7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

1/122

Pfplrt lg tjf

Hfgfnsf [kafnkf @ldrh Xdsm Glrkf ln

Hfgfnsf Antfccaefnkf

Kluntfransurefnky (KLAN)

ntfccaefnkf, [urvfaccdnkf, dnh

fklnndassdnkf (A[P) Lpfrdtalns

Gf`rudry 024

Lggakf lg tjf Vnhfr [fkrftdry lg Hfgfnsf

lr Dkquasataln, Xfkjnlcley dnh Cleastaks

Udsjanetln, H.K. 02;24-;482

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

2/122

XjasrfplrtasdprlhuktlgtjfHfgfnsf[kafnkf@ldrh(H[@).XjfH[@asdGfhfrdcDhvaslry

Kliiattff fstd`casjfh tl prlvahf anhfpfnhfnt dhvakf tl tjf [fkrftdry lg Hfgfnsf.

[tdtfifnts, lpanalns, klnkcusalns, dnh rfkliifnhdtalns an tjas rfplrt hl nlt nfkfssdracy

rfprfsfnttjflggakadcplsatalnlgtjfHfpdrtifntlgHfgfnsf.

Xjf H[@ Dhvaslry Erlup ln Hfgfnsf Antfccaefnkf Xdsm Glrkf ln Kluntfr Ansurefnky

(KLAN) Antfccaefnkf, [urvfaccdnkf dnh Pfklnndassdnkf (A[P) Lpfrdtalns klipcftfh ats

anglridtalnedtjfraneanOdnudry0244.

XjasrfplrtasVNKCD[[AGAFHdnhrfcfdsd`cftltjfpu`cak.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

3/122

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

4/122

LGGAKF LG XJF [FKPFXDPQ LG HFGFN[F;482 HFGFN[F RFNXDELN

UD[JANEXLN, HK 02;24;482

Gf`rudry0;,0244

IFILPDNHVIGLPXJFKJDAPIDN,HFGFN[F[KAFNKF@LDPH

[V@OFKX? GandcPfplrtlgtjfHfgfnsf[kafnkf@ldrh(H[@)XdsmGlrkflnHfgfnsf

Antfccaefnkf Kluntfransurefnky (KLAN) Antfccaefnkf, [urvfaccdnkf, dnh

Pfklnndassdnkf(A[P)Lpfrdtalns

Dttdkjfh as tjf gandc rfplrt lg tjf H[@ Xdsm Glrkf ln Hfgfnsf Antfccaefnkf,

Kluntfransurefnky (KLAN) Antfccaefnkf, [urvfaccdnkf, dnh Pfklnndassdnkf (A[P)

Lpfrdtalns

stuhy.

Xjf

Xdsm

Glrkf

wds

dsmfh

tl

ahfntagy

jlw

Hfpdrtifnt

lg

Hfgfnsf

(HlH) antfccaefnkf kdn ilst fggfktavfcy supplrt KLAN lpfrdtalns. Xjf prankapdc

l`ofktavf lg tjf Xfris lg Pfgfrfnkf wds tl angcufnkf anvfstifnt hfkasalns `y

rfkliifnhane dpprlpradtf antfccaefnkf kdpd`acatafs tl dssfss ansurefnkafs,

unhfrstdnh d plpucdtaln an tjfar fnvarlnifnt, dnh supplrt KLAN lpfrdtalns. Xl

drravf dt tjf prankapdc l`ofktavf tjf Xfris lg Pfgfrfnkf (XLP) rfqufstfh tjf Xdsm

Glrkf dhhrfss gavf drfds tl ankcuhf tjf hfvfclpane rlcf lg HlH A[P an KLAN

lpfrdtalns, tl ankcuhf rfcfvdnt kustlifrs dnh tjfar rfspfktavf rfquarfifnts=

dcclkdtaln lg HlH A[P rfslurkfs tl supplrt KLAN kdpd`acatafs= kjdnefs tl tjf A[P

prlkfss tl aiprlvfsupplrt tlKLAN= aiifhadtf aiprlvfifnts annftwlrmdeacaty

dnh anglridtaln sjdrane dkrlss iassaln pdrtnfrs klnhuktane KLAN= dnh fifreanetfkjnlcleafsdnhiftjlhlcleafscamfcytlprlvahftjfjaejfstpdylgg.

Xl rfsplnh tl tjf XLP, tjf Xdsm Glrkf rfvafwfh fxastane catfrdturf dnh ift watj

ilrftjdn422sfnalr dnhiahcfvfclggakadcsdnhrfprfsfntdtavfsgrlidkrlssHlH,

tjf Antfccaefnkf Kliiunaty (AK), anhustry, nlnprlgat kliiunaty, dnh dkdhfiad

anvlcvfh an arrfeucdr wdrgdrf, KLAN, A[P, dnh rfcdtfh dktavatafs. Xjf Xdsm Glrkf

fxdianfhtjfiuctapjdsfKLANkjdccfnef,wjakjankcuhfstjfnffhtlklntanuftl

supplrt KLAN lpfrdtalns an Dgejdnastdn= prfpdrf glr fifreane dnh urefnt KLAN

A[P lpfrdtalns tjdt wacc jdvf tl`f ift usane kurrfnt rfslurkfs= dnh`uachane d

kdpd`acatytlhfdcwatjclnetfriKLANskfndralsusanenfwklnkfptslglpfrdtalns

(KLNLR[)dnhrfslurkfs.

@dsfhlnatsanvfstaedtalntjfXdsmGlrkfdrravfhdttjfglcclwanel`sfrvdtalns?

HlHcdkmsdkliilnunhfrstdnhanelgKLAN

HlHjdsdssuifhrfsplnsa`acatyglrKLANA[P`yhfgduct

HFGFN[F [KAFNKF

@LDPH

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

5/122

HlHA[Pasndrrlwcyantfrprftfhtlifdntfkjnakdcantfccaefnkfklccfktaln`y

dar`lrnfpcdtglris

A[P kdpd`acatafs jdvf nlt`ffn dppcafh fggfktavfcy dedanst KLAN lpfrdtalns

tjdthfdcwatjplpucdtalnsanpdrt`fkdusfdkliprfjfnsavfsftlgantfccaefnkf

rfquarfifntsglrKLANhlfsnltfxast

XjfV.[.Elvfrnifntasnltanvfstanedhfqudtfcyantjfhfvfclpifntlgslkadc

dnh`fjdvalrdcskafnkfanglridtalntjdtaskratakdccyaiplrtdnttlKLAN

A[PsupplrtglrKLANaskurrfntcy`fanelvfrsjdhlwfh`ykluntfrtfrrlrasi

dnhglrkfprltfktalnrfquarfifnts

AnkrfdsanetjfglkuslgA[PglrKLANlnankapafntansurefnkafswluchprlvahf

ilrf wjlcflgelvfrnifnt lptalns dnh rfhukf tjf nffh glr idolr

kliiatifntlgiacatdryglrkfs

Nfw [&X slcutalns iust dhhrfss tjf krasas an prlkfssane, fxpclatdtaln, dnhhassfiandtaln(RFH)dnhdsslkadtfhkliiunakdtalnskdusfh`ytjfhfcueflg

sfnslrhdtd

Nfwdnhfifreanetfkjnlcleafsdnhtfkjnaqufskdn`ffipclyfhtlaiprlvf

lurunhfrstdnhanelgKLANfnvarlnifnts

Xjf dttdkjfh rfplrt prlvahfs tjf rdtalndcf glr tjf Xdsm Glrkfs ganhanes dnh

rfkliifnhdtalns,rfsplnhstlgavfspfkagakXLPtdsms,dnhnltfssu`stdntadcplcaky

euahdnkf ln dspfkts lg KLAN dnh A[P ds wfcc ds nuifrlus dnh anklnsastfnt

hfganatalnslgmfytfrisdsslkadtfhwatjtjfstuhy.

Uf dpprfkadtf tjf klntra`utalns idhf`y tjf Hfpdrtifnt lg Hfgfnsf, Antfccaefnkf

Kliiunaty, anhustry, dnh dkdhfiad wjl tllm tjf taif tl prlvahf us watj tjfar

mnlwcfhef dnh fxpfrtasf= tjf ifi`frs lg tjas stuhy= tjf Fxfkutavf [fkrftdry= tjf

H[@[fkrftdradtdnhatsiacatdrydssastdnt.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

6/122

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

7/122

XD@CFLGKLNXFNX[ a

XD@CFLGKLNXFNX[FZFKVXAWF [VIIDPQ?XD[MANE DNH MFQ GANHANE[..............................................................av4. ANXPLHVKXALN,XD[MANE,DNH[XVHQ[XPVKXVPF.....................................................440. HFGANANEKLANDNHA[P............................................................................................. 02;. XLPXD[M[..................................................................................................................... 06

;.4. XLPXD[M4? UJDXA[XJFHFWFCLRANEPLCFLGHLHA[PANKLANLRFPDXALN[=UJLDPFXJFKV[XLIFP[DNHUJDXDPFXJFPFTVAPFIFNX[

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

8/122

aa KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

;.6. XLPXD[M6? UJDXFIFPEANEXFKJNLCLEAF[DNHIFXJLHLCLEAF[,KLI@ANDXALN[LG[FN[LP[,DNHANWF[XIFNX[ANANGLPIDXALNGV[ALNDNHDNDCQ[A[

DPFCAMFCQXLRPLWAHFXJFJAEJF[XRDQLGG

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

9/122

XD@CFLGKLNXFNX[ aaa

CA[XLGGAEVPF[DNHXD@CF[

GAEVPF4.XLPDNHHFPAWFHXD[M[................................................................................. 40GAEVPF0.[XVHQKLNXFZXXULAIRFPDXAWF[..................................................................46GAEVPF;.RL[[A@CFKLANKJDCCFNEF[........................................................................... 47GAEVPF8.DHWDNXDEF[DNHHA[DHWDNXDEF[LGILWANECFGXLG@DNE..................45GAEVPF6.KLANDNHXJFKLNGCAKX[RFKXPVI.................................................................4:GAEVPF7.HF[APFHKJDNEFANA[PXD[MANERPLKF[[.......................................................;7GAEVPF5.FGGFKX[@D[FHA[PXD[MANERPLKF[[................................................................;7XD@CF4.HFGANAXALN[LGKLAN........................................................................................... 04XD@CF0.HFGANAXALN[LGA[P................................................................................................ 00XD@CF;.[FCFKXFHA[P[LVPKF[GLPAPPFEVCDPUDPGDPF..............................................05XD@CF

8.

XPDHAXALNDC

UDPGDPF

W[.

APPFEVCDP

UDPGDPF

[VPWFACCDNKF

....................

0:

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

10/122

av KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

FFZZFFKKVVXXAAWWFF[[VVIIIIDDPPQQ??XXDD[[MMAANNEEDDNNHHMMFFQQGGAANNHHAANNEE[[

Ujy tjas stuhy wds klnhuktfh. Xjas rfplrt wds klnhuktfh dt tjf rfqufst lg tjfn Vnhfr

[fkrftdry lg Hfgfnsf glr Antfccaefnkf (V[H(A)), Xjf Jlnlrd`cf Odifs P. Kcdppfr, dnh

dssaenfh`y tjf Hfgfnsf [kafnkf @ldrh (H[@) tl ats Rfridnfnt Hfgfnsf Antfccaefnkf Xdsm

Glrkf. Xjas rfqufst glcclwfh tjf pu`cakdtaln lg Idolr Efnfrdc Iakjdfc X. Gcynns

`cufprant pdpfr ln antfccaefnkf supplrt tl kluntfransurefnky (KLAN) lpfrdtalns an

Dgejdnastdn.Anjaspdpfr,IEGcynnprlvahfhdkdnhahdssfssifntlgantfccaefnkfsupplrt?

Aenlrdntlgclkdcfklnliaksdnhcdnhlwnfrs,jdzyd`lutwjltjfplwfr`rlmfrsdrf

dnhjlwtjfyiaejt`fangcufnkfh,ankuralusd`luttjfklrrfcdtalns`ftwffnvdralus

hfvfclpifntprlofktsdnhtjfcfvfcslgkllpfrdtalndilnevaccdefrs,dnhhasfnedefh

grlipflpcf an tjf`fstplsataln tl ganhdnswfrswjftjfrdahwlrmfrslrDgejdn

slchafrsV.[.antfccaefnkflggakfrsdnhdndcystskdnhlcattcf`utsjrueanrfsplnsftljaej

cfvfchfkasalnidmfrssffmanetjfmnlwcfheftlwdefdsukkfssguckluntfransurefnky.4

IE Gcynns kliifnts klif dt d taif wjfn Hfpdrtifnt lg Hfgfnsf (HlH) rfslurkf

klnstrdantsdnhkjdccfnefsdrf`fklianeilrffvahfnt,fvfndstjfHfpdrtifntgdkfsdwahf

rdneflgprlspfktavfKLANlpfrdtalnsantjfguturf.Dsdrfsuct,tjfHfpdrtifntiusttdmf

antl dkklunt wjdt at jds cfdrnfh an rfkfnt dnh kurrfnt KLAN lpfrdtalns, tjf nffh tl

klntanuf supplrtane kurrfnt lpfrdtalns ds fggfktavfcy ds plssa`cf, dnh tjf kjdccfnefs lg

prfpdraneglrtjfguturf.Xjasrfplrtrfprfsfntsdnfgglrttlunhfrstdnhtjf`dcdnkftjdtwacc

`frfquarfhtliffttjfsfkjdccfnefs,dnhtlpcdndkklrhanecy.

XjasstuhyklifsdtdnaiplrtdntilifntantjffvlcutalnlgVnatfh[tdtfs(V.[.)ndtalndc

sfkuraty. D Hfgfnsf [kafnkf @ldrh 0228 [uiifr [tuhy fxdianfh tjf nffh tl put

kdpd`acatafsan

pcdkf

tl

prfpdrf

ln

dElvfrnifnt

wahf

`dsas

glr

jlstacatafs,

ds

wfcc

ds

tjf

nffh tl haianasj V.[. iacatdry anvlcvfifnt an tjlsf dktavatafs an dn lrhfrcy dnh fggfktavf

idnnfr.0 Xjf rfplrt nltfh tjf nffh glr kdpd`acatafs an std`acazdtaln dnh rfklnstruktaln=

strdtfeak kliiunakdtaln= mnlwcfhef, unhfrstdnhane dnh antfccaefnkf= dnh ahfntagakdtaln,

clkdtaln,dnhtrdkmaneglrdsyiiftrakwdrgdrf.; Xjfprakflgnltjdvanetjfsfkdpd`acatafs

an pcdkf lr lg nlt pcdnnane tl usf tjfsf kdpd`acatafs wds stacc unglchane ds tjdt stuhy wds

wrattfn.Xjffnlrilusklstlgnlt gafchane tjfsfkdpd`acatafs askcfdr tlhdy. Atsdprakf tjf

V.[. as pdyane an cavfs dnh an ndtalndc trfdsurf. Xjf 0228 rfplrt nltfh tjf wahf sft lg

rfquarfifnts tjdtiust`fift tldhhrfss tjf gucc cagfkykcflgjlstacatafs.Xjasstuhy tdmfs

antl dkklunt tjf l`sfrvdtalns dnh rfkliifnhdtalns lg tjdt fgglrt, fxtfnhane ats

rfkliifnhdtalns

antl

klnkfpts

tl

fnjdnkf

tjf

kdpd`acatafs

lg

tjf

V.[.

Elvfrnifnt

(V[E)

an

4IakjdfcX.Gcynn,IdttRlttanefr,dnhRducH.@dtkjfclr,GaxaneAntfc? D@cufprantglrIdmaneAntfccaefnkfPfcfvdnt

anDgejdnastdn(Udsjanetln,HK?KfntfrglrdNfwDifrakdn[fkuraty,Odnudry0242)?5.Fipjdsasdhhfh.

0Pfplrt lg tjfHfgfnsf [kafnkf@ldrh 0228 [uiifr [tuhy lnXrdnsataln tl dnhgrliJlstacatafs (Udsjanetln, HK?

Hfgfnsf[kafnkf@ldrh,Hfkfi`fr0228).

;A`ah.,v.Fipjdsasdhhfh.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

11/122

FZFKVXAWF[VIIDPQ v

efnfrdc, dnh tjf Antfccaefnkf Kliiunaty (AK) an pdrtakucdr, tl put an pcdkf antfccaefnkf

kdpd`acatafstjdtsupplrtfifreanerfquarfifntsglrKLANlpfrdtalnstjrluejluttjffntarf

cagfkykcflgtjlsflpfrdtalns,grlipcdnnane,tlfxat.

Gandccy, tjf pfrtanfnkf lg tjas rfplrt as dipcagafh`y tjf wlrhs lg [fkrftdry lg Hfgfnsf

Pl`frtEdtfs,wjlnltfhandndhhrfssdttjfVnatfh[tdtfsIacatdryDkdhfiydtUfstRlant

tjdt tjf V.[. Driy dnh tjf rfst lg tjf V.[. Elvfrnifnt nffh kdpd`acatafs tl prfvfnt

gfstfrane prl`cfis grli erlwane antl gucc`clwn krasfs wjakj rfquarf klstcy dnh

klntrlvfrsadccdrefskdcfDifrakdniacatdryantfrvfntaln.8

Dstjfndtaln`uachsdnfwndtalndcsfkuratystrukturftjdtdhhrfssfs`ltjecl`dckjdccfnefs

dnh gaskdc rfdcatafs, tjfsf kdpd`acatafs wacc`f haggakuct tl l`tdan. Xjas rfplrt idmfs spfkagak

rfkliifnhdtalnsrfedrhanetjfA[PdpprldkjfsdnhrfslurkfsnffhfhtledantjfsfKLAN

kdpd`acatafs.

Xfris

lg

Pfgfrfnkf

(XLP).

Xjf

V[H(A)s

XLP

glr

tjf

stuhy

(Dppfnhax

D)

ahfntagafh

gavf

tdsms?

Ujdt as tjf hfvfclpane rlcf lg HlH antfccaefnkf, survfaccdnkf, dnh rfklnndassdnkf

(A[P)anKLANlpfrdtalns=wjldrftjfkustlifrsdnhwjdtdrftjfrfquarfifnts

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

12/122

va KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

slkadcskafntasts,dnhdvdraftylgcfdhanetjanmtdnmskjlcdrs.Dklipcftfcastanelg`rafganes

rfkfavfh`ytjfXdsmGlrkfkdn`fglunhanDppfnhaxK.

MfyGanhanes.VnhfrcyanetjasstuhysmfyganhanesastjfiuctapjdsfKLANkjdccfnef?tjf

nffhtlklntanufsupplrtaneKLANlpfrdtalnsanDgejdnastdn=saiuctdnfluscyprfpdraneglr

fifreanednhurefntKLANskfndralstjdtwaccjdvftl`fiftusanefxastanerfslurkfs=dnh

`uachane d kdpd`acaty tl hfdc watj clnetfri KLAN skfndrals usane nfw Klnkfpt lg

Lpfrdtalns(KLNLR[)dnhrfslurkfs.Mfyganhanesdrfprfsfntfhansuiidry`fclw,dnhan

hftdacan[fktaln8,wjakjdcslprlvahfsrfkliifnhdtalns.

4.HlHcdkmsdkliilnunhfrstdnhanelgKLAN.

XjfcdkmlgdsanecfdutjlratdtavfhfganatalnlgKLANasaipfhanedkliilnunhfrstdnhane

dnh unagafh dpprldkj tl KLAN lpfrdtalns watjan tjf HlH dnh dkrlss tjf V[E.

DkklipdnyanetjascdkmlghfganatalnasdiuctapcakatylgKLANKLNLR[.

0.HlH

dssuifh

rfsplnsa`acaty

glr

KLAN

A[P

`y

hfgduct.

Hfspatf d ndtalndc strdtfey dnh kavaciacatdry kdipdaen pcdn tjdt kdccs glr d wjlcflg

elvfrnifnt,plpucdtalnkfntrakdpprldkjtlKLAN,tjfV[Easnltfipclyanedccfcfifnts

lg ndtalndc plwfr an tjf pcdnnane dnh klnhukt lg KLAN lpfrdtalns. HlH dssuifh

rfsplnsa`acaty glr vartudccy dcc KLAN antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts`y hfgduct. Anhffh, dpdrt

grli`fanedsaendtlrytltjf0221V.[.ElvfrnifntKluntfransurefnkyEuahf,tjfHfpdrtifnt

lg[tdtfjdssjlwncattcffvahfntantfrfstan`uachanelrsupplrtanetjfpdrtnfrsjaphfskra`fh

`ytjfEuahf.6 XjascdkmlgpdrtnfrsjapaipfhfsprlerfsstlwdrhdwahfrdpprldkjtlKLAN.

;. HlH dnh AK lggakadcs tfnh tl glkus ndrrlwcy ln dar`lrnf tfkjnakdc klccfktaln

kdpd`acatafsdnh

systfis

rdtjfr

tjdn

ln

tjf

wahfr

kdpd`acatafs

nffhfh

tl

supplrt

KLAN.

Xjasl`sfrvdtalnassupplrtfh`ytjfgdkttjdttfkjnakdcklccfktalnpcdtglriskliidnhcdrefr

plrtalns lg tjf `uheft dnh prlhukf ilrf aiifhadtf fggfkts rdtjfr tjdn clnefr tfri,

glunhdtalndc anglridtaln glr plpucdtalnkfntrak lpfrdtalns. Xjf Xdsm Glrkf nltfs tjdt

haskussalns watj HlH sfnalr lggakadcs rfedrhane A[P glr KLAN turnfh grfqufntcy tl tjf

su`ofkt lg tfkjnakdc klccfktaln systfis dnh kdpd`acatafs wjacf fxkcuhane ltjfr klccfktaln

slurkfs (f.e. Lpfn [lurkf Antfccaefnkf (L[ANX), Juidn Antfccaefnkf (JVIANX)) dnh

prlkfssane, fxpclatdtaln, dnh hassfiandtaln (RFH) assufs. Xjf Hfgfnsf [kafnkf @ldrhs

[uiifr[tuhylg0242nltfhtjdtan0221HlHrfprfsfntfh70pfrkfntlgtjfrfquarfifnts

glrL[ANX,`utprlvahfhlncy;pfrkfntlgL[ANXgunhane.7 XjfcdkmlgdttfntalntlL[ANX

as`uttrfssfh`ytjfrfplrtsganhanetjdtan0221HlHjdhlncy48pfrkfntlgtjfAKsL[ANXidnplwfr, dnh gunhfh tjdt prlplrtaln cdrefcy tjrluej Hfgfnsf`uheft suppcfifntdcs.5

6Vnatfh[tdtfsElvfrnifntKluntfransurefnkyEuahf(Udsjanetln,HK?V[E,Odnudry0221).

7 Pfplrt lg tjf Hfgfnsf [kafnkf @ldrh 0242 [uiifr [tuhy ln Fnjdnkane Dhdptd`acaty lg V.[. Iacatdry Glrkfs

(Udsjanetln,HK?Hfgfnsf[kafnkf@ldrh,Odnudry0244)?77.

5A`ah.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

13/122

FZFKVXAWF[VIIDPQ vaa

Lvfrdcc, tjfsf prl`cfis tfnh tl fxkcuhfvdcud`cf slurkfs lg slkadc dnh`fjdvalrdc skafnkf

hdtd,ankcuhanejuidneflerdpjy.

8.A[Pkdpd`acatafsjdvfnlt`ffndppcafhfggfktavfcydedanstKLANlpfrdtalns tjdthfdc

watjplpucdtalns anpdrt`fkdusf d kliprfjfnsavf sftlg antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts glr

KLANhlfs

nlt

fxast.

Xjfhfgfnsfantfccaefnkfkliiunatyjdsnlttrdnscdtfhtjlsfdspfktslgkliidnhfrsantfnt

hfdcane watj KLAN antl antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts, tjluej tjf Vnatfh [tdtfs Elvfrnifnt

AntferdtfhKavacadnIacatdryKdipdaenRcdnglr [upplrt tlDgejdnastdn hfskra`fs an hftdac tjf

nffh tl glkus ln plpucdtaln sfkuraty, elvfrndnkf, dnh fklnliak hfvfclpifnt.: Xjf

rfdslnsglrtjasdppdrfntrfcuktdnkftlfnedeflntjasassufdrfvdrafh,`utlnfmfyrfdslnas

tjdt antfccaefnkf defnkafs, dt cfdst tjlsf an tjfUdsjanetln, H.K.drfd, tfnh tl`frfdktavf,

wdataneglrqufstalnstl`fdsmfh,rdtjfrtjdntryanetldntakapdtftjfi.Xjasdpprldkjidy

`ftllklnsfrvdtavfandpfralhlgrdpahslkadckjdnef,prliltfh`yanstdntkliiunakdtalns.

6.Xjf

V[E

as

nlt

anvfstane

dhfqudtfcy

an

tjf

hfvfclpifnt

lg

slkadc

dnh

`fjdvalrdc

skafnkfanglridtalntjdtaskratakdccyaiplrtdntglrKLAN.

Idny, ag nlt ilst, spfkagak KLAN A[P rfquarfifnts drf plpucdtalnkfntrak dnh drf nlt

fxkcusavfcyslcvd`cfwatjjdrhwdrflrjdrh,pjysakdcskafnkfskafntagakdnhtfkjnakdc([&X)

slcutalns.Lnfsfnalr antfccaefnkflggakfrwatjyfdrslggafchfxpfrafnkfplantfhluttjdt:2

pfrkfnt lg usfguc lpfrdtalndc hdtd glr KLAN hlfs nlt klif grli cfedky antfccaefnkf

haskapcanfs. Ellh antfccaefnkf ln KLAN fxasts lutsahf tjf trdhatalndc antfccaefnkf

lrednazdtalns.Dntjrlplcleakdc,slkalkucturdc,jastlrakdc,juidneflerdpjakdc,fhukdtalndc,

pu`cakjfdctj,dnhidnyltjfrtypfslgslkadcdnh`fjdvalrdcskafnkfhdtddnhanglridtaln

drf nffhfh tl hfvfclp d hffp unhfrstdnhane lg plpucdtalns. [ukj hdtd, klccfktfh dnh

dndcyzfhusanetjfskafntagakiftjlh,asvatdctlKLANsukkfss.

7.A[PsupplrtglrKLAN askurrfntcylvfrsjdhlwfh`ykluntfrtfrrlrasi (KX)dnhglrkf

prltfktalnrfquarfifnts.

Anrfdctfris,A[PsupplrtlgKLANasnltdsjaejdpralratyglrtjfKli`dtdntKliidnhs,

Iacatdry Hfpdrtifnts, dnh Hfgfnsf Defnkafs ds KX dnh glrkf prltfktaln, tjus dhvfrsfcy

aipdktane tjffggfktavfnfsslg KLANlpfrdtalns. KLAN as nltnfkfssdracy dndctfrndtavf tl

KX=slifA[Prfquarfifntsdrfkliilntl`ltjmanhslglpfrdtalns,`utKLAN,pdrtakucdrcy

plpucdtalnkfntrakKLAN,rfquarfsslifA[Plgatslwn.

5.KLAN

A[P

jds

nlt

`ffn

dhhrfssfh

fdrcy

an

tjf

klngcakt

spfktrui

dnh

jds

nlt

suggakafntcy ankcuhfh dwjlcflgelvfrnifnt dpprldkj.Xjf cdkm lg glkus ln ankapafnt

ansurefnkafscaiatslptalnsdnhankrfdsfsrasmlgunrfklvfrd`cfKLANprl`cfis,hfspatf

tjfkliiatifntlgidolriacatdryglrkfs.

: Vnatfh [tdtfs Elvfrnifnt Antferdtfh KavacadnIacatdry Kdipdaen Rcdn glr [upplrt tl Dgejdnastdn (Md`uc,

Dgejdnastdn?Vnatfh[tdtfsFi`dssyMd`uc/V[GLP,Dueust0221).

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

14/122

vaaa KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

Ansurefnkyjds`ffn tjfilstprfvdcfnt glrilgdrifhklngcaktsankfdt cfdst4181.

Hfspatf tjdt gdkt, glcclwane tjf Waftndi Udr dnh tjrluej tjf`dcdnkflg tjf Klch

Udr, tjf V.[. iacatdry fstd`casjifnt turnfh ats `dkm ln ansurefnky, rfgusane tl

klnsahfr lpfrdtalns dedanst ansurefnts ds dnytjane ltjfr tjdn d cfssfrankcuhfh

kdsf

glr

glrkfs

strukturfh

glr

dnh

prfpdrfh

tl

gaejt

twl

idolr

tjfdtfr

wdrs.1

Jastlrakdc stuhafs lg ansurefnkafs lvfr tjf yfdrs jaejcaejt tjf gdkt tjdt ansurefnkafs drf

ilrf camfcy ag d stdtf kdnnlt prlvahf gunhdifntdc sfrvakfs dnh ag tjf plpucdtaln`fcafvfs

tjfydrfdtrasm.Andhhataln,ltjfr gdktlrs,sukjdstjfqudcatylg cfdhfrsjap andpdrtakucdr

kluntrydnh tjdtkluntrysplcatakdckucturfkdn`f aiplrtdnt gdktlrs anwjftjfrlrnltdn

ansurefnky hfvfclps. Xjf Xdsm Glrkf hlfs nlt prlplsf tjdt dny spfkagak kli`andtaln lg

gdktlrs wacc rfsuct an dn ansurefnky. Nlnftjfcfss, rfkfnt jastlry kdn `f anstruktavf.

Klcli`ad,glrfxdipcf,jds`ffnerappfh`ydtfndkalusansurefnky,fvfndstjfhruetrdhf

jds aipfracfh tjdt elvfrnifnts d`acaty tl elvfrn fggfktavfcy. Klcli`ads strlne plcatakdc

cfdhfrsjap,jlwfvfr,jdsidhffggfktavfusflgV.[.sfkuratydnhhfvfclpifntdssastdnkf,ds

wfccdstjfplcatakdcdnhhapclidtaksupplrtlgV.[.cfdhfrs.Dsdrfsuct,tjfV.[.jdsnlt`ffnklipfccfh tl kliiat su`stdntadc V.[. glrkfs tl kli`dt dn ansurefnky dnh hfgfnh tjf

slvfrfaenprfrledtavfslgKlcli`adselvfrnifnt.Anklntrdst,tjfyfdrscfdhaneuptl1/44

watnfssfhcattcfV.[.elvfrnifntanvlcvfifntanDgejdnastdn.Dsdrfsuct,V.[.anglridtaln

slurkfs an Dgejdnastdn wfrf caiatfh, wjakj klnstrdanfh V.[. pltfntadc tl jfcp sjdpf an

DgejdnastdndsatudtalncfsshdnefrlustlV.[.antfrfsts.Xjffvfntslg1/44cfgttjfV.[.watj

gfwlptalnsanDgejdnastdn=kli`dtdrfeaiftjdtdcclwfhtfrrlraststldttdkmus,lrcavfwatj

dhdnefrlusstdtusqul.XjfXdsmGlrkftjfrfglrfouhefstjdtfdrcyantfrvfntalnpralrtldn

ansurefnkytdmanejlchwlucheavftjfV.[.ilrflptalnsdnhrfhukftjfcamfcajllhlgidolr

kli`dtantfrvfntaln.42

Ancaejtlgtjasrfklrh,atastjfvafwlgtjfXdsmGlrkftjdtarrfeucdrwdrgdrfdnhansurefnkafs

wacc klntanuf tl`f dn fnhurane kjdccfnef tl rfealndc std`acaty dnh V.[. ndtalndc sfkuraty

antfrfsts. Fifreane dnh fnhurane KLAN assufs nffh dttfntaln nlw. Dhhrfssane pltfntadc

ansurefnkafs an tjfar ankapafnt pjdsf (a.f., cfgt lg`dne) wacc prlvahf plcakyidmfrs dnh

kliidnhfrs ilrf wjlcflgelvfrnifnt lptalns dnh d`fttfr prlspfkt glr hftfrrane lr

prfvfntanetjfnffhglrkli`dtlpfrdtalns.@uachanedklccfktalndnhdndcytakfgglrtcfgtlg

`dne dcsl prlvahfs tjf ifdns glr sustdanfh, klnsastfnt, dnh ilrf fggfktavf A[P supplrt

sjluch dn ansurefnky`fklif dktavf. Xjas idmfs nfkfssdry d ilrf glkusfh dpprldkj tl

KLAN antfccaefnkf supplrt, ankcuhane d Ndtalndc Antfccaefnkf Idndefr (NAI) glr KLAN,

antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts harfktfh spfkagakdccy tl KLAN (ankcuhane plpucdtalnkfntrak

mnlwcfhef), dnh d strdtfeak anhakdtalns dnh wdrnane (A&U) ilhfc tl fnd`cf fdrcy

1 Kjrastlpjfr Rduc, Klcan R. Kcdrmf, dnh @ftj Eracc, Waktlry Jds d Xjlusdnh Gdtjfrs? [lurkfs lg [ukkfss an

Kluntfransurefnky([dntdIlnakd,KD?XjfPDNHKlrplrdtaln,0242)?xaaa.

42XjfXdsmGlrkfrfvafwfh6;kdsfstuhafslg ansurefnkafs. Anfvfrykdsftjfdktalns tdmfnwfrfrfdktavfdnh

lkkurrfhdgtfrtjfansurefnkyjdhtdmfnjlch.[ffMdcfvA.[fpp,@fstRrdktakfsanKluntfransurefnky,Iacatdry

Pfvafw(IdyOunf0226)?:40.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

15/122

FZFKVXAWF[VIIDPQ ax

aipcfifntdtaln lg wjlcflgelvfrnifnt lptalns. [lif A&U anhakdtlrs drf prl`d`cy

dcrfdhydvdacd`cf.

d.FggfktavfKLAN,dnh antfccaefnkfglrKLAN,iust rfgcfktdwjlcflgelvfrnifntfgglrt

dnhwjlcflgelvfrnifntkdpd`acatafs.

Dsnltfhantjf0228H[@[uiifr[tuhy,tjfV.[.rfquarfstjfifdnstltrdnsatalnantldn

lutlgjlstacatafs.Nlwjfrf as tjasnffhilrfsdcafnttjdn glrKLAN.Dhhrfssane tjffntarf

cagfkykcflgKLANrfquarfsmnlwcfhefidndefifntkdpd`acatafstjdtsfrvfdwahfvdraftylg

V.[. Elvfrnifnt hfpdrtifnts dnh defnkafs (HlH, Hfpdrtifnt lg [tdtf, tjf Antfccaefnkf

Kliiunaty, ftk.) D NAI glr KLAN wluch `f d`cf tl gdkacatdtf fggakafnt dnh fggfktavf

antfccaefnkf supplrt tl KLAN fnd`canedmnlwcfhef idndefifnt kdpd`acaty tjdtsupplrts

wjlcflgelvfrnifnt fgglrts dnh wjakj wluch fnklurdef usf lg d `rldhfr rdnef lg

anglridtalnslurkfstjdtel`fylnhcfedkyantfccaefnkfklccfktaln.

:. Xjf hfcuef lg sfnslr hdtd as krfdtane d krasas an prlkfssane, fxpclatdtaln, dnh

hassfiandtaln

(RFH)

dnh

dsslkadtfh

kliiunakdtaln,

ds

wfcc

ds

dn

ankrfdsane

nffh

glr

dhvdnkfhdndcysastjdtdhhrfssfs`fjdvalrlgerlupsdnhtjfkucturdcgrdifwlrmlgerlup

hfkasalns.

Xjfansdtad`cfhfidnhglranglridtalndnhfipjdsaslnklccfktalnasprlhukanedhfcueflg

hdtd,lvfrwjfcianetjfd`acatytlprlvahfusfguc,dktalnd`cfantfccaefnkfandtaifcyidnnfr.

Xjas krasas an RFH as fxdkfr`dtfh `y pcdnnfh dnh prlerdiifh klccfktaln dssfts dnh

hfidnhsnfw[&XslcutalnstlaiprlvftjffggakafnkydnhfggfktavfnfsslgA[Psupplrtglr

KLAN.

Ilrflvfr,tjfrfasdnffhtlhfvfclpdnhtrdanpflpcftlhlDhvdnkfhDndcysasdnhtjas

iust`fhlnfiukjfdrcafrantjfkdrffrslgtjf`fstdndcysts.Xjascfvfclgdndcysasasnffhfh

dt tjfvfry grlntfnhlgdny guturfklngcakt,nltsfvfrdcyfdrshlwn tjfrldh.Xrdanane glrDhvdnkfhDndcysas wluch stdrtdt tjfvfry`feannanelgdn dndcysts kdrffrdnhklntanuf

tjrluejlutjas/jfrkdrffr.Atankcuhfscdneudef,hffpkucturdcdwdrfnfss,dnhsfcfktglrislg

fnvarlnifntdctrdananewjakjfnklurdefsdnhsupplrtsdndcysaslntjfjfdctjlgdrfealn.

Dndcystsnffhtlidmfprlerfsstlunhfrstdnhtjfkucturfgarstjdnhdnhtjfynffhtlrfturn

tl kratakdc dssaenifnts watjan tjfar antfccaefnkf defnky. Ilrf dnh ilrf, tjf dndcysts wacc

nffh tl`fpcdkfh an tjf gafch anlrhfr tl`f`fstplsturfh glr antfccaefnkflpfrdtalnsdnh

klngcaktsdstjfydrasf.

1. Nfw dnh fifreane tfkjnlcleafs dnh tfkjnaqufs kdn `f fipclyfh tl aiprlvf

unhfrstdnhanelgKLANfnvarlnifnts.

Xfkjnlcleafs drf fifreane tl aiprlvf unhfrstdnhane lg tjf pjysakdc dttra`utfs (ianfrdc

rfslurkfs,kcaidtfs,eflerdpjafs,ankcuhanekucturdceflerdpjy),dswfccdstjlsfpfrtanfnttl

ahfntagyanepdttfrnlgcagfdktavatafslgerlupsdnhanhavahudcs.Xfkjnlcleafskdnrfcdtftjfsf

dttra`utfstlankapafntdnhrfdcansurefnkafs.Nfwdndcytaktfkjnlcleafsjlchtjfprliasflg

skdcaneuptjfd`acatytlgactfrrdwhdtd,ahfntagyifdnanepdttfrnslgdktavaty,dnhprfsfnt

dndcystswatjidtfradcusfguc tlunhfrstdnhaneKLANsatudtalns, tjusdcclwanedndcysts tl

pfrglrirfdcdndcysas,rdtjfrtjdnfxjdusttjfisfcvfskuccanerdwhdtd.Xfkjnlcleykdndcsl

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

16/122

x KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

`ffipclyfhtlunhfrstdnhwjdt asnlridc andpdrtakucdrfnvarlnifnt,jfcpanetlsplt

trfnhs tjdt rfprfsfnt dnlidcafs tjdt idy plrtfnh clnetfri kjdnefs dnh tjf rasf lg

anstd`acaty.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

17/122

4.ANXPLHVKXALN,XD[MANE,DNH[XVHQ[XPVKXVPF 44

44.. AANNXXPPLLHHVVKKXXAALLNN,,XXDD[[MMAANNEE,,DDNNHH[[XXVVHHQQ[[XXPPVVKKXXVVPPFF

Xjas rfplrt klnvfys tjf ganhanes dnh rfkliifnhdtalns lg tjf Rfridnfnt Hfgfnsf

Antfccaefnkf XdsmGlrkf (Xdsm Glrkflr XG) lg tjfHfgfnsf[kafnkf@ldrhrfcdtavf tl A[P an

supplrtlgKLANlpfrdtalns.Xjasrfplrtassu`iattfhanrfsplnsftltjfXfrislgPfgfrfnkf

lgIdrkj:,0242,prlvahfh`ytjfLggakflgtjfVnhfr[fkrftdrylgHfgfnsfglrAntfccaefnkf

(LV[H(A)).DklpylgtjfXLPasprlvahfhanDppfnhaxDtltjasrfplrt.

XjasstuhyklifsdtdnaiplrtdntilifntantjffvlcutalnlgV.[.ndtalndcsfkuraty.Dstuhy

pu`casjfh`y tjfHfgfnsf[kafnkf@ldrh an 0228,fxdianfh tjfnffh tl putkdpd`acatafs an

pcdkftlprfpdrflndElvfrnifntwahf`dsasglrjlstacatafs,dswfccdstlhaianasjV.[.

iacatdry anvlcvfifnt an tjlsf dktavatafs an dn lrhfrcy dnh fggfktavf idnnfr. 44 Xjf 0228

rfplrt nltfh tjf nffh glr kdpd`acatafs an std`acazdtaln dnh rfklnstruktaln= strdtfeak

kliiunakdtaln=mnlwcfhef,unhfrstdnhanednhantfccaefnkf=dnhahfntagakdtaln,clkdtaln,dnh

trdkmane glr dsyiiftrak wdrgdrf.40 Xjf prakf lg nlt jdvane tjfsf kdpd`acatafs an pcdkf, lr

pcdnnane tl usf tjfsf kdpd`acatafs wds stacc unglchane ds tjdt stuhy wds wrattfn. Xjffnlrilushaifnsalnslgtjdtprakfdrfkcfdrtlhdy.AtsdprakftjfV.[.aspdyaneancavfsdnh

anndtalndctrfdsurf.Xjf0228rfplrtnltfhtjfwahfsftlgrfquarfifntstjdtiust`fifttl

dhhrfss tjf gucc cagfkykcflgjlstacatafs.Xjasstuhy tdmfs antldkklunt tjfl`sfrvdtalnsdnh

rfkliifnhdtalns lg tjdt rfplrt, fxtfnhane atsrfkliifnhdtalns antlklnkfpts tl fnjdnkf

tjfkdpd`acatafslgtjfV[E anefnfrdc,dnhtjfAK anpdrtakucdr,tlput anpcdkfantfccaefnkf

kdpd`acatafstjdtsupplrtfifreanerfquarfifntsglrKLANlpfrdtalnstjrluejluttjffntarf

cagfkykcflgtjlsflpfrdtalns,grlipcdnnane,tlfxat.

Xjf XLP harfktfh tjf Xdsm Glrkf tl prlvahf ganhanes tjdt kdn`f usfh tl angcufnkf A[P

anvfstifnt hfkasalns ds tjfy rfcdtf tl KLAN. Dctjluej tjf XLP fipjdsazfh skafnkf dnh

tfkjnlcleyeavfntjfarpltfntadccysaenagakdntklntra`utalntlantfccaefnkfsupplrttlKLAN,

tjfXLPdcslharfktfhtjfXdsmGlrkftldssfssansurefnkafsdnhunhfrstdnhdplpucdtaln

an tjfar fnvarlnifnt. Xjf XLP dcsl nltfh tjdt jlst ndtaln kavacadn sfntaifnt kratakdccy

aipdkts KLAN sukkfss, anhakdtane dntjrlplcleakdc dnh slkalkucturdc gdktlrs iust dcsl`f

dhhrfssfh.Xjfsfgdktlrs,dnhtjfiuctahaifnsalndc,kldcatalnndturflgKLANlpfrdtalns,

jdvf aipcakdtalns glr tjf sklpf lg tjas Xdsm Glrkfs fgglrts, d plant idhf kcfdr`y tjf

haskussalnslggfrfhan[fktalns;.4.0(Ujldrftjfkustlifrs

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

18/122

40 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

0. UjdtastjfrfkliifnhfhdcclkdtalndnhusflgHlHA[PrfslurkfstlsustdanKLANkdpd`acaty dclne watj ltjfr klipftane antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts, glr fxdipcf,

kluntfrtfrrlrasi

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

19/122

4.ANXPLHVKXALN,XD[MANE,DNH[XVHQ[XPVKXVPF 4;

Xjf Xdsm Glrkf glunh sfvfrdc anklnsastfnt hfganatalns glr tjf tfri KLAN ankcuhfh an d

vdrafty lg dutjlratdtavf slurkfs, ds wfcc ds haggfrane KLNLR[. Xjfsf haggfrfnt hfganatalns

dcclw HlH lrednazdtalns dnh AK ifi`frs tl kjllsf tjf lnf(s) tjfy camf`fst, kdusane

klngusaln dnh haggfrfnt antfrprftdtalns dilne hfkasalnidmfrs dnh lpfrdtlrs. Xjfsf

haggfrfnkfs drf saenagakdnt wjfn lnf trafs tl rfcdtf KLAN tl ltjfr iacatdry dktalns= f.e.,

kluntfrtfrrlrasi,arrfeucdrwdrgdrf,dnhglrkfprltfktaln.

HlH A[P dcsl jdsd nui`frlg hfganatalns. An atssaipcfst glri, HlH A[P as usfh`y

ilst HlH dnh AK ifi`frs tl ifdn tfkjnakdc klccfktaln grli idnnfh lr unidnnfh

dar`lrnfpcdtglriscamftjfIT1/Pfdpfr,PT8/Ecl`dcJdwm,lrIK40/Ca`frty.Xjasvafw,

wjfn dppcafh tl KLAN, tfnhs tl fxkcuhf ltjfr trdhatalndc slurkfs lg antfccaefnkf= f.e.,

L[ANX dnh JVIANX. At dcsl aenlrfs dnh prfkcuhfs tjf usf lg ltjfr fxtrfifcy vdcud`cf

slurkfs lg hdtd dnh mnlwcfhef grli tjf slkadc skafnkfs tjdt jdvf pdrtakucdr utacaty glr

KLAN.Xjfsftfris,dnhdhfskraptalnlgjlw tjfXdsmGlrkfusfhtjfi,drfdhhrfssfh an

erfdtfrhftdacan[fktaln0lgtjfrfplrt.

Xjf sfklnh pdrt lg tjf garst tdsm (wjl drf tjf kustlifrs dnh wjdt drf tjf

rfquarfifnts

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

20/122

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

21/122

4.ANXPLHVKXALN,XD[MANE,DNH[XVHQ[XPVKXVPF 46

GAEVPF0.[XVHQKLNXFZXXULAIRFPDXAWF[

Xjf XG idmfs d nui`fr lg rfkliifnhdtalns watj rfspfkt tl tjfsf fifreane KLAN

kjdccfnefs,fvfndstjfV.[.idyjdvftlhfdcwatjilrfurefntKLANskfndrals.XjfXdsm

Glrkf`fcafvfsnlwastjftaiftlklnsahfrjlwtldhhrfssKLANantfccaefnkfrfquarfifnts

glrtjfguturf.DstjfV.[.ElvfrnifntKluntfransurefnkyEuahfsprfgdkfnltfs?UjftjfrtjfVnatfh

[tdtfs

sjluch

fnedef

an

dny

pdrtakucdr

kluntfransurefnky

as

d

idttfr

lg

plcatakdc

kjlakf,`ut tjdt at wacc fnedef an sukj klngcakts hurane tjf hfkdhfs tl klif as d nfdr

kfrtdanty.47

A[P glrKLANidyhaggfr grli kluntry tl kluntry,`ut tjfrf drf slif efnfrak`dsak A[P

rfquarfifnts (tjdtunhfrcaf tjfXdsm Glrkfs ganhanes dnh rfkliifnhdtalns) tjdt kdn`f

ahfntagafh dnh tjfn ilhagafh tl suat d spfkagak kluntry hfpfnhane ln kurrfnt strdtfeak

rfquarfifnts.XjfXdsmGlrkf ahfntagafh,ds accustrdtfh anGaeurf;,d rfprfsfntdtavf castlg

kluntrafs tjdt kurrfntcy plsf d pltfntadc KLAN kjdccfnef. [lif lg tjfsf kluntrafsidy

rfprfsfntdnfifreaneKLANkjdccfnef,wjacfltjfrsidy`fklifilrfurefnt.Atsjluch`f

fipjdsazfh tjdt tjas cast as prlvahfh glr accustrdtavf purplsfs dnh hlfs nlt nfkfssdracy

rfprfsfntdny

dssfssifnt

`y

tjf

HlH

lr

tjf

AK

rfedrhane

fifreane

KLAN

satudtalns,

nlr

as

tjfcastanpralratylrhfr.[fttanetjfdktudcpralratafswluch`fdvfryhyndiakprlkfss`dsfh

lnkurrfntndtalndcsfkuratyl`ofktavfs.

47A`ah.,v.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

22/122

47 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

GAEVPF;.RL[[A@CFKLANKJDCCFNEF[

Xjf Xdsm Glrkf l`sfrvfh tjdt fklnliak krasfs, kcaidtf kjdnef, hfilerdpjak prfssurfs,

rfslurkfskdrkaty,lrpllrelvfrndnkfkluchkdusftjfsfstdtfs(lrltjfrs)tlgdaclr`fklif

slwfdmtjdttjfy`fkliftdreftsglrdeerfsslrs/ansurefnts.XjfXdsmGlrkf`fcafvfstjdtd

elvfrnifnts clss lg ats d`acaty tl fxfrkasf slvfrfaen prfrledtavfs an aiplrtdnt rfealns,

ankcuhane

`lrhfr

drfds,

dcclwane

dn

ansurefnky

tl

edan

kratakdc

idss,

idy

rfprfsfnt

dn

aiplrtdnt KLAN prfhaktlr. Anstd`acaty kdn dssuif rfealndc haifnsalns rdpahcy.

Anglridtaln, ecl`dc anglridtaln angrdstrukturf, dnh slkadcifhad kdn dipcagy tjf spffh,

antfnsaty, dnh ilifntui lg fvfnts tjdt kjdccfnef rfeaif std`acaty. Xjf tjrfdt lg tjf

prlcagfrdtalnlgwfdplnslgidssfggfkts antjfjdnhslgilrfndtalnsdnhnlnstdtfdktlrs

gurtjfrklipcakdtfstjfidttfr.[ukjdrfdskluch`fklifsdnktudrafsgrliwjakjtlcdunkj

dttdkmslntjfV.[.jlifcdnh,rfkruatpfrslnnfc,dnhgandnkf,trdan,dnhsuppcylpfrdtalns.

Xjfrfglrf,andhhatalntl[&X,tjfXGkjlsftlfxdianftjfklntra`utalnstjdtslkadcskafnkfs

(ankcuhane dntjrlplcley dnh slkalcley) kdn idmf tl fnsurane fggfktavf A[P supplrt tl

KLAN, dswfcc ds tjf anvfstifnts tjdtiaejt`fidhf an juidn rfslurkfs/prlgfssalndc

hfvfclpifnt.Xjf

Xdsm

Glrkfs

klnsahfrdtalns

wfrf

angcufnkfh

ds

wfcc

`y

haskussalns

tjdt

accustrdtfhhaggfrfnkfsdilnetjfkurrfntKLANlpfrdtalns(DgejdnastdndnhArdq),dnhpdst

dnh prlspfktavf KLAN lpfrdtalns sukj ds an Waftndi, tjfJlrn lgDgrakd, Cf`dnln, lr

Ifxakl.

XjfXdsmGlrkfklnkcuhfhtjdt agV.[.plcakyastlhftfrdnhprfvfntKLANsatudtalnsgrli

`fklianeidolrklngcaktsilrffipjdsassjluch`fpcdkfhcfgtlg`dne(`fglrftjfnffhtl

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

23/122

4.ANXPLHVKXALN,XD[MANE,DNH[XVHQ[XPVKXVPF 45

idmfdidolrkliiatifntlgkli`dttrllps)dnhwjacftjfansurefnkyasstaccanatsankapafnt

pjdsf.Dstjf0244NdtalndcIacatdry[trdtfeylgtjfVnatfh[tdtfslgDifrakdnltfs?Rrfvfntanewdrs as ds aiplrtdnt dswannane tjfi,dnh gdr cfss klstcy. 45Xjfrf drfidny rfdslns tlklnsahfr tjas sjagt tl cfgt lg `dne. Gaeurf 8 suiidrazfs tjf mfy dhvdntdefs dnh

hasdhvdntdefslgidmanetjassjagt.

GAEVPF8.DHWDNXDEF[DNHHA[DHWDNXDEF[LGILWANECFGXLG@DNE

[jluchtjf

V.[.

ilvf

tl

dcfgt

lg

`dne

dpprldkj

tl

KLAN,

usfguc

anhakdtlrs

tl

jfcp

prfhakt

ansurefnky skfndrals dnhhfdcwatj tjfi fdrcy drfnffhfh, tjusidmane anhakdtalns dnh

wdrnanes (A&U) anhakdtlrs dn aiplrtdnt kliplnfnt lg guturf KLAN pcdnnane dnh

lpfrdtalns (sff Gaeurf 6). At as aiplrtdnt tlnltf tjdt at asplssa`cf tljdvf saiuctdnflus

lpfrdtalns(f.e.,KLAN,KX,klnvfntalndc,ftk.)hfpfnhanelntjfhfganataln(s)kjlsfn.

45 Xjf Ndtalndc Iacatdry [trdtfey lg tjf Vnatfh [tdtfs lg Difrakd? Pfhfganane Difrakds Iacatdry Cfdhfrsjap(Udsjanetln,HK?KjdaridnlgtjfOlantKjafgslg[tdgg,:Gf`rudry0244)?5.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

24/122

4: KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

GAEVPF6.KLANDNHXJFKLNGCAKX[RFKXPVI

Hurane tjfKlchUdr, tjfV.[.wdsd`cf tlhfvfclpdstrdtfeak A&Uilhfc tjdtwdswfcc

unhfrstllh. At prlhukfh kcfdrcy hfganfh antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts antfnhfh tl prfvfnt d

surprasfnukcfdrdttdkm.AthrlvfA[Ppjysakdctfkjnlcleafs,klccfktalniftjlhs,dnhdndcysas=

atyafchfhmfyanhakdtlrs(prankapdccyiacatdryanndturf)=dnhatrfquarfhdktavatynlris

tlhasklvfrsaenagakdntkjdnefs.

At as tjfXdsmGlrkfs`fcafg tjdtdsaiacdrstrdtfeak A&Uilhfckdn`fhfsaenfh glrKLAN.

Xjasilhfcwluchnffhnfwdnhhaggfrfnt A[Prfquarfifnts=dkcfdrunhfrstdnhanelgtjf

fnvarlnifntkratakdctlhftfriananekdusfs/lraeanslgprl`cfi(s)=dnhtjfdhhatalnlgslkadc

skafnkfs tl tjfpjysakdc skafnkfs.Mfy anhakdtlrswaccilst camfcy`fnlniacatdry sukj ds

plcatakdc, fklnliak, slkadc,dnh clsslgelvfrnifnt slvfrfaenprfrledtavfs anmfy rfealns.

[ukjdndpprldkjwluch rfquarfdwjlcflgelvfrnifntpcdn tlhftfrianf rfquarfifnts,

klccfktaln,dndcytakdc,dnhhassfiandtalnpralratafs.

Ujacf d plpucdtalnkfntrak dpprldkj tl Dgejdnastdn dppfdrs wfccsuatfh tl tjf vaccdef

`dsfh ndturf lg Dgejdn slkafty, d haggfrfnt dpprldkj idy `f rfquarfh tl kluntfr

ansurefnkafstjdt

hrdw

tjfar

strfnetj

grli

hrue

kdrtfcs

lr

ltjfr

iltavdtane

glrkfs.

Nlnftjfcfss, rfkfntKLAN tjanmanejds`ffn angcufnkfherfdtcy`y tjfplpucdtalnkfntrak

vafwlgKLAN,lnftjdtfipjdsazfsslkadc,plcatakdc,dnhkucturdcklntfxtdsiukjdshftdacfh

anglridtalnd`lut tjfdhvfrsdry.DsIEGcynnnltfs,tfnhfnky tllvfrfipjdsazfhftdacfhanglridtalnd`luttjffnfiydttjffxpfnsflgtjfplcatakdc,fklnliak,dnhkucturdcfnvarlnifnt4:4:

Gcynn,ftdc.,GaxaneAntfc,5.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

25/122

4.ANXPLHVKXALN,XD[MANE,DNH[XVHQ[XPVKXVPF 41

Xjas vafw lg kurrfnt KLAN hlktranf dppfdrs tl fxfrt ilrf lr cfss angcufnkf ln iacatdry

cfdhfrs, hfpfnhane ln tjfar lrafntdtaln dnh fxpfrafnkf. Ujacf tjas Xdsm Glrkf hlfs nlt

fxprfssdnlpanalnlnKLANhlktranfdnhklnkfptslglpfrdtalns,atvafwstjfslkadcskafnkfs

ds aiplrtdnt tl unhfrstdnhane tdreft plpucdtalns, tjf rlcf lg ansurefnkafs watjan dnh

klnnfktfhtltjfsfplpucdtalns,dnhtjfnffhtlsfpdrdtftjfantfrfstslgtdreftplpucdtalns

grli tjlsf lg ansurefnkafs. Xjf Xdsm Glrkf dcsl nltfs tjdt plstUlrch Udr AA skafntagak

rfsfdrkj ankcuhfh wlrm an tjf hfvfclpifnt lg lrednazdtalndc hfsaen dnh hyndiaks dnh

systfis dndcysas ds wdys tl dpprldkj rfsucts hravfn iacatdry lpfrdtalns dnh tjf fggakafnt

dcclkdtalnlgrfslurkfstldkjafvfrfsucts.

An efnfrdc, tjf Xdsm Glrkf vafws V.[. kluntfransurefnky ds dn fgglrt tl hfny sukkfss tl

ansurefntilvfifntswjlwluchusftjftfrratlrytjfyklntrlctlfnhdnefrtjfsdgftylgtjf

Vnatfh[tdtfsdnhatsdccafs.Dsdrfsuct,tjfsklpflgtjfXdsmGlrkfsklnsahfrdtalnankcuhfh

tjf wahf rdnef lg pltfntadc KLAN skfndrals dnh lpfrdtalns= d wahf vdrafty lg skafnkf,

tfkjnlcley, dnh ltjfr rfslurkfs=dnhd vafw tjdtskafnkf ankcuhfs tjf usflg tjfskafntagak

iftjlh lg jypltjfsas efnfrdtaln, hdtd klccfktaln, dnh dndcysas dsslkadtfh watj tjf slkadcskafnkfs.Dnycfgtlg`dnedpprldkjtlKLANwaccrfquarftjfusflgslkadcskafnkfsanA[P,

andhhatalntltjfdppcakdtalnlgtjfpjysakdcskafnkfs.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

26/122

02 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

00.. HHFFGGAANNAANNEEKKLLAANNDDNNHHAA[[PP

Xjf Xdsm Glrkf rfvafwfh kurrfnt plcaky, hlktranf, strdtfey, dnh pcdns tjdt fstd`casj tjf

vasaln,l`ofktavfs,euahfcanfs,dnhrfsplnsa`acatafswatjan tjfV[Ednh tjfHlH glrKLAN=

ltjfr

dspfkts

lg

arrfeucdr

wdrgdrf

ankcuhane

KX,

unklnvfntalndc

wdrgdrf

(VU),

glrfaen

antfrndc hfgfnsf (GAH), dnh std`acaty lpfrdtalns ([L)= ds wfcc ds A[P. Xjf purplsf lg tjf

rfvafwwdstlfstd`casjdkcfdr`dsfcanfglrtjasstuhy.

An rfvafwane tjfsf dutjlratdtavf slurkfs, tjf Xdsm Glrkf glunh tjdt tjfrf as su`stdntadc

plcaky euahdnkf ln mfy dspfkts lg KLAN dnh A[P ds wfcc ds nuifrlus, dnh anklnsastfnt

hfganatalnslgtjfmfytfrisdsslkadtfhwatjtjasstuhy.Fxdipcfslgtjfsfhaskrfpdnkafsdrf

haspcdyfhanXd`cfs4dnh0.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

27/122

0.HFGANANEKLANDNHA[P 04

Kluntfransurefnky(KLAN)

Hfganataln [lurkf

4 Xjf`cfnhlgkliprfjfnsavfkavacadndnhiacatdryfgglrtshfsaenfhtl

saiuctdnfluscyklntdanansurefnkydnhdhhrfssatsrlltkdusfs.Vncamf

klnvfntalndcwdrgdrf,nlniacatdryifdnsdrflgtfntjfilstfggfktavf

fcfifnts,watj

iacatdry

glrkfs

pcdyane

dn

fnd`cane

rlcf.

V.[.ElvfrnifntAntfrdefnkyKLAN

Euahf(Odn0221)

0 Xjlsfiacatdry,pdrdiacatdry,plcatakdc,fklnliak,psykjlcleakdc,dnhkavak

dktalnstdmfn`ydelvfrnifnttlhfgfdtansurefnky.

OlantRu`cakdtaln(OR)420

HfpdrtifntlgHfgfnsfHaktalndrylg

IacatdrydnhDsslkadtfhXfris(Dprac

0224,difnhfh0242)

; Kliprfjfnsavfkavacadndnhiacatdryfgglrtstdmfntlhfgfdtdnansurefnky

dnhtldhhrfssdnyklrferafvdnkfs.OR;08 KLANLpfrdtalns(Lkt0221)

8 Dkluntfransurefnkykdipdaenasdiaxlglggfnsavf,hfgfnsavf,dnh

std`acatylpfrdtalnsklnhuktfhdclneiuctapcfcanfslglpfrdtalns.

DriyGafchIdnudc(GI); 08

Kluntfransurefnky(Hfk0227)

6 KLANlpfrdtalnsankcuhfsupplrtanedJlstNdtalnsiacatdry,

pdrdiacatdry,plcatakdc,fklnliak,psykjlcleakdc,dnhkavakdktalnstdmfntl

hfgfdtdnansurefnky.Dvlahanetjfkrfdtalnlgnfwansurefntsdnhglrkane

fxastane

ansurefnts

tl

fnh

tjfar

pdrtakapdtaln

as

vatdc

tl

hfgfdtane

dn

ansurefnky.KLANlpfrdtalnslgtfnankcuhfsfkuratydssastdnkfprlerdis

sukjdsglrfaeniacatdrysdcfsprlerdis,tjfglrfaeniacatdrygandnkane

prlerdi,dnhantfrndtalndciacatdrytrdananednhfhukdtalnprlerdis.

[fvfnmfyKLANCanfslgFgglrt?4)Fstd`casjkavacsfkuraty

0)Fstd`casjkavacklntrlc

;)[upplrtJNsfkuratyglrkfs

8)[upplrttlelvfrndnkf

6)Pfstlrffssfntadcsfrvakfs

7)[upplrttlfklnliakdnhangrdstrukturfhfvfclpifnt

5)Klnhuktanglridtalnfnedefifnt

GIA; 08.0XdktaksanKLAN(Idrkj

0221)

7 [upplrttlKLANashfganfhdssupplrtprlvahfhtldelvfrnifntantjf

iacatdry,pdrdiacatdry,plcatakdc,fklnliak,psykjlcleakdc,dnhkavakdktalnat

unhfrtdmfstlhfgfdtansurefnky(OR420).Aipcakatantjashfganatalnasd

cfeataidtfpdrtnfr

ndtaln

(RN)

elvfrnifnt

an

plwfr

watj

slif

kdpdkaty

tl

harfktdnhklnhuktKLANlpfrdtalns.[upplrttlKLANkdnankcuhfanharfkt

supplrt,harfktsupplrt(nltanvlcvanekli`dt)dnhharfktsupplrt(anvlcvane

kli`dt).

Dar

Glrkf

Hlktranf

Hlkuifnt

(DGHH)

0;ArrfeucdrUdrgdrf(Dueust0225)

5 Xjfsftlgplcatakdc,fklnliak,slkadc,iacatdry,cdwfnglrkfifnt,kavacdnh

psykjlcleakdcdktavatafswatjtjfdaitlhfgfdtansurefnkydnhdhhrfssdny

klrferafvdnkfs.

@a[KOlantLpfrdtalnsEuahfcanfs

(OLE)42/24(NDXL)(Idy0242)

: Dttra`utfslgKLAN?

Rlcatakdcpraidky(dnhdkcfdrcyhfganfhplcatakdcl`ofktavf)

Atasdstrueecfglrtjfplpucdtaln,nltdedansttjfplpucdtaln

Xjfrfcfvdnkflgcfeataidky

Antfccaefnkfhravfslpfrdtalns

Vnatylgfgglrt(tjfrfquarfifntlgdkllrhandtfhelvfrnifnt strukturf)

Nfutrdcazftjfansurefnkydnhaslcdtftjfansurefntsgrlitjfarsupplrt

Rrfpdrf

glr

dprltrdktfh

kdipdaen

[fkuratyunhfrtjfrucflgcdwasfssfntadc

Jdnhlvfrrfsplnsa`acatytltjfclkdcglrkfsdssllndsprdktakd`cf

Cfdrndnhdhdptquakmcy

DccafhOlantHlktranf(DOR);.8.8Olant

HlktranfglrKLAN(NDXLpu`ln

KLAN)(Nlv022:)

XD@CF4.HFGANAXALN[LGKLAN

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

28/122

00 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

Antfccaefnkf,[urvfaccdnkf,dnhPfklnndassdnkf(A[P)

Hfganataln [lurkf

4 Dndktavatytjdtsynkjrlnazfsdnhantferdtfs tjfpcdnnanednh

lpfrdtaln

lg

sfnslrs,

dssfts,

dnh

prlkfssane,

fxpclatdtaln,

dnh

hassfiandtalnsystfisanharfktsupplrtlgkurrfntdnhguturflpfrdtalns.

Xjasasdnantferdtfhantfccaefnkfdnhlpfrdtalnsgunktaln.

OR420HaktalndrylgIacatdrydnh

Dsslkadtfh

Xfris

(Dprac

0224,

difnhfh0242)

0 Antfccaefnkf,survfaccdnkf,dnhrfklnndassdnkfasdndktavatytjdt

synkjrlnazfsdnhantferdtfstjfpcdnnanednhlpfrdtalnlgsfnslrs,

dssfts,dnhprlkfssane,fxpclatdtaln,dnhhassfiandtalnlgsystfisan

harfktsupplrtlgkurrfntdnhguturflpfrdtalns.Xjasasdnantferdtfh

antfccaefnkf dnhlpfrdtalnsgunktaln.GlrDriyglrkfs,tjaskli`anfhdris

lpfrdtalnglkusfslnpralratyantfccaefnkfrfquarfifntswjacfdnswfrane

tjfkliidnhfrskratakdcanglridtalnrfquarfifnts.(OR024klntdansA[P

hlktranf.)XjrluejA[P,kliidnhfrsdnhstdggsklntanuluscypcdn,tdsm,

dnhfipclyklccfktalndssftsdnhglrkfs.Xjfsfklccfkt,prlkfss,dnh

hassfiandtftaifcydnhdkkurdtfanglridtaln,kli`dtanglridtaln,dnh

antfccaefnkf tlsdtasgytjfkliidnhfrskratakdcanglridtalnrfquarfifnts

(KKAP)dnh

ltjfr

antfccaefnkf

rfquarfifnts.

Ujfn

nfkfssdry,

A[P

dssfts

idyglkuslnspfkadcrfquarfifnts,sukjdsanglridtalnrfquarfhglr

pfrslnnfcrfklvfrylpfrdtalns.Atsupplrtsguccspfktruilpfrdtalns

tjrluejglurtdsms? A[Psynkjrlnazdtaln,A[Pantferdtaln,[urvfaccdnkf,

Pfklnndassdnkf.

GI;2Lpfrdtalns(Gf`022:)

; Xjfpurplsflgantfccaefnkf, survfaccdnkf,dnhrfklnndassdnkf(A[P)

lpfrdtalnshuranedKLANastlhfvfclptjfantfccaefnkf nffhfhtldhhrfss

tjfassufshravanetjfansurefnky.[fvfrdcgdktlrsdrfpdrtakucdrcy

aiplrtdntglrA[PlpfrdtalnsanKLANfnvarlnifnts.Xjfsfankcuhftjf

glcclwane? dglkuslntjfclkdcplpucdkf=klccfktalnlkkurranedtdcc

fkjfclns=clkdcazfhndturflgansurefnkafs.

GI;08Kluntfransurefnky(Hfk

0227)

8 XjfeldclgA[Plpfrdtalnsastlprlvahfdkkurdtf,rfcfvdnt,dnhtaifcy

antfccaefnkf tlhfkasalnidmfrs.XjfDarGlrkf`fstdkjafvfstjaseldc

tjrluejfggfktavffipclyifntlgA[Pkdpd`acatafs,dnh`ykdpatdcazaneln

tjfantfrlpfrd`acaty

fxastane

dilne

lur

A[P

systfis,

ds

wfcc

ds

nln

trdhatalndcslurkfs,tlkrfdtfsynfreytjrluejantferdtaln.

DGHH01A[P(Ouc0225)

6 [urvfaccdnkfdnhrfklnndassdnkfrfgfrtltjfifdns`ywjakjtjf

anglridtalnasl`sfrvfh.[urvfaccdnkfassystfidtakl`sfrvdtalntl

klccfktwjdtfvfrhdtdasdvdacd`cf,wjacfrfklnndassdnkfasdspfkagak

iassalnpfrglrifhtll`tdanspfkagakhdtd.

IacatdryXrdnsglridtaln?

Antfccaefnkf[urvfaccdnkf,dnh

Pfklnndassdnkf(Odn022;)

XD@CF0.HFGANAXALN[LGA[P

Dsanhakdtfhprfvaluscy,haggfrfnthfganatalnslgtfrisdnhdsslkadtfhantfrprftdtalnslgtjfar

ifdnanedcclwtjfHlHkliplnfnts,ankcuhanetjfantfccaefnkfkliplnfntslgtjfiacatdry

hfpdrtifntsdnhkli`dtdntkliidnhsdnhtjfkli`dtsupplrtdefnkafstjdtdrfpdrtlgtjf

AK, tl kjllsf tjf lnf(s) tjfy prfgfr. Xjas, an turn, prlhukfs d cdkm lg kcdraty dnh kdusfs

klngusalnd`lutwjdtasifdnt`y`ltjKLANdnhA[P.

[lifhfgfnsflggakadcs,glrfxdipcf,nfatjfrhaggfrfntadtfKLANgrliltjfrarrfeucdrwdrgdrf

lpfrdtalnssukjdsKXnlrhastaneuasjatgrlitrdhatalndcmanftakiacatdrylpfrdtalns.Ujacf

arrfeucdr wdrgdrf kdn `f klnhuktfh anhfpfnhfntcy lr an kli`andtaln watj trdhatalndc

wdrgdrf (sff Gaeurf 6), KLAN as pdrt lg d spfktrui lg arrfeucdr wdrgdrf dktavatafs dnh

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

29/122

0.HFGANANEKLANDNHA[P 0;

lpfrdtalns ankcuhane KX, VU, GAH, dnh [L. Jlwfvfr, rfdc hastanktalns fxast dilne

trdhatalndc wdrgdrf dnh arrfeucdr wdrgdrf dnh tjf gdacurf tl unhfrstdnh tjf haggfrfnkfs

`ftwffn KLAN, KX, glrkf prltfktaln, dnh klnvfntalndc stramf lpfrdtalns jds dhvfrsf

klnsfqufnkfsglrtjffxfkutalnlgV.[.ndtalndcsfkuratyplcakydnhstrdtfey.Xjasgdacurfjds

dhfcftfralusfggfktlntjfHlHdnhAKsunhfrstdnhanelgtjfantfccaefnkfrfquarfifntsglr

fggfktavfsupplrtlgV.[.,iuctandtalndc,dnhkldcatalnKLANlpfrdtalns.

XjfXdsmGlrkfhasklvfrfhdsaiacdrcdkmlgkcdratydnhklngusalnwatjandnh`ftwffnHlH

kliplnfnts dnh tjf AK d`lut tjf tfri A[P. Xjf deerfedtaln lg A[P as atsfcg slifwjdt

klngusanesankf atfqudtfstjf aiplrtdnkflg antfccaefnkf,survfaccdnkf,dnhrfklnndassdnkf.

Angdkt,antfccaefnkf astjfl`ofktavflgA[P,dnhsurvfaccdnkfdnhrfklnndassdnkfdrfkdrrafh

luttlklntra`utftltjdtl`ofktavf.

Ilrflvfr(dnhdsnltfhprfvaluscy),tjfXdsmGlrkfglunhtjdtsliffqudtfHfgfnsfA[P

watjtfkjnakdcklccfktalnanefnfrdcdnhidnnfhdnhunidnnfhdarkrdgtanpdrtakucdr.[ukj

iasantfrprftdtaln

unnfkfssdracy

klnstrdans

tjf

vafw

lg

plcakyidmfrs,

pcdnnfrs,

dnh

wdrgaejtfrstldrfcdtavfcyndrrlwsftlgtfkjnakdcklccfktalnpcdtglrisrdtjfrtjdntjf`rldh

drrdylgdssftsrfslurkfh`ytjfIacatdryAntfccaefnkfRrlerdi(IAR),iukjcfsstjflvfrdcc

kdpd`acatafsdnhkdpdkatylgtjfndtalnsantfccaefnkffntfrprasf.

A[P glr KLAN (dnh A[P an efnfrdc) ankcuhfs dcc antfccaefnkf haskapcanfs, dcc slurkfs lg

anglridtaln, dnh dcc dspfkts lg tjf prlkfss lg klccfktane hdtd dnh turnane at antl

lpfrdtalndccy usfguc antfccaefnkf upln wjakj tl fstd`casj klntfxt, krfdtf mnlwcfhef, dnh

anglrihfkasalnsdnhdktalns.Atfnklipdssfspcdnnanednhharfktalnlgantfccaefnkf,iassaln

dnh klccfktaln idndefifnt, tdsmane, juidn dnh tfkjnakdc klccfktaln, prlkfssane,

fxpclatdtaln, prlhuktaln, dnh hassfiandtaln. Ilrflvfr, watj rfspfkt tl L[ANX at ankcuhfs

nlntrdhatalndc slurkfs lg plcatakdc, slkalkucturdc,`fjdvalrdc, fklnliak, dnh ltjfr slkadc

skafnkfanglridtalnglunhantjfpu`cakdnhpravdtfsfktlrs.

Glrtjfpurplsfslgtjasstuhy,tjfXdsmGlrkfusfhtjfhfganatalnsglunhanOlantRu`cakdtaln

(OR)420,HfpdrtifntlgHfgfnsfHaktalndrylgIacatdrydnhDsslkadtfhXfris?41

ArrfeucdrUdrgdrf(AU)?Dvalcfntstrueecfdilnestdtfdnhnlnstdtfdktlrsglr

cfeataidky dnh angcufnkf lvfr tjf rfcfvdnt plpucdtaln(s). Arrfeucdr wdrgdrf gdvlrs

anharfktdnhdsyiiftrakdpprldkjfs,tjluejatidyfipclytjfguccrdneflgiacatdry

dnh ltjfr kdpdkatafs, an lrhfr tl frlhf dn dhvfrsdrys plwfr, angcufnkf, dnh wacc.

(087)

Ansurefnky? Xjf lrednazfh usf lg su`vfrsaln lr valcfnkf `y d erlup lr

ilvfifnt tjdt sffms tl lvfrtjrlw lr glrkf kjdnef lg d elvfrnane dutjlraty.

Ansurefnkykdndcslrfgfrtltjferlupatsfcg.(0;;)

41OR420HfpdrtifntlgHfgfnsfHaktalndrylgIacatdrydnhDsslkadtfhXfris(Udsjanetln,HK?XjfOlant[tdgg,Dprac

0242).

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

30/122

08 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

Kluntfransurefnky (KLAN)? Kliprfjfnsavfkavacadndnhiacatdryfgglrts tdmfn

tlhfgfdtdnansurefnkydnhtldhhrfssdnyklrferafvdnkfs.(444)

Kluntfrtfrrlrasi (KX)? Dktalns tdmfn harfktcy dedanst tfrrlrast nftwlrms dnh

anharfktcytlangcufnkfdnhrfnhfrecl`dcdnhrfealndcfnvarlnifntsanjlspatd`cftl

tfrrlrastnftwlrms.(44;)

Antfccaefnkf?Xjfprlhuktrfsuctane grli tjfklccfktaln,prlkfssane, antferdtaln,

fvdcudtaln,dndcysas,dnh antfrprftdtalnlgdvdacd`cf anglridtalnklnkfrnane glrfaen

ndtalns, jlstacf lr pltfntadccy jlstacf glrkfs lr fcfifnts, lr drfds lg dktudc lr

pltfntadc lpfrdtalns. Xjf tfri as dcsl dppcafh tl tjf dktavaty wjakj rfsucts an tjf

prlhuktdnhtltjflrednazdtalnsfnedefhansukjdktavaty.(0;8)

[urvfaccdnkf? Xjf systfidtak l`sfrvdtaln lg dfrlspdkf, surgdkf, lr su`surgdkf

drfds,pcdkfs,pfrslns,lr tjanes`yvasudc,durdc,fcfktrlnak,pjltlerdpjak,lrltjfr

ifdns.(867)

Pfklnndassdnkf?Diassalnunhfrtdmfntll`tdan,`yvasudcl`sfrvdtalnlrltjfr

hftfktaln iftjlhs, anglridtaln d`lut tjf dktavatafs dnh rfslurkfs lg dn fnfiy lr

dhvfrsdry, lr tl sfkurf hdtd klnkfrnane tjf iftflrlcleakdc, jyhrlerdpjak, lr

eflerdpjakkjdrdktfrastakslgdpdrtakucdrdrfd.(;1;)

A[P?Dndktavatytjdtsynkjrlnazfsdnhantferdtfstjfpcdnnanednhlpfrdtalnlg

sfnslrs, dssfts, dnh prlkfssane, fxpclatdtaln, dnh hassfiandtaln systfis an harfkt

supplrt lg kurrfnt dnh guturf lpfrdtalns. Xjas as dn antferdtfh antfccaefnkf dnh

lpfrdtalnsgunktaln.(0;5)

Ansuiidry,angcufnkaneglrfaenelvfrnifntsdnhplpucdtalnsasdklipcfxdnhanjfrfntcyplcatakdcdktavaty.Xjfiacatdryrlcfanarrfeucdrwdrgdrfkdipdaensanefnfrdc,dnhKLANan

pdrtakucdr rfquarfs tjf d`acaty tl pcdn, klnhukt, dnh sustdan antferdtfh lpfrdtalns lg

antfrdefnky dnh iuctandtalndc kavacadn dnh iacatdry lrednazdtalns tl supplrt d glrfaen

elvfrnifntlrplpucdtalntjrfdtfnfh`yarrfeucdrdhvfrsdrafs.Anltjfrwlrhs,atrfquarfs

tjfwjlcflgelvfrnifntdpprldkjhfskra`fh`ytjf[fkrftdrafslg[tdtfdnhHfgfnsfantjf

V.[. Elvfrnifnt Kluntfransurefnky Euahf. Ujacf V.[. glrkfs drf supfr`cy trdanfh an tjf

trdhatalndcdspfktslgvalcfntkli`dt,tjfsfarrfeucdrwdrgdrfdnhKLANkdipdaensidygdac

ag wdefh `y iacatdry ifdns dclnf. Eavfn tjdt at as V[E plcaky tl hftfr dnh kluntfr

ansurefnkafs,tjfntjfhfgfnsfantfccaefnkfkliiunatysjluchpcdkfilrffipjdsaslncfgt

lg`dne

`fglrf

tjf

nffh

glr

d

cdref

kliiatifnt

lg

V.[.

kli`dt

trllps

wjacf

dn

ansurefnkyasstaccandnankapafntstdeflghfvfclpifnt,dnhtjdttjfwjlcflgelvfrnifnt

dpprldkjsjluch`feavfntjfkdpd`acatafsnfkfssdrytlsukkffh.A[Psjluch`fkrdgtfhdnh

rfslurkfhtlsupplrttjasdpprldkj.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

31/122

;.XLPXD[M[ 06

;;.. XXLLPPXXDD[[MM[[

;.4. XLPXD[M4?UJDXA[XJFHFWFCLRANEPLCFLGHLHA[PANKLAN

LRFPDXALN[=UJLDPFXJFKV[XLIFP[DNHUJDXDPFXJFPFTVAPFIFNX[

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

32/122

07 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

XjfV[H(A)asdssaenfhrfsplnsa`acatytl?

d. Idantdan stdnhdrhs dnh euahf tjf hfvfclpifnt lg kdpd`acatafs dnh kdpdkaty glr

pfrsastfnt antfccaefnkf, survfaccdnkf, dnh rfklnndassdnkf dnh dssfssifnt lg

lpfrdtalndc drfds dnh fnvarlnifnts tjdt idy sfrvf ds sdgf jdvfns glr arrfeucdr

tjrfdts.

`. Dhvdnkf antfccaefnkf dnh anglridtaln pdrtnfrsjaps watj antfrdefnky dnh

antfrndtalndc pdrtnfrs, ds dpprlpradtf, tl ahfntagy dnh prfvfnt lr hfgfdt arrfeucdr

tjrfdtsgrlistdtfdnhnlnstdtfdktlrsdkrlsslpfrdtalndcdrfdsdnhfnvarlnifnts.

k.Andkklrhdnkfwatjstrdtfeakeuahdnkfhlkuifnts,aiprlvfdccslurkfklccfktalntl

ahfntagyarrfeucdrtjrfdtsgrlistdtfdnhnlnstdtfdktlrs.Fnsurftaifcyanglridtaln

hassfiandtaln grli tjf strdtfeak tl tjf tdktakdc cfvfc, rfklenazane tjdt arrfeucdr

wdrgdrf pcdkfspdrtakucdr rfcadnkf ln rfcfdsd`cfprlhukts tl gdkacatdtfwlrmanewatj

glrfaensfkuratypdrtnfrs.

h.Idndeftjfhfvfclpifntlgdpprlpradtfdndcytakdcantfccaefnkfilhfcs,tllcs,dnhhdtdtlprlvahfantfccaefnkfsupplrttlV.[.DrifhGlrkfsglrarrfeucdrwdrgdrf.

f. Anklrplrdtf antl antfccaefnkf prlhukts anglridtaln hfravfh grli slkadc dnh

`fjdvalrdcskafnkfslurkfsantjfpu`cakdnhpravdtfsfktlrs.

g.Rrlofktdktavatypdttfrnslndrfealndcdnhecl`dcskdcfglrdndcyzane`ltjgrafnhcydnhdhvfrsdryjuidnnftwlrmstjrluejilhfcanednhsaiucdtalnkdpd`acatafs.

e. An klnounktaln watj tjf KKHPs, pralratazf kdpd`acatafs tl ahfntagy, clkdtf, trdkm,

dnh tdreft dhvfrsdry nftwlrms, kfccs, dnh anhavahudcs an lrhfr tl nfutrdcazf tjfarangcufnkfdnhlpfrdtalndckdpdkaty.

j. Rrliltf antfccaefnkf dnh kluntfrantfccaefnkf kdrffr pdtjs tjdt dttrdkt dnh rftdan

tjf qudntaty dnh qudcaty lg pfrslnnfc watj arrfeucdr wdrgdrfrfcfvdnt smaccs, an

kllrhandtaln watj tjf [fkrftdrafs lg tjf Iacatdry Hfpdrtifnts dnh tjf Vnhfr

[fkrftdrylgHfgfnsfglrRfrslnnfcdnhPfdhanfss(V[H(R&P)).00

Xjfrfasdsu`stdntadcedp`ftwffntjfplcakyeuahdnkfdnhatsaipcfifntdtaln.Xjasrfplrt

fxdianfstjlsfrfdslns,ankcuhanetjffxaefnkafslglnelanekli`dtlpfrdtalns.

;.4.4. HFWFCLRANEPLCFLGHLHA[PANKLANLRFPDXALN[

[ankftjf

fnh

lg

tjf

Klch

Udr,

tjf

glkus

lg

tjf

hfgfnsf

antfccaefnkf

kliiunaty

jds

kjdnefh

tl dhhrfss nfw tjrfdts tl V.[. ndtalndc antfrfsts. An dhhataln tl tjf cdref glridtalns lg

rfcdtavfcy stdtak tdrefts kliprasane tjf drifh glrkfs dnh supplrtane angrdstrukturf lg dn

dhvfrsdradcstdtf, tjfhfgfnsf antfccaefnkfkliiunatyiustnlw glkuslnsidcc,haspfrsfh

tdrefts tjdt kjdrdktfrazf sukj nlnstdtf dktlrs ds tfrrlrast dnh ansurefnt nftwlrms. At idy

00A`ah.,7.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

33/122

;.XLPXD[M[ 05

dcslnffhtlsupplrtwjlcflgelvfrnifntKLANstrdtfeafs,dswfccdssupplrttjffgglrtslg

dccafswatjwjakjtjfV.[.idyhfsarftlwlrmwatjanifftaneKLANkjdccfnefsdrlunhtjf

wlrch.[fktaln;.8.4nltfstjdtnftwlrmslgdccafsdnhNELsdrflgtfnanklipdta`cfwatjV.[.

systfis, tjus janhfrane lpfrdtalns tjdt rfquarf rfslurkfs `fylnh tjlsf lg tjf V.[.

elvfrnifnt.

XjfsftjrfdtsdnhnffhshlnltjdvfdkliilnhlktranflrKLNLR[.Xjfyjdvfnfatjfr`ae

saendturfstll`sfrvfnlrfnhuranesaendcstlantfrkfpt.Xjfyklnkfdctjfisfcvfswatjantjf

clkdc plpucdtaln dnh utacazf ecl`dc kliiunakdtalns, gandnkf, dnh tfcfkliiunakdtalns

angrdstrukturfs tl jfcp kliidnh, klntrlc, dnh fxfkutf tjfar lpfrdtalns. Xjfsf tjrfdts drf

jahhfn,idsmfh,dnhgcfftane.Ilrflvfr,kluntfrdktanetjfsftjrfdtsdnhhfnyanetjfitjf

d`acaty tl dkjafvf tjfar plcatakdciacatdry l`ofktavfs rfquarfs nfw dnh haggfrfnt typfs dnh

kli`andtalnslgantfccaefnkf/anglridtaln.

Dhhrfssane tjfsf nfw tjrfdts tjus rfquarfs antfccaefnkf/anglridtaln nlt lncy grli

trdhatalndc

antfccaefnkfslurkfs

dnh

iftjlhs,

`ut

dcsl

grli

dcc

fkjfclns

lg

wdrgaejtfrs

ds

wfcc ds nlntrdhatalndc slurkfs. Xjfrf as nl hliandnt lr sanecf antfccaefnkf haskapcanf lr

slurkflganglridtalntlslcvftjfkjdccfnefsplsfh`yKLANlpfrdtalns.Anhffh,dccslurkf

dnhiuctaANXantfccaefnkfasfssfntadcglrdkjafvanetjfpfrsastfnt,prfhaktavf,dktavaty`dsfh

A[PrfquarfhtlsukkfssguccykluntfrdnansurefnkydssjlwnanXd`cf;.

[fcfktfhA[P[lurkfsglrAU

KLIANX EIXA

FCANX XjfridcDndcysas

GA[ANX Ky`frDktavaty

FL

AIANX

(f.e.,

RDN,

I[A,

GIW)

JVIANX

Antfrrledtaln

PDHDPAIANX [lurkfLpfrdtalns

PGID[ANX Hf`rafganes

FLID[ANX @aliftraks

PDHDPID[ANX JuidnEflerdpjy/XfrrdanDndcysas

EflpjysakdcID[ANX HlkuifntFxpclatdtaln(HLKFZ)

Rlstfvfntglrfnsaks Hf`rafganes

Juidn/KucturdcEflerdpjy [lkadcErlup/NftwlrmHyndiaks

XD@CF;.[FCFKXFHA[P[LVPKF[GLPAPPFEVCDPUDPGDPF

VncamftrdhatalndcA[P,wjfrftjfglkustypakdccyaslntjfclkdtalnlgdndntakapdtfhdktavaty,

A[Pglrarrfeucdrwdrgdrfiustglkuslnhasklvfranetjfunmnlwndktavatylgdndhvfrsdry,

kjdrdktfrazane at,dnhfxpclatane at.GlrsupplrtlgKLANlpfrdtalns atdcslrfquarfsdkcfdr

dnhsustdanfhglkuslnplpucdtalnkfntrakdktavatafssukjdselvfrndnkf,hfvfclpifnt,dnh

clkdc plpucdtaln sliftaifs `fglrf tjf stdrt lg jlstacatafs. Xjas hfidnhs d tjlrluej

unhfrstdnhane lg jastlrakdc, slkalkucturdc, fklnliak, fhukdtalndc, dnh fnvarlnifntdc

dspfktslgtjfdrfdlglpfrdtalnsandhhatalntlplcatakdcdnhiacatdrygdktlrsdnhtrfnhs.Xjas

an turn rfquarfs ilrf `dsak lr gunhdifntdc antfccaefnkf ds wfcc ds dsslkadtfh slkadc,

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

34/122

0: KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

`fjdvalrdc,dnhplcatakdcskafnkfsanglridtalngrlislurkfsantjfpu`cakdnhpravdtfsfktlrs.

Xd`cf8klipdrfsdnhklntrdstsltjfrdspfktslgA[Pglrtrdhatalndcvfrsusarrfeucdrwdrgdrf.

XrdhatalndcUdrgdrfvs.ArrfeucdrUdrgdrf[urvfaccdnkf

XrdhatalndcUdrgdrfKlnkfpts ArrfeucdrUdrgdrfRdrdhaei

UdrXaifJlrazln Pfcdtavfcy[jlrtHfkasavf@dttcfs ClneUdr

RfrsastfntA[P Vn`canmaneFyf[idrtklccfktalnidndefifnt `dsfhln

tjfgrfqufnkylgkjdnef

Rfrsastfnt[urvfaccdnkf [anecf[fnslr08/5,AIANXRFH

Dktavaty[urvfaccdnkf,iuctaANXRFH,

Fxpclatdtalndnhklccfktalnnlclnefr

tfiplrdccysynkjrlnazfh

Eflrfeastrdtaln Hasklvfrytleflrfeastfr Eflrfeastfrtlhasklvfr

KlccfktalnGlkus Xdrefthravfn Dktavatafsdnhtrdnsdktalnshravfn

Antfntlgklccfktaln GanhrfidanfhpafkfstldpuzzcfVnhfrstdnhiystfrafs= Vnrdvfc

nftwlrms

KlccfktalnRfralh Ianutfs/jlurs Uffms/ilntjs

RFHpjaclslpjy AIANX IuctaANX

FxpclatdtalnRrlkfss 4st,0

nh,;

rhpjdsffxpclatdtaln

Xaifpjdsfh,cdyfrfhdpprldkj,Pfdc

taifdnhglrfnsaks

RFHRrlhukts AR@/@HD/LvfrwdtkjRFHidynltyafchdganasjfhantfccaefnkf

prlhukt

Xdrefts IacatdryLrhfrlg@dttcf Rflpcfdnhnftwlrms

Xdreft[aendturfs [lvaftstycfiacatdrysaendturfs

Nlnklnvfntalndcsaendturfssukjds

lrednazdtalndc strukturf,

kliiunakdtalns,ilvfifnt

XdreftAhfntagafr @FNui`fr RrlpfrNdif

HdtdXdeeane

[tlvfpapfh

watjan

ANX

Iftdhdtd

tdeefh

tl

canm

sfnslr

tl

dktavatytleflrfgfrfnkftldktaln

[fnslrutacazdtaln Nltantferdtfh Guccyantferdtfh

HlktranfdnhXXRs UfccFstd`casjfh Nfwklnkfpts,cfdrnanewjacfhlane

Xrdanane [anecfANXspfkadcazdtaln IuctaANXLpsAntfcspfkadcazdtaln

Anglridtalnsjdrane Nffhtlmnlw Nffhtlsjdrf/iuctaANXsynfrey

XD@CF8.XPDHAXALNDCUDPGDPFW[.APPFEVCDPUDPGDPF[VPWFACCDNKF

Dsnltfhd`lvf,tjfrfdrfidolredpsanA[Pkdpd`acatafsdnhkdpdkatafsglrKLANlpfrdtalns,

pdrtakucdrcyanplpucdtalnglkusfhklccfktalndnhdndcysas.Ilrflvfr,tjfrfasdnd`sfnkflg

dndcytakdc kdpd`acaty tjdt dhjfrfs tl iftjlhlcleafs lg ilhfrn slkadc skafnkf dnh

psykjlcleakdcrfsfdrkjtfkjnaqufsdnhdssfssifnttllcs.Xjfd`sfnkflgtjasfxpfrtasfantjf

gafchhfnafsdndcysts,pcdnnfrs,dnhlpfrdtlrsdnaiplrtdntwjdtagtllcglrdssfssanetjf

klnsfqufnkfslgpcdns.

Xl tjdt fnh, tjf Xdsm Glrkf glkusfh ln jlw A[P kdn supplrt tjlsf dspfkts lg KLAN, ds

hfganfh an tjf`rldhfst sfnsf. Xjf Xdsm Glrkf dpprfkadtfs tjf patgdccs lg klnsahfrane tjf

dppcakdtalnlgHlHA[Pkdpd`acatafstjdtel`fylnhtrdhatalndciacatdrylpfrdtalns,`uttjfrf

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

35/122

;.XLPXD[M[ 01

asdnaipcakatnffhtldppcyslifA[Pkdpd`acatafsdedanstdspfktslgKLANtjdtdrfpraidracy

kavacadnanndturf.Agwannanelvfrtjfclkdcplpucdkfastjfeldc,tjfntjfV.[.iustfipcly

A[Pkdpd`acatafsandplpucdtalnkfntrakidnnfrwatjlut,jlwfvfr,prfkcuhaneA[Psanjfrfnt

vdcufanhfdcanewatjansurefntstjrluejmanftakifdns.

An pdrtakucdr, d mfy hfvfclpane rlcf lg Hfgfnsf A[P an KLAN dnh ltjfr arrfeucdr wdrgdrf

rfcdtfh nftwlrm lpfrdtalns as tl prlvahf dktavaty`dsfh antfccaefnkf (D@A). D@A as krlss

haskapcanfdnhiuctaANXdnhasdppcakd`cf`ltjtlpjysakdcdnhnlnpjysakdcdktavatafsdnh

trdnsdktalns, ankcuhane slkalkucturdc`fcafgs dnh`fjdvalrs, gandnkadc trdnsdktalns, lpfn

slurkf anglridtaln,dnhky`frdktavatafs. At cfnhs atsfcg tlunhfrstdnhanepdttfrnslg cagf,

cdrefrslkadcnftwlrms,dnhunusudclrsuspakalusdktavaty.

Xjf`cfnhanelgD@Awatjwahfdrfdsurvfaccdnkf,juidneflerdpjy,dnhltjfrkdpd`acatafs

dppfdrstl`fdpdrtakucdrcyprliasanepdtjglrHlHA[PtlsupplrtKLANlpfrdtalns.[ukj

d`cfnhwaccjfcpsupplrt?

Hftfktaln,eflclkdtaln,dnhkjdrdktfrazdtalnlgtrdnsdktalns/dktavatafs=

Ahfntagakdtalndnheflclkdtalnlgtjffntatafsklnhuktanetrdnsdktalns/dktavatafs=

Ahfntagakdtalndnheflclkdtalnlgnftwlrmsdilnedktlrs/fntatafs=

HfvfclpifntlgpdttfrnslgcagfsupplrtaneA&U,prfhaktavfdndcysas,dnhkluntfr

hfnadcdnhhfkfptaln=dnh

Vnhfrstdnhanetjf`rldhfrantfrdktalns`ftwffn/dilnenftwlrms.

;.4.0. UJLDPFXJFKV[XLIFP[

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

36/122

;2 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

iassalns.Dsdrfsuct,idnydspfktslgtjfKLANkdipdaen,`rldhcyhfganfh,drfrfcdtavfcy

unhfrsfrvfh `y A[P, ankcuhane antfccaefnkf tjdt supplrts dkjafvane tjf trdnsglridtavf

fggfktskdccfh glr`y tjfKliidnhfr lg tjf Antfrndtalndc [fkuratyDssastdnkfGlrkf (A[DG)

dnh tjf Vnatfh [tdtfs Di`dssdhlr tl Dgejdnastdn, ds wfcc ds tl supplrt tl std`acaty

lpfrdtalns

dnh

glrfaen

antfrndc

hfgfnsf.

XlsdytjdtA[PunhfrsfrvfhtjfsfdspfktslgKLANasnltifdntdsdkratakasilgjlwA[Pas

lpfrdtane tlhdy. An idny rfspfkts, A[P as fnlriluscy sukkfssguc an supplrtane tjf

lpfrdtalnslgV.[.glrkfstlhfgfdttfrrlrastsdnhansurefnts.

Ujy jdvf A[P kdpd`acatafs nlt`ffn dppcafh klnsastfntcy dedanst tjlsf dspfkts lg KLAN

lpfrdtalns tjdt hfdc watj plpucdtalns

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

37/122

;.XLPXD[M[ ;4

DkjafvanesfkuratylgtjfplpucdtalnastjfgarststfpandKLANkdipdaen.AnDgejdnastdn,ds

andnyrfealnsu`ofkttldnansurefnky,tjfpflpcfiustgffcgrffgrlivalcfnkfdnhklfrkaln

`y ansurefnts, kraiandcs, dnh tfrrlrasts, dnh iust klif tl trust tjf sfkuraty glrkfs lg tjf

elvfrnifnt tl prltfkt tjfi. Xjf kjdccfnefs tl dkjafvane tjas cfvfc lg sfkuraty an

Dgejdnastdndrfsu`stdntadc?

Xjfrfdrfansuggakafntglrkfsprfsfnt(DgejdnNdtalndc[fkuratyGlrkfs(DN[G)dnh

A[DG)tlsfkurfplpucdtalnkfntfrs.

DgejdnNdtalndcRlcakf(DNR)hfvfclpifntjdscdeefhhuftlklrruptalndnhd`usf,

pllrqudcatydnhftjnak`dcdnkflgrfkruats,jaejkdsudctyrdtfs,dttrataln,andhfqudtf

cleastaks,pllrcfdhfrsjap,ansuggakafntDN[Gkllpfrdtaln,dnhunhfrrfslurkanednh

ifntlrane.

Antfrndtalndciacatdrydktalnrfsuctaneankavacadnkdsudctafsfxdkfr`dtfhplpucdr

ansfkuratydnhankrfdsfhdcafndtaln.

Xl rfifhy tjfsf sjlrtgdccs dnh krfdtf d sfkurf fnvarlnifnt glr tjf plpucdtaln, tjf

IkKjrystdc/Famfn`frrykdipdaenpcdnkdccfhglrtwfcvftdsmstl`ffxfkutfh?

KliiunatyCfvfcXdsms?

Fstd`casj`dsanednhklnhuktlpfrdtalnsglrsfkuratyprfsfnkfankratakdcdrfds.

Pfhukfkavacadnkdsudctafsdnhltjfrdktstjdtkrfdtflpplsatalndilnetjf

plpucdtaln.

PfglridnhifntlrDNRunatstlprltfktkliiunatafsdnhfstd`casjrucflgcdw.

Fnsurf

fqudc

dkkfss

tl

DNR

rfkruatifnt

glr

dcc

plpucdtaln

erlups

tjrluej

plcatakdc

lutrfdkj.

Il`acazfsupplrtdnhtrustglrDN[Gfgglrts.

RrlvankadcCfvfcXdsms?

@uachdnhifntlrKLANkdpd`cfDgejdnNdtalndcDriy(DND)tlhfgfdtantfrndc

tjrfdtsdnhsupplrttjfDNRdsnfkfssdry.

AiprlvfDN[Gantfrlpfrd`acaty,kllrhandtaln,kllpfrdtaln,dnhiutudcsupplrt,

pdrtakucdrcyDNDansupplrtlgtjfDNRanklntfstfhdrfds.

RcdkfDgejdnsankjdreflglpfrdtalnswlrmanetlwdrhstrdnsgfrlgcfdhsfkuratyrfsplnsa`acaty.

NdtalndcCfvfcXdsms?

HfvfclpIanastrylgHfgfnsf(ILH),DNDdnhIanastrylgtjfAntfralr(ILA)

kdpdkatyglrdkkluntd`acaty,antfrlpfrd`acaty,dnhlvfrsaejt.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

38/122

;0 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

HfvfclpstrdtfeafsdnhankfntavfstliataedtfjaejcfvfcslgDN[Gdttrataln.

XdsmsdtdccCfvfcs?

[upplrtrfhuktalnlgDN[Gklrruptalndnhd`usf.

Aiprlvf `lrhfr sfkuraty fgglrts tl stfi krlss `lrhfr gclw lg ansurefnts dnh

ansurefntcleastaks.0;

FdkjlgtjfsftdsmsaipcafshfsaenanedsftlgA[Ptdsms.Glrfxdipcf,tjfgarsttwltdsmsdt

tjf Kliiunaty Cfvfc kdcc glr fstd`casjane`dsane dnh d sfkuraty prfsfnkf an kratakdc drfds

dnhrfhukanekavacadnkdsudctafs(prfsuid`cygrli`ltjansurefntsdnhkldcatalnglrkfs).A[P

supplrtwluchrfquarfsukj`dsakhdtddspjysakdcdssfssifntslgtfrrdan,canfslgsaejt,dnh

dkkfss tl mfy angrdstrukturf. Fqudccy aiplrtdnt wluch `f tjf fvdcudtaln lg nlridc

plpucdtaln ilvfifnt pdttfrnsdnh dktavatafs, kjdrdktfrazdtalnlg kjdnefs anpdttfrns, dnh

dnunhfrstdnhanelgjlwdktavatafsvdryantjfklursflgdhdylrwffm.

Pfhukane plpucdtaln kdsudctafs wluch fntdac hftfrianane tjf prlxaiaty lg ansurefnt

dktavatafstlkavacadnjlifsdnh`usanfssfs.Jlwfvfr,atiaejtdcslifdnhfvfclpanednA[P

strdtfey tlprldktavfcyhftfkt tjrfdtsdedanstmfy clkdc cfdhfrsdnhrfprfsfntdtavfslg clkdc

elvfrnifnt, wdrnane kratfrad glr trdnsiattane tjrfdts tl Dgejdns wjl drf tdreftfh, tjf

kdpd`acatytltrdkmclkdccfdhfrshuranetjrfdtpfralhs,dnhprlkfhurfsglrsfdrkjdnhrfskuf

lgclkdcs.[ukjdnfgglrtwluchnffhtl`fwlrmfhlutwatjclkdcDgejdnplcakf.

A[Plpfrdtalndcpcdnnanewaccnffhtltdmfantldkkluntprltfktalnlgslurkfsdnhiftjlhs,

sjdraneplcakafs,dnhlpfrdtalndc caiatdtalns an tjf clkdcfnvarlnifnt.Ujacffdkjlg tjfsf

assufswaccrfquarfdhfhakdtfhfgglrttlrfslcvf,tjfilstaiplrtdntplantantjasfxdipcfas

tjdt A[P usf sjluch`f`dcdnkfh`ftwffn ganh, gax, dnh ganasj (G;) iassalns dnh harfkt

supplrttlilnatlrtjfsfkuratylgplpucdtalnsdnhmfyanhavahudcs.

0;Vnatfh[tdtfsAntferdtfhKavacadnIacatdryKdipdaenRcdnglr[upplrttlDgejdnastdn,6.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

39/122

;.XLPXD[M[ ;;

;.0. XLPXD[M0?UJDXA[XJFPFKLIIFNHFHDCCLKDXALNDNHV[FLGHLH

A[PPF[LVPKF[XL[V[XDANKLANKDRD@ACAXQDCLNEUAXJLXJFP

KLIRFXANEANXFCCAEFNKFPFTVAPFIFNX[,GLPFZDIRCFKX

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

40/122

;8 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

tjfy wacc krfdtf prl`cfis ag pcdnnfh dnh klnhuktfh watjlut rfedrh glr tjf rfcdtalnsjaps

dilneKLAN,KX,dnhKAFHlpfrdtalns.

Xjfklipcfxatylg KLANdnhltjfrkluntfrnftwlrmlpfrdtalnsrfquarfs dstrdtfeakrdtjfr

tjdndhjlkdpprldkjtlA[Piassalnidndefifnt.Xjfantfccaefnkfrfquarfifntstlsupplrt

dplpucdtalnkfntrakKLANstrdtfeydrfhaggfrfntgrlitjlsftlkluntfrtfrrlrastnftwlrms.An

pdrtakucdr,tjfskdcfdnherdnucdratylganglridtalnrfquarfhtldssfsspdttfrnslg`fjdvalrdt

clkdc, tra`dc, dnh slkaftdc cfvfcs dnh kliprfjfnh tjdt dktavaty drf haggfrfnt. Dn drrdy lg

klccfktaln dssfts dnh sfnslr pjfnlifnlcley ds wfcc ds dsslkadtfh tdsmane, prlkfssane,

fxpclatdtaln,dnhhassfiandtalnkdpd`acatafsdrf`fanefipclyfh tll`tdandnh unhfrstdnh

pfrtanfnthdtddnh anglridtaln.Xjfsfkdpd`acatafsdrftypakdccynlt`fanelrkjfstrdtfh and

wdy tl fnsurf tjdt kratakdc qufstalns d`lut tjf KLAN kdipdaen kdn `f dnswfrfh.

Vnglrtundtfcy,tjfKLANkdipdaendppfdrstl`fdsfklnhdry,lrpfrjdpstfrtadry,pralraty

glr A[P,`fjanh glrkfprltfktalndnhKX.KLAN unhfrtdmfncfgtlg`dne jlwfvfr,lggfrs

tjfpltfntadctlhaianasjtjfnffhglrsu`sfqufntglrkfprltfktalndnhfvfnKXlpfrdtalns.

Ds tjf 0244NdtalndcIacatdry

[trdtfey

nltfs? Ujacf sukj ]KXY lpfrdtalns hasrupt an tjf

sjlrttfri, tjfy kdnnlt`f hfkasavf dnh hl nlt klnstatutf d vad`cf clnetfri strdtfey glr

kli`dtanefxtrfiasi.06

XjfXdsmGlrkfsanvfstaedtalnlgA[Plpfrdtalnstlhdyglunhdjaejhferfflgfipjdsasln

iassalnstjdtanvlcvftjfrdpahhfgfdtlgtfrrlrastnftwlrmstjrluejtjffggfktavfdppcakdtaln

lgG;tdktaks.XjfXdsmGlrkfhahnltganhdkcfdrdrtakucdtalnlgtjfhfsarfh`dcdnkf`ftwffn

tjlsf iassalns dnh tjf iassalns tjdt drf spfkagafh an tjfIkKjrystdc/Famfn`frry kdipdaen

pcdn.07

Xjf hfgfnsf antfccaefnkf kucturf as fvlcvane sclwcy tl ifft tjf hfidnhs lg supplrtane

iuctailhdc, jy`rah lpfrdtalns (dnh wjlcflgelvfrnifnt lpfrdtalns). Xjdt kucturf as

praidracy glkusfh ln tdreftffrane dnh wfdplnffrane tl fnd`cf V.[. iacatdry glrkfs tl

hfstrlyfnfiykli`dtdntsdnhtjfarwdridmanekdpdkaty.Andhhataln,HlHtrdhfkrdgtdnh

kucturfsfpdrdtftdreftffrsdnhefnfrdcdndcysts.Xjfrfasansuggakafntdttfntalntltjfnffhtl

prlvahf antfccaefnkf supplrt lg klipcfx lpfrdtalns dnh kluntfrdkt jy`rah, iuctailhdc

klngcakt. Ds tjf KLAN prl`cfi `fklifs ilrf strdtfeak dnh prfvdcfnt, tjf fxpfrtasf lg

lpfrdtlrs nffhs tl`f ilrfkclsfcyklupcfhwatj tjfefnfrdcdndcystdnhwatjdndcysts an

gafchsrdneanegrlitdreftdndcysasdnhiassalnpcdnnanetltjfslkadcskafnkfs.

Gandccy, tjf nffh tl dhhrfss KLAN kluntfrantfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts rfquarfs ilrf

fipjdsas.JdrhcfsslnsanArdqdnhDgejdnastdn,nlttlifntalnltjfrfnvarlnifnts(grliDcefrad tl Cf`dnln) unhfrsklrf tjf slpjastakdtfh antfccaefnkf kdpd`acatafs lg ansurefnt

ilvfifnts. Xjfsf kdpd`acatafs prlvahf ansurefnts tjf ifdns tl angactrdtf elvfrnifnt

fntatafscfgtlg`dne, tldntakapdtf tjfiacatdrylpfrdtalnslg tjfelvfrnifnts tjfy gaejt,

06XjfNdtalndcIacatdry[trdtfeylgtjfVnatfh[tdtfslgDifrakd,7.

07Vnatfh[tdtfsElvfrnifntAntferdtfhKavacadnIacatdryKdipdaenRcdnglr[upplrttlDgejdnastdn.

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

41/122

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

42/122

;7 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

pcdndkllrhandtfhA[Pstrdtfeyglrdkjafvanedhfsarfhfggfkt,tjdtas,tjfnffhfhmnlwcfhef

tl fxfkutf d kliplnfntlg tjfKLANpcdn.Xjas sjagt glrkfs dilrfhyndiak rfcdtalnsjap

`ftwffntjfusfr,fntfrprasf,dnhklccfktalnpcdtglri,dnhhravfsdkllrhandtfhfgglrtdkrlss

antfccaefnkf defnkafs tjdt elfs `fylnh saipcf tdreftane iassalns tjdt kdn typakdccy `f

hfskra`fh

ds

tjf

G;

iassaln

lg

KX.

Gaeurf

7

`fclw

accustrdtfs

tjas

haggfrfnkf

dnh

jlw

tjdt

cfdhstldhaggfrfntsftlgqufstalnstjdtiust`fdnswfrfh`ytjfantfccaefnkfklccfktlrdnh

dndcyst.Xjfprlkfss gclwln tjf cfgt asusfhilrfkliilncydnh tjf gclwln tjf raejt as

wjdttjfXdsmGlrkfvafwsdsnffhfhpdrtakucdrcyandklipcfxKLANklntfxt.

GAEVPF7.HF[APFHKJDNEFANA[PXD[MANERPLKF[[

Gaeurf 7 kdpturfs tjf mfy kjdnefsnffhfh`ut as saipcastak.Dilrfhfsarfh fnh stdtf as

accustrdtfhanGaeurf5.

GAEVPF5.FGGFKX[@D[FHA[PXD[MANERPLKF[[

@y glkusanefgglrts tlwdrhdkjafvanednfggfkt,iuctapcdtglri klccfktaln strdtfeafswacc`f

rfganfh, tjf antfntlg tjfusfrwacc`f sdtasgafh,dnh andpprlpradtf A[P rfqufsts kdusfh`y

cdkmlgusfrmnlwcfheflnA[Pkdpd`acatafsasnuccagafh.Fggfkts`dsfhA[Pfnd`cfsdndcyststl

`filrf annlvdtavfdnh krfdtavf anhfvfclpane klccfktaln strdtfeafsdnh gusaneiuctaANX

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

43/122

;.XLPXD[M[ ;5

hdtd strfdis. Xl grff up tjf dndcyst tl prl`cfislcvf dnh strdtfeakdccy pcdn, dutlidtfh

iftjlhs iust `f hfvfclpfh (lr aiprlvfh) tl glkus tjf dndcyst ilrf quakmcy ln

qufstalnd`cfdktavatydnhdutlidtfhtllcs`uacttldkklipcasjrlutanf`llmmffpanetdsms.

Dgffh`dkmifkjdnasiaskratakdctlsukkfssgucfggfkts`dsfhA[Ptldssurfusfrantfntasift.

Ahfdccy, tjas gffh`dkm ifkjdnasi anvlcvfs d rfdctaif kliiunakdtalns canm`ftwffn tjf

usfr, dndcyst, dnh klccfktlr tl gdkacatdtf aiifhadtf rfdttdkm lg d tdreft hfkm wjacf tjf

pcdtglriasstaccantjfdrfdlgantfrfst.Xjasrfdctaifklccd`lrdtalndcsldcclwstjfglchanean

lgfifrefntlpplrtunatafslgjaejfrpralratytltjfusfr.

;.0.;. DGLPIDCDRRPLDKJXLNFFH@D[FHDNDCQ[A[

AtasaiplrtdnttldcclkdtfA[Prfslurkfs`dsfhlndraelrlusplrtglcalidndefifntprlkfss

tjdt`dcdnkfshfsarfhlpfrdtalndcnffhstlhdydnhtjlsfdntakapdtfhantjfguturf.KLANA[P

rfquarfifnts sjluch`f sffn an tjf klntfxt lg tjf gucc spfktrui lg arrfeucdr wdrgdrf A[P

rfquarfifnts.An

dhhataln,

KLAN

A[P

rfquarfifnts

sjluch

`f

sffn

an

tjf

klntfxt

lg

tjf

A[P

rfquarfifnts glr jy`rah, iuctailhdc sfkuraty lpfrdtalns. Xjf Xdsm Glrkf`fcafvfs tjdt

tjfrfassu`stdntadclvfrcdpantjfA[Prfslurkfsrfquarfhdclnetjasspfktrui.Jlwfvfr,tjf

`uheft prlkfss jds gdacfh tl rfklenazf KLAN lpfrdtalns ds hastankt grli KX, KAFH dnh

ltjfr arrfeucdr wdrgdrf rfquarfifnts. Xjas kdusfh tjf A[P rfquarfifnts prlkfss tl smfw

dedanst,dnh anslifkdsfs,lvfrcllm aiplrtdntKLANrfcdtfh A[Pkdpd`acatafs,rfsuctane an

dnunhfranvfstifntlgRjdsf2dnhRjdsf4KLANlpfrdtalnA[Prfquarfifntsdstjfyrfcdtf

tl ankapafnt ansurefnkafs dnh plpucdtalnkfntrak sfkuraty lpfrdtalns. Dppcyane d glridc

plrtglcalidndefifntdpprldkjwluchfnsurfdilrfraelrlusdnhtrdnspdrfntprlkfss`y

wjakjA[Prfslurkfdcclkdtalnskdn`fidhfansupplrtlgKLANdnhdccltjfrantfrrfcdtfh

ilhfslgsfkuratylpfrdtalns.

[ukj d prlkfss kdn`f dppcafh dt d nui`fr lg fkjfclns grli, glr fxdipcf, d spfkagak A[P

iassalnpcdn,tltjfRFHprlkfss,tltjflvfrdccA[Piassalndrkjatfkturf,lrtlstrdtfeycfvfc

glridolrA[Pdkquasatalnhfkasalns.Anfdkjkdsf,tjfmfyastlstdrtwatjtjfl`ofktavfsdnh

hftfrianf tjf `fst lptaln rdtjfr tjdn tjf ilrf tfiptane prdktakf lg stdrtane watj tjf

gdiacadr lptaln. Ds nltfh an d prfvalus H[@ rfplrt, tjf usf lg glridc hfkasalnsupplrt

dpprldkjfs (ankcuhane systfis dndcysas dnh lpfrdtalns rfsfdrkj) kdn dah an tjf

hfvfclpifntlgdnA[Pplrtglcal,dswfccdsantjfsfcfktalnlgspfkagakrfslurkfstldkjafvf

spfkagakpurplsfs.0:

Glcclwanesukj

dn

dpprldkj

wacc

jfcp

fnsurf

tjdt

tjf

klipcfxaty

lg

KLAN

A[P

rfquarfifnts

asguccydpprfkadtfh,dnhtjdttjfsfrfquarfifntsdrfeavfnprlpfrdttfntalnantjfrfslurkf

dcclkdtalnprlkfss.[ukjdndpprldkjkdnjfcp`dcdnkfKLANdnhltjfrrfquarfifnts,dnh

dcclwA[Prfslurkfstl`fdkquarfhdnhidndefhantjfklntfxtlgtjfwahfrrfquarfifntslg

dilrfklipcfx,wjlcflgelvfrnifntdpprldkj.

0:Pfplrt lg tjfHfgfnsf [kafnkf@ldrhXdsm Glrkf ln AntfccaefnkfLpfrdtalnsPfsfdrkjDppcakdtalnsglr Antfccaefnkf,

[urvfaccdnkf,dnhPfklnndassdnkf(Udsjanetln,HK?Hfgfnsf[kafnkf@ldrh,Odnudry0221).

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

44/122

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

45/122

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

46/122

82 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

rdtjfrtjdnantfrisgdiacadrtltjfAK=tjdtas,tjfydrfdrtakucdtfhankustlifrspfdmrdtjfr

tjdnAKspfdm.[lifkustlifrshlnltmnlwjlwtlkliiunakdtfglridccywatjtjfAKtl

fnsurf tjfar rfquarfifnts drf dhhrfssfh. Ds d rfsuct, KLAN antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts drf

nltidtfradccyaipdktaneA[Pklccfktalns.Dsfvahfnkf,tjfXdsmGlrkfnltfstjdttjfhfgfnsf

antfccaefnkf

kliiunaty

jds

nlt

trdnscdtfh

tjf

kliidnhfrs

antfnt

ds

stdtfh

an

tjf

V[E

Antferdtfh KavacadnIacatdry Kdipdaen Rcdn glr [upplrt tl Dgejdnastdn antl antfccaefnkf

rfquarfifnts tl supplrt KLAN lpfrdtalns. Dctjluej tjas pcdn wds prliucedtfh tl

drtakucdtftjfstrdtfeydnhtdsmsrfquarfhtldkjafvfV.[.dnhdccafhKLANl`ofktavfs,tjfrfas

nldsslkadtfhsftlgantfccaefnkfrfquarfifntshfravfhtlsupplrtfxfkutalnlgtjfpcdn.Nlr

as tjfrf d stdnhane tfipcdtf lg antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnts tl supplrt KLAN lpfrdtalns an

efnfrdc.

Cllmane dt tjf prl`cfi grli tjf AKs pfrspfktavf, tjfrf drf nl ifkjdnasis glr

systfidtakdccyrfklrhanednhglcclwaneuplntjfsdtasgdktalnlgantfccaefnkfrfquarfifntsds

tjfy pfrtdan tl tjf haggfrfnt kliplnfnts lg d KLAN kdipdaen. Glr fxdipcf, tjf

rfquarfifntshdtd`dsfkdccfhKLCA[FVIhlfsnltprlvahftjfklntfxt`fjanhrfqufstsglranglridtaln. Ds d rfsuct, ilst rfquarfifnts drf cfvafh lutsahf tjf KLCA[FVI prlkfss

tjrluejlnflnlnfhaskussalnsdnhfidacs.

Xl rfifhy tjas satudtaln, tjf Xdsm Glrkf rfkliifnhs tjdt tjf HNA dnh tjf V[H(A)

unhfrtdmfdkliprfjfnsavfanvfntlrylgantfccaefnkfrfquarfifntsdstjfypfrtdantlKLAN,

ankcuhanewjl lraeandtfh tjf rfquarfifnts,jlw tjfy drfrfklrhfhdnhhastra`utfh tl tjf

AK,tjfpralraty,dnhdndssfssifntlgjlwwfcctjfAKassfrvakanetjlsfrfquarfifnts.[ukj

dn anvfntlry sjluch sfrvf ds tjf garst stfp an hfvfclpane d kliprfjfnsavf, systfidtak

prlkfss glr euahane AK klccfktaln dnh dndcysas tl supplrt kustlifr nffhs watj rfspfkt tl

KLAN.

Xjf anglridtalnnffhslg KLANdnh ltjfrklipcfxlpfrdtalns rfquarf diax lgklccfktaln

kdpd`acatafsgrliidnyantfccaefnkfhaskapcanfs.Kurrfntiftjlhsglrpcdnnanednhgandnkane

guturfklngcaktsdrfcdrefcyhravfn`ypcdnnaneglrIdolrKli`dtLpfrdtalns(IKLs).Xjas

cfdhstldnai`dcdnkflgguturf anvfstifntwfaejtfhtlwdrh cdrefklccfktalnsystfis.Xjas

ankcuhfs wahf drfd pfrsastfnt survfaccdnkf kdpd`acatafs, gucc iltaln vahfl (GIW), saendcs

antfccaefnkf([AEANX),erlunhilvanetdreftanhakdtaln(EIXA),cdsfrhftfktalndnhrdneane,

kliputfr nftwlrm fxpclatdtaln, gandnkadc antfccaefnkf (GANANX), hlkuifnt fxpclatdtaln,

JVIANX,dnh`aliftraks.HlHgafchfhdnhprlerdiifhdvdstdrrdylgtfkjnakdcklccfktaln

kdpd`acatafstjdtkdn`ffipclyfhfggfktavfcytliffttjftrdhatalndcKLANkjdccfnef.

JVIANXdnh[pfkadcLpfrdtalnsGlrkfs([LG)tjdtdrfdssaenfhandpdrtakucdrkluntrylr

rfealn lvfr dn fxtfnhfh pfralh lg taif drf pdrtakucdrcy vdcud`cf dssfts glr klccfktane

anglridtaln tl supplrt KLAN lpfrdtalns. Kdsf lggakfrs dnh [pfkadc Glrkfs pfrslnnfc wjl

drf aiifrsfh an tjf cdneudef dnh kucturf lg d pdrtakucdr slkafty drf kratakdc slurkfs glr

klccfktane anglridtaln tl mffp d ganefr ln tjf pucsf lg d plpucdtaln dnh supplrt KLAN

lpfrdtalns.Glrfxdipcf,tjfIdranfKlrpsFxpfhatalndryAntfccaefnkfPldhIdp(nlwanhrdgt)

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

47/122

;.XLPXD[M[ 84

jaejcaejtstjfnffhglrdrkjavanednhilhfcaneslkadchyndiakswatjanpdrtakucdrkucturfs=

fggfktavfcy`raneanetleftjfrtjfwlrmlgjunhrfhslgdndcystsglrusf`ytjfVnatfh[tdtfs

IdranfKlrps(V[IK).Xjaswlrmiust`ffnklurdefhdnhdcclwfhtlerlw.@utlgtfntjas

asnltjdppfnane.Lnfsfnalrantfccaefnkflggakfrwatjyfdrslggafchfxpfrafnkfplantfhlut

tjdtiahcfvfcidndefrsdtidolrantfccaefnkfdefnkafshlnltfnklurdefcdneudeftrdanane

lrtlursantjfgafch,dnhanslifkdsfshasklurdeftjfsfdctleftjfr.XjfXdsmGlrkflutcanfh

tjrluejlut tjas rfplrt slif rfkliifnhdtalns, wjakj ag aipcfifntfh an d sustdanfh

idnnfr,waccjfcpaiprlvftjfAKsd`acatytlunhfrstdnhdnhrfplrtlnclkdckucturfs.

An rfkfnt yfdrs tjf HlHs A[P klccfktaln anvfstifnt nfkfssdracy glkusfh ln ifftane tjf

rfquarfifntslgtjfkurrfntklngcakt,rfsuctaneantjfprlkurfifntlgdsuatflgsfnslrsdnh

pcdtglris tjdtdrflptaiazfh glrklccfktaln anhfsfrtdnhiluntdanlus tfrrdans.Ilrflvfr,

tjfsf sfnslrs drf cdrefcy hfsaenfh (dnh fipclyfh) tl supplrt G; lpfrdtalns tjdt drf

nfkfssdryglrklnhuktaneKXdnhkli`dtlpfrdtalns.XjasfipjdsascfdvfsHlHpltfntadccy

sjlrtantjfd`acatytlklccfktanltjfrtypfslgtfrrdan.(f.e.ounecf)dswfccdsltjfrpjdsfslg

tjfKLANiassaln(f.e.,wjfrfansurefntsidy`fstdrtanetlturndplpucdtalnerlup).Andhhataln,tjfidsslghdtd`faneklccfktfh`ytjfpcdtglrisdnhsfnslrskurrfntcy anusf as

glrkanetjfnffhtl`uachdilrffggfktavfRFHkdpd`acaty,lnftjdtprlvahfsswagtfrglrfnsaks

tl fxdianf dnh dndcyzf dntfkfhfnt dktavatafs, dcclws glr dccslurkf dndcysas, dnh idmfs

`fttfr usf lg`dnhwahtj dnh kliiunakdtaln kdpd`acatafs. [u`stdntadc fgglrts lg HlHs A[P

XdsmGlrkfdrfunhfrwdytldhhrfsstjasprl`cfi,`utnfwRFHsystfisdnhXXRsiust`f

fipclyfhtljdnhcftjfgcllhlgnfwklccfktalnhdtd.Xjaswaccnfkfssatdtfidssavfkjdnefs

ankucturftlpfriatilrfdutlidtaln,tjfhaskdrhanelgcfssusfguchdtd,dnhtjfdkkfptdnkf

lgnfwglridtslgA[Prfplrtane.

Uatjantjfkurrfntlpfrdtalndcfnvarlnifnt,tjfrfdrfgfwfggfktavf,tfiplrdccydkkfptd`cf

iftjlhlcleafs glr tjf antferdtaln (lr gusaln) lg kurrfnt cfvfcs lg hdtd strfdiane grli tjf

idny spdkf`dsfh, dar`lrnf, il`acf, an satu, dnh tfrrfstradc rfiltf sfnslrs, cft dclnf rfdc

taif antferdtaln. Xjas aipfhfs HlHs d`acaty tl cfvfrdef iuctapcf, nftwlrmfh

sfnslr/pcdtglri kli`andtalns an d taifcy gdsjaln tl dkjafvf hliandnt satudtalndc

dwdrfnfss. Xjas gusaln prl`cfi wacc lncy`f fxdkfr`dtfh`y tjf gcllh lg hdtd grli nfw

klccfktalnsystfisd`luttl`fgafchfh.

Fgglrts drf unhfrwdy tl klrrfkt tjf idssavf prl`cfis lg hdtd dkkfss. Xjf Anglridtaln

[jdraneAntferdtfhRrlhuktXfdi(ARX),fstd`casjfhunhfrtjfduspakfslgtjfV[H(A),glrtjf

purplsf lgsynkjrlnazane anglridtaln sjdrane anatadtavfs ansupplrt lg A[DG rfquarfifnts

dnhVnatfh[tdtfsglrkfsanDgejdnastdn,idhfsu`stdntadcprlerfss.Jlwfvfr,tjfA[PXdsmGlrkfsjluchvasatfdkjlgtjfidanhassfiandtalnnlhfs(sukjdstjfHastra`utfhKliiln

Erlunh[tdtaln(HKE[))tlhftfrianftjffxtfnttlwjakjdndcyststjfrfjdvftjfnfkfssdry

tllcs tl fxfkutf tjfar`dsak KLAN iassaln dnh idmf nfkfssdry quakm gax anvfstifnts tl

rfifhysjlrtgdccs.

An dhhataln, tjf plrtglcal dndcysas dpprldkj hfskra`fh an tjf prfvalus sfktaln wluch dcsl

jfcpfstd`casjd`fttfr,sjlrttfriplrtglcaldnh`dcdnkflgA[PrfslurkfsglrkurrfntKLAN

7/28/2019 Defense Science Board Task Force on Defense Intelligence, Counterinsurgency (COIN) Intelligence, Surveillance, a

48/122

80 KLANA[PLRFPDXALN[

lpfrdtalns.Lvfrtaif,fxpdnhfhsaiucdtaln,ediane,dnhgafchtfstanesjluch`ffipclyfh

tlsupplrtdssfssifntslgjlwA[Pklccfktalndnhdndcysaskdn`faiprlvfhdsatdppcafstld

KLAN kdipdaen. Glr fxdipcf, klccfktaln efliftrafs lg tdreft drfds drf haggfrfnt glr fdkj

rfealn wjfrf ansurefnkafs fxast lr kluch tdmf rllt. Glr anstdnkf, Dgejdnastdn as

prfhliandtfcy

rurdc,

watj

jaej

fcfvdtalns,

wahfcy

haspfrsfh

clne

dnh

ndrrlw

sfttcfifnts,

dnhgfwvfjakcfs=wjacfArdqjdslnfcdrefhfnsfcyplpucdtfhur`dndrfd,wjfrfvfjakcfsdrf

dttrdktavftdreftsglrtrdkmane.

Xl gdkacatdtf tjas saiucdtaln fgglrt, HlH iaejt klnsahfr ilhagyane lr klnstruktane d tfst

rdnefaniluntdanlustfrrdanhfsaenfhtldssfssKLAN assufs.[ukjdrdnefiaejt ankcuhf

wahfcyhaspfrsfh vaccdefs tl gdkacatdtf dnh fvdcudtf nfw klccfktaln dnh sdipcane

strdtfeafs,dswfccdstltfstdctfrndtavfsfkuratyKLNLR[dnhplcakafs.

Gandccy, tjfrf as nl dppdrfnt glridc AK prlkfss glr dssfssane AK pfrglridnkf dedanst d

kustlifrs dccslurkf rfquarfifnts (a.f., iftraks) spfkagakdccy glr KLAN dnh ifdsurane

tjf lpplrtunaty klst glr aipcfifntane sukj nfw rfquarfifnts.01 Gurtjfr, iftraks tjdtfvdcudtfprlerfsslgtjfansurefnky,dssffngrlitjfvafwplantlgtjfansurefntcfdhfrsjap,

drf d kratakdc dnh lgtfn lvfrcllmfh antfccaefnkf rfquarfifnt.;2 Xjas rfh pfrspfktavf

dndcysas iust hrdw upln d hffp unhfrstdnhane lg tjf vdcufs dnh eldcs lg ansurefnt

cfdhfrsjap. D rfvafw lg pltfntadc iftraks glr antfccaefnkf supplrt tl KLAN sjluch `f

unhfrtdmfn`y V[H(A) (dnh pfrjdps tjf HNA) ds pdrt lg dn lvfrdcc duhat lg antfccaefnkf

rfquarfifnts.

;.;.0. A[PAN[VRRLPXLGUJLCFLGELWFPNIFNX,RLRVCDXALNKFNXPAKKLAN

ANAXADXAWF[

Dcilst dcc hfganatalns lg KLAN lpfrdtalns kdcc glr tjf anvlcvfifnt dnh klnstruktavf

pdrtakapdtalnlgtjfwjlcflgelvfrnifnt,watjkavacadndefnkafsantjfcfdhdnhtjfiacatdry

andsupplrtanerlcfdndpprldkjlutcanfh`ytjf0221V.[.ElvfrnifntKluntfransurefnky

Euahf. Xjf dktavf dnh klnstruktavf pdrtakapdtaln dnh cfdhfrsjap lg dccafs, NELs, d tdreft

ndtalns cfeataidtf elvfrnifnt, dnh tjf dggfktfh plpucdtaln, ds wfcc ds tjf iacatdry,

wlrmane tleftjfr`dsfh ln d kljfrfnt strdtfey as tjf ilst camfcy pdtj tl dkjafvane V.[.

KLAN l`ofktavfs. HlH cfdhfrs sjluch idmf tjf kdsf glr sukj d strdtfey dnh wlrm watj

cfdhfrs lg ltjfr defnkafs tl krfdtf tjf kdpdkaty glr d wjlcflgelvfrnifnt dpprldkj. A[P

rfslurkfpcdnnanesjluchtdmfantldkklunttjfnffhslgdwjlcflgelvfrnifntdpprldkj,

dnhtjfnffhtlsupplrtHlHdnhnlnHlHkliplnfnts.

Andsaiacdrvfan,A[Prfslurkfpcdnnanesjluchdkkliilhdtffifreaneplpucdtalnkfntrak

klnkfptsdswfcc.HlHjdstdmfnslifstfpsantjasharfktaln.[tuhafslnpdttfrnslgcagfdn