- Home
Documents
- Dairy industry doesn’t own the word milk - Yale Law School
2
'DLU\ LQGXVWU\ GRHVQW RZQ WKH ZRUG PLON _ 7KH+LOO KWWSVWKHKLOOFRPEORJVFRQJUHVVEORJSROLWLFVGDLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQWRZQWKHZRUGPLON Ickt kpfvut fqgp,u qxp ujg ,oknm, %< -867,1 3($5621 23,1,21 &2175,%8725 u 30 (67 7+( 9,(:6 (;35(66(' %< &2175,%87256 $5( 7+(,5 2:1 $1' 127 7+( 9,(: 2) 7+( +,// ==< 6+$5(6 6+$5( 7: -XVW ,Q +RXVH 'HPRFUDWV ODXQFK LQTXLU\ LQWR ++6 VWLPXOXV SD\RXWV +286( u 0 6 $*2 0,7 PDNHV KLVWRU\ HOHFWLQJ ůLUVW EODFN ZRPDQ VWXGHQW ERG\ SUHVLGHQW LQ \HDUV 1(:6 u 0 6 $*2 3HORVL FDOOV 7UXPSV GHFLVLRQ WR ZLWKGUDZ 86 IURP :+2 DQ DFW RI H[WUDRUGLQDU\ VHQVHOHVVQHVV +286( u 0 $*2 3URWHVW HUXSWV RXWVLGH %URRNO\QV %DUFOD\V &HQWHU RYHU GHDWK RI *HRUJH )OR\G 1(:6 u + 0 $*2 3URWHVWV YDQGDOLVP UHSRUWHG RXWVLGH &11 KHDGTXDUWHUV LQ $WODQWD 0(',$ u + 0 $*2 .HQQHWK %UDLWKZDLWH VZRUQ LQ DV 1DY\ VHFUHWDU\ '()(16( u + 0 $*2 &KLFDJR PD\RU GURSV FRGHG IERPE EODVWLQJ 7UXPSV FRQWURYHUVLDO WZHHW RQ *HRUJH )OR\G SURWHVWV 1(:6 u + 0 $*2 7UXPS YHWRHV PHDVXUH DLPHG DW EORFNLQJ +VTU BT TFOBUPST XFSF DFMFCSBUJOH UIFJS GSFFEPN UP ESJOL NJML SBUIFS UIBO KVTU XBUFS EVSJOH UIF JNQFBDINFOU USJBM TPNF NFNCFST PG UIF CPEZ DIPTF UP DPOUJOVF UIFJS RVFTU UP SFTUSJDU "NFSJDBOT GSPN CVZJOH BOZUIJOH MBCFMFE oNJMLp UIBU EPFTOnU DPNF GSPN B DPX *UnT BO BCTVSE BOE VODPOTUJUVUJPOBM BUUFNQU UP SFTUSJDU QSPEVDUT GSPN VTJOH B DPNNPO UFSN UIBU DPOTVNFST VOEFSTUBOE "U UIF SFRVFTU PG UIF EBJSZ JOEVTUSZ 4FOT %8JT BOE 3*EBIP BTLJOH '%" $PNNJTTJPOFS 4UFQIFO )BIO UP CBO UFSNT MJLF oDPDPOVU NJMLp BOE oBMNPOE NJMLp *O GBDU UIF TFOBUPST XBOU BMM NJML UFSNT CBOOFE VOMFTT UIF QSPEVDU CFJOH EFTDSJCFE JT DPXnT NJML 5IF TFOBUPST DMBJN UIBU UFSNT MJLF oDPDPOVU NJMLp BOE oBMNPOE NJMLp BSF DPOGVTJOH #BMEXJO BOE 3JTDI NBZ CF FBTJMZ DPOGVTFE CVU "NFSJDBO DPOTVNFST BSF OPU 5IFZ VOEFSTUBOE UIBU DPDPOVU NJML EPFTOnU DPNF GSPN DPXT KVTU MJLF UIFZ VOEFSTUBOE UIBU QFBOVU CVUUFS JT EJôFSFOU UIBO CVUUFS "OE UIBU DIJDLFOT EPOnU IBWF ŪJOHFST "OE UIBU ZPV EPOnU XFBS DPUUPO DBOEZ 5IBOLGVMMZ GPS "NFSJDBOT XIP FOKPZ BMM UZQFT PG NJML UIF HPWFSONFOU EPFTOnU PXO PVS MBOHVBHF 6OEFS UIF 'JSTU "NFOENFOU XIBU NBUUFST JT XIFUIFS SFBTPOBCMF DPOTVNFST BSF DPOGVTFE CZ UIFTF UFSNT OPU XIBU QPMJUJDJBOT XJTI UIPTF XPSET NFBOU 4JODF SFBTPOBCMF DPOTVNFST BSF OPU DPOGVTFE CZ UFSNT MJLF oDPDPOVU NJMLp BOE oBMNPOE NJMLp UIF 'JSTU "NFOENFOU QSPUFDUT UIFJS VTF (FUUZ *NBHFT 5BNNZ #BMEXJO +JN 3JTDI SFDFOUMZ XSPUF B MFUUFS
Dairy industry doesn’t own the word milk - Yale Law School
-
Upload
others
-
View
3
-
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Dairy industry doesn_t own the word _milk_ _ TheHill
'DLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQ WRZQWKHZRUG PLON _7KH+LOO
KWWSVWKHKLOOFRPEORJVFRQJUHVVEORJSROLWLFVGDLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQWRZQWKHZRUGPLON
Icktkpfv utfqg p,uqxpujg ,oknm,
%<-867,13($562123,1,21&2175,%8725u30(67
7+(9,(:6(;35(66('%<&2175,%87256$5(7+(,52:1$1'1277+(9,(:2)7+(+,//
==< 6+$5(6 6+$5( 7:
-XVW,Q
+RXVH'HPRFUDWV ODXQFKLQTXLU\LQWR++6 VWLPXOXVSD\RXWV
+286(u06$*2
0,7PDNHVKLVWRU\ HOHFWLQJLUVWEODFN ZRPDQVWXGHQWERG\ SUHVLGHQWLQ\HDUV
1(:6u06$*2
3HORVLFDOOV7UXPS V GHFLVLRQWRZLWKGUDZ86 IURP:+2 DQDFWRI
H[WUDRUGLQDU\ VHQVHOHVVQHVV +286(u0$*2
3URWHVWHUXSWVRXWVLGH %URRNO\Q V%DUFOD\V &HQWHURYHUGHDWKRI
*HRUJH)OR\G 1(:6u+0$*2
3URWHVWVYDQGDOLVP UHSRUWHGRXWVLGH&11 KHDGTXDUWHUVLQ$WODQWD
0(',$u+0$*2
.HQQHWK %UDLWKZDLWH}VZRUQLQDV 1DY\VHFUHWDU\ '()(16(u+0$*2
&KLFDJRPD\RUGURSV FRGHG IERPEEODVWLQJ 7UXPS VFRQWURYHUVLDO
WZHHWRQ*HRUJH)OR\G SURWHVWV 1(:6u+0$*2
7UXPSYHWRHVPHDVXUH DLPHGDWEORFNLQJ
+VTUBTTFOBUPSTXFSFDFMFCSBUJOHUIFJSGSFFEPNUPESJOLNJMLSBUIFSUIBO
KVTUXBUFSEVSJOHUIFJNQFBDINFOUUSJBM TPNFNFNCFSTPGUIFCPEZ
DIPTFUPDPOUJOVFUIFJSRVFTUUPSFTUSJDU"NFSJDBOTGSPNCVZJOHBOZUIJOH
MBCFMFEoNJMLpUIBUEPFTOnUDPNFGSPNBDPX*UnTBOBCTVSE BOE
VODPOTUJUVUJPOBM BUUFNQUUPSFTUSJDUQSPEVDUTGSPNVTJOHBDPNNPOUFSN
UIBUDPOTVNFSTVOEFSTUBOE
"UUIFSFRVFTUPGUIFEBJSZJOEVTUSZ 4FOT %8JT BOE 3*EBIP
BTLJOH'%"$PNNJTTJPOFS
4UFQIFO)BIOUPCBOUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLpBOEoBMNPOENJMLp*OGBDU
UIFTFOBUPSTXBOUBMMNJMLUFSNTCBOOFEVOMFTTUIFQSPEVDUCFJOH
EFTDSJCFEJTDPXnTNJML5IFTFOBUPSTDMBJNUIBUUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLp
BOEoBMNPOENJMLpBSFDPOGVTJOH
#BMEXJOBOE3JTDINBZCFFBTJMZDPOGVTFE CVU"NFSJDBODPOTVNFSTBSF
OPU5IFZVOEFSTUBOEUIBUDPDPOVUNJMLEPFTOnUDPNFGSPNDPXT KVTUMJLF
UIFZVOEFSTUBOEUIBUQFBOVUCVUUFSJTEJôFSFOUUIBOCVUUFS"OEUIBU
DIJDLFOTEPOnUIBWFJOHFST"OEUIBUZPVEPOnUXFBSDPUUPODBOEZ
5IBOLGVMMZGPS"NFSJDBOTXIPFOKPZBMMUZQFTPGNJML UIFHPWFSONFOU
EPFTOnUPXOPVSMBOHVBHF6OEFSUIF'JSTU"NFOENFOU XIBUNBUUFSTJT
XIFUIFSSFBTPOBCMFDPOTVNFSTBSFDPOGVTFECZUIFTFUFSNT OPUXIBU
QPMJUJDJBOTXJTIUIPTFXPSETNFBOU4JODFSFBTPOBCMFDPOTVNFSTBSFOPU
DPOGVTFECZUFSNTMJLFoDPDPOVUNJMLpBOEoBMNPOENJML pUIF'JSTU
"NFOENFOUQSPUFDUTUIFJSVTF
(FUUZ*NBHFT
'DLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQ WRZQWKHZRUG PLON _7KH+LOO
KWWSVWKHKLOOFRPEORJVFRQJUHVVEORJSROLWLFVGDLU\LQGXVWU\GRHVQWRZQWKHZRUGPLON
9LHZ/DWHVW2SLQLRQV!!
9,(:$//
%PPS%BTIEFMJWFSZNBO IBTHVOESBXOPOIJN
#JSEXBUDIFSRVFTUJPOT XIFUIFSSFTQPOTFUP
E\
7FHFUBCMFNJMLUFSNTIBWFCFFOBSPVOETJODFPVSOBUJPOnTGPVOEJOH BOE
FWFOGPSDFOUVSJFTCFGPSF"TGBSCBDLBTUIFUIDFOUVSZ SFDJQFTDBMMFE
GPSUIFJOHSFEJFOUoBMNPOEFTNZMLp*O 'SBODJT#BDPOOPUFEUIBU
oUIFSFCFQMBOUT UIBUIBWFB.JMLJOUIFNXIFOUIFZBSF$VUp"OEUIFUI
DFOUVSZ&ODZDMPQBFEJB#SJUBOOJDBTUBUFEUIBUoUIFFNVMTJWFMJRVPSTPG
WFHFUBCMFTNBZCFDBMMFEWFHFUBCMFNJMLTp*OGBDU DPOTVNFSTTP
BQQSFDJBUFEUIFJEFBUIBUUIFUFSNoNJMLpEJEOPUOFDFTTBSJMZNFBODPXnT
NJMLUIBUXIFO"NFSJDBOJOWFOUPS+PIO$BMMFOQBUFOUFEIJTOFXBOUBDJEJO
IFOBNFEJU.JMLPG.BHOFTJB/POFPGUIJTBQQFBSTUPIBWFDPOGVTFE BOZPOF
5IJTMBDLPGDPOTVNFSDPOGVTJPOJTUIFSFBTPOXIZUIF'%"IBTSFQFBUFEMZ
SFKFDUFE#JH%BJSZnTFôPSUTUPQVOJTIOPOEBJSZNJMLTFMMFSTGPSVTJOHUIFTF
UFSNT8IFOZPVCBOUIFDPNNPOUFSNTUIBUDPOTVNFSTVOEFSTUBOE CFTU
DPOTVNFSDPOGVTJPOEPFTOnUHPEPXO*UHPFTVQ
4POPXUIFHJBOUJOUFSOBUJPOBMEJBSZDPOHMPNFSBUFTIBWFGPVOEBHSPVQPG
TFOBUPSTXIPBSFXJMMJOHUPGFJHODPOGVTJPOJOPSEFSUPEPUIFJSCJEEJOH0G
DPVSTF OPPOFSFBMMZUIJOLT#BMEXJO 3JTDI BOEUIFJSPUIFSTVQQPSUFSTBSF
DPOGVTFEBCPVUDPDPOVUNJML*OTUFBE XIBUJTIBQQFOJOHJTUIBUUIFZBSF
HPJOHUPEPXIBUFWFSUIFHJBOUDPNQBOJFTUFMMUIFNUPEP OPNBUUFSIPX
NBOZDPOTVNFSTUIFZIVSUPSDPOTUJUVUJPOBMQSPWJTJPOTUIFZTISFE
#JH%BJSZJTOnUMJNJUJOHJUTFMGUP$BQJUPM)JMMFJUIFS8JUIBOFWFSFOEJOH
BSNZPGMPCCZJTUTBUJUTEJTQPTBM JUJTBMTPUSZJOHUPDPOWJODFTUBUF
MFHJTMBUVSFTUPCBOUIJTUSVUIGVMTQFFDI+VTUMBTUXFFL UIF7JSHJOJB)PVTF
KPJOFE/PSUI$BSPMJOBBOE.BSZMBOEJO #VUKVTUMJLFJO
/PSUI$BSPMJOBBOE.BSZMBOE UIFMBXXJMMPOMZUBLFFôFDUJGTUBUFTEP
UIFTBNFUIJOH TPFWFOJGUIF7JSHJOJB4FOBUFXFSFUPDPODVSBOE
7JSHJOJBnTHPWFSOPSXFSFUPTJHOUIFCJMMJOUPMBX OPUIJOHNFBOJOHGVM
XPVMEIBQQFOGPSZFBST5IJTJTXIZ#JH%BJSZJTTPGPDVTFEPO#BMEXJO
BOE3JTDI
5IFHPPEOFXTJTUIBUFTUBCMJTIFE'JSTU"NFOENFOUQSFDFEFOUBMSFBEZ
TIPXTUIBUUIJTUZQFPGCBOJTMJLFMZUPCFSVMFEVODPOTUJUVUJPOBM#VUJOUIF
QSPDFTTPGMPTJOHJODPVSU UIFHPWFSONFOUXJMMTQFOENJMMJPOTPGUBY EPMMBST
BGUFSXIJDIUIFHPWFSONFOUXJMMMJLFMZCFPSEFSFEUPQBZFWFO
NPSFUPUIFDIBMMFOHFSTnBUUPSOFZT)PQFGVMMZ #BMEXJOBOE3JTDIDBOJOE
BCFUUFSVTFGPSUIFJSUJNFBOEUIFUBYQBZFSTnNPOFZ
+VTUJO1FBSTPOJTB4FOJPS"UUPSOFZBUUIFOPOQSPJU
XIFSFIFXBTUIFJSTUBUUPSOFZJO64IJTUPSZUPXJOB'JSTU"NFOENFOU
DIBMMFOHFBHBJOTUBGPPETUBOEBSEPGJEFOUJUZ)JTMBXKPVSOBMBSUJDMFPOUIJT
UPQJDXBTSFDFOUMZQVCMJTIFEJOUIF(FPSHFUPXO+PVSOBMPG-BX1VCMJD
1PMJDZ
XFL 7$00<%$/':,1 -,05,6&+
7UXPS86 WHUPLQDWLQJ UHODWLRQVKLSZLWK:+2
6HFRQGVHQDWRUWHVWVSRVLWLYHIRUFRURQDYLUXVDQWLERGLHV
QBTTJOHTJNJMBSMBXT
*OTUJUVUFGPS+VTUJDF
6+$5( 7:((7