Date/Time: Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority ... · CMS-BM-003 Firm Name: Engineer: SEA CONSULTANTS INC. 2822 Bidder: Firm Name: Bid Date: 3600 03/15/2012 MIG Corporation

Line Item Description Unit Unit Price Total PriceQuantity Total PriceUnit PriceTotal PriceUnit Price

Contract D15CN01

VarianceBidderEngineer

Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority

Capital Management System

Comparison of Bids

PAWTUCKET LAYOVER IMPROVEMENT PROJECT,PAWTUCKET, RI

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:

SEA CONSULTANTS INC.

2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3600

03/15/2012

MIG Corporation

FP 1 $25,000.00 $25,000.00 $25,000.00 $25,000.00 $0.00 $0.00CPM SCHEDULING0110.002

LS 1 $50,133.00 $50,133.00 $275,000.00 $275,000.00 $224,867.00 $224,867.00FIELD OFFICE - TRAILER0130.100

LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $1,454,000.00 $1,454,000.00 ($831,211.00) ($831,211.00)ALL OTHER WORK0130.137

AN 1 $100,000.00 $100,000.00 $100,000.00 $100,000.00 $0.00 $0.00RAILROAD FLAGMEN0130.426

AN 1 $10,000.00 $10,000.00 $10,000.00 $10,000.00 $0.00 $0.00TRAFFIC OFFICERS SERVICES0130.429

AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007

AN 1 $50,000.00 $50,000.00 $50,000.00 $50,000.00 $0.00 $0.00TRACK USE STANDBY0160.008

AN 1 $15,000.00 $15,000.00 $15,000.00 $15,000.00 $0.00 $0.00LICENSED SITE PROFESSIONALSERVICES

0160.094

TN 6,650 $19.91 $132,401.50 $22.50 $149,625.00 $2.59 $17,223.50DISPOSAL - IN-STATE UNLINEDLANDFILL

0221.356

Page 1 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3600

03/15/2012

MIG Corporation

AN 1 $100,000.00 $100,000.00 $100,000.00 $100,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALL OTHER SOIL HANDLING ANDDISPOSAL

0221.367

CY 240 $62.36 $14,966.40 $40.00 $9,600.00 ($22.36) ($5,366.40)EXCAVATE AND BACKFILLBELOW NORMAL GRADE

0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $33.00 $3,300.00 $15.15 $1,515.00TEST PITS0222.442

CY 3,472 $65.04 $225,818.88 $30.00 $104,160.00 ($35.04) ($121,658.88)STRUCTURAL BACKFILL0222.479

AN 1 $50,000.00 $50,000.00 $50,000.00 $50,000.00 $0.00 $0.00MISCELLANEOUS TRACKCONSTRUCTION

0290.103

$2,377,685.00 ($714,630.78)$3,092,315.78Total Estimate Contract Base Bid:

Page 2 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3600

03/15/2012

MIG Corporation

Alternate #A01 Line Items

LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $590,000.00 $590,000.00 ($49,263.00) ($49,263.00)ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100

$590,000.00 ($49,263.00)$639,263.00Subtotal Alternate # A01:

Page 3 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3600

03/15/2012

MIG Corporation


LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $890,000.00 $890,000.00 ($326,694.00) ($326,694.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200

$890,000.00 ($326,694.00)$1,216,694.00Subtotal Alternate # A02:

$3,857,685.00 ($1,090,587.78)$4,948,272.78Contract Total - Base Bid and Alternates:

Page 4 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3302

03/15/2012

C.R.C. Company, Inc.


LS 1 $50,133.00 $50,133.00 $5,000.00 $5,000.00 ($45,133.00) ($45,133.00)FIELD OFFICE - TRAILER0130.100

LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $1,780,000.00 $1,780,000.00 ($505,211.00) ($505,211.00)ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094

TN 6,650 $19.91 $132,401.50 $20.00 $133,000.00 $0.09 $598.50DISPOSAL - IN-STATE UNLINEDLANDFILL

0221.356

Page 5 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3302

03/15/2012



0221.367


0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $26.00 $2,600.00 $8.15 $815.00TEST PITS0222.442



0290.103


Page 6 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3302

03/15/2012



LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $460,000.00 $460,000.00 ($179,263.00) ($179,263.00)ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100


Page 7 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3302

03/15/2012



LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $770,000.00 $770,000.00 ($446,694.00) ($446,694.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200



Page 8 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1046

03/15/2012

Aetna Bridge Cmpany



LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $2,064,000.00 $2,064,000.00 ($221,211.00) ($221,211.00)ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094


0221.356

Page 9 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1046

03/15/2012

Aetna Bridge Cmpany


0221.367


0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $100.00 $10,000.00 $82.15 $8,215.00TEST PITS0222.442

CY 3,472 $65.04 $225,818.88 $0.01 $34.72 ($65.03) ($225,784.16)STRUCTURAL BACKFILL0222.479


0290.103


Page 10 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1046

03/15/2012

Aetna Bridge Cmpany


LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $500,000.00 $500,000.00 ($139,263.00) ($139,263.00)ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100


Page 11 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1046

03/15/2012

Aetna Bridge Cmpany


LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $775,000.00 $775,000.00 ($441,694.00) ($441,694.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200



Page 12 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1873

03/15/2012

J. F. White Contracting Co.



LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $2,082,000.00 $2,082,000.00 ($203,211.00) ($203,211.00)ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094

TN 6,650 $19.91 $132,401.50 $20.00 $133,000.00 $0.09 $598.50DISPOSAL - IN-STATE UNLINEDLANDFILL

0221.356

Page 13 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1873

03/15/2012



0221.367

CY 240 $62.36 $14,966.40 $76.00 $18,240.00 $13.64 $3,273.60EXCAVATE AND BACKFILLBELOW NORMAL GRADE

0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $70.00 $7,000.00 $52.15 $5,215.00TEST PITS0222.442



0290.103


Page 14 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1873

03/15/2012



LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $662,400.00 $662,400.00 $23,137.00 $23,137.00ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100

$662,400.00 $23,137.00$639,263.00Subtotal Alternate # A01:

Page 15 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1873

03/15/2012



LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $1,128,840.00 $1,128,840.00 ($87,854.00) ($87,854.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200

$1,128,840.00 ($87,854.00)$1,216,694.00Subtotal Alternate # A02:

$4,486,952.00 ($461,320.78)$4,948,272.78Contract Total - Base Bid and Alternates:

Page 16 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1292

03/15/2012

CARDI CORP.



LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $2,374,000.00 $2,374,000.00 $88,789.00 $88,789.00ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094

TN 6,650 $19.91 $132,401.50 $0.01 $66.50 ($19.90) ($132,335.00)DISPOSAL - IN-STATE UNLINEDLANDFILL

0221.356

Page 17 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1292

03/15/2012

CARDI CORP.


0221.367


0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $75.00 $7,500.00 $57.15 $5,715.00TEST PITS0222.442



0290.103


Page 18 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1292

03/15/2012

CARDI CORP.


LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $639,100.00 $639,100.00 ($163.00) ($163.00)ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100

$639,100.00 ($163.00)$639,263.00Subtotal Alternate # A01:

Page 19 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

1292

03/15/2012

CARDI CORP.


LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $819,700.00 $819,700.00 ($396,994.00) ($396,994.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200



Page 20 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2269

03/15/2012

Lm Heavy Civil Construction, Llc



LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $2,252,000.00 $2,252,000.00 ($33,211.00) ($33,211.00)ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094


0221.356

Page 21 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2269

03/15/2012



0221.367


0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $65.00 $6,500.00 $47.15 $4,715.00TEST PITS0222.442



0290.103


Page 22 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2269

03/15/2012



LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $680,000.00 $680,000.00 $40,737.00 $40,737.00ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100


Page 23 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2269

03/15/2012



LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $1,084,000.00 $1,084,000.00 ($132,694.00) ($132,694.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200



Page 24 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3531

03/15/2012

J.H. Lynch and Sons



LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $2,622,000.00 $2,622,000.00 $336,789.00 $336,789.00ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094

TN 6,650 $19.91 $132,401.50 $15.00 $99,750.00 ($4.91) ($32,651.50)DISPOSAL - IN-STATE UNLINEDLANDFILL

0221.356

Page 25 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3531

03/15/2012

J.H. Lynch and Sons


0221.367


0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $55.00 $5,500.00 $37.15 $3,715.00TEST PITS0222.442



0290.103

$3,147,684.72 $55,368.94$3,092,315.78Total Estimate Contract Base Bid:

Page 26 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3531

03/15/2012

J.H. Lynch and Sons


LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $920,000.00 $920,000.00 $280,737.00 $280,737.00ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100


Page 27 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3531

03/15/2012

J.H. Lynch and Sons


LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $1,100,000.00 $1,100,000.00 ($116,694.00) ($116,694.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200


$5,167,684.72 $219,411.94$4,948,272.78Contract Total - Base Bid and Alternates:

Page 28 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2687

03/15/2012

R. ZOPPO CO. INC.



LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $2,475,000.00 $2,475,000.00 $189,789.00 $189,789.00ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094


0221.356

Page 29 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2687

03/15/2012

R. ZOPPO CO. INC.


0221.367


0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $100.00 $10,000.00 $82.15 $8,215.00TEST PITS0222.442



0290.103


Page 30 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2687

03/15/2012

R. ZOPPO CO. INC.


LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $500,000.00 $500,000.00 ($139,263.00) ($139,263.00)ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100


Page 31 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2687

03/15/2012

R. ZOPPO CO. INC.


LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $650,000.00 $650,000.00 ($566,694.00) ($566,694.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200



Page 32 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3203

03/15/2012

A.A. Will Corporation


LS 1 $50,133.00 $50,133.00 $50,000.00 $50,000.00 ($133.00) ($133.00)FIELD OFFICE - TRAILER0130.100

LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $2,670,000.00 $2,670,000.00 $384,789.00 $384,789.00ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094

TN 6,650 $19.91 $132,401.50 $11.00 $73,150.00 ($8.91) ($59,251.50)DISPOSAL - IN-STATE UNLINEDLANDFILL

0221.356

Page 33 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3203

03/15/2012



0221.367

CY 240 $62.36 $14,966.40 $60.00 $14,400.00 ($2.36) ($566.40)EXCAVATE AND BACKFILLBELOW NORMAL GRADE

0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $100.00 $10,000.00 $82.15 $8,215.00TEST PITS0222.442



0290.103


Page 34 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3203

03/15/2012



LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $550,000.00 $550,000.00 ($89,263.00) ($89,263.00)ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100


Page 35 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

3203

03/15/2012



LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $950,000.00 $950,000.00 ($266,694.00) ($266,694.00)ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200



Page 36 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2697

03/15/2012

RAILROAD CONSTRUCTION CO. INC.



LS 1 $2,285,211.00 $2,285,211.00 $3,448,168.00 $3,448,168.00 $1,162,957.00 $1,162,957.00ALL OTHER WORK0130.137



AN 1 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $32,000.00 $0.00 $0.00ALLOWANCE0160.007



0160.094


0221.356

Page 37 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2697

03/15/2012



0221.367


0222.091

CY 100 $17.85 $1,785.00 $282.00 $28,200.00 $264.15 $26,415.00TEST PITS0222.442



0290.103

$4,359,298.00 $1,266,982.22$3,092,315.78Total Estimate Contract Base Bid:

Page 38 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2697

03/15/2012



LS 1 $639,263.00 $639,263.00 $931,000.00 $931,000.00 $291,737.00 $291,737.00ALTERNATE NO. 10001.100


Page 39 of 50


Contract D15CN01




Comparison of Bids


Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer:


2822 Bidder:

Firm Name:

Bid Date:

2697

03/15/2012



LS 1 $1,216,694.00 $1,216,694.00 $1,523,000.00 $1,523,000.00 $306,306.00 $306,306.00ALTERNATE NO. 20001.200

$1,523,000.00 $306,306.00$1,216,694.00Subtotal Alternate # A02:

$6,813,298.00 $1,865,025.22$4,948,272.78Contract Total - Base Bid and Alternates:

Page 40 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:

Engineer: 2822 Bidder:

Bid Date:

2697

03/15/2012

SEA CONSULTANTS INC.PAWTUCKET LAYOVER IMPROVEMENT PROJECT,PAWTUCKET, RI

Contract

Firm Name: RAILROAD CONSTRUCTION CO. INC.


Total Type Alternate group 01 - not in bid total = $639,263.00 $931,000.00 ($291,737.00)

Total Type Alternate group 02 - not in bid total = $1,216,694.00 $1,523,000.00 ($306,306.00)

Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $4,359,298.00 ($1,266,982.22)

Contract Total - Base Bid and Alternates: $4,948,272.78 $6,813,298.00 ($1,865,025.22)

Page 41 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

3203

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: A.A. Will Corporation


Total Type Alternate group 01 - not in bid total = $639,263.00 $550,000.00 $89,263.00

Total Type Alternate group 02 - not in bid total = $1,216,694.00 $950,000.00 $266,694.00

Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $3,234,270.00 ($141,954.22)

Contract Total - Base Bid and Alternates: $4,948,272.78 $4,734,270.00 $214,002.78

Page 42 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

2687

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: R. ZOPPO CO. INC.




Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $3,199,810.00 ($107,494.22)


Page 43 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

3531

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: J.H. Lynch and Sons



Total Type Alternate group 02 - not in bid total = $1,216,694.00 $1,100,000.00 $116,694.00

Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $3,147,684.72 ($55,368.94)

Contract Total - Base Bid and Alternates: $4,948,272.78 $5,167,684.72 ($219,411.94)

Page 44 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

2269

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: Lm Heavy Civil Construction, Llc




Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $2,859,272.00 $233,043.78


Page 45 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

1292

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: CARDI CORP.


Total Type Alternate group 01 - not in bid total = $639,263.00 $639,100.00 $163.00


Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $2,817,601.22 $274,714.56


Page 46 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

1873

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: J. F. White Contracting Co.




Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $2,695,712.00 $396,603.78


Page 47 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

1046

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: Aetna Bridge Cmpany




Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $2,644,334.72 $447,981.06

Contract Total - Base Bid and Alternates: $4,948,272.78 $3,919,334.72 $1,028,938.06

Page 48 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

3302

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: C.R.C. Company, Inc.




Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $2,418,760.00 $673,555.78


Page 49 of 50

D15CN01



Comparison of Bids

Report ID:

Date/Time:

CMS-BM-003

Firm Name:


Bid Date:

3600

03/15/2012


Contract

Firm Name: MIG Corporation




Total Type Basic = $3,092,315.78 $2,377,685.00 $714,630.78


Page 50 of 50

Documents

Date/Time: Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority ... · CMS-BM-003 Firm Name: Engineer: SEA CONSULTANTS INC. 2822 Bidder: Firm Name: Bid Date: 3600 03/15/2012 MIG Corporation