Declaration of Lee D. Apotheker, Favors v. Cuomo Redistricting Case

8/2/2019 Declaration of Lee D. Apotheker, Favors v. Cuomo Redistricting Case

1/23

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTEASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK xMA RK, A. FAVORS, et al. C.A. No. 11-CV-05632Plaintiffs,RR)(GEL)(DLI)(RLM)v.

ANDREW M. CUOM O, et al .Defendants.

ECF CASE

DECLARATION OF LEE D. APOTHEICERLee D . Apotheker declares pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 17461. I am an A ssociate with the law firm of Pannone Lopes D evereaux & West LLC , which

represents Plaintiff-Intervenor Yitzchok U llman in the abov e-captioned action. I submit thisdeclaration in opposition to the Assembly Ma jority Defend ants' Motion to Dismiss

2. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of the Hudson V alley section ofCom mon C ause's State Assembly Redistricting Plan.

3. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of the results from Ram apoElection District 55 from the 20 10 elections. These results have been ex cerpted fromhttp://www.co sockland.nv.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt

4. Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and correct copy of the results from Ram apoElection District 58 from the 2 010 elections. These results have bee n excerpted fromhttp://www.co.rockland.ny.us/BOE/EL30110210.tx t

5. Attached hereto as Exhibit D is a true and correct copy of the results from Ram apoElection District 35 from the 2010 e lections. These results have be en excerpted fromhttp://www.co sockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.

Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 297-1 Filed 04/09/12 Page 1 of 23 PageID #:4641


2/23

Lee D. Apotheker

Dated: White Plains, New YorkApril 9, 2012



3/23

EXHIBITA



4/23



5/23

Common Cause Reform PlanLower Hudson State Assembly - CC Reform A D 89 consists of MountPleasant, Ossining, and northeastWestchester to become a morecompact central/North Westchesterdistrict.

- CC Reform AD 90 is a highly compactnorthwest Westchester districtincluding Peekskill, Cortlandt,Yorktown, New Castle, and MountKisco.

- CC Reform AD 99 keeps PutnamCounty whole, adding Somers inWestchester and Pawling in Dutchessto balance population numbers.

- The CC Reform M ap splits RocklandCounty between three ADs (94, 95,96), rather than four as it is currently.

COMMON CAUSE REFORM MAPS STATE ASSEMBLY REDISTRICTING PLANage I 38HUDSON VALLEYComm on Cause Reform Map descr iption and explanat ion

- The Mid-Hudson region, including Northern Westchester, Rockland, Orange, Putnam, Southern Dutchess, and Southern Ulster counties,grew by over 7% from 2000 to 2010. Due to this significant growth, many of the current ADs are now severely overpopulated.

o Since Assembly districts must follow town boundaries whenever possible, the Common Cause Reform Maps group certain townstogether in the same district in order to achieve relative equivalence of population between the districts within the targetedpopulation variance.o The CC Reform Pan attempts to keep regional communities of interest (e.g. Hudson riverfront vs. Catskills, Poughkeepsie metroarea vs. Newburgh-Beacon metro area) together as much as possible.



6/23

Y.12/0 Irian Paul, Common CauCommon Cause Reform PlanOrange/South Ulster State Assembly

wIns. '10mites

COMMON CAUSE REFORM MAPSSTATE ASSEMBLY REDISTRICTING PLAN Page I 39

CC Reform AD 94 includes the entire town of Ramapo, which has grown to a size very close to the ideal population for a district.- CC Reform AD 95 is drawn to combine almost all of Clarkstown and Orangetown.

The Common Cause Reform Plan maintains +/- 3% as the range in which districts can be drawn in order to bettercomply with the principle of one person, one vote. The town of Orangetown cannot be combined with Ramapo,Clarkstown, or Greenburgh across the river without exceeding +1- 3%. So the plan must break a town in Rockland Countyin order to comply with the population deviation rules set forth in the Common Cause criteria.

A small area of Clarkstown directly adjacent to the downtown Spring Valley area in Ramapo is added to CCReform AD 94. Since the Spring Valley area is a distinct community of interest within Rockland County, it'sappropriate to keep it together.

CC Reform A D 96 covers the northRockland and south Orange Countyriverfront, an area characterized by thehighlands of Harriman and BearMountain State Parks.In Orange County, CC Reform AD 97keeps Middletown within a compact basecomposed of western Orange County,including Middletown and Port Jervis. Itis preferable to include Middletownwithin an Orange County outer suburbsdistrict rather than one that extends farto the north into the rural Catskills.

- CC Re fo rm AD 98 i s d rawn as a compac tcentral Orange--south Ulster district, anarea which experienced particularlyheavy population growth during the lastten years. Central Orange-S outh Ulster isdistinct from either the Hudsonriverfront or the interior Catskills.



7/23

- CC Reform AD 100 keepsNewburgh and Beacon (which liedirectly across the Hudsonconnected by I-84) together,grouping them with the towns ofFishkill and New Windsor, but notincluding Poughkeepsie.CC Reform AD 101 is compact andcentered on the Hudsonwaterfront from Lloyd and NewPaltz in the south to Saugertiesand Red Hook in the north.

- CC Reform AD 102 consists ofPoughkeepsie and its surroundingsuburbs.

- CC Reform AD 103 covers themore rural and agricultural areasof Dutchess and Columbiacounties.

Common Cause Reform PlanMid-Hudson State Assembly

Rhinebeck

COMMON CAUSE REFORM MAPS STATE ASSEMBLY REDISTRICTING PLAN Page 140

- Although there's an argument to be made for keeping Poughkeepsie together with Newburgh and Beacon based on demographiccommonalities, Poughkeepsie and Newburgh-Beacon are distinct areas, each forming the center of its own local economy. The City ofPoughkeepsie should not be separated from the surrounding Town of Poughkeepsie, and Beacon should not be separated from Fishkill.CC R eform AD 1 07 is a com pact Catskills district consisting of Sullivan and parts of Ulster and Delaware counties. The Southern T ier andHudson-Catskills area are completely distinct regions of the state with different issues and priorities. Accordingy, the Common CauseReform Map draws districts which do not transect these two regions.



8/23

COMMON CAUSE REFORM MAPS - STATE ASSEMBLY R EDISTRICTING PLANage 1 41Major Demographic Changes:- No major demographic changes, other than a 7% increase in total population in the region including Northern Westchester, Rockland,Orange, Putnam, Southern Dutchess, and Southern Ulster counties from 2000 to 2010. A detailed analysis of the demographics of thisregion, including illustrative maps and a discussion of some of the assumptions and factors shaping the districts drawn in the CommonCause Reform Map can be found on Common Cause/NY's redistricting blog, Mapping Democracy.

DIST POP %DEV %NHWhtVAP %NHBIkVAP %NHAsnVAP %HspVAP89 130,450 1.1% 73.0% 4.9% 4.3% 16.8%90 129,813 0.6% 71.8% 6.9% 4.2% 15.9%94 131,361 1.8% 59.1% 18.8% 4.7% 15.8%95 128,850 -0.2% 74.0% 6.3% 9.3% 9.1%96 128,195 -0.7% 69.9% 6.3% 3.5% 18.7%97 129,226 0.1% 71.3% 8.7% 2.0% 16.2%98 129,542 0.4% 80.7% 5.0% 1.9% 10.8%99 128,659 -0.3% 85.6% 1.9% 1.9% 9.6%

10 0 127,774 -1.0% 62.1% 13.6% 3.0% 19.4%10 1 130,228 0.9% 85.9% 4.4% 2.0% 6.0%102 129,340 0.2% 71.3% 12.5% 3.8% 10.4%10 3 131,483 1.9% 86.9% 3.7% 2.5% 5.6%10 7 128,346 -0.6% 84.7% 4.8% 1.2% 7.8%

Several ADs in the Hudson Valley form coalition influence districts, with ADs 94 (Ramapo) and 100 (Newburgh-Beacon) having thestrongest minority influence.

Incumbent(s) no longer in current district:- Galef (90-D), Calhoun (96-D), Gunther (98-D), Katz (99-R), Molinaro (103-R)

New distr icts wi th no incumbe nts wi th in borders- CC Reform A D 96, (North Rockland-Southeast Orange), CC Reform District 99 (Putnam), CC Reform Distict 103 (Interior Dutchess and

Columbia).



9/23

EXHIBITB



10/23

Page 1 of 4

District Summary Rockland CountyBoard of Elections

OFFICIAL RESULTS11/24/10

0223 Ramapo 55 VOTES PERCENTREGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL0BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL1103BALLOTS CAST - BLANK1 .09GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR(VOTE FOR)Andrew M. Cuomo (DEM) 1007 93.41Carl P.Paladino(REP)60 5.57Andrew M. Cuomo (IND) 7 .65Carl P.Paladino(CON)2 .19Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 2 .19Howie Hawkins(GRN)0Jimmy McMillan (RDH)0Warren Redlich (LBT)0Charles Barron (FDM)0Carl P.Paladino(TXP)0Kristin M.Davis(APP)0WRITE-IN0Total1078Over Votes4Under Votes21COMPTROLLER(VOTE FOR)Thomas P.DiNapoli(DEM) 1020 94.62Harry Wilson (REP) 50 4.64Harry Wilson(IND) 1 .09Harry Wilson (CON) 2 .19Thomas P. DiNapoli(WOR) 5 .46Julia A. Willebrand (GRN)0John Gaetani(LBT) 0WRITE-IN0Total1078Over Votes0Under Votes25

ATTORNEY GENERAL(VOTE FOR)Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM)1033 95.47Dan Donovan (REP)41 3.79Eric T. Schneiderman(IND)3 .28Dan Donovan (CON)1 .09Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR)4 .37Carl E.Person(LBT)0Ramon J. Jimenez(FDM)0WRITE-IN0Total1082Over Votes2Under Votes19

http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt /9/2012



11/23

UNITED STATES SENATOR(VOTE FOR)

Page 2 of 4

Charles E.Schumer(DEM) 1021 94.71Jay Townsend (REP) 52 4.82Charles E.Schumer(IND) 1 .09Jay Townsend (CON) 0Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 4 .37Colia Clark(GRN)0Randy A. Credico(LBT)0WRITE-IN0Total1078Over Votes2Under Votes23UNITED STATES SENATOR(VOTE FOR)Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 1004 93.48Joseph J. DioGuardi(REP)6 4 5.96Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 0Joseph J. DioGuardi(CON)0Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 3 .28Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 1 .09Joseph Huff (RDH)1 .09John Clifton(LBT) 1 .09Vivia Morgan (APP) 0Bruce Blakeman (TRP)0WRITE-IN0Total1074Over Votes2Under Votes27

STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE9 th Judicial District(VOTE FOR)Colleen D.Duffy (DEM)37 .89Linda Christopher (DEM)991 23.86Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM)987 23.76J. Emmett Murphy (DEM)33 .79Matthew J . Byrne(REP)982 23.64James Maisano(REP)979 23.57Gerry Klein(REP)54 1.30J . Emmett Murphy (REP)38 .91Matthew J.Byrne(IND)18 .43James Maisano (IND)20 .48Lawrence H. Ecker(IND)1 .02J .Emmett Murphy(IND).. 0Matthew J. Byrne (CON)2 .05James Maisano (CON)2 .05Lawrence H. Ecker (CON)1 .02J. Emmett Murphy (CON)0Colleen D.Duffy (WOR)0Linda Christopher (WOR)4 .10Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR)3 .07Matthew J. Byrne (RTL)1 .02James Alexander Burke(RTL) 1 .02WRITE-IN0Total4154Over Votes84

http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/BOE/EL30110210.txt /9/2012



12/23

Page 3 of 4

Under Votes174REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS17th Congressional District(VOTE FOR)Eliot L.Engel(DEM)1025 94.91Anthony Mele(REP) 36 3.33York Kleinhandler (CON)16 1.48Eliot L.Engel(WOR)3 .28WRITE-IN0Total1080Over Votes2Under Votes21STATE SENATOR38th District(VOTE FOR)David S. Carlucci(DEM)27 2.59C. Scott Vanderhoef (REP)9 9 6 95.49C. Scott Vanderhoef(IND)17 1.63C. Scott Vanderhoef(CON)2 .19David S. Carlucci(WOR)1 .10WRITE-IN0Total1043Over Votes19Under Votes41MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY95th Assembly District(VOTE FOR)Ellen C.Jaffee(DEM) 1030 95.28Thomas A. Morr (REP)46 4.26Ellen C.Jaffee(IND) 2 .19Thomas A. Morr (CON)0Ellen C. Jaffee(WOR) 3 .28WRITE-IN0Total1081Over Votes0Under Votes22RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL(VOTE FOR)Patrick J. Withers(DEM) 1019 9 9 .32Patrick J .Withers(IND) 2 .19Patrick J. Withers(CON) 2 .19Patrick J. Withers(WOR) 3 .29WRITE-IN0Total1026Over Votes0Under Votes77RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL(VOTE FOR)Daniel Friedman (DEM) 1030 95.55Robert Romanowski (REP)42 3.90Daniel Friedman (IND) 2 .19Daniel Friedman (CON) 1 .09

http://www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt /9/2012



13/23

Daniel Friedman (WOR)WRITE-IN30 Page 4 of 4.28Total1078Over Votes1Under Votes24RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE(VOTE FOR)David J.Stein(DEM)1020 94.53Noah Weinberg (REP)53 4.91David J.Stein(IND)2 .19Noah Weinberg (CON)1 .09David J .Stein(WOR)3 .28WRITE-IN0Total1079Over Votes4Under Votes20




14/23

EXHIBITC



15/23

Page 1 of 4

District Summaryockland CountyFFICIAL RESULTSBoard of Elections11/24/100226 Ramapo 58 VOTES PERCENTREGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL0BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL858BALLOTS CAST - BLANK0GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR(VOTE FOR)Andrew M. Cuomo(DEM) 800 94.45Carl P.Paladino(REP)42 4.96Andrew M. Cuomo(IND) 4 .47Carl P.Paladino(CON)1 .12Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 0Howie Hawkins(GRN)0Jimmy McMillan (RDH)0Warren Redlich (LBT)0Charles Barron (FDM)0Carl P.Paladino(TXP)0Kristin M.Davis(APP)0WRITE-IN0Total847Over Votes1Under Votes10COMPTROLLER(VOTE FOR)Thomas P. DiNapoli(DEM) 80 7 96.30Harry Wilson (REP) 31 3.70Harry Wilson (IND) 0Harry Wilson (CON)0Thomas P. DiNapoli(WOR)0Julia A. Willebrand (GRN)0John Gaetani(LBT) 0WRITE-IN0Total838Over Votes0Under Votes20

ATTORNEY GENERAL(VOTE FOR)Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM)813 96.33Dan Donovan (REP)30 3.55Eric T.Schneiderman(IND)1 .12Dan Donovan (CON)0Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR)0Carl E.Person(LBT)0Ramon J . Jimenez(FDM)0WRITE-IN0Total844Over Votes0Under Votes14

http://wwvv.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt /9/2012



16/23

UNITED STATES SENATOR(VOTE FOR)

Page 2 of 4

Charles E.Schumer(DEM) 805 95.49Jay Townsend (REP) 38 4.51Charles E.Schumer(IND) 0Jay Townsend (CON) 0Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 0Colia Clark(GRN)0Randy A. Credico(LBT)0WRITE-IN0Total843Over Votes0Under Votes15UNITED STATES SENATOR(VOTE FOR)Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 79 7 94.88Joseph J . DioGuardi(REP)43 5.12Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 0Joseph J . DioGuardi(CON)0Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 0Cecile A. Lawrence (GRN) 0Joseph Huff(RDH)0John Clifton (LBT) 0Vivia Morgan (APP) 0Bruce Blakeman(TRP)0WRITE-IN0Total840Over Votes0Under Votes18

STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE9 th Judicial District(VOTE FOR)Colleen D.Duffy(DEM)17 .52Linda Christopher ( DEM)800 24.25Lawrence H. Ecker (DEM)800 24.25J. Emmett Murphy (DEM)18 .55Matthew J. Byrne(REP)789 23.92James Maisano (REP)779 23.61Gerry Klein (REP)29 .88J . Emmett Murphy (REP)19 .58Matthew J. Byrne(IND)19 .58James Maisano (IND)20 .61Lawrence H. Ecker (IND)0J. Emmett Murphy (IND)0Matthew J . Byrne(CON)1 .03James Maisano(CON)3 .09Lawrence H.Ecker(CON)1 .03J . Emmett Murphy (CON)0Colleen D.Duffy (WOR)0Linda Christopher (WOR)1 .03Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR)0Matthew J . Byrne (RTL)1 .03James Alexander Burke (RTL) 2 .06WRITE-IN0Total3299Over Votes4




17/23

Page 3 of 4

Under Votes12 9REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS17th Congressional District(VOTE FOR)Eliot L. Engel(DEM)816 96.34Anthony Mele(REP) 18 2.13York Kleinhandler(CON)13 1.53Eliot L. Engel(WOR)0WRITE-IN0Total847Over Votes0Under Votes11STATE SENATOR38th District(VOTE FOR)David S. Carlucci(DEM)21 2.55C. Scott Vanderhoef(REP)78 3 94.91C. Scott Vanderhoef(IND)18 2.18C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON)3 .36David S. Carlucci(WOR)0WRITE-IN0Total825Over Votes10Under Votes23MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY95th Assembly District(VOTE FOR)Ellen C.Jaffee(DEM) 805 95.83Thomas A. Morr (REP)34 4.05Ellen C.Jaffee(IND) 1 .12Thomas A. Morr(CON)0Ellen C.Jaffee(WOR)0WRITE-IN0Total840Over Votes1Under Votes17RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL(VOTE FOR)Patrick J . Withers(DEM) 810 9 9 . 63Patrick J. Withers(IND) 2 .25Patrick J . Withers(CON) 1 .12Patrick J. Withers(WOR) 0WRITE-IN0Total813Over Votes0Under Votes45RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL(VOTE FOR)Daniel Friedman (DEM) 814 9 6 . 90Robert Romanowski(REP)24 2.86Daniel Friedman (IND) 1 .12Daniel Friedman (CON) 1 .12

http://www.co.rockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.bct /9/2012



18/23

Daniel Friedman(WOR)WRITE-IN00 Page 4 of 4Total84 0Over Votes0Under Votes18RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE(VOTE FOR)David J .Stein(DEM)803 95.71Noah Weinberg (REP)35 4.17David J .Stein(IND)1 .12Noah Weinberg(CON)0David J .Stein(WOR)0WRITE-IN0Total839Over Votes2Under Votes17

http://www .cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.0ct /9/2012



19/23

EXHIBITD



20/23

Page 1 of 4

District Summary Rockland CountyBoard of Elections

OFFICIAL RESULTS11/24/10

0203 Ramapo 35 VOTES PERCENTREGISTERED VOTERS - TOTAL0BALLOTS CAST - TOTAL1017BALLOTS CAST - BLANK0GOVERNOR AND LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR(VOTE FOR)Andrew M. Cuomo(DEM) 78 22.35Carl P.Paladino(REP)234 67.05Andrew M. Cuomo(IND) 3 .86Carl P.Paladino(CON)16 4.58Andrew M. Cuomo (WOR) 2 .57Howie Hawkins(GRN)3 .86Jimmy McMillan (RDH)5 1.43Warren Redlich (LBT)2 .57Charles Barron(FDM)0Carl P.Paladino(TXP)4 1.15Kristin M.Davis(APP)0WRITE-IN2 .57Total349Over Votes2Under Votes6 66COMPTROLLER(VOTE FOR)Thomas P. DiNapoli(DEM) 645 82.17Harry Wilson (REP) 121 15.41Harry Wilson(IND) 2 .25Harry Wilson (CON) 9 1.15Thomas P.DiNapoli(WOR) 5 .64Julia A. Willebrand (GRN)0John Gaetani(LBT) 1 .13WRITE-IN2 .25Total785Over Votes1Under Votes231

ATTORNEY GENERAL(VOTE FOR)Eric T. Schneiderman (DEM)56 2 81.92Dan Donovan (REP)96 13.99Eric T.Schneiderman(IND)12 1.75Dan Donovan (CON)7 1.02Eric T. Schneiderman (WOR)4 .58Carl E.Person(LBT)1 .15Ramon J .Jimenez(FDM)0WRITE-IN4 .58Total686Over Votes1Under Votes330

http //www.cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.0ct /9/2012



21/23

Page 2 of 4

UNITED STATES SENATOR(VOTE FOR)Charles E.Schumer(DEM) 445 71.31Jay Townsend (REP) 156 25.00Charles E.Schumer(IND) 7 1.12Jay Townsend (CON) 10 1.60Charles E. Schumer (WOR) 4 .64Colia Clark (GRN)0Randy A. Credico (LBT)2 .32WRITE-IN0Total624Over Votes1Under Votes39 2UNITED STATES SENATOR(VOTE FOR)Kirsten E. Gillibrand (DEM) 76 8.74Joseph J . DioGuardi(REP)759 87.24Kirsten E. Gillibrand (IND) 4 .46Joseph J. DioGuardi(CON)29 3.33Kirsten E. Gillibrand (WOR) 1 .11Cecile A. Lawrence(GRN) 0Joseph Huff(RDH)0John Clifton(LBT) 1 .11Vivia Morgan (APP) 0Bruce Blakeman (TRP)0WRITE-IN0Total87 0Over Votes2Under Votes145

STATE SUPREME COURT JUSTICE9 th Judicial District(VOTE FOR)Colleen D.Duffy (DEM)683 22.09Linda Christopher (DEM)668 21.60Lawrence H. Ecker(DEM)78 2.52J . Emmett Murphy (DEM)11 .36Matthew J. Byrne(REP)679 21.96James Maisano (REP)742 24.00Gerry Klein (REP)95 3.07J. Emmett Murphy (REP)66 2.13Matthew J . Byrne(IND)10 .32James Maisano(IND)9 .29Lawrence H. Ecker(IND)2 .06J . Emmett Murphy (IND)1 .03Matthew J. Byrne(CON)13 .42James Maisano (CON)13 .42Lawrence H. Ecker(CON)3 .10J. Emmett Murphy (CON)8 .26Colleen D.Duffy (WOR)3 .10Linda Christopher (WOR)3 .10Lawrence H. Ecker (WOR)0Matthew J. Byrne(RTL)0James Alexander Burke(RTL)0WRITE-IN5 .16Total3092Over Votes4

http://www .cosockland.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.0ct /9/2012



22/23

Page 3 of 4

Under Votes972REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS17th Congressional District(VOTE FOR)Eliot L.Engel(DEM)713 88.02Anthony Mele (REP) 53 6.54York Kleinhandler (CON)31 3.83Eliot L. Engel(WOR)6 .74WRITE-IN7 .86Total810Over Votes1Under Votes20 6STATE SENATOR38th District(VOTE FOR)David S. Carlucci(DEM)5 .52C .Scott Vanderhoef(REP)908 94.00C .Scott Vanderhoef(IND)24 2.48C. Scott Vanderhoef (CON)27 2.80David S. Carlucci(WOR)0WRITE-IN2 .21Total9 66Over Votes1Under Votes50MEMBER OF ASSEMBLY95th Assembly District(VOTE FOR)Ellen C. Jaffee(DEM) 119 44.91Thomas A. Morr(REP)130 49.06Ellen C.Jaffee(IND) 4 1.51Thomas A. Morr (CON)10 3.77Ellen C.Jaffee(WOR) 2 .75WRITE-IN0Total26 5Over Votes0Under Votes752RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL(VOTE FOR)Patrick J. Withers(DEM) 847 95.81Patrick J . Withers(IND) 14 1.58Patrick J . Withers(CON) 15 1.70Patrick J. Withers(WOR) 6 .68WRITE-IN2 .23Total884Over Votes0Under Votes133RAMAPO TOWN COUNCIL(VOTE FOR)Daniel Friedman (DEM) 893 93.80Robert Romanowski (REP)21 2.21Daniel Friedman (IND) 15 1.58Daniel Friedman (CON) 16 1.68

http://www.cosocIdand.ny.us/B0E/EL30110210.txt /9/2012



23/23

Daniel Friedman (WOR)WRITE-IN61 Page 4 of 4.63.11Total952Over Votes0Under Votes65RAMAPO TOWN JUSTICE(VOTE FOR)David J . Stein(DEM)850 90.62Noah Weinberg (REP)53 5.65David J .Stein(IND)22 2.35Noah Weinberg (CON)6 .64David J .Stein(WOR)6 .64WRITE-IN1 .11Total938Over Votes2Under Votes77Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 297-1 Filed 04/09/12 Page 23 of 23 PageID #:4663

Documents

Declaration of Lee D. Apotheker, Favors v. Cuomo Redistricting Case