Public and private partnership in certification

Willem Strabbing

Agenda

• The Smart Meters Coordination Group

• Smart Meter P&S requirements

• An European approach for security certification of products

1

The Smart Meters Coordination Group

SM-C

G a

cts

as a

dvis

ory

grou

p to

the

ESO

sH

elps

coo

rdin

ate

stan

dard

isat

ion

activ

ities

SMCG plenary

CEN NationalCommETSI CEER/ERGEGCENELEC EURELECTRICESMIG MARCOGAZFACOGAZ EUROGASAQUA WELMECCEN/CLC ANEC

IssuedmandateM/441towardsthe3ESO´s:

Founded:SmartMeteringCoordinationGrouptoassistthemandatedwork

SMCG Chair: Willem Strabbing

Accepted mandate and responsible for standards

Feeds back the results from its work

CEN TC294

CLC TC13

CLC TC205

ETSI M2M

SmartMeteringStandard-making

Individual members support work of the Task Forces

TF Use Cases

TF Glossary

TF P&S

Involves TC’s through 4 coordinating TC’s

2

Home Automation End Device

Metering End Device(E / G W H)MID requirements

Local Network Access Point (LNAP)

Neigbourhood Network Access Point (NNAP)

AMI Head End System

C

H1Meter communicationfunctions

DisplayMetrology

HA communication functions

Simpleexternal consumer

display

H3

Home automation functions

Additionalfunctions

M

C

G1

H2

G1

L

N

WAN NN LN

G2

C

ReferenceArchitecture

3

Deliverables of the SM-CG

Related to original task and the reference architecture• 6 main functionalities • A list if standards • A repository of Use Cases• A repository of technical requirements• A repository of Privacy and Security requirements

Latest work• Minimum security requirements• An inventory of security certification approaches

4

P&S requirements collection

• Collected security and privacy requirements 2013-2015 from several EU member states

• About 300 related to infrastructure

• About 425 related to organisation

• Large range in abstraction level

• Many similarities

5

Minimum security requirements

Objectives:• To assist member states that still have to define• To show the similarities• To have a basis for a EU certification approach

Process:• Focus on infrastructure requirements• Clustering according categories from Common

Criteria• Combine requirements that are similar and

mentioned by several MShttp://www.cencenelec.eu/standards/Sectors/SustainableEnergy/SmartMeters/Pages/default.aspx

6

Certification approaches

The SMCG Task Force evaluated those that are selected by:• UK: CPA

• France: CSPN

• Germany: CC

• USA: ISO/IEC 19790 (FIPS)

Common Criteria is mature, internationally accepted and includes a certification approach

7

One EU certification approach

• The current approaches for Smart Metering are not so very different and related to CC

• MS invent their own solution because there are only national solutions

• The price of certification ranges from 200k – 1000

• An example for other products in energy or other sectors• Similar to metrological certification based on MID• Increases trust in the product

8

Next steps

In ECSO:• WG1 – Standardisation / Certification

• WG3 – Vertical market applications

Develop a security certification approach through cPPP• Technical Community

» Multiple stakeholders related to energy market» IT security authorities» Test labs

• Basis level certification» Start with Essential Security Requirements» Similar to Metrological certification» Additional national evaluations

9

Challenges

• The EU target is 80% in 2020 - expected now is about 70%

• There will be “new generation” after 10 years - Italy andSweden are planning 2nd generation

• Countries will however develop their own certification approaches

• So we need to have a solution asap - if possible start preparations in 2017

10

ESMIG - Boulevard A. Reyers 80 - 1030 Brussels, BelgiumDDI: +32 (0)2 206 68 78 - secretariat@esmig.eu

www.esmig.euTwitter: ESMIG_EU

Thank you for your attention!

Willem StrabbingManaging Director, ESMIG

11