8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 1/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZJBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

CGCGY $ TBO OGZ[ FFUH@AO \/ CGCGY& ZIO ;>5>9Gmbnf8 HCgcgyEcto/j`mGFFN@[ Y/ UG[GYZ& ZIO 271<51Gmbnf8 GUg{gyzEcto/j`mMNJABGF K/ JGFN@& ZIO 2><>>1Gmbnf8 MJgfn`Ecto/j`m

IGOHBMNO I/ BW& ZIO 9:<17;Gmbnf8 IBwEcto/j`m<25 Zboz`mg Z{ygg{Zbo Dybojnzj`& JB >;222-2<5;[gfgua`og8 !;27. :>2-7;55Dbjznmnfg8 !;27. :><-<211

JBFK\GFF FGZFNG $ UY@J[@Y& UJBOKYG\ GZIGOZABKG& ZIO 959:52Gmbnf8 gzigozabkgEjbfk|gff-fgzfng/j`m2555 \nfzanyg I`wfgtbyk& Zwn{g 455F`z Bolgfgz& JB >552<-9;4:[gfgua`og8 !92:. 49>->5;5Dbjznmnfg8 !92:. 49>->599

B{{`yog~z d`y Kgdgokbo{ IYWJG CBYB[X

WON[GK Z[B[GZ KNZ[YNJ[ J@WY[

JGO[YBF KNZ[YNJ[ @D JBFND@YONB

\GZ[GYO KNTNZN@O

WON[GK Z[B[GZ @D BMGYNJB&

Ufbno{ndd&

t/

IYWJG CBYB[X&

Kgdgokbo{/

Jbzg O`/ JY O`/ 5>-595:-@K\

KGDGOKBO[ IYWJG CBYB[X„ZM@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^AGBYNOL YGLBYKNOL[GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF\N[OGZZGZ3 MGM@YBOKWM @DU@NO[Z BOK BW[A@YN[NGZ NOZWUU@Y[ [AGYG@D

Kb{g8 Dgiywby~ 1& 9525[nmg8 22855 b/m/J`wy{y``m8 22Hwklg8 A`o/ @{nz K/ \ynla{ NN

Uyg-[ynbf J`od/8 Dgiywby~ 1& 9525[ynbf Kb{g8 Dgiywby~ 9:& 9525

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 2 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 2/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

nKGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

[BIFG @D J@O[GO[Z 

Ublg

MGM@YBOKWM @D U@NO[Z BOK BW[A@YN[NGZ///////////////////////////////////////////2

N/  NO[Y@KWJ[N@O/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 2

NN/  DBJ[Z/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////;

B/  Hbmgz H`aoz`o dbfzgf~ kgongz {` {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ agmbkg z{b{gmgo{z {` Nygff no kgdgozg `d Iywjg Cbyb{x bokCI A`mg„z z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uy`jgzz/ ///////////////////////////////////////////////;

I/  Lby~ Yb~ ufgbkz lwnf{~ {` `og j`wo{ `d `iz{ywj{n`o `d  hwz{njg wokgy m`wo{nol uygzzwyg bd{gy abtnol kgdgokgk {`{ag l`tgyomgo{ CI A`mg„z z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uy`jgzz/ ///////////////////22

NNN/  BYLWMGO[ ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2;

B/  Iywjg Cbyb{x„z nobinfn{~ {` jbff Hbmgz H`aoz`o bok Lby~Yb~ bz |n{ogzzgz `o anz igabfd abmugyz anz binfn{~ {` uw{`o b kgdgozg/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2;

I/  @of~ b uyg-{ynbf gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol |nff bff`| {ag J`wy{bok kgdgozg j`wozgf {` woj`tgy {ag {ywg jnyjwmz{bojgzwokgy |anja Hbmgz H`aoz`o bok Lby~ Yb~ igjbmgl`tgyomgo{ |n{ogzzgz/ ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2>

NT/  J@OJFWZN@O /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////95

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 9 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 3/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

nnKGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

[BIFG @D BW[A@YN[NGZ 

Ublg!z.

 Dgkgybf Jbzgz

 By{awy Bokgyzgo FFU t/ Won{gk Z{b{gz7;; W/Z/ 4>4 !9557. /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////21

Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Blwnfby 727 W/Z/ 7>: !2>>7. ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2<& 21

Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Ifbjc <4< D/9k 2::; !>{a Jny/ 2>17.////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 2;

Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Kgflbk`-Jbykgobz><; D/9k 29: !>{a Jny/ 2>>9.//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 27

Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Kwoo;:; D/ Zwuu/ 9k 295: !M/K/ Bfb/ 9554. //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////21

Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Ny|no429 D/9k 2219 !>{a Jny/ 2>15.////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 24

Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ F`ugx; D/:k 2;77 !>{a Jny/ 2>>:.//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////27

Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Yg~gz7<< D/:k 254> !>{a Jny/ 955>.//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 2& 9

Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ ZbmwgfnO`/ JY 51-55274-JHJ/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// :

\bzanol{`o t/ [gqbz:11 W/Z/ 2; !2>4<. ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////2;

\ynla{ t/ Knjcnoz`o

::4 D/9k 1<1 !>{a Jny/ 2>4;./////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////24Dgkgybf Z{b{w{gz

21 W/Z/J/ ¬ :<2//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 22

21 W/Z/J/ ¬ 2729!i./////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////21

21 W/Z/J/ ¬ 272>////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////22& 29

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg : `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 4/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZJBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

[@ [AG WON[GK Z[B[GZ @D BMGYNJB BOK N[Z J@WOZGF @D

YGJ@YK8

UFGBZG [BCG O@[NJG {ab{ b{ {ag {nmg bok ufbjg zg{ d`y{a bi`tg& `y bz

z``o {agygbd{gy bz {ag mb{{gy mb~ ig agbyk& Kgdgokbo{ Iywjg Cbyb{x |nff m`tg {ag

J`wy{ {` j`okwj{ b uyg-{ynbf gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol no `ykgy {` gquf`yg bok rwgz{n`o

|n{ogzzgz wokgy `b{a yglbyknol {ag dbfzg kgonbfz mbkg i~ Hbmgz H`aoz`o {` {ag

l`tgyomgo{ yglbyknol anz uygtn`wz z{b{gmgo{z {` Nygff $ Mbogffb FFU fb|~gyz&

|anja |gyg gqjwfub{`y~ {` My/ Cbyb{x& bok anz zwizgrwgo{ bf{gygk {gz{nm`o~ no

dbt`y `d {ag l`tgyomgo{„z jbzg blbnoz{ My/ Cbyb{x/

M`yg`tgy& My/ Cbyb{x m`tgz {ag J`wy{ {` j`okwj{ b uyg-{ynbf gtnkgo{nby~

agbynol `o {ag jnyjwmz{bojgz wokgy |anja Lby~ Yb~ igjbmg b j``ugyb{nol

l`tgyomgo{ |n{ogzz i~ ufgbknol lwnf{~ {` j`okwj{ |anja |bz o`{ jynmnobf& kgzun{g

j`oznz{go{f~ kgdgoknol {ag fb|dwfogzz `d {ag bj{z jabylgk blbnoz{ My/ Cbyb{x/

[anz M`{n`o nz ibzgk `o {ag b{{bjagk Mgm`ybokwm `d U`no{z bok

Bw{a`yn{ngz& {ag b{{bjagk Buugoknq& {ag Kgjfbyb{n`o `d Igohbmno Bw no Zwuu`y{ `d 

{ag M`{n`o& {ag Ygrwgz{ d`y Hwknjnbf O`{njg& {ag Kgjfbyb{n`o `d Igohbmno Bw no

Zwuu`y{ `d {ag Ygrwgz{ d`y Hwknjnbf O`{njg& bff dnfgk j`ojwyygo{f~ agyg|n{a& {ag dnfgzbok ygj`ykz no {anz jbzg& bok bo~ bylwmgo{ `y gtnkgojg `ddgygk b{ {ag agbynol `o

{ag M`{n`o/

Kb{gk8 Hbowby~ ;& 9525 Ygzugj{dwff~ zwimn{{gk&

CGCGY $ TBO OGZ[ FFUJBFK\GFF FGZFNG $ UY@J[@Y& UJ

I~8  z H`ao \/ Cgcgy H@AO \/ CGCGY

B{{`yog~z d`y Kgdgokbo{ IYWJG CBYB[X 

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg ; `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 5/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

2KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

MGM@YBOKWM @D U@NO[Z BOK BW[A@YN[NGZ

N/  NO[Y@KWJ[N@O

[ag gtnkgojg bz n{ gqnz{gk igd`yg {ag uy`zgjw{n`o igjbmg not`ftgk za`|z

{ab{ {ag {|` ug`ufg m`z{ ygzu`oznifg d`y z{`jc `u{n`oz b{ CI A`mg‛

J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg Jabny Hbmgz H`aoz`o bok Awmbo Ygz`wyjgz jangd Lby~

Yb~‛i`{a dnymf~ igfngtgk {ab{ {ag z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uybj{njg |bz fb|dwf& bok {ag~

|gyg |nffnol {` zb~ z`/ @ojg {ag uy`zgjw{ yz l`{ ba`fk `d {agm& {ab{ jabolgk/

@{agy ibjckb{nol jbzgz no {anz Knz{ynj{ bok {anz Jnyjwn{ za`| {ab{ {ag l`tgyomgo{„z

gdd`y{z {` znfgojg& ygjbz{ `y `w{ynla{ mnzyguygzgo{ {ag z{b{g `d mnok `d u`{go{nbf

|n{ogzzgz d`y {ag kgdgozg jbo jyn{njbff~ bddgj{ |ag{agy {ag kgdgokbo{ lg{z b dbny

{ynbf/ My/ Cbyb{x {agygd`yg ygrwgz{z bo gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol |n{a ygzugj{ {` {ag

l`tgyomgo{„z j`okwj{ {`|byk Mgzzyz/ H`aoz`o bok Yb~& {|` nmu`y{bo{ |n{ogzzgz

|a`zg {gz{nm`o~ buugbyz {` abtg ygjgo{f~ gt`ftgk dy`m dbt`ybifg {` {ag kgdgozg {`

dbt`ybifg {` {ag l`tgyomgo{/

No {ag ygjgo{ {ynbf `d Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Ywgafg& O`/ JY 51-552:>-JHJ& igd`yg

Hwklg Jbyog~& {ag l`tgyomgo{ dnyz{ znfgojgk u`{go{nbf kgdgozg |n{ogzzgz |n{a

{aygb{z `d uy`zgjw{n`o& bok {ago bd{gy Hwklg Jbyog~ lybo{gk b m`{n`o d`y kgdgozg|n{ogzz nmmwon{~& n{ {aygb{gogk b |n{ogzz |n{a uy`zgjw{n`o wofgzz ag {gz{ndngk b

jgy{bno |b~/ No {ay`|nol `w{ {ag jbzg |agyg {ag l`tgyomgo{ abk ‖no{nmnkb{gk bok

nmuy`ugyf~ nodfwgojgk {ag S] |n{ogzzgz jyn{njbf {` S{ag] kgdgozg&” Hwklg Jbyog~

d`wok {ab{ {ag ‖jwmwfb{ntg gddgj{ `d {ab{ mnzj`okwj{ abSk] knz{`y{gk {ag {yw{a-

dnoknol uy`jgzz bok j`muy`mnzgk {ag no{glyn{~ `d {ag {ynbf/” Zgg Kgjfbyb{n`o `d 

Igohbmno Bw no Zwuu`y{ `d Ygrwgz{ d`y Hwknjnbf O`{njg !‖Bw Kgjf/ YHO”. ´ 9& Gqa/

B !29275> [ybozjynu{ `d Uy`jggknolz no Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Ywgafg& Ygrwgz{ d`y

Hwknjnbf O {njg. b{ 72>78<-25/ No Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Yg~gz& 7<< D/:k 254> !>{a Jny/

955>.& {ag Ono{a Jnyjwn{ agfk no 955> {ab{ {ag uy`zgjw{`yz abk j`mmn{{gk

mnzj`okwj{ no {agny jf`znol z{b{gmgo{ i~ bylwnol {ab{ jgy{bno bizgo{ |n{ogzzgz dy`m

{ag J`mubo~„z !Iy`jbkg. dnobojg kguby{mgo{ |`wfk {gz{nd~ b jgy{bno |b~& |ago

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 7 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 6/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

9KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

{ag l`tgyomgo{ cog| {ag~ |`wfk o`{/  Nk/ b{ 25<</ Z{yncnolf~ znmnfby nzzwgz buugby

{` ig bynznol no {anz jbzg/

Hbmgz H`aoz`o |bz {ag d`ymgy Jabny `d {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg `d {ag

CI A`mg I`byk `d Knygj{`yz/ Ag bfz` zgytgk `o {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg `d 

Won{gk Agbf{ajbyg& b j`mubo~ |n{a znlondnjbo{ z{`jc `u{n`o nzzwgz& bok |bz {ag

Jangd Gqgjw{ntg @ddnjgy `d Dboong Mbg/ @o Zgu{gmigy 29& 9554& My/ H`aoz`o |bz

no{gytng|gk i~ Nygff $ Mbogffb FFU !‖Nygff”.& `w{znkg j`wozgf d`y {ag CI A`mg

I`byk `d Knygj{`yz„ nokgugokgo{ notgz{nlb{n`o ygfb{nol {` z{`jc `u{n`oz/ B mgm`

zwmmbynxnol My/ H`aoz`o„z no{gytng| |n{a Nygff |bz uygubygk b{ {ag {nmg/ My/

H`aoz`o„z z{b{gmgo{z |gyg gq{ygmgf~ agfudwf {` My/ Cbyb{x bok j`oznz{go{ |n{a My/

Cbyb{x„z bo{njnub{gk kgdgozg b{ {ynbf/ Ag {`fk Nygff b{ fgbz{ gnla{ zgubyb{g {nmgz {ab{

n{ |bz j`mm`of~ wokgyz{``k {ab{ {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg abk kgfglb{gk {`

mboblgmgo{& gtgo nd nod`ymbff~& {ag bw{a`yn{~ {` unjc {ag lybo{ kb{g bok gqgyjnzg

uynjg d`y `u{n`oz/ Ag kgdgokgk {ag u{n`o lybo{ uy`jgzz b{ CI A`mg bok z{b{gk

{ab{ ag abk o` gqugj{b{n`o bz {` |ab{ {ag lybo{ kb{g d`y `u{n`oz za`wfk ig/ Ibzgk

`o {a`zg z{b{gmgo{z& My/ H`aoz`o |bz b z{y`ol kgdgozg |n{ogzz/

@d j`wyzg& {agzg z{b{gmgo{z ufbjgk My/ H`aoz`o jf`zgy {` {ag z{`jc `u{n`ouybj{njgz b{ CI A`mg {ab{ abk l`{{go My/ Cbyb{x noknj{gk& bok n{ nz o`{ abyk {`

nmblnog b uy`zgjw{`y u`no{nol `w{ {` My/ H`aoz`o {ag ynzcz `d z` {gz{nd~nol b{ {ynbf/

[agygbd{gy& `o Hwf~ 25& 9551& ogbyf~ {|` ~gbyz bd{gy anz no{gytng| |n{a Nygff& My/

H`aoz`o |bz no{gytng|gk i~ {ag uy`zgjw{`yz no {anz jbzg bok mgmigyz `d {ag DIN/

Kwynol {ab{ no{gytng|& My/ H`aoz`o kgongk abtnol mbkg {ag z{b{gmgo{z b{{yniw{gk

{` anm i~ Nygff bok noz{gbk lbtg b mbycgkf~ knddgygo{ bjj`wo{ `d {ag gtgo{z‛`og

dby m`yg j`oznz{go{ |n{a {ag l`tgyomgo{„z {ag`y~ no n{z Noknj{mgo{‛bok bf{a`wla

{`y{wygk& dby fgzz gqjwfub{`y~ `d My/ Cbyb{x/ @of~ ygjgo{f~ knk My/ Cbyb{x ygjgntg

dy`m Nygff {ag bj{wbf o`{gz {bcgo i~ Nygff kwynol My/ H`aoz`o„z no{gytng|/ [agzg

o`{gz byg gq{ygmgf~ kg{bnfgk bok byg no rwgz{n`o-bok-boz|gy d`ymb{& ygbknol bfm`z{

fncg b {ybozjynu{/ [ag~ j`odnym {ab{ My/ H`aoz`o mbkg {ag fgol{a~& gqjwfub{`y~

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 4 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 7/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

:KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

z{b{gmgo{z b{{yniw{gk {` anm i~ Nygff/

A`| bok |a~ My/ H`aoz`o mbkg {|` zwja knz{noj{ zg{z `d z{b{gmgo{z& l`nol

z` dby bz {` dbfzgf~ kgo~ abtnol mbkg {ag dnyz{ zg{& nz bo nzzwg `d {ag w{m`z{

nmu`y{bojg& |anja nmufnjb{gz My/ Cbyb{x„z kwg uy`jgzz ynla{ {` b dbny {ynbf/ Abtnol

mbkg gqjwfub{`y~ z{b{gmgo{z {` Nygff& bok {ago abtnol !dbfzgf~. kgongk mbcnol zwja

z{b{gmgo{z kwynol bo no{gytng| |n{a {ag l`tgyomgo{& ybnzgz tgy~ {y`wifnol

nodgygojgz bi`w{ My/ H`aoz`o„z {gz{nm`o~ bok n{z mbonuwfb{n`o& rwgz{n`oz {ab{ jbo

`of~ ig bkkygzzgk tnb b uyg-{ynbf agbynol no |anja My/ H`aoz`o& {ag Nygff fb|~gyz

|a` no{gytng|gk anm& bok {ag DIN blgo{ |a` j`okwj{gk {ag l`tgyomgo{ no{gytng|

{gz{nd~ wokgy `b{a/

Lby~ Yb~ |bz {ag Tnjg Uygznkgo{ `d Awmbo Ygz`wyjgz b{ CI A`mg& bok {ag

gqgjw{ntg m`z{ knygj{f~ ygzu`oznifg d y `u{n`o uybj{njgz b{ {ag J`mubo~/ My/ Yb~

abz {`fk {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ kwynol {ag jyn{njbf ~gbyz no rwgz{n`o‛2>>> {ay`wla

9557‛ag igfngtgk {ab{ {ag |b~ no |anja `u{n`oz |gyg lybo{gk b{ CI A`mg |bz

go{nygf~ fb|dwf bok uy`ugy/ A`|gtgy& My/ Yb~ bfz` abz z{b{gk {ab{ j`mmgojnol no

bi`w{ Mb~ 9554& ag mnzfgk {ag J`mubo~„z lgogybf j`wozgf |a` |bz j`okwj{nol bo

notgz{nlb{n`o no{ {ag J`mubo~„z anz{ ynjbf z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uybj{njgz/ No 9551&bz {ag uygzzwyg `o My/ Yb~ m`wo{gk no bktbojg `d bo noknj{mgo{& ag gtgo{wbff~

go{gygk no{` b ufgb bok j``ugyb{n`o blyggmgo{ |n{a {ag l`tgyomgo{ uwyzwbo{ {`

|anja My/ Yb~ ufgbkgk lwnf{~ {` `og j`wo{ `d `iz{ywj{n`o `d hwz{njg d`y abtnol

mnzfgk {ag lgogybf j`wozgf/

[agzg jnyjwmz{bojgz byg anlaf~ zwzunjn`wz bok wowzwbf& no {ab{ n{ buugbyz

{ab{ {ag j`okwj{ {` |anja My/ Yb~ ufgbkgk lwnf{~ k`gz o`{ j`oz{n{w{g b jynmg wokgy

buufnjbifg dgkgybf fb|/ [anz nz {y`wifnol no fnla{ `d Hwklg Jbyog~„z ygjgo{ dnoknol

no Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Zbmwgfn& O`/ JY 51-55274-JHJ& {ab{ bo gqgjw{ntg abk iggo

iwffngk no{` ufgbknol lwnf{~ {` b jynmg {ab{ ag knk o`{ j`mmn{& bz |gff bz anz dnoknol

no Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Ywgafg {ab{ Oboj~ [wff`z& {ag l`tgyomgo{„z cg~ j``ugyb{nol

|n{ogzz bok bfz` bo AY gqgjw{ntg fncg My/ Yb~& abk iggo ibklgygk bok abybzzgk

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg < `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 8/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

;KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

no{` dwyonzanol dbfzg {gz{nm`o~ no gqjabolg d`y uy`mnzgz `d fgongoj~ uwyzwbo{ {` b

i`lwz ufgb blyggmgo{/ No `ykgy {` zbdglwbyk My/ Cbyb{x„z kwg uy`jgzz ynla{ {` b

dbny {ynbf& {ag J`wy{ za`wfk bfz` j`okwj{ b uyg-{ynbf agbynol yglbyknol My/ Yb~& no

|anja ag {gz{ndngz bok {ag J`wy{ nz lntgo {ag `uu`y{won{~ {` gtbfwb{g {ag zwzugj{

jnyjwmz{bojgz zwyy`woknol anz lwnf{~ ufgb/

Lntgo {ag gfwzntg& iw{ jywjnbf& nzzwg `d no{go{ {ab{ uygzgo{z n{zgfd no gbja `d 

{agzg ibjckb{nol jbzgz& bok {ag u`{goj~ `d l`tgyomgo{ {aygb{z {` gqgjw{ntgz |a`

j`wfk {gz{nd~ no b |b~ {ab{ |`wfk agfu b kgdgokbo{& n{ nz jywjnbf {ab{ {ag J`wy{ a`fk b

agbynol no{` !b. {ag nogqufnjbifg& kybmb{nj& bok dbfzg kgonbfz i~ My/ H`aoz`o bi`w{

abtnol uygtn`wzf~ mbkg u`|gydwf gqjwfub{`y~ z{b{gmgo{z3 bok !i. {ag

jnyjwmz{bojgz wokgy |anja My/ Yb~ igjbmg b l`tgyomgo{ j``ugyb{ y i~ ufgbknol

lwnf{~ {` j`okwj{ |anja |bz o`{ jynmnobf/

NN/  DBJ[Z

B/  Hbmgz H`aoz`o dbfzgf~ kgongz {` {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ ag mbkgz{b{gmgo{z {` Nygff no kgdgozg `d Iywjg Cbyb{x bok CI A`mg„z z{`jc`u{n`o lybo{ uy`jgzz/

My/ H`aoz`o zgytgk bz Jabny `d CI A`mg„z J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg dy`m

2>>7 wo{nf 9555 bok ygmbnogk bz b mgmigy dy`m 955; {` 9551/ Nygff no{gytng|gkanm `o Zgu{gmigy 29& 9554 `o igabfd `d {ag I`byk `d Knygj{`y„z nokgugokgo{

notgz{nlb{n`o ygfb{nol {` z{`jc `u{n`oz/ My/ H`aoz`o„z ygzu`ozgz |gyg jyn{njbf

igjbwzg& bz b f`ol-{nmg mgmigy bok d`ymgy jabny `d {ag J`mmn{{gg& ag j`wfk

zugbc {` |ag{agy {ag J`mubo~„z z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uybj{njg |bz {ybozubygo{&

|ag{agy {ag J`mmn{{gg |bz b|byg bok buuy`tgk `d mboblgmgo{ zgfgj{nol {ag

lybo{ kb{gz& bok |ag{agy {anz uybj{njg |bz igfngtgk {` ig fb|dwf b{ {ag {nmg/

Bjj`yknol {` {ag mgm` uygubygk i~ Nygff {ag kb~ bd{gy {ag no{gytng| !{ag

‖Nygff Mgm`”.& |anja |bz ibzgk `o {ag kg{bnfgk o`{gz {bcgo kwynol {ab{ no{gytng|&

My/ H`aoz`o8

|`wfk j`ojgkg {agyg |bz b kgfglb{n`o `d bw{a`yn{~ {` zg{ {ag lybo{ kb{gbok uynjg& iw{ zbnk {ab{ n{ |bz ogtgy knzjwzzgk bz b ‑kgfglb{n`o&„bf{a`wla n{ |bz jfgbyf~ |n{ano mboblgmgo{„z bzznlogk kw{ngz {` mbcg

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 1 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 9/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

7KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

{ag kg{gymnob{n`o/

․/

H`aoz`o gqufbnogk {ab{ nd {ag bzznlomgo{ `d b kb{g abk o`{ iggokgfglb{gk& znojg gtgy~`og cog| bi`w{ n{& z`mgi`k~ |`wfk abtgrwgz{n`ogk {ag uybj{njg/ H`aoz`o dgf{ {ab{ {agyg |bz o` `og {bcnol

bktbo{blg `d {ag z~z{gm `y ignol ogdbyn`wz bok {ab{ {ag ub{{gyo `d igabtn`y ugyznz{nol `tgy {ag ugyn`k tbfnkb{gk {ag kgfglb{n`o/

․/

H`aoz`o bkkgk {ab{ {agyg |bz o` knzjwzzn`o yglbyknol kgfglb{nol {`mboblgmgo{ {ag u`|gy {` zg{ {agny `|o `u{n`o uynjg& iw{ {ab{ n{ |bzjfgby uybj{njg& j`okwj{gk no {ag `ugo bok |anja {ag J`mmn{{gg |bzb|byg d/

Kgjfbyb{n`o `d Igohbmno Bw no Zwuu`y{ `d M`{n`o d`y Gtnkgo{nby~ Agbynol

Yglbyknol [gz{nm`o~ `d Jywjnbf \n{ogzzgz !‖Bw Kgjf/”. ´ 9& Gqa/ B !Nygff

No{gytng| Mgm` d`y Hbmgz H`aoz`o kb{gk Zgu{gmigy 2:& 9554. b{ 93 73 4/

@ojg {ag l`tgyomgo{ l`{ ba`fk `d My/ H`aoz`o& a`|gtgy& anz {gz{nm`o~

{bjcgk zabyuf~ no {ag `uu`zn{g knygj{n`o/ Bjj`yknol {` {ag l`tgyomgo{„z Dgkgybf

Iwygbw `d Notgz{nlb{n`o D`ym DK-:59 `d n{z no{gytng| `o Hwf~ 25& 9551& {ag

l`tgyomgo{ zugjndnjbff~ bzcgk My/ H`aoz`o |ag{agy {agyg abk iggo b kgfglb{n`o `d 

bw{a`yn{~ {` mboblgmgo{ {` zg{ {ag lybo{ kb{g/ \anfg My/ H`aoz`o dnyz{ z{b{gk {ab{

‖{ag z{`jc `u{n`o b|byk uy`jgzz abk gt`ftgk `tgy {nmg zwja {ab{ n{ mnla{ abtg

iggo nmufngk {ab{ {agyg |bz kgfglb{n`o&” ag zbnk {ab{ Nygff abk o`{ bjjwyb{gf~

jabybj{gynxgk |ab{ ag abk {`fk {agm/ Bw Kgjf/ ´ :& Gqa/ I !Hbmgz H`aoz`o D`ym

:59 kb{gk Hwf~ 22& 9551. b{ 2/ Zwzunjn`wzf~& a`|gtgy& bz {ag j`wyzg d {ag

l`tgyomgo{„z no{gytng| |`yg `o& My/ H`aoz`o„z kgonbfz `d {ag kgfglb{n`o nzzwg

igjbmg m`yg dnym& bok anz mgm`y~ `d |ab{ ag {`fk Nygff m`yg knm/ My/ H`aoz`o

zbnk {ab{ ag knk o`{ ygjbff {gffnol Nygff {ab{ gtgy~`og cog| bi`w{ {ag kgfglb{n`o `y

{ab{ n{ |bz tbfnkb{gk i~ {ag dbj{ {ab{ o` `og rwgz{n`ogk n{/  Nk/ b{ ;/ Ag {`fk {ag

l`tgyomgo{ wogrwnt`jbff~ {ab{ ‖Sag] ogtgy blyggk |n{a {ag j`ojgu{ {ab{ {ag

zgfgj{n`o `d b lybo{ kb{g |bz kgfglb{gk {` mboblgmgo{&” bok {ab{ ‖{ag

J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg |bz o`{ b|byg {` anz co`|fgklg {ab{ mboblgmgo{ |bz

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg > `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 10/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

4KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

unjcnol {ag z{yncg uynjg/” Nk/ b{ ;-7/

J`wozgf d`y My/ Cbyb{x ygjgo{f~ `i{bnogk {ag o`{gz {bcgo i~ {ag Nygff fb|~gyz

no{gytng|nol My/ H`aoz`o !{ag ‖Nygff O`{gz”.& |anja zgytgk bz {ag ibznz d`y {ag Nygff

Mgm`/ [agzg o`{gz |gyg j`o{gmu`ybog`wzf~ {bcgo b{ {ag {nmg `d {ag no{gytng|&

bok byg kybd{gk no {ybozjynu{ d`ymb{& nkgo{nd~nol {ag rwgz{n`oz u`zgk i~ Nygff bok {ag

ygzu`ozgz lntgo i~ My/ H`aoz`o/ [ag Nygff O`{gz j`odnym no z{byc kg{bnf {ab{ {ag

Nygff Mgm`„z bjj`wo{ `d My/ H`aoz`o„z z{b{gmgo{z |gyg {bcgo bfm`z{ tgyib{nm

dy`m My/ H`aoz`o„z `|o |`ykz/

R8 Wokgy {ag jnyjwmz{bojg ~`w byg kgzjyninol& ~`w byg kgfglb{nol {`mboblgmgo{ {ag bw{a`yn{~ {` zg{ {ag lybo{ kb{g& bok {awz {ag uynjg0

B8 ^gz& n{ |bz ogtgy knzjwzzgk bz b kgfglb{n`o& iw{ n{ |bz jfgbyf~|n{ano mboblgmgo{„z bzznlogk kw{ngz {` k` {ab{/

Bw Kgjf/ ´ ;& Gqa/ J !Nygff J`o{gmu`ybog`wz O`{gz `d No{gytng| |n{a Hbmgz

H`aoz`o kb{gk Zgu{gmigy 29& 9554. b{ ;/

R8 SZ]`mg ug`ufg mnla{ ygbk {anz bz bo bj{wbf knzjwzzn`o Sbi`w{kgfglb{n`o] ig{|ggo mboblgmgo{ bok {ag j`mmn{{gg/ \g abtgo„{zggo bo~{anol fncg {anz igd`yg/

B8 [anz nz {`y{wygk& iw{ nd n{ |gygo„{ kgfglb{gk& bok gtgy~S og] cog|bi`w{ n{& nd {agyg |bz Sznj] z`mg ygzgytb{n`oz bi`w{ Sn{]& z`mgi`k~

|`wfk abtg rwgz{n ogk n{/ N{ zggmz {` mg {ab{ ~`w jbo„{ abtg buybj{njg `d igabtn`y {ab{ ugyznz{z nd n{ abk o`{ iggo kgfglb{gk/ [anz|bz o`{ b `og-`dd ogdbyn`wz {bcnol bktbo{blg `d {ag z~z{gm/

 Nk/ b{ 29/

Znmnfbyf~& bjj`yknol {` {ag Nygff Mgm`& My/ H`aoz`o zbnk {ab{

SA]g {a`wla{ mboblgmgo{„z not`ftgmgo{ no zg{{nol {ag lybo{ kb{g |bzig{{gy kgzjynigk bz b uybj{njg& bok {ab{ n{ abk l`og `o d`y ~gbyz bok{ab{ nod`ymgk nokntnkwbfz abk {agny g~gz `ugo {` n{& bok o` `og abkgtgy zwllgz{gk {agyg mnla{ ig {bq& bjj`wo{nol& `{agy nzzwgzzwyy`woknol {ag igabtn`y/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ B b{ ;/ Iw{ |ago no{gytng|gk i~ {ag l`tgyomgo{& My/ H`aoz`o

blbno {`{bff~ knzjfbnmgk anz uyn y u`zn{n`o/ Ag {`fk {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ Nygff abk

‖`tgyz{b{gk” n{& bok {ab{& no{gy bfnb8

Ag abk o` ygbz`o {` igfngtg {ab{ {ag `{agy J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{ggmgmigyz igfngtgk {ab{ mboblgmgo{ |bz unjcnol {ag lybo{ kb{g bokH`aoz`o knk o`{ a`fk {anz tng| gn{agy igjbwzg {ag zugjndnj {`unj `d 

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 25 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 11/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

<KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

mboblgmgo{ unjcnol {ag lybo{ kb{g |bz o`{ knzjwzzgk no {agJ`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg mgg{nolz/

․/

Gqgjw{ntg mboblgmgo{„z `of~ ygzu`ozninfn{~ |bz {` j`mufg{g {agbff`jb{n`o uy`jgzz& o`{ {` zg{ {ag z{yncg uynjg `d {ag z{`jc `u{n`oz/

Gqgjw{ntg mboblgmgo{ knk o`{ abtg {ag bw{a`yn{~ {` unjc {ag z{`jc `u{n`o uynjg& bok {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg knk o`{ buuy`tg `yyb{nd~ {anz uybj{njg/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ I b{ 9/ Iw{ {ag Nygff O {gz& `ojg blbno& j`odnym {ab{ My/ H`aoz`o„z

kgonbfz {` {ag l`tgyomgo{ |gyg dbfzg/ Ag knk no dbj{ {gff Nygff {ab{ mboblgmgo{„z

not`ftgmgo{ no zg{{nol {ag lybo{ kb{g |bz j`mm`o co`|fgklg/ Blbno& {ag Nygff

Mgm` rw`{gz ogby tgyib{nm {ag ygzu`ozg My/ H`aoz`o lbtg kwynol anz no{gytng|

|n{a {agm/

R8 \`wfk {ag J`mu/ J`mmn{{gg& wokgy {ag kgfglb{n`o‛

B8 N k`o„{ co`| nd N„k jbff n{ kgfglb{n`o/ N{ |bz {ag uybj{njg/ Bokgtgy~i`k~„z g~gz |gyg `ugo& bok n{ |bz {ag uybj{njg bok n{ |go{ `o d`y~gbyz/ Nod`ymgk nokntnkwbfz |gyg uygzgo{& bok gtgy~i`k~ cog| bi`w{{ag uybj{njg& bok j`o{nowgk {` `jjwy |n{a`w{ {ag igogdn{ `d bo~`ogzb~nol {agyg mnla{ ig {bq uy`ifgmz& bjj`wo{nol uy`ifgmz& `{agyuy`ifgmz/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ J b{ 25/

Kwynol anz no{gytng| |n{a Nygff& My/ H`aoz`o bfz` knzjwzzgk {ag nzzwg `d {aglybo{ kb{g d`y z{`jc `u{n`oz/ Bjj`yknol {` {ag Nygff Mgm`8

H`aoz`o noknjb{gk {ab{ ag abk o` gqugj{b{n`o b{ {ag {nmg yglbyknol|ago {ag z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ kb{g |`wfk ig zg{& bok n{ |bz o`{ wo{nf {agubz{ j`wufg m`o{az {ab{ ag fgbyogk bi`w{ {ag tbyn`wz u`zznifg kb{gz/Ag knk o`{ ygjbff |ag{agy J`mmn{{gg mgg{nolz j`yygzu`okgk {` {aglybo{ kb{gz& `y |ag{agy ugyabuz `{agy mgg{nolz j`yygzu`okgk {` {agkb{gz& bok ygtng| `d {ag k`jwmgo{z knko„{ ygdygza anz ygj`ffgj{n`o/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ B b{ </ Iw{ |ago ag zu`cg { {ag l`tgyomgo{& ag zbnk {ab{ ag knk no

dbj{ abtg bo gqugj{b{n`o bz {` {ag lybo{ kb{g/ [ag l`tgyomgo{„z D`ym :59 z{b{gz

{ab{8

H`aoz`o bzzwmgk kb{gz |gyg zg{ bz `d {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{ggmgg{nol kb{g ․/ H`aoz`o knk o`{ co`| {ab{ {ag kb{g wzgk {` kg{gymnog{ag z{`jc `u{n`o z{yncg uynjg |bz knddgygo{ dy`m {ag kb{g `d {ag z{`jc uynjg `o {ag kb~ `d {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg mgg{nol/

․/

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 22 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 12/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

1KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

[ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg mgmigyz cog| {ab{ bkkn{n`obf lybo{zoggkgk {` ig mbkg {` {ag yboc-bok-dnfg& {agygd`yg {ag J`mugozb{n`oJ`mmn{{gg mgmigyz cog| {ab{ {agyg |bz dwy{agy |`yc {` ig k`og i~gqgjw{ntg mboblgmgo{/ A`|gtgy& gtgy~`og no {ag J`mugozb{n`oJ`mmn{{gg mgg{nol knk o`{ co`| {ab{ uby{ `d {ag wodnonzagk iwznogzz{ab{ gqgjw{ntg mboblgmgo{ oggkgk {` k` |bz {` ja``zg b z{yncg uynjg{ab{ |bz knddgygo{ dy`m {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg mgg{nol kb{g/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ I b{ 2-9/

[ag Nygff O`{gz blbno {gff b knddgygo{ z{`y~& `og {ab{ nz {`{bff~ j`oznz{go{ |n{a

{ag Nygff Mgm` iw{ z{bokz no z{byc j`o{ybz{ |n{a |ab{ My/ H`aoz`o fb{gy {`fk {ag

l`tgyomgo{8

R8 Bz b ygzwf{ `d {anz uybj{njg |g„tg iggo kgzjyninol& |ab{ |bz ~`wygqugj{b{n`o bz {` |ab{ {ag lybo{ kb{g |bz l`nol {` ig0

B8 N knk o`{ abtg bo gqugj{b{n o/ Znq{~ kb~z bl`& N fgbyogk bi`w{ {agtbyn`wz kb{gz/ N knko„{ ygjbff |ag{agy |g abk J`mu/ J`mmn{{ggmgg{nolz bz {ag kb{g& `y z`mg `{agy mgg{nol bz {ag kb{g/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ J b{ 2;/

Bz ~g{ bo`{agy gqbmufg& bjj`yknol {` {ag Nygff Mgm`& H`aoz`o |bz bzcgk b

zgyngz `d rwgz{n`oz yglbyknol anz {a`wla{z `o My/ Cbyb{x„z not`ftgmgo{ no zg{{nol

{ag lybo{ kb{g bok gqgyjnzg uynjg8

H`aoz`o abk o` ygj ffgj{n`o `d Cbyb{x zg{{nol {ag lybo{ kb{g/ \ago

bzcgk& a~u`{ag{njbff~& |ag{agy n{ |`wfk knz{wyi anm {` fgbyo Cbyb{x& bz`uu`zgk {` mboblgmgo{& |bz unjcnol {ag gqgyjnzg uynjg `d anz `|o`u{n`oz& H`aoz`o zbnk ag knk o`{ {anoc n{ |`wfk abtg knz{wyigk anm no{ag {nmg igd`yg Zbyibogz-@qfg~ bok bff {ag ygjgo{ b{{go{n`o {`mboblgmgo{ nmuy`uyng{~/ Ag lb{agygk dy`m {ag ygjgo{ fn{gyb{wyg {ab{awokygkz `d j`mubongz abk `u{n`oz uybj{njgz znmnfby {` CIA !ago`{gk {ab{ anz `|o j`mubo~ knk o`{& bf{a`wla `og `d {ag `{agyj`mubongz `o |a`zg i`byk ag zb{ knk./ Ag zbnk {ab{ abk ag fgbyogkCbyb{x |bz l`nol {` unjc {ag igz{ uynjg `tgy b : m`o{a ugyn`k& agmnla{ `y mnla{ o`{ abtg abk b uy`ifgm3 yglbykfgzz n{ |bz go{nygf~a~u`{ag{njbf& bz {ag nzzwg |bz ogtgy ybnzgk no J`mmn{{gg mgg{nolz& `yi~ mboblgmgo{& b{ bo~ {nmg/

․/

H`aoz`o |bz wozwyg a`| ag |`wfk abtg ygzu`okgk nd& a~u`{ag{njbff~&ag abk fgbyogk {ab{ mboblgmgo{„z uybj{njg |bz {` ibjckb{g z{`jc `u{n`oz/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ B b{ :-;/ \ago {ag l`tgyomgo{ iy`wla{ {anz {` My/ H`aoz`o„z

b{{go{n`o& ag zbnk {ab{ ag ‖knk o`{ ygjbff mbcnol {a`zg z{b{gmgo{z bok zwja

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 29 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 13/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

>KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

z{b{gmgo{z knk o`{ z`wok fncg z`mg{anol Sag] |`wfk abtg zbnk/”  Nk / b{ :/ Dwy{agy&

bjj`yknol {` {ag D`ym :598

H`aoz`o zbnk nd ag abk fgbyogk {ab{ Cbyb{x |bz ibjckb{nol z{`jc `u{n`oz& Sag] |`wfk abtg j`oznkgygk {ag bj{n`o {`{bff~ nobuuy`uynb{g b{{ag {nmg/ A`|gtgy& H`aoz`o |`wfk o`{ abtg co`|o nd zwja bj{n`o |bz

nmugymnzznifg/ H`aoz`o |`wfk abtg {a`wla{ zwja bj{n`oz |gyg b ibkuybj{njg / / / ag |`wfk abtg iy`wla{ n{ {` {ag b{{go{n`o `d {ag `{agyJ`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg mgmigyz bok ag |`wfk abtg ygj`mmgokgk{ab{ b dnqgk kb{g ig wzgk d`y bff dw{wyg boowbf z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{z/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ I b{ :/ \n{a yglbyk { anz z{b{gmgo{ bi`w{ a`| ag |`wfk abtg

ygzu`okgk nd ag abk fgbyogk {ab{ mboblgmgo{ abk iggo ibjckb{nol& My/ H`aoz`o

fbmibz{gk Nygff& {gffnol {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ ag ‖dgf{ {ab{ Nygff„z notgz{nlb{`yz |gyg

{y~nol {` d`yjg Sanm] {` mbcg b z{b{gmgo{ {ab{ {ag~ |bo{gk {` agby / / / Sag] dgf{

nyyn{b{gk kwynol anz no{gytng| |n{a Nygff igjbwzg ag dgf{ {ag~ |gyg knz`ylbonxgk bok

{ag~ knk o`{ dwff~ wokgyz{bok |ab{ {ag~ |gyg notgz{nlb{nol/” Ag {`fk {ag

l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ ‖anz boz|gyz kwynol {ag Nygff no{gytng| |gyg zfbo{gk blbnoz{ {ag

oglb{ntg nmufnjb{n`oz Nygff buugbygk {` |bo{ anm {` kyb| / / / /”  Nk/ b{ :/

Iw{ {ag Nygff O`{gz {gff b knddgygo{ z{`y~/ No dbj{& My/ H`aoz`o„z `|o |`ykz&

bz zg{ d`y{a no {ag Nygff O`{gz& kgm`oz{yb{g gtgo m`yg jfgbyf~ {abo {ag Nygff Mgm`

{ab{ My/ H`aoz`o dnymf~ igfngtgk {ag uy`jgzz b{ CI A`mg |bz uy`ugy/ M`yg`tgy&{agyg nz o` noknjb{n`o {ab{ Nygff uw{ bo~ uygzzwyg `o My/ H`aoz`o {` d`yjg anm {`

boz|gy {agny rwgz{n oz no bo~ uby{njwfby |b~/ [` {ag j`o{yby~& {ag Nygff O`{gz za`|

{ab{ My/ H`aoz`o„z ygzu`ozgz |gyg {a`wla{dwff~ bok dyggf~ lntgo/

R8 Zwuu`zg ~`w fgbyogk {ab{ noz{gbk `d mboblgmgo{& n{ |bz IywjgCbyb{x {ab{ |bz unjcnol {ag gqgyjnzg uynjg& `d anz `|o `u{n`oz0\`wfk {ab{ knz{wyi ~`w0

B8 N k`o„{ {anoc z`/ Mb~ig {`kb~& |n{a Z@Q& bok bff {anz

mboblgmgo{ nmuy`uyng{~/ N lb{agy dy`m ygbknol {ag fn{gyb{wyg {ab{ b{awokygkz `d j`mubongz {`kb~& {ag~ abk uybj{njgz z`mg|ab{ znmnfby {`{anz/ \g knk o`{ abtg {anz b{ m~ j`mubo~& iw{ `og `d {ag {agyj`mubongz& `o |a`zg i`byk N zb{& abk b znmnfby uy`jgkwyg/ Nd z`mg`ogabk zbnk Iywjg nz l`nol {` zn{ by`wok d`y {aygg m`o{az bok unjc {agigz{ uynjg& N mnla{ abtg abk b uy`ifgm& mb~ig N mnla{ o`{/ [`kb~ N|`wfk/ Iw{ {anz nz jgy{bnof~ a~u`{ag{njbf& {anz |bz ogtgy ybnzgk noJ`mmn{{gg mgg{nolz& i~ mboblgmgo{& b{ bo~{nmg `y bo~ u`no{/

․/

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 2: `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 14/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

25KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

R8 Z` gtgo nd ~`w abk co`|o {ab{ ibjckb{nol |bz l`nol `o& ~`w|`wfko„{ abtg co`|o n{ |bz b uy`ifgm0

B8 [ag ug`ufg `o {anz I`byk |gyg gq{ygmgf~ dnobojnbff~z`uanz{njb{gk/ Nd z`mgi`k~ abk zbnk& {agyg mnla{ ig bo bjj`wo{nolnzzwg& b jygkninfn{~ nzzwg& |g |`wfk abtg notgz{nlb{gk n{/

Gtgo {a`wla b owmigy `d wz jbmg `w{ `d j`mubongz& |gff& m~j`mubo~ |go{ `o b dnqgk kb{g& z`mg j`mubongz abk knddgygo{ kb{g-zg{{nol mgjabonzmz/ N mgbo& z`mg `d {ag f``c-ibjcz no {agzg jbzgz|gyg mwja f`olgy ugyn`kz-agyg& n{ |bz tgy~ j`oz{ybnogk/

N jbo bzzwyg ~`w {ab{ {agyg |gyg o` knzjwzzn`oz ig{|ggo {agJ`mmn{{gg bok j`wozgf& bjj`wo{bo{z& `tgy {ag uy`uyng{~ `d {aguybj{njg/ Abk {anz abuugogk& gtgy~i`k~ |`wfk abtg uwffgk wu {agnyjabny& bok zbnk ‑fg{„z lg{ {` {ag i`{{`m `d {anz/„

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ J b{ 43 25/

Znmnfbyf~& My/ H`aoz`o {`fk Nygff {ab{ {ag nkgb {ab{ My/ Cbyb{x„z not`ftgmgo{

no {y~nol {` unjc ‖{ag igz{ uynjg” |`wfk ‖o`{ abtg iggo b uy`ifgm/” [ag Nygff

Mgm` z{b{gz {ab{8

H`aoz`o dgf{ {ab{ {ag fbokzjbug abz jabolgk& bok {ab{ b{ {ag {nmg& {agnkgb {ab{ mboblgmgo{& `y Cbyb{x& |`wfk ig not`ftgk no {y~nol {` unjc {ag igz{ uynjg& |`wfk o`{ abtg iggo b uy`ifgm/ Abk {ag J`mubo~zbnk& ‑|g byg l`nol {` unjc z`mg kb{g ig{|ggo Zgu{gmigy bokKgjgmigy d`y {anz lybo{&„ n{ |`wfk o`{ abtg iggo b uy`ifgm/ Agygn{gyb{gk {ab{ {anz knk o`{ abuugo& o`y |bz n{ {ag uybj{njg b{ anz `|oj`mubo~ {` abtg b dfgqnifg lybo{ kb{g/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ B b{ 4/ [ag l`tgyomgo{ bzcgk My/ H`aoz`o bi`w{ {anz zugjndnj

z{b{gmgo{/ Bz bo non{nbf mb{{gy& My/ H`aoz`o {`fk {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ ag knk o`{

ygjbff zb~nol {anz {` Nygff/ Dwy{agy& ag zbnk {ab{8

Sb]{ {ag {nmg& Sag {a`wla{] gz{bifnzanol b lybo{ kb{g |bz b knddgygo{j`ojgu{ {abo ja``znol b z{yncg uynjg hwz{ {` `i{bno b f`| uynjg u`no{/B{ {ag {nmg& H`aoz`o |`wfk abtg j`oznkgygk n{ ugymnzznifg d`ybkmnonz{yb{ntg ygbz`oz {` l` ibjc& d`y gqbmufg {` {ag iglnoonol `d brwby{gy& iw{ o`{ {` unjc b z{`jc `u{n`o z{yncg uynjg f``cnol ibjc hwz{ {`f`jc no b f`|gy uynjg/

․/

[ag za`uunol `d z{`jc `u{n`o kb{gz |`wfk abtg iggo ig~`ok bo~{anol{ab{ H`aoz`o |`wfk abtg nmblnogk/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ I b{ 73 2-9/ Blbno& {ag Nygff O`{gz& a`|gtgy& uy`tg {ab{ {ag Nygff

Mgm` bjjwyb{gf~ jbu{wygk My/ H`aoz`o„z z{b{gmgo{z‛{ag zbmg z{b{gmgo{z ag fb{gy

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 2; `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 15/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

22KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

j`wfk o`{ ygjbff |ago zugbcnol |n{a {ag l`tgyomgo{8

R8 N{ mbcgz zgozg {` mg {ab{ {ag j`mmn{{gg Snz] o`{ l`nol { ignot`ftgk no gtgy~ bff`jb{n`o {` gtgy~ gmuf`~gg/ K` ~`w ygjbff bo~knzjwzzn`o b{ bo~ {nmg& bi`w{ kgfglb{nol {` mboblgmgo{ bw{a`yn{~ {`uynjg u{n`oz0

B8 O`& N k`o„{/ @o {ag `{agy abok& n{ igjbmg {ag uybj{njg/ [agj`mmn{{gg |bz buubygo{f~ b|byg `d n{/ @itn`wzf~ n{ |bzo„{ ankkgody`m {ag j`mmn{{gg/ Iw{ o`& N k`o„{ ygjbff knzjwzzn`o/

N lwgzz |ab{ N„m {y~nol {` zb~ nz {ab{ {ag fbokzjbug abz jabolgk/ [ab{mboblgmgo{& {ab{ Iywjg |`wfk ig not`ftgk no {y~nol {` unjc {ag igz{uynjg& b{ {ag {nmg& |bz o`{ b uy`ifgm/

M~ j`mubo~ uybj{njg |bz knddgygo{& iw{ `o n{z dbjg {anz |bz o`{ bonzzwg/ Nd {ag~ abk zbnk& |g„yg l`nol {` unjc z`mg kb{g ig{|ggoZgu{gmigy bok Kgjgmigy& d`y {anz lybo{& n{ |`wfk o`{ abtg iggo bonzzwg/ N k`o„{ ygjbff {ab{& {a`wla/

Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ J b{ </

I/  Lby~ Yb~ ufgbkz lwnf{~ {` `og j`wo{ `d `iz{ywj{n`o `d hwz{njg wokgym`wo{nol uygzzwyg bd{gy abtnol kgdgokgk {` {ag l`tgyomgo{ CIA`mg„z z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uy`jgzz/

Bd{gy ~gbyz `d mbno{bnonol anz noo`jgojg& Lby~ Yb~ nz o`| j``ugyb{nol |n{a

{ag l`tgyomgo{ bok nz gqugj{gk {` ig jbffgk b{ {ynbf `o n{z igabfd/ [ag l`tgyomgo{

abk {aygb{gogk My/ Yb~ |n{a b f`ol& kyb|o-`w{ uy`zgjw{n`o d`y z`mg `d {ag zbmg

jynmgz jabylgk blbnoz{ My/ Cbyb{x/ Ag bfz` dbjgk {ag uy zugj{ `d b fgol{a~ uynz`ozgo{gojg‛{ag mbqnmwm bff`|bifg wokgy {ag Zgo{gojnol Lwnkgfnogz& |anja {ag

l`tgyomgo{ {`fk anm n{ no{gokgk {` zggc nd j`otnj{gk/ Kwg {` anz dbmnf~

jnyjwmz{bojgz& a`|gtgy& My/ Yb~ igfngtgk {ab{ uynz`o {nmg |bz o`{ bo `u{n`o/ Anz

|ndg |bz znjc bok ag abk {|` janfkygo d`y |a`m ag |bz ygzu`oznifg/ Zgg& g/l/& Bw

Kgjf/ ´ 7& Gqa/ K !J`oong D`q D`ym :59 kb{gk Hwog 21& 9551. b{ :/ Wokgy {anz

m`wo{nol uygzzwyg& My/ Yb~ ufgbkgk lwnf{~ {` `og j`wo{ `d j`ozunybj~ {` `iz{ywj{

 hwz{njg uwyzwbo{ {` 21 W/Z/J/ zgj{n`oz :<2 bok 272> `o Kgjgmigy 27& 9551/

[ag l`tgyomgo{ ja`zg {` jabylg My/ Yb~ wokgy b ygfb{ntgf~ og|& wo{gz{gk

z{b{w{g/ Zgj{n`o 272>& go{n{fgk ‖Kgz{ywj{n`o& bf{gyb{n`o& `y dbfzndnjb{n`o `d ygj`ykz no

Dgkgybf notgz{nlb{n`o bok ibocywu{j~” |bz gobj{gk |n{a {ag ubzzblg `d {ag

Zbyibogz-@qfg~ Bj{& bok nz uynmbynf~ yglbykgk bz bo bo{n-k`jwmgo{ kgz{ywj{n`o

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 27 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 16/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

29KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

uy`tnzn`o/ [agyg nz o` bffglb{n o {ab{ My/ Yb~ kgz{y`~gk bo~ k`jwmgo{z/ Noz{gbk&

bjj`yknol {` {ag Nod`ymb{n`o jabylnol My/ Yb~ bok {ag l`tgyomgo{„z ygjn{b{n`o b{

{ag ufgb bff`jw{n`o agbynol& ag j`ozunygk {` ‖jbwzgS] b dbfzg ygj`yk `y k`jwmgo{ {`

ig jygb{gk&” bok {` ‖nmugkg& `iz{ywj{ `y nodfwgojg b j`o{gmufb{gk notgz{nlb{n`o `d 

{ag Zgjwyn{ngz bok Gqjabolg J`mmnzzn`o SZGJ]/” Bw Kgjf/ YHO ´ :& Gqa/ I

!9>5> [ybozjynu{ `d Lby~ Yb~ Ufgb Bff`jw{n`o Agbynol. b{ :9892-993 22899-9;/

[ag bffglgk ‖dbfzg ygj`yk `y k`jwmgo{” {ab{ My/ Yb~ j`ozunygk {` ‖jbwzg”

|bz {ag ygu`y{ `o {ag J`mubo~„z z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uy`jgzz kybd{gk i~ {ag lgogybf

j`wozgf d`ff`|nol anz no{gyobf notgz{nlb{n`o/ Zgg Bw Kgjf/ YHO ´ ;& Gqa/ J

!Nod`ymb{n`o no Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Yb~. ´ 25/ Bjj`yknol {` {ag l`tgyomgo{& abk n{z

jbzg blbnoz{ My/ Yb~ l`og {` {ynbf& n{ |`wfk abtg uy`tgo ig~`ok b ygbz`obifg k`wi{

{ab{ ‖iglnoonol bz gbyf~ bz mnk-Mbyja 9554& bok goknol `o `y bi`w{ mnk-Bwlwz{

9554& {agyg |bz bo blyggmgo{ ig{|ggo {|` `y m`yg ugyz`oz”‛n/g/& Mgzzyz/ Yb~

bok Cbyb{x‛‖{` nmugkg& `iz{ywj{ `y nodfwgojg b j`o{gmufb{gk notgz{nlb{n`o `d {ag

SZGJ] no tn`fb{n`o `d S] zgj{n`o 272>/” Bw Kgjf/ YHO& Gqa/ I b{ 22895-97/ ^g{&

My/ Yb~ {`fk {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ ‖ag igfngtgk n{ |bz `cb~ {` fng {` Anyz{ SCI

A`mg„z lgogybf j`wozgf] igjbwzg n{ |bz of~ bo no{gyobf notgz{nlb{n`o/” Bw Kgjf/&Gqa/ G ´ 4 !Lby~ Yb~ D`ym :59 kb{gk 25<51. b{ ;/ [agyg nz znmuf~ o` gtnkgojg

{ab{ bo~ ZGJ notgz{nlb{n`o no{` CI A`mg |bz j`o{gmufb{gk b{ {ag {nmg {ab{ My/

Yb~ zu`cg {` {ag lgogybf j`wozgf/

Bz knzjwzzgk nodyb& a`|gtgy& {ag l`tgyomgo{ ogl`{nb{gk b ufgb blyggmgo{ no

|anja My/ Yb~ ufgbkgk lwnf{~ {` j`okwj{ {ab{ |bz o`{ jynmnobf& bok igjbmg b

l`tgyomgo{ j``ugyb{nol |n{ogzz no gqjabolg/ Bok |anfg ag ufgbkgk lwnf{~ {` anz

bj{z no 9554 kwynol {ag lgogybf j`wozgf„z notgz{nlb{n`o& ag z{bwojaf~ mbno{bnogk

i`{a igd`yg bok bd{gy {ag ufgb blyggmgo{ {ab{ CI A`mg„z z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{

uybj{njg abk bf|b~z iggo j`oznkgygk {` ig fb|dwf bok uy`ugy/ D`y gqbmufg& gtgo no

{ag |ggcz fgbknol wu {` {ag ufgb blyggmgo{& My/ Yb~ {`fk {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ ag

‖abko„{ zggo bo~{anol |y`ol |n{a {ag uyg-Z@Q” uy`jgzz& bok {ab{ ‖So]` bfbym igffz

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 24 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 17/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

2:KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

|gyg {ynllgygk d`y Sanm] j`ojgyonol CI„z `u{n`o kb{nol uybj{njgz wo{nf 9554” |ago

{ag mgknb dygox~ o ibjckb{nol b{ `{agy j`mubongz iglbo/ Bw Kgjf/ ´ <& Gqa/ D

!Lby~ Yb~ D`ym :59 kb{gk 259;51. b{ ;-7/

My/ Yb~ mbno{bnogk ygugb{gkf~ {ab{ {ag uybj{njg |bz {ybozubygo{& z{b{nol {ab{

ag ‖bf|b~z igfngtgk {ag~ abk b {ybozubygo{ uy`jgzz& igjbwzg `d {ag k~obmnj `d 

CI„z |`ycnol gotny`omgo{/”  Nk/ ‖SA]g knko„{ igfngtg n{ |bz b zgjyg{ a`| {ag~

unjcgk {ag lybo{ kb{g/ CI |bzo„{ b d`ymbf gotny`omgo{ bok znojg Sag] |bzo„{

anknol bo~{anol& ag dnlwygk {ab{ gtgy~`og cog|/” Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ G b{ 4/ No dbj{&

My/ Yb~ {`fk {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ ag fncgk {ag lybo{ uybj{njg igjbwzg ag ‖dgf{ {ab{

ja``znol b f`| z{`jc uynjg |bz b l``k i``z{gy {` gmuf`~gg m`ybfgS/]” Bw Kgjf/ ´

1& Gqa/ L !Lby~ Yb~ D`ym :59 kb{gk 22;51. b{ ;/ Bok {agzg bzzgy{n`oz `d 

noo`jgojg byg j`oznz{go{ |n{a My/ Yb~„z `|o o`{gz |yn{{go no mnk-9554‛igd`yg

ag kgjnkgk {` ufgbk lwnf{~‛no |anja ag tnl`y`wzf~ kgdgokgk {ag z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{

uybj{njg bok j`odnymgk {ab{ mboblgmgo{ abk bf|b~z igfngtgk {ag uybj{njg {` ig

fb|dwf/ Zgg Bw Kgjf/ ´ >& Gqa/ A !Lby~ Yb~ Abok|yn{{go O`{gz. b{ 2/  Bjj`yk  nk/ ´

25& Gqa/ N !Lby~ Yb~ Abok|yn{{go O`{gz `o Mgm`ybokwm Uygubygk i~ CI A`mg

J`wozgf Mwolgy& [`ffgz $ @fz`o FFU kb{gk Hwog 94& 9554./My/ Yb~ dwokbmgo{bff~ jabffgolgk {ag l`tgyomgo{„z {ag`y~ {ab{ ag bok 

My/ Cbyb{x zgfgj{gk {ag lybo{ kb{g bok gqgyjnzg uynjg |n{a jynmnobf no{go{/ Ag {`fk

{ag l`tgyomgo{ {ab{ anz ‖nkgb `d ibjckb{nol |bz kb{nol `u{n`oz igd`yg {ag kb{g {ab{

{ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg mg{”‛b uybj{njg {ab{ ogtgy abuugogk b{ CI A`mg/

Zgg Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ D b{ 2/ Ag gtgo {`fk CI A`mg„z lgogybf j`wozgf kwynol {ag

no{gyobf notgz{nlb{n`o {ab{ ‖{ag lybo{ kb{g |bz {ag kb~ {ag~ unjcgk&” nk/ b{ 9& bok

{ab{ gtgo d`ff`|nol {ag Zbyibogz-@qfg~ Bj{& ag ‖|bz z{nff `d {ag igfngd {ab{ {ag

lybo{ kb{g |bz {ag kb{g zgfgj{gk d`y {ag lybo{ kb{g/ N{ |bz `cb~ igjbwzg {ag~ wzgk

{ag mbycg{ uynjg `o {ag kb~ {ab{ |bz unjcgk/” Bw Kgjf/& Gqa/ D b{ ;/

J`oznz{go{ |n{a {ag gtnkgojg& My/ Yb~ abz mbno{bnogk {` {ag l`tgyomgo{

{ab{ gtgy~`og not`ftgk no CI A`mg„z z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uy`jgzz& nojfwknol

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 2< `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 18/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

2;KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

anmzgfd bok My/ Cbyb{x& igfngtgk {ab{ n{ |bz fb|dwf/ Kgzun{g {ab{& {ag uy`zgjw{`yz

gddgj{ntgf~ dfnuugk My/ Yb~& jbun{bfnxnol `o {aygb{z `d b fgol{a~ uynz`o {gym& bok ag

nz o`| gqugj{gk {` lntg {gz{nm`o~ dbt`ybifg {` {ag l`tgyomgo{ uwyzwbo{ {` {ag

{gymz `d anz j``ugyb{n`o blyggmgo{/

NNN/  BYLWMGO[

B/  Iywjg Cbyb{x„z nobinfn{~ {` jbff Hbmgz H`aoz`o bok Lby~ Yb~ bz|n{ogzzgz `o anz igabfd abmugyz anz binfn{~ {` uw{ `o b kgdgozg/

Hbmgz H`aoz`o bok Lby~ Yb~ byg bm`ol {ag {|` m`z{ jywjnbf |n{ogzzgz no

{anz jbzg/ Bz Jabny bok& fb{gy& mgmigy `d CI A`mg„z J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg&

My/ H`aoz`o |bz ygzu`oznifg d`y fgbknol {ag J`mubo~ no buuy`tnol bok dwoknol

z{`jc `u{n`o b|bykz d y gmuf`~ggz& bok zg{{nol j`mugozb{n`o u`fnj~/ Bok bz {ag

agbk `d Awmbo Ygz`wyjgz& Lby~ Yb~ bkmnonz{gygk {ab{ j`mugozb{n`o u`fnj~ `o b

j`mubo~|nkg ibznz/ [ag~ uygtn`wzf~ mbkg u`|gydwf gqjwfub{`y~ z{b{gmgo{z `o

igabfd `d My/ Cbyb{x bok no kgdgozg `d {ag z{`jc `u{n`o lybo{ uy`jgzz‛{ag uy`jgzz

d`y |anja {ag~ |gyg i`{a ugyz`obff~ ygzu`oznifg/ Uygzgo{f~& a`|gtgy& My/ H`aoz`o

jbo o` f`olgy ig jbffgk bz b kgdgozg |n{ogzz bd{gy abtnol kybmb{njbff~ dfnuugk anz

{gz{nm`o~ no dbt`y `d {ag l`tgyomgo{ kgzun{g gbyfngy z{b{gmgo{z no dbt`y `d My/

Cbyb{x„z kgdgozg& bok l`nol z` dby bz {` kgo~ abtnol mbkg {a`zg gbyfngy z{b{gmgo{z/

My/ Yb~ abz bfz` iggo gddgj{ntgf~ dfnuugk& bd{gy ogl`{nb{nol b j``ugyb{n`o ufgb

blyggmgo{ |n{a {ag l`tgyomgo{ d`y j`okwj{ {ab{ |bz o`{ gtgo jynmnobf/

[agzg jnyjwmz{bojgz ybnzg b z{y`ol nodgygojg `d u`{go{nbf l`tgyomgo{

mnzj`okwj{& bok abmugy My/ Cbyb{x„z binfn{~ {` uygzgo{ b kgdgozg/ [ag Zwuygmg

J`wy{ abz mbkg jfgby {ab{8

S{]ag ynla{ {` `ddgy {ag {gz{nm`o~ `d |n{ogzzgz& bok {` j`mugf {agnyb{{gokbojg& nd ogjgzzby~& nz no ufbno {gymz {ag ynla{ {` uygzgo{ bkgdgozg& {ag ynla{ {` uygzgo{ {ag kgdgokbo{„z tgyzn`o `d {ag dbj{z bz|gff bz {ag uy`zgjw{n`o„z {` {ag hwy~ z` n{ mb~ kgjnkg |agyg {ag {yw{afngz / / / [anz ynla{ nz b dwokbmgo{bf gfgmgo{ `d kwg uy`jgzz `d fb|/

\bzanol{`o t/ [gqbz& :11 W/Z/ 2;& 2> !2>4<./  Bjj`yk Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Ifbjc & <4<

D/9k 2::;& 2::< !>{a Jny/ 2>17. !‖S[]ag l`tgyomgo{ mb~ o`{ no{gydgyg |n{a

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 21 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 19/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

27KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

kgdgozg bjjgzz {` |n{ogzzgz/”./ Hwklg Jbyog~ ygj`lonxgk {ag znlondnjbojg `d {anz

ynla{ |ago ag `ykgygk bo gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol wu`o dnoknol b z{y`ol nodgygojg {ab{

{ag l`tgyomgo{ abk unjcgk `dd u`{go{nbf kgdgozg |n{ogzzgz& `og-i~-`og& |n{a

{aygb{z& no{nmnkb{n`o& bok i`lwz ufgb blyggmgo{z no gqjabolg d`y j``ugyb{n`o/ Ag

d`wok {ab{& d`y {ag kgdgokbo{„z kwg uy`jgzz ynla{z {` abtg bo~ mgbonol& ‖{ag

l`tgyomgo{ mwz{ o`{ k` bo~{anol {` no{nmnkb{g `y nmuy`ugyf~ nodfwgojg |n{ogzzgz/”

Bw Kgjf/ YHO& Gqa/ B b{ 72>7827-2</

Bok n{ |bz `of~ bd{gy j`okwj{nol {ag gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol j`wfk Hwklg Jbyog~

ufbnof~ z{b{g& ‖N o`| co`| {ag go{nyg z{`y~ `d |ab{ abuugogk/”  Nk/ b{ 72>789-:/

Hwklg Jbyog~ ygj`lonxgk {ab{ igjbwzg& bz agyg& {ag kgdgokbo{z„ jynmnobf no{go{ |bz

{ag jgo{ybf nzzwg igd`yg {ag hwy~& ‖n{ |bz nmugyb{ntg / / / {` jbff {ag S] btbnfbifg

|n{ogzzgz |a` abk co`|fgklg `d S{ag j`mubo~„z] z{`jc-`u{n`o lybo{nol uybj{njgz/”

 Nk/ b{ 72>782>-9:/ Ag d`wok {ab{ {ag l`tgyomgo{ abk ygokgygk {a`zg |n{ogzzgz

wobtbnfbifg d`y {ag kgdgozg i~ abybzznol `og‛Oboj~ [wff`z‛bok j`gyjnol agy

no{` go{gynol no{` bo ‖wowzwbf” ufgb blyggmgo{ |n{a b ‖rwgz{n`obifg dbj{wbf ibznz3”

cggunol `og‛Kbtnk Kwff‛‖abolnol no {ag |nok” bok wojgy{bno `d |ag{agy {ag

l`tgyomgo{ |`wfk jabylg anm3 bok iwff~nol {ag {anyk‛Agoy~ Zbmwgfn‛no{`ufgbknol lwnf{~ {` b jynmg ag knk o`{ j`mmn{/  Nk/ b{ 72>48:-72>>8;/ My/ Cbyb{x

m`tgz d`y bo gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol z` {ab{ {ag ‖go{nyg z{`y~ `d |ab{ abuugogk” |n{a

ygzugj{ {` My/ H`aoz`o„z kybmb{nj ygtgyzbf `d {gz{nm`o~ bok kgonbf `d uyn`y

z{b{gmgo{z& bok My/ Yb~„z wowzwbf j``ugyb{n`o ufgb blyggmgo{ jbo j`mg {` fnla{/

No {ag dbjg `d zwzunjn`wz jnyjwmz{bojgz ybnznol bo nodgygojg `d u`zznifg

uy`zgjw{`ynbf mnzj`okwj{& {ag J`wy{ abz {ag bw{a`yn{~ {` `ykgy bo gtnkgo{nby~

agbynol uwyzwbo{ {` n{z zwugytnz`y~ u`|gyz/ [ag Ono{a Jnyjwn{ abz ygj`lonxgk

gquygzzf~ {ab{ {ag ‖gqgyjnzg `d zwugytnz`y~ u`|gyz nz bo buuy`uynb{g mgboz `d 

u`fnjnol g{anjbf mnzj`okwj{ i~ uy`zgjw{`yz/” Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ F`ugx& ; D/:k 2;77&

2;4: !>{a Jny/ 2>>:./ M`yg`tgy& {ag J`wy{ abz {ag bw{a`yn{~ ‖{` ybnzg zwb zu`o{g

mb{{gyz {ab{ mb~ bddgj{ {ag ynla{z `d jynmnobf kgdgokbo{z/” Won{gk Z{b{gz t/

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 2> `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 20/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

24KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

 Kgflbk`-Jbykgobz& ><; D/9k 29:& 294 !>{a Jny/ 2>>9./ Uwyzwbo{ {` {ab{

zwugytnz`y~ u`|gy& ‖Sn]d& no dbj{& b mb{gynbf nzzwg `d dbj{ |gyg ybnzgk ‑|anja nd 

ygz`ftgk no bjj`ykbojg |n{a !buugffbo{„z. j`o{go{n`oz |`wfk go{n{fg anm {` ygfngd&„

bo gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol |`wfk ig ygrwnygk/” Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Ny|no& 429 D/9k 2219&

221< !>{a Jny/ 2>15. !rw`{nol \ynla{ t/ Knjcnoz`o& ::4 D/9k 1<1& 112 !>{a Jny/

2>4;../ [ag dbj{wbf bffglb{n oz zg{ d`y{a bz {ag ibznz d`y {ag oggk d y {ag agbynol

mwz{ ig bzzwmgk bz {ywg/ Zgg nk/ Buuf~nol {anz z{bokbyk {` {ag dbj{z kgzjynigk

bi`tg bok no {ag b{{bjagk gqanin{z& {ag gqgyjnzg `d {ag J`wy{„z zwugytnz`y~ u`|gyz

nz hwz{ndngk/

My/ H`aoz`o„z z{b{gmgo{z {` Nygff& mgm`ynbfnxgk no {ag Nygff Mgm` bok

jbu{wygk no z{byc kg{bnf i~ {ag Nygff O`{gz& j`mu`y{ |n{a cg~ gfgmgo{z `d 

My/ Cbyb{x„z kgdgozg/ [a`zg z{b{gmgo{z gz{bifnza {ab{ My/ Cbyb{x„z jabylgk bj{z

|gyg buuy`tgk& b{ fgbz{ kg dbj{`& i~ {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg/ My/ H`aoz`o

z{b{gk {ab{& gtgo bz Jabny `d {ag J`mmn{{gg& ag abk o` gqugj{b{n`o bz {` |ab{ {ag

lybo{ kb{g d`y `u{n`oz za`wfk ig& bok ag |bz j`odnkgo{ no {ag bkmnonz{yb{ntg uy`jgzz

mboblgmgo{ wzgk { zgfgj{ {ab{ kb{g/ Dwy{agy& i~ {gffnol Nygff {ab{ ag |`wfk o`{ ig

j`ojgyogk nd {ag lybo{ kb{g |bz zgfgj{gk znmuf~ `o {ag ibznz {ab{ n{ abk {ag igz{uynjg& My/ H`aoz`o dwokbmgo{bff~ jabffgolgk {ag uygmnzg `d {ag l`tgyomgo{„z jbzg

blbnoz{ My/ Cbyb{x/ Nd gtgo {ag J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg„z Jabny knk o`{ abtg b

uy`ifgm |n{a f``cnol ibjc {` unjc b lybo{ kb{g ibzgk `o {ag igz{ uynjg& {ago {ag

l`tgyomgo{„z jbzg dbffz buby{/ Dwy{agy& My/ H`aoz`o mbkg jfgby {` Nygff {ab{

gtgy~`og not`ftgk no {ag lybo{ uybj{njg |bz b|byg {ab{ mboblgmgo{ |bz zgfgj{nol

{ag kb{g bok igfngtgk {ag uy`jgzz {` ig buuy`uynb{g& bok {ag J`mubo~ ygfngk `o

gqugy{z {` gozwyg {ab{ {agny igfngd |bz bjjwyb{g/

My/ H`aoz`o„z z{b{gmgo{z jabffgolg agbk-`o {ag l`tgyomgo{„z {ag`y~ {ab{

My/ Cbyb{x ogdbyn`wzf~ j`ojgbfgk {ag lybo{ uybj{njg dy`m {ag J`mugozb{n`o

J`mmn{{gg/ No dbj{& anz z{b{gmgo{z {` Nygff mbcg `w{ b zjgobyn` no |anja {ag

J`mmn{{gg nz bj{wbff~ j`mufnjn{ no {ag j`okwj{ {ag l`tgyomgo{ o`| tng|z bz

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 95 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 21/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

2<KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

jynmnobf/ N{ nz ygbz`obifg {` nodgy {ab{ {ag l`tgyomgo{ mbkg My/ H`aoz`o b|byg `d 

{ag kbolgy`wz nmufnjb{n`oz `d {agzg z{b{gmgo{z/ Ygj`lonxnol {a`zg kbolgyz&

My/ H`aoz`o lbtg {ag l`tgyomgo{ b knddgygo{ tgyzn`o `d gtgo{z‛`og {ab{ dn{ |n{a

{ag l`tgyomgo{„z {ag`y~ `d {ag jbzg& knzbzz`jnb{nol i`{a anmzgfd bok {ag

J`mugozb{n`o J`mmn{{gg dy`m co`|fgklg d bo~{anol mboblgmgo{ knk |n{a

ygzugj{ {` `u{n`oz/ My/ H`aoz`o bfz` kgongk co`|fgklg `y ygj`ffgj{n`o `d anz `|o

z{b{gmgo{z {` Nygff& ygdfgj{nol anz oggk {` nozwfb{g anmzgfd gtgo dwy{agy/ Iw{ |g o`|

co`| {ab{ {a`zg kgonbfz |gyg dbfzg/ Bok kgzun{g co`|nol bi`w{ {agzg kybmb{nj

jabolgz no My/ H`aoz`o„z {gz{nm`o~& {ag l`tgyomgo{ z{nff uw{ anm igd`yg {ag lybok

 hwy~ bok gfnjn{gk {ag tgyzn`o `d gtgo{z zwzunjn`wzf~ dbt`ybifg {` {ag l`tgyomgo{ z`

{ab{ n{ j`wfk lg{ bo noknj{mgo{ yg{wyogk/

A`| bok |a~ My/ H`aoz`o mbkg gqjwfub{`y~ z{b{gmgo{z no dbt`y `d My/

Cbyb{x {` Nygff `o jywjnbf nzzwgz {ab{ |nff ig {yngk no {anz jbzg& {ago dbfzgf~ kgongk

{ab{ ag mbkg zwja z{b{gmgo{z |ago zugbcnol {` {ag l`tgyomgo{& bok {ago uy`tnkgk

knbmg{ynjbff~-`uu`zgk {gz{nm`o~ no dbt`y d {ag l`tgyomgo{ ybnzgz {y`wifnol

nodgygojgz {ab{ jbo `of~ ig woj`tgygk no bo gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol/

Bkkn{n`obff~& My/ Yb~„z jwyygo{ u`z{wyg bz b l`tgyomgo{ |n{ogzz bd{gy ~gbyz`d mbno{bnonol anz noo`jgojg bok kgdgoknol {` {ag l`tgyomgo{ {ag `u{n`oz lybo{

uy`jgzz b{ {ag J`mubo~ mwz{ bfz` ig gquf ygk b{ b agbynol/ My/ Yb~„z bo{njnub{gk

{gz{nm`o~ `o {ag lybo{ uy`jgzz |nff ig bm`ol {ag m`z{ jywjnbf no {anz jbzg/ Ag |bz

no{nmb{gf~ not`ftgk no tny{wbff~ gtgy~ bzugj{ `d lybo{ bff`jb{n`o& uynjnol& bok

bkmnonz{yb{n`o/ Igd`yg {ag l`tgyomgo{ l`{ ba`fk d My/ Yb~& ag |`wfk abtg

{gz{ndngk {ab{ ag& My/ Cbyb{x& bok gtgy~`og not`ftgk no {ag lybo{ uy`jgzz b{ CI

A`mg igfngtgk n{ {` ig fb|dwf& bok abk o` no{go{ {` wzg {ag uy`jgzz bz b mgboz {`

kgdybwk d`y {agny igogdn{/ My/ Yb~ z{bokz igd yg {ag J`wy{ {`kb~& a`|gtgy& bz b

dgf`o& abtnol ogl`{nb{gk b ufgb blyggmgo{ d`y b o`o-gqnz{go{ jynmg {` uy`{gj{

anmzgfd dy`m uynz`o/

Wokgy inoknol Zwuygmg J`wy{ uygjgkgo{& a`|gtgy& My/ Yb~„z jabylgk

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 92 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 22/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

21KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

j`okwj{ |bz o`{ jynmnobf/ No Won{gk Z{b{gz t/ Blwnfby & 727 W/Z/ 7>: !2>>7.& {ag

Zwuygmg J`wy{ agfk {agyg mwz{ ig b ‖ogqwz” no ‖{nmg& jbwzb{n`o& `y f`lnj” ig{|ggo

{ag bffglgkf~ `iz{ywj{ntg bj{ bok {ag bnm `d {ag `iz{ywj{n`o/  Nk/ b{ 7>>/ No Blwnfby &

{ag Zwuygmg J`wy{ yghgj{gk bz ‖zugjwfb{ntg” {ag l`tgyomgo{„z {ag`y~ {ab{ b

kgdgokbo{ nz lwnf{~ `d `iz{ywj{nol b ugoknol lybok hwy~ uy`jggknol |agyg ag mbkg

dbfzg z{b{gmgo{z {` bo notgz{nlb{nol blgo{ ‖|a` mnla{ `y mnla{ o`{ {gz{nd~ igd`yg

S{ab{] lybok hwy~/”  Nk/ b{ 455-52/ [ag Zwuygmg J`wy{ z{ygol{agogk {anz ogqwz

ygrwnygmgo{ bok gq{gokgk Blwnfby no By{awy Bokgyzgo FFU t/ Won{gk Z{b{gz& 7;;

W/Z/ 4>4 !9557./ N{ agfk {ab{ hwy~ noz{ywj{n`oz |gyg ‖jyn{njbff~ dfb|gk” |agyg {ag~

‖fgk {ag hwy~ {` igfngtg {ab{ n{ knk o`{ abtg {` dnok bo~ ogqwz ig{|ggo {ag

ugyzwbSzn`o] {` kgz{y`~ k`jwmgo{z Swokgy 21 W/Z/J/ ¬ 2729!i.] bok bo~ uby{njwfby

uy`jggknol/”  Nk/ b{ <5</ No k`nol z`& {ag By{awy Bokgyzgo J`wy{ mbkg jfgby {ab{

gtgo iy`bk z{b{w{`y~ fbolwblg k`gz o`{ fgbtg y``m d`y {ag l`tgyomgo{ {` bylwg

{ab{ b uy`jggknol ‖oggk o`{ gtgo ig d`ygzggo/”  Nk/ b{ <5<-51/ Zgg bfz` Won{gk 

Z{b{gz t/ Kwoo& ;:; D/ Zwuu/ 9k 295:& 295< o/9 !M/K/ Bfb/ 9554. !o`{nol {ab{ bo

‖`ddnjnbf uy`jggknol” wokgy zgj{n`o 2729!i. nz o`{ d`ygzggbifg hwz{ igjbwzg n{ nz

u`zznifg./ Agyg& {agyg |bz o` ‖j`o{gmufb{gk” notgz{nlb{n`o i~ {ag ZGJ no{` z{`jc 

`u{n`o lybo{ nzzwgz b{ {ag J`mubo~ b{ {ag {nmg `d My/ Yb~„z bffglgkf~ `iz{ywj{ntg

bj{z& fg{ bf`og {ag ygrwnzn{g ogqwz {` zwja bo notgz{nlb{n`o/ No dbj{& {ag l`tgyomgo{

gtgo bjco`|fgklgk bz mwja |ago n{ bjjgu{gk anz ufgb& wznol fbolwblg {`

kgm`oz{yb{g hwz{ a`| b{{gowb{gk {ag uwyu`y{gk j`oogj{n`o ig{|ggo bo~ dw{wyg&

u`zznifg ZGJ notgz{nlb{n`o bok My/ Yb~„z bj{z |bz8 ‖[ag JG@ bok Yb~ i`{a

blyggk {ab{ nd {anz no{gyobf notgz{nlb{n`o |bz o`{ j`o{y`ffgk& n{ j`wfk gt`ftg no{` bo

nokgugokgo{ notgz{nlb{n`o {ab{ j`wfk u`zznif~ fgbk {`& bm`ol `{agy {anolz& bo ZGJ

notgz{nlb{n`o& b j`ozgrwgojg {ab{ abk iggo uwifnjf~ ygu`y{gk b{ b owmigy `d 

j`mubongz/” Bw Kgjf/ YHO& Gqa/ I b{ 9>89:-:589 !gmuabznz bkkgk./ O`|agyg

k`gz {ag l`tgyomgo{ z{b{g {ab{ b{ {ag {nmg My/ Yb~ bffglgkf~ mbkg dbfzg z{b{gmgo{z

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 99 `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 23/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

2>KGDGOKBO[„Z M@[N@O D@Y GTNKGO[NBY^ AGBYNOL YG [GZ[NM@O^ @D JYWJNBF \N[OGZZGZ

JBZG O@/ JY O`/ 5>-95:-@K\;4;7>;/52

{` {ag J`mubo~„z lgogybf j`wozgf& {ag ZGJ j`o{gmufb{gk bo notgz{nlb{n`o no{` CI

A`mg„z lybo{ uybj{njg/ [ag notgz{nlb{n`o b{ CI A`mg |bz uwygf~ no{gyobf kwynol

{ag {nmg ugyn`k jabylgk no {ag Nod`ymb{n`o/

Bf{a`wla n{ nz o`{ j`mufg{gf~ jfgby |a~ My/ Yb~ ufgbkgk lwnf{~& {ag z{y`ol

nodgygojg nz {ab{ n{ bff`|gk anm {` bt`nk {ag u`zzninfn{~ `d b kyb|o-`w{ jynmnobf

uy`zgjw{n`o‛|anja {ag l`tgyomgo{ {aygb{gogk‛kwynol b {nmg d knyg ugyz`obf

jnyjwmz{bojgz& nojfwknol bo nff zu`wzg/ Ufgbknol lwnf{~ {` {ag jabylgk jynmg bfz`

mgbo{ {ab{ My/ Yb~ |`wfk fncgf~ o`{ abtg {` zgytg bo~ uynz`o {nmg o`y ub~

ygz{n{w{n`o& {agygi~ cggunol {ag zwiz{bo{nbf |gbf{a {ab{ ag abk bjrwnygk no {ag d`ym

`d CI A`mg z{`jc u{n`oz/ D`y {ag l`tgyomgo{& {ag jabylg bok {ag zwizgrwgo{

ufgb blyggmgo{& {a`wla notbfnk& zgjwygk My/ Yb~„z j``ugyb{n`o bok {gz{nm`o~

blbnoz{ My/ Cbyb{x/ M`yg`tgy& {ag ufgb blyggmgo{ mbkg My/ Yb~ b dgf`o/ No k`nol

z`& {ag uy`zgjw{`yz `ugyb{gk wokgy {ag zbmg ygbz`onol bz {agny j`ffgblwgz

uy`zgjw{nol Ywgafg/ No Hwklg Jbyog~„z |`ykz& {ag l`tgyomgo{ uygdgyz d`y n{z z{by

|n{ogzz {` ufgbk {` b dgf`o~ igjbwzg ‖n{ f``cSz] m`yg j`otnojnol {` b hwy~/” Bw

Kgjf/ YHO& Gqa/ B b{ 72>4827-24/

I/ 

@of~ b uyg-{ynbf gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol |nff bff`| {ag J`wy{ bok kgdgozgj`wozgf {` woj`tgy {ag {ywg jnyjwmz{bojgz wokgy |anja Hbmgz H`aoz`obok Lby~ Yb~ igjbmg l`tgyomgo{ |n{ogzzgz/

Bo gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol ibjcgk i~ {ag J`wy{„z zwiu`gob u`|gy nz {ag `of~

ygmgk~ {ab{ jbo woj`tgy {ag {ywg jnyjwmz{bojgz zwyy`woknol My/ H`aoz`o„z dbfzg

kgonbfz `d uyn`y z{b{gmgo{z bok kybmb{nj jabolg no {gz{nm`o~& bok My/ Yb~„z

wowzwbf lwnf{~ ufgb/ \g gqugj{ {ab{ {ag l`tgyomgo{ mb~ bylwg& d`y gqbmufg& {ab{

kgdgozg j`wozgf nz dygg {` jy`zz-gqbmnog My/ H`aoz`o b{ {ynbf bok zggc {` nmugbja

anm |n{a anz z{b{gmgo{z {` Nygff/ [ab{ bylwmgo{ mnzzgz {ag u`no{/ My/ Cbyb{x„z

no{gygz{ nz o`{ {` knzjygkn{ My/ H`aoz`o i~ nmugbjanol anm3 anz dwokbmgo{bf

no{gygz{ nz d`y My/ H`aoz`o {` {gff {ag {yw{a/ Nd {ag l`tgyomgo{ abz jbwzgk

My/ H`aoz`o {` dgby {gffnol {ag {yw{a‛bz ag dyggf~ {`fk Nygff‛{ago My/ Cbyb{x„z

ynla{ {` jbff |n{ogzzgz no anz kgdgozg abz bfygbk~ iggo kguyntgk/ Znmnfbyf~& nd {ag

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 9: `d 9;

8/14/2019 Defense Motion in U.S. v. Karatz

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/defense-motion-in-us-v-karatz 24/24

2

9

:

;

7

4

<

1

>

25

22

29

2:

2;

27

24

2<21

2>

95

92

99

9:

9;

97

94

9<

91

 

l`tgyomgo{ jbwzgk My/ Yb~ {` ibylbno b|b~ {ag {yw{a no gqjabolg d`y fgongoj~

uwyzwbo{ {` anz ufgb blyggmgo{& My/ Cbyb{x„z ynla{z abtg iggo j`muy`mnzgk/

No Ywgafg& Hwklg Jbyog~ d`wok {ab{ {ag l`tgyomgo{„z mnzj`okwj{ {`|byk

Oboj~ [wff`z |bz ogn{agy gybzgk o`y ygmgkngk i~ {ag kgdgokbo{z„ binfn{~ {` jy`zz-

gqbmnog agy b{ {ynbf/ Agy {gz{nm`o~ abk bfygbk~ iggo nyygubybif~ ‖{bno{gk” i~ {ag

l`tgyomgo{„z mbonuwfb{n`o/  Nk/ b{ 72>>824/ No dbj{& {ag kgdgozg abk {ag

`uu`y{won{~ {` jy`zz-gqbmnog bff `d {ag |n{ogzzgz |a` abk iggo mbonuwfb{gk i~ {ag

l`tgyomgo{& ~g{ Hwklg Jbyog~ z{nff {ayg| `w{ {ag noknj{mgo{z `o {ag z`fg ly`wok

{ab{ {ag kgdgokbo{z abk iggo kgongk {agny ynla{ {` jbff {agzg |n{ogzzgz `o {agny `|o

igabfd/ \ag{agy {ab{ zbmg ynla{ abz iggo kguyntgk agyg nz b rwgz{n o {ab{ jbo `of~

ig boz|gygk {ay`wla b uyg-{ynbf gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol kwynol |anja My/ H`aoz`o&

My/ Yb~& bok `{agyz byg uw{ wokgy `b{a bok igd`yg {anz J`wy{/

NT/  J@OJFWZN@O

D`y bff {ag ygbz`oz z{b{gk bi`tg& My/ Cbyb{x ygzugj{dwff~ ygrwgz{z {ab{ {ag

J`wy{ j`okwj{ bo gtnkgo{nby~ agbynol `o {ag l`tgyomgo{„z mnzj`okwj{ no

uy`zgjw{nol {anz mb{{gy/

Kb{gk8 Hbowby~ ;& 9525 Ygzugj{dwff~ zwimn{{gk&

CGCGY $ TBO OGZ[ FFUJBFK\GFF FGZFNG $ UY@J[@Y& UJ

I~8  z H`ao \/ Cgcgy H@AO \/ CGCGY

B{{`yog~z d`y Kgdgokbo{ IYWJG CBYB[X 

Jbzg 985>-jy-5595:-@K\ K`jwmgo{ 15 Dnfgk 52/5;/9525 Ublg 9; `d 9;