Court in W.P.No.25563/2012.

Now, the Hon’ble High Court has passed an order dated 17.08.2012 vide W.P.No. 25563 of 2012 reads as hereunder:

“….respondent No. 2 (SRC NCTE) is directed to reconsider the petitioners’ application for establishment of a D.El.Ed college for the academic year 2012-13, take a decision afresh and communicate the same to the petitioners within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.”

The SRC in its 232nd meeting held on 29th –31st August 2012 considered the Hon’ble High Court order dt. 17/08/2012 and decided to process further in Next SRC meeting

Further, the committee advised SRO to file an appeal and write to advocate for 2012-2013 is not possible and since it is not implementable and to file the affidavit for session 2013-2014.

Accordingly, the application is processed:-

The committee considered the matter and as per the request of the institution the D.El.Ed course (SRCAPP1338) & (SRCAPP1334) is permitted to withdraw, as the said courses were applied along with another course at the same time for the session 2012-2013, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

Further, with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course (SRCAPP1338) & (SRCAPP1334), since the institution has applied for three courses


155


at a time i.e, SRCAPP1338, SRCAPP1334 & SRCAPP1339 – D.El.Ed courses, the management/institution can apply for one course at a time as per Regulations.

Further,

The SRC in its 234th meeting held on 17th-18th October, 2012 considered the Hon’ble High Court order dt. 17/08/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 16.11.2012. The institution submitted its reply on 04.12.2012.


Original Building Completion Certificate is not submitted. Photocopy of Building completion certificate first page 1 not signed by the approving authority.

As per sale deed, the land was registered on 14.11.2000. However,, as per encumbrance certificate dt. 14.02.2012 the land was mortgaged with UCO Bank on11.12.2008, which is not permissible as per 8 (7) (i) of extant NCTE regulation.

Updated Encumbrance Certificate is required.




Pushpavathi College of Education,

Guntur District

AP

Pushpavathi College of Education, Plot/Khasara No. 490/A, NRT-CH P Road, Kanaparru Village and Post, Nadendla Taluk, Kanaparru City, Guntur District- 522549, Andhra Pradesh

Pushpavathi Educational Society, Plot No. 490/A, NRT-CH P Road, Kanaparru Village and Post, Nadendla Taluk, Kanaparru City, Guntur District- 522549, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Pushpavathi College of Education, Plot/Khasara No. 490/A, NRT-CH P Road, Kanaparru Village and Post, Nadendla Taluk, Kanaparru City, Guntur District- 522549, Andhra Pradesh for D.EL.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical copy received on 04.10.2011

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 08.11.2011 followed by reminder on 22.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011 and the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 07.02.12

The SRC in its 218th meeting held on 28th February 2012 considered the reply of the


156


institution dt. 07.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. In the building plan submitted, Sy.No. 490 is not matching with land document.

2. In the building plan submitted, Sy.No. 490/4 is not matching with building plan and land document.

3. In the Land usage certificate, Sy.NO. 490/A is not matching with Land document, Building plan & building completion certificate.

4. It is observed from the records that Survey numbers, Door No. are same for two or more different societies, who have submitted land document which is found registered on the same day. The land documents of SRCAPP-1269 & 1188 are one and the same.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 22/03/2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 03/04/2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09-10 may 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 03.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 09.06.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 12.06.2012


Building Completion certificate is not approved by the competent authority.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Southern Regional Committee in its 224th meeting held on 14th – 17th June 2012 decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide F.No.SRCAPP1269 /D.EI.Ed/ AP/2012-2013/44975 dated 10/07/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-403/2012 Appeal/8 th

Meeting-2012 dated 05.09.2012 states that ‘the council concluded that the appeal deserved to accepted and the matter remanded to SRC for further processing of the application as per Regulations.”

The matter is placed before SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th-28th September 2012, considered the matter decided to process and put up.

NCTE Hqtrs order dt. 18.09.2012 stated as “the council, taking into account all aspects of the matter including the submission of a building completion certificate issued by the Executive Engineer, Public Works Deptt, concluded that the appeal deserved to be accepted and the matter remanded to the SRC for further processing of the application as per Regulations”.


157


The SRC in its 234th meeting held on 17th-18th October 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 05-09-2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) OF NCTE Act, for the following:

1. As per building plan submitted, total built up area given as 1566.2 sq.mtrs, whereas, as per building completion certificate it is given as 19092.56 sq.ft, both are not matching.

2. Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted.

3. As per size of the multipurpose hall is only 113.52 sq.mtrs, which is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 19.11.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 06.12.2012.


94. SRCAPP975D.El.EdChenna Keshava

College of Education, Rangareddi

DistrictAP

Chenna Keshava College of Education, Plot No. 43/AA, Burugupally Village, Vikarabad Post and Taluk, Rangareddi District – 501101, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Chenna Keshava Educational Society, Plot No. 4-5-2, Alibagh Street, Vikarabad Post and Taluk, Rangareddi District - 501101, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Chenna Keshava College of Education, Plot No. 43/AA, Burugupally Village, Vikarabad Post and Taluk, Rangareddi District – 501101, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 18.10.2011/ 15.12.2012 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011. The institution has not submitted reply to the deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days.As per sub-clause (1) of Clause 7 of NCTE Regulation 2009, the applicant institution is required to submit deficiencies to the Southern Regional Committee Office within 60 days from the date of receipt of communication of deficiencies, failing which the application will be treated as rejected and closed, no extension to time will be granted and any submission received after 60 days will be treated as invalid and not entertained.The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012 considered the matter as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7 (1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP975/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/41888 dated 30.05.2012.The 335/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting- 2012 dated 18.09.2012 has stated as follows:


158


“ the Council conclude that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC with a direction to process the application and to take the further decision thereafter.

The council hereby remands back the case of Chenna Keshava College of Education, Plot No. 43/AA, Burugupally Village, Vikarabad Post and Taluk, Rangareddi District – 501101, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.

In obedience to the Appellate authority order dated 24.09.2012, the SRC in its 233 rd

meeting held on 26th –28th September 2012 decided to process & put up the application.

Accordingly, the application is being processedThe SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17th – 18th October 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 24.09.2012 to the deficiency letter and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

1) In the building plan submitted, Sy.No. and land area & built up area is not mentioned.

2) In the building completion certificate and land usage certificate sy.No. 43/A/2 & 43/A/1 is mentioned, which are not tallying with land document, building plan submitted.

3) Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted.

4) Original Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

5) The management is running “Srinivasa Pharmaceutical Institute” in the same building/premises where the proposed course is located, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 19.11.2012.Now the institution has submitted its written representation dt. 20.11.2012 received in the office of SRC on 21.11.2012 as follows:.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.21.11.2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


Dwaraka College of

Elementary Teacher

Education, Mahbubnagar

DistrictAP

Dwaraka College of Elementary Teacher Education, No. 374 & 375, Singaram Village, Narayanpet Post & Taluk, Mahbubnagar District-5092010, Andhra Pradesh

Dwaraka Educational Society, No. 4-6-40/41, Gopalpet Street, Narayanpet Village, Post & Taluk, Mahbubnagar District-509210, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Dwaraka College of Elementary Teacher Education, No. 374 & 375, Singaram Village, Narayanpet Post & Taluk, Mahbubnagar District-5092010, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 30/09/2011.



159


Government for recommendation on 03/11/2011 followed by reminder on 07/12/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 28/12/2011. The institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on 23/02/2012.

The SRC in its 219th meeting held on 15th – 16th March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 23.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue Show cause Notice.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 04.04.2012. The institution submits its written representation on 26.04.2012. The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the stipulated time of 21 days.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th 10th May 2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 26/04/2012, i.e., after 22 (Twenty two) days from the date of issue of show cause notice letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 14(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly Rejection order was issued to the institution on 15.06.2012.

The institution was preferred to appeal at NCTE, Hqtr, New Delhi. The original file was sent to the NCTE, Hqtr, New Delhi on 06.08.2012.

Original file received from NCTE, Hqtr on 05.09.2012 as Stated as follows:-

After perusal of the documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, and after considering the oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the council concluded that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the case to the SRC for consideration of show cause notice reply and for taking further decision thereafter.

Now therefore, the council hereby remands back the case of Dwaraka College of Elementary Teacher Education, Mahabub Nagar, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC NCTE for necessary action as indicated above.

The institution submits relevant document dt. 26.04.2012 as per requirement of above the grounds

The SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th-28th September 2012, considered the Appellate authority order dt. 05/09/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

The land documents registered on 04.11.2011 is after making of application on-line, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

In the meanwhile, the institution has submitted its written representation on 17.10.2012 (with reference to SRC’s website notification).

The committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 17.10.2012 and decided to further process.

96. SRCAPP1332 Sharada D.Ed College, Plot/Khasara No.8, Hanwada Village, Post and Taluk,


160


D.El.EdSharada D.Ed

College, Mahabubnaga

r DistrictAP

Mahabubnagar District - 509334, Andhra Pradesh.

Sharada Educational Society, Plot No. 8. Hanwada Village and Post Office, Hanwada City and Taluk, Mahabubnagar District – 509001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sharada D.Ed College, Plot/Khasara No.8, Hanwada Village, Post and Taluk, Mahabubnagar District - 509334, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 28.10.2011/15.12.2011(Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 23.02.2012.

The SRC in its 220th Meeting held on 30th – 31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 23.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.



1. Land documents are registered on 01.12.2011 i.e, after submitting on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulations of 2009.

2. The management has admitted in its reply received by SRC on 08.05.2012 that they could not register the land before application submission & registered land on 01.12.2011 and other documents like land usage certificate, building completion certificate, encumbrance certificate etc. also indicate the transaction after the date of Registration 01.12.2011.


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May 2012, decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009 to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide no. F.No.SRCAPP1332/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/43287 dated 29.06.2012.The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide no. F.No. 89-381/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting –2012 dated 18.09.2012 has stated as follows:

“ the application of the institution be processed by the SRC in accordance with the extant Regulations, relaxed by the NCTE Committee with regard to the date of the registration of the land documents. The council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC with a direction to process the application and to take the further decision thereafter.

The council hereby remands back the case of Sharada D.Ed College, Plot/Khasara No.8, Hanwada Village, Post and Taluk, Mahabubnagar District – 509334, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.

In obedience to the Appellate authority order dated 24.09.2012, the SRC in its 233rd

meeting held on 26th –28th September 2012 decided to process the application.

Accordingly, the application is being processed


161


The SRC in its 234th meeting held on 17th –18th October 2012 considered the Appellate authority order dt. 24-09-2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

As per notarized English version of the land document submitted, the land is in favour of joint name, I.e, it is in applicant society’s name and also with some individual name viz; Shri R.Sanjeeva Reddy, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

In the building plan submitted, proposed institution’s name is not mentioned.

As per affidavit submitted, total built up area mentioned as 1645 sq.mtrs, whereas, in building completion certificate it is given as 23484 sq.ft.

Accordingly show cause notice was issued to the institution on 16.11.2012. The institution has replied to the show cause notice on 26.11.2012.

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by the committee and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under, ( and to lodge criminal complaint against the society for point No. 1)

The institution has not submitted any written clarification with regard to joint ownership of the land. The institution vide letter dt. 26.11.2012 has simply submitted land documents alongwith another notarized English version showing the land in the name of applicant society only. However, the land documents which were submitted on 23/02/2012 in reply to deficiency letter dt. 29.12.2011, clearly shows the land is in joint name viz., (i) Sharadha Educational Society & (ii) R. Sanjeev Reddy. On thorough observation of the land documents submitted on both occasion, it is noted that the name of an individual has been removed from the land documents submitted later intentionally while taking Xerox of the same and produced fabricated documents to SRC. This is a clear-cut case of cheating and concealment of facts.

In the building plan, multipurpose hall is not shown. The area of one assembly hall is 104 sq.mtrs against the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.

No clarification has been given regarding mentioning 1645 sq.mtrs built up area in the earlier affidavit dt. 07.01.2012.



97. APS00354B.Ed

Intel Institute of Teacher Education, Anantapur

DistrictAP

Intel Institute of Teacher Training, INTEL Campus, Kalyandurg Road, Akkampalli Cross, Ananthapur District - 515 004, Andhra Pradesh.

Intel Educational Society, D.No. 2/200, 3rd Road, New town, Ananthpur – 515004, Andhra Pradesh was submitted an application for grant of recognition to Intel Institute of Teacher Training, INTEL Campus, Kalyandurg Road, Akkampalli Cross, Ananthapur District - 515 004, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed course on 31.12.2001.

Recognition was granted to the institution vide SRC order dated 04.04.2003 (as per recognition order) with condition to shift the institution to permanent premises.

The matter was placed in 178th meeting of SRC held on 13th – 14th July, 2010 where in the committee observed from the records of the institutions were accorded recognition in the rented premises and they had not yet shifted to the permanent premises/building. In view of non-shifting of colleges to permanent building the committee decided to issue Show cause Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act and obtain shifting fees and other document for causing


162


inspection for shifting.

As per the direction of Regional Committee Shoe Cause Notice was issued with request to submit following document with in 21 days of receipt of letter.

1) Demand Draft of Rs.40000/- towards inspection fee in favour of “The Member Secretary, NCTE” payable at Bangalore should be submitted.

2) Land document of new building/location for having own land in the name of the Institution/Society/Trust.

3) Building plan of the new building duly approved by the Government authority.4) Building Completion Certificate from the Government authority in the Prescribed format

( Format enclosed ) 5) Land usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities stating that the land is

exclusively permitted / sanctioned for educational Purposes only should be submitted.6) Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government should be submitted.7) Fixed Deposits Receipts of Rs. 5 Lakhs Kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with SRC in

Nationalized Bank for a period of 5 years towards Endowment fund in ORIGINAL should be submitted.

8) Fixed Deposits Receipts of Rs. 3 Lakhs Kept in JOINT ACCOUNT with SRC in Nationalized Bank for a period of 5 years towards Reserve funds in ORIGINAL should be submitted.

9) Certificate of registration / Bye-law of the Society/Trust should be submitted.10) The affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper In the prescribed format with Notary attestation

should be submitted regarding land and building.

As per the perusal of the file the institution did not shifted to permanent premises as per norms and standards and conditions mentioned in recognition order dated 04.04.2003 and not communicated the shifting of premises to the SRC and not paid the prescribed fees for shifting premises. SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd – 23rd February, 2011 consideration the matter and decided to Withdraw he recognition to Intel Educational Society, D.No. 2/200, 3 rd Road, New town, Ananthpur – 515004, Andhra Pradesh which fail to shift to permanent premises within prescribed time limit of three years as per the norms, and also they had failed to respond to Show Cause Notice.

Accordingly the application of Intel Educational Society, D.No. 2/200, 3rd Road, New town, Ananthpur – 515004Andhra Pradesh was rejected vide order 07.04.2011. The Institution preferred for go to appeal at NCTE Hqrs. Where in NCTE Hqr. has directed in order dated 03.08.2011 as under:“After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, VT report and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and set aside SRC’s order dated 07.04.2011 with a direction to the SRC to trace the reply of the institution and if not available, obtain a copy of the same with all relevant document including fee or inspection from the appellant and take further action thereafter. Accordingly, the appeal is accepted and the order of the SRC dated 07.04.2011 is reversed”. The SRC Considered the Council direction Dt. 03.08.2011 and decided to direct the institution to submit a copy of reply supposed to have submitted to the show cause notice issued by SRC on 07.08.2009, with all relevant documents including fee for inspection from the institution to take further action.

Accordingly a letter was issued to the institution and now the institution has submitted its reply on 24.10.2011.

The Committee in its 214th meeting held on 28th Nov 2011 considered the reply of the institution dt. 29.07.2011 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for the following:

1) The institution has not submitted the original Affidavit in Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the


163


prescribed format with notary attestation.2) In the Affidavit, point no. 8 applicant’s signature is missing.3) As per the Affidavit the status of Land is not clear.4) Building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not

submitted.5) Land usage certificate from the concerned Government authority stating that the land is

exclusively permitted/sanctioned for Educational purposes only is not submitted.6) Non-encumbrance certificate submitted is not legible, and the latest encumbrance

certificate is to be submitted.

Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on 30.01.2012.Now, the institution has submitted its written representation dt. 24.02.2012 received in the office of SRC on 27.02.2012.The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012, considered the written reply of the institution vide letter dt. 11.09.2012 (with reference to the on-line) and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has not submitted latest approved staff list as per NCTE norms from the affiliating body/University.

As per the direction of SRC, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012 and the institution has submitted its reply vide its letter dt. 15.11.2012 on 19.11.2012 as follows:

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 15.11.2012 and 19.11.2012, and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has not submitted original staff approval list from affiliating body/University.

The institution has not appointed Fine Arts and Physical Teacher as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

The institution has not appointed Lecturer in foundation course.

As per NCTE rules and Regulations 2009, the Principal needs to have Ph.D in education with 10 years os experience.


Consideration of MISC., Cases (Volume- 03)

98. APS09534B.Ed

Periyar

Periyar Maniammal University, Department of Education School of Humanities Universities, Science & Management, Periyar Nagar, Vallam,


164


Maniammal University,

Department of Education

School of Humanities Universities,

Thanjavur District

TN

Thanjavur-613403, TamilnaduPeriyar Maniammal University, Department of Education School of Humanities Universities, Science & Management, Periyar Nagar, Vallam, Thanjavur-613403, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 17.06.2008. The institution was granted recognition on 25.09.2009 with an annual intake of 100 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dated 20.12.2011 submitted its proposal for change of premises for the programme within the University campus. Accordingly, a letter sent to the institution seeking for Rs. 40,000/- towards change of premises along with documents on 04.01.2012.

The institution vide its letter dtd. 08.02.2012 submitted required documents and DD bearing no. 644257 dtd. 25.01.2012 for Rs. 40,000/- towards change of premises fee on 08.02.2012.

The NCTE, Hqrs vide letter dtd. 27.02.2012 had forwarded a complaint dtd. 16.01.2012 which was received against the institution from Dr. B. Ramaswamy, Mayur Vihar, Delhi-110091. NCTE, Hqrs has stated that “some allegations have been made by complainant against the aforesaid institution. You are, therefore, requested to examine the matter and to take necessary action against the institution as per the NCTE Act, 1993, by placing the complaint before the Regional Committee and to furnish action taken to NCTE, Hqrs., New Delhi within a month”.

The SRC in its 219th meeting held on 15th-16th March, 2012 considered the matter and decided to call for Affidavit from the complainant. Also the committee decided to call for comments from the institution after receiving the affidavit from the complainant.

Accordingly, a letter was sent to the complainant on 13.04.2012. The complainant has not submitted any written representation/affidavit till date.

The institution has submitted shifting inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/- on 08.02.2012. Further, as per NCTE notification dated 13.09.2011, the institution is required to submit another Rs. 10,000/- (ten thousand) as shifting fee as per norms.Further, the NCTE Hqrs has forwarded a complaint against the institution on 06.12.2012 from Dr. B.Ramaswamy, Mayur Vihar, Delhi-110091 and has requested to take necessary action against the institution as per the NCTE Act, 1993, by placing the complaint before the Regional Committee.

The Committee considered the complaint matter and reply of the institution dt. 08-02/2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause ins pection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms, after collecting balance of inspection fee of Rs. 10000/- and instruct VT members to look into the specific allegations in the complaint.


165


99. SRCAPP564D.P.Ed

Bharathiar University, Coimbatore

DistrictTN

Bharathiar University, Plot No. 257815/76F, Maruthamalai Road, Coimbatore-641046, Tamilnadu.

Bharathiar University, Plot No. 257815/76F, Maruthamalai Road, Coimbatore-641046, Tamilnadu had applied for grant of recognition for D.P.Ed Course for two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 20.09.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 26.09.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 29.09.2011. A reminder letter was issued to the State Government on 14.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 14.10.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 14.12.2011.

The committee in its 216th meeting held on 11th-12th January 2012 considered the matter and observed that there is a distinction between Diploma and P.G. Diploma. Universities are not ordinarily expected to offer Dip. Courses. Clarification is to be sought from NCTE (HQ) on whether the application is to be rejected or to be processed further.

Further, the committee decided to seek clarification from UGC Regional Office in Bangalore, whether universities can offer Diploma courses and P.G. Diploma courses.

Accordingly, a letter was sent to the Member Secretary & University Grants Commission Regional Office on 06.03.2012.

A clarification letter has been received from NCTE (HQ) dt. 21.03.2012, which reads as under :

“The NCTE Act and Regulations do not prevent University from offering a Diploma course in teacher Education. SRC may take a decision with regard to the application of the university in accordance with position of law as it prevails.”

As per SRC decision, clarification has been asked from UGC. Regional office in Bangalore. The Regional Director UGC, Bangalore has sent a letter to the Joint Secretary, CPP II, UGC New Delhi, for clarification regarding Universities offering Diploma course. The committee considered the matter and decided to await for UGC clarification.

The committee in its 221st meeting held on 19th-20th April 2012 considered the matter and decided to await clarification from UGC Regional Office Bangalore.

Further, a reminder letter was issued to the UGC, New Delhi with a copy to office at Bangalore on 25.05.2012.

As the UGC has not offered any clarification in this regard, the matter was placed before SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30-31 July 2012 and SRC considered the matter and decided to Communicate NCTE decision/order which reads as under:

“The NCTE Act and Regulations do not prevent University from offering a Diploma course in teacher education. SRC may take a decision with regard to the


166


application of the University in accordance with position of law as it prevails”.

The SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30th-31st July,2012 considered the matter and decided to write to University for clarification. Accordingly, a letter was sent to the University on 08.10.2012. The University has submitted its clarification on 19.11.2012.

The committee considered the clarification from the University vide letter dt. 19.11.2012 and decided to request University to submit detailed curriculum of D.P.Ed course to NCTE through SRC as an Innovative Programme.

100. ------D.Ed

Johne College of Education,

Nalgonda District

AP

Johne College of Education, Suryapet, Nalgonda District, Andhra Pradesh.

An application was submitted by Johne College of Education, Suryapet, Nalgonda District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition for D.Ed course and that their application was not considered because of ban on opening of new colleges by the NCTE.

The institution had approached Hon’ble High court in W.P. No. 5256/11 in the matter of Solmanraju Educational Society Vs NCTE without approaching the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi U/S 18 of NCTE Act.

The Hon’ble High court has passed an order dated 21.04.2011 as under:

“It may be true the State Government as well the first respondent have reviewed the situation as to the necessity or otherwise of according permission to establish new colleges of education in the State in further and that the existing institutions are fond to be adequate. However, the right that is accrued to the petitioners on the basis of their application and the consideration there of by the first respondent cannot be taken away on account of the change of policy. It is settled principle of law that whenever an application is made, it must be considered and processed in accordance with the provisions of law or the policy that existed as on the date of presentation. Subsequent changes may apply to the applications that are made thereafter.

Hence, the writ petition is disposed of directing the first respondent to take necessary steps as contemplated in its communication dated 24-11-2009 and pass appropriate orders. There shall be no order as to costs”.

The Committee considered the matter and decided in 205th meeting held on 18th-19th May, 2011 to process the application for D.Ed course, only on submission of original application and related supporting documents within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

The institution has submitted reply on 16/05/2012 along with as follows:-

The Committee in its 223rd Meeting of SRC held on 29th – 31st May 2012, considered the matter and decided to process the application.

Mean while the institution has submitted two letters dt. 11.06.2012 and 21.06.2012 along with processing fees of Rs. 41000/- Vide DD No. 907024 dt. 14.05.2012.

The SRC in its 225th Meeting held on 25th – 27th June 2012, considered the matter and decided to process the file together along with the file of Seven Hills College


167


of Education Nalgonda District.As per the direction of SRC, Deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 23.07.2012 and the institution has not replied so far even after the expiry of stipulated period of 60 days.

The committee considered the matter, as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.Ed course.


S.R.M. D.Ed College,

Prakasam District

AP

S.R.M. D.Ed College, Khasara No. 564; 8651A1A2A1; 564, Plot No. 12-5-78, Kandukuru Village and Post, Kandukuru City and Taluk, Prakasam District – 523105, Andhra Pradesh

Muzammiel Educational and Cahritable Trust, Plot No. 11-2-15/3, Santosh Nagar Road, Kandukuru Village and Post, Kandukuru City and Taluk, Prakasam District – 523105, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to S.R.M. D.Ed College, Khasara No. 564; 8651A1A, 2A1; 564, Plot No. 12-5-78, Kandukuru Village and Post, Kandukuru City and Taluk, Prakasam District – 523105, Andhra Pradesh for D.EL.Ed Course of Two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 26.09.2011 and physical copy received on 26.09.2011.


The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 05.03.2012. Institution states Deficiency letter received on 07.01.2012.



The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th and 20th April 2012, considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 05.03.2012, i.e., after 72 (Seventy two) days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, the application of S.R.M. D.Ed College, Khasara No. 564; 8651A1A2A1; 564, Plot No. 12-5-78, Kandukuru Village and Post, Kandukuru City and Taluk, Prakasam District – 523105, Andhra Pradesh for permission to D.El.Ed course was rejected. Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution on 30.05.2012.



168


“the Council concluded that the appeal deserved to be accepted and the matter remanded to the SRC for further processing as per regulations.”

Meanwhile, the institution has submitted some other documents as on 04.09.2012.

The SRC considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17/08/2012 and the institutions reply vide letter dt. 04-09-2012, all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012. The institution has submitted the reply on 06.11.2012.

The SRC in its 235th meeting held on 20th-21st November 2012, decided to cause inspection.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 10th t to 13th

December 2012 and the same was intimated to the institution on 03.12.2012.

The institution has submitted its written representation received by SRC on 05.12.2012 requesting for postponement of inspection stated that “now my mother’s condition is not good. She is hospitalized. So I am not in the station. I am also in hospital to take care of her such a tedious possession, I am unable to co-operate and follow the visiting team. So please kindly postpone the inspection. Honourable Sir, my humbly request is in the month of January please appoint the visiting team for inspection.”

The Committee considered the letter from the institution dt.05.12.2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection in Jan, 2013, under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

102. APS00290B.Ed

Elim College of Education, East Godavari

DistrictAP

Elim College of Education, Amalapuram Revenue Division Church of Christ Campus, Janakipeta Street, Amalapuram East Godavari District-533201.

Elim College of Education, Amalapuram Revenue Division Church of Christ Campus, Janakipeta Street, Amalapuram East Godavari District-533201. Andhra Pradesh had submitted an application on 31.12.2001 to the Southern Regional committee of NCTE for grant of recognition for starting B.Ed course of one year from the academic session 2002-03 with an annual intake of 120 students.

The institution has been granted recognition by SRC NCTE on 03.03.2003 with an annual intake of 100 students with the condition that “ the institution shall shift to its own premises within three years from the date of recognition”. Consequent upon completion of three years the matter was pursued with the institution by way of sending a letter and calling details of land, building etc of permanent premises along with an inspection fee amounting to Rs 40000/-

The institution since has submitted the requisite fee of Rs 40000/- for shifting the premises from leased to permanent building in its letter dated 17.09.2007

Accordingly inspection of the institution was carried out on 30.03.2011


169


The SRC in its 205th Meeting held on 18th-19th May, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with Notary attestation is to be submitted.

The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer is not submitted.

Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational Purposes is to be submitted.

Fresh Non-Encumbrance certificate from the competent authority is not submitted.

Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.

Technology lab & Other labs/Physical Education needs to be strengthened.

Seating capacity in the library is only for 10 students, which is inadequate.

No journals are available in the library.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 30/06/2012.

The institution has not submitted reply to the show cause notice even after stipulated period of 30 days and till today.

Meantime, three Complaints against institution received on 29/06/2012, 18/07/2012, 17/09/2012 & 06/12/2012 with out address stated that “ the Elim College of Education, Amalapuram was formed and functioning since 2002-2003 to till date based on the orders issued by the competent authorities vide reference first to third cited. Having obtained certificate from the Government of Andhra Pradesh. Recognition form NCTE and affiliation from Andhra University the college “ ELIM COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, Amalapuram” stated functioning form the academic year 2002-2003 with and intake of 100 students. At the time of formation of college late Dhanaraj Bonthu the then secretary & correspondent has produced the necessary land documents for about five acres land and necessary equipment & infrastructure as per the NCTE Norms and Standards for Bachelor of education programme leading to Bachelor of Education (B.Ed) degree. Subsequently due to financial crisis the then secretary & correspondent sold the lands shown for B.Ed the required equipment of laboratory and furniture are also not sufficient to full fill the norms prescribed by the NCTE regarding infrastructure two RCC building were provided B.Ed purpose out of which one building was already sold out and the B.Ed classes are being continued in single building only and it is not sufficient and moreover the building is not approved by the Amalapuram Municipal corporation authorities except ground floor. The management committee is misguiding the inspection team every time by showing orphanage buildings and school buildings in the church of Christ campus which were in the same premsis. After the demise of Dr. Dhanaraju Bonthu i.e. on August 3rd 2011 Mr. Joseph Raju


170


Bonthu took charge as the secretary and correspondent for the Elim College of Education, Amalapuram and has submitted proposals for sanctioning of D.Ed (DIET) college in the same premises to the Director, NCTE, Bangalore even though there are mp required infrastructure and laboratory for B.Ed College.

1. Multipurpose hall with seating capacity of 200 and a dias (2000 sq.ft) 2. Library-cum-reading room(NIL)3. ICT Resource Centre(NIL)4. Psychology Resource Centre (NIL)5. Art and Craft Resource Centre (NIL)6. Health and Physical Education Resource Centre (NIL)7. Science and Mathematics Resource Centre (NIL)8. Principal’s Office(NIL)9. Staff Room (NIL)10. Administrative Office(NIL)11. Visitors Room(NIL)12. Girl’s Common Room(NIL)13. Seminar Room(NIL)14. Canteen(NIL)

I submit that the above facts are true and I am bringing to your kind notice to initiate suitable action as deemed fit by sending a special team of inspectors surprisingly and conducting an open enquiry by a special officer or by NCTE special team. I request an early action in this matter as a present batch has gone out and new batch will be coming after edcet-2012. If no action is taken by you in this matter then I will be forced to seek the court of law”.




The committee considered the non-reply of the institution to the issue of show cause notice dt. 30/06/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.Ed course.


171


Consideration of Table Agenda

102 SRCAPP920D.El.Ed

Adarsha Institute of Elementary Teacher Education, Mahabubnagar District

AP

Adarsha Institute of Elementary Teacher Education, Khasara No.454/e/1, 454/e/3, 454/e/4, Adarsha Hills Street, Narayanpet Village and Post Office, Narayanpet Taluk and City, Mahabubnagar District-509210, Andhra Pradesh

Adarsha Educational Society, Plot No.1-5-30/4, Adarsha Hills Street, Narayanpet Village and Post Office, Narayanpet Taluka and City, Mahabubnagar District-509210, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Adarsha Institute of Elementary Teacher Education, Khasara No.454/e/1, 454/e/3, 454/e/4, Adarsha Hills Street, Narayanpet Village and Post Office, Narayanpet Taluk and City, Mahabubnagar District-509210, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 05.10.2011.


172


The Application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 08.11.2011/22.12.2011 (Reminder).A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on SRC 29.12.2011

The institution has not submitted reply to the deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days and till date.

As per sub-clause (1) of Clause 7 of NCTE Regulation 2009, the applicant

institutions is required to submit deficiencies to the Southern Regional Committee Office Within 60 days from the date of receipt of communication of deficiencies, failing which the application will be treated as rejected and closed, no extension to time will be granted and any submission received after 60 days will be treated as invalid and not entertained. The SRC in its 221st meeting of SRC held on 19th – 20th April, 2012 has considered the matter, as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly rejection order was issued to the institution on 30.05.2012

The Appeal order was received from Hqtr on 17.08.2012 as follows :-

The council hereby remand back the case of Adarsha Institute of Teacher Education, warangal, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE for the necessary action as indicated above.

The institution has submitted the documents on 24.09.2012.

The Committee duly considered the Appellate authority order dt. 17/08/2012 and reply of the insituttion to the show cause notice and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

Certified copy of the land documents from sub-registrar is not submitted.

The earmarked land area is 2123.5 sq.mtrs, which is less than the requirement of 2500 sq.mtrs as per NCTE Regulations.


The extent of land as per land documents is 2123.50 sq.mtrs and as per encumbrance certificate and affidavit submitted not matching.

Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted. In the BCC submitted, column No. 9 is not duly filled up for course/college name.



173



As per of SRC-223rd meeting decision refusal and rejection order issued on 30.10.2012. (copy enclosed)

The institution has approached to Hon’ble High Court in writ petition No. 34632/2012 in the matter of Adarsha Educational Society VS NCTE and another. The Hon’ble High Court has passed an order dated 06.12.2012 by this office on 14.12.2012 as under:-

“the Court takes exception to the manner to which the Southern Regional Committee (SRC) for the National Council for Teacher Education has processed the application of the petitioner. The appellate authority allowed the appeal on 18-09-2012 and remanded the matter to the SRC. However a wrong date was mentioned so much so the name of the institution was also wrongly mentioned as though it is from Warangal.

The appellate authority directed the SRC to consider the aspect of whether there is any delay in submission of the title deeds. The SRC proceeds as though it is perusing application for the first time and passed an order, which shocks the conscience of the Court.

One week time is granted to the SRC to take corrective steps.

The southern Regional Committee in its 236th meeting held on 16-18th Dec, 2012 considered the matter and all the relevant documentary evidences decided to Re-issue show cause notice to correct address in Mahabubnagar of the applicant institution, and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 15 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Copies of registered land documents for Sy.Nos. 454/E/1 & 454/E/4 duly certified by sub-registrar are not submitted as required under sub-regulation 7 (1) (iv) of the extant NCTE regulations 2009 as amended from time to time.

Original approved building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted.The institution has submitted Xerox copy of building plan with rectification in built up area by hand as 1788.54 sq.mtrs. The built up area required for both B.Ed and D.Ed course(s) together in the same building/premises should be 3000 sq.mtrs., however, the institution has not shown proper ear-markation for both the courses.

Moreover, in the Xerox copy of building plan, a seminar hall measuring 22.85X8.25 Sq. Mrs. at second floor is shown as “Mortgage area” which is not permissible as per sub regulation 8 (7) (ii) of the extant regulation 2009.

Original building completion certificate from competent civil authority is not submitted. In the copy of BCC submitted, column No. 9 is not duly filled up for course/college name.


174


As per encumbrance certificates submitted by the institution, the survey numbers are 454/C/1 & 454/C/4, whereas in other documents, Sy.Nos. are 454/E/1 & 454/E/4. It needs clarification.



175

Documents

Deferred items of 235th meeting - SRC - National Council …srcncte.in/Decisions and Minutes 2010-13/Minutes/Minutes... · Web viewNo Code Course Name of the Institution State Remarks